Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina...

84
Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC

Transcript of Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina...

Page 1: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategies for Effective Instruction

Marc W. Zolar

April 5, 2006

Presented to:Central Carolina Community College

Sanford, NC

Page 2: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

About the Presenter: Marc Zolar

Marc is an instructional design consultant and certified distance learning mentor. He has a broad professional background spanning the corporate, government and academic sectors. The list of organizations Mr. Zolar has worked with on learning and development programs includes: America Online, American Research Institute, AT&T, Central Carolina Community College, Florida State University, IBM, U.S. Department of Defense, United State Marine Corps, University of North Carolina at Wilmington, Verizon, Walden University.

He holds a Master’s degree in instructional design and development and is active in professional organizations in the field as a writer and speaker.

Marc can be reached at [email protected]

Page 3: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Today’s Topics

Constructivism and Adult Learning Principles

Lecture vs. Facilitation Blended Learning approaches Giving students ownership in the learning

process Accommodating different learning styles Reflective activity

Page 4: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Today’s Approach

This room as a Community of Learning.

Presentation of content and ideas for open discussion.

Collect Best Practices.

Page 5: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Sharing your thoughts?

What is your guiding philosophy about teaching?

Page 6: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Topic 1

Constructivism And Adult Learning Principles

Page 7: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

What is Constructivism? “Constructivism is a philosophy of

learning founded on the premise that, by reflecting on our experiences, we construct our own understanding of the world we live in. Each of us generates our own "rules" and "mental models," which we use to make sense of our experiences. Learning, therefore, is simply the process of adjusting our mental models to accommodate new experiences.“

(Source: http://www.funderstanding.com/constructivism.cfm)

Page 8: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Principles of Constructivism

Learning is a search for meaning

Learning occurs in a context

Instruction is tailored to learners’ mental models

Constructing knowledge is purpose of learning (not “right” vs. “wrong”)

(Source: Zolar, M. Constructivism 101. NC Quest Program, University of North Carolina at Wilmington.)

Page 9: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Impact on Curriculum

Less standardized curriculum

Customized to connect to learner’s prior knowledge

Emphasizes hands-on problem- solving

(Source: Zolar, M. Constructivism 101. NC Quest Program, University of North Carolina at Wilmington.)

Page 10: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Impact on Instruction

Teacher as facilitator/guide rather than authority

Focus on making connections between facts

Experimentation, open-ended questions, extensive reflection, dialogue among students

(Source: Zolar, M. Constructivism 101. NC Quest Program, University of North Carolina at Wilmington.)

Page 11: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Impact on Assessment

Ongoing assessment during instruction

De-emphasizes traditional grading methods

Self-assessment, learner articulates growth through projects and reflection

(Source: Zolar, M. Constructivism 101. NC Quest Program, University of North Carolina at Wilmington.)

Page 12: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Constructivist Strategies Inquiry learning Discovery learning Situational

learning Problem-based

learning Cognitive

Apprenticeship

(Source: Zolar, M. Constructivism 101. NC Quest Program, University of North Carolina at Wilmington.)

Page 13: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Constructivist Words and Phrases

Context Authentic Multiple perspectives Learner-centered Prior knowledge Higher-order thinking Meaningful

connections Social negotiation

(Source: Zolar, M. Constructivism 101. NC Quest Program, University of North Carolina at Wilmington.)

Page 14: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Discussion Question/Activity #1

List some constructivist strategies that you currently use, or could easily implement in your classroom.

Page 15: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

What is Adult Learning Theory (Andragogy)?

“Andragogy is a theory developed by Malcolm Knowles which attempts to describe how adults learn. His hypothesis was that adult learning could not follow the principles of traditional pedagogy in which teachers are responsible for making decisions about what will be learned, how it will be learned and when it will be learned. Because adults in general are more self-directed, they should take control of their own learning. The definition of an adult, however, is not strictly related to age. Knowles (1980) himself, defined adulthood as "the point at which individuals perceive themselves to be essentially self-directing". “

(Source: http://claweb.cla.unipd.it/home/cwhigham/cam_hy_whig/andragogy.htm)

Page 16: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

How are Adult Learners Different?

