TgApplications - Presentación
Transcript of TgApplications - Presentación
Page 1
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Physical Chemistry of AmorphousPhase/State Transitions in Foods:
Dr Ted Labuza Department of Food Science and NutritionUniversity of MinnesotaSt Paul MN 55108
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Water relations
uThermodynamics
uDynamics
uStructure
☞
☞
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Concept of aw and Tg
DoesnÕt require a rocket scientistbut it helps
Page 2
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
uThe voice had become so rigid that it cracked.
uThatÕs how molecules behave today, and thatÕs how
u they behaved back then, though in those days nobody
u blamed molecules for brittleness any more than they
ucredited them for plasticity.
uFrom Jitterbug Perfume by Tom Robbins
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
textural changes
uloss of crispness > BET
uloss of bowl life >0.5
uhardening of cookies ~0.4
ubread staling
ucaking of powders @ ~ 0.4
water activity or molecular mobility ?
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Polymer Science Approachfree volume theory for diffusion
Diffusion and reaction function of:temperature above glass temperatureamount of plasticizer present (water)size of molecule diffusing
Page 3
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Amorphous SolidPhases
solids (%)
Tg
rubbery
glassy
temperature
0% 100%
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Early 1948 Quote
ÒGlasslike low molecular weight substances comprisean importance group of materials. In the broad standing,physical properties of common glassy materials such asbrittleness, natural resins, stiff pitchesand hard candies are included.Ó
Principles of High Polymer Theory and PracticeA. Schmidt and C. MairlesMcGraw Hill 1948 page 191
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Crystal Collapse
Melt
> 210¡C
Liquidstream
spin
recrystallize
Glass
cool
Rubber
humidify
Page 4
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
uspecific heat change (DTA, DSC, DDSC)
u thermal mechanical (caking, DMA, DMTA)
u thermal expansion (TGA)
uBrittle-ductile
udiffusional (ESR)
umolecular relaxation (NMR)
uother
Tg measurement Techniques
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Method
heat at some constant rate (scanning rate)
1. DTA: single heater - measure DT as heat2. DSC: two heaters - measure energy input to keeptemperature the same (more sensitive)3 DDSC: DSC with sine wave T oscillation
sample blank
Heater
need to calibrate with indium for T meltneed constant baselineneed to clean pans of oil deposit
thermocouples
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Theoretical differential scanning calorimetrythermogram -- thermal property change
free volume increase causes drop in Cp above glass transition
en
do
the
rmic
Temperature
Tg
Tm
cT
Page 5
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
soluble coffee @ aw 0.75
use derivative function to get midpoint
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Mechanical properties ofMaterials
u YoungÕs modulus
E= σσσσ / εεεε (σσσσ = stress, εεεε = strain)
u Shear stress
G = f / s
u Complex YoungÕs modulus
E* = E« + i E««
E« = storage modulus
E««= loss modulus
i = square root of -1
u tan ¶ = E«« / E«
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Manufacturers
uRheometrics
uPolymer labs DMTA
uPerkin Elmer DMA
Computerand transducer
sample
Probe
scan at single frequencies eg 1 Hz = 1 cycle/secscan at multiple frequencies
temperaturecontrolled
Page 6
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
DMTA
OscillatingProbe
Sample
Stable fixture
From Rheometrics Website
DMTA in lab
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Dynamic Mechanical ThermalAnalysis - mechanical property change
log E« (Pa)
temperature
low temperature
transition
drop in E«
slope
Tan¶ peak
Tan ¶
Elastic modulus drops significantly at glass transition
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
5
5.5
6
6.5
7
7.5
8
8.5
-30 20 70 120
0
0.1
0.2
0.3
0.4
0.5
0.6
0.7
Lo
g M
od
ulu
s
(Pa
)
Ta
n δ
Temperature (¡C)
E«
E««
Tan δ
Tg results Nabisco Chocolate wafer
Page 7
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
DMTA plot
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Brittle-ductile transition Tb
uBrittle fractureÐ Òclean breakÓ
u Ductile fractureÐ no Òclean breakÓ
Ð sample deformed (yielding)
uAt constant strain and moisturecontent, the temperature at which thesystemÕs fracture changes from brittlefracture to ductile is the Tb.
