The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in...

16
The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying British supermarkets

Transcript of The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in...

Page 1: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

The exploitationof tea workers inIndia and Kenyasupplying Britishsupermarkets

Page 2: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so
Page 3: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

01

The tea industry is a booming globalbusiness.With 3.5 million tons of teaproduced each year – including 1.6million tons for export – tea harvestingis an important source of income formillions of workers across the globe.India and Kenya are two of the world’stop four tea-producing nations, earninghundreds of millions of pounds inexports each year. But in spite of themassive revenues tea sales generate,workers who pick and pack the leavesface horrendous conditions and earnfar below a living wage.

This report is a contribution toWar onWant’s ongoing campaign for corporateaccountability and Unite the Union’scampaign for the fair treatment of allworkers employed by businesses insupermarkets’ supply chains.The reportexposes the poverty wages, poor workingconditions and desperate insecurity ofworkers in Kenya and India who produce thetea sold in British supermarkets. Shockingly,these conditions have not improved sinceWaronWant’s groundbreaking report into the teasector in Sri Lanka almost 40 years ago. 1

UK supermarkets are signatories tovoluntary codes of conduct which are meantto guarantee decent working conditions and aliving wage to the workers in their supplychains. However, as we show in this report,tea workers in Kenya and India aresystemically denied these basic rights.

War onWant has repeatedly exposed theexploitation and poor treatment of overseasworkers supplying UK supermarkets. Similar

problems exist with products as diverseas meat, garments, wine and cut flowers.Despite the evident failure of voluntaryethical standards to improve conditions forworkers, the UK government has failed totake action to hold companies to account.

War onWant has a long history ofworking in partnership with both UKand international trade unions and withgrassroots organisations in developingcountries to combat the root causes ofpoverty. Similarly, Unite has a proud traditionof activism in support of workers’ rightsaround the world. This report recommendsaction that readers can take to send amessage to British supermarkets and tochallenge the UK government to adoptregulation that would allow exploitedworkers to seek redress.

John HilaryExecutive Director,War onWant

Jack Dromey MPDeputy General Secretary, Unite

Preface

Page 4: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

The British famously love their tea,brewing 165 million cups a day – anastonishing 60 billion cups a year.2 Butthe UK is not the only country partialto a cuppa.Tea is the second mostpopular drink in the world after water.Overall, 3.5 million tons of tea areproduced annually, of which 1.6 milliontons are exported.3

Kenya and India are two of the largestproducers and exporters of tea in the world,and together produce more than half of thetea drunk in the UK.4 The UK is the secondlargest importer of tea, accounting for nearly10% of world tea imports by volume. The UKbuys 16% of India’s exported tea, and 19%of Kenya’s.5

Although countries such as Kenya and Indiaare major tea producers, the structure of theglobal supply chain means that the lion’s shareof profits is captured by large multinationalcorporations.Tea producing countries havealso been hit by a decline in tea prices, as aresult of global supply exceeding demand.

Tea is usually exported after primaryprocessing (drying and bulk packaging).This means that blending, final packagingand marketing – which are the mostlucrative stages in the overall process– are mainly carried out by tea companiesin the buyer countries (see Figure 1).The buying and packing side of the teasupply chain is very concentrated,which gives the companies involved ahigh level of power over the prices paidto producers. Just four corporationsdominate the global tea trade:Unilever (UK/Netherlands),Van Rees(Netherlands), James Finlay (UK) andTataTetley/Stansand (UK).6

In the UK, the retail market is similarlyconcentrated, with the top four companiescontrolling 65% of the retail market:

Tetley (Tata), PGTips (Unilever),Twinings(Associated British Foods) andTyphoo(Apeejay Surrendra Group). Supermarketown-brands account for nearly 20% of themarket, and more than 80% of total UKtea sales take place through their outlets.7

As tea passes through packers and retailers,the final two stages of its journey to theconsumer, they capture a massive 86%of the value added, compared to 7% forthe producing country.