• They are self-directed

• They are goal oriented • They are practical and problem-solvers • They have accumulated life experiences.

(Source: http://claweb.cla.unipd.it/home/cwhigham/cam_hy_whig/andragogy.htm )

Page 17: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Implications of Andragogy for Instruction• Learners should know why they are studying something.

• Instruction should be task-oriented, and it should take into account the wide range of different backgrounds of learners.

• Learners should be able to relate what is being studied to their personal/professional experiences.

• Learners should be motivated and ready to learn.

• Learners should be involved in the planning and evaluation of their instruction.

• Instruction should be problem-centered rather than content-oriented.

(Source: http://claweb.cla.unipd.it/home/cwhigham/cam_hy_whig/andragogy.htm )

Page 18: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Applying the Principles of Andragogy

• Learner-centered classes will stimulate dialogue and knowledge construction.

• Learners will benefit from a scaffolding approach to learning where the teacher provides more support in the early stages of the course .

• Teachers should see themselves as facilitators and co-learners.

• Teachers should recognize that learners are individuals with different life experiences and learning preferences. Some adult learners will still prefer the traditional pedagogical approach to teaching and learning.

• Teachers should gradually try to push learners away from their comfort zone in the direction of a deeper approach to learning.

(Source: http://claweb.cla.unipd.it/home/cwhigham/cam_hy_whig/andragogy.htm )

Page 19: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Practical Tips

Ten Practical Tips for Teachersof Adult Learners

Adults prefer instructors who:

1. Are content experts 6. Consider learner interests2. Provide relevance 7. Individualize instruction3. Are well organized 8. Use active learning4. Don’t waste time 9. Encourage self-directed learning5. Provide clear learning goals 10. Are supportive and non-threatening

(Source: http://www.dit.ie/DIT/lifelong/adult/adlearn_strategies.pdf )

Page 20: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Discussion Question/Activity #2

Describe one new activity you could add to one of your courses that is consistent with adult learning theory.

Page 21: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Topic 2

Lecture vs. Facilitation

"It is in fact nothing short of a miracle that the modern methods of instruction have not yet entirely strangled the holy curiosity of inquiry. . . . It is a very grave mistake to think that the enjoyment of seeing and searching can be promoted by means of coercion and a sense of duty."

- - - - - Albert Einstein

Page 22: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Lecture: “Sage on the Stage”

At the root of the lecture model lies the notion that knowledge resides in the head of the teacher, and the student learns this knowledge by listening to the teacher.

(Source: http://www.elearnspace.org)

Page 23: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Characteristics of Effective/Ineffective Lectures

Characteristics of the Effective Lecture 

Characteristics of the Ineffective Lecture 

Educator-student interaction   100% educator talk, with limited or no interaction

Two-way communication   One-way communication

Educator-student questions  Few if any questions (educator or student) 

Shared responsibility for active learning  Student depends on educator for all information 

Small group, problem-solving activities  No student activities 

Variety of supporting media   No supporting media

Limited note taking required (students have copies of lecture notes) 

Extensive note taking required

Source: http://www.reproline.jhu.edu/English/6read/6training/lecture/delivering_lecture.htm

Page 24: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Lecture ComponentsSilberman (1990) suggests five approaches to maximizing students’ understanding and retention during lectures. These can be used to help ensure the effective transfer of knowledge.

Use an opening summary. At the beginning of the lecture, present major points and conclusions to help students organize their listening. 

Present key terms. Reduce the major points in the lecture to key words that act as verbal subheadings or memory aids. 

Offer examples. When possible, provide real-life illustrations of the ideas in the lecture. 

Use analogies. If possible, make a comparison between the content of the lecture and knowledge the students already have. 

Use visual backups. Use a variety of media to enable students to see as well as hear what is being said.

Source: http://www.reproline.jhu.edu/English/6read/6training/lecture/delivering_lecture.htm

Page 25: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Lecture or Not to Lecture?

