Requisitos de La Accion Reivindicatoria TSJ

8/19/2019 Requisitos de La Accion Reivindicatoria TSJ

1/65

LA REPÚBLICA BOLIVARIANA DE VENEZUELA

EN SU NOMBRE:EL JUZGADO SUPERIOR PRIMEROEN LO CIVIL, MERCANTIL Y DEL TRÁNSITODE LA CIRCUNSCRIPCIÓN JUDICIAL DEL ESTADO ZULIA

IINTRODUCCIÓN

Conoce é !e J"#$%&o S"'e()o( P()*e(o &e +% '(e en!e c%" %, '(o&"c!o &e&) !() "c)-n ."e e/ec!"%(% +% O/)c)n% &e Rece'c)-n 0 D) !() "c)-n &e Doc"*enen /ec1% 23 &e /e (e(o &e 3244, con *o!)5o &e +% %'e+%c)-n )n!e('"e !% en /ec1&e ene(o &e 3244, 'o( e+ % o$%&o en e7e(c)c)o GERMÁN 8LORES, )n c()!o eIn'(e% o$%&o %7o e+ n9*e(o 4;


2/65

URDANETA PERN?A, !)!"+%(e &e +% Cé&"+% &e I&en!)&%& No ; V@4V@4


3/65

%*e()!% c(e&) )+)&%& '%(% +o J" !)c)% +e , e 'o( +o ."e e !e S"'e()o( (e)5)+% J" !)c)% &e e &ec+%(%( SIN LUGAR, (e5oc%( +% *) *% 0% ."e e o '%(c)%+)#%c)-n, %1 e '(e % ."e e+ &e*%n&%n&o e enc"en!(% en Po e )-n &e+ *) *o +o %/)(*%, 'e(o e +e o+5)&- %+ T() "n%+ &e +% c%" % ."e e ! &

"/)c)en!e*en!e en %"!o ."e e+ &e*%n&%n&o !)ene "n% 'o e )-n +e$ !)*% 'o( *%.")nce 4 % o ; O e ."e e+ !)ene * &e .")nce 4 % o 'o e0en&In*"e +e no e +e$ !)*o E ) !en '("e % en %"!o !%n!o )n !("*en!%+e !e !)*on)%+e ."e +% Po e )-n e !% '(o %&% 0 e +e$ !)*%, 'e(o T() "n%+ )+ '("e % > no +% !o*- en c"en!% 0 co+oc% en oc% &e+ &e*%n&%n&o ."e 7%e '(e %&o; No &e*o !(- +% c)"&%&%n% MELBA JOSE8INA PERNIA BUSTOS, +% 5en&e*%&(e &e +% &e*%n&%n!e , en n)n$9n *o*en!o &e*o !(- e( 1)7% &e+ c)"DIMAS PERNIA, n) *"c1o *eno '(e en!- %c!% o '%(!)&% &e n%c)*)en!o, n) %&e De/"nc)-n; Se )*'"$no )c P+%n)++% S"ce o(%+ 0 e &e conoc)-, !%&e*o !(- +% &e*%n&%n!e H K"e +% c)"&%&%n% Me+ % Jo e/)n% Pe

1% )!o )c e+ )n*"e +e en e+ % o 4


4/65

En /ec1% 3 &e &e % ()+ &e 3244, +% c)"&%&%n% MARIANGEL URD%c!"%n&o en no* (e '(o')o 0 en (e'(e en!%c)-n &e MARIANYEL URDANETA,%n!e )&en!)/)c%&% , '(e en!- e c()!o &e In/o(*e &e con/o(*)&%& con +e !% +ece e+ %(! c"+o 4< &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+, e %+%n&o +

F H De +% '("e % %'o(!%&% 'o( +% '%(!e &e*%n&%&% e e5)&enc)%, ."no con !)!"0en e+e*en!o '(o %!o()o "/)c)en!e '%(% &e 5)(!"%( +% '(e!en )-n &%c!o(% en 7")c)o, *eno %9n '%(% %5%+%( +o %+e$%!o e $()*)&o en &e*%n&%&% o+o e +)*)!- % con )$n%( '(o %n#% )*'e(!)nen!e , ."e no $(e+%c)-n con +% %cc)-n )nco%&% en " con!(%

H C)"&%&%no J"e#, &e +% '("e % %'o(!%&% 'o( n"e !(% (e'(e en!%c '%(!e %c!o(%, ."e&o )c e5)&enc)%&o en +% %

L% '(oce&enc)% en &e(ec1o &e +% %cc)-n '(o'"e !%, 'o( e( e+ )en )n*"e +e o&e +% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% &e n"e !(% 9n)c% 0 e c+" )5% '(o')e&%&, %

+% c%&en% &oc"*en!%+ %$(e$%&% % +% %c!% , e 'ec /)c%*en!e e+ &oc"&e )&%*en!e A"!en!)c%&o %n!e +% No!%( % P9 +)c% Se$"n&% &e M%(%c%Z"+)%, en /ec1% 4 &e Se'!)e* (e &e+ % o 322 , 'o !e()o(*en!e '(o!oco+)#%&o %Re$) !(o In*o )+)%()o &e+ Se$"n&o C)(c")!o &e+ M"n)c)')o M%(%c%) o &e+Z"+)%, en /ec1% 3 &e Oc!" (e &e+ % o 322 , %no!%&o %7o e+ NQ 6, P()*e(o, To*o 4 , +o c"%+ +e$)!)*% e+ &e(ec1o ."e no % ) !e o (e e+ *)Doc"*en!o P9 +)co é !o , ."e &e*"e !(%n +% +e$%+)&%& &e+ %c!o !(% '(o')e&%&, c"0o e/ec!o 7"( &)co no /"e(on c"e !)on%&o 'o( e+ &e*%n&*e&)%n!e %+$9n *e&)o &e )*'"$n%c)-n, 'o( +o ."e 1%cen '+en% '("e % en +% '(e ec%" % &e+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& %+e$%&o 'o( +% %c!o(% en

I$"%+*en!e ."e&o )c e5)&enc)%&o ."e e+ &e*%n&%&o &e %"!o e enc 'o e )-n &e +% co % (e)5)n&)c%&%, e &ec)(, e enc"en!(% en 'o e )-n &)n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()%, !%+ 0 co*o e+ *) *o +o %/)(*o

" Con!e !%c)-n, ."e&%n&o % )*) *o &e*o !(%&% !%+ 'o e )-n, % !(%5In 'ecc)-n J"&)c)%+ 0 &e +% E 'e(!)c)% (e%+)#%&% % &)c1o )n*"e +e en '(o %!o()%, con +o c"%+ e !)ene c"*'+)&o !%* )én e !e (e.") )!o, nece %()o '% '(oce&% +% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()%

Se &e*o !(- e+ (e.") )!o %!)nen!e % +% /%+!% &e &e(ec1o &e 'o ee( &e+ &ePo e )-n I+e$ !)*% , e !o, 'o(."e e+ &e*%n&o )c no +o$(- &e 5)(!"

/"n&%*en!o &e 1ec1o 0 &e &e(ec1o e $()*)&o 'o( +% '%(!e %c!o(% en " &e!%*'oco '(o*o5)- &oc"*en!o %+$"no ."e &e*o !(% e ."e " 'o e )-n e +e$ !)*%

Se &e*o !(- e+ (e.") )!o %!)nen!e % +% I&en!)&%& &e +% co % (e)5)n&)c%."e e+ o 7e!o &e +% (e)5)n&)c%c)-n e e+ *) *o o (e e+ c"%+ co*o '%(!e %%+e$%*o n"e !(o &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%&, 0 c"0% )&en!)&%& no /"e o 7e!%& '%(!e &e*%n&%&%; Re.") )!o é !e ."e !%* )én ."e&o )c &e*o !(%&o *e&In 'ecc)-n J"&)c)%+ 0 &e+ +% E 'e(!)c)% (e%+)&%& % &)c1o )n*"e +e, +&e*o !(%(on ."e e+ )n*"e +e e co((e 'on&e &e %c"e(&o % +o '%( *e!(o" )c%c)-n, +)n&e(o , no*enc+%!"(% 0 "'e(/)c)e &e c()!o en e+ In/o(*


5/65

E 'e(!)c)%, con e+ e %+%&o 'o( +% '%(!e o+)c)!%n!e en e+ &oc"*en!o &e %c!"%c)one e !% ."e !%*'oco /"e(on o 7e!%&% 'o( e+ &e*%n&%n&o &

H En e+ c% o &e %"!o , e )n!e('" o +% '(e en!e %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% cc)"&%&%no JORGE ERNESTO LA CRUZ, 0 en !%+ en!)&o e %+e$- 0 '(o o

o*o '(o')e!%()% &e+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e %cc)-n, 0 e +e &)e !()c!o c"*'+)*)en!o % +o (e.") )!o e )$)&o 'o( +% Doc!()n% 0 +% J"() '("& '%!()%, o !en)&o co*o c()!e()o )*'e(%n!e en +% &ec) )one e*%n%&% &M )*o T() "n%+ &e J" !)c)%, 0 +o c"%+e 1%n )&o (e)!e(%&o 1% !% + '%(% +% '(oce&enc)% &e +% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()%, 'e(o e+ &e*%n&%n&o 'on%&% '(o o )c % +o e/ec!o &e &e 5)(!"%( +% *) *%, n) +o$(o )c &5e(%c)&%& &e +o 1ec1o 0 %($"*en!o con +o c"%+e /"n&%*en!o con!e !%c)-n 0 " &e/en %, 'o( +o ."e, e+ en!enc)%&o( &e +% c%" % (e o+5)- '+%n!e%&o en /o(*% e '(e %, 'o )!)5% 0 '(ec) %, &%n&o c"*'+)*)en!o %+ '()nc)e 1%" !)5)&%&, con %((e$+o % +% '(e!en )-n &e&"c)&% 0 % +% e ce'c)oneo'"e !% , 0 con/o(*e % +o %+e$%&o 0 '(o %&o en %c!% , 0 1% )en&o

&e*o !(%&o +% !)!"+%()&%& &e+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& &e+ )en )n*"e +e %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()%, e &ec)( +o e+e*en!o (e%+e &e +% '(o')e&%&, e+ &ec+%(- co*o c"*'+)&o +o '(e "'"e !o &e +% %cc)-n, H , !o&o +o c"%+ e5."e +% Sen!enc)% &)c!%&% 'o( e+ J"e# &e +% c%" % e enc"en!(% %7" !%&%

En /ec1% 2 &e *%0o &e 3244, e+ % o$%&o GERMÁN 8LORES, en (e'(e en!%&e +% '%(!e &e*%n&%&%, '(e en!- " O e(5%c)one % +o In/o(*e en +o!é(*)no :

F H E '(e %n conno!%&o J"() !% P%!()o e )n!e(n%c)on%+e FA CON8ESDE PARTE RELEVO DE PRUEBAS ; E +-$)co ."e '%(% +o &e*%n&%n!e%"!o e % '(o %n#% %'o(!%&% 'o( *) 'o&e(&%n!e on )*'e(!)nen!e , +o ."e no +o on co*o e )c &)c1o 1% !% e+ c%n %nc)o e+ T() "n%+ &e +% c%"

)c % /%5o( &e +% &e*%n&%n!e con " &ec) )-n Un A&e/e )o J"( &)c&e*%n&%n!e e oc"'%n &e (e'e!)( en " IN8ORMES '(e en!%&o en /ec1% % ()+ &e 3244 0 'o( ."e )c : % con/e )-n &e P%(!e Re+e5o &e P("e % Lo e

)c e+ !() "n%+ &e +% c%" % 0 +o (e')!en +% &e*%n&%n!e &e %&oc"*en!o %&*)n) !(%!)5o con )$n%&o o+o &e*"e !(%n +% Po e )-n, *P(o')e&%& ; Y e '(ec) %*en!e e o +o ."e &e*o !(- e+ &e*%n&%n&o JOERNESTO LA CRUZ '+en%*en!e )&en!)/)c%&o en %"!o o e ."e %c% o e "n & 'o ee( +e$ !)*%*en!e co*o e &e*o !(- ."e 'o ee +% co % en /o(*% P%c)/)c% Con!)n"% )c e In)n!e(("*')&% 0 con %n)*o )c 'o( "'"e !o &e !ene( +% coe !e c% o )en In*"e +e co*o "0% co*o &"e o; Y e ."e ."e&o )c e5)&enc)."e con +% )n 'ecc)-n e &e*o !(- ."e e+ )n*"e +e no e e+ *) *o, Y% ."e % e*"0 )en e '+)c%&o 'o( e+ T() "n%+ &e +% c%" % ."e e con!(%&)ce 'e(o/%5o(ece( % +% &e*%n&%&% , 0% e '(e % ."e 1%0 &o %* )en!e o e ."e e*%!e* !)co &o e )$"%+ % "no, Re')!o 0 (e)!e(o ."e&o )c '(o %&o co


6/65

c"*"+o )c &e P("e % !%n!o )n !("*en!%+e co*o Te !)*on)%+e 0 % een n"e !(o In/o(*e ."e e+ &e*%n&%n&o e !% 'o e0en&o en /o(*% Le$)!)*% e e In*"e +e 'o( *% &e .")nce 4 % o 0 e+ ."e e &e " '%&(e D)/"n!o DIMPERNIA, e )*'"$no )c &oc"*en!o '(e en!%&o 'o( +% &e*%n&%n!e en !)1 )+ 0 e+ T() "n%+ no e '(on"nc)o )c %+ (e 'ec!o; A+ )$"%+ ."e e &e con+% c)"&%&%n% *%&(e &e +% &e*%n&%n!e /"e(% 9n)c% 0 "n)5e( %+5en&e&o(% &e+ )n*"e +e % " 1)7% e o(% Me+5% Pe(n)% B" !o , )&en!)/)c%&% , no &e*o !(- e % c"%+)&%& &e e( +% '(o')e!%()% &e e e )n*5en&)- % " 1)7% &e*%n&%n!e

En /ec1% 2 &e *%0o &e 3244, +% c)"&%&%n% MARIANGEL URDANETA, %en no* (e '(o')o 0 en (e'(e en!%c)-n &e MARIANYEL URDANETA, %n!e)&en!)/)c%&% , '(e en!- " O e(5%c)one % +o In/o(*e en +o )$")en!e

F H E+ &e*%n&%&o en " e c()!o &e )n/o(*e en e !% S"'e()o( In !%n

'(e!en&)&o c"e !)on%( +% Sen!enc)% '(o/e()&%, con %($"*en!o &e )((e 'e!o c%&e /"n&%*en!%c)-n +e$%+ %+$"n%, &e conoc)en&o e5)&en!e*en!e +o e/ec!oo()$)n%n con/o(*e % n"e !(% )c o(&en%*)en!o 7"( &)co '(oce %+, %+ *o*%!%c%( o c"e !)on%( "n &oc"*en!o %&*)n) !(%!)5o 0 % +% no(*% (e+%c)on '("e % !e !)*on)%+, !o&o +o c"%+ no +e 'e(*)!e en!en&e( +o /"n&%*en!o +e$%&ec) )-n (ec"(()&%, o+o '% % % )((e 'e!%( +% *%7e !"o )&%& &e+ T() "n%+% &ec) )-n co*o Fcon!(%&)c!o()%, %* )$"%, '%(c)%+)#%&%, 0 ."e e "n 7"( &)co , en /(%nc% 5)o+%c)-n &e +o e !% +ec)&o en e+ %(!)c"+o )c 4


7/65

."e % ) !e % +% %c!o(% o (e e+ *) *o

Ten)en&o en con )&e(%c)-n +o %n!e e %+%&o en c"%n!o % +o )no e(5%c)one '(e en!%&% 'o( +% '%(!e , e nece %()o (e!(o!(%e( e %+ *)n!e('o )c)-n &e +% &e*%n&% 0 % " con!e !%c)-n '%(% % &e+)*)!%( +&) c"!)&o en e !% /% e; A !%+ e/ec!o en /ec1% 3< &e no5)e* (e &e 322< e+ C"%(!o &e P()*e(% In !%nc)% en +o C)5)+, Me(c%n!)+ 0 &e+ T( n )!oC)(c"n c()'c)-n J"&)c)%+ &e+ E !%&o Z"+)%, +e &)o en!(%&% % +% &e*%n& 'o( +o % o$%&o JUAN CARLOS BARRETO 0 MERVIS ARRIETA, e(e'(e en!%c)-n &e +% c)"&%&%n% MARIANGEL URDANETA PERNMARIANYEL URDANETA PERN?A> 'e!)c)on%n&o en " +) e+o +o )$")en

K"e con !% &e &oc"*en!o '(o!oco+)#%&o %n!e e+ Re$) !(o In*o )+)%()o &e+ C)(c")!o &e+ M"n)c)')o M%(%c%) o &e+ E !%&o Z"+)%, en /ec1% 3 &e oc!"322 , %no!%&o con e+ NQ 6, '(o!oco+o 4Q, !o*o 4 , ."e " (e'(e en!%&% %&.

