Spooky Business - corporate espionage against non profit organizations

8/22/2019 Spooky Business - corporate espionage against non profit organizations

1/54

!"##$% '()*+,))!-#."#./0, 1)"*#+/2, 32/*+)04#+".#5*0 6.2/+*7/0*#+)

'% 8/.% 9()$*+

1)),+0*/: ;+5#.6 '#? @ABCD

E/)F*+20#+G H- ICCJKLICIM JNOPNCJC

4#Q,


2/54

1

!"#$% '( )'*!%*!+

%,%)-!./% +-00"12 3

.*!1'4-)!.'* 5

SF, R./Q, +,T T#.:U #5 V#."#./0, ,)"*#+/2, D

SF, .*), #5 V#."#./0, ,)"*#+/2, /2/*+)0 +#+".#5*0 #.2/+*7/0*#+) K

*"11"!./%+ '( )'16'1"!% %+6.'*"7% 8

',V$,00 '.#T+ ;+0,.+/0*#+/: Q)> /7&+EE='2?/(2+'31 =:/+, !0("*U JC

'.#T+ [ E*::*/


3/54

2

!F,::X'=X\/+5.,U !VF:*V$,+.*,U,.XY/$:(%0 Q)> 8.,,+",/V, J@

\VH#+/:Uc) Q)> _#+U#+ 8.,,+",/V, J@

!0./05#. JI&+?/S&+7/ /'- .()/(*+) D3; (++/


4/54

3

!"#$ &'()*$+ ,- .#/. 0(1 2( .#,34- ,3 .#$ -$'5,6$ (7 0(1' 6(13.'0 .#/. /'$ 81-. 3(. /&&'(&',/.$

.( 2( ,3 .#$ &',5/.$ -$6.('9:8

SS X+$' R)%''/'1 -2)%?(+) +* ($% &%'()/7 @'(%772J%'?% 6J%'?0

%BCDEFGHC +EIIJKL

#$23 )%B+)( 23 /' %**+)( (+ -+?=E%'( 3+E%($2'J K% I'+K 72((7% />+=(! ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J%/J/2'3( '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3; #$% %'(2)% 3=>N%?( 23 D%27%- 2' 3%?)%?0; @' )%?%'( 0%/)31($%)% $/D% >%%' *%K 3%)2+=3 N+=)'/723(2? %**+)(3 Z /'- '+ 3%)2+=3 J+D%)'E%'( %**+)(3 SS (+?+E% (+ (%)E3 K2($ ($% )%/72(0 +* ?+)B+)/(% 3B02'J /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2(3;

G=?$ +* K$/( K% 2(I'+K />+=( ($23 3=>N%?( $/3 >%%' ='?+D%)%- >0 /??2-%'(; .+ ($%B2?(=)% K% $/D% 23 *)/JE%'(/)0 /( >%3(! N=3( / *%K 3'/B3$+(31 (/I%' E+3(70 /( )/'-+E1/)232'J *)+E >)2772/'( 3()+I%3 +* 7=?I1 J2D2'J / E%)% 2'I72'J +* ($% *=77 )/'J% +* %3B2+'/J%/?(2D2(0 /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2(3;

#$%)% /)%1 $+K%D%)1 / *%K ($2'J3 K% ?/' 3/0 *+) ?%)(/2';

#$% ?+)B+)/(% ?/B/?2(0 *+) %3B2+'/J% $/3 3I0)+?I%(%- 2' )%?%'( 0%/)3; G+3( E/N+)?+EB/'2%3 '+K $/D% / ?$2%* ?+)B+)/(% 3%?=)2(0 +**2?%) (/3I%- K2($ /33%332'J /'- E2(2J/(2'J[($)%/(3\ +* /77 3+)(3 Z 2'?7=-2'J *)+E '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3; 6'- ($%)% 23 '+K / 3=)*%2( +*B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 *2)E3 K2772'J /'- />7% (+ ?+'-=?( 3+B$23(2?/(%- 3B02'J +B%)/(2+'3/J/2'3( '+'B)+*2(3;

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

G/'0 +* ($% K+)7-]3 7/)J%3( ?+)B+)/(2+'3 /'- ($%2) ()/-% /33+?2/(2+'3 SS 2'?7=-2'J ($% :;.;&$/E>%) +* &+EE%)?%1 H/7E/)(1 G+'3/'(+1 R/'I +* 6E%)2?/1 U+K &$%E2?/71 ^)/*(1 &+?/S&+7/1 &$%D)+'1 R=)J%) ^2'J1 G?U+'/7-]31 .$%771 R


5/54

4

G/'0 -2**%)%'( (0B%3 +* '+'B)+*2(3 $/D% >%%' (/)J%(%- K2($ %3B2+'/J%1 2'?7=-2'J%'D2)+'E%'(/71 /'(2SK/)1 B=>72? 2'(%)%3(1 ?+'3=E%)1 *++- 3/*%(01 B%3(2?2-% )%*+)E1 '=)32'J$+E% )%*+)E1 J=' ?+'()+71 3+?2/7 N=3(2?%1 /'2E/7 )2J$(3 /'- /)E3 ?+'()+7 J)+=B3;

&+)B+)/(2+'3 $/D% >%%' 72'I%- (+ / K2-% D/)2%(0 +* %3B2+'/J% (/?(2?3; #$% E+3( B)%D/7%'(

(/?(2? /BB%/)3 (+ >% 2'*27()/(2+' >0 B+32'J / D+7='(%%) +) N+=)'/723(1 (+ +>(/2' 2'*+)E/(2+'*)+E / '+'B)+*2(; R=( ?+)B+)/(2+'3 $/D% >%%' 72'I%- (+ E/'0 +($%) $=E/'1 B$032?/7 /'-%7%?()+'2? %3B2+'/J% (/?(2?3 /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2(3; G/'0 +* ($%3% (/?(2?3 /)% %2($%) $2J$70='%($2?/7 +) 277%J/7;

&+)B+)/(2+'3 %'J/J% 2' %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2(3 K2($ '%/) 2EB='2(0; #0B2?/7701 ($%03=**%) '+($2'J E+)% ($/' E2'+) /-D%)3% E%-2/ ?+D%)/J% 2* ($%2) %3B2+'/J% 23 %VB+3%-; #$%7/?I +* /??+='(/>272(0 E/0 %'?+=)/J% +($%) ?+)B+)/(2+'3 (+ ?+'-=?( %3B2+'/J%;

&+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3 B)%3%'(3 / ($)%/( (+ -%E+?)/?0 /'- (+2'-2D2-=/7 B)2D/?0; U%E+?)/?0 ?/''+( *='?(2+' K2($+=( /' %**%?(2D% ?2D27 3+?2%(0; R=( ?2D27

3+?2%(0 /'- 2(3 '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3 -%B%'- ?)=?2/770 +' ($%2) />272(0 (+ I%%B 3+E% 2-%/312'*+)E/(2+'1 /'- ?+'D%)3/(2+'3 B)2D/(%;

@'-2D2-=/7 ?2(2Y%'3 /'- J)+=B3 -+ '+( 7+3% ($%2) )2J$( (+ B)2D/?0 E%)%70 >%?/=3% ($%0-23/J)%% K2($ ($% /?(2D2(2%3 +) 2-%/3 +* / ?+)B+)/(2+'; #$% )2J$( (+ B)2D/?0 -+D%(/273 K2($+=) ,2)3( 6E%'-E%'( )2J$(3 (+ 3B%%?$1 B=>72? -%>/(%1 /'- *=77 B/)(2?2B/(2+' 2' ($%[E/)I%(B7/?% +* 2-%/3;\ @( 23 %3B%?2/770 ='N=3( ($/( ?+)B+)/(2+'3 3/>+(/J% 6E%)2?/'3]*='-/E%'(/7 )2J$(3 ($)+=J$ /?(2+'3 ($/( /)% ='%($2?/7 +) 277%J/7;

G/'0 ($2'J3 ?/' >% -+'% (+ B)+(%?( '+'B)+*2(3 *)+E ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J%; &+'J)%33 3$+=7-2'D%3(2J/(% /'- $+7- $%/)2'J3 +' ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2(3; &+'J)%33 /'-

3(/(% 7%J237/(=)%3 3$+=7- %'/?( 7%J237/(2+' (+ ?)2E2'/72Y% ($% ($%*( +* ?+'*2-%'(2/71'+'%?+'+E2? 2'*+)E/(2+' $%7- >0 ($%2) ?)2(2?3; M/K %'*+)?%E%'( Z %3B%?2/770 ($% :;.;U%B/)(E%'( +* X=3(2?% Z 3$+=7- B)2+)2(2Y% 2'D%3(2J/(2'J /'- B)+3%?=(2'J ?+)B+)/(%%3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2(3;


6/54

5

.MFKNOEDFGNM

!PC QKJHC MCR RNKSO NT DNKUNKJFC CVUGNMJWC

@' ($% :'2(%- .(/(%31 ?+)B+)/(2+'3 $/D% $2)%- B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(+)3 32'?% ($% ?+7+)*=7 /'-

%'(%)B)232'J 677/' %'2J' 3(/)(;=32'%33 K/3 (/I%' +D%) >0 $23 3+'31 K$+ $/- 2-%/3 +* ($%2) +K'; #$%0 ='-%)(++I?+'()+D%)32/7 K+)I1 3=?$ /3 /'(2S='2+' /'- 3()2I%S>)%/I2'J +B%)/(2+'3; #$=3 >%J/' ($%7+'J )23% +* ($% ?+)B+)/(% 3B0S*+)S$2)%1 /'- ($% %**+)( (+ ?+='(%)/?( ($+3% K$+ -/)%- (+2EB/2) ($% B)+*2(3 +* ?+)B+)/(% 6E%)2?/;

#+-/01 E+3( 7/)J% ?+)B+)/(2+'3 B+33%33 ($%2) +K' 2'(%)'/7 2'(%772J%'?% ?/B/>272(2%3; #$%)%23 /' 2'3(2(=(2+'/72Y%- 3%?=)2(0 /'- 2'(%772J%'?% *='?(2+' K2($2' %D%)0 E/N+) ?+EB/'0 Z /?$2%* 3%?=)2(0 +**2?%) +* 3+E% 3+)(; #$%0 B%)*+)E [($)%/( /33%33E%'(3\ +* /77 I2'-31

2'?7=-2'J ($% B+(%'(2/7 2EB/?( +* '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3;

.+E% +* ($%2) 3(/** +) ?+'()/?(+)3 /)% *+)E%) %EB7+0%%3 +* ($% C/(2+'/7 .%?=)2(0 6J%'?01&%'()/7 @'(%772J%'?% 6J%'?01 .%?)%( .%)D2?% /'- +($%) 2'(%772J%'?% +) 7/K %'*+)?%E%'(/J%'?2%31 ($% E272(/)01 +) 7+?/7 B+72?%; .+E% +* ($%E $/D% 3B%'( -%?/-%3 2' 2'(%772J%'?%K+)I; 6 *%K J2/'( ?+)B+)/(2+'31 3=?$ /3 H/7E/)(1 $/D% %33%'(2/770 )%B72?/(%- 2' E2'2/(=)%/' %'(2)% &@6 -2)%?(+)/(% +* 2'(%772J%'?% Z *+) ($%2) +K' B)2D/(% =3%;

&+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% 23 '+K ?+EE+'B7/?%; b%)%]3 $+K ($% .6C. @'3(2(=(%1 / 7/)J%?0>%)3%?=)2(0 %-=?/(2+' B)+D2-%)1 %VB7/2'3 2(! [#$% 2'?)%/32'J $2J$ 3(/I%3 J/E% +*?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% 23 >%2'J B7/0%- >0 2'-2D2-=/731 ?+)B+)/(2+'3 /'- ?+='()2%3 K+)7-K2-%;

#$%3% B7/0%)3 K277 =3% /'0 %($2?/71 /'- 2' E+3( ?/3%31 /'0 ='%($2?/71 E%/'3 (+ /?e=2)% -/(/($/( K277 J2D% ($%E / ?+EB%(2(2D% +) *2'/'?2/7 /-D/'(/J% +D%) ($%2) ?+EB%(2(2+';\T P%(%)/')%B+)(%) 4/E+' X/D%)3 E/I%3 / 32E27/) B+2'(; [#$%)% 23 3+ E=?$ E+'%0 /( 3(/I%1\ X/D%)33/031 [($/( %D%)0+'% 23 3B02'J +' %D%)0>+-0 %73%; H% 72D% 2' /' 2'*+)E/(2+' /J% K$%)% -/(/23 E+'%0; @* 0+= J%( E+)% -/(/ ($/' ($% '%V( J=01 0+= $/D% ($% %-J%;\9

.2'?% ($% %'- +* ($% &+7- H/)1 ($%)% $/3 /73+ >%%' / 7/)J% 2'?)%/3% 2' ($% '=E>%) +* B)2D/(%2'D%3(2J/(2D% /'- 2'(%772J%'?% *2)E3 Z 3(/**%- K2($ *+)E%) J+D%)'E%'( %EB7+0%%3 Z -+2'J%3B2+'/J% K+)I 7/)J%70 ='?$%?I%- >0 7/K %'*+)?%E%'(; 63 6''2% G/?$+'1 / *+)E%) :^3%?=)2(0 /J%'?0 G@L /J%'(1 (+7- ($% A$? @./.$-+/3[#$% >2J ?$/'J% 2' )%?%'( 0%/)3 $/3>%%' ($% $=J% J)+K($ 2' ($%3% h3%?=)2(0i ?+EB/'2%3j;H$%)% >%*+)% 2( K/3 / $/'-*=7 +*B)2D/(% -%(%?(2D% /J%'?2%31 '+K ($%)% /)% $='-)%-3 +* E=7(2'/(2+'/7 3%?=)2(0 +)J/'2Y/(2+'31K$2?$ +B%)/(% K2($ 7%33 )%J=7/(2+' ($/' ($% 3B++I3 ($%E3%7D%3;\g

T.$/'% H; A+>2'3+'1 [&+)B+)/(% 43B2+'/J% Tc8;\ .6C. @'3(2(=(%1 TccQ;9X=-2($ H++-31 [.B2%31 M2%3 S /'- /


7/54

6

4/E+' X/D%)3 $/3 )%B+)(%- +' ($% 3$/-0 %($2?3 +* ($% ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% 2'-=3()0; [63+'% %VB%)2%'?%- 2'-=3()0 +B%)/(2D% (+7- E%1 kH%])% N=3( +'% 3?/'-/7 /K/0 *)+E /J+D%)'E%'( ?)/?I-+K';\ H2($ 3+ E=?$ ='3/D+)0 ?+'-=?( (/I2'J B7/?%1 ($% 2'-=3()0 3%%E372I%70 (+ %VB7+-% 2'(+ B=>72? D2%K;

,+)E%) &@6 -2D232+' ?$2%* G%7D2' 5++-E/' $/3 32E27/) ?+'?%)'3 />+=( ($%3% B)2D/(%2'(%772J%'?% *2)E3; [4D%)0($2'J 23 >%2'J /(()/?(%- (+ ($%3% B)2D/(% ?+EB/'2%3 2' (%)E3 +*2'-2D2-=/73 /'- %VB%)(23% /'- *='?(2+'3 ($/( K%)% '+)E/770 -+'% >0 ($% 2'(%772J%'?%?+EE='2(01\ $% 3/03; [G0 E/N+) ?+'?%)' 23 ($% 7/?I +* /??+='(/>272(01 ($% 7/?I +*)%3B+'32>272(0; #$% %'(2)% 2'-=3()0 23 %33%'(2/770 +=( +* ?+'()+7; @(l3 +=()/J%+=3;mL

.+E% +* ($23 7/?I +* /??+='(/>272(0 /'- )%7/(2D% 2EB='2(0 E/0 -%)2D% *)+E ?+$%32D% [+7- >+0'%(K+)I3\ K2($2' *+)E%) 2'(%772J%'?%1 7/K %'*+)?%E%'( /'- E272(/)0 ?2)?7%3; .=?$?/E/)/-%)2% 23 '+( 3=)B)232'J; #$% &@6]3 [+7- >+0 '%(K+)I\ 23 7%J%'-/)0; A%J/)-2'J ($%,R@1 4/E+' X/D%)3 -%3?)2>%3 / 72((7%SI'+K' B=>72?/(2+'1 ($% "'/&*,3$1 K$2?$ [723(3 %D%)0

)%(2)%- ,R@ /J%'( 2' ($% ?+='()0 K$+ K+)I3 2' ($% B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 >=32'%33;\ X/D%)3-%3?)2>%3 ($% "'/&*,3$/3 [/ >2( 72I% /' 2'3(2(=(2+'/72Y%- +7-S>+0 '%(K+)I *+) )%(2)%- 5SE%';\O

!PC KGVC NT DNKUNKJFC CVUGNMJWC JWJGMVF MNMUKNTGF NKWJMGXJFGNMV

#$)+=J$+=( ($% (K%'(0S*2)3( ?%'(=)01 '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3 /'- /?(2D23(3 $/D% >%%'(/)J%(3 +* ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J%; R=( K% -+']( I'+K %V/?(70 $+K E/'0; M2((7% 23 B=>72?70I'+K' />+=( 3=?$ %3B2+'/J%1 >%?/=3% ($% B%)B%()/(+)3 3()2D% E2J$(270 (+ I%%B ($%2)+B%)/(2+'3 3%?)%(; 63 +'% 3%?=)2(0 N+=)'/7 +>3%)D%31 [E+3( ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% ?/3%3 '%D%)

?+E% (+ 72J$(;\Q#$% %'(2)% 3=>N%?( )%E/2'3 E=)I0 /( >%3(;f

#$23 )%B+)( 23 /' %**+)( (+ -+?=E%'( K$/( K% -+ I'+K1 %D%' ($+=J$ ($% -%(/273 2' %/?$ ?/3%/)% */) *)+E ?+EB7%(%; G=?$ +* K$/( K% I'+K $/3 >%%' ='?+D%)%- D2/ 2EB)+>/>7% 3()+I%3+* J++- *+)(='%1 3=?$ /3 K$23(7%>7+K%)3 K2($2' B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 *2)E31 7%/I%--+?=E%'(3 +) >2Y/))% ?+2'?2-%'?%3; #$/( 3=JJ%3(3 ($/( K$/( K% -+ I'+K 23 E%)%70 ($%B)+D%)>2/7 (2B +* ($% 2?%>%)J;

G/'0 */?(+)3 $/D% ?+'()2>=(%- (+ ($% )23% +* ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2(3 /'-K$23(7%>7+K%)31 3=?$ /3 ($% )232'J /D/27/>272(0 +* *+)E%) &@61 C.6 /'- +($%) E272(/)01

LX%)%E0 .?/$2771 [R7/?IK/(%)]3 /?0$'= @&0; `C%K a+)I! b/)B%)&+772'31 Tc8cd1 BB; 88TS9;

Q[b+K A%/7 @3 ($% A23I +* &+)B+)/(% 43B2+'/J% #+-/0n\ @$61',.0 B,'$6.('C- D$&('.1 @'3(2(=(%+* G/'/J%E%'( _ 6-E2'23()/(2+'1 6B)27 Tcco;f#K+ )%?%'( >++I3 /)% 277=E2'/(2'J! 4D%72'% M=>>%)31 @$6'$. E/3($15'$- ,3 .#$ B/'


8/54

7

2'(%772J%'?% /'- 7/K %'*+)?%E%'( +**2?2/73p ($% +=(3+=)?2'J +* J+D%)'E%'( 2'(%772J%'?%+B%)/(2+'3 (+ B)2D/(% 2'(%772J%'?% *2)E3p ($% 3B)%/- +* 3=)D%277/'?% (%?$'2e=%3 J%'%)/770p($% )232'J B+K%) /'- 3+B$23(2?/(2+' +* %7%?()+'2? 3=)D%277/'?%p ($% ?+'(2'=%- J)+K($ +*?+)B+)/(% B+K%) 2' ($% :'2(%- .(/(%3p ($% B/=?2(0 +* 7/K %'*+)?%E%'( )%3+=)?%3 3B%'( +'B)+(%?(2'J '+'B)+*2(3p /'- ($% */27=)% (+ B='23$ ?+)B+)/(2+'3 /'- ($%2) B)2D/(% 2'(%772J%'?%

*2)E3 *+) ='%($2?/7 +) 277%J/7 %3B2+'/J%;

,+) E/'0 ?+EB/'2%31 ($% 2'(/'J2>7% D/7=% +* ($%2) >)/'- 23 / B)%?2+=3 /33%(; ,+) ($23)%/3+'1 E/'0 ?+EB/'2%3 E/0 D2%K '+'B)+*2(3 /'- K$23(7%>7+K%)3 /3 B+(%'( /'-='B)%-2?(/>7% /-D%)3/)2%31 /'- K/'( (+ I'+K %D%)0($2'J ($%0 ?/' />+=( ($%E; &+EB/'2%3(/I% [>)/'- )23I\ 3%)2+=3701 K$2?$ /73+ 7%/-3 ($%E (+ +=(3+=)?% ($%2) %**+)(3 (+ (/)J%('+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'31 ($=3 )%-=?2'J ($% >)/'- )23I +* 3=?$ /?(2D2(2%3 /'- $2-2'J >%$2'-3$2%7-3 +* B7/=32>7% -%'2/>272(0;

