RECALCI!JLATION OF STATE TOXIC CRITERIA...U.S. Environmental Protection Agency OfRCE OF WATEK...
Transcript of RECALCI!JLATION OF STATE TOXIC CRITERIA...U.S. Environmental Protection Agency OfRCE OF WATEK...
U.S. Environmental Protection Agency OfRCE OF WATEK REGULATlCN& AND STANDAJIDS
WIJNGTON DC lDMO
RECALCI!JLATION OF STATE
TOXIC CRITERIA
Octo&er 198l
CAMP DRESSER • .MdCEE, INC ANNANDAU, VA UDQ)
Tho ITI.Itonolln 11111 ntpoti'!'U ~ undof the dtrecllon olthe Ct1- """8"""'"'* Dlv~ olon. Office ol Wotor, ol the u.s. Envt""'"""tot Pl'otoctlon Agenoy. Tho outi!Oit wtoh to Ilion!< t/11 pro-lonol otoll of the Cflll<!o """ Sto"'*"• Dt...,...,.,_,n J)llllcul• l'lttrlc* T-. Actlog Otvle olon DtiiCtor. Aton fl\ll>N ftonk Goo-oil~ _, M!c/IMI Ru!IQ!e<o-IO< tho •-otlono ...., -~~~--theY ..... oH-w!>ICII O(W ntli<lettd t~""'''llout. Wo _,kl '*' IIIII to ocl(-1-t/11 lnt- t """ _,.,..,.. ot - _,,. It the EPA Envttonmo<!tol - UbonltOIY, Duluth-IIOI'bo" J.-1, Dlntelot; _,.. RUllO, Oe!>u!l' Olroc10<; OIIO<Ioo SIOj)hon; Ron Cortoon: ond Stephen L4uno-ln on...,.rlog '"" qUIItlono on till ol.._lllc ptO!ocol ond """td oon>p<llor pr~am Which-. -•OIItd ot tho !AbofotQ<Y.
TABLE OF CONTENTS
"'"" ACKNOW~EDGEMENTS ••••.• . ••.••••• , ....................... ............ . , . , ..... Ill SUMMARY ....... .... . ... . ............ . ........................................... •II
SECnON 1. INTAOOUCllON .. . ...... . . , ... , ...... , .............. , . • , ..... , ... , ..... 1·1 1.1 BACKGROUND .................................. , .................. 1·1 U OAOANIZA TION • .. .. .. .. .. • .. .. • .. .. • .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. .. .. I· 1
SECTION 2. Af'PAOACH .............. . ............. . . ..... ...... .... ......... , , •••. 2·1 2.1 THETWO-NUMBEACFIITEAlON ....................................... 2.1 2.2 AECA~CU~TIOHOFSITE.SPECIFICCAITERI.A ......................... 2·2 2.3 SPECIES DISTAIBunON ............................ , .. .. • .. .. .. .. .. • 2-4 2.1 CA~CU~OONOFMAXIMUMVAWECAITERIABYSTATE •... , ..... ...... 2-8 2.5 CALCU~TIONOFTHESTATE»D.t.YAVEAAOECAITERION ., ...... , .. ,, 2.12 2.8 SAMPlE CALCU~TION ..................... , .. ,. . .. , ..... , ....... , 2>13
SECTION 3. RESU~TS ............................... . ........... . ...... ....... ..... ~1 3.1 SPECIES DISTRIBUTION BY STATE .. . • .. . .. • .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. .. • .. .. . ~ 1 32 IST ... TEWATtfiOUALITYCAITEAIA ........... ., ............. ., ......... 3-2
SECTION I . DISCUSSION ......................................... ., ..... ., . .. .. .. .. 4'1
REFERENCES ... , ............... ....... , ••• ,. ..... , .... .. .. ......... , ...... , • • • • • • fl.1
APPENDICES
A. RMidlntNonhAmertcanSpecltaof Aq\lallcAnlm.JaUMd ln T~lciryTtata ............ A-1 Jll.l. Stolt IDNum'*' ..... .. .. . ..... . .. ......... ................. . ................. 11-1 11-2. FamllyiDNum'*' .................... ........................................ 11-1 8-3. SpeolooiDNumt>oroondFamllyCluolllcalton ..................................... &2 8-4. -~~aa.bylltato . .. . ................................ ...... . . .......... 8-3 B-6. ~IMDioltlbullonlnlheUnltiiCISIIIII ....... . ..................... . . . .. ... ..... N M . Mlntmt.Hn 0.1.1 Rtqul,..,.nlt, ••••• , ••• , •.••••.•••••• , •••••• , •.• , •.• • • • , . . • . • • • • • a.o c. TO)Iiclty Doll lor f-t>wator AGUOli<> U!o C.lto~a. byC~>tmlcal .... . , ............. .. . . C.1 O. TollJclf10eta t<MFtnhwal.rAquatlc UftCtlttrta. bySl.a1t ••••.• , •• ~· . • •~ •.••.••. ·H. ~1 E. Aecaicula!Uon Aetul·ta •• ~ •.••.••. •.•• .••••• ••• ••.••••••••.•. •• ~ .. .. .... , • • .. • • • • • • £-1
LIST OF FIOUIIES
Ftouro
1.1 l'lolocolo PYopoud by EPA lot Slt..spoclflo Crtllril lolodll~lton ............. , . .. . . . • 1-2 :1.1 otllftbutton ot ~'"""""In the untied StaiN ................................. w·
LIST Of' TABLES
2.1 NA(tonai»DD}'A-Ctl..na . ...................... . .......... . ..... . ..... .. . 2-3 2.2 Uat of SpedM _..,.. fn tM Acut• ToJIIclty Oeta a... . . . . . . .. ..... . . , . .. , . 2--6 2.3 u.t ol-o-~o< --.tltylog ,,. ~~ Dtttrfbullon
ollhetnwortiOnlll~leo .................................... . ............... 2-4 U NattonaiAouii TolllcltyDIIa IMOI'IIonloM ..... , ..................... . .... . ....... 2•14 2.5 ~~oe--.t~U.IIor-ftly!Vollla ........................................... 2•11 U -lloylvanla-t~IMTOI<IcloyDatotorC~Iord.,. ...................... .. . . 2•15 2.7 Ponnoyl'tonla FomllyAouiiTo•lcii\'Tab4elo<Ctllordano ............................. 2·15 U Nottonal Aovte Toxicity Datolo< Nl- ................. .............. . ........... 2-18 2.1 ~Myi¥anlaAel4dent~Toxk::ltyOilt.,OfNic .. l ... ........... ................. ""18 2.10 -noylwonla_,_lyToll/cttyDelalo<N- .. . ... , ..................... . . 2>11 2.11 NtttonaiCiuO!>IcTOIIIcii\'Dolalor N!cl!al ............................ , ............ 20:1 3.1 141nlnwmDatofloQIII........,,._...,..Nota.lelb\'ll>eNaiiOnoiToxlcliyOola-••.•. 3-1 3.2 VII-ot • onch In ,,. Maximum Value Crtllril Equallon,by &lilt . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . .. . . . 3-8 ._1 ~tono1Nattonalond8t.,.Mui""'"'VIMuoCrt..na ........... ............... 4'2 1.2 ~tonoiNatlonalond8taii»DayA-CfitMta ... ........................ 4'3
SUMMARY
In"" oHon to -lot IM atatHinlldAI>IInq IM Natlonol wotor q•ollty ortt111o lo looat CO<!dltlona. EPA haa ~ a Mrlu ol pn>tocolt lor oonoldoratton. One ol tM PfOio«>ll, ,. • ..,-.~ to .. lhe State Aoold«>l Sjloc:loo Recal<lllallon, modllloo IM National wot« q•aJity cntlflo to ,.,loct lhe olllh -•111*='-compooillon. WltlltM pn>tocol, - · waiO!'q<~"'lly crttlflamoy 1>0 calcul&loclwiiN>ut IM ,_ IOf oddt~onal to•lclty tooting.
Tho otato -• Sjloc:loo floeolc\l!otlol\ Protoool lolmp-ocl;, tllto -'· Tho-'~ el-1 o..wy of tho pulollol'lod lltotatu .. on IM-rlj)Neol ~fitrlbutlonaln tho U..tod SWftol lei fl'lllh•al« fPeCIM fn tt'M fletfo!W data bl.l« aocla ~letlon of atate ••ttr quali fY Clil-'• tor 21 tollo chomlc:alo wllOM nlllOflOI wolol qU.Uity crl\erla na .. bMn PllOIIItood 1>)1 EPk
Oi\1)' ftwe penlent ot th6 21 ~· 1\l'fe mett.ne mlntmtlm data requ~a on tM natiOnal ltwef, The Mate cM.t.J. beN It IJMd to teoatcU1&1t t,. m-.h,,um wauw QUAJCty cri1wta wtt1 when al'l of the dalt req.ulrtm.ntt .,. not a.au•Htd. ~Y·"\Ie '*'*''of Inn. have atatt criteria W'hlch Itt more atrlnoent t~n the na11ona1 c:rit*"•· TM recaAcuttled lnat.-nt.tneout muknum or1t.na f'law been ~ lllnocl by ••tr-lltton lor oil ..... but two (0001* crttortiiOf Moine ono Now YortQ. Tho voJidltyot IM IIIII water -'lty c:rltortl ll tor;oly ~on IM COII'OCI -nt.tlon ol IM Hnllllvlty ol the ttltt ret6dent P1$Uiat~ by the , .. toenl -r>ICIH da•• baM. Wlthm ttw~ ''~or thl cu~t guldotl- one! IM re-t opectoo -utltlon methocl, the rftUitl o( thto tludy moY 1lwoyo 1>0 mocllltocl with oddtti<><lal t .. lclty dote.
1.1 U CKCIIIOUND
IE.CTlOHt INTRODUCTION
;, the F-allleglot"' of 28 Novotnbof 11180, the &ovlronmentll P!otoctlon AotMy (EP"l onnouncocl tM OWIIIIII>IIhy ot erltlfll doc""'onto lorN o l tM e6 polhltontl dlatgnat~ u to•lo under Section 3011 f~) It) ot the CIMn Wiler Act. WIIOf qu1Hty C<ltorto IOf 2S of thOOI e6 dHlgnot~ pollutonto WotOilrltPIJOIIIIIocl ln "ou.lityCrtt-lorWotor'' (l.I.S. EPA.J\I!y, lm).tho"Roc!Sooto.";, o oontlnulflllollon, EPA"-'-onc1 uporldld theorlgtMI "'ltorQuollty crliOfl• tor IM.dHioMt.O IOl<IC poiiUIOillO (A3FR21508, 18loloy 1m 031'R1110211. 5 July 1m .. FRI- 15 - 187Vl, .-no to tile 1vaiOOI>Illty of the ctltorto docll"'""to .,..,uf'()Od tn 1eea,
Num«<.cal notlonll wotor'Qillllty crttort1 ,. .. _, dotl-by EPA lor 21 oftM e6 • ...,.,., ... , ... COIGinq to guidoU- 11110 P"bl- In IM Flldl.-l lleglltOf ol28 -otnbof 11110 (46FRI931ej. Thou n1tlonal cr!tono .,..- upon otondonl IO>Iclty 10110 potlorm-.! In tho labo<lto<y with a vwiO\Y of • quatlc apec ... whoM oomblnltlon IM6tlthe minimum deta rtquhem~nt (to be dl.cuNtd In Slc11on 2.1 .1~
A oiii>OoqllOill mocl"lcatlon to the glil<lollnet J111b!1- In thO F-.JIIeglot., !ncl""": ""ot family ratllot than -too M tM bk>4oglcalun" upon w!Och tho flnll Acuto Value (fAV) n the ANI CttiCI>ic Votuo (FCV) oro -: a c1>anoe In IM 1!\;,tmum data rwqulrwrnonr. end • chii1VO In tho mothocl of _...,. anoJYI10 uoocl lor colculotlng tho fAV n rov.111o _....lng ~-of till• rooort • .,.,the """"""lcol.oro-on rhll-moti!OdoloOY.
