Reservation in promotions in India
-
Upload
aiswarya-murali -
Category
Documents
-
view
228 -
download
0
Transcript of Reservation in promotions in India
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
1/19
RESERVATION IN PROMOTIONS IN INDIA- IS ITA TRUE FULFILLMENT OF SOCIAL JUSTICE
AIMS?
Date: 12th September 2014
Submitted By: Submitted To:
Aiswarya Murali Ms. Aakanksha Kumar
BA, LL.B Faculty of CG-1
1st Semester
or! Count" #,$#%
NATIONAL L AW UNIV !SIT" # $OD%&U! SU'' ! S SSION
($UL" )N OV 'B ! 2014*
1
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
2/19
A+,-o./ed eme-t
& take this o''ortunity to e('ress my )ratitu!e an! 'ersonal re)ar!s to ' Aa,a-, ha umar
for ins'irin) an! )ui!in) me !urin) the course of this 'ro*ect work. & also owe my sincere thanks
to the li+rary staff, ational Law ni ersity for the cor'oration an! facility e(ten!e! from time
to time !urin) the 'ro)ress of my 'ro*ect work.
Aiswarya Murali
2
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
3/19
!e ear+h methodo/o y
Sub3e+t " Constitutional Go ernance
Topi+ " /eser ation in 0romotions in &n!ia- &s it a true fulfillment of social *ustice aims
For the com'letion of this 'ro*ect & ha e utili2e! the !octrinal research from 'rimary an!
secon!ary sources. Books, Articles an! commentaries on case laws ha e contri+ute! the ma*or
'art of my research.
3
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
4/19
S+ope o the &ro3e+t
3his 'ro*ect takes into account the 'ro isions in the constitution for reser ation in 'romotions. &t
also analyses the a''lication of the amen!e! article in the real life scenario an! also runs throu)h
the hi)hly !e+ate! 4uestion of its true fulfillment of social *ustice an! e4uity.
4
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
5/19
Tab/e o 5o-te-t
&ntro!uction......................................................................................................................................1
n!erstan!in) Article 15 Clause 67A8 9f 3he &n!ian Constitution................................................:
/eser ation in 0romotions- A com'rehensi e analysis...................................................................5
Meetin) constitutional 'ro isions with social *ustice......................................................................%Conclusion.....................................................................................................................................11
Bi+lio)ra'hy..................................................................................................................................1#
5
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
6/19
6
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
7/19
I-trodu+tio-
e li e in a country where e4uality an! free!om is 'romise! an! this free!om an! e4uality is a
)ift of !emocracy to us. 9ur constitution )i es us the ri)ht to free!om an! most im'ortantly to
e(ercise this free!om in an e4uita+le manner. At the same time it is incum+ent on the 'art of the
state to ensure that e4uality 're ails in all sections of the society. ;ence it was to achie e this
'ur'ose< the system of reser ation was enshrine! in our constitution. So that the so-calle!
!e'ri e! classes can come at 'ar with the so-calle! 'ri ile)e! ones. 3he Constitution of &n!ia
allows this kin! of 'ositi e !iscrimination in or!er to +rin) a+out e4uality of o''ortunity an!
status in the society. 3he foun!in) fathers ha! ne er inten!e! /eser ation to +e a tem'orary
'henomenon. /eser ations to the un!er'ri ile)e! were to +e e(ten!e! until they were u'lifte!
socially an! sta+ili2e! economically. /eser ations with the iew of hel'in) the !e'ri e! classes
to )ain a +etter footin) an! a ail e4ual +enefits of an in!e'en!ent an! free nation was intro!uce!
in the system.