&+)B+)/(2+'3 $/D% =3%- / J)%/( D/)2%(0 +* $=E/'1 B$032?/7 /'- %7%?()+'2? %3B2+'/J% (/?(2?3;6??+)-2'J (+ X/?I U%D2'%1 / 9TS0%/) D%(%)/' +* ($% &@61 /'- *+)E%) /?(2'J -2)%?(+) +* 2(3

*+)%2J' +B%)/(2+'31 [#$% B)2D/(% 3%?(+) $/3 D2)(=/770 /77 ($% 3/E% (%?$'2e=%3 /3 ($%J+D%)'E%'(;\oG/'0 +* ($%3% (%?$'2e=%31 /( 7%/3( K$%' =3%- >0 B)2D/(% ?+)B+)/(2+'31 /)%='%($2?/7 +) 277%J/71 /'- $/D% ='-%'2/>70 >%%' =3%- /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3;

6 -2D%)3% /))/0 +* '+'B)+*2(3 $/D% >%%' (/)J%(%- >0 %3B2+'/J%1 2'?7=-2'J %'D2)+'E%'(/71/'(2SK/)1 B=>72? 2'(%)%3(1 ?+'3=E%)1 *++- 3/*%(01 B%3(2?2-% )%*+)E1 '=)32'J $+E% )%*+)E1J=' ?+'()+71 3+?2/7 N=3(2?%1 /'2E/7 )2J$(3 /'- /)E3 ?+'()+7 J)+=B3;

G/'0 +* ($% K+)7-]3 7/)J%3( ?+)B+)/(2+'3 /'- ($%2) ()/-% /33+?2/(2+'3 SS 2'?7=-2'J ($% :;.;&$/E>%) +* &+EE%)?%1 H/7E/)(1 G+'3/'(+1 R/'I +* 6E%)2?/1 U+K &$%E2?/71 ^)/*(1 &+?/S&+7/1 &$%D)+'1 R=)J%) ^2'J1 G?U+'/7-]31 .$%771 R%%' 72'I%- (+ 3B02'J +' '+'B)+*2(3; #$% )%D+7D2'J -++) I%%B3 3B2''2'J; .2V 0%/)3 /J+1($% 2'D%3(2J/(2D% )%B+)(%) U+=J7/3 ,)/'(Y 3=JJ%3(%-1 [#$% >%3( %3(2E/(% 23 ($/( 3%D%)/7$='-)%- *+)E%) 2'(%772J%'?% /J%'(3 '+K K+)I 2' ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J%j;#$%3% %VS3B2%3/BB70 / $2J$%) 7%D%7 +* %VB%)(23%1 $+'%- >0 J+D%)'E%'( 3%)D2?%1 (+ ($% ?)=-%) (/?(2?3/7)%/-0 B)/?(2?%- >0 B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(+)3;\8c

@' )%?%'( 0%/)31 ($%)% $/3 >%%' / 7/)J% ()/'3*%) +* J+D%)'E%'( 2'(%772J%'?% +B%)/(2+'3 *)+EJ+D%)'E%'( 3(/** (+ B)2D/(% *2)E3; [#$% &@61 C.6 /'- +($%) /J%'?2%3 +'?% )%'+K'%- *+)($%2) /'/70323 +* 2'(%772J%'?% /'- *+) ($%2) (%?$'2?/7 B)+K%33 2' ?+D%)( +B%)/(2+'31 %7%?()+'2?3=)D%277/'?% /'- +D%)$%/- )%?+''/233/'?% $/D% +=(3+=)?%- E/'0 +* ($%2) ?+)% (/3I3 (+

oU+=J7/3 ,)/'(Y1 [.B0; P3; .B0;\ H('.7(*,(1 U%?%E>%) 8Q1 TccQ;8cU+=J7/3 ,)/'(Y1 [.B0; P3; .B0;\ H('.7(*,(1 U%?%E>%) 8Q1 TccQ;


9/54

8

B)2D/(% 2'(%772J%'?% /)E2%31\ K)2(%3 #2E .$+))+?I; [63 / )%3=7(1 3B02'J $/3 >7+33+E%- 2'(+ /-+E%3(2? E/)I%( K+)($ '%/)70 qLc >2772+' / 0%/);\88 @' Tc8c1 ($% K/-#,34.(3 H(-.K/3 />7%(+ 2-%'(2*0 81o98 B)2D/(% ?+EB/'2%3 ($/( [K+)I +' (+BS3%?)%( ?+'()/?(3;\ #$% H(-./73+%3(2E/(%- ($/( [+=( +* fLg1ccc B%+B7% K2($ (+BS3%?)%( ?7%/)/'?%31 TOL1ccc /)%?+'()/?(+)3;\8TH$27% 3=?$ +=(3+=)?2'J 23 +=(32-% ($% 3?+B% +* ($23 )%B+)(1 2( 3B%/I3 (+ ($% 2EE%'3%?/B/?2(0 +* 2'(%772J%'?% J/($%)2'J *+) $2)%1 K$2?$ ?+)B+)/(2+'3 E/0 %EB7+0 (+ (/)J%('+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3;

@' ($23 )%B+)(1 K% -%*2'% ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% /3 ?+)B+)/(2+'3] =3% +* ='%($2?/7 +) 277%J/72'D%3(2J/(2D% +) 3=)D%277/'?% (%?$'2e=%3 (+ +>(/2' 2'*+)E/(2+' />+=( ($% /?(2D2(2%3 +* +($%)?+)B+)/(2+'31 K$23(7%>7+K%)31 /?(2D23(31 /'- '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3;

#$23 )%B+)( B)%3%'(3 '/))/(2D%3 +* ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J%1 E+3( +* ($%E -=)2'J ($% B/3(3%D%'(%%' 0%/)3; H% K277 /73+ -23?=33 3+E% )%?%'( ,R@ 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 +* '+'B)+*2(

+)J/'2Y/(2+'31 /3 K%77 /3 / ?+)B+)/(%S,R@ B/)('%)3$2B +' 2'(%772J%'?% E/((%)3;

88#2E .$+))+?I1 @&,$- 7(' L,'$F "#$ @$6'$. K('*2 (7 M3.$**,4$36$ N1.-(1'6,34; `C%K a+)I!.2E+' _ .?$=3(%)1 Tccfd1 BB; 88ST;8TU/'/


10/54

9

*JKKJFGHCV NT DNKUNKJFC CVUGNMJWC

#CDYCFF #KNRM .MFCKMJFGNMJS HVZ IJML MNMUKNTGF WKNEUV

@' 8oog1 X+$' &; U+-- E%( A2?$/)- R%?I%(( /( / >/) 2' 4/3(+'1 G/)07/'-; .$+)(70 ($%)%/*(%)1

R%?I%(( 2'()+-=?%- U+-- (+ )+I% ($% 3(+)0 +* RR@]3 %3B2+'/J% +B%)/(2+'31 K)+(% ($/( RR@

[3B2%- +' 5)%%'B%/?% /'- +($%) %'D2)+'E%'(/7 +)J/'2Y/(2+'3 *)+E ($% 7/(%8ooc3 ($)+=J$ /( 7%/3( Tccc1 B27*%)2'J -+?=E%'(3 *)+E ()/3$ >2'31 /((%EB(2'J(+ B7/'( ='-%)?+D%) +B%)/(2D%3 K2($2' J)+=B31 ?/32'J +**2?%31 ?+77%?(2'J B$+'%)%?+)-3 +* /?(2D23(31 /'- B%'%()/(2'J ?+'*2-%'(2/7 E%%(2'J3; 6??+)-2'J (+

?+EB/'0 -+?=E%'(3 B)+D2-%- (+ E(.#$' O(3$->0 / *+)E%) 2'D%3(+) 2' ($%*2)E1 ($23 3%?=)2(0 +=(*2( ?+77%?(%- ?+'*2-%'(2/7 2'(%)'/7 )%?+)-3r-+'+) 723(31-%(/27%- *2'/'?2/7 3(/(%E%'(31 ($% .+?2/7 .%?=)2(0 '=E>%)3 +* 3(/** E%E>%)313()/(%J0 E%E+3r*)+E ($%3% +)J/'2Y/(2+'3 /'- B)+-=?%- 2'(%772J%'?%)%B+)(3 *+) B=>72? )%7/(2+'3 *2)E3 /'- E/N+) ?+)B+)/(2+'3 2'D+7D%- 2'%'D2)+'E%'(/7 ?+'()+D%)32%3;\8g

7KCCMUCJDC

,+) E=?$ +* ($% 8ooc31 5)%%'B%/?% ?+'-=?(%- / ?/EB/2J' (+ B$/3% +=( ($% =3% +* ?$7+)2'%

(+ E/'=*/?(=)% B7/3(2?3 /'- B/B%); 43B%?2/770 2' ($% %/)70S /'- E2-S8ooc31 5)%%'B%/?%]3?/EB/2J' J%'%)/(%- ?)2(2?/7 E%-2/ ?+D%)/J% *+) U+K1 ($% K+)7-]3 7/)J%3( B)+-=?%) +*

89@'?2-%'(/7701 2( K/3 X/E%3 A2-J%K/0 K$+ *2)3( )%B+)(%- 2' 8oOO ($/( B)2D/(% -%(%?(2D%3`$2)%- >0 5%'%)/7 G+(+)31 2( K/3 7/(%) -23?7+3%-d K%)% (/272'J /'- 2'D%3(2J/(2'J A/7B$C/-%); .%% X/E%3 A2-J%K/01 [#$% U2?I;\ "#$ A$? D$&1)*,61 G/)?$ 8T1 8oOO;8gX/E%3 A2-J%K/01 [R7/?I WB31 5)%%' 5)+=B3;\ E(.#$' O(3$-1 6B)27 881 Tccf;


11/54

10

?$7+)2'%;8L @( /73+ K+' 3=BB+)( *)+E ($% &72'(+' /-E2'23()/(2+' /'- +($%) J+D%)'E%'(/7>+-2%3;8O

@' /' %**+)( (+ /77%D2/(% 2(3 B+72(2?/7 /'- B=>72?2(0 ()+=>7%31 U+K $2)%- ^%(?$=E1 / B=>72?)%7/(2+'3 *2)E; 6??+)-2'J (+ G/)I ,7+%J%7 +* 5)%%'B%/?%1 U+K B/2- ^%(?$=E )+=J$70

qLcc1ccc /''=/770 *+) 0 5)%%'B%/?%1 >%(K%%' X=70 891 8oof /'- X=70 8f1Tccc1 RR@ /'- 2(3 ?+'()/?(+)3 ?+'-=?(%- [E+)% ($/' 8Tc -+?=E%'(%- USM2'%3 /(5)%%'B%/?%]3 +**2?%3;\8Q

E(.#$' O(3$-2'(%)D2%K%- +'% B/)(2?2B/'( 2' / US72'% /J/2'3( 5)%%'B%/?%!

X%''2*%) #)/B'%771 K$+ K/3 -/(2'J hRR@ %EB7+0%% #2Ei H/)- 2' ($% 7/(%8ooc31 )%?/773 /' %D%'2'J K$%' 3$% /??+EB/'2%- H/)- +' / N+> 2'H/3$2'J(+' U;&; [b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l3 ?/); #)/B'%77 3/03 3$% -2-'l( I'+K K$/( ($%0 -2- K2($ ($% >/J3r/'-H/)- '%D%) %VB7/2'%-;8f

8L.%%1 *+) %V/EB7%1 @D/' 6E/(+1 [#$% &)=3/-% 6J/2'3( &$7+)2'%;\ @6,$36$1 X=70 o1 8oo9;4723/>%($ ^2)3?$'%) /'- U/D2- b='(%)1 [6((/?I3 +' &$7+)2'% 5/($%) ,+)?%;\ G#$+,6/* K$$%) 91 8oo9; G/)J/)%( ^)2Y1 [&7/3$2'J +D%) &$7+)2'%;\ A/.,(3/* O(1'3/*1 G/)?$ 8o18oog; R+> H0331 [&$7+)2'%! 47%E%'(/)01 /7 R/' +' &$7+)2'%1 R=(@'-=3()0 5)+=B3 ./0 #$%)% @3 C+ U/'J%);\ N'*/32( @$3.,3$*1 6B)27 o1 8ooL; X2E G+))231 [@'

.()2?(%3( &+'*2-%'?% ; ; ; #$% &$%E2?/7 @'-=3()0l3 .%?)%(3;\ L(1-.(3 G#'(3,6*$1 W?(+>%) TL18oof;8OR)/- ^'2?I%)>+?I%)1 [&72'(+' H+=7- R+((7% :B :3% +* &$7+)2'%;\ &$)23(2/' .?2%'?%G+'2(+)1 ,%>)=/)0 TT1 8oog; [


12/54

11

W), #5 "#:*V, #55*V,.); #+ ?+'-=?( US72'%3 /J/2'3( 5)%%'B%/?%]3 H/3$2'J(+' +**2?%31 RR@$2)%- / 3=>?+'()/?(+)1 X/E%3 U/)+'1 / U23()2?( +* &+7=E>2/ B+72?% +**2?%);8o 6??+)-2'J (+ ($%5)%%'B%/?% ?+EB7/2'(1 U/)+' [K/3 %VB%?(%- (+ =3% $23 +**2?2/7 B+72?% >/-J% (+ J/2' /??%33(+ -=EB3(%)3 ($/( K%)% %'?7+3%- >0 / 7+?I%- *%'?%;\ U/)+' B/)(2?2B/(%- 2' [/( 7%/3( LL\ +*($% US72'%3 /J/2'3( 5)%%'B%/?%;Tc

@' /' %E/27 -23?=332'J $+K (+ /??%33 ($% J/)>/J% /'- )%?0?72'J +* /'+($%) '+'B)+*2( (/)J%(1RR@]3 #2E H/)- K)2(%3! [G/0>% +'% +* +=) R72? %-=?/(2+'FK)2(2'J-%B/)(E%'( K/3 ($% 7/)J%3( 2' (%)E3 +* *7++) 3B/?% /'- '=E>%) +* %EB7+0%%3 +>3%)D%-;\T9

RR@ /BB/)%'(70 ()2%- (+ -%(%)E2'% ($% 3%?=)2(0 ?+-%3 *+) 5)%%'B%/?% +**2?% -++)31 /'- E/0K%77 $/D% =3%- ($%3% ?+-%3 (+ %'(%) 5)%%'B%/?% +**2?%3; ,+='- /E+'J ($% RR@ -+?=E%'(3)%7/(%- (+ 5)%%'B%/?% K/3 / $/'-K)2((%' 723( +* 3%?=)2(0 ?+-%3 ($/( 3%%E3 (+ $/D% >%%'

8oU/)+' 3(277 K+)I3 *+) ($% U23()2?( +* &+7=E>2/ B+72?%1 2' ($% 3B%?2/7 +B%)/(2+'3 -2D232+';$((B!FFKKK;72'I%-2';?+EFB=>FN/E%3S-/)+'FT/Fof9FTL;Tc5)%%'B%/?% D; #$% U+K &$%E2?/7 &+EB/'0 %( /7;1 /( o;T8X/E%3 A2-J%K/01 [R7/?I WB31 5)%%' 5)+=B3;\ E(.#$' O(3$-1 6B)27 881 Tccf;TTX/E%3 A2-J%K/01 [R7/?I WB31 5)%%' 5)+=B3;\ E(.#$' O(3$-1 6B)27 881 Tccf; RR@ B%)3+''%7?$/)( /'- >2+3! $((B!FFKKK;J)%%'B%/?%;+)JF=3/F%'FE%-2/S?%'(%)F)%B+)(3FRR@SB%)3+''%7S?$/)(F;T95)%%'B%/?% D; #$% U+K &$%E2?/7 &+EB/'0 %( /7;1 /( 88;


13/54

12

=3%- >0 RR@ 3(/** +) ?+'()/?(+)3 (+ ()0 (+ +B%' 5)%%'B%/?% +**2?% -++)3; #$%0 /BB/)%'(70(%3(%- E/'0 ?+-%31 /'- '+(%- K$2?$ +'%3 K+)I%- /'- K$2?$ -2- '+(;Tg

6??+)-2'J (+ ($% 5)%%'B%/?% ?+EB7/2'(1 [RR@ B)+?=)%- /'- $%7- $2J$70 ?+'*2-%'(2/75)%%'B%/?% )%?+)-31 2'?7=-2'J1 *+) %V/EB7%1 ?+'*2-%'(2/7 B%)3+'/71 *2'/'?2/7 /'-

%EB7+0E%'( )%?+)-3 Z K$2?$ ?+=7- +'70 $/D% >%%' 3%?=)%- *)+E 5)%%'B%/?%]3 +**2?%3j\TL

E*.,0/")G F/V$*+2 /+U #0F,. ,:,V0.#+*V )(.Q,*::/+V,> 6EB7% %D2-%'?% 3=JJ%3(3 ($/( RR@/'- 2(3 3=>S?+'()/?(+)3 ?+'-=?(%- %7%?()+'2? 3=)D%277/'?% +* 5)%%'B%/?%; 6??+)-2'J (+ ($%5)%%'B%/?% ?+EB7/2'(!

RR@ I%B( / *27% 7/>%7%- [H2)% #/B @'*+\ ($/( K/3 *+='- /7+'J K2($ 5)%%'B%/?%2'(%)'/7 -+?=E%'(3;TO

[RR@ $2)%- #)2H%3( @'D%3(2J/(2+'3 (+ B)+?=)% ($% B$+'% ?/77 )%?+)-3 +* 5)%%'B%/?%%EB7+0%%3 +) ?+'()/?(+)3; RR@ +>(/2'%- ($% )%?+)-3 +* ?%77=7/) B$+'% ?/773 B7/?%-

/'- )%?%2D%- >0 5)%%'B%/?% %EB7+0%%3 +) ?+'()/?(+)3 *)+E 5)%%'B%/?%]3 ?%77=7/)B)+D2-%); ,+) %V/EB7%1 RR@ +>(/2'%- / 723( +* ?/773 E/-% (+ /'- *)+E h5)%%'B%/?%+)J/'2Y%)i R%($ s27>%)(]3 ?%77 B$+'%1 K$2?$ K/3 B/2- *+) >0 5)%%'B%/?%;\TQ

[RR@ B=)?$/3%- ($% 3%)D2?%3 +* C%(./*%1 @'?;1 / ?+EB/'0 ($/( 3B%?2/72Y%3 2' ?+EB=(%)2'()=32+' /'- %7%?()+'2? 3=)D%277/'?%1 *+) 2(3 K+)I +' 5)%%'B%/?% B)+N%?(3; G+3( +*C%(./*%]3 (+B %V%?=(2D%3 K%)% *+)E%) C/(2+'/7 .%?=)2(0 6J%'?0 %EB7+0%%312'?7=-2'J X+% %%' $2)%- >0 U+K (+ K+)I +' E/((%)3 )%7/(%- (+ 5)%%'B%/?%;9c

SF,50 #5 V#+5*U,+0*/: *+5#. 6??+)-2'J (+ ($% 5)%%'B%/?% ?+EB7/2'(1 -+?=E%'(3+>(/2'%- *)+E 5)%%'B%/?% 2'?7=-% [?+'*2-%'(2/7 3()/(%J0 2'*+)E/(2+'\ />+=( 5)%%'B%/?%]3?/EB/2J'3 /J/2'3( [(+V2? ?$%E2?/731 J7+>/7 K/)E2'J1 '=?7%/) %'%)J01 J%'%(2? %'J2'%%)2'J

Tg$((B!FFE+($%)N+'%3;?+EF*27%3F7%J/?0F'%K3F*%/(=)%FTccfFcgFb/'-K)2((%'S5


14/54

13

/'- ($% B+77=(2+' +* *23$%)2%3 /'- +?%/'3;\ .B%?2*2? ?/EB/2J' 3()/(%J0 -+?=E%'(3 2'?7=-%![#+V2?3 &/EB/2J' G%%(2'J 6J%'-/ *+) ,%>)=/)0 T1 8ooop 5%'%(2?/770 G+-2*2%- W)J/'23E3&/EB/2J' .()/(%J0p 57+>/7 H/)E2'J .()/(%J0p &72E/(% &/EB/2J' .$2B #+=) U)/*( .?$%-=7%p&+EE='2?/(2+'3 +($ / B/((%)' /'- B)/?(2?% +*/?(2+'3 >0 ($% U%*%'-/'(3 (+ 2'()=-% =B+' /'- 2'D/-% ($% B)2D/?0 /'- 7/K*=7 2'(%)%3(3 +*5)%%'B%/?% /'- E23/BB)+B)2/(% 2(3 ?+'*2-%'(2/7 2'*+)E/(2+' *+) %?+'+E2? J/2';\9T#$% 3=2(K/3 -23E233%- +' .%B(%E>%) o1 Tc88; X=-J% A+3%E/)0 G; &+770%) )=7%- ($/( [#$% -2)%?(D2?(2E +* ($23 /77%J%- K2)% *)/=- K/3 '+( 5)%%'B%/?%G>=( / ($2)- B/)(01 /'-1 ($%)%*+)%1 ($%72'I >%(K%%' 5)%%'B%/?%l3 2'N=)2%3 /'- U%*%'-/'(3l /77%J%- )/?I%(%%)2'J /?(2D2(0 23 (++/((%'=/(%- (+ >% /?(2+'/>7% ='-%) A@&W;\99

