Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

11
12 Government initiatives and Socio‐political dimensions The countries discussed in this study are at different phases of solar energy development. Germany leads the nations in installations of solar panels (PV) with roughly half the world’s installations and is the third largest producer of solar cells and modules, after Japan and China. Government and people are enthusiastic in using solar energy and R & D is fuelling new technologies and new companies. Government and citizens of USA are trying and testing different technologies to suit the vast requirement of energy. USA is the biggest consumer of energy in the world. Incentives and aggressive programs in some states (especially southern states like Nevada, Arizona, and California) are creating possibilities for various technologies to get tested (recently Nevada One for CSP demonstration). Venture capital of around USD 3.4 billion was invested in 2007 alone in solar startups. Government is under pressure by interest groups like the solar industry, green groups and green politicians to give a full hearted support. Oil industry has created two pronged strategy of lobbying for more exploration opportunities in restricted areas (Alaska), and on the other hand creating solar divisions within the companies to project a green image and to take advantage of the growing solar industry. India along with China is the fastest growing consumer of energy in the world. With around 8 % GDP growth for last decade and burgeoning middle class, it is set to become one of the largest market for energy, the gap between supply and demand is huge, and the Indian Government having realized that has recently pushed for solar energy programs. The Indian market is untapped, its solar industry is nascent, and with high insolation and an average 250 days of sunlight it can become the most attractive target for solar products in coming decades. Germany: Factors driving the growth of German Solar Industry: Energy crisis: The fossil fuel ( Oil) energy crises of 1973‐74 and 1979‐80 with severe economic impacts led to the emergence of renewable energy sources as potential risk reducers. International initiatives: Kyoto protocol and commitment of Germany to reduce greenhouse gases by 21 % from 1990 emissions levels within 2008‐2012. Promotion of Renewable energy technology: Start of government support in 1974 for R&D for wind turbine development with initiative like GROWIAN (wind plant project). This became a reference point for support for renewable energy program including solar energy programs. Feed in tariff programs: Federal Electricity Feed Law (StrEG) adopted in 1991 became the most important instrument for the promotion of renewable energy in Germany

Transcript of Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

Page 1: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

12

GovernmentinitiativesandSocio‐politicaldimensionsThecountriesdiscussedinthisstudyareatdifferentphasesofsolarenergydevelopment.Germanyleadsthenationsininstallationsofsolarpanels(PV)withroughlyhalftheworld’sinstallationsandisthethirdlargestproducerofsolarcellsandmodules,afterJapanandChina.GovernmentandpeopleareenthusiasticinusingsolarenergyandR&Disfuellingnewtechnologiesandnewcompanies.GovernmentandcitizensofUSAaretryingandtestingdifferenttechnologiestosuitthevastrequirementofenergy.USAisthebiggestconsumerofenergyintheworld.Incentivesandaggressiveprogramsinsomestates(especiallysouthernstateslikeNevada,Arizona,andCalifornia)arecreatingpossibilitiesforvarioustechnologiestogettested(recentlyNevadaOneforCSPdemonstration).VenturecapitalofaroundUSD3.4billionwasinvestedin2007aloneinsolarstartups.Governmentisunderpressurebyinterestgroupslikethesolarindustry,greengroupsandgreenpoliticianstogiveafullheartedsupport.Oilindustryhascreatedtwoprongedstrategyoflobbyingformoreexplorationopportunitiesinrestrictedareas(Alaska),andontheotherhandcreatingsolardivisionswithinthecompaniestoprojectagreenimageandtotakeadvantageofthegrowingsolarindustry.IndiaalongwithChinaisthefastestgrowingconsumerofenergyintheworld.Witharound8%GDPgrowthforlastdecadeandburgeoningmiddleclass,itissettobecomeoneofthelargestmarketforenergy,thegapbetweensupplyanddemandishuge,andtheIndianGovernmenthavingrealizedthathasrecentlypushedforsolarenergyprograms.TheIndianmarketisuntapped,itssolarindustryisnascent,andwithhighinsolationandanaverage250daysofsunlightitcanbecomethemostattractivetargetforsolarproductsincomingdecades.Germany:FactorsdrivingthegrowthofGermanSolarIndustry:

Energycrisis:Thefossilfuel(Oil)energycrisesof1973‐74and1979‐80withsevereeconomicimpactsledtotheemergenceofrenewableenergysourcesaspotentialriskreducers.