Source: http://www.reproline.jhu.edu/English/6read/6training/lecture/delivering_lecture.htm

Lecture is appropriate when: Lecture is not appropriate when:

Disseminating information quickly to a large audience

Presenting complex, detailed or abstract information 

Presenting new information before using other media or activities (e.g., a brief lecture before playing a videotape)

Dealing with information concerning feelings and attitudes

Providing an overview of a topic  Training in psychomotor (hands-on) skills

Arousing interest in a topic Teaching high-level cognitive skills (e.g., synthesis and evaluation) 

Page 26: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Discussion Question/Activity #3

How much do you rely on lecture as an instructional strategy? How do you determine whether or not to use this strategy?

Page 27: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Facilitation: “Guide on the Side”

Learners learn best when given control of the experience, under the guidance and direction of a skilled instructor.

(Source: http://www.elearnspace.org)

Page 28: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

What is Facilitation?

Facilitation is the process of enabling groups to work cooperatively and effectively

(http://www.infodesign.com.au/usability/facilitation.html)

Page 29: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

What is a facilitator’s job?“Quite simply, a facilitator's job is to make it easier for the group to do its work. By providing non-directive leadership, the facilitator helps the group arrive at the decisions that are its task. The role is one of assistance and guidance, not control.”(Source: Ward-Green and Hill Associates at:

http://www.wghill.com/facilitate.htm)

Page 30: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Some Guidelines for Effective Facilitation

1. Address students’ current mode of thinking and learning in class:

Many students believe they are supposed to:•to have the right answers; •to meet explicit or implicit expectations of authority figures; •not to ask questions or share information; •not to experiment or to make mistakes; and/or •not to challenge the status quo.

These types of student fears/misconceptions need to be addressed directly and honestly by the instructor. Students must be made to feel that your classroom is a “safe” place to explore new learning.

Source: http://www.cdtl.nus.edu.sg/link/Mar2002/tm4.htm

Page 31: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Some Guidelines for Effective Facilitation

2. Manage class dynamics

As a facilitator, a faculty member will have to balance the following sets of opposing factors that influence how a class should be conducted:

•Structure: How rigidly or flexibly should the lesson be run? Pacing: How rapidly or leisurely should the group be pushed to achieve learning? •Group Interaction: How do group members relate to the facilitator and to each other? •Focus: Which is more important to impart, all course content as planned or the process of learning? •Concern: Should energy be directed at individual or group needs? •Control: To what extent are students empowered to perform in class?

Source: http://www.cdtl.nus.edu.sg/link/Mar2002/tm4.htm

Page 32: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Some Guidelines for Effective Facilitation

Source: http://www.cdtl.nus.edu.sg/link/Mar2002/tm4.htm

3. Establish core values

The teacher-as-facilitator should have a set of core values to guide his/her actions (Argyris & Schon, 1974). These core values will prevent the facilitator from behaving defensively when strong differences in views erupt in class or when students conduct themselves in an unacceptable manner.

Page 33: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Some Guidelines for Effective Facilitation

Source: http://www.cdtl.nus.edu.sg/link/Mar2002/tm4.htm

4. Communicate

It is paramount for a facilitator to listen to not only what is said, but also what is not said during a discussion. The facilitator has to

•Be alert and spot when and how individual students within the class express confusion or strong feelings. •Practice empathy so as to quickly respond to any doubts or questions students may have.

To encourage dialogue in class, both students and the faculty member have to suspend their own assumptions and show respect for each other in class: individual pride and ego must make way for a sincere interest in learning from one another.

Page 34: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Some Guidelines for Effective Facilitation

Source: http://www.cdtl.nus.edu.sg/link/Mar2002/tm4.htm

5. Sculpt students’ thinking

For effective facilitation, facilitator’s probing or questioning skills, and the ability to integrate or summarize various viewpoints is important. In this manner, different viewpoints can be generated and presented, and all in the class can achieve a fuller understanding of what is taught or learned.

The aim of ‘sculpting’ is not to impose one’s view on the students, but to help them mould their new understanding of the concepts learned to their existing body of knowledge and views (if any).

