The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and...

37
1 Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved. www.esi-group.com www.esi-group.com Copyright © ESI Group, 2017. All rights reserved. The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL) & Hybrid Twins Alain de Rouvray Vincent Chaillou PDG DGD Forum TeratecJune 27, 2017 From « Industry 4.0 » to « CAE 4.0 + »

Transcript of The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and...

Page 1: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

1

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com www.esi-group.com

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017. All rights reserved.

The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL)

& Hybrid Twins

Alain de Rouvray Vincent Chaillou

PDG DGD

Forum Teratec– June 27, 2017

From « Industry 4.0 » to « CAE 4.0 + »

Page 2: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

2

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

The Outcome Economy

Outcome is not a Product nor a Service, but a Solution !

“How the Industrial IoT* is changing every business”

Joseph Barkai – 2016

IDC Manufacturing Insights

Product Lifecycle Strategies

*IoT: Internet of Things

Page 3: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

3

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

The Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL)

People don’t want to buy a quarter-inch drill;

They want a quarter inch hole!

Theodore Levitt

HBS* – Marketing Professor

*HBS: Harvard Business School

And … a good one!

Page 4: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

4

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com www.esi-group.com 4

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017. All rights reserved.

The context of the Digital Transformation

From a Good Product to an Effective Solution

Page 5: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

5

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Product from ‘Nominal’ to ‘in Life’

The context of the Digital Transformation – Industry Disruption

Simulation (HPC)

Technology

IoT / Cloud

Delivery

Certified In Operation

Manufacture

Robotics Smart Factory

PLM Product Lifecycle Management

PPL Product Performance Lifecycle

Effective Solution:

Hybrid Twin !

Page 6: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

6

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

From Automated to Smart to Outcome

The context of the Digital Transformation – Enterprise Disruption

Automated Production

/ Product Certification Intelligent Production

/ Smart Factory

Solution Value

/ Performance

Industry 3.0

Eco-system !

Page 7: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

7

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Product:

from: ‘a Tool’ to ‘on Demand’ to ‘Enabler’

The context of the Digital Transformation – Customer Disruption

Product Service ‘App’ based Solution

Anonymous!

Page 8: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

8

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Impact on resources and customers – Distributed eco-systems

The context of the Digital Transformation – Jobs Disruption

Democratize, Customize and Bring jobs ‘home’ ?

Conceive Make Connect

Ubiquitous !

Page 9: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

9

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Heralding the impact of ICT* and IoT*

The context of the Digital Transformation – International Initiatives

Industry 4.0

Fourth industrial revolution for the

virtualization of manufacturing

‘Industrie du futur’:

Transform the industrial model by

digital technology

‘Manufacturing 2025’:

Transition from ‘made’ in China to

‘design’ in China

‘Innovate UK’:

Innovation agency to drive the

science and technology innovations

‘Horizon 2020’:

Funding program to support

and foster research

National Network for

Manufacturing Innovation

(NNMI) Improve US

Manufacturing Competitiveness

Smart Factory ! ICT*: Information & Communication Technologies – IoT*: Internet of Things

Page 10: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

10

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com www.esi-group.com 10

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017. All rights reserved.

The Transformation of the CAE world

To « Industry 4.0 » with « CAE 4.0 + »

Page 11: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

11

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

G.HC.17.016.A.

from Product Management “PLM” to Product Performance “PPL”

The CAE-4 disruptive challenges:

HPC + ICT + IVE HPC

CAE 1+2

As built as tested

per Component

Analysis & Simulation

for design and validation

Virtual Prototype

for multi-domain

Pre-certification

A.I.: Artificial Intelligence – M.L.: Machine Learning – D.L: Deep Learning – IoT: Internet of Things

HPC: High Performance Computing – ICT: Information & Communication Technologies - IVE: Immersive Virtual Engineering

CAE 3

As calibrated

per Silo

VIRTUAL PROTOTYPE

“The Singularity is Near” ! Ray Kurzweil – 2005 -

! Big Data !

