Satu Mare Strategic Agenda
-
Upload
sabina-dimitriu -
Category
Documents
-
view
219 -
download
1
description
Transcript of Satu Mare Strategic Agenda
This document is an Open Content – You may copy, distribute and display the work only if credit to the authors is given (attribution)
WP4Urban Programming
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
ERDF PP10 Municipality of Satu Mare (RO)
Version 01
Prepared by:
The Satu Mare
Municipality
www.satu-mare.ro
Reviewed by:
STATUS Content
Management
URBASOFIA
www.urbasofia.eu
Urban Planning Institute
of the Republic of Slovenia
www.uirs.si
Workpackage 4 Urban Programming
Activity 4.2 Definition of planning scenarios:
prioritization design of urban strategic agenda
D4.7 IntegratedStrategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in
Satu Mare
ERDF PP10 Municipality of Satu Mare (RO)
2/94
Project number: SEE/D/0297/4.1/X
Project acronym: STATUS
Project title: Strategic Territorial Agendas for "Small and Middle-Sized Towns" Urban Systems
Instrument: INTERREG IV B SEE
Call identifier: South East Europe Call D
Activity code:
StartdateofProject: 2012-12-01
Duration: 24 month
Deliverablereferencenumberandtitle(asinAnnex1): D4.7IntegratedStrategic
Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Duedateofdeliverable(asinAnnex1): 2014-11-30
Actualsubmissiondate: see “History” Table below
Revision:
Organizationnameofleadcontractorforthisdeliverable:
Municipality of Kavala
Projectco-fundedbytheEuropeanCommissionwithinthe INTERREG IVB South
East Europe Programme(2007-2013)
Dissemination Level
PU Public PU
PP Restrictedtootherprogrammeparticipants(includingtheCommission
Services)
RE Restrictedtoagroupspecifiedbytheconsortium
CO Confidential,onlyformembersoftheconsortium(includingtheComm
issionServices)
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
3
Title:
D 4.7 - Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in ERDF PP10 Municipality of Satu Mare (RO)
Author(s)/Organisation(s):
The Satu Mare Municipality
WorkingGroup:
WP4
References:
STATUS Final Application Form (INTRA-5108827)
STATUS Project and financial management handbook
ShortDescription:
Output 4.2, 4.5 and 4.6 are going to be combined and presented as the final Strategic Territorial / Agenda.
Content manager coordinates. Scientific and technological partners provide methodologies and techniques, tools
necessary to facilitate the exchange of ideas, knowledge and expertise in the activated participatory planning process
leading to the final Agendas design.
Keywords:
Strategic territorial agenda, strategy, workshops, participatory tool, geoblog, stakeholders, working groups, solutions,
problems
History:
Version Author(s) Status Comment Date
00 Barbara Music (UIRS) 1. Draft Template of the report 16/09/2014
01 The Satu Mare Municipality
1. Draft Draft of the report Xx/xx/2014
Review:
Version Reviewer Comment Date
01
Sabina Dimitriu (As. CM)
Pietro Elisei (CM)
Review of Report Template 23/09/2014
xx/xx/2014
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
4
Table of Contents
Table of Contents................................................................................................................................... 4
Table of Figures ..................................................................................................................................... 5
Abbreviation List ................................................................................................................................... 5
1 The importance/purpose of the Strategic Urban Agenda (SUA) .............................................. 6
2 Scope and vision of the SUA 2015-2025 ....................................................................................... 7
3 The process leading to design of the SUA in Satu Mare ............................................................ 8
4 Goals and projects of the SUA ................................................................................................... 22
5 Implementation of the SUA ........................................................................................................ 37
6 Project Fiches: Priority projects corresponding to each goal / objective of the SUA ........... 68
7 The Poster Plan ............................................................................................................................ 68
8 Conclusions .................................................................................................................................. 71
9 References .................................................................................................................................... 71
10 Annexes......................................................................................................................................... 72
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
5
Table of Figures
Tables
Table 1: List of prioritized projects ........................................................ Error! Bookmark not defined.
Table 2: ST/UA´s Action Plan of TPs area ............................................ Error! Bookmark not defined.
Table 2: ST/UA´s Action Plan of TPs area in a timeline ....................... Error! Bookmark not defined.
Table 3: Risk assessment ....................................................................................................................... 37
Table 4: Monitoring and evaluation framework of the ST/UA .............. Error! Bookmark not defined.
Figures
Figure 1: The process of designing ST/UA (source: own design) .......................................................... 8
Figure 2: Timeline of the process of ST/UA design (source: own design) ............................................. 8
Abbreviation List
CKP - cities knowledge platform
ST/UA - Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda
TP – Territorial Partner
SEE – South Eastern Europe
UC – Urban Centers
UTF – Urban task forces
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
6
1 The importance/purpose of the Strategic Urban
Agenda (SUA)
Even though modern planning principles such as the idea of sustainable development, the
increasing concern for environment protection, or the bottom-up, participative approach have
played an important role in recent years’ efforts to organize the vision for the development of the
city, the scarcity of local, regional and national funding as well as the limited access to European
financing prevented many of the most important development projects from being implemented.
Therefore, having in view the coming programming period, local decision makers felt the need to
have a new city sustainable development strategy designed, to have a fresh diagnose of the current
situation, better assess post-crisis opportunities, upgrade the list of projects and thus increase the
chances of attracting the necessary financial support for the mid-term development of Satu Mare.
Several local and supra-local development policy documents have recognized the significant
potential of Satu Mare as an economic, educational, cultural, touristic etc. center, the underlying
conclusion being that if a clever development strategy were successfully implemented, it would
trigger extensive improvement in the whole surrounding area, creating opportunities and
channeling energies.
All decision makers agree that Satu Mare has an important development potential, based on:
its geographic position, close to the Hungarian and Ukrainian borders;
the natural and cultural corridor of the Someş river, in the middle of a plain with a rich
agricultural potential;
a rather good quality environment, lacking major polluting factors;
a relevant hydrographic network;
a well-established, multicultural urban community;
an active cultural life;
a balanced job market;
a stable economy, with a changing industrial profile and a growing tertiary sector.
They also agree, however, that there is enough room for improvement in any domain and that
there really is a need for a strategic document able to define and prioritize interventions meant to
ensure a sustainable progress. The almost unanimous opinion was that the vision of the document
should be based on the intrinsic city potential, aiming at turning negative aspects into valuable
assets.
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
7
2 Scope and vision of the SUA 2015-2025
Regarding vision formulation and setting the strategic development directions on medium and long term,
the Satu Mare Municipality is in the same situation with similar cities within the country and other less
favored areas of the EU, in the context of the fundamental guidelines defined by EC through the Europe
2020 strategy. Formulating the city development vision for the next decade is a very important step in
drawing up its strategy, representing the basis for the orientation of local and national budgetary resources
as well as of European grants for the period 2014-2020.
The implementation of measures aimed to achieving the vision and hence to reaching the development
goals, first requires their integration into a unitary structure in order to provide overviews of both projects
and funding sources.
The development strategy of Satu Mare Municipality has been interactively drafted during three rounds of
public debates with the local administrative institutions, NGOs and other interested parties. Thus, during
the second workshop the development vision for 2025 as well as the major directions of public intervention
were formulated.
The Satu Mare Municipality can play an important role at national and regional level, as well as on the
European regional context, being territorially located at the confluence of three cultures representing at the
same time border areas: Romania - Hungary - Ukraine. Natural resources (fertile plains, geothermal waters,
the Someş river which crosses the city) and the status of urban development pole recommends it for a
greater role in the regional economy. It is obvious that the city does not yet exploit its significant
development potential and major resources which open multiple European funding opportunities for 2014-
2020. An ex-ante conditionality in accessing these grants is to define a vision for the city socio-economic
evolution as well as an integrated development strategy that subscribes to the three major lines of action
defined in the Europe 2020 Strategy: smart, sustainable and inclusive growth.
Development vision of the Satu Mare Municipality - Horizon 2025
By 2025, Satu Mare will be a pole of urban development, an applied research center with an
inclusive economy and a sustainable lifestyle. The abundance of geothermal waters and the
location on the Someş river will support the touristic character of the city.
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
8
3 The process leading to design of the SUA in Satu
Mare
The process of designing the Strategic Urban Agenda follows three major steps:
Figure 1: The process of designing ST/UA
(source: Barbara Mušič, UIRS own design)
3.1 Timeline of the overall process of the SUA design
Figure 2: Timeline of the process of ST/UA design
(source: Barbara Mušič, UIRS own design)
3.2 Operational Analysis
Work Package 3 provided the framework for a thorough preparation for the complex work of
designing the Strategic Urban Agenda. We started from the concept that in order to achieve the main
objectives of STATUS, namely to draft a comprehensive strategic agenda and prepare for the setup of a
future urban center, the main prerequisite is the identification of the most relevant stakeholders for the
target area. Their selection was be based on the principle of their level of expertise in the most relevant
fields that were to be considered when attempting to design a middle-term sustainable development
strategy for the municipality.We obviously needed to build up a more or less heterogeneous group of
people willing to engage in a participatory process of collecting data that should be as accurate and reliable
as possible, analyzing and interpreting it from various perspectives, highlighting strong and weak points
and trends, identifying areas of intervention, proposing measures to address the problems and projects to be
taken into consideration for the future.
Identification of problems
Finding solutions
Designing the ST/UA
June 15 2013WP3 Inception
November 28-29 2013
WP4 Workshop 1
March 20-21 2014WP4 Workshop 2
July 3-4 2014WP4 Workshop 3
WP5 UTC + UC
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
9
Then we moved on to operational analysis, trying to identify first the economic opportunities and
problems/threats in the area and concluding that in what economy is concerned, the tendencies
manifest in the past few years showed that, after a marked decrease, the production of the once
well represented machine-building, wood processing, and textile industries has stabilized, making
good use of the existing production infrastructure and rather well qualified work force. An
industrial branch has, in the meanwhile, expanded and consolidated, attracting significant foreign
investment – the automotive parts industry. Although some of the traditional foodstuffs industry
(milk processing) has been lost due to a debatable decision of the foreign investor (Friesland),
other quite significant investments have proved successful in meat processing and cereal
processing. Other new branches have started production, although not at a very large scale –
abrasives and solar panels. On the whole, industry has managed to maintain a dominant role in the
city economy despite major cutbacks suffered in the 1990s.
Also, after the 2000-2008 boom and the subsequent abrupt fall, constructions are now slowly
revigorating and on the other hand, the tertiary sector has expanded significantly with actors
ranging from large retailers, banks, or telecom companies to thousands of SMEs.
After also analyzing the infrastructure situation, environment protection efforts, the socio-cultural
domain or local governance, we came up with the following preliminary SWOT analysis:
Strengths Weaknesses
Location proximity to the Hungarian (10 km) and
Ukrainian (35 km) borders
Relatively excentric position within
the national territory
Close to the Polish and Slovak borders
Accessibility road, rail and airways connections Traffic congestion, growing vehicle
number
European motorway network 50 km
away
Infrastructure Largely rehabilitated street infrastructure Some 25% of the street infrastructure
still in need of rehabilitation
Recently modernized water supply
network and waste water treatment
station
Recently built waste deposit station Insufficiently developed recycling
Recently replaced natural gas distribution
network
Population,
demographic changes
Tolerant, open-minded multi-cultural
society, multilinguism
Aging population, negative
demographic growth
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
10
and social processes
Growing percentage of people with
higher education
Insufficient technical higher
education graduates
Natural resources Thermal water, forests, natural
protected areas, parks and green
areas, low pollution
Insufficiently exploited resources
Cultural heritage Rich cultural heritage, historical
buildings and monuments, history, art,
folk art museums, memorial houses
Several historic buildings in need for
rehabilitation
Theatre, philharmonic, public libraries Need for subsidies, insufficient
audience
Poetry magazine, poetry annual festival,
yearly folk art, jazz, symphonic music,
theatre festivals
Difficulty in securing the necessary
financial support
Culture promotion institutions
Economy industrial tradition
foreign investments
Overall friendly business environment Relatively large labor taxes
Skilled and dynamic workforce Emigration trend within the skilled
workforce group
Diversified economic activities,
consolidating tertiary sector
Diversified industry – machine
building, automotive parts and wiring,
textiles, foodstuffs, wood processing
and furniture
Relatively low productivity as
compared to the EU standards, few
high-tech activities
Relatively large consumer market Medium to low buying capacity
Presence of supermarket chains Elimination of some of the small
commercial competitors
Industrial parks
Unemployment Moderate to low unemployment Moderate to low unemployment
Tourism Significant touristic potential, historic
buildings and monuments, thermal water,
aqua parks, touristic infrastructure and
Lack of tourism promotion
institutions, lack of marketing plan
for attracting tourists, insufficient
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
11
agencies promotional material, insufficient
leisure infrastructure
Social infrastructure Diversity of social institutions and
NGO’s
Insufficient funding
increasing public-private cooperation in
dealing with social issues
Roma people integration efforts
Quality of living Relatively good housing conditions Low life expectancy,
Growing education level, expanding
higher education institutions
Modest buying capacity
Improving health care infrastructure Insufficient leisure opportunities
Other
Opportunities Threats/Risks
Location Setting up of a regional logistic center
Accessibility Increased number of flights
Infrastructure absorbtion of EU funds
Ring road and corresponding bridge
connected to the motorway network
Difficulties in coordinating
infrastructure interventions,
insufficient funding, incoherent
regional infrastructure investments
loss of influence to the future
regional center
unfavorable evolution of European
crisis
Updated GUP, expansion of inner city
limit
Delayed upgrading process,
inadequate results
Population,
demographic changes
and social processes
Well-developed education institutions
network, well qualified teaching staff
Continuing aging tendency,
continuing emigration trend
Natural resources Navigation on the Somes river Inadequate use of resources
Cultural heritage Insufficient funding for the
rehabilitation of the built heritage
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
12
Economy Constant or growing interest of foreign
investors for the city
Export dependency, prolongued
world/ European economic crisis
Expansion of the industrial park Lack of greenfield space
Setting up of a business incubator Lack of legal stability
Strengthening of the SME sector Impovering taxation and regulations,
lack of proper support,
Unemployment Growing entrepreneurial spirit Growth of unemployment and
poverty level
Tourism Development of cure, transit, business
and cultural tourism
Inadequate touristic promotion
activities, lack of marketing strategy,
inadequate services quality
Social infrastructure Local, national European support
programmes
Insufficient funding
Quality of living Revigorating economy
Other
The conclusion was that there was an obvious need for a city development strategy, one that
would help decision makers:
Make Satu Mare even more attractive for domestic and foreign investors
Overcome crisis effects and find new ways of generating sustainable, environment friendly
economic growth, by stimulating R&D, IT businesses, high-tech industries, high added
value activities with low or no environmental impact.
Capitalize on the city’s geo-strategic position at a crossroads of commercial, cultural and
touristic routes, promote road infrastructure projects that keep commercial traffic out of the
city and link Satu Mare to the European motorways network (50 km away)
Find ways to bring out the most of the really significant cultural and touristic potential,
make better use of the geo-thermal resources, stimulate projects aiming at creating leisure
opportunities, capitalize on the rather unpolluted environment, protected natural areas,
further encourage environment protection activities, awareness, education
Strengthen bonds to the several higher education institutions that function in the city, better
adapt lower education to the higher education offer and labor market demands, capitalize
on the multi-ethnic, skilled work force
Continue investments in the health care system, attract highly qualified medical staff
Capitalize on the existing network of social assistance institutions, improve cooperation
with the NGO network
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
13
3.3 Urban programming and Urban Task Forces (UTF)
We started off by drafting a rather comprehensive list of stakeholders, including the most relevant
public institutions, universities, business organizations, civil society and private sector
representatives in an attempt to get a broad view on urban issues and define a coherent vision on
its future development. We sent all of them a letter signed by the mayor, explaining in broad lines
what the STATUS project is about, how we intended to approach the elaboration of the city
development strategy and asking for their cooperation. We then had individual meetings with each of
them separately, and most answered eagerly assuming participation. Some, however were either not
able or unwilling to accept the challenge, but by the time the first workshop was organized, the degree
of acceptance was rather satisfying.
