SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in...

31
ACCREDITATION Accreditation Standards and Processes SSH Accreditation SSH ACCREDITATION PROCESS Society for Simulation in Healthcare Council for Accreditation of Healthcare Simulation Programs Informational Guide for the Accreditation Process from the SSH Council for Accreditation of Healthcare Simulation Programs

Transcript of SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in...

Page 1: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

ACCREDITATION

08Fall

A c c r e d i t a t i o n S t a n d a r d s a n d P r o c e s s e s

SSHAccreditation

SSHACCREDITATIONPROCESS

SocietyforSimulationinHealthcareCouncilforAccreditationofHealthcareSimulationProgramsInformationalGuidefortheAccreditationProcessfromtheSSHCouncilforAccreditationofHealthcareSimulationPrograms

Page 2: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page2

TableofContents

HEALTHCARESIMULATIONACCREDITATIONBACKGROUND 3

BENEFITSOFSSHACCREDITATION 4

ELIGIBILITYANDSTANDARDS 5

SURVEYPROCESS 7ACCREDITATIONCYCLE 7SURVEYPROCESS 8ACCREDITATIONAPPLICATIONREVIEWPROCESS 8INITIALON-SITESURVEYPROCESS 8ACCREDITATIONDECISIONS&IMMEDIATEPOST-SURVEYPROCESS 8MAINTAININGACCREDITATION&RENEWALAPPLICATIONPROCESS 9APPEALSPROCESS 10

SIMULATIONPROGRAMREVIEWERS 11

COSTOFACCREDITATION 12

APPENDIXI:STEPSFORSSHACCREDITATION 13

APPENDIXII:FAQS 15

GLOSSARYOFTERMSFORSSHACCREDITATION 25

Page 3: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page3

Background:AccreditationinHealthcareSimulationTheSocietyforSimulationinHealthcare(SSH)wasestablishedinJanuary2004torepresenttherapidlygrowinggroupofeducators,researchscientists,andadvocateswhoutilizeavarietyofsimulationmethodologiesforeducation,testing,andresearchinhealthcare.ThemembershipoftheSocietyisunitedbyitsdesiretoimproveperformanceandreduceerrorsinpatientcareusingmulti-modalsimulationmethodologiesincludingtasktrainers,patientsimulators,virtualreality,screen-basedsimulatorsandstandardizedpatients.Recognizingthatsimulationrepresentsaparadigmshiftinhealthcareeducation,SSHpromotesimprovementsinsimulationtechnology,educationalmethods,practitionerassessment,andpatientsafetythatpromotecompetentandexcellentpatientcare,includingcontinuousmeasurementsandimprovementsinpatientoutcomes.Consistentwithitsmission–tobeaaleadinginterprofessionalsocietythatadvancestheapplicationofsimulationinhealthcarethroughglobalengagement-SSHhasdevelopedanaccreditationprocessforsimulationprogramsfocusedonhealthcare.Forpurposesofthisaccreditationprocess,asimulationprograminhealthcare(hereforwardknownas“Program”)isdefinedasanorganizationorgroupwithdedicatedresources(personnelandequipment)whosemissionisspecificallytargetedtowardimprovingpatientsafetyandoutcomesthroughassessment,research,advocacyandeducationusingsimulationtechnologiesandmethodologies.ProgramsseekingSSHaccreditationwilldemonstratecompliancewithCoreStandardsandfulfillmentofstandardsappliedtooneormoreofthreeareasofsimulation/simulatoruse:

1. Assessment2. Research3. Teaching/Education

AProgrammayseekaccreditationforitsoverallsystemeffortsinthefollowingarenaonlyiftheyareapplyingforaccreditationinoneoftheabove3areas.SystemsIntegrationandPatientSafetycannotbeappliedforasa“stand-alone”area.AprogramcannotbeaccreditedONLYinSystemsIntegrationandPatientSafety.4.SystemIntegrationandPatientSafety

Page 4: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page4

BenefitsofSSHAccreditationThebenefitsofaccreditationaccruevaluetotheorganization,theindustryandthecommunity.Benefitsinclude,butarenotlimitedto:• Improveshealthcareeducationthroughtheidentificationofbestpracticesandrecognitionofpractice

• Improveshealthcaresimulationthroughprovidingstandardizationandapoolofknowledgeofbestpractices

• Strengthenspatientsafetyeffortsthroughsupportofsimulationmodalities• Supportseducationandconsultationongoodpracticesandbenchmarkstoimprovebusinessoperations

• Encouragesthesharingofbestpracticesthrougheducationandconsultation• Providesexternalvalidationofindividualsimulationprograms• Strengthensorganizational,community,andlearnerconfidenceinthequalityofeducationandservices

• Garnerslocalsupport,resources,andcommitment• Fostersafeedbackloopbetweeneducationandpracticebyparticipatinginacontinuousprocessofimprovement

• Encouragesperformanceimprovementwithinthesimulationprogram• Providesacompetitiveedgeinthecommunity,programofferings,andgrantfunding

• Providesacustomized,intensiveprocessofreviewgroundedintheuniquemissionandvaluesoftheorganization

• Enhancesstaffrecruitmentanddevelopment• Recognizesexpertiseinsimulationaboveandbeyonddomainexpertise

Page 5: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page5

ELIGIBILITY&STANDARDSAProgramiseligibleforSSHAccreditationwhenitisabletodemonstratecompliancewiththeestablishedcoreandareaspecificstandards.Aprogrammusthaveaminimumoftwoyearsexperienceinthefunctionalareainwhichaccreditationissought.AllprogramsmustdemonstratecompliancewiththecriteriaassociatedwiththefollowingsevenCoreStandards:CORESTANDARDS

1. Mission&Governance2. ProgramManagement3. ResourceManagement4. HumanResources5. ProgramImprovement6. Integrity7. ExpandingtheField

Inaddition,theProgrammustdemonstratecompliancewiththestandards/criteriainoneormoreofthefollowingfunctionalareas:ASSESSMENTSTANDARDS

1. Resources&Technology2. Assessors3. AssessmentTools4. AssessmentSupport

RESEARCHSTANDARDS

1. Mission2. ResearchOversight3. ResearchActivity4. Researchers5. ResearchCollaboration6. Compliance

TEACHING/EDUCATIONSTANDARDS

1. EducationalActivities2. EducationalActivityDesign3. QualifiedEducators4. EvaluationandImprovement

Page 6: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page6

AnadditionaloptionforProgramswhohavemettheaboverequirementstoberecognizedinthefunctionalarea(s)ofAssessment,and/orResearch,and/orTeaching/EducationistoseekaccreditationintheareaofSystemIntegration&PatientSafetyStandards:SYSTEMINTEGRATION&PATIENTSAFETYSTANDARDS

1. Mission&Scope2. IntegrationActivities

***FurtherinformationontherequiredcriterianeededforeachofthestandardscanbefoundintheAccreditationStandardspostedonline.

Page 7: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page7

ACCREDITATIONCYCLEApplicationinstructionsareavailableonlineathttps://ssih.org/accreditation.Thewebsiteprovidesinstructionsoncompletingandsubmittingtheapplicationandrequireddocumentation.TheAccreditationCycle(commontimeframes):AnnualDeadlinesforApplication

ReviewedandinitialresponsesbySSH

TimeframeforScheduledVisit

SSHAccreditationBoardofReview

May15December15

JuneJanuary

August–NovemberMarch–July

October-DecemberJune–August

Page 8: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page8

ACCREDITATIONSURVEYPROCESS

AccreditationApplicationReviewProcessTheaccreditationapplicationreviewisthefirststepintheaccreditationprocess.Oncesubmitted,theSSHAccreditationstaffwillreviewtheapplication.Iftheapplicationiscompleteandalleligibilitycriteriamet,anon-sitereviewwillbescheduled.