&e " '(o$en)!o(% Me+ % Jo e/)n% Pe(n % B" !o , 5ene#o+%n%, *%0o( &e e&&e +% cé&"+% &e )&en!)&%& N(o; =; 3 ;


8/65

Ne$-, (ec1%#- 0 con!(%&)7o +o %($"*en!o e $()*)&o en e+ e c()!o +) e+%+% c)"&%&%n% Me+ % Jo e/)n% Pe(n % B" !o , no e(% +% 9n)c% 1)7% D)*% Pe(n %, en 5)(!"& &e ."e é+ !%* )én e(% 1)7o &e+ (e/e()&o c)"&%

I$"%+*en!e ne$-, (ec1%#- 0 con!(%&)7o ."e e+ )n*"e +e &e c()!o +o o !"5c)"&%&%n% Me+ % Jo e/)n% Pe(n % B" !o , 'o( 1e(enc)% %+ *o()( " '%&Pe(n %, 0% ."e e++% e co+oc- o+%*en!e co*o 1e(e&e(%, % % )en&% &o!(o 1e(*%no n%!"(%+e > 'o( +o !%n!o &e conoc)- e+ )n !("*en!o "ce

Ne$- ."e e+ )n*"e +e /"e oc"'%&o '(o +% c)"&%&%n% MELBA JOSE8INA PERBUSTOS en e+ *e &e 7"+)o &e 4


9/65

M"n)c)')o A"!-no*o M%(%c%) o &e+ E !%&o Z"+)%, en /ec1% 3 &e oc!" (e &322 > (e$) !(%&o con e+ N(o; 6, '(o!oco+o '()*e(o, !o*o 4 , &e+ +)co((e 'on&)en!e> con !)!"0en e+e*en!o '(o %!o()o "/)c)en!e , 5%+e&e( 'e(!)nen!e '%(% &e*o !(%( e+ c%( c!e( &e '(o')e!%()% ."e !)enen +% c)"&M%() n$e+ C1).")n.")( U(&%ne!% Pe(n % 0 M%()%n0e+ C1).")n.")( U(&Pe(n %, con (e+%c)-n %+ )en % (e)5)n&)c%(; A e &3; E+ 1ec1o &e encon!(%( e e+ &e*%n&%&o en 'o e )-n &e +% co % (e)5)n&)c )en, con (e+%c)-n %+ '(e en!e (e.") )!o, con )&e(% e !e en!enc)%&o( ."e !%*enc"en!(% c"*'+)&o, '"e e+ &e*%n&%&o e enc"en!(% en 'o e )-n &e+ )en*) *o +o %/)(*-, '"e e !e (e.") )!o no /"e &e %!)&o en e+ 7")c)o; A e &ec6; L% /%+!% &e &e(ec1o &e 'o ee( &e+ &e*%n&%&o; E !e (e.") )!o !%* )én ec"*'+)&o, en (%#-n &e ."e +% '%(!e &e*%n&%&% no &e 5)(!"- +o %+e$%!o e 'o( +% '%(!e %c!o(%> n) *eno %9n '(o*o5)- &oc"*en!o %+$"no ."e &e*o !(%(%

" 'o e )-n e +e$ !)*%; A e &ec)&e=; L% )&en!)&%& &e +% co % (e)5)n&)c%&%, e !o e , ."e +% co % (ec+%*%

o (e e+ c"%+ e+ &e*%n&%n!e %+e$% &e(ec1o co*o '(o')e!%()o; Con (e+%c)(e.") )!o, 0, 'o( c"%n!o, +% '%(!e &e*%n&%&% no o 7e!- +% )&en!)&%& &e+ '"e e +)*)!- % e %+%( ."e !%* )én e(% 1)7o &e+ c)"&%&%no D)*% Pe!() "n%+ con )&e(% ."e e+ (e.") )!o en c"e !)-n !%* )én e enc"en!(% c"*'+)&o;

e &ec)&e;En 5)(!"& &e +o /"n&%*en!o %n!e e '"e !o , ."e&% en!en&)&o ."e +%&e*%n&%&% c)"&%&%no Jo($e E(ne !o L% C("#, &e e( en!(e$%(+e % +% M%() n$e+ C1).")n.")( U(&%ne!% Pe(n % 0 M%()%n0e+ C1).")n.")( U(&Pe(n %, e+ )en )n*"e +e &e " '(o')e&%& " )c%&o en e+ ec!o( Ce((o E+ P%(%

6, N(o; 4 @ =, '%((o.")% C1).")n.")( *"n)c)')o M%(%c%) o &e+ e !%&o Z"

c"%+ con !% &e "n% "'e(/)c)e &e 2=,2= *e!(o c"%&(%&o , 0 e ! co*'(e&en!(o &e +o )$")en!e +)n&e(o : no(!e: con '(o')e&%& ."e e o /"e &e A(!"(o P1o0 &e M)c1e+e D) Gene(% Con!), S"(: " /(en!e, con +% c%++e 6, e !e: c '(o')e&%& ."e e o /"e &e G+o()% O$)+*), 1o0 &e L") N%5%((o Gon# +e# 0 con +% '(o')e&%& &e I % % V%+ "eT%+ co*o con !% &e+ &oc"*en!o %"!en!)c%&o %n!e +% No!%( % P9 +)c% M%(%c%) o &e+ E !%&o Z"+)%, en /ec1% 4 &e e'!)e* (e &e+ % o 322 , )n N(o; 43, !o*o 4 3, &e+ +) (o (e 'ec!)5o 0 '(o!oco+)#%&o %n!e e+ Re$) !(o In*o )&e+ Se$"n&o C)(c")!o &e+ M"n)c)')o A"!-no*o M%(%c%) o &e+ E !%&o Z"/ec1% 3 &e oc!" (e &e+ % o 322 > (e$) !(%&o con e+ N(o; 6, '(o!oco+o '()*e(o,4 , &e+ +) (o co((e 'on&)en!e> &e con/o(*)&%& con +o &) '"e !o en e+ %(! c"+C-&)$o C)5)+, !o&o +o c"%+ ."e&%( en!%&o en +% '%(!e &) 'o )!)5% &e+ '(eA e &ec)&e;

IIIE TENSIÓN Y L?MITES DE LA CONTROVERSIA

De %((o++%&% +% con!(o5e( )% en c"e !)-n, e !% A+#%&% o e(5% ."e +% *


10/65

% e !% +ece( ) en e+ '(e en!e c% o e con/)$"(%(on +o e+e*en!o e !% +ec&oc!()n% 0 +% 7"() '("&enc)% &e+ T() "n%+ S"'(e*o &e J" !)c)% '%(% ."e e c+% (e)5)n&)c%c)-n> e 'ec /)c%*en!e e &e e &e!e(*)n%( ) e+ )n*"e +e ."e (ec+ '%(!e %c!o(% co)nc)&e con e+ ."e e enc"en!(% oc"'%&o 'o( +% &e*%n&%&% e!é(*)no, 0 ) % /"e(%, e &e e( &e!e(*)n%( ) +% c)"&%&%n% C1).")n.")( U(&%ne!% Pe(n % 0 M%()%n0e+ C1).")n.")( U(&%ne!% Pe(n %+e$ !)*% '(o')e!%()% &e+ )n*"e +e en c"e !)-n

E !% +ec)&% +% c%($% '(o %!o()%, e !% A+#%&% '% % % 5%+o(%( +% 'o( +% '%(!e ;

PRUEBAS DE LA PARTE ACTORA:

In5oc- e+ *é()!o /%5o(% +e ."e %((o7%n +% %c!% '(oce %+e , %+ (e 'ec!oe !% J"#$%&o(% ."e !%+ )n5oc%c)-n no e "n *e&)o &e '("e % '(o')%*en!e, 'e(o

+% o+)c)!"& &e %'+)c%c)-n &e+ '()nc)')o &e +% co*"n)&%& &e +% '("e %*e&)o '(o %!o()o con )$n%&o en e+ '(e en!e 7")c)o, e 5%+o(%( n en /%5o(e#c%n % %* % '%(!e , '"e %"n )n )n5oc%( e+ *é()!o &e +% %c!% , en e+ &e e( &e %'+)c%( &e o/)c)o e+ '()nc)')o %n!e (e/e()&o, e$9n e+ c"%+ "n%+o *e&)o &e '("e % e )n!(o&"cen en e+ '(oce o, no on &e " o e c+" )5 '(o*o5en!e )no ."e 'o( e+ con!(%()o con/o(*%n '%(!e )n!e$(%+ &e+ 7")c)o en c%'%ce &e c(e%( o no con5)cc)-n o )n&)c)o &e +% 5e(&%& %+ (ec!o( &e+

Doc"*en!%+e :4;@ De+ /o+)o < %+ con )$n- o()$)n%+ &e &oc"*en!o &e 5en!%, " c()!

c)"&%&%n% Me+ % Jo e/)n% Pe(n % B" !o 0 +% c)"&%&%n% M%()%nU(&%ne!% Pe(n % 0 M%()%n0e+ C1).")n.")( U(&%ne!% Pe(n %, %"!en!)c% No!%( % P9 +)c% Se$"n&% &e M%(%c%) o &e+ E !%&o Z"+)%, en /ec1% 4&e+ % o 322 , %no!%&o %7o e+ No; 43, To*o 4 3, 0 '(o!oco+)#%&o %n!e e+In*o )+)%()o &e+ Se$"n&o C)(c")!o &e+ M"n)c)')o A"!-no*o M%(%c%) o &e+ EZ"+)%, en /ec1% 3 &e oc!" (e &e+ % o 322 , (e$) !(%&o %7o e+ No; 6, '(o!o!o*o 4 Q; E !% '("e % e 5%+o(%&% &e con/o(*)&%& con +o ."e e !% +ece =3 &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+ 'o( e( "n &oc"*en!o '9 +)co, 0 &e+ *)

e &e '(en&e e+ ! !"+o &e '(o')e&%& &e +% &e*%n&%n!e o (e e+ )n*"e ++% '(e en!e con!(o5e( )%;

3;@ De+ /o+)o 42 %+ 4 , con )$n- o()$)n%+ &e ce(!)/)c%&o &e o+5enc)% &e e*%n%&o &e +% Ge(enc)% Re$)on%+ &e T() "!o In!e(no , Re$)-n Z"+)%n%, DT(%*)!%c)one , en &on&e e e %+% co*o 9n)c% 1e(e&e(% &e+ c)"&%&%Pe(n %, % +% c)"&%&%n% Me+ % Jo e/)n% Pe(n %> 0 e &e7% con !%nco 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e con!(o5e( )%, co*o '%(!e &e +% "ce

L% *enc)on%&% '("e % e !(%!% &e "n &oc"*en!o '9 +)co %&*)n) !(%!)5o, ."


11/65

&e "n% '(e "nc)-n &e ce(!e#%, &e 5e(%c)&%& 0 +e$%+)&%& ."e +e 5)ene )*'(e%c!"%c)-n &e "n /"nc)on%()o '9 +)co %&*)n) !(%!)5o en e+ e7e(c)c)o &e " /"ne++o '(o&"c!o &e+ '()nc)')o &e e7ec"!)5)&%& 0 e7ec"!o()e&%& ."e &)*%n%n &e con/o(*)&%& con e+ %(! c"+o &e +% Le0 O($ n)c% &e P(oce&)A&*)n) !(%!)5o ; A ."e, +% '(e "nc)-n (e+%!)5% %n!e *enc)on%&% '"c"e !)on%&% 0 &e 5)(!"%&% *e&)%n!e '("e % en con!(%()o, &e %++ ."e +% /o(*% &e)*'"$n%c)-n e con +% '("e % en con!(%()o ."e +% &e 5)(!9e, )en %+ &e*o !/%+ e&%& &e +o 1ec1o &oc"*en!%+e ,+% *%n)/e !%c)-n ."e 1)c)e(% o!(o /"nc)on%()o&e +% %&*)n) !(%c)-n '9 +)c% o +% '%(!e )n!e(5)n)en!e> +o ."e no oc"(()- en e+ '(e en!e c% o, en 5)(!"& &e ."e /"e &e conoc)&% e )*'"$n%&% 'e(o no e '(o*o5n)n$"n% '("e % en con!(%()o> 'o( +o ."e e con )&e(% ."e e !e *e&)o &e '("e %%"!én!)co, 0 $o#% &e 5e(%c)&%& 0 +e$%+)&%& 0 !)ene '+eno 5%+o( '(o %!oco*o )n !("*en!o '9 +)co ne$oc)%+;

De +% *enc)on%&% '("e % ."e 1% ."e&%&o /)(*e, e &e '(en&e e+ 1ec1o &e

9n)c% ene/)c)%()% &e +% "ce )-n &e+ c)"&%&%no D)*% Pe(n % e(% +Me+ % Jo e/)n% Pen %, .")én 'o !e()o(*en!e 5en&)- e+ )n*"e +e ."e e encon!(%&en!(o &e +% *enc)on%&% "ce )-n 0 ."e e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e con!(o5e( )c)"&%&%n% M%()%n$e+ U(&%n!e% 0 M%()%n0e+ U

6;@ De+ /o+)o 4 %+ 3= con )$n- co')% ce(!)/)c%&% &e &oc"*en!o '(o!oco+)#+% O/)c)n% S" %+!e(n% &e+ Se$"n&o C)(c")!o &e Re$) !(o &e+ M"n)c)')o M%&e+ E !%&o Z"+)%, &e /ec1% 3 &e %$o !o &e+ % o 4 , %7o e+ No; 4 , !o*o Q> %+ c"%+ e +e %!() "0e '+eno 5%+o( '(o %!o()o &e con/o(*)&%& coe !% +ece e+ %(! c"+o =3 &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+, 0 &e+ *

e5)&enc)% +% '(o')e&%& &e+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e &e*%n&% &e+D)*% Pe(n %, .")en /o(*% '%(!e &e +% c%&en% &oc"*en

E 'e(!)c)%:P(o*o5)- e 'e(!)c)% o (e e+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e e !e +)!)$)o )!"%&o en e+ ecP%(% o, c%++e 6, n9*e(o 4 @ =, P%((o.")% C1).")n.")( &e+ M"n)c)')o M%&e+ e !%&o Z"+)%, +% c"%+ /"e con )$n%&% en e+ e 'e&)en!e en /ec1% 26 &&e 322 , &)c!%*)n%n&o +o e 'e(!o no* (%&o +o )$")en!e: FK"e e+ )n*o 7e!o &e e !% E 'e(!)c)%, e co((e 'on&e &e %c"e(&o % +o '%( *e!(o &e UL)n&e(o , No*enc+%!"(% 0 "'e(/)c)e, %n!e()o(*en!e &e c()!o en e+ c"e('o &e In/o(*e con e+ e %+%&o 'o( +% '%(!e o+)c)!%n!e en e+ Doc"*en!o &e Men "(%&e Men "(% N(o; M@


12/65

C)5)+, 'o( +o ."e e 5%+o(%&% &e %c"e(&o % +% (e$+% &e +% %n% c( !)ce+ %(! c"+o 2< e7" &e*, %+ o e(5%( ."e &e +% *) *% e &e '(en&e +% )&ee+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e &e*%n&% 0 e+ ."e e enc"en!(% oc"'%&o &e*%n&%&o;

