Thesis 11.15.11

65
The Efficacy of the National Survey of Children’s Health at assessing childhood obesity risk in children ages 10-17 years. 1

Transcript of Thesis 11.15.11

Page 1: Thesis 11.15.11

The Efficacy of the National Survey of Children’s Health at assessing childhood obesity risk in children ages 10-17 years.

1

Page 2: Thesis 11.15.11

INTRODUCTION

Childhood Obesity:

31.7% of 2-19 year old children in the U.S. are overweight/obese.

Overweight/obese children are more likely to be overweight/obese into adulthood.

Research indicates several parental factors may contribute to childhood obesity.

2

Reference: 3, 17

Page 3: Thesis 11.15.11

Childhood Obesity Models

Several models used to depict variables involved in childhood obesity:

Socio-Economic Model

Ecological Systems Theory

Model of Societal/Environmental Factors Affecting Childhood Obesity

3

Page 4: Thesis 11.15.11

Parental Influence on Childhood Obesity

Tabacchi G, Giammanco S, Guardia ML, Giammanco M. (2007) A review of the literature and a new classification of the early determinants of childhood obesity: from pregnancy to the first years of life. Nutrition Research, 27, 587-604.

4

Page 5: Thesis 11.15.11

National Survey of Children’s Health (NSCH)

National Survey of Children’s Health

Sponsored by the Maternal and Child Health Bureau.

Assesses the physical and emotional health of children ages 0-17.

Age of children chosen for study (10-17 years)

State and Local Area Integrated Telephone Survey (SLAITS):

Used to determine the emotional and physical healthstatus, as well as, children’ access to medical care and insurance in the U.S.

NSCH overview (www.cdc.gov/SLAITS/NSCH)

5

Page 6: Thesis 11.15.11

Rationale

Childhood obesity is a growing problem.

Identification of contributing factors can lead to effective intervention efforts.

NSCH is a fairly new surveillance system

Initiated in 2003

Potential to aid in future intervention efforts

6

Page 7: Thesis 11.15.11

Purpose

To investigate the extent of variables measured by NSCH that are predictive of childhood obesity risk in children ages 10-17 years.

7

Page 8: Thesis 11.15.11

8

What Research Says…

Page 9: Thesis 11.15.11

Parents’ Obesity

Genetic factors Higher genetic predisposition when

parents are obese.

Greater risk when both parents are overweight.

Lifestyle factors Parents with higher BMI scores may

live obesity-promoting lifestyles

Parent physical activity: strong positive predictor of childhood inactivity.

References: 26, 29

9

Page 10: Thesis 11.15.11

Maternal Pregnancy Nutrition

‘Fetal Origins Theory’ The Dutch Famine: Early

1900’s

Higher rates of Obesity in women exposed to famine in 1st and 2nd trimesters: ‘Thrifty Phenotype Hypothesis’

Diet Composition Low Protein

High fat/cholesterol

Low/High Calorie: Infant and mother weight gain

References: 96, 98, 99, 10, 11, 12, 13

10

Page 11: Thesis 11.15.11

Maternal Practices of Breastfeeding and Weaning

Breastfeeding vs formula feeding

Rapid ‘catch-up growth’

Age of weaning

World Health Organization (WHO): > 6 mos

Department of Health (DOH): > 4 mos

Infant’s developmental progress

References: 100, 84-86, 6, 10, 11, 8, 91, 90, 87, 88

11

Page 12: Thesis 11.15.11

Parental Employment Status

Shift away from traditional dynamic: Father = breadwinner and mother stays home. Both parents lead busy lifestyles.

Research has shown mothers working more hours more likely to have overweight children.

However, two incomes may result in access to healthier choices.

References: 3, 17, 18

12

Page 13: Thesis 11.15.11

Parental Education

Higher parental education linked to higher physical activity in children.

Research indicates inverse relationship between childhood obesity and education level of head of household.

Parents who are educated on the importance of health may be more inclined to make healthier choices for their families.

References: 15, 16, 26

13

Page 14: Thesis 11.15.11

Socioeconomic Status

Research is inconsistent. Studies looking at nutrient level

data found little association.

Studies looking at specific food groups found relationships.

One study found SES positively related to fruit/vegetable consumption and negatively related to fast food consumption.