Page 35: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Characteristics of Effective Facilitators

Source: http://home.twcny.rr.com/hiemstra/tlchap5.html

Effective facilitation does not happen overnight. It requires commitment and practice on the part of

the instructor or trainer. Aker (1976) studied effective facilitators in detail and believed they were

individuals who exhibited the following characteristics:

1. Have great empathy--i.e., try to see things as seen by their learners. 2. Consistently use reward, seldom if ever use punishment, and never ridicule. 3. Have a deep sense of their responsibility, enjoy their work, and like people. 4. Feel secure in their own abilities, yet believe that they can do better. 5. Have a profound respect for the dignity and worth of each individual and accept

their fellow learners as they are without reservation. 6. Have a keen sense of fairness and objectivity in relating to others. 7. Are willing to accept or try out new things and ideas and avoid drawing premature

conclusions. 8. Have high levels of patience. 9. Recognize the uniqueness and strengths of each individual and build upon such

strengths. 10. Are sensitive to the needs, fears, problems and goals of their fellow learners. 11. Reflect on their experiences and attempt to analyze them in terms of success and

failure. 12. Are humble in regard to their role and avoid the use of power which is assumed by

some educators. 13. Do not pretend to have the answers and enjoy learning along with others. 14. Are continuously expanding their range of interest. 15. Are committed to and involved in their own lifelong learning (p. 3).

Page 36: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Discussion Question/Activity #4

List some core values you might establish in your classroom for facilitated exercises.

Page 37: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Topic 3

Blended-Learning Approaches

Page 38: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

What is Blended Learning?

Blended learning is the combination of multiple approaches to teaching or to educational processes which involve the deployment of a diversity of methods and resources or to learning experiences which are derived from more than one kind of information source.

Examples include combining technology-based materials and traditional print materials, group and individual study, structured pace study and self-paced study, tutorial and coaching.

Source: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blended-learning

Page 39: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Why Use Blended Learning?

Helps to accommodate different learning styles Expands learning beyond the classroom Gives students additional ownership in the learning processCreates a community of learning

Page 40: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Web-based Options for Face-to-Face Classes

Option 1: Asynchronous Discussion Boards in Blackboard:

Reinforces material covered in class and asks student to use higher-level thinking skills in answering questions.

Is a relatively low pressure strategy allowing students to carefully ponder assigned questions and prepare a thoughtful response before posting.

The exchange of ideas, including your insights, quickly creates an energy that can fuel your class and help create a sense of community among your learners.

Page 41: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Web-based Options for Face-to-Face Classes

Option 2: Synchronous Chats in Blackboard:

More active participants in your class will embrace this method.

Real-time exchange of ideas is not only exciting, but also teaches the participants to assimilate information quickly and to communicate their points more succinctly.

Managing a synchronous chat experience requires the instructor to know and enforce some basic guidelines.

Page 42: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Web-based Options for Face-to-Face Classes

Option 3: Web-based Research Assignments

The Internet is a powerful and free resource that has relevance to every conceivable content domain.

Encouraging some guided discovery learning using sites identified by the instructor as a starting point (e.g. Webquests, situated learning sites, etc).

Allow student to explore resources of their choosing, but provide guidelines for citation and validation of sources.

Page 43: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Web-based Options for Face-to-Face Classes

Option 4: Online learning weeks

Skip a few face-to-face sessions during the semester and instead require students to complete classwork online. Include assignments that require students to engage in different kinds of activities. For instance, you might ask your students to complete a Web-based research project, and then join a small group of their classmates for a synchronous chat session followed by an asynchronous discussion posting to share their conclusions. When you see your students again in the classroom, you can lead a lively discussion about their distance learning experience in addition to what they learned in new content.

Page 44: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Web-based Options for Face-to-Face Classes

Option 5: Distance-based collaborative projects for small groups

Assign students into small groups and ask them to work collaboratively at a distance. Successful online collaboration will foster discipline and responsibility. Ask your students to use the tools at their disposal to socially negotiate a method for completing the collaborative assignment with their peers, and then execute it. Have each group present their results including the method they used to work together.

Page 45: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Discussion Question/Activity #5

Have you used any of these online components? If yes, what were the results. If no, which appeal to you (if any)? Why?

Page 46: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Topic 4

Giving students ownership in

the learning processIt is not what you teach, but what they learn, that matters.

Page 47: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Student Ownership in Learning

Current educational research says puts increasing responsibility on the student for truly meaningful learning to occur. Promoting student ownership in the learning process is consistent with constructivist approaches to learning and adult learning theory.