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Three point bend
Page 8
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Methods and MaterialsBrittle-ductile transition temperature (Tb)
Str
ess
Strain
At constantmoisture content
Yield (Maximum stress = yield strength)
Brittle Break (Maximum stress = brittle strength)
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
-4¡C
15¡C
Stress vs. Strain7.23% moisture content
-0.5
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
0 0.002 0.004 0.006 0.008
Strain
Str
ess (
MP
a)
Tb results
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Methods and MaterialsBrittle-ductile transition temperature (Tb) at constant moisture
content
Str
en
gth
(M
Pa
)
Temperature (¡C)
σσσσb - brittle strength
σσσσy - yield strength
Tb Adapted fromVincent (1961)
Page 9
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Tb: 3.73% Moisture Content
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
-10 10 30 50
Temperature (¡C)
Str
en
gth
(M
Pa)
Tb
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
r2 = 0.98
Tb as a Function of Moisture Content
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
3 5 7 9
Moisture Content (g H2O/ 100 g solids)
Te
mp
era
ture
(¡C
)
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
0.40.30.20.10.0
-100
0
100
200
DE 5
DE 15DE 20DE 25DE 36
DE 10
Maltodextrins
moisture (g water/g solid)
Tem
pera
ture
(°C
)
Maltodextrin Tg values
Tg decreases with decreasing MW
Page 10
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Sugar Tg values
0.50.40.30.20.10.0-80
-55
-30
-5
20
45
70
95
120
lactose-Roos
sucrose-Roos
sucrose/amioca-Roos
maltose-Roos
glucose-Chan
maltose-Noel
moisture (g water/g solid)
Tem
pera
ture
(°C
)
Sugars
lactose
glucose
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Tg of crackers by DMTA at a heating rate of 3oC/min
-200
20406080
100120140160180
0 0.05 0.1 0.15 0.2 0.25
E´ slopetan
T(oC)
water content (g water/ g solids)
¶
average 10¡C drop per 1% moistureTg = room temperature at 8-10% waterTg < 0¡C @ 30% moisture
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Cracker & Bread vs cereal components
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
0 10 20 30 40
Cracker DMTAGliadin DMSGlutenin DMSGlutenin DSCAmylopectinDMTAGluten DMTABread(Modified TMA)
Tg (oC)
moisture (%)
Page 11
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Ingredient effects
usugars lower Tg curve
ustarch highest Tg line
uproteins lower than starch
uLower MW lower the Tg
u? of mixing Tg how to predictÐ Kauzman equation
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Texture Applications
u dynamics and structure
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Characteristics of the glassy and rubbery states.
Tg
solids (%)
rubbery
glassy
temperaturecrisp, brittlehigh viscosityreduced free volume
slow reaction rateshigh moduluslower heat capacity
softermore flexiblelower modulus
greater free volumelower viscosityfast reaction rates
sugar crystallization
Page 12
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998Thermodynamics with dynamics
0 ¡C Te
Tm
freezing line
ice
super sat solution
0% solids
100%
State Diagram
and
Roos and Karel Food Tech 45(12): 66 1991
Tg
tplabuza © 1998Thermodynamics with dynamics
0 ¡C Te
Crystal melt line
Tm
freezing line
ice
super sat solution
0% solids
100%
State Diagram
and
Roos and Karel Food Tech 45(12): 66 1991
Tg
tplabuza © 1998Thermodynamics with dynamics
0 ¡C Te
Crystal melt line
Tm
Solution
freezing line
ice
super sat solution
0% solids
100%
State Diagram
and
boiling line
vapor
Roos and Karel Food Tech 45(12): 66 1991
Page 13
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998Thermodynamics with dynamics
0 ¡C Te
Tg'
Glassy state
rubberystate
Crystal melt line
Tm
Solution
freezing line
ice
super sat solution
0% solids
100%
State Diagram
Tg dry
-135¡C
and
Cg'
boiling line
vapor
Roos and Karel Food Tech 45(12): 66 1991
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Potential Tg applications
u stickiness and caking
u staling of bread
u hardening of fruit pieces
u popcorn volume
u checking of pasta
u crispness change of snacks, cereal,pizza crust
u chocolate sugar bloom
u hardening of soft cookies
u volatile loss in drying,
Page 14
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Powder stability problems
uProcessingÐ Flow problems: powder sticking to equipment
walls and collecting zones.
