The need for smart order routing in a fragmented market
Transcript of The need for smart order routing in a fragmented market
www.sungard.com
Burgundy Seminar - How to stay competitive in a fragmented market!
10 September, 2009
Philippe Ramkvist-Henry - Business Expert, SunGard Front Arena
The need for smart order routing in a
fragmented market
Networks
Institutional
Customers
Other
banks
Bank
System
Stock
Exchanges
Sell Side business – Today
Bank
System
Bank
System
Warrants &
Structured Prod.
Exchanges
Derivatives
Exchanges
Data vendors
(Reuters, Bloomberg)
Institutional
Customers
Networks
Stock
Exchanges
and
MTFs
Orders(indication of interest) IOI’s
TradesTrade Adverts
Order Network &Internal Market
InternalMatching
Internal Matchingof Order flow –Manual or Automatic
MiFIDReporting
FIX
SalesPersons
Tel
Excel
Programs
Bank
System
Bank
System
Other
banks
Integration
RoutingRules
FIX
FIX
ExecutionTraders
FIX
Industry View
SMART
web
TNP SDK
DMA clientRetail
Customers
Branch
Offices
There is only one market!
Consolidation
Ownership consolidation
Fewer platformsNew owners
New platforms
Orderbook liquidity fragmentation
Fragmentation
Screenshots are from the test systems!
Before – Recent – Now – StatoilHydro
What does a SOR do?
� Can connect and trade on multiple markets
� Uses realtime consolidated price view
� Where is the liquidity?
� What are the prices?
� What’s the multi market spread (EBBO of connected markets)?
� Manages venue specifics
� Rount lots
� Hours of service, trading phases etc
� Tick Sizes
� Preference venues based on
� Prices, Liquidity, Phase
� Market Share
� Execution & Settlement costs (price promotions etc)
Internal MarketInternal Market
Strategy example (Exhaust)
SMARTSMART
Order
Instruction
Volume available
No volume available
SMART Algo:
“Exhaust”
• Order moved to the markets in sequence.
• Remaining quantity moved to the next market.
Bank using
Synthetic SOR Strategies
� Use out-of-the-box in combination to create unique strategies suiting your business.
� Exhaust, Sweep
� Post, Post Best, Spray
� Cross Protect
� Hunter
� Retail order flow
� Sweep, Post (to Primary), Cross Protect
� All parameters hidden to user
� RetailStrategy
� Institutional order flow
� Exhaust, Post Best
� Some parameters available, example: MinQty
� InstStrategy
Exhaust example – Audit log (example 1)
Sell 50 000@70,5 executed in full at Chi-X at the average 70.5337! ~4,8bps improvement
Detail
� Order is sent as IOC 50 000@70,55
� 7974 is matched (all visible and Iceberg qty at 70,55)
� Order is returned to SMART for new decision
� Someone adds 4 961@70,55!
� Only possible to discover this newly added liquidity with low latency market data!
� SMART discovers the new 4 961@70,55
� Order is sent as IOC 42 026@70,55
� etc...
Exhaust example 2 - Audit log
Hits the market 10 times! Chi-X, Burgundy, SAX
Price improvement on
21084 shares!
50 000@76,008
~1,1bps improvement
Burgundy Statistics – August 2009
9,7%
8,8%
8,2%
17,8%
Note! Chi-X, NEURO, BATS etc are missing from market share statistics
8%
Sell Side – Do you need to own the SOR?
� You’re working for the buy-side
� Add value!
� Don’t use buy-side tools
� Differientiate!
� Oustsource your flow?
� Stay in control of your valuable assets!
� Be transparent with your customers!
� Internalization of customer order flow
� Difficult when acting on multiple markets
� Integrate SOR in your ALL you orderflow
� Leverage increased automation and transparency!
Internalization of customer order flow
Before MTF’s
� Crossing customer orders facilitated by exchange
� Internalization not really needed
With the MTF’s
� With more fragmentation likelihood of two customer orders being at same venue is lower.
� In order not to decrease chance of execution in-house internalization needed.
Necessary Solution
� Smart Order Routing with Internalization interaction
� Withdraw of moved crossing orders in the market
More statistics – OBX Market share
Data from BATS, http://www.batstrading.co.uk/market_data/venue/index/OBX/
� About 5-7% traded away from Oslo Börs
� Already reached +11% one day!
More statistics – OMXS30 Market share
� Already ~22% traded on the MTFs
Data from BATS, http://www.batstrading.co.uk/market_data/venue/index/OBX/
History repeating?
OMXS30 7 Months ago
OBX 1 Month ago
20% traded outside Oslo Börs
in 6 months?
Thank you!
Philippe Ramkvist-Henry
Business Expert – Order Management and Distribution
SunGard Front Arena
Connect with me on: