UNIFIED (TRIPARTITE) RESEARCH AGENDA · B. 2nd FGD On the 2nd FGD held last Feb 7, 2016, Dr....
Transcript of UNIFIED (TRIPARTITE) RESEARCH AGENDA · B. 2nd FGD On the 2nd FGD held last Feb 7, 2016, Dr....
UNIFIED (TRIPARTITE) RESEARCH AGENDA
for the
Philippine Society of Gastroenterology
Philippine Society of Digestive Endoscopy
Hepatology Society of the Philippines
2016-2021
INTRODUCTION
THE PSG-PSDE-HSP UNIFIED RESEARCH AGENDA
Research occupies a pivotal role in the Mission-Vision statements of the three societies engaged in gastrointestinal
and hepatic diseases, namely the Philippine Society of Gastroenterology, Philippine Society of Digestive Endoscopy and
Hepatology Society of the Philippines. A Unified Research Agenda (URA) was formulated to help achieve these goals. The
URA will help steer GI research in an organized manner in the direction envisioned by the three societies. A Research Agenda structures a prioritization process so that an organization can systematically weigh factors in its consideration of
research projects and activities. Henceforth, the Research Agenda shall serve as a guide to maximize resource utilization
and minimize duplication of research efforts. It shall identify the research priorities in the next 3-5 yrs.
The National Unified Health Research Agenda (NUHRA), a major document produced by the Research Agenda
Committee of the Philippine National Health Research System, serves as the country’s template for health research and
development efforts. (Philippine National Health Research System. National Unified Health Research Agenda. 20112016.
Pdf accessed July 2016). The Unified Research Agenda of PSG/PSDE/HSP was formulated in alignment with the NUHRA
goals on general health research and development.
THE RESEARCH TEAM
Involved in the preparation and formulation of the URA are the following:
1. Section Chiefs, Training Officers and Research Coordinators of the 13 training institutions
2. Joint Research and Research Education
3. Board representatives for research from PSG, PSDE and HSP 4. Representative from the Accreditation
Board
PREPARATION FOR THE FORMULATION OF URA
Strategic Planning and Focus Group Discussions (FGDs)
Prior to the formulation of the URA, FGDs were held to review and reassess the status of GI research in the country and identify related issues. All training institutions and above-mentioned groups of gastroenterologists were duly
represented. Dr. Raul Destura, an established research specialist both local and international, served as facilitator and
mentor. (Highlights of the meetings are attached in the Appendix).
A. 1st FGD
The 1st FGD was held last September 21, 2015. Past performance based on the research goals identified in
the 2010 PSG Strategic Planning was reviewed and assessed. Gap Mapping and Gap Analysis were done, including identification of strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and treats. Discussion also included defining the roles of the
Research Coordinators of the training institutions and JRRE, and how they can proactively share responsibilities.
Finally, the essential components of a research infrastructure namely: a) new office b) Research Development Unit (RDU) c) website and d) research funding mechanism, were identified as future needs.
B. 2nd FGD
On the 2nd FGD held last Feb 7, 2016, Dr. Destura elaborated on the Concept of Research Agenda: its
importance to all the stakeholders, priority setting tools and processes to be followed in formulating the research
agenda, including the Five Steps in priority setting per disease.
The group benchmarked the state of GI research in the Philippines and concluded an average of 3/10. On brainstorming, issues identified were lack of warm research bodies from training institutions and the need for an
engaging research environment. Consultants should be encouraged to actively participate in research
conceptualization up to completion to ensure high quality of research outputs. There is a call to re-educate
consultants involved in training and research. Issues on lack of enthusiasm and interest need to be examined and
solved. Lastly, as reflected also in the 1st FGD, it is essential to revisit the current training programs for a paradigm shift in leveraging research as an integral component of subspecialty training.
The group agreed that creation of a Unified Tripartite Research Agenda shall enable the three societies to
produce rational research outputs using cross- disciplinary/integrated approach and shall minimize confusion in
allocation of funds.
RESEARCH AGENDA PROPER
The Research Team met last May 7, 2016 to formulate the Unified Tripartite Research Agenda. All training institutions were duly represented. The JRRE members and research representatives from the three societies were present. Dr. Raul Destura served as external facilitator. The team followed the standard procedures required to formulate a research agenda.
