Tomo Wavelabs I-Corps@NIH 121014
-
Upload
steve-blank -
Category
Education
-
view
381 -
download
2
Transcript of Tomo Wavelabs I-Corps@NIH 121014
OAT guided cryoablation of prostate cancer – new
standard for minimal rectal damage, impotence and
cancer recurrence
Original Opportunity Estimates
$140,000 – estimated price/unit of the technology
Total Available Market:
Total number of urological hospitals in U.S – 2,000
(1,570 ranked by U.S. News)
$280 million
Served Available Market:
1,200 clinics served by cryoablation providers
$168 million
Target Market:
Focused cryoablation, est. half – 600 clinics
$84 million
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
NIH I-Corps™ Team #16
Sergey Ermilov (C-level Exec) VP Research and Development
Peter Brecht (Industry Exp) Director, Business Development
Elena Petrova (PI) Scientist
Customer interviews: 126 Instructor engagements: 43
Week 1 Week 10
Team 16
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Fast
Faster
Original idea
$140,000 x 600 = $84,000,000
600 units: High-resolution T-maps Enhanced contrast of ice ball
urologist TomoWave, Inc.
37oC
Physiological
temperature
-7oC
Freezing
-6oC
Flipped OA signal
-1oC
T0 – zero OA signal
Temperature
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
DIRECT SALE TO PHYSICIANS
Week 1: Business Model Canvas
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Tech
Fe
atu
res
Co
llage
of
“Cu
sto
me
rs”
And next we … GooB
Urologic surgeons
Hospital specialists
Thermal therapy scientists
Patient support groups
Got out
of the
Building!
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
GooB ― first experience
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
GooB ― solution
Well … just walk in to the hospital!
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Reality 1: We are doctors! And we need better
treatment control and … better money!
1 C accuracy 1 mm spatial resolution 1 frame per second
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Doctor’s Pains Doctor’s Gain
Reality 2: … and, by the way, we do not buy your
equipment!. Mobile service instead!
Selling
Leasing
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Bu
yer
Customer archetypes
o 50-75 years old man diagnosed with a localized prostate cancer o Pays in full or splits costs with medical insurance o Values excellent cancer control, fast recovery & min complications
o 30-60 years old o Practices cryoablation or just from residency o Mostly rents equipment and buys consumables o Values patient’s satisfaction, fast learning & payment comparable to office dollars
TomoWave Cryoablation
business Patient Urologist
Decision Maker User, Influencer Buyer
o Stressed by competition and defiant surgeons o CEO, Director of Marketing, CTO o Buys/licenses monitoring technology or OEM o Values larger servable market & competitive advantage
Proposer: academic urologist experimenting with novel prostate cancer treatment techniques Saboteur: prostatectomy guru and radiologist Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Reality 3: Customers need market growth!
Partnership is unavoidable!
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Texas
Cryoablation of prostate cancer: Cash
flow
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Clinical Technology
Ultrasound OEM
Patient
Cryoablation manufacturer-
provider
OAT OEM (TWL)
Private Insurance
Urologist Product/Service Payment
Medicare
Outpatient facility
Cancer treatment & post-treatment activities
$1
k, a
nn
ua
l pa
ymen
ts
Self-payment per procedure
Self-payment per procedure
$786 per procedure
$800-1k per procedure
Federal tax
$5.5k per procedure
Lease equipment, sell consumables
Market Size
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
$5,500 – price of a single cryoablation procedure Based on HealthTronics pricing
12,000 – current number of annual prostate cryoablation treatments in US Based on HealthTronics estimates
230,000 – number of new prostate cancer cases in US in 2014 http://seer.cancer.gov/statfacts/html/prost.html
Total Available Market:
100% market dominance. Fixed price. 50-50 split of the
revenue growth
$600 million
Served Available Market:
Double current prostate cryoablation market. Fixed price. 50-50
split of the revenue growth
$66 million
Target Market:
Double prostate cryoablation market for a single major player.
Fixed price. 50-50 split of the revenue growth
$33 million
Week 1
Week 2
Week 3
Week 4
Week 5
Week 6
Week 7
Week 8
Week 9
Week 10
NIH I-Corps™ lessons learned
Cryo-provider
• Better Control
• Easy Learning
Urologist
• Better Control
• Easy Learning
Cryo-provider
• OEM
• License
• Tech sale
Cryo-provider
• Partners
• Market Growth
Urologist
• Technical Specs
Urologist
• Better Control
• Easy Learning
• Reimbursement
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Our Journey
LaunchPad Business Model Canvas: Week 1
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Our Journey
LaunchPad Business Model Canvas: Week 3
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Our Journey
LaunchPad Business Model Canvas: Week 6
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Our Journey
LaunchPad Business Model Canvas: Week 8
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Our Journey
LaunchPad Business Model Canvas: Week 10
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
$ 60M = double of annual revenue
Urologist
2 Leasing
No complications No cancer
2 Happy patient w/o cancer
Technology License
OEM
Cryoequipment provider
Next? … To be continued!