Jn 'liCOOfllttOfl ot tN feet thai JocaJ en¥1f'Ortmtn\AJ ~tb1a ma.J affect the \OIUC!ty ot a polltt-1..,1, EP4 lntondo to gl\4 IIO<IbllttY 10 tile 011101 In 11>0 .Wico\lon or the Jl1lbllonocl notlonoJ wotot QUI.I~ty ct!lttnl ~ glvtng 1"em me opuon o• moolf'Y'ng tne ethena tnrouon • .. t.-.pecUio ana•)"'ia, '" ,,. cant•._, of thta r.pon, tn. t«m " lll...,.c:Jtlc•' will be "'M<f tynonymoualy With the term ~<at.at• IIM(llflt.11
tn en effort to ... lit the atatM '" Mapttno the n1tton11 crlletfa to toeaJ ~1Uon1. EPA hu ~ 1 M(loo of P<Oioeolo(Fig- 1.1)~ ihelol>cntory- wotwquolltycrttorll moy bo modttlod by talolnq loeal vo~otlon In opoctoo compooltlon one! wllhr chomlotry Into ICCO<Mt. Tho llfal PfOiocol. Which to dHignocl to lako r- - loo ....,.,.."lon lnlo occounl, to the oul>loct ol thto ropon. Thto orotocot wll1.......,f0<1h 1>0 rof-lo utho roeoleullllon ..--.Tho ,.,.,llOO.ol thto fop0<1 lo-on: • 1 o..wy of tho llt•a lure on 1/>0 - · roonlcol ~lot~butloo In "'" tlnllod StitH ot Nloctroo "-"'"'"'
tllh trl<flnv.n-... """ • a rec4Je1JiaUon, bMect on l.N ~~QU~.tlc &pt<:lH tMIO«\t In 1 g'lven atate, ot tfta ll:ate werer qualitY
crftel1a fat the 21 Cl'lolmk:ala Whole t\lllonal wa1er qu-'lty Cffterla hew bMn publllhed.
U OIIGANIZAtlOI.I
Tho --.gy uood In thto -'I• outUnocl In 5octlon II. Tho rMUito .,.. pr.Mnlocl In Sooctton ~ ono In the ~-. A diOCUHton o f lhe rooulto will bo found In soetron 4.
RUIDe/IT SP8ClES t:Ffi/CTS R£CAI.CtJlATE CRITERIA USI"G R£SIO£HT SPECIES QUA F'ROI4 liTERATURE
MnOIIM. S/Tt IIAT!iR QIQIIS'tRY Ul'~ TEST INDICATOR SPECIES IN 'CU"'"' lAIIOAATORY WATU QUAl. lTV AAO IN SITE WATER; CRITERIA tc:IOIFY MT!OHAI. CRITERIA
RZS~ SFtCilS ~10 sm ~AnN CII1XIS'1RI t:rnas TEST RESIOE!IT SPECIES
IW Silt WATER; CAl. ClUTE lEI/ CRITERIA
,...l,t _,._.,OAiw_.,...... __
"
SITE-SPECIFIC WATER QUAL lTV
CRITERIA
t.t n.ll TWO-fiUM•fll C-
TIIo natloNJ c~t41f1o lof tho ~><otoctk>n o1 ,_, ,., oqt10tlc fifo - fly bOth m .. lmtHn ...,
:10<1oy --·•••- ~"" '-"'"""" <<1141f1on~ TM cumutotlvo '"""'""' oloxoutllont - lllo -"'"" :10<1oy -- .., .. to llmlloel to eo hOu!O In onr 30 oon-utlvo doyo. Tllto •-·-· th- '"""' ' 0! """*""'' ••tlf qualify e~to~o 11 lnt- 10 e><ovtdo - · •• protection for oquotlc Ill• ..., 110 .,_ !Of bOth long.lonn. nao<ty eonotonl, oonlfnuout .,_. olluat-• ..., oltllttlor>tol nuetuollngcoocont .. llololnellldlng lntormlltonl-Tho ........ ,_ ........ -- uolnglllo """* -thodologleo (GIIIdoiiMO) dltcUtoOd In Soc:llon I,
2.t.t TM MoknumVoluoCtttlfk>n
Tho mu.l""'"' YOM cr1llflon (aloo ,......., to oo 1/lo Fl/101 Cllror1lc Vokro, RN) 1e --0y dttldlng tllo FiJIOIAcull V-IFAV) Oy tllo- ol (01 Z. «(til tho oc--Tho FAY to dollneclootllo.--•fq-11!-ottllo-!IO.._...,f.,.,IJ!eolnlllonoiiOfloldoto biM hom «N&e loxtclty.
Tllo""""IOltleiiJdatoutOdloflhlcoletllo-oltno '"v .-__, .. _,...,....,._, famllloo 1410111hot ollollhl -"'0.,. ,_
1. thOIM<IySolmofttdootnlhlc-~ z. ..,. -IPOrfonb!y worm woiOr) family In tho •-Oolotdlth\'00, 1. ..,. othlf '""''Y tn tllo Ph!'hlm l>ordoto (o.o. nih. ampNbton. otcJ. ... ...----10·9- - .... .....-....... 5. • - --(0.9- ... .-. !oopocl. .....,, - -· <toyfloh. otc.l. e. anlnooet(o.o. meyfly.dr-Ry, ~ • .-l!y, .-.y, -·· rNdgo.OICJ, 7. o lomlfylno,.,......_INn_orQioraoto~g.llotJ,.,._AN>oiiOo.-._otc.l.
and a. ·-tr..,...,...,.,.,,_,.,onrllftl'lum_...__
2. u Tho »>ey ~~- Qltotlon
Tho 30<111J - -.. 1o-oo 111o- o1 thO ,.,-..., ,...., Cllror1lc v- (FCII). Flnol "'""'' VoluotFI'IIl. -Final ~Y-(l'f!'h Tho 'FCV,.., 1>0-0y "'Y ot thofong:
t. ----WO!f-tllll-ottllonotlc••••_.,..._--.-,..ICIIy. ....,tiiOnotlonol-tc~--..--Oylllo._loOintiiOno
-• .. tc"rdolo- Of,
...
2. tile.- e>OUinod from dMdlng 1/le FAV b\' 1/le l®t..,lwonlc ratio; 01, -3, tM e.pec~1 mHn ch,.,tc value at .n frnportant •peclu1 tudl N 1 com"*cJalfy Of I"KtM•
lloNolly lmpottont .,.. .... The KUt~kl ratto t. the fWPtMtn'tattw valu. whtch ct\lriCI.,.,.. the Kut• .enallhflty of a
--_, ... 10 "' dwunlo fOllolly. n. Ffl'./ 11 defined u the lowwet v.lue lt'l • el'!tonlc tNt with an eque.tto. vucultt plant or ff'\ a.
- Of ""- leol with on •too. Tho FRY 11 oatcufated by d"'ldlng a maximum pomllaolbto tloouo ..,....,l(o!IOn by an--'"'" -tratlon loct01.
Tho notional -y- ctltl<la and tho ~lng FCV, Ff"V and FRY 110 filled In TObie 2. 1. Th.-lo no 3Q.<Ioy ....... et1twton IO< Aldlln.-tc 0< 81- . Acu-ronlo ndlot.,. -'lal>lo lor 15-., t!luopennlltingcolculotionol lho FCV from tho FAV. Tho FAVolor~ond ~ -.oleo ..tcutotod hom cMJnlc tO<IcflydolA uotng tho nMood ~- ,..,,....,tho ... ,. tOJllclly o! Zinc lo - .,.,..._,~ chnli11c Zinc IO)Uctty to _,...Y unot!octOd by -,.,_..fcxe, lttttMd or Mttll'IQ ~~ ~Cfti~OIMCI on the FAV and lM ac~~ f:MIQ, a vatue ot '7 moll wu ChOMn beciUM ~ f"'C)f'MMnt• lN cttror!'le ~.._ ol bOtl\ a MtllltiW ln...,ebrata (Ooplln/o 1111/fl~ In nlld wow and a moda<ataty aanall,.. filii (Ffoclflah) In aoH waror. Tho FCVo In T-2.1 -.ool®llloct uaiiiQ tho r!Maoct -hodology,thiiOicn, llley do nol-lly fiG'" wflh t""" pul>llahodln tho F-.. Aoglol« ol 28 -bor 111110.
U MCAI.C:UUI11011 Of ~CIWTQA
~N to 1M rKA'CUI,atJOf' proolduta, al1.-.peoettk:" t~•••' aqualk: 1111 c·rtllrla ft\AY be mocllflacl ,..,_, ony _,lanai ~Itt raatlng. Tho moclllk:allOII ,....,... ... moy bl ouUinoct u t~towa.:.
1. ao1oot 1110 approonolo -• _ ... toxlclly data hom ifHI notional da,. - · '2. caleulat• tt. FAV U ... ftl !"'- alt ... p.efHe data baM 11M t~• ~Nd ftWihOdofooy, 3. dlllna tho oiiH~IIo maximum cr11orfo by dtYidffiO tho FAV by tt•• tow« ot Co) 2. Of (l>llho
IICUtKf'lf'Oftle tatJo. 4. calcultta thl FCV by-"' boUI oltho 1114~ 01-
(0l calcu!ata tho FCV by ciMdlng lho --Od FAV by the lll:utKn""'fc ,.flo, or lbl II tho Ml- I'CV II..._.. ltom -lo 10Jo1Cil1 dll_a. calcUI&to 1111 FCV """'0 1111 r~ ._.., cnronJc 1oatclty daaa, and
5. dlllna 1111 3Q.<Ioy -• •- by -11"9 tho mlnlm\.0!1 ol tho FRY, F~. and 1111 reoaiCU'-ted FOVe.
It t.IMt't .,.. not MOUOh r•k:Jent ~tu In the natiOn .. lotk:tty Olta beN to mMt thre minimum dlto ..caol-~ -ltlonof tMICionl-ilo blotaoaya In labcntort water moy ba -In ordor ro ~ thlo ...,....,..... Tho Slaleo .,_ claolcla on tho dolo __ ._~ lor MC/1 lltu• lion.
Tho two-nombor n otional cmorra • - boon dlwtopoct by EPII !Of 11 Chlmk:alo. Tho dl<t•atl<><l of
•n-IHc.-tHcl""'-""--"-''"--''"'~"-· ,_,. uon. ttt••c-cmo ~urn cttt.M""'-... oatcld.a.J few thtM o1W ~·tor WhiCh onl\1 n• ttoMJ muJmum c"'ert• .,. av•IIDie.
T-1.1 Nrioolai»Oay .-_-
f.lf'l• t CNont.c Valut1
~ TD!;t t'Jl!!2 Wll ~
....... ..._ .. c..rmr.., ~t.Q!(InH)·~
122 ~ 3 ...... 14,0 av-lum t•.wm.o Coooo< ..,._.nH)-O.!!J
s.n u O/Onl .. ...-~u
DOT Dlolclrtn _,__. Encll*llt.tn 0.41~ l'Noln o-u "-"" ,_ ~·=!!!:!! - >.&) .... ""'~nH)-10.'1
Undii!M ~ -.:UO'j .. -.. Nlcl;ol ••!!l!!·~!il ·•·'!l , ... l'C11'~
-~- 116.31nl7~ Ill.., To·- 1.0741t23
loin< •~lnHJ • 2.511 3.0
'ly" 1: c..cu•.t.o by~ FAV by acvt.-.e"'Otllc ra!lo. TYPt 2: Cllk:~l.l-.:1 ffom t~lcf~ 441-• 0..., Ty~ 3; OIMtlMG from c:ro.rvnic: vat 1M of t!nP(Wfant ·~
•FCV1; Fk\81 Chmnk: Valu.. r,.IM' I. FCVZ:. Final Ctttonle Vllue1 fJ1)I 2; FCVl:. fiN! Q,ronlc V~ Type 3, r-ftN : Fln .. RM)oue \'111.te, FPY ~ FlMI Plant V8h.M,
., .... ...... ........ ...... _.,. ~~v·tue~
Wll 1+'11 Will
210 ... ACA
·-~ Ff'N 10 FC'I1
I'CVO
FCVI 0.00,1 0.3 FRV
O..OOti 100 -FCV! o.;oaa .,. Ff'N 0,0000 21.7 FRV
FC'n
1.000 FCV1 0.20 FRV
ACII 0,01.t FRV
FCVI
ome . .,. FCVt
.7.0 FCV3
..