Study by Ogden, et al found childhood obesity prevalence decreases as income increases, however, most obese children are not low income.

References: 16, 18, 19

14

Page 15: Thesis 11.15.11

Single Mother or No-worker Father

Journal of Pediatrics: middle school children with unemployed father had increased risk compared to working fathers.

Children of single mothers or unemployed parents more likely to develop obesity.

References: 1, 2

15

Page 16: Thesis 11.15.11

Attitudes of Mother

Mother’s mental and emotional characteristics

Mother’s perception of Child’s weight

Mother’s concern for her child’s weight from personal experience

Maternal restriction

References: 60-62, 68, 63, 64, 73, 82, 70, 72

16

Page 17: Thesis 11.15.11

Number of Siblings

Children of the same family will learn the same food culture

However, others argue that each child is different

Weight status of child

Concern of mother for child increases pressure to eat or restrict to change food culture

Genetic and environmental factors influence food culture and weight

References: 50, 52, 57, 59

17

Page 18: Thesis 11.15.11

Religion and Beliefs

No direct research literature

Participation in religion is inversely related to increased body weight

Stress-coping mechanism, social support and doctrine itself

Some religions promote dietary restriction Catholicism, Judaism, Seventh Day Adventists

What about prayer, reading your bible?

References: 43, 46, 48, 41, 49

18

Page 19: Thesis 11.15.11

Built Environment

Grocery store access Linked with open space and width

of streets

Physical activity level varies based on: SES Housing and neighborhood

characteristics Presence of parks and

walking/biking paths Age of parks

Sex of child Distance from school

Friends in the area Parent’s perception of

neighborhood safety

References: 120, 121, 125, 127, 129

19

Page 20: Thesis 11.15.11

OUR Model20

Page 21: Thesis 11.15.11

Methodology

Study Design

Non-experimental

Analytical

Key Variables:

Dependent: BMI

Independent: Childhood Obesity Factors

IRB Approval Level - Exempt

21

Page 22: Thesis 11.15.11

Statistical Procedures

Data available for use through the NSCH. Analyzed using SPSS version 19.

Computed Frequencies and Chi Square.

Variables were recoded.

22

Page 23: Thesis 11.15.11

Sample Population Results23

45,897 Children aged 10-17 made up the study 23,866 Males 21,985 Females

Other Descriptive Statistics available: Federal Poverty level based on SCHIP qualification Family structure Parental Marital/Cohabitation Status Parent Social Support Religious service attendance Parental physical activity per week Parental Mental and Emotional Health Status Parental General Health Parent Stress Coping Ability Parent-Child Relationship Status