Articles 16 to 1% of the &n!ian constitution )uarantees /i)ht to =4uality
to all 'ersons within the territory of &n!ia. Article .15718 is a facet of Art.16 an! they are closely
inter-connecte!. Art.15 718 'articulari2es the )enerality of Art.16 an! i!entifies, in a
constitutional sense, >e4uality of o''ortunity? in matters of em'loyment un!er the state. n!er
Art. 15768, the state may make reser ation of a''ointments or 'osts in fa or of any @+ackwar!
class of citi2ens which, in the o'inion of the state, is not a!e4uately re'resente! in the 'u+lic
ser ices un!er the state. /eser ation in 'romotions is one such 'ro ision un!er this Article
which is hi)hly !e+ate! u'on. 3he $$ th Amen!ment to the constitution inserte! Article 1576A8
'ermittin) reser ation e en in matters of 'romotion. But this was restricte! to 'romotions in
fa or of SC S3, 'ro i!e! they were not a!e4uately re'resente! in the ser ices un!er State. &n a
7
http://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2010/11/indian-constitution-a-comprehensive-analysis-loopholes-and-more/http://www.youthkiawaaz.com/2010/11/indian-constitution-a-comprehensive-analysis-loopholes-and-more/ -
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
8/19
su+se4uent !ecision, reser ation in matters of 'romotion has +een u'hel! 1.3hus +y insertin)
Article 1576A8, 0arliament amen!e! the Constitution an! remo e! the +ase as inter'rete! +y the
Su'reme Court in the Man!al case. /eser ation can therefore a''ly not only to initial
recruitment +ut also in matters of 'romotion.
1 Ashok Kumar Gupta State of Uttar Pradesh 71 $8DSCC#E1.
8
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
9/19
U-der ta-di- Arti+/e 16 5/au e 4(A* O The I-dia- 5o- titutio-
Article 15 of the &n!ian constitution )uarantees e4uality of o''ortunity in matters of 'u+lic
em'loyment. 3here shall +e e4uality of o''ortunity for all citi2ens in matters relatin) to
em'loyment or a''ointment to any office un!er the state. Clause 6 un!er this article says that
nothin) in this article shall 're ent the state from makin) any 'ro ision for the reser ation of
a''ointments or 'osts in fa or of any +ackwar! class of citi2ens, which, in the o'inion of the
state, is not a!e4uately re'resente! in the ser ices un!er the state. 3his clause e('ressly 'ermits
the state to make a 'ro ision for the reser ation of a''ointments or 'osts in fa or of any
+ackwar! classes of citi2ens which, in the o'inion of the State are not a!e4uately re'resente! in
the ser ices un!er the State. 3he 'ower conferre! on the State can only +e e(ercise! in fa or of
+ackwar! classes an! therefore, whether a 'articular class of citi2ens is +ackwar!, is an o+*ecti e
factor to +e !etermine! +y the state. hile the State necessarily has to ascertain whether a
'articular class of citi2ens is +ackwar!. ow comin) into Clause 76A8, it )oes on like this
> othin) in this article shall 're ent the state from makin) any 'ro ision for reser ation in
matters of 'romotion 7with conse4uential seniority, to any class or classes of 'osts in the ser ices
un!er the state in fa or of the Sche!ule! Castes an! the Sche!ule! 3ri+es which, in the o'inion
of the State, are not a!e4uately re'resente! in the ser ices un!er the State.? #
3his Clause was inserte! +y the Constitution 7$$ th Amen!ment8 Act, 1 D to
o ercome the !ecision in Man!al case that no reser ation in 'romotions coul! +e ma!e un!er
Clause 768. ustifyin) 'romotion, to the Sche!ule! Castes an! Sche!ule! 3ri+e can!i!ates in
'romotion, the court ha! at one 'oint hel! that e en their seniority ac4uire! +y 'romotion o er
2 Durga Das Basu, Shorter Constitution of India, Vol 1.
9
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
10/19
the )eneral class can!i!ates shall not +e affecte! +y su+se4uent 'romotion of the )eneral class
can!i!ates. &t has, howe er in A*ith Sin)h 7&&8 . State of 0un*a+ : , later o errule! itself an! hel!
that reser e! cate)ory 'romotes coul! not count their seniority in the 'romote! cate)ory from
the !ate of their continuous officiatin) in the 'romote! 'ost is- - is the )eneral can!i!ates who
were senior to them in lower cate)ory an! who were later 'romote!. A senior )eneral can!i!ate
at the lower le el, if he reaches the 'romotional le el later +ut +efore the further 'romotion of
the reser e! cate)ory can!i!ate, he will +e treate! as senior at the 'romotional le el to the
reser e! can!i!ate e en if the reser e! can!i!ate was 'romote! to that le el earlier. &nci!entally
the court also remarke! that Article 15768 an! 76-A8 is not a fun!amental ri)ht. &t is an ena+lin) 'ro ision which must +e +alance! a)ainst the ri)ht to e4uality )uarantee! in Articles 16 an!
