Towsoninstructionputnam2010

12
Tips for writing a critical analysis paper

description

Presentation for basic library instruction on research and writing a critical analysis paper on climate change

Transcript of Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Page 1: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Tips for writing a critical analysis paper

Page 2: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Laksamee Putnam Email: [email protected] Office: Cook Library M-F: 8-12 Phone: 210.488.4972. Twitter: @LibrarianLaks

Page 3: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Find the research

Evaluate the information

Start your paper

Page 4: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Science scandal◦ University of East

Anglia’s Climatic Research unit

Cherry-picked information

Global warming is a lie!

You will be sorting through all of this…

Image taken from MailOnline

Page 5: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Publication Cycle Scientific Research

Slow and steady Fast and

interesting

High quality resources

Images taken from The Publication Cycle and Scientific Research tutorial

Page 6: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Keep track! Centralize your research!

Google?

Wikipedia?

Databases?

Library?

Terminology

Primary vs. Secondary Resources

Gather and Organize

Narrow it down

Page 7: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

It’s an analysis

It’s an argument

Creating a clear debatable thesis

Page 8: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Can you read everything? Trusted resources…

Subject Gateways at Towson Library

Web of Science

Access Science

Opposing Viewpoints?

Page 9: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Don’t cherry pick! Be logical…

Scan for main ideas Abstract, Intro, Conclusion

Examine and compare multiple sources

Apply the information toward your argument

When was it published?

How many sources does it cite?

How many other articles cite it?

Page 10: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Great now I have a huge list of resources…

Take a step back, what does the list say?

Start with an outline

Your paper should mirror a primary source◦ Cite your work◦ OWL

Page 11: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Find the research

Evaluate the information

Start your paper

Page 12: Towsoninstructionputnam2010

Laksamee Putnam Email: [email protected] Office: Cook Library M-F: 8-12 Phone: 210.488.4972. Twitter: @LibrarianLaks