THE STATE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT / THE UNIVERSITY OF...
Transcript of THE STATE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT / THE UNIVERSITY OF...
THE STATE EDUCATION DEPARTMENT / THE UNIVERSITY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK
Commissioner of Education E-mail: [email protected]
President of the University of the State of New York Twitter:@NYSEDNews 89 Washington Avenue, Room 111 Tel: (518) 474-5844 Albany, New York 12234 Fax: (518) 473-4909
February 28, 2017 Revised – §3012-d Supplemental Form for Alternate SLOs (Material Change) Mr. Michael S. Bonnewell, Superintendent Albion Central School District 324 East Avenue Albion, NY 14411 Dear Superintendent Bonnewell: Congratulations. I am pleased to inform you that the material change you submitted to your currently approved Annual Professional Performance Review (APPR) plan on the Supplemental Form for Alternate SLOs meets the criteria outlined in Subpart 30-3 of the Commissioner’s Regulations and has been approved. As a reminder, we are relying on the certifications and assurances that are part of your approved APPR plan and those found in the Supplemental Form for Alternate SLOs. If any material changes are made to your approved plan, your district/BOCES must submit such material changes to us for approval. Please see the attached notes for further information.
Please be advised that, pursuant to Education Law §3012-d, the Department will be analyzing data supplied by districts, BOCES, and/or schools and may order a corrective action plan if there are unacceptably low correlation results between the Student Performance category and the Teacher Observation or Principal School Visits category, and/or if the teachers’ or principals’ overall ratings and subcomponent scores show little differentiation across educators and/or the lack of differentiation is not justified by equivalently consistent student achievement results, and/or if schools or districts show a pattern of anomalous results in the Student Performance category and/or the Observation/School Visits category.
The New York State Education Department and I look forward to continuing our work together, with the goal of ensuring that every school has world-class educators in the classroom, every teacher has a world-class principal to support his or her professional growth, and every student achieves college and career readiness.
Thank you again for your hard work.
Sincerely,
MaryEllen Elia
Commissioner Attachment
c: Clark J. Godshall
PLEASE NOTE: Pursuant to section 30-3.17 of the Rules of the Board of Regents, during the 2015-16 through 2018-19 school years, your district/BOCES must calculate transition scores and ratings for teachers and principals that exclude the results of grades 3-8 ELA and math State assessments and any State-provided growth scores. During the 2016-17 through 2018-19 school years only, your district/BOCES must use the alternate SLOs described in your “Supplemental Form for Alternate SLOs” which have been incorporated into your approved §3012-d APPR plan for teachers and principals who, as a result of the above exclusions, have no remaining measures in the Student Performance Category. During this transition period, your district/BOCES must also continue to provide affected teachers and principals with their original APPR scores and ratings calculated based on the measures in your currently approved APPR plan without any modifications, substitutions, or replacements as a result of the transition regulations. Original APPR scores and ratings must be used for advisory purposes only and shall have no impact on employment decisions, tenure determinations, or teacher and principal improvement plans. Teachers and principals whose APPRs do not include grades 3-8 ELA and math State assessments or State-provided growth scores are not impacted by the transition regulations. Accordingly, APPR scores and ratings for such staff must be calculated pursuant to your district’s/BOCES’s approved APPR plan without any modifications, and no transition scores and ratings need be generated. The transition period will end at the conclusion of the 2018-2019 school year. Beginning in the 2019-20 school year, each educator will receive only a single set of scores and ratings pursuant to the measures outlined in your district’s/BOCES APPR plan. Only documents that are incorporated by reference in your APPR have been reviewed and are considered as part of your APPR; therefore, any supplemental documents such as memorandums of agreement or understanding that were uploaded with your APPR but are not incorporated by reference in your APPR have not been reviewed. However, the Department reserves the right to review the uploaded attachments at any time for consistency with your APPR plan and/or to ensure compliance with applicable laws and regulations; and as a result of such review, the Department may reject your APPR plan and/or require corrective action.
ALBION CSD Status Date: 02/28/2017 10:39 AM
Annual Professional Performance Review - Supplemental Form for AlternateSupplemental Form Directions - Directions
Page Last Modified: 02/28/2017
Directions
As an alternative to completing this Supplemental Form for Alternate SLOs, a district/BOCES may open their APPR plan and include the relevant
information in Task 2 (Transition) and Task 7 (Transition).
To open your approved APPR plan, please contact [email protected].
Pursuant to section 30-3.17 of the Rules of the Board of Regents, during the 2015-16 through 2018-19 school years, your district/BOCES must calculate
transition scores and ratings for teachers and principals that exclude the results of grades 3-8 English Language Arts (ELA) and Math State assessments and any
State-provided growth scores. During the 2016-17 through 2018-19 school years only, alternate student learning objectives (SLOs) must be generated to
calculate transition scores and ratings for teachers and principals who have no remaining Student Performance Category measures as a result of the above
exclusions. Please note that districts/BOCES must also continue to provide affected teachers and principals with their original APPR scores and ratings
calculated based on the measures in their currently approved APPR plan without any modifications, substitutions, or replacements as a result of the transition
regulations during the transition period. Original APPR scores and ratings must be used for advisory purposes only and shall have no impact on employment
decisions, tenure determinations, or teacher and principal improvement plans.
Teachers and principals whose APPRs do not include grades 3-8 ELA and math State assessments or State-provided growth scores are not impacted by the
transition regulations and their evaluations shall be calculated pursuant to their district’s/BOCES’ approved APPR Plan without any changes, and no transition
scores and ratings need to be generated.
This supplemental form must be completed by districts/BOCES whose Education Law §3012-d Annual Professional Performance Review (APPR) plans were
approved by the Department for use beginning in the 2015- 16 school year in order to specify the alternate SLOs, as described above, that will be used for
applicable teachers and principals during the remainder of the transition period (i.e., the 2016-17 through 2018-19 school years). Beginning in the 2019-20
school year, districts and BOCES will no longer be required to calculate transition scores and ratings, and will only calculate a single set of scores and ratings
for each educator pursuant to the measures and assessments outlined in their approved §3012-d APPR plan. For more information please see the December
2015 Board of Regents item at http://www.regents.nysed.gov/common/regents/files/1215bra10.pdf, and the Department’s Frequently Asked Questions
Guidance document regarding sections 30-2.14 and 30-3.17 of the Rules of the Board of Regents on EngageNY at
https://www.engageny.org/resource/guidance-on-new-york-sannual-professional-performance-review-law-and-regulations.
This form must be completed and submitted no later than March 1, 2017 for the 2016-17 school year. Please note that if your district/BOCES wishes to make
changes to the measures and assessments used for the alternate SLOs in future school years, you must submit this form on or before March 1 of the school year
in which the changes will take effect. The Department will not accept late submissions of this form.
Upon submission, the Department will only review the information included on this supplemental form and no other portions of the APPR plan will be
reviewed by the Department for compliance with Education Law §3012- d. Therefore, it is the responsibility of the district/BOCES to assure that the changes
requested in this form will not have an impact on the implementation of any other part of their approved APPR plan since the Department will not be reviewing
the remaining portions of the approved APPR plan for compliance with Education Law §3012-d. The Department recommends that districts/BOCES consult
with their local counsel before submitting this supplemental form or any material changes to their currently approved plan in the APPR Portal.
02/28/2017 10:39 AM Page 1 of 6
ALBION CSD Status Date: 02/28/2017 10:39 AM
Annual Professional Performance Review - Supplemental Form for AlternateTask 2. Transition Student Performance - Required (Teachers) - Task 2 Alternate SLOs
Page Last Modified: 02/28/2017
Task 2) Required Student Performance Subcomponent (Transition Period, 2016-17 through 2018-19)
Please note: Clicking 'Save' or 'Save & Continue' will alter the last date modified timestamp for this page. As a reminder, the Statement of Assurances
must be signed and dated after the latest timestamp on each page in order for this application to be approved. You may use the survey navigation
on the left to move directly to the Statement of Assurances page.
The measures indicated in this section only apply during the 2016-17 through 2018-19 school years.
For guidance on the Required subcomponent of the Student Performance category, see NYSED APPR Guidance: https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-
3012-d.
For guidance on the use of alternate SLOs during the transition period, see: https://www.engageny.org/resource/guidance-on-new-york-s-annual-professional-
performance-review-law-and-regulations.
During the 2016-17 through 2018-19 school years, pursuant to the requirements of §30-3.17 of the Rules of the Board of Regents, grades 3-8 NYS
ELA/math assessments and any State-provided growth scores may only be used for advisory purposes and may not be used for the purpose of
calculating transition scores and ratings.
If grades 3-8 ELA/math State assessments and any State-provided growth scores are the entirety of the Student Performance category, districts/BOCES must
also develop an alternate SLO based on assessments that are not grade 3-8 ELA/math State assessments and/or on State-provided growth scores for the
Required subcomponent of the Student Performance category during the transition to higher standards through new State assessments aligned to revised
learning standards and a revised State-approved growth model.
2.2-2.10) Alternate SLOs (Transition Period, 2016-17 through 2018-19)
Using the table below, please first select a measure and assessment(s) that will be used for the alternate SLO
during the 2016-17 through 2018-19 school years, then indicate the applicable courses.
Measure State or Regents
Assessment(s)
Locally-Developed Course-
Specific Assessment(s)
Third Party
Assessment(s)
Applicable
Course(s)
District- or BOCES-
wide results
Common Core
English
Common Core
Algebra
Living Environment
Global 2
US History
3 ELA
3 Math
4 ELA
4 Math
5 ELA
5 Math
6 ELA
6 Math
7 ELA
7 Math
8 ELA
8 Math 2.11) HEDI Scoring Bands
Highly Effective Effective Developing Ineffective
20 19 18
97-
100
%
93-
96
%
90-
92
%
17 16 15
85-
89
%
80-
84
%
75-
79
%
14 13
67-
74
%
60-
66
%
12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
55-
59
%
49-
54
%
44-
48
%
39-
43
%
34-
38
%
29-
33
%
25-
28
%
21-
24
%
17-
20
%
13-
16
%
9-
12
%
5-
8%
0-
4%
02/28/2017 10:39 AM Page 2 of 6
ALBION CSD Status Date: 02/28/2017 10:39 AM
Annual Professional Performance Review - Supplemental Form for AlternateTask 2. Transition Student Performance - Required (Teachers) - Task 2 Alternate SLOs
Page Last Modified: 02/28/2017
2.12) Teachers with More Than One Growth Measure (Transition)
For more information on teachers with more than one growth measure, please see NYSED APPR Guidance and NYSED SLO
Guidance: https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
If educators have more than one alternate SLO, the measures will each earn a score from 0-20 points which districts/BOCES must weight proportionately based
on the number of students in each SLO.
Please Note
Clicking 'Save' or 'Save & Continue' will alter the last date modified timestamp for this page. As a reminder, the Statement of Assurances must be
signed and dated after the latest timestamp on each page in order for this application to be approved. You may use the survey navigation on the left to
move directly to the Statement of Assurances page.
02/28/2017 10:39 AM Page 3 of 6
ALBION CSD Status Date: 02/28/2017 10:39 AM
Annual Professional Performance Review - Supplemental Form for AlternateTask 7. Transition Student Performance - Required (Principals) - Task 7 Alternate SLOs
Page Last Modified: 02/28/2017
Task 7) Required Student Performance Subcomponent (Transition Period, 2016-17 through 2018-19)
Please note: Clicking 'Save' or 'Save & Continue' will alter the last date modified timestamp for this page. As a reminder, the Statement of Assurances
must be signed and dated after the latest timestamp on each page in order for this application to be approved. You may use the survey navigation
on the left to move directly to the Statement of Assurances page.
The measures indicated in this section only apply during the 2016-17 through 2018-19 school years.
For guidance on the Required subcomponent of the Student Performance category, see NYSED APPR Guidance: https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-
3012-d.
For guidance on the use of alternate SLOs during the transition period, see: https://www.engageny.org/resource/guidance-on-new-york-s-annual-professional-
performance-review-law-and-regulations.
During the 2016-17 through 2018-19 school years, pursuant to the requirements of §30-3.17 of the Rules of the Board of Regents, if excluding grade 3-
8 ELA/math State assessments and any State-provided growth scores results in no remaining student performance measures, districts/BOCES must
develop alternate SLOs based on assessments that are not grade 3-8 ELA/math State assessments for the Required subcomponent of the Student
Performance Category during the transition to higher standards through new State assessments aligned to revised learning standards and a revised
State-approved growth model.
7.1-7.2) Alternate SLOs (Transition Period, 2016-17 through 2018-19)
Please list the grade configurations of the schools or principals where alternate SLOs will apply. For each configuration, also indicate the measure
and assessment(s) used for the alternate SLO.
For each grade configuration indicate the following:
• Column 1: lowest grade that corresponds to the building or program
• Column 2: highest grade that corresponds to the building or program
• Column 3: measure used
• Column 4: assessment(s) used
Follow the examples below.
(1) lowest grade (2) highest grade (3) measure (4) assessment(s)
Grades K-2 Building K 2District- or BOCES-wide
results
Common Core English,
Common Core Algebra,
Living Environment, Global
2, US History
Grades 11-12 Building 11 12 Principal-specific resultsCommon Core English, US
History
Using the table below, please select the assessment(s) that will be used for the alternate SLOs during the 2016-17
through 2018-19 school years for each grade configuration listed. In all other school years, the SLO will be based
on the largest grades/courses in the principal’s school building, using State or Regents assessments as the
underlying evidence for such SLOs where they exist.
