]Republic of the ~l)ilippineS' -...

3
]Republic of the ~l)ilippineS' ~upremc ({onrt <l»ffice of the QCourt ~bminigtrator iR!lllllila OCA CIRCULAR NO. 35-2013 TO THE COURT OF APPEALS, SANDIGANBAYAN, COURT OF TAX APPEALS, REGIONAL TRIAL COURTS, SHARI'A DISTRICT COURTS, METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURTS, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURTS IN CITIES, MUNICIPAL TRIAL COURTS, MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIAL COURTS, SHARI'A .CIRCUIT COURTS, THE OFFICE OF THE CHIEF STATE PROSECUTOR, PUBLIC ATTORNEY'S OFFICE AND THE INTEGRATED BAR OF THE PHILIPPINES SUBJECT COURT RESOLUTIONS DATED APRIL 13,2009 AND OCTOBER 22, 2012 For your information and guidance, quoted hereunder are pertinent portions of the Resolutions dated April 13, 2009 and October 22, 2012 of the Honorable Third and First Divisions, respectively in A. C. No. 7179 (Amalgamated Motors Phils., Inc. Represented by Felimon R. Cuevas vs. Atty. Jose Allan M. Tebelin), to wit: Court Resolution dated April 13, 2009 A.C. No. 7179 (Amalgamated Motors Phils., Inc., Represented by FeZimonR. Cuevas vs. Atty. JoseAllan M. Tebellin) - Acting on the complaint against respondent, the Court resolves to ADOPT AND APPROVE the Board Resolution No. XVIII-2008-482 of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines [IBPI Board of Governors. Accordingly, the Court further resolves to SUSPEND respondent from practice of law for one (1) year. The letter of the IBP transmitting the documents pertaining to this case with information that no motion for reconsideration was filed in this case is NOTED.

Transcript of ]Republic of the ~l)ilippineS' -...

Page 1: ]Republic of the ~l)ilippineS' - oca.judiciary.gov.phoca.judiciary.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/OCA-Circular-No... · ]Republic of the ~l)ilippineS' ~upremc ({onrt

]Republic of the ~l)ilippineS'~upremc ({onrt

<l»ffice of the QCourt ~bminigtratoriR!lllllila

OCA CIRCULAR NO. 35-2013

TO THE COURT OF APPEALS, SANDIGANBAYAN,COURT OF TAX APPEALS, REGIONAL TRIALCOURTS, SHARI'A DISTRICT COURTS,METROPOLITAN TRIAL COURTS, MUNICIPALTRIAL COURTS IN CITIES, MUNICIPAL TRIALCOURTS, MUNICIPAL CIRCUIT TRIALCOURTS, SHARI'A .CIRCUIT COURTS, THEOFFICE OF THE CHIEF STATE PROSECUTOR,PUBLIC ATTORNEY'S OFFICE AND THEINTEGRATED BAR OF THE PHILIPPINES

SUBJECT COURT RESOLUTIONS DATED APRIL 13,2009AND OCTOBER 22, 2012

For your information and guidance, quoted hereunder arepertinent portions of the Resolutions dated April 13, 2009 andOctober 22, 2012 of the Honorable Third and First Divisions,respectively in A. C. No. 7179 (Amalgamated Motors Phils., Inc.Represented by Felimon R. Cuevas vs. Atty. Jose Allan M. Tebelin),to wit:

Court Resolution dated April 13, 2009

A.C. No. 7179 (Amalgamated Motors Phils., Inc.,Represented by FeZimonR. Cuevas vs. Atty. JoseAllanM. Tebellin) - Acting on the complaint againstrespondent, the Court resolves to ADOPT AND APPROVEthe Board Resolution No. XVIII-2008-482 of the IntegratedBar of the Philippines [IBPI Board of Governors.Accordingly, the Court further resolves to SUSPENDrespondent from practice of law for one (1)year.