..
1llo --col dlttni>Uilon of - ._... In lhe n<lllonal """'" ond Cllmnlc lo•lclly dato -It roqulrod f<>< lhe c.OICU4ollon of ltMI 14t~llc·w•t« Cluallty ctttona. The _.,.ell taktn In llndloo ll!o ._. "'"''lbUtJonofo !IMcllllod In SoctJon 1.3 ond IM colculollon of the ototo ..,..lmum votuo orit- It -bod In s.etJon ~.Tho col .... ollon of ll!o ototo _,. --cntor!o It dJo· WONd It\ s.etlon 2.5. A - c.lc\I!Otlon - lil ... ttaloo all ol ttMI --1!1- lo -ted"' s.et""' 2.11. '
1llo -rOI>hl<al dlolrlbutJon of t"'* ._. In lho natlonot oe<~~o ond oh""'lc; to•lclty dolo -II NQUirod fa< ttMI OllcuiOIIon Of tho ottHI*tllC·WOIIf quolfty otltlfiL 1llo --tll<on tn flndi"' the Ol*loodlttrlbutiOno lldMCttbodln Soctlon 2.3 ondlhe colcuiOIIon of tho olat<t maximum voluo - lo dooertbod 1!1 s.etlon 2A Tho ootoulot""' of llle otote ao<~ay --crttono lo dlo• •- In s.etloo1 U A- cOioulatlon W1>k:1! llluotrat<to all of 11\0--1- lo -ted In Soctloo1 U
U ~ DIUMUTIOOI
n-.. e5blolog..--•-tad In tho notlonaltoxlc;ltydala-ta< the 21oh«nleolo dl..- Ill IIIlo-. "-_, ..... uoled "'Tllllloo t ano 3ot-ottho ctttono documont• (U.S, fPA. 111101. Of INN 116 opeolH, 48.,. fiiMI ond 47 - ..,_..., ln-oll<ol-1llo ti*IH tooled In Otdlf to -lop ocuto to•lcfty daU. tor -h of tho 21 -....-.... uoted In Tlllllo :u.
1M c.l ... IUcatlon of theM lpetfea by famlty, Ofdet, cJua, and pt\yk.l«< 11 preMnted ln ~he: A. 1\p!>ondfx A.~ lr<>m "G..-t.. for OorMno N-'cal Hlllonal Wolor Oualtty Crtlotto tor the -Jon of -Uo U!o and ~· UNo" (U.S. EPA. 1• lo -nUaJ tor eol<ulalloo the tomlly - _."""'""'"' •aJuoa"""' i¥011- Ol*loo to)lolty oata, a •• • tor c:lloclltoo 11\0 tomlly oompooltiOn of 11\0 tolllctty deto- -"'"' ltMI minimum Clala requ-• (Soctlon 2.1. 1~
A Ut•atu,. I:4.HWY wM c:onouc.ect on the dtttrtbvtkM't or theM eoeetn In tM Unh-.d Stetea. TN l>'ln•:toal ,..,.,_ '"' ldanttfYing tho dtotrii>Utlon olll\o llotod .. floh- woolha "All"' of Hollh - F-hWI.111f A-" (1M 01 al., 1880). A com-e OOCurileot It notOValllllllo lor ln---01. T-!Y ,., __ ,. .. UMd to ldan!ll\' "" -aplllcal dlotrll>llllon ot '"" 47 lo· .. no~n~a_,.._ A 1101 olin __ ..,.. ... Mdtilo,., __ ..-ll)ldantlly 111olrdlotrl.blltlon ta pre..nted In T'eb'e U The lnfonn.tUon In Tabte2:.31NUttl from an 11Ct..-.al¥e IUfWY of tM liteflhn, --· 11110 lnlom101lon OhO<Iid not ba oon- dO!IniUIIo u WlidoltiOY -tin -"1110 tnt 00> • ...,.,_ ot....,. -·partie.....,'"'* whlcll.,. not ot Ngn OOI(In*<:lol voluo.
$nco .-lo no con....,,.,., lor I'OOO<'dlftllllle -apl\lodlolrli>Uilon of Ol*ln(l.o.,-bY ot1.1o 0< bY "- I>Min dralnogo 0< bY othlf _,.,...- 1011_, -•1 lorml!t &II _, In tho tn.,.h ... fiorthepllfllO-OftiiiO "'))ft,tlleOIOiewuoelte~odMthtmoOIIIIlfHOIItlallgoograpl\1001 c1011mn•.
..... ..._..._~,_. ---,....,..._..._... ......... ..... .....,..,.... .. l
...... ...,..._..,.*""'-....
..... """'**" .... ---.... fO...-~ ------__ .., -----------------......... ~~ -----.............. ~) ---------__ .., ---<>..-a Gr ........ ~
~~ ...... -----.._ ___ ---0.. ...... ....._._ ........ ._...,._...a-.. ...,.., .. ,.._..,. ...... -- -
f til i J I it It I J I 112 I .1. X . . . X ' . . . . . . . • .
' . . ' • • .. ' ' ' . . .
• X 1. J. X . . . . . . . . . •• . . . . . . . . . X . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . t . . • • . • ' • . . . . . . . • . ' .. ' • . • • . . •• . ..
• . . . • . . . . . . . . ' . . . . . . . . •
H
T-U Uoi_..,.__ .... _TGIIIolly--~
- IJJJiJit111fliiiRI&J• .......,..._..~,,..,..,.. . . ' - •tJiiu ~lldd lldal. --- • .. . ._.....,.._..,C.......,._ lOll • -...-~ ....... . . . . ..._ .......................... . • . --- . . . . . , ......... .,........ .......... . ' ' . ' ' ' ' . . . ... Jl l X X . . --- . . . . . . . . . .............. , • .. • --- . . ..._.,.. ....................... . ~ ............ J . ..-.a-........... ~ . -- . ' . . ' o.-ca.. ....... .--... . --- • ...... .._ ............ ~ • ..._...,....__,..,.... . ............................. • . . __ .., . ' . . ............................... • ..... .. ~o.--.t . . . . a.-..e..a..,_ ............ . . . . . r......,.........,. ....... . ..... ......... ., ................... . . . • . --- • --- . . . • . . . --- . --- . • . • -- . . . . --- . . . ~ . a a. • • a . ' ' . .. .._ ........ ,..... .... . . . . . ...._..,...~ ......... ' c::.. ....................... . . . . . . . . . .. ... ........ ~____, . -.,..._.,..,..._.,.. . .,..,...,_.......,..~~ . . a...--. ................. . . . . . . . . . . . __ ,...,.......__.., . . . . . a--,_ .... ~ . . . . ..... .................. . . . . . . .._, ................ . . . . . . .. . .. .: . I I • I .. . .. , ... ........................ . ...................... . . a.-. ..... ...-~ . . . .... , ............ . I . --- . . . . . .... ,. ........... ,........ . . . . . . . . .. . .. --- . .. . . . . . . • • ... l • • . . .. ~, ....................... . .......,......., .................. . _.... ................ . .........,..,_ .................. • . . . --. ..... c... ..... . ............. ...._. .......... ... . .. . .............. ~ ' . ... ~ ........ ....,_..... . --- . . ..................... ~ . --- .. .. A a a X a .. . . . . . . ...._.. .... ..._, ......... . c.. c.-c-... . . . . . . ' .. "'-~~,_ .. . . ...... -........ ~ .. ................. ~ .
N .,
T-UI.Iolol __ .__,... ..
~-.... - ....... - --..,._. ..... ,.,, ............. ,.,, .....,..,..,.., ....,._ ...... ""
....,,......,., ~m
....... ~.,. ............ 1'2
- ·""
--~ ....... .,. ~ ..... ,..,_ ........... ttl'l
~·-'--ten'
W.W..ltu ........ ~1171
u.a./ltfll, ,...~l
....,.,~,,. u.e.-. ............. t. ........ .,
U CALCULATIOM OF IIAXIIIIUM VALUE CIU'TIIIIA IV STATI
2.<1.1 Procedu'"
~ celeul4t!Of\ of at•t• aquatic Ufe Cffttma te baed on the tnf«meUon In 1t1te retkMnt tpeclM llolt. """C<lllle opeoleolo~lclty dala.lof lhe da!f•allon of nauonal watlfqulllly en1011a, aa .,._.., lo "Gul<loOI- lor Oo!Mno Slit Sl>ool!lc Walor QuiJity C.ij- Ia< lhe P<otoctk>l> oii\Qulllc Ufo and lit u-· (IJ;S. EPA. \ IIG!-
2.<1,1.1 Maaim4lm llolue C.~l(\t ~I of HIIIG ....
Catcul•don of the m.t.XImum v~ut crttetta. for tMM c:hem5CaJe "'hoN1ox·k::lty I& .,.~tot hold .... , II dono OCC«dlog 10 lhe following Placed .... ;
1. U.lno till EPA crllt<to documonl lor lho tol<lc chomlcll ollol-1, Nlacl from T- 3 lho SpocliM Moen A®lo Vol .. (SMAV) lor oocn ._ ... ,..lclonllo lho >1111,
:!. FO< tell. family wllh OM«,..,. SMA VI avllloble, oaullto tho Family Moen A<:ull Vlluo (FMAV) u lhe goomt:lr1c mHO or IM ovallll>lo SMAVo.
3. C.lclllolt 1111 alalo Final Aculo Vlluo uolng 111o Ploceduroo outlined below wt>lcl! "' ell• cu- In ''G<IIeloll- '"' D!of1.;lno N""*""" National w-Qulllly (:ttl""" IOf 1110 "''*"' '""' ol Aouauc Ulo""" no UNo'' (U.S.. EPA, 11112); cal O<<lof 111o Ft,IAV• ,...,.low lo nogn. (b) Aoolgn ronko(R) lolhl FMAVo from "1" IO<tho-tto"N" IOtthohlgiMot.lltwoormOtO
FW.Ve - ldontJcal, M>l11ttlly -IV• 111om ,_,.., ronu. (c) Coiculato 111o curnUiot""' p<opotiJ"" (P) lor_., FMA\1 •• RfOj + 1~ (d) Sol0011ho IOIK FMAVi which hovo """"'lotlvo propot~lono •-••• 0Jl6~1 1"-oro loot
than~ FMAVI, tllooo wiW olw~ be till lour loW"I FMA\11~ (e) Uolng tho NlociOd FMAVo end PI, colculoto tho loll.,.ing eoolllctenlt:
M' • W-{!II/1')'!•1 E41n FMAV)' -llUin !'>IAVJI'I41
(2.1)
'i • Cf.On !'MAVW4
v • Clffl4
(I) tho Slate FAY lo dllined u :
FAV•o"
wHhA • I<• vm:- y
"
...