Page 24: Thesis 11.15.11

24

4940 10.8%

4673 10.2%

5380 11.7%

5861 12.8%

6088 13.3%

6720 14.6%

6952 15.1%

Child's Age

10

11

13

14

15

16

17

21,97552.1%

23,85547.9%

Sex of Child

Male

Female

Child Statistics

Page 25: Thesis 11.15.11

25

4935 10.9%

31,88070.7%

4632 10.3%

1897 4.2%

1776 3.9%

Ethnicity/Race

Hispanic

White

Black

Multi-racial

Other

2186 5.0%

29,121 66%

6754 15.3%

6040 13.7%

Child's BMI

Underweight

Healthy Weight

Overweight

Obese

Child Statistics

Page 26: Thesis 11.15.11

26

20,67245.0%

16,45235.8%

6043 13.2%

2729 5.9%

Number of Siblings

1

2

3

4+

20,67145.0%

14,77432.2%

8921 19.4%

1315 2.9%

214 0.5%

Birth Position

1

2

3

4

5

Siblings

Page 27: Thesis 11.15.11

Family Members27

33,42872.8%

9656 21.0%

2806 6.1%

Respondent Relationship to Child

Mother

Father

All Other

29,24164.1%

4910 10.8%

8027 17.6%

3446 7.6%

Family Structure

Two Parent; Biological/AdoptedTwo Parent; Step Family

Single Mother; No Father presentOther Family Type

Page 28: Thesis 11.15.11

Education28

3261 7.8%

9209 21.9%

29,49970.3%

Mother Education Level

Less than High School

High School Graduate

More than High School

2676 7.6%

8414 23.9%24,128

68.5%

Father Education Level

Less than High School

High School Graduate

More than High School

Page 29: Thesis 11.15.11

Income29

41,25690.9%

4107 9.1%

Parent Empolyment status at least 50 out

of past 52 weeks

Yes

No

4824 10.5%

7378 16.1%

15,57633.9%

18,11939.5%

Federal Poverty Level based on DHHS

Guidelines

0-99% FPL

100-199% FPL

200-399% FPL

400% FPL +

Page 30: Thesis 11.15.11

30

Results of Hypothesis Testing

Page 31: Thesis 11.15.11

Maternal General Health Status

Hₒ1a: There is no association between childhood obesity and maternal general health status.

REJECTED(p value = .000)

Maternal General Health Status

Health Status Excellent Very Good and

GoodFair and poor Total

Underweight and Healthy Weight

8787 (30.2%) 17773 (61.2%) 2501 (8.6%) 29061 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

2458 (21.2%) 7437 (64.2%) 1686 (14.6%) 11581 (100.0%)

Total 11245 (27.7%) 25210 (62.0%) 4187 (10.3%) 40642 (100.0%)

31

Page 32: Thesis 11.15.11

Paternal General Health Status

Hₒ1b: There is no association between childhood obesity and paternal general health status.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Paternal General Health Status

Health Status ExcellentVery good and

goodFair and poor Total

Underweight and Healthy Weight

7259 (28.9%) 16219 (64.6%) 1635 (6.5%) 25113 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

1946 (21.3%) 6195 (67.9%) 981 (10.8%) 9122 (100.0%)

Total 9205 (26.9%) 22414 (65.5%) 2616 (7.6%) 34235(100.0%)

32

Page 33: Thesis 11.15.11

Maternal Physical Activity Level

Hₒ2a: There is no association between childhood obesity and maternal physical activity level.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Mother’s days of Physical Activity (PA) per week

Underweight and Healthy Weight

Overweight and Obese Total

0 days of PA 6253 (68.0%) 2948 (32.0%) 9201 (100.0%)

1 to 4 days of PA 15467 (72.7%) 5808 (27.3%) 21275 (100.0%)

5 to 7 days of PA 7217 (72.4%) 2749 (27.6%) 9966 (100.0%)

33

Page 34: Thesis 11.15.11

Paternal Physical Activity Level

Hₒ2b: There is no association between childhood obesity

and paternal physical activity level.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Father’s days of Physical Activity (PA) per week

Underweight and Healthy Weight Overweight and Obese Total

0 days of PA 4425 (70.4%) 1859 (29.6%) 6284 (100.0%)

1 to 4 days of PA 11738 (75.4%) 3837 (24.6%) 15575 (100.0%)

5 to 7 days of PA 8733 (72.4%) 3321 (27.6%) 12054 (100.0%)

34

Page 35: Thesis 11.15.11

Maternal Mental and Emotional Health

Hₒ3a: There is no association between childhood obesity and maternal mental and emotional health status.

ACCEPTED (p value = .929)

Maternal Mental and Emotional Health Status

Health Status Excellent Very Good and

Good

Fair and poor Total

Underweight and

Healthy Weight

10324 (35.3%) 17252 (58.9%) 1691 (5.8%) 29267 (100.0%)

Overweight and

Obese

4192 (35.3%) 6993 (58.8%) 698 (5.9%) 11883 (100.0%)

Total 14516 24245 2389 41150

35

Page 36: Thesis 11.15.11

Paternal Mental and Emotional Health

Hₒ3b: There is no association between childhood obesity and paternal mental and emotional health status.

ACCEPTED (p value = .861)

Paternal Mental and Emotional Health Status

Health Status Excellent Very Good and

Good

Fair and poor Total

Underweight and

Healthy Weight

9773 (39.2%) 14136 (56.8%) 996 (4.0%) 24905 (100.0%)

Overweight and

Obese

3991 (39.5%) 5702 (56.4%) 409 (4.0%) 10102 (100.0%)

Total 13764 19838 1405 35007

36

Page 37: Thesis 11.15.11

Paternal Perceptions of Child Health

Hₒ3c: There is no association between childhood obesity and parental perceptions of child health status.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Parent’s Perception of Child health Status