W' W?(+>%) Q1 Tc881 5)%%'B%/?% )%S*27%- 2(3 7/K3=2( 2' U23()2?( +* &+7=E>2/ .=B%)2+) &+=)(;9gW' ,%>)=/)0 L1 Tc891 U& .=B%)2+) &+=)( X=-J% G2?$/%7 A/'I2' )=7%- ($/( 5)%%'B%/?% E/0B)+?%%- K2($ B/)(3 +* 2(3 ?/3%1 >=( -23E233%- *+=) +* 2(3 ?7/2E3;

W' W?(+>%) f1 Tc891 / ?+/72(2+' +* '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3 *27%- /' /E2?=3 >)2%* 2' ($%U23()2?( +* &+7=E>2/ &+=)( +* 6BB%/731 =)J2'J ($% ?+=)( (+ [-%?7/)% ($% B)/?(2?% +*k?+EE%)?2/7 -=EB3(%) -2D2'J] (+ >% /' 277%J2(2E/(% E%/'3 *+) / ?+EB/'0 (+ +>(/2'2'*+)E/(2+' *)+E /' /-D%)3/)0;\ #$% >)2%* -%*2'%3 [?+EE%)?2/7 -=EB3(%) -2D2'J\ /3[?+EB/'2%3 )=EE/Jh2'Ji ($)+=J$ ($% ()/3$ +* ($%2) ?+EB%(2(+)3 +) ?)2(2?3 2' 3%/)?$ +* ()/-%3%?)%(3 +) +($%) D/7=/>7% 2'*+)E/(2+';\9L #$% '+'B)+*2(3 *272'J ($% /E2?=3 >)2%* 2'?7=-%

433%'(2/7 @'*+)E/(2+'p ($% &%'(%) *+) b%/7($1 4'D2)+'E%'( /'- X=3(2?%p A/2'*+)%3( 6?(2+'C%(K+)Ip @'3(2(=(% *+) 6J)2?=7(=)% /'- #)/-%


15/54

14

(+ J%'%(2?/770 %'J2'%%)%- *++-; 4E/273 )%7/(%- (+ .T2]3 +B%)/(2+'3 3=JJ%3( ($% ?+EB/'0 E/0$/D% %'J/J%- 2' -=EB3(%) -2D2'J /J/2'3( ($%3% '+'B)+*2(3 /'- E/0 $/D% =3%- / U23()2?( +*&+7=E>2/ B+72?% +**2?%) (+ %'(%) ($% B)%E23%3 +* +'% +* ($% '+'B)+*2(3;

W'% -+?=E%'( )%?+D%)%- *)+E RR@]3 *27%3 K/3 /' %E/27 *)+E X/0 R701 / *+)E%) .%?)%( .%)D2?%

/J%'(1 (+ #2E H/)-1 / *+)E%) G/)07/'- .(/(% #)++B%)!

[A%?%2D%- / ?/77 *)+E ^%(?$=E 0%3(%)-/0 /*(%)'++' )% ($)%% 32(%3 2' U&; @(3%%E3 #/?+ R%77 (=)'%- +=( 3+E% B)+-=?( E/-% *)+E >2+%'J2'%%)%- ?+)';#$% ?$%E2?/73 =3%- +' ($% ?+)' $/D% '+( >%%' /BB)+D%- *+) $=E/'?+'3=EB(2+'; b%'?% #/?+ R%77 B)+-=?%- B+(%'(2/7 J7+KS2'S($%S-/)I (/?+3;#/?+ R%77 23 +K'%- >0 ^)/*(; #$% ^%(?$=E W**2?%1 C%K a+)I1 $/3 ($% >/77; #$%03=3B%?( ($% 2'2(2/(2D% 23 >%2'J J%'%)/(%- *)+E +'% +* ($)%% B7/?%3!8;&%'(%) *+) ,++- ./*%(01 Q($ _ =27-2'J /3 &$27% 4E>/330; 6)E%- J=/)- 2' 7+>>0 _ ?/E%)/3%D%)0K$%)%; #$%)% 23 / -=EB3(%) 2' ($% /77%0 >%$2'- ($% >=27-2'J; U+'l( I'+K2* 2( 23 (2%- (+ >7-J; +) / '%2J$>+)$++- B)+B%)(0; &/E%)/3 %D%)0K$%)%;t9 23 -+/>7% >=( >%$2'- 7+?I%- 2)+' J/(%3 /( )%/) +* >7-J;\9O

#$% '%V( -/01 R70 3%'( H/)- /'+($%) %E/27!

[A%! U=EB3(%) U2D%;@ J+( $+7- +* X2E U/)+' h/ U23()2?( +* &+7=E>2/ B+72?% +**2?%) K+)I2'J *+) RR@i

0%3(%)-/0; b% K/3 3=BB+3%- (+ -+ P%)E+'( 6D% /'- =27-2'J `B)+>/>70 B233%- +** >%?/=3% ($%0 K+I% $2E=Bd1 ($% J=03 K/7I ($% >/J3 +=( (+ ($% ()=?I +'% /( / (2E%; H$%' ($%0 *2'23$($%0 7+?I%- ($% J/(% >%$2'- ($%E; #$%)% K/3 3+ E=?$ ()/3$ ($%0 $/- (+?+EB/?( ($% ()=?I (K+ (2E%3 K$27% ($%0 K%)% ($%)%; @ -2- '+( *2'- /'0($2'J*)+E ($% L($ *7++)1 >=( ($% J++- '%K3 23 2(l3 -+/>7%;\9Q

W' .%B(%E>%) Tf($1 H/)- )%B72%-!

[5++- '%K3u #$2'I ($/( +'?% X2E hU/)+'i ?/773 0+= >/?I K% K277 I'+K K$%)%K% 3(/'-; @* $% ?/'l( J%( 2' K2($ ($% 3$2%7-1 2( K277 >% -2**2?=7( /( 32J$( t8; @($2'I tT K% ?/' -+ )%J/)-7%33; #$% 233=% 23 / $+( +'% 2' J%'%)/7; @lD% >%%'*+77+K2'J 2( *)+E $%)%; U+'l( *+)J%( +=) 5< h5)%%'B%/?%i >+0 2' R/7(2E+)% $/3

9OX/E%3 A2-J%K/01 [R7/?I WB31 5)%%' 5)+=B3;\ E(.#$' O(3$-1 6B)27 881 Tccf;9QX/E%3 A2-J%K/01 [R7/?I WB31 5)%%' 5)+=B3;\ E(.#$' O(3$-1 6B)27 881 Tccf;


16/54

15

>%%' $/'-72'J ($% K+)I *+) 5% K+)($ / ?$%?I 2' ($% ?2(0; G/0>%+'% +* +=) R%*+)%\;9f

(CMFNM )NIIEMGDJFGNMV

,%'(+' &+EE='2?/(2+'3 23 / B=>72? )%7/(2+'3 *2)E *+='-%- >0 U/D2- ,%'(+' ($/(3=BB+)(3 B=>72? 2'(%)%3(1 %'D2)+'E%'(/7 /'- +($%) '+'B)+*2( J)+=B3; E(.#$' O(3$-

)%B+)(%- ($/(!W' U%?%E>%) f1 8ooo1 / RR@ +B%)/(2D%1 /??+)-2'J (+ /' 2'(%)'/7 )%B+)(1 k3/(

3=)D%277/'?%] /( hU/D2-i ,%'(+'l3 H/3$2'J(+' $+E%1 >%J2''2'J /( T!Lc /E; @'($% )%B+)(1 ($% +B%)/(2D% '+(%- ($% (2E% +* ($% E+)'2'J J/)>/J% B2?IS=B /'-($/( $% )%(=)'%- (+ ($% +**2?% (+ k3+)( E/(%)2/7] /'- k/'/70Y%;] RR@ )/'>/?IJ)+='- ?$%?I3 +' >+($ ,%'(+' /'- $23 ($%'SK2*%; #$% ?+EB/'0l3 *27%3?+'(/2'%- B$+(+J)/B$3 +* ($%2) $+=3% /3 K%77 /3 ?72%'( 723(31 >2772'J2'*+)E/(2+'1 /'- B%)3+''%7 2'*+)E/(2+' *)+E ,%'(+' &+EE='2?/(2+'3;R%(K%%' X=70 8oof /'- ,%>)=/)0 Tcc81 ,%'(+' 3/031 $23 *2)E %VB%)2%'?%-3%D%)/7 >)%/IS2'31 -=)2'J K$2?$ >+V%3 +* *27%3 /'- (K+ 7/B(+B3 K%)% 3(+7%';#$% ?=7B)2(3 K%)% '%D%) ?/=J$(;9o

6??+)-2'J (+ ($% 5)%%'B%/?% ?+EB7/2'(1 RR@ +>(/2'%- ?+'*2-%'(2/7 2'(%)'/7-+?=E%'(3 *)+E ,%'(+' &+EE='2?/(2+'31 2'?7=-2'J [>277/>7% (2E% 3=EE/)0 )%B+)(31)%*7%?(2'J ($% K+)I B%)*+)E%- *+) ,%'(+' ?72%'(3p 2'(%)'/7 *%% E%E+)/'-/1 K$2?$B)+D2-% 2'3()=?(2+'3 *+) 2'D+2?2'J B/)(2?=7/) ?72%'(3p (2E%372B )%B+)(31 K$2?$-+?=E%'( ($% >277/>7% $+=)3 +* %/?$ %EB7+0%%p /'- / ?$%?I *+) ($% )%2E>=)3%E%'(+* / $%/7($ 2'3=)/'?% ?7/2E *+) U/D2- ,%'(+'1 K$2?$ K/3 E/27%- (+ $23 $+E%/--)%33;\gc

9f$((B!FFE+($%)N+'%3;?+EF*27%3F7%J/?0F'%K3F*%/(=)%FTccfFcgF7%vTc.2(%3S6--)%33%3;B-*;9oX/E%3 A2-J%K/01 [R7/?I WB31 5)%%' 5)+=B3;\ G+($%) X+'%31 6B)27 881 Tccf;$((B!FFE+($%)N+'%3;?+EF*27%3F7%J/?0F'%K3F*%/(=)%FTccfFcgF@'(%)'/7vTcA%B+)(S./(S.=)D%277/'?%;B-*;gc5)%%'B%/?% D; #$% U+K &$%E2?/7 &+EB/'0 %( /7;1 /( 8Q;


17/54

16

7KCCMUCJDC[ )$%"* JMO FPC $JYC )PJKSCV 6KN]CDF

,)+E 8ofg (+ Tcc81 &WCU46 P23(/ E/'=*/?(=)%- D2'07 ?$7+)2-% /( / */?(+)0 2' M/I%&$/)7%31 M+=232/'/;g8 @' 8ooQ1 &WCU46 P23(/ K/3 *+='- J=27(0 +* [K/'(+' /'-)%?I7%33 -23)%J/)- +* B=>72? 3/*%(0\ /'- *2'%- qQ E2772+' 2' B='2(2D% -/E/J%3 *+)

7%/I3 +* %($07%'% -2?$7+)2-%1 /' 2'(%)E%-2/(% ?+EB+='- 2' ($% B)+-=?(2+' +*B+70D2'07 ?$7+)2-%;gT ,+) E/'0 0%/)3 5)%%'B%/?% ?/EB/2J'%- (+ %VB+3% ($% -/'J%)3+* B+70D2'07 ?$7+)2-% /'- ($% B+77=(2+' J%'%)/(%- >0 &WCU46 P23(/;g9

6??+)-2'J (+ ($% 5)%%'B%/?% ?+EB7/2'(!

[W' G/0 TO1 8oof1 K+)I2'J /( ($% >%$%3( +* >+($ &WCU46 P23(/ /'-U%Y%'$/771 RR@ 2'2(2/(%- ($% kM/I% &$/)7%3 +=( %'D2)+'E%'(/7 +)J/'2Y/(2+'3 /'- ?/EB/2J'%)3;\gg

#+ /3323( K2($ ($% M/I% &$/)7%3 %(K%%' &M46C /'- 5)%%'B%/?%j;A+J%)3 3%'( E+)% ($/'OL '/))/(2D% )%B+)(3 /'- *+)K/)-%- /( 7%/3( 8Lc ?+'*2-%'(2/7 %E/273 (+./B+'%; ./B+'%1 2' (=)'1 *+)K/)-%- ($% ?+'*2-%'(2/7 %E/273 /'- )%B+)(31/7E+3( -/2701 (+ H/)- >%(K%%' 6=J=3( 8oof /'- C+D%E>%) 8ooo;\gL

[@' 8oof1 X/0 R70 ()/D%7%- (+ M+=232/'/ (+ 3=)D%27 ($% +**2?%3 /'- $+E%3 +*/?(2D23(3 K+)I2'J 2' M/I% &$/)7%3; b% 3=>E2((%- '=E%)+=3 )%B+)(3 -%(/272'J

$23 /?(2D2(2%31 K$2?$ 2'D+7D%-j?+77%?(2'J /'- 3+)(2'J ()/3$ *)+E D/)2+=37+?/(2+'3; @' 8ooo1 R70 K/3 )%2E>=)3%- *+) 3=BB72%3 B=)?$/3%- 2' G/)07/'-2' ?+''%?(2+' K2($ $23 &WCU46 P23(/ 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3! 666 >/((%)2%31 ()/3$>/J31 / ()/3$ ?/' /'- I%03j($% ?$/)J% (+ &WCU46 P23(/ *+) E/I2'J kI%03]*=)($%) B)+D2-%3 3=BB+)( *+) ($% ?+'?7=32+' ($/( RR@ K/3 ='7/K*=770 J/2'2'J/??%33 (+ 5)%%'B%/?% B)%E23%31 +) B)+B%)(0 )%7/(%- (+ 5)%%'B%/?%1 ($/( 2( $/-

g8@' Tcc81 &WCU46 P23(/ K/3 B=)?$/3%- >0 ./3+71 / J2/'( .+=($ 6*)2?/' ?$%E2?/7 ?+EB/'0;gT[&WCU46 P23(/ B='23$%- +D%) 7%/I3p &WCU46 P23(/ &+; B/03 qQ E2772+' *+) ?$%E2?/73B277;\ G#$+,-.'0 /32 M321-.'01 C+D%E>%) 91 8ooQ;g9.%%1 *+) %V/EB7%1 [5)%%'B%/?%1 M/I% &$/)7%31 M/;1 A%32-%'(3


18/54

17

'+ 7/K*=7 )2J$( (+ /??%33;\gO

*NKFP /JSSCL )NJSGFGNM

6??+)-2'J (+ E(.#$' O(3$-1[@' 8ooO /'- 8ooQ 2' '+)($%)' &/72*+)'2/1 K$%)% R)+K'2'JS,%))23 @'-=3()2%3 K/3%'J/J%- 2' / >/((7% +D%) ($% *=(=)% +* / J/)>/J% -=EB1 RR@ ?+'-=?(%- K$/( 2(3)%?+)-3 7/>%7%- k?+D%)( E+'2(+)2'J] /'- k2'(%772J%'?% J/($%)2'J] +' ($% C+)($ P/77%0&+/72(2+'1 / ?2(2Y%'3 J)+=B +BB+3%- (+ ($% R)+K'2'JS,%))23 B)+N%?(; @' .%B(%E>%)8ooQ1 RR@ )%?%2D%- / B/0E%'( +* q8of1ff8;cL *)+E R,@;\gQ

*EKVGMW PNIC JDFGHGVFV

6??+)-2'J (+ ($% K/-#,34.(3 H(-.= RR@ 3B2%- +' '=)32'J $+E% /?(2D23(3 K$+ K/'(%-

2EB)+D%- ?+'-2(2+'3 /( / G/)07/'- '=)32'J $+E% ?/77%- b%>)%K b+E%!

@' 8ooQ1 /( / ?+EE='2(0 ?%'(%) 2' G+'(J+E%)0 &+='(01 /?(2D23(3 $%7-E%%(2'J3 (+ -23?=33 b%>)%K b+E%; #$% J)+=B1 E/-% =B 7/)J%70 +* )%32-%'(3l)%7/(2D%31 /77%J%- B++) E%-2?/(2+' ?+'()+73 /'- )+=J$ ()%/(E%'( +* )%32-%'(3;63 ($%0 3()/(%J2Y%-1 /' ='-%)?+D%) +B%)/(2D% K/3 B/02'J ?7+3% /((%'(2+'; b%))%B+)(3 SS /7+'J K2($ E%%(2'J /J%'-/31 72?%'3% B7/(% '=E>%)3 /'--%3?)2B(2+'3 +* /-D+?/(%3 SS K%)% )%7/0%- (+ b%>)%K b+E% +**2?2/731 ($%)%?+)-3 3$+Kj;WD%) / 0%/)1 ($% '=)32'J $+E% B/2- RR@ />+=( qLc1ccc *+)2'D%3(2J/(2D% K+)I1 /??+)-2'J (+ 2'D+2?%3 /--)%33%- (+ ?$2%* %V%?=(2D%H/))%' .7/D2'jgf

0JKL $NE +JUNMC JMO FPC #KJOL )JIUJGWM

,)+E ($% E2-S8ooc3 ($)+=J$ E=?$ +* ($% Tccc31 G/)0 G?,/(% K/3 / B)+E2'%'( D+7='(%%)*+) J=' ?+'()+7 J)+=B3; .$% )/' *+) / 3%/( +' ($% >+/)- +* -2)%?(+)3 +* ($% R)/-0 &/EB/2J'(+ +=( ($% B7/'3 /'- /?(2+'3 +*($%3% /'- +($%) '/(2+'/7 J=' ?+'()+7 J)+=B3; #$%01 $+K%D%)1 -2- '+( I'+K ($/( $%) +($%)2-%'(2(0 K/3 G/)0 M+= ./B+'%1 K$+ 32'?% ($% 7/(% 8ofc3 $/- >%%' B/2- >0 ?+)B+)/(2+'3 (+

gO5)%%'B%/?% D; #$% U+K &$%E2?/7 &+EB/'0 %( /7;1 /( T9Sg;gQX/E%3 A2-J%K/01 [R7/?I WB31 5)%%' 5)+=B3;\ E(.#$' O(3$-1 6B)27 881 Tccf;gfX%''/ X+$'3+'1 [&+)B+)/(% 43B2+'/J% U%(/27%- 2' U+?=E%'(3p U%*='?( G-; 6J%'?0#/)J%(%- 6?(2D23(3;\ K/-#,34.(3 H(-.1 X='% TT1 Tccf; .%% /73+ [.B02'J >0 C=)32'J b+E%U)/K3 ,2)%;\ "#$ T('?/'21 X=70 8f1 Tccf;


19/54

18

3B0 +' ?2(2Y%'3] J)+=B3;go ,+) %V/EB7%1 3$% $/- K+)I%- *+) R%?I%(( R)+K' @'(%)'/(2+'/7 (+2'*27()/(% ($% M/I% &$/)7%31 M+=232/'/ %'D2)+'E%'(/7 +)J/'2Y/(2+' &M46C;Lc ,+) ($% :;.;.=)J2?/7 &+)B+)/(2+'1 3$% $/- 2'*27()/(%- /'2E/7 )2J$(3 /?(2D23(3 K$+ K%)% B)+(%3(2'J 2(3 =3%+* -+J3 2' E%-2?/7 ()/2'2'J;L8 @' / Tcc9 -%B+32(2+'1 #2E H/)-1 *+)E%) B)%32-%'( +* RR@1 3/2-($/( ($% C/(2+'/7 A2*7% 633+?2/(2+' $/- >%%' / ?72%'( +* ./B+'%]3; R2772'J )%?+)-3 3$+K ($/(

($% CA6 B/2- RR@ ['%/)70 qfc1ccc\ *+) 3%)D2?%3 )%'-%)%- >%(K%%' G/0 8ooo /'- 6B)27Tccc;LT

-+ )PJIQCK NT )NIICKDC\9#7JKL (COCKJS\9EMFNM ^ =GSSGJIV HVZ -Z+Z )PJIQCK=JFDP\6EQSGD )GFGXCM\6EQSGD )JIUJGWM\0NHC'MZNKW\/CSHCF 1CHNSEFGNM\)CMFCK TNK"ICKGDJM 6KNWKCVV\!GOCV (NEMOJFGNM\_EVFGDC !PKNEWP 0EVGD\0NHC FN "ICMO\1EDYEV+NDGCFL

@' X/'=/)0 Tc881 /' %V%?=(2D% 2' ($% ?+EB=(%) 3%?=)2(0 *2)E bR5/)0 ,%-%)/7 ?7/2E%- (+$/D% 2-%'(2*2%- ($% 7%/-%)3$2B +* ($% $/?I%) ?+77%?(2D% 6'+'0E+=3;L9 @' )%3B+'3%1 ($%

?+77%?(2D% $/?I%- ($% *2)E]3 %E/27 /'- +($%) /??+='(31 /'- )%7%/3%- 2(3 *27%3 +' ($%@'(%)'%(;Lg#$23 ?)%/(%- / )/)% +BB+)(='2(0 (+ )%D2%K ($% )%?%'( 2'(%)'/7 K+)I2'J3 +* /'2EB+)(/'( B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(2D% *2)E;LL

#$% -+?=E%'(3 )%D%/7 B)+B+3/73 E/-% >0 bR5/)0 ,%-%)/7 (+ ($% B+K%)*=7 :;.; 7/K *2)Eb='(+' _ H2772/E31 (+ $%7B 2(3 ?72%'(1 ($% :;.; &$/E>%) +* &+EE%)?%1 -23?)%-2( 2(3 '+'B)+*2(?)2(2?3;

#$% -+?=E%'(3 +**%) ($% N+2'( 3%)D2?%3 +* ($)%% *2)E3! bR5/)0 ,%-%)/71 ($% 2'(%772J%'?%/'/70323 *2)E >0 G+7%;\ E(.#$' O(3$-1 X=70 9c1 Tccf; X+$' .(/=>%) /'- .$%7-+'A/EB(+'1 "(U,6 @*124$ ,- J((2 T(' Q(1F >,$-= B/+3 >,$- /32 .#$ H1)*,6 D$*/.,(3- M321-.'0;`G+')+%1 G4! &+EE+' &+=)/J% %)( 4; ^%337%) /'- G2?$/%7 .7/?IE/'1 [R+E> .=3B%?(! l@ H/3 .%( :Blp./03 l,)2%'-l SS :;.; .=)J2?/7l3 6J%'( SS )=/)01 Tc88;Lg&$/)7%3 6)($=)1 [6'+'0E+=3 6((/?I3 :. .%?=)2(0 &+EB/'0;\ J1/'2,/31 ,%>)=/)0 Q1 Tc88;LL4)2? M2B(+' /'- &$/)72% ./D/J%1 [b/?I%)3l &7/3$ H2($ .%?=)2(0 ,2)E .B+(72J$(3 @'e=2)2%3 (+U23?)%-2( A2D/73;\ "#$ A$? Q('< ",+$-1 ,%>)=/)0 8T1 Tc88;LO,+) >/?IJ)+='-1 3%%!