...... ....................... _ .. .,.,...., .. .,..iel9orol:
<*I (Siatt FA yY2. or
ItO! ...,., FA\'I'IOC- '"'lol
ZAU ...._ V-~-· "'-lortoiH""*----too-.u..-totoxlcllyoltiJC-~c-t. ~. NICUI, -"""Zl<lc. n..lcn,CI'IIorialot_ ... ____ lngloollnal
-oquatloft_ll_lhO FAYM OIYncntonol -:
FAY • OIUIMI<ICH. + .11
-Hit lilt ---10011 OICoOII,.•Io IN--""'"·"""''""" llnoiOClllo 1n1«cop1, The-•lt-oo lllo--OIIIIIhe_....,._..._lotln---~--~---lot..,,__ .......... _ •t~~~-or~~~e __ """_.,.. _____ ....,.._.,.._...,.. _., . ...,... __ ... _ _,.,,., . ....,._ ... __ ... _,. ~10 ... - ln.,.._laldd!J----.a ... --...... c:tll ..... tho--or·-- ........ -........,.,., __ ,.,1110_ n.o-or.-.... ..._....,..,._.,. .. ~ .. -
1. Uotnv lilt EI'Acn-_,lot tilt....,...., or ""-t.- 1n>m T- 31110 _, .. ........ oro -..In o portlcu .... ot&!o n ,_, lilt Spoclto- Aculo lnl"-1 (SMAQ. Tho IIIIIAI-.-olod M 1110 goomotllc- or 1110 o\'1111-lnt-o (II. • 1111 YOIII,.., oa:
w- w • tllo ,_,.., LC,.- In T-1 or N---., •• ""' ___ ..,.,._.,.__ __ ,,tho_ oiT-1ollllo-do<olmont.
H·--at-1110~--od.ln'"OIIC.OO~ a.,.,...,,....., __ .,..._ ___ ._ ... ,,.,.,., __ _ ~loiAI)oo ""ooomotllc __,or"'"---
5. c.rc..toto il'o-f, j,""" Wlor lilt _l'lftol......,. 1'4!*ton uolng tllo ,_ ro•"""""" "0'10UIIIno<llnSoctlon 2A.1.1, .-uwtlng " AoiAI" Ior "FWAII".
._ Tho •• F.,., Acute Equation to oollnod oa:
F/i,V • Olip!'>(ln CHl•AJ
and • • mMn KU'te •-- tot tne cttemtcM ~~step .. , .. _
5. The Ol&!o .... tmwn"""' Ofl- lo-MIN IOf90f of:
(ol (elolo FAyY2..,
~~ (01010 FA~UIHhronlc ratio) 12.111
2A.2 Cornc><~tor "'""'""' AltlniOIKIJ .. FORTIIAN -(fOURSTAlT),... uood IOCioleulolo 111o tltlo "'""""""' \'IIIU.
Ofllocl&. The PIOII'"'" to on .. ,_-ol o -lor PfOII'OI!I do'IOioptd •1 lllo U.S. EPA Eft. .. __ ... ~lory in- ThoOulvlll ---- ~ ... ...,.. :::",.O:,'!".::':r=:==::,floQioloror21-IWO. The0ulv1lt_,...
' · _, __ ... _,_,,. ... ..,....,..._lot any g....,,_, 2..colculotoiMI'looi.4Yolh---l-loo, l . cloleuloto lilt FAY uolng 1110 modified motnodology, 011c1
'· - tho rnoclllleO -· dolO - ogolnot .... modified ""''"" or "'" min- .... requh'wmet'tta.
The program Ol*ltM on '" dale fllea.:
ACUTEI.OAT
FAMILY.OAT
CHEMNAWE.OA T
Dote lllo olopoctoo ocuiO ... _ (lC. or Ec..J u ._odIn T-1 o1 tllo ct1t"'• OOeU\'Ninta. n. oni'Y ·-~~ te the ~ loCU .. ll'ajwe fo.SII,.Ior~Oooo(/ffJ/Itk:lt/ft'(IOOCIJIIifJ-10"-In>m 1110 ........ ... 0.2 ,.goo to 211.0 ~.
Ooio fttoot .... _...- -10....-.""""'"" ,.......,. ,0 ....,_.., TIIIoltot- oll opociMior-IIOOOC<IIttootlclt)'.--IOtt11021-
Dote fllo ol lwtr ,.,_ ..,., •- 10 """"'""·
Ooto lito ol 21 e11emtco1 ·- 18 II wnlcll ..... ,_, .. ,__ ~uatlo 'lfe c.rnerta, and tNW of wft'Ch n,.,. mtWmum ctUerla .
.. ..
...
SRO.DAT DIU Ulo of IM -t-IM In .. .._CHowOii _,.._ not lnoludoll);boeh lleto ord_... _ _...~.....,10--
STATtHAME.NEW Slate ,.,_ of lllo .. IWoo tor wlllch lllo - watOI -tloetlt.ri1 .... --1«1-Tho -- llloa-ACUT£1.11o\T, SI'EQES.DAT. CHEMHAMEDAT__. ~ ~thoU.&. EPA-- '--•IO<Y In o.Mit
U ~c:ui.AT'ION OF TliiiTAft _,A ¥aMI~
Tho :IO<Iar - c:tltOftOII II doll- II IM rnlnlmum of lllo FCV. FfiY « FIW. Tho ilwoa --ln'*"""' tllerwl- FCV ---laf'*"""'IMCOr-odlrogM-FCV.In __ .,._FCV--~-..""""-'"v~ .... ...,..--.,. -.FCV--~..-., ... -FAV~tlla-lcllltiO.Foflglooft_., tlla -omoc-IIIJo-lntM ___ _ torolf•-tn ltlo.,..
-t"-""'-FCV--,...., ' """"'tc-yelatO l>loa, """"ao Ooot>ot Wid lAid, 1110 _,. ~- laf --ion Otlllo FAV(EQuo;lon 2.!11"" -lOt -ling 11io atoll FCV baaadoo '"' .,.., -t tamiiV """""ctoalcltydala. Thoelataraaldonllamllydalo- uMd fO< lllo FCV catcuiMion •• CIIO-od ~-of lila ,_lng-1.--oo.ldty .. ....,.._..of-w-.""' S!>ociM- awor.oc: v- IIMCVI of,... - - · - - ,. ---ldly---(lrll'ot - ,......., wllll- Of_.. SMCV1 l"oll- . Ukulooo 1111 Fomlly- DMunlc
Vol111u u.o _,...,. moan ol tho.....- SMCVa.
2.-CfWONc toi<JciiY Il l function of-(0) -t 1110--Cl\rof!lc """"""' CIMCI)of tlleololor- -'"from IM
natlonol-lciOOICotyo.tl--"' l'ot-I....,--Of_,. SMCI .. - . .... - • N Faml"'- OwoniC lnt-(F~MIN~-oftr>o --SMCIL
2.U ComtM• l'lognwn
-~~~"lctontlniOt!I'IOllon--11-,tho--WU -IOcolcUIOCo l ... ...,_._ FCVO, Ff'V lind Frw-laf - ...... Tho -ulotlonO- clono tor 18.-o.,
30<Ioy --- --... __ Ind.....,_
Tho vorlatlon In ltato 1-1 --WOIIId 1fleclhoro of tile FCVo:
I . FCV ca!Cull lecl II FAY d!vldecl by 10utKhlor!lo ratio, and :!. FCV CIIOulllecl lrorn tho alate cnro.lc toxlc!IY diiO bMO
ThoPIOQI __ _...,.,...n......,_, .. .,.-''lodltlloono.,.,...._II••-IOoot --.ntoMitOM-ItltlyNefi-~-OI OOINl " Wifinoi i>I-UIIIov-. Tho !If_,_ llnii>4Y-OIII,....., _ _,_.,.mlo""""" U lo\III'U CALCULATlOII
The eetcuiAtlon ot the trnhwatet' ~quatlc life ct1t..-~ ,ot Ch~ and Nlcket tot the state ot J-.nni)'IVV.II.,. ptMtnt.:J tO IIIUIUite tht ""'Culldon m.thod,
2.1.1 eto- en ..... t« ,..,.,.,.,.,"'
1- Tho .... ,..urn Vlluo c.tt-TIIo 111111"'0 polnl II IM ootlonet acutoloddl'f "-1•- lot Ch-(T-2A)-.
opocl" ID nurnbllra,- -tnelt -"'rnoao ...... - 11011f-lod. Tho_ ... 10 """'"* ta otwen In the oolumn •·SMQ" end tM epec'-t ~ -cute Wlh,. In u,. cok.lmn "l~" With ..,~. ot ..,. With 1M old ol tile r .. ldonl II* ... 1111 IOf IM Gtolo ol """"•Y~ ... ,. cr- 2.l5l. ,,. "'"""' -"' , .. tcJIY "''' ,., tho swto cr- 2Al ... """ _ ,, ~tJot -.Jngthod..-. lo<_t_...lrornT_ :!. • • ThollohllfiOCioalnTU _. ,... 1-1- ~A Ol'd a-31. Tho fomlfy ...,, toiiCity - tor ,...,I,..,_(T-2.7)1o~f>Vcoi<;ufollnglheF~-kutoV-(FMAV)Iaf -"of IMo\gM apocloo "'-•In T-2.1. Tho FMAV 11-uo11evoo-rtc moan of 1M """-- moan oouto ••- tor opociM l>llonglng to thO lornlty. Fo< outnp11, • "'''· ,.,_ mlnoow a nd gotdfl1h 11tl>llong to IM lomlly ol Cyllflnld ... TM FMI>V tor O)'prtnldM 11 lhon eolculolocl ao:
p .Oa51.0• 12..t» .. • tU
-•3.0.&1.0...,12.0.,. .,._... ,_. -'••111-ol 1110 ,,......,....._
01 oq..oJcOfO"'omo- ln ,...,rytv..,IO .....,.,,,. lourlarnllloO """'t-0111"' to OIIOtGono,
tiiOtr """· cumuliiM - 1011 1111<1 FII.AY 11111:
'"
~IA--T-,DMollor- T-U _,..__..,._T_,Dolallor-- lC60 LHLceo 1IHO !!I!!!!* ~~ Rank 1..0!0 b!!~ !!!!2 ,_ ...
1 3,0000 1.- ee.o C....,(Cypn--) (jig/!) 2 t.3201 1- 31.0 - Slwimp ,,.._,.. Qd-lt) ~ 1&.0000 2.1'080 311.0 !It-fly (l'I.....,IIC)'O a.llfomlca) ' 3.0000 . .- ee.o ~ teyl)(lnoo 0111>101 4 ··- 3-2:17'11 ~ lllatn- Trout {Solmo ~-) 2 8.3246 , ..... 31.0 01- Sllrimp(.._l .. ,.,.,notOI o~ltl
• li!I.OOOO 3.21111 22.0 Scud tOommiiUOI .. UIIrto) 3 25.- 3.237'11 !18.0 Rain- TIOIIt (8almo gtlni~Oit)
• ··- ~~.- 21.0 __ ,, ..... , .. , 4 30,- 3.- 21.0 SOlid tOammatUI fucletut)
7 4<1.- 3.1087 ••~o ~ Trovt (S.tt\eetinUI fc>nUttlllt, 5 ... - 3.8017 eto 81- TrOllt (Sol,.llnoa fonUnalla) a 61.01110 U321 710 FothMdMinnow~lorl~u) • 51,0134 U321 '73.0 Fa1~aac1 Minnow (pj~''" """""'"' I 6ol.7111 4.0021 13.0 81uegtll ~lo moch<-lruo) 7 !>1.7111 (.0021 113.0 81u.gllt !"-""• mKroc~lruoJ
10 !18.- ri.G2114 M.O Collo Salmon (Onoolll)'nC~I klootch) • 81.- ·-1 11.0 QcMdfll h (C.tMIIul I UrltUI) 11 ... - 11.0030 ~ Qltnook Set-~~·· ll/lawytiCIIaj 12 ..__ ··- 13.0 CI-(Ool>llla rMQNj 11 .. .- 4A081 11.0 Ool<l!loh ~·· _ •• , ,. 1 • • ..., U1170 ao.o ~~lila nMlcUCata)
f-U ---UIIIIor_,.._ VI 3.o 4.o a.o e.o 7.0 e.o
T-U -.,-~....,-T......,T_IIor_
e.o 10.0 11.0 111.0 15.0 18.0 ta.o 10.0 21.11 2(.0 :zs.o -a.o 30.G 31.0 - l'lCeG LH(!'U)e(!! F>IO F!l!l!ly 31.0 31.11 110.0 111.0 03.o ae.o •r.o eo,o 62.G !IS.O aa.o 51.0 eo.o 11 0 ....,, 62.G I3R lOR ee.o 11.0 ee.o IU IQ.O 11.0 710 711.0 7&.0 77.0 1U 6.3201 l.&rl4t 27 -11.0 111.0 IIJI IU 17/J IU ee.o ZUll4 3.111!18 40 ()yptl-IO.o tl.O 12.0 I3R kO ee.o IU S3MZI UZ23 • -17.0 IU ee.o 101.0 102.0 • .$ ae.- 3.- 2S -k7110 II.Gll21 .. ~
... . ..