AccreditationOn-SiteSurveyProcessTheon-sitesurveyprocessisaone-day*structuredreviewwhereReviewerswillbudgettheirfocusundereachcriteriauniquetoeachprogramwiththegoaltosupporttheprogram’seffortstoimprovetheiroperationsandoveralloutcomes.TheSSHSimulationAccreditationReviewTeam(SSH-SART)willbeassignedandannouncedatleastonemonthpriortothescheduledvisit.*Sitereviewsforareasapplyingforallfourareasmayberequiredtoextendintoanadditionalday.

AGENDAFORREVIEWDAY(Sample)

Check-in(onlineverificationprocess)OpeningReviewingofDocumentationCriteriainStandardsInspectionandObservationofProgramEnvironmentInterviewUsersandLearnersObservationofSimulationProcessesReviewofCurriculaReviewofQualityAssuranceDataReviewofQualityImprovementInitiativesSSH-SARTDeliberation(Closed)Closing

AccreditationDecisions&ImmediatePost-SurveyProcessAccreditationdecisionsaremadebytheAccreditationBoardofReviewbasedonevidenceofcompliancewithestablishedaccreditationstandardsandcriteria.Evidenceofcomplianceisprovidedbytheprogramandverifiedbythesurveyteamduringsitevisits.Atthecompletionofthesitevisit,thesurveyteamwillprepareasummaryofthesurveyfindings.TheaccreditationdecisionwillbemadebytheSSHAccreditationBoardofReviewfollowingreviewofthesurveyteam’sEvidenceofCriteriaforStandardsFeedbackReport.TheAccreditationBoardofReviewwillmakethedecisionthataccreditationisgrantedornotgranted.

Page 9: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page9

Whenaprogramisgranted,orisnotgrantedaccreditation,afeedbackreportwillbeprovided.AProgramnotgrantedaccreditationmustwaitonefullcyclebeforebeingeligibletoreapply.

MAINTAININGACCREDITATION&RENEWALAPPLICATIONPROCESSAccreditationisgrantedforafive(5)yearperiod.Reportsarerequiredannuallyandanytimeasubstantialchangewithintheprogramoccurs.Inordertomaintainaccreditation,theprogrammustsubmitanannualSSHAccreditationSelf-Studyreportandanannualfee.ThereportwillbeduebyJune15ofeachyear,aftertheyeartheprogramwasgrantedAccreditation.Failuretoprovidetheannualreportandfeebythestateddeadlinecouldresultindismissaloftheprogram’saccreditationstatus.ThereporttemplatewillbeprovidedtoeachaccreditedprogrambytheDirectorofAccreditationatleast3monthspriortothedeadlineforsubmission.Forrenewedaccreditation,aprogrammustsubmitaRenewalApplicationtoSSHAccreditationCouncilinthecycle5yearsfollowinginitialaccreditation.

Page 10: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page10

APPEALSPROCESSTheSocietyforSimulationinHealthcareseekstoimplementafairandtransparentaccreditationprocess.Appealsconcerningaccreditationdecisionswillbeevaluatedinareasonable,carefulandtimelymanner.SimulationprogramsseekinganappealmustformallycommunicatetheirconcernstotheExecutiveDirectoroftheSocietyforSimulationinHealthcarewithin2weeksoftheaccreditationdecision.Appealsmustbeinwriting;theExecutiveDirectorwillconfirmreceiptoftheappealwithin2weeks,willinformtheAccreditationCounciloftheappeal,andforwardtheappealtotheExecutiveCommitteeofSSH(actingAppealsCommittee).Appealsmustspecifythecriteriaunderdispute,andshouldincluderelevantdocumentation.TheAppealsCommitteemaycontacttheapplicantprogramtorequestadditionalinformationorclarification.TheAppealsCommitteewillreplytotheAppealinwriting,within8weeksunlessotherwisecommunicatedbytheExecutiveDirector.AnyquestionsorconcernsaboutAccreditation,Standards,Processes,andSSHAccreditationServicesshouldbeforwardedto:AndrewSpainDirectorofAccreditationandCertificationSocietyforSimulationinHealthcareOfficePhone:573.340.3735aspain@ssih.orgKristynGadlageAccreditationandCertificationCoordinatorSocietyforSimulationinHealthcareOfficePhone:[email protected]

Page 11: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page11

SIMULATIONPROGRAMREVIEWERS(Surveyors)Thereviewteam,SSH-SART,canincludeoneormoreReviewerswhohaveseniorlevelexperienceandhavedemonstratedsimulationexpertiseintheSSHStandardsofAccreditation.SSHReviewersaretrainedandcertified,andwillreceivecontinuingeducationonadvancesinquality-relatedperformanceevaluation.Reviewteamsmayconsistofphysicians,nurses,simulationprogramadministrators,orotherqualifiedindividuals.AllReviewersarevolunteers;theywillbecompensatedfortheirtravelexpenses,butwillnotreceivesalaryfromSSH.

Page 12: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page12

COSTOFCYCLEACCREDITATIONTheaccreditationfeeforthecorestandardsandoneoftheARTstandardsis$5975.00.ThefeescheduleformultipleART-Sstandardsreviewsisshownbelow.Theaccreditationfeeispaidwithin60daysfromSSHnotificationofeligibilityandacceptanceandistobesubmittedwithaLetterofIntent.ThesurveyfeedoesnotincludeReviewertravelfeesthataretheresponsibilityofeachprogram.SSHwillinvoiceeachprogramattheconclusionofthesitevisitforsitereviewertravelincludingairfare,hotelaccommodations,meals,othertransportationneeded,andincidentalsoccurredasadirectrelationtoaccreditationon-sitereview.FeeScheduleforSSHAccreditation*AccreditationService AmountDueApplicationReview $100.00On-SiteSurvey(Core+1)

$5,975.00

On-SiteSurvey(Core+2) $6,250.00On-SiteSurvey(Core+3) $6,499.00On-SiteSurvey(Core+4) $6,975.00ReviewerTravel(travelforreviewerspaidbysite).Invoicewillbesenttoprogramwithin2weekspostreview

Variable

1Y,2Y,3Y,4YReportReview $255.00each

*Fees subject to increase. Please contact Director of Accreditation for further information.

