Table of Cases

A v Scottish Ministers SC PCA v Scottish Ministers [2007] CSOH SLT (OH)Aberdeen Railway Co v Blaikie Bros (1853) 15 D (HL) 20Adams v Advocate General, 2003 SC 171 (OH) Adams v Scottish Ministers, 2004 SC 665Air 2000 v Secretary of State for Transport (No 1), 1989 SLT 698 Air 2000 v Secretary of State for Transport (No 2), 1990 SLT 335 At Homes Nationwide Ltd v Morris, 2007 GWD 31-535 AXA General Insurance v Lord Advocate [2010] CSOH 2B v Highland Regional Council [2007] CSOH 126; 2007 SLT 844 171,

174,175

Barker v Lewis, 2007 SLT (Sh ct 48; 2008 SLT (Sh ct 17Beggs v Scottish Ministers, 2004 SLT 755 (OH) Beggs v Scottish Ministers, 2006 SC 649 (IH) Beggs v Scottish Ministers [2007] 1 WLR 455; 2007 SLT 235 (RL)Belgian Linguistics Case (No 2) (1968) 1 EHRR 252Botanic Gardens Picture House Ltd v Adamson, 1924 SC 549Boyne v Grampian Regional Council, unreported, 15 April 1983Brown v Richardson, 2007 GWD 28-490Brown v Stott, 2000 JC 328Burnett's Trustee v Grainger, 2004 SLT 513C v City of Edinburgh Council [2008] CSOR 60; 2008 SLT 522Caledonian Railway Co v Greenock and Wemyss Bay Railway Co (1872)

M 892 Callison v Scottish Ministers, unreported 25 June 2004 (OH)Cameron v Leal 2010 Farn LR 82 Campbell v Aberdeen City Council, 2007 Hous LR 26 , Charm an v Charman [2007] 1 FLR 1246

Chebotareva v King's Executrix, 2008 Fam LR 66

TABLE OF CASES xi

Clancy v Caird, 2000 SC 441Clingham v Royal Borough of Kensington and Chelsea; R (on behalf

of McCann) v Crown Court of Manchester [2003] 1 AC 787Coates v Lothian Regional Council, 1999 Farn LR 8Commission for Local Authority Accounts in Scotland v Stirling

District Council, 1984 SLT 442 Commonwealth of Australia v State of Tasmania (1983) 158 CLR 1Council for Music in Hospitals v Trustees for Richard Gerald

Associates, 2008 SLT (Lands Tr) 17, 44 Crichton v McBain, 1961 JC Cumming v HM Advocate, 2003 SCCR 261 D & J Nicol v Dundee Harbour Trustees, 1915 SC (HL) 12Da Silva Mouta v Portugal (2001) 31 EHRR 47David Watson Property Management v Woolwich Equitable Building

Society, 1992 SLT 430Davidson v Scottish Ministers, 2002 SC 205 (IH); [2002] 1 Prison

Law Reports 58 (OH)Davidson v Scottish Ministers (No 2), 2005 SC (HL) 7Davidson v Scottish Ministers (No 3), 2005 SC (HL) 1 Davidson v Scottish Ministers, 2006 SC (HL) 42Deans v Glasgow Housing Association, 2009 Hous LR 92 Dickie v HM Advocate (1897) 24 R (J) 82 Dickson v HM Advocate, 2008 JC 181 Dingle v Turner [1972] AC 601 Douglas v Duke of Hamilton (1769) 2 Pat 143Dove, Petrs, 2002 SC 257; 2002 SLT 640, affd 2002 SLT 1269 DPP of Jamaica v Mollison [2003] 2 AC 411 DS v HM Advocate, 2007 SC (PC) 1 East Lothian Council, Petrs, 2008 SLT 921 163, Edinburgh City Council v K [2009] CSIH 46; 2009 SC 625 Emmott v Michael Wilson & Partners [2008] EWCA Civ 184;

[2008] 2 All ER (Comrn) 193 Emms v Lord Advocate, 2008 SLT 2 (OH) ERDC Construction Ltd v H M Love & Co (No 2),1996 SC 523 Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Plowman (1995) 128 ALR 391Estate of KF Mortensen v Denmark (Admissibility) (2006)

43 EHRR SE9 F v D, 2009 Fam LR III Faely v Clark, 2006 GWD 28-626

xii LAW MAKING AND THE SCOTTISH PARLIAMENT

Fairley v Fairley, 2008 Farn LR 112 75, Fairley Yacht Slip Ltd v Lumsden, 1977 SLT (Notes) 41Fiona Trust & Holding Corp v Privalov [2007] 4 All ER 951 308, Fitzpatrick v Sterling Housing Association [2001]1 AC 27 Flynn v HM Advocate, 2004 SC (PC) 1 . Forbes v Aberdeenshire Council and Trump International Golf