Internationalinitiatives: KyotoprotocolandcommitmentofGermanytoreduce

greenhousegasesby21%from1990emissionslevelswithin2008‐2012.

PromotionofRenewableenergytechnology:Startofgovernmentsupportin1974forR&DforwindturbinedevelopmentwithinitiativelikeGROWIAN(windplantproject).Thisbecameareferencepointforsupportforrenewableenergyprogramincludingsolarenergyprograms.

Feedintariffprograms:FederalElectricityFeedLaw(StrEG)adoptedin1991became

themostimportantinstrumentforthepromotionofrenewableenergyinGermany

Page 2: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

13

duringthe1990s.ThesuccessortoStrEG,EEGprogram,aimstofacilitateadoublingofrenewableenergy’s1997shareinthepowergenerationfuelmixby2010—toaminimumof12.5%.(see Appendix Government A).[ Feed-in tariff is an indirect subsidy to the producers of solar energy by spreading the cost of production over all the consumers ]

Politicaldevelopment:TheelectionofGermany’sRed‐Greencoalitiongovernmentin

1998broughtwithitadditionalpoliciesandlegislationpromotingthegrowthofrenewableenergy.Forexample,the1999EcologicalTaxReform(ETR)initiallyincreasedthetaxesonmotorfuels,fueloils,andnaturalgas,andalsoleviedanelectricitytaxacrossallsectors

Policies: Germanyhasreliedonacombinationoffiveprimarypolicyinstrumentsforthepromotionofrenewableenergy:

• DirectinvestmentinR&D;• Directsubsidies;• Government‐sponsoredloans;• Taxallowances;• Subsidiesforoperationalcosts/feed‐intariffs.

EEG:EEGwasadoptedinApril2000.TheEEGaimstofacilitateadoublingofrenewableenergy’s1997shareinthepowergenerationfuelmixby2010—toaminimumof12.5%.UnlikethatoftheStrEG,theEEG’sremunerationsystemisnotbasedonaverageutilityrevenueperkWhsold,butratheronafixed,regressivefeed‐intariffforrenewablesources.Low‐costrenewableenergyproducersarecompensatedatlowerratesthanhigher‐costproducers,providingstrongincentivesforthedevelopmentandoperationofrenewableenergyinstallationsonlower‐qualitysites.Also,undertheEEG,gridoperatorsareobligatedtopurchasepowerfromlocalproducers;anation‐wideequalizationschemehasbeenimplementedtoreducethecostdifferentialspaidbygridoperatorsindifferentpartsofthecountryforthepurchaseofrenewably‐generatedelectricity.Recentamendmentsfor2009andonwardshasbeenpassedas“slidingscalefordigression”(see Appendix Government B for major European countries).

Consumerpreferences

Increasingefficiency,hencelowercostperunit,ofdifferenttechnologiesisamajorattractionforswitchingtosolarenergy.Inadditiongridparityispredictedtobereachedbetween2012to2015[seefeed‐tariffsappendix]

Government’sincentivesandsubsidiesarepushfactorsfordemand;theydonotpullmoreconsumersasisgenerallythoughtof.So,consumer’sawarenessbecomescriticalforgrowthoftheindustry.

Page 3: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

14

Thehighlevelofpublicawarenessovergreenhouseeffectandglobalwarmingisimpactingthetrendofusageandsourceofenergy.Thiswillbeamajordriverofgrowthinrenewableenergysector.

USA:

FactorsdrivingthegrowthoftheAmericanSolarIndustry:

SoaringOilcosts:Theprohibitivecostofoil(reaching$4/gallon)inrecentyearsandtheimportbillofUSAarethepushfactorsfortheUSgovernmenttolookatalternativesourcesofenergy,seriously.Thoughwindandsolarprogramsandresearchstartedwaybackin1960’s,itwasmainlyconfinedtospaceapplicationanddemonstrationtechnologies.

