The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark · PDF fileThe Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Report ......
Transcript of The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark · PDF fileThe Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Report ......
Complete Benchmark Results
The Adobe InDesign CS2
Benchmark Report
Productivity Measures of Adobe InDesign CS2
Client: Adobe Systems
© Pfeiffer Consulting 2005
Reproduction and distribution prohibited without prior written permission
For information contact:
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
Table of Contents
About the Benchmark Project ..................................................................... 3About this Report ................................................................................................................... 4
About the Benchmark Project ................................................................................................. 4
Productivity Measures: Methodology Overview ...................................................................... 4
Overview ......................................................................................................................................... 4About the execution of the productivity benchmark ....................................................................... 4Scripting ......................................................................................................................................... 5Keyboard shortcuts ......................................................................................................................... 5
Hardware Overview ................................................................................................................ 5
Hardware platform ......................................................................................................................... 5Hardware configurations used ........................................................................................................ 5System software .............................................................................................................................. 5
Configuration — Overview ...................................................................................................... 5
System setup ................................................................................................................................... 5
Application Software .............................................................................................................. 5
Benchmarks and Productivity Measures: Detail ......................................... 6Application Integration Benchmarks ...................................................................................... 7
Assignment Based Benchmarks ............................................................................................. 7
Overview ......................................................................................................................................... 7Magazine publishing productivity measures ................................................................................... 7
Productivity in Everyday Design Operations ........................................................................... 8
Overview ......................................................................................................................................... 8Productivity in everyday design operations: complete assignment .................................................. 8Placing picture files ......................................................................................................................... 8Importing formatted tables ............................................................................................................. 8
Productivity Gains from Built-in Functionality ........................................................................ 9
Overview ......................................................................................................................................... 9Drop shadow .................................................................................................................................. 9Creating a simple transparency effect ............................................................................................. 9Formatting of text with nested style sheets ..................................................................................... 9Formatting multiple paragraphs with “Apply Next Style” .............................................................. 9Formatting multiple objects with Object Styles .............................................................................. 9Sharing parts of a page with Snippets ............................................................................................. 9Generating a PDF file .................................................................................................................... 10Place multi-page PDF file .............................................................................................................. 10
Section: Table of Contents
For further information contact: [email protected] October 14, 2005
1
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
Results and Charts ..................................................................................... 11Application Integration Benchmarks ...................................................................................... 12
Assignment Based Benchmarks: Magazine Publishing Productivity Measures ....................... 15
Productivity in Everyday Design Operations ........................................................................... 18
Productivity Gains from Built-in Functionality ........................................................................ 23
Section: Table of Contents
For further information contact: [email protected] October 14, 2005
2
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Section: About the Benchmark Project
For further information contact: [email protected]
October 14, 2005
3
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
About the Benchmark Project
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
1 About this Report
This report presents the results of the benchmarks conducted for the Adobe InDesign CS2 Productivity Benchmark Project.
2 About the Benchmark Project
This benchmark project was conceived and conducted to document differences in productivity between design and publishing workflows based on Adobe InDesign CS2 and QuarkXPress 6.5, respectively.Additional applications common in these workflows, such as Adobe Photoshop and Adobe Illustrator, were used wherever necessary.
3 Productivity Measures: Methodology Overview
3.1 Overview
The creative workflow benchmarks were defined as complete publishing/design assign-ments, covering everyday design operations and magazine publishing. For every assignment, a real-world publishing workflow example was defined in detail. Every aspect of the assignments was covered. Additional benchmarks were conducted to measure specific aspects such as productivity in everyday work situations as well as the impact of integration with native file formats on overall productivity.(See also “Benchmarks and Productivity Measures: Detail” on page 6)
3.2 About the execution of the productivity benchmarks
Productivity Benchmarks were composed as a number of phases. Every phase of the benchmark was then defined as several sets of clearly defined, repeatable steps. These steps were then executed in a strictly identical way by trained professionals. Each set of steps was executed three times; the average of all three results was used in the charts. The total times for each benchmark were obtained by cumulating the average mea-sures obtained for each individual set of steps.
Section: About this Report
For further information contact: [email protected] October 14, 2005
4
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
3.3 Scripting
No scripting was used in the execution of the benchmark: the main aim of these measures was to show real-world productivity, and had to take into account the time necessary for a trained operator to perform all the steps required in a project.