TomoWave Laboratories, Inc.
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Final Notes
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
With respect to submitting an SBIR/STTR Phase II application, we are making the following decision (PICK ONE):
• Go with a significant pivot: The feasibility data generated in the Phase I grant provide the appropriate technical foundation for a Phase II application, BUT we are targeting very different customer segments than we had originally anticipated
Start
Current Investment Readiness Level (IRL)
Prior to NIH I-Corps™ – 1
Current – 5
APPENDIX
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Slide A1: Story Telling
The World: market/Opportunity – how it operates Characters: Customers/Value Proposition/Product-Market-Fit, pick few examples to illustrate Narrative arc – lessons learned how? Enthusiasm, despair, learning, then insight! Show images and demo to illustrate learning Editing – does each slide advance the characters and plot?
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Slide A2: Theater
Point audience at what they need to see! Self-explanatory Use analogies Tell a story that others can repeat Use common audience appropriate language
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
OAT guided cryoablation of prostate cancer – new
standard for minimal rectal damage, impotence and
cancer recurrence
Interviews: 123
Sergey Ermilov (C-level Exec)
Peter Brecht (Industry Exp)
Elena Petrova (PI)
Team # 16
OA-US
module
to visualize
ice ball with
high contrast
and monitor
temperature
near rectal
wall
Joseph F. Harryhill, “Cryoablation for Salvage Treatment of Prostate Cancer,” Web: Univ. of Pennsylvania Health System, March 23, 2011
Original Market
Estimates
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
$140,000 – estimated price/unit of the technology Source: Estimate is based on known price for some of the components(laser, ultrasound probe,
DAQ) and company’s price policy for similar system for small animal imaging
Total Available Market:
Total number of urological hospitals in U.S – 2,000
(1,570 ranked by U.S. News) Source: http://health.usnews.com/best-hospitals/rankings/urology
$280 million
Served Available Market:
Healthtronics, Inc. - major provider of prostate
cryoablation – 600 clinics http://www.healthtronics.com/
GalilMedical, Inc. – another, est. about the same 600
clinics http://www.galilmedical.com/
$168 million
Target Market:
Focused cryoablation, est. half – 600 clinics
$84 million
Customer archetypes
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
o 50-75 years old man diagnosed with a localized prostate cancer o Pays in full or splits costs with medical insurance o Values excellent cancer control, fast recovery & min complications
o 30-60 years old o Practices cryoablation or just from residency o Mostly rents equipment and buys consumables o Values patient’s satisfaction, fast learning & payment comparable to office dollars
TomoWave Cryoablation
business Patient Urologist
Decision Maker Influencer Buyer
o Stressed by competition and defiant surgeons o CEO, Director of Marketing, CTO o Buys/licenses monitoring technology or OEM o Values larger servable market & competitive advantage
Proposer: academic urologist experimenting with novel prostate cancer treatment techniques Saboteur: prostatectomy guru and radiologist
Customer relationships funnel
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
New monitoring algorithms New US co-registration
($100k) Journal publications In person communication Co-development
Joint journal articles Software updates Hardware & probe
upgrades
Awareness Interest
Consideration Purchase
TV & media promotion Free trials of new technology Up-Selling features Cross-Selling new technology
with consumables Referral deal on consumables
($1M) Joint clinical studies Presentations & Demo at conferences & med schools
Focus groups Existing social media groups Free educational trainings Free trial lease
Joint journal articles Low cost lease Free software updates Free on-site trainings Free tech support Dedicated social media
group (active recruiting)
Relay success stories to general public through TV & social media
($10k) Clinical brochures Paid links from cancer educational websites
Clinical brochures Referral by physicians Paid links from cancer
educational websites
Get Grow Keep
Unbundle Up-Sell Cross-Sell Referrals
The channel economics
(approximate numbers)
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Cost of Goods $60K
Direct sales to physicians
R&D, Selling Cost, Gen & Admin $80K
-5% Profit $78K
List Price $230K
Our revenue $218K
Cost of Goods $60K
Indirect sales to cryoproviders
R&D, Selling Cost, Gen & Admin $70K
-5% Pro-fit
$55K
List Price $230K
Our revenue $185K
Reseller 15%
COGS
OEM to cryomanufacturer
SGA -5% Pro-fit
List Price $380K
Our revenue $220K
Reseller
License? Sell technology?