Parent reported

child health

status

ExcellentVery Good and

GoodFair and poor Total

Underweight and

Healthy Weight

21273 (68.0%) 9471 (30.3%) 557 (1.8%) 31301 (100.0%)

Overweight and

Obese

6493 (50.8%) 5743 (44.9%) 553 (4.3%) 12789 (100.0%)

Total 27766 15214 1110 44090

37

Page 38: Thesis 11.15.11

Maternal Education Level

Hₒ4a: There is no association between childhood obesity and maternal education status.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Mother Highest Education Level Completed

Education Level

Completed

Less than high school

12 years/high school graduate

More than high school

Total

Underweight and Healthy Weight

1639 (5.7%) 5846 (20.2%) 21411 (74.1%) 28896 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

1217 (10.6%) 3018 (26.3%) 7262 (63.2%) 11497 (100.0%)

Total 2856 (7.1%) 8864 (21.9%) 28673 (71.0%) 40393 (100.0%)

38

Page 39: Thesis 11.15.11

Paternal Education Level

Hₒ4b: There is no association between childhood obesity and paternal education status.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Father Highest Education Level Completed

Education Level

Completed

Less than high school

12 years/high school graduate

More than high school

Total

Underweight and Healthy Weight

1405 (5.6%) 5433 (21.8%) 18095 (72.6%) 24933 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

1002 (11.1%) 2678 (29.7%) 5348 (59.2%) 9037 (100.0%)

Total 2407 (7.1%) 8120 (23.9) 23443 (69.0%) 33970 (100.0%)

39

Page 40: Thesis 11.15.11

Parent Employment Status

Hₒ5a: There is no association between childhood obesity and parent employment status.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Was anyone in the household employed at least 50 weeks out of the past 52 weeks?

Employment Status No Yes Total

Underweight and Healthy Weight

2341 (7.6%) 28656 (92.4%) 30997 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

1467 (11.6%) 11168 (88.4%) 12635 (100.0%)

Total 3808 (8.7%) 39824 (91.3%) 43632 (100.0%)

40

Page 41: Thesis 11.15.11

Parent Income

Hₒ6a: There is no association between childhood obesity and household poverty level based on DHHS guidelines.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Poverty level of this household based on DHHS guidelines

0-99% Federal Poverty Level

100-199% Federal Poverty

Level

200-399% Federal Poverty

Level

400% Federal Poverty Level

or greaterTotal

Underweight and Healthy Weight

2436 (7.8%) 4453 (14.2%) 10673 (34.1%) 13745 (43.9%) 31307 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

1891 (14.8%) 2539 (19.8%) 4459 (34.9%) 3905 (30.5%) 12794 (100.0%)

Total 4327 (9.8%) 6992 (15.9%) 15132 (34.3%) 17650 (40.0%) 44101 (100.0%)

41

Page 42: Thesis 11.15.11

Parent Income

Hₒ6b: There is no association between childhood obesity and household poverty level based on SCHIP qualifications.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Poverty level of this household based on DHHS guidelines based on SCHIP qualifications

0-99% Federal Poverty Level

100-199% Federal

Poverty Level

200-399% Federal

Poverty Level

400% Federal Poverty Level

or greaterTotal

Underweight and Healthy Weight

6889 (22.0%) 5551 (17.7%) 5122 (16.4%) 13745 (43.9%) 31307 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

4430 (34.6%) 2513 (19.6%) 1946 (15.2%) 3905 (30.5%) 12794 (100.0%)

Total 11319 (25.7%)

8064 (18.3%) 7068 (16.0%) 17650 (40.0%) 44101 (100.0%)

42

Page 43: Thesis 11.15.11

Parental Marital Cohabitation Status

Hₒ7a: There is no association between childhood obesity and parental marital cohabitation status.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Marital/Cohabitation Status of Child's Parent(s) in the Household

Married Cohabitating NeitherNo parents in the household

Total

Underweight and Healthy Weight

23905 (76.8%) 1241 (4.0%) 5008 (16.1%) 954 (3.1%) 31108 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

8462 (66.7%) 757 (6.0%) 2848 (22.4%) 623 (4.9%) 12690 (100.0%)

Total 32367 (73.9%) 1998 (4.6%) 7856 (17.9%) 1577 (3.6%) 43798 (100.0%)