20/54

19

2'(%772J%'?% 3%)D2?%3 (+ ($% :;.; E272(/)0 /'- 2'(%772J%'?% /J%'?2%3; #+J%($%)1 ($% ($)%% *2)E3?/77%- ($%E3%7D%3 [#%/E #$%E23;\

@' )%3B+'3% (+ 3+72?2(/(2+'3 *)+E b='(+' _ H2772/E31 3%D%)/7 #%/E #$%E23 -+?=E%'(3+=(72'% / ?/EB/2J' (+ (/)J%( :;.; &$/E>%) H/(?$1 / '+'B)+*2( K/(?$-+J J)+=B ($/(

E+'2(+)%- ($% :;.; &$/E>%) +* &+EE%)?%; #%/E #$%E23 B)+B+3%- (+ %V%?=(% $2J$70='%($2?/7 /'-F+) B+332>70 277%J/7 (/?(2?31Lf3=?$ /3!

[&)%/(% / */73% -+?=E%'(1 B%)$/B3 $2J$72J$(2'J B%)2+-2?/7 *2'/'?2/7 2'*+)E/(2+'1 /'-E+'2(+) (+ 3%% 2* :. &$/E>%) H/(?$ /?e=2)%3 2(; 6*(%)K/)-1 B)%3%'( %VB72?2(%D2-%'?% B)+D2'J ($/( 3=?$ ()/'3/?(2+'3 '%D%) +??=))%-;\

[h&i)%/(% / */I% 2'32-%) B%)3+'/ /'- J%'%)/(% ?+EE='2?/(2+'3 K2($ &(H h&$/'J% (+H2'i; 6*(%)K/)-1 )%7%/3% ($% /?(=/7 -+?=E%'(3 /( / 3B%?2*2%- (2E% /'- %VB7/2' ($%/?(2D2(0 /3 / &(H ?+'()2D%- +B%)/(2+'; R+($ 2'3(/'?%3 K277 B)+D% ($/( :. &$/E>%)H/(?$ ?/''+( >% ()=3(%- K2($ 2'*+)E/(2+' /'-F+) (%77 ($% ()=($;\Lo

#%/E #$%E23 B)+B+3%- (+ K/J% %7%?()+'2? K/)*/)% /J/2'3( :;.; &$/E>%) H/(?$ /'- 2(3/772%3; W'% #%/E #$%E23 B)+B+3/7 +**%)3 (+ %EB7+0 bR5/)0 ,%-%)/7]3 ?/B/>272(2%3 *+)[@'*+)E/(2+' WB%)/(2+'3;\ @'*+)E/(2+' WB%)/(2+'3 23 / E272(/)0 (%)E *+) %7%?()+'2? K/)*/)%;#$% B)+B+3/7 2'?7=-%3 bR5/)0 ,%-%)/7]3 %VB%)(23% 2' [P=7'%)/>272(0 A%3%/)?$F4VB7+2(U%D%7+BE%'(\ /'- [G/7K/)% 6'/70323 /'- A%D%)3% 4'J2'%%)2'J;\Oc6'+($%) #%/E #$%E23-+?=E%'( B)+B+3%3 (+ =3% / 3+*(K/)% %'J2'%%) [)%3B+'32>7% *+) ($% -%32J' /'--%D%7+BE%'( +* ?=3(+E >+(3\;O8 G/'0 I2'-3 +* E/7K/)% =3% ?=3(+E >+(3;

W($%) %E/273 3$+K ($/( bR5/)0 ,%-%)/7 2'D%3(2J/(%- ($% ?)2(2?3 +* ($% :;.; &$/E>%) +*

;1-,3$-- M3-,2$'1 G/)?$ 8c1 Tc88; %) Tf1 Tc89;dLf.%% ^%D2' s%%3%]3 %($2?3 ?+EB7/2'( /J/2'3( b='(+' _ H2772/E3 /((+)'%03 X+$' H; H++-31A2?$/)- M; H0/(( /'- A+>%)( #; w=/?I%'>+331 ,%>)=/)0 T91 Tc88;$((B!FFKKK;D%7D%()%D+7=(2+';=3F2E/J%3FbxHxR/)x?+EB7/2'(;B-*;Lo[:. &$/E>%) H/(?$ @'*+)E/(2+' WB%)/(2+'3 A%?+EE%'-/(2+';\ C+D%E>%) To1 Tc8c;$((B!FF2E/J%3T;/E%)2?/'B)+J)%33;+)JF#$2'I


21/54

20

&+EE%)?%1 2'?7=-2'J ($%2) 3B+=3%31 ?$27-)%'1 )%72J2+=3 /?(2D2(2%3 /'- B%)3+'/7 72D%3 Z /'-%D%' J/($%)%- B$+(+3 +* ($%E;OT

#%/E #$%E23 B)+B+3%- (+ b='(+' _ H2772/E3 / qTcc1ccc E+'($70 B)2?% (/J *+) 2'2(2/7)%3%/)?$1 K2($ / qT E2772+' E+'($70 ?+3( *+) / *=77 ?/EB/2J';O9

#%/E #$%E23 B)+B+3%- (+ %EB7+0 D%(%)/'3 +* ($% :;.; E272(/)0 /'- 2'(%772J%'?% 3%)D2?%3; @'/ B)+B+3/7 (+ b='(+' _ H2772/E31 #%/E #$%E23 K/'(%- (+ [$2J$72J$(jI%0 B%)3+''%7 /3)%B)%3%'(/(2D% +* ($% +=(3(/'-2'J (/7%'( K2($2' +=) +)J/'2Y/(2+'3\ K$+ K+=7- ?+'-=?( +)+D%)3%% %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3; #$+3% B%+B7% 2'?7=-%!

5=0 ,272BB%7721 [/ *+)E%) :;.; 6)E0 G272(/)0 @'(%772J%'?% +**2?%) K2($ 3%)D2?% 2'5%)E/'01 ^+)%/1 @)/e /'- 6*J$/'23(/'1 /'- /3 / ?2D272/' .B%?2/7 63323(/'( (+ ($%U2)%?(+) +* ($% C.6j;b% E+3( )%?%'(70 )%(=)'%- *)+E 3%D%)/7 K%%I3 2' 6*J$/'23(/'2' X='% Tc8c1 ?+'-=?(2'J / ?+EB)%$%'32D% /33%33E%'( *+) 3%'2+) -%*%'3% /'-2'(%772J%'?% +**2?2/73;\

U+=J +)-%) 2' TccL (+ 3(+B ($% *7+K +* 3=2?2-% >+E>%)32'(+ R/J$-/-j; 63 / ?+EE/'-%)1 U+=J )/' ($% %'(2)% 2'(%772J%'?% ?0?7%! 2-%'(2*2%-$2J$S7%D%7 (%))+)23(31 B7/''%- E2332+'3 (+ I277 +) ?/B(=)% ($%E1 7%- ($% E2332+'3B%)3+'/7701 ($%' %VB7+2(%- ($% 2'(%772J%'?% /'- %D2-%'?% J/($%)%- +' (/)J%( (+ -%*%/(>)+/-%) %'%E0 '%(K+)I3;\

6/)+' R/))1 K$+ [3%)D%- /3 ($% U2)%?(+) +* #%?$'+7+J0 *+) ($% &0>%) 3%?=)2(0 /'-.@5@C# R=32'%33 :'2( K2($2' C+)($)+B 5)=EE/']3 @'(%772J%'?% .03(%E3U2D232+'j;hb%i 3%)D%- 8T 0%/)3 2' ($% :'2(%- .(/(%3 C/D0 /3 /' %'723(%- ?)0B(+7+J23(13%'2+) 32J'/73 /'/703(1 3+*(K/)% B)+J)/EE%)1 /'- 303(%E /-E2'23()/(+)j;G); R/))$/3 B2+'%%)%- E/'0 =3%3 +* ($% @'(%)'%( /'- '%K E%-2/ *+) ($% B=)B+3%3 +*?+'-=?(2+' >)+/- 2'*+)E/(2+' +B%)/(2+'3 ?/EB/2J'3 *+) I%0 2'(%772J%'?%?=3(+E%)3;\Og

OT.?+(( ^%0%31 [:. &$/E>%)]3 M+>>023(3 .+72?2(%- ,2)E (+ @'D%3(2J/(% WBB+'%'(3] ,/E272%31&$27-)%';\ #$2'I )=/)0 8c1 Tc88; 4)2? M2B(+' /'- &$/)72% ./D/J%1 [b/?I%)3l

&7/3$ H2($ .%?=)2(0 ,2)E .B+(72J$(3 @'e=2)2%3 (+ U23?)%-2( A2D/73;\ "#$ A$? Q('< ",+$-1,%>)=/)0 8T1 Tc88;O9R%)2?+ #%?$'+7+J2%31 bR5/)0 ,%-%)/71


22/54

21

#%/E #$%E23 +**%)%- (+ 2'*27()/(% ?)2(2?3 +* ($% :;.; &$/E>%) +* &+EE%)?%; @' / [>)2%*\ *+)b='(+' _ H2772/E31 ($%0 B)+B+3% (+ [=3% ($% *+77+K2'J (/?(2?3 (+ E2(2J/(% %**%?( +*/-D%)3/)2/7 J)+=B3;\ #$%3% (/?(2?3 2'?7=-%! [U23?)%-2(1 &+'*=3%1 .$/E%1 &+E>/(1 @'*27()/(%1,)/?(=)%;\ #$%0 B)+B+3%- =32'J ($%3% (/?(2?3 /J/2'3( ($% &%'(%) *+) 6E%)2?/' %)( H%233E/'1 B)%32-%'( +* 72? &2(2Y%';OO

9#7JKL (COCKJS\9EMFNM ^ =GSSGJIV\#JMY NT "ICKGDJ HVZ =GYG$CJYV

@' 7/(% C+D%E>%) Tc8c1 X=72/' 633/'J%1 %-2(+)S2'S?$2%* +* ($% '+'B)+*2( E%-2/ +)J/'2Y/(2+'H2I2M%/I31 /''+='?%- $23 2'(%'(2+' (+ [(/I% -+K'\ / (+B :;.; >/'I /'- )%D%/7 / ?+))=B(2+'3?/'-/7 K2($2' 2(; R/'I +* 6E%)2?/ K/3 -%%B70 ?+'?%)'%- ($/( 2( E2J$( >% ($% 3=>N%?( +*H2I2M%/I3] =B?+E2'J )%D%7/(2+'3;OQ bR5/)0 ,%-%)/7 )%3B+'-%- (+ ($%3% %D%'(3 K2($ / N+2'(B)+B+3/7 (+ b='(+' _ H2772/E3 Z /7+'J K2($


23/54

22

6' 2EB72?2( ($)%/( (+ )=2' ($% ?/)%%) +* 57%'' 5)%%'K/7-1 / B)+E2'%'( N+=)'/723(1 2*$% ?+'(2'=%3 (+ 3=BB+)( H2I2M%/I3;Of

@' +($%) -+?=E%'(3 B)%3%'(%- (+ b='(+' _ H2772/E31 *+) 2(3 ?72%'( R/'I +* 6E%)2?/1 bR5/)0,%-%)/7 >+/3(3 +* 2(3 [@W h@'*+)E/(2+' WB%)/(2+'3i G2332+' 4VB%)(23%;\ @'*+)E/(2+'

WB%)/(2+'3 23 / E272(/)0 (%)E *+) %7%?()+'2? K/)*/)%; bR5/)0 ,%-%)/7 /73+ +**%)%- 2(3%VB%)(23% 2' [&+EB=(%) C%(K+)I 6((/?I\1 [&=3(+E E/7K/)% -%D%7+BE%'(\1 [&+EB=(%)C%(K+)I 4VB7+2(/(2+'\1 /'- [B%)323(%'( 3+*(K/)% 2EB7/'(3\;Oo

#$% :;.; U%B/)(E%'( +* X=3(2?% /BB%/)3 (+ $/D% B7/0%- / I%0 )+7% 2' ($%3% %D%'(3; "#$ "$6#L$'/*2)%B+)(%- ($/( [b='(+' /'- H2772/E3 K%)% )%?+EE%'-%- (+ R/'I +* 6E%)2?/]3J%'%)/7 ?+='3%7 >0 ($% U%B/)(E%'( +* X=3(2?%1 /??+)-2'J (+ ($% %E/27 ?$/2' D2%K%- >0 #$%#%?$ b%)/7-;\Qc@* ($23 23 ()=%1 2( )/23%3 ($% e=%3(2+' +* K$%($%) ($% X=3(2?% U%B/)(E%'(/3323(%- R/'I +* 6E%)2?/ 2' 2(3 >/((7% /J/2'3( H2I2M%/I31 /'- $+K E=?$ X=3(2?% U%B/)(E%'(+**2?2/73 I'%K +* /'- %D%' 3=BB+)(%- ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( H2I2M%/I3 /'- 2(3 /772%3;

)PCHKNM\AKNSS GM %DEJONK

@' 6=J=3( Tc8c1 / N+=)'/723( '/E%- G/)0 &=--%$% K)+(% />+=( ($% %**+)(3 >0 ^)+771Q8/J2/'( B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 *2)E1 (+ )%?)=2( $%) /3 / [?+)B+)/(% 3B0\ *+) &$%D)+'; #$%?+EB/'0 $/3 >%%' ()02'J ='3=??%33*=770 (+ 3(/D% +** / qo;L >2772+' *2'% /)232'J *)+E /7/K3=2( /77%J2'J ($/( #%V/?+QT3B277%- 99c E2772+' J/77+'3 +* +27 /)+='- M/J+ 6J)2+1 4?=/-+);#$% 3B277 >)+=J$( ?/'?%) /'- +($%) -23%/3%3 (+ 7+?/7 )%32-%'(3; 6??+)-2'J (+ &=--%$%1 ^)+77+**%)%- $%) qTc1ccc (+ B+3% /3 / N+=)'/723( K$27% ?+'-=?(2'J 2'(%)D2%K3 (+ ='-%)E2'% /3(=-0 +* ($% $%/7($ %**%?(3 +* ($% +27 3B277; .$% K)+(%1 [@* @ K%'( (+ M/J+ 6J)2+ /3 E03%7* /'-B)%(%'-%- (+ K)2(% / 3(+)01 '+ +'% K+=7- 3=3B%?( ($/( ($% 3(/))0S%0%- 0+='J 6E%)2?/'

B+I2'J /)+='- K/3 /?(=/770 3$2772'J *+) &$%D)+';\ &=--%$% (=)'%- -+K' ($% E+'%01 /'-2'3(%/- B%''%- / ?$/)E2'J /)(2?7% />+=( $%) %VB%)2%'?% 2' "#$ I.*/3.,6;Q9

Of[#$% H2I2M%/I3 #$)%/(! 6' WD%)D2%K >0


24/54

23

=JSIJKF HVZ -U "WJGMVF FPC =JS

,+) 0%/)31 H/7E/)( $/3 E/2'(/2'%- / )+>=3( ?+)B+)/(% 2'(%772J%'?% /'- 3%?=)2(0-%B/)(E%'(1 3(/**%- >0 / [(%/E +* *+)E%) +**2?2/73 *)+E ($% &;@;6;1 ,;R;@; /'- X=3(2?%

U%B/)(E%'(1\ /??+)-2'J (+ ($% A$? Q('< ",+$-;Qg

@' G/)?$ TccQ1 H/7E/)(]3 [#$)%/( A%3%/)?$ /'- 6'/70323 5)+=B\ *2)%- R)=?% 5/>>/)-1 /?+EB=(%) (%?$'2?2/'1 *+) ='/=($+)2Y%- )%?+)-2'J +* ?+'D%)3/(2+'3 >%(K%%' H/7E/)( /'- /A$? Q('< ",+$-)%B+)(%)1 G2?$/%7 R/)>/)+1 /'- 2'(%)?%B(2'J H/7E/)( ?+77%/J=%3] (%V(E%33/J%3; 6*(%) 7%/D2'J H/7E/)(1 5/>>/)- -23?7+3%- 3+E% +* H/7E/)(]3 3=)D%277/'?%B)/?(2?%31 2'?7=-2'J (/)J%(2'J ?2(2Y%'3 J)+=B3 /'- ?)2(2?3; 6??+)-2'J (+ ($% K/** @.'$$.O(1'3/*1

[@' 7/(% 3B)2'J TccO1 H/7SG/)( 7%/)'%- ($/( 3%D%)/7 /'(2SH/7SG/)( J)+=B3E2J$( B)+(%3( /( ($% /''=/7 3$/)%$+7-%)3 E%%(2'J 2' X='%; &+EB/'0

%V%?=(2D%3 K%)% ?+'?%)'%- ($% ?2D27S)2J$(3 J)+=B 6?+)' `($% 633+?2/(2+' +*&+EE='2(0 W)J/'2Y/(2+'3 *+) A%*+)E C+Kd /'- 7+?/7 :B 6J/2'3( ($% H/7E%E>%)3 K+=7- -23)=B( 2(3 E%%(2'J; H/7SG/)( 3%'( / 7+'JS$/2)%- %EB7+0%%K%/)2'J / K2)%7%33 E2?)+B$+'% (+ :B 6J/2'3( ($% H/7l3 ,/0%((%D277%1 6)I;1J/($%)2'J1 /'- %/D%3-)+BB%- *)+E '%/)>01 3/03 5/>>/)-; kH% *+77+K%-/)+='- ($% B%)2E%(%) K2($ / 3=)D%277/'?% D/'1m $% 3/03;]\QL

`SCDFKGDGFa OC (KJMDC HVZ 7KCCMUCJDC

W' C+D%E>%) 8c1 Tc881 ($% ,)%'?$ =(272(0 z7%?()2?2({ -% ,)/'?% K/3 *2'%- 8;L E2772+' 4=)+3

*+) $/?I2'J 2'(+ ($% ?+EB=(%)3 +* 5)%%'B%/?% ,)/'?%; 4U, K/3 /73+ )%e=2)%- (+ B/0 /'/--2(2+'/7 Lcc1ccc 4=)+3 2' -/E/J%3 (+ 5)%%'B%/?% ,)/'?%; 4U, $2)%- ($% B)2D/(%2'(%772J%'?% *2)E ^/)J=3 &+'3=7(/'(31 K$2?$ 2' (=)' 277%J/770 +>(/2'%- / ?+B0 +* ($% $/)--)2D% +* a/''2?I X/-+(1 ($% *+)E%) ?/EB/2J' -2)%?(+) +* 5)%%'B%/?% ,)/'?%; #$2%))0 M+)$+1($% $%/- +* ^/)J=3 &+'3=7(/'(31 K/3 3%'(%'?%- (+ ($)%% 0%/)3 2' B)23+'1 (K+ +* K$2?$ K%)%3=3B%'-%-; 4U,]3 *+)E%) $%/- +* '=?7%/) B)+-=?(2+' 3%?=)2(01


