Trans-Boundary Cooperation in the South Asia Power Sector:

Opportunities and Challenges

Mike TomanManager, Environment and Energy Team

Development Research Group, World Bank

CUTS Regional Event, Kolkata, 7 August 2014

2

Disclaimer

The results are preliminary and presented for the purpose of discussion only.

3

Why the interest in regional power integration?

• Short-term gains from ability of trade to relieve shortages

• Long-term gains from opportunity to utilize lower-cost generation at regional level

• Potential environmental gains – to the extent trade facilitates greater utilization of cleaner generation technologies

4

What is our approach?• Quantitative analysis with long-term

electricity planning model to simulate impacts, potential gains of cooperation– Full regional cooperation– Partial cooperation (Bangladesh, Bhutan, India,

Nepal)• Qualitative analysis of institutional and policy

issues

5

Summary of baseline scenario• Regionally capacity grows by a factor of 4• Baseline capacity growth is very coal-intensive

in Bangladesh, India, Pakistan– Least-cost technology– CO2 emissions also grow (4X regionally)

6

Regional cooperation/trade• Major increases in hydro (~30GW with full

regional cooperation), displacing significant additions to coal capacity– But still a lot of coal – drop in CO2 emissions

relative to baseline is ~3%• Significant additional investments in

interconnection– Allows more short-term capacity sharing as well as

transmission capacity for major new hydro capacity

7

Gains from cooperation/trade• Direct gains from trade are moderate in present

value terms – ~US$20B over 2015-2040, discounted at 8% (real rate – fairly high)

• About 80% of this still is achieved with cooperation just among Bangladesh, Bhutan, India, Nepal

• Higher coal prices => significant additions to hydro capacity and trade, higher power costs

• Lower gas prices => some increase in domestic capacity and reduction in trade (in relative terms)

8

Why are the gains seemingly so modest?

• Trade is an incremental effect to the huge growth of regional capacity going forward– All the increased hydro export to India in the

analysis is ~5% of its total electricity use in 2040• Lying behind these discounted net benefit

figures are some large positive impacts– ~US$11B in additional generation and

transmission CAPEX for trade facilitates ~US$28B in OPEX savings (undiscounted figures)

9

Why are the gains seemingly so modest?

• The baseline definition also matters– We assume that current inefficiencies in domestic

power sectors cannot be sustained; in particular, even without trade, persistent shortages are attenuated

– In work still to be done we are going to attempt to quantify the benefit of improved domestic sector performance relative to current BAU

10

So what about all this market efficiency business?

• Increases economic value in its own right• But in addition, why interconnect very

inefficient domestic power systems/markets?– Longer-term cooperation and trade benefits would

be even lower because regulatory distortions reduce value of investment, create risks that raise financing costs

– Conversely, improved domestic sector performance is a key part of reaping full gains from regional cooperation and trade

11

What are possibilities for achieving regional power cooperation and trade

agreement in SAR?• Experiences from many other regional

arrangements with varying degrees of prescriptiveness are generally positive– Even with country size asymmetries– Even with disputes/conflicts among countries– Can proceed in steps/gradually increasing number

of participants and requirements– But broader-scale, more formally organized

coordination can yield considerably more benefit– It takes time and serious dialogue

12

There are synergies between regional cooperation agreements and domestic policy reforms

• Broader success in regional agreements depends on significant power market liberalization, especially in pricing and access– Want prices to reflect opportunity costs, provide

effective signals for regional investments• Prospects of increased gains from regional

coordination may help strengthen case for admittedly difficult domestic reforms

13

How are gains from regional power cooperation and trade shared?

• No simple or unique answer• If markets have been liberalized with competition

among buyers and sellers (“B2B”), price = marginal cost will determine a sharing of gains

• If decision making is concentrated in relatively few hands such that market power can be exercised, importers are likely to capture more of the gains from trade– They have more options than exporters, especially

hydro

14

To summarize…• Increased regional power cooperation and trade

can provide a valuable addition to broader efforts to improve sector performance

• Experience suggests agreement on (sub)regional power cooperation and trade is institutionally feasible for SAR, and can build incrementally

• The efficiency of domestic power systems/markets will have substantial influence on size and distribution of benefits from cooperation and trade – as well as being important in its own right

15

A Regional Power Market Master Plan?

• Necessary technical requirements for high level of inter-operability

• Institutional structures for nondiscriminatory cross-border transmission access, loss sharing– Including provision for equitable and transparent

cross-border transmission siting and land access– Also provision for efficient, non-predatory

transmission pricing• Further developed regional transmission plan– Priority capacity expansions for increasing trade

16

A Regional Power Market Master Plan?

• Commercial provisions for contracting, dispute resolution

• Addition of electricity to the South Asian Free Trade Area agreement

• Plans for developing more elaborate regional power trading mechanisms– Can build on positive experience with power

trading in India, e.g. IEX– Utilize regional dialogue among SAARC energy

regulators

17

Thank you for your kind attention; I look forward to your questions and comments

mtoman@worldbank.org