43

Page 44: Thesis 11.15.11

Parental Legal Status

Hₒ7b: There is no association between childhood obesity and parental legal status.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Derived: Legal Marital Status of Child's Parent(s) in the Household

Married Separated Divorced WidowedNever

Married

No Parents in

HouseholdTotal

Underweight and Healthy Weight

23905 (76.8%)

708 (2.3%)

3146 (10.1%)

442 (1.4%)

1961 (6.3%)

954 (3.1%)

31116 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

8462 (66.7%)

449 (3.5%)

1514 (11.9%)

255 (2.0%)

1391 (11.0%)

623 (4.9%)

12694 (100.0%)

Total 32367 (73.9%)

1157 (2.6%)

4660 (10.6%)

697 (1.6%)

3352 (7.7%)

1577 (3.6%)

43810 (100.0%)

44

Page 45: Thesis 11.15.11

Family Structure

Hₒ7c: There is no association between childhood obesity and family structure.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Type of family structure in household

Two parent, biological or

adopted

Two parent, step family

Single mother, no father present

Other family type

Total

Underweight and Healthy Weight

20872 (67.0%) 3299 (10.6%) 4829 (15.5%) 2148 (6.9%) 31148 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

7234 (56.9%) 1473 (11.6%) 2851 (22.4%) 1156 (9.1%) 12714 (100.0%)

Total 28106 (64.1%) 4772 (10.9%) 7680 (17.5%) 3304 (7.5%) 43862 (100.0%)

45

Page 46: Thesis 11.15.11

Number of Siblings

Hₒ8a: There is no association between childhood obesity and number of siblings.

ACCEPTED (p value = .174)

How many people less than 18 years old live in this household

Children in

Household1 2 3 4 Total

Underweight

and Healthy

Weight

14095

(45.0%)

11305

(36.1%)

4106 (13.1%) 1800 (5.7%) 31306

(100.0%)

Overweight

and Obese

5900 (46.1%) 4505 (35.2%) 1645 (12.9%) 744 (5.8%) 12794

(100.0%)

Total 19995 15810 5751 2544 44100

46

Page 47: Thesis 11.15.11

Birth position of Siblings

Hₒ8b: There is no association between childhood obesity and birth position of siblings.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

Birth position of the child relative to other children in the household

Birth

Position1 2 3 4 5 Total

Underweigh

t and

Healthy

Weight

14095

(45.0%)

10314

(32.9%)

5916

(18.9%)

865 (2.8%) 116 (.4%) 31306

(100.0%)

Overweight

and Obese

5900

(46.1%)

3842

(30.0%)

2612

(20.4%)

364 (2.8%) 76 (.6%) 12794

(100.0%)

Total 19995 14156 8528 1229 192 44100

47

Page 48: Thesis 11.15.11

Family Meals

Hₒ9a: There is no association between childhood obesity and number of family meals.

REJECTED (p value = .000)

In the past week, on how many days did all family members living in the household eat a meal together?

Days per week 0 1 to 4 5 to 7 Total

Underweight and Healthy Weight

1483 (4.8%) 12181 (39.0%) 17551 (56.2%) 31215 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese

616 (4.8%) 4656 (36.5%) 7490 (58.7%) 12762 (100.0%)

Total 2099 (4.8%) 16837 (38.3%) 25041 (56.9%) 43977 (100.0%)

48

Page 49: Thesis 11.15.11

Neighborhood Parks and Walking Paths

Hₒ10a: There is no association between childhood obesity and the presence of neighborhood parks and walking paths.

ACCEPTED (p value = .459)

Does a park or playground area exist in your neighborhood?

No Yes Total

Underweight and

Healthy Weight

6388 (20.6%) 24652 (79.4%) 31040 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese 2569 (20.3%) 10108 (79.7%) 12677 (100.0%)

Total 8957 34760 43717

49

Page 50: Thesis 11.15.11

Presence of Sidewalks and Walking Paths

Hₒ10b: There is no association between childhood obesity and the presence of walking paths.

ACCEPTED (p value = .472)

Do sidewalks or walking paths exist in your neighborhood?