The letter of the IBP transmitting the documentspertaining to this case with information that no motion forreconsideration was filed in this case is NOTED.

Page 2: ]Republic of the ~l)ilippineS' - oca.judiciary.gov.phoca.judiciary.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/OCA-Circular-No... · ]Republic of the ~l)ilippineS' ~upremc ({onrt

"Court Resolution dated October 22, 2012

A.C. No. 7179 (Amalgamated Motors Phils., Inc.,represented by Felimon R. Cuevas, complainant, versus,Atty. Jose Allan M. Tebelin, respondent).

xxx :xxx xxx xxx

On April 13, 2009, the Court suspended respondentAtty. Jose Allan M. Tebelin from the practice of law for oneyear, to wit:

Acting on the complaint against therespondent, the Court resolves to ADOPT ANDAPPROVE the Board Resolution No. XVIII-2008-482 of the Integrated Bar of the Philippines(IBP) Board of Governors. Accordingly, the Courtfurther resolves to SUSPEND respondent frompractice of law for one (1)year. .

The records show, however, that the copy of the April13, 2009 Resolution served by registered mail uponrespondent Atty. Tebelin was returned to this Courtunserved with notation "RTS moved." A copy also of theCourt's subsequent Resolution dated June 15, 2009 sent toAtty. Tebelin was likewise returned to this Court unservedwith notation "RTS moved."

On June 22, 2010, the Court received a letter fromAttys. Arlene G. Lapuz-Ureta, Elsie S. Ramos and ElvinMichael L. Cruz of Lapuz-Ureta Ramos Arches Cruz andManlagnit reporting the unauthorized practice of law of oneAtty. Jose Allan M. Tebelin. Attys. Lapuz-Ureta, Ramos andCruz said that Atty. Tebelin filed pleadings before theRegional Trial Court of Pasay City, Branch 108, on August11, 2009, November 3, 2009, May 4, 2010 and May 13,2010. They submitted copies of the pleadings filed by Atty.Tebelin which also show his new addresses. They also saidthat Atty. Tebelin attended a hearing on May 28, 2010.

We find the vigilance of Attys. Lapuz-Ureta, Ramosand Cruz in reporting the violation seemingly committed byAtty. Tebelin. We are unable however to condemn Atty.Tebelin for his continued practice of law. The records showthat he did not receive the Court's resolution suspendinghim from the practice of law. The returned Resolution datedApril 13, 2009 should have been reported to the Court forappropriate action. But the records do not bear a resolutionon said returned resolution. Thus, all that the Court canfairly do is to serve anew upon Atty. Tebelin, at his newaddresses on record, the Resolution dated April 13, 2009and to dismiss the reported violation by Atty. Tebelin of theCourt's order suspending him from the practice of law.

Page 3: ]Republic of the ~l)ilippineS' - oca.judiciary.gov.phoca.judiciary.gov.ph/wp-content/uploads/2014/05/OCA-Circular-No... · ]Republic of the ~l)ilippineS' ~upremc ({onrt

WHEREFORE, the Court DISMISSES the report ofunauthorized practice of law by respondent Atty. Jose AllanM. Tebelin, filed by Attys. Arlene G. Lapuz-Ureta, Elsie S.Ramos and Elvin Michael L. Cruz.

The Court further ORDERS that the Resolution datedApril 13, 2009 be served personally upon respondent Atty.Jose Allan M. Tebelin at his new addresses on record.

SO ORDERED.

The Resolutions dated April 13, 2009 and October 22, 2012 werepersonally served on the respondent, thru his authorized agent AraJane P. Juanillo, at his new address at TEBELIN MENDEZ LAWOFFICE, 2nd Floor, Margaphil Technical Institute Unit J, Violeta Court,2814 F.B. Harrison St., Pasay City 1300 on 31 January 2013.

March _6_,2013

~~~

J~AS P. MARQUEZ~o~:~ Administrator

~~.MBC/ \ s/rrc/02-18-IJ/cresolutions-AC7179.doc