Some strategies to do this are:

Learning Contracts Social negotiation of assignments and/or evaluation criteria Collaborative work Presentations

Page 48: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategy 1: Learning ContractsStudent name and details

This is pretty obvious

Course name and level So is this, but the course level is important, because that sets the expectations of the piece of work: the level criteria should be set out clearly somewhere—perhaps in the handbook.

Outcomes to be addressed

They may not be expressed as outcomes, but this is where the student puts the course requirements about the piece of work.

Form of submission It could be a project, a portfolio, a videotape of practice, an object the student has made, a computer program ... If the tutor signs the form, she is agreeing that a submission of this type will be acceptable

ATHERTON J S (2003) Learning and Teaching:  Learning Contracts [On-line] UK: Available: http://146.227.1.20/~jamesa//teaching/learning_contracts.htm

Page 49: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Learning Contracts, continued

Outline of submission

This is the crunchy bit: this is where the student sets out her intentions for the submission. Much of the rest of the form may be governed by course regulations, but this has to be original. It is a statement of the student's solution to the problem, "How am I going to produce evidence that I can meet these outcomes?"

Resources and assistance

This section is also the place to clarify complicating issues, such as collaborative work in a small group, and how marks are to be apportioned

Signatures These are what make the magic work: the contract is not worth anything until it has been agreed and signed by both student and tutor. Usually the student keeps the main copy to submit with the completed work, but the tutor can keep one on file for security purposes if necessary. The tutor's signature makes explicit the implicit bargain above. She is agreeing that if the student delivers what is promised, credit will be awarded.

Page 50: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategy 2: Social Negotiation of Criteria

One very effective way to promote student ownership is to give them input over the evaluation process for assignments. For instance, you might conduct an activity to create a rubric for a class project.

Why should students create their own rubrics?

“Reading or listening to a teacher's expectations is very different for a student than creating and accomplishing his or her own goals. The purpose of inviting students to develop their own evaluation structure is to improve their motivation, interest, and performance in the project. As students' overall participation in school increases, they are likely to excel in it.”

(Source: http://www.teachervision.fen.com/teaching-methods/rubrics/4586.html?detoured=1)

Page 51: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategy 2: Social Negotiation of Criteria

Once students are involved in project-based learning:

• Students are motivated intrinsically to design their own assessment tool

• Once students have invested a significant amount of time, effort, and energy into a project, they naturally want to participate in deciding how it will be evaluated.

• The knowledge gained through experience in a particular field of study provides the foundation for creating a useful rubric.

(Source: http://www.teachervision.fen.com/teaching-methods/rubrics/4586.html?detoured=1)

Page 52: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategy 2: Social Negotiation of Criteria

Example Rubric: Bridge Building Project

In this case, the class was divided into teams. Each group decided on their own "Company Name" as well as who would fill the following department head positions: project director, architect, carpenter, transportation chief, and accountant. All students were required to help out in every department. Each group received $1.5 million (hypothetically) to purchase land and supplies.

Students were asked to think about what parts of the design, construction, budget, and building journal were the most significant to the overall bridge quality. The class came up with four different rubrics

(Source: http://www.teachervision.fen.com/teaching-methods/rubrics/4586.html?detoured=1)

Page 53: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategy 2: Social Negotiation of Criteria

(Source: http://www.teachervision.fen.com/teaching-methods/rubrics/4586.html?detoured=1)

The budget rubric is provided as an example:

Budget Criteria

4Excellent

3 Good

2 Fair

1 Unacceptable

LegibilityCompletely legible.

The budget shows two or three marks or stains, but is legible.

The budget is barely legible, with numerous marks or stains.

The budget is messy and illegible.

Supplies & MaterialsAccountability

Completely accounted for.

Five-sixths of the materials and labor are accounted for.

Two-thirds of the materials and labor are accounted for.

Materials and labor are not accounted for.

Ledger ActivityAll daily activities are recorded.

Five-sixths of the daily balance of funds is indicated.

Two-thirds of the daily balance of funds is indicated.

The daily balance of funds is nonexistent.

Ledger BalanceBalance is completely accurate.

The daily balance has two or three inaccuracies.

The daily fund record has more than three inaccuracies.

The daily fund balance is inaccurate.