In 'ecc)-n J"&)c)%+:Se o+)c)!- )n 'ecc)-n 7"&)c)%+ o (e e+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e e !e +)!)$)o )!"%

ec!o( E+ P%(% o, c%++e 6, n9*e(o 4 @ =, P%((o.")% C1).")n.")( &e+ MM%(%c%) o &e+ e !%&o Z"+)%> +% c"%+ /"e e5%c"%&% en /ec1% 3 &e 7"+)en +% c"%+ e &e7- con !%nc)% &e +o )$")en!e: F H E+ !() "n%+ 1%ce "n (ee+ )n*"e +e 0 o e(5%: e ) !e "n% c% % con "n% ce(c% 'e()*e!(%+ &e +ce*en!o +%nco en e+ /on&o +o."e &e %(c)++% 0 %+ /(en!e ce(c% &e %+%* (con '"e(!% &e 'e%!-n 0 en!(%&% '%(% 5e1 c"+o &e &o 3 1o7% en +% '%!)ene %+%* (e &e '9% &e !(e 'e+o > e+ '%!)o en e+ /(en!e e ! +)*')o, e ) !en/(on!%+e > 0 +% c% % e ! co*'"e !% &e &o 3 %* )en!e , "n %* )en!e %

e+ '% )++o ."e &% %cce o %+ o!(o )n*"e +e, con % e(!"(% '%(% 5en!%n% , '"e(!% en e+ *) *o, con !ec1o &e #)nc 0 ') o &e ce*en!o, (e."e*%&o conc"%(!)%&"(% ; En e+ e$"n&o %* )en!e, e ) !e "n% '"e(!% &e 1)e((o ."e &% %)n*"e +e con ') o &e ce*en!o (e."e*%&o con $()e!% , e+ !ec1o e &e % e !o> e5en!%n% con 5)&()o 0 e !("c!"(% &e 1)e((o, &on&e /"nc)on% +% coc)n% 0 e+

HE !% )n 'ecc)-n 7"&)c)%+ e %'(ec)%&% *e&)%n!e +% %n% c( !)c%, &e con/oe !% +ec)&o en e+ %(! c"+o 2< &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+, en conccon e+ 4;=62 &e+ C-&)$o C)5)+> 0 &e +% *) *%, %+ )$"%+ ."e &e +% e 'e(!)c)%

e &e '(en&e +% )&en!)&%& en!(e e+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e &e*%n&

e enc"en!(% oc"'%&o 'o( e+ &e*%n&%&o> 'o( +o ."e e +e o!o($% 5%+o( '(o %Te !)*on)%+e :P(o*o5)- +% !e !)*on)%+e &e +o c)"&%&%no O c%( S%+%*%nc% K"Leone+ V%(e+% Gon# +e# 0 So(%)&% Jo e/)n% 8e(n n&e# 8"en*%0o(> &e +/"e(on e5%c"%&o +o )$")en!e :

E+ c)"&%&%no O c%( S%+%*%nc% K")n!e(o, ()n&)- &ec+%(%c)-n 0 *%n)/e !-% +% c)"&%&%n% M%()%n$e+ C1).")n.")( U(&%ne!% Pe(n % 0 M%()%n0eU(&%ne!% Pe(n %, &e &e 1%ce 4 % o 'o(."e /"e(on co*'% e(o &e+ +)ceo."e conoce %+ &e*%n&%&o en 5)(!"& &e ."e /"e "n% 5e# %+ !e((eno 7"n!o co*enc)on%&% c)"&%&%n% , 0 e+ e o( Jo($e E(ne !o L% C("# e encon!(% %%++ con "n% e o(% 0 &o n) o *eno(e , 0 e +e o+)c)!- ."e &e %+o7%(% ."e no 'o ee +% 'o e )-n &e+ *) *o; Se %+- ."e 5)o 0 o0- ."e e+ c)"&%&%/%++ec)&o D)*% Pe(n %, o+o !en % "n% 1)7% ++%*%&% Me+

E !% !e !)*on)%+ e 5%+o(%&% 'o( e !% A+#%&% en 5)(!"& &e ."e &e +&e '(en&e e+ 1ec1o &e ."e e/ec!)5%*en!e e+ &e*%n&%&o e ! oc"'%n&o e+ )n*


13/65

o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e con!(o5e( )%;

E+ c)"&%&%no Jo é Leone+ V%(e+% Gon# +e#, ()n&)- " &ec+%(%c)-n, +% 5%+o(%&% 'o( é !% A+#%&% 'o( c"%n!o *%n)/e !- e( e 'o o &e +% c)"&%&U(&%ne!% Pe(n %, .")en e 1e(*%n% &e +% %c!o(% > 0 en con ec"enc)%, !c"en!% +o ."e e %+% e+ %(! c"+o = 4 &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+, é+&e ec1%&o;

PRUEBAS DE LA PARTE DEMANDADA:

In5oc- e+ *é()!o /%5o(% +e ."e %((o7%n +% %c!% '(oce %+e , o (e +o '(on"nc)- e !% A+#%&%;

Doc"*en!%+e :4;@ En e+ /o+)o 4 con )$n- o()$)n%+ &e ce(!)/)c%&o &e 'o e )-n &e /ec1% 43

&e+ % o 3226, e 'e&)&o 'o( +% Go e(n%c)-n &e+ e !%&o ZL% *enc)on%&% '("e % e !(%!% &e "n &oc"*en!o '9 +)co %&*)n) !(%!)5o, ."&e "n% '(e "nc)-n &e ce(!e#%, &e 5e(%c)&%& 0 +e$%+)&%& ."e +e 5)ene )*'(e%c!"%c)-n &e "n /"nc)on%()o '9 +)co %&*)n) !(%!)5o en e+ e7e(c)c)o &e " /"ne++o '(o&"c!o &e+ '()nc)')o &e e7ec"!)5)&%& 0 e7ec"!o()e&%& ."e &)*%n%n &e con/o(*)&%& con e+ %(! c"+o &e +% Le0 O($ n)c% &e P(oce&)A&*)n) !(%!)5o ; A ."e, +% '(e "nc)-n (e+%!)5% %n!e *enc)on%&% '"c"e !)on%&% 0 &e 5)(!"%&% *e&)%n!e '("e % en con!(%()o, &e %++ ."e +)*'"$n%c)-n e con +% '("e % en con!(%()o ."e +% &e 5)(!9e, )en %+ &e*o !

/%+ e&%& &e +o 1ec1o &oc"*en!%+e , +% *%n)/e !%c)-n ."e 1)c)e(% o!(o /&e +% %&*)n) !(%c)-n '9 +)c% o +% '%(!e )n!e(5)n)en!e > +o ."e no oc"(( '(e en!e c% o> 'o( +o ."e e con )&e(% ."e e !e *e&)o &e '("e % e %"!én!)co, 0 &e 5e(%c)&%& 0 +e$%+)&%& 0 !)ene '+eno 5%+o( '(o %!o()o !%()/%&o co*o ) '9 +)co ne$oc)%+;

A1o(% )en, e+ &oc"*en!o en c"e !)-n o!o($% "n ce(!)/)c%&o %+ &e*%n&% 'o e )-n +e$ !)*% o (e e+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e con!(o5e( )%, +o 'e(/ec!%*en!e %&*) ) +e e$9n e+ %(! c"+o


14/65

L% *enc)on%&% '("e % e !(%!% &e "n &oc"*en!o '9 +)co %&*)n) !(%!)5o, ."&e "n% '(e "nc)-n &e ce(!e#%, &e 5e(%c)&%& 0 +e$%+)&%& ."e +e 5)ene )*'(e%c!"%c)-n &e "n /"nc)on%()o '9 +)co %&*)n) !(%!)5o en e+ e7e(c)c)o &e " /"ne++o '(o&"c!o &e+ '()nc)')o &e e7ec"!)5)&%& 0 e7ec"!o()e&%& ."e &)*%n%n &e con/o(*)&%& con e+ %(! c"+o &e +% Le0 O($ n)c% &e P(oce&)A&*)n) !(%!)5o ; A ."e, +% '(e "nc)-n (e+%!)5% %n!e *enc)on%&% '"c"e !)on%&% 0 &e 5)(!"%&% *e&)%n!e '("e % en con!(%()o, &e %++ ."e +)*'"$n%c)-n e con +% '("e % en con!(%()o ."e +% &e 5)(!9e, )en %+ &e*o !/%+ e&%& &e +o 1ec1o &oc"*en!%+e , +% *%n)/e !%c)-n ."e 1)c)e(% o!(o /&e +% %&*)n) !(%c)-n '9 +)c% o +% '%(!e )n!e(5)n)en!e > +o ."e no oc"(( '(e en!e c% o> 'o( +o ."e e con )&e(% ."e e !e *e&)o &e '("e % e %"!én!)co, 0 &e 5e(%c)&%& 0 +e$%+)&%& 0 !)ene '+eno 5%+o( '(o %!o()o !%()/%&o co*o ) '9 +)co ne$oc)%+, en e+ en!)&o &e ."e &e+ *) *o e &e '(en&e ."e e/ec!)5%*en&e*%n&%&% e/ec!"- *e7o(% %+ )n*"e +e ."e oc"'%

6;@ En e+ /o+)o 6 con )$n- o()$)n%+ &e con !%nc)% &e (e )&enc)% &e+ &e*/ec1% 6 &e *%(#o &e+ % o 322 , e*)!)&% 'o( +% Je/%!"(% C)5)+ &e +% PC1).")n.")( &e+ e !%&o Z"+)%, &on&e e e %+% ."e é+ *) *o (e )&e en +%n9*e(o &e +% c% % 4 @ =, ec!o( P%(%

En (e+%c)-n % +% 5%+o(%c)-n &e e !% '("e %, e !% A+#%&% e %co$e %e '"e !o o (e +o &oc"*en!o %&*)n) !(%!)5o , 0 en !%+ en!)&o, %+ e( e*%"n% %"!o()&%& '9 +)c% 0 no 1% e( )&o &e 5)(!"%&o *e&)%n!e '("e % en co+e o!o($% 5%+o( '(o %!o()o en e+ en!)&o &e ."e con e+ *) *o e &e*"e !(% .

'o e )-n &e+ %c!o( en e+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e con!(o5e(=;@ En e+ /o+)o = con )$n- o()$)n%+ &e con !%nc)% &e (e )&enc)% &e+ &e/ec1% 4 &e /e (e(o &e+ % o 322 , e*)!)&% 'o( +% % oc)%c)-n &e 5ec)no &P%(% o A o5e e'%( , &e +% P%((o.")% C1).")n.")( > 0 en e+ /o+)o co()$)n%+ &e con !%nc)% &e (e )&enc)% &e+ &e*%n&%&o, e*%n%&% &e +%C1).")n.")( &e /ec1% 4 &e /e (e(o &e+ % o 322 ;

L% &oc"*en!%+e ."e %n!ece&en no 'o een 5%+o( '(o %!o()o, en 5)(!"& &e ."*) *% e*%n%n &e !e(ce(o , .")ene &e )e(on 1% e(+% (%!)/)c%&o % !(% '("e % !e !)*on)%+, e$9n +o ."e e !% +ece e+ %(! c"+o =64 &e+ C-&P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+;

;@ En e+ /o+)o con )$n- o()$)n%+ &e con !%nc)% e*%n%&% &e +% Ene(&e Vene#"e+%, &e /ec1% 4= &e *%(#o &e+ % o 322 , % no* (e &e Y&)!% Pe((e+%c)-n % e !% '("e %, e !% A+#%&% o e(5% ."e +% *) *% 5e( % o (%7eno % +% '(e en!e con!(o5e( )%, 'o( +o ."e no e +e o!o($% 5%+o( '(o %


15/65

;@ De+ /o+)o < %+ 3 con )$n- o()$)n%+ &e+ e 'e&)en!e N(o; =33 , &e /ec 7"+)o &e+ % o 4 , o (e "n %cc)&en!e ."e '%&ec)- e+ &e*%n&%&o oc"(()&o&e 7"n)o &e+ % o 4 , e*%n%&o &e +% D)(ecc)-n Gene(%+ &e T(%nCo*"n)c%c)one ; En e+ /o+)o 6 con )$n- o()$)n%+ &e )n !("*en!o e*%n%&C"e('o Técn)co &e Po+)c % J"&)c)%+, &e /ec1% 3 &e &)c)e* (e &e+ % o 4 ;, e+ &e*%n&%n&o e/ec!"- "n% &en"nc)%;

Con (e+%c)-n % +% '("e % ."e %n!ece&en, ) )en e !(%!%n &e &oc"*en!o%&*)n) !(%!)5o , +o c"%+e no /"e(on %!%c%&o n) e con )$n- '("e % en e !% A+#%&% o e(5% ."e n%&% !)enen ."e 5e( con +% con!(o5e( )% " c)!%."e on )*'e(!)nen!e 0 no e +e o!o($% 5%+o( '(o %!o()o;


16/65

C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+;

;@ Con e+ e c()!o &e )n/o(*e en '()*e(% )n !%nc)%, en +% e$"n&% ')e#% &e%+ 33 con )$n- &o co')% ce(!)/)c%&% e*%n%&% &e +% O/)c)n% S"Se$"n&o C)(c")!o &e Re$) !(o &e+ D) !()!o M%(%c%) o E !%&o Z"+)%> +%e++% e !(%!% &e "n% )en1ec1"( % e/ec!"%&% 'o( e+ c)"&%&%no D '(o!oco+)#%&% e+ & % 3 &e oc!" (e &e 4 < , %7o e+ No; 4 , '(o!oco+o 4Q,+% e$"n&% e (e/)e(e % +% %&7"&)c%c)-n &e +% '(o')e&%& &e+ )n*"e +e '(e en!e con!(o5e( )%, %+ *enc)on%&o c)"&%&%no D)*% Pe(n %, *e&)%n!e & '(o!oco+)#%&o e+ & % 4 &e *%0o &e 4 < , %7o e+ No; 42, '(o!oco+o 4Q, E !% &oc"*en!%+e !%* )én /"e(on '(o*o5)&% 'o( +% '%(!e %c!o(% 0 " 5%

e enc"en!(% e 'ec)/)c%&% en e+ n"*e(%+ !e(ce(o, 0 &e*"e !(%n +% '(o')e&%)n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e &e*%n&%, ."e &e!en!% % e+ c)"&%&%no D)*.")en /o(*% '%(!e &e +% c%&en% &oc"*en!%+

Te !)*on)%+e :P(o*o5)- +% !e !)*on)%+e &e +o c)"&%&%no N%!)5)&%& &e+ C%(*en MCon "e+o S nc1e# Mo(%+e , Be % e &e+ C (*en Ro% C1)()no 0 Ne++0 YPe(n % &e P e#> &e +o c"%+e /"e(on e5%c"%&o +o )$

E+ c)"&%&%no E+5) Con "e+o S nc1e# &e Mo(%+e , ()n&)- &ec+%(%c)-n 0."e conoce &e &e 1%ce .")nce % o %+ c)"&%&%no Jo($e E(ne !o L% C("#, ee+ *enc)on%&o c)"&%&%no !)ene 5)5)en&o * &e 4 % o en +% c% % c%++e 6, N(o; 4 @ =, &e +% '%((o.")% C1).")n.")( &e+ M"n)c)')o M%(%c%e !%&o Z"+)%, 0 ."e +e 1% 1ec1o *e7o(%

L% c)"&%&%n% Be % e &e+ C%(*en Ro% C1)()no , ()n&)- &ec+%(%c)-n 0en!(e o!(% co % ."e no conoce % +% c)"&%&%n% M%()%n0e+ 0 M%()%nPe(n % 0 % +% *%&(e &e %* % , Me(5% Pe(n % B" !o ; Se %+- ."e c)"&%&%no Jo($e E(ne !o L% C("#, .")en !)ene * &e .")nce % o 5)5)en&o c%++e 6, N(o; 4 @ =, &e +% '%((o.")% C1).")n.")( , M"n)c)')o M%(%c%) o &eZ"+)%; Re/)()- ."e &e '"é &e +% *"e(!e &e+ '(o$en)!o( &e+ c)"&%&%no Jo($e EL% C("#, )$")- 5)5)en&o en +% c% % con " 1)7o 0 " e