No Yes Total

Underweight and

Healthy Weight

8876 (28.6%) 22172 (71.4%) 31048 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese 3579 (28.2%) 9092 (71.8%) 12671 (100.0%)

Total 12455 31264 43719

50

Page 51: Thesis 11.15.11

Neighborhood Safety

Hₒ10c: There is no association between childhood obesity and neighborhood safety.

ACCEPTED (p value = .229)

How often does your child feel safe in your community or neighborhood?

Never Sometimes Usually Always Total

Underweight

and Healthy

Weight

569 (1.8%) 2734 (8.8%) 10587 (34.2%) 17098 (55.2%) 30988

(100.0%)

Overweight

and Obese

229 (1.8%) 1188 (9.4%) 4242 (33.5%) 6985 (55.2%) 12644

(100.0%)

Total 798 3922 14829 24083 43632

51

Page 52: Thesis 11.15.11

Religious Service Attendance

Hₒ11a: There is no association between childhood obesity and religious service attendance.

ACCEPTED (p value = .081)

About how often does the child attend a religious service?

None

At least once

per year but

less than

once per

month

At least

once per

month but

less than

once per

week

At least

once per

week but

less than

daily

Daily Total

Underweight

and Healthy

Weight

4850

(15.6%)

4094

(13.2%)

5886

(18.9%)

15947

(51.3%)

312 (1.0%) 31089

(100.0%)

Overweight

and Obese

1974

(15.5%)

1549

(12.2%)

2430

(19.1%)

6631

(52.2%)

125 (1.0%) 12709

(100.0%)

Total 6824 5643 8316 22578 437 43798

52

Page 53: Thesis 11.15.11

Parental Social Support

Hₒ11b: There is no association between childhood obesity and parental social support.

ACCEPTED (p value = .286)

Is there someone that you can turn to for day-to-day emotional help with parenthood/raising

children?

Definitely and

somewhat agree

Somewhat and

definitely disagreeTotal

Underweight and

Healthy Weight

28313 (92.1%) 2444 (7.9%) 30757 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese 11505 (91.7%) 1035 (8.3%) 12540 (100.0%)

Total 39818 3479 43297

53

Page 54: Thesis 11.15.11

Parental Stress Coping Skills

Hₒ11c: There is no association between childhood obesity and parental stress coping skills.

ACCEPTED (p value = .744)

In general, how well do you feel you are coping with the day to day demands of

parenthood/raising children?

Very well and

somewhat well

Not very well and not

very well at allTotal

Underweight and

Healthy Weight

30739 (98.5%) 479 (1.5%) 31218 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese 12547 (98.4%) 201 (1.6%) 12748 (100.0%)

Total 43286 680 43966

54

Page 55: Thesis 11.15.11

Parent-Child Relationship Status

Hₒ11d: There is no association between childhood obesity and parent-child relationship status.

ACCEPTED (p value = .202)

How well can you and your child share ideas or talk about things that really matter?

Very well and

somewhat well

Not very well and not

very well at allTotal

Underweight and

Healthy Weight

21289 (97.5%) 550 (2.5%) 21839 (100.0%)

Overweight and Obese 8732 (97.2%) 249 (2.8%) 8981 (100.0%)

Total 30021 799 30820

55

Page 56: Thesis 11.15.11

Conclusions of NSCH Variables56

Not Addressed Needs Improvements Addressed

Page 57: Thesis 11.15.11

Conclusions

NSCH has room for growth

NSCH has a narrow scope of variables measured that are predictive childhood obesity risk.

10 out of 25 variables measured adequately

10 out of 25 variables notmeasured adequately

5 out of 25 variables need revisions

57

Page 58: Thesis 11.15.11

DISCUSSION

Strengths Large sample size

Randomized sample size

Large variety of topics

Limitations Random digit dialing

Self reported data

Bias?

Potential for non-response bias exists: the sample interviewed differed from the targeted child population in a systematic fashion

Lack of continuous data for all age groups

58

Page 59: Thesis 11.15.11

RECOMMENDATIONS for Changes to NSCH

Alternate selection method Eliminate SLAITS as selection method

Adding cell phones

Increase variability of sample by over-sampling minorities Hispanic/African American populations

Low income

Housing type

Education Level

All data for all ages Breastfeeding/Age of Weaning

59

Page 60: Thesis 11.15.11

QUESTIONS?60

Page 61: Thesis 11.15.11

References

6. Position of the American Dietetic Association: Promoting and Supporting breastfeeding. (2009) JADA, 1926-

42.