Direct leasing to physicians
-5% Profit $1.5K
List Price $9K
Our revenue $8.5K
COGS/20 $3K
SGA/20 $4K
Indirect leasing to cryoproviders
-5%
List Price $9K
Our revenue $7.2K
Pro-fit
$0.7K
Resell
15%
COGS/20 $3K
SGA/20 $3.5K
Key Activities and Resources
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Freedom to operate
Quality data
Regulatory approval
Final product
Sales
• Internal financing
• Patent lawyer
• SBIR/SBA • Internal
financing • R&D facility,
equipment • R&D
personnel
• SBIR/SBA • Investment • R&D facility
and equipment
• R&D personnel
• Mentors, advisors
•Investment •Assembly facility •Laser, optical, US, electronic parts
•Trade secrets, patents, licenses
• Engineers, tech-nicians, quality control
•Mentor, advisors
Finance Physical Intellectual Human
Purpose Activity Resource
• Investment • Internal
financing • Marketing
personnel • Sales
personnel • Customer
service • Mentors,
advisors
5 steps to our success
• Clinical trials • Negotiation
of reimburse-ment
• Manufacturing • Licensing
• Marketing • Sales/Leasing • Education • TechSupport
•Blocking patents on OA imaging
•Ultrasound license
• R&D • Clinical
studies
Key Resources: IP
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Field IP solution
Ice ball
IP
OA technology
Thermal monitoring
Ultrasound imaging
Cryoablation
Block-ing
patent
Trade secrets
Blocking patent / licensing
Blocking patent / licensing
Partners
Partners Service
directly to urologists
Licensing Open
platform Develop
ment Electro
nics Soft-ware
Probes
Original Revenue Models
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
CMP
TWL
Urologist Sale Cash
Leasing
Cash
Reimbursement
Licensing
TWL – TomoWave Labs CMP – Cryoablation Manufacturer & Provider
Sales
Leasing
CMP
TWL
Urologist Licensing
License Fee
Leasing
Cash
Reimbursement
Leasing
Cash
CMP
TWL Urologist
Leasing
Cash
Reimbursement
Cryoablation of prostate cancer: Cash
flow
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Clinical Technology
Ultrasound OEM
Patient
Cryoablation manufacturer-
provider
OAT OEM (TWL)
Private Insurance
Urologist Product/Service Payment
Medicare
Outpatient facility
Cancer treatment & post-treatment activities
$1
k, a
nn
ua
l pa
ymen
ts
Self-payment per procedure
Self-payment per procedure
$786 per procedure
$800-1k per procedure
Federal tax
$5.5k per procedure
Lease equipment, sell consumables
Market Size
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
$60,000 – estimated price/unit of the technology Source: Estimate is based on direct costs + 100% margin. $17k – 805 nm Q-switched OEM
laser, $7k proprietary modified OEM ultrasound, $6k – proprietary OAUS probe, $0k –
proprietary software.
Total Available Market:
Total number of urological hospitals in U.S – 2,000 (1,570
ranked by U.S. News) Source: http://health.usnews.com/best-hospitals/rankings/urology
1 unit per hospital – 2,000 units
$120 million
Served Available Market:
Current share of cryoablation in prostate cancer ~ 1%
Dominating revenue model (>90%) – mobile service
Need 50% less units – 1,000 units
$60 million
Target Market:
Bipolar U.S. market of cryoablation providers:
HealthTronics www.healthtronics.com
50% market – 200 units
GalilMedical www.galilmedical.com
50% market – 200 units
Total number of in-field units – 400, Market growth – 600 units
$36 million
Finance and operation timeline
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
OEM to CMP 2 (300 units)
R&D, Preclin. studies
R&D, Clinical studies (30 patients, 3 units),
GMP
Exclusive OEM to CMP 1 (20 units)
Spending
Profit
Time
OEM to CMP 1 (300
units)
6 months 24 months 42 months
Co-development with CMP 1
18 months
$200k $1M
20 x $30k = $600k
600 x $30k = $18M
Evolution of Business Model Canvas
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
R$: Now only direct sales revenue stream remains CS: Direct sales to one of two major cryoablation manufacturers and providers C: Direct sales via OEM or acquisition KA: Quality control will be required for in-house assembly of OAT units and probes. KA: Requirements for clinical studies were updated to reflect time frame, available funds, and planned business development
Key Activities and Resources/Partners
Team #16, I-Corps @ NIH, Chevy Chase, MD
Partner Activity Resource
• Clinical trials • Negotiation of
reimbursement
• Manufacturing • Licensing
• Marketing • Sales/Leasing • Education • TechSupport
•Patents on OA imaging
•Ultrasound license
• R&D • Clinical
studies
Cryoablation provider
Clinicians
Ultrasound machine producer
•R&D personnel •R&D facility, equipment •Consultants
•Marketing personnel
•Sales personnel
• Investment • SBIR/SBA
•Assembly facility
•Laser, electronics and parts
Trade secrets, patents, licenses
•Engineers, technicians •Quality control
Customer service