A comparative analysis of the initial stakeholders list and that following the first workshop
shows differences that are almost self-explanatory: we were disappointed by the lack of interest
shown by several public institutions, private companies and even the elected representative of a
rather disadvantaged neighborhood and, on the other hand, have received positive feedback from
others whom we had omitted from the initial list. Moreover, there has been a decision to
supplement the initial stakeholders list with members of the Internationally Financed Projects
Department in the City Hall, as they would play a key role in both the elaboration and the
implementation of most of the projects that would result from the strategy. Overall, we ended in
having 31 participants in the first workshop, as compared with the 34 on the initial list.
59%14%
12%
15%
Initial Stakeholders List - 34
Public Institutions
Civil Society
Private Stakeholders
University, R&D
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
14
Participation in the second workshop was somewhat increased: Some institutions and
organizations sent two, even three representatives (The Satu Mare Metropolitan Area, The
Technical University of Cluj, The Satu Mare Local Taxes and Contributions Department), a few
new institutions showed up that couldn’t make it for the first workshop ( The Satu Mare County
Education and Health Departments), we had a foreign expert in mobility and traffic planning and
two independent architects involved in the elaboration of the new GUP, while the City Hall
decided to send more Internationally Financed Projects Department staff. On the other hand, there
were a few institutions and organizations that couldn’t be present due to a parallel event organized
at county level. Overall, we had an attendance list of 40 in Workshop II.
64%11%
18%
7%
Workshop I Attendance - 31
Public Institutions
Civil Society
Private Stakeholders
University, R&D
59%14%
12%
15%
Workshop II Attendance - 40
Public Institutions
Civil Society
Private Stakeholders
University, R&D
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
15
Workshop III gathered an attendance of 32, with some institutions missing due to overlapping
engagements, one important addition (The North-West Regional Development Agency) and a
stronger presence of the Water Distribution Company and The County Environment Protection
Agency represented by 2, respectively 3 people.
Overall, we had a great, rewarding experience regarding the willingness to participate in the
debates, to contribute, to bring arguments, to analyze, evaluate, suggest solutions, prioritize etc.
We could conclude by noting that once we managed to get people to come – which was
particularly difficult because of fluid schedules and overlapping engagements – they were more
than eager to contribute.
Setting up an Urban Task Force once the design phase of the Agenda was completed seemed
a justifiable endeavor meant increase the capacity to implement the Strategy. It was also a logical
follow up of the participatory process on which the elaboration of the strategy was based, in the
sense that such an entity can ensure better sustainability, providing a better chance for the
achievement of the objectives and ambitions assumed during the design phase.
Therefore, following a careful assessment of the individual contributions and degree of
involvement, as well as taking into consideration the available expertise in various domains and
the capacity to attract and mobilize additional experts for particular, project-based tasks, a number
of people among the stakeholders were asked to form the nucleus of the Urban Task Force.
The main goals of the workshop dedicated to the formation of the Urban Task Force were to
reach consensus regarding the necessity of setting up this body and its organizational form and
structure. The event was included into the agenda of Workshop III and was organized as a separate
session on July 4th
2014.
72%
19%
6%
3%
Workshop III Attendance - 32
Public Institutions
Civil Society
Private Stakeholders
University, R&D
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
16
All 32 Workshop III participants took part in the discussion whose conclusion was that for
functionality reasons, we should not set up a large organization, but rather rely on a compact
group of people who can resort to the expertise and support of all the other stakeholders
whenever necessary.
An illustration of the combination of methods used in attracting stakeholders and
maintaining their interest can be found in the following diagram:
Participatorytools in the process of
ST/UA design
public events
letters of intent to
stakeholders
public round tables
individualmeetings
using theGeoblog as a
tool
expert’s assistance
56%19%
19%
6%
Satu Mare Urban Task Force - 18
Public Institutions
Civil Society
Private Stakeholders
University, R&D
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
17
WG2WG1
WG3 WG4
Regarding the three workshops during which the Satu Mare Development Strategy took shape we may say
they were a beneficial participatory exercise, both for the stakeholders and for the Municipality.
The first workshop took place on November 28-29 2013 and it was primarily focused on identifying
problems. Wehad stakeholders from all fields of activity, able to contribute effectively to the
identification of problems in the areas studied within the project and a team of hired experts in the
following domains: urban planning, social issues, environment, economy and governance.
Based on available documents and information, the team ofexperts prepared the SWOT analyses
for the above-mentioned areas, which was discussed and completedduring the workshop.
Identified weaknesses were stated as problems and then prioritized.
The workshop activity was organized in both plenary sessions and working groups:
1. Urban planning and mobility
2. Social (education, culture, social protection, health)
3. Environment
4. Economy
The topics of discussion for each working group have been the following:
1. Working Group 1 – Urban Planning and Mobility. Moderated by Arête Management
Consulting
Topography, Someş River corridor, roads, industrial sites, urban area, Metropolitan
Area, urban structures, urban regeneration, cultural heritage, urban sprawl, spatial
planning;
Strategic inner-city areas, territorial fragmentation, peripheral neighborhoods, urban
values, public spaces, land opportunities, blocks of flats;
Natural potential (river, lakes, vegetation, forests), gardens, abandoned/under-
used/polluted/degraded areas;
Border point, international airport, express road Nyiregyhaza – Baia Mare, position
relative to other European/national roads, railway infrastructure, inter-modal facilities;
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
18
Roads network, bypass road, traffic, Someş River crossing points (bridges), railway
crossing, streets quality, public transportation, passenger services, sidewalks, bicycle
lanes, alternative (environment friendly) means of transportation, parking places.
2. Working Group 2 – Social field. Moderated by Arête Management Consulting
Population, ethnical structure, labour force, emigration of young people, criminality
rate, wage level, dependency rate, demographic aging, unemployed, birth rate, human
resources, retired persons, professional orientation/reconversion/qualification,
population mentality, human development;
Educational network, infrastructure renovation, places and attendance by levels of
education, cooperation between public institutions and NGOs, elderly care centers,
social projects, shelters for vulnerable people, leisure facilities, vocational education
infrastructure, accommodation and transportation for commuters, social housing,
access of people with disabilities into institutions and transportation means;
Educational level, educational units, educational events, local public expenditure in
education, school population, school dropout, life-long learning;
Medical units, medical staff, medical equipment, life expectancy, mortality rate,
natural increase of population;
Local public expenditure in cultural infrastructure, cultural institutions, cultural
events, books, lack of Summer Theatre, hall of events, Children’s Theatre;
Stadium, Municipal Sports Club, sports events, lack of Olympic swimming pool,
multifunctional sports hall.
3. Working Group 3 – Environment. Moderated by Arête Management Consulting
Air monitoring, air pollution;
Water sources, water quality, geothermal waters;
Water supply, presence of asbestos in the water distribution network, water loss in the
networks;
Waste water collection and treatment;
Waste management, waste disposal, waste agents, recycling, biodegradable waste;
Lack of waste management system.
4. Working Group 4 – Economy. Moderated by Arête Management Consulting
Vicinity of European highways, Satu Mare Metropolitan Area, Data Portal, economic
indicators, average wage, distance to neighboring localities, labor force,
unemployment, industry, active companies, foreign investors, export, services, local
resources and products, industrial parks, agriculture, airport, political and economic
lobby & local marketing, market demand, R&D, technological transfer and applied
research, old technologies, cooperation between education and industry, road
infrastructure, industrial sites, legislation on PPP, TIC, air transportation, clustering,
exhibition hall, absorbtion of EU funds, available competences and skills;
Tăşnad spa, culture and traditions, historical monuments and buildings, local festivals,
protected natural areas, medieval churches, lakes and rivers, fishing, extreme sports
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
19
opportunities, tourism infrastructure, tourism services, staff quality, lack of
information centers and tourism database, rural tourism, business tourism, landscape,
cultural and historic heritage, roads, tourist routes, bicycle lanes.
5. Plenary session – Territorial Governance. Moderated by Arête Management
Consulting
Public debates, transparency of information, cooperation between public and private
actors, business community (best practice).
The topics debated upon by the experts and participants during the second workshop, organized on
March 20-21 2014, in plenary sessions or working groups were:
the strategic framework for the development of Satu Mare, including all relevant
regulations issued at EU/national/regional/local level, applicable during the next
programming period 2014-2020;
the frame of reference for the strategy, comprising the socio-economic analysis for the
Municipality of Satu Mare;
finalization of the problem trees and identification of solutions taking into account the
main orientations (strategic directions) established by the Europe 2020 Strategy and the
commitments of the Romanian government;
establishing the priority axes for the future development of the Satu Mare municipality
and the solutions to address the issues already identified during first workshop, based
on the guidelines derived from the Europe 2020 thematic objectives and the investment
priorities contained by the operational programs for the 2014-2020 period.
The focus was on finding solutions to the problems identified during workshop 1 and grouping them
under six priority axes (listed below) as pillars for the sustainable development:
PA 1 – Improving accessibility and incentive measures for a sustainable mobility
PA 2 – Environmental protection and promotion of efficient use of resources including energy
efficiency measures at local level
PA 3 – Tourism and cultural heritage, including actions to improve the urban environment, city
revitalization, regeneration and remediation of contaminated sites
AP 4 - Promoting an inclusive socio-economic environment and combating poverty
AP 5 –Promotion of RDI and measures to boost local SMEs competitiveness
PA 6 – An efficient public administration, orientated towards citizens and businesses
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
20
WG2WG1
WG3 WG4
The four working groups were the same as those set up in the first seminar:
a) Urban planning and mobility
b) Social (education, culture, social protection, health)
c) Environment
d) Economy
The main topics discussed within each working group were:
Working Group 1 – Urban Planning and Mobility. Moderated by Arete
Management Consulting
Correlation of the strategy with the proposals and regulations of the future Urban
Master Plan of Satu Mare City (under preparation);
Urban structure, urban heritage, historic area protection against negative effects of
traffic, public spaces, urban regeneration;
Urban development issues: strategic intra-urban lands, solving territorial
fragmentation, peripheral neighborhoods, urban sprawl;
Natural potential (river, lakes, vegetation, forests), gardens, abandoned/under-
used/polluted/degraded lands;
External accessibility: border points, international airport, express road Nyiregyhaza –
Baia Mare, position towards other European/national roads, railway infrastructure,
interchange facilities;
Roads network and traffic: bypass road, connectivity (ring roads), Someş River
crossing points (bridges), railway crossing facilities, streets quality, internal
accessibility;
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
21
Transport: public transportation - infrastructure and services for passengers, sidewalks,
pedestrian streets and areas, bicycle lanes, veloroutes, parking places, accessibility
within the Metropolitan Area.
Working Group 2 – Social Issues. Moderated by Arete Management
Consulting
1. Attracting and maintaining qualified labor in the city;
Training suitable competences for the labor market;
Increase of living standards;
Reduction the school dropout;
Increase city attraction.
Working Group 3 – Environment. Moderated by Arete Management
Consulting
Air monitoring, air pollution;
Water sources, water quality, geothermal waters;
Ecologically sustainable solutions to make the Someş River practicable for water
sports (rowing, kayak, a.s.o.) and for leisure navigation;
Waste water collection and treatment;
Waste management, waste disposal, waste agents, recycling and recovery,
biodegradable waste;
Working Group 4 – Economy. Moderated by Arete Management
Consulting
Vicinity of European motorway network, Satu Mare Metropolitan Area, foreign
investments, services with added value, capitalization on local resources and products,
new / expanded industrial parks (airport industrial park), agriculture and food
processing industry, use of EU funds, available competences and skills of labor force;
Boost tourism by capitalization on the geothermal potential of Satu Mare through
developing an integrated approach leading to the setup of a spa/geriatric tourism
center in parallel with necessary investments to increase the attractiveness of the
Someş River area and rehabilitation of the historic Centre of the city as viable options
for recreation for both residents and tourists;
Support for further development of the technical University in Satu Mare especially in
order to add value and capitalize on local and regional natural resources namely
agriculture, food processing and renewable technologies (geothermal waters) through
applied research;
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
22
Support for high-skilled workforce: investment in high-school laboratory
infrastructure, development of scientific laboratories in local University,
renovating/building new campuses etc.
Following workshop 2, the team of experts came up with the draft Strategic Agenda which was
distributed to the stakeholders for consultation and comments, in preparation for the final
workshop.
Workshop 3took place on July 3-4 2014 and it concentrated – in plenary session - on the design
of the Strategic Agenda, grouping integrated projects under Priority Axes, Investment Priorities
and Specific Objectives.
Furthermore, estimated budgets were discussed, as well as monitoring indicators.
The second day was dedicated to the issues regarding the setting up of the Urban Task Force.
4 Goals and projects of the SUA
Following the fundamental guidelines set forth by the EUROPE 2020 Strategy, the Satu Mare City
Development Strategy 2015 – 2025 is centered around a vision that is expected to be fulfilled by
(integrated) projects meant to achieve Specific Objectives grouped under Investment Priorities that fall
under Priority Axes.
All of these are synthetically presented in the following table (including cost estimation, potential sources
of funding and prioritization within 3 categories) while a more detailed presentation can be found in
ANNEX 1:
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
23
PA 1 – Improving accessibility and incentive measures for a sustainable mobility
IP. 1.1. Improving regional accessibility
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
1.1.1 Improving regional accessibility of
Satu Mare (to TEN-T and other high speed
roads)
1.1.1.1 City road bypass CCSM, ROP,
NCHNRR A-B
1.1.1.2Express road Nyiregyhaza - Satu Mare-
Baia Mare 6.000.000 euro/km
LIOP (?), ROP,
CCSM, NCHNRR A-B
1.1.1.3 Express road Satu Mare – Halmeu -
Turda 6.000.000 euro/km ROP, CCSM A-B
1.1.2Improving accessibility within
MASM 1.1.2.1 Rehabilitation of CR 193, NR 18H 60,000,000
CCSM, ROP,
NCHNRR A-B
IP. 1.2. Optimize urban mobility including through modernization and development of public transport, based on a sustainable urban mobility for Satu Mare
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation Potential source of
funding Project priority*
1.2.1 Improving road network connectivity
(according to GUP and / or mobility plan)
1.2.1.1 Pedestrian and bicycle bridge over the
Someș river, on the railway bridge structure
between Micro 17 - Unio and str. Ș trandului
2,000,000 LCSM A
1.2.1.2 Pedestrian and bicycle bridge over the
Someş river on the axis October 25 Square -
pedestrian route Corneliu Coposu and Liberty
Square
4,500,000 LCSM, ROP A-B
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
24
1.2.1.3 Road bridge over the Someș river in
the western part of the city (str. Ș trand) 30,000,000 LCSM, ROP B
1.2.1.4 Streets penetration to supplement the
existing road network according to ZUP / GUP 40,000,000 LCSM, ROP A-B
1.2.1.5 Extension and modernization of roads,
intersections refurbishment, according to ZUP
/ GUP
30,000,000 LCSM, ROP A-B
1.2.2. Organizing an efficient, safe,
ecological public transport
1.2.2.1 Integrated project of public transport
system modernization and greening regarding:
- Bus fleet renewal for the public transport
and urban logistics ( electrified or hybrid
vehicles), 13,500,000 lei / 10 hybrid buses - -
- computerization of the transport system
(25,000,000 lei)
- extension of public transport routes
50,000,000 lei
- refurbishment and multiplication of public
bus stops etc.
(10,000,000 lei)
98,500,000 ROP, LCSM A
1.2.3. Stimulating mobility within MASM
1.2.3.1 Intermodal bus terminal in the
northern part of the city - connected to other
transport modes
1,500,000 CCSM, LCSM A-B
1.2.3.2 Intermodal bus terminal in the
southern part of the city - connected to other
transport modes
1,500,000 CCSM, LCSM A-B
1.2.4. Gradual construction of an
infrastructure for cyclists
1.2.4.1 Bicycle lanes to and within the central
area 15,000,000 ROP, LCSM A
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
25
1.2.4.2. Bicycle parkings (at public institutions
and other public interest activities, in
relationship with public transport stations etc.