Very little of the profits included in theretail price of a box of tea goes to thetea-producing country. Instead, whilstmultinational corporations reap largerewards, tea workers are condemnedto a life of penury. A tea picker makes just1p for each £1.60 box of tea bags soldin a British supermarket.

ABitterCupTheexploitationofteaworkersinIndiaandKenyasupplyingBritishsupermarkets

The global tea industry02

Figure 1:Who makes money from your cup?8

retailer(e.g. supermarket)

blender(e.g.Typhoo,Tetley)

factory

trader/buying agent

tea auction/broker

tea picker

53%33%7%6%1%

<1%

A tea picker makes just1p for each £1.60 box oftea bags sold in a Britishsupermarket.

Page 5: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

03

Workers process leaves at a tea collection centre supplyinga tea factory in Kenya. Tea workers in Kenya earn under £40amonth – less than half a living wage.

Photo:JonSpaull

Page 6: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

UK supermarkets have committed tothe payment of a living wage to allworkers employed by businesses intheir supply chains.10 Despite theircommitment, tea workers employedby businesses in both India and Kenyawhich supply British retailers are paidless than half of what would constitutea living wage. A living wage allows aworker to provide his or her family withthe basic human necessities of decentfood, shelter, clothing, clean water,health care, education and transport,plus a little extra for discretionaryitems. In this respect it is different froma minimum wage, which is ofteninsufficient to cover living costs.

Kenyan tea workers were asked to state howmuch they need to support themselves andtheir family. In general, tea factory workersgave higher figures for a living wage than teapickers, as they need to spend more onfood and other basic expenses.The averagebetween the tea pickers and tea factoryworkers was 10,679 Kenyan shillings (KES)(£84.40), which confirms current estimatesfor a living wage of 10,000 KES (£79.03)given by flower worker trade unions.11

Workers in the tea processing factoryinterviewed for this report were paid about5,000 KES (£39.52) per month beforeovertime, i.e. half a living wage.Tea pickers,who are paid a piece rate for each kilogramof tea they harvest, are even worse off.Teapickers on the smaller estates earn between2,500 KES (£19.76) a month in the dryseason and 5,000 KES (£39.52) in the wetseason.Those interviewed for this reportwere only earning on average 3,060 KES(£24.18) a month – under half of whatthey see as a living wage.

Even the highest paid workers struggle tosurvive on the wages they earn. Food is their

biggest concern, and the vast majorityof workers report that their salaries areinadequate to buy food for themselves andtheir families.The average monthly foodbudget of Kenyan tea pickers is 2,600 KES(£20.55), which takes up almost all theiraverage monthly earnings. Even though theyspend a huge proportion of their earnings onfood, many tea pickers must make do on onemeal a day.They also describe struggling tofind the money to rent even small one-roomshacks made of scrap wood, which costaround 300 KES (£2.37) per month.

Workers all report that these pressures areincreasing as living costs, particularly foodprices, have risen sharply while wagesstagnate.With the bare necessities of foodand shelter consuming so much of a worker’searnings, families struggle to find the moneyfor other fundamental expenditures such asclothing, health care and school fees. On suchlow salaries, savings are non-existent, whichincreases workers’ insecurity and vulnerability.Many must also take on additional work tosupplement their wages.This ranges fromfarming a small plot to brewing home-madeliquor for sale.

Low wages are also widespread in the Indiantea sector.The estate examined in this reportpays its labourers 1,220 rupees (Rs) permonth, the equivalent of £15.45, but workersestimate that a living wage would be at leastRs 3,500 (£44.34) per month.This means theirearnings are a mere 35% of a living wage.

For Indian workers, lack of food is the majorconcern.The rise in global food prices overthe last few years has forced a reduction inthe amount of food consumed becauseworkers simply cannot afford to buy whatthey need. Consequently, there is widespreadmalnutrition and medical studies have foundthat 60% of the children in Indian tea estatesare underweight.12

ABitterCupTheexploitationofteaworkersinIndiaandKenyasupplyingBritishsupermarkets

Half a living wage04

Page 7: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

05

Indian tea workers spraychemicals over a field inAssam state.