L% c)"&%&%n% N%!)5)&%& &e+ C%(*en M%c1%&o ()n&)- &ec+%(%c)-nconoce %+ c)"&%&%no Jo($e E(ne !o L% C("# &e &e 1%ce !(e)n!% % o ; M%co*o en e+ % o 4 e+ *enc)on%&o c)"&%&%no e*'e#- % 1%ce( +o %((e$)n*"e +e ."e 1% )!%, 0 co*o e++% e !% % %((e$+%n&o " c% % !%* )én, +eco )!% '%(% ."e !e(*)n%(% &e %((e$+%( " c% %; Se %+- ."e e+ c)"&%&E(ne !o L% C("# 1% 5)5)&o en e e )n*"e +e 'o( * &e .")nce % o , &e +o c+o '()*e(o !(e % o +o 5)5)- con " '%&(e D)*% Pe(n % 1% !% +% /ec/%++ec)-, 0 &e '"é &e e !o )$")- 5)5)en&o en +% *) *% c% %, (e%+)# n&o+%((e$+o ;


17/65

Con (e 'ec!o % +% !e !)*-n)%+e ."e %n!ece&en, e !% A+#%&% +e o!o '(o %!o()o en 5)(!"& &e ."e +% *) *% &e*"e !(%n +% 'o e )-n &e+ %c(e 'ec!o %+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e &e*%n&%, +% c"%+ 1% )&o '%c /)c% e )n)n!e(("*')&%;

L% c)"&%&%n% Ne++0 Yo+%n&% Pe(n % &e P e# *%n)/e !- e( %*)$o & '%(!e , e )nc+" o e( *%&()n% &e+ &e*%n&%&o> 'o( +o ."e +% *) *% e &e5)(!"& &e +o ."e e !% +ece e+ %(! c"+o =< &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o

IVMOTIVACIONES PARA DECIDIR

A1o(% )en, %n%+)#%&% +% '("e % e5%c"%&% 'o( +% '%(!e , e !%

'(on"nc)%( e o (e +o '"n!o con!(o5e(!)&o en +% '(e en!e c%" %, (e/ee 'ec /)c%*en!e % +% 5e()/)c%c)-n &e +o (e.") )!o con %$(%&o 'o( +% &o 7"() '("&enc)% &e+ T() "n%+ S"'(e*o &e J" !)c)% '%(% ."e '(oce&% +% (e)5)n&

o+)c)!%&% 'o( +% c)"&%&%n% MARIANGEL URDANETA PERMARIANYEL URDANETA PERN?A &e+ )n*"e +e ."e %&"cen e &e " '(o')e&%

A1o(% )en, +% %cc)-n &e (e)5)n&)c%c)-n e enc"en!(% (e$"+%&% en e+ %(! cC-&)$o C)5)+, e+ c"%+ con %$(% +o )$")en!

FE+ '(o')e!%()o &e "n% co % !)ene e+ &e(ec1o &e (e)5)n&)c%(+% &e c"%+.")e( 'o

&e!en!%&o(, %+5o +% e ce'c)one e !% +ec)&% 'o( +%S) e+ 'o ee&o( o &e!en!%&o( &e '"é &e +% &e*%n&% 7"&)c)%+ 1% &e7%&co % 'o( 1ec1o '(o')o, e ! o +)$%&o % (eco (%(+% % " co !% 'o( c"en&e*%n&%n!e> 0, ) % no +o 1)c)e(e, % '%$%( " 5%+o(, )n 'e(7")c)o &e +%!)ene e+ &e*%n&%n!e '%(% )n!en!%( " %cc)-n con!(% e+ n"e5o 'o ee&o( o &e!e

En (e+%c)-n %+ conce'!o 0 (e.") )!o &e +% %cc)-n &e (e)5)n&)c%c)-n, e+ &oc!oUMMEROW, en " o (% BIENES Y DEREC OS REALES De(ec1o C)5)+ II

Se$"n&% E&)c)-n, ' $ ; 6= , 6=


18/65

'(o')e!%()o ;A* o conce'!o @ 'o( 5 % &e )+" !(%c)-n o (e +o c()!e()o ."e '(e )&en +% &en /o(*% '%c /)c%@/"n&%n +% (e)5)n&)c%c)-n en +% e ) !enc)% &e "n & '(o')e&%& 0 en +% %" enc)% &e +% 'o e )-n &e+ )en en e+ +e$)!)*%&S"'onen, % +% 5e#, &e &e e+ n$"+o &e+ +e$)!)*%&o '% )5o, +% &e!en!%c)-n &e +% co % )n e+ co((e+%!)5o &e(ec1o; L% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% e 1%+++o !%n!o, % +% (ec"'e(%c)-n &e +% 'o e )-n o (e +% co % &e +% ."e e+ !)!&e 'o7%&o con!(% " 5o+"n!%& 0 % +% &ec+%(%c)-n &e+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e& 'o( e+ %"!o( &e+ 1ec1o +e )5o; En e !% 1)'-!e ) , +% (e !)!"c)-n &e+ )en %'co*o "n% (e "+!%n!e &e+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& (econoc)&o 'o( e+ '(on"nc)%*)&e+ o($%n) *o 7"() &)cc)on%+ co*'e!en!e; L% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% e F%con&en% o, c"%n&o *eno , %cc)-n con !)!"!)5%, en e+ en!)&o &e ."e, %&e!en&e( % +% &ec+%(%c)-n &e ce(!e#% &e+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%&, !)en&e % o '%(% e+ /"!"(o, e+ &e*%n&%&o &)*)!% +% 'o e )-n, (e !)!"0én&o+% %+ '(o

H

REKUISITOS DE LA ACCIÓN REIVINDICATORIAL% '(oce&enc)% &e +% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% e 1%++% con&)c)on%&% % +&e +o )$")en!e (e.") )!o :% E+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& o &o*)n)o &e+ %c!o( (e)5)n&)c% E+ 1ec1o &e encon!(%( e e+ &e*%n&%&o en 'o e )-n &e +% co % (e)5c L% /%+!% &e &e(ec1o % 'o ee( &e+ &e*%n&& En c"%n!o % +% co % (e)5)n&)c%&%: " )&en!)&%&, e !o e , ."e +% co %+% *) *% o (e +% c"%+ e+ %c!o( %+e$% &e(ec1o co*o '(o')e

HEn 5)(!"& &e e++o, e+ %c!o( &e e( '(o %( en e+ 7")c)o (e 'ec!

% K"e e '(o')e!%()o &e +% co %> K"e e+ &e*%n&%&o 'o ee o &e!en!% e+ )ec K"e e+ )en c"0o &o*)n)o '(e!en&e e e+ *) *o ."e 'o ee o &e!en!% e+&e*%n&%&o )&en!)&%& ;

Con )&e(% 'e(!)nen!e e !e T() "n%+ S"'e()o( (e%+)#%( "n %n +) ) 7"() '("&enc+o (e.") )!o ."e &e en e( &e*o !(%&o 'o( e+ %c!o( &en!(o &e +o 7")(e)5)n&)c%c)-n;

E+ %"!o( Ne()o Pe(e(% P+%n% en " o (% C-&)$o C)5)+ Vene#o+%no, C%(% ' $ ; 3 = 0 3 , !(%n c() e 7"() '("&enc)% &e +% e !)n!% Co(!e o (e e+ %(!&e+ C-&)$o C)5)+, % !(%5é &e +% c"%+ e !%

;@ E+ %c!o( &e e, con +o *e&)o +e$%+e , ++e5%( %+ J"e# e+ con5enc)*)ee$"(o &e ."e +% co % 'o e &% 'o( e+ %&5e( %()o +e 'e(!enece en " )&en!)

con ec"enc)%, '%(% ."e '(o 'e(e +% %cc)-n, &e e '(o %( e+ /"n&%*en!o &e&e*%n&%, )n ."e e+ &e*%n&%&o e !é o +)$%&o % %&"c)( '("e % %+$con e(5%c)-n &e " 'o e )-n; L% '("e % &e+ %c!o( e co*'+e!%, '"e , c"%n&o %


19/65

&e+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& e &e*"e !(% ."e e+ &e*%n&%&o 'o ee %."e++% c(e !)!"c)-n e ')&e; S) e+ %c!o( no 1% '(o %&o e !% &o con&)c)one o c)(c"n%c"*"+%!)5% , " &e*%n&% /%!%+*en!e 1% &e e( &e ec1%&% 'o( /%+!% &En c"%n!o % +% co % (e)5)n&)c%&%, e (e.")e(e " co*'+e!% )&en!)/)c%c)-n o +o *) *o, +% '("e % '+en% &e ."e %."é++% e +% *) *% ."e !en % e+ '(o')e!%(c%" %n!e, '%(% ."e +% %cc)-n '(o 'e(e; L% )&en!)/)c%c)-n *%!e()%+ en e !o5)ene % e( "n% nece )&%& ."e e+ !() "n%+ 1% &e %'(ec)%( !en)en&o en c"en!."e %'%(e#c% en 7")c)o; En c"%n!o % +% '("e % &e +% '(o')e&%&, c"%n&o %*1%n '(o&"c)&o e+e*en!o '(o %!o()o en e+ 7")c)o (e)5)n&)c%!o()o, &e e '(e5%+&e/)n)!)5% e+ *e7o( &e(ec1o, e &ec)(, %."e+ ."e &% con&)c)-n 7"( &)c% *% /% +% '%(!e ."e +o 1%ce 5%+e(, '%(% $o#%( 0 e( !en)&o co*o '(o')e!%()o &e +con )&e(%&% !o&% +% c)(c"n !%nc)% &e +%

En 7"() '("&enc)% * (ec)en!e, e+ T() "n%+ S"'(e*o &e J" !)c)%, en S%+

C% %c)-n C)5)+, % !(%5é &e en!enc)% &)c!%&% en /ec1% 3< &e % ()+ &e 3)$")en!e:

FP%(% &ec)&)(, +% S%+% o e(5E+ %(! c"+o = &e+ C-&)$o C)5)+, &)ceF;;;E+ '(o')e!%()o &e "n% co % !)ene e+ &e(ec1o &e (e)5)n&)c%(+% &e c"%+.")e(o &e!en!%&o(, %+5o +% e ce'c)one e !% +ec)&% 'o( +%S) e+ 'o ee&o( o &e!en!%&o( &e '"é &e +% &e*%n&% 7"&)c)%+ 1% &e7%&co % 'o( 1ec1o '(o')o, e ! o +)$%&o % (eco (%(+% % " co !% 'o( c"en&e*%n&%n!e> 0, ) % no +o 1)c)e(e, % '%$%( " 5%+o(, )n 'e(7")c)o &e +%

!)ene e+ &e*%n&%n!e '%(% )n!en!%( " %cc)-n con!(% e+ n"e5o 'o ee&o( o &e!eSe$9n P")$ B("!%", +% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()%, e F;;;+% %cc)-n ."e '"e&e e7e( '(o')e!%()o ."e no 'o ee con!(% e+ 'o ee&o( ."e no '"e&e %+e$%( ! !"+o 7"( &co*o /"n&%*en!o &e " 'o e )-n;;; T(%!%&o E+e*en!%+ &e De(ec1o C)5)+ To*o VI ' $; 42 , c)!%&o 'o( e+ A"!o( Vene#o+%no Ge(! "**e(oX, Co*'(en&)-&e B)ene 0 De(ec1o Re%+e ; De(ec1o C)5)+ II; E&)c)one M%$on, !e(ce(% eC%(%c% 4 2, ' $; 66 ;L% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% e "n% %cc)-n (e%+, 'e!)!o()%, &e n%!"(%+e#% ec)5)+ 0 e e7e(ce ERGA OMNES, e &ec)(, con!(% c"%+.")e(% ."e e% e+ &e!en!con!(% !o&o 'o ee&o( %c!"%+ ."e c%(e#c% &e ! !"+o &e '(o')e&L% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% "'one !%n!o +% '("e % &e+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& &e+ &e*%n&%n!e co*o +% '()5%c)-n o &e!en!%c)-n 'o e o()% &e +% co %, 'o(e e+ '(o')e!%()o 0 no e " ce'!) +e &e '(e c()'c)-n e !)n!)5%;L% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()%, e enc"en!(% con&)c)on%&% % +% conc"((enc

)$")en!e (e.") )!o : % De(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& o &o*)n)o &e+ %c!o( (e)5)n& Encon!(%( e e+ &e*%n&%&o en 'o e )-n &e +% co % ."e e !(%!% &e (e)L% /%+!% &e+ &e(ec1o % 'o ee( &e+ &e*%n&%&o> & I&en!)&%& &e +% c

e% +% *) *% (ec+%*%&% 0 o (e +% c"%+ e+ %c!o( (ec+%*% &e(ec1o co*o


20/65

L% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% co((e 'on&e e c+" )5%*en!e %+ '(o')e!%()o con 'o ee&o( ."e no e '(o')e!%()o; En con ec"enc)%, +% c%($% &e +% '("e % +% &e*%n&%n!e;En e+ c% o &e e 'ec)e, +% (ec"(()&% &ec)&)- %F;;;Se %'(ec)%n +o &oc"*en!o (e$) !(%&o e+ 4< &e %$o !o &e 4 == %7o%+ To*o 4, e+ 4< &e no5)e* (e &e 4 == %7o e+ N ; 46< 0 e+ %"!en!)c%&o e+ &e 4 4 %7o e+ N; %+ To*o 36, % co*o +% %c!"%c)one 'o( %n!e N%c)on%+ De'%(!%*en!o &e S"ce )one co*o '("e % &e '(o')e&%& &&e*%n&%n!e en +% '(e en!e c%" % en " con&)c)-n &e 1e(e&e(o &eTRINIDAD MART?NEZ ALMARZA 0 &e ROSA ELVIRA 8UENMAYOR DEMART?NEZ o (e "n% c% )!% 0 "n% c1o#% con !(")&% o (e !e((eno e7)&oen!(e +% c%++e O Le%(0 0 D(; K")n!e(o L"#%(&o &e +% c)"&%& &e M%+)n&e(%&% %+ no(!e con An% M%( % U#c !e$"), %+ "( con +% c%++L"#%(&o, %+ e !e con +% c%++e O Le%(0 0 %+ oe !e con M%!)+&e &De +% %c!"%c)one c"*'+)&% 'o( %n!e +% O/)c)n% &e In.")+)n%!o &e +% A

M%(%c%) o e e5)&enc)% ."e +o &e*%n&%n!e , (e'(e en!%&o 'o( EDGAMART?NEZ 8UENMAYOR, o+)c)!%(on Re$"+%c)-n &e A+.")+e(e o ()n*"e +e %n!e()o(, % +o c"%+ e o'" o e+ &e*%n&%Se %'(ec)%n +o &oc"*en!o (e$) !(%&o e+ = &e /e (e(o &e 4 < S)c %7oP(o!oco+o 4, To*o 44 0 e+ 62 &e *%0o &e 4 < S)c %7o e+ No; 43, P(o!ocoTo*o 64 co*o '("e % &e +% %&.") )c)-n 'o( ADALBERTO BRICE[O CASTRO &e+% ALCALD?A DEL MUNICIPIO MARACAIBO &e #on% &e !e((eno e7)&o en C< N @2=, P%((o.")% S%n!% L"c)% &e+ M"n)c)')o M%(%c%) o 0 &e +%ADALBERTO BRICE[O CASTRO, &e +% *) *% #on% &e !e((eno % OSCAALBERTO GONZÁLEZ 8ERRER;

Se$9n e+ &oc"*en!o (e$) !(%&o e+ 4< &e 7"+)o &e 4 < S)c %7o e+ NP(o!oco+o 4, To*o 44, e e5)&enc)% ."e OSCAR ALBERTO GONZÁLEZ 8ERRER&% en 5en!% % JOS LEONARDO MART?NEZ URDANETA "n +oc%+ co*e(c