Page 13: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page13

APPENDIXI:StepsforSSHAccreditation

Page 14: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page14

NOTE:PerSSHAccreditationPolicy,nocontactwillbemadebytheprogramtotheSSH-SART(SimulationAccreditationReviewTeam)orCouncil.AllQuestionsmaybedirectedtotheDirectorofAccreditation,AndrewSpain,ortotheAccreditationCoordinator,KristynGadlage.

Page 15: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page15

APPENDIXII:FrequentlyAskedQuestions(FAQ)

1. Eligibility2. Standards3. Processes4. Reviewers(Surveyors)5. OtherAccreditingOrganizations

1.ELIGIBILITYQ1.1:Inordertobeconsideredforaccreditation,doesmyProgramhavetobeinafreestandingCenterorfacility? A1.1:No.AProgrammaybeinastand-alonefacilityormaybeinsideahospitalorschool.AlthoughfacilitiesmustbeadequatetomeetthegoalsandobjectivesoftheProgram,thedefiningcharacteristicsofanaccreditedprogramistheworkitdoes,notthephysicalstructure. Q1.2:MysimulationProgramisfairlynew.IsitpossibletobeaccreditedwhenwehaveonlylimitedexperienceasaProgramorifwehaveplansforwhatweintendtodo? A1.2:Inordertobeconsideredforaccreditation,aProgramneedstohavebeeninexistencefortwoyearsandbeabletodemonstratethatithastherequisitesystemsandprocessesinplaceandthatitisachievingitsstatedgoalsanddemonstratingoutcomes.Inaddition,theprogrammusthaveatleast2yearsexperienceineacharea(Assessment,Research,TeachingandSystemsIntegration)forwhichtheapplicationissubmitted. Q1.3:IsSSHseekingtoaccreditsimulationprogramsoronlytoapprove/endorsetheiractivities?

A1.3:Thegoalisaccreditation.Thedefinitionof“Accreditation”isbelievedtobeconsistentwithothernationalaccreditationbodiessuchasCouncilforHigherEducationAccreditation(CHEA)andUSDepartmentofEducation(USDE).Whenfullyimplemented,theSSHaccreditationprocesseswillinclude:(a)completionofaself-study,(b)asitevisit,(c)areportfromthereviewers,(d)areviewoftheteamreportbytheBoardofReview,and(e)adecisionbytheBoardofReview.Anappealprocessisalsoavailable.

Page 16: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page16

Q1.4:IsthereaminimumlengthoftimeaProgrammustbeinexistencebeforeseekingaccreditation?A1.4:Aprogrammustbeinexistencefor2yearsbeforeseekingaccreditation.Theprogrammustalsohaveatleast2yearsexperienceineacharea(Assessment,Research,TeachingandSystemsIntegration)forwhichtheapplicationissubmitted.Basedoninputfromnewcentersthatgreworganicallyorreliedheavilyonconsultants,evenwithawell-developedstrategicplanandahigh-levelbusinessplan,ittakesanaverageof18monthstobefullyoperational.Q1.5:OurprogramisnotintheUnitedStates:canwestillapply?A1.5:Yes.SSHisaninternationalsociety.SSHisactivelyworkingwithotherinternationalorganizationsandhasperformedsitereviewsforinternationalprograms.Weareintegratinginternationalsitereviewerstoperformon-sitereviewsofapplicantprograms. Q1.6:Iappliedforaccreditationin2013andwasfoundnottohavemetallofthestandards/criteriaforaccreditation.WhenistheearliestIcanreapply?A1.6:Inordertoassureprogramshaveadequatetimetocomeintocompliancewiththestandards,programsmustwaitoutonefullcycle.Inthiscase,youwillneedtowaituntilthe2015cycletoreapply.Q1.7:IamfromaprogramoutsideoftheUnitedStates.DoapplicationmaterialsneedtobesubmittedinEnglish?A1.7:Weencourageapplicationsfromsimulationcentersacrosstheglobe.Wedonotyethavetheresourcestosupportallthepossiblelanguagesforprogramsseekingaccreditation.ThereforedocumentationforreviewmustbesubmittedinEnglish,andourvisitingteamwillrequireyourcentertoprovidesomeonewithknowledgeofyoursimulationcenterwhoisfluentinEnglishaswellasyourprimarylanguagetotranslatefortheteam. 2.STANDARDSQ2.1:IfmyProgramwantstoonlyseekaccreditationforSystem-IntegrationandPatientSafety,isthatpossible? A2.1:No.AProgramcannotonlyseekaccreditationintheareaofSystemIntegrationandPatientSafety.Thisisnotastandaloneaccreditationdesignation.AProgrammustalsomeetthecorestandardsandthestandardsassociatedwithatleastoneofthethreefunctionalareas:Assessment,Education,orResearch.Ifyour

Page 17: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page17

Programmeetsalltherequirementsinoneormoreoftheseareas,andyourProgramprovidessupportingevidencerelatedtothestandardsforSystemIntegrationandPatientSafety,yourProgramcanbeconsideredforrecognitionintheareaofSystemsIntegrationandPatientSafety. Q2.2:IfmyprogramwantstobeaccreditedinonlyEducation,andSystemsIntegrationandPatientSafety,isthispossible?A2.2:Yes.IfyourProgramdocumentscompliancewiththecorestandardsaswellasthestandardsassociatedwithEducation,andyourprogramalsosuppliesevidenceofcompliancewiththestandardsforSystemIntegrationandPatientSafety,SSHwillconsideryourProgramfordualaccreditationinEducationaswellasSystemsIntegrationandPatientSafety. Q2.3:InotethatthereisnotaspecificrequirementfortheamountofdedicatedtimetheProgramDirectormustspendwiththeProgram.HowwillSSHknowwhatis“adequate?” A2.3:CurrentlythereisnoevidencethatestablishesaminimumamountoftimenecessarytoassureaqualityProgram.Giventhevariabilityofprogramsandorganizationalstructures,wefeelthatitisreasonabletoassesstheadequacyoftimecommitmentsbasedontheoverallqualityofProgram’sstructure,processes,andoutcomes.Throughtheaccreditationprocess,theProgramwillbeaskedtodemonstratehowitmeetsitsstatedgoalsandisincompliancewiththeestablishedstandards.Aswecollectdataovertime,however,webelievethatwemaybeabletoidentifyathresholdfordedicatedtimenecessaryfromtheProgramDirector.Ifwedo,wewillintegratethatevidenceintofutureaccreditationstandards. Q2.4:Inseveralplacestherearestatementsabout“experts”and“qualifiedindividuals.”Howwillthesetermsbeoperationalizedinanobjectiveandconsistentmanner? A2.4:Asanemergingdiscipline,someofthesetermsarehardtodefine.WhilewebelievethatitisimportantfortheProgramstosupplytheirrationaleforjudgingtheiradministrators,instructors,andresourcepersons“qualified”or“expert,”thisisanareawhereweneedsomeinputfrominvolvedstakeholders.Althoughwehavecollectivelydefinedthesetermsinourglossary,wewelcomeyourfeedbackforoperationaldefinitionsthatweshouldusefortheseterms. Q2.5:Whatistheexpectationfor“oversight”andhowwouldaProgramreconcilemultipledepartmentsusingonefacility?A2.5:TheCouncilmembersbelievethatifmultipledepartmentsareusingone