Costlyalternativefuels:Bio‐fuelhasbeenanoptionbuttheconcernsaboutethanolasfuel(inparticular,whichwasfirstusedinBrazil)beingtoocostlyintermsofgrowingcost,costofland,lostnutritioninsoil(duetoextensivecornfarming)andsocio‐economiccostoflostopportunitiesindevelopingcountries(withlesslandarea),feedingUSA’srequirementhasbecomehighlycontroversialandhasforcedthegovernmenttolookatwindandsolarenergyasalternatives.

Oilfrombitumen,tar(Venezuela),Shale(propositionedbysomelikeIHS’sDanielYergin)isnotrecoverablepractically.Mr.Yerginonlypointstocapacityandnotrealrecoverableoil.Additionally,environmentalistsarelobbyingagainstexplorationofoilinunexplored/virginterritories(Alaska,Antarctica)andalsofromsourcessuchassandandtar.Oilfromcoalandcleancoaltechnologiesareinlaboratoryexperiments,unprovenforproduction.

Solarenergyincentivesandprograms: USAfederalgovernmentsandstatesgovernments(speciallysixsouthernstates)haveincentives,taxbreaks,loans,grantsandsubsidiesforsolarenergyinstallationsforcommercialandresidentialpurposes(seeappendix).AbillhasbeenintroducedinUScongressfor10millionsolarroofsby2018.

Politicalpressure:AlGoreandmanyotherpoliticianshavestartedacampaignforrenewableenergy.Themoveissupportedbytherenewableenergyindustryandenvironmentallyconsciouspublic(realizingthehighsocialandeconomiccostonthenation,nottomentiontheirownpersonalwoes).Thecreditcrunchandhousingcriseshavefurtheredthecloutofthesepoliticians.

(see Appendix Government C for Programs and incentives )

Page 4: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

15

Consumerpreferences

RateofreturnoninvestmentandnofuelrequirementthedrivingcostsforgeneralpopulationinUSA(evenMassachusettswhereaveragesunshineislessthan5hoursonayearlybasis).EspeciallyPVmodulewith25yearsofguaranteedserviceisamajorpull.

Socialconsciousnessand“green”image[beingseenas“forwardthinking”symbol]aremajorattractionsforconsumersbutthesehavealongwaytogo.

Tightgovernmentregulationsandfinesonindustriesareforcingindustriestoreducetheircarbonemissionburdenonenvironmentasaprecautionarymeasure.Inthelongrun,theindustriesaretryingtoreducetheirfuelbillandbuildagreenimageintheeyesoftheiremployeesandconsumers.ItisnotmerelyCSR.

India

IndiaBeckons:FactorsdrivinggrowthforsolarenergyinIndia

GovernmentPolicy:RecentannouncementsbytheprimeministerofIndiaforNAPCC(nationalactionplanforclimatechange)includeaNationalSolarmission.(See Appendix

government D for details).Thishasencouragedtheindustriestoinvestinsolarenergy.

Insolation:Highinsolation(sunlight’sintensity)onmajorityofIndia’sland,its400millionmiddleclassandanother500millionpeopleinruralareasmakeIndiaasanattractivesolarinvestmentdestination. Withanaverageof250daysofsunlightandanintensityof4to7kWh/m2itisoneofideallocationssuitedforsolarenergygrowth.

HighOilimportbill:Indiaisdependentonothercountriesforoil.ItslargepopulationandincreasingGDPpercapitahavefurthercontributedtoitshighconsumptionofoil.Thisyearitcost6%GDPofIndia,toimporttherequiredoil(around73Billion$estimatedfor2007‐08Fiscalyear1).

Cheaphumanresourcesandtechnicaltalent:TalentandcheaplabormakeIndiaaveryattractivedestinationforsolarenergy.

Page 5: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

16

FollowingrecentNAPCCannouncements,bigindustrialhouseslikeTATAPower,RelianceIndustries,andADAG(AnilDhirubhaiAm200abniGroup)haveannouncedinvestmentsworthUSD6billion.