02/28/2017 10:39 AM Page 4 of 6
ALBION CSD Status Date: 02/28/2017 10:39 AM
Annual Professional Performance Review - Supplemental Form for AlternateTask 7. Transition Student Performance - Required (Principals) - Task 7 Alternate SLOs
Page Last Modified: 02/28/2017
Grade
From
Grade To Measure State or Regents
Assessment(s)
Locally-Developed
Course-
Specific Assessment(s)
Third Party
Assessment(s)
K 5 District- or BOCES-wide results Common
Core English
Common
Core Algebra
Living
Environment
Global 2
US History
6 8 District- or BOCES-wide results Common
Core English
Common
Core Algebra
Living
Environment
Global 2
US History 7.3) HEDI Scoring Bands
Highly Effective Effective Developing Ineffective
20 19 18
97-
100
%
93-
96
%
90-
92
%
17 16 15
85-
89
%
80-
84
%
75-
79
%
14 13
67-
74
%
60-
66
%
12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
55-
59
%
49-
54
%
44-
48
%
39-
43
%
34-
38
%
29-
33
%
25-
28
%
21-
24
%
17-
20
%
13-
16
%
9-
12
%
5-
8%
0-
4%
7.4) Principals with More than One Growth Measure (Transition)
For more information on principals with more than one growth measure, please see NYSED APPR Guidance and SLO
Guidance: https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
If educators have more than one alternate SLO, the measures will each earn a score from 0-20 points which districts/BOCES must weight proportionately based
on the number of students in each SLO.
Please Note
Clicking 'Save' or 'Save & Continue' will alter the last date modified timestamp for this page. As a reminder, the Statement of Assurances must be
signed and dated after the latest timestamp on each page in order for this application to be approved. You may use the survey navigation on the left to
move directly to the Statement of Assurances page.
02/28/2017 10:39 AM Page 5 of 6
ALBION CSD Status Date: 02/28/2017 10:39 AM
Annual Professional Performance Review - Supplemental Form for AlternateStatement of Assurances - Upload Statement of Assurances
Page Last Modified: 02/28/2017
Upload Statement of Assurances
Please Note: SED Monitoring timestamps each page revision individually and signatures cannot be dated earlier than the last revision. Clicking 'Save' or
'Save & Continue' on any page will alter the last date modified timestamp for that page.
Please obtain the required signatures, create a PDF file, and upload your joint certification of the APPR Plan using
this form: Supplemental Form Statement of Assurances.
APPR Certification 2-28-17.pdf
02/28/2017 10:39 AM Page 6 of 6
1of2
AnnualProfessionalPerformanceReviewTask1.SchoolDistrictInformationCreated:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:10/01/2015
ForguidancerelatedtoAnnualProfessionalPerformanceReviewplans,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Task1.SchoolDistrictInformation
Disclaimers
TheDepartmentwillreviewthecontentsofeachschooldistrict's/BOCES'AnnualProfessionalPerformanceReview(APPR)planassubmittedusingthisonlineform,includingrequiredattachments,todetermineiftheplanrigorouslycomplieswithEducationLaw§3012-dandSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.Departmentapprovaldoesnotimplyendorsementofspecificeducationalapproachesinadistrict's/BOCES'plan.
TheDepartmentreservestherighttorequestfurtherinformationfromadistrict/BOCEStomonitorcompliancewithEducationLaw§3012-dandSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.Assuch,eachdistrict/BOCESisrequiredtokeepdetailedrecordsonfileforeachsectionofthecurrentlyimplementedAPPRplan.SuchdetailedrecordsmustbeprovidedtotheDepartmentuponrequest.TheDepartmentreservestherighttodisapproveorrequiremodificationofadistrict's/BOCESplanthatdoesnotrigorouslyadheretotherequirementsofEducationLaw§3012-dandSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.
TheDepartmentwillnotreviewanyattachmentsotherthanthoserequiredintheonlineform.Anyadditionalattachmentssuppliedbytheschooldistrict/BOCESareforinformationalpurposesonlyfortheteachersandprincipalsreviewedunderthisAPPRplan.Statementsand/ormaterialsinsuchadditionalattachmentshavenotbeenapprovedand/orendorsedbytheDepartment.However,theDepartmentconsidersvoidanyothersignedagreementsbetweenandamongpartiesinanyformthatprevent,conflict,orinterferewithfullimplementationoftheAPPRPlanapprovedbytheDepartment.TheDepartmentalsoreservestherighttorequestfurtherinformationfromtheschooldistrict/BOCES,asnecessary,aspartofitsreviewofthisplan.
IftheDepartmentreasonablybelievesthroughinvestigation,orotherwise,thatstatementsmadeinthisAPPRplanarenottrueoraccurate,itreservestherighttorejectthisplanatanytimeand/ortorequestadditionalinformationtodeterminethetruthand/oraccuracyofsuchstatements.
1.1)SchoolDistrict'sBEDSNumber:450101060000
IfthisisnotyourBEDSNumber,pleaseenterthecorrectonebelow
450101060000
1.2)SchoolDistrictName:ALBIONCSD
Ifthisisnotyourschooldistrict,pleaseenterthecorrectonebelow
ALBIONCSD
1.3)Assurances
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
2of2
Assurethatthecontentofthisformrepresentsthedistrict's/BOCES'entireAPPRplanandthattheAPPRplanisincompliancewithEducationLaw§3012-dandSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.
Checked
Assurethatadetailedversionofthedistrict's/BOCES’entireAPPRplaniskeptonfileandthatacopyofsuchplanwillbeprovidedtotheDepartmentuponrequestforreviewofcompliancewithEducationLaw§3012-dandSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.
Checked
AssurethatthisAPPRplanwillbepostedonthedistrict/BOCESwebsitenolaterthanSeptember10thofeachschoolyear,orwithin10daysaftertheplan’sapprovalbytheCommissioner,whichevershalllateroccur.
Checked
Assurethatitisunderstoodthatthisdistrict's/BOCES'APPRplanwillbepostedinitsentiretyontheNYSEDwebsitefollowingapproval.
Checked
1.4)SubmissionStatus
Isthisafirst-timesubmissionunderEducationLaw§3012-dorthesubmissionofmaterialchangestoanAPPRplanapprovedpursuanttoEducationLaw§3012-d?Fordistricts,BOCESorcharterschoolsthatdidhaveanexistingapprovedAPPRplanunderEducationLaw§3012-d,thismustbelistedasasubmissionofmaterialchangestotheapprovedAPPRplan.
First-timesubmissionunderEducationLaw§3012-d
1of14
Task2.StudentPerformance-RequiredSubcomponent(Teachers)Created:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:10/26/2015
UsethelinksabovetomovebetweenpagesinTask2;besuretoclick'Save&ContinueEditing'beforemovingtoanotherpage.The'Next'buttonatthebottomofthepagecanbeusedtomoveforwardonlywhenthecurrentpageiscomplete.ForguidanceontheRequiredsubcomponentoftheStudentPerformancecategory,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Page1:Task2.1,Task2.2(4-8ELAandMath)
Page1:Task2.1(Assurances)andTask2.2(4-8ELAandMath)
REQUIREDSUBCOMPONENT
(100%ofStudentPerformancecategoryifonlytheRequiredsubcomponentisusedoratleast50%whenusedwiththe
Optionalsubcomponent)
(A)ForateacherwhosecourseendsinaState-createdoradministeredtestforwhichthereisaState-provided
growthmodelandatleast50%ofateacher’sstudentsarecoveredundertheState-providedgrowthmeasure,such
teachershallhaveaState-providedgrowthscorebasedonsuchmodel.
(B)ForateacherwhosecoursedoesnotendinaState-createdoradministeredtestorwherelessthan50%ofthe
teacher’sstudentsarecoveredbyaState-providedgrowthmeasure,suchteachershallhaveaStudentLearning
Objective(SLO)developedandapprovedbyhis/hersuperintendentoranothertrainedadministrator,usingaform
prescribedbytheCommissioner,consistentwiththeSLOprocessdeterminedordevelopedbytheCommissioner,
thatresultsinastudentgrowthscore;providedthat,foranyteacherwhosecourseendsinaState-createdor
administeredassessmentforwhichthereisnoState-providedgrowthmodel,suchassessmentmustbeusedas
theunderlyingassessmentforsuchSLO.
2.1)Assurances
Pleasechecktheboxesbelow:
AssurethatthegrowthscoreprovidedbyNYSEDwillbeused,whererequired.
Checked
Assurethatback-upSLOswillbesetbythesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministratorforall4-8ELAandMathteachersintheeventthataState-providedgrowthscorecannotbegeneratedforthatteacher.
Checked
Foranygrade/subjectthatrequiresaback-upSLO,butforwhichtherearenotenoughstudents,notenoughscores,ordataissuesthatpreventateacher-specificSLOfrombeingcreated,thesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministratorshalldevelopaschool-wideback-upSLOusingavailableState/Regentsassessments.
Checked
STATE-PROVIDEDMEASURESOFSTUDENTGROWTH
Forteachersingrades4-8CommonBranch,ELA,andMath,NYSEDwillprovideagrowthscoreandrating.Thatratingwillincorporatestudents'academichistorycomparedtosimilarlyacademicallyachievingstudentsandtakesintoconsiderationstudentswithdisabilities,English
2of14
languagelearners,studentsinpoverty,and,inthefuture,anyotherstudent-,classroom-,andschool-levelcharacteristicsapprovedbytheBoardofRegents.Whilemostteachersof4-8CommonBranch,ELAandMathwillhaveState-providedscoresandratings,somemayteachothercourseswherethereisnoState-providedgrowthmeasure.Teacherswith50–100%ofstudentscoveredbyState-providedgrowthmeasureswillreceiveagrowthscoreandratingfromtheStateforthefullStudentPerformancecategoryoftheirevaluation.Teacherswith0–49%ofstudentscoveredbyState-providedgrowthmeasuresmusthaveSLOsfortheStudentPerformancecategoryoftheirevaluationandoneSLOmustusetheState-providedmeasureifapplicableforanycourses.(SeeAPPRGuidanceandSLOGuidanceformoredetailonteacherswithState-providedgrowthmeasuresandSLOs.)
ForthoseteacherswhowouldtypicallyreceiveaState-providedgrowthscore,thedistrict/BOCESmustalsoincludeaback-upSLOprocessintheeventthattherearenotenoughstudents,notenoughscores,ordataissuesthatpreventaState-providedgrowthscorefrombeingcalculatedforthatteacher.
2.2)Grades4-8ELAandMath:Assessments
Usingthedrop-downboxesbelow,pleaseselecttheassessmentthatwillbeusedfortheback-upSLOsforthegrade/subjectlisted.
Pleasenote:Ifyourdistrict/BOCESdoesnothavegrade/subject-specificteachersforoneormoreoftherowsintask2.2,choose"NotApplicable"fromthedrop-downbox.Thiswouldbeappropriateif,forexample,thedistrict/BOCESdoesnothavecertaingrades;thedistrict/BOCESdoesnotofferaspecificsubject;etc.Ifagrade/subjectendsinaStateassessment,i.e.,4-8ELAorMath,suchassessmentmustbeusedastheunderlyingevidencefortheSLO.
Grade4ELAAssessmentName
NYSGrade4ELAAssessment
Grade5ELAAssessmentName
NYSGrade5ELAAssessment
Grade6ELAAssessmentName
NYSGrade6ELAAssessment
Grade7ELAAssessmentName
NYSGrade7ELAAssessment
Grade8ELAAssessmentName
NYSGrade8ELAAssessment
Grade4MathAssessmentName
NYSGrade4MathAssessment
Grade5MathAssessmentName
NYSGrade5MathAssessment
3of14
Grade6MathAssessmentName
NYSGrade6MathAssessment
Grade7MathAssessmentName
NYSGrade7MathAssessment
Grade8MathAssessmentName
NYSGrade8MathAssessment
Page2:Task2.3(3ELAandMath),Task2.4(4and8Science)
Page2:Task2.3(3ELAandMath)andTask2.4(4and8Science)
STUDENTLEARNINGOBJECTIVES:CoursesEndingwithStateAssessmentsorRegentsExams
SLOsaretherequiredstudentperformancemeasureforteacherswhodonotreceiveaState-providedgrowthscore.(Pleasenotethatforteacherswithmorethanonegradeandsubject,SLOsmustcoverthecoursestaughtwiththelargestnumberofstudents,combiningsectionswithcommonassessments,untilamajorityofstudentsarecovered.)ForguidanceonSLOs,seeNYSEDSLOGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Forgrade3ELAandmath,grade4and8science,highschoolmath,science,andsocialstudiescoursesassociatedwithRegentsexamsor,inthefuture,withotherStateassessments,thefollowingmustbeusedastheevidenceofstudentlearningwithintheSLOforstudentstakingsuchassessments::
Stateassessments(orRegentsorRegentequivalents),requiredifoneexists
2.3)Grade3ELAandMath:Assessments
Usingthedrop-downboxesbelow,pleaseselecttheassessmentthatwillbeusedfortheSLOsforthegrade/subjectlisted.
Pleasenote:Ifyourdistrict/BOCESdoesnothavegrade/subject-specificteachersforoneormoreoftherowsintask2.3,choose"NotApplicable"fromthedrop-downbox.Thiswouldbeappropriateif,forexample,thedistrict/BOCESdoesnothavecertaingrades;thedistrict/BOCESdoesnotofferaspecificsubject;etc.Ifagrade/subjectendsinaStateassessment,i.e.,grade3ELAorMath,suchassessmentmustbeusedastheunderlyingevidencefortheSLO.
Grade3ELAAssessmentName
NYSGrade3ELAAssessment
Grade3MathAssessmentName
NYSGrade3MathAssessment
2.4)Grades4and8Science:Assessment(s)
Usingthedrop-downboxbelow,pleaseselecttheassessmentthatwillbeusedfortheSLOsforthegrade/subjectlisted.
4of14
Pleasenote:Ifyourdistrict/BOCESdoesnothavegrade/subject-specificteachersforoneormoreoftherowsintask2.4,choose"NotApplicable"fromthedrop-downbox.Thiswouldbeappropriateif,forexample,thedistrict/BOCESdoesnothavecertaingrades;thedistrict/BOCESdoesnotofferaspecificsubject;etc.Ifagrade/subjectendsinaStateassessment,i.e.,grade8Science,suchassessmentmustbeusedastheunderlyingevidencefortheSLO.