)!"%&o en +% c%++e < S)c No; @2= &e M%(IIIE+ %n +) ) conco(&%&o &e +% '("e % &e %"!o %'(ec)%&% 'o( e !e T(."e +o &e*%n&%n!e on '(o')e!%()o &e con !("cc)one (e%+)#%&% en!e((eno )!"%&% en +% c%++e < No; @2= &e +% c)"&%& &e M%(%c%) o en1e(e&e(o &e JOS TRINIDAD MART?NEZ ALMARZA 0 ROSA ELVIRA8UENMAYOR DE MART?NEZ .")ene +% %&.")()e(on % !eno( &e &oc"*en '9 +)co no !%c1%&o &e /%+ o en +% '(e en!e c%" %; E+ &e*%n&%&o e +% #on% &e !e((eno )!"%&% en +% c%++e < N ; @2=, M%(%c%) o 'o( 1%

e$9n &oc"*en!o '9 +)co no !%c1%&o &e /%+ o en +% '(e en!e c%" % 0 " c%%&.")()- &e +% ALCALD?A DEL MUNICIPIO MARACAIBO;

;;;o*) ) ;;;En +% '(e en!e c%" % +o &e*%n&%n!e !)enen '(o %&o " &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&con !("cc)one e&)/)c%&% en #on% &e !e((eno e7)&o, con !("cc)one ."e on e&e (e)5)n&)c%c)-n 0 %9n c"%n&o e+ &e*%n&%&o %&*)!e ."e e % *e


21/65

)en1ec1"( % e ! n en " 'o e )-n no %'%(ece '(o %&o ."e e+ &e*%n&%&o +)n&e )&%*en!e, &e *o&o ."e no c"*'+e +% '%(!e %c!o(% +o (e.") )!o &e+ %

= &e+ C-&)$o C)5)+ S)c '%(% +% '(oce&enc)% &e +% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%con ec"enc)% +% &e*%n&% '(o'"e !% &e e e( &ec+%(%&% )nL% (econ5enc)-n '(o'"e !% 'o( e+ &e*%n&%&o /"e con!e !%&% e !e*'o( ne%* 'o( +% '%(!e %c!o(% e$9n %+e$% e+ %'o&e(%&o &e+ &e*%n&%&o 0 e+ J"eIn !%nc)% % +o &ec+%(% %+"&)en&o c-*'"!o &e & % &e &e '%c1o con !&e+ J"#$%&o %n!e()o( ."e !"5o conoc)*)en!o &e +% c%" %; E+ o/)c)o (e/e()&o nen +% %c!% &e+ '(e en!e e 'e&)en!e 0 en con ec"enc)% e !e J"#$%&o S&e e !)*% +% e !e*'o(%ne)&%& &e +% con!e !%c)-n 0 !)ene co*o con!(%(econ5enc)-n; A e &ec)&e;E+ &e*%n&%&o@(econ5)n)en!e !)ene '(o %&o " &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& o (e!e((eno en +% c"%+ e ! n e&)/)c%&% +% con !("cc)one c"0% (e)5)n&)c%c)-n '%(!e &e*%n&%n!e, )n e* %($o no '("e % en /o(*% %+$"n% e+ (econ5)n)e 'o e )-n +e$ !)*% ."e %+e$% e7e(ce( o (e +% *e7o(% 0 )en1ec1"( % e

o (e &)c1% #on% &e !e((eno n) '("e % e+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& ."e %+e$% !en&)c1% *e7o(% 0 )en1ec1"( % , '(o %&o e ! en +% %c!% ."e +% #on" )c%&% en +% c%++e < , No; @2= %n!e e7)&% /"e &%&% en 5en!% 'o( +M"n)c)')o M%(%c%) o 0 +o &e*%n&%n!e no 1%n e7e(c)&o %cc)-n o (e +!e((eno )no o (e +% con !("cc)one en e++% e&)/)c%&% , con +o c"&e !(")&o +o /"n&%*en!o &e +% (econ5enc)-n 0 +% *) *% &e e e( &eA e &ec)&e;;; ;En con ec"enc)%, e+ &e*%n&%n!e e ! o +)$%&o % '(o %( 'o( +o *eno &o (% K"e e+ &e*%n&%n!e e (e%+*en!e +e$ !)*o '(o')e!%()o &e +% co % ."e '(e)5)n&)c%( 0 K"e +% co % &e ."e e &)ce '(o')e!%()o e +% *) *% c"0% &e

)+e$%+ +e %!() "0e % +% &e*%n&%&%; L% /%+!% &e "no o c"%+.")e(%(e.") )!o , e "/)c)en!e '%(% ."e e &ec+%(e )n +"$%( +% %c

A1o(% )en, e !% +ec)&o +o (e.") )!o nece %()o '%(% ."e '(oce&% +% (e)5)n&)c%c)-n, e nece %()o '%(% e !% A+#%&% &e!e(*)n%( ) e/ec!)5%&e*%n&%n!e M%()%n$e+ U(&%ne!% Pe(n % 0 M%()%n0e+ U(&%ne!% '(o')e!%()% &e+ )n*"e +e ."e (ec+%*%n, 0 ) e !e e enc"en!(% oc"'%&o 'oc)"&%&%no Jo é E(ne !o L% C("#, % co*o +% )&en!)&%& &e+

L% '%(!e &e*%n&%n!e (ec+%*% en " +) e+o &e &e*%n&% +% (e)5)n&)c%!e((eno " )c%&o en 7"() &)cc)-n &e +% P%((o.")% C1).")n.")( &e+ *"n)cM%(%c%) o &e+ E !%&o Z"+)%, ec!o( Ce((o E+ P%(% o, c%++e 6, No

"'e(/)c)e e &e .")n)en!o c"%!(o *e!(o c"%&(%&o , con c"%!(o &ec *e!(o &ec"%&(%&o 2=,2= *! 3 , co*'(en&)&o &en!(o &e +o )$")en!e +)n&e(o :Con '(o')e&%& ."e e o /"e &e A(!"(o Pe(n %, 1o0 &e M)c1e+e D) Gen%(o ConSUR: S" /(en!e, +% c%++e 6> ESTE: P(o')e&%& ."e e o /"e &e G+o()% O$)+*), L" N%5%((o Gon# +e#> 0 OESTE: Con '(o')e&%& &e I % % V%+ "en%>


22/65

e e5)&enc)% en &oc"*en!o &e co*'(%@5en!% &e )&%*en!e '(o!oco+)#%&o 'o( O/)c)n% S" %+!e(n% &e+ Se$"n&o C)(c")!o &e Re$) !(o &e+ M"n)c)')o M%(%cE !%&o Z"+)%, en /ec1% 3 &e oc!" (e &e 322 , (e$) !(%&o %7o e+ No; 6, '(o!o*o 4 Q, &oc"*en!o ."e 0% /"e %n%+)#%&o 'o( e !% J"#$%&o

A1o(% )en, %+ %n%+)#%( +o (e.") )!o '%(% ."e '(oce&% +% (e)5)n&)c%c)-n&e e++o e ! (e/e()&o % +% '(o')e&%& &e+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e &co*o 0% e *enc)on- e !% A+#%&% '"&o 5e()/)c%( ."e e+ &oc"*en!o 'o( e+ c"%&e*%n&%n!e %&.")()e(on e+ )n*"e +e e 'e(/ec!%*en!e 5 +)&o 0 /"e &e )&% '(o!oco+)#%&o %n!e e+ Re$) !(o In*o )+)%()o &e+ Se$"n&o C)(c")!o &e+ MA"!-no*o M%(%c%) o &e+ E !%&o Z"+)%, en /ec1% 3 &e oc!" (e &e+ %(e$) !(%&o %7o e+ No; 6, '(o!oco+o 4Q, !o*o 4 Q> 0 % *) *o, e+ &oc"*en%n!ece&e en /ec1%, e !(%!% &e "n% &ec+%(%c)-n "ce o(%+ e*)!)&% 'o( e+ &on&e e e !% +ece co*o 9n)c% 1e(e&e(% &e+ c)"&%&%no D)*% Pe(n %, %Me+ % Pe(n %, 'o( +o !%n!o e++% e(% +% 9n)c% '(o')e!%()% &e+ )n*"e +e en

A"n%&o % e++o, con !% en %c!% &oc"*en!o '(o!oco+)#%&o % !(%5é &c)"&%&%no D)*% Pe(n % %&.")()- e+ )en, e 'ec /)c%*en!e e+ ."e ()e+% &e+ /3= &e +% '()*e(% ')e#%, 0 ."e e enc"en!(% )n c()!o en +% O/)c)n% S" %+!e(Se$"n&o C)(c")!o &e Re$) !(o &e+ M"n)c)')o M%(%c%) o &e+ E !%&o Z"+)%3 &e %$o !o &e 4 , %7o e+ No; 4 , '(o!oco+o 4Q, !o*o Q> 'o( +o .con ec"enc)% +% c%&en% &oc"*en!%+ e enc"en!(% '+en%*en!e &e*o !(%&%% co*o +% '(o')e&%& 'o( '%(!e &e +% &e*%n&%

En c"%n!o % +% )&en!)&%& &e+ )n*"e +e (ec+%*%&o, en +% '("e % &e e

()e+% &e+ /o+)o 4 6 %+ 326 &e +% '()*e(% ')e#% &e+ e 'e&)en!e, +o e 'e(!o ++% conc+" )-n: FK"e e+ )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e e !% E 'e(!)c)%, e co((e 'on&%c"e(&o % +o '%( *e!(o &e U )c%c)-n, L)n&e(o , No*enc+%!"(% 0 S"'e%n!e()o(*en!e &e c()!o en e+ c"e('o &e e !e In/o(*e con e+ e %+%&o 'o( +%

o+)c)!%n!e en e+ Doc"*en!o &e Men "(% P+%no &e Men "(% No; M@


23/65

con ec"enc)% e !e (e.") )!o e enc"en!(% 5%+)&%&

A1o(% )en, ."e&%n&o /)(*e e+ 1ec1o &e ."e e/ec!)5%*en!e e+ &e*%n&%&o e 'o e )-n &e+ )en )n*"e +e o 7e!o &e +% '(e en!e &e*%n&%, 0 &e ."e % 'e %(."e&- &e*o !(%&o en %"!o % !(%5é &e +% !e !)*on)%+e 0 &e+ &oc"*en%&*)n) !(%!)5o ."e ()e+% en e+ /o+)o 3 &e +% '()*e(% ')e#% &e+ e 'e&)en!ee/ec!"%(on "n% e()e &e )en1ec1"( % %+ *) *o> e !% A+#%&% o e(5% '(e en!e c% o no e ) !e "n% (econ5enc)-n en &on&e e 1" )e(en (ec+%*%& '(eno* (%&% *e7o(% , 'o( +o ."e en con ec"enc)% no !)ene ."e '(on"nc)%( e (e 'ec!o;

8)n%+*en!e, %+ 1% e( e &e*o !(%&o !o&o +o (e.") )!o ."e e )$e +% &oc 7"() '("&enc)% '%(% ."e '(oce&% +% (e)5)n&)c%c)-n, e !% A+#%&% &ec+LUGAR +% %'e+%c)-n )n!e('"e !% 'o( e+ % o$%&o Ge(* n 8+o(e en (e'(e en&e +% '%(!e &e*%n&%&%, 0 CON8IRMARÁ e+ /%++o e*%n%&o &e+ J"#$%&

P()*e(% In !%nc)% C)5)+, Me(c%n!)+ 0 &e+ T( n )!o &e +% C)(c"n c()'c)-n J"&e !%&o Z"+)%, en /ec1% 2= &e oc!" (e &e 3242, ."e &ec+%(- CON LUGA&e*%n&% )n!e('"e !% 'o( +% c)"&%&%n% MARIANGEL URDANETA PERMARIANYEL URDANETA PERN?A en con!(% &e+ c)"&%&%no JORGE ERNELA CRUZ; A e &ec)&e;

IVDISPOSITIVO

Po( +o /"n&%*en!o %n!e e '"e !o , é !e JUZGADO SUPERIOR PRIMERO LO CIVIL, MERCANTIL Y DEL TRÁNSITO DE LA CIRCUNSCRIPCIÓNJUDICIAL DEL ESTADO ZULIA, %&*)n) !(%n&o 7" !)c)% en no* (e &eRe'9 +)c% Bo+)5%()%n% &e Vene#"e+% 0 'o( A"!o()&%& &e +% Le0, PRIMERO: SIN LUGAR e+ (ec"( o &e %'e+%c)-n )n!e('"e !o en /ec1% 46 &e ene&e 3244 'o( e+ % o$%&o GERMÁN 8LORES, con!(% &e +% &ec) )-n &)c!%&JUZGADO CUARTO DE PRIMERA INSTANCIA EN LO CIVIL, MERCANTILY DEL TRÁNSITO DE LA CIRCUNSCRIPCIÓN JUDICIAL DEL ESTADOZULIA, en /ec1% 2= &e oc!" (e &e 3242, en e+ 7")c)o 'o( REIVINDICACIÓN

e$")&o 'o( +% c)"&%&%n% MARIANGEL URDANETA PERN?A 0 MARIANURDANETA PERN?A, en con!(% &e+ c)"&%&%no JORGE ERNESTO LA CR!o&o )&en!)/)c%&o ;SEGUNDO: SE CON8IRMA +% &ec) )-n &)c!%&% 'o( e+ JUZGADO CUARTOPRIMERA INSTANCIA EN LO CIVIL, MERCANTIL Y DEL TRÁNSITO DE LACIRCUNSCRIPCIÓN JUDICIAL DEL ESTADO ZULIA, en /ec1% 2= &e oc!" (e


24/65

&e 3242;TERCERO: SE ORDENA %+ c)"&%&%no JORGE ERNESTO LA CRUZ 1%cen!(e$% % +% c)"&%&%n% MARIANGEL URDANETA PERN?A 0 MARIAURDANETA PERN?A, &e+ )n*"e +e ."e e enc"en!(% " )c%&o en 7"() &)cc)-n &P%((o.")% C1).")n.")( &e+ *"n)c)')o M%(%c%) o &e+ E !%&o Z"+)%, ec!o( CP%(% o, c%++e 6, No; 4 @ =, c"0% "'e(/)c)e e &e .")n)en!o c"%!(oc"%&(%&o , con c"%!(o &ec *e!(o &e *e!(o c"%&(%&o 2=,2= *! 3 , co*&en!(o &e +o )$")en!e +)n&e(o : NORTE: Con '(o')e&%& ."e e o /"e &e APe(n %, 1o0 &e M)c1e+e D) Gen%(o Con!)> SUR: S" /(en!e, +% c%++e 6>P(o')e&%& ."e e o /"e &e G+o()% O$)+*), 1o0 &e L" N%5%((o Gon# +e#> 0 OCon '(o')e&%& &e I % % V%+ "en%CUARTO: SE CONDENA EN COSTAS % +% '%(!e &e*%n&%&% %'e+%ncon/o(*)&%& con +o ."e e !% +ece e+ %(! c"+o 3 4 &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&C)5)+;

PUBL?KUESE, REG?STRESE 0 NOTI8?KUESE; Dé7e e 'o( Sec(e!%( % co')ce(!)/)c%&% &e con/o(*)&%& con +o e !% +ec)&o en e+ A(! c"+o 3= &e+ P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+;

D%&%, e++%&% 0 /)(*%&% en +% S%+% &e De '%c1o &e é !e JUZGADOPRIMERO EN LO CIVIL, MERCANTIL Y DEL TRÁNSITO DE LACIRCUNSCRIPCION JUDICIAL DEL ESTADO ZULIA, en M%(%c%) o, % +o& % &e *%(#o &e+ % o 324 ; A o : 32= &e +% In&e'en&enc)% 0 48e&e(%c)-n;LA JUEZ PROVISORIA

8DOD(%; ISMELDA RINCÓN OCANDOEL SECRETARIO

8DOA o$; MARCOS 8AR?A KUIJANO

En +% *) *% /ec1% %n!e()o(, )en&o +% n"e5e &e +% *% %n% :22 %;*; '" +)c- e+ /%++o ."e %n!ece&e;EL SECRETARIO