15718. &t !isa)ree! with the !ecisions which treate! Article 15768 an! 76-A8 as fun!amental ri)hts
an! im'ose! an o+li)ation u'on the state to enforce them. 3he court su))este! a +alancin)
+etween Articles 15718 an! 15768 an! 76-A8. A)ain. &n State of Bihar . Bal Mukun! Shah 6 the
court has hel! that Article 15768 is an ena+lin) 'ro ision within which e en *u!icial ser ices can
+e +rou)ht. But while 'ro i!in) reser ation un!er this 'ro ision the re4uirement of maintenance
of efficiency of a!ministration un!er Article ::D must +e taken into account. Also, while makin)
reser ation in the su+or!inate *u!icial ser ices the ;i)h Court must +e consulte!. 3he Court has
state! that the 'rimary 'ur'ose of Art.15768 is !ue re'resentation of certain classes in certain
'osts. But, alon) with Art.15768, there are Arts.16, 15718 an! ::D as well. Arts. 16 an! 15 lay
!own the 'ermissi+le limits of the affirmati e action +y way of reser ation which may +e taken
un!er Arts. 15768 an! 1576-A8. hile 'ermittin) reser ations, Art. 16 an! 15718 also lay !own
3 71 8 $ SCC #E .
4 7#EEE8 6 SCC 56E.
10
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
11/19
certain limitations at the same time. Art. ::D ensure that the efficiency of a!ministration is not
*eo'ar!i2e!. D
5 Mahen!ra 0 *ain, &n!ian Constitutional Law, Hol &
11
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
12/19
!e er7atio- i- &romotio- ) A +omprehe- i7e a-a/y i
0romotion of S C an! S 3 em'loyees out of turn +ecause of the scheme of reser ation )i es rise
to se eral 'ro+lems, es'ecially, 'ertainin) to seniority of such 'ersons o er the em'loyees
+elon)in) to the )eneral cate)ory. 3he Su'reme Court has sou)ht to )ra''le with such 'ro+lems
kee'in) in iew consi!erations of e4uity an! fairness. hile talkin) a+out reser ation in
'romotions, a ery im'ortant case that shoul! +e cite! is I nion of &n!ia . Hir'al Sin)h
Chauhan 5. &n this casea two- u!)e Bench of the Su'reme Court reiterate! what the court sai! in
&n!ra Swahney . nion of &n!ia $, that 'ro i!in) reser ation in 'romotion factually create! a
'oi)nant an! o+*ectiona+le situation in Hir'al. 3he Court state! that it was all left to the
!iscretion of the res'ecti e States to !eci!e u'on the reser ation or roster in the matter of
'romotions an! hence it was not uniform. 3he )eneral can!i!ate who was senior will always
ha e 'reference o er the can!i!ate who 'romote! +y the irtue of reser ation notwithstan!in)
that he was 'romote! su+se4uent to the reser e! can!i!ate. Jet in A*it Sin)h anu*a . State of
0un*a+%, a three Bench of the Su'reme Court went a ste' ahea! +y takin) into consi!eration
Articles 16, 15 an! ::D, the Su'reme Court has now cate)orically lai! !own that when there
arises a 4uestion to fill u' a 'ost reser e! for a SC S3 can!i!ate in a still hi)her )ra!e, then a
SC S3 can!i!ate is to +e 'romote! first, +ut when the 4uestion is in res'ect of 'romotion to a
)eneral cate)ory 'ost, then the )eneral cate)ory can!i!ate who has +een 'romote! later woul! +e
6 A&/ 1 5 SC 66%
7 A&/ #EEE SC 6 %
8 A&/ 1 5 SC 11%%
12
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
13/19
consi!ere! first for 'romotion a''lyin) either the 'rinci'le of seniority cum merit or merit cum
seniority.