Grade4ScienceAssessmentName
NYSGrade4ScienceAssessment
Grade8ScienceAssessmentName
NYSGrade8ScienceAssessmentandLivingEnvironmentRegents
Page3:Task2.5(HSCoursesEndinginaRegents),Task2.6(HSELA)
Page3:Task2.5(HighSchoolCoursesEndinginaRegentsExam)andTask2.6(HighSchoolELA)
STUDENTLEARNINGOBJECTIVES:CoursesEndingwithStateAssessmentsorRegentsExams
SLOsaretherequiredstudentperformancemeasureforteacherswhodonotreceiveaState-providedgrowthscore.(Pleasenotethatforteacherswithmorethanonegradeandsubject,SLOsmustcoverthecoursestaughtwiththelargestnumberofstudents,combiningsectionswithcommonassessments,untilamajorityofstudentsarecovered.)ForguidanceonSLOs,seeNYSEDSLOGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Forgrade3ELAandmath,grade4and8science,highschoolmath,science,andsocialstudiescoursesassociatedwithRegentsexamsor,inthefuture,withotherStateassessments,thefollowingmustbeusedastheevidenceofstudentlearningwithintheSLOforstudentstakingsuchassessments:
Stateassessments(orRegentsorRegentequivalents),requiredifoneexists
2.5)HighSchoolCoursesEndinginaRegentsExam:Assessments
Note:Additionalhighschoolcoursesmaybelistedbelowinthe“AllOtherCourses”sectionofthisform.
Usingthedrop-downboxesbelow,pleaseselecttheassessmentthatwillbeusedfortheSLOsforthegrade/subjectlisted.
Pleasenote:Ifyourdistrict/BOCESdoesnothavegrade/subject-specificteachersforoneormoreoftherowsintask2.5,choose"NotApplicable"fromthedrop-downbox.Thiswouldbeappropriateif,forexample,thedistrict/BOCESdoesnothavecertaingrades;thedistrict/BOCESdoesnotofferaspecificsubject;etc.Ifagrade/subjectendsinaRegentsassessment,i.e.,highschoolRegentscourses,suchassessmentmustbeusedastheunderlyingevidencefortheSLO.
Global2AssessmentName
Global2Regents
USHistoryAssessmentName
USHistoryRegents
LivingEnvironmentAssessmentName
5of14
LivingEnvironmentRegents
EarthScienceAssessmentName
EarthScienceRegents
ChemistryAssessmentName
ChemistryRegents
PhysicsAssessmentName
PhysicsRegents
AlgebraIAssessmentName
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
GeometryAssessmentName
CommonCoreGeometryRegentsandGeometryRegents
AlgebraII/TrigonometryAssessmentName
CommonCoreAlgebraIIRegentsandAlgebraII/TrigonometryRegents
STUDENTLEARNINGOBJECTIVES:HighSchoolEnglishLanguageArts
SLOsshallbeusedfortherequiredstudentperformancemeasureforteacherswhodonotreceiveaState-providedgrowthscore.(Pleasenotethatforteacherswithmorethanonegradeandsubject,SLOsmustcoverthecoursestaughtwiththelargestnumberofstudents,combiningsectionswithcommonassessments,untilamajorityofstudentsarecovered.)
ForhighschoolEnglishLanguageArts,thefollowingmustbeusedastheevidenceofstudentlearningwithintheSLO:
Stateassessments(orRegentsorRegentequivalents),requiredinatleastoneyearofhighschoolEnglishLanguageArts
ForgradelevelswheretheRegentsexamisnotused:
District-determinedassessmentsfromlistofState-approved3rdpartyassessments;orState-approveddistrict,regionalorBOCES-developedassessments;orSchool-orBOCES-wide,group,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
2.6)HighSchoolEnglishLanguageArtsCourses:MeasuresandAssessments
Usingthedrop-downboxesbelow,pleaseselectthemeasurethatwillbeusedforSLOsforthegrade/subjectlisted.Onceameasureisselected,acorrespondingmenuwillappearfortheselectionofthenameoftheassessment(s)used.
Note:AdditionalhighschoolEnglishLanguageArtscoursesmaybelistedbelowinthe“AllOtherCourses”sectionofthisform.
Pleasenote:Ifyourdistrict/BOCESdoesnothavegrade/subject-specificteachersforoneormoreoftherowsinquestions2.6,choose"Not
6of14
Applicable"fromthedrop-downbox.Thiswouldbeappropriateif,forexample,thedistrict/BOCESdoesnothavecertaingrades;thedistrict/BOCESdoesnotofferaspecificsubject;etc.
Grade9ELAMeasure
School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessment
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade9ELAschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Grade10ELAMeasure
School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessment
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade10ELAschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Grade11ELAMeasure
Regentsassessment
Grade11ELARegentsAssessmentName
CommonCoreEnglishandComprehensiveEnglishRegents
Grade12ELAMeasure
School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessment
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade12ELAschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState
7of14
assessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Page4:Task2.7(K-2ELAandMath)
Page4:Task2.7(K-2ELAandMath)
STUDENTLEARNINGOBJECTIVES:CourseswithoutStateAssessmentsorRegentsExams
SLOsshallbeusedfortherequiredstudentperformancemeasureforteacherswhodonotreceiveaState-providedgrowthscore.(Pleasenotethatforteacherswithmorethanonegradeandsubject,SLOsmustcoverthecoursestaughtwiththelargestnumberofstudents,combiningsectionswithcommonassessments,untilamajorityofstudentsarecovered.)
Forothergrades/subjects:district-determinedassessmentsfromoptionsbelowmaybeusedasevidenceofstudentlearningwithintheSLO:
State-approvednon-traditionalstandardized3rdpartyassessments(gradesK-2)State-approveddistrict,regionalorBOCES-developedassessmentsSchool-orBOCES-wide,group,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
2.7)GradeK-2ELAandMath:MeasuresandAssessments
Usingthedrop-downboxesbelow,pleaseselectthemeasurethatwillbeusedforSLOsforthegrade/subjectlisted.Onceameasureisselected,acorrespondingmenuwillappearfortheselectionofthenameoftheassessment(s)used.
Pleasenote:Ifyourdistrict/BOCESdoesnothavegrade/subject-specificteachersforoneormoreoftherowsinquestions2.7,choose"NotApplicable"fromthedrop-downbox.Thiswouldbeappropriateif,forexample,commonbranchteachersalsoteach6thgradescienceand/orsocialstudiesandthereforewouldhaveState-providedgrowthmeasures;thedistrict/BOCESdoesnothavecertaingrades;thedistrict/BOCESdoesnotofferaspecificsubject;etc.
GradeKELAMeasure
School,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedfortheKELAschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
8of14
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Grade1ELAMeasure
School,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthe1ELAschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Grade2ELAMeasure
School,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade2ELAschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
GradeKMathMeasure
School,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegradeKmathschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
9of14
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Grade1MathMeasure
School,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade1mathschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Grade2MathMeasure
School,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade2mathschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Page5:Task2.8(Grades6-7Science,6-8SocialStudies),Task2.9(Global1)
Page5:Task2.8(Grades6-7Scienceand6-8SocialStudies)andTask2.9(GlobalStudies1)
STUDENTLEARNINGOBJECTIVES:CourseswithoutStateAssessmentsorRegentsExams
SLOsshallbeusedfortherequiredstudentperformancemeasureforteacherswhodonotreceiveaState-providedgrowthscore.(Pleasenotethatforteacherswithmorethanonegradeandsubject,SLOsmustcoverthecoursestaughtwiththelargestnumberofstudents,combiningsectionswithcommonassessments,untilamajorityofstudentsarecovered.)
Forothergrades/subjects:district-determinedassessmentsfromoptionsbelowmaybeusedasevidenceofstudentlearningwithintheSLO:
State-approved3rdpartyassessments
10of14
State-approveddistrict,regionalorBOCES-developedassessmentsSchool-orBOCES-wide,group,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
2.8)Grades6-7ScienceandGrades6-8SocialStudies:MeasuresandAssessments
Usingthedrop-downboxesbelow,pleaseselectthemeasurethatwillbeusedforSLOsforthegrade/subjectlisted.Onceameasureisselected,acorrespondingmenuwillappearfortheselectionofthenameoftheassessment(s)used.
Pleasenote:Ifyourdistrict/BOCESdoesnothavegrade/subject-specificteachersforoneormoreoftherowsinquestions2.8,choose"NotApplicable"fromthedrop-downbox.Thiswouldbeappropriateif,forexample,commonbranchteachersalsoteach6thgradescienceand/orsocialstudiesandthereforewouldhaveState-providedgrowthmeasures;thedistrict/BOCESdoesnothavecertaingrades;thedistrict/BOCESdoesnotofferaspecificsubject;etc.
Grade6ScienceMeasure
School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade6scienceschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Grade7ScienceMeasure
School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade7scienceschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Grade6SocialStudiesMeasure
School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
11of14
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade6socialstudiesschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Grade7SocialStudiesMeasure
School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade7socialstudiesschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Grade8SocialStudiesMeasure
School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedforthegrade8socialstudiesschool,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
2.9)RegentsGlobalStudies1:MeasuresandAssessments
Note:Additionalhighschoolsocialstudiescoursesmaybelistedbelowinthe“AllOtherCourses”sectionofthisform.Onceameasureis
12of14
selected,acorrespondingmenuwillappearfortheselectionofthenameoftheassessment(s)used.
Usingthedrop-downboxesbelow,pleaseselecttheassessmentthatwillbeusedforSLOsforthegrade/subjectlisted.
Pleasenote:Ifyourdistrict/BOCESdoesnothavegrade/subject-specificteachersforoneormoreoftherowsinquestions2.9,choose"NotApplicable"fromthedrop-downbox.Thiswouldbeappropriateif,forexample,thedistrict/BOCESdoesnothavecertaingrades;thedistrict/BOCESdoesnotofferaspecificsubject;etc.
Global1Measure
School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedfortheGlobal1school,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
Page6:Task2.10(AllOtherCourses),Tasks2.11-2.14
Page6:Task2.10(AllOtherCourses),Task2.11(HEDIScoringBands),Task2.12(TeacherswithMoreThanOneGrowth
Measure),Task2.13(Assurances)andTask2.14(UseoftheOptionalSubcomponentandStudentPerformanceCategory
Weighting)
2.10)AllOtherCourses
Fillin,asapplicable,forallotherteachersinadditionalgrades/subjectsthathaveSLOs.Ifyouneedadditionalspace,duplicatethisformandupload(below)asanattachmenttoyourAPPRplan.Youmaycombineintoonelineanygroupsofteachersforwhomtheanswersintheboxesarethesameincluding,forexample,"allotherteachersnotnamedabove".
For"AllOtherCourses"indicatethefollowing:
Column1:lowestgradethatcorrespondstothecourseColumn2:highestgradethatcorrespondstothecourseColumn3:subjectofthecourseColumn4:measureusedOnceameasureisselected,acorrespondingmenuwillappearfortheselectionofthename(s)oftheassessment(s)used.
Todesignate"AllCoursesNotNamedAbove":lowestgrade=K,highestgrade=12,subject=AllCoursesNotNamedAbove
Tolistspecificcourses,followtheexamplesbelowK-3Art:
lowestgrade=Khighestgrade=3subject=Artmeasure=State-approveddistrict,regional,orBOCESdevelopedassessment
13of14
assessment=DistrictA-developedK-3ArtAssessment
Grades9-12EnglishElectives:
lowestgrade=9highestgrade=12subject=EnglishElectivesmeasure=School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessmentassessment=CommonCoreEnglishRegents
OtherCourses#1Grade(s),SubjectandMeasure
LOWESTGRADE HIGHESTGRADE SUBJECT MEASURE
K 12Allcoursesnotnamedabove
School-orBOCES-widegroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonState/Regentsassessments
Indicatetheassessment(s)usedfortheOtherCourses#1school,orBOCESgroup,team,orlinkedresultsbasedonStateassessments:
ResponsesSelected:
CommonCoreEnglishRegents
ComprehensiveEnglishRegents
CommonCoreAlgebraRegents
LivingEnvironmentRegents
Global2Regents
USHistoryRegents
NoResponsesSelected
Ifyouneedadditionalspace,uploadacopyof"Form2.10:AllOtherCourses"asanattachmentforreview.ClickhereforadownloadablecopyofForm2.10.(MSWord).
(Noresponse)
2.11)HEDIScoringBands
HighlyEffective Effective Developing Ineffective
20 19 18
97-100%
93-96%
90-92%
17 16 15
85-89%
80-84%
75-79%
14 13
67-74%
60-66%
12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
55-59%
49-54%
44-48%
39-43%
34-38%
29-33%
25-28%
21-24%
17-20%
13-16%
9-12%
5-8%
0-4%
2.12)TeacherswithMoreThanOneGrowthMeasure
IfeducatorshavemorethanoneState-providedgrowthscoreandrating,thosescoresandratingswillbecombinedintoonescoreandHEDIratingfortheRequiredStudentPerformancesubcomponentprovidedbytheDepartment.(Examples:CommonbranchteacherwithState-providedmeasuresforbothELAandMathingrade4;middleschoolmathteacherwithboth7thand8thgrademathcourses.)
14of14
IfeducatorshavemorethanoneSLO(oraState-providedgrowthmeasureandanSLO),themeasureswilleachearnascorefrom0-20pointswhichdistricts/BOCESmustweightproportionatelybasedonthenumberofstudentsineachSLO(orintheState-providedgrowthmeasureandtheSLO).Formoreinformationonteacherswithmorethanonegrowthmeasure,pleaseseeNYSEDAPPRGuidanceandNYSEDSLOGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
2.13)Assurances
ForguidanceonSLOsandthedevelopmentofback-upSLOs,pleaseseeNYSEDAPPRGuidanceandNYSEDSLOGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
AssurethattheteacherhasanSLOoraback-upSLO,whereapplicable,consistentwiththegoalsettingprocessdevelopedbytheCommissionerthatresultsinastudentgrowthscore.