Page 54: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategy 3: Collaborative WorkWhat is collaboration and why should students do it?

Collaboration is the social process that supports learners' development of capabilities in which they learn to do without assistance things that they could initially do only with assistance.

By collaborating, students can develop their potential for learning. Specifically, students can learn to approach and solve new problems so that they develop the capability to solve problems that do not exist at the moment of learning.

Source: http://www2.gsu.edu/~wwwltc/howto/enablestudentcollab.htm

Page 55: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategy 3: Collaborative WorkWhat is required for students to collaborate?

To collaborate, students need: The task, e.g., a problem or project, the completion of which

requires conceptual change in students A group of students with problem-solving or project-developing

capabilities distributed among them Meaningful assistance for needed capabilities not distributed

among group members Time to interact with each other Guidance for developing group processes and assessing their

progress

Source: http://www2.gsu.edu/~wwwltc/howto/enablestudentcollab.htm

Page 56: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategy 3: Collaborative WorkHow do I get students to collaborate?To entice students to collaborate, it is helpful to: Shift course situations and reward structures to encourage students

to view interactions with peers as indispensable learning resources. Assign tasks that are suitable for collaboration, i.e., tasks that

require the integration rather than just the accumulation of ideas. Make the collaborative aspects of a course sufficiently large that

students cannot safely ignore them. Stage the first collaborative activities in ways that build swift trust

among group members so they can get to work on the task to attain useful results quickly, which encourages subsequent collaboration.

Have student groups make the results of their collaboration visible to other student groups,

Source: http://www2.gsu.edu/~wwwltc/howto/enablestudentcollab.htm

Page 57: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategy 4: Portfolio-based assessment

A portfolio is a collection of work used as proof, as evidence. It demonstrates: “Look what I have done, look what I can do, I have made these things, these are my products.”

What is a portfolio?

Source: NC Quest Program, UNCW at:

http://uncw.edu/ed/ncquest

Page 58: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Why create a portfolio? To provide a holistic perspective of your students learning journey

To document your students mastery of specific goals and objectives of the course through the selection and presentation of select pieces of “evidence” or “data.”

To serve as a tool for learning, to be built and reflected upon in a continuous manner as you proceed in your professional development.

Source: NC Quest Program, UNCW at:

http://uncw.edu/ed/ncquest

Page 59: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Implementing Portfolios

Introduce the basic structure/requirements at the beginning of the semester

Encourage student input in negotiating some components

Provide recommendations and examples

Require a portfolio outline prior to assembling

Page 60: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

What a Portfolio is NOTKeep in mind this is not a scrapbook. It should be a learning tool that includes select pieces of evidence, along with written reflections that explain, for example, why you chose each artifact, in what course objectives growth took place, what obstacles you overcame, and what goals you have for continued growth in this particular area. As you assess your own learning, there should be a strong connection that links your growth to overall goals of the course.

Source: NC Quest Program, UNCW at:

http://uncw.edu/ed/ncquest

Page 61: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Discussion Question/Activity #6

What methods do you currently use to promote student ownership in the learning process?

Page 62: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Topic 5

Accommodating different learning styles

Page 63: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Theory on Learning Styles

There are many theories and models onlearning styles. Some theorists to explore

are:

Gardner (Multiple Intelligences) McCarthy (4MAT) Dunn and Dunn (Cognitive Style Theory) Shindler (Paragon Learning Style

Inventory)

Page 64: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

A Few Basic Ideas

No two learners learn in the identical way. 

An enriched environment for one learner is not necessarily enriched for another. 

No learner is all one learning style The instructor’s learning style has

an impact

Page 65: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Some Familiar Styles

Auditory  Visual Tactual Kinesthetic

(Source: http://www.geocities.com/~educationplace/4mod.html)

Page 66: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Auditory Learners

Find it easy to learn by listening  Enjoy dialogues and discussion Do well talking through problems Are easily distracted by noise and other

auditory inputs Students who are NOT auditory learners

often struggle during lectures to concentrate or understand what is being said by the instructor

(Source: http://www.geocities.com/CollegePark/Union/2106/aud.html)

Page 67: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategies for Auditory Learners

Incorporate audio tapes, Internet content including audio, and discussion activities along with lectures.