8DOA o$; MARCOS 8AR?A KUIJANO

REPÚBLICA BOLIVARIANA DE VENEZUELA


25/65

En " no* (e:JUZGADO SUPERIOR PRIMERO EN LO CIVIL, MERCANTIL Y DEL

TRÁNSITO DE LA CIRCUNSCRIPCIÓN JUDICIAL DEL ESTADOBOLIVARIANO DE M RIDA

DETERMINACIÓN PRELIMINAR DE LA CAUSA

E+ '(e en!e e 'e&)en!e e enc"en!(% en e !% A+#%&%, en 5)(!"& &e+ (ec"( o &e%'e+%c)-n )n!e('"e !o *e&)%n!e &)+)$enc)% &e /ec1% 2 &e 7"n)o &e 3244 /o+) 'o( e+ % o$%&o en e7e(c)c)o YOVANNY ROJAS, 5ene#o+%no, *%0o( &e e&%&,% o$%&o, !)!"+%( &e +% cé&"+% &e )&en!)&%& n9*e(o ;23 ;= 6, )n c()!o en

In'(e% o$%&o %7o e+ n9*e(o ;2= , en " con&)c)-n &e %'o&e(%&o 7"&)c)%c)"&%&%no JOS JACINTO CANDALES PAC ECO, 5ene#o+%no, *%0o( &e e&!)!"+%( &e +% cé&"+% &e )&en!)&%& n9*e(o


26/65

Me&)%n!e e c()!o &e /ec1% 4 &e oc!" (e &e 3244 /o+)o , e+ % o$%&o enJOS YOVANNY ROJAS LA CRUZ, en " con&)c)-n &e %'o&e(%&o 7"&)c)%+ & '%(!e %c!o(% '(e en!- en "n 24 /o+)o 9!)+ e c()!o &e )n/o(*e ;

Po( %"!o &e /ec1% 23 &e no5)e* (e &e 3244 /o+)o < , e !e T() "n%+ &)7o \VI0 en!(- en !é(*)no '%(% &ec)&)( e+ '(e en!e (ec"( o &e %'e+%c)-n, &e con/o(*)&%con +o e !% +ec)&o en e+ %(! c"+o 34 &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+;

Po( %"!o &e /ec1% 4 &e ene(o &e 3243 /o+)o , e !e T() "n%+ &)/)()- +% '"&e +% en!enc)% '%(% e+ !()$é )*o & % c%+en&%()o con ec"!)5o )$")en!e % +(e/e()&o %"!o;

Po( %"!o &e /ec1% 4 &e /e (e(o &e 3243 /o+)o , e !e T() "n%+ &e7- con !)en&o +% o'o(!"n)&%& &e &)c!%( en!enc)% en +% '(e en!e c%" %, no '(o/e( %en 5)(!"& &e e ) !)( o!(% c%" % en e !%&o &e en!enc)% ."e &e %n e( & '(e/e(enc)% % c"%+.")e( o!(o % "n!o;

Encon!( n&o e +% '(e en!e c%" % en e !%&o &e &)c!%( en!enc)%, '(oce&e e% '(o/e()(+%, '(e5)% +% con )&e(%c)one )$")en!e :

I

S?NTESIS DE LA CONTROVERSIA

L% '(e en!e c%" % e )n)c)- *e&)%n!e +) e+o '(e en!%&o en /ec1% 4 &e 7"+)o /o+)o 24 %+ 26 , 'o( %n!e e+ J"#$%&o &e P()*e(% In !%nc)% en +o C)5)+ 0 M

+% C)(c"n c()'c)-n J"&)c)%+ &e+ E !%&o Mé()&%, con e&e en E+ V)$ %, 'o( eJOS YOVANNY ROJAS LACRUZ, !)!"+%( &e +% cé&"+% &e )&en!)&%& N e )n c()!o en e+ In !)!"!o &e P(e5) )-n Soc)%+ &e+ A o$%&o %7o e+ N ;2=%c!"%n&o con e+ c%( c!e( &e %'o&e(%&o 7"&)c)%+ &e+ c)"&%&%no JOS JACANDALES PAC ECO, 5ene#o+%no, c% %&o, *%0o( &e e&%&, !)!"+%( &e +%

)&en!)&%& n9*e(o


27/65

e+ %n!e()o(, e &ec)( &oce *e!(o 43* , !e((eno &e +% "ce )-n D"$%(!e> COSDEREC O: Con *e&)&% &e &)ec)oc1o *e!(o 4 * , !e((eno ."e on o /"e(on &

o(%c)o S%+% > COSTADO IZKUIERDO: En e !en )-n &e 5e)n!)c"%!(o *e!(o c)nc"en!% cen! *e!(o 3=, 2* , !e((eno ."e on o /"e(on &e o(%c)o S%+% >

Doc"*en!o P(o!oco+)#%&o en +% O/)c)n% In*o )+)%()% &e Re$) !(o P9 +)co &eM"n)c)')o An&(é Be++o &e+ E !%&o Mé()&%, %7o e+ NQ 4=, /o+)o 3 %+ /oTo*o 5o , P(o!oco+o P()*e(o, C"%(!o T()*e !(e &e+ % o &o *)+ )e!e 3;22< , /ec1% c"%!(o 2= &e D)c)e* (e &e+ % o &o *)+ )e!e 3;22< > 0 %ne - co')%ce(!)/)c%&% *%(c%&% \B; K"e &)c1o In*"e +e, &e &e 1%ce S)e!e 2< *e e 1 'o e &o *%!e()%+*en!e )n e+ con en!)*)en!o &e " '(o')e!%()o: JOS JACINTOCANDALES PAC ECO> ."e &)c1o oc"'%n!e )n (%#-n n) %"!o()#%c)-n %'%(en1%n oc"'%&o e+ )n*"e +e )+e$%+*en!e 0% ."e " *%n&%n!e n) ).")e(% e !% +econ!(%!o &e %((en&%*)en!o, 'o( +o ."e %c"&)- % c)!%(+o 'o( %n!e +% P(e/ec!"(%

M"n)c)')o An&(é Be++o ] L% A#"+)!% 0 !%*'oco +o$(- +% &e oc"'%c)-n &e+)n*"e +e> 0 en (%#-n &e e++o, e 'o( +o ."e e 5e /o(#%&o en no* (e 0 (e'(e en!%&e " *%n&%n!e % &e*%n&%( co*o en e/ec!o +o 1%ce /o(*%+*en!e 'o(REIVINDICACION &e '(o')e&%&, %+ c)"&%&%no: ERNESTOO R; VALLVEMORALES 5ene#o+%no, *%0o( &e e&%&, !)!"+%( &e +% ce&"+% &e )&en!)/)c%

;333;


28/65

SEGUNDO: K"e e &ec+%(e ."e e+ &e*%n&%&o c)"&%&%no ERNESTO R; VALMORALES, &e!en!% )n&e )&%*en!e &)c1o In*"e +e;TERCERO: K"e e+ De*%n&%&o, en 5)(!"& &e +% oc"'%c)-n )+e$%+ ."e *%n!)enee+ )n*"e +e '(o')e&%& &e " *%n&%n!e, en c% o &e no &e oc"'%( 5o+"n!%()%*

(e/e()&o )n*"e +e, e% o +)$%&o % &e5o+5e(, (e !)!")(, 0 en!(e$%( )n '+%#o %c)"&%&%no JOS JACINTO CANDALES PAC ECO, e+ )n*"e +e "! "'(%)&en!)/)c%&o;CUARTO: K"e e+ &e*%n&%&o /"e(% o +)$%&o % '%$%( +o co !o 0 co !%K"e % +o e/ec!o &e +% &e!e(*)n%c)-n &e +% c"%n! %, e !)*- +% &e*%n&% &e CINCUENTA MIL BOLIVARES B ; 2;222,22 ; 8)n%+*en!e ')&)- ."e +%&e*%n&% /"e(% %&*)!)&%, " !%nc)%&% con/o(*e % &e(ec1o, 0 &ec+%(%&%!o&o +o '(on"nc)%*)en!o &e Le0;

Me&)%n!e %"!o &e /ec1% 36 &e 7"+)o &e 322 /o+)o 43 , e+ T() "n%+ &e +% c%&*)!)- +% &e*%n&%, 'o( no e( con!(%()% %+ o(&en '9 +)co, % +% "en% c%+$"n% &) 'o )c)-n e '(e % &e +% Le0 0 e*'+%#- %+ c)"&%&%no ERNESTO RVALLVE MORALES, 5ene#o+%no, *%0o( &e e&%&, !)!"+%( &e +% cé&"+% &e ) N ;333;


29/65

RAMON VALLVE MORALES, en " con&)c)-n &e '%(!e &e*%n&%&%, con/)()- 'o%'"& %c!% % +% % o$%&% DUNIA C IRINOS LAGUNA, !)!"+%( &e +% cé&")&en!)&%& N 6; 3 ;


30/65

P)&)- /"e(% %&*)!)&% +% )n!e(5enc)-n /o(#%&% o+)c)!%&% 0 ."e !(%*)!%&% &e(ec1o /"e(% &ec+%(%&% con +"$%( en +% en!enc)% % &)c!%( e en e+ '(oceSe %+o co*o &o*)c)+)o '(oce %+ +% )$")en!e &)(ecc)-n: A5en)&% 4= en!(e c%+E&)/)c)o \Renn0 , P()*e( P) o, Loc%+ 6, E+ V)$ %, E !%&o Mé()&%;

Me&)%n!e %"!o &e /ec1% 3 &e *%(#o &e 322 /o+)o 6= , e+ J"#$%&o &e P()*In !%nc)% en +o C)5)+ 0 Me(c%n!)+ &e +% C)(c"n c()'c)-n J"&)c)%+ &e+ E !%&con e&e en E+ V)$ %, &e con/o(*)&%& con e+ o(&)n%+ = &e+ %(! c"+o 6


31/65

A o$%&o %7o e+ N 3=;4 , '%(% ."e +% (e'(e en!%(% 0 o !"5)e(% " &e(e)n!e(e e en e+ 7")c)o '(e en!%&o;

En /ec1% 4 &e 7"n)o &e 322 5!o; /o+)o 6 , +% Sec(e!%()% &e+ J"#$%&o &e

In !%nc)% en +o C)5)+ 0 Me(c%n!)+ &e +% C)(c"n c()'c)-n J"&)c)%+ &e+ E !%&con e&e en E+ V)$ %, '(e5)o co*'"!o &e +o & % &e &e '%c1o &) c"(()&o eT() "n%+, &e7- con !%nc)% ."e +% '%(!e &e*%n&%&% c)"&%&%n% ELEINYZGUILLEN PERN?A, no con )$n- e c()!o &e con!e !%c)-n % +% &e*%n&%;

Po( &)+)$enc)% &e /ec1% 2< &e 7"+)o &e 322 /o+)o 6 , +% % o$%&% VIRGMOLINA GUTIERREZ, en " c%( c!e( &e co@%'o&e(%&% 7"&)c)%+ &e +% '%con )$n- en &o /o+)o 9!)+e , e c()!o &e '(o*oc)-n &e '("e % en e+ 7")c)o;

En e c()!o '(e en!%&o en /ec1% 2 &e 7"+)o &e 322 /o+)o =4 , +% % o$%&C IRINOS LAGUNA 0 DOMENICA SCIORTINO 8INOL, %'o&e(%&% 7"&)c)%&e +o co@&e*%n&%&o , ERNESTO RAMON VALLVE MORALES 0 ELEINYZYZAMAR GUILLEN PERN?A, '(o*o5)e(on '("e % en e+ 7")c)o;

Me&)%n!e %"!o &e /ec1% 46 &e 7"+)o &e 322 /o+)o =3 , e+ J"#$%&o &e +% PIn !%nc)%, o(&en- e %$(e$%(% %+ e 'e&)en!e +o e c()!o &e '("e % con )$+% '%(!e &e+ '(oce o;

Po( &)+)$enc)% &e /ec1% 4= &e 7"+)o &e 322 /o+)o =6 , e+ co@%'o&e(%&o 7 '%(!e co@&e*%n&%&%, % o$%&% DUNIA C IRINOS LAGUNA, )*'"$n- +% '(&oc"*en!%+ '(o*o5)&% 'o( +% '%(!e %c!o(%;

Me&)%n!e %"!o &e /ec1% 34 &e 7"+)o /o+)o == , e+ T() "n%+ &e +% P()*e(% I&ec+%(- )*'(oce&en!e +% o'o )c)-n /o(*"+%&% 'o( +% %'o&e(%&% 7"&)c)%+ &eco&e*%n&%&o, c)"&%&%no ERNESTO RAMON VALLVE MORALES;

Me&)%n!e %"!o &e /ec1% 34 &e 7"+)o &e 322 8o+)o = 0 = , e+ J"#$%&o

In !%nc)% en +o C)5)+ 0 Me(c%n!)+ &e +% C)(c"n c()'c)-n J"&)c)%+ &e+ E !%&con e&e en E+ V)$ %, %&*)!)- 'o( e( +e$%+e 0 '(oce&en!e , %+5o " 5%+o(en!enc)%, +% '("e % '(o*o5)&% 'o( +% '%(!e en e+ 7")c)o;

En %"!o &e /ec1% 4 &e oc!" (e &e 322 5!o; &e+ /o+)o =< , e+ J"#$%&o &e +In !%nc)%, 0 '(e5)o co*'"!o &e +o & % &e &e '%c1o &) c"(()&o en e+ T() "e+ &éc)*o .")n!o & % &e &e '%c1o )$")en!e, '%(% ."e +% '%(!e con )$n%(%n


32/65

)n/o(*e co((e 'on&)en!e ;

Po( &)+)$enc)% &e /ec1% 4 &e no5)e* (e &e 322 /o+)o = , e+ % o$%&o JOYOVANNY ROJAS LACRUZ, en " con&)c)-n &e co@%'o&e(%&o 7"&)c)%+ &e

%c!o(%, con )$n- e c()!o &e )n/o(*e 0 %ne o en e+ e 'e&)en!e /o+)o = %+ Po( %"!o &e /ec1% 4= &e &)c)e* (e &e 322 /o+)o = e+ T() "n%+ &e +% P()*In !%nc)% &e con/o(*)&%& con e+ %(! c"+o 4 &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!oe+ +%' o &e +o e en!% & % c%+en&%()o con ec"!)5o , '%(% &)c!%( en

Me&)%n!e %"!o &e /ec1% 4 &e *%(#o &e 3242 /o+)o , e+ J"#$%&o &e P()*In !%nc)% en +o C)5)+ 0 Me(c%n!)+ &e +% C)(c"n c()'c)-n J"&)c)%+ &e+ E !%&con e&e en E+ V)$ %, &e con/o(*)&%& con e+ %(! c"+o 3 4 &e+ C-&)$o &e

P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+, &)/)()- 'o( e ce o &e !(% %7o, e+ +%' o '%(% &)c!%( en!e/)7- e+ +%' o &e !(e)n!% & % c%+en&%()o con ec"!)5o )$")en!e '%(% &)c!