Product Development Management

Page 12: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

12

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

G.HC.17.016.A.

from Product Management “PLM” to Product Performance “PPL”

The CAE-4 disruptive challenges:

HPC + ICT + IVE HPC

AI + ML + DL

CAE 1+2

As built as tested

per Component

As faulted

as interacting

Analysis & Simulation

for design and validation

Virtual Prototype

for multi-domain

Pre-Certification

Hybrid Twin

For Outcome and

Performance

Virtual Twin

in its Usage Environment

A.I.: Artificial Intelligence – M.L.: Machine Learning – D.L: Deep Learning – IoT: Internet of Things

HPC: High Performance Computing – ICT: Information & Communication Technologies - IVE: Immersive Virtual Engineering

CAE 3 CAE 4 CAE 5-6

Cloud + IoT

Updated with

real life data

As calibrated

per Silo

HYBRID TWIN VIRTUAL PROTOTYPE

Product Development Management

Operational

Life

Page 13: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

13

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

The transformation of the CAE-4 world

Physics-based Virtual Twin

Instrumented Physical Asset

Simulation Data

Data-driven Virtual Twin

Sensor

Act

Machine Learning Empirical models

Reduced order models

Faulted models

Math-based

Causal models 0d/1d system model

3d/4d detailed models

Data Lake

Update

Auto-learning

Historical

Data

Decision

ML* Models

Foresight vs Hindsight Actionable !

Learning

Apply

Wrapping elements

Page 14: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

14

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Design, visualize, analyze, take decisions using both data sets

The Art of Modeling for Full Life Performance

Example of the Wind Hybrid Twin™:

The context of CAE-4 Transformation

ANALYSIS &

SIMULATION

VIRTUAL

FAB &

TESTING

VIRTUAL

TWIN

DESIGN &

CALIBRATION

for

VALIDATION

MULTI DOMAIN

MODELING

for

PRE-

CERTIFICATION

VIRTUAL

ENVIRONMENT

for

OPERATIONAL

INTERACTIONS

DATA DRIVEN

SOLUTION

for

PERFORMANCE

CAE 1/2 CAE 3 CAE 4 CAE 5/6

Outcome Value!

Page 15: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

15

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Design, visualize, analyze, take decisions using both data sets

Example of Hybrid Twin™: Data driven solution performance for “Outcome” value

The context of CAE-4 Transformation

Add a

4th Crank

Page 16: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

16

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Design, visualize, analyze, take decisions using both data sets

Example of The Virtual Twin: Multi-domain modeling for fabrication and testing

The context of CAE-4 Transformation

Mecca

Giant Umbrellas

Environment

Interaction Desert wind

Virtual Prototype

Page 17: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

17

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Motion of pedestrian – example of crowd flow

The context of CAE-4 Transformation

Environment

Interaction:

people

Page 18: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

18

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com www.esi-group.com 18

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017. All rights reserved.

Smart Factory for fabrication and repair

Page 19: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

19

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Actionable factor: Right ‘Materials’ for better Quality products

Smart Factory

Fabrication

/ Assembly Line

Maintenance

/ Repair

Materials

/ as used & damaged

“Engineering” materials !

Page 20: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

20

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Virtual Manufacturing Solution – Virtual Prototype

Smart Factory for fabrication and repair - Component

Fatigue

Performance

‘as built’

Page 21: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

21

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Structural Health Monitoring Solution – Hybrid Twin Smart Factory for fabrication and repair

Virtual

1 Billion colums of data

Real Sensor

Big Data

Model Reduction

for near-real-time

Continuous learning and improvement of

data driven virtual model from real aircraft

Real

Page 22: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

22

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Multi-Scale characterization of Engineering materials

Smart Factory for fabrication and repair

The Virtual Material Lab to climb the pyramid of models

From “coupon”, to “element”, to “component”, to “full scale”

micro

meso

macro

scales

Page 23: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

23

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Multi-Scale characterization of Engineering materials