84. Stettler N, Zemel BS, Kumanyika S and Stallings VA. (2002) Infant weight gain and childhood overweight

status in a multicenter cohort study. Pediatrics, 109: 194-9.

85. Sloan S, Gildea A, Stewart M Sneddon H and Iwaniec D. (2007) Early weaning is related to weight and rate of

weight gain in infancy. Child: Care, Health and Development, 34(1): 59-64.

86. Dennison BA, Edmunds LS, Stratton HH, and Pruzek RM. (2006) Rapid weight gain predicts childhood

obesity. Obesity, 14(3): 491-99.

87. Ong KK, Ahmed ML, Emmet PM, Dunger DB and ALSPAC study team. (2000) Association between postnatal

catch-up growth and obesity in childhood: a prospective cohort study. British Medical Journal, 320: 967-71.

88. Mehta KC, Specker BL, Batholmey S, Giddens J and Ho M. (1998) Trial on timing of introduction to solids and

food type on infant growth. Pediatrics, 102: 569-73.

90. Manios Y, Moschonis G, Grammatikaki E, Anastasiadou A and Liarigkovinos T. (2010) Determinants of

childhood obesity and association with maternal perceptions of their children’s weight status: the GENESIS

study. J Am Diet Assoc, 110: 1527-31.

91. Ounsted M and Sleigh G. (1975) The infant’s self-regulation of food intake and weight gain. Difference in

metabolic balance after growth constraint or acceleration in utero. Lancet, 7922: 1393-97.

100. Dewey KG. (2001) Nutrition, growth and complementary feeding of breastfed infant. Pediatr Clin North Am,

48: 87-104.

61

Page 62: Thesis 11.15.11

References

10. Von Kries R, Koletzko B, Sauerwald T, Von Mutius E, Barnert D. (2003) Breastfeeding and obesity: cross

sectional study. BMJ, 319, 147-50.

11. Hedinger ML, Overpeck MD, Kuczmarski RJ, Ruan WJ. (2001) Association between infant breastfeeding and

overweight in young children. JAMA, 285, 2461-506.

12. Moreira P, Padez C, Mourao-Carvalhal R, Rosado V. (2007) Maternal weight gain during pregnancy and

overweight in Portuguese children. International Journal of Obesity, 31, 608-14.

13. Fawzi WW, Forman MR, Levy A, Graubard BI, Naggan L, Berendes HW. (1997) Maternal anthropometry and

infant feeding practices in Israel in relation to growth in infancy: North African Infant Feeding study. Am J

Clin Nutr, 65, 1731-37.

96. Barker DJ. (2007) The origins of the developmental origins theory. J Intern Med, 261: 412-17.

98. Ravelli GP, Stein ZA, and Susser MW. (1976) Obesity in young men after famine exposure in utero and early

infancy. New England J of Med, 295: 349-53.

99. Hales CN and Barker DJ. (2001) The Thrifty Phenotype hypothesis. Br Med Bull, 60: 5-20.

49. Shatenstein B and Ghadirian P. (1997) Influences on diet, health behaviours and their outcomes in select

ethnoclutural and religious groups. Nutrition, 14: 223-30.

48. Hummer RA, Rogers RG, Nam CB, and Elison CG. (1999) Religious involvement and U.S adult mortality.

Demography, 36: 273-85.

46. Kim KH, Sobal J and Wethington E. (2003) Religion and Body weight. International Journal of Obesity, 27:

469-77.

62

Page 63: Thesis 11.15.11

References

59. Lajunen HR, Kaprio J, Keski-Rahkonen A, Rose RJ, Kulkkinen L, Rissanen A, et al. (2009) Genetic and environmental effects on body mass index during adolescence: a prospective study among Finnish twins. Int J Obes, 33: 559-67.

57. Keskitalo K, Silventoinen K, Tuorila H, Perola M, Pietilainen KH, Rissanene A, et al. (2008) Genetic and environmental contribution to food use patterns of young adult twins. Physiol Behav, 93: 235-42.

52. Silventoinen K, Rokholm B, Kaprio J and Sorensen TIA. (2010) The genetic and environmental influences on childhood obesity: a systematic review of twin and adoption studies. International Journal of Obesity, 34: 29-40.