Photo:epa/Corbis

Page 8: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

In Kenya, tea pickers are employedon a day-to-day basis so they canbe easily laid off when their labouris not required.This forces themto seek new employment eachday, making their lives extremelyprecarious.They wake up not knowinghow far they will have to walk to findwork, or if there is any work to befound.They have no benefits at all,and missing a day’s work for illnessor any other reason often meansthey cannot afford to eat that day.

Although factory workers have slightlymore secure conditions than tea pickers,the majority are hired on a casual basis (theexceptions being managers and specialisedworkers such as engineers). Factories arekeen to keep workers on temporarycontracts because casual workers are noteligible for any employment benefits. Incontrast, a permanent employee is entitledto the full range of benefits, including sickpay, maternity leave, paternity leave and paidannual holiday.

Under Kenyan law, workers are entitledto a permanent contract after three monthson the job.To avoid having to provide thebenefits guaranteed to permanent employees,factories lay off workers before theycomplete a three-month term, only to rehirethem immediately afterwards.This legalloophole is ruthlessly exploited year afteryear by factory management. One of theworkers interviewed for this report explainsthe process:

I have worked as a casual worker in the factoryfor the last 10 years. I sign a contract of threemonths for every new engagement with thefactory.What is annoying is that the managementwill never allow me to complete the three months.On a lucky contract period, I am allowed tocomplete two months, after which my contractis terminated. I am allowed back soon afterwardsto sign another three-month contract and I havelived by this cycle for the last nine years. I havenever had a break exceeding three monthswithout a contract with the factory. By keepingus on a three months contract the factoryis protected from providing employment benefits(e.g. leave, pension) to us.We cannot changethis, we cannot complain, we need the job evenif it is for a day.

In India most workers live on the largeplantation estates where they work.Thismeans that they do not need to searchfor work on a daily basis. However, theincreasing use of temporary contractsmirrors the Kenyan problem. If workers arenot permanent, the plantation does not haveto provide benefits such as medical facilities,maternity leave and food rations.Temporaryworkers are forced to pay out of pocket forthese services or benefits.

Indian workers face the additional threatof owners closing or abandoning teaestates, which has left some workers in Indiacompletely destitute.Tea estates are largeand often geographically isolated, makingtheir workers completely dependent uponthem for their livelihoods.When ownersabandon estates, workers can starve.

ABitterCupTheexploitationofteaworkersinIndiaandKenyasupplyingBritishsupermarkets

Casual work, precarious lives06

Page 9: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

07

Kenya, like many countries in sub-Saharan Africa, is suffering from increasingcompetition for natural resources such as water.This problem has beenmade even worse by the devastating recent drought, which has led to foodand water shortages for more than three million Kenyans.13 Water scarcityas a result of the drought has had a profound impact on agriculture andwildlife-based tourism, two of Kenya’s major industries.14

The tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantityof tea produced, and so the amount of work available for tea pickers has fallen.One estate producing tea sold in British supermarkets reported a 23% drop intea production as result of the drought. Jobs are scarcer, and if a tea picker islucky enough to find work, the quantity of tea that can be picked in a day islower, reducing their daily earnings. Factory workers also lose out, with manycasual workers laid off until the amount of tea to be processed increases. Atthe same time, reduced rainfall and crop failures have pushed up the price offood by 50%, making it even more difficult to make ends meet.15

WATER SCARCITY IN KENYAPhoto:Jon

Spaull

Working on a day-to-day basis, manyKenyan tea pickers are not providedwith basic benefits like sick leave.