Checked
Assurethatallgrowthtargetsrepresentaminimumofoneyearofexpectedgrowth,asdeterminedbythesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministrator.Suchtargets,asdeterminedbythesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministrator,mayonlytakethefollowingcharacteristicsintoaccount:poverty,studentswithdisabilities,Englishlanguagelearnersstatusandprioracademichistory.
Checked
Assurethatallgrowthtargetsareapprovedbythesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministrator.
Checked
AssurethatanydisagreementbetweenpartiesregardingthecontentoftheSLO,includingthegrowthtarget,willberesolvedbythesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministrator.
Checked
Assurethatifateacher’sSLOisbasedonasmallnsizepopulationandthedistrict/BOCESchoosesnottousetheHEDIscoringbandslistedintask2.11,thentheteacher’s0-20scoreandHEDIratingwillbedeterminedusingtheHEDIscoringbandsspecifiedbytheDepartmentinAPPRGuidance.
Checked
AssurethatprocessesareinplaceforthesuperintendenttomonitorSLOs.
Checked
AssurethatthefinalStudentPerformancecategoryratingforeachteacherwillbedeterminedusingtheweightsandgrowthparametersspecifiedinSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.
Checked
2.14)UseoftheOptionalSubcomponentandStudentPerformanceCategoryWeighting
IftheOptionalsubcomponentisnotused,theRequiredsubcomponentwillcomprise100%oftheStudentPerformancecategory.IftheOptionalsubcomponentisused,theRequiredsubcomponentmustcompriseatleast50%oftheStudentPerformancecategory.
PleaseindicatetheuseoftheOptionalsubcomponentbymakingtheappropriateselectionbelow.InformationrelatedtotheOptionalsubcomponentwillbeenteredintoTask3.
TheOptionalsubcomponentWILLNOTbeused;theRequiredsubcomponentwillcomprise100%oftheStudentPerformancecategory.
1of1
Task3.StudentPerformance-OptionalSubcomponent(Teachers)Created:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:10/05/2015
UsethelinksabovetomovebetweenpagesinTask3;besuretoclick'Save&ContinueEditing'beforemovingtoanotherpage.The'Next'buttonatthebottomofthepagecanbeusedtomoveforwardonlywhenthecurrentpageiscomplete.ForguidanceontheOptionalsubcomponentoftheStudentPerformancemeasure,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Page1:Task3.1
Page1:Task3.1(UseoftheOptionalSubcomponentoftheStudentPerformanceCategory)
OPTIONALSUBCOMPONENT
(Upto50%ofStudentPerformancecategoryifselected)
Suchsecondmeasureshallapplyinaconsistentmanner,totheextentpracticable,acrossallclassroomsinthesame
grade/subjectinthedistrict/BOCESandbeeither:
(A)asecondState-providedgrowthscoreonaState-createdoradministeredtest;providedthattheState-provided
growthmeasureisdifferentthanthatusedintheRequiredsubcomponent,or
(B)agrowthscorebasedonaState-designedsupplementalassessment,calculatedusingaState-providedor
approvedgrowthmodel.
3.1)UseoftheOptionalSubcomponentoftheStudentPerformanceCategory
PleaseindicatetheuseoftheOptionalsubcomponentbymakingtheappropriateselectionbelow.
IftheOptionalsubcomponentWILLbeused,pleasefillouttasks3.2-3.12byusingthe"Next"buttontomovethrougheachtask.
TheOptionalsubcomponentWILLNOTbeusedintheStudentPerformancecategoryforanyteacher.
1of5
Task4.TeacherObservationCategoryCreated:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:10/23/2015
Pleasenote,withinthissection,task4.1maycontaintherubricselection(s)fromyourplanasitexistedonJune2,2015.*Theremainingtasksinthissectionwillnotcontaindatafromyourpreviousplanandmustbecompleted.*Pleasenotethatdocumentsandlanguagewillnotbepre-populatedintotheplanifyourdistrict/BOCESchosetostartwithablankapplication.
ForguidanceontheTeacherObservationcategory,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Page1
4.1)TeacherPracticeRubric
SelectateacherpracticerubricfromthemenuofState-approvedrubricstoassessperformancebasedontheobservableNYSTeachingStandards.IfyourdistricthasbeengrantedavariancebyNYSEDthroughthevarianceprocess,select"districtvariance"fromthemenu.
Ifyourdistrict/BOCESisusinganadditionalrubric,pleaseselecttherubricfromthesecondmenubelow.Ifyourdistrict/BOCESwillnotuseasecondrubric,pleaseselect"N/A"fromtheendofthedrop-downmenu.(Note:Anydistrict/BOCESmayusemultiplerubrics,aslongasthesamerubricisusedforallclassroomteachersinagrade/subjectacrossthedistrict/BOCES.)
Rubric1
Danielson’sFrameworkforTeaching(2011RevisedEdition)
Rubric2
(Noresponse)
4.2)Assurances
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
AssurethatallobservableNYSTeachingStandards/Domainsoftheselectedpracticerubricareassessedatleastonceayearacrossthetotalnumberofannualobservations.
Checked
AssurethattheprocessforassigningpointsfortheTeacherObservationcategorywillbeincompliancewiththelocally-determinedsubcomponentweightsandoverallObservationcategoryscoreandratingbasedontheconstraintsprescribedbytheCommissionerinSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.
Checked
Assurethatthesamerubric(s)isusedforallclassroomteachersinagrade/subjectacrossthedistrict/BOCES;providedthatdistricts/BOCESmaylocallydeterminewhethertousedifferentrubricsforteacherswhoteachdifferentgradesand/orsubjectsduringtheschoolyear.
Checked
Assurethatthesamerubric(s)isusedforallobservationsofaclassroomteacheracrosstheobservationtypesinagivenschoolyear.
Checked
4.3)ProcessforWeightingRubricDomains/Subcomponents
Pleasedescribetheprocessforweightingtheobservabledomains/subcomponentsofthechosenpracticerubric(e.g.,Allobservablecomponentswillbeweightedequallyandaveraged).ForguidanceontheTeacherObservationcategory,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
2of5
Allobservablecomponentswillbeweightedequallyandaveragedwithinadomain.
Tenuredteachersareweightedasseenbelowinsection4.5.
Probationaryteachersshallbeweighted:90%principal,10%independentevaluator,andwillnothaveapeerobserver.
4.4)CalculatingObservationRatings
Pleasechecktheboxesbelow:
Assurethateachsetofobservations(bysupervisor/othertrainedadministrator,independent,orpeer)willbecompletedusingtheselectedpracticerubric,producinganoverallscorebetween1and4.TheoverallweightedobservationscorewillthenbeconvertedintoaHEDIratingusingthechartshownbelow.
Checked
Assurethatonceallobservationsarecomplete,thedifferenttypesofobservationswillbecombinedusingaweightedaverageconsistentwiththeweightsspecifiedintask4.5below,producinganoverallObservationcategoryscorebetween0and4.Intheeventthatateacherearnsascoreof1onallratedcomponentsofthepracticerubricacrossallobservations,ascoreof0willbeassigned.
Checked
AssurethatifthedistrictisgrantedanannualIndependentEvaluatorHardshipWaiverbytheDepartment,thesecondobservation(s)shallbeconductedbyoneormoreevaluatorsselectedandtrainedbythedistrict,whoaredifferentthantheevaluator(s)whoconductedtheobservation(s)requiredtobeperformedbytheprincipal/supervisororothertrainedadministrator.
Checked
TeacherObservationScoringBands
OverallObservationCategoryScoreandRating
Minimum Maximum
H 3.5to3.75 4.0
E 2.5to2.75 3.49to3.74
D 1.5to1.75 2.49to2.74
I 0 1.49to1.74
Usingthedropdownmenusbelow,pleaseindicatethelocally-determinedrubricscoringrangesbasedontheconstraintsprescribedbytheCommissionerinSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegentsforeachoftheratingcategories.
MinimumRubricScore MaximumRubricScore
HighlyEffective 3.50 4.00
3of5
Effective 2.50 3.49
Developing 1.50 2.49
Ineffective 0.00 1.49
4.5)TeacherObservationSubcomponentWeighting
RequiredSubcomponents:
-ObservationsbyPrincipal(s)orOtherTrainedAdministrators:Atleast80%oftheTeacherObservationcategoryscore
-ObservationsbyImpartialIndependentTrainedEvaluator(s)*:Atleast10%,butnomorethan20%oftheTeacher
Observationcategoryscore
OptionalSubcomponent:
-ObservationsbyTrainedPeerObserver(s):Nomorethan10%oftheTeacherObservationcategoryscorewhenselected
Pleasebesurethetotaloftheweightsindicatedequals100%.
*IfthedistrictisgrantedanannualIndependentEvaluatorHardshipWaiverbytheDepartment,thissubcomponentwillbesatisfiedthroughtheuseofoneormoreevaluatorsselectedandtrainedbythedistrict,whoaredifferentthantheevaluator(s)whoconductedtheobservation(s)requiredtobeperformedbytheprincipal/supervisororothertrainedadministrator.
Principal-required IndependentEvaluator(s)-required
PeerObserver(s)-optional
Indicatetheweightingofeachsubcomponent:
80% 20% N/A
IfyourdistricthasallocatedweighttoPeerObserver(s),pleaseindicatethegradesandsubjectsforwhichPeerObserverswillbeused:
(Noresponse)
4.6)Assurances
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
Assurethatindependentevaluator(s)arenotemployedinthesameschoolbuilding,asdefinedbyBEDScode,astheteacher(s)theyareevaluating.
Checked
Assurethat,ifobservationsarebeingconductedbytrainedpeerobserver(s),theseteacher(s)receivedanoverallratingofEffectiveorHighlyEffectiveinthepreviousschoolyear.
Checked
Assurethatthefollowingelementswillnotbeusedincalculatingateacher'sObservationcategoryscoreandrating:evidenceofstudentdevelopmentandperformancederivedfromlessonplans,otherartifactsofteacherpractice,andstudentportfolios,exceptforstudentportfoliosmeasuredbyaState-approvedrubricwherepermittedbytheDepartment;useofaninstrumentforparentorstudentfeedback;useofprofessionalgoal-settingasevidenceofteachereffectiveness.
Checked
4of5
Assurethatthelengthofallobservationsforteacherswillbeconductedpursuanttothelocally-determineddurations.
Checked
Assurethatindependentevaluator(s)willbetrainedandselectedbythedistrict/BOCES.
Checked
Assurethatpeerobserver(s),asapplicable,willbetrainedandselectedbythedistrict/BOCES.
Checked
Assurethatatleastoneoftherequiredobservationswillbeunannounced.
Checked
4.7)NumberofObservations
ProbationaryTeachers
Indicatethenumberofunannouncedandannouncedobservationsforeachobservationtypeintheboxesbelow(e.g.,minimumof2,5).IftheOptionalPeerObservationsubcomponentwillnotbeused,pleaseindicate,"N/A".
Principal-required IndependentEvaluator(s)-required
PeerObserver(s)-optional
Unannounced 1 1 N/A
Announced 2 0 N/A
TenuredTeachers
Indicatethenumberofunannouncedandannouncedobservationsforeachobservationtypeintheboxesbelow(e.g.,minimumof2,5).IftheOptionalPeerObservationsubcomponentwillnotbeused,pleaseindicate,"N/A".
Principal-required IndependentEvaluator(s)-required
PeerObserver(s)-optional
Unannounced 0 1 N/A
Announced 1 0 N/A
4.8)ObservationMethod
ProbationaryTeachers
Principal-required IndependentEvaluator(s)-required
PeerObserver(s)-optional
Willunannouncedobservationsofteachersbedoneinperson,byvideo,orboth?
InPerson InPerson N/A
Willannouncedobservationsofteachersbedoneinperson,byvideo,orboth?
InPerson N/A N/A
TenuredTeachers
Principal-required IndependentEvaluator(s)-required
PeerObserver(s)-optional
Willunannouncedobservationsofteachersbedoneinperson,byvideo,orboth?
N/A InPerson N/A
5of5
Willannouncedobservationsofteachersbedoneinperson,byvideo,orboth?
InPerson N/A N/A
1of2
Task5.OverallScoring(Teachers)Created:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:10/05/2015
ForguidanceonAPPRscoring,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Page1
5.1)ScoringRanges
StudentPerformance:HEDIratingsmustbeassignedbasedonthepointdistributionbelow.
OverallStudentPerformanceCategoryScoreandRating
Minimum Maximum
H 18 20
E 15 17
D 13 14
I 0 12
TeacherObservation:HEDIratingsmustbeassignedbasedonlocally-determinedrangesconsistentwiththeconstraintslistedbelow.
OverallObservationCategoryScoreandRating
Minimum Maximum
H 3.5to3.75 4.0
E 2.5to2.75 3.49to3.74
D 1.5to1.75 2.49to2.74
I 0 1.49to1.74
5.2)ScoringMatrixfortheOverallRating
2of2
TeacherObservation
HighlyEffective(H) Effective(E) Developing(D) Ineffective(I)
StudentPerformance
HighlyEffective(H) H H E D
Effective(E) H E E D
Developing(D) E E D I
Ineffective(I) D* D* I I*IfateacherisratedIneffectiveontheStudentPerformancecategory,andaState-designedsupplementalassessmentwasincludedasanOptionalsubcomponentoftheStudentPerformancecategory,theteachercanberatednohigherthanIneffectiveoverall(seeEducationLaw§3012-d(5)(a)and(7)).
5.3)Assurances
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
AssurethateachsubcomponentandcategoryscoreandratingandtheOverallratingwillbecalculatedpursuanttotherequirementsspecifiedinSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.
Checked
Assurethatitispossibletoobtainazeroineachsubcomponent. Checked
Assuretheoverallratingdeterminationforateachershallbedeterminedaccordingtotheevaluationmatrix.