10,00,000 ROP, LCSM A
1.2.4.3 Setting up of a network of self-service
bicycle stations 18,000,000 ROP, LCSM A-B
1.2.4.4 Bicycle lanes Bariṭ iu St– Gorunului
St - CR194A, for access to the Noroieni
recreational area
10,000,000 ROP, LCSM A-B
1.2.4.5 Bicycle routes between Satu Mare and
Păuleș ti, Odoreu, Vetiş, Dara 10,000,000 ROP, LCSM A-B
1.2.4.6 Redevelopment of a bicycle route Satu
Mare-Botiz on the narrow railway
embankment
10,000,000 ROP, LCSM A-B
1.2.4.7 Redevelopment of a bicycle route
from Satu Mare to Viile Satu Mare; 10,000,000 ROP, LCSM A-B
1.2.5. Reorganization of the parking
network
1.2.5.1 Creation of a / some park&ride
facilities on the ring road around the
downtown area (in intermodal relation with
public transport stations, bicycle parkings) –
coordination with 3.1.1.1
17,000,000/multi-storey
car park (270 spaces) ROP, LCSM A
1.2.5.2 Creation of a / some parking decks
(under- / aboveground) in the historical
downtown area (in October 25 Square and / or
around Liberty Square area etc.) -
Coordination with 3.1.1.1
40,000,000 lei/
underground car park(400
spaces)
ROP, LCSM A
1.2.5.3 Creation of a parking for large
vehicles (heavy traffic) 3,000,000 ROP, LCSM B
1.2.6. Improvement and expansion of the
infrastructure for pedestrians
1.2.6.1 Pedestrian underground passage under
the railway between Traian and Cimitirelor St. 26,000,000 ROP, LCSM B
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
26
1.2.6.2 Create / extend roads / areas
reservedfor pedestrians (pedestrian pathways,
shared spaces or zones under 30 km/h)
1,500,000 ROP, LCSM A,B
PA 2 - Environmental protection and promotion of efficient use of resources including energy efficiency measures at local level
IP. 2.1 Investments in water and wastewater/rainwater collection to meet environmental acquis of the European Union
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
2.1.1 Support for the completion of
connecting households to public water-
sewage network and elimination of
leakages from the drinking water
distribution network
2.1.1.1 Complete connection of Satu Mare
households to the water-sewage public service. 20,000,000 lei
Ongoing SOP
Environment A
2.1.1.2 Rehabilitation of the drinking water
supply network 20,000,000 lei
Ongoing SOP
Environment A
2.1.2 Promoting solutions for indirect
discharge of waste waters (dispersion in
the meadow area) coming from the
Wastewater Treatment Plant (even if they
fully comply with the standards set by
NTPA001)
2.1.2.1 System of indirect discharge of treated
water into the Someș river 900,000 lei CF, ERDF C
2.1.3 Building a buffer tank for the
collection of pluvial waters in case of
heavy rainfall
2.1.3.1 Buffer tank for the collection of pluvial
waters in case of heavy rainfall 1,500,000 lei CF, ERDF A
2.1.4 Effective management of sludge
resulted from the wastewater treatment
plant, including recycling measures
2.1.6.1 Implementation of measures related to
WWTP sludge management 30,000,000 lei CF, ERDF B-C
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
27
IP. 2.2 Investments in the waste collection and disposal sector to comply with European directives
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
2.2.1 Support/organization, including
using administrative instruments
(differentiated incentive fees, refusal to
pick up mixed waste etc.) of separate
collection of potentially economically
viable/recyclable waste from households
and companies
2.2.1.1. Increasing the awareness level of the
population and local authorities regarding
specific urban waste management issues.
300,000 lei ACOP, HCOP,
LCSM A
2.2.1.2. Development / Stimulating selective
waste collection by expanding the waste
collection points network
500,000 lei ACOP, HCOP,
LCSM A
2.2.2 Measures in view to stimulating
the economic use of compost
2.2.2.1 Elaboration of a Guide for the
production of compost in households and in
companies adapted to the specific local
conditions
50,000 lei ACOP, HCOP A
2.2.2.2. Adoption of a procedures manual for
the stimulation of compost production from
biodegradable waste (including offering
specialized technical assistance and necessary
tools)
50,000 lei ACOP, HCOP A
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
28
2.2.2.3. Support for the setting up of a
specialized company for the production and
capitalization of compost.
ACOP, HCOP,LCSM A-B
2.2.2.4. Extending waste storage capacity at
Doba with an anaerobic composting
installation for biodegradable waste (sludge)
with biogas as a byproduct
1,000,000 lei
LIOP, LCSM, ETC,
Environment Fund,
State budget
B
2.2.3 Measures aimed at stimulating
capitalization of the collected recyclable
waste at local level
2.2.3.1. Elaboration of a market study on the
opportunity of developing recyclable waste
processing industries in Satu Mare
200,000 lei
ACOP, HCOP,
LCSM, Environment
Fund
A-B
2.2.3.2. Preparation by the municipal / county
authorities of the necessary decisions and
procedures in order to stimulate the
development of waste processing industries in
Satu Mare (including compost production out
of biodegradable waste).
100,000 lei ACOP, HCOP,
LCSM A
IP. 2.3 Supporting energy efficiency and renewable energy use in public infrastructure, public buildings and housing in parallel with drawing up a strategy
aimed to increasing the energy efficiency at municipal level
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
29
2.3.1. Continuation of thermal
rehabilitation of condominiums including
replacement of roof asbestos tiles
2.3.1.1 Thermal rehabilitation of residential
buildings
ROP, LCSM,
Private sources A
2.3.1.2 Thermal rehabilitation of public
buildings ROP, LCSM A,B,C
2.3.2. Support for energy renewable
resources: solar panels, photovoltaic
panels, geothermal sources
2.3.2.1 Investments in drilling and distribution
of geothermal energy as heating source for the
Satu Mare city
4,500,000 lei/MWt LIOP, ROP, LCSM
Environment fund B
2.3.2.2 Investments in producing thermal
energy based on biomass / solar energy 1,800,000 lei
LIOP, ROP, LCSM
Environment fund B
2.3.3. Ecological public lighting 2.3.3.1 Investments in ecological public
lighting 25,000,000 lei
Romanian-Swiss
Fund, Norwegian
Fund, Environmental
Fund, LIOP, LCSM
A,B
PA 3 – Tourism and cultural heritage, including actions to improve the urban environment, city revitalization, regeneration and remediation of contaminated
sites
IP. 3.1 Improvement of the urban environment, urban revitalization, regeneration and remediation of contaminated sites and promotion of measures to
reduce risks to human health (including noise reduction)
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
30
3.1.1 Reorganization and redevelopment of
the central area
3.1.1.1 Integrated Territorial Project (ITI) -
rehabilitation of center area partially
pedestrian, improvement and expansion of
pedestrian infrastructure, limited access for
vehicles, parking reorganization, infrastructure
for cyclists: lanes, parkings etc., ecologic
public lighting and rehabilitation of utilities
networks etc. (coordination with 1.2.6.1,
1.2.5.1, 1.2.5.2)
40,000,000 lei +
17,000,000 lei parking (pt.
1.2.5.1)+
40,000,000 lei (pt.
1.2.5.2)+
15,000,000 (pt. 1.2.4.1)
ROP, CLSM A
3.1.1.2. Modernization of the Firemen Tower
park, Garden of Rome 4,000,000 lei x 2 parks ROP, LCSM A
3.1.1.3. Rehabilitation of the Dinu Lipatti
Philharmonic 7,000,000 lei ROP, LCSM A
3.1.1.4 Investments for the capitalization of the
Administrative Palace building terrace ROP, LCSM, ETC A,B
3.1.2 Regeneration / rehabilitation of
public spaces in collective residential
districts
3.1.2.1. Integrated projects - redevelopment of
public spaces favorable to non-motorized
traffic (pedestrian or bicycle) inside residential
districts: pathways, shared-spaces or areas
under ’30 (km/h) –Solidarităţii area, Micro
14,15,16,17 area, Carpaţi I, II districts
20,000,000-30,000,000
lei/ district ROP, LCSM
3.1.3 Promotion of a sustained cultural life
3.1.3.1 Setting up of the Romanian language
Puppet Theatre 3,000,000 lei ROP, LCSM A
3.1.3.2 Setting up of the Summer Theater 6,000,000 lei ROP, LCSM B
3.1.4 Development of an integrated project
sports – tourism – leisure: multifunctional
hall on the stadium grounds
3.1.4.1 Development of an integrated project
sport – tourism – leisure: multifunctional hall
on stadium grounds
45,000,000 ROP, LCSM, ETC B
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
31
IP. 3.2 Sustainable capitalization of natural heritage for leisure and sports
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
3.2.1 Spatial planning of the Somes
riverbed with a view to practicing / hosting
competitions for water sports
3.2.1.1 Redevelopment of Someș riverbed in
view to ensuring proper fairway 50,000,000 lei ROP, ETC, LCSM B-C
3.2.1.2 Development of public spaces and
recreational and leisure services along the
Someș river
5,000,000 lei
Public – private
partnership, ROP,
LCSM
A,B
3.2.2 Developing an integrated spa
center by capitalizing on geothermal
waters - ITI - at Noroieni
3.2.2.1 Construction of a spa center ROP, ETC, LCSM A,B,C
3.2.2.2 Investment in drilling and construction
of geothermal water pools ROP, ETC, LCSM A,B,C
3.2.2.3 Construction of a geriatric care /
treatment center 67,500,000 lei ROP, ETC, LCSM A,B,C
PA 4 - Promoting an inclusive socio-economic environment and combating poverty
IP. 4.1 Investments in the health and social infrastructures, ensuring inclusive access of disadvantaged categories to public services
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
32
4.1.1 Support for the elderly and for the
people with special needs
4.1.1.1 Setting up of a multifunctional
residential center for the elderly 6,000,000 lei ROP A
4.1.1.2 Setting up and support for a
multifunctional socio-medical center 10,000,000 lei ROP A-B
4.1.2 Support for the victims of
domestic violence
4.1.2.1 Setting up of a support center for the
victims of domestic violence 2,900,000 lei ROP B
4.1.3 Social and economic integration
of marginalized communities and of
disadvantaged persons
4.1.3.1 Rehabilitation of a building for social
housing units
13,000,000 lei – 120
households ROP A
IP. 4.2 Investing in education, skills and lifelong learning
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
4.2.1 Reducing and preventing school
dropout
4.2.1.1 Construction/ expansion/
modernization of school campus 2,000,000 –10,000,000 lei ROP, MNE
4.2.2 Development of professional
pathway and training of labor market
required skills
4.2.2.1 Ensuring necessary equipment for
laboratories in elementary schools/
professional schools/ high schools
1,000,000 lei/educational
unit ROP
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
33
PA 5 –Promotion of RDI and measures to boost local SMEs competitiveness
IP. 5.1 Support of scientific and technical university education
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
5.1.1 Support for attracting students from
county and regional level to attend a
technical university in Satu Mare
5.1.1.1 Redevelopment of university campus
CL, MEN, POCU A-B
5.1.1.2 Offering merit related grants for
valuable highschool graduates that go to
college in Satu Mare
5.1.2 Support for the development of
technical and applied university education
5.1.2.1 Expansion of laboratories space in the
Satu Mare Extension of the Cluj Napoca
Technical University Campus
CL, MEN, POCU
A-B-C
5.1.3 Supporting university education in
areas that exploit local natural resources
(foodstuffs chemistry, foodstuffs industry,
food safety, agronomy, environment
protection, geothermal waters/energy etc.)
5.1.3.1 Setting up of a university study line for
foodstuffs chemistry/foodstuffs industry/
agronomy/ environment protection/ food
safety/ geothermal energy etc.
CL, MEN, POCU B
IP. 5.2 Support applied research in Satu Mare
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
34
5.2.1 Support for the setting up of a
regional center for applied research and
continuous training in the field of
advanced design and manufacturing
technologies in partnership with the
Technical University of Cluj Napoca
5.2.1.1 Setting up a regional applied research
center by rehabilitation of kindergarten
building
POC, POCU, CL,
CTE, CJ
A
5.2.2 Support for the establishment of a
regional center for applied research for the
capitalization of local resources (e.g.
agronomy and foodstuffs industry,
environmental protection, renewable
energy - geothermal)
5.2.2.1 Setting up a regional center for applied
research for the capitalization of local
resources
POC, POCU, CL,
CTE, CJ B
5.2.3 Attracting highly qualified
specialists to Satu Mare (providing
housing, transportation subsidies, etc.)
5.2.3.1 Offering housing facilities for highly
trained personnel willing to relocate to Satu
Mare
POCU, CL A,B,C
5.2.3.2 Offering settling bonuses for highly
trained personnel willing to relocate to Satu
Mare
I.P. 5.3 Support the creation of new SMEs to exploit local resources and research results
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
5.3.1 Expansion of industrial parks /
business incubators
5.3.1.1 Expansion/Setting up of technological
park for food processing industry/ environment
protection technologies
10,000,000 lei A
5.3.1.2 Partnership Agreement for setting up a
regional exhibition center for agronomy/
foodstuffs industry/ thermal water spa tourism/
nonconventional industries
A,B
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
35
PA 6 – An efficient public administration, orientated towards citizens and businesses
IP. 6.1 A public administration in the service of citizens including e-government
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
6.1.1 Implementation and certification of
an integrated management system
(environment, quality, health and
occupational safety) in compliance with
international standards ISO 14001, ISO
9001 and OHSAS 18001.
6.1.1.1 Certified integrated management
system for the Satu Mare City Hall 50,000 lei ACOP, HCOP A
6.1.2 Modernization of the City Hall
management
6.1.2.1 Drawing up performance indicators for
the provided services, `by human resources
development and use of modern technologies
ACOP, HCOP A,B
6.1.3 E-administration, One stop shop for
local permits issued electronically and
reduction of administrative burden
6.1.3.1 Digital platform and database of all
local public interventions and their
beneficiaries
ACOP, HCOP A,B
6.1.3.2 Setting up of a One stop shop ACOP, HCOP A,B
6.1.4 General cadaster of Satu Mare
Municipality available online
6.1.4.1 General cadaster of Satu Mare
Municipality available online ACOP, HCOP, ROP A,B
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
36
IP. 6.2 Building partnerships to implement the city development strategy
Specific Objective Project name Total cost estimation (lei) Potential source of
funding Project priority *
6.2.1 Increased capacity of the Satu Mare
municipality to work in local/regional/
international partnerships
6.2.1.1 Creation of project related partnerships
(e.g. rehabilitation of the central historic
downtown in partnership with the buildings
owners, with potential investors in pubs and
restaurants, with bicycle rental facilities
owners, with the philharmonic etc.)
ACOP, HCOP,
LCSM A
*Category of project: A – Priority 1 (Years 1-5); B-Priority 2 (Years 5-10); C-Priority 3 (>10
years);
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
37
5 Implementation of the SUA
5.1 Key actors responsible for the implementation of the ST/UA
An important point needs to be made clear at this stage: only the Municipality can be responsible for the
implementation of the Strategic Agenda, as the only legal entity that can initiate, ensure funding, launch
and carry out procurement procedures etc.
The Urban Task Force can only act as a support group, assisting the City in carrying out all the complex
procedures regarding the implementation. This has already been made clear in the Partnership Agreement
which states that the UTF is called upon to monitor the implementation of the Development Strategy, as
well as offer (especially know-how) support in various technical fields, as well as for the identification of
possible funding or project related partnerships.
On the other hand, since the strategic document has only just been elaborated, a more or less definite action
(beyond the project prioritization presented in the table above) plan would be – at the time being – a rather
unrealistic endeavor which we will not engage in.
For most of the public interventions included in the Strategy technical projects have yet to be drawn up,
possible funding sources still need to be identified, procurement procedures have to be carried out and then
an implementation calendar can be elaborated, or responsibilities can be assigned to appointed project
management teams.