ConsumerPreferences

Ruralcitizenswithlittleornoelectricityandfarmerscouldbethelargestsegmenttobetappedforoff‐gridapplications.Necessitieslikepoweringthewaterpump,lightbulbs,televisionscangeneratehugedemand

Solarwaterheatinghasthepotentialtopullinurbanpopulace’sdemand,whichcanbecomeastartingpointforusageofsolartechnologiesforhouseelectricityconsumption

Industriesthoughawaredon’twanttoinvestingreentechnologiesasthereisnosocialpressurenow.Buttheawarenessofpublicandmediaisincreasing,whichcanbeapushfactorforindustriestoadoptsolartechnology.Brandimageisanotherfactorwhichwillforcetheindustriestorethinktheirstrategy

Governmentitselfisverybigconsumerandbyadoptingthetechnologyitself,itcanpullthegeneralconsumersandpushtheindustries(indirectlybycreatingpressure)inadoptingthesolartechnology.

Conclusion

Solarenergyindustryisanascentindustrywithgreatpotentialtogrow.Thegrowthcanbepropelledbyinitiativesandprogramsbygovernments,whichcanprovidebothpullandpushfactorsfordemand.Feed‐intariffs,greenimageandsubsidiescandrivethegrowthininitialstagesbutlongtermsustainablegrowthispossibleonlywithmainstreamacceptanceofthetechnology.Acceptancewillcomefromsustainedgovernmenteffort(suchastaxbreaks/holidays),economicalcostforendusers,easeofuseandawarenessofecologicalcostamongstcitizensandindustries.Quotaallotmentandaggressivepushbythegovernmentcanworkfortheshortterm(asinSpain)butlongtermgrowthispossibleonlybyadoptionbycitizens(Germany).

Page 6: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

17

IssuesandChallengesforSolarenergyIndustryandPlayers1.Cost:Gridparityorcostofsolarenergyequivalenttocostofcurrentenergyresourcesisamajorchallenge.Inaugust2008,solarelectricitycostwasaround21.3centsKwh1,whichis5timesthenormalpriceofelectricitygeneratedbyfossilfuels.EvenpowergeneratedthroughCSP(proven)andCPV(unproveninthefield)technologiesisabove8cents/Kwh.ThismakesitunacceptableformostofthecitizensofdevelopingcountrieslikeIndiaandChina,wheremostofthedemandinfuturewouldbegenerated(IndiaandChinacombinedenergyneedswouldgrowby40%by2030,IEAEnergyOutlook2007).Germancitizensandindustrywouldfeelthepinchasthesubsidiesandfeed‐intariffarereducedandcostwillincrease.USAwillremainthe2ndlargestconsumerofenergyin2030.Soitbecomesimperativeforcostofsolarenergytobeequivalenttocostofenergygeneratedbyfossilfuels.Economiesofscale(increasedusage)andadvancementintechnologycanachievethatobjective.Balanceofsystemcomponents(BOS‐componentswhicharenotPVmodulesorTurbine/transmissionsysteminCSP/CPV)costbetween20‐70%dependingontechnologyandcountry.Efficiencyandeconomicalintegrationofcomponentslikeinverters,batteriesbecomecrucial.1.1EconomiesofScale:Thisisacomplexissueasit’sinter‐twinedwithcostofthesystemorelectricitygenerated.Increasingofthescalecanreducethecostandreducingofthecostwillincreasetheusage.Itisaviciouscircle.1.2DependencyonGovernmentincentives:Asitisanewindustryanditstartedgrowinginresponsetoincreasingcostofoil,moregreenhousegasemissionsandclimatechange,thegovernmentsupportissustainingtheindustrynow.Ifthecostofsolarenergydoesnotdecreaseorcostoftheoilgoesdown,theincentiveforgovernmentandpublicsupportmaygodown,leadingtolimitingthegrowthoftheindustry2.SunshineandInsolation:AccordingtoIEAareabetween30˚NorthandSouthofequator,isthebestforgenerationofsolarenergy.Insolationoramountandintensityofsunlightvaryacrosstheglobeandduringseasons,Localconditionsalsoareamajorinfluencefactor.Soeachcountryandareaneedstoadoptdifferenttechnologiesforgenerationoftechnology.Areasbeyond60˚N&Shavetodependonsummertimeforgenerationofelectricity.3.Installation:Installationandintegrationwithbuildings,structuresremainamajorchallenge.Technologycannotbefullycombinedwithoutsortingoutissueslikeaesthetics,area,degradationofcells/systemsovertime,trainedpersonnel.4.Integrationwithpowergrid:IntegrationwithpowergridisoneofthechallengesofPVorupcomingtechnologiesinrooftops/residentialsystems.Thisisbecausewhenpoweriswithdrawnorfedintothegridsystemfrequencyofthegridfluctuates,leadingtodestabilizationofthesystem.5.UnprovenTechnology:Manytechnologiesclaimedassuccessfulinlabhasnotyetbeenproveninthefield.Theresultsinthefiledcanbedifferentornotaspositiveasinlab.Integrationwithothertechnologiesandgridsupplyalsocanbechallengestotheindustry.1 www.solarbuzz.com, august 2008