Tape record lectures and make them available for student use.

Encourage auditory learners to use tape recorders to record lectures, and

their own verbal notes. join a study group. Talk through solutions to technical/math

content and record it in their own words.

Page 68: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Visual Learners

Like to see demonstrations and written descriptions of concepts 

Often use lists to organize notes and recognize words by sight

Have active imaginations Are easily distracted by movement or action

Are generally unaware of noise Student who are NOT visual learners often read a

page and realize they don’t know what they just read. They often have difficulty with reading assignments and overhead notes.

(Source: http://www.geocities.com/CollegePark/Union/2106/vis.html)

Page 69: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategies for Visual Learners

Use diagrams, illustrations, Internet

Use tables and charts with color coding to present text-based information

Encourage visual learners to re-write notes, color codes with highlighters, create study aides containing key information from text books and classroom assignments.

Page 70: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Tactual Learners

Like to take notes during a lecture or when reading 

Often draw or doodle to remember things Do well with hands-on projects

(demonstraton, labs, etc.) Students who are NOT tactual learners

generally do not take notes, and struggle to keep up during hands-on exercises.

(Source: http://www.geocities.com/CollegePark/Union/2106/tac.html)

Page 71: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategies for Tactual Learners

Use hands-on activities (labs, models, writing assignments)

Incorporate assignments using computers

Encourage tactual learners to: create flashcards Devise symbols or icons to help

classify information

Page 72: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Kinesthetic Learners

Do well when they are involved or active in the learning activity 

Have high energy levels Often don’t retain information presented

during lecture Don’t do as well when asked to sit and read Students who are NOT kinesthetic learners

prefer to sit and watch rather than get involved in activities.

(Source: http://www.geocities.com/CollegePark/Union/2106/kin.html)

Page 73: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Strategies for Kinesthetic Learners

Create large diagrams wall or floor Huge floor/wall puzzles Large Maps on wall or floor Team-based activities using chart paper posted on

wall to score Overheads projected on wall so students can move

to them for games. Acting Interviewing Peer coaching Skits Role Playing

(Source: http://www.geocities.com/CollegePark/Union/2106/kinact.html)

Page 74: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Plan for Different Learning Styles Every class represents the spectrum of

different learning styles. Incorporate this consideration into your

instructional design process (e.g. Include activities relevant for all four styles when developing lesson plans)

Assess the possible bias of your own learning style when planning instructional approaches.

Encourage students to learn more about their own learning style.

Allow students to have input in creating/revising/choosing course activities.

Page 75: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Discussion Question/Activity #7

What is the biggest obstacle you face in attempting to address multiple learning styles in the classroom?

Page 76: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Topic 6

Reflective Activity

Page 77: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Reflective Activity

A variety of activities can be used to facilitate student reflection.

Student journals Student presentations (portfolios) Interviews Asynchronous threaded discussions Classroom discussions

Page 78: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Reflective Activity

What does reflect activity do to stimulate learning?

Challenges students to make connections between experiences and concepts Encourages students to contemplate the process in addition to the content Makes the student the determiner of learning Improves critical thinking and writing skills.

Page 79: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Reflective Activity

Examples of reflective questions: Discuss the key differences between the roles of online instructor and face-to-face instructor. What aspects of effective online teaching do you feel pose the biggest challenge for you given your own personal style and attributes as a teacher? Discuss your own personal experience with online learning to date. This can include participation as learner and/or instructor. What were the strengths and weaknesses of the online learning you participated in? Highlight specific aspects that were particularly effective or ineffective. What do you think is the biggest obstacle to success in an online learning environment? Consider your own characteristics as an adult learner. What are some strategies that could be used in an online course to maximize the value of the experience for you? What strategies might frustrate you? Discuss any modifications to your own behavior that you might need to make in order to become an effective distance learner

Page 80: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Questions and Comments

The floor is yours!