Ð Result: problems in clean upreduce efficiency
reduce product yield
reduce product quality
uStorage with timeÐ stickiness: powder sticks to walls of containers
Ð caking: clumping and collapse of powders
Ð crystallization of sugars: formation of hard mass
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
iso-viscosity (elasticity) lines
T ¡C
% solids
glass transition line
decreasingviscosity
about 102 drop per 10¡C
m
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Caking
RUBBERY
GLASSY
¥ stickiness¥ caking¥ collapse
% solids
TemperatureA
C
B
Tg curve
Page 15
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
T ¡C
% solids
glass transition line
sticky point + 10
caking Tg + 20
collapse & flow Tg +50
crystallization +20 to 30
Solid phase changes
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
phase change
¥ crystal state minimum free energy
aw= 0.2 aw=0.45
Saltmarch and Labuza JFS 45:1231; 1980
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Applying the WLF model
2
l ogk
k=
- C 1( T - T )
C + ( T - T )
ref ref
ref
l ogk
ref
k
-1
=C 2
C 1(T - T ref )+
1
C1
Linear Regression method
Page 16
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
WLF Kinetics*Effect of temperature above Tg
T- Tg Rate Increase Æ rate increase
3 107 10010 678 678 (0->10¡C)11 100020 74580 110 (10->20¡C)21 100,00030 261,030 3.5(20->30¡C)40 417,648 1.6(30->40¡C)
Òuniversal constants
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Lactose CrystallizationRoos & Karel JFS 57:775 Tg = 32¡C
T- Tg t seconds Q105 109.5 (100 yrs)
10 107 316
20 104.8 (~ 1day) 158
30 103 63
40 102 (< 2 min) 10
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
sugar crystallization rates
lactose>sucrose>glucose>fructose
Page 17
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Samples composition in %weight (dry basis)
Powder
Enfamil¨
(Mead Johnson)
Prosobee¨
(Mead Johnson)
Good Start¨
(Carnation)
Protein
12.15
16.39
12.97
Fat
30.94
28.96
27.57
Carbohydrate
56.91(lactose)
54.64(corn syrup solids)
59.46(lactose/maltodextrin)
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Tsc as function of water activity
Enfamil¨
Good Start¨
Prosobee¨
1.00.80.60.40.20.0
20
40
60
80
100
120
140
160
storage water activity
Temperature(¡C)
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Crystallization and Crispness
Soft Fresh BakedCookie
CrispCookie
Constant T, %RH no moisture change
Page 18
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Sucrose Recrystallization (Makower & Dye. 1956)
uExperiment measured rate of sucrosecrystallization from a glass at differentrelative humidities
Ð At RH < 12%, no crystallization in 3 years
Ð At 33.6% RH, crystallization is rapid
uWater activity of soft cookie is 0.65
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
uMeasure changes from soft to firm
uInstrument Texture AnalyserTA.XT2
uPuncture Test
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Texture Analyzer - Fresh (1 hr) Cookie
uFresh soft cookie - flexible -probe makes a well
Page 19
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Texture: 0ld (7 days) & Firm Cookie
uOld firm cookie - fractured &punctured
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Texture Analyzer GraphsSlope is a function of the Modulus
8 hr cookie
slope = 43 g/mm5 day cookie
slope=594 g/mm
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Texture Analysis
Cookie Texture Using Punch Test
Force (g) to Peak
0
150
300
450
600
750
900
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Age of Cookie in Days
Page 20
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Texture Analysis
Cookie Texture Using Punch Test
Gradient or Slope (g/mm) to Peak
0
150
300
450
600
750
900
0 2 4 6 8 10 12
Age of Cookie in Days
Slo
pe
to
Pe
ak
g/m
m
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Siemens D5005 X-ray Diffractometer
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Powder X-ray Diffraction
uX-ray pattern unique for everycrystalline form - ÒfingerprintÓ
uTechnique well suited foridentification
uScattering phenomenonÐ X-rays hit crystalline solids - scatter in all
directionsÈ In some of these directions, the scattered beams are completely
in phase and reinforce one another to form the diffracted beams.