Po( &)+)$enc)% &e /ec1% 3 &e *%0o &e 3242 /o+)o 0 3 &e *%(#o &/o+)o < , e+ % o$%&o YOVANNY ROJAS, en " con&)c)-n &e co@%'o&e(%&

&e +% '%(!e %c!o(%, o+)c)!- %+ J"#$%&o &e +% P()*e(% In !%nc)% e &)c!%

IIDE LA SENTENCIA APELADA

En /ec1% 3 &e % ()+ &e 3244 /o+)o %+ , e+ JUZGADO DE PRIMERAINSTANCIA CIVIL Y MERCANTIL DE LA CIRCUNSCRIPCIÓN JUDICIALDEL ESTADO M RIDA, con e&e en E+ V)$ %, &ec+%(- +o ."e % con!)n"%c)-n !(% c() en )n 5e( ) :

\ O*) ) :

IIP+%n!e%&% +% con!(o5e( )% en +o !é(*)no '(ece&en!e*en!e e '"e !o , e !e T '%(% &ec)&)( o e(5%:De con/o(*)&%& con e+ %(! c"+o = &e+ C-&)$o C)5)+:E+ '(o')e!%()o &e "n% co % !)ene e+ &e(ec1o &e (e)5)n&)c%(+% &e c"%+.")e( 'o&e!en!%&o(, %+5o +% e ce'c)one e !% +ec)&% 'o( +% +e0e ;S) e+ 'o ee&o( o &e!en!%&o( &e '"é &e +% &e*%n&% 7"&)c)%+ 1% &e7%&o


33/65

co % 'o( 1ec1o '(o')o, e ! o +)$%&o % (eco (%(+% % " co !% 'o( c"en!% &e+&e*%n&%n!e> 0, ) % no +o 1)c)e(e, % '%$%( " 5%+o(, )n 'e(7")c)o &e +% o!)ene e+ &e*%n&%n!e '%(% )n!en!%( " %cc)-n con!(% e+ n"e5o 'o ee&o( o &e!enCo*o '"e&e 5e( e, +% no(*% %n!e !(%n c()!% no '(ec) % +o e !(e*o ."e &e e

e+ %c!o( '%(% e7e(ce( con é )!o +% (e/e()&% '(e!en )-n, &e %++ ."e, e+ en!enc)%'+)c%( +% en e %n#% &e +% &oc!()n% 0 &e +% 7"() '("&enc)% o (e e+ '%(!En !%+ en!)&o, +% S%+% &e C% %c)-n C)5)+ &e+ T() "n%+ S"'(e*o &e J" !)c

en!enc)% &e /ec1% 3< &e % ()+ &e 322=, con 'onenc)% &e+ M%$) !(%&o CAROBERTO VELEZ, %ce(c% &e +% ++%*%&% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% &e7- en!%

)$")en!e:L% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% e "n% %cc)-n (e%+, 'e!)!o()%, &e n%!"(%+e#% e enc)5)+ 0 e e7e(ce ERGA OMNES, e &ec)(, con!(% c"%+.")e(% ."e e% e+ &e!en!%con!(% !o&o 'o ee&o( %c!"%+ ."e c%(e#c% &e ! !"+o &e '(o')e&%&;

L% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% "'one !%n!o +% '("e % &e+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& '&e+ &e*%n&%n!e co*o +% '()5%c)-n o &e!en!%c)-n 'o e o()% &e +% co %, 'o( .e e+ '(o')e!%()o 0 no e " ce'!) +e &e '(e c()'c)-n e !)n!)5%;L% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()%, e enc"en!(% con&)c)on%&% % +% conc"((enc)% &

)$")en!e (e.") )!o : % De(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& o &o*)n)o &e+ %c!o( (e)5)n&)c Encon!(%( e e+ &e*%n&%&o en 'o e )-n &e +% co % ."e e !(%!% &e (e)5)nL% /%+!% &e+ &e(ec1o % 'o ee( &e+ &e*%n&%&o> & I&en!)&%& &e +% co

e% +% *) *% (ec+%*%&% 0 o (e +% c"%+ e+ %c!o( (ec+%*% &e(ec1o co*oL% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% co((e 'on&e e c+" )5%*en!e %+ '(o')e!%()o con!(% e

'o ee&o( ."e no e '(o')e!%()o; En con ec"enc)%, +% c%($% &e +% '("e % +% !)en&e*%n&%n!e; HEn con ec"enc)%, e+ &e*%n&%n!e e ! o +)$%&o % '(o %( 'o( +o *eno &o (e% K"e e+ &e*%n&%n!e e (e%+*en!e +e$ !)*o '(o')e!%()o &e +% co % ."e '(e!en(e)5)n&)c%( 0 K"e +% co % &e ."e e &)ce '(o')e!%()o e +% *) *% c"0% &e!)+e$%+ +e %!() "0e % +% &e*%n&%&%; L% /%+!% &e "no o c"%+.")e(% &e e(e.") )!o , e "/)c)en!e '%(% ."e e &ec+%(e )n +"$%( +% %cc)-n;

" (%0%&o &e+ T() "n%+ XXX;! 7;$o5;5e &ec) )one ; C% o E"(o Án$e+8"en*%0o( 0 o!(o con!(% O c%( A+ e(!o Gon# +e# 8e((e(; E '; N ; AA32@C@3

222 33En e !e *) *o o(&en &e )&e% , +% &oc!()n% 1% ) !e*%!)#%&o, ."e '%(% ."e '( '(e!en )-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()% '(e5) !% 'o( e+ %(! c"+o = &e+ C-&)$o C)5)+, \HA+&e*%n&%n!e +e co((e 'on&e +% c%($% '(o %!o()% &e !(e % 'ec!o '()nc)'%+ee e+ '(o')e!%()o &e +% co % o 7e!o &e +% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()%; 3 K"e e+ &+% &e!en!% 0 6 L% )&en!)&%& &e +% co %H ; D"."e Co((e&o(, R; 322 ; P(o+% P(o')e&%& 0 +% Po e )-n, '; 622 S)n e* %($o, e$9n +% en!enc)% %n!e


34/65

'%(c)%+*en!e !(% c()!%, e+ &e*%n&%n!e, \H e ! o +)$%&o % '(o %( 'o( +o *e(e.") )!o : % K"e e+ &e*%n&%n!e e (e%+*en!e +e$ !)*o '(o')e!%()o &e +% co '(e!en&e (e)5)n&)c%( 0 K"e +% co % &e ."e e &)ce '(o')e!%()o e +% *) *% c&e!en!%c)-n )+e$%+ +e %!() "0e % +% &e*%n&%&%; L% /%+!% &e "no o c"%+

&o (e.") )!o , e "/)c)en!e '%(% ."e e &ec+%(e )n +"$%( +% %cc)-nHAce(c% &e+ '()*e( (e.") )!o, % % e(: ."e e+ &e*%n&%n!e e (e%+*en!e +e$ !)*o '(o')e!%()o &e +% co % ."e '(e!en&e (e)5)n&)c%(, +% &oc!()n% e 1% '(on"nc)%&!é(*)no )$")en!e :\H e )n&) 'en % +e ."e e !e ! !"+o e !é '+en%*en!e &o!%&o &e e/)c%c)% 7"(1%ce( )n&"&% +e e+ &e(ec1o &e '(o')e&%& ."e )n5oc% e+ %c!o(; L% %cc)-n(e)5)n&)c%!o()% con !)!"0e "n% %cc)-n 9!)+ ."e -+o %+ '(o')e!%()o e con/e()&%Me )neo, %+ &e!e(*)n%( +o ."e e+ (e)5)n&)c%n!e &e e &e*o !(%(, e (e/)e(e % &e*o !(%c)-n &e e co*'(en&e( \e+ /"n&%*en!o &e+ '(o')o &e(ec1o, +o ."e )$n)/)c

."e \'%(% .")!%( +% 'o e )-n % o!(o, nece )!% &e*o !(%( +% %n!e()o()&%& &e+&e(ec1o %+ 'o ee&o( on" 'e!)!o()o > 0 &)ce !%* )én ."e +% '("e % )nc"* e % '(o')e!%()o, 'o(."e e+ 'o ee&o( e &e*%n&%&o 0 n%&% &e e '(o %( '%(% con e 'o e )-nH M% no 1% &e e( "/)c)en!e '%(% " !en!%( e+ &e(ec1o &e+ %c!o( + '(e en!%c)-n &e "n ! !"+o c"%+.")e(%, %"n."e e !é (e$) !(%&o 0 no e% n"+o 'o(&e/ec!o &e /o(*%; A+ %c!o( +e % !% '(o %( " '(o')o &o*)n)o c"%n&o e+ ! !"+o%&.") )c)-n e o()$)n%()o> 'e(o c"%n&o e &e()5%&o, !)ene ."e '(o %(, %&e*&o*)n)o &e " %n!ece o(e ; Y %+ (e 'ec!o &e e (eco(&%( e +o %/)(*%&o 'o( P\L% c%($% &e +% '("e % (ec%e o (e e+ %c!o(, .")en &e e( '(o %( e+ &e(ec1o

'(o')e&%& ."e '(e!en&e +e co((e 'on&e> no % !%( ."e &e*"e !(e +% c%(enc)% &e(ec1o &e+ &e*%n&%&oH " (%0%&o &e+ T() "n%+ Pe(e(% P+%n% , C-&)$o C)5)+ Vene#o+%no, ''; 3 0 3 ;En e !e en!)&o, +% &oc!()n% e %+%: \P%(% %&.")()( +% '(o')e&%& e (e.")e!(% +%!)5o, % *eno ."e e !(%!e &e +% oc"'%c)-n; E+ ."e .")e(e &e*o !(%( " '(o')e&%& ^&)ce Co+)n 0 C%')!%n!^ &e e &e*o !(%( e+ 1ec1o &e+ c"%+ (e "+!e&e(ec1o; A1o(% )en, /"e(% &e+ c% o &e oc"'%c)-n, 1%0 &o 1)'-!e ) ."e &) !) )en e+ '(o')e!%()o &e()5% " &e(ec1o &e +% Le0, ."e +o 1%ce (e "+!%( &e +% 'o '(o+on$%&%> o )en " &e(ec1o '(o5)ene &e "n %c!o 5o+"n!%()o 5en!%, &on%c

'e(*"!%, e!c; ."e +e 1% !(%n /e()&o +% '(o')e&%&H En e+ c% o en ."e e+ (e)5)n&e 1) % "n ! !"+o, é !e &e e( e( &e +o ."e +o (o*%no 0 no o!(o , &e '"é ++%*%*o "n 7" !o ! !"+o, e &ec)(, "n %c!o !(% +%!)5o ; Un)5e( )&%& CenVene#"e+%; 4 =; C-&)$o C)5)+ &e Vene#"e+% ART?CULOS = %+ 6 '; 46En c"%n!o %+ e$"n&o (e.") )!o, % % e(: ."e +% co % &e ."e e &)ce '(o')e!%()*) *% c"0% &e!en!%c)-n )+e$%+ +e %!() "0e % +% &e*%n&%&% )&en!)/)c%c+% &oc!()n% en e %:


35/65

\Hen c"%n!o % +% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()%, c% e )n5oc%( no(*% e 'ec)%+e )&en!)&%& ."e 1%n e+% o(%&o +% 7"() '("&enc)% 0 +% &oc!()n%; E !% no(*(e "*)( e en ."e e+ %cc)on%n!e en (e)5)n&)c%c)-n &e e co*'(o %( ."e on "n%*) *% co % %."e++% &e!e(*)n%&% en e+ +) e+o, &e +% c"%+ e '(e!en&e '(o')e

'o e &% 'o( e+ &e*%n&%&o; P%(% e !% +ece( +% )&en!)&%& &e "n )n*"e +e&e!e(*)n%(+e 'o( " )!"%c)-n, *e&)&% , +)n&e(o 0 %+$"n% o!(% c)(c"n !%!)en&en % )n&)5)&"%+)#%(+o, 0% ."e )&en!)/)c%(, e!)*o+-$)c%*en!e, e.")5%+e %

)n$"+%()#%(, % 1%ce( ."e %+$o %'%(e#c% &) !)n!o &e !o&o +o ."e e +e % e*%&e* &e e !% )n$"+%()#%c)-n, e+ %c!o( &e e '(ec) %( en %"!o ."e e+ )n*"(e)5)n&)c%&o e e+ *) *o ."e 'o ee e+ &e*%n&%&o; E co*o "n% e$"n&% /%e 'ec /)c%, &e +% !%(e% &e )&en!)/)c%c)-n )*'(e!e(*)!) +e '%(% ."e e+ %cc)on%n

"c"* % en " '(e!en )-nH " (%0%&o &e+ T() "n%+ Pe(e(% P+%n% , N;c)!;, ''; 3 0 3 ;

En e+ '(e en!e c% o, +% '%(!e %c!o(% c)"&%&%no JOS JACINTO CANDALESPAC ECO, '(e!en&e +% (e)5)n&)c%c)-n &e "n )en )n*"e +e \H " )c%&o en e+ econoc)&o co*o \B%(()o Cen!en%()o , &e +% 'o +%c)-n &e L% A#"+)!% M"n)c)')oBe++o &e+ E !%&o Mé()&%, c"0o +)n&e(o 0 *e&)&% on +o )$")en!e : 8e !en )-n &e &oce *e!(o 43 * , "n c%*)no 5ec)n%+> 8ONDO: en )$"%+ *e&)&+% %n!e()o(, e &ec)( &oce *e!(o 43 * , !e((eno &e +% "ce )-n D"$%(!e> CODEREC O: Con *e&)&% &e &)ec)oc1o *e!(o 4 * , !e((eno ."e on o /"e(on

o(%c)o S%+% > COSTADO IZKUIERDO: En +% e !en )-n &e 5e)n!)c"%!(o *e!con c)nc"en!% cen! *e!(o 3=, 2 * , !e((eno ."e on o /"e(on &e+ no* (%&o

o(%c)o S%+% H > c"0% '(o')e&%&, e$9n %&"ce, con !% &e &oc"*en!o '(o!oc 'o( %n!e +% O/)c)n% &e Re$) !(o P9 +)co &e+ M"n)c)')o An&(é Be++o &e+ E !Mé()&%, en /ec1% 2= &e &)c)e* (e &e 322


36/65

+% %c!o(% e &)ce '(o')e!%()%;De con/o(*)&%& con +o %(! c"+o 4;6 = &e+ C-&)$o C)5)+, en conco(&%nc)%

2 &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+, co((e 'on&e % +% '%(!e +% c%($% '("e % &e " (e 'ec!)5% %/)(*%c)one &e 1ec1o;

IIIP%(% &e!e(*)n%( ) +o '(e "'"e !o %n!e no* (%&o 1%n )&o &e*o !(%&oe 1%ce nece %()o en"nc)%(, %n%+)#%( 0 5%+o(%( e+ *%!e()%+ '(o %!o()o c"(

%"!o , '%(% +o c"%+ e o e(5%:PRUEBAS DE LA PARTE DEMANDANTE:J"n!o con e+ +) e+o &e +% &e*%n&%, +% '%(!e &e*%n&%n!e '(o&"7o e+ )n !("*/"n&%*en!%+, e+ c"%+ /"e '(o*o5)&o 'o !e()o(*en!e, &"(%n!e e+ +%' o '(o %!o()o

e$9n e c()!o &e /ec1% 2< &e 7"+)o &e 322 /; =2 , 0 e !(%!% &e+ *e&)o '(o)$")en!e:

ÚNICO: Doc"*en!o '(o!oco+)#%&o 'o( %n!e +% O/)c)n% In*o )+)%()% &e Re$) !P9 +)co &e+ M"n)c)')o An&(é Be++o &e+ E !%&o Mé()&%, con e+ o 7e!o &e &\H +% '(o')e&%& +e$ !)*% &e " _*)` *%n&%n!e o (e e+ c"%+ e o+)c)!% +%REIVINDICACIÓNHDe+ %n +) ) &e &)c1o )n !("*en!o, ."e con !% %$(e$%&o % +o /o+)o 2< %+ '(e en!e e 'e&)en!e, e '"e&e con !%!%( ."e e !(%!% &e "n &oc"*en!o '9 +)coo()$)n%+, '(o!oco+)#%&o 'o( %n!e +% O/)c)n% In*o )+)%()% &e Re$) !(o P9 +)cM"n)c)')o An&(é Be++o &e+ E !%&o Mé()&%, en /ec1% 2= &e &)c)e* (e &e 32e+ N(o; 4=, /o+)o 3 %+ , P(o!oco+o P()*e(o, To*o Oc!%5o, C"%(!o T()*e !(e &

% o 322


37/65

COSTADO DEREC O: Con *e&)&% &e &)ec)oc1o 4 M! ; , !e((eno ."e on /"e(on &e o(%c)o S%+% > COSTADO IZKUIERDO: En e !en )-n &e 5e)n!)c"%*e!(o con c)nc"en!% cen! *e!(o 3=, 2 M! , !e((eno ."e on o /"e(on &e+no* (%&o o(%c)o S%+% , 'o( e+ '(ec)o &e VEINTICINCO MIL BOL?VARES B