Page 7: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

18

6.Weaksupplychain:Weaksupplychain(especiallyinCSP)duetocyclicalactivitydevelopmenthasledtodwindlingofequipmentvendors.Tomeettheprojecteddemand,manufacturingcapacityhastobeexpanded(forCSP).7.Lackofadequatelandclosetoloadcenters:Lackoflandforinstallationofsolarfarmsprojects(especiallyincountrieslikeIndia,wherelandiscostlyandunavailable)closetoconsumption/populationcentersaddtothecostofelectricity.Thisisamajorconstraintindevelopmentofsolarfarms,whichhasthepotentialtoreachgridparity.8.LackofspendingpowerandFinancingoptionsindevelopingcountriesisanimpedimenttothegrowthofthesolarindustryincountrieslikeIndiaandchina.

Page 8: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

19

StrategyChallengesforSolarEnergyPlayers“Globalenergysystemisonincreasinglyanincreasinglyunsustainablepath.Challengeforallcountriesistoachievetransitiontoamoresecure,lowcarbonenergysystem.”–WorldEnergyOutlook2007,IEA.Differentscenariospredictworld’sinstalledsolarenergygrowthto35Gwto40Gigawattby2015.In2007,worldinstalled3.5Gigawattofsolarenergy,47%ofinstallationwasinGermany,Spain23%,USA10%andrestoftheworld20%.India’stotalgrowthwasameager20Mwoutoftotalgenerationofcloseto100,000Mw.SupplyofPVsystemsintheworldespeciallypolysiliconPVwillbesignificantlymorethantheexpecteddemandforthreeorfouryearsbecauseofthreefactors.HugecapacityadditioninmanufactureofPVqualitysilicon(inresponsetoearliershortage)in2009,dropingrowthrateofSpain’sdemandduetoendofgovernment’senforcedPVenergyprogram(inSeptember2008)anduncertaintyinUSgovernment’ssolarenergypolicies.Theaboveinformationisnotacauseofconcernbutacauseforoptimismforsolarenergyindustryasmediumtermopportunitiesarehuge.Economic,socialandecologicalconsequencesofpastenergyusagepatternwouldforcethecountriesandtheirpopulacetochangetheirhabitsthusevenimpactingbigenergyplayers(companiesandconsortiumslikeOECD).Sowhatcouldbethestrategychallengesforpresentandfuturesolarenergyplayersinthisageofrapidchangeanduncertainties?CountriesGermany:Thegrowthrateofnearly25%isnotsustainableafter3‐5yearsduetotwofactors.AsGermanyhasbeenaleaderthehugegrowthinsolarinstallationmeansthatthedemandwillnotbeatthesamelevelaspreviously.25‐30%ofdemandby2015wouldbegeneratedbyGermany.USA:TheuncertaintiesofgovernmentpoliciesinUSAhavebeenadampenerinthegrowthofdifferentsolartechnologiesandgrowthofdemand.Yet,somepoliticalinitiativeslikeMillionsolarroofs“programcreateslongtermoptimism.TheincreasedinsecurityofUSAduetochanginggeopoliticsofOilwouldleadittosupportenergyselfreliantpolicies.Differentintensitiesofsunlightgeneratepossibilitiesofdeploymentofdifferenttechnologies,thusincreasingpowergeneratingpotential.RisingconcernoverCO2emissionsisanotherpushfactorfordevelopmentofdemandforcleanenergy.10‐15%shareofpotentialdemandwouldcomefromUSAby2015.India:Thecountry’srecentprogramof1Gigwatt/yearinstallationshowsthatthesecondlargestpopulatedcountryisacceptingthefactthatitsownresourcesofcoalandhydropowerisinsufficientforitspowerneeds,wherethereisademandsupplygapof14%atpeakloads.Secondly,amountofinsolationand“sun‐days”(average270days)arebignaturaldriversforgrowthoftechnologieslikeCPV,CSPandPV.Risingnumberoflitigationsoverhydropowerprojects,lowqualityofcoalhigh,airpollution,deforestationandincreasingoildependencyofthecountryarepushfactorsforgenerationofcleanenergy.Offgridusageinwaterpumpsforagriculture,ruralelectrification;demandforwaterheatinginurbanareasarepullfactorsin