Checked
Assurethatastudentwillnotbeinstructed,fortwoconsecutiveschoolyears,byanytwoteachersofthesamesubjectinthesameschooldistrictwhohavereceivedIneffectiveratingsunderEducationLaw§3012-dintheyearimmediatelypriortotheschoolyearinwhichthestudentisplacedintheteacher’sclassroomunlessthedistricthasreceivedawaiverfromtheDepartment.
Checked
1of5
Task6.AdditionalRequirements(Teachers)Created:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:11/06/2015
Pleasenote,withinthissection,tasks6.2(improvementplan),6.4(appealslanguage)and6.6(traininglanguage)maycontaininformationfromyourplanasitexistedonJune2,2015.*Theremainingtasksinthissectionwillnotcontaindatafromyourpreviousplanandmustbecompleted.Additionally,task6.6mustbemodifiedtoaddresstrainingofindependentevaluatorsand,asapplicable,peerobservers.*Pleasenotethatdocumentsandlanguagewillnotbepre-populatedintotheplanifyourdistrict/BOCESchosetostartwithablankapplication.
Formoreinformationontheadditionalrequirementsforteachers,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Page1
6.1)Assurances:TeacherImprovementPlans
Assurethatthedistrict/BOCESwillformulateandcommenceimplementationofaTeacherImprovementPlan(TIP)forallteacherswhoreceiveaDevelopingorIneffectiveratingbyOctober1followingtheschoolyearforwhichsuchteacher'sperformanceisbeingmeasuredorassoonaspracticablethereafter.
Checked
AssurethatTIPplansdevelopedandimplementedbythesuperintendentorhis/herdesignee,intheexerciseofhis/herpedagogicaljudgment,shallinclude:identificationofneededareasofimprovement,atimelineforachievingimprovement,themannerinwhichtheimprovementwillbeassessed,and,whereappropriate,differentiatedactivitiestosupportateacher'simprovementinthoseareas.
Checked
6.2)Attachment:TeacherImprovementPlanForms
AsarequiredattachmenttothisAPPRplan,uploadtheTIPformsthatareusedintheschooldistrict/BOCES.AllTIPplansdevelopedandimplementedbythesuperintendentorhis/herdesignee,intheexerciseofhis/herpedagogicaljudgment,mustinclude:
1)identificationofneededareasofimprovement;2)atimelineforachievingimprovement;3)themannerinwhichtheimprovementwillbeassessed;and,whereappropriate,4)differentiatedactivitiestosupportateacher'simprovementinthoseareas.
Foralistofsupportedfiletypes,gototheResourcesfolder(above)andclickTechnicalTips.Pleasebesuretoupdateadocumentwithaformlayout,withfillablespacesandnotjustanarrative.
https://NYSED-APPR3.fluidreview.com/media/assets/survey-uploads/49388/3882112-
Df0w3Xx5v6/Teacher%20Improvement%20Plan_8iOCzbX.doc
6.3)Assurance:Appeals
Pleasechecktheboxbelow:
Assurethedistrict/BOCEShascollectivelybargainedappealproceduresthatareconsistentwiththeregulationsandthattheyprovideforthetimelyandexpeditiousresolutionofanappeal.
Checked
6.4)Appeals
2of5
PursuanttoEducationLaw§3012-d,ateachermayonlychallengethefollowinginanappealtotheirdistrict/BOCES:
(1)thesubstanceoftheannualprofessionalperformancereview;whichshallincludethefollowing:(i)intheinstanceofateacherratedIneffectiveontheStudentPerformancecategory,butratedHighlyEffectiveontheObservationcategorybasedonananomaly,asdeterminedlocally;
(2)theschooldistrict's/BOCES'adherencetothestandardsandmethodologiesrequiredforsuchreviews,pursuanttoEducationLaw§3012-d;and
(3)theadherencetotheregulationsoftheCommissionerandcompliancewithanyapplicablelocallynegotiatedprocedures,aswellastheschooldistrict's/BOCES'issuanceand/orimplementationofthetermsoftheteacherorprincipalimprovementplan,asrequiredunderEducationLaw§3012-d.
Describetheprocedureforensuringthatappealsofannualperformanceevaluationswillbehandledinatimelyandexpeditiousway:
Whileateacherisnotauthorizedtotriggertheappealprocessuntilheorshereceivesacompositerating,teachersareencouragedtoseek
clarificationoraskquestionsatanypointintheevaluationprocess.
OnlyaunitmemberwhoiscoveredbyN.Y.EducationLaw§3012d(“CoveredUnitMember”or“teacher”)mayappealtheresultofa
performancereviewand/oranimprovementplanpursuanttothefollowingprocedure:
a.ACoveredUnitMembermaychallengeonlythesubstanceofanAPPR,theDistrict’sadherencetothestatutorystandardsand
methodologiesrequiredforsuchreview,theDistrict’scompliancewithitsownproceduresandtimelinesforconductingtheAPPRandthe
RegulationsoftheCommissionerofEducationand/ortheissuanceorimplementationofateacherimprovementplan(“TIP”).Suchchallenge
mustbesubmittedinwritingtotheAdministratorperformingthereview,togetherwithanysupportingdocumentation.Thechallengemust
explainindetailthespecificreason(s)whythematteridentifiedisthesubjectofthechallenge.Ateachermaynotfilemultipleappeals
regardingthesameAPPRorTIP.Allgroundsforappealmustberaisedwithspecificitywithinoneappeal.Anygroundsnotraisedatthetime
theappealisfiledshallbedeemedwaived.Allsupportinginformationmustalsobesubmittedatthetimetheappealisfiled.Anyinformationnot
submittedatthetimetheappealisfiledshallnotbeconsidered.Inanappeal,theteacherhastheburdenofdemonstratingaclearlegalrightto
thereliefrequestedandtheburdenofestablishingthefactsuponwhichheorsheseeksrelief.Thechallengemustbesubmittedwithinfifteen
calendardaysofthereceiptoftheAPPRand/orTIPwhichisthesubjectofthechallenge,orotheractcomplainedof,oritisdeemedwaived.
ForpurposesofthisMemorandumofAgreement,calendardaysshallexcludetheperiodsoftheWinter,Mid-WinterandSpringrecesses.The
administratorinvolvedwillscheduleameetingwithin15calendardaysofreceiptofawrittenappealtodiscussthechallenge.ACoveredUnit
MembermayselectanAssociationrepresentativetoparticipateinthemeeting.Withinfifteencalendardaysofthemeeting,theAdministrator
whoissuedtheAPPRand/orTIPshallsubmittotheteacheradetailedwrittenresponsetotheAppeal.Theresponsemustincludeany
additionaldocumentsorwrittenmaterialsspecifictothepoint(s)ofdisagreementthatsupporttheresponseandarerelevanttotheresolution
oftheappeal.Foratenuredteacherwhoreceivedaratingof“highlyeffective”,or“effective”oranon-tenuredteacherwhoreceivedany
rating,including“ineffective”,theAdministrator’sdeterminationshallbefinal.Ifthatteacherdisagreeswiththeresponse,theteachermay
submitawrittenstatementoutliningthebasisforthatdisagreementtobeincludedinhisorherfilealongwiththedisputedAnnualProfessional
PerformanceReview.
b.IfatenuredCoveredUnitMemberreceivedaratingof“ineffective”or“developing”anddisagreeswiththeAdministrator’sresponsetothe
challenge,theteachermaysubmitthechallenge,theAdministrator’sresponse,andawrittenstatementexplainingindetailthereason(s)for
disagreementwiththeresponsetotheSuperintendentofSchoolswithin15calendardaysofreceiptoftheadministrator’sresponse.A
meetingwillbescheduledwithin15daysofthereceiptofthewrittenappealoftheadministrator'sdecisionoftheappealinpartAtodiscuss
theappeal.ThetenuredCoveredUnitMembermayselectanAssociationrepresentativetoparticipateinthemeeting.TheSuperintendent
shallrenderafinaldeterminationonthechallengewithin15calendardaysthereafter.
3of5
c.Achallengeordeterminationunderthisappealprocessshallnotbethesubjectofagrievance,andthearbitrationprovisionsofthe
CollectiveNegotiationsAgreementshallnotapplytoanysuchchallengeordetermination.Theteacherretainsanydefensesheorshemay
haveintheeventtheAPPRorTIPisutilizedinasubsequent3020-bproceeding.Nothinginthisappealsprocessshallbeconstruedtoalter
ordiminish,orinanywayrestrictoraffecttheDistrict’snon-reviewableauthoritytoterminatetheappointmentofordenytenuretoa
probationaryteacheratanytimeincludingduringthependencyofanappealforstatutorilyandconstitutionallypermissablereasonsandany
suchterminationordenialshallnotinanywaybesubjecttothegrievanceandarbitrationprocessoftheCollectiveNegotiationsAgreement.
d.Anevaluationthatisthesubjectofanappealshallnotbesoughttobeofferedinevidenceorplacedinevidenceinanyproceeding
conductedpursuanttoEducationLaw§3020boranylocallynegotiatedalternatedisciplinaryprocedureuntiltheappealprocessisconcluded.
e.Nothinginthissectionshallbeconstruedtoalterordiminishtheauthorityofthegoverning
bodyofadistricttograntordenytenuretoorterminateprobationaryteachersorprobationarybuildingprincipalsduringthependencyofan
appealpursuanttothissectionforstatutorilyandconstitutionallypermissiblereasons,includingtheteacher’sperformancethatisthesubject
oftheappeal.
6.5)Assurance:Evaluators
Thedistrict/BOCESassuresthatallevaluatorswillbeproperlytrainedandleadevaluatorswillbecertifiedonthebelowelementspriortocompletingateacher’sevaluation.Note:independentobserversandpeerobserversneedonlybetrainedonelements1,2,and4below.
Checked
(1)TheNewYorkStateTeachingStandards,andtheirrelatedelementsandperformanceindicatorsandtheLeadershipStandardsandtheirrelatedfunctions,asapplicable(2)Evidence-basedobservationtechniquesthataregroundedinresearch(3)ApplicationanduseofthestudentgrowthpercentilemodelandanyothergrowthmodelapprovedbytheDepartmentasdefinedinsection30-3.2ofthisSubpart(4)ApplicationanduseoftheState-approvedteacherrubric(s)selectedbythedistrict/BOCESforuseinevaluations,includingtrainingontheeffectiveapplicationofsuchrubricstoobserveateacher’spractice(5)Applicationanduseofanyassessmenttoolsthattheschooldistrict/BOCESutilizestoevaluateitsclassroomteachers(6)ApplicationanduseofanylocallyselectedmeasuresofstudentgrowthusedintheOptionalsubcomponentoftheStudentPerformancecategoryusedbythedistrict/BOCEStoevaluateitsteachers(7)UseoftheStatewideInstructionalReportingSystem(8)ThescoringmethodologyutilizedbytheDepartmentand/orthedistrict/BOCEStoevaluateateacherunderthisSubpart,includingtheweightingsofeachsubcomponentwithinacategory;howoverallscores/ratingsaregeneratedforeachsubcomponentandcategoryandapplicationanduseoftheevaluationmatrix(es)prescribedbytheCommissionerforthefourdesignatedratingcategoriesusedfortheteacher'soverallratingandtheircategoryratings(9)SpecificconsiderationsinevaluatingteachersofEnglishlanguagelearnersandstudentswithdisabilities
6.6)TrainingofLeadEvaluators,Evaluators,IndependentObservers,andPeerObserversandCertificationofLead
Evaluators
Describetheprocessfortrainingevaluators,includingimpartialandindependentobserversandpeerobservers,andcertifyingandre-certifying
4of5
leadevaluators.Yourdescriptionmustinclude:1)theprocessfortrainingleadevaluatorsandevaluators,includingimpartialindependentobserversandpeerobservers,2)theprocessforthecertificationandre-certificationofleadevaluators,3)theprocessforensuringinter-raterreliability,4)thenature(content)andtheduration(howmanyhours,days)ofsuchtraining.
Allevaluators(districtandindependent)andleadevaluatorsofthedistrictshallbetrainedannuallyandcertified/recertifiedbythegoverning
bodyofthedistricttoconductevaluationsundertheCommissioner'sRegulations3012dandRegentsRules30-3.TheOrleans-Niagara
BOCESNetworkTeamwillprovidethetraininginathreehoursessiononceperyear.Documentationandattendancerostersserveas
evidenceofparticipation.
AllAlbionevaluatorsandleadevaluatorswillcontinuetoparticipateinrefreshertrainings.Inaddition,theDistrictwillconductatleasttwointer-
raterreliabilityactivitiesofatleastonehourduration,bringingallevaluatorstogetherforthetrainingusingDanielsonRubriccalibration
materials.Allevaluatorswillviewlessons,evaluatethemindependentlyusingtheapprovedrubric,andcomparetheresultsoneachoftheir
independentcalculationsoftheobservedteacher'sperformancetocreateconsistencyamongDistrictraters.
6.7)Assurances:TeacherEvaluation
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
Assurethatthedistrict/BOCESshallcomputeandprovidetotheteachertheirscoreandratingfortheStudentPerformancecategory,ifavailable,andfortheTeacherObservationcategoryforateacher'sAnnualProfessionalPerformanceReview,inwriting,nolaterthanthelastschooldayoftheschoolyearforwhichtheteacherisbeingmeasured,butinnocaselaterthanSeptember1oftheschoolyearnextfollowingtheschoolyearforwhichtheteacher'sperformanceisbeingmeasured.
Checked
Assurethattheevaluationsystemwillbeusedasasignificantfactorforemploymentdecisions.
Checked
Assurethatteacherswillreceivetimelyandconstructivefeedbackaspartoftheevaluationprocess.