••
II p ,......., "!!!!l
Mil' I
0.17 8.S2 -o.3:l :ZUA ~-o.eo ~- -OA7 AO,OO o--
1. wltll P _....., oo AICH • t)-N lo U..IOial-oiiMIIt•ln ""'au.to IO,.lclty cl.ta - · -•• ,...,. IIIIo - . llolng tho,.,_ oii'MAV Olld P 101 U..tour 1\'1001 oonoiU.. IMIIIIOO, Iho --· M, i, ~ Olld A- tor till &toto F1nol Acllie Voluo{FAV)oen l>o col· -bot opp~ytng u.. tormw _.., 1n 111o-~:
M' • I(!'l - KWI'fiA! • o.o44 ll!n I'MAVI'I - ICinn I'MAvrt4J
'i • liOn FilA.,_. • s.oe
9 -~- o.&ZJ
A • l+~• l.t3 12.1111
-FA'IIo:
' " " .... S.10,.gll C:U7)
-----~~--tllo-fAV-IIyh-o< toii.O<fOI ... ___ ,. __ Ior~lo i·(>~IM
---lor~lrw.,._ol--111.56,-lotiiO-. FAV-bof2.
2.-~A ... ,.cm-- -lY ·-ctfl-1• cloflnod u tho minimum ollho f!MI ctwonk: Voluo (FCV),
tho Fino! --Voluo (I'IIV) «tho Flnol Ptonl Voluo (I'PV). 'I'Mno to no FP'I ovollllllo lor ~.Tho FRVIoO.CIOAl ,.g/1 (IMl-2.1~ Thollnolchn>nk:.Utaoollonot ou"k:"""f"' tho coJculotloll of on FCN. Tho ocutKI\ronlc IIIIo tor CO>IoniiiMII 14.0 (1M l-2.1) which o•- on FCV fo< l'llnno)'lvonlo ol 0.22 I'QII, colcu141tod u 3.1CWIA.O. w'*' 3.10 io tho FAV fo< -noytvoniL Competing 0.22 jjQ/1 (FCV) wllh O.OOA3 ,.gil (FII~ tho -oy IVIf"VV C~totloll tor Clllofdono tor tho Stow of ""'••r"'•'"· O.OOA31'011, •• c-..
Ul.2 Nle~ol Cit- fot ""'nort..onlo
l . Tho Mllllmum Yoluo Cift-
Tho ocuta t<>ldcltyol Nk:f\llhu- 11lotod to tho """'houln ••-•ta< bot on • • ·Uol- (U.S. EPA. tliiOI:
- -·-.. -toxlclty, thoottoctol -hoototoo.-r...,.thol-· otory- LC,. voiUOL lno!Md ol uolng - LC,.O u tho Cloto- tho acuto ..,_ t-.pt .. ,, -.Tho oc.W ln-OIIIoenl>o- u tho acuto voluo ln tho-olo - """"' Q.o., m ~~ • 01. T1lo ,.._ "'"'" to•lCIIY oooo tor I<IClflll ' " 1110 -olo-"**log!owlll'T_U_thovoi-HIIodlntlleeo!UIM"LC50" oro - .,_, oouto lni-L llolng INI u 1110 110111110 point - IOIICM!nQ 1M -
...,.... --'" Soctton u.1,,,. .- -IO!UC"" "'" rr- """"""-. ...,.,!OnWytoiOCI!Ydala(T-2.lOiort-. Tho,_ t-leo- oono~u.. to Ntcro.l ln '"' Stalt or~"-· ~no~< t....uy_,
...,.. ..,,_(NAil.,_~ -•-•vo-lon(P)-R p I'MAI FMIII~
~
0.07 ... ~ o. .. &..65 ~olllooo Cl.21 U4 CenlfOidliciM Q.2l lUll Pllllodlnklu
~u -,--~T•Ialty-fetlllaUI - -~ ""'* IHO ~ ... loo9l!t
I liMe! ...- !11.0 -~-· ,..;)(0110) ,_ ... __ ,......, ___ CioT'IIot ___ ..._.
2 ...... UliO .... ~a..~II•NPMttfaJ • =·- ~ Wl ~~~,.-• JOUlC a.7018 ... "'"*' .... ~ MUtlll•t
-~ u;eo I.H LCI!O ~0 Sp!clet • --- 6..1118 tz.O --~·o-1 6 .OU1et &M05 2.0 1\otUtt ("'ltootnt ICUtlooml•) Will 1 03t.l200 ...... <6.0 loliGOo (C<!IIC>no""'• So~
I 040.~ e.oen 11.0 ,e.lhMdM\ni'\OW'(PI~~)
' SUIWO ~ !3.0 ~ "'""""'" fNIO'!OI • !IOU3111 1.22111 11.0 C.rv (C)'P'tJWt ,..lew••••• t ,._, ·-- 15.0 ~~PIIIIC*fo) \0 ooe.awo UU) tl.O Dl~lll ~· m.ctod'!'rw) :1 tciiAoa) UM to.O --(Anll>iallllloo_,,., " U7.1e20 ...... ,, $).0 ~M 1M ~tlta roNr~ll
12 U.$1el ··- ... Whllt ~,(MOtON ~a,J I =- ~..- 33.0 lollfi!YI-1•-.1 l3 - ·- ••. o Scwd fOM'tmW\It ~.) 0 301J1!012 S.?UII kO Stttpod - (Moo'ono IIUIIIII ) •• "'·'cas ...... 4.0 lrl•tt•worm CH•• ISOJ • -- o ..... ta.o -~~~o-•1 •• 1'31-ISJ$ ·- ... SnolliMWcola .. J 7 """"'" a.- 2.0
,..,.,.(1'111_.. _ _,,, .. 1007M l .t ts.& 11.0 cao.dtttl'l ~Ct/Mt~Ut wrtl..,.) • ...- .._ <111.0 ...... ~-~ !1 ,,.... .. ··- 112.0 a-ofll-1111001
• ~ t..Oir.l 7:1-.0 ,_ .. ,_~_ ... , II ...... 7.1011 11.0 ~I!UIIIttll\(1~1\1101~)
10 ........ .... 61.0 Oolppylf'ooclllo ... ......., II IIOt.UOI uvt .., ~~c.plo)
T-t.!O _,..__ F-,T......, -··-12 ~ 1.23:10 tiS.O ....... ~--~ 13 ur.teao Ul12 03.0 - &I!MtiUJIIO-'" 161.611t ·- kO -----· - R.CSO ~F\.5!!1 rMO ·~ 10 IN.MZI
.. _ 2U -~-J -,. 721.101:1 .._ 40 --... ..... SI>J
f1 7:11.:1375 .... 5.0 Snoll CMWo<* 111>4 ,.,_ ·- •• -II 10CI7M ..., .. Q .O ~~--· - . ....,. .. -" -.a• ·- 12.0 --,~u- 34"717 ~- .. eanu ........ ~ , ....... 7.3021 112.0 ~flr~"-'1 • 401.21. ~- I -21 _,, 7.1157 35.0 .......,.~~ • .. ..... ·-- .a& ~ 22 22aA1 7,.,.., 11.0
__ ,..,,_.....~
I - ·-- ., .............. 1 filii.- ..... to, .. ~ • a1.tao OAOIZ l1 ._.._ • ... MoD ._ Z5 -10 7>1.>GI:I ..... 10 -11 1)1,33," ._ IZ ----12 ·- 7~ .. .. H)4100itCf ....
u ::l2041. 17011 c,.._ ... . ..
-
wllll P cllculotO<I u RIIN +I}-N lo tho totAII nlllftbl< ol nmlllet In tile Slott dati bae, whlclllo 13 In IIIIo • - · Sul>ottlullng II- vet- Into OQutllonl 2.1 to 2.$, WI -In tho lot loWing:
M'•O.a:ZA (2.181
i • &AI 12.201 y • o.,.tH (2.21) ,. ·<1.22 C2.ZIJ
Tho Flnol Aoull lnt--' (FA!) lo:
FAI• .. • 07,7 (U3J
ano '"" FIMI- E®otton to:
Fi\V • F"tl( Ofllo?IM(hord-M IUAI
FAV a 11.7 JJ.?IIn (llordnooo)) (2.251
«
FI<V • o/O.?IIn ~)+I<) (2.2e)
FI<V • o/O.?Itn ~~ + 4.22) IUn - tho~...,_,.. rotlo lor Nk:IIOI (ItA) lo _,.,Ilion 2. lho """"""'" wlluo
Cl'tli'lo (loi\IC) lot N~ lot tho 8uoltt ol ....,noylw_lo'
M\IC•P'All2)oi0·781n~~ (2.2e)
MVC: ~ 33.1 o/D.TO tn (llltdnooo)j 1:1.21)
or
MVC o olD• TO In(-) + 3.52]
2. Tho »ooy "- ()1llflon
Tho Clt«N>to 1'*'<>111' o1 N..,.... lo rwtotO<I to honlnooo In lrMhwow tn tho..,. woy ooto ..... toxtcliy (lquailon 2.1fll, Tho nollonol clvonlc toxl<liy dolo bUe (T- 2.11) oonlalno
only t't;O '""'"'" ""''•" 111 1'1dlgenouo to !'lntfoy!V~~>Io (Cypffni<IM.,., Soll)'onk1M)1 therel«t, lt'\4t FCV (*'~not be c.atcu111.a frQI'I'I the s .. t• ctw~lc lO(te1t) de._ bull,
Rink Fl~ LN fl2!!!!J FNO F""'ll~
WII
2.5411 0.8361 " OlpM!doo 1Aell1 2.01* <10 Cyo<jn!doo' 17- ~ 311 Solma<)I<IM"
23,7813 3,111811 30 Hyd'-'~Ch!Cilll
'"lncl'-• to !'lrmoyl""'"·
Tho • •• II- ocuiO<IIronlc rollo 10 tU 1JM Tol>lo 2.1i ""len altowo o Fino! Chronic EQUI> non to ... """''' '""'""", .. Flnot .... ,. fquotlon:
C2.3tl
With the Stat• F1n1l Ac.i.lte Equ•Uon gl'¥en by Equallon US, tN Stat• Flnat Chronlo Equotlon Ia cloflned oo:
FCV . ~Jo.rotn (hordnooo»
FCV ~ 3,4t of0.781n (llorclnoooM
~cv • olD. 78tn (llordnooo} + 1.251
9~ thlrw II no ·FI1V 0t FPV for Nlctc.l, tho Fino! CM>nlc EqiMion, Which n-- tW FlnaJ Chronic VIIU. u a lunctlon Of hardnMI, Ia tM Pwtu'l•~•nla 30-day IWI'IOI cr1tetton IO<Nicr..t.
...
