Report of the Operating Committee Don Watkins Operating Committee Chair April 28, 2009.

Report of the Operating Committee

Don Watkins

Operating Committee Chair

April 28, 2009

2

Today

● 2008 Goals Status

● 2009 Goals

● Charter (consent agenda)

● Dissolution of the RCS

● Approve Griffith Energy Report

● Approve OTS Training Policy

● Approve WECC Procedures for Regional Blackstart Capability Plan Standards

2

3

Today (cont.)

● RAS Classification (failed)

● Due Process Items

● Standards Implementation

● Area Control Error Diversity Interchange (ADI)

● Status on various efforts (include RBC and ADI)

● FRR

4

2008 Goals Status

1. Develop [and implement] a Business Plan for reviewing, rewriting, or deleting OC documentation. Groups are now determining the needed changes to

each document: reformatting only to submitting standards or criteria requests to replace existing documents.

This list will then be prioritized and work assigned commensurately.

Our goal is to have this project completed by the Spring of 2010. On Schedule.

5

2008 Goals Status

● 2. Create and implement a work plan for creating a Frequency Responsive Reserves (FRR) Based Contingency Reserve Standard. Drafting Team made this a Criteria, not

Standard Up for OC Ballot in June – Goal met to date See below

6

2008 Goals Status3. Ensure Balancing Authorities (BA),

Generator Owners (GO) and Transmission Operators (TOP) supply both operational and planning data for the West-wide System Model and for other reliability purposes. This year’s focus on data related to RC needs

has been proficiently accomplished by the WECC RC Staff.

Provided for dialogue in the last 2 OC meetings. Data being supplied. Issues remain.

7

2008 Goals Status

4. Determine the impacts of renewable resource integration and operation on the Western Interconnection. Low requirement for OC engagement Have some education on various initiatives

and activities to address some issues.

8

2009 Operating Committee GoalsEach goal will be assigned a project manager, a work

plan that includes coordination with other committees, and identification of the client.

1. Complete the Document Conversion Project.Aiming for completion by April 2010

2. Develop a Strategy for WSM applications (UFAS, Planning, operations, etc.) and begin implementation.

Enabling local TOP use of data & Topology

Explore exporting to planning and operations bases

Other applications

9

2009 Operating Committee Goals

3. Develop a plan, with PCC, for Synchro-Phasor infrastructure and tools for situational awareness and operations analysis.

Planning joint OC/PCC team

Scope includes situational awareness, disturbance analysis, model validation, special controls.

Infrastructure to support applications

10


4. Support efforts from VGS in developing analysis, tools, and methodologies to include the integration and operation of variable generation in the West

Encourage education and support of tools such as ACE Diversity Interchange, Reliability Based Control, Dynamic schedules, etc.).

11


5.Initiate a joint review with the PCC and update of the WECC Off-Nominal Frequency Load Shedding and Restoration Plan, addressing load variations. Joint OC/PCC Team is being formed to

accomplish study work by fall 2009

12

Dissolution of RCS

● WECC has assumed all management responsibility for the Reliability Coordinators (RC)

● Discontinuation of RC data to the RCS

● OC voted to approve dissolution of this sub-committee effective upon vote.

13

Certification of the Griffith Energy Balancing Authority

● The certification process was completed in accordance with the aforementioned rules for determining if the applicant has the necessary tools, processes, and procedures to perform the functions of a NERC certified BA.

● The BA certification team recommends to WECC that they approve certification of Griffith as a NERC certified BA.

14

Certification of the Griffith Energy Balancing Authority

Entertain a motion to Approve the certification of the Griffith Energy

Balancing Authority

15

Approve the Operation Training Subcommittee Training Policy

● Policies and practices regarding the WECC Operations Training Program

● Passed OC: 32 for, 0 against, 3 abstain

Entertain a motion to Approve the Operation Training Subcommittee

Training Policy

16

WECC Blackstart Capability Plan

● A Regional Blackstart Capability Plan (BCP) is required by NERC Standard EOP-007-0, Requirement 1 and is necessary to ensure that the quantity and locations of system blackstart generators are sufficient and that they can perform their expected functions as specified in overall coordinated Regional System Restoration Plans.

17


● EOP-009-0 then requires the GO and GOPs follow the Blackstart Capability plan.

● Email Ballot: 19 for, 3 against, 1 abstain

● Reasons for “no”: See no value in maintaining a central database but the entity understands that WECC has to maintain a database based on a NERC standard and may not have a choice in this issue. +…..