Checked
AssurethatthefollowingprohibitedelementslistedinEducationLaw§3012-d(6)arenotbeingusedaspartofanyteacher’sevaluation:evidenceofstudentdevelopmentandperformancederivedfromlessonplans,otherartifactsofteacherpractice,andstudentportfolios,exceptforstudentportfoliosmeasuredbyaState-approvedrubricwherepermittedbytheDepartment;useofaninstrumentforparentorstudentfeedback;useofprofessionalgoal-settingasevidenceofteachereffectiveness;anydistrictorregionally-developedassessmentthathasnotbeenapprovedbytheDepartment;andanygrowthorachievementtargetthatdoesnotmeettheminimumstandardsassetforthinregulationsoftheCommissioner.
Checked
AssurethatifthedistrictisgrantedanannualIndependentEvaluatorHardshipWaiverbytheDepartment,thesecondobservation(s)shallbeconductedbyoneormoreevaluatorsselectedandtrainedbythedistrict,whoaredifferentthantheevaluator(s)whoconductedtheobservation(s)requiredtobeperformedbytheprincipal/supervisororothertrainedadministrator.
Checked
6.8)Assurances:Assessments
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
5of5
Assurethat,whereapplicable,ifstudentsinCommonCorecoursesaretakingboththe2005LearningStandardsandCommonCoreversionsoftheRegentsAssessment,thenthedistrict/BOCESwillusethehigherofthetwoscorestodeterminewhetherastudenthasmethis/hergrowthtarget.
Checked
Assurethattheamountoftimedevotedtotraditionalstandardizedassessmentsthatarenotspecificallyrequiredbystateorfederallawforeachclassroomorprogramwithinagradeleveldoesnotexceed,intheaggregate,onepercentoftheminimumrequiredannualinstructionalhoursforthegrade.
Checked
Assurethatindividualswithvestedinterestintheoutcomeoftheirassessmentsarenotinvolved,totheextentpracticable,intheadministrationandscoringofthoseassessments.
Checked
6.9)Assurances:Data
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
AssurethatSEDwillreceiveaccurateteacherandstudentdata,includingenrollmentandattendancedata,andanyotherstudent,teacher,school,course,andteacher/studentlinkagedatanecessarytocomplywithregulations,inaformatandtimelineprescribedbytheCommissioner.
Checked
Assurethatthedistrict/BOCESprovidesanopportunityforeveryclassroomteachertoverifythesubjectsand/orstudentrostersassignedtothem.
Checked
AssurescoresandratingsforallteacherswillbereportedtoNYSEDforeachcategory,aswellastheoverallrating,asperNYSEDrequirements.
Checked
Assurethatenrolledstudentsinaccordancewithteacherofrecordpoliciesareincludedandmaynotbeexcluded.
Checked
Assurethatproceduresforensuringdataaccuracyandintegrityarebeingutilized.
Checked
1of5
Task7.StudentPerformance–RequiredSubcomponentCreated:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:11/06/2015
ForguidanceontheRequiredsubcomponentoftheStudentPerformancecategory,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Page1
REQUIREDSUBCOMPONENT
(100%ofStudentPerformancecategoryifonlytheRequiredsubcomponentisusedoratleast50%whenusedwith
Optionalsubcomponent)
(A)Foraprincipalingrades4-8ELA,mathand/orhighschoolcourseswithStateorRegentsassessments(or
principalsofprogramswithanyoftheseassessments)whohaveatleast30%ofhis/herstudentscoveredundera
State-providedgrowthmeasure,suchprincipalshallhaveaState-providedgrowthscorebasedonsuchmodel.
(B)Foraprincipalwherelessthan30%ofhis/herstudentsarecoveredundertheState-providedgrowthmeasure,
suchprincipalshallhaveaStudentLearningObjective(SLO),consistentwiththeSLOprocessdeterminedor
developedbytheCommissioner,thatresultsinastudentgrowthscore;providedthat,foranyprincipalwhose
buildingorprogramincludescoursesthatendinaState-createdoradministeredassessmentforwhichthereisno
State-providedgrowthmodel,suchassessmentmustbeusedastheunderlyingassessmentforsuchSLO.
7.1)STATE-PROVIDEDMEASURESOFSTUDENTGROWTH
Forprincipalswithatleast30%oftheirstudentscoveredunderaState-providedgrowthmeasure,suchprincipalshallhaveaState-providedgrowthscorebasedonsuchmodel.Pleaselistthegradeconfigurationsoftheschool(s)/program(s)inyourdistrict/BOCESwhereitisexpectedthat30-100%ofaprincipal’sstudentsaretakingassessmentswithaState-providedgrowth,(e.g.,K-5,PK-6,6-8,6-12,9-12,etc.).Forprincipalswherelessthan30%oftheirstudentsarecoveredunderaState-providedgrowthmeasure,suchprincipalsshallhaveaSLOconsistentwithagoalsettingprocessdeterminedordevelopedbytheCommissionerthatresultsinastudentgrowthscore;providedthatforanyteacherwhosecourseendsinaStatecreatedoradministeredassessmentforwhichthereisnoState-providedgrowthmodel,suchassessmentmustbeusedastheunderlyingassessmentforsuchSLO.(SeeGuidanceformoredetailonprincipalswithState-providedmeasuresandSLOs.)
ForthoseprincipalswhowouldtypicallyreceiveaState-providedgrowthscore,thedistrict/BOCESmustalsoincludeaback-upSLOprocessintheeventthattherearenotenoughstudents,notenoughscores,ordataissuesthatpreventaState-providedgrowthscorefrombeingcalculatedforthatprincipal.
PleaselistthegradeconfigurationsoftheschoolsorprincipalswhereState-providedgrowthmeasureswillapply(pleaselist,e.g.,K-5,PK-6,6-8,6-12,7-12,9-12).Foreachconfiguration,alsoindicatethemeasureandassessment(s)usedfortheback-upSLO.
Foreachgradeconfigurationindicatethefollowing:
Column1:lowestgradethatcorrespondstothebuildingorprogramColumn2:highestgradethatcorrespondstothebuildingorprogramUsethecheckboxestoindicatetheStateassessmentsorRegentsexamsused
FollowtheexamplesbelowGradesK-6:
lowestgrade=Khighestgrade=6
2of5
assessments=NYSGrades4-6ELAandMathAssessments(checkall)
Grades7-12:
lowestgrade=7highestgrade=12assessments=NYSGrades7-8ELAandMathAssessmentsandAllRegentsassessmentswhichareusedtogeneratetheprincipal'sState-providedgrowthscore(checkall)
GradeConfiguration#1
GRADEFROM GRADETO
K 5
GradeConfiguration#1AssessmentName(s)
ResponsesSelected:
NYSGrade4ELAAssessment
NYSGrade5ELAAssessment
NYSGrade4MathAssessment
NYSGrade5MathAssessment
ResponsesSelected:
ClicktoAddAnotherConfiguration
GradeConfiguration#2
GRADEFROM GRADETO
6 8
GradeConfiguration#2AssessmentName(s)
ResponsesSelected:
NYSGrade6ELAAssessment
NYSGrade7ELAAssessment
NYSGrade8ELAAssessment
NYSGrade6MathAssessment
NYSGrade7MathAssessment
NYSGrade8MathAssessment
ResponsesSelected:
ClicktoAddAnotherConfiguration
GradeConfiguration#3
3of5
GRADEFROM GRADETO
9 12
GradeConfiguration#3AssessmentName(s)
ResponsesSelected:
AllRegentsassessmentswhichareusedtogeneratetheprincipal'sState-providedgrowthscore
NoResponsesSelected
7.1)Assurances
AssurethatthegrowthscoreprovidedbyNYSEDwillbeused,whererequired.
Checked
Assurethatback-upSLOswillbesetbythesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministratorforallprincipalswhoreceiveaState-providedgrowthscoreintheeventthataState-providedgrowthscorecannotbegeneratedforthatprincipal.
Checked
7.2)STUDENTLEARNINGOBJECTIVES
SLOsmustbeusedforprincipalsinbuildingsorprogramsinwhichfewerthan30%ofstudentstakeGrades4-8ELA,math,and/orhighschoolcourseswithStateorRegentsassessments.SLOswillbedevelopedusingtheassessmentscoveringthemoststudentsintheschoolorprogramandcontinuinguntilatleast30%ofstudentsintheschoolorprogramarecoveredbySLOs.ForguidanceonSLOs,seeNYSEDSLOGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.Thedistrict/BOCESmustselectthetypeofassessmentthatwillbeusedwiththeSLOfromtheoptionsbelow.
Ifanygrade/courseinthebuildinghasaState-providedgrowthmeasureANDtheprincipalmusthaveSLOsbecausefewerthan30%ofstudentsinthebuildingarecovered,thentheSLOsmustbeginfirstwiththeSGPresults.AdditionalSLOsmustthenbesetbasedongrades/subjectswithStateassessmentsforwhichthereisnoState-providedgrowthmeasure,whereapplicable.IfadditionalSLOsarenecessary,principalsmustbeginwiththegrade(s)/courses(s)thathavethelargestnumberofstudentsusingschool-widestudentresultsfromoneofthefollowingassessmentoptions:
State-approved3rdpartyassessment;orState-approveddistrict,regional,orBOCES-developedassessment.
Foreachgradeconfigurationindicatethefollowing:
Column1:lowestgradethatcorrespondstothebuildingorprogramColumn2:highestgradethatcorrespondstothebuildingorprogramColumn3:measureusedOnceameasureisselected,acorrespondingmenuwillappearfortheselectionofthename(s)oftheassessment(s)used.
FollowtheexamplebelowGradesK-3:
lowestgrade=Khighestgrade=3measure=StateorRegentsassessmentassessment=NYSGrade3ELAAssessmentandNYSGrade3MathAssessment
GradeConfiguration#1GradesandMeasure
4of5
GRADEFROM GRADETO MEASURE
NoResponsesSelected
7.3)HEDIScoringBands
HighlyEffective Effective Developing Ineffective
20 19 18
97-100%
93-96%
90-92%
17 16 15
85-89%
80-84%
75-79%
14 13
67-74%
60-66%
12 11 10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1 0
55-59%
49-54%
44-48%
39-43%
34-38%
29-33%
25-28%
21-24%
17-20%
13-16%
9-12%
5-8%
0-4%
7.4)PrincipalswithMoreThanOneGrowthMeasure
IfeducatorshavemorethanoneState-providedgrowthscoreandrating,thosescoresandratingswillbecombinedintoonescoreandHEDIratingfortheRequiredStudentPerformancesubcomponentprovidedbytheDepartment.(Examples:PrincipalsofK-8schoolswithgrowthmeasuresforELAandmathgrades4-8.)IfeducatorshavemorethanoneSLO(oraState-providedgrowthmeasureandanSLO),themeasureswilleachearnascorefrom0-20pointswhichdistricts/BOCESmustweightproportionatelybasedonthenumberofstudentsineachSLO(orintheState-providedgrowthmeasureandtheSLO).Formoreinformationonprincipalswithmorethanonegrowthmeasure,pleaseseeNYSEDAPPRGuidanceandNYSEDSLOGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
7.5)Assurances
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
AssurethattheprincipalhasanSLOoraback-upSLO,whereapplicable,consistentwiththegoalsettingprocessdevelopedbytheCommissionerthatresultsinastudentgrowthscore.
Checked
Assurethatallgrowthtargetsrepresentaminimumofoneyearofexpectedgrowth,asdeterminedbythesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministrator.Suchtargets,asdeterminedbythesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministrator,mayonlytakethefollowingcharacteristicsintoaccount:poverty,studentswithdisabilities,Englishlanguagelearnersstatusandprioracademichistory.
Checked
Assurethatallgrowthtargetsareapprovedbythesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministrator.
Checked
AssurethatanydisagreementbetweenpartiesregardingthecontentoftheSLO,includingthegrowthtarget,willberesolvedbythesuperintendentoranothertrainedadministrator.
Checked
Assurethatifaprincipal’sSLOisbasedonasmallnsizepopulationandthedistrict/BOCESchoosesnottousetheHEDIscoringbandslistedintask7.3,thentheprincipal’s0-20scoreandHEDIratingwillbedeterminedusingtheHEDIscoringbandsspecifiedbytheDepartmentinAPPRGuidance.
Checked
AssurethatprocessesareinplaceforthesuperintendenttomonitorSLOs.
Checked
AssurethatthefinalStudentPerformancecategoryratingforeachprincipalwillbedeterminedusingtheweightsandgrowthparametersspecifiedinSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.
Checked
7.6)StudentPerformanceSubcomponentWeighting
5of5
IftheOptionalsubcomponentisnotused,theRequiredsubcomponentwillcomprise100%oftheStudentPerformancecategory.IftheOptionalsubcomponentisused,theRequiredsubcomponentmustcompriseatleast50%oftheStudentPerformancecategory.
PleaseindicatetheuseoftheOptionalsubcomponentbycheckingtheboxbelow.InformationrelatedtotheOptionalsubcomponentwillbeenteredintoTask8.
TheOptionalsubcomponentWILLNOTbeused;theRequiredsubcomponentwillcomprise100%oftheStudentPerformancecategory.
1of1
Task8.StudentPerformance–OptionalSubcomponentCreated:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:10/05/2015
UsethelinksabovetomovebetweenpagesinTask8;besuretoclick'Save&ContinueEditing'beforemovingtoanotherpage.The'Next'buttonatthebottomofthepagecanbeusedtomoveforwardonlywhenthecurrentpageiscomplete.ForguidanceontheOptionalsubcomponentoftheStudentPerformancecategory,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Page1:Task8.1
Page1:Task8.1(UseoftheOptionalSubcomponentoftheStudentPerformanceCategory)
OPTIONALSUBCOMPONENT
(Upto50%ofStudentPerformancecategoryifselected)
Suchsecondmeasureshallapplyinaconsistentmanner,totheextentpracticable,acrossallbuildingswiththesame
gradeconfigurationorprograminthedistrict/BOCESandbeeither:
(A)asecondState-providedgrowthscoreonaState-createdoradministeredtest;providedthatadifferent
measureisusedthanthatfortheRequiredsubcomponentintheStudentPerformancecategory,or
(B)agrowthscorebasedonaState-designedsupplementalassessment,calculatedusingaState-providedor
approvedgrowthmodel.