25/54

24

#$% 3(+)0 +* ($% $/?I2'J /'- 2(3 -23?+D%)0 23 E/J'2*2?%'(70 ?+'D+7=(%-; @' Tcco1 / ,)%'?$2'D%3(2J/(2'J N=-J% '/E%- #$+E/3 &/33=(+ /??2-%'(/770 ='?+D%)%- ($/( z7%?()2?2({ -%,)/'?% $/- 3B2%- +' 5)%%'B%/?% ,)/'?%1 /'- /BB/)%'(70 +($%) 5)%%'B%/?% +**2?%3 2'4=)+B% /3 K%77; 4U, 23 ($% K+)7- 7/)J%3( +B%)/(+) +* '=?7%/) B+K%) B7/'(3; @( 23 fLv

+K'%- >0 ($% ,)%'?$ J+D%)'E%'(; 5)%%'B%/?% $/3 7+'J ?/EB/2J'%- /J/2'3( ($% =3% +*'=?7%/) B+K%);QQ

6??+)-2'J (+ ($% M3.$'3/.,(3/* L$'/*2 "',)13$1 ($% ,)%'?$ N=-J%]3 2'D%3(2J/(2+' +* /3%B/)/(% $/?I2'J +B%)/(2+' K/3

[B2?I%- =B >0 / 3B%?2/7 ?0>%)?)2E% ='2( +* ($% ,)%'?$ @'(%)2+) G2'23()01 h/'-i7%- (+ / ,)%'?$ ?+EB=(%) 3B%?2/723(1 67/2' w=2)+3j;;63 ($% ,)%'?$ /=($+)2(2%3-%7D%- E+)% -%%B70 2'(+ G); w=2)+3l3 ?+EB=(%)1 ($%0 *+='- / ?+B0 +* ($% $/)--)2D% +* a/''2?I X/-+(1 ($% *+)E%) ?/EB/2J' -2)%?(+) +* 5)%%'B%/?% ,)/'?%1/3 K%77 /3 ($/( +* ,){-{)2IS^/)%7 &/'+01 / ,)%'?$ 7/K0%) /'- 3$/)%$+7-%)

)2J$(3 /?(2D23( K$+ $/3 >/((7%- 3+E% +* ($% ?+='()0l3 7/)J%3( ?+EB/'2%312'?7=-2'J P2D%'-2 /'- 4=)+B%/' 6%)+'/=(2? U%*%'3% _ .B/?%1 ($% B/)%'( +*($% /2)?)/*( E/'=*/?(=)%) 62)>=3j;G); M+)$+ h/ *+)E%) ,)%'?$ 2'(%772J%'?%/J%'( /'- $%/- +* ^/)J=3 &+'3=7(/'(3i /73+ /-E2((%- ($/( $% $/- ?+77%?(%--/(/ +' 5)%%'B%/?%; b23 ?72%'( ($/( (2E%1 $% 3/2-1 K/3 z7%?()2?2({ -% ,)/'?%1K$2?$ $/- B/2- $2E *+) k3()/(%J2? 2'(%772J%'?%] +' /'(2S'=?7%/) ?/EB/2J'%)3;G); M+)$+ $/3 3/2- $23 ?+'(/?(3 /( 4;U;,; K%)% kB%)*%?(70 /K/)%] +* ($% $/?I2'J/'- ($/( 3=?$ /?(2D2(2%3 K%)% ='-%)3(++- (+ >% 2'?7=-%- ='-%) ($% (K+ +'%S0%/) ?+'()/?(3 $% 32J'%- K2($ ($% ?+EB/'0j;#$% 2'D%3(2J/(2+' *+='- ($/( 2'/--2(2+' (+ 2'*+)E/(2+' +' 5)%%'B%/?% 2' ,)/'?%1 4;U;,; +>(/2'%- -/(/ +' ($%%'D2)+'E%'(/7 +)J/'2Y/(2+'l3 /?(2D2(2%3 2' .B/2'1 R%7J2=E /'- R)2(/2'1 K$%)%

4;U;,; 7/3( 0%/) /J)%%- (+ >=0 ($% 7/)J%3( '=?7%/) B+K%) ?+EB/'0 ($%)%1R)2(23$ 4'%)J0j; @' /' 2'(%)D2%K K2($ /' 2'(%772J%'?% H%> 32(%1M%)%'3%2J'%E%'(;?+E1 G); M+)$+ 3/2- $% /33=E%- k*=77 )%3B+'32>272(0] *+)$/?I2'J 2'(+ ($% 5)%%'B%/?% ?+EB=(%)1 >=( $% /--%- ($/( ll@ K+=7- 72I% (+ 3%%4;U;,;1 K$2?$ 3B+'3+)%- ($% +B%)/(2+'1 (/I% )%3B+'32>272(0 *+) 2(3 B/)(;llQf

#$%)% 23 %D2-%'?% ($/( 4U, '+( +'70 3B2%- +' 5)%%'B%/?% ,)/'?%1 >=( +($%) 5)%%'B%/?%+**2?%3 2' 4=)+B%; 6??+)-2'J (+ ($% J1/'2,/31

[6 ,)%'?$ 2'D%3(2J/(2+' 2'(+ /77%J/(2+'3 ($/( ,)/'?%l3 3(/(% %'%)J0 J2/'( 4U,3B2%- +' 5)%%'B%/?% $/3 (/I%' / '%K (=)' /*(%) / 3=JJ%3(2+' 2' ?+=)(

-+?=E%'(3 ($/( ($% ?+EB/'0 E/0 $/D% E+'2(+)%- %'D2)+'E%'(/723(3 /?)+334=)+B%1 2'?7=-2'J R)2(/2'j;h#$%i ,)%'?$ '%K3 K%>32(% G%-2/B/)(1 K$2?$ $/33%%' -+?=E%'(3 *)+E ($% 2'D%3(2J/(2+'1 ($23 K%%I B=>723$%- %V()/?(3 +* ($%

QQ[C=?7%/) &+'*72?(;\ "#$ X6(3(+,-.1 6B)27 T91 Tcco;QfU/D2- X+7701 [&0?72'J @'e=2)0 4VB+3%3 &+)B+)/(% H+)7- +* .B2%3 /'- b/?I%)3;\ #$%@'(%)'/(2+'/7 b%)/7- #)2>='%1 6=J=3( 81 Tcco; .%% /73+ 6'J%72e=% &$)23/*231 [4'%)J0 R+336??=3%- W* .B02'J W' 5)%%'B%/?%;\ 5=/)-2/'1 6B)27 T1 Tcco;


26/54

25

(%3(2E+'0 >0 /' 4U, 3%?=)2(0 %V%?=(2D% /'- *+)E%) B+72?% ?+EE/'-%) K$+ 23='-%) 2'D%3(2J/(2+' *+) ?+'3B2)2'J (+ ?+'-=?( 277%J/7 3=)D%277/'?%j;63I%-/>+=( / &US)+E +* 2'*+)E/(2+' *)+E -%(%?(2D%3 ($/( K/3 *+='- 2' $23 +**2?%3/*%1 $% 3/2- 2( ?+'(/2'%- 2'*+)E/(2+' />+=( %'D2)+'E%'(/7 J)+=B 3()=?(=)%3/'- 3=EE/)2%3 +* E%%(2'J3; k@( K/3 / e=%3(2+' +* ($% h5)%%'B%/?%i '+'S

J+D%)'E%'(/7 J)+=Bl3 +)J/'23/(2+' 2' R%7J2=E1 .B/2'1 B%)$/B3 R)2(/2'1 7%(l33/0 4=)+B%1] $% /--%-;\Qo

%Z'*\+DNFFGVP 1CVNEKDCV 7KNEU\+DNFFGVP 6NRCK\/CKGDNSJ\1CQCDDJ !NOO HVZ FPC )JIUTNK )SGIJFC "DFGNM

#$% &/EB *+) &72E/(% 6?(2+' `[&72E/(% &/EB\d 23 / ?72E/(% /?(2D23( J)+=B ($/( 3(/)(%- 2' ($%:^; @( 3=BB+)(3 -%?+EE2332+'2'J +* ?+/7S*2)%- B+K%) B7/'(3 (+ E2(2J/(% ?/)>+' -2+V2-%%E2332+'3 ($/( ?/=3% ?72E/(% ?$/'J%; W' W?(+>%) 8QS8f1 Tcco1 /BB)+V2E/(%70 81ccc/?(2D23(3 *)+E &72E/(% &/EB /'- +($%) J)+=B3 J/($%)%- (+ ?+'-=?( ?2D27 -23+>%-2%'?% (+

3$=( -+K' ($% A/(?72**%S+'S.+/) ?+/7 B7/'(;fc

.2V(%%' E+'($3 7/(%)1 ($% J1/'2,/3)%B+)(%- ($/( ($)%% 7/)J% %'%)J0 ?+EB/'2%3 $2)%- ($%B)2D/(% 3%?=)2(0 *2)E P%)2?+7/ (+ 2'*27()/(% ($% ?72E/(% ?$/'J% /?(2D23(3;f8#$% ?+EB/'2%3?+'-=?(2'J ($% %3B2+'/J% K%)%!

4;WC1 [+'% +* ($% K+)7-l3 7/)J%3( 2'D%3(+)S+K'%- B+K%) /'- J/3 ?+EB/'2%3; 6(*/?272(2%3 /?)+33 4=)+B%1 A=332/1 /'- C+)($ 6E%)2?/1 +=) E+)% ($/' QT1ccc%EB7+0%%3 J%'%)/(%- /BB)+V; 4:A89T >2772+' 2' 3/7%3 2' Tc8T;\fT @( 23 ?=))%'(70 ($%K+)7-]3 8L($7/)J%3( ?+EB/'0;

.?+((23$ A%3+=)?%3 5)+=B1 [($% 7/)J%3( 3=)*/?% E2'2'J ?+/7 B)+-=?%) 2' ($% :^ /'-($% ?+='()0l3 3%?+'- 7/)J%3( ?+/7 E2'2'J ?+EB/'0;\f9

.?+((23$ 32-2/)0 +* @>%)-)+7/1 / J7+>/7 ,+)(='% Lcc ?+EB/'0 /'- ($%9o($7/)J%3( %'%)J0 ?+EB/'0 2' ($% K+)7-;fg

Qo6'J%72e=% &$)23/*231 [4U, .B2%- +' 4'D2)+'E%'(/723(3 2' R)2(/2'1 &+=)( U+?=E%'(3.=JJ%3(;\ J1/'2,/31 6B)27 8Q1 Tcco;fcG/(( ,+)-1 [#$% 4?+ 6?(2D23(3 H$+ 6)% &/EB2'J 6J/2'3( &72E/(% &$/'J%;\ &CC1 W?(+>%)Tc1 Tcco; G/(( U2?I2'3+' /'- U/'2%77% UK0%)1 [


27/54

26

6??+)-2'J (+ %E/273 +>(/2'%- >0 ($% J1/'2,/31 P%)2?+7/]3 ?$2%* %V%?=(2D%1 A%>%??/ #+--3B2%- +' /?(2D23(3 >0 =32'J [/72/3 %E/27 /--)%33%3 (+ %VB)%33 /' 2'(%)%3( 2' ?/EB/2J'313=>3?)2>2'J (+ /?(2D23(S+'70 E/272'J 723(3j2' X=70 Tcco1 #+-- 3/2- 3$% K/3 /' /?(2D23(jK$+K/'(%- (+ E/I% k/ B+32(2D% ?+'()2>=(2+' (+ ($% B7/'%(];\fL

#EKWCK AGMW JMO 4GUSNIJFGD !JDFGDJS +CKHGDCV HVZ FPC )NJSGFGNM NT .IINYJSCC =NKYCKV

#$% &+/72(2+' *+) @EE+I/7%% H+)I%)3 23 / ?+EE='2(0 +)J/'2Y/(2+' ($/( /-D+?/(%3 *+) ($%2'(%)%3(3 +* 7+KSK/J% 2EE2J)/'( K+)I%)3 2' ,7+)2-/; @' Tccf1 &@H K/3 ?+'-=?(2'J /?/EB/2J' /J/2'3( R=)J%) ^2'J1 )%J/)-2'J ($% ?+EB/'0]3 )%*=3/7 (+ B)+D2-% */2)?+EB%'3/(2+' (+ (+E/(+ B2?I%)3;

W'% -/01 &@H +)J/'2Y%) G/)? A+-)2J=%3 (++I / ?/77 *)+E &/)/ .?$/**%)1 K$+ ?7/2E%- 3$%K/3 / 3(=-%'( /( R)+K/)- &+EE='2(0 &+77%J%; .$% K/'(%- (+ D+7='(%%) *+) &@H; R=(

A+-)2J=%3 >%?/E% 3=3B2?2+=3 K$%' .?$/**%) /3I%- />+=( /' =B?+E2'J ?+'*%)%'?% ?/77;H$%' A+-)2J=%3 J++J7%- .?$/**%)1 $% *+='- ($/( 3$% +K'3 U2B7+E/(2? #/?(2?/7 .%)D2?%31 [/3%?=)2(0 /'- 2'D%3(2J/(2D% *2)E ($/( /-D%)(23%3 2(3 />272(0 (+ B7/?% k+B%)/(2D%3] 2' ($% )/'I3 +*(/)J%( J)+=B3;\fO

R=)J%) ^2'J $/3 ?+'*2)E%- ($/( 2( $2)%- U2B7+E/(2? #/?(2?/7 3%)D2?%3 [*+) 0%/)3\ /'- =3%- 2((+ +>(/2' 2'*+)E/(2+' />+=( &@H]3 B7/'31 /'- ($/( [X+$' &$2-3%01 ($% ?$2%* %V%?=(2D% +*R=)J%) ^2'J1 I'%K />+=( ($% =3% +* U2B7+E/(2? #/?(2?/7 .%)D2?%3;\fQ

!PC 6PJKIJDCEFGDJS1CVCJKDP JMO 0JMETJDFEKCKV "VVNDGJFGNM JMO NFPCKV HVZ _JICV$NHC\AMNRSCOWC %DNSNWL .MFCKMJFGNMJS

X/E%3 M+D% 23 ($% U2)%?(+) +* ^'+K7%-J% 4?+7+J0 @'(%)'/(2+'/71 /' +)J/'2Y/(2+' ($/( K+)I3(+ 2EB)+D% /??%33 (+ %33%'(2/7 -)=J31 (+ )%-=?% B$/)E/?%=(2?/7 -)=J B)2?%3 K+)7-K2-%1 /'-(+ B)+(%?( ?+'3=E%)3 2' ?+B0)2J$(; M+D% 23 /' /K/)-SK2''2'J /-D+?/(%p 2' TccO1 ^4@ K+' /G/?6)($=) 6K/)- *+) &)%/(2D% /'- 4**%?(2D% @'3(2(=(2+'31 /'- 2' Tc891 M+D% K+' / 4D/'31 [.B%?2/7 A%B+)(! 5)%%' 5)+=B3 #/)J%(%- )=/)0 8L1 Tc88;fO6E0 R%''%(( H2772/E31 [#+E/(+


28/54

27

.$+)(70 /*(%) ($% B/33/J% +* ($% 6**+)-/>7% &/)% 6?(1 M+D% 3/03 $% )%?%2D%- / D232( 2' $23+**2?%3 *)+E / E/' K$+ 3/2- $% K/3 )%?%'(70 7%( J+ *)+E $23 N+> /( 0 ($% C/(2+'/7 ,+)%2J' #)/-% &+='?27 `C,#&d (+ B)+D2-% 2'(%772J%'?% +' C5W3 K+)I2'J +'2'(%77%?(=/7 B)+B%)(0 233=%3; M+D% 3/031 [#$%0 /BB)+/?$%- 3+E%+'% K% I'%K1 K2($ /B)+B+3/7 (+ B)+D2-% 2'*+)E/(2+' +' ^'+K7%-J% 4?+7+J0 @'(%)'/(2+'/7 /'- +($%) C5W3K+)I2'J +' 2'(%77%?(=/7 B)+B%)(0 233=%31 /3 B/)( +* / B)+J)/E (+ ?+='(%) C5W /-D+?/?0%**+)(3 +' >%$/7* +* ?+'3=E%)3;\ 4D%'(=/7701 M+D% 3/031 ($% C,#& ?+'()/?(%- K2($ ($%A+E=7=3 57+>/7 @33=%3 G/'/J%E%'(1 /' [2'(%)'/(2+'/7 B+72?0 ?+'3=7(/'?0\ ($/( /-D23%3

[3%D%)/7 E%E>%)3 +* ($% ,+)(='% 8cc;\ff#$% E/'/J2'J B/)('%) +* A+E=7=3 23 X+$' .(=>>31K$+3% K2*% 23 P2?(+)2/ 6; 43B2'%71 / *+)E%) A+E=7=3 %EB7+0%%; 43B2'%7 K/3 :;.; @'(%77%?(=/70 / B)2D/(% %0%'/E%- A2?$/)- ,)+%EE2'Jj; ,)+E 8off (+ 8oof1 ,)+%EE2'J /'- $23 3%D%)/7 3$%77 %'(2(2%3`K2($ '+ %EB7+0%%3 +) *='?(2+'3d K%)% B/2- E+)% ($/' qf;f E2772+' >0 ,%7- %'(2(2%3;\o8

#$% %3B2+'/J% +B%)/(2+'3 3=??%%-%- 2' B7/?2'J [/BB)+V2E/(%70 8O ='-%)?+D%) +B%)/(2D%3/( (/2'%- $2J$70?+'*2-%'(2/7 >/'I /??+='( '=E>%)3 /'- >/'I 2'*+)E/(2+' *)+E R/'I +* 6E%)2?/1 ?)%-2(

ff$((B!FFKKK;J+)+E=7=3;?+EFB)+*27%F;fo#+'0 A+EE1 [,+)E%) H$2(% b+=3% @< /-D23%) P2?(+)2/ 43B2'%7 (+ 7%/- R.6;\ H(*,.,6(16=J=3( Tf1 Tc89;oc[A2J$(3 5)+=B ./03 &2)?=3 .B2%- +' @(;\ "#$ A$? Q('< ",+$-1 X='% 81 TccT;o8$((B!FFKKK;B%(/;+)JF*%/(=)%3F)2'J72'JS>)+3S%7%B$/'(J/(%;/3BV;


29/54

28

?/)- 2'*+)E/(2+'1 B%)3+'/7 E%-2?/7 2'*+)E/(2+'1 ?+'*2-%'(2/7 2'(%)'/7 *2'/'?2/7 )%?+)-31 /'-B%)3+''%7 2'*+)E/(2+';\oT

@' /--2(2+'1 >+($ @/*(3/'- ($% K/-#,34.(3 H(-.B=>723$%- 7+'J /)(2?7%3 )%?+='(2'J ($%%7/>+)/(% %2J$(S0%/) %**+)(3 +* ^%''%($ ,%7- /'- &7/2) 5%+)J% (+ 32-%()/?I / *)%%7/'?%

)%B+)(%) *)+E K)2(2'J />+=( /'2E/7 K%7*/)% 3?/'-/73 K2($2' ($% ?2)?=3;o9

#"% HVZ )JIUJGWM "WJGMVF FPC "KIV !KJOC

@' .%B(%E>%) Tcc91 ($% @132/0 ",+$-+* M+'-+' )%B+)(%- ($/( R64 .03(%E3ogSS ($% K+)7-]3>2JJ%3( K%/B+'3 *2)EoLSS $/- $2)%- / B)2D/(% 2'(%772J%'?%SJ/($%)2'J *2)E (+ 2'*27()/(%/?(2D23(3 +BB+3%- (+ ($% J7+>/7 /)E3 ()/-%;oO 6??+)-2'J (+ ($% @132/0 ",+$-1 R64 B/2-8Tc1ccc B%) 0%/) [*+) /( 7%/3( *+=) 0%/)3\ (+ / ?+'3=7(/'?0 7%- >0 4D%70' M% &$%'% (+2'*27()/(% ($% &/EB/2J' 6J/2'3( 6)E3 #)/-%; #$% J)+=B K/3 2'*27()/(%- [>0 /( 7%/3( $/7* /-+Y%' /J%'(3 2' ($% 8ooc3;\ U=)2'J ($23 (2E%1 &66# +BB+3%- ($% 3/7% +* R64]3 b/KI N%(3 (+