5.2 Risk assessment
At this stage only a preliminary risk matrix has been drawn up, which is presented in the table below:
Table 1: Risk assessment
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
38
Priority Axes Investment Priorities Specific Objectives Specific Risks
PA 1 –
Improving
accessibility
and incentive
measures for a
sustainable
mobility
IP. 1.1. Improving
regional accessibility
1.1.1 Improving regional accessibility of Satu Mare (to
TEN-T and other high speed roads)
Investments planned in the National General Master Plan
for Transport are not achieved until 2025, as the NGMPT
does not feature a timeline. If investments are
programmed for 2015-2025, there is a risk of still not
receiving financing. If financed, there is a risk that for
objective reasons works are not completed
1.1.2 Improving accessibility within MASM Lack of support from the County Council
IP. 1.2. Optimize urban
mobility including
through modernization
and development of
public transport, based
on a sustainable urban
mobility for Satu Mare
1.2.1 Improving road network connectivity (according to
GUP and / or mobility plan)
GUP is not approved
Difficulties in land expropriation
1.2.2. Organizing an efficient, safe, ecological public
transport
Risk of inhabitants opposition due to increase in transport
cost
1.2.3. Stimulating mobility within MASM Lack of interest on the part of potential passengers
1.2.4. Gradual construction of an infrastructure for
cyclists
Lack of understanding on the part of vehicle drivers
Lack of interest on the part of potential beneficiaries
1.2.5. Reorganization of the parking network Possible opposition from the vehicle drivers
1.2.6. Improvement and expansion of the infrastructure
for pedestrians
Opposition from the vehicle drivers because driving space
is affected
PA 2 -
Environmental
protection and
promotion of
efficient use of
resources
including
energy
efficiency
measures at
local level
IP. 2.1 Investments in
water and
wastewater/rainwater
collection to meet
environmental acquis of
the European Union
2.1.1 Support for the completion of connecting
households to public water-sewage network and
elimination of leakages from the drinking water
distribution network
Possible lack of interest on the part of the beneficiaries
due to increase in costs
2.1.2 Promoting solutions for indirect discharge of
waste waters (dispersion in the meadow area) coming
from the Wastewater Treatment Plant (even if they fully
comply with the standards set by NTPA001)
Possible difficulties in acquiring the necessary ground
Possible opposition from neighboring households
2.1.3 Building a buffer tank for the collection of
pluvial waters in case of heavy rainfall
2.1.4 Effective management of sludge resulted from Lack of adequate technical solutions / high cost
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
39
the wastewater treatment plant, including recycling
measures
Lack of interest on the part of the decision makers
IP. 2.2 Investments in the
waste collection and
disposal sector to comply
with European directives
2.2.1 Support/organization, including using
administrative instruments (differentiated incentive fees,
refusal to pick up mixed waste etc.) of separate collection
of potentially economically viable/recyclable waste from
households and companies
Non conformation / non participation of the inhabitants
2.2.2 Measures in view to stimulating the economic
use of compost
Lack of SMEs interested in the activity
2.2.3 Measures aimed at stimulating capitalization of
the collected recyclable waste at local level
Low profitability
IP. 2.3 Supporting energy
efficiency and renewable
energy use in public
infrastructure, public
buildings and housing in
parallel with drawing up
a strategy aimed to
increasing the energy
efficiency at municipal
level
2.3.1. Continuation of thermal rehabilitation of
condominiums including replacement of roof asbestos
tiles
Lack of cooperation from the owners/tenants
2.3.2. Support for energy renewable resources: solar
panels, photovoltaic panels, geothermal sources
Lack of interest on the part of the authorities
2.3.3. Ecological public lighting
PA 3 –
Tourism and
cultural
heritage,
including
actions to
improve the
urban
environment,
city
revitalization,
IP. 3.1 Improvement of
the urban environment,
urban revitalization,
regeneration and
remediation of
contaminated sites and
promotion of measures to
reduce risks to human
health (including noise
reduction)
3.1.1 Reorganization and redevelopment of the central
area
Opposition from the company owners active in the area
during the rehabilitation works
Opposition from the drivers that transit the area frequently
Lack of cooperation from the building owners in the area
3.1.2 Regeneration / rehabilitation of public spaces in
collective residential districts
Opposition from residents using those public spaces
3.1.3 Promotion of a sustained cultural life Insufficient participation of the public and partial non-
sustainability of the investment
3.1.4 Development of an integrated project sports –
tourism – leisure: multifunctional hall on the stadium
grounds
Public opposition due to high investment cost
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
40
regeneration
and
remediation of
contaminated
sites
IP. 3.2 Sustainable
capitalization of natural
heritage for leisure and
sports
3.2.1 Spatial planning of the Somes riverbed with a
view to practicing / hosting competitions for water sports
Public opposition due to high investment cost
3.2.2 Developing an integrated spa center by
capitalizing on geothermal waters - ITI - at Noroieni
Poor sustainability due to lack of profile SMEs
PA 4 -
Promoting an
inclusive socio-
economic
environment
and combating
poverty
IP. 4.1 Investments in the
health and social
infrastructures, ensuring
inclusive access of
disadvantaged categories
to public services
4.1.1 Support for the elderly and for the people with
special needs
4.1.2 Support for the victims of domestic violence Lack of a foolproof system for identifying eligible
beneficiaries
4.1.3 Social and economic integration of marginalized
communities and of disadvantaged persons
Lack of cooperation from the beneficiaries
IP. 4.2 Investing in
education, skills and
lifelong learning
4.2.1 Reducing and preventing school dropout
Impossibility of eliminating all factors that generate this
phenomenon
Lack of cooperation from parents/students
4.2.2 Development of professional pathway and
training of labor market required skills
Insufficient interest of parents/students
PA 5 –
Promotion of
RDI and
measures to
boost local
SMEs
competitiveness
IP. 5.1 Support of
scientific and technical
university education
5.1.1 Support for attracting students from county and
regional level to attend a technical university in Satu
Mare
Insufficient interest of highschool graduates for attending
tertiary education
Attraction of consecrated university centers
5.1.2 Support for the development of technical and
applied university education
Insufficient interest of highschool graduates for attending
such difficult profiles
5.1.3 Supporting university education in areas that exploit
local natural resources (foodstuffs chemistry, foodstuffs
industry, food safety, agronomy, environment protection,
geothermal waters/energy etc.)
Insufficient interest of highschool graduates for attending
a new profile
IP. 5.2 Support applied
research in Satu Mare
5.2.1 Support for the setting up of a regional center for
applied research and continuous training in the field of
advanced design and manufacturing technologies in
partnership with the Technical University of Cluj Napoca
Difficulties with the financial support for research
projects
Insufficient qualified staff
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
41
5.2.2 Support for the establishment of a regional center
for applied research for the capitalization of local
resources (e.g. agronomy and foodstuffs industry,
environmental protection, renewable energy - geothermal)
Difficulties with the financial support for research
projects
Insufficient qualified staff
5.2.3 Attracting highly qualified specialists to Satu
Mare (providing housing, transportation subsidies, etc.)
Insufficient motivation for relocation
I.P. 5.3 Support the
creation of new SMEs to
exploit local resources
and research results
5.3.1 Expansion of industrial parks / business
incubators
Lack of interest on the part of investors for industrial
parks/business incubators
PA 6 – An
efficient public
administration,
orientated
towards
citizens and
businesses
IP. 6.1 A public
administration in the
service of citizens
including e-government
6.1.1 Implementation and certification of an integrated
management system (environment, quality, health and
occupational safety) in compliance with international
standards ISO 14001, ISO 9001 and OHSAS 18001.
Difficulties in building and implementing the system
Insufficient motivation of employees for implementing
the system
6.1.2 Modernization of the City Hall management Opposition from staff against applying rigorous
performance criteria
6.1.3 E-administration, One stop shop for local permits
issued electronically and reduction of administrative
burden
Difficulties in administrative reorganization
Difficulties in training the necessary staff
6.1.4 General cadaster of Satu Mare Municipality
available online
Impossibility of completing this complex documentation
within the given time span
IP. 6.2 Building
partnerships to
implement the city
development strategy
6.2.1 Increased capacity of the Satu Mare municipality to
work in local/regional/ international partnerships
Lack of trust on the part of investors in the PPP system
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
42
General Risks
Technical Financial Institutional Legal
Insufficiently elaborated technical
projects
Lack of sufficient resources for the
implementation
Limited support from the part of the
City Hall for the implementation of
the strategy
Legislation and government policy
changes that cannot be anticipated at
the moment of the strategy
elaboration
Local technical competences deficit Investment value and operating
costs are underestimated
Lack of sufficiently qualified local
contractors for certain projects
Legal barriers that come up due to
the reglementation of certain
domains
Underestimating costs and
overestimating locally available
resources
Significant delays in payments to
the contractors that can stop works,
delay execution and increase costs
Insufficient competence level of the
City Hall staff
Slow judicial procedures
Poor quality works generating
increase of maintenance and repair
costs
Investment cost increase following
project reevaluation
Delays in approving technical
projects and issuing construction
permits
Legal uncertainties regarding the
properties involved in investments
projects
Less than optimal technical
solutions
Insolvency of contractors / suppliers
that can block projects
Uncertainties regarding the
operation having significant
influence on prioritizing the strategy
specific objectives
Selected contractors do not have the
necessary technical capacities for
carrying out works
Changes in the taxation system Lack of sufficiently qualified staff
for carrying out specific
assignments
Changes in the technical
requirements of the project
Increase of interest rates to an
unsustainable level
Lack of interest on the part of
certain institutions in solving
specific problems
Temporary suspension of FESI Limited capacity of attracting EU
funding
Delays in launching operational
programmes
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
43
5.3 Sustainability of the SUA
The Satu Mare City Development Strategy 2015 – 2025 has been from the start conceived to follow the
fundamental guidelines defined by EC through the Europe 2020 Strategy, aiming at sustainable
development.
Even a brief survey of the priority axes, investment priorities, specific objectives and proposed projects
presented below clearly demonstrates the same approach.
Infrastructure interventions have in view the decrease of fossil fuel use, the promotion of non-motorized
mobility, public transport interventions aim at replacing the bus fleet with electric/hybrid vehicles, there is
a consistent section dedicated to the promotion of energy efficient measures for housing units and public
buildings, even the use of geo-thermal resources for heating, tourism measures primarily have in view
ecologic interventions along the Someş river banks and the use of thermal water, economy interventions
aim at increasing added value and better use of local resources by means of applied research and without
intensive energy consumption, while social interventions aim at promoting an inclusive environment for
disadvantaged groups.
5.4 Monitoring and evaluation
As already mentioned above, during the final workshop experts and stakeholders have defined the
monitoring indicators for the Satu Mare Development Strategy 2015-2025 which are presented in the table
below.
According to the Partnership Agreement for the setting up of the Urban Task Force, the group will have
ordinary meetings every three months and extraordinary ones whenever at least 5 of the members deem
necessary. Therefore, since the group has only been officially constituted in September, their first meeting
will take place in December 2014, when it is expected that they will start discussing how they will assume
roles regarding monitoring particular projects according to their individual expertise.
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
44
PA 1 – Improving accessibility and incentive measures for a sustainable mobility
PI - 1.1. Improving regional accessibility (result indicators)
Bypass road for transit traffic (according to mobility study)
2015 2020 2025
0 40% 80%
Decrease of car accidents number in the city
2015 2020 2025
0 5% 10%
Support of sustainable commuting with the SMMA
2015 2020 2025
0 5% 10%
OS 1.1.1.Improving regional accessibility of Satu Mare (to TEN-T and other high speed roads)– output indicators
No. km constructed roads
2015 2020 2025
0 11+25+15 20+50+35
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
45
OS 1.1.2 Improving accessibility within the SMMA – output indicators
No. km of modernized roads
2015 2020 2025
15 35
PI 1.2 Optimize urban mobility based on a sustainable urban mobility plan for Satu Mare (result indicators)
Decrease of traffic waiting time
2015 2020 2025
15% 25%
Decrease of GHG (according to town hall study)
2015 2020 2025
10% 30%
Increased no. of public transport trips /% of PT trips in the modal structure of travel
2015 2020 2025
8% 15%
Increased passengers satisfaction
2015 2020 2025
8% 15%
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
46
Increased trip safety / reduced no. of accidents
2015 2020 2025
10% 20%
Increased no. of PT trips in the urban and suburban areas
2015 2020 2025
0% 15% 30%
Decreased no. of car commuting trips to Satu Mare
2015 2020 2025
0% 8% 15%
Increased % of non-motorized trips in modal travel structure
2015 2020 2025
0% 12% 20%
Reduced no. of street parking places / reduced no. of cars parked on the street
2015 2020 2025
200 1000 2000
Area of roadway given up for pedestrians/cyclists (sqm)
2015 2020 2025
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
47
500 4000 7500
Increased no. of pedestrian trips / % of pedestrian trips in modal structure of travel
2015 2020 2025
0% 10% 20%
OS 1.2.1. Improving road network connectivity (according to GUP and / or mobility plan) – output indicators
No. of km of built roads
2015 2020 2025
0 6 12
No. of km of widened roads
2015 2020 2025
0 0,5 2
No. of km of rehabilitated/modernized roads
2015 2020 2025
0 25 50
OS 1.2.2. An efficient, safe, ecological public transport – output indicators
No. of electric / hybrid vehicles purchased
2015 2020 2025
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
48
0 5 10
No. of PT stations modernized
2015 2020 2025
0 200 200
No. of km of PT roadway modernized
2015 2020 2025
0 5 10
OS 1.2.3. Stimulating mobility within SMMA – output indicators
No. of bus terminals with intermodal transfer facilities newly built
2015 2020 2025
0 1 2
OS 1.2.4. Design and (gradual) build of an infrastructure for cyclists – output indicators
No. of km of built lane
2015 2020 2025
0 50 150
No. of parkings/parking places built (for bicycles)
2015 2020 2025
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
49
30 300 600
Area covered by self-service (km2)
2015 2020 2025
0 1,2
5
OS 1.2.5. Reorganization of parking network – output indicators
No. of parking places created in decked structures
2015 2020 2025
0 300 1000
OS 1.2.6. Improvement and expansion of the infrastructure for pedestrians – output indicators
Area/no. of sqm streets for pedestrians: pathways/areas under 30 km/h, shared-space
2015 2020 2025
400 2000 5000
PA 2- Environmental protection and promotion of efficient use of resources including energy efficiency measures at local level
PI 2.1 Investments in water and wastewater/rainwater collection to meet environmental acquis of the European Union (result indicators)
Complete connection of housing units to the drinking water/wastewater public network
2015 2020 2025
99,98% / 98,05% 100% / 100%
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
50
Elimination of leakages in the drinking water distribution network
2015 2020 2025
35% 23% 18%
Increased rate of compliance with NTPA 001
2015 2020 2025
97% 100% -
Increased quality of wastewater treatment processes
2015 2020 2025
97% 100% -
OS 2.1.1 Support for the completion of connecting households to public water-sewage network and elimination of leakages from the drinking water
distribution network – output indicators
No. of households connected to drinking water/wastewater distribution network
2015 2020 2025
44103/43251 44112/44112
Length of rehabilitated drinking water distribution/ sewage network
2015 2020 2025
13,26 / 27 14,66 / 27
OS 2.1.2 Promoting solutions for indirect discharge of waste waters (dispersion in the meadow area) coming from the Wastewater Treatment Plant (even if
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
51
they fully comply with the standards set by NTPA001) – output indicators
Volume indirectly discharged / Volume totally treated (%)
2015 2020 2025
0 50 80 - 100
OS 2.1.3 Building a buffer tank for the collection of pluvial waters in case of heavy rainfall – output indicators
Functional buffer tank
2015 2020 2025
0 1
OS 2.1.4 Effective management of sludge resulted from the wastewater treatment plant, including recycling measures –output indicators
Volume of recycled treated sludge/total volume of treated sludge produced (%)
2015 2020 2025
0% 30% 60%
PI 2.2 Investments in the waste collection and disposal sector to comply with European directives(result indicators)
Fully functional selective waste collection system
2015 2020 2025
0 1 1
Volume of stored biodegradable waste
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
52
2015 2020 2025
5000 3500 1500
OS 2.2.1 Support/organization, including using administrative instruments (differentiated incentive fees, refusal to pick up mixed waste etc.) of separate