Page 18: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page18

facility,thattheneedforanoversightbodyandstandardpoliciesandprocedureswouldbecritical.ThereisnosinglewayinwhichaProgramshouldprovideoversightforactivities.TheProgramwouldneedtodescribeintheSelfStudyhowthisoversightisaccomplishedandevaluated.

Q2.6:Concernwasexpressedaboutneedingtoprovidebudgetsandfinancialsupportinformation.

A2.6:Thisisviewedassensitiveinformationbyanumberofrespondents.ThegoalinthiselementistoensurethattheProgramhasthemeansnecessarytosupportitsmissionandassurestability.Someprogramsmaybeuncomfortablesupplyingsalaryinformationataperson-by-personlevel;thisobjectivecouldbeachievedifinformationwereprovidedinaggregateatthelevelofcategoriesofrevenueandexpense.Forexample,totalsalaryexpense,totalnon-salaryexpense,andtotalcapitalexpenseinformationwouldsuffice.Thisinformationwillremainconfidential.Q2.7:Whataretheexpectationsforthequalificationsofinstructors/faculty?Isanadvanceddegreerequiredorisexperienceasufficientqualification?Howwillcompetencybedemonstrated?Willweneedtosharetheevaluationsofourindividualinstructorsandfaculty?

A2.7:TheCouncilmembersagreethatthismaybedifficultareatoaddressastherearepeoplewhohavebeendoingcredibleworkandleadingthefieldwithoutanadvanceddegreeinthespecialtyofsimulation.Similartotheprocessesdevelopedwithmanynewermedicalspecialties,individualswhohavebeendevelopingthisfieldwillbeevaluatedviareviewofportfolios,résumés,curriculadeveloped,etc.Tocrediblyachieveaccreditation,wehavetoassessthequalificationsofinstructors,facultyandotherswhoperformvitalrolesinthePrograminthecontextofthatprogram.Applicantsmusthaveaformalprocesstodocument,evaluateandreviewthequalifications,trainingandexperienceofallstaff.Q2.8:Whatdowemeanwhenwesay“evidence-based”suchasevidence-basededucationalmaterials? A2.8:Itwasagreedthatthereisnotthesamelevelofevidenceinsimulationasthereisindiabetescare,forexample.TheBestEvidenceinMedicalEducation(BEME)projectoutlinesthechallengesinthisregard.EducationalmaterialsormethodsthathavebeenproventhroughrigorousinterventionsandresearchwillbeintegratedintoaccreditationstandardsandconsultationasdeemedappropriateandgenerallyapplicablebytheAccreditationCouncil.

Page 19: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page19

Q2.9:CanIutilizemyinstitutionalororganizationalpoliciesandproceduresinsteadofcreatingadditionalpoliciesandproceduresforjusttheProgram?A2.9:Whiletherearesomeorganizationalpoliciesandproceduresthatcanbecross-referencedtoapplytothesimulationprogram,otherpoliciesandproceduresmustbedevelopedspecificallyfortheProgram.Programpoliciesandproceduresareexpectedtoaddressconfidentiality,complaintresolution,qualityimprovement,instructor/assessortrainingandevaluation,andvideoretentionspecifictothesimulationenvironmentencompassingallindividualsinvolvedwiththeProgram.Q2.10:WhatisaStrategicPlan?A2.10:Astrategicplanistheprocessofcomprehensive,integrativeprogramplanningthatconsidersthefutureofcurrentdecisions,overallpolicy,program/organizationdevelopmentandlinkstooperationalplans.Theprocessshouldalignwithandallowtheprogramtofulfillitsmissionandachieveitsvision.Allareasofaccreditationincludingcorestandards,assessment,research,teaching/education,andsystemsintegrationandpatientsafetyshouldbealignedwiththestrategicplanoftheProgram.Q2.11:Whatismeantbyprioritizationofprogramutilization?As.11:InalignmentwiththeProgram’smission/visionandstrategicplan;theProgramhasaprocessforprioritizingsimulationcourses,activities,andrequestsinasystematicmanner.Theprogramisabletodescribethisprocessandprovidedocumentationofprioritizationsmadethatfollowthedescribedprocess.Q2.12:WhatisSystemsIntegrationandcanyouprovideanexample?A2.12:Systemsintegrationincludesaligningorganizationalgoalsandsimulationactivities,withbidirectionalfeedback.Theseareexamplesofseveralwaysthatsimulationcanbeusedtosupportorganizationalgoalswhenintegratedintoabi-directionalprocess(e.g.usingafeedbackloop):

1.Simulationcanbeemployedtohelppeoplelearnorpracticemethodsthatcouldbehelpfulinattaininganorganizationalgoal,suchimprovingtheprocessofcentrallineaccessasmeansofreducingthenumberofhospital-acquiredinfections.Itisnotnecessarythatsimulationoccurasanisolatedintervention;itcouldbeacomponentofamulti-prongedeffort.

2.Simulationcouldbeusedasanintentionalin-situprobebeforeopeningneworrenovatedpatientcareunits,providingpracticetotheparticipantsaswellasinformationtotheorganizationtosupportimprovementsbeforeactualpatientcareoccursinthoseunits.

Page 20: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page20

3.SimulationcontentcouldbebasedonSeriousSafetyEvents,precursorevents,pro-activeidentificationofpossiblelatenthazards,etc.

4.Systemhazardsorlatentconditionscouldbeidentifiedduringsimulations,andthatinformationprovidedtoappropriateorganizationalleadersforremediation.Identificationoftheseconditionscouldbeintentionallysought,orrecognizedserendipitously.

5.Virtual,tabletoporothertypesofsimulationscouldbeusedasacomponentofamodelingprocessintendedtobetterunderstandorimprovepatientflow,hospitalsystemsorotheraspectsofpatientcare.

6.Simulationscanbedesignedtocrosstheboundariesofmultiplepatientcareareas,disciplinesand/orsupportsystemssuchasasimulationwhichbeginsatthehelicopterlandingpad,andprogressesintotheED,includingtransportandsecurityofficersaswellashealthcareproviders.