8.1)UseoftheOptionalSubcomponentforStudentPerformanceMeasures
PleaseindicatetheuseoftheOptionalsubcomponentbymakingtheappropriateselectionbelow.
IftheOptionalsubcomponentWILLbeused,pleasefillouttasks8.2-8.4byusingthe"Next"buttontomovethrougheachtask.
TheOptionalsubcomponentWILLNOTbeusedintheStudentPerformancecategoryforanyprincipal.
1of4
Task9.PrincipalSchoolVisitCategoryCreated:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:10/16/2015
Pleasenote,withinthissection,task9.1maycontaintherubricselection(s)fromyourplanasitexistedonJune2,2015.*Theremainingtasksinthissectionwillnotcontaindatafromyourpreviousplanandmustbecompleted.*Pleasenotethatdocumentsandlanguagewillnotbepre-populatedintotheplanifyourdistrict/BOCESchosetostartwithablankapplication.
ForguidanceonthePrincipalSchoolVisitcategory,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Page1
9.1)PrincipalPracticeRubric
SelectaprincipalpracticerubricfromthemenuofState-approvedrubricstoassessperformancebasedonISLLC2008Standards.IfyourdistricthasbeengrantedavariancebyNYSEDthroughthevarianceprocess,select"districtvariance"fromthemenu.
Ifyourdistrict/BOCESisusinganadditionalrubric,pleaseselecttherubricfromthesecondmenubelow.Ifyourdistrict/BOCESwillnotuseasecondrubric,pleaseselect"N/A"fromtheendofthedrop-downmenu.(Note:Anydistrictmayusemultiplerubrics,aslongasthesamerubricisusedforallprincipalsinthesameorsimilarprogramsorgradeconfigurationsacrossthedistrict.)
Rubric1
MultidimensionalPrincipalPerformanceRubric
Rubric2
N/A
9.2)Assurances
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
AssurethatallobservableISLLC2008LeadershipStandards/Domainsoftheselectedpracticerubricareassessedatleastonceayearacrossthetotalnumberofannualschoolvisits.
Checked
AssurethattheprocessforassigningpointsforthePrincipalSchoolVisitcategorywillbeincompliancewiththelocally-determinedsubcomponentweightsandoverallSchoolVisitcategoryscoreandratingbasedontheconstraintsprescribedbytheCommissionerinSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.
Checked
Assurethatthesamerubric(s)isusedforallprincipalsinthesameorsimilarprogramsorgradeconfigurationsacrossthedistrict/BOCES;providedthatdistricts/BOCESmaylocallydeterminewhethertousedifferentrubricsforaprincipalassignedtodifferentgradelevelconfigurationsorbuildingtypes.
Checked
Assurethatthesamerubric(s)isusedforallschoolvisitsforaprincipalacrosstheschoolvisittypesinagivenschoolyear.
Checked
9.3)ProcessforWeightingRubricDomains/Subcomponents
Pleasedescribetheprocessforweightingtheobservabledomains/subcomponentsofthechosenpracticerubric(e.g.,Allobservablecomponentswillbeweightedequallyandaveraged).ForguidanceonthePrincipalSchoolVisitcategory,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:
2of4
https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Allobservablecomponentswillbeweightedequallyandaveraged.
9.4)CalculatingSchoolVisitRatings
Pleasechecktheboxesbelow:
Assurethateachsetofschoolvisits(bysupervisor/othertrainedadministrator,independent,orpeer)willbecompletedusingtheselectedpracticerubric,producinganoverallscorebetween1and4.TheoverallweightedschoolvisitscorewillbeconvertedintoaHEDIratingusingthechartshownbelow.
Checked
Assurethatonceallschoolvisitsarecomplete,thedifferenttypesofschoolvisitswillbecombinedusingaweightedaverageconsistentwiththeweightsspecifiedintask9.5below,producinganoverallSchoolVisitcategoryscorebetween0and4.Intheeventthataprincipalearnsascoreof1onallratedcomponentsofthepracticerubricacrossallobservations,ascoreof0willbeassigned.
Checked
PrincipalSchoolVisitScoringBands
OverallSchoolVisitCategoryScoreandRating
Minimum Maximum
H 3.5to3.75 4.0
E 2.5to2.75 3.49to3.74
D 1.5to1.75 2.49to2.74
I 0 1.49to1.74
Usingthedropdownmenusbelow,pleaseindicatethelocally-determinedrubricscoringrangesbasedontheconstraintsprescribedbytheCommissionerinSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegentsforeachoftheratingcategories.
MinimumRubricScore MaximumRubricScore
HighlyEffective 3.50 4.00
Effective 2.50 3.49
Developing 1.50 2.49
Ineffective 0.00 1.49
3of4
9.5)PrincipalSchoolVisitSubcomponentWeighting
RequiredSubcomponents:
-SchoolVisitsbySupervisor(s)orotherTrainedAdministrator(s):Atleast80%ofthePrincipalSchoolVisitcategory
score
-SchoolVisitsbyImpartialIndependentTrainedEvaluator(s):Atleast10%,butnomorethan20%ofthePrincipalSchool
Visitcategoryscore
OptionalSubcomponent:
-SchoolVisitsbyTrainedPeerObserver(s):Nomorethan10%ofthePrincipalSchoolVisitcategoryscorewhenselected
Pleasebesurethetotaloftheweightsindicatedequals100%
Supervisor-required IndependentEvaluator(s)-required
PeerObserver(s)-optional
Indicatetheweightingofeachsubcomponent:
90% 10% N/A
9.6)Assurances
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
Assurethatindependentevaluator(s)arenotemployedinthesameschoolbuilding,asdefinedbyBEDScode,astheprincipal(s)theyareevaluating.
Checked
Assurethat,ifschoolvisitsarebeingconductedbytrainedpeerobserver(s),theseprincipal(s)receivedanoverallratingofEffectiveorHighlyEffectiveinthepreviousschoolyear.
Checked
Assurethatthefollowingelementswillnotbeusedincalculatingaprincipal'sschoolvisitcategoryscoreandrating:evidenceofstudentdevelopmentandperformancederivedfromlessonplans,otherartifactsofprincipalpractice,andstudentportfolios,exceptforstudentportfoliosmeasuredbyaState-approvedrubricwherepermittedbytheDepartment;useofaninstrumentforparentorstudentfeedback;useofprofessionalgoal-settingasevidenceofprincipaleffectiveness.
Checked
Assurethatthelengthofallschoolvisitsforprincipalswillbeconductedpursuanttothelocally-determineddurations.
Checked
Assurethatindependentevaluator(s)willbetrainedandselectedbythedistrict/BOCES.
Checked
Assurethatpeerobserver(s),asapplicable,willbetrainedandselectedbythedistrict/BOCES.
Checked
Assurethatatleastoneoftherequiredschoolvisitsbythesupervisorortrainedadministratorwillbeunannounced.
Checked
Assurethatschoolvisitswillnotbeconductedviavideo. Checked
9.7)NumberofSchoolVisits
ProbationaryPrincipals
Indicatethenumberofunannouncedandannouncedschoolvisitsforeachschoolvisittypeintheboxesbelow(e.g.,minimumof2,5).IftheOptionalPeerSchoolVisitsubcomponentwillnotbeused,pleaseindicate,"N/A".
4of4
Supervisor-required IndependentEvaluator(s)-required
PeerObserver(s)-optional
Unannounced 1 0 N/A
Announced 1 1 N/A
TenuredPrincipals
Indicatethenumberofunannouncedandannouncedschoolvisitsforeachschoolvisittypeintheboxesbelow(e.g.,minimumof2,5).IftheOptionalPeerSchoolVisitsubcomponentwillnotbeused,pleaseindicate,"N/A".
Supervisor-required IndependentEvaluator(s)-required
PeerObserver(s)-optional
Unannounced 1 0 N/A
Announced 1 1 N/A
1of2
Task10.OverallScoring(Principals)Created:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:10/05/2015
ForguidanceonAPPRscoring,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Page1
10.1)ScoringRanges
StudentPerformance:HEDIratingsmustbeassignedbasedonthepointdistributionbelow.
OverallStudentPerformanceCategoryScoreandRating
Minimum Maximum
H 18 20
E 15 17
D 13 14
I 0 12
PrincipalSchoolVisits:HEDIratingsmustbeassignedbasedonlocally-determinedrangesconsistentwiththeconstraintslistedbelow.
OverallSchoolVisitCategoryScoreandRating
Minimum Maximum
H 3.5to3.75 4.0
E 2.5to2.75 3.49to3.74
D 1.5to1.75 2.49to2.74
I 0 1.49to1.74
10.2)ScoringMatrixfortheOverallRating
2of2
PrincipalSchoolVisit
HighlyEffective(H) Effective(E) Developing(D) Ineffective(I)
StudentPerformance
HighlyEffective(H) H H E D
Effective(E) H E E D
Developing(D) E E D I
Ineffective(I) D* D* I I*IfaprincipalisratedIneffectiveontheStudentPerformancecategory,andaState-designedsupplementalassessmentwasincludedasanOptionalsubcomponentoftheStudentPerformancecategory,theprincipalcanberatednohigherthanIneffectiveoverall(seeEducationLaw§3012-d(5)(a)and(7)).
10.3)Assurances
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
AssurethateachsubcomponentandcategoryscoreandratingandtheOverallratingwillbecalculatedpursuanttotherequirementsspecifiedinSubpart30-3oftheRulesoftheBoardofRegents.
Checked
Assurethatitispossibletoobtainazeroineachsubcomponent. Checked
Assuretheoverallratingdeterminationforaprincipalshallbedeterminedaccordingtotheevaluationmatrix.
Checked
1of5
Task11.AdditionalRequirements-PrincipalsCreated:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:11/06/2015
Pleasenote,withinthissection,tasks11.2(improvementplan),11.4(appealslanguage)and11.6(traininglanguage)maycontaininformationfromyourplanasitexistedonJune2,2015.*Theremainingtasksinthissectionwillnotcontaindatafromyourpreviousplanandmustbecompleted.Additionally,task11.6shouldbemodifiedtoaddresstrainingofindependentevaluatorsand,asapplicable,peerobservers.*Pleasenotethatdocumentsandlanguagewillnotbepre-populatedintotheplanifyourdistrict/BOCESchosetostartwithablankapplication.
Forguidanceonadditionalrequirementsforprincipals,seeNYSEDAPPRGuidance:https://www.engageny.org/resource/appr-3012-d.
Page1
11.1)Assurances:ImprovementPlans
Pleasechecktheboxesbelow:
Assurethatthedistrict/BOCESwillformulateandcommenceimplementationofaPrincipalImprovementPlan(PIP)forallprincipalswhoreceiveaDevelopingorIneffectiveratingbyOctober1followingtheschoolyearforwhichsuchprincipal'sperformanceisbeingmeasuredorassoonaspracticablethereafter.
Checked
AssurethatPIPplansdevelopedandimplementedbythesuperintendentorhis/herdesignee,intheexerciseofhis/herpedagogicaljudgment,shallinclude:identificationofneededareasofimprovement,atimelineforachievingimprovement,themannerinwhichtheimprovementwillbeassessed,and,whereappropriate,differentiatedactivitiestosupportaprincipal'simprovementinthoseareas.
Checked
11.2)Attachment:PrincipalImprovementPlanForms
AsarequiredattachmenttothisAPPRplan,uploadthePIPformsthatareusedintheschooldistrict/BOCES.AllPIPplansdevelopedandimplementedbythesuperintendentorhis/herdesignee,intheexerciseofhis/herpedagogicaljudgment,mustinclude:
1)identificationofneededareasofimprovement;2)atimelineforachievingimprovement;3)themannerinwhichtheimprovementwillbeassessed;and,whereappropriate,4)differentiatedactivitiestosupportaprincipal'simprovementinthoseareas.
Foralistofsupportedfiletypes,gototheResourcesfolder(above)andclickTechnicalTips.Pleasebesuretoupdateadocumentwithaformlayout,withfillablespacesandnotjustanarrative.
https://NYSED-APPR3.fluidreview.com/media/assets/survey-uploads/49338/3882124-
Df0w3Xx5v6/Principal%20Improvement%20Plan_6C6UZLG.doc
11.3)Assurance:Appeals
Pleasecheckboxbelow:
Assurethedistrict/BOCEShascollectivelybargainedappealproceduresthatareconsistentwiththeregulationsandthattheyprovideforthetimelyandexpeditiousresolutionofanappeal.
Checked
11.4)Appeals
2of5
PursuanttoEducationLaw§3012-d,aprincipalmayonlychallengethefollowinginanappealtotheirdistrict/BOCES:(1)thesubstanceoftheannualprofessionalperformancereview;whichshallincludethefollowing:
(i)intheinstanceofaprincipalratedIneffectiveonthestudentperformancecategory,butratedHighlyEffectiveontheschoolvisitcategorybasedonananomaly,asdeterminedlocally;
(2)theschooldistrict's/BOCES'adherencetothestandardsandmethodologiesrequiredforsuchreviews,pursuanttoEducationLaw§3012-d;and(3)theadherencetotheregulationsoftheCommissionerandcompliancewithanyapplicablelocallynegotiatedprocedures,aswellastheschooldistrict's/BOCES'issuanceand/orimplementationofthetermsoftheteacherorprincipalimprovementplan,asrequiredunderEducationLaw§3012-d.Describetheprocedureforensuringthatappealsofannualperformanceevaluationswillbehandledinatimelyandexpeditiousway:
Whileaprincipalisnotauthorizedtotriggertheappealprocessuntilheorshereceivesacompositerating,principalsareencouragedtoseek
clarificationoraskquestionsatanypointintheevaluationprocess.