collection of potentially economically viable/recyclable waste from households and companies – output indicators
No.of awareness campaigns organized by the City Hall
2015 2020 2025
4 25 45
No. of functional selective collection points created
2015 2020 2025
250 260 270
OS 2.2.2 Measures in view to stimulating the economic use of compost – output indicators
Volume of biodegradable waste processed
2015 2020 2025
1500 t 3000t 5000t
OS 2.2.3 Measures aimed at stimulating capitalization of the collected recyclable waste at local level – output indicators
Volume of locally recycled waste
2015 2020 2025
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
53
5000t 12000t 20000t
PI 2.3 Supporting energy efficiency and renewable energy use in public infrastructure, public buildings and housing in parallel with drawing up
a strategy aimed to increasing the energy efficiency at municipal level (result indicators)
Reduced energy losses in residential/public buildings (MWh)
2015 2020 2025
7,48 30,8 57,2
Reduced energy consumption for public lighting
2015 2020 2025
100% 40% 40%
OS 2.3.1. Continuation of thermal rehabilitation of condominiums including replacement of roof asbestos tiles – output indicators
No. of thermally rehabilitated buildings
2015 2020 2025
850 3500 6500
OS 2.3.2. Support for energy renewable resources: solar panels, photovoltaic panels, geothermal sources – output indicators
Percentage of households/public buildings using thermal energy from geothermal/biomass/solar (%) sources
2015 2020 2025
5% 20% 30%
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
54
OS 2.3.3. Ecological public lighting – output indicators
Percentage of ecological public lighting
2015 2020 2025
0 100% 100%
PA 3 – Tourism and cultural heritage, including actions to improve the urban environment, city revitalization, regeneration and remediation of
contaminated sites
PI 3.1 Improvement of the urban environment, urban revitalization, regeneration and remediation of contaminated sites and promotion of
measures to reduce risks to human health (including noise reduction) (result indicators)
Increased no. of downtown located companies active in fields related to tourism and recreational activities
2015 2020 2025
0 15 20
Increased quality of living/Increased satisfaction of population (survey)
2015 2020 2025
35% 50% 70%
OS 3.1.1 Reorganization and redevelopment of the central area – output indicators
No. of sqm of rehabilitated roadway
2015 2020 2025
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
55
1500 12000 18000
No. of sqm of new pedestrian pathway
2015 2020 2025
0 1200 2000
No. of ml. of rehabilitated public infrastructure (water/sewage/gas)
2015 2020 2025
13,26 / 27/ 0 14,66 / 27 / 6
No. of km of bicycle lane
2015 2020 2025
7 50 100
No. of sqm of redeveloped park area
2015 2020 2025
0 19000 40000
No. of sqm of rehabilitated buildings facades
2015 2020 2025
0 2500 5000
OS 3.1.2 Regeneration / rehabilitation of public spaces in collective residential districts – output indicators
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
56
No. of sqm of redeveloped/rehabilitated public space
2015 2020 2025
0 7000 12000
OS 3.1.3 Promotion of a sustained cultural life – output indicators
No. of cultural events
2015 2020 2025
150 200 350
OS 3.1.4 Development of an integrated project sports – tourism - leisure – output indicators
Multifunctional hall/stadium built
2015 2020 2025
0 0 1
PI 3.2 Sustainable capitalization of natural heritage for leisure and sports (result indicators)
Organization of regional/national watersports competitions
2015 2020 2025
0 2 3
Increased number of tourists
2015 2020 2025
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
57
3% 15% 35%
OS 3.2.1 Spatial planning of the Somes riverbed with a view to practicing / hosting competitions for water sports – output indicators
Length of river/banks redeveloped
2015 2020 2025
0 800 1400
No.of participants involved in nautical sports/year
2015 2020 2025
30 200 350
OS 3.2.2 Developing an integrated spa center by capitalizing on geothermal waters - ITI - at Noroieni – output indicators
Functional thermal water spa and geriatric center
2015 2020 2025
0 1 1
PA 4 - Promoting an inclusive socio-economic environment and combating poverty
PI 4.1 Investments in the health and social infrastructures, ensuring inclusive access of disadvantaged categories to public services
Decreased no of people exposed to social exclusion risk
2015 2020 2025
-5% -9%
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
58
OS 4.1.1 Support for the elderly and for the people with special needs – output indicators
No. of centers rehabilitated/built
2015 2020 2025
4 6 8
No. of assisted persons
2015 2020 2025
300 400 500
OS 4.1.2 Support for the victims of domestic violence – output indicators
No.of centers rehabilitated/built
2015 2020 2025
0 1 1
No. of assisted persons
2015 2020 2025
0 40 40
OS 4.1.3 Social and economic integration of marginalized communities and of disadvantaged persons – output indicators
No.of centers rehabilitated/built
2015 2020 2025
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
59
1 2 3
No. of assisted persons
2015 2020 2025
1030 + 70 1400 2300
PI 4.2 Investing in education, skills and lifelong learning (result indicators)
School dropout percentage of total population under 24 years old in Satu Mare reduced by 3%
2015 2020 2025
-1% -2% -3%
Increased number of tertiary education graduates in the Satu Mare under 35 population
2015 2020 2025
+500 +3500 +8000
OS 4.2.1 Reducing and preventing school dropout – output indicators
No. of high school campuses created/modernized/extended
2015 2020 2025
0 1 2
OS 4.2.2 Development of professional pathway and training of labor market required skills – output indicators
No. of laboratories modernized
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
60
2015 2020 2025
0 5 10
PA 5 –Promotion of RDI and measures to boost local SMEs competitiveness
PI 5.1 Support of scientific and technical university education (result indicators)
Increased no. of scientific/technical university graduates who work in fields related to their studies
2015 2020 2025
5% 15% 20%
OS 5.1.1 Support for attracting students from county and regional level to attend a technical university in Satu Mare – output indicators
No of university students coming from outside Satu Mare
2015 2020 2025
0 1 1
OS 5.1.2 Support for the development of technical and applied university education – output indicators
No of technical university graduates
2015 2020 2025
60 90 160
No. of sqm of rehabilitated building / no. of sqm of extended space for laboratories
2015 2020 2025
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
61
200 500 700
5.1.3 Supporting university education in areas that exploit local natural resources (foodstuffs chemistry, foodstuffs industry, food safety, agronomy,
environment protection, geothermal waters/energy etc.) – output indicators
University department established
2015 2020 2025
1 1
No of foodstuffs chemistry / foodstuffs industry / food safety / agronomy / environment protection / geothermal waters /energy etc. graduates
2015 2020 2025
PI 5.2 Support applied research in Satu Mare (result indicators)
No. of patents/trademarks registered by the Satu Mare research center
2015 2020 2025
2 8 18
No. of RDI projects transferred to industry
2015 2020 2025
2 8 18
OS 5.2.1 Support the establishment of a regional center for applied research and continuous training in the field of advanced design technologies and
manufacturing in partnership with the Technical University of Cluj Napoca -output indicators
Functional regional applied research and life learning professional training center in the field of design and manufacturing advanced technologies
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
62
2015 2020 2025
0 1 1
No. of research projects completed
2015 2020 2025
2 20 30
OS 5.2.2 Support for the establishment of a regional center for applied research for the capitalization of local resources (e.g. agronomy and foodstuffs industry,
environmental protection, renewable energy - geothermal)– output indicators
Functional applied research center for the capitalization of local resources
2015 2020 2025
0 1 1
No. of research projects completed
2015 2020 2025
0 6 11
OS 5.2.3 Attracting highly qualified specialists to Satu Mare (providing housing, transportation subsidies, etc.)– output indicators
No. of attracted highly qualified specialists
2015 2020 2025
0 10 25
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
63
PI 5.3 Support the creation of new SMEs to exploit local resources and research results (result indicators)
Increased number of functional SMEs/1 000 inhabitants
2015 2020 2025
0% 5% 10%
Increased no. of jobs in local SMEs
2015 2020 2025
2% 7% 15%
OS 5.3.1 Expansion of industrial parks / business incubators – output indicators
No. of business centers/incubators redeveloped/developed technological parks
2015 2020 2025
0 1 1
No. of SMEs attracted /occupancy rate
2015 2020 2025
0 10 15
PA 6 – An efficient public administration, orientated towards citizens and businesses
PI 6.1 A public administration in the service of citizens including e-government (result indicators)
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
64
Increased satisfaction of citizens regarding the services supplied by the Satu Mare City Hall
2015 2020 2025
35% 50% 70%
OS 6.1.1 Implementation and certification of an integrated management system (environment, quality, health and occupational safety) in compliance with
international standards ISO 14001, ISO 9001 and OHSAS 18001– output indicators
Functional Functional integrated management system
2015 2020 2025
0 1 1
OS 6.1.2 Modernization of the City Hall managementbydrawing up performance indicators for the provided services, by human resources development and
use of modern technologies – output indicators
System of performance indicators
2015 2020 2025
0 1 1
OS 6.1.3 E-administration, One stop shop for local permits issued electronically and reduction of administrative burden – output indicators
No. e-administration services functional
2015 2020 2025
0 2 5
OS 6.1.4 General cadaster of Satu Mare Municipality available online– output indicators
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
65
General cadaster of Satu Mare Municipality available online
2015 2020 2025
0 1 1
PI 6.2 Building partnerships to implement the city development strategy (result indicators
No. of investment priorities fully implemented
2015 2020 2025
0 0 14
OS 6.2.1 Increased capacity of the Satu Mare municipality to work in local/regional/ international partnerships– output indicators
Functional Urban Task Force for the implementation of the development strategy
2015 2020 2025
1 1 1
Nr. social partners of the Satu Mare City Hall
2015 2020 2025
2 5 8
Partnerships focused on the investment priorities included in the development strategy
2015 2020 2025
1 3 6
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
66
5.5 Recommendations for the implementation of the SUA
During the strategy implementation period, the cooperation between authorities and stakeholders will
continue in order to ensure the transparency of decisions and community acceptance.
Formalizing an implementation mechanism involves several stages that begin with the creation of a
working group who will supervise the process throughout its duration. The advantages of such a
mechanism are obvious. Besides the aforementioned transparency and acceptance, the cooperation between
local authority and community representatives will lead to a continuous exchange of views on common
interest problems and, consequently, to making important decisions. At the same time, a basis is created for
the next strategic collaborations or for solving certain needs/problems that could not be referred to when
formulating the strategic document. Community cohesion is also an important advantage from the
perspective of civil society.
The phases that are to be gone through during the implementation period of the strategy are summarized
below:
I. Formation of a Urban Task Force for strategy implementation (UTF)
The basic principles of the working group were established together with the stakeholders
during the third workshop, held in early July 2014. The UTF includes Satu Mare authorities and
interested organizations representatives who took part in all discussions and related activities
during all three workshops within the project. It also includes a wide range of organizations in
all strategic areas: economic, environmental and social infrastructure. The UTF is designed to
track the implementation of the projects defined in the projects portfolio within their time frame,
and also to monitor the projects (output) and the strategic (result) indicators for the effects to be
reflected at city, community level.
The UTF members were required to elaborate the Partnership Agreement as a constitutive
document including a minimum series of working procedures for monitoring the indicators.
In the absence of a previous similar work experience, during the strategy execution it may be
necessary to adjust / adapt these internal documents in order to meet the realities occurring
during the implementation of such a comprehensive program. This strategy adjustment is not
meant to alter the UTF credibility or ability in any way, but rather to prove the flexibility of its
members. Therefore, those represented should not hesitate when such decisions need to be
made.
II. Creating partnerships
Besides the UTF who supervise the correct execution of the strategic plan, in order to fulfill the
purpose, namely the development and implementation of major / complex and sensitive projects
- either included in the strategic document or occurred as a response to certain emerging needs –
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
67
other human and material resources may be required, the formation of yet other partnerships
might be necessary. The liability of each party shall be clearly defined, avoiding shared
responsibility and risk intervention failure with waste of available resources.
Regarding regional projects execution, the complementarity of interventions, including the use
of resources, is a prerequisite for success. Lack of correlation between implementation and
resources allocation graphs, drafted by each region, as well as inefficient cooperation between
the responsible authorities within the involved regions, can lead to partial or total failure of the
project and to the waste of already scarce resources.
If innovative projects are carried out, less common in national context, partnership with
professional institutions at international level can be salutary in order to achieve the desired
results.
III. Monitoring the strategy implementation
Monitoring is a distinct activity during the strategy implementation period, which highlights the
deviations from the execution schedule and the eventual problems occurred during the measures
/ interventions development.
The UTF and, where appropriate, the partnership members will assess the achievements of the
strategy implementation process on two levels:
- at project level, by assessing: the execution of activities according to the schedule and
allocated resources, the achievement of the expected results to the quality intended. If
any problems occur, measures will be taken in order to solve them and their
implementation will be supervised;
Each project assessment will be carried out on a quarterly basis;
- at the strategy level, by assessing: the aggregate effects (result indicators) obtained at
community level as a result of projects implementation and any other effects that were
not initially foreseen;
The strategy assessment will be carried out on an annual basis;
IV. The strategy assessment
The strategy assessment required to be carried out annually shall be conducted taking into
account at least the following criteria:
- relevance of interventions related to the community needs;
- effectiveness of interventions, achievement of strategic objectives;
- efficiency of:
implementation system (at the level of Satu Mare City Hall and established UTF,
eventually of established partnerships);
interventions (obtained effects/outputs related to the allocated resources)
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
68
6 Project Fiches: Priority projects corresponding
to each goal / objective of the SUA
The table on pp.23-36 presents the projects number, description, estimated cost, funding opportunities and
envisaged timeline. With the exception of two infrastructure projects (1.1.1.2 and 1.1.1.3) all projects are
located exclusively in Satu Mare. Opportunities for partnerships have not yet been taken into consideration,
although they will surely be discussed at the right time.
7 The Poster Plan
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
69
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
70
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
71
8 Conclusions
One can say that the participatory process of the elaboration of the Satu Mare Development Strategy 2015
– 2025 has been a rewarding experience for all those involved, both because the result (the document) has
so far been regarded as satisfactory and because the process itself has managed to generate a very positive
work atmosphere, one in whichthe willingness to participate in the debates, to contribute, to bring
arguments, to analyze, evaluate, suggest solutions, prioritize etc. emerged as the natural way to be
in the given context.
We could conclude by noting that once we managed to get people to come – which was
particularly difficult because of fluid schedules and overlapping engagements – they were more
than eager to contribute. Throughout the three workshop meetings the stakeholders readily
engaged in the debates generated in the workgroups, contributing with information, expertise and
suggestions to the shaping-up of the Strategic Agenda. Good moderation also helped, together
with the careful establishing of a positive, relaxed atmosphere of pertinent discussions among
equals, whereby everyone could feel their opinion counts. There were no patronizing attitudes, no
attempts to ignore or soften negative aspects. Overall, we are quite satisfied with the degree of
active participation and genuine interest we could observe throughout the process and which,
despite our somewhat pessimistic expectations, did not decrease towards the end.
We are aware that ensuring a long-term participatory process in urban development is an even
more difficult task, but we do count on the already established relations and work atmosphere
within the group to play an important role. The more than democratic way the UTF partnership
agreement is conceived will also definitely help maintain this positive atmosphere. Other than that,
we will try to keep people motivated by showing appreciation for their efforts, by making sure that
as many as possible of their ideas and projects get implemented, by small incentives like, maybe
offering training, organizing social events, ensuring publicity for their work.