AprogramcanbeconsideredforSystemsIntegrationaccreditation(seeglossary)ifitdemonstratesconsistent,planned,collaborative,integrated,anditerativeapplicationofsimulation-basedassessment,research,and/orteachingactivitieswithprocessimprovementandsafetyprinciplestoimproveclinicalcare,patientsafety,and/oroutcomemetricsacrossthehealthcaresystem(s).Q2.13:OurprogramwouldliketoapplyforaccreditationintheareaofAssessment,butatthistimeweonlyprovidemarketedcoursessuchasACLSandPALS.AreweeligibleforAccreditationinAssessment?A2.13:ApplicationforaccreditationinAssessmentwillbelimitedtothosecenterscreating,validating,and/orperforminghumanperformanceassessmentusingexplicit,preferablyvalidated,criteria.Assessmentleadershipandassessorsmusthavespecificandsubstantialtraining,expertise,anddemonstratedcompetencyintheartandscienceofhumanassessment.Assessmenttoolsmaybe(1)internallycreatedifjustifiedbyexpertpanelreviewor(2)definedbyprofessionalsocieties,licensingbodies,orcertificationorganizations.Externallycreatedstandardizedandmarketedcourses,andthestandardizedassessmenttoolsassociatedwithsuchcourses,willbeconsidered,butmaynotbesufficient,intheaccreditationofprogramsinAssessment.3.PROCESSESQ3.1:WillallPrograms-largeandsmall-beabletoaffordaccreditationifthefeesaresettofullycoverexpenses?WilltherebeanadequatenumberofReviewerstoreviewProgramsinatimelymannerifthereisarapiduptakeofSSHaccreditationinthesimulationcommunity?

Page 21: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page21

A3.1:Itistheexpectationthatthecostwillbereasonablefortheservice.TheCouncilhadselected20additionalreviewersandtrainedthosereviewersinitiallyin2011withadditionalannualrequiredtraining.Q3.2:Requiring a site visit is an expensive element of an accreditation program. Is it necessary that it is included in the processes? A3.2:TheCouncilagreedthatitisimportanttodetermineanddocumentthevalueofon-sitevisits.Ingeneral,webelievethatthepurposeistoclarifyandverifythreeelements:(1)sitecharacteristics,byobservation(2)outcomes,byspeakingwithlearnersandobservingtrainingsessionsorvideosand(3)organizationalsupportandalignment,bymeetingwithkeyindividuals.Weareevaluatingourfindingstodeterminewhethertocontinuethisaspectofourprocess.Q3.3:Istheaccreditationdesignationtimelimited? A3.3:Theaccreditationdesignationislimitedto5yearswithproofofmaintenanceandimprovementviaanannualreport.Q3.4:HowdoestheAccreditationcommitteedevelopandimproveitsstandardsandprocesses?ThefollowingcommentwasreceivedbytheAccreditationCouncil:“Accreditingbodiesmusthaveprocessesfortheestablishment,reviewandrevisionoftheiraccreditationstandards,policiesandprocedures.BasedontheinformationprovideditisnotclearwhatprocessestheSSHisusingtoestablishitsaccreditationstandards,policiesandprocedures.AtaminimumtheSSHaccreditationprocessesshouldbewidelydistributedforreviewandcommentbythecommunityofinterest.”

A3.4:TheCouncilbelievesthatthisstatementistrueandweareconductingouractivitiesinaresponsibleandprofessionalmanner.TheDRAFTstandardswereestablishedbyexpertconsensus,includingexpertsinadultlearning,evaluation,simulationandaccreditation.CommentsandinputintothedevelopmentofthestandardsweresolicitedattheannualmeetingandbypostingtheDRAFTstandardsonthewebsiteandsolicitingcommentsfromthepublic.ThestandardswereagainrevisedfollowingcompletionofPhaseI,byexpertconsensus,reviewofdatacollectedduringtheinitialphase,andfeedbackfromprogramswhoparticipated.Q3.5:Isthereacourseororientationwecantakebeforeapplying?A3.5:Atthistime,SSHdoesnothavesuchacourse.ItispossiblethatSSHwill

Page 22: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page22

developsuchaprograminthefuture. Q3.6:Howcantheorganizationusethestatementofaccreditation? A3.6:Basedonthepilotstudyfindings,theuseofthestatementofaccreditationwillbefurtherdefined,andaccreditedinstitutionsaswellasinterestedapplicantswillbeinformedofthepotentialuses.Q3.7:Whatisthedurationofaccreditation? A3.7:Threeyearswithannualself-studyreports. Q3.8:Ifmyprogramwasnotgrantedaccreditation,whencanwereapply?A3.8:AfteraperiodofoneyearfromBoardofReviewdecision Q3.9:WhatarethepossibleAccreditationdecisions? A3.10:“Accredited”or“NotAccredited.”Wewillorwillnotgrantaccreditation. Q3.11:Whatdothefeesinclude? A3.11:Thefeescoversurveyexpensesandallowforreinvestmentinthemissionofaccreditation.Inadditiontothestatedfees,theprogramisalsoresponsibleforreviewertravelexpenses.Q3.12:Isthereanappealprocessifmyprogramisdeniedaccreditation?A3.12:SSHhasdevelopedanappealprocessforprogramsthataredeniedaccreditation.Q3.13:CanIpayinEuros?A3.13:AlthoughSSHisaninternationalorganization,paymentsmayonlybemadeinUSdollarssincethebankutilizedbySSHresidesintheUnitedStates.4.REVIEWERS/SURVEYORS