Links [2010] CSOH 1 G v Argyll and Bute Council [2008] CSOH 61; 2008 SLT 541 George Wimpey East Scotland Ltd v Fleming, 2006 SLT

(Lands Tr) 59 293Ghaidan v Godin-Mendoza [2004] 2 AC 557 Glasgow Rape Crisis Centre v Secretary of State for the Home

Department, 2000 SC 527Global Santa Fe Drilling Co (North Sea) Ltd v Lord Advocate,

2009 SLT 598 (IH)Gordon, Appellant, 2007 Farn LR 76Gow v Grant, 2010 Farn LR 21 Grampian Regional Council v John McGregor (Contractors) Ltd,

1994 SLT 133H v H, 2005 SLT 1025 (Ex Div) Hakeen v Hussain, 2003 SLT 515 (OH) Halladale (Shaftsbury) Ltd, unreported, 20 June 2005 (Lands Tr) Hamilton v Grampian Regional Council, 1995 GWD 8--443;

1996 GWD 5-227 Hampson v HM Advocate, 2003 SLT 94 Harris v HM Advocate [2009] HCJAC 80; 2009 SLT 1078 Harvey v Strathclyde Regional Council, 1989 SLT 612 Hassneh Insurance Co of Israel v Mew [1993]2 Lloyd's Rep 243Hesterv McDonald, 1961 SC 370Hislop v MacRitchie's Trustees (1881) 8 R (HL) 95HM Advocate v A, 2005 SLT 975 HM Advocate v Birkett, 1993 SLT 395 HM Advocate v HD, 1953 JC 65 253Hoekstra v HM Advocate (No 2) 2000 SLT 602 Hunter v HM Advocate, 1984 JC 90 IRC v City of Glasgow Police Athletic Association [1953] AC 380 IRC v Falkirk Temperance Cafe Trust, 1927 SC 261 Jäggi v Switzerland, Application No 58757/00, 13 July 2006 JA MacTaggart & Co v Harrower (1906) 8F llOl

TABLE OF CASES xiii

Jamieson v Rodhouse, 2009 Farn LR 34 Jensen v Tyler, 2008 SLT (Lands Tr) 39 John G McGregor (Contractors) Ltd v Grampian Regional

Council, 1991 SLT 136 JT v Stirling Council, 2007 SC 783JT Mackley & Co Ltd v Gosport Marina Ltd [2002] EWHC 1315

(TCC) Kamer v Austria (2004) 38 EHRR 21 Kaur v Lord Advocate, 1980 SC 319Kelly v Docherty, 1991 SLT 419 Kennedy v Lord Advocate (No 1),2008 SLT 195 (OH)Kennedy v Lord Advocate (No 2) [2009] CSOH 1 King v East Ayrshire Council, 1998 SLT 1287 Lv L, 1996 SLT 767 Laverty v Strathclyde Regional Council, 188 GWD 2-6 Lawley v Sutton 2010 GWD 14-254Lesotho Highlands Development Authority v Impregila spA [2006]

1 AC 221 Logan v Harrower, 2008 SLT 1049 (HCJ) Lord Advocate's Reference (No 1 of 2000) re nuclear weapons,

2001 JC 143 (HCJ) Lothian Regional Council v Rennie, 1991 SLT 465 M v Home Office [1994]1 AC 377 M v S, 2008 SLT 871 Mv S, 2009 Farn LR 149 McCall v Scottish Ministers, 2006 SC 266 MacColl v Crofters' Commission [2007] Housing LR 46McDonald v Secretary of State for Scotland, 1994 SC 234 (IH) McKenzie v Scottish Ministers, 2004 SLT 1236 (OR) McKerr, In re [2004]1 WLR 807 (HL (NI)) MacLennan v MacLennan, 1958 SC 105 Mahmood v Mahmood, 1993 SLT 589 Mahmud v Mahmud, 1994 SLT 599 Marckx v Belgium (1979) 2 ERRR 330 Martin v HM Advocate [2010] UKSC 10 Matadeen v Pointu [1999] AC 98 Mikulic v Croatia, Application No 53176/99,7 February 2002 Millar (1870) 1 Coup 430 Millar v Dickson, 2002 SC (PC) 30

xiv LAW MAKING AND THE SCOTTISH PARLIAMENT

Minister of Home Affairs v Fourie (2006) 20 BHRC 368 Moncrieff v Jamieson, 2007 SLT989 Muirhead v Mcintosh (1886) 13 R (J) 52 Napier v Scottish Ministers, 2005 SC 229 (OH); 2005 SC 307 (IH) Neill v Scobbie, 1993 GWD 8-572 Niven v Lord Advocate, 2009 SLT 876 (OH) P v HM Advocate, 1991 SCCR 933 Pollich v Heatley, 1910 SC 469 R v Brent LBS, ex p Omar (1991) 23 HLR 446 R v HM Advocate, 2003 SC (PC) 21R v Somerset County Council, ex p Dixon [1998] Env LR III R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex p Brind [1991]