9 References
The Satu Mare City Development Strategy 2015 – 2025
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
72
10 Annexes
ANNEX 1
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
73
3. Development priority axes
The development vision of Satu Mare Municipality with the 2025 horizon will be sustained through six
priority axes of intervention, thus ensuring, through integrated implemented projects, the basis for a
sustainable, inclusive and intelligent growth, in accordance with the guidelines set out at EU level through
the Europe 2020 strategy as follows:
1. PA 1 – Improving accessibility and incentive measures for a sustainable mobility
Through this integrated development priority axis, the purpose is to improve the quality of
territorial (external) and urban (internal) accessibility in a sustainable manner, as a major premise
of a territory economic development, generally, and of a city, particularly. A good development of
passengers and freight flows is the main condition of connecting urban areas to regional, national
and continental economic streams.
The improvement of the accessibility is an incentive not only to expand the trade but also on
mobility mitigation within the Metropolitan Area Satu Mare, with positive effects on the medium
and long term regarding the increase of employment and the enticement of well-trained workforce
from the localities on which Satu Mare Municipality exerts a degree of influence.
A basic attribute of the Europe 2020 strategy is the sustainability, i.e. the capacity of a system to
provide a better quality service / product with a reduced consumption of resources especially from
the non-renewable and polluting category. Thus, through local development strategies, the increase
of the life quality will be carried out by providing services based mainly on renewable energy or
with a low pollution degree.
2. PA 2 – Environmental protection and promotion of efficient use of resources including energy
efficiency measures at local level
Through this integrated development priority axis it is aimed on the one hand:
Compliance with environmental standards and European directives transposed into
national law and assumed by Romania under the Treaty of Accession regarding: i) a
centralized supply of drinking water as a measure of increasing the comfort and health
status of city residents; ii) collection and wastewater treatment respecting the principle of
water discharge back to the nature at the same quality and parameters in which it was
taken; iii) integrated waste management especially considering the biodegradable waste
amount decrease deposited in the ecological landfills and ensuring of recycling degree
according to EU directives;
and, on the other hand, environmental protection by increasing efficiency of resources use:
Promoting measures in order to increase energy efficiency and use of renewable energy in
public infrastructure, including public buildings and residential sector. This investment
priority will have a dual effect, both reducing carbon emissions through the use of
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
74
renewables for domestic heating and hot water and resource protection through the thermal
rehabilitation of buildings, implementation of projects to ensure a public lighting with a
reduced consumption of energy (green lamps etc.) that will lead to substantial savings of
energy consumption.
3. PA 3 – Tourism and cultural heritage, including actions to improve the urban environment, city
revitalization, regeneration and remediation of contaminated sites
By implementing the measures comprised by this axis it is envisaged the city revitalization, due to the
capitalization of local heritage, of a more attractive and healthy urban environment. The main interventions
which shall be supported concern:
Reorganization and redevelopment of the city historic central area, and also the
development of urban tourism offer, by supporting the spa and leisure activities;
Improving the quality of living, particularly in collective residential areas
The capitalization of natural heritage for leisure and sport, firstly the opportunity conferred
by the Someș river crossing the city, taking into account the amelioration and preservation
of the existing ecosystem.
4. AP 4 - Promoting an inclusive socio-economic environment and combating poverty
The development of this axis is based on the thematic objectives set by the Europe 2020 strategy
for the social field:
TO8: Promoting employment and supporting labor mobility
TO9: Promoting social inclusion and combating poverty
TO10: Investing in education, skills and lifelong learning
The strategic objectives of the municipality in the social field are subordinated to those above,
being defined as:
To decrease the number of social exclusion cases
To decrease school dropout
To increase competencies in line with labor market requirements
To entice medical staff in the city
By implementing the measures under this axis it is aimed to develop the accessibility and quality of
social and health services provided within Satu Mare Municipality, to reduce the spatial
concentration of poverty and to increase the employment and social inclusion degree, and also to
improve the educational infrastructure required for a modern specific process in line with the trends
of the labor market.
5. AP 5 –Promotion of RDI and measures to boost local SMEs competitiveness
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
75
Through the Reform Programme 2011-2013, Romania has committed to allocate 2% of its GDP on
RDI activities until 2020 Given that in 2012 Eurostat recorded for Romania only 0.47% of GDP
allocated for RDI, it is clear that achieving the set target requires a collective effort from both the
central and local public authorities and the private sector to allocate funds for this purpose and
achieve practical results that will lead to an increased competitiveness of the Romanian economy.
Without supported RDI activities, the competitiveness of the Romanian economy will remain on a
low level compared to other countries within Central and Eastern Europe. In this context, the
municipality support for the development of an educational pathway for RDIis absolutely
necessary, being well known that the appetite to pursue a career in research is manifested and
shaped during the upper secondary education (high school). Under these conditions, as a first step
for the establishment of an applied research center in the city, it is necessary to increase education
in high school by proper equipping them with educational materials and laboratory infrastructure,
by awarding meritorious students, by supporting the students with low material opportunities etc.
In the SMEs field, Romania is also ranking the last among EU member states in terms of their
number per one thousand inhabitants. As well, the situation is neither better in terms of quality,
most SMEs carrying out trade activities mainly with incomes which put them in an area of
subsistence with operating periods which typically are not exceeding two years. SM County and
the same name municipality are no exceptions, a situation which requires targeted measures in
order to stimulate and support SMEs with productive activities, especially in fields which exploits
the area resources and those with a recognized added value (ICT, auto and electronic components
and parts etc.).
In this regard in May of 2014, the Law no. 62/2014 amending and supplementing Law no.
346/2004 on the stimulation of establishment and development of small and medium enterprises,
which in Article 19 states, among other things, that the government and public authorities
"organize and conduct at central and local level, knowledge and promotion activities, including
through mass-media, examples of good practices in entrepreneurship, business ethics and
performance, on the form of specific meetings - symposiums, conferences, forums, exhibitions,
discussion clubs, exchanges, rankings and contests or other similar”.
6. PA 6 – An efficient public administration, orientated towards citizens and businesses
Development Plan of the North-West Region for the period 2014 - 2020 sets out the specific
objective of increasing the efficiency and quality of services offered by public administration for
the regional citizens.
Through this priority, Satu Mare City Hall aims to promote measures in order to increase the
efficiency of services provided to citizens, primarily through the introduction of an integrated
management system. It also shall be promoted "single window” measures and extensive facilities
of online payments shall be developed.
At the same time, for the strategy implementation, and within it of generally accepted projects by
community, will be encourage the development and the cooperation in wide partnerships or on
specialized branches, depending on the specific interventions.
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
76
4. Investment priorities and specific objectives
PA 1 – Improving accessibility and incentive measures for a sustainable mobility
IP. 1.1. Improving regional accessibility
By connecting the city of Satu Mare to the road and rail infrastructure of regional interest, to the major road
and rail infrastructure on the European high speed transport corridors TEN-T Core, it is an important
premise to increase the city accessibility to a broader territory, regional, national, trans boundary, even
continental. This increased territorial accessibility will support the economic growth and the (spa) touristic
attractiveness development of the city.
Specific objectives and opportune projects:
1.1.1. Improving regional accessibility of Satu Mare Municipality (to TEN-T and other high speed
roads)
1.1.1.1. Road city bypass
The creation of a city road bypass is important for regional traffic flow, on west-east direction, by
removing the requirement to transit the city of Satu Mare, with all its consequences of increasing the travel
time.
At the same time, by removing the transit traffic within the city will have numerous positive effects of
physical, economic, environmental, social nature: reducing the volume and traffic jams, especially when
crossing the Someş river on the two road bridges, reducing exhaust emissions, the noise and vibration, a
more pleasant urban environment for residents, tourists and economic agents.
1.1.1.2. Express road Nyiregyhaza -Satu Mare- Baia Mare;
The creation of the express road Nyíregyháza - Satu Mare - Baia Mare will have the advantage of
mitigation of city relationship, within the regional and transboundadry territory on the east-west direction.
1.1.1.3. Express roadSatu Mare – Halmeu - Turda
The creation of the express road Satu Mare - Suplacu of Barcău (Zalau) will connect the city to
Transylvania Highway (A3) and thereby will increase the accessibility of the national territory.
1.1.2. Improving accessibility within MASM
The rehabilitation of several national and county roads on which the commuting between Satu Mare and its
metropolitan area localities is running will increase the comfort of these trips.
IP. 1.2. Optimize urban mobility based on a sustainable urban mobility plan of Satu Mare
Municipality
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
77
(Re)organizing the mobility within Satu Mare Municipality and also within its area of influence - MASM,
must be designed in the future, related to the new logic of sustainable mobility. This new paradigm of
mobility is supported and progressively imposed by the European Transport and Mobility Policy whose
programming documents define a new philosophy, promotes good practices, create new tools for planning
and implementation, by organizing a new type of urban moving systems, based less on individual
motorized mobility and vehicles using fossil fuels and more on collective public transport and non-
motorized modes of transport. This new approach of urban mobility it is to improve the accessibility, to
reduce the pollution and improve the quality of living.
Currently, the model of city adaptation to the car is not only obsolete but also consistently discouraged by
the European Community.
The obligation to carry out a Sustainable Urban Mobility Plan concomitantly with the General Urban Plan
of a locality was introduced by Law no. 190 from 06.26.2013 on the approval of the Government
Emergency Ordinance no. 7/2011 amending and supplementing Law no. 350/2001 on territorial planning
and urbanism (art. 46).
1.2.1. Improving road network connectivity (according to GUP and / or mobility plan)
By improving the city road network connectivity will have the effect of reducing travel distances (more
direct relationship between origin and destination), reducing the traffic volume and encourage non-
motorized travel on foot or by bike.
Improving connectivity of the road network by increasing the number of crossings over the Someş river
could reduce the polarization of motorized flows on the existing bridges. However, by creating the bypass
road it is predicted a decrease in the transit movement resulting in a significant reduction of motorized
traffic and of the pressure existing on the two bridges.
An increased connectivity for pedestrians transit routes is a priority. The creation of direct links as well as
the reduction of displacement distances between the points of interest, especially between those located on
the Someş river sides (residential areas, central area, economic, leisure activities etc.) will boost the choices
for non-motorized travel modes. In this regard, I consider two proposals:
1.2.1.1 Creating a pedestrian and bicycle bridge over the Someș river, on the railway bridge
structure between Micro 17 - Unio and str. Ș trandului;
1.2.1.2 Creating a pedestrian and bicycle bridge over the Someş river on the axis October 25
Square - pedestrian route Corneliu Coposu and Liberty Square which will connect the center located on the
northern shore of Someş with the green spaces area that is planned (the GUP out in preparation) to be
redesigned, on the southern shore of Someş. The immediate benefits are: 1. a direct, comfortable and
pleasant access, walking or cycling, to the downtown area of a large number of inhabitants, residents of
collective housing districts Micro 14, 15, 16, 17; 2. the increase of the central area attractiveness which
may enhance the economic dynamism and can support a process of regeneration and rehabilitation of the
old buildings. In the medium and long term, it would create a touristic route that connects the central area
with the touristic activities and spa facilities planned to be developed in the northern part of the city.
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
78
The proposed pedestrian bridge should be seen not only as a proper infrastructure in operational terms, but
should be approached as a notable presence within the urban landscape of the city of Satu Mare, as a spatial
landmark that can become an element of its identity.1
In a later stage, the creation of a new bridge that connects the road network, the north with the south, on the
western part of the city is worth to be considered.
1.2.1.3 Road crossing bridge over Someș river in the western part of the city (str. Ș trand)
1.2.1.4. Streets penetration to supplement the existing road network according to ZUP / GUP, may
improve the road connectivity and the permeability of certain urban areas. An example is a road
breakthrough in order to connect to the existing road network - Bd. Aurel Vlaicu and Platanului on the
southern shore of Someş river;
1.2.1.5Extension and modernization of roads, intersections refurbishments are also needed.
1.2.2. Organizing an efficient, safe, ecological public transport
1.2.2.1 Integrated project of public transport system modernization and greening is a necessity
and at the same time an opportunity for the current context, when among the European Union's funding
priorities, there is the improvement and greening of public transport systems support. An increased use of
public transport and a decrease of car use as well as the reduction of non-renewable resources consumption
and pollution are the expected effects of this objective.
For Satu Mare Municipality an integrated project of rehabilitation, modernization and greening of the
public transport system and urban logistics is required in order to integrate and coordinate the various types
of interventions:
Vehicle fleet renewal for public passenger transportation and urban logistics (vehicles powered by
fossil fuels / electrified or hybrid);
Extension of public transport routes and rehabilitation of roadways;
The computerization of the transport system;
Redeployment of public transport stations with shorter distances between stops;
Creating modal transfer points (between local and suburban transportation, between bike / car /
public transport etc.).
1.2.3. Stimulating mobility within SMMA
Construction of bus terminals related to modal transfer systems, will have as an effect the encouragement
for the use of the collective suburban and of the local daily transport between Satu Mare and its area of
1It is noteworthy the Turda city's example which, by carrying out an intelligent, creative project of salt mine
redevelopment, a "flagship" project, created an internationally known landmark, so enhancing the touristic attractiveness of the city. Also, many European and American cities construct exclusively pedestrians and cyclists bridges over rivers or major roads that cross their lands, such as, for example Jubilee and Millennium bridge in London, Simone de Beauvoir in Paris, Santiago Calatrava pedestrian bridges in Bilbao, Venice, Calgary, Bilbao and so on
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
79
influence and, thereby, the reduction of private car movement pendulum. This will lead to the congestion
reduction on roads penetrating within Satu Mare, which is also related to an emissions decrease.
Within Satu Mare Municipality are appropriate:
1.2.3.1 Bus terminal on the northern part of the city (at Botiz with the modal node str. Fabricii);
1.2.3.2 Bus terminal in the southern part of the city (str. Gara Ferăstrău).
These bus stations should also organize the intermodal relation with other transport modes through transfer
parking (park & ride and bike & ride) and a direct and convenient relationship with local public transport
stops.
1.2.4. Design and build (gradual) of an infrastructure for cyclists
The size (approx. 5 km diameter), the plain topography and the greenery of the city represent important
premises for the encouragement and development of cycling by creating appropriate infrastructure. That is
an ecological mode of transport with numerous direct and indirect benefits for the population’s health,
through the physical effort involved and pollution reduction. Increasing the share of cycling has a positive
effect on the quality of public space as well, through diminished use of urban land by this means of
transport, both moving and parking.
A complex infrastructure of bicycle trails, parkings, self-service stations, could be gradually created. An
area where interventions should be done with priority is the central area, which needs to get a new
attractivity for both locals and tourists. There are also required touristic and recreational routes for cyclists,
between Satu Mare and its suburban leisure areas, but also to the localities which generate commuters to
and from Satu Mare.
Following projects are appropriate:
1.2.4.1. Bicycle lanes to and within central area - coordination with 1.3.1.1;
1.2.4.2. Bicycle parkings (at public institutions and other public interest activities, in relationship
with public transport stations etc.);
1.2.4.3. Creation of a network of self-service bicycle stations;
1.2.4.4 Bicycle lanes str.Bariţiu - str.Gorunului - CR194A, for access to the recreational area of Noroieni;
1.2.4.5 Bicycle routes between Satu Mare and Păuleș ti, Odoreu, Vetiş, Dara;
1.2.4.6 Redevelopment of a bicycle route Satu Mare-Botiz;
1.2.4.7 Redevelopment of bicyclelane from Satu Mare to Viile Satu Mare.
1.2.5. Reorganization of parking network
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
80
In order to improve the urban landscape and the quality of housing, the rehabilitation of public spaces is
needed, through recovery of land resources currently affected by ground parking.
A reorganization of parking is required especially in central, historical area, which attracts numerous
pedestrians and concentrates an important architectural heritage in need to be rehabilitated. It is required to
diminish the number of ground parking places (to discourage access by car in the area) and creating in
compensation of parking decks, underground or over ground. One or more intermodal parkings (park &
ride) can be placed on the boundary road around the central area, so that to be possible to leave and use the
public transport, bicycle or just walk to the Liberty square area.