Page 23: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page23

Q4.1:Concernwasexpressedthattheprocessofaccreditationwouldreward“insiders”. A4.1:TheCouncilunderstandsthatthisconcernisnotatypicalforanygroupbeginningaccreditationand/orcertificationprocesses.Itistheexpressintentofeveryoneinvolvedintheprocessthatparticipation,objectivity,transparencyanddueprocesswillbebuiltintoSSH’saccreditationpolicies.CouncilmembershaverecusedtheirassociatedinstitutionsfromapplyingforaccreditationduringthePilotPhase,butwillbeeligibleforaccreditationinfutureyears.Sitereviewersmustsignaconflictofinterestattestingthereisnorealorperceivedconflictwhenperforminganon-sitereview.Innocircumstancewillasitereviewerorcouncilmemberbeinvolvedinthereviewoftheirassociatedinstitution.5.OTHERACCREDITINGORGANIZATIONSQ5.1:HowdowereconcileaccreditationbySSHwiththatofotherbodies?A5.1:Whilespecialtyordomainspecificrequirementswillcontinuetovarybyspecialty,SimulationasaspecialtyistherecognizedexpertiseofSSH.TheuniquevalueofaccreditationbySSHistherecognitionofsimulationexpertiseasopposedtodomainexpertise.TheaccreditationofasimulationprogrambySSHofferstobothinterprofessionalcentersandparentinstitutionstheadvantagesofeconomyofscale,wherebythe“commondenominator”ofexcellenceinaccreditedsimulation-basedprocessescanprovideimportantlocalstatureandwell-deservedcredibility.SSHisopenlywillingtocooperateandcoordinatewithspecialtyorganizationsinfacilitatingaconjointfunctionofaccreditationprocesses,suchthatduplicationofeffortsisavoidedwherepossible.SSHviewsaccreditationbythisorganizationasuniquelyvaluable,andabenchmarktowhicheverysimulationcentershouldaspireformanyreasons,includingthefollowing:• Theintegrationofsimulationintohealthcaresystemsandprocessesisincreasingandwillprogressivelybecomepartofthetraining,assessment,research,andprocessimprovementinfrastructureofalldisciplines,althoughatvaryingtrajectories.Overtime,becausealldisciplineswillvaluetheimpactofsimulation-basedprocesses,therewillbeanaturaltendencytobothcoordinateanddictatesimulation-relatedprocessesaccordingtoeachdiscipline’sperceivedneeds.Thismay,infact,includeaccreditation,potentiallyemergingfromeverydistinctdiscipline.• Logistically,itmaybecomeunwieldyandexpensiveforanyonesimulationcentertodevotetherequiredenergiestoobtainingcertificationinmanydistinctdisciplinesthroughentirelydifferentpathways.Strategically,foranyparentinstitution,itmaybefinanciallystressfulandadministrativelyinefficienttoallow

Page 24: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page24

(orexpect)everydistinctdisciplinewithinitsspheretoacquireuniqueaccreditationstatus,disciplinebydiscipline.

Q5.2:Howdoweaddressthepotentialforaccreditationrequirementsthatconflictwithcurrentorfuturestandardsofotheraccreditingorganizations?ThefollowingcommentwasreceivedbytheAccreditationCouncil:“TheintroductiontotheSSHaccreditationstandardsstatesthataSimulationProgramisdefinedasan"organizationorgroupwithdedicatedresourceswhosemissionisspecificallytargetedtowardsimprovingpatientsafetyandoutcomesthroughassessment,research,advocacyandeducationusingsimulationtechnologiesandmethodologies"(referfirstpage,secondparagraph).TheCouncilonAccreditationofNurseAnesthesiaEducationalPrograms(COA)isconcernedifthisstatementmeansthatSSHwillspecificallyaccreditnurseanesthesiaprogramswithsimulationcentersandthatprogramsthatseekSSHaccreditationwillhavetomeetSSHeducationalrequirementsthatmayconflictwithCOArequirements.Whilethecurrentdraftstandardsareverygeneralthisalsoleavestherequirementsforcomplianceuptointerpretation.ItisalsoimportanttonotethatthestandardsaresubjecttofuturerevisionandmaybecomeproblematicifwhenrevisedtheyconflictwithCOArequirements.Tohelpaddresstheseconcernsa"SimulationProgram"needstobemoreclearlydefinedandastatementaddedthatdeferstheestablishmentofaspecializededucationalprograms'educationalrequirementstothespecializedaccreditingorganizationsuchastheCouncilonAccreditationofNurseAnesthesiaEducationalPrograms(COA)thatisrecognizedbytheU.S.DepartmentofEducation(USDE)andtheCouncilforHigherEducationAccreditation(CHEA)toaccreditnurseanesthesiaeducationalprograms.”A5.2:TheAccreditationCouncilbelievesthataccreditationbySSHprovidesauniquevalue(seeFAQ).Wedonotforeseeaconflictwiththestandardsofotherspecialtyaccreditingorganizations.Q5.3:AccreditationoftheSSHaccreditationprocess? A5.3:Webelieveitisappropriatetoseekrecognitionasanaccreditingorganization.

Page 25: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page25

GlossaryofTermsforSSHAccreditation1. Accreditation–aprocesswherebyaprofessionalorganizationgrants

recognitiontoasimulationprogramfordemonstratedabilitytomeetpre-determinedcriteriaforestablishedstandards.

2. AccreditationCycle–theperiodfromprogramapplicationforaccreditationto

notificationofaccreditationstatus.Thisperiodincludes:reviewofinitialapplication,notificationofselectionforon-sitereview,on-sitereviewbySSH-SARTteam,BoardofReviewdeliberation,andnotificationoffinaldecisiontoprogram.TherewillbeoneAccreditationcycleperyear.

3. ART-S–acronymforAssessment,Research,Teaching/Education,andSystem

Integrationstandards.a. Assessment–Recognitionofprogramscreating,validating(beyond

faceandcontentvalidity),and/orperformingstandardsofhumanperformanceassessment.

b. Research–Recognitionofprogramsactivelyinvolvedindatagathering,analysis,anddisseminationofknowledgeforadvancingthescienceofsimulation.

c. Teaching/Education–Recognitionofprogramsforregular,recurringactivitieswithdefinedcurriculaandongoingvalidationthatemployssimulationmethodologiesappropriateforlearningobjectivestoinstruct,teach,ortrainparticipantsforformativeintegrationofcognitive,procedural,andattitudinalgoals.Theprogramwillbeabletodemonstrateeffectivenessoftheircurriculum.

d. SystemsIntegration–Recognitionofprogramswhodemonstrateconsistent,planned,collaborative,integrated,anditerativeapplicationofsimulation-basedassessment,research,andteachingactivitieswithsystemsengineeringandriskmanagementprinciplestoachieveexcellentbedsideclinicalcare,enhancedpatientsafety,andimprovedoutcomemetricsacrossthehealthcaresystem(s).

4. Assessor–apersonwhoperformsstandardsofhumanperformanceassessment.Assessorsmusthavespecificandsubstantialtraining,expertise,anddemonstratedcompetencyintheartandscienceofhumanassessment.

Page 26: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page26

5. Bestpractice–anideathatassertsthatthereisatechnique,method,process,

activity,incentive,orrewardthatismoreeffectiveatdeliveringaparticularoutcomethananyothertechnique,method,process,etc.Theideaisthatwithproperprocesses,checks,andtesting,adesiredoutcomecanbedeliveredwithfewerproblemsandunforeseencomplications.Bestpracticescanalsobedefinedasthemostefficient(leastamountofeffort)andeffective(bestresults)wayofaccomplishingatask,basedonrepeatableproceduresthathaveproventhemselvesovertimeforlargenumbersofpeople.

6. Biosketch–abriefsummaryofone’sprofessional/educationaccomplishments,

publications,andaffiliations.Abiosketchisanabbreviatedcurriculumvitaemeanttohighlightimportantaspectsoftraining,education,experience,andprofessionalinterest.

7. Certification–theprocessthroughwhichanorganizationgrantstoan

individualwhomeetscertainestablishedcriteriaandeligibilityrequirements.Certificationisavoluntaryprocess.