18


Entertain a motion to Approve the WECC Blackstart Capability Plan

19

Remedial Action Scheme (RAS) Classification guideline

● The Protection Systems are classified under three categories: RASs, Safety Nets and Local Area Protection Schemes. The guideline lists the definition for each category and the NERC standards that are applicable to each category.

● TP: 17, 9, 2● TC: 5, 5, 8● State & Provincial: 1,0,0● Failed● Concern as to consistency with standards.

20

Items in Due Process

1. VAR-001-WECC-1 Voltage and Reactive Control

2. WON Security Policy 3. Modification of the WECC Unscheduled Flow

Mitigation Plan 4. After-the-Fact Tagging Guidelines 5. Frequency Responsive Reserve 6. Blackstart Unit Testing Business Practice 7. WIAB Criterion (WIT/TAS Backup)8. Bulk Electric System Definition 9. More coming….. In-hour, etc.

21

Standards Implementation

● ATEC

● Tier 1 revised (7)

22

Standards - Automatic Time Error (ATEC) Correction

● OPS has completed workshops, surveys, and preparation for implementation

● Requirements for BA’s: Assure consistent application in all BA’s and to provide for starting with zero on peak and off peak accrued inadvertent.

● Awaiting FERC approval.

23

Standards – Unscheduled Flow (UF)

● Looking at: dues calculation, utilization of accommodation versus relief requirements, non-tagged use of transmission, a desire to move toward a more accurate Transmission Distribution Factor, how to address network flows in the USF mitigation process.

● The new criteria will use transmission priority to determine relief requirement.

24

VAR-001-WECC-1 Voltage and Reactive Control

● The Control Work Group (the drafting team) is addressing the issue of required AVR action and voltage schedules vs. VAR schedules.

● Issuing a survey to better understand the issue and potential solutions.

25

Bulk Electric System

● RPIC wanted to use due process

● Assigned to OC by SRRC

● OC will vote

● Stakeholder advisory vote

● Then, if passed, to board. (….or?)

26

ADI

● The study team will present their findings to the Operating Practices Subcommittee the week of May 13th.

● Ensuing findings and recommendations will be provided to the OC.

● Looking for potential risks and mitigation.

27

Reliability Based Control

● The Performance Work Group is developing a Field Trial.

● Preliminarily considering a 1 year trial requiring all large BA’s (over 500 MW peak)

● Monitor and alarm to the standard. Would likely wave CPS2 but still employ something similar for protection.

28

Frequency Responsive Reserves (FRR)

● After the 3rd round of comments, the drafting team voted to forward the FRR Criterion to the OC.

● Final tally: Yes=8; No=3

● Will be up for ballot in June OC

● Possible board ballot in July

29

What’s in it?

● Modeled the data ● Showed two basic

responses Primary Response

(AKA: Point C) Zero to 30

seconds Secondary

Response (AKA: Point B) 31 seconds to 15

minutes

Frequency Response

A = 60.000

C = 59.812

B = 59.874

59.750

59.775

59.800

59.825

59.850

59.875

59.900

59.925

59.950

59.975

60.000

60.025

60.050

-30 -20 -10 0 10 20 30 40 50 60

Time (Seconds)

Frequency (Hz)

30

A recent event for example

59.851

59.884

59.918

59.951

59.985

60.018

04:08:00.00 04:08:30.00 04:09:00.00 04:09:30.00 04:10:00.00 04:10:30.00 04:11:00.00

Pacific Time

VINC

MOGS

DEVR

BGCR

ALAM

KRMR

DEV2

ANTP

VLLY

MAGN

ELDO

LUGO

CNTL

MRLM

SRNO

RCT1

RCT2

SPVL

VEST

BPA1

04/19/09 Event at 04:06 Pacific Time (04/19/09 at 11:06 GMT )

1000 MW loss

31

Two periods of response

● Primary: governor - “Shall average greater than or equal to 100% during the Primary Frequency Response Measurement Period.”

● Secondary: frequency bias - a response average greater than or equal to 50% and less than or equal to 200%.

32

Why FRR?

● We have reserve requirements but not a specific response requirement.

● The system and its abilities to respond are changing. (e.g. wind)

-----------------

OC FRR Q&A Conference call

June 5, 10am-1pm Pacific time

33

Questions?

Report of the Operating Committee Don Watkins Operating Committee Chair April 28, 2009.

Documents

Transcript of Report of the Operating Committee Don Watkins Operating Committee Chair April 28, 2009.