Page 21
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
BraggÕs Law
nλλλλ ====2d sin θθθθ
u λλλλ is the wavelength of parallel monochromatic
x-ray beam (CuKαααα)))) λλλλ=1.54
u Incident on crystalline sample at an angle θθθθ
u d is the distance between the planes of thecrystal
u n is the order of reflection (an integer)
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Sucrose Powder X-ray Pattern
10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 262-Theta(¡)
x10^3
2.0
4.0
6.0
8.0
10.0
Inte
nsity(C
ou
nts
)
[P24-1977.dif] C12H22O11 - Sucrose, SCAN: 5.0/37.25/0.05/1(sec), Cu, I(max)=10000, 02/18/00 13:13
24-1977> C12H22O11 - Sucrose
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
X-ray Patterns for Other Ingredients:Flour, margarine, & Egg Solids
10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 262-Theta(¡)
0
100
200
300
400
500
600
Other ingredientsgive background
Page 22
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Soft Cookie - 1 hour
10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26
2-Theta(¡)
0
250
500
750
1000
1250
Inte
nsity(C
ou
nts
)
[1HR#2.MDI] 1 hour cookie, SCAN: 10.0/27.0/0.05/1(sec), Cu, I(max)=384, 05/21/00 17:21
24-1977> C12H22O11 - Sucrose
If get rid of background,peaks are very small.
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Cookie - 1 day - Peaks Grow
10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 262-Theta(¡)
0
250
500
750
1000
1250
Inte
nsi
ty(C
ou
nts
)
[1DAY#5.MDI] 1day .91gram Cookie#3, SCAN: 10.0/27.0/0.05/1(sec), Cu, I(max)=489, 05/22/00 17:56
24-1977> C12H22O11 - Sucrose
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Cookie - 5 days - Continue to Grow
10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 262-Theta(¡)
0
250
500
750
1000
1250
Page 23
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Cookie - 10 Days
10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 26
2-Theta(¡)
0
250
500
750
1000
1250
Inte
nsi
ty(C
ou
nts
)
[10DA#1.MDI] 10 day cookie, 0.98 g, SCAN: 10.0/27.0/0.04/1(sec), Cu, I(max)=1338, 05/31/00 22:02
24-1977> C12H22O11 - Sucrose
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Overlay & Offset of Patterns
10 12 14 16 18 20 22 24 262-Theta(¡)
0
500
1000
1500
Inte
nsity(C
ou
nts
)
[1HR#2.MDI] 1 hour cookie, SCAN: 10.0/27.0/0.05/1(sec), Cu, I(max)=384, 05/21/00 17:21
[1DAY#5.MDI] 1day .91gram Cookie#3, SCAN: 10.0/27.0/0.05/1(sec), Cu, I(max)=489, 05/22/00 17:56[5DAY#2.MDI] Cookie made on 5/21 scanned on 5/26 - 1.03 grams, SCAN: 10.0/27.0/0.04/1(sec), Cu, I(max)=758, 05/26/00[10DA#1.MDI] 10 day cookie, 0.98 g, SCAN: 10.0/27.0/0.04/1(sec), Cu, I(max)=1338, 05/31/00 22:02
24-1977> C12H22O11 - Sucrose
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Sucrose
Fructose
Dual Texture Cookieglass transition solution
Tg sucrose > Tg fructose
hard
soft center
Page 24
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Ingredients (in descending order)Used to Make Soft Cookies
uKeebler - Soft Batch Chocolate ChipÐ Sugar, HFCS, modified food starch
uKeebler - Soft Ôn ChewyÐ Sugar, HFCS, modified food starch, date paste, molasses,
invert sugar
uNabisco - Chewy Chips Ahoy(microwaveÕem)
Ð HFCS, sugar, dextrose, lactose, corn starch, molasses
uPepperidge Farm - Soft Baked ChocolateChunk
Ð Raison paste, sugar, fructose, brown sugar, invert sugar
uArchway - Chocolate ChipÐ Sugar, HFCS, corn syrup, corn starch modified
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Soft Cookies
desire long life withsoft texture
make fresh like
problemhardens with age