8. Complaint–acomplaint,asdefinedforthepurposesofaccreditation,isany

writtenorverbalcomplaintrelated(butnotlimited)tocoursedelivery,educatorconduct,programmanagement,roomdesign/comfort,andlearnertolearnermisconduct.Acomplaintcanbemadebyanypersonassociatedwiththesimulationprogramincludinglearners,educators,assessors,andtechnicalspecialists.

9. ComplaintResolutionProcess(forprograms)–aformalprocessdesignedto

maintainopencommunicationbetweenallmembersandlearnersofasimulationprogram.Theexpressionofsatisfactionordissatisfactionisanimportantopportunitytoimprovequalityofaprogram.Acomplaintresolutionprocessmustincludetheprocedureforinvestigatingcomplaints,managingcomplaints,providingfeedback,andimplementationofmeasuresforimprovement.

10. Compliance–describesthegoalthatprogramsseektomeetormaintainthe

standardsandpoliciessetforthbytheCouncilforAccreditationofHealthcareSimulationPrograms.

11. ConfidentialityProcedure(Learnerspecific)–aprocedurethatmaintainsthe

confidentialityoflearnerswhileengagedinasimulation-relatedactivity.Theproceduremustaddressprocedurestopreventthedisclosureofinformationrelatedtolearnerperformancetounauthorizedindividualsorsystems.

12. ContentExpert–awell-establishedindividualwithsubstantiveexpertiseinthe

relatedtopicareaandservesasaconsultant.

Page 27: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page27

13. CoreInstructors/Educators/Staff/Faculty–thoseindividualsthatare

intricatelyandroutinelyinvolvedinthesimulationeducationcurriculumandthatareresponsibleforthecontent,implementation,andevaluationofthecurriculum.

14. CoreStandards–thefundamentaloperationalstandardsthatunderpinthe

successofaProgram.Therearestandardsassociatedwithfive(5)elementsthatallProgramsmustmeetregardlessofthespecificareainwhichtheyareapplyingforaccreditation.TheCoreStandardsare:(1)Mission&Governance,(2)Organization&Management,(3)Facilities,Technology,SimulationModalities,andHumanResources(4)Evaluation&Improvement,(5)Integrity,(6)Security,and(7)ExpandingtheField

15. Course–adesignedactivityinvolvingtheuseofsimulationthathasbeen

developedusingsimulationmethodologywithidentifiablegoals,objectives,andoutcomes.

16. Curriculum–acompleteprogramoflearningrelatedtosimulationthatincludes

identified/desiredresults,adesignforincorporationofsimulationintoeducationalactivities,andsuggestedmethodsofassessmentforevaluation.

17. CurriculumVitae(CV)–awrittendescriptionofone’sworkexperience,

educationbackground,professional/organizationalaffiliations,andprofessionalaccomplishments.ACVismorecomprehensiveanddetailedthanatraditionalresume.

18. Debriefing–aformal,reflectivestageinthesimulationlearningprocess.

Debriefingisaprocesswherebyeducatorsandlearnersre-examinethesimulationexperienceandfostersthedevelopmentofclinicaljudgmentandcriticalthinkingskills.Itisdesignedtoguidelearnersthroughareflectiveprocessabouttheirlearning.

19. Deliberation–TheCouncilforAccreditationofHealthcareSimulationPrograms

willassessapplicationsforcompliancewiththeAccreditationStandards.Thisprocesswillincludeareviewoftheapplicationassubmittedaswellasthefindingsfromthereviewteams.TheAccreditationReviewersandBoardofReviewwillmeetinclosedsessiontoreviewapplications.

20. Educator–aspecialistinthetheoryandpracticeofsimulationeducationwho

hastheresponsibilityfordeveloping,managing,and/orimplementingeducationalactivities.

21. EligibleforAccreditation–Tobeeligibleforaccreditation,programsmustbe

inexistenceforatleast2yearsoverallandatleast2yearsforeachareafor

Page 28: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page28

whichaccreditationisrequested.Inaddition,programsmustdemonstratethattheymeetthecorestandardsofaccreditation.

22. Evidence-based–Educationalmaterialsormethodsthathavebeenproven

throughrigorousevaluationandresearchwillbeintegratedintoaccreditationstandardsandconsultationasdeemedappropriateandgenerallyapplicablebytheCouncilforAccreditationofHealthcareSimulationPrograms.

23. ExperientialLearning–theprocessoflearningthroughdirectexperience.

Experientiallearninginvolvesthelearneractivelyparticipatingintheexperience,learnerreflectionontheexperience,useofanalyticalskillstoconceptualizetheexperience,andtheuseofdecision-makingandproblem-solvingskillstogainnewideasfromtheexperience.

24. Facilitator–anindividualthathelpsbringaboutanoutcomebyproviding

indirectassistance,guidanceorsupervision25. Formativeassessment–aprocessfordeterminingthecompetenceofaperson

engagedinahealthcareactivityforthepurposeofprovidingconstructivefeedbackforthatpersontoimprove.

26. Governance-Governanceencompassestheresponsibilityforsecuringthelong

termsustainabilityofthesimulationprogram;assuringthatitfulfillsitsobligationstoitsconstituentsandthatitismeetingitsdesiredmissionandvision.Governancealsoincludessupportingtheprioritiesandstrategicdirectionofthesimulationprogram.

27. HighStakesAssessment-Ahigh-stakesassessmentisonehavingimportant

consequencesforthetesttaker,andservesasthebasisofamajordecision.Passingisassociatedwithimportantbenefits,suchassatisfactionofalicensureand/orcertificationrequirement,ormeetingacontingencyforemployment.Failingtoohasimportantconsequences,suchasbeingrequiredtotakeremedialclassesuntiltheassessmentcanbepassed,orbeingbannedfrompracticewithinacertaindisciplineordomain.Thus,highstakesassessmentisonethat:●isasingle,definedassessment(perhapswithcomponentsubunits)●hascleardistinctionbetweenthosewhopassandthosewhofail●hasdirectconsequencesforpassingorfailing(something"atstake").

28. HybridSimulationMethodologies–theuseofacombinationoftypesofsimulationthatintegratestheuseofsimulatorsandstandardizedhumanpatientsimulatorsinasimulationevent.

29. Integrity–aprogramisconsideredtohaveintegrityifitisconsistentinits

mission,actions,values,methods,measures,principles,expectations,andoutcomes.

Page 29: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page29

30. Interprofessional–whenstudentsfromtwoormoredifferentprofessions

learnfromandabouteachothertoimprovecollaborationandthequalityofcare.Althoughthistermmaybeassociatedwithmulti-disciplinaryandmulti-specialtylearning;interprofessional,forthepurposesofthisdocument,isdistinguishedfrommultidisciplinary(theactofjoiningtwoormoredisciplineswithoutintegration)andinterdisciplinary(connectingandintegratingschoolsofprofessionswiththeirspecificperspectives,tocompleteatask).