Page 9: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

20

India.Indiahasthepotentialtoconsumearound7‐10%ofdemandifitstartsfulfillingitstargetofinstalling1Gigawattofsolarenergy,by2015.45%ofdemandwouldcomefromtherestoftheworld;sowhichwouldbetheotherpotentialconsumersofsolarenergy?Chinawithitshugeenergydemand,Francewithitsshifttowardsrenewableandmovingawayfromthelastcoal‐basedplants,GreeceandItaly(wsjaugust2008)2duetoabundantsunlight,Australiawithoppositeseasonsasnorthernhemisphereandgoodamountofsunlight(speciallyinsouthandwest),Japanwithcommitmenttogreenhousegaseswouldbeothermajorconsumers.StrategyScenariosofPlayersDuetorapidlyrisingdemand,differentusages,anduncertaintiesarisingduetogovernmentsupportandhighcost,solarenergyplayershavetoadoptstrategiessupportingtheirlongtermandshorttermgoals.Gridparitywillremainthemostimportantconcernforanytechnology.Nowwelookatstrategyscenariosofthreebroadsegmentsofsolartechnology.MonoandPolysiliconphotovoltaicplayersSilicontechnologieswillremainthebiggestplayersuntil2015,thoughtheirsharewoulddeclineduetoadvancementsinothertechnologies(likeCSP)andcostreduction.

1) Geographicalexpansion‐‐‐‐CostofPVmoduleshavealsobeenhighduetoloweconomiesofscale.GeographicalexpansionintonewmarketslikeAustralia,India,andGreeceetcwouldallowlowcostandpriceandthusfurtherpenetration.

2) Alliancesacrossthevaluechain‐‐Alliancesofcompaniesacrossthevaluechain(from

siliconingotstowaferstosystemstoinstallationsandservices)wouldbuildastrongsupplychainandcreatestabilityintheindustry.

3) Consolidation‐‐‐Consolidationoftheindustrywith1)mergersandacquisitions2)

meltingawayofdifferenttechnologiesandcompaniesduetoobsolescenceandloweconomiesofscale,wouldbenefitthemonoandpolysiliconmanufacturers.

4) Integrationwithplayersinconventionalandrenewableenergysegments:Combinationof

solartechnologywithotherrenewableenergysegment(likewind)or/andconventionalenergycompanieslikecoalandhydropowerwouldresultinmoreacceptabilityandgrowth.

5) Creatingnewopportunitieswithdifferentindustries:Poweringindustriesliketelecom

andseawaterpurificationcouldcreateapplicationsinawiderdimensionleadingtospread,imageandgrowth.

6) Takingdifferentsolartechnologiesintheirfold:BigsiliconPVplayercouldthinkoftaking

differenttechnologiesintothefoldofthecompanytocatertodifferentgeographiesandusages.

Page 10: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

21

ThinFilmplayersBesidesgeographicexpansionandallianceswithconventionalandnonconventionalenergyplayersthinfilmcouldconsideranyorcombinationofstrategies:

1) Targetsegmentfocus:Targetinganarrowsegment(likecommercialbuildingsorlessintensesunlightareaoftheworld)couldgivethethinfilmplayerstwoadvantages;a)AvoiddirectcompetitionwithestablishedtechnologieslikesiliconPV,b)Establishingtheindustryinanewfield.

2) Creatingnewproducts:Thinfilmshaveflexibility,thispropertycanbeusedtocreate

newproductsegmentsuchaslowpowerdevices,militaryapplicationsandintegrationwithmodeoftransportationsuchasships,planesandautomobiles.

3) CompetingwithSiliconbasedplayers:Thethirdscenariocouldbedirectcompetition

withsiliconplayersinthebigdomainslikeresidentialandcommercialspace.Specially,commercialuserswouldliketohavemoreenergy(Kwh)ratherthanhighcostofinstallation($/watt).