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Dual Texture Cookiesoft center/crispy outer layer
% solids
dough
10070
inner layer
outer layer
T ¡C
frying orbaking
sucrosebased
fructose based
Page 25
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Bread staling
long shelf life military bread
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
TGAState Diagram for Bread
LeMeste et al. (1992)
10090807060
0
40
80
120
160
% solidsOmnitherm Model 500 Polymer Labs
Tg = -12¡C @ 32% moisture
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
White bread Tg = -11¡C m =25%
Ra
te
Temperature
GrowthNucleation
37°C0°C 4°C-20°C
maximum staling at 4¡C stopped in freezer at -15¡C
Page 26
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Effect of water activity on snack food crispness(Katz and Labuza, 1981)
Crispness Intensity Monolayer Values critical
Product aw mc aw mo g H2O/100 g g H2O/100g
Saltine 0.39 7.0 0.22 4.8Potato Chip 0.51 5.7 0.21 2.9Corn Curl 0.36 4.2 0.18 2.9Popcorn 0.49 6.1 0.17 3.4
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Perceived crispness Corn flakes
Sauvegeot and Blond 1991 J Texture Studies 22:423
0
2
4
6
8
10
Sen
so
ry S
co
re
0 0.2 0.4 0.6 0.8 1water activity
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Tg Studies of Cereals
u LeMeste et. al . , 1992. White pan bread. ModifiedThermomechanical Analysis.
u Kalichevsky et. al. , 1993. Wheat gluten. DMTA.
u Kalichevsky et. al. , 1993. Amorphous amylopectin. DMTA.
u Cocero and Kokini, 1991. Glutenin. Dynamic MechanicalSpectrometry and DSC.
u De Graaf et. al. , 1993. Gliadin. Dynamic MechanicalSpectrometry.
u Wang and Jane 1994 Starch retrogradation
u Labuza and Nikoladis 1996 J. Food Sci, J Thermal Analysiscracker and itÕs dough
u Hyman PhD Thesis U of Minn 2000
Page 27
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Effect of moisture gain oncrispness loss
temperature
Tg
solids (%)
rubbery
glassy
T room
finishedcrispcrackermoisture gain
? where is crispnesslost
0% 100%
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
T ¡C
% solids
glass transition line
sensory crispness Tg + ? ¡C
Solid phase changes
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Improved crispness of dry snack food
temperature
T room
20 40 60 80 100
% solids
frying,
extrusion or
puffing
dough or
raw food
reformulatedcurve
normal curve
crispsoggy
Page 28
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Te
mp
era
ture
Moisture
glass
rubber
Crispy
Less Crispy
25¡C
Moisture content at which the crispnessintensity begins to decreases sharply atroom temperature
Tg curve for gluten
Gluten (Attenburrow et al. 1992 & Nicholls et al. 1995)
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Te
mp
era
ture
Moisture
glass
rubber
Crispy
Less Crispy
25¡C
Moisture content at which the crispnessintensity begins to decreases sharply atroom temperature
Tg curve for starch
Starch (Attenburrow et al. 1992 & Nicholls et al. 1995)
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Te
mp
era
ture
Moisture
glass
rubber
Crispy
Less Crispy
25¡C
Moisture content at which the crispnessintensity begins to decreases sharply atroom temperature
Tg curve
Crispy bread (Roudaut et al. 1998)
Page 29
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Te
mp
era
ture
Moisture
glass
rubber
Crispy
Less Crispy
25¡C
Moisture content at which the crispnessintensity begins to decreases sharply atroom temperature
Tg curve
Extruded Model system (Roos et al. 1998)
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Tg curveTe
mp
era
ture
Moisture
glass/crispy
rubber/soggy
Crispy
Less Crispy
25¡C Tci