Page 81: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Resources

•Facilitation: A Different Pedagogy?; CDTLink at: http://www.cdtl.nus.edu.sg/link/Mar2002/tm4.htm

•Pedicases at: http://www.pedicases.org/home.phtml

•Learning Styles at: http://www.geocities.com/~educationplace/ls.html

•Life Tips: Homework Tips, at: http://homework.lifetips.com/cat/59411/different-learning-styles/index.html

•Explorations in Learning and Instruction: Theory Into Practice (TIP) Database at: http://tip.psychology.org/

•Learning and Teaching Website, James Atherton at: http://www.learningandteaching.info/

•CDT Link at: http://www.cdtl.nus.edu.sg/link/default.htm

•Teachervision.com at: http://www.teachervision.fen.com/tv/

•Center for Teaching and Learning Website at Georgia State University. Available at: http://www2.gsu.edu/~wwwctl/

•Instructional Design Knowledge Base at George Mason University at: http://classweb.gmu.edu/ndabbagh/Resources/IDKB/index.htm

Page 82: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

Resources, continued.

•UMUC-Verizon Virtual Resource Site for Teaching with Technology: http://www.umuc.edu/virtualteaching/vt_home.html

•Web Teacher at: http://www.webteacher.org/windows.html

•Concept to Classroom at: http://www.thirteen.org/edonline/concept2class/index.html

•Multimedia Cases (Situated Learning), Mable Kinzie UVA at: http://kinzie.edschool.virginia.edu/id.html

•Moodle (freeware course management system) at: http://moodle.com/?moodlead=moodle.org

•Big Dog’s ISD page at: http://www.nwlink.com/~donclark/hrd/sat.html#intro

•Yahoo Web Beginner’s Guides at: http://dir.yahoo.com/Computers_and_Internet/Internet/World_Wide_Web/Beginner_s_Guides

•Distance Education Clearinghouse at:http://www.uwex.edu/disted/home.html

•University of Hawaii, Faculty Development Teaching Tips Index at: http://honolulu.hawaii.edu/intranet/committees/FacDevCom/guidebk/teachtip/teachtip.htm#assessment

Page 83: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

References

ATHERTON J S (2003) Learning and Teaching:  Learning Contracts [On-line] UK: Available: http://146.227.1.20/~jamesa//teaching/learning_contracts.htm Accessed: 1 April 2006

Blended-learning, Wikipedia at: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blended-learning

Institute of Learning, University of Hull at: http://claweb.cla.unipd.it/home/cwhigham/cam_hy_whig/andragogy.htm

Kelly, Diana K., Teaching Strategies for Adult Learners, Dublin Institute of Technology, at: http://www.dit.ie/DIT/lifelong/adult/adlearn_strategies.pdf

Life Tips: Homework Tips, at: http://homework.lifetips.com/cat/59411/different-learning-styles/index.html Retrieved April 2, 2006.

NC Quest Program Website, University of North Carolina at Wilmington at: http://www.uncw.edu/ed/ncquest/

Student Generated Rubrics, Pearson Education Network, teachervision.com at: http://www.teachervision.fen.com/teaching-methods/rubrics/4586.html?detoured=1 Retrieved April 2, 2006.

Sullivan, Richards; McIntosh, Noel. ReproLine, The Reading Room at:

http://www.reproline.jhu.edu/English/6read/6training/lecture/delivering_lecture.htm Retrieved April 1, 2006.

Page 84: Strategies for Effective Instruction Marc W. Zolar April 5, 2006 Presented to: Central Carolina Community College Sanford, NC.

References

TLTC Website, Center for Teaching and Learning, Georgia State University: Enabling student collaboaration at: http://www2.gsu.edu/~wwwltc/howto/enablestudentcollab.htm Retrieved April 3, 2006.

Ward-Green and Hill Associates at: http://www.wghill.com/facilitate.htm. Retrieved March 31, 2006.

What is Constructivism, funderstanding.com at: http://www.funderstanding.com/constructivism.cfm

Wilson, Cynthia, Learning Styles Website at: http://www.geocities.com/~educationplace/4mod.html Retrieved April 1, 2006.

Yoong, Shu Moo. Facilitation: A different pedagogy?. Centre for Development of Teaching and Learning, CDTLink. March 2002, 6:1 at: http://www.cdtl.nus.edu.sg/link/Mar2002/tm4.htm

Zolar, M. (2004) Constructivism 101. NC Quest Program, University of North Carolina at Wilmington.)