Page 10: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

The work of tea labourers is arduous inaddition to being low paid and insecure.Tea pickers are on their feet all day withheavy baskets on their backs, often onuneven terrain and in harsh weatherconditions. Injuries are common, as arerespiratory and water-borne diseases.16

There is often exposure to pesticidesand insecticides, which the ILO citesas one of the major health and safetyhazards tea workers face.17

In Kenya, tea pickers work long hours, sixdays per week.They are also expected towork without breaks. One of the womenworkers interviewed for this report stated:

Nobody cares whether those working in the farmhave human feelings such as hunger.You reportfor work, you will have something to eat onceyou return home.

Because they are paid per kilogram, extrahours such as long trips to the tea factory’sbuying centres are not paid.

Tea factory workers face similar problems.Despite being entitled to tea and lunchbreaks during the day, casual workers aregenerally denied a lunch break.Whenharvests are high during the rainy season,overtime is compulsory.Workers can beforced to put in as many as 74 hours a week.

ABitterCupTheexploitationofteaworkersinIndiaandKenyasupplyingBritishsupermarkets

Poor working conditions08

Beatrice started working as a tea picker when she was 11 years old.Thoughshe dreamt of pursuing her education in hopes of a brighter future, herparents couldn’t afford to send her to school beyond primary level. Now 36,she ekes out a precarious existence for herself and her two children, rising at6am to search for employment for the day.The tea Beatrice picks is sold inBritish supermarkets.

On a good day, Beatrice will find tea-picking work within a few minutes’ walkof where she lives. On a bad day, she faces a walk of up to three hours to findemployment. Once she finds work, tea picking means she will be on her feetall day with a heavy basket on her back, usually without a break.

Working up to six days a week, Beatrice is paid a mere 6 Kenyan shillings (KES)per kilogram of tea she delivers to the tea factory – the equivalent of just 5p.18

During the dry season she may struggle to pick 15 kg in a day, giving her a dailywage of 90 KES (75p).This meagre amount is a fraction of what she needs tosupport her family.

As a casual worker, Beatrice is not eligible for benefits such as sick leave andmaternity leave. If she has to miss a day’s work, she and her children do not eat.Moreover, if Beatrice gets hurt on the job, she will not be able to afford healthcare.Tea picking is dangerous work, and Beatrice faces the risk of debilitatinginjury, including fractures, back injuries, major skin burns and poisoning fromexposure to pesticides.

THE LIFE OF A TEA PICKER

Page 11: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

09

Although overtime is paid, payment isdetermined by management and it is neverexplained to workers how this is calculated.

Women face the burden of responsibilityfor the housework and child care in additionto their employment. Female intervieweesdescribe rising before dawn to tend to theirhouseholds and then setting out to spend allday labouring in the fields.

Working hours in India are similar to thosein Kenya, and women labourers again notethe difficulty of performing cooking, cleaningand child care duties in addition to spendingeight or more hours in the fields.Time off isvery limited. Indian plantation workers arealso entitled to one day of paid leave forevery 20 days worked, but the workers weinterviewed had never even heard of thisright, let alone been granted it. Instead, theyreceive three and a half days off annually formajor holidays. Also, despite being entitled to14 days of paid sick leave a year, workers do

not enjoy this right in practice. As one said:“If we are ill, we can stay away from work,but the principle is no work, no pay.”

In addition to long hours, workers in theKenyan tea factory describe how there isa lack of protective clothing needed to dothe work safely, such as masks to preventthe inhalation of tea dust.This causesrespiratory problems and headaches, butworkers are not eligible for health carebecause they are kept on casual contracts.They are forced to bear the coststhemselves.Workers also report thatinjuries result in dismissal, and compensationis unheard of.

Similarly, Indian tea estates provideinappropriate or poor quality protectiveequipment such as coats, shoes and maskswhich are not suitable for use in a tropicalclimate.Workers at the Indian estate wereseen using pesticide spraying equipmentwithout any protective gear whatsoever.

A Kenyan tea worker with his wife and daughter outside their home.Basic sanitation facilities are rarely provided in the areas wheretea pickers live, leading to high rates of water-borne illnesses.