50. Keller KL, Pietrobelli A, Johnson SL and Faith MS. (2006) Maternal restriction of children’s eating and encouragements to eat as the ‘non-shared environment’: a pilot study using the child feeding questionnaire. International Journal of Obesity, 30: 1670-75.

60. Magnus O, Irgens LM, Haug K Mystad W, Skjaerven R and Stoltenberg C. (2006) Cohort Profile: the Norwegian Mother and child cohort study. Int J Epidemiol, 35: 1146-1150.

61. Ystrom E, Nielgel S, Knut-Inge K and Vollrath ME. (2008) The impact of maternal negative affectivity and general self-efficacy on breastfeeding: the Norwegian Mother and child cohort study. J Pediatr, 152: 68-78.

62. Ystrom E, Nielgel S, Knut-Inge K and Vollrath ME. (2005) The impact of maternal negative affectivity on dietary patterns of 18-month-ol children in the Norwegian mother and child cohort study. MaternChild Nutr, 5: 234-42.

63. Kroke A, Strathmann S and Gunther ALB. (2006) Maternal perceptions of her child’s body weight in infancy and early childhood and their relation to body weight status at age 7. Eur J Pediatr, 165: 875-83.

63

Page 64: Thesis 11.15.11

References

64. Francis LA, Hofer SM and Birch LL (2001) Predictors of maternal child-feeding style: maternal and child characteristics. Appetite, 37: 231-43.

68. Birch LL, Fisher JO, and Davison KK. (2003) Learning to overeat: maternal use of restrictive feeding practices promotes girls’ eating in the absence of hunger. Am J Clin Nutr, 78: 215-20.

70. Lindsay AC, Sussner KM, Greaney ML, and Peterson KE. (2011) Latina mothers’ beliefs and practices related to weight status, feeding and the development of child overweight. Public Health Nursing, 28(2): 107-18.

72. Boyington JA, and Johnson AA. (2004) Maternal perception of body size as a determinant of infant adiposity in an African-American community. J Natl Med Assoc, 96: 351-62.

73. Kuang JS, Becerra K, Oda T, Walker E, Xu R, Donohue M, et al. (2007) Parental ability to discriminate the weight status of children: results of a survey. Pediatrics, 120: 112-19.

82. Baughcum AE, Chamberlin LA, Deeks CM, Powers SW and Whitaker RC. (2000) Maternal perceptions of overweight preschool children. Pediatrics, 106: 1380-86.

120. Galvez MP, Pearl M, and Yen IH. Childhood obesity and the Built Environment: A Review of the Literature from 2008-2009. Curr Opin Pediatr, April 2010; 22(2) 202-07.

121. Veugelers P, Sithole F, Zhang S, et al. Neighborhood characteristics in relation to diet, physical activity and overweight of Canadian children. Int J Pediatr Obes, 2008(3); 152-159.

125. Santos MP, Page AS, Cooper AR, et al. Perceptions of the built environment in relation to physical activity in Protuguese adolescents. Health Place, 2009 (15); 548-52.

127. Babey SH, Hastert TA, Yu H, et al. Physcial activity among adolescents. When do parks matter? Am J Prev Med, 2008(34); 345-48.

129. Tester J, Baker R. Making the playfields even: Evaluating the impact of an environmental intervention on park use and physical activity. Prev Med, 2009 (48); 316-20.

64

Page 65: Thesis 11.15.11

References

43. Williams DR and Sternthal MJ. (2007) Spirituality, religion and health; evidence and research directions.

MJA, 186(10): S47-50.

41. Koenig HG, Jays JC, George LK, Blazer DG, Larson DB, and Lanerman LF. (1997) Modeling the cross-sectional

relationships between religious, physical health, social support and depressive symptoms. Am J Geriatr

Psychiatry, 5: 131-44.

17. Anderson PM, Butcher KF, Levine PB (2003). Economic Perspectives on Childhood Obesity. Federal

Reserve Bank of Chicago.

3. Ogden CL, Carroll MD, Curtin LR, Lamb MM, Flegal KM. (2010) Prevalence of High body mass index

in US children and adolescents, 2007-2008. JAMA, 303, 235-275.

65