@'-+'%32/; 6??+)-2'J (+ ($% @132/0 ",+$-1 /J%'(3 K+)I2'J *+) R64

[-+K'7+/-%- ?+EB=(%) *27%31 )2*7%- ($)+=J$ B%)3+'/7 -2/)2%31 ?+'-=?(%-3=)D%277/'?% +' ?/EB/2J'%)3 /'- B/33%- +' >/'I /??+='( -%(/273; M%((%)3 (+/'- *)+E 3%'2+) M/>+=) B+72(2?2/'3 2'?7=-2'J X/?I .()/K K$%' $% K/3 $+E%3%?)%(/)01 ($% G< 6'' &7K0- /'- U/D2- &7/)I K$27% $% K/3 ($% +BB+32(2+'3B+I%3E/' +' -%*%'?%1 K%)% ?+B2%- /'- 3%'( (+ R64; G%%(2'J3 K2($ G%?/=3% R64 3%?=)%- ($% 3%)D2?%3 +*[B%)$/B3 ($% E+3( 3=??%33*=7 ?+)B+)/(% 3B0 +* )%?%'( (2E%31 G/)(2' b+J>2';\ 6??+)-2'J (+

($% J1/'2,/31 [@' Tcc9 3%?=)2(0 ?+'3=7(/'( 4D%70' M% &$%'% K/3 /77%J%- (+ $/D% >%%')%?%2D2'J %E/273 *)+E b+J>2'1 Lf1 K$+ $/- 3B%'( 32V 0%/)3 )232'J ($)+=J$ ($% &66#; .+3=??%33*=7 K/3 ($% /77%J%- +B%)/(2+' ($/( b+J>2' >%?/E% / (/)J%( *+) G%( 3=)D%277/'?%;W**2?%)3 K%)% ?+'D2'?%- $% K/3 / I%0 k-+E%3(2? %V()%E23(];\of

oT$((B!FFKKK;B%(/;+)JF*%/(=)%3F)2'J72'JS>)+3S%7%B$/'(J/(%;/3BV;o9X%** .(%2'1 [#$% 5)%/(%3( P%'-%((/ +' 4/)($;\ @/*(31 6=J=3( 9c1 Tcc8; X%** .(%2'1 [.%'- 2'($% &7+K'3;\ @/*(31 6=J=3( 981 Tcc8; A2?$/)- M%2>01 [.%'- 2' ($% &7+K'3;\ "#$ K/-#,34.(3H(-.1 C+D%E>%) Tc1 TccL;og:'(27 C+D%E>%) 8ooo1 R64 .03(%E3 K/3 ?/77%- R)2(23$ 6%)+3B/?%;oL[.@)=/)0 891 TccQ;oQ[6)E3 ,2)E H/J%- U2)(0 H/) W' %) Tf1 Tcc9;of


30/54

29

@' TccQ1 ($% &/EB/2J' 6J/2'3( ($% 6)E3 #)/-% (++I 7%J/7 /?(2+' (+ *+)?% -23?7+3=)% +* ($%3B02'J; @( ='?+D%)%- ($/( %%' B/2- T1Lcc B%) E+'($ >0 R64]3 3%?=)2(0-%B/)(E%'( (+ 3B0 +' &66#; 6??+)-2'J (+ ($% J1/'2,/31

[G); G%)?%) +>(/2'%- / &U K2($ -%(/273 +* ?+'*2-%'(2/7 7%J/7 /-D2?% )%?%2D%-

*)+E ($% B%/?% ?/EB/2J'%)3l 7/K0%)3 /'- /( ($% %'- +* 7/3( 0%/) B/33%- 2( (+G2?$/%7 G?52'(01 $%/- +* R64l3 3%?=)2(0 -%B/)(E%'(j;#$% 72(2J/(2+' )%D%/7%-($/( G); G%)?%)1 K$+ $/- / $23(+)0 +* 2'*27()/(2'J B%/?% J)+=B3 3=?$ /3 &CUh&/EB/2J' *+) C=?7%/) U23/)E/E%'(i1 $/- -23J=23%- $23 -%/72'J3 K2($ R64*)+E $23 $+E% 2' M+=J$>+)+=J$j;#$% G%)?%) +B%)/(2+' ?/E% (+ 72J$( >%?/=3%R64 B/33%- ($% 2'*+)E/(2+' (+ 2(3 7/K0%)31 677%' _ WD%)01 K$+ -%?2-%- ($%0$/- (+ -23?7+3% 2( (+ ($% ?+=)(; R64 ($%' *+=J$( (+ )%323( -23?7+3=)% +* ($%2)/J%'(l3 2-%'(2(0;\oo

7SNQJS 'UCM

.%D%)/7 '%K3 /)(2?7%3 )%B+)( ($/( 57+>/7 WB%' ?+'-=?(3 %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2(+)J/'2Y/(2+'3; 6??+)-2'J (+ 2(3 K%>32(%1 57+>/7 WB%' `4=)+B%d [/-D23%3 +=) %V23(2'J >/3% +*E+)% ($/' oc ?72%'(3\8cc/'- B)+D2-%3 3%)D2?%3 3=?$ /3 2'(%772J%'?% J/($%)2'J *+) [?72%'(3 /(/ E+)% 3%)2+=3 7%D%7 +* ($)%/( *)+E /?(2D23E;\ .=?$ 3%)D2?%3 2'?7=-%1 *+) %V/EB7%1 / [TgS$+=) K/)'2'J 3%)D2?% 2'-2?/(2'J1 K$%)%D%) B+332>7%1 2* / ?+EB/'0 23 />+=( (+ >% (/)J%(%-1\/'- [h2iEE%-2/(% ?2)?=7/(2+' +* '%K /?(2D23( (/?(2?31\ /'- [h?i2)?=7/(2+' +* ($% E+D%E%'( +*/?(2D23( J)+=B3;\8c86??+)-2'J (+ ($% J1/'2,/31

[#$% ?+EB/'0 >%3(SI'+K' *+) E+'2(+)2'J B)+(%3( J)+=B3 23 57+>/7 WB%'1*+='-%- / -%?/-% /J+ >0 A+- M%%E2'J1 / *+)E%) 3B%?2/7 >)/'?$ +**2?%)jh@(i

E/2'(/2'3 k/ -23?)%%( K/(?$] +' B)+(%3( J)+=B3 ($/( ?+=7- -/E/J% / *2)El3)%B=(/(2+'; @( 23 ='-%)3(++- (+ $/D% +**%)%- (+ %EB7+0 3%D%)/7 %VSB+72?%+**2?%)31 2'?7=-2'J hG/)Ii ^%''%-01 K$+ 3/2- $% K/3 $2)%- >0 M%%E2'J 7/3(0%/)j;&+=)( -+?=E%'(3 )%D%/7 57+>/7 WB%' (+ >% +'% +* (K+ ?+EB/'2%32'D+7D%- 2' ($% E+'2(+)2'J +* ($% &/EB/2J' 6J/2'3( ($% 6)E3 #)/-% *+) /)E3E/'=*/?(=)%) R64;\8cT

ooA+> 4D/'3 /'- U/D2- M%2J$1 [R64 .B0 C/E%- R0 &/EB/2J'%)3 @3 ,)2%'- W* M%/-2'J #+)0;\J1/'2,/31 6B)27 8o1 TccQ; .%% /73+ G/)I #$+E/31 [G/)(2' /'- G%;\ J1/'2,/31 U%?%E>%) g1TccQ;8cc$((B!FFKKK;J7+>/7+B%'S=I;?+EF/>+=(x=3F8c8$((B!FFKKK;J7+>/7+B%'S=I;?+EF3%)D2?%3F8cT


31/54

30

.MYCKIJM 7KNEU JMO )bG HVZ 6SJMC +FEUGO

6??+)-2'J (+ ($% J1/'2,/31 /'+($%) ?+EB/'0 ($/( ?+'-=?(3 [E+'2(+)2'J h+*i B)+(%3(%)3\ 23($% @'I%)E/' 5)+=B; 6??+)-2'J (+ 2(3 K%>32(%1 ($% @'I%)E/' 5)+=B 23 /' [2'(%)'/(2+'/7

>=32'%33 )23I /'- 2'(%772J%'?% ?+EB/'0;\8c9 #$% 5=/)-2/' )%B+)(3 ($/( ($% @'I%)E/' 5)+=B

[%EB7+03 *+)E%) G%( ?+EE2332+'%) M+)- @E>%)( /3 / 3()/(%J2? /-D23%); 6k)%3()2?(%-] )%B+)( B)+-=?%- >0 ($% ?+EB/'0 ($)%% 0%/)3 /J+ K/)'3 +* /J)+K2'J ($)%/( +* k%?+S(%))+)23E]; :'-%) / 3%?(2+' +' k)%?%'( /?(3 +* %?+S(%))+)23E]1 ($% -+?=E%'( 723(3 / '=E>%) +* B%/?%*=7 ?/EB/2J' J)+=B312'?7=-2'J ($% /'(2S/D2/(2+' ?+77%?(2D% 0 #+>0 ^%'-/771 K$+ K+)I%-*+) /'+($%) 3%?=)2(0 *2)E1 &T2 @'(%)'/(2+'/7; b% B+3%- /3 k^%' #+>2/3] 2' /'/((%EB( (+ 2'*27()/(% ($% /'(2S/D2/(2+' ?+77%?(2D% /??+&+)B; b% 7/(%) >%?/E% B%)$/B3 ($% E+3( 2EB+)(/'( (+>/??+ 2'-=3()0 K$23(7%>7+K%) %D%);H2J/'- E/-% / '=E>%) +* $2J$SB)+*27% /77%J/(2+'3 /J/2'3( ($% ?+EB/'01 2'?7=-2'J ($/(R_H &$/2)E/' #$+E/3 ./'-%*=) 72%- (+ &+'J)%33 ='-%) +/($ />+=( '2?+(2'% /--2?(2+';

6??+)-2'J (+ ($% K/** @.'$$. O(1'3/*1 R_H )%3B+'-%- >0 $2)2'J / [*+)E2-/>7% (%/E\ +*7/K0%)3 /'- B)2D/(% -%(%?(2D%3 (+ 2'D%3(2J/(% /'- -23?)%-2( $2E1 2'?7=-2'J!

[7/K0%)3 *)+E ($% >2J C%K a+)I *2)E &$/->+=)'% _ 0 / *+)E%) h/'- ?=))%'(i C%Ka+)I &2(0 B+72?% ?+EE2332+'%)1 A/0E+'- ^%770; #$23 23 ($% *2)E @D/'/ #)=EB$2)%- (+ 2'D%3(2J/(% $%) )2D/7 G/)7/ G/B7%3 /'- ($/( .%'; 4-K/)- ^%''%-0=3%- (+ ?$%?I 2'(+ /' +BB+'%'( 2' $23 8oog ?/EB/2J';\8cL

8c9$((B!FFKKK;2'I%)E/';?+EFJ>F$+E%;8cg


32/54

31

#$%O(1'3/*)%B+)(%- ($/(

[A%B)%3%'(/(2D%3 +* R_H +**%)%- ($% *)=2(3 +* ($%2) 2'D%3(2J/(2+' (+ "#$ K/**

@.'$$. O(1'3/*! / LccSB/J% *27% >%/)2'J ($% (2(7% k#$% G23?+'-=?( +* X%**)%0 .;H2J/'- 6D/27/>7% 2' ($% 72? A%?+)-;] .=>$%/-2'J3 2'?7=-% kH2J/'-l3 M2%36>+=( b23 A%32-%'?%1] kH2J/'-l3 M2%3 :'-%) W/($] /'- kW($%) M2%3 R0 H2J/'-;]6 ?7+3% 7++I /( ($% *27%1 /'- 2'-%B%'-%'( )%3%/)?$ >0 ($23 '%K3B/B%) 2'(+ 2(3I%0 ?7/2E31 2'-2?/(%3 ($/( E/'0 +* ($% 3%)2+=3 /77%J/(2+'3 /J/2'3( G); H2J/'-/)% >/?I%- >0 3?/'( +) ?+'()/-2?(+)0 %D2-%'?%; .+E% +* ($% ?$/)J%3 SS2'?7=-2'J ($/( $% B7%/-%- J=27(0 (+ 3$+B72*(2'J SS /)% -%E+'3()/>70 ='()=%;\

+PCSS\#6\0JMTKCO +DPSGDYCMKGCOCK\9JYSELF HVZ 7KCCMUCJDC

@' Tcc81 ($% @132/0 ",+$-+* M+'-+' )%B+)(%- ($/( ($% B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(2D% *2)E b/?I7=0(1K$2?$ $/3 [?7+3% 72'I3\ (+ ($% R)2(23$ 3B0 /J%'?0 G@O1 $2)%- / 3B0 '/E%- G/'*)%-.?$72?I%')2%-%) (+ 2'*27()/(% 5)%%'B%/?% +' >%$/7* +* +27 ?+EB/'2%31 2'?7=-2'J .$%77 /'-R+=( ($% E+D%E%'(3 +* ($% E+(+)D%33%7 5)%%'B%/?% 2' ($% '+)($ 6(7/'(2?;\

0D4NMJSOcV HVZ $NMONM 7KCCMUCJDC

@' W?(+>%) 8ofo1 G?U+'/7-]3 $2)%- 3%D%' B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(+)3 (+ 2'*27()/(% M+'-+'5)%%'B%/?%; 6??+)-2'J (+ ($% >(- I34$*$- ",+$-1 ($% 2'*27()/(+)3 [(++I '+(%31 *+77+K%-+)J/'2Y%)3 (+ ($%2) $+E%31 3(+7% 7%((%)3 /'-1 (+ -%E+'3()/(% ($%2) >+'/ *2-%31 %/J%)70D+7='(%%)%- (+ -23()2>=(% ($% */?( 3$%%( -%'+='?2'J ($% ?+EB/'0 ($/( $/- 3%?)%(70 $2)%-($%E;\8cQ

8cOG/=)2?% &$2((%'-%' /'- C2?$+7/3 A=**+)-1 [G@O l,2)El .B2%- +' 5)%%' 5)+=B3;\ "#$@132/0 ",+$-1 X='% 8Q1 Tc88; .%% /73+ &$/B(%) O +* 4D%72'% M=>>%)31 @$6'$. E/3($15'$- ,3.#$ B/'


33/54

32

+FKJFTNK

W' ,%>)=/)0 TQ1 Tc8T1 ($% '+'SB)+*2( E%-2/ +)J/'2Y/(2+' H2I2M%/I3 >%J/' )%7%/32'J %E/273*)+E ($% #%V/3S>/3%- B)2D/(% 2'(%772J%'?% *2)E .()/(*+)18cf3$+K2'J ($/( 2( $/- ?+'-=?(%-

%3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( $=E/' )2J$(31 /'2E/7 )2J$(3 /'- %'D2)+'E%'(/7 J)+=B31 +' >%$/7* +*?+EB/'2%3 3=?$ /3 &+?/S&+7/ /'- U+K &$%E2?/7;8co

)NDJ?)NSJ JMO +FKJFTNK HVZ 6CNUSC TNK FPC %FPGDJS !KCJFICMF NT "MGIJSV

@' X='% Tcco1 .()/(*+) )%3B+'-%- (+ / 3%( +* e=%3(2+'3 *)+E / &+?/S&+7/ %V%?=(2D%1 P/' &;H27>%)-2'J1 K$+ K/3 m7++I2'J /( />70 ($%

K+)7-]3 E+3( -%/-70 2'-=3()2/7 -23/3(%); C+ +'% )%/770 I'+K3 $+K E/'0 B%+B7% K%)% I277%-+' ($/( '2J$( /'- 3=>3%e=%'(70p )%?%'( %3(2E/(%3 *)+E ($% @'-2/' J+D%)'E%'( $/D% )/'J%-*)+E 8L1ccc (+ 8O1ccc;88T b+K%D%)1 ($%3% D2?(2E3 K%)% '%D%) /-%e=/(%70 ?+EB%'3/(%-; @'Tcc81 :'2+' &/)>2-% >%?/E% / K$+770 +K'%- 3=>32-2/)0 +* U+K &$%E2?/7;

8cf.()/(*+) $/3 )%?%2D%- qQcc1ccc 2' go *%-%)/7 ?+'()/?(3 32'?% Tccf1 2'?7=-2'J gf?+'()/?(3 K2($ ($% U%B/)(E%'( +* U%*%'3%1 /??+)-2'J (+ :.6.B%'-2'J;J+D `/??%33%-W?(+>%) Tf1 Tc89;d8co$((B!FFK2I27%/I3;+)JF($%SJ2*27%3;$(E788c67%V2 G+3()+=31 U/D2- ./'-%)3+' /'- X/E%3 R+'%1 [H2I2M%/I3 A%D%/73 .B0?)/*( .%?)%(3+* ($% l.$/-+K &@6;l\ "#$ ",+$-`+* M+'-+'d1 ,%>)=/)0 Tf1 Tc8T; H2I2M%/I3$((B!FFK2I27%/I3;+)JFJ2*27%3F-+?3FLggQ9LTx)%SB%(/S;$(E7888H2I2M%/I3; $((B!FFK2I27%/I3;+)JFJ2*27%3F-+?3FLTfTOTfx)%SB=>72?SB+72?0Se=%3(2+'S*+)S?+?/S?+7/S;$(E7; .%% /73+ %) To1 Tc88;


34/54

33

@' ,%>)=/)0 Tc8T1 H2I2M%/I3 )%D%/7%- %E/273 3$+K2'J ($/( U+K &$%E2?/7 $2)%- .()/(*+) (+E+'2(+) R$+B/7 N=3(2?% /?(2D23(31 2'?7=-2'J ($% a%3 G%';889

+FKJFTNK JMO FPC !CBJV 4CUJKFICMF NT 6EQSGD +JTCFL HVZ 'DDEUL "EVFGM JMO 4CCU 7KCCM

1CVGVFJMDC

@' C+D%E>%) Tc881 / .()/(*+) +B%)/(2D% '/E%- ^+)%'/ s=?$/ )%?+='(%- ($/( 3$% $/- /['%K 3+=)?%\ K$+ K/3 B)+D2-2'J $%) K2($ 2'*+)E/(2+' />+=( /' %'D2)+'E%'(/7+)J/'2Y/(2+' '/E%- U%%B 5)%%' A%323(/'?%; .$% 2-%'(2*2%- ($% 3+=)?% /3 / [#%V/3 U%K/(?$%-j;#$% 7+?/7 6=3(2' ?$/B(%) K/3 B/)( +* ($% W??=B0 6=3(2' ?)+K- /(?2(0 $/771 $+K%D%)1 ($2'J3 K%)% '+( m)/-2?/7m %'+=J$ *+) ($%E 32'?% ($%0 -+'+( >%72%D% 2' K+)I2'J K2($2' ($% 303(%E; H$%' @ K/3 K+)I2'J :F& +' C+D;L($1 3+E% +* E0 ?+'(/?(3 (+7- E% ($/( /( ($% 5%'%)/7 633%E>70 +' C+D; g($1($%)% K/3 3+E% ?+'*72?( >%(K%%' )%J=7/) W??=B0 B%+B7% /'- U%%B 5)%%';\88L

0NMVJMFN[ #SJDYRJFCK JMO !NFJS .MFCSSGWCMDC +NSEFGNMV HVZ EMMJICO JDFGHGVFV

X%)%E0 .?/$277 )%B+)(%- 2' ($% A/.,(3E/J/Y2'% ($/( ($% 3%?=)2(0 *2)E [R7/?IK/(%)1 ($)+=J$

#+(/7 @'(%772J%'?%1 3+=J$( (+ >%?+E% ($% k2'(%7 /)E] +* G+'3/'(+1 +**%)2'J (+ B)+D2-%+B%)/(2D%3 (+ 2'*27()/(% /?(2D23( J)+=B3 +)J/'2Y2'J /J/2'3( ($% E=7(2'/(2+'/7 >2+(%?$ *2)E;\88O@' )%?%'( 0%/)31 R7/?IK/(%) $/3 (K2?% >%%' )%S'/E%-! *2)3( /3 4 .%)D2?%3 /'- /J/2' /36?/-%E2;88Q

889H2I2M%/I31 $((B!FFK2I27%/I3;+)JFJ2*27%3F)%7%/3%-/(%FTc8TScTSTQSccS3()/(*+)-SE+'2(+)%-S>$+B/7S/?(2D23(3S2'?7=-2'J;$(E7; .%% /73+ :7)2I G?^'2J$(1 [6 H2?I%- M%/I!.()/(*+)1 U+K &$%E2?/731 /'- @'-2/;\ #$% @'-2/ .2(%1 Tc8T; C%$/ #$2)/'21 [C%K3K/77/$!M+'J A%/-3 4-2(2+';\ A$? Q('< ",+$->7+J31 G/)?$ 8f1 Tc8T; %) 8L1 Tc8c;88Q6?/-%E2 $/3 )%?%2D%- qT;8 >2772+' 2' *%-%)/7 ?+'()/?(31 2'?7=-2'J q8;L >2772+' K2($ ($%.(/(% U%B/)(E%'( /'- qOcQ E2772+' K2($ ($% U%*%'3% U%B/)(E%'(1 /??+)-2'J (+:.6.B%'-2'J;J+D `/??%33%- W?(+>%) Tf1 Tc89d;


35/54

34

6??+)-2'J (+ -+?=E%'(3 $% +>(/2'%-1 .?/$277 )%B+)(%- 2' ($% A/.,(3($/(1

#$)+=J$ #+(/7 @'(%772J%'?% /'- ($% #%))+)23E A%3%/)?$ &%'(%)1 R7/?IK/(%)/73+ -2- >=32'%33 K2($ / )/'J% +* E=7(2'/(2+'/7 ?+)B+)/(2+'3; 6??+)-2'J (+