Concentratedsolarpower(CSP)andConcentratedPhotovoltaic(CPV)Thesetechnologiesarecentralizedpowerproductionsorientedandcanbeintegratedeasilywithcurrentpowerproductionelementsofthesystemsuchasturbine(Rankinecycle,suchasStirlingdishesforCSP)andexistingpowergrid.

1) Powerpurchaseagreements:OneofreasonsofhighcostofCSPandCPVtechnologiesaretheirhugeprojectdevelopmentcostsandafewinstallations,leadingtohighcomponentscost.Whenthesetechnologieswouldbeimplementedonalargerscale,theyhavethepotentialtoproduceelectricityatgridparity.Longtermpowerpurchaseagreementswouldpropelthesetechnologiestobecosteffectiveandalsoattractmorefinancingoptions.

2) Highsolarinsolationareasasmarkets:AsCSPandCPVdependuponhighintensityof

sunlight,thecompaniesshouldconcentrateongeographieswhichhavehighinsolationandhavelargeareasforinstallation.Infutureitcanbebuiltonlandearlierusedbyfossilfuelpowerplants.

EmergingTechnologiesEmergingtechnologieslikeNanofilms(Nanosolar),OrganicPV(KonarkaTech),XCPV,MicroCSPhavethepotentialtocreatenewstandardsinthefield.

1) Applicationsandintegration:Themainstrategyofnewemergingplayerswouldbetoplayondifferentapplicationsotherthanelectricitygenerationonlargescale.OrganicPVornanofimscannotgeneratelargescaleelectricitylikesolarfarms.Soapplicationslikeelectricitywindows,façade,etcandintegrationwiththestructuresorsubstratesbecomecriticalfactors.

Page 11: Strategy challenges of Solar Energy Players-3

22

2) MicroCSPandX‐CPV:LowCostandintegrationwiththeexistingpowergenerating

systemwouldbemajorfactorsintheiracceptance.Itmaytake4‐5yearstodevelopthesetechnologiestobecompatiblewiththeexistinginfrastructure.

UtilitiesUtilitieshavethepotentialtobepartnersforbigscalepower(solarfarms)generatingplayersandtechnology(likeCSP,PVandCPV).UtilitiesbythevirtueoftheirexistinginfrastructurecouldbeveryactivepartnerswithSiliconPVandThinfilmplayers,byenteringintoinstallationandintegrationandutilizingtherelationshipwiththeendusers.

Playersshouldalsofocusonloweringbarriersofentrythrough1)developmentandtrainingoffuturesolarenergyprofessionals2)developanddisseminatestandardcodesandbestpracticestofacilitateinstallationofsolartechnologies.Partneringwithindustriesandcitiestopromoteinstallationcouldbeapotentstrategy,whichwouldalsoincreasevisibilityandeconomiesofscaleofdifferenttechnologies.ConclusionStrategychallengesintherapidlyevolvingmarketanduncleargovernmentsupportmakessolarindustryveryuncertainforatleast4‐5yearsbutalsoposesagreatexpansionopportunity,speciallyifthecostisbroughtdowntoconventionalfuelsandmethodsofproduction.EmergingtechnologiessuchasorganicPV,X‐CPVandMicroCSPhavethepotentialtotransformthewholeenergygamewithlowcost,flexibledesignandeaseofuse.Installationandruggednessofthesystemswouldbealwayscriticalfactorsingrowthofthesolarenergyindustry.Publicawarenessandhighcarbonemissionsarepushingthegovernmentandindustriestolookatalternativesbutlowcostofoil(comparativelywithsolarenergy,despitetherecentrisetounprecedentedlevel)easyavailability,establishedindustriescenteredontheproductionoffossilbasedfuel(likepowerplants,refineries),highinvestmentsaddtoinertiaagainstnewsourcesofenergy.Next4‐5yearswouldbeverycrucialforsolarenergyindustryasitwoulddecidewhatpathitchoosetobeanestablishedsourceofenergyfortheworldalongwithwindenergy(notincompetitionwith).Rightnowthequestioniswideopenandwehavetowaitandwatchtheoneofthegreatestturnsofhistoryafterinformationrevolution.Theenergyrevolution!