The role of process analytical technology (pat) in green chemistry and green engineering webinar
-
date post
21-Oct-2014 -
Category
Documents
-
view
1.501 -
download
2
description
Transcript of The role of process analytical technology (pat) in green chemistry and green engineering webinar
The Role of Process Analytical Technology (PAT) in
Green Chemistry and Green Engineering – Part II
Tuesday December 1st
4am, 9am, and 2pm EST
Presenter: Dominique Hebrault, Ph.D.Senior Technology and Application
Consultant
1
The Twelve Principles of Green Chemistry
Green Chemistry and Continuous or Bio Process
Green Chemistry and Continuous or Bio Process
Green Chemistry and Continuous or Bio Process
5
Outline
Case Studies
- Monitoring of a Biotransformation using ReactIR™
- Development of a Continuous Process with ReactIR™
- RC1e Calorimetry: a Tool for Continuous Process Development
- Bioprocess Monitoring using RC1e Calorimetry
Conclusion
Monitoring of Baeyer-Villiger bio-
transformation kinetics and finger-
printing using ReactIR spectroscopy
Introduction
Most fermentation monitoring concerns
the determination of analyte
concentrations
ReactIR™ used for:
-Measuring progress and kinetics
-Conversion of cyclododecanone (CDD)
into lauryl lactone (LL)
-Catalyzed by a recombinant NADPH-
dependent cyclopentadecanone
monooxygenase
Source: Peter C.K. Lau et al, Biotechnology Research Institute, National Research Council, Canada; Industrial Biotechnology 2006, 138–142;
Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 2006, 2707–2720
Case Study: FTIR as PAT tool for Biotransformation
Case Study: FTIR as PAT tool for Biotransformation
Results of CDD biotransformation as
a function of cell growth in a fed-
batch culture
Qualitative: 3-D spectral fingerprint of
CDD conversion to LL shows:
-Decrease of CDD absorbance at 1713cm-1
- Increase of LL absorbance at 1741cm-1
Source: Peter C.K. Lau et al, Biotechnology Research Institute, National Research Council, Canada; Industrial Biotechnology 2006, 138–142;
Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 2006, 2707–2720
Quantitative: Peak profiling and
quantitative calibration model using
QuantIRTM to monitor
-Use of authentic standards of CDD and LL
-Detection sensitivity for LL: 0.2 mM
Case Study: FTIR as PAT tool for Biotransformation
-Better understanding of reaction
kinetics
-Original utilization of ReactIR™
technology for offline qualitative and
quantitative monitoring of
cyclododecanone biotransformation
Source: Peter C.K. Lau et al, Biotechnology Research Institute, National Research Council, Canada; Industrial Biotechnology 2006, 138–142;
Applied and Environmental Microbiology, 2006, 2707–2720
-Further development in online
monitoring and automatic controlling
-Initial expansion to a wider range of
cycloketones
9
Outline
Case Studies
- Monitoring of a Biotransformation using ReactIR™
- Development of a Continuous Process with ReactIR™
- RC1e Calorimetry: a Tool for Continuous Process Development
- Bioprocess Monitoring using RC1e Calorimetry
Conclusion
Development and Scale-up of Three
Consecutive Continuous Reactions for
Production of 6-Hydroxybuspirone
Introduction
Control base / buspirone stoichiometry is
critical to product quality
Optimization based on offline analysis is
time consuming and wasteful
Actual feed rate adjusted based on the
feedback from inline FTIR: Flow cell and
ReactIR™ DiComp probe
Case Study: FTIR as PAT Tool for Continuous Process
Source: Thomas L. LaPorte,* Mourad Hamedi, Jeffrey S. DePue, Lifen Shen, Daniel Watson, and Daniel Hsieh, Bristol-Myers Squibb
Pharmaceutical Research Institute, NJ, USA, Organic Process Research and Development, 2008, 12, 956-966; Mettler Toledo Real Time
Analytics Users’ Forum 2005 - New York
Case Study: FTIR as PAT tool for Continuous Process
Implemented startup strategy
-Start with slight undercharge of base
(feed rate) to reduce diol 8
-Flow rate increased at 1% increments
until no decrease of Buspirone 1 signal
is observed
-Base feed rate was reduced 1-3%
-Works well because enolization fast,
equilibrium reached within minutes
KHMDS
Source: Thomas L. LaPorte,* Mourad Hamedi, Jeffrey S. DePue, Lifen Shen, Daniel Watson, and Daniel Hsieh, Bristol-Myers Squibb
Pharmaceutical Research Institute, NJ, USA, Organic Process Research and Development, 2008, 12, 956-966; Mettler Toledo Real Time
Analytics Users’ Forum 2005 - New York
Case Study: FTIR as PAT Tool for Continuous Process
Outcome
-Ensure product quality via proper ratio
and base feed rate
-Minimize waste of starting material
-Faster reach of steady state via real-
time detection of phase transitions
-FTIR also used for enolization
monitoring during steady state
Scale-up
-Lab reactor: Over 40 hours at steady
state
-Pilot-plant reactor: Successful
implementation (3-batch, 47kg/batch)
Source: Thomas L. LaPorte,* Mourad Hamedi, Jeffrey S. DePue, Lifen Shen, Daniel Watson, and Daniel Hsieh, Bristol-Myers Squibb
Pharmaceutical Research Institute, NJ, USA, Organic Process Research and Development, 2008, 12, 956-966; Mettler Toledo Real Time
Analytics Users’ Forum 2005 - New York
13
Outline
Case Studies