2'(%)'/7 #+(/7 @'(%772J%'?% ?+EE='2?/(2+'31 >2+(%?$ J2/'( G+'3/'(+r($%K+)7-l3 7/)J%3( 3=BB72%) +* J%'%(2?/770 E+-2*2%- 3%%-3r$2)%- ($% *2)E 2'TccfZco; #$% )%7/(2+'3$2B >%(K%%' ($% (K+ ?+EB/'2%3 /BB%/)3 (+ $/D% >%%'3+72-2*2%- 2' X/'=/)0 Tccf K$%' #+(/7 @'(%772J%'?% ?$/2) &+*%) R7/?I ()/D%7%-(+ s=)2?$ (+ E%%( K2($ ^%D2' H273+'1 G+'3/'(+l3 3%?=)2(0 E/'/J%) *+) J7+>/7233=%3;

6*(%) ($% E%%(2'J 2' s=)2?$1 R7/?I 3%'( /' %SE/27 (+ +($%) R7/?IK/(%)%V%?=(2D%31 2'?7=-2'J (+ hR7/?IK/(%) +K'%) /'- *+='-%) 4)2Ii /323 B)+(%?(2'J ($% G+'3/'(+ h>)/'-i '/E%;;;; 6$%/- +* ($% ?=)D% 2'*+/'- 2'32J$(F$%/-3 =B 23 K$/( $% 23 7++I2'J *+);m R7/?I /--%- ($/( #+(/7@'(%772J%'?% mK+=7- -%D%7+B 2'(+ /?(2'J /3 2'(%7 /)E +* G+'3/'(+;m R7/?I /73+'+(%- ($/( G+'3/'(+ K/3 ?+'?%)'%- />+=( /'2E/7 )2J$(3 /?(2D23(3 /'- ($/(($%0 -23?=33%- $+K R7/?IK/(%) m?+=7- $/D% +=) B%)3+'`3d /?(=/770 N+2'h/?(2D23(i J)+=B`3d 7%J/770;m R7/?I K)+(% ($/( 2'2(2/7 B/0E%'(3 (+ #+(/7@'(%772J%'?% K+=7- >% B/2- +=( +* G+'3/'(+l3 mJ%'%)+=3 B)+(%?(2+' >=-J%(m>=( K+=7- %D%'(=/770 >%?+E% / 72'% 2(%E 2' ($% ?+EB/'0l3 /''=/7 >=-J%(; b%%3(2E/(%- ($% B+(%'(2/7 B/0E%'(3 (+ #+(/7 @'(%772J%'?% /( >%(K%%' q8cc1ccc/'- qLcc1ccc; 6??+)-2'J (+ -+?=E%'(31 G+'3/'(+ B/2- #+(/7 @'(%772J%'?%

q8TQ1ccc 2' Tccf /'- q8cL1ccc 2' Tcco;


36/54

35

!PKCC KCSJFCO VFNKGCV NT CVUGNMJWC

#$% *+77+K2'J ($)%% 3(+)2%31 K$27% '+( 3()2?(70 />+=( ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2(+)J/'2Y/(2+'31 /)% ?7+3%70 )%7/(%- (+ 3=?$ /?(2D2(0; #$% *2)3( 23 / ?/3% +* %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( /'/?(2D23( K$+ $/- %VB+3%- / B+K%)*=7 B+72(2?2/']3 )+7% /3 / *+)E%) -2)%?(+) +* / */27%- 3/D2'J3

/'- 7+/' *2'/'?2/7 2'3(2(=(2+'; #$% 3%?+'- 23 / ?/3% +* %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( /'2E/7 )2J$(3/?(2D23(3 (+ ='?+D%) ($% 72I%72$++- +* B)+(%3(3 /J/2'3( ?+)B+)/(% %V$2>2(+)3 /( +'% +* ($%2)?+'*%)%'?%3; #$% ($2)- ?+'?%)'3 %V(%'32D% /'- K2-%S)/'J2'J ?+)B+)/(% %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3('+'S/?(2D23(3;

9CMKL 9LOC[ TNKICK OGKCDFNK NT )SLOC (COCKJS +JHGMWV JMO $NJM HVZ !GI "MOCKVNM

@' 8oof1 ($% G#,6/4( "',)13$)%B+)(%- ($/( 4)'2% A2YY+1 / B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(+)1 $/- >%%'$2)%- (+ 2'D%3(2J/(% #2E 6'-%)3+'1 / *+)E%) >/'I ?+'3=7(/'( /'- ?)2(2? +* :;.; A%B; b%')0b0-%; b0-% K/3 / -2)%?(+) +* &70-% ,%-%)/7 ./D2'J3 /'- M+/' >%(K%%' 8of8Sfg;88f#$% ._M

K/3 -%?7/)%- 2'3+7D%'( 2' 8ooc1 /'- ?+3( ($% (/VB/0%)3 qOQ E2772+'1 >=( b0-% K/3/BB/)%'(70 ($% +'70 -2)%?(+) K$+ -2- '+( ?+'()2>=(% (+ ($% 3%((7%E%'(; 6( ($% (2E% ($/(A2YY+ K/3 $2)%- (+ 2'D%3(2J/(% 6'-%)3+'1 A%B; b0-% K/3 ?$/2)E/' +* ($% :;.; b+=3%X=-2?2/)0 &+EE2((%%;

A2YY+ (+7- ($% &/B2(+7 b277 '%K3B/B%) D(** G/**($/( 2' 8ooL [$% K/3 /3I%- >0 / 7/K0%)K+)I2'J *+) b0-% (+ k*2'- +=( K$/( ($23 J=0 6'-%)3+' K/3 (/7I2'J />+=( /'- K$/( $% $/-;]\A2YY+ ($%' B+3%- /3 / (%7%D232+' B)+-=?%) 3%%I2'J /' 2'D%3(2J/(2D% 3(+)0 />+=( b0-%; :'-%)*/73% B)%(%'3%31 $% /??%B(%- gcc B/J%3 +* -+?=E%'(3 *)+E 6'-%)3+' /'- J/D% ($%E (+ +'%+* b0-%]3 7/K0%)3; 6??+)-2'J (+ A2YY+1 6'-%)3+' [K/3 3(2))2'J =B ($2'J3 3+ >/- ($/( ($%0h&70-%]3 -2)%?(+)3i ?+=7- '%D%) 3%((7% ($% ?/3%1 /'- ($%0 K/'(%- (+ 3%((7% 2(; 6'-%)3+' I%B(3(2))2'J =B )%B+)(%)3;\88o @' 8ooQ1 ($% A%3+7=(2+' #)=3( &+)B+)/(2+' *2'/770 3%((7%- 2(3 q8Q;TE2772+' 7/K3=2( /J/2'3( &70-%]3 -2)%?(+)3 *+) / E%)% qfLc1ccc; b0-% 7/(%) /-E2((%- ($/( $237/K0%)1 X/E%3 .?$2)+((1 $/- 2' */?( $2)%- A2YY+1 /'- ($/( b0-% $/- >%%' 2'*+)E%- +* ($%)%3=7(3 +* ($% 2'D%3(2J/(2+';8Tc

88fG2I% U+)'2'J /'- A/0 52>3+'1 [b0-% U%'2%3 b/D2'J ,+% @'D%3(2J/(%-;\ G#,6/4( "',)13$1W?(+>%) 8f1 8oof;88oU/E+' &$/BB2%1 [


37/54

36

+NDGCFL NT !NBGDNSNWL JMO .MTNKIJFGNM *CFRNKY "VVNDGJFCV HVZ JMGIJS KGWPFV JDFGHGVFV

#$% .+?2%(0 +* #+V2?+7+J0 23 / [B)+*%332+'/7 /'- 3?$+7/)70 +)J/'2Y/(2+' +* 3?2%'(23(3 *)+E/?/-%E2? 2'3(2(=(2+'31 J+D%)'E%'(1 /'- 2'-=3()0;;;\8T8@' Tccf1 ($% +)J/'2Y/(2+' B7/''%- (+

$+7- 2(3 /''=/7 ?+'*%)%'?% 2' .%/((7%1 >=( K/3 ?+'?%)'%- />+=( ($% B+(%'(2/7 *+) B)+(%3(3/J/2'3( %V$2>2(+)31 2'?7=-2'J b='(2'J-+' M2*% .?2%'?%3; .+1 2( ?+EE2332+'%- / [($)%/(/'/70323\ >0 @'*+)E/(2+' C%(K+)I 633+?2/(%31 K$2?$ K/3 *+='-%- >0 / *+)E%) ,R@ 3B%?2/7/J%'( /3 /' [2'D%3(2J/(2D% /'- 3%?=)2(0 3+7=(2+'3 B)+D2-%);\8TT #$% .+?2%(0 +* #+V2?+7+J0/3I%- @'*+)E/(2+' C%(K+)I 633+?2/(%3 (+ %D/7=/(% ($% B+(%'(2/7 *+) B)+(%3(3 /'--23)=B(2+'3 /( ($% %D%'(; @C6]3 8TSB/J% [($)%/( /'/70323\ 2'?7=-%31 /E+'J E/'0 +($%)($2'J31 )%*%)%'?%3 (+ ($% /?(2D23(3] /?/-%E2? /'- B)2D/(% 72D%31 2'?7=-2'J K$+ K/3 -/(2'JK$+E;8T9

*CRV )NKUZ\*CRV .MFCKMJFGNMJS\*CRV -A\*CRV NT FPC =NKSO

U=)2'J ($% 7/3( 3%D%' 0%/)31 C%K3 &+)B;1 2(3 &4W A=B%)( G=)-+?$1 /'- 2(3 3=>32-2/)0 C%K3@'(%)'/(2+'/78Tg$/D% >%%' 2'?)%/32'J70 %'J=7*%- 2' / 3B)/K72'J 3?/'-/7 )%7/(%- (+ 277%J/7$/?I2'J +* (%7%B$+'% D+2?%E/273; .+E% +* ($% 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 2'(+ ($23 E/((%) /)% +'J+2'J;,+77+K2'J /)% 3+E% +* ($% I%0 %D%'(3 2' ($23 -%D%7+B2'J 3(+)0;

@' TccO1 &72D% 5++-E/'1 ($% )+0/7 %-2(+) /( A$?- (7 .#$ K('*21 / '+KS-%*='?( '%K3B/B%)+K'%- >0 C%K3 &+)B;1 B7%/-%- J=27(0 (+ 2'(%)?%B(2'J B$+'% E%33/J%3 )%J/)-2'J ($% R)2(23$A+0/7 ,/E270; 6 B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(+) $2)%- >0 A$?- (7 .#$ K('*21 57%'' G=7?/2)%1 /73+B7%/-%- J=27(0;8TL

W' 6B)27 f($1 Tc881 C%K3 @'(%)'/(2+'/71 / 3=>32-2/)0 +* C%K3 &+)B; /'- B/)%'( ?+EB/'0 +*A$?- (7 .#$ K('*21 /B+7+J2Y%- /'- +**%)%- ?+EB%'3/(2+' (+ %2J$( B%+B7% K$+3% B$+'%D+2?%E/273 K%)% $/?I%-1 2'?7=-2'J ($% /?()%33 .2%''/ G277%) /'- #%33/ X+K%771 / *+)E%) :;^;?/>2'%( E2'23(%);8TO

8T8.+?2%(0 +* #+V2?+7+J0 K%>32(%; $((B!FFKKK;(+V2?+7+J0;+)JFJBF/>+=(3+(;/3B8TT@'*+)E/(2+' C%(K+)I 633+?2/(%3 K%>32(%; $((B!FFKKK;2'/S2'?;?+EF/>+=(S=3;B$B;@'*+)E/(2+' C%(K+)I3 633+?2/(%3 $/3 )%?%2D%- q9;8 E2772+' 2' O8 *%-%)/7 ?+'()/?(312'?7=-2'J T8 K2($ ($% U%B/)(E%'( +* b+E%7/'- .%?=)2(01 /'- f K2($ ($% U%B/)(E%'( +*U%*%'3%1 /??+)-2'J (+ :.6.B%'-2'J;J+D `/??%33%- W?(+>%) Tf1 Tc89;d8T9H277 7% /(!$((B!FFKKK;J)%%'23($%'%K)%-;?+EF>7+JFKBS?+'(%'(F@E/J%3F2'/x(+V%VB+x($)%/(;B-*;8TgW' X='% TO1 Tc891 C%K3 @'(%)'/(2+'/7 )%S'/E%- 2(3%7* C%K3 :^; [C%K3 @'(%)'/(2+'/7&$/'J%3 C/E% (+ C%K3 :^;\ ;;G1 X='% TO1 Tc89;8TLX%E2E/ ^2331 [5++-E/'


38/54

37

W' X=70 g($1 Tc88 ($% J1/'2,/3)%B+)(%- ($/( A$?- (7 "#$ K('*2$2)%- B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(+)3(+ $/?I ($% D+2?%E/273 +* G2770 U+K7%)1 / E2332'J 3?$++7J2)7; U+K7%) $/- >%%' E=)-%)%-1>=( K$%' A$?- (7 .#$ K('*2-%7%(%- 3+E% +* $%) D+2?%E/2731 2( J/D% $%) */E270 */73% $+B%($/( 3$% E2J$( >% /72D%; #$% D+2?%E/27 -%7%(2+'3 2'(%)*%)%- K2($ ($% B+72?% 2'D%3(2J/(2+' +*

$%) -%/($; b%) */E270 ?/77%- ($% D+2?%E/27 $/?I2'J [$%2'+=3\ /'- [-%3B2?/>7%;\8TQ

W' X=70 Q($1 Tc88 ($% B/,*0 "$*$4'/)%B+)(%- ($/( 57%'' G=7?/2)%1 ($% B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(+)K+)I2'J *+) A$?- (7 .#$ K('*21 E/0 $/D% $/?I%- ($% D+2?%E/273 +* )%7/(2D%3 +* 3+7-2%)3I277%- 2' @)/e /'- 6*J$/'23(/';8Tf

673+ +' X=70 Q($1 ($% $%/- -%(%?(2D% 32*(2'J ($)+=J$ ($% *27%3 +* 57%'' G=7?/2)% (+7- ($%J1/'2,/3 ($/( E+)% ($/' g1ccc B%+B7% E/0 $/D% >%%' (/)J%(%- K2($ B$+'% $/?I2'J;8To

W' X=70 88($1 ($% B/,*0 E,''(')%B+)(%- ($/( A$?- (7 .#$ K('*2$/- /3I%- / B)2D/(%2'D%3(2J/(+) (+ [$/?I 2'(+ ($% oF88 D2?(2E3] B)2D/(% B$+'% -/(/\ /'- ($/( [N+=)'/723(3 /3I%-

$2E (+ /??%33 )%?+)-3 3$+K2'J ($% ?/773 ($/( $/- >%%' E/-% (+ /'- *)+E ($% E+>27% B$+'%3>%7+'J2'J (+ ($% D2?(2E3 /'- ($%2) )%7/(2D%3;\ #$% B)2D/(% 2'D%3(2J/(+)1 / *+)E%) C%K a+)I&2(0 B+72?% +**2?%)1 -%?72'%- ($% N+> >%?/=3% [b% I'%K $+K 2'3%'32(2D% 3=?$ )%3%/)?$ K+=7->%1 /'- $+K >/- 2( K+=7- 7++I;\89c

W' X=70 891 R)2(23$ 723$%- ($% M%D%3+' @'e=2)0 (+2'D%3(2J/(% ($% )+7%3 +* ($% E%-2/ /'- ($% B+72?% 2' ($% B$+'% $/?I2'J 3?/'-/7;898

W' X=70 Tf($1 ($% J1/'2,/3)%B+)(%- ($/( [./)/ 0 .?+(7/'- a/)- ($/( ($%0 $/D%*+='- %D2-%'?% (+ 3=JJ%3( 3$% K/3 (/)J%(%- >0 ($% A$?- (7 .#$ K('*2l3 2'D%3(2J/(+) 57%''

G=7?/2)%1 K$+ 3B%?2/723%- 2' $/?I2'J D+2?%E/27;\89T

W' 6=J=3( 8O($1 / R)2(23$ b+=3% +* &+EE+'3 ?+EE2((%% )%7%/3%- / TccQ 7%((%) >0 *+)E%)A$?- (7 .#$ K('*2)+0/7 %-2(+) &72D% 5++-E/' /77%J2'J / ?+D%)S=B +* ($% B$+'% $/?I2'J3?/'-/7 /( A$?- (7 .#$ K('*2; #$% J1/'2,/3)%B+)(3 ($/(

8TQC2?I U/D2%3 /'- 6E%72/ b2771 [G2332'J G2770 U+K7%)l3 P+2?%E/27 H/3 b/?I%- >0 C%K3 +*($% H+)7-;\ J1/'2,/31 X=70 g1 Tc88;8TfG/)I b=J$%31 U='?/' 5/)-$/E1 X+$' R2'J$/E /'- 6'-0 R7+V$/E1 [0 C%K3 +* ($% H+)7-;\ "#$ B/,*0 "$*$4'/ X=70 Q1 Tc88;8To./'-)/ M/D277%1 [%) g1ccc1 ./03 .%'2+) U%(%?(2D%;\J1/'2,/31 X=70 Q1 Tc88;89cU/D2- &+772'31 [27%3 #/BB%- >0 C%K3 +*($% H+)7- A%B+)(%)3;l\ B/,*0 E,''('1 X=70 Q1 Tc88;898M%D%3+' @'e=2)0 K%>32(% /( $((B!FFKKK;7%D%3+'2'e=2)0;+)J;=IF;89TC2?I U/D2%3 /'- 6E%72/ b2771 [C%K3 +* ($% H+)7- #/)J%(%-


39/54

38

[5++-E/' ?7/2E3 ($/( B$+'% $/?I2'J K/3 kK2-%70 -23?=33%-] /( %-2(+)2/7E%%(2'J3 /( ($% B/B%) ='(27 h*+)E%) A$?- (7 .#$ K('*2%-2(+)i &+=73+'$2E3%7* >/''%- *=)($%) )%*%)%'?%3 (+ 2(p ($/( &+=73+' +**%)%- (+ 7%( $2E I%%B$23 N+> 2* $% /J)%%- '+( (+ 2EB72?/(% ($% B/B%) 2' $/?I2'J K$%' $% ?/E% (+?+=)(p /'- ($/( $23 +K' $/?I2'J K/3 ?/))2%- +=( K2($ k($% *=77 I'+K7%-J% /'-

3=BB+)(] +* +($%) 3%'2+) N+=)'/723(31 K$+E $% '/E%-;\899

W' X=70 T91 Tc8T1 M%D%3+' @'e=2)0 U%B=(0 63323(/'( &+EE2332+'%) .=% 6I%)3(%3(2*2%- ($/(1 )%J/)-2'J D2?(2E3 +* B$+'% $/?I2'J1 [@' (+(/7 2( 23 >%72%D%- ($/( ($%)%/)% g1QQL 3=?$ ]B+(%'(2/7] D2?(2E31 +* K$2?$ 8cf8 $/D% 3+E% /--2(2+'/7 */?(+) K$2?$E%/'3 K% ?+'32-%) ($%E 72I%70 (+ $/D% >%%' D2?(2E3; #$%3% */?(+)3 2'?7=-% /=-2+)%?+)-2'J +* D+2?%E/27 E%33/J%31 %%' 2' B+33%332+' +* E/(%)2/7-+K'7+/-%- +) +($%)K23% +>(/2'%- *)+E 3(+7%' E+>27% (%7%B$+'%3;\89L

#$% ,R@ K/3 +) 23 ?+'-=?(2'J / B)%72E2'/)0 2'D%3(2J/(2+' +* K$%($%) C%K3 &+)B; D2+7/(%-/'0 :;.; 7/K3 2' ($% B$+'% $/?I2'J 3?/'-/7; C%K3 &+)B; 23 $%/-e=/)(%)%- 2' C%K a+)I &2(0/'- 2'?+)B+)/(%- 2' U%7/K/)%; 6??+)-2'J (+ ($%I--(6,/.$2 H'$--1 ($% ,R@ 2'D%3(2J/(2+'2'?7=-%3 K$%($%) C%K3 &+)B; %EB7+0%%3 +) ?+'()/?(+)3 E/0 $/D% >)2>%- B+72?% +**2?%)31 2'D2+7/(2+' +* ($% ,+)%2J' &+))=B(


40/54

39

W' 6=J=3( 8O1 Tc891 D$1.$'-)%B+)(%- ($/( [M+'-+' B+72?% /)% /?(2D%70 2'D%3(2J/(2'J A=B%)(G=)-+?$l3 R)2(23$ '%K3B/B%) >=32'%33 *+) B+332>7% ?)2E2'/7 D2+7/(2+'3 +D%) /77%J/(2+'3 +*B$+'%S$/?I2'J /'- 277%J/7 B/0E%'(3 (+ B=>72? +**2?2/73 >0 2(3 N+=)'/723(3j\89o

W' .%B(%E>%) 8f1 Tc891 ($% B/,*0 "$*$4'/)%B+)(%- ($/( :;.; .%'/(+) X/0 A+?I%*%77%)1

?$/2)E/' +* ($% &+EE2((%% +' &+EE%)?%1 .?2%'?% /'- #)/'3B+)(/(2+'1 [D232(%- C%K3&+)Bl3 M+'-+' $%/-e=/)(%)3 %/)72%) ($23 0%/)1 2' B)%B/)/(2+' *+) / B+(%'(2/7 .%'/(%2'D%3(2J/(2+';\ 6??+)-2'J (+ ($% B/,*0 "$*$4'/

#$% .%'/(% ?+EE2((%% 23 ='K2772'J (+ 7/='?$ / *=77S3?/7% 2'D%3(2J/(2+' 2'(+ ($%/77%J%- K)+'J-+2'J ='(27 /*(%) / 3%)2%3 +* ?)2E2'/7 ()2/73 +* *+)E%) C%K3 &+)B3(/**1 -=% (+ >%J2' '%V( E+'($; b+K%D%)1 .%'/(+) A+?I%*%77%) 23 ='-%)3(++- (+>% I%%' (+ /E/33 /3 E=?$ %D2-%'?% /3 B+332>7% /$%/- +* ($% ()2/731 3+ ($/( ($%?+EE2((%% ?/' 7/='?$ / B+(%'(2/7 2'D%3(2J/(2+' +'?% ?)2E2'/7 B)+?%%-2'J3$/D% *2'23$%-j;M/3( 0%/)1 $% K)+(% (+ M+)- X=3(2?% M%D%3+' )%e=%3(2'J /'0%D2-%'?% 3=JJ%3(2'J ?)2E2'/7 ?+'-=?( $/- +??=))%- 2' ($% :.1 2'D+7D%- :.