hen a reser e! can!i!ate is recruite! at the initial le el he !oes not )o throu)h the same
normal 'rocess of selection which is a''lie! to a )eneral can!i!ate. A reser e! can!i!ate )ets
a''ointment to a 'ost reser e! for his )rou'. ;e is 'romote! to a hi)her 'ost without com'etin)
with )eneral can!i!ates. 3he normal seniority rule, from the !ate of continuous officiatin) from
the !ate of 'romotion a''lies when a can!i!ate is 'romote! in the normal manner an! not to the
'romotion of a reser e! can!i!ate. &n the case of Ba!a''ana ar . State of Karnataka , the
Su'reme Court has a)ain confirme! its !ecision in the 're ious cases an! !irecte! that the
seniority lists as +etween the )eneral an! reser e! 'romotes, an! 'romotions, +e re iewe! in the
li)ht of the rulin) in that case. 3he Court !irecte! that the seniority of the )eneral can!i!ates +e
restore! accor!in)ly.
&n each case the Court has )ot to +e satisfie! that the State has e(ercise! its !iscretion in
makin) reser ations in 'romotions for SCs an! S3s an! for which the State concerne! will ha e
to 'lace +efore the Court the re4uisite 4uantifia+le !ata in each case an! satisfy the Court that
such reser ations +ecame necessary on account of ina!e4uacy of re'resentation of SCs an! S3s
in a 'articular class or classes of 'osts without affectin) )eneral efficiency of ser ices as
man!ate! un!er Article ::D of the Constitution. Su+*ect to the limitations intro!uce! +y this
*u!)ment, the Su'reme Court u'hel! the Constitutional ali!ity of the Constitution 7$$th
Amen!ment8 Act, 1 D 1E.
9 3 #EEE7Su''l.:8 SC 6E%
10 M. Nagaraj . Union of India ,7#EE58 % SCC #1#
13
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
14/19
'eeti- +o- titutio-a/ pro7i io- .ith o+ia/ 3u ti+e
3he ma*or contro ersy an! !e+ate that s )oin) on a+out the i!ea of reser ation is that
/eser ation 'olicy has +luntly 'romote! caste o er intellect an! har! work. As a result we are
'ro!ucin) su+stan!ar! en)ineers, !octors, +ureaucrats an! other 'rofessionals un!er the 'resent
reser ation 'olicy. 3here+y 'romotin) incom'etent 'eo'le an! 'romotes these 'eo'le o er
!eser in) an! 4ualifie! in!i i!uals. Amon) them the ma*orly conteste! 4uestion will +e a+out
the nee! for reser ation in 'romotions.
&f one takes a look at the issue o+*ecti ely one will reali2e that the intention +ehin! reser ations
is not faulty at all +ut it is the im'lication an! the a''lication of it that has 'ro e! ineffecti e.
3he way reser ation has +een im'lemente! all these years has !ee'ene! an! a))ra ate! the caste
!istinctions in the society, mar)inali2e! the 'oor an! the nee!y an! has +enefite! only the
to'most layer of the so calle! Backwar! classes. 3he +enefit of reser ation has faile! to trickle
!own to the lowest section of the society. Moreo er, it has kille! the s'irit of +rotherhoo! an!
healthy com'etition, the !esire to sur)e forwar! an! to work har!. Jet all this statements can +e
counter ar)ue! +y 'ro'erly im'lementin) the true essence of the 'olicy of reser ation. A solution
attri+ute! +y the concerne! citi2ens to this is that, rather than em+e!!in) a 'ro iso in the
constitution that ensures reser ations in 'romotions, what we nee! is a constitutional amen!ment
that will )i e any state or institution currently su+*ect to reser ations a 1E-year win!ow in which
14
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
15/19
to try out alternate affirmati e i!eas an! 'lans, su+*ect to 'erio!ic re iews. At the en! of 1E
years, if the 'lan is a failure, the amen!ment can +e ma!e to automatically la'se an! com'ulsory
reser ations man!ate! instea!. 3his seems to +e a fair enou)h i!ea that can +e im'lemente! yet
its outcomes still remain a +lurre! reality. 3he main reason a!!uce! for )i in) 'romotions on a
caste +asis is that there are ery few SC S3 can!i!ates in the hi)her echelons of )o ernment. &n
or!er to +rin) a+out e4uality in this arena, the e(istin) 'ro isions in the constitution itself seems
to +e fair enou)h. Jet the a''lication of the 'roce!ure ou)ht to +e tar)ete! an! *ustifie! throu)h
all means. 3he !uty to im'lement the rule of reser ation is a constitutional !uty to +e 'erforme!