- Monitoring of a Biotransformation using ReactIR™
- Development of a Continuous Process with ReactIR™
- RC1e Calorimetry: a Tool for Continuous Process Development
- Bioprocess Monitoring using RC1e Calorimetry
Conclusion
An Integrated Approach Combining
Reaction Engineering and Design of
Experiments for Optimizing Reactions
Introduction
Early phase RC1e experiments to obtain
a basic understanding of:
-Enthalpy
-Kinetics
-Mass Balance
-Type of phases
Case Study: Calo for Reaction Kinetics Screening
Source: D.M. Roberge, Department of Process Research, Lonza, Switzerland, Organic Process Research and Development, 2004, 8, 1049-1053;
Mettler Toledo 15th International Process Development Conference 2008, Annapolis, USA; Chem. Eng. Tech., 2005, 28, No. 3, 318-323
Type A: Very fast, t1/2< 1 s, controlled by
mixing
Type B: Rapid, 1 s < t1/2< 10 min, mostly
kinetically controlled
Type C: Slow, t1/2 > 10 min, safety issue
in a batch mode
50% of reactions in the
fine/pharmaceutical industry could
benefit from a continuous process
(microreactors)
RC1e allows precise measurement of
reaction enthalpy
Instantaneous reaction heat is related to
reaction rate
Results: Very fast reaction
-No heat accumulation
-Dosing controlled
Case Study: Calo for Reaction Kinetics Screening
Source: D.M. Roberge, Organic Process Research and Development, 2004, 8, 1049-1053; Mettler Toledo 15th International Process Development
Conference 2008, Annapolis, USA; Chem. Eng. Tech., 2005, 28, No. 3, 318-323
C=C double bond oxidized / cleaved by
aqueous NaOCl catalyzed by Ru
Type A: Very fast, t1/2< 1 s
controlled by mixing
Results: Rapid reaction
-Heat signal function of dosing rate
-Reagent accumulates and reacts
after the end of the dosage
-Lower temperatures favor high
accumulation
-Higher temperatures favor formation
of side products
Case Study: Calo for Reaction Kinetics Screening
Source: D.M. Roberge, Organic Process Research and Development, 2004, 8, 1049-1053; Mettler Toledo 15th International Process Development
Conference 2008, Annapolis, USA; Chem. Eng. Tech., 2005, 28, No. 3, 318-323
Quench of ozonolysis into methanol /
dimethyl sulphide
Type B: Rapid, 1 s < t1/2< 10 min, mostly
kinetically controlled
Results: Slow reaction
-Accumulation of energy > 70%
-Most of the heat potential evolves
after the end of addition
-Typically initiated by temperature
increase or catalyst addition
-Autocatalytic reaction and / or
induction period
Case Study: Calo for Reaction Kinetics Screening
Source: D.M. Roberge, Organic Process Research and Development, 2004, 8, 1049-1053; Mettler Toledo 15th International Process Development
Conference 2008, Annapolis, USA; Chem. Eng. Tech., 2005, 28, No. 3, 318-323
Knoevenagel-type reaction catalyzed by NaOH:
intramolecular aromatic ring condensation
Type C: Slow, t1/2 > 10 min, safety
issue in a batch mode
Conclusion
Real time RC1e calorimetry also for early
on kinetics and safety assessment
18
Outline
Case Studies
- Monitoring of a Biotransformation using ReactIR™
- Development of a Continuous Process with ReactIR™
- RC1e Calorimetry: a Tool for Continuous Process Development
- Bioprocess Monitoring using RC1e Calorimetry
Conclusion
Biocalorimetry and Respirometric
Studies on Metabolic Activity of
Aerobically Grown Batch Culture of
Pseudomonas Aeruginosa
Introduction
Goal is to select an enhanced culture,
design a bioreactor, for treatment of
saline wastewater (tanning industry)
Metabolic efficiency of halobacterial
strains evaluated by RC1e calorimetry
Heat is a by-product of metabolic
processes, nonspecific, non-invasive and
insensitive to the electrochemical, and
optical properties
Source: S. Mahadevan et al, Department of Chemical Engineering, CLRI, Chennai, India; Biotechnology and Bioprocess Engineering 2007, 12, 340-
347; Biochemical Engineering Journal 2008, 39, 149-156
Case Study: RC1e Calorimetry for Biotransformation
Glucose
O2 uptake
Growth, heat
Results
Good correlation of kinetic profiles by
standard method (shaker), simulation,
and reaction heat
Source: S. Mahadevan et al, Department of Chemical Engineering, CLRI, Chennai, India; Biotechnology and Bioprocess Engineering 2007, 12, 340-
347; Biochemical Engineering Journal 2008, 39, 149-156
Case Study: RC1e Calorimetry for Biotransformation
Biomass Concentration
Substrate ConcentrationHeat rate follows growth curve at various
glucose concentration
Shows affinity of strain to glucose
Heat yield coefficient (kJ heat evolved per
g dry cell formed) determined from total
heat versus biomass concentration
Source: S. Mahadevan et al, Department of Chemical Engineering, CLRI, Chennai, India; Biotechnology and Bioprocess Engineering 2007, 12, 340-
347; Biochemical Engineering Journal 2008, 39, 149-156
Case Study: RC1e Calorimetry for Biotransformation
Heat yield vs biomass growth
Heat yield coefficient (kJ heat evolved per
g of glucose consumed) determined from
total heat versus substrate concentration
Substrate breakdown results in more heat
evolution than biomass growth
Heat yield vs substrate
Oxycalorific coefficient determined from
the slopes of heat generated versus
cumulative oxygen uptake
Literature reported aerobic tendency of P.