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Tg curveTe
mp
era
ture
Moisture
glass/crispy
rubber/soggy
Crispy
Less Crispy
25¡C
Tci curve
Page 30
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Prinzenrolle (GBB Report 1996)
R2 = 0.89
R2 = 0.94
R2 = 0.87
-60
-40
-20
0
20
40
60
80
100
0 5 10 15 20
Moisture Content(g H2O/ 100 g solids)
Te
mp
era
ture
(¡C
)
E' onset DMTAE' onset DMALinear (E' onset DMTA)Poly. (E' onset DMA)Linear (E' onset DMA)
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
-40
-30
-20
-10
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
3 5 7 9
Moisture (g H2O/ 100 g solids)
Te
mp
era
ture
(¡C
)
Sensory Tci
E' onset DMTA
E' onset DMA
Tb
Nabisco Chocolate Wafers
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Economic $$$ Decisions
¥ Formulation Change
¥ ? how far above Tg issensory perception change
¥ Packaging Change
¥ lower WVTR
¥ Processing
¥ lower moisture content
Page 31
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
popcorn collapse and flow
500
1000
1500
2000
2500
3000
0 0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8
water activity
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Flavor Encapsulation
A Tg song
ÒDoes your chewing gum loose its flavoron the bed post over night ?Ó
Lonnie Donegan and his Stiffle band1951 Top Ten Hit
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Reaction kinetics
uDo reactions stop below the Tg line ?
uIs GAB/BET monolayer important ?
uImpact on shelf life prediction ?
Page 32
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
20% Loss of ChlorophyllFreeze dried spinach 37¡C
0 . 80 . 70 . 60 . 50 . 40 . 30 . 21
10
100
1000
water activity
Tim
e fo
r 20
% c
hlor
ophy
l los
s at
37
°C 9 months 4 g water/100 g solids
2 days
16 g water/100 g
Moisture 4 x increase rate 140 x increase
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Relative Stability Map
0.1 0.2 0.3 0.4 0.5 0.6 0.7 0.8 0.9 1.00.0
water activity
Lipid oxidation
moisture
vitamin
NEB
Enzymeactivity
Mold yeast Bacteria
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
lysine/ xylose Karmas et al1992
Temperature range Relative rate increase Relative rate increase pred ic ted observed Tg → Tg + 10°C 6 7 8 21 .8Tg + 10°C → Tg + 20°C 1 1 0 7 .39Tg + 20°C → Tg + 30°C 3 . 5 4 .06Tg + 30°C → Tg + 40°C 1 .58 2 .82
Universal constants are ÒNOTÓ
Page 33
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
NEB Karmas et al 1992
0.00330.00320.00310.00300.00290.00280.0027-10
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
2
1/T (K-1)
ln(k
)
rubbery
glassy
Tg
Ea = 45.1 kcal/mol
Ea = 20.8 kcal/mol
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Ascorbic Acid Resultsmoisture = 0.085 g H2O/g solid
8060402000.0
0.1
0.2
0.3
Temperature (¡C)
Tg= 46.5¡C
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
r
Break in Arrhenius plot
Rubbery : E a =12.5 kcal/mole2
=0.87
Glassy: = 20.8 kcal/mole=0.98
All: E a =19.4 kcal/mole =0.98
3.8e-33.6e-33.4e-33.2e-33.0e-32.8e-3
-8
-6
-4
-2
0
1/T (K-1)
Tg
= 46.5¡C
Ascorbic acid degradation, Maltodextrin DE15 matrix
Page 34
Dr Ted Labuza University of Minnesota Department of Food Science and Nutrition St Paul MN 55108voice 612-624-9701 fax 651-483-3302 [email protected]
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
Conclusions
uwater activity important todescribe driving force forequilibria and chemical shelflife
uglass transition describesdynamics and structurefunctions
uboth are critical
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
AACC BOOK
Tg
tplabuza © 1998
A overturned glass
water activity or a glass transition