Spiritual Transformation within the OI Network: Field Experience & Findings

7th Annual Microenterprise Conference

March, 2004

Suzy Salib-Bauer, Senior Technical Analyst

Product Development Division, OI Network© Opportunity International, 2004; All rights reserved; do not copy or distribute without permission

Overview of Opportunity International 27+ partners in four regions 487,000 clients $224 avg. loan size $123M in total assets $84M in outstanding loans 2.65% arrears > 30 days

Mission & Motivation Mission: To provide microenterprise

development services that enable clients to transform their businesses, families & communities, without regard to race, religion or gender.

Motivation: To respond to Jesus Christ’s call to serve the poor.

“Triple Bottom Line” Outreach Sustainability Transformational Impact

Transformational Impact Economic Social Political Spiritual

“Any positive change in attitudes, awareness, or beliefs that results in a higher level of spiritual practice or understanding.”

Transformation – How To? Mission statement Loan officers training Weekly/Bi-weekly meetings Client Training modules Loan Officer Incentives Institutional Resources Evaluation & Monitoring

Client Impact Monitoring System (CIMS) Purpose:

Measure transformational impact Compare performance Network-wide Use information for management decision-

making

Pilot-Testing at SAT Initial assessment to establish baseline Quantitative survey with 581 clients Qualitative survey with 56 clients Results to shape monitoring system

SAT basics: 16 branches across Ghana 41,000 clients 91% women 80% portfolio in Trust Banks

Pilot-Testing at SAT Indicators developed by SAT staff through

participatory process with senior management and loan officers

Church attendance Prayer and devotional life Leadership in church activities Tithing

Quantitative Survey Findings• Not what was expected….

Spiritual ImpactIn Regards to Your Christian Practice…

Mature Non Clients

Attend Church 97.8% (15.9% Since SAT)

99.6%

Family Attends Church* 86.3%(16.4 % Since SAT)

99.0%

Family Devotions* 68.8%(15.7% Since SAT)

99.6%

Give Advice Based on Scripture* 86.8% (27% Since SAT)

94.2 %

Leadership At Church 62.9 %(19.2% Since SAT)

80.0%

Prayer Group In Home* 30.9 %(5.7% Since SAT)

65.0%

Increase in Tithing 85.9 % 79.5%

Quantitative Survey FindingsQuantitative Findings at SAT

020406080

100120

Impact Indicators

Pe

rce

nta

ge Mature

Maturesince SAT

Incoming

Possible explanations Need to appear “holy” to be credit worthy SAT’s Christian reputation growing Mature clients are busier with business

Open-ended Responses More trust in God – 17% More Christian business practices – 12% More patient with others – 12% More thankful to God – 11% More prayerful – 9%

Qualitative Findings

Prior to joining SAT… Not attending church regularly

“…Because I didn’t have money to pay tithe and offerings my attendance was poor.” – SAT client

Not employing Christian business practices “Because I was not able to make ends meet, I

cheated my customers. I inflated the prices of my goods.” – SAT client

Qualitative Findings Currently… Able to pay tithes and give special offerings

“God has been so good and with SAT’s help, I’m able to pay my tithe and this has made me feel good.” – SAT client

Qualitative Findings Increase in church attendance and leadership

“I am now an active member of the church and even a leader of a group advising people on the need to serve God.” – SAT client

“(Attending church) has made me stop certain evils, especially bitterness and backbiting.” – SAT client

Qualitative Findings Application of Biblical principles to business

The church gives us a lot of training and advice…(for example) how and why we should refund monies overpaid to us by our customers.” – SAT client

As a result… Added questions to CIMS survey on

Training in business ethics Participation in worship services Participation in other religious activities Strength of relationship with God

Spiritual Transformation In the past… Low self-esteem and little confidence (28)

“I felt that society looked down on our family, thinking we were lazy.”

“I was always crying because I had little to do and little money.”

Spiritual Transformation In the past… Social isolation and shame (13)

“My family members would not inform me of ceremonies or events because I had no money.”

“My dignity as a woman was affected. You know there is no respect for the poor. I had no friends.”

Spiritual Transformation In the past… Conflict with family and children (7)

“I used to beat my children in response to small provocations because I felt bad about my life. My children were withdrawn and they disobeyed me often.”

Spiritual Transformation In the present… Greater self-esteem and more confidence (25) Involvement in family functions (e.g. funerals,

naming ceremonies, etc.) - (22) Help others in need (7)

Spiritual Transformation In the present…

“I am now accorded so much respect and counted among the lots.”

“Now when there is a problem my neighbors and family members inform me because they know that when I am not able to help in person, I can assist financially.”

As a result… Added questions to CIMS survey on:

Self-confidence Participation in community activities

Social Civic Worship/Religious Other

Giving/donations Money or in-kind

Overall quality of life

Network-wide Challenges Commercial pressures Systems/operations Management decision-making Rewards/recognition