31. LearnerContactHour–aunitofmeasurementthatdescribesoneperson

participatingfor60minutesinanorganizedlearningactivitythatiseitherdidacticorclinicalexperiencerelatedtosimulation

32. Medical/Clinical/ProgramDirector–anindividualwhooverseesthedaily

operationofasimulationprogram.Thismayincludethedevelopment,implementation,andassessmentofthesimulationprogram.Thedirectoroverseesthepersonnel,budgetary,andregulatoryconcernsandisaccountablefortheoveralladministrationoftheprogram.

33. Moulage–theartofapplyingmockinjuriesormanifestationsofabnormal

medicationconditionstoincreasetheperceivedrealismofasimulation.34. Program–WhileSSHunderstandsthedifferenceinterminologyfrom

organizationtoorganization;forthepurposesofthisdocument,anysimulationcenterorserviceisreferredtoasa“program”.Thisrequiresutilizationofsimulationforhealthcareeducation,assessmentand/orresearchwithdedicatedpersonnelanddefinedsimulationcurriculum.Seesimulationprograminhealthcare

35. Realism–theabilitytoimpartthesuspensionofdisbelieftothelearnerby

creatinganenvironmentthatmimicsthatofthelearner’sworkenvironment.Realismincludestheenvironment,simulatedpatient,andactivitiesoftheeducators,assessors,and/orfacilitators.

36. ResearchExpertise–whenanindividualdemonstratesextensiveknowledgein

simulationthroughresearchasevidencedbymultiplepublicationsofrigorousstudiesutilizingsimulation.

37. Simulation–atechniquethatusesasituationorenvironmentcreatedtoallow

personstoexperiencearepresentationofarealeventforthepurposeofpractice,learning,evaluation,testing,ortogainunderstandingofsystemsorhumanactions.Simulationistheapplicationofasimulatortotrainingand/orassessment.

Page 30: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page30

38. SimulationCenter–entitywithdedicatedinfrastructureandpersonnelwheresimulationcoursesareconducted.AcentermaysupportseveralSimulationPrograms.

39. SimulationExpert(Educator)–anindividualwhohasdemonstratedexpertise

insimulationeducation,curriculumdesign,implementation,andevaluationthroughyearsofexperience.

40. SimulationExpertise–anindividualwhoisregardedinthecommunityasan

expertinsimulationthroughyearsofexperienceorresearchexpertiseandoftenactsasaconsultantormentorforotherindividualsinthecommunity

41. SimulationFidelity–thephysical,contextual,cognitive,andemotionalrealism

thatallowspersonstoexperienceasimulationasiftheywereoperatinginanactualactivity.

42. SimulationGuideline–arecommendationofthequalitiesforsimulation

fidelity,simulationvalidity,simulationprogram,orforformativeorsummativeevaluation.

43. SimulationPrograminHealthcare–anorganizationorgroupwithdedicated

resourceswhosemissionisspecificallytargetedtowardsimprovingpatientsafetyandoutcomesthroughassessment,research,advocacy,andeducationusingsimulationtechnologiesandmethodologiesincludingformalworkshops,courses,classes,orotheractivitythatusesasubstantialcomponentofsimulationasatechnique.Aformalsworkshop,course,class,orotheractivitythatusesasubstantialcomponentofsimulationasatechnique.

44. SimulationStandard–astatementoftheminimumrequirementsfor

simulationfidelity,simulationvalidity,simulationprogram,orforformativeorsummativeevaluation.

45. SimulationValidity–thequalityofasimulationorsimulationprogramthat

demonstratesthattherelationshipbetweentheprocessanditsintendedpurposeisspecific,sensitive,reliable,andreproducible.

46. Simulator–anyobjectorrepresentationusedduringtrainingorassessment

whichbehavesoroperateslikeagivensystemandrespondstotheuser’sactions.

47. SSH-SART–SocietyforSimulationinHealthcareSimulationAccreditation

ReviewTeam.EachsitebeingsurveyedforaccreditationshallundergoasurveyprocessunderthereviewofaSSH-SARTgroup.

Page 31: SSH Accreditation Informational Guide Accreditation Process 2017.pdfSSH promotes improvements in simulation technology, educational methods, practitioner assessment, and patient safety

Copyright©2017bySocietyforSimulationinHealthcareMaynotbeused,altered,ordisseminatedwithoutexpresswrittenpermissionfromSSH Page31

48. SubstantialProgramChange–ASubstantialprogramchangeisonethataffectsthemission/vision,structure,organizationalleadership,functionality,policies/procedures,and/ortheorganizationalchart(s)oftheProgram.AllsubstantialprogramchangesshouldbereporttotheManagerofAccreditation.

49. Standardized(Human)PatientSimulation–simulationusingapersonor

personstrainedtoportrayapatientscenario,oractualpatient(s)forhealthcareeducationinbothskillsandcommunicationandhealthcareassessment.

50. StandardizedPatient–anindividualwhoistrainedtoactasarealpatientin

ordertosimulateasetofsymptomsorproblemsusedforhealthcareeducation,evaluation,andresearch.

51. SteeringCommittee–acommitteecomposedofhigh-levelstakeholderswho

provideguidanceonkeyissues,marketingstrategies,resourceallocationandoverallprogrampoliciesandobjectives.

52. StrategicPlan–theprocessofcomprehensive,integrativeprogramplanning

thatconsidersthefutureofcurrentdecisions,overallpolicy,program/organizationdevelopmentandlinkstooperationalplans.Theprocessshouldalignwithandallowtheprogramtofulfillitsmissionandachieveitsvision.

53. SummativeEvaluation–aprocessfordeterminingthecompetenceofaperson

engagedinahealthcareactivityforthepurposeofcertifyingwithreasonablecertaintythattheyareabletoperformthatactivityinpractice.

54. SystemsEngineering–aninterdisciplinaryfieldofengineeringfocusingon

howcomplexprojectsshouldbedesignedandmanaged.Logistics,coordinationofdifferentteams,modeling,automaticcontrolofmachinery,andhumanfactorsbecomemorechallengingwhendealingwithcomplexandhigh-stakeshealthcareprovision.Thisfielddevelopsandassesseswork-processesandtools(includingsimulation)tohandlesuchprojects,andoverlapswithbothtechnicalandhuman-centereddisciplines.

55. Task-Trainer–trainingmodelsutilizedtoteachorpracticeaspecificskill.

Examplesincludeintravenouslinearms,intra-osseouslinelegs,intubationheads,andcentralvenouslinechests.

56. TechnicalSpecialist–anindividualwhoprovidestechnologicalexpertiseand

instructionalsupportforasimulationprogram.Thisincludes,butisnotlimitedto,dailyoperationsofthesimulationlab,maintenanceofequipment,managementoflabsupplies,managementofsimulators,programresponsibilityofsimulators,andcollaborationwithfacultyandstaff.