?2(2Y%'3 +) */77%' K2($2' ($% N=)23-2?(2+' +* :. 7/K3; #$% ,R@ /'- U+X /)%?=))%'(70 2'D%3(2J/(2'J /'0 B+(%'(2/7 D2+7/(2+'3 +* ($% ,+)%2J' &+))=B(%) 8f1 Tc89;


41/54

40

(#. GMHCVFGWJFGNMV NT MNMUKNTGF NKWJMGXJFGNMV

U=)2'J ($% 7/3( -+Y%' 0%/)31 ($% ,R@ $/3 2EB)+B%)70 3B2%- +' +) 2'D%3(2J/(%- '+'B)+*2(+)J/'2Y/(2+'3 /'- /?(2D23(3 /**272/(%- K2($ ($%E;8g8 #$% ,R@ /73+ E/-% */73% 3(/(%E%'(3/>+=( +'% +* ($%3% 2'?2-%'(3 (+ &+'J)%331 ($% E%-2/ /'- ($% B=>72?;

,+77+K2'J / 3()2'J +* '%K3 /)(2?7%3 />+=( ,R@ 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 +* '+'B)+*2( /-D+?/?0 J)+=B313+E% G%E>%)3 +* &+'J)%33 )%e=%3(%- ($/( ($% @'3B%?(+) 5%'%)/7 +* ($% U%B/)(E%'( +*X=3(2?% )%D2%K ($%3% ?/3%3; #$% W**2?% +* ($% @'3B%?(+) 5%'%)/7 233=%- 2(3 )%B+)( 2'.%B(%E>%) Tc8c1 )%J/)-2'J ,R@ 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 >%(K%%' Tcc8ScO; #$% )%B+)( K/3 3$/)B70?)2(2?/7 +* ($% ,R@; #$% W**2?% +* ($% @'3B%?(+) 5%'%)/7

[?+'?7=-%- ($/( ($% */?(=/7 >/323 +* +B%'2'J 3+E% +* ($% 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 +*2'-2D2-=/73 /**272/(%- K2($ ($% J)+=B3 K/3 */?(=/770 K%/Ij;@' 3+E% ?/3%31 K%/73+ *+='- ($/( ($% ,R@ %V(%'-%- ($% -=)/(2+' +* 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 2'D+7D2'J/-D+?/?0 J)+=B3 +) ($%2) E%E>%)3 K2($+=( /-%e=/(% >/323j; @' 3+E% ?/3%31($% ,R@ ?7/332*2%- 3+E% +* 2(3 2'D%3(2J/(2+'3 )%7/(2'J (+ '+'D2+7%'( ?2D27-23+>%-2%'?% ='-%) 2(3 [6?(3 +* #%))+)23E\ ?7/332*2?/(2+';\8gT

@' B/)(2?=7/)1 ($% W**2?% +* ($% @'3B%?(+) 5%'%)/7 ?+'?7=-%- ($/(!

#$% ,R@]3 2'D%3(2J/(2+' +* ($% #$+E/3 G%)(+' &%'(%) `[=)J$]3 B%/?% /'- 3+?2/7N=3(2?% ?%'(%)\d /'- ($% ,R@]3 E233(/(%E%'(3 />+=( 2( [)/23%- ($% E+3( ()+=>72'J233=%3 2' ($23 )%D2%K;\8g9 #$% W@5 )%B+)( '+(%- ($/( /' ,R@ /J%'( K/3 -2)%?(%- (+/((%'- / =)J$ B%/?% )/770 3B+'3+)%- >0 ($% G%)(+' &%'(%); #$% /J%'( K)+(% /3$+)( )%B+)( +' 2(1 K$2?$ >+)% ($% 30'+B323 72'% [h(i+ )%B+)( )%3=7(3 +* 2'D%3(2J/(2+'+* =)J$ /'(2SK/) /?(2D2(0;\8gg #$% W@5 )%B+)( 3(/(%- ($/( 2( *+='- ($23 ,R@)%B+)( [%V()%E%70 ()+=>72'J +' 2(3 */?%; @( -%3?)2>%- '+ 7%J2(2E/(% B=)B+3% *+) ($%,R@ (+ /((%'- ($% %D%'(; @( ?)%/(%- / 3()+'J 2EB)%332+' ($/( ($% ,R@]3 )%/3+' *+)>%2'J ($%)% K/3 (+ E+'2(+) ($% ,2)3( 6E%'-E%'( /?(2D2(2%3 +* B%)3+'3 K2($ /'(2SK/)D2%K3; @( 3=BB72%- '+ %D2-%'?% +) %D%' 3=3B2?2+' ($/( /'0 ?)2E2'/7 +) (%))+)23(

8g8#$% ,R@ $/3 / )%?+)- +* ?+'-=?(2'J +B%)/(2+'3 -%32J'%- (+ 3=)D%271 -23)=B( /'- -23?)%-2(/?(2D23(3 /'- '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3; .%%1 *+) %V/EB7%1 $23(+)2%3 +* &W@C#4M(- I34$*$- ",+$-1 .%B(%E>%) T81 Tc8c; 6E0 5++-E/'1 [,R@A/2-3 /'- ($% &)2E2'/72Y/(2+' +* U233%'(;\ "#$ N'$4(3,/31 W?(+>%) 81 Tc8c;8g9W@5 )%B+)( /( 8Qg;8ggW@5 )%B+)( /( 9c;


42/54

41

%7%E%'( K/3 /33+?2/(%- K2($ ($% G%)(+' &%'(%) +) 72I%70 (+ >% B)%3%'( /( ($%%D%'(;\8gL

[h#i$% ,R@]3 3(/(%E%'(3 (+ &+'J)%33 /'- ($% B=>72? />+=( ($% )%/3+' ($% /J%'(/((%'-%- ($% %D%'( h=)J$ B%/?% )/770i K%)% 2'/??=)/(% /'- E237%/-2'Jj;($%

,R@ 3(/(%- 2' / B)%33 )%3B+'3% /'- h,R@i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gO

[h#i$% */?(=/7 B)%-2?/(2+' *+) ($% h,R@]3i B)%72E2'/)0 2'e=2)2%3j*+) / *%-%)/7 ?)2E%K/3 ($2'\8gQ)%J/)-2'J E%E>%)3 +* ($% =)J$ W)J/'2Y2'J 5)+=B1 /' [/**272/(%\ +*($% #$+E/3 G%)(+' &%'(%); #$% 723$ $23 B/)(2?2B/(2+' 2' ($% 3+=)?%B)+J)/E1 '+( (+ B)%D%'( +) -%(%?( (%))+)23E; R%?/=3% +* ($23 2EB)+B%) B=)B+3%1 K%?+'?7=-%- ($/( ($% ,R@]3 ?+77%?(2+' +* 2'*+)E/(2+' />+=( %)3] ,2)3(6E%'-E%'( /?(2D2(2%3 K/3 '+( kB%)(2'%'( (+ /'- K2($2' ($% 3?+B% +* /' /=($+)2Y%-7/K %'*+)?%E%'( /?(2D2(0] /'- ($%)%*+)% )/23%- 3%)2+=3 e=%3(2+'3 ='-%) ($% =(%- (+ ($% ?/3% )%E/2'2'J +B%' *+) O 0%/)3; H% ?+'?7=-%- ($/(($% 7%'J($0 -=)/(2+' +* ($% 2'D%3(2J/(2+' K/3 =')%/3+'/>7% /'- K/3 2'?+'323(%'(K2($ ,R@ B+72?0 )%e=2)2'J ($/( /' 2'D%3(2J/(2+' K2($ B+(%'(2/7 2EB/?(3 +' ,2)3(6E%'-E%'( /?(2D2(0 k'+( >% B%)E2((%- (+ %V(%'- >%0+'- ($% B+2'( /( K$2?$ 2(3='-%)702'J N=3(2*2?/(2+' '+ 7+'J%) %V23(3;]\8go

8gLW@5 )%B+)( /( Lo;8gOW@5 )%B+)( /( 8QO;8gQW@5 )%B+)( /( 8Qo;8gfW@5 )%B+)( /( 8Qo;8goW@5 )%B+)( /( 8f8;


43/54

42

A%J/)-2'J ($% ,R@]3 2'D%3(2J/(2+' +* %)31 [($% ,R@ /)(2?=7/(%-72((7% +) '+ >/323 *+) 3=3B%?(2'J / D2+7/(2+' +* /'0 *%-%)/7 ?)2E2'/7 3(/(=(%j;($% ,R@]3+B%'2'J 4& h%7%?()+'2? ?+EE='2?/(2+'i -2- '+( /)(2?=7/(% /'0 >/323 (+ 3=3B%?( ($/(($%0 K%)% B7/''2'J /'0 *%-%)/7 ?)2E%3j;H% /73+ *+='- ($/( ($% ,R@ I%B( ($232'D%3(2J/(2+' +B%' *+) +D%) 9 0%/)31 7+'J B/3( ($% ?+)B+)/(% 3$/)%$+7-%) E%%(2'J3($/( ($% 3=>N%?(3 K%)% 3=BB+3%-70 B7/''2'J (+ -23)=B(j;H% ?+'?7=-%- ($/( ($%2'D%3(2J/(2+' K/3 I%B( +B%' k>%0+'- ($% B+2'( /( K$2?$ 2(3 ='-%)702'J N=3(2*2?/(2+''+ 7+'J%) %V23(%-1] K$2?$ K/3 2'?+'323(%'( K2($ ($% ,R@]3 G/'=/7 +* @'D%3(2J/(2D%/'- WB%)/(2+'/7 5=2-%72'%3 `G@W5d;\8LT

A%J/)-2'J ($% 2'D%3(2J/(2+' +* ($% &/($+72? H+)I%) /'- 2(3 E%E>%)31 [($% ,R@]3?7/332*2?/(2+' +* +'% +* ($%3% E/((%)3 ='-%) ($% 6?(3 +* #%))+)23E ?7/332*2?/(2+' K/32'/BB)+B)2/(%1 >%?/=3% ($% /?(3 2' e=%3(2+' `()%3B/33 +' / E272(/)0 */?272(0d -2- '+(2'?7=-% ($% =3% +* D2+7%'?% +) *+)?%;\8L9

8LcW@5 )%B+)( /( 8f8;8L8W@5 )%B+)( /( 8fT;8LTW@5 )%B+)( /( 8fTS9;8L9W@5 )%B+)( /( 8fL;


44/54

43

+EKHCGSSJMDC NT FPC 'DDEUL =JSS +FKCCF INHCICMF

#$%)% /)% '=E%)+=3 '%K3 /??+='(3 /'- )%B+)(3 +* 7+?/7 B+72?%1 U%B/)(E%'( +* b+E%7/'-.%?=)2(0 /'- ,R@ 3=)D%277/'?% +* ($% W??=B0 H/77 .()%%( E+D%E%'(; ,+) %V/EB7%1 G/(($%KA+($3?$27- +* ($% H'(4'$--,5$E/J/Y2'% )%B+)(%- ($/(!

[WD%) ($% 7/3( *%K 0%/)31 ($% U%B/)(E%'( +* b+E%7/'- .%?=)2(0 /'- 7+?/7 7/K%'*+)?%E%'( +**2?%)3 $/D% %'J/J%- 2' K2-%3B)%/- -+E%3(2? 3B02'J +'W??=B0 H/77 .()%%( /?(2D23(31 /E+'J +($%)31 +' ($% 3$/I0 B)%E23% ($/( ($%3%/?(2D23(3 B+3% / (%))+)23( ($)%/(; W*(%'1 b+E%7/'- .%?=)2(0 /'- +($%) 7/K%'*+)?%E%'( /J%'?2%3 $/D% ?++)-2'/(%- K2($ ($% B)2D/(% 3%?(+)1 K+)I2'J +'>%$/7* +*1 +) 2' ?++B%)/(2+' K2($1 H/77 .()%%( *2)E3 /'- +($%) ?+EB/'2%3 ($%B)+(%3(%)3 $/D% ?)2(2?2Y%-j;#$% -+?=E%'(3 )%D%/7 E/'0 2'3(/'?%3 +* 3=?$E23-2)%?(%- K+)I >0 7/K %'*+)?%E%'( /)+='- ($% ?+='()0; #$% B2?(=)% ($%0B/2'( +* 7/K %'*+)?%E%'( 2' ($% 0 ($% U%B/)(E%'( +* b+E%7/'- .%?=)2(01 -%D+(%- ()%E%'-+=3)%3+=)?%3 (+ ()/?I2'J /'- 2'*27()/(2'J W??=B0 )=/)0 Tf1 Tc8T; X/3+' &$%)I23 /'- s/?$ &/)(%)1 [,R@ .=)D%277/'?% +* W??=B0 H/77.()%%( U%(/27%-;\ L177,34.(3 H(-.1 X/'=/)0 L1 Tc89; U+E2'2e=% U%>=?e=+0SU+-7%01 [,R@&+'32-%)%- W??=B0 G+D%E%'( %) TQ1 Tc8T;.B%'?%) G/'-%71 [@ .B0 /' W??=B0! W>/E/]3 Ub. .=)D%273 M%J2(


45/54

44

.MTKJ7JKO> JM (#.?DNKUNKJFC GMFCSSGWCMDC UJKFMCKVPGU

52D%' ($% K%77S-+?=E%'(%- />=3%3 >+($ >0 ?+)B+)/(2+'3 /'- ($% ,R@ 2' 3B02'J +''+'B)+*2(31 ($% e=%3(2+' /)23%3 K$%($%) ($% 3%?)%(2D% ,R@S?+)B+)/(% 2'(%772J%'?%B/)('%)3$2B ?/77%- @'*)/5/)- 23 +) ?+=7- >%?+E% /'+($%) D%$2?7% +) (++7 *+) ='%($2?/7 +)

277%J/7 %3B2+'/J% /J/2'3( '+'B)+*2( +)J/'2Y/(2+'3;

#$% ?+D%) +* ($% G/)?$ Tccf 233=% +* "#$ H'(4'$--,5$*%/(=)%- /' /)(2?7% />+=( @'*)/5/)-1 /72((7%SI'+K' B/)('%)3$2B >%(K%%' B)2D/(% 2'-=3()01 ($% ,R@ /'- ($% U%B/)(E%'( +*b+E%7/'- .%?=)2(0;8LO 63 +* ($%'1 @'*)/5/)- ?7/2E%- ($% B/)(2?2B/(2+' +* [E+)% ($/' T91ccc)%B)%3%'(/(2D%3 +* B)2D/(% 2'-=3()01\ 2'?7=-2'J 9Lc +* ($% ,+)(='% Lcc ?+EB/'2%3; #$%@'*)/5/)- K%>32(% ?7/2E3 ($/( 2(3 [B)2E/)0 *+?=3j23 (+ 3$/)% /?(2+'/>7% 2'(%772J%'?%2'*+)E/(2+' *+) 2'D%3(2J/(2D% B=)B+3%3;\8LQ

6??+)-2'J (+ "#$ H'(4'$--,5$1

[W'% +* ($% /-D/'(/J%3 +* @'*)/5/)-1 /??+)-2'J (+ 2(3 7%/-2'J E%E>%)31 23 ($/(($% ,R@ J2D%3 ($%E / $%/-3S=B +' / 3%?=)% B+)(/7 />+=( /'0 ($)%/(%'2'J2'*+)E/(2+' )%7/(%- (+ 2'*)/3()=?(=)% -23)=B(2+' +) (%))+)23Ej; kH% J%( D%)0%/30 /??%33 (+ 3%?=)% 2'*+)E/(2+' ($/( +'70 J+%3 (+ @'*)/5/)- E%E>%)31]h&$/2)E/' +* ($% R+/)- +* U2)%?(+)3 +* ($% @'*)/5/)- C/(2+'/7 G%E>%)36772/'?% %)3 $/D% ?+'()2>=(%- (+ />+=( 8cc ,R@?/3%31] .?$'%?I 3/03;8Lf

#$% 6E%)2?/' &2D27 M2>%)(2%3 :'2+' 23 ?+'?%)'%- />+=( ($% 3B%?2/7 /-D/'(/J%3 J)/'(%- (+?+)B+)/(2+'3 ='-%) @'*)/5/)-; 6??+)-2'J (+ ($% 6&M:]3 X/0 .(/'7%01

[k#$% ,R@ 3$+=7- '+( >% ?)%/(2'J / B)2D27%J%- ?7/33 +* 6E%)2?/'3 K$+ J%(3B%?2/7 ()%/(E%'(j;#$%)%]3 '+ k>=32'%33 ?7/33] 2' 7/K %'*+)?%E%'(; @* ($%)%l32'*+)E/(2+' ($% ,R@ ?/' 3$/)% K2($ TT1ccc ?+)B+)/(% >2JK2J31 K$0 -+'l( ($%0N=3( 3$/)% 2( K2($ ($% B=>72?n #$/(l3 K$+ ($%2) )%/7 k3B%?2/7 )%7/(2+'3$2B] 233=BB+3%- (+ >% K2($; .%?)%?0 23 '+( / B/)(0 */D+) (+ >% J2D%' +=( (+*)2%'-3j;#$23 >%/)3 / -23(=)>2'J )%3%E>7/'?% (+ ($% ,R@]3 $/'-2'J +=(kJ++-2%3] (+ ?+)B+)/(2+'3 2' )%(=)' *+) *+7-2'J ($%E 2'(+ 2(3 -+E%3(2?3=)D%277/'?% E/?$2'%)0;]\8Lo

8LOG/(($%K A+($3?$27-1 [#$% ,R@ U%B=(2Y%3 R=32'%33;\ "#$ H'(4'$--,5$1 G/)?$1 Tccf;8LQ$((B!FFKKK;2'*)/J/)-;'%(F*/e;B$BnE'8_3E8ST;8LfG/(($%K A+($3?$27-1 [#$% ,R@ U%B=(2Y%3 R=32'%33;\ "#$ H'(4'$--,5$1 G/)?$1 Tccf;8LoG/(($%K A+($3?$27-1 [#$% ,R@ U%B=(2Y%3 R=32'%33;\ "#$ H'(4'$--,5$1 G/)?$1 Tccf;


46/54

45

(KCdECMFSL JVYCO dECVFGNMV JQNEF DNKUNKJFC CVUGNMJWC

9NR DNIINM GV DNKUNKJFC CVUGNMJWC JWJGMVF MNMUKNTGFVe

H% -+']( )%/770 I'+K; b%)%]3 K$/( K% -+ I'+K;

G+3( E/N+) ?+EB/'2%3 $/D% ?)%/(%- /' 2'3(2(=(2+'/72Y%- 2'(%)'/7 ?$2%* 3%?=)2(0 B+32(2+' Z /?$2%* 2'(%772J%'?% +**2?%) +* 3+E% 3+)(; #$%3% B%+B7% +*(%' 3(/)( >0 /3I2'J ($% e=%3(2+'!K$/( [($)%/(3\ %V23( (+ +=) ?+EB/'0n @' 3+E% ?/3%3 Z >=( K% -+']( I'+K $+K E/'0 SS?+)B+)/(2+'3 2-%'(2*0 '

Spooky Business - corporate espionage against non profit organizations

Documents

Transcript of Spooky Business - corporate espionage against non profit organizations