Aeruginosa confirmed here
Source: S. Mahadevan et al, Department of Chemical Engineering, CLRI, Chennai, India; Biotechnology and Bioprocess Engineering 2007, 12, 340-
347; Biochemical Engineering Journal 2008, 39, 149-156
Case Study: RC1e Calorimetry for Biotransformation
Heat vs O2 uptake
Cell number increases until substrate(s)
depleted, then stops growing, and die
Heat flux ideal candidate to monitor
growth rate
Heat vs colony forming unit
Conclusion
-Growth and activity of P. Aeruginosa
monitored by biocalorimetry, which fits
biomass growth and oxygen uptake
rates
-Oxycalorific coefficient and heat yield
values found matches theoretical
values
Source: S. Mahadevan et al, Department of Chemical Engineering, CLRI, Chennai, India; Biotechnology and Bioprocess Engineering 2007, 12, 340-
347; Biochemical Engineering Journal 2008, 39, 149-156
Case Study: RC1e Calorimetry for Biotransformation
Better understanding of biokinetics of
halotolerant P. Aeruginosa isolated from
tannery soak liquor
Helps efficient design of bioreactor
24
Outline
Case Studies
- Monitoring of a Biotransformation using ReactIR™
- Development of a Continuous Process with ReactIR™
- RC1e Calorimetry: a Tool for Continuous Process Development
- Bioprocess Monitoring using RC1e Calorimetry
Conclusion
Summary
- Did the reaction work?
- Understand selectivity and reactivity
- Identify intermediates or by-products
- How long did it take?
- Endpoint, initiation-point, stall-point
- Can this process be scaled-up?
- Identify key control parameters
- Understand, measure reaction
kinetics
- Will it be safe?
- Measure reaction heat/enthalpy
- Determine heat capacity, heat
transfer coefficient
- Worst case scenario estimation
- Thermal accumulation and
conversion
Challenges of (bio)process development: ReactIR™, calorimetry, reactors
Software for Design, Data Acquisition and Analysis
Reaction Progress Kinetic Analysis: A Powerful
Methodology for Mechanistic Studies of
Complex Catalytic Reactions*
*Donna G. Blackmond, Angew. Chem. Int. Ed. 2005, 44, 4302 – 4320
Data Reaction Progress Kinetic FitSummary Simulate
Temperature Model Comment
Models
Only two data points. Rerun
DeleteNew Isothermal model
Button/menu drop down –
Options:
1) New Isothermal model
2) New temp. depend. model
3) New from selected model
Reaction Conditions
Parameter Axis Lo Hi
40.0 60.0Y axis
5.00 8.00Constant
10.0 20.0X axis
Edit Model
1.00
1.50
0.01
24.3e-4
k:
a:
b:
E act:
Apply
Time
to 9
5% co
nver
sion
of A
TA(0)
10.0
20.0 40.0
60.0
0.000
2.000
4.000
6.000
8.000
10.000
12.000
14.000
16.000
0.000 10.000 20.000 30.000 40.000
[A],[B
]
time
This point the user clicked on represents A(0)=15
and T=48 C. The entire reaction is shown at right
using these reaction conditions.
Simulation Output
Conversion of at minutes60A
Time to % conversion of 95 A
Q Peak during minute reaction60
A(0)
B(0)
T
T=48 C
Early-on kinetic evaluation
Temperature dependence model
Catalyst stability evaluation
Simulation
Internal usage only
Questions and Answers
For further information on products and applications:
Visit us at www.mt.com/autochem
OR
Email us at [email protected]
OR
Call us + 1.410.910.8500
Visit www.mt.com/ac-webinars for the current webinar schedule and access to the
on-demand webinar library
Don’t miss the 17th International Process Development Conference - May 16 to 19,
2010 in Baltimore, MD, USA – www.mt.com/ipdc
27