3.4 Keyboard shortcuts
Commonly used keyboard shortcuts were authorized in certain sets of benchmarks, and used in an identical way in all programs.
4 Hardware Overview
4.1 Hardware platform
All benchmarks and productivity measures were conducted on the Macintosh platform.
4.2 Hardware configurations used
• 2.5 GHz Power Mac G5
4.3 System software
• Mac OS 10.4
5 Configuration — Overview
5.1 System setup
• All tests were performed using a standard system installation and configuration.
• All computers were completely re-initialized prior to tests, using the default values for installation.
• All hard drives were re-formatted using a single partition.
• All software was installed from scratch, using default settings.
• The only software installed on the systems were the applications necessary for the benchmarks.
• No peripherals were connected to the systems during performance benchmarks.
6 Application Software
All application software was used in its most recent officially available release:• Adobe InDesign CS2
• QuarkXPress 6.5
• Adobe Photoshop CS2
• Adobe Illustrator CS2
Section: About the Benchmark Project
For further information contact: [email protected] October 14, 2005
5
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Section: Benchmarks
For further information
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
Benchmarks and Productivity Measures: Detail
and Productivity Measures: Detail
contact: [email protected] October 14, 2005
6
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
7 Application Integration Benchmarks
These benchmarks measured the productivity linked to integration of the page layout applications with Adobe Illustrator and Adobe Photoshop.Application integration Benchmarks were comprised of:
• Photoshop Round-trip (50MB)
• Photoshop Round-trip (100MB)
• Photoshop Round-trip (200MB)
• Illustrator Round-trip
For QuarkXPress 6.5, Photoshop files were accessed though the PSD Import XTension. PSD Import is not directly included with QuarkXPress 6.5, but can be downloaded at no charge from the Quark website. (Without PSD Import, Photoshop files need to be converted to a standard format in order to be used in a QuarkXPress page layout)
8 Assignment Based Benchmark
8.1 Overview
The assignment based benchmark consisted in a complete publishing project, a double-page spread for a magazine, which was executed from the start to finish in a clearly defined and completely monitored way.
8.2 Magazine publishing productivity measures
The project for the magazine publishing productivity benchmark consisted in the creation of an opening spread for a magazine feature. Work included creating the basic layout, importing pictures and text, formatting text, creating a headline with a drop shadow as well as other image work in Photoshop, importing and placing a graphic element from Illustrator and fine-tuning the final page layout.Project Phases:
• Phase 1: Create basic layout
• Phase 2: Import and format text
• Phase 3: Image-related work(Create and adjust picture and drop-shadow,add and position Illustrator graphic.)
Section: Application Integration Benchmarks
For further information contact: [email protected] October 14, 2005
7
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
9 Productivity in Everyday Design Operations
9.1 Overview
Several Benchmarks were defined to assess the real-world productivity of QuarkXPress and InDesign in everyday work situations. How do the programs perform when they are faced with the task of repeated reformatting of the same page? How fast can a designer try out different sizes for a same illustration, change column arrangements or experiment with different typefaces?
9.2 Productivity in everyday design operations: complete assignment
In order to measure fluidity in common design and page layout operations, Pfeiffer Consulting created a special project file: a 70 page, multi-column document. All columns in the document were linked; the complete text-chain contained a 55 000 word (328 000 characters) text; in addition, every page contained several pictures. The benchmark project consisted in repeated modifications of this document: switching to a specific spread in the middle of the document, reformatting the text and picture boxes, switching to another page, deleting one picture box and scaling up another one, and so forth.
9.3 Placing picture files
Importing images is one of the most frequent tasks in building page layouts.This benchmark measured the time necessary to place several image files in a page layout, in order to assess the throughput which can be expected from both programs for this operation.
9.4 Importing formatted tables
This benchmark measured the time necessary to import a formatted Excel spreadsheet fitting into a single A4 page. The time measured was the time required to display the imported table in the page layout document.
Section: Benchmarks and Productivity Measures: Detail
For further information contact: [email protected] October 14, 2005
8
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
10 Productivity Gains from Built-in Functionality
10.1 Overview
Adobe InDesign CS2 incorporates a number of original functions which are not currently available in QuarkXPress, such as creation of drop shadows, transparency effects, among several others.The following benchmarks were defined in order to measure the impact of these functions on productivity, when compared to workflows based on QuarkXPress.