1.1 1P«C10 IM81'IIIMITION IY IT An
SECTIOH 3
RESULTS
Wuefloltllo--10--WOWquolily_fll'_ .. _,.~ dhtl.-lllcellan-~IOII!o--b>lwftllioolotllonotlanolda1a--HIn~ a.t n 1H. -'MIY·8i>odoo l<lonllllc4ollan --tile-110 lllmlly Cl-latlooo .,._..., ln~lx &3.-..., _....,.11110<1 bl'l<lontlllc4ol1Dft numl>o! In ~ 11-4..., K..., tlle<llolrlllutlan In tno tlnllod 6ttotoo tWowolln "ltolla.,. not lncludod) o1 tho II& opocloo Ill llle notiDO., O.la- to-'"' In Apf>ondl• K A..,.,_ HOI ol---,_ lnloodcJty-~IX &3)il!e- tno
-·-""·--_,....,··--.......... 58,_,.,_...._., __ lo.,. .... _.,... _____ ln&ocllan2.t. t,lo--
ln "-""'< M Tho 58 lomlllooot .. ...,.., In"-""'< Nby 10 nw..-. Tho -tloftolllpol- lornlltoo to tno
---leQU-OO_bo_bym.oelllng ... OOO.nurnborlnohoflgonto- ol tile Olgllo opocllloddot.l noq<;~-to. Nolo INt .-t ol tno lomlltoo "'Ill' oattoly ...,...,.,., ... ol""' minimum O.la -"-IL Fot oumplo, 111« 1 - ol U.O lomiiY --M& -.
~ .:~4 . .!:"..:-,::=::..~~r:.=-:_m:,:,::: ploytum Cllotdooa.
,...,..._., _ _...,.,,._.,., __ , ....... 1074,__,.
<10 to 70- ol tile tooal-lft In IN noUonol loxlolty do!a-.- Votll.,.. tno-'""' ..-olr-._loo....,lloflorldohullle_,, EJil~l--too .,.,._tlno!t41olotoo;
roUto< ll'ltii<HI/no KllllcomiC) rotllo</l'tl--,...,-.., ,.ell apJ _, ~ .. I!Oitm«ltMJ .,....IO'f'llllvO ·--IWI -'!Pft"/MIIlJ -IDop~tnM ->J ci-on (o.plrfllo pu/kotlo} c-(SI~uo HmJiotuo} oopopoo~ lunl<lontttlod) --'IHr«IJelo-J -lly(l-apJ mltlfiO ~ .. ,.,.,. ... ,
..
mldQe~uoapl mlrlfler-lltlod/ -.lly/un-JIIoft)
'*" ~ CO<Piol ._,_,_IW_.-) ......... .,. --!hot.,. widely .- ~o *'100 lMit-octuoldlolltwltonle Umllod, ,. pl.wtan, ~- ............ .,.,"'-,__ ..... _In "ffol ... 41
·-oc-.-~~J""'-"'""~-ol ... -.__.,-.~-~~- ............ __ .,,. __ ol
Dopionllm- - of tho -IP!II-. Tho --ol Oap/lnM .,...,.In ,.1111_ -~•-lnF~&1,_1o_llodl!o!n ''TM~ol--~· ,.._, 111&1): , ... 01-Uon --14ol ... _ .... - /lellllnll""*"-"-In,_ but .. not -In.,. ~!cool--~-~ tiP). o.plrnlo .--.-~,.... _ _.....,._ln_~~"·--
Cioot, ~~"'-"""'·"·--~,.,.._ _ __,.,_"'"'"-·""'
--~-u CYAn WATD OUAI.IT'I' ~
Tho otMI wol4r qlllllty Clltorto -· .-" l!o!n ~,._ion ol 111o .-lculetlon -llod .,. -Mdlnlhll_,ln_-.:llnolby-~Ciancl-b\'-~x 01- Tho ________ ""'_ .... ___ _ ...,.
01_, __ ... _--...r_. .... ...,_ol ..... doolapotnta.lllo-__ .........,_ .... ___ .,._IOirtc:lly _____ _ -ln-utatlootho_max......,....,._.,. __ ~--lly only 11w -lOOt. Codmlum. Cl\fvmlum, Cooper ..., Zlnc~-_,, olllle minimum doola noq<;~- ....,,.. _,.not oatlollod. ror _., ellomlwt ollnlOIMI, _,_...,In T- 3.1 ThonoliOtlotlOiOICII)'-- ... , .. -.~ •• Cll-,-... ~lion, Endrln, - .U- .PC8. T---)-notomlllooln~--Mivopoda 01 a.onsoto.,. 01.11- ... nino-~ . ....,_, ~-. CywOGo, --~--....,-.. _.,..,_, __ ... __ 10 _ _...
- .. _.., ""'-.,~ _,_ ""'-Olc>nleu --~-I0--7.Dall_ol_klf_ol,._llllto ___ ...,_ ... _,., .. ,to_-· "~~"~-"'"'"---""-'"'""' ..... ...,......,.,.,.,. crl-donot ,_tile mlnlmumda1a ~e~~-.-tnoo_loololty.,...""' o~weyo o -ot,.notlanol toololly dela. tile- otonlnol>41"yol moo!---to,_ tile -""' 0.1a ..... - Jo -lolont<lotlln ,,. not_,loxlclly--.
Tho UOI olllle - In .........,_C n D IIOirOiel>t!OIWord. Fotl- ... --lty crl- ... ~lotlho-otiiiiCHOon_.,bo_l __ ol~ln---Cor
, ........ , D4o- ol ,.,.,..., ........ "' ... United ...... (tllodlllod--.. 1117)
..
T-Lt -..o. .. ,....,_II_Aiollai.,_II_T_..,_._
-------.._ -·---~ -l.o -----
-
' Tlw .............. ""'*'-" ... ~
' · "" .............. ~ .. c-.~ 2.0.0-lllol!p .... __ .. ___ .... _0.0000.
..
............... ........_ ....... ___ w.'\........_01.,...... .... _______ .,._ -.. .. ---·--·- ·_..,·-· --·-· '·"-.. ·----·a.--................ .. .,., ................... ~ .
....................... ,.. .........
IObiH lo< MiC~IO<Inln A-1• D. TM ITW:I""'m nluo 0111.,.,.. loi.I!O,.g/1, wfl~ woa Obtolnedb)l .JI\Itdl'nO 1~ $1•t• ,nel Acwt• V•lue br l; tn. :)Oode.J•verav- c:,-tt.raon '* O.~a.,grtw'lllch ... O.t¥.0 bydWtdlng the SUit Ftl\tl Acute Vah.le by acutKiuonle raUOoi26(Me Tl.b&e2.1). OtMt" UMh •• t111tor· ma\~ It~~ IV.IIi!Mtln tMH 16btll. TN IOiat tU.rmblt of f&mU ... In tM State retldent de·la OMI for Mkn~ It a~L The four moat t 14'1t lllw famlltn and ''*' FMAV1 .,..;
Family
Onomf11lm.-ato!ytnl«homlt1tolnto<maltonthollhoMiclllgonfAVIOfUndenoloi-1Mn tho tomHy,..,. ocuto nluo ollho moot -•ttl .. tomt!y (21.110 •Gil for S.Oimo<tt-). sem.. lite '"v lo thovoluewfllcft c........-tolho flftft-lllo,ltlon tho,AV oi\Outd bo I-I hen tt>otoml!y!MIII ocuta voluo of lite mool -"""' l111ttiiY If t11o toto! numb« or -lomtltoo lo teoelllon Zl.
tn all..-... COlli lor- cCW>tatni"G- 1t1on rour-. --· !Mmulmum cttiOita moybo colculotod boood on tho"'"'"""'""' g!Yon tnt--Tmlllornulmum""'uocttt"""" ot~lor~uMn.empiO, ,..motalllottlgl!t __ ....,,_ __
""lllolour moot_,, ... ot 21.00. u ... <12.21)""" ~.on. Tllo-- - lor lllo ,,.v ..., bo COICVIO!Id 1>)1.-tiM~ t-•11-lnto -2.1 10 U, ~
M'•OlOrl l11l i .. ,. .. ~ 'I •0,&1 1131 "•aal P-•)
Tho FAY to:
......... t'-211011 1151 n.o...,t..,.._,.tl0_1_3~10t22~1orttte2tc_t-._o t
otT-2.t~tn--thoocu<~rolloo«<Q1'101•"""'21oroltoflllo_ot_ Tho ,..tmum n1110 erltor1on, wfllcll to clollnocl• lite F"V -1>1' lite omaltorollo)2 01 1b1 lllo .........,IC ,.Ito, fft"1 bo olmpy cleftned ll lllo FAV/2. Tho--voluo cnt-ol Unci.,. lor MlcftlgOIIIIIIIorolorodollnocloo:
fAV/2 • 112n • Uolglt
.. ..
..,_llngthl~·-""_""_-"""lnl-Z.tii_Tho_ - ... lo .. a&.O-~thl--voluoolo.uf,.gii. ~INivoluo-lltl -FRY o1 1ao, thl30<1of --e.- ooo.a» 1'011· Tllo --o11111 ~--lo-lnlhi-(++~M··-· --~~~~--ot> t.lnodbyd~thlf~V-1111--"Ff:'r'~-lltlvoluo--lllo c:NoniCIOXICIIJ'diiA-"fPI/" -lhollllonluo woo triO fiMI- VIIIUOO: "FRY" .,.,.... me F1nal AMadut v.-.,., .. scv .. ......,.. .. ,,_ ¥11U. .. the cntonk v.tu. of knponanl --·lto-IOIO&IcltYdouboll-not moot lhomlnlmum6all-lr-to, o olll (')II prlnlod noatlotho moxlmum nluecrlt-. If lite &totodel.o 101 -••-ttten 1-lomiHoo. "' " ' 11 pttntld Mel tM ,.. .. k>nal muamum Yl h,,. cttten• le pnnted u eM ttl .. fTI!Uimum velue cttt~. Tho -ftlltllrw""'tono tnt--: IO-lite <IIC\o!Oiod •oluo Ol-In tho tll>lo: IO ulltho.,., tlonol ott-: "' 1o cot!Ciucl - lltonat to•telty tooto or _,llor>al_too oo that lito otatt toidcltr d ... -II -10 moot lho mln""um doll '-QU-11, IIWi- colcUIIIOIIIo crl-. FO< ,_. _,.. tnto<mallon on .-.ng 1111 minimUm doiA --•• (oo 11 to doelcle 1111 tool _.. ... ldcllttonalloo..,_ o - moy -lo 1111 In-Ion g!Yonln "-""• E. In"-""" E. ,,. ..... ....,clllmic<olllwolllllllo-olthl ____ l.ltfOoil-todbf -tO-...._.... .. , moybo _..,_
Ono ol.,. rnl---- lo "1111 1111\Hy Sol-" ....,...lo ..... - ""' tndlgoo!OUIIIIIour Sllloa:--T-""" lllloo~oa~Rlt. l')to __,-In thll.. ... --,.,..,--thl-!yol-ngtlolo__..r-._ ... ~ -b)la''rolgotollloe.ltol.,._o·o -
FOIIhlol1c'-loM (Cd. cu, Pb, Ag, Nl""" Zll) wfloM "'"'" IOlltct!y to dlpenclenl on ltatdnooo In - . lhlnl- ,_,In lhl cal"""' " LCISJ Voiuo" end lllo muJmum nluo crtt.to ,_,,. lllo -oi~C"""D-onlytotrllocutaln*""91o, tltlllo,lhl.-ot..,_ol• t.ct.lnordottoool_..,...._, .. ____ ............. ld ...... lt>!ylllo
---(CI!I-tn~C-Ob)lthlhanl.-o-1.--
-Ya1·--ctl-loro--llonoiHmgltaoC.00, • ""--·olollo..,_lllllo-oll- l ollllo""'.to ~
H a ---tonlllfftllll CoCO•
Eqoollan (3.7),., ... ""- -
VCR • ~Intwl+zl
(UJ
Table 3.2 -•• o tot>uiOIIo<> ot' n110 oi-J 011d z (1110 100 Int-I for the -um oa1ua C11te<lo ,.,., ..... -_ ............. lf1110ota~304oY_..OOC~Iaoion forL.aad loc,_ aa1110 FinaiC!'o<onlcVolua coic<Mfodfrom
tile Ch- oorlcltV dalo l>eM A,_ notad wll!l FCV). Ilion tho val-- In both~lhOYid bo multiplied by the"'"' .... .,._.,.. Mlcllon to -• IO< ....., .... v~obiii!V (EQI>Ooo liOn ~.7) wtlh V equal to 2.l& 1\1.1. EPA, 1111(11. For oum~. tllo 30<Ioy •-ooe L.aad Ctlt~l !Of NM Ycxlo II O.OCI004 oxp(2.35 (In (HOtdiiOII)J whlcll yteldo 1 ¥aluo ol OAei'Gil fo< a hMIMN of~ mQ11 CoCO,. For,,_- In AW<n<ll- C anc! 0 In whtcll lhe lalllllotad :~!>day -oo Cl1t....., lot,,_ olx Chemlcall It - od by ACII CrnMJ>ino the 'falualtlhe QUC>\ .... 1 of the F/W IIIVIdtd by 1110 oc-C~ rtiiO),., o.<l)uat,..,t m•"' bo fl\adO to ..tloclombiel!lllanl ..... tn ,_ ._ Equauon 3.1 o!IOvld bo - .In Whlo!\ tho lol>ulotod 30<1_, ..... lo ouboiJIU1ad lor CR .,., 1M IMUit (VCII) ~ ,,. ~ • .._ (:rit..VW. J;v p~pa., tM ~y .ww.g. c.dmiom ctl'-"on fol ~ v.,._ boO.OOOO OICP(t.OII tn ~11. ...... 0.0000 lalal<onlrom~x Cor o, and t .oe lo 1-from T- U If tile -~ "'"',_ Ia 110 mQII aa C.C00 t11o 3l)doy -ooe c.dnolum cttlottonlot _ Y.,._0.0201'GJ1.