AC 696 187R v Secretary of State for Transport, ex p Factortame (No 2) [1991]

1 AC 603R v Walker, 1999 SC 380 R v Wycombe DC, ex p Holmes (1988) 22 HLR 150 R (Hurst) v London Northern District Coroner [2007]2 AC 189 R (Wellington) v Secretary of State for the Home Department [2009]

1 AC 335 45Rafique v Amin, 1997 SLT 1385 Ralston v Scottish Ministers, 2004 SLT 1263 (OH) Regan v M ulIen, 2006 GWD 25-56 Reid (1861) 4 lrv 124 Robertson v Robertson (1888) 15 R 1001 , Rojas v Berllaque (Attorney General for Gibraltar intervening) [2004]

1 WLR 201Romano v Standard Commercial Property Services Ltd, 2008

SLT 859 Sahin v Germany (2003) 36 EHRR 43 Salah Abdadou v Secretary of State for the Home Department,

1998 SC 504 (OH)Sand Marper v United Kingdom [2008] ECHR 1581; (2009)

48 EHRR 50 Schalk and Kopf v Austria, Application No 30141/04, 24 June 2010 Scottish Co-operative Wholesale Society v Finnie, 1937 SC 835 Scottish Hierarchy of the Roman Catholic Church v Highland

Regional Council, 1988 SC (HL) 1 Scottish Old People's Welfare Council v Secretary of State for

TABLE OF CASES xv

Social Security, 1987 SLT 179 (OH)Sheikh v Sheikh, 2005 Farn LR 7 Sheltered Housing Management Ltd v Jack, 2008 SLT 1058;

2007 GWD 32-553 Shiels v City of Edinburgh Council, 1999 Fam LR 86Shilliday v Smith, 1998 SC 725 Simpson v Edinburgh Corporation, 1960 SC 313 SM, Appellant, 2007 Fam LR 2Smith v Donnelly, 2002 JC 55 Smith v Greenhill, 1993 SCLR 776 Smith v Prior, 2007 GWD 30-523 Smith v Scott, 2007 SC 345Söderbäck v Sweden (1998) 29 EHRR 95 Sohrab v Khan, 2002 SLT 1255 . Somerville v Scottish Ministers, 2008 SC (HL) 45;

2007 SC 140 Special Commissioners for the Purposes of Income Tax v Pemsel

[1891] AC 531 Spencer Thomas of Buquhollie v Newell, 1992 SLT 973Starrs v Ruxton, 2000 JC 208Swanson v Manson, 1907 SC 426 T, Petr, 1997 SLT 724 (IH) 42, Teague Developments Ltd v City of Edinburgh Council,

unreported, 27 February 2008 (Lands Tr) Thomas Dagg & Sons Ltd v Dickensian Property Co Ltd, 2005

GWD 6-84Town Council of Oban v Callander and Oban Railway (1892)

19 R 912 293Trammel v United States, 445 US 40 (1980) Turner v Hamilton (1980) 17 R 494Vale Do Dio Doce Navegacao SA v Shanghai Bao Steel Ocean

Shipping Co Ltd [2000] 2 All ER (Cornm) 70 Ventureline Ltd, unreported, 2 August 2006 (Lands Tr) WA'sLegal Representative v Highland Council [2008] CSIH 5;

2008 Farn LR 130 WD v Glasgow City Council [2007] CSOH 139; 2007 SLT 881,

affd [2007] CSIH 72; 2008 SC 117 Webster (1847) Ark 269 263Whaley v Lord Advocate, 2008 SC (HL) 107

Whaley v Lord Watson of Invergowrie and The ScottishParliament, 2000 SC 340

Whaley and Friend v Lord Advocate [2005] CSIH 69; 2006 SC 121;Friend's appeal refused [2007] UKHL 53; 2007 SLT 1209

Wink's Executors v Tallent, 1947 SC 470 Wilson v Independent Broadcasting Authority, 1979 SC 351 XY v Scottish Ministers, 2007 SC 631