10.2 Drop shadow
This benchmark measured the time necessary for creating a headline with a drop-shadow. InDesign CS2 integrates this possibility; QuarkXPress based workflows require the use of a separate program (usually Photoshop or Illustrator) for achieving this effect.
10.3 Creating a simple transparency effect
This benchmark measured the time necessary to create a simple transparency effect over an image in a page layout document. For QuarkXPress the effect was created using Adobe Photoshop.
10.4 Formatting of text with nested style sheets
This test compared the time necessary to apply rich formatting by using the Nested Styles option in InDesign CS2. The benchmark measured the time necessary to apply character style sheets individually for portions of a paragraph, as compared to the time required to apply the nested style sheet.
10.5 Formatting multiple paragraphs with “Apply Next Style”
The benchmark measured productivity gains linked to the use of the “Apply Next Style” feature introduced with InDesign CS2, compared with formatting the same pragarphs individually.
10.6 Formatting multiple objects with Object Styles
This benchmark measured the productivity impact of InDesign CS2’s “Object Styles” feature, compared to the time necessary for formatting several objects individually.
10.7 Sharing parts of a page with Snippets
The benchmark measured the time necessary to share parts of a page with a co-worker on the local area network, in one case using traditional methods such as cut and paste into a different document, in the other by using the “Snippets” feature introduced with InDesign CS2.
Section: Benchmarks and Productivity Measures: Detail
For further information contact: [email protected] October 14, 2005
9
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
10.8 Generating a PDF file
This benchmark measured the time necessary to create a PDF file from a page layout document.The benchmark consisted in creating PDF files of different versions: • PDF 1.3
• PDF 1.5
• PDF-X1a
(QuarkXPress 6.5 can only export PDF 1.3 files. For the other versions of PDF files, automatic conversion using Acrobat Distiller was used.)
10.9 Place multi-page PDF file
This benchmark measured the time to place a 5-page PDF document inside an exisiting page layout document.
Section: Benchmarks and Productivity Measures: Detail
For further information contact: [email protected] October 14, 2005
10
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark Report
Section: Results and Charts
For further information contact: [email protected]
October 14, 2005
11
Pfeiffer01001011
Consulting
Results and Charts
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
12
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
Application I
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
ntegration Benchmarks
Photoshop Round-trip
QQuarkXPress 6.5 InDesign CS2
550 MB 14.24 7.81100 MB 16.02 8.42200 MB 25.2 13.5
IIllustrator Round-trip Round-trip
QuarkXPress 6.5 IInDesign CS2
Illustrator Roundtrip 22.3 19.5
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
13
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
p
25.2
25 30
InDesign CS2
QuarkXPress 6.5
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Application Integration: Photoshop Round-tri
7.8
8.4
13.5
14.24
16.02
0 5 10 15 20
50 MB
100 MB
200 MB
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
14
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
19.5
22.3
20 25
InDesign CS2
QuarkXPress 6.5
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Application Integration: Illustrator Round-trip
0 5 10 15
Illustrator Round-trip
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
15
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
Assignment
2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Based Benchmarks: Magazine Publishing Productivity Measures
Magazine Publishing Productivity Assignment
QQuarkXPress 6.5 InDesign CS
Phase 1: Basic Layout 557.2 356.43
Phase 2: Text Work 364.6 369.7
Phase 3: Image Work 549.1 175.4
CComplete Assignment 1470.9 9901.53
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
16
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
557.2
6
549.1
3
.7
0 500 600
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Magazine Publishing Assignment: Detail
364.