Following projects are appropriate:
1.2.5.1. Creation of a / some park&ride facilities on the ring road around downtown area (in
intermodal relation with public transport stations, bicycle parkings)–coordination with 3.1.1.1;
1.2.5.2. Creation of a / some parking decks (underground, over ground) in the historical downtown
area (in October 25 Square and / or around Liberty Square area etc.) - Coordination with 3.1.1.1;
1.2.5.3. Creation of a parking for large vehicles (heavy traffic).
Planning of parking plots in the central area should be done in coordination with the integrated project for
the rehabilitation of downtown area (1.3.3.1).
1.2.6. Improvement and expansion of the infrastructure for pedestrians
Improvement of pedestrian infrastructure and of public spaces is essential to increasing quality of living
and travel safety in the city. Solutions of partial transformation into pedestrian pathways or reorganization
as shared-space or slow speed area (under 30km / h) should be adopted in the central area, which must be
thus valued (see action 1.3.3.1) as well as in residential neighborhoods (blocks of flats) that require
community pleasant hubs for pedestrians and cyclists, designed as "spaces for living and social interaction"
and not just as infrastructures for traffic.
Conditions for safe pedestrian movement must also be improved, including at railway crossings.
Following projects are appropriate:
1.2.6.1. Pedestrian underground passage beneath railway between Traian and Cimitirelor streets;
1.2.6.2. Create / extend roads / areas favorable to pedestrians within neighborhoods: pedestrian
pathways, shared spaces or zones under 30 km/h. This category of streets’ reorganization needs to be
coordinated / integrated in rehabilitation projects part of action 3.1.2.1.
AP 2- Environmental protection and promotion of efficient use of resources including
energy efficiency measures at local level
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
81
IP. 2.1 Investments in water and wastewater/rainwater collection to meet environmental acquis of
the European Union
At European level, public services of water supply and sewage goes through a period of major changes and
enjoys special attention from policy makers. There is an increasing awareness of the social dimension of
public services such as water supply and sanitation and the impact they have on social cohesion.
Water services and sanitation fall within the wider category of public services of general economic interest,
whose uniform regulation in the EU began by elaborating the Green Paper launched by the European
Commission for discussions in all member and candidate countries.
The quality of surface water intended for the procurement of drinking water, protection of groundwater
against pollution caused by certain dangerous substances, protection of waters against pollution caused by
nitrates from agricultural sources, the quality of water intended for human consumption, wastewater
treatment, water management at river basin level are matters governed by European Union directives. Their
provisions were transposed into Romanian legislation and must be fully implemented.
According to the proposed strategic vision for the development of the city of Satu Mare - Horizon 2025,
quality of the Someș river water is crucial for supporting the touristic feature of the city. The need to
improve water quality of the river Someș arises from the provisions of Directive 2000/60/EC - Water
Framework Directive which states that "Member States shall protect and enhance all artificial water bodies
and heavily modified water bodies in order to achieve a good ecological potential and a good chemical
status for surface waters within at most 15 years (2015) since the entry into force of this Directive ".
Reducing water losses in the distribution network of drinking water (about 35% in 20132) represents a
priority for Satu Mare due to social and economic reasons (cost reduction for the population) as well as due
to the need to reduce the risk of contamination of water supplied to consumers.
Specific objectives proposed for the investment priority 2.1 mainly focus on combating pollution of
Someș river waters by measures targeting generalization of passing of all wastewater produced in the city
(full connection to public services - water canal, avoiding the detour of WWTP when excessive rainfall)
through WWTP as well as on improving efficiency of WWTP (expansion and improvement of technical
processes in the plant, including improved management of sewage sludge).
To prevent direct concentrated discharge of treated water in the river area provided for tourism
development and to minimize the content of nutrients and organic matter from water discharged, the
proposal is to promote indirect evacuation of treated waters (spreading in the meadow area). This project is
subject to regaining public possession of the meadow area crossed by the draining pipe coming from the
WWTP Satu Mare.
Implementation of these actions would improve water quality and Somes river banks and ameliorate
groundwater quality. They also target long-term effects on drinking water quality restoration in the upper
groundwater layers. It thus helps to increase the quality of the natural environment by improving the
quality of natural tourism and leisure areas.
2TC APASERV Satu Mare - Annual Report 2013
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
82
Both the European Regional Development Fund (ERDF)3 and Cohesion Fund (CF)
4 support investment
priorities aimed to preserving and protecting the environment, promoting the efficient use of resources by
"investments in the water sector to meet the requirements of EU acquis in the field of environment and to
respond to specific needs identified by Member States for investments that exceed these requirements.
IP. 2.2 Investments in waste sector to comply with European directives
Among main commitments of the Ministry of Environment and Climate Changes in the field of prevention
and management of waste5 are worth mentioning those relating directly to Satu Mare Municipality:
developing measures to encourage waste prevention and reuse, promoting the sustainable use of
resources;
increase the recycling rate and improve the quality of recycled materials, working closely with the
business sector and firms which recover waste;
In order to improve services for the public and business sector, National Strategy for Waste Management is
considering:
promotion of green areas;
supporting initiatives that increase awareness of people to reduce, reuse, recycle and recover waste
from households;
collaboration among local authorities to increase the efficiency and quality of collected waste,
making them easier to recycle and recover;
Collaboration between local authorities and the business sector to improve separate collection and
treatment of waste.
According to the above, the aim of NSWM is to orientate Romania to a “society of recycling” through:
prioritizing efforts in the waste management field in accordance with the waste hierarchy;
encouraging waste prevention and reuse for greater resource efficiency;
development and expansion of separate waste collection systems in order to promote high quality
recycling;
developing / implementing technologies / recycling facilities and / or recover with high efficiency
of extraction and use of raw materials from waste;
supporting energy recovery from waste, where appropriate, for waste that cannot be recycled;
reducing the amount of waste disposed of in landfills.
Much of municipal waste generated in Romania is represented by the bio waste (biodegradable garden and
park waste, food and kitchen waste from households, restaurants, caterers or retail stores compatible with
3REGULATION (EU). 1301/2013 OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT and THE COUNCIL from 17th December 2013 on the
European Regional Development Fund 4 REGULATION (EU). 1300/2013 OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT and THE COUNCIL from 17th December 2013 on
the Cohesion Fund 5November 6th, 2013 National Strategy for Waste Management 2014-2020 - NSWM (on 01-Jan-2014 the Act has
been approved by Decision 870/2013
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
83
waste from food processing units6). Storing this type of waste has adverse effects on the environment
(methane emissions, GHG contributing to global warming) and human health. Therefore, the Landfill
Directive requires a schedule to reduce the amount of biodegradable waste landfilled.
The need for a national policy for the management of sewage sludge7 has occurred as a result of
investments made or in progress for the construction and rehabilitation of treatment plants. Investments are
imposed by requirements of Romania's Accession Treaty to EU. It is estimated that in the coming years
sludge production will increase about five times compared to the current situation.
So far few operators of wastewater treatment plants in Romania have available recovery options for sludge.
Over 90% of sewage sludge produced in Romania is currently stored in sewage plants.
The lack of significant progress in the implementation of sustainable management methods of sewage
sludge is mainly due to the required costs (estimated at about 50% of the total cost of treatment) and
technical difficulties involved in new techniques of sludge disposal. It should not be neglected that in
sewage sludge, chemical compounds that prevent its exploitation for agriculture (just as an example) are to
be found. Sludge quality depends entirely on the quality and control of wastewater discharged into sewage
system.
To comply with EU legislation, operators of wastewater treatment plants must adopt sustainable
management (practicable, sustainable and efficient cost) which involves identifying the best treatment,
recovery and / or sludge disposal options.
Specific objectives of the investment priority 2.2 refers to actions which would significantly improve the
rate of separately collecting from households and firms the recoverable or recyclable waste in parallel with
local development of waste processing / recovering facilities to producing useful raw materials for the
industry.
In order to reduce the quantities of biodegradable waste disposed at the only ecological county landfill, the
proposed specific objective is to commission new composting plants (or plant expansion from Doba). Co-
composting of solid waste could be an option for recovery of sewage sludge subject to a strict control of
sewage discharge of wastewater containing heavy metals or other categories of toxic or hazardous
substances.
Proposed projects within the priority investment 2.2 are eligible for the CF and ERDF which support
"investment in the waste sector to meet the requirements of EU acquis in the field of environment and to
respond to specific needs identified by Member States for investments which exceed these requirements."
These actions would lead to a reduction in waste destined for the landfill from Satu Mare County and the
capitalization of part of the waste as fertilizer in agriculture, ultimately increasing the quality of the
environment by reducing the intake of pollutants in water bodies, soil and subsoil.
6Appendix 1 pt. 3 of Law no. 211/2011
7General Directorate MA SOP Environment: National Strategy for sludge management, Part III. (final version no. 2) -
National Strategy for management of sewage sludge (Project Code: SOP / 6 / AT / I.1.2010), February 2012
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
84
IP. 2.3 Supporting energy efficiency and renewable energy use in public infrastructure, public
buildings and housing in parallel with drawing up a strategy aimed to increasing the energy
efficiency at municipal level.
Emissions from energy represent most emissions of greenhouse gases (GHG), efficient use of energy
greatly contributing to the achievement of a low carbon economy and combating climate change. The
buildings sector is a major energy consumer and a major contributor to GHG emissions. Public buildings
and blocks of flats in Romania were built to low standards during the communist regime, and renovating
the existing housing stock has been neglected. The energy performance of public buildings and apartment
blocks is therefore very low, the levels of consumed energy placing the buildings sector among the most
significant sources of CO2 emissions.
Within the city of Satu Mare significant improvements are needed in the existing buildings stock, also in
public lighting to ensure both comfort and welfare of the inhabitants as well as sustainability of energy.
Specific objectives included in the investment priority 2.3 refer to both the thermal rehabilitation of public
buildings (including consolidation measures) and of the residential buildings as well as to the projects for
the promotion of renewable energy (solar, photovoltaics, geothermal sources) and public lighting scheme
(replacing incandescent lighting with efficient use of energy lighting , long life lamps providing
appropriate comfort).
Supporting energy efficiency, smart energy management and use of renewable energy in public
infrastructures including public buildings and in housing sector is one of the investment priorities of the EU
funds2014-2020 under the thematic objectives set out in Article 9 of Regulation (EU) 1303/2013,8
consistent with the needs of development and growth potential in Article 15 (1) (a) (i) of the Regulation
and set out in the partnership agreement.
AP 3 – Tourism and cultural heritage, including actions to improve the urban
environment, city revitalization, regeneration and remediation of contaminated sites
IP. 3.1Improving the urban environment, urban revitalization, regeneration and remediation of
contaminated sites and promoting measures to reduce risks to human health (including noise
reduction)
3.1.1. Reorganization and redevelopment of the central area
Reorganization and redevelopment of the central area for the rehabilitation of public spaces and of the
buildings stock, improving urban ambience, will result in an increased attractiveness of the area, a revival
of economic activities, overall a process of urban regeneration. The historic center can become a touristic
8REGULATION (EU). 1303/2013 OF THE EUROPEAN PARLIAMENT and THE COUNCIL from 17th December 2013 laying
down common provisions on the European Regional Development Fund, the European Social Fund, the Cohesion Fund, the European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development and the European Maritime and Fisheries Fund and laying down general provisions on the European Regional Development Fund, the European Social Fund, the Cohesion Fund and the European Maritime and Fisheries Fund.
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
85
attraction of the city which alongside with spa and leisure activities to represent an appealing "urban offer"
for locals as well as for tourists and investors.
Following projects are appropriate:
3.1.1.1. Integrated Territorial Project (ITI) - rehabilitation of center area partially pedestrian,
improvement and expansion of pedestrian infrastructure, limited access for vehicles, parking
reorganization, infrastructure for cyclists: lanes, parkings etc., ecologic public lighting and rehabilitation of
utilities networks etc. (coordination with 1.2.6.1, 1.2.5.1, 1.2.5.2) 3.1.1.2. Modernization of the
Firemen Tower Park, Garden of Rome;
Redevelopment of recreational places will be designed with a view to increasing the attractiveness of
the city leading as well, to the progress of adjacent areas.
3.1.1.3. Rehabilitation of "Dinu Lipatti “Philharmonic;
Rehabilitation of the building of a cultural institution such as the Philharmonic brings up several
advantages, e.g. increased safety of spectators / pedestrians, improving the urban landscape and increasing
the attractiveness for tourists, including externally, as a result of organizing international concerts.
3.1.1.4 Investments for the capitalization of the Administrative Palace building terrace.
3.1.2 Regeneration / rehabilitation of some public spaces in residential collective neighborhoods
To increase the quality of housing, priority has to be given to the achievement, primarily within residential
areas collectiveneighborhoods, of small centralities playing the role of community interaction spaces,
suitable for both pedestrians and cyclists.
Following projects are appropriate:
3.1.2.1. Integrated projects - redevelopment of public spaces favorable to non-motorized traffic
(pedestrian or bicycle) inside residential districts: pathways, shared-spaces or areas under ’30 (km/h) –
Solidarităţii area, Micro 14,15,16,17 area, district Carpaţi I, II.
These projects need to be correlated with interventions under 1.2.1.3.
3.1.3 Promotion of a sustained cultural life
3.1.3.1 The establishment and equipping of Puppet Theatre in Romanian language- theatrical
production is extremely important for an early age education. Lack of a Romanian language puppet theatre
requires its re-establishment either within the premises of an existing cultural institution or by renovating a
different building.
3.1.3.2 The establishment of the Summer Theater - establishment of the Summer Theatre - for the
promotion of quality entertainment of the population, namely the theater, as well as music, Satu Mare City
Hall aims to establishing a summer theater that draws broad categories of citizens, including from
neighboring villages by applying symbolic prices to hosted shows.
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
86
3.1.4 Development of an integrated project sport – tourism - leisure, multifunctional hall on the
stadium plot of land
3.1.4.1 Development of an integrated sports - travel - entertainment, multifunctional hall on stadium grounds - taking into account the city's related endowment of a fairly advanced degree of wear for practicing sports and leisure activities and given the city position as capital of the county, promoter of cultural, sports, tourism and economic activities or, alternatively the necessity to build a multipurpose hall, to host various events, large scale, which would both serve to promote sports and culture among the city's population, as well as to attract tourists to these events. In addition, the facilities of the multi-purpose hall and the organization of international competitions / festivals will, as well, attract foreign tourists.
IP. 3.2 Sustainable capitalization of natural heritage for leisure and sport
3.2.1Spatial planning of Somes riverbed with a view to practicing / organization of competitions for
water sports (Somes corridor organized as spatial development ax at urban and metropolitan / regional
level) - Integrated Project (ITI)).
According to the proposed strategic vision for the development of the city of Satu Mare - Horizon 2025, the
river Somes corridor is of a crucial importance for supporting the touristic feature of the city.
The main destination for tourism purposes of the river sector which crosses Satu Mare city would be sport
and recreational navigation that requires a minimum fairway to provide suitable conditions for boats. The
river sector which crosses Satu Mare city has a high degree of artificialisation, the hydraulic works
undertaken to protect against flooding making the river bed look like a grinding canal but with banks
having a natural look. Lacking of habitat wealth, the sector of interest of the Somes river cannot
accommodate a varied ecosystem as it would be normal for a river of its size.
The river does not ensure the necessary fairway over the whole sector which crosses Satu Mare. There is
even an area where the riverbed is obstructed by the remains of an old demolished building.
The projects related to specific objective 3.2.1 aim primarily to cleaning the river bed of the construction
debris. The solution proposed seeks natural sustainability of navigation limited to a certain size under
conditions of increasing complexity of habitats and maintaining full current floods capacity transit. ERDF
and CF provide support for investment priorities aimed at promoting resource efficiency in terms of
conservation and environmental protection by:
o investment in the water sector to meet EU acquis in the environment and to meet the needs identified
by Member States beyond these requirements;
o preserve, protect, promote and develop natural and cultural heritage;
o protecting and restoring biodiversity and soil, and the promotion of ecosystem services, including
Natura 2000, and green infrastructure;
Planning river sector alongside measures to improve water quality (priority 2.1) will make the area more
attractive than at present (2014) for investments in spaces and facilities for recreation and leisure. The
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
87
measure aims to ensuring quality of natural touristic and recreation area of the Somes river corridor by
improving and further by conservation of existing ecosystem.