n...,. -chemlcAia(Copporand l..ood)-notlcnol~ •-crtt.na ""'colc:ulalad """''he ___ Of_tlleclwonlctoxlc:ltyiO<CopperiJ~t ol-w- L.aaa to.,__, on hotdMM t- T-2.1~
.. ••
--------_ .. -::. --_ .. ---==. - · ---------------------------;:·· -------
..-. ---- --- --- --- __.,__ ......z__ -L~-.&.... .....1.-....1.--1-_._....l.-._._-'--L-UI • U\ Ut - tM , .. 4UI eA .,_ lll •J• ..- I M , . . ..... .... .. . _. t.a ... . ... ... ' " _, . ... ' " , . • U t Ulf .-ut , .. · ~· . ,. •tt H I . t,_g .. I.G t.a • ' • tat - &H •• • UI . ,. ...., HI .. ... .. l,a, •• _..,. .... - · · ,. .. •• .,. "' ' ·" ... u .. • ... •• _,._. ..,. .. ..- •• - t,u .,. ... •n ~tu .. •• •• - a.a .... ·•• •• ..,, ..,. ... •n · &n aa a.u , . ......... ........ Ml . ... ... ,, .. , .... .... . •• ~~ .,.. _. .... ur .. , ,. ...,. ,,. .. ,..,. ..,. ta •• - &ai ... . ... •• ... . ,. .... "' .... a.N ut •.• · Uf ... -a.•• , . .... . ,. uo ., .. .... , .. ._. ._. - 11'1 .... .. , ., ... . ... . . ,. Ul , , • • • ... ... ta - UI t.M - Ltl t.a U. t.N U l M'J · ' • ... Ul .. .. , ,,. ..... .... •• • I.Jt . ,. ... l,rJ ..... , • • ... :: ::: :: =~= ~ ::: :: :: :~ ::: :: ~~ "' - a.• ... ..._ .. u• - J.JD ' " u r , ., _, .,. .. •• lM . ... Ul · •• ,. • UI tf't Ul U'J • 1.61 aa ... ._. ....u. ... .. ,.., 1.» ur . ,. ut •n . ,_. ... ~~
•• _,. ... · •• •• a.n 411 ue u1 .. ..,., ta ~~ •• -an ... ·t• tM ...... .,. Ul ,.,. · •• .. ur •• .. aa~ ... - w ur "-" , _,. ,.. ' n ·•*' aa ..... .. ........ _..,. ,_. ..... ... ... ' " .... ... .... • • _,. Ulll .. ... u r • UI ' "' ._.. 1 11 · " '' &a .u. • • · U • ..,. .... Ut • I.JI t JII .. '" ..... .... U' . . . .. ft .... _,_. ... .. ... 4.Jt ... ,,. ...... ... '-"' •• - U1 .. • A.H , . - I U t J'I Ul 1 12 ...... &II Ul tjl -IM .... • 1• I . Uf ... &a Vl • &, .. I.U ~ - ut .... • IM IM Ull . .. :t.a l !'t .. , .... &U , . .. ._ .... . .. . . ... . . ._.,_ ),If t.-'1 .. .... .. ,.
... .. ,u. . ... -·· ,_. ..... 1.19 .... " ' .. , .... .. ta _,_. ... • lf" Ull ._.. . ... Ul t n • f .if ... Ul
.. · 6.# .... . . .. ... .. ,., .,. . .. '" ..... .. Ul • • • UI Ut .. ta t_Jt I.H t.A a.- tn · J• ... 1M ta .. ...,. .. -•M ta .._._. VI ._. U l • UI' .. '1;1 \at -4.D .... ......... .. ... . ..... Ul .. ... Ul ....
•• · UI .... · IM ,_. l.1l ' " .. VI · • • ... U l •• .. u. .,. _,., ur .., , ,. u. '"' ·•n ... 1.u .... ....... .... ..... '-»' 1M . ,. .... ' " . , ... ... .. ut - Uo6 ... ... . .... "' '" .._,. ... , ,. .... Ul .... •• .. ...,. "" · •• •• . .. .,_ ._.. ,., ... , . .. an \ • • .._ .... _.._, ta "n ..,. ..,. . ,.. ..... ... a. ta - ..n ._. - a.n •• · •• ' -" ,_ Ul • '-" aa \JI •• _..., ... .. ur •• a.w ..,. J.M , ,. .. ..., ... a.u , . __.. Ull .... •a U1 ._,. ... t ..Q • UI .. 1.\1 Ia! ........... ....... .. . . .,. .. ._,, ....... .. ~ ... ...., .... . .. Ul ..,. .. .... ut _,. .. .. ta · UI ... • Ia! ut ..... t.N Ul .. , · fa .. a. Ia! • U"' .. • UI , . • UI ._,. Ul l .lt .... ,, .. , .. ............... ·--........ ..,.._ __ ._ ...... .__ ......
.. ............. -~---
SECTION 4
DISCUSSION The mlnlmlltn Gala ,.qulrement, '-"'Cf'l •u cliecUIMd ..ntw, aP«Jt'-• t~tei\Y tNt re&UI~ for at
..... IIOhl dltter.nt famiiM. The In tWit of thi61WQUk'emeont l1 to UIUrt t~t ttw CWOIIIItmt oont~ In • cdttofion ")out.tk>n r1tpf'tMnt 1 ~eriety of dlt-'mller organltmt oommonTy found In the t QUatlc lnYir<>n"*'t. tllo cai<:UIIIk>n lloolf II porlorm.d on IM four moat MniW ... OIIM OIQ~t l""'lllel wllloh 110 -"""to .. uory tM minimum dlto _1.......,1.
o.o.t 11000 CUM...,.,. conlldlftd In thta thldy In on»r to rea~l&te ct'ltlfla fof nett of 21 Chem~Jt f«MC:h of 41tlt.tn.. The mt"lmc.Knd&la ,..qul~t c:oukf not tM HlleUtd In 01 ~~or ~~ ~nalloot or at.et• eod dtem~l •••!Tttned.tn tonM ceen. t~ rn1nlm1.1m 41t.e. H-. c:annot 1>e rMt ACCOf'dh~ 'o thf Rtttat~ on apeelea dtelrlbuuon, for •wnl)~. -ll.li'nortlde 1~ a... not I~ In foot ttt,tM: Fbtd&. teanua, Mttalulp;pt arw:s teuL
For ~ c.... In whk:tl tM minimum Oata beN couki not be aatltfled. c:titetta W«t caiC1Jiatld ~P*eM u t'*-wu Information evalllbltl on 11 ._ .. ,tow famtNH. 1l)ert were tO Qhrlmlut• tor whkh toxJchy tNt CS.ta were tva1Jab61 f« at Maat tou, t•mm .. ln t act! alattt. F« many ttat ... - · -....,. II'OIIfltc:tont d1t1 f<>< 1M fl-4 ..,.,lllnlr>Q cnlll!llcoto ~1<:. ChlonSinl,IUI!In,l.Md and ~tO lj>9ly till mi..., !Mt!>ocfo!OII)I.- I IW" Ct\lorlonCOUI<l not boca4> culatoct. tM nalloool C<ltorlon wu -oct. This -urrodln _..,,lmlllly lf'"IJO!te!11 ol ti!O.,.... ...... ,_
TM ~·•-' .w. I'NX)mum wah ... ~en• are ~ q~.~t~UtaU...y *'11'1 1M nalklnll v• luee In table .t.1. 11'"4 the lekray •*• ¥tlu.t.,. ~ Jn 1'abM •.2. h"l ~ng 1 along .. c.homl<:l~ IM ttale c<Korlo lind to bo attllof p<oclomln~~~lly ...,.. llrlr>Qiftl 0< ~nanlly -t trt..-.t than the Nflonal •-' .. for 1 gtv.n c»llutant. "The r~~Qfeutated etltltta .,. IT1Cft t111noet~t It'
116po<""'t ol IM - · Tht •l•t• "').clflc ctltetla Whlel\ ..,. e.aJc.ut• ted aH•r rwno~ttno ~~~ famlllet .,.
~ted In A~ C by c'~lcal and In Aol*ldt, 0 by at1te. to e.ch ceM tht ~uonaJ cfltef'f• ancs the eta1• crn.,ta ..,.. tibt.Aat.ct togetMf •ltn tnt tu;.mt.r of tamllltt '" rhl naUOtW data bul Wl'lk:h are fftkSel\1 In a o•wn ll_ate, and tne nama of tM tOUt familia VMd 10 rKalcul•te tf'lt ctllerta. n.. national I vatu. wu UMd N 1 etaN value whentWIIr ffttfflf trwt 'our f.atnttl• ._.,. ayaJIIOHt.
The lnformaUon In theM ~IGH. which lhoutd be of frnmedlatt UM to HM atetet, telleote the otant of Jnd the llmttttiOnt lmpoaed by the natloneJ d1ta bulat conttllutec:t wMn thtawott( wu dono. Tho nalloolll dill- It not • flnl.- produd by"'"""""""-· anc1 EP.., II conUflUO!IY addln; now tnl......,tloo.