Selection Criteria
Topics were evaluated according to the following criteria:
1. Is the agenda “doable”? Do we have the data?
2. Topic addresses multiple goals in the strategic plan?
3. Will the study’s output move the existing knowledge forward?
4. Will the study impact the fellows-in training, the three societies and the country as a whole?
5. Can we use prior studies to leverage this study?
6. How much new information will the study provide?
Prioritization Process
The areas for research were categorized as follows:
1. Quick wins (high impact, short term time frame, 0-12 months)
2. Stars (high impact, long term time frame 12-24 months)
3. Building Blocks (low impact, short term time frame, 0-12 months)
4. Back Burners (Low impact, long term time frame 12-24 months)
Each participant voted for their choice of topics.
Top Priority Areas For Research:
GERD
Peptic Ulcer Disease
Enteric Infections
Gallstones
GI Bleeding
Gastro-Intestinal TB
Hepatitis B
NAFLD
Liver Cirrhosis
Colorectal Cancer
Liver Cancer
Pancreatitis
Among the topics mentioned above, the following were chosen to be the Top Ranking Areas for Research:
1st – Hepatitis B
2nd – Peptic Ulcer Disease
3rd – Colorectal Cancer
4th – Enteric infections
5th – NAFLD and GI TB
6th – Liver cancer
RESEARCH AGENDA PRIORITIES
TOPIC “QUICK WINS”
High impact
Short term time frame (0-
12 months)
“STARS”
High impact
Long term time frame (12-24
months)
“BUILDING
BLOCKS”
Low impact Short
term time frame
(0-12 months)
“BACK
BURNERS”
Low impact Long
term time frame
(12-24 months)
GERD Relapse rate after 4 weeks of PPI for symptomatic GERD and 8 weeks for Erosive Esophagitis
PPI complications (short & long
term)
National Data
base/prevalence
using a validated
questionnaire
Surveillance strategy
for Barrett’s
PEPTIC ULCER
DISEASE
Endoscopic features of H.
pylori Infection
Antibiotic resistance in naïve
patients
Prevalence of H.
pylori infection in
the general
population and
in PUD
Incidence of gastric cancer in patients with initial metaplasia, gastric atrophy, nonNSAID, non- H. pylori
ENTERIC
INFECTIONS
Epidemiology/Susceptibilit y pattern of enteric infections in the Phils: Acute (<2wks)
Acute persistent (2-4 wks)
Chronic (>4weeks)
C difficile toxin: diagnostic
utility/accuracy in
antibiotic-associated
diarrhea (AAD)
Clinical outcomes of AAD
Policy development for
clearance of food handlers
Luminal amoebicides
Prevalence of protozoal infections in
asymptomatic
patients
Concentration
technique for stool
sample of food
handlers (screening)
GALLSTONES Prevalence of gallstone
complications
Medical stone dissolution
Criteria development (scoring
system) for diagnosis of
symptomatic gallstones
Histopathologica
l and radiologic
correlation in
symptomatic
patients
Clinical outcomes of
patients with
adenomyomatosis
GI BLEEDING Use of vasoactive drugs vs
standard of care
Risk of bleeding of novel
antiplatelets/anti-coagulants
Adherence of MDs to practice guidelines
Etiologies of
UGIB/LGIB
Outcome of
adherence vs
nonadherence to
initial scoring
LIVER
CIRRHOSIS
Prevalence of
complications of Portal
Hypertension
Hepatoprotectants/antioxidant
s for the prevention of
decompensation or
development of complications
(adjunct to standard of care)
Etiologies of
cirrhosis
Time for diagnosis to
any outcome
HEPATITIS B Prevalence of e-positive and e-negative for treatment
National sero-
prevalence/incidence of
Hep B born 1991 and above
Cost effectiveness of hepatitis vaccination (0-5 yrs old post vaccination)
Comparison of treatment
outcomes between specialist vs
generalist treatment in
consultation/coaching through
skype
Isolate core antigen-positive in patients to undergo immunosuppression
NAFLD Prevalence all types Lean NAFLD: Risks profile
Non- cirrhotic HCC due to
NAFLD
Use of
hepatotropics in
NAFLD
Association with
DM type 1 & NAFLD
CRC Right vs left -sided colon
cancer profile
Genomics of CRC in the young
(index patient)
Registry
Adenoma
detection rate
LIVER CA Validation of scoring
system or create a new
scoring system
Registry Changing
epidemiology of
HCC over the
past 30 years
Tissue and serum
repository
PANCREATITIS
Clinical profile of non-gallstone,
non-alcoholic pancreatitis
Clinical
significance of
chronic
pancreatitis
detected by EUS
for chronic
abdominal pain
GI TB Updated prevalence of TB
including location,
radiologic & clinical
correlation
Registry- hepatobiliary and colon TB (tissue and serum repository)
RCT of treatment for 6,9,12
months
Criteria of IBD vs TB
Incidence of MDRTB
Metal stenting in TB
strictures
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE UNIFIED RESEARCH AGENDA
The PSG, PSDE and HSP Board shall give the final approval prior to implementation of the Unified
Research Agenda.