Photo:JonSpaull

Page 12: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

Living conditions for tea workers arepoor in both Kenya and India. In Kenya,the tea factory supplying Britishsupermarkets only provides housingfor a few workers, mostly management.All other workers rent in the nearbymarket village. Houses are small, withwhole families crowded into one room.

In India, plantations are required by thePlantation Labour Act to provideaccommodation for their workers, alongwith medical care, education facilities, safewater and benefits like sick leave.19Whilsthousing is provided, it is of poor quality andin need of maintenance.

Decent sanitation facilities and a lack ofsafe water are also major problems. In Kenya,the only sanitation facilities are pit latrines,which can foster water-borne diseases.Indian workers do not even have these basicfacilities and have to use open ground, whichfurther jeopardises their health.Water safetyis another concern for workers. Only thoseKenyan workers who live in the factory haveaccess to piped water. All other workers haveto get their water from the river, where therisk of contamination is high.The Indianworkers fare badly again, as access tosafe drinking water is an acute problem.

Because of the Plantation Labour Act,the conditions found at the Indian estatedirectly violate Indian law. A major studythat interviewed 920 families in 25% of thetea gardens in Assam found that the sameregrettable conditions were the norm ratherthan the exception.20 The children of teaworkers in Assam suffer due to their parents’

low wages and miserable living conditions,as evidenced by the high prevalenceof malnutrition.

Even worse than their current situationis the fact that these circumstances deprivechildren of an education that might enablethem to break the cycle of grinding poverty.Under Indian law, plantations must provideeducational facilities, canteens, crèches andso on.The failure to provide educationaland support facilities condemns tea workersand their children to a future of poverty.Without schools on the estate, parentsmust find money for school fees and childrenhave to walk many kilometres to school.A mother explains:

My children go to school. I could afford to put themin school only because I sold hariya [local liquor].Otherwise, with our wages, how can we afford tosend children to school? I had to pay Rs 160[£2.05] just for his admission.The managementdoes not give any educational support. Only Godis helping us to educate our children.

Girls are not sent to school at all, whichmeans that most are illiterate, while boysrarely complete their education.

Parents in Kenya struggle similarly tostretch their meagre wages to coverschool fees.With government subsidies mostchildren can attend primary school, wherefees typically are around 3,000 KES a year.Secondary education school fees arealmost 20,000 KES a year, which isequivalent to at least four months’ wages,so as a consequence most children haveto drop out.

ABitterCupTheexploitationofteaworkersinIndiaandKenyasupplyingBritishsupermarkets

Poor living conditions10

Page 13: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

11

This report reveals the continuing failureof UK retailers to improve the conditionsof workers employed by businesses in theirsupply chains, despite their repeated claimsto be addressing the issue.With Britishsupermarkets unwilling to clean up their act,War onWant and other allied organisationshave been fighting for an independentwatchdog to oversee their business practicesoverseas. In a major campaign victory, eachof Britain’s three major political parties hasnow pledged support for a supermarketombudsman. But there is much stillto do to win rights for overseasworkers in supermarket supply chains.

We are asking all readers to take thefollowing actions to ensure that therights of tea workers are respected:

1. Call on the UK governmentIt is clear that voluntary codes of conductfor corporations have failed.The governmentmust implement a binding regulatoryframework to ensure the rights of overseasworkers are protected.We are asking oursupporters to demand that the governmentregulate UK companies and adopt legislationenabling overseas workers to seek justice inthe UK when they suffer from exploitativebuying practices.

One way to ensure greater corporateaccountability is to establish a Commissionfor Business, Human Rights & Environment.This commission, which has been endorsedby the Joint Parliamentary Committee onHuman Rights, would have the authorityto investigate and prosecute human rightsabuses, including those committedagainst workers.

Write to Ken Clarke QC, Lord Chancellorand Secretary of State for Justice, callingon the government to set up a Commissionfor Business, Human Rights & Environment.You can contact the Ministry of Justice at102 Petty France, London SW1H 9AJ.