honestly, sincerely an! in its true content an! s'irit an! the 'u+lic ser ant entruste! with the !utyan! 'ower to im'lement it, shoul! +e accounta+le. 3he !iscretionary 'ower of the State to make
re4uisite reser ation is a+solutely *ustifie!. = ery !iscretionary 'ower is not necessarily
!iscriminatory. =4uality is not iolate! +y mere conferment of !iscretionary 'ower. &t is iolate!
+y ar+itrary e(ercise +y those on whom it is conferre!. 3he 'ro isions un!er Article 1576-A8 are
'ermissi e in nature. 3hey lea e it to the state to 'ro i!e for reser ation. 3he 'ro isions
re)ar!in) the reser ation in 'romotion is ma!e +y Go ernment +y enactin) a law 'ro i!in) for
reser ation kee'in) in min! the 'arameters in Article 15768 an! Article ::D.
3he State is not +oun! to make reser ation for Sche!ule! Castes or Sche!ule!
3ri+es in matters of 'romotion. ;owe er, if they wish to e(ercise their !iscretion an! make
reser ations in 'romotions, the State ha e to collect 4uantifia+le !ata showin) +ackwar!ness of
the class an! ina!e4uacy of re'resentation of that class in 'u+lic em'loyment, kee'in) in min!
maintenance of efficiency, as in!icate! +y Article ::D. 3he conce'ts of efficiency, +ackwar!ness,
ina!e4uacy of re'resentation are re4uire! to +e i!entifie! an! measure!. 3hat e(ercise !e'en!s
on a aila+ility of !ata. 3hat e(ercise !e'en!s on numerous factors. &t is for this reason that
15
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
16/19
ena+lin) 'ro isions are re4uire! to +e ma!e +ecause each com'etin) claim seeks to achie e
certain )oals.
5o-+/u io-
/eser ation in 'romotions +ecomes socially *ustifie! when it is im'lemente! +y assimilatin) the
true i!ea of its connotation. 3he !octrine of e4uality of o''ortunity in Art. 15718 is to +e
reconcile! in fa or of +ackwar! classes un!er Art. 15768 in such a manner that Art.15768, while
16
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
17/19
ser in) the cause of +ackwar! classes shall not unreasona+ly encroach u'on the fiel! of e4uality.
&t is necessary to strike such a +alance so as to attract meritorious an! talente! 'ersons to the
'u+lic ser ices. &t is also necessary to ensure that the rule of a!e4uate re'resentation in Art.15768
for the +ackwar! classes an! the rule of a!e4uate re'resentation in 'romotion for SC S3 un!er
Art.1576-A8 !o not a! ersely affect the efficiency in a!ministration which is a tantamount of the
4uality of the workin) in!i i!uals within it.
17
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
18/19
Bib/io raphy
5a e
Ashok Kumar Gupta State of Uttar Pradesh 71 $8DSCC#E1
Ajith Singh (II) . State of Punjab 71 8$SCC#E
State of ihar . a! Mukund Shah ( #EEE86SCC 56E
Union of India . "irpa! Singh #hauhan A&/ 1 5 SC 66%
Indra S$ahne% . Union of India A&/ #EEE SC 6 %
Ajit Singh &anuja . State of Punjab A&/ 1 5 SC 11%%
adappana'ar . State of Karnataka 3 #EEE7Su''l.:8 SC 6E%
M. Nagaraj . Union of India ,7#EE58 % SCC #1#
Boo,
ur)a as Basu, Shorter Constitution 9f &n!ia, H9L 1, Le(is e(is
Mahen!ra 0 *ain, &n!ian Constitutional Law, Hol &
18
-
7/21/2019 Reservation in promotions in India
19/19
19