Prepared by:
MA. TERESITA Z. CABREIRA, MD
PSG Board of Director
Chair, Committee on Research and Research Education
Noted by:
Peer Review Chairpersons: RUTH URSULA C. CINCO, MD
JANUS P. ONG, MD
JRRE Chair: ROBERTO N. DE GUZMAN JR., MD
RESEARCH FACILITATOR: RAUL DESTURA, MD
Dated July 12, 2016
THE RESEARCH TEAM
1. Eda Jo D. Amatong, MD- Representative, Veterans Memorial Medical Center 2. Rona Marie A. Ata, MD - Representative Cardinal Santos Medical Center 3. Sarah Jean C. Bellido, MD - Representative St Luke's Medical Center Quezon City 4. Joseph C. Bocobo, MD -Training Officer, St. Luke’s Medical Center Global 5. Ma. Teresita Z. Cabreira, MD– PSG Board representative 6. Ruth Ursula C. Cinco, MD- Research Coordinator, Veterans Memorial Medical Center 7. Marie Michelle S. Cloa, MD- PSDE Board representative 8. Arsenio L. Co, MD- Training Officer, Chinese General Hospital and Medical Center 9. Ian Homer Y. Cua, MD - Research Coordinator, St Luke's Medical Center Quezon City 10. Roberto N. De Guzman Jr., MD - Chair, JRRE 11. Gentry A. Dee, MD- Training Officer, Cardinal Santos Medical Center 12. Evelyn B. Dy, MD- Chief Section, Manila Doctors Hospital 13. Norberto I. Estanislao IV. MD- Member, JRRE 14. Enjel A. Gabriel, MD- Research Coordinator, Cebu Doctors University Hospital 15. Roel Leonardo R. Galang, MD - Training Officer, Makati Medical Center 16. Lovell B. Gatchalian, MD -Research Coordinator, East Avenue Medical Center 17. Wilmyr H. Hababag, MD- Research Coordinator, Veterans Memorial Medical Center 18. Anne Marie Geraldine J. Javier, MD- Chair, Accreditation Board 19. Jo-ann Y. Khow, MD- Research Coordinator, Metropolitan Hospital 20. Marie Antoinette DC. Lontok, MD - Research Coordinator, St. Luke’s Medical Center Global 21. Roberto N. Lopez, MD -Training Officer, Metropolitan Hospital 22. Therese C. Macatula, MD- Representative, UP- PGH 23. Mara Maan V. Mañgio-Manansala, MD - Member, JRRE 24. Jonathan Angelo M. Miguel, MD- Member, JRRE 25. Bernadette A. Moscoso, MD- Chief Section, Cebu Doctors University Hospital 26. Karla Maria P. Nomorosa-Suzara, MD - Member, JRRE 27. Janus P. Ong, MD- Research Coordinator, UP- PGH 28. Arlinking K. Ong-Go, MD -Member, JRRE 29. Benjamin Gerardo A. Perez, MD- Chair, PSDE Research Coordinator 30. Rommel P. Romano, MD - Research Coordinator, University of Sto Tomas Hospital 31. Estrellita J. Ruiz, MD - Chief Section, University of Sto Tomas Hospital 32. Marilyn C. Talingdan-Te, MD - Representative, Manila Doctors Hospital