2.Write to British supermarketsUnite the Union has been a leader inthe campaign for the rights of workers insupermarket supply chains. Unite earneda major victory in March 2010 when Asda,one of Britain’s largest retailers, signed onto a joint initiative with the trade union toput an end to unfair treatment of workerssupplying the supermarket with meat andpoultry products.

You can help ensure that the rightsof tea workers are protected bywriting to supermarket chief executives.

Take action

It has been nearly 40 years since War on Want first highlighted the

exploitation of tea workers in its report The State of Tea. That report focused

on Sri Lanka and found that workers struggled on low wages, were exposed

to unsafe conditions and lived in substandard housing. With this new report

on the tea estates in India and Kenya supplying British supermarkets, we find

a situation that has hardly changed. Workers continue to struggle on poverty

wages and are exposed to deplorable living and working conditions.

Page 14: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

ABitterCupTheexploitationofteaworkersinIndiaandKenyasupplyingBritishsupermarkets

12

Demand that supermarkets takeresponsibility for all workers employedby their businesses in their supply chains– wherever they work – by signingUnite’s Minimum Standards Agreement,which includes:

• Ending workplace discrimination;

• Eliminating harassment or bullyingof workers;

• Ceasing the practice of suppliers usingcontract labour to effectively denyworkers basic rights;

• Giving temporary and agency workers thesame benefits as permanent workers; and

• Affording workers engaged on temporarycontracts full employment protection rights.

To contact Sainsbury’s, write to:Justin King, Chief ExecutiveJ Sainsbury Plc, 33 HolbornLondon EC1N 2HT.

To contactTesco, write to:Terry Leahy, Chief ExecutiveNewTesco House, Delamare RoadCheshunt, Hertfordshire EN8 9SL.

To contactWaitrose, write to:Mark Price, Managing DirectorWaitrose Limited, Doncastle RoadBracknell RG12 8YA.

To contact Morrison’s, write to:Dalton Philips, Chief ExecutiveHilmore House, Gain LaneBradford BD3 7DL.

3. Join us!

War onWant relies on your contributionsto continue campaigning for workers’rights. Become a member today – youcan join our movement online atwww.waronwant.org/joinus

Page 15: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

1. The State of Tea: A War on Want Investigationinto Sri Lanka’s Tea Industry and the Plight of theEstate Workers,War onWant, London, 1974

2. UKTea Council, Tea Glossary and Faq’s, 2010

3. Sanne van derWal, Sustainability Issues in the TeaSector: A Comparative Analysis of Six Leading ProducingCountries, Centre for Research on MultinationalCorporations (SOMO), Amsterdam, 2008

4. The tea industries are structured differently in Kenyaand India. In Kenya, smallholders account for 60%of production.They are overseen by the KenyaTeaDevelopment Agency Limited (KTDA), which owns59 factories throughout the country. In India, largeplantations account for 74% of tea produced.TeaBoard of India, Production of Tea in India, 2009;and Apeejay Surrendra Tea, Apeejay Group, 2010

5. Kenya Tea Production Improves in November, CapitalBusiness, December 2009; Exports of Tea from India,Tea Board of India, 2009

6. van derWal, Sustainability Issues in the Tea Sector,SOMO, 2008

7. Mintel, ‘Tea and Herbal Tea’, Market Intelligence,London, 2009

8. Value added in the tea supply chain, adapted from:van derWal, Sustainability Issues in the Tea Sector,SOMO, 2008

9. Production costs are estimated to account for 8%of the retail price of tea, and include labour, input,transport costs, etc as well as profit. M.Vander Sticheleand S. van derWal, The Profit Behind Your Plate:Critical Issues in the Processed Food Industry,Centre for Research on Multinational Corporations(SOMO), Amsterdam, 2006

10. Many supermarkets are signatories to the EthicalTrading Initiative base code, which includes acommitment to paying workers a living wage.