Smart Factory for fabrication and repair

Raw Data Repository

Virtual Material Lab

Scripts, Mesoscale

models, Unit cell

Materials Repository

Crs Wel Com SMF Standards ISO, ASTM, BIS

Tests Tensile, Torsion, Shear, Bending, Compression, Rupture

Materials Steel, Al, Composites

Specimen Shapes & Sizes

SMF

• Additive Layer Manufacturing

Ab-Initio

Solver specific

&

model coherent

Page 24: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

24

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Design

Process

Window

Material

Properties

Deposition Strategy

Fabrication of Engineering materials – Additive Layering Manufacturing (ALM)

Smart Factory for fabrication and repair

Process Efficacy

&

Part Quality

Page 25: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

25

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com www.esi-group.com 25

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017. All rights reserved.

ESI as a catalyst and digital solution integrator

Within the Eco-system(s)

Page 26: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

26

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

ESI as a catalyst and digital solution integrator

Combinational

Innovation

&

Industry Transfer

CAE 4.0 +

Page 27: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

27

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com www.esi-group.com 27

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017. All rights reserved.

Aeronautics

Focus

Page 28: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

28

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Expliseat: Get it right ‘as built’ & ‘as tested’

ESI as a catalyst and digital solution integrator

Achieved EASA certification at first try-out

Titanium Seat

Foam-Tissues-Composites-Metals-Assembly-

Ergonomics-Comfort-Safety-Certification

Virtual Twin

Page 29: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

29

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Key partner of the Aeronautic sector

ESI as a catalyst and digital solution integrator

Aeronautics Factory of the Future (UAF)

Embedded Systems and Advanced Functions (SEFA)

SOlutions For Industrial metal Additive manufacturing (SOFIA)

Co-creation & Collaborative Innovation

Aerospace Factory Additive Manufacturing

Page 30: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

30

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Virtual Reality Solution – Safran Nacelles

ESI as a catalyst and digital solution integrator

“Virtual reality represents a technology of the future that will have an impact on the efficiency

of our developments. The factory of the future is already here.”

Nicolas Lepape

Virtual & Augmented Reality R&T Project Manager Safran Nacelles

Page 31: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

31

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

ESI as a catalyst and digital solution integrator

“Due to increased awareness of ergonomics

and advances in design capabilities,

we now have a seat at the design table.”

Rich Gardner

Collaborative Peer review

Page 32: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

32

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Growing Eco-system

ESI as a catalyst and digital solution integrator

Innovative propulsive systems

Innovative propulsive Architecture

Innovative nacelle, structure and

integration Virtual Test

Co-creation

Integration

& Transfer

Page 33: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

33

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com www.esi-group.com 33

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017. All rights reserved.

Take Away

Page 34: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

34

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

The Outcome Economy :

Take Away: The Digital Transformation – 1/2

• Solutions Performance ‣ Enterprise Eco-system ‣ Customer Anonymous ‣ Jobs Ubiquitous

• Industry 4.0

‣ Smart Factory • ‘As built’ ‘as tested’ theory/causal based modeling • Data driven modeling update • Virtual Lab for Engineering materials

• CAE 4.0 + ‣ Virtual Prototyping

• Multi-Trade chaining per Domain • Multi-Domain integration per Component within Systems and Operational Environment • Immersive Virtual Engineering (IVE) for Collaborative Peer review

Page 35: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

35

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

The CAE-4 Outcome Value Proposition

Take Away: The Digital Transformation – 2/2

“As built

As Tested”

for

Pre-Certification

Virtual

Prototype

“As used”

& repaired

In real Operation

Product Development Lifecycle

keep it right and use it right

Theory

based

&

Data driven

updated

PLM Product Lifecycle

Management

PPL Product Performance

Lifecycle

Page 36: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

36

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Hot forming - AP&T

Smart Factory for fabrication and repair – Assembly Cell

Page 37: The Outcome Economy: Product Performance Lifecycle (PPL ... · Pre-Certification For Outcome and Performance ... Key partner of the Aeronautic sector ESI as a catalyst and digital

37

Copyright © ESI Group, 2017, All rights reserved.

www.esi-group.com

Thank you for your attent ion!

ESI as catalyst and digital solution integrator