3 ;222,22 ."e +e /"e(on '%$%&o en &)ne(o e/ec!)5o, en e e *) *o %c!o; D)c1o)n*"e +e /"e(on %&.")()&o 'o( e+ 5en&e&o( e$9n &oc"*en!o '(o!oco+)#%&o%n!e e+ Re$) !(o P9 +)co &e+ M"n)c)')o An&(é Be++o &e+ E !%&o Mé()&%, e3 &e no5)e* (e &e 322< 0 43 &e *%(#o &e 4 4, con +o N(o ; 3 0 = , P(o!ocoP()*e(o, To*o Sé'!)*o 0 Se$"n&o, T()*e !(e C"%(!o 0 P()*e(o (e 'ec!)5%*en!e;En con ec"enc)%, e !e T() "n%+, con /"n&%*en!o en +o %(! c"+o 4;6


38/65

MOSTA8Á PAOLINI, e e !% +ec)-:\HEn e !e o(&en &e )&e% , 0% +% S%+% 1% e !% +ec)&o en %n!e()o(e /%++ No; 622 &e+ 3 &e *%0o &e 4 ."e +% e 'ec)%+)&%& &e+ &oc"*en!o %&*)+o con/)$"(% co*o "n% !e(ce(% c%!e$o( % &e '("e % )n !("*en!%+; En e/ec!o, e

e 'ec)%+ c+% e &e &oc"*en!o e c()!o no '"e&e % )*)+%( e %+ &oc"*en!o '9 +)&e/)n)&o en e+ %(! c"+o 4;6 < &e+ C-&)$o C)5)+, '"e no '%(!)c)'% &e+ c%( c!ene$oc)%+ ."e c%(%c!e()#% % e !e 9+!)*o; S)n e* %($o, " c%( c!e( %"!én!)co &e&e+ 1ec1o &e e( "n% &ec+%(%c)-n e*%n%&% &e "n /"nc)on%()o '9 +)co, con +/o(*%+)&%&e e )$)&% en e+ %(! c"+o 4 &e +% Le0 O($ n)c% &e P(oce&)*A&*)n) !(%!)5o ;A , con/o(*e %+ c()!e()o o !en)&o 'o( +% &oc!()n% n%c)on%+ *%0o()!%()%, cco)nc)&e e !% S%+%, e+ e 'e&)en!e %&*)n) !(%!)5o (ec!)" : &oc"*en!o %&*)n

e % e*e7% % +o &oc"*en!o '()5%&o (econoc)&o o !en)&o 'o( (econoc)&o

%(! c"+o 4;6 6 e)" &e* , 'e(o -+o en +o ."e conc)e(ne % " 5%+o( '(o %!o()o, ."e en %* o c% o , e !)ene 'o( c)e(!o " con!en)&o, en !%n!o ."e +% &ec+%(%e/ec!"%&% en &)c1o )n !("*en!o no e%n o 7e!o &e )*'"$n%c)-n % !(%5é &c"%+.")e( $éne(o &e '("e % c%'%# &e &e 5)(!"%( " 5e(%c)&%&; Sen!enc)% & No; 22 3 &e /ec1% 34 &e *%0o &e 3223 Ne$()++% &e +% &ec) )-nDe+ /%++o '%(c)%+*en!e !(%n c()!o, e &e '(en&e con *e()&)%n% c+%()&%& ."ce(!)/)c%&% &e+ e 'e&)en!e %&*)n) !(%!)5o (e*)!)&% 'o( e+ en!e '9 +)co ."eco((e 'on&%, con !)!"0en "n% !e(ce(% c%!e$o( % &e '("e % &oc"*en!%+, % )*)en +o ."e %!% e % " 5%+o( '(o %!o()o % +o )n !("*en!o '()5%&o (econoc)&

!en)&o +e$%+*en!e 'o( (econoc)&o , en +o !é(*)no con %$(%&o en e+ %(! c&e+ C-&)$o C)5)+, !o&% 5e# ."e 1%cen /e &e+ 1ec1o *%!e()%+ &e +% &ec+%(%e++o con!en)&% , 1% !% '("e % en con!(%()o; HA1o(% )en, !%+ 0 co*o e %&5)(!)e(%, c%&% )n !("*en!%+ )nco('o(%&% %+ e%&*)n) !(%!)5o !en&( e+ 5%+o( '(o %!o()o con/o(*e % +% n%!"(%+e#% &e+ &."e e !(%!e, 'e(o !%+ 0 co*o +o 1% e !% +ec)&o e !% S%+%, +o &oc"*en!o%&*)n) !(%!)5o e 5%+o(%( n )$"%+*en!e co*o "n )n !("*en!o '()5%&o (econoc!en)&o +e$%+*en!e 'o( (econoc)&o, % !eno( &e +o &) '"e !o en e+ %(! c"+o 4;6 6C-&)$o C)5)+; " (%0%&o &e+ T() "n%+ J"() '("&enc)% Vene#o+%n% R%*

G%(%0, T; CC LVI 3= C% o: Ec1o C1e*)c%+ 3222 C;A; ''; = 3 %+ =Sen!%&% +% %n!e()o( '(e*) % 7"() '("&enc)%+, +% c"%+ %co$e e !e J"#$%&o( con/o(*)&%& con e+ %(! c"+o 634 &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+, +o &oc '9 +)co %&*)n) !(%!)5o , e % )*)+%n % +o )n !("*en!o '()5%&o (econoc)!en)&o +e$%+*en!e 'o( (econoc)&o , 'o( +o !%n!o, no '"e&en e( '(o&"c)&o en !o!)e*'o 1% !% +o 9+!)*o )n/o(*e , e$9n '(ece'!9% e+ %(! c"+o =6 &e+ C-&)$oP(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+;


39/65

De o!(% '%(!e, en &)c1% con !%nc)% no e e %+% +o +)n&e(o 0 *e&)&% &."e +% O/)c)n% &e C%!% !(o M"n)c)'%+ &e+ M"n)c)')o An&(é Be++o &e+ E !%Mé()&%, e %+% co*o '(o')e&%& &e+ c)"&%&%no JOS JACINTO CANDALEPAC ECO, '"e e+ *) *o e +)*)!% % e %+%( " no*enc+%!"(% *"n)c)'%+, &e

."e, +% *) *% e% )n "/)c)en!e '%(% &e*o !(%( +% )&en!)&%& en!(e e+ )n*"e +(e)5)n&)c%c)-n e '(e!en&e 0 e+ )&en!)/)c%&o en e+ e+e*en!o '(o %!o()o %n%+)#5)(!"& ."e, no e %+% +o +)n&e(o '%(!)c"+%(e &e+ *) *o;En con ec"enc)%, e !e J"#$%&o( &e e !)*% e+ *e&)o &e '("e % %n%+)#%&o 'o

)&o '(o*o5)&o &e *%ne(% e !e*'o( ne% 'o( !%(& % 0 'o( e( )*'e(!)nen!e; AS? SDECIDE;@3 Con !%nc)% e*%n%&% 'o( e+ Con e7o Co*"n%+ &e+ ec!o( E+ E con&)&o;Con !% %+ /o+)o 6 &e+ '(e en!e e 'e&)en!e, o()$)n%+ &e con !%nc)% e 'e&)&24 &e no5)e* (e &e 322 , 'o( +o *)e* (o &e+ Con e7o Co*"n%+ &e+ ec!o( E+

E con&)&o, " )c%&o en L% A#"+)!% M"n)c)')o An&(é Be++o &e+ E !%&o Mé."e e 1%ce con !%( +o )$")en!e: \H K"e en e+ ec!o( E+ E con&)&o e enc"en!(c% % " )c%&% en +% c%++e '()nc)'%+ I )&o(o Bece((% N )c 4 44, 1%*) *% +o c)"&%&%no , )c E+e)n0# G")++én 0 E(ne !o R )c V%++5e MDe+ %n +) ) &e e !e )n !("*en!o, e '"e&e con !%!%( ."e e !(%!% &e "n &oc" '9 +)co %&*)n) !(%!)5o, e+ c"%+ e$9n e+ '(ece&en!e 7"() '("&enc)%+ "'(% !(%

e &e e % )*)+%( % +o )n !("*en!o '()5%&o (econoc)&o o !en)&o +e$%+*(econoc)&o , 'o( +o !%n!o, no '"e&en e( '(o&"c)&o en !o&o !)e*'o 1% !% +o 9+)n/o(*e , e$9n '(ece'!9% e+ %(! c"+o =6 &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+;

De o!(% '%(!e, en &)c1% con !%nc)% no e e %+% +o +)n&e(o 0 *e&)&% &."e &)c1o Con e7o Co*"n%+, e %+% ."e e 1% )!%&o 'o( +o c)"&%&%no EYZAMAR GUILL N PERN?A 0 ERNESTO RAMÓN VALLVE MORALES, '"ee+ *) *o e +)*)!% % e %+%( " no*enc+%!"(% *"n)c)'%+, +o c"%+ e )n "/)c)&e*o !(%( +% )&en!)&%& en!(e e+ )n*"e +e c"0% (e)5)n&)c%c)-n e '(e!en&e 0 e)&en!)/)c%&o en e+ e+e*en!o '(o %!o()o, en 5)(!"& ."e, no e %+% +o +)n&e(o '%(!)c"+%(e &e+ *) *o;En con ec"enc)%, e !e J"#$%&o( &e e !)*% e+ *e&)o &e '("e % %n%+)#%&o 'o

)&o '(o*o5)&o &e *%ne(% e !e*'o( ne% 'o( !%(& % 0 'o( )*'e(!)nen!e; AS? SE

DECIDE;@PRUEBAS DE LA PARTE DEMANDADA Y DE LA TERCEROINTERVINIENTE:Me&)%n!e e c()!o &e /ec1% 2 &e 7"+)o &e 322 /; =4 +% (e'(e en!%n!e 7"+% '%(!e &e*%n&%&% 0 &e +% !e(ce(o )n!e(5)n)en!e, '(o*o5)e(on +o *e&)o &e

)$")en!e :ÚNICO: Doc"*en!o %"!en!)c%&o %n!e +% No!%( % P9 +)c% &e E+ V)$ %, con


40/65

&e \H '(o %( ."e no e ) !e )&en!)&%& en!(e e+ )n*"e +e 'o e &o 'o( " _n"e !(*%n&%n!e 0 e+ )n*"e +e " )c%&o en +% 'o +%c)-n &e L% A#"+)!%, M"n)c)')o Be++o &e+ E !%&o Mé()&%,HDe+ %n +) ) &e +% %c!% ."e )n!e$(%n e+ '(e en!e e 'e&)en!e e '"e&e con

o (% )n e(!o % +o /o+)o 3 0 3 +% c"%+ con!en$% +% &"(%c*) *o J"() '("&enc)% Vene#o+%n% R%* (e# a G%(%0, T; CC IV 33= C% oM%*')e() en o+)c)!"& &e )n!e('(e!%c)-n, ''; 36= %+ 3==Sen!%&% +% %n!e()o( '(e*) % 7"() '("&enc)%+, 5)nc"+%n!e '%(% e !e T() "n%+con/o(*)&%& con e+ %(! c"+o 66 &e +% Con !)!"c)-n &e +% Re'9 +)c%, +% e+% "n)-n conc" )n%()% (e.")e(e &e "n% en!enc)% &e/)n)!)5%*en!e /)(*e ."e +%


41/65

(econo#c% o &e +% &ec+%(%c)-n con7"n!% &e +o conc" )no %n!e e+ Re$) !(%co((e 'on&)en!e;En con ec"enc)%, % 7")c)o &e .")en en!enc)%, %+ no 1% e( )&o &e*o !(%&o e '(e en!e 7")c)o, e+ conc" )n%!o en!(e e+ &e*%n&%&o 0 +% !e(ce(o )n!e(5)n)en!e,

&e 5%+o( '(o %!o()o e+ con!(%!o &e %((en&%*)en!o con/o(*e con e+ c"%+ e+ &e '(e!en&e &e*o !(%( +% 'o e )-n '(ec%()% &e "n )n*"e +e, con "n% )&en!)&%& &+% &e+ )en )n*"e +e ."e e '(e!en&e (e)5)n&)c%(; AS? SE DECIDE;@A )*) *o, .")en en!enc)% con )&e(% *ene !e( 1%ce( (e/e(enc)% % +% %c!"%c)-!e(ce(o c)"&%&%n% ELEINYS YZAMAR GUILL N PERN?A @@++%*%&% %+% '%(!e &e*%n&%&%, 'o( e( co*9n % e++% +% c%" %@@ .")en en " o'o(!"n)no &)o con!e !%c)-n n) % +% &e*%n&% '()nc)'%+ n) % +% c)!%, 0 e+ *e&)o '(o %%n%+)#%&o no %'o(!- n%&% % " /%5o(, &e %++ ."e, en %'+)c%c)-n &e +% noen e+ %(! c"+o 6 6 &e+ C-&)$o &e P(oce&)*)en!o C)5)+, &e % '(o&"c)( e e+ e/e

)n&)c%&o en e+ %(! c"+o 6 3 e)" &e*;A1o(% )en, % 7")c)o &e e !e 7"() &)cen!e, %+ no 1% e( ."e&%&o &e*o !(%&%e ) !enc)% &e +% "n)-n conc" )n%()% en!(e +% !e(ce(o con +% '%(!e &e*%n&%&con !%nc)% &e +% (e+%c)-n 7"( &)co *%!e()%+ ."e +o 5)nc"+%, e &ec)(, &)c1e +)!) con o(!e &e +% '%(!e &e*%n&%&%, 'o( +o !%n!o, no '"e&e '(o&"c)( n)n$9en e+ '(e en!e 7")c)o !%+ %c!)5)&%&; AS? SE ESTABLECE;@A +% co % , en +% '(e en!e c%" % e+ '(o +e*% 7"&)c)%+ e cen!(% en &e&e*%n&%n!e c)"&%&%no JOS JACINTO CANDALES PAC ECO, e '(o')e!%()o"n )en )n*"e +e \H " )c%&o en e+ ec!o( conoc)&o co*o \B%(()o Cen!en%()o , &

'o +%c)-n &e L% A#"+)!% M"n)c)')o An&(é Be++o &e+ E !%&o Mé()&%, c"0o0 *e&)&% on +o )$")en!e : 8RENTE: en e !en )-n &e &oce *e!(o 43 * , "c%*)no 5ec)n%+> 8ONDO: en )$"%+ *e&)&% ."e +% %n!e()o(, e &ec)( &oce *e!(* , !e((eno &e +% "ce )-n D"$%(!e> COSTADO DEREC O: Con *e&)&% &e&)ec)oc1o *e!(o 4 * , !e((eno ."e on o /"e(on &e o(%c)o S%+% > COSTADIZKUIERDO: En +% e !en )-n &e 5e)n!)c"%!(o *e!(o con c)nc"en!% cen! *e!(o

3=, 2 * , !e((eno ."e on o /"e(on &e+ no* (%&o o(%c)o S%+% H> 0 %&e*!%+ co*o +o %/)(*% en e+ +) e+o@@ e+ (e/e()&o )n*"e +e e !% )en&o oc"'%&)+e$ !)*%*en!e 0 )n " %"!o()#%c)-n 'o( e+ c)"&%&%no ERNESTO RAMÓN

VALLVE MORALES;So (e +% % e &e +% con )&e(%c)one %n!e()o(e , e !e J"#$%&o( &e e %n% 'o(*eno()#%&%*en!e +o '(e "'"e !o nece %()o '%(% &e!e(*)n%( +% '(oce&enc+% ++%*%&% %cc)-n (e)5)n&)c%!o()%, ."e e$9n +% &oc!()n% &e +% S%+% &&e+ T() "n%+ S"'(e*o &e J" !)c)%, en en!enc)% &e /ec1% 3< &e % ()+ &e 322= 'onenc)% &e+ M%$) !(%&o CARLOS OBERTO VELEZ, on +o )$")en!e :En con ec"enc)%, e+ &e*%n&%n!e e ! o +)$%&o % '(o %( 'o( +o *eno &o (e

Requisitos de La Accion Reivindicatoria TSJ

Documents

Transcript of Requisitos de La Accion Reivindicatoria TSJ