11. Email correspondence with Kenyan Plantation andAgriculturalWorkers Union, 11 February 2010.

12. G. K. Medhi et al., ‘Study of Health Problems andNutritional Status ofTea Garden Population ofAssam’, Indian Journal of Medical Sciences 60, vol 60,no 12 (2006)

13. JohnVidal, ‘The last nomads: drought drives Kenya’sherders to the brink’, The Guardian, 3 September 2009

14. Jefferey Gettleman, ‘Lush land dries up, witheringKenya’s hopes’, The New York Times, 8 September 2009

15. JohnVidal, ‘Climate change is here, it is a reality’,The Guardian, 22 September 2009

16. van derWal, Sustainability Issues in the Tea Sector,SOMO, 2008

17. Vander Stichele and van derWal, The Profit BehindYour Plate, SOMO, 2006

18. All conversions in the report are calculated using theprevailing exchange rate during the period interviewswere conducted. For Kenyan shillings (KES), the averageSeptember and October 2009 rate of 126.53 KES/GBPis used. For Indian rupees (Rs), the average June 2009rate of 78.94 Rs/GBP is used.

19. The legislation that governs working conditions on teaestates in India is the Plantation Labour Act of 1951.The major provisions include that plantations mustprovide: housing for each worker; medical facilities;educational facilities; sufficient and clean drinking water;sickness and maternity benefits; and canteens, crèchesand recreational facilities.The cost of social serviceprovision impacts plantations’ profit margins, and theyargue that the government should assume responsibilityinstead.These requirements have also been cited as areason for companies’ abandoning plantations in favourof branding and marketing tea. In the meantime, as ourresearch shows, plantations either have substandardfacilities or fail to provide them altogether. There isno effective monitoring or enforcement to ensurethe minimum legal standards for workers’ conditions.

20. Gita Bharali, ‘TheTea Crisis, Heath Insecurityand Plantation Labourers’ Unrest’, in Society,Social Change and Sustainable Development,North Bengal University, 2007

How the research was conductedWar onWant’s researchers conducted in-depth interviews with tea workers in central Kenya fromSeptember to October 2009. A total of 22 workers were interviewed, including 14 tea pickers who picktea for a factory supplying tea sold in UK supermarkets, and eight workers from the factory itself.Workerswere selected using a snowballing technique in which one picker and one factory worker were initiallyidentified and each subsequent respondent was asked to name another worker. In total 14 women andeight men participated, which corresponds with the gender breakdown in Kenya’s agricultural workforce.

The International Union of Food, Agricultural, Hotel, Restaurant, Catering,Tobacco and AlliedWorkers’Association (IUF) represents millions of workers worldwide employed in food supply chains.The IUFcampaigns against the exploitation of tea workers, in India and Pakistan. In India, IUF researchers visited theplantation supplying tea sold in UK supermarkets on two occasions, where they spoke with over 30 workersand visited and photographed the facilities.The focus of this research was on violations of the PlantationLabour Act.

All names in this report have been changed in order to protect the identity of the workers concerned.

Notes

Page 16: The exploitation of tea workers in India and Kenya supplying ... Bitter Cup.pdfThe tea sector in Kenya has been hit with an 8% overall decline in the quantity of tea produced,and so

War onWantWar onWant fights poverty in developing countriesin partnership and solidarity with people affected byglobalisation.We campaign for human rights, especiallyworkers’ rights, and against the root causes of globalpoverty, inequality and injustice.

Cover picture: A female tea picker on an estate nearKerugoya, Kenya Picture: Jon Spaull

This report has been produced with the financialassistance of the European Union.The contents of thereport are the sole responsibility of War onWant andcan under no circumstances be regarded as reflectingthe position of the European Union.

Published: July 2010

Written by Anna Morser basedon research by Dr George Michukiand the IUF

War onWantDevelopment House56-64 Leonard StreetLondon EC2A 4LYUnited Kingdom

Tel: +44 (0)20 7549 0555Fax: +44 (0)20 7549 0556Email: [email protected]

www.waronwant.org

Company limited by guaranteeReg No. 629916Charity No. 208724

Design www.wave.coop

Printed on recycled paper