356.4
369
175.4
0 100 200 300 40
Phase 1: Basic Layout
Phase 2: Text Work
Phase 3: Image Work
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
17
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
1470.9
1200 1400 1600
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Magazine Publishing Assignment: Total
901.53
0 200 400 600 800 1000
Magazine PublishingAssignment
Section: Results and Charts
For further information contact: [email protected]
Modified: October 14, 2005
18
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark ReportPfeiffer01001011
Consulting
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
Productivity in Everyday Design Operations
Productivity in Everyday Design Operations
QuarkXPress 6.5 IInDesign CS2
Phase 1 443.8 29.7PPhase 2 70.8 440.2Phase 3 884.9 50.6PPhase 4 91.7 669.7Total 2291.1 190.3
InDesign CS2 : Table Import
QuarkXPress 6.5 IInDesign CS2
Import Formatted Table From Excel 36.6 3.1
Place Images (Average time for 10 Images)
QuarkXPress 6.5 IInDesign CS) InDesign CS2 + Bridge
AAverage Time per Image 8.2 6.8 3.8
Section: Results and Charts
For further information contact: [email protected]
Modified: October 14, 2005
19
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc. Benchmark ReportPfeiffer01001011
Consulting
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
Productivity in Everyday Design Operations: Detail
43.8
70.8
84.9
91.7
29.7
40.2
50.6
69.7
0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0 50.0 60.0 70.0 80.0 90.0 100.0
Phase 1
Phase 2
Phase 3
Phase 4
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS2
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
20
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
291.1
0 300 350
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Productivity in Everyday Design Operations
190.3
0 50 100 150 200 25
Total
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
21
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
8.2
6.8
6 7 8 9
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS)
InDesign CS2 + Bridge
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Placing Picture Files
3.8
0 1 2 3 4 5
Average Time per Image
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
22
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
36.6
30 35 40
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Importing Formatted Tables
3.1
0 5 10 15 20 25
Import Formatted Table fromExcel
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
23
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
Productivity
Create Drop S graphs with "Apply Next Style"
QuarkXPress 6.5 InDesign CS InDesign CS2Total 20.4 20.1 5.4
62.7 61.1 37.8
Create Transp
Total QuarkXPress 6.5 InDesign CS InDesign CS274.6 68 21.7
Formatting ofayout through "Snippets"
Format 5 repetit QuarkXPress 6.5 InDesign CS InDesign CS237.1 33.8 13.4
Generate PDFcts with Object Styles
Generate PDFX 1 QuarkXPress 6.5 InDesign CS InDesign CSGenerate PDF 1. 61.4 56.9 14.3Generate PDF 1.Note: PDF 1.3 crea
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Gains from Built-in Functionality
hadow Formatting Multiple Para
QuarkXPress 6.5 InDesign CS2147.7 21.1 Simple Example
Complete Article
arencyPlace Multipage PDF File
QuarkXPress 6.5 InDesign CS2188.8 27.4
Place 5 Page PDF File
Text with Nested StylesSharing Parts of a Page L
QuarkXPress 6.5 InDesign CS2ive paragraphs 58.9 11.2
Share Parts of a Page Layout
FileFormatting Multiple Obje
QuarkXPress 6.5 InDesign CS2a (Acrobat Distiller) 26.7 6.7
5 (Acrobat Distiller) 28.7 5.3 Format Multiple Objects
3 17.1 6.5ted with QuarkXPress' integrated PDF Export
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
24
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
147.7
120 140 160
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Create Drop Shadow
21.1
0 20 40 60 80 100
Total
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
25
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
188.8
160 180 200
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Create Transparency Effect
27.4
0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140
Total
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
26
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
es
58.9
50 60 70
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Repetitive Text Formatting through Nested Styl
11.2
0 10 20 30 40
Format 5 repetitive paragraphs
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
27
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
26.7
28.7
25 30 35
QuarkXPress 6.5 + Distiller
InDesign CS2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Generate PDF File
17.1
6.7
5.3
6.5
0 5 10 15 20
Generate PDFX 1a
Generate PDF 1.5
Generate PDF 1.3(QuarkXPress PDF Export)
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
28
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
tyle"
62.7
61.1
50.0 60.0 70.0
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS
InDesign CS2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Formatting Multiple Paragraphs with "Apply Next S
20.4
20.1
5.4
37.8
0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0
Simple Example
Complete Article
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
29
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
74.6
68
60 70 80
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS
InDesign CS2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Place Multi-page PDF File in Page Layout
21.7
0 10 20 30 40 50
Place 5 Page PDF File
Section: Results
For further inform
Modified: October 14, 2005
30
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
37.1
33.8
30.0 35.0 40.0
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS
InDesign CS2 + Snippets
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Share Parts of a Page through "Snippets"
13.4
0.0 5.0 10.0 15.0 20.0 25.0
Share Parts of a Page Layout
Section: Results
For further inform Modified: October 14, 2005
31
Benchmark ReportPfeiffe01001011
Consult
Time in seconds. Shorter is better.
s
61.4
56.9
50.0 60.0 70.0
QuarkXPress 6.5
InDesign CS
InDesign CS2
and Charts
ation contact: [email protected]
The Adobe InDesign CS2 Benchmark Project
Client: Adobe Systems, Inc.ring
Formatting Multiple Objects with Object Style
14.3
0.0 10.0 20.0 30.0 40.0
Modify Objects