3.2.2 Developing an integrated spa center by capitalizing geothermal waters - ITI - to Noroieni
(decontamination of sites available for this purpose owned by City Hall, the carrying out of
geological studies and of drillings, construction of pools and accommodation and treatment facilities
etc.)
Romania occupies third place among European countries in terms of geothermal potential, after Italy and
Greece9, however, a very small part of these resources are exploited and used as a source of heat or for
recreation and spa. Romania can boast a long culture of spa, especially as social services for retired people
and members of trade unions, categories for whom the know-how and anti-aging treatments have been well
established by research conducted over time, currently undervalued.
The presence of these valuable resources is punctually, spread across national territory especially in the
west of the country, including the county of Satu Mare which hosts about 30% of the geothermal waters of
Romania10
.
Underground water reservoir in the county of Satu Mare, in addition to high temperatures (25 ° C at
shallow to 80 ° C at depths of over 1 km) presents features of curative mineral waters containing
carbonated chlorosodic minerals with alkaline properties, low sulfur, bicarbonated. However, the
geothermal resource is modestly valued at the county level (by the resorts of local interest such as Tăşnad
and Acâș ) but not in Satu Mare city, where there is a single pool with thermal water for recreation
purpose.
In order to capitalize the underground geothermal resources in Satu Mare city to its highest value, it is
necessary to approach an integrated vision, thus, the development of a medical spa complex offering just
related services is no longer attractive for tourists, therefore, in order to meet expectations and trends, the
offer should be enriched with wellness and spa components.
Satu Mare city has all the characteristics desirable for the development of spa tourism with a leisure
integrated component, but it is also necessary a clear marketing positioning and the proposition of certain
products that can differentiate the municipality in order to allow the city to enter regional and national
competition primarily with county Bihor and secondly with the offer coming over the border from
Hungary. Developing an attractive spa center is closely linked to staff performance and the existence of a
more diverse offer to include a combination of services in all three areas of this type of tourism in order to
address a wider range of different consumers: health (thermal water treatments and complementary
products such as sludge, algae etc.), leisure (wellness and use of water in a playful manner - water park and
spa) and sport (fitness centers and spa).
Spa tourism builds increasingly its image on the preventive treatment of medical conditions, and on the
relaxation components, thus representing an increasing attraction worldwide. It is practiced by over 10
9http://www.geosee.eu/wp-content/uploads/2014/04/WP-3.1-Romania-final.pdf
10Study on the assessment of current renewable energy sources potential from
Romaniahttp://www.minind.ro/domenii_sectoare/energie/studii/potential_energetic.pdf
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
88
million people and is manifested especially in Europe, distributed in several countries such as Germany (6
million), Italy (1,8 million), France (500.000), Spain (200.000). Regarding the wellness segment, it has a
more widespread popularity worldwide, also because of its more accessible character not necessarily
relying on local natural resources, with an estimated 100 million people who opt annually for such
services.11
Therefore, a combination of the two components, health and relaxation can be an appropriate
development of spa tourism rallied to new consumer needs and trends.
Strengthening of health tourism is encouraged as well by the European Union strategy for economic
development, therefore approx. 95 million euro will be allocated through ERDF within the ROP 2014-2020
for actions like the economic capitalization of the nationally and locally spa tourism potential and
investment in public touristic infrastructure for recreation. The investment objective is in line with the
rehabilitation of the Satu Mare’s historiccenter, the construction of bike trails within the city and to the
leisure areas, as a favorite travel mode so that tourists can benefit from an integrated package of services
and recreation.
AP 4 - Promoting an inclusive socio-economic environment and combating poverty
In Satu Mare, certain categories of people are more at risk of poverty and social exclusion than the general
population: these include women, children, youth, the elderly, people with disabilities, certain ethnic
minorities (especially Roma).
Living in disadvantaged communities presents numerous housing and of ensuring a decent living problems.
So far, infrastructure projects of social housing have not been accompanied by "soft" measures such as re-
professionalization, requalification and support of employment. Precisely for this reason, in order to reduce
the incidence and spatial concentration of poverty, it is necessary the development and implementation of
integrated plans to include, in addition to the mandatory measures, aimed at building / rehabilitation of
social housing as well as complementary interventions in education, health, social and employment related
services.
Besides genetic, environmental, economic and socio-cultural development factors, the population health is
also determined by access to quality health services, which depends almost entirely on health infrastructure.
In addition to medical services, social services infrastructure investments are equally necessary. Reducing
the size of the working population due to the negative dynamics of the labor market, migration of the
working age population etc. exert increased pressure on the social assistance system, determining new
demand for social services and benefits.
Provision for integrated health and social services will be sought after, offered in health and social units, so
that most exposed categories of people (people with chronic illnesses and low income, sick children from
low-income families and young people with certain illnesses coming from state institutions) to receive
support from the municipality. To meet the requirements necessary to achieve the objectives set for by
11
Masterplan for the development of spa tourism - http://turism.gov.ro/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Masterplan-turism-balnear.pdf
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
89
Strategy 2020 in social field, investments will be made related to the quality of infrastructure, of the
associated facilities aimed at enhancing prevention services, information, media etc. for the creation of pro-
active type of social services. The investment will be funded in the following fields:
o development of modern residential centers providing services on specified or unspecified
time periods which will secure an optimal framework for hosting and care for people in
need, besides boarding, other services can be provided in an integrated manner, personal
care and counseling etc.;
o development of non-residential centers, such as day centers, occupational profile centers,
recovery and social integration centers, and also services provided by social canteens,
social ambulance etc., due to offering of a wide range of services appropriate to different
types needs of beneficiaries;
o construction / rehabilitation / modernization / expansion of medical care infrastructure
(outpatient, emergency room facilities, medical centers, integrated social intervention,
etc.);
o equipping specific medical services infrastructure built / rehabilitated / upgraded /
expanded;
o rehabilitation / modernization / expansion of infrastructure services (non-residential
centers, day centers, respite centers, etc.);
o specific equipping of social services infrastructure constructed / rehabilitated / upgraded /
expanded;
o rehabilitation / modernization / expansion of infrastructure related to leisure, culture and
sport.
The implementation of such measures will have positive results in terms of both social and economic point
of view. Identification, at regional level, of rehabilitation projects, modernization and endowment of social
centers of various types will be made in accordance with the priorities set forth by sectorial strategies in the
field and by the Regional Development Plan.
IP. 4.1 Investments in health and social infrastructure which contribute to development, ensuring
inclusive access of disadvantaged categories of people to public services
This investment priority is addressing the most vulnerable people, identified through the SWOT analysis,
the research documentation and discussions with stakeholders. The provided measures aim for,at the same
time, the strategic directions set out at national, regional or European level in order to sustain the financial
effort of the city of Satu Mare with national or European funds.
National Strategy for Health for the period 2014 - 2020 sets out a number of priorities regarding public
health or health services. For the second category, the provided measures are those to whose achievement
can contribute also the municipalities, in cooperation with county councils managing the medical units.
Regarding the actions and measures that can be taken by Satu Mare City Hall in the field of health, closely
working with the County Council which coordinates health infrastructure is a must, so as investments
implemented for developing the field and attracting competent medical staff to fall under a unified
framework, especially since the city is the leading provider of integrated public services in the county.
According to the SWOT analysis, the elderly are one of the most vulnerable categories, both socially and in
medical terms. To meet their needs, the municipality could involve in the setting up of some medical and
social units, accessible for other vulnerable groups (e.g. members of low-income families).
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
90
In the social field, the high number of low-income elderly requires greater attention to help them through
the creation of modern residential centers that provide diversified services and provide a decent life to those
assisted, who do not have capacity / ability to live alone, the extension of home delivered services for those
who want to live in their own home but cannot handle alone. It is desirable to carry out the measures
proposed by the municipality in cooperation with NGOs active in the field who have the required
experience and personnel.
SWOT analysis revealed a large number of victims of domestic violence. Given the scale of the
phenomenon and the fact that currently, these people do not receive professional help, is useful to be
created by the municipality of a support center, possibly in partnership with an NGO active in the field.
Social inclusion and employment growth targets represent major European objectives taken over by
national strategies. Related measures that lead to achieving the targets and hence of meeting the existing
needs, are addressing a wide range of vulnerable groups that can be supported on multiple levels.
The municipality may act in different directions, depending on the target group:
for young people coming from institutions, their integration into family housing will be considered, as well as training in specialized centers;
Roma people will be guided to qualify for a job in specialized centers, according to the skills and market requirements ;
individuals / families who have applied for social housing will be supported either in residential accommodation or social housing that could be newly built, rehabilitated or upgraded;
for people with disabilities, it will be considered the modernization / rehabilitation / equipment of specific social infrastructure. In addition, the idea of social economy will be promoted. The City Hall could become involved by modernizing and making available of some spaces with modest rent;
victims of domestic violence can be supported through a residential center, and also benefit of specific counseling;
persons returning from prison will be guided, qualified / retrained through a counseling and professional recruitment center, eventually in partnership with specialized NGOs;
IP. 4.2 Investing in education, skills and lifelong learning
Education and training are strategic areas in any modern society, creating conditions for starting a career
and essential in achieving the goals related to employment, social inclusion and standard of living. For this
reason, the Europe 2020 strategy sets as one of main objectives, investment in education, skills and lifelong
learning.
Education and Training Strategy for the period 2014 - 2020 establishes as national targets reduction of
early school leaving, increase the participation rate in tertiary education of young people 30-40 years,
promoting lifelong learning and increase of population participation rate in lifelong learning. A number of
measures related to training are provided at the county level or in the local action plan for vocational
education of Satu Mare County from 2013 to 2020.
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
91
In the city of Satu Mare, amid increasing dropout, which increases unemployment among young people,
the city may act by modernizing school campuses, where low income youth can study, assisted by mentor
teachers, enjoy full boarding and practice extracurricular activities (sports, cultural, etc.).
For the young people with poor financial possibilities, residents in rural areas of the county, who choose to
study in the city, affordable boarding can be created. In addition, children from neighboring villages who
do not want to check in at the campus, transport could be ensured by the municipality under gratuity, based
on student badge on predetermined routes depending on the number of students from respective localities.
In support of mothers with young children who want to return to work, the municipality can ensure new
kindergartens places, in parallel with raising the educational act, all pre-schools, primary, secondary and
vocational education will be modernized and properly equipped (including libraries and laboratories),
knowing that, especially schools of arts and crafts, live a shortage of modern equipment to train
competences required by the labor market.
In view of urban regeneration, the municipality will be able to build or rehabilitate buildings to
accommodate social and community activities, cultural, recreational and sports.
AP 5 –Promotion of RDI and measures to boost local SMEs competitiveness
PI 5.1Support of scientific and technical university education
5.1.1 Support the development of technical university education
Following projects are appropriate for public financing:
granting public support for the setting up of some academic laboratories in the fields of interest;
providing university and research staff, if the case might be, with housing support;
financing the publication of scientific articles in high profile journals in the country and abroad;
providing free use of land / buildings for academic laboratories;
granting public support for the rehabilitation of laboratories in highschools for scientific
disciplines;
granting public support for rehabilitation / equipping / upgrading university campus according to
the law;
granting scholarships high school graduates with very good result who choose to pursue a technical
faculty in Satu Mare;
5.1.2 Supporting university education in areas that exploit local natural resources (food chemistry,
food industry, food safety, agronomy, environment protection, geothermal waters/energy etc.)
The city of Satu Mare is included in the elite pool of the 13 centers established by law as poles of urban
development.
This statute imposes certain responsibilities to the city in relation to a range of criteria such as: i) economic
development potential; ii) RDI capacity (universities, research institutes, centers of excellence; iii) adequate
business infrastructure; iv) accessibility (road, railway, airport, naval); v) public services; vi) capacity of
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
92
administrative association.
Satu Mare Municipality needs to position itself not only as the economic engine of the county but as a
flagship city of region for technologies and activities which capitalize local resources transforming them
into high added value products and services.
In order to meet this goal, it is thus necessary for the municipality to strengthen support for the university
specializations which target and make use of local resources such as food chemistry, food industry, food
safety, agronomy, environment protection, geothermal waters/energy etc.
5.1.3 Support attracting students from county and regional level to pursue a technical faculty in Satu
Mare
According to the SWOT analysis, the great majority of students in the city of Satu Mare are enrolled in
economic and public administration faculties. In order to support the setting up of local research centers
with regional and national visibility, the number of local graduates from technical and scientifical
specializations should be substantially increased. Even though the Technical University from Cluj is
managing the extension in Satu Mare, the tradition still exists for the highschool graduates to attend
technical universities in well-established educational centers. It is thus important for the Municipality of
Satu Mare to support attracting students from county and regional level to pursue a technical faculty in Satu
Mare, and further, to remain and work in the city.
PI 5.2Support applied research within county / city of SM
5.2.1 Support the establishment of a regional center for applied research and continuous training in
the field of advanced design technologies and manufacturing in partnership with the Technical
University of Cluj Napoca
Following projects are appropriate for public financing:
rehabilitation of a kindergarten building with destination regional center for applied research in
partnership with the Technical University of Cluj Napoca
5.2.2 Support the establishment of a regional center for applied research for the capitalization of
local resources (e.g. agronomy and food industry, environmental protection, renewable energy -
geothermal)
Following projects are appropriate for public financing:
rehabilitation / modernization of a building with destination regional center for applied research in
order to capitalize on local resources in partnership with the County Council;
investment in equipping regional center for applied research;
5.2.3Attracting highly qualified specialists in the municipality SM (providing housing, transportation
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
93
subsidies, etc.)
Following projects are appropriate for public financing:
granting funding support by the town hall of Satu Mare for housing of highly skilled specialists
who choose to settle in Satu Mare;
granting reward for specialists from other areas who choose to conduct business activities in the
city of SM (as entrepreneurs in areas with high added value);
IP. 5.3Support the creation of new SMEs to exploit local resources and research results
5.3.1 Expansion of industrial parks / incubators
Following projects are appropriate for public financing:
o creating an exhibition hall/space for SMEs (possibly setting up a "house of SMEs") especially for
SMEs which exploit through value added activities resources available in the area of SM especially in
the food industry, horticulture, agronomy, renewable resources, environmental unconventional
technologies, software etc. .;
o setting up thematic industrial parks with integrated environmental authorization so that SMEs with
related activities may not require additional authorization;
o building of a multifunctional spa center with European grant (including a geriatric treatment center)
and located in a former leisure area of the city (Noroieni);
AP 6 – An efficient public administration, orientated to citizens and businesses
IP. 6.1. Public administration to serve citizens including e-government
During the implementation of the Strategy measures will be undertaken to streamline the activities of the
Satu - Mare town hall in relation to citizens and businesses. In this respect it actions will encompass the
following:
o implementation of measures aimed at institutional management: changing internal procedures and
adoption of integrated management system and introduction of a new system of performance
indicators for the services provided;
o implementation of measures aimed at diversifying and increasing the quality of services provided by
the municipality to the taxpayers: creating one stop shop, extending electronic services, general
cadaster available on-line etc.
IP. 6.2. Building partnerships to design and implement the development strategy of Satu Mare
Municipality
Since the strategic document was done with the participation of broad categories of stakeholders, in order
for the interventions provided for in the actions plan to be implemented in a transparent manner, and the
results to be accepted by the community representatives, it is necessary to keep this collaboration by
creating working partnerships locally on projects topics or broader, depending on the nature of the
intervention.
Output 4.7 Integrated Strategic Territorial/Urban Agenda in Satu Mare
Municipality of Satu Mare ROMANIA
94
As certain measures must be integrated into interventions performed at regional level, the creation of
regional partnerships is also appropriate. Sharing experiences with similar institutions internationally can
also be required in adopting innovative and effective measures, already tested in similar contexts.