OnlyaunitmemberwhoiscoveredbyN.Y.EducationLaw§3012d(“CoveredUnitMember”or“principal”)mayappealtheresultofa
performancereviewand/oranimprovementplanpursuanttothefollowingprocedure:
a.ACoveredUnitMembermaychallengeonlythesubstanceofanAPPR,theDistrict’sadherencetothestatutorystandardsand
methodologiesrequiredforsuchreview,theDistrict’scompliancewithitsownproceduresandtimelinesforconductingtheAPPRandthe
RegulationsoftheCommissionerofEducationand/ortheissuanceorimplementationofaprincipalimprovementplan(“PIP”).Suchchallenge
mustbesubmittedinwritingtotheAdministratorperformingthereview,togetherwithanysupportingdocumentation.Thechallengemust
explainindetailthespecificreason(s)whythematteridentifiedisthesubjectofthechallenge.Aprincipalmaynotfilemultipleappeals
regardingthesameAPPRorPIP.Allgroundsforappealmustberaisedwithspecificitywithinoneappeal.Anygroundsnotraisedatthetime
theappealisfiledshallbedeemedwaived.Allsupportinginformationmustalsobesubmittedatthetimetheappealisfiled.Anyinformationnot
submittedatthetimetheappealisfiledshallnotbeconsidered.Inanappeal,theprincipalhastheburdenofdemonstratingaclearlegalright
tothereliefrequestedandtheburdenofestablishingthefactsuponwhichheorsheseeksrelief.Thechallengemustbesubmittedwithin
fifteencalendardaysofthereceiptoftheAPPRand/orPIPwhichisthesubjectofthechallenge,orotheractcomplainedof,oritisdeemed
waived.ForpurposesofthisMemorandumofAgreement,calendardaysshallexcludetheperiodsoftheWinter,Mid-WinterandSpring
recesses.Theadministratorinvolvedwillscheduleameetingwithin15calendardaysofreceiptofawrittenappealtodiscussthechallenge.A
CoveredUnitMembermayselectanAssociationrepresentativetoparticipateinthemeeting.Withinfifteencalendardaysofthemeeting,the
AdministratorwhoissuedtheAPPRand/orPIPshallsubmittotheprincipaladetailedwrittenresponsetotheAppeal.Theresponsemust
includeanyadditionaldocumentsorwrittenmaterialsspecifictothepoint(s)ofdisagreementthatsupporttheresponseandarerelevantto
theresolutionoftheappeal.Foratenuredprincipalwhoreceivedaratingof“highlyeffective”,or“effective”oranon-tenuredprincipalwho
receivedanyrating,including“ineffective”,theAdministrator’sdeterminationshallbefinal.Ifthatprincipaldisagreeswiththeresponse,the
principalmaysubmitawrittenstatementoutliningthebasisforthatdisagreementtobeincludedinhisorherfilealongwiththedisputedAnnual
ProfessionalPerformanceReview.
b.IfatenuredCoveredUnitMemberreceivedaratingof“ineffective”or“developing”anddisagreeswiththeAdministrator’sresponsetothe
challenge,theprincipalmaysubmitthechallenge,theAdministrator’sresponse,andawrittenstatementexplainingindetailthereason(s)for
disagreementwiththeresponsetotheSuperintendentofSchoolswithin15calendardaysofreceiptoftheadministrator’sresponse.A
meetingwillbescheduledwithin15daysofthereceiptofthewrittenappealoftheadministrator'sdecisionoftheappealinpartAtodiscuss
theappeal.ThetenuredCoveredUnitMembermayselectanAssociationrepresentativetoparticipateinthemeeting.TheSuperintendent
shallrenderafinaldeterminationonthechallengewithin15calendardaysthereafter.
3of5
c.Achallengeordeterminationunderthisappealprocessshallnotbethesubjectofagrievance,andthearbitrationprovisionsofthe
CollectiveNegotiationsAgreementshallnotapplytoanysuchchallengeordetermination.Theprincipalretainsanydefensesheorshemay
haveintheeventtheAPPRorPIPisutilizedinasubsequent3020-bproceeding.Nothinginthisappealsprocessshallbeconstruedtoalter
ordiminish,orinanywayrestrictoraffecttheDistrict’snon-reviewableauthoritytoterminatetheappointmentofordenytenuretoa
probationaryprincipalatanytimeincludingduringthependencyofanappealforstatutorilyandconstitutionallypermissablereasonsandany
suchterminationordenialshallnotinanywaybesubjecttothegrievanceandarbitrationprocessoftheCollectiveNegotiationsAgreement.
d.Anevaluationthatisthesubjectofanappealshallnotbesoughttobeofferedinevidenceorplacedinevidenceinanyproceeding
conductedpursuanttoEducationLaw§3020boranylocallynegotiatedalternatedisciplinaryprocedureuntiltheappealprocessisconcluded.
e.Nothinginthissectionshallbeconstruedtoalterordiminishtheauthorityofthegoverningbodyofadistricttograntordenytenuretoor
terminateprobationaryprincipalsorprobationarybuildingprincipalsduringthependencyofanappealpursuanttothissectionforstatutorily
andconstitutionallypermissiblereasons,includingtheprincipal’sperformancethatisthesubjectoftheappeal.
11.5)Assurance:Evaluators
Thedistrict/BOCESassuresthatallevaluatorswillbeproperlytrainedandleadevaluatorswillbecertifiedonthebelowelementspriortocompletingaprincipal’sevaluation.Note:independentobserversandpeerobserversneedonlybetrainedonelements1,2,and4below.
Checked
(1)TheNewYorkStateTeachingStandards,andtheirrelatedelementsandperformanceindicatorsandtheLeadershipStandardsandtheirrelatedfunctions,asapplicable(2)Evidence-basedobservationtechniquesthataregroundedinresearch(3)ApplicationanduseofthestudentgrowthpercentilemodelandanyothergrowthmodelapprovedbytheDepartmentasdefinedinsection30-3.2ofthisSubpart(4)ApplicationanduseoftheState-approvedprincipalrubric(s)selectedbythedistrict/BOCESforuseinevaluations,includingtrainingontheeffectiveapplicationofsuchrubricstoobserveaprincipal’spractice(5)Applicationanduseofanyassessmenttoolsthattheschooldistrict/BOCESutilizestoevaluateitsbuildingprincipals(6)ApplicationanduseofanylocallyselectedmeasuresofstudentgrowthusedintheOptionalsubcomponentoftheStudentPerformancecategoryusedbythedistrict/BOCEStoevaluateitsprincipals(7)UseoftheStatewideInstructionalReportingSystem(8)Thescoringmethodologyutilizedbythedepartmentand/orthedistrict/BOCEStoevaluateaprincipalunderthisSubpart,includingtheweightingsofeachsubcomponentwithinacategory;howoverallscores/ratingsaregeneratedforeachsubcomponentandcategoryandapplicationanduseoftheevaluationmatrix(es)prescribedbytheCommissionerforthefourdesignatedratingcategoriesusedfortheprincipal'soverallratingandtheircategoryratings(9)SpecificconsiderationsinevaluatingprincipalsofEnglishlanguagelearnersandstudentswithdisabilities
11.6)TrainingofLeadEvaluators,Evaluators,IndependentObservers,andPeerObserversandCertificationofLead
Evaluators
Describetheprocessfortrainingevaluators,includingimpartialandindependentobserversandpeerobservers,andcertifyingandre-certifying
4of5
leadevaluators.Yourdescriptionmustinclude:1)theprocessfortrainingleadevaluatorsandevaluators,includingimpartialindependentobserversandpeerobservers,2)theprocessforthecertificationandre-certificationofleadevaluators,3)theprocessforensuringinter-raterreliability,4)thenature(content)andtheduration(howmanyhours,days)ofsuchtraining.
Allevaluators(districtandindependent)andleadevaluatorsofthedistrictshallbetrainedannuallyandcertified/recertifiedbythegoverning
bodyofthedistricttoconductevaluationsundertheCommissioner'sRegulations3012dandRegentsRules30-3.TheOrleans-Niagara
BOCESNetworkTeamwillprovidethetraininginathreehoursessiononceperyear.Documentationandattendancerostersserveas
evidenceofparticipation.
AllAlbionevaluatorsandleadevaluatorswillcontinuetoparticipateinrefreshertrainings.
Inaddition,theDistrictwillconductatleasttwointer-raterreliabilityactivitiesofatleastonehourduration,bringingallevaluatorstogetherfor
thecalibrationtrainingusingtheMultidemensionalPrincipal'sPerformanceRubrictocreateconsistencyamongDistrictraters.
11.7)Assurances:PrincipalEvaluation
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
Assurethatthedistrict/BOCESshallcomputeandprovidetotheprincipaltheirscoreandratingfortheStudentPerformancecategory,ifavailable,andforthePrincipalSchoolVisitcategoryforaprincipal'sAnnualProfessionalPerformanceReview,inwriting,nolaterthanthelastschooldayoftheschoolyearforwhichtheprincipalisbeingmeasured,butinnocaselaterthanSeptember1oftheschoolyearnextfollowingtheschoolyearforwhichtheprincipal'sperformanceisbeingmeasured.
Checked
Assurethattheevaluationsystemwillbeusedasasignificantfactorforemploymentdecisions.
Checked
Assurethatprincipalswillreceivetimelyandconstructivefeedbackaspartoftheevaluationprocess.
Checked
AssurethatthefollowingprohibitedelementslistedinEducationLaw§3012-d(6)arenotbeingusedaspartofanyprincipal’sevaluation:evidenceofstudentdevelopmentandperformancederivedfromlessonplans,otherartifactsofprincipalpractice,andstudentportfolios,exceptforstudentportfoliosmeasuredbyaState-approvedrubricwherepermittedbythedepartment;useofaninstrumentforparentorstudentfeedback;useofprofessionalgoal-settingasevidenceofprincipaleffectiveness;anydistrictorregionally-developedassessmentthathasnotbeenapprovedbythedepartment;andanygrowthorachievementtargetthatdoesnotmeettheminimumstandardsassetforthinregulationsoftheCommissioner.
Checked
AssurethatifthedistrictisgrantedanannualIndependentEvaluatorHardshipWaiverbytheDepartment,thesecondschoolvisit(s)shallbeconductedbyoneormoreevaluatorsselectedandtrainedbythedistrict,whoaredifferentthantheevaluator(s)whoconductedtheschoolvisit(s)requiredtobeperformedbythesupervisororothertrainedadministrator.
(Noresponse)
11.8)Assurances:Assessments
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
5of5
Assurethat,whereapplicable,ifstudentsinCommonCorecoursesaretakingboththe2005LearningStandardsandCommonCoreversionsoftheRegentsAssessment,thenthedistrict/BOCESwillusethehigherofthetwoscorestodeterminewhetherastudenthasmethis/hergrowthtarget.
Checked
Assurethattheamountoftimedevotedtotraditionalstandardizedassessmentsthatarenotspecificallyrequiredbystateorfederallawforeachclassroomorprogramwithinagradeleveldoesnotexceed,intheaggregate,onepercentoftheminimumrequiredannualinstructionalhoursforthegrade.
Checked
Assurethatindividualswithvestedinterestintheoutcomeoftheirassessmentsarenotinvolved,totheextentpracticable,intheadministrationandscoringofthoseassessments.
Checked
11.9)Assurances:Data
Pleasecheckalloftheboxesbelow:
AssurethatSEDwillreceiveaccurateteacherandstudentdata,includingenrollmentandattendancedata,andanyotherstudent,teacher,school,course,andteacher/studentlinkagedatanecessarytocomplywithregulations,inaformatandtimelineprescribedbytheCommissioner.
Checked
Assurethatthedistrict/BOCESprovidesanopportunityforeveryclassroomteachertoverifythesubjectsand/orstudentrostersassignedtothem.
Checked
AssurescoresandratingsforallprincipalswillbereportedtoNYSEDforeachcategory,aswellastheoverallrating,asperNYSEDrequirements.
Checked
Assurethatenrolledstudentsinaccordancewithpoliciesforstudentassignmenttoschoolsandmaynotbeexcluded.
Checked
Assurethatproceduresforensuringdataaccuracyandintegrityarebeingutilized.
Checked
1of1
Task12.JointCertificationofAPPRPlanCreated:04/30/2013
Lastupdated:11/16/2015
Page1
Pleaseobtaintherequiredsignatures,createaPDFfile,anduploadyourjointcertificationoftheAPPRPlanusingthisform:APPRDistrictCertificationForm.PleasenotethatReviewRoomtimestampseachrevisionandsignaturescannotbedatedearlierthanthelastrevision.
https://NYSED-APPR3.fluidreview.com/media/assets/survey-uploads/49456/3882126-JbgOrIWgSl/APPR-cert-11.16.15.pdf
FiletypessupportedforuploadsPDF(preferred)MicrosoftOffice(.doc,.ppt,.xls)MicrosoftOffice2007:Supportedbutnotrecommended(.docx,.pptx,.xlsx)OpenOffice(.odt,.ott)Images(.jpg,.gif)OtherFormats(.html,.xhtml,.txt,.rtf,.latex)Pleasenotethat.docx,.pptx,and.xlsxformatsarenotentirelysupported.Pleasesaveyourfiletypesas.doc,.pptor.xlsrespectivelybeforeuploading.
Albion Central School District
Principal Improvement Plan
Professional: Improvement Team Designated by the Superintendent of Schools:
Administrator:
Other:
Area in need of Improvement as identified by APPR: 1.
2.
3.
Performance
Goal
Time Frame Strategies/Activities Evidence/Assessment Performance Outcome
Professional Development Recommendation:
Responsible Person:
Professional Development Recommendation:
Responsible Person:
Principal Union Representative District Representative Superintendent
Albion Central School District
Teacher Improvement Plan
Professional: Improvement Team Designated by the Superintendent of Schools:
Support Teacher:
Mentor Teacher:
Administrator:
Other:
Area in need of Improvement as identified by APPR: 1.
2.
3.
Performance
Goal
Time Frame Strategies/Activities Evidence/Assessment Performance Outcome
Professional Development Recommendation:
Responsible Person:
Professional Development Recommendation:
Responsible Person:
Teacher Union Representative District Representative Superintendent