Fort~ c .... in,.r,lcf1 1.he 'f'lttlmumoata req\dr~t waa nat ullll*l, lf'lt.adc:UUOn o• \Oldc:ity <fat. tor new famlliH 1hould l11tprt'OII'* lM quallry ot I'IC&Icu~ted tllt~Ufe Crlt.t"L Gtw.n the l~rQ* numblt ot ~nalh)nt of alate ~ dWmlcal tOt Which the mlnlmum data requtremtnt eoutd not be f'tHK, It le no1 Ilk.,) thet the n.atlonal Oatt baM will eoon a. ••t.netvt enQU9h to.....,. all u'* t tat•• tor lll lho iol<lc ohlml<:llo. Thlo boloo 1111 COM. • otalo might lind It oJU>ocl...,t to nm -oct-yo II\ Otdtf ,to &ugfMf'lt tht dAt• tw.M for • tpeolflc: pollutant. By compiling tht ~fnh'nu.m data Nqulr• mont wlltl IM lnformllton In ~dl• E. ola" b4olo;lato ono.dd bo ol>lo ,_lly to dot""'lno 11-f&mll ... fot which ~WONII to~t~lty tnt r.tulle lie lncUcet«<.
---... _ ----_ .. ------·· ------........ -- ·· ----------....... ------..._ -------·-, ...... -:r4 --
- · ···--·- -· - ·· -- · - -·. - · - ·- ------- ·· -- · -- · -- - .. . -.. - --. .. - . . -. - - . ..
- .... - . - .... ... . - . - . . . .. .... -- - ·• - - .... - . - .. . . .. . .. .. .. - .. - - .. - .... .. . ... . .. - • - •• - - - - - - •• - o- • - ... - •• -- · --- · -- ·- -·- · · -. .. . . ...... ... - ..... .. .. . . . : : : : : : : : : : : ~ : : : : : : : : : .. 0 ... .. . . ... - - .. . 0 .... ... 0 ••
.. . - . . ...... ... ... .. . .. -.. - . . . :::::::::::::::: : :: : ! ---··- ------ --- --- ... . ... .. -.. ...... - - .. ... - .. ..... -. -- ..... - - - .... .... -- . - - . -.. - .... ...... ........ -.. . .. . -.. . -.. -- ... -.. . ... .. . . . .. .. .... -- ...... .. - ... .... ..
•• - ... .. .. - • • • t • - .. 0 .... . . .. .... ... - .. - ... ... .. .. ... - .. · - ----- -- - ··· --- - · · - ··· . . .. .... .... .... .. . ... ...... .. . .. .. . ... . . ... . -.. - .. . - .. .. .. .. -- .. .. - . .. - .. -- ... . . - . . . .. .. -- .. --. .. - . .. . . .. .. . - - -- - ..... . . . . -.. -- .. -- -.. - . . . . .. .. .. - - - .. - .. .. . •· .. - . .. .. -- - - - - ... -- . · · - ' · --·--· · · · · -- - -·· . ..... - .... -... .... . . - ..... . . .. .. .. .. - .... .. .. .. ... ... - .. -----.......... ~~~---............ ,.....,.._ - .. __ ...., _____ .........,..._ ........ OIIWIOn
0 .._,.... __ ,_..._ ....... 1 _ __ ..,.._.,..._.
.......................................
--------,...,. ... =----_ ..
-----· --_ ..
----------_,_ _..._ ----t:~ .... ._ -·-.... -------.... ._ ..... ._.~ ... ----. ._...,_..,._. ............. """ ............ - ..... -... .... .. ............... , .......
IIEF£REHCE8
llou,..,n, R.W., o1 al. "Tho~ Stone filM (Pieco91"") of U.. Rocky Mountalna, Me<nc>IB of ""' Am.ttc.n Eni0111040Q~ Society," 00 N.-nba<, 1m.
ao..oflold, E. L, F'"hwll« Alnphlpod CNtl_,l ol Glacl&lod Nof1h Amo~ .... Tha canadian fltld· Nllllllllo~ Vol..,. 72. No. 2, -~113. Al><fi.J..,., 1168,
.,_,.,..,, ~ oncl Jommlnaon, B .. Aquallc 01,__. ollhl Wotlcl, 011- on<l Boy<t, Edkll>ufOh, 11171.
&-., J.l... ~ Syatomallco 01 "O<Ih ~ ()opMI&. lol-.. ollhl ~1®1 _,.of Artl one SCI..,_, 1/olumo XIII, H-.ba<, llkl7.
B<lrl<o, 8. 0., Tha Ml'/flloo 0< ~.,. oiiUinoia, B<ll11lln ol thlllllndl Natural HIIIOI"1 ~. Stoll of ltllndl, Olpll1mont of AQHcuhUfl 1n<1 Educallon, lolay , tlkl3.
Edmun<lo, Cloo<go F., ol II. Tho~ May!! ill of North an<l C<tntraiAmlrlco, IJn""!Oity o!Min-PIMa, lolln-lt. 1Vl'e.
em--. WX, an<IJ-. M.K., ThiAmo,rcan -moll!llural III._GulclltoSha41t.AI!rod A, ki1ol>f, Inc, - Yo<1<. 181'f.
Fltchot, F. C. J ., r ,rchopiOIONm C.talogua, VolUme 0/, M~cnldoo Atc-ychldM, N_, ..... achl Enlomo4ogiiCill Vt<oonlglnQ, Amalonllm, 111113.
llobbl, II.M .. C<ay!lehll (Aotocldll) of NO<Ih 1n<1 Mldcllo .......,. .. llloco of F101hwaler Ecoe,.toma ldonttncatlon Manual No. II fa< EPA, May 1872.
11ollhuo, LB., /lo General ~lon of thl PaiMrnor>ldM o1 lhl AtneHeu, 11. Tha 6ublomlly Pll-ldll, IJnl ... ally of Soul~ C.II!O<nla f'ml, loa AnQolta, catll«nla, 111(12.
Hotal.,, J.Fl. ~ Freahtlia'\tr Atr\pt\II)Od CNI\JCMf'\1 (GammlridU) o, North Amtflca, BiOta ot F-watt< E-yaloma ldlnllllcatlon Manuel No, ~ lor EPA, Apfll, 11172.
H'ymM, LH., The lnwriet>rat .. , Vofume Vt, Moflute.a I, M~Gfaw-HIII, 1087 .
Kink, R .. Pwoonll COmmunication, DMalon of WO<mo, Mu-m ol Natural Hlatory, Smlthlonlon ,,.. ttllute,
~ D.S .• •• at. ~Uu o, North ""*1can Ftwrtwtler Fie-. Hor'ttl carotin. Sttf• flluMI.Ifn o( H•tUflll Hlaoory, 1880.
MMttt, R.W., and CUmmlnt, K.W .. M Introduction 10 tNAqlUIIIc lnMCtl ot North·A.meric.&, Thlrd Prln· linQ, 1\ondoiiiHunl P\Jblllhlftll COmpany, tll71 (od.~
Ponnll<. R.W .. FnrOhwote< 1....,11><1111 of thl Uftltod StitH, JOhn Wlloy & sono, 1111e.
"'
• I
REFERENCES(C~~
8WI<, B.P, and Gal"!>, A.A., Tho -leO....<'*- ~~ 01_.._.. _..,. lion ol !he El>IOmOIQolcAI Soolooyol-, YOI- 10, No. 1, 10111.
UJI. ~IAl-- AOoUIOo <'* llwlllptOno .,_,.. Notlh ol foM•Ioo.AQt1Gu41n H-Ho. 2111. U.S. Dopeltmont ol AQt1GoltUI'O, AIIOutl lteiS,
UJ1. ~lal -ton ,ogoncy, O-IO<Do<M111JSI-IIIc Wall< Oualtl'f Cit- tor 11M~-oi-Uc Ulo _,ltl UNa. 1tt2.
UJI.--ial-lo<l Agoncy, .._.,, Wat• Quality Crllorial«~. EPA-. 11180.
U.S.--Iow>~. W-ClwH!yQ!-- 'I-alllll()l(<5ffl7'1318.il8 - . 1111101.
UJI. Emt,_,lal -oc:tlow> ~. o..ldal- tor Do<M1111- Quail()! Crt- 10< lila-llo<l ol Aquatic U.. (4SI'1l21e0&, II M~, ! 078) and (W'RI~ ~ July, 1811).
U.S.--ton AQaolcy, Wot•Qoe~l'( Q!IO!Ia Doc""*"o: A .. tlablllly (44FA1-. 15 - . l!PI).
UJI. --lal ~ AQancY, O...Ony Crlletla fo< - · I07e. W011o«, E.N, Ttto OdonaiO ol c.nada and AOUka,llnl..,.ll'f ol T"""'1o -.. 11153.
Wll'd, H.B. and Wlpj)lo, O.C., F--lllolooY. - EdHton, le72.
Will- w. o, F_,., -IAM!tldMiol ll<>nli ~- ol .--"'"' eooavot-ullcallon ...,..a/No. 7,- 10< EPA, W~, 1el2.
""-....................................... ~-..,.--..., .... -"-'....,_..__ .. .. ~ .... AINI'Ihn ..... ... _...,_ _ _ ~ ...
=:-':=..':'~-..:.."::!:':. =. ::.:::.:-..:.--:: ~""'•oe..-...a......-....,. .. __........,.._.......,.._..., .,..-. .. .-.....~ .. w __ ....,...._....,. .._,...,..._....,.....~
""' __ ........ -...._.WI!Ic-M.,._....,_.,_.,,,_,.__ :--~::oc:'r:;:.,e::::;r--~~.,=c::::=.-.: w---.o.c...-. ...... . ,,__, .. _._..,._f!Oifl .... ..._ .. ...... .,..,_. .......... .....,. ....... ................ . .... ....... ...... ~--1'1 ...... .~ ............ .... .. .,.,u. .. ............... --- 1"* -- ------ - - --~NTJ'MIMWIIW• ·- -- - --- · -=-- --__ ..
..__..... - -- ---~ ... --- - - --- =~ -=- - --· ~~-- - - --... -· -· "::""" - --- ·- ·-- --- -- ~-- - --- ----.----" tWX. --- .... - · --~
·--- - -- -·- ---- ----t ii .. Q --~ --· ---- ~ -"';'- -·- -- ---·- --- --........... _ .. --~MDIIISII6t .... - ~ -" - -·--·- -
-----------· ---== =------------==J!IJ!!Ig ------== ~ . . --------
-· ~ .... .-..-.--.ft:,_.,._.,.....,.,.. -· _.,_,.._.. __ .,,.....,........,~.~ -- -- --- ·--- - - - - - - - =--- - --- -- - - -- - -- _,. -- -- --- - -- ..... -- -- --- · - --- -- - ._ .. b!l!!!!!>! ... -- --- .. _ ... _ --- - --- ===- - -- -- --- - -- --- - -- - - -- -- - ----- - &:-.:. - -- -- --- - -=:- - - -· ........... ~.._.., - - - -- - -- -- --- - ..... -· -- ~-- - am.wlll> llmili!IEl"f"""*-=. -- -- -·- - ..... =· ~ -- --- - -- ..... -- =-·- - - -- - - ·-- - -- - -- - -- -- ,_ -- --~ - - -- - -- --- - -- --- -- .... _ -- "'"" ~ -· -- - ...... -- "'="" ~ -- --- oo::;- "'==" __ .. -- -- --- - -- - 11:1!1111 -- --.. _ - - -·- -- - -- --- -- - - .,., - """' - Z.:l:- - -- -- '==-- -- --- - - -- -·- --- - -·- -- - --- -· -=- - - --·- -·- -- -- -- - =:.-,_ __ -- -- --- -- - - -·- -- -- ---· -- - --- - -· - -- - -- - ·- -- - --- - -- - -- -- =-- ----·- - _ .. -·- - -- --- === - - -- -·- -- -- - - -·· -- - --- -- - =:=. -- .::-.:. - - -- -- - --- - - - -- ,_, ,_ -- - -·- -- - -- --- - -·- -- -- --- -- -- - -· --- - -- --'"'" - - -- ....... _ -- -· - - -- - ....,.,..,.. ::.=. ... -- --..... - -· - ==-- E?.i.. '-==- - -- -- -- "'==-' - -·- --- - -- -·- -- - --- ·- -- -- --..
- - -------- ----------- -------- -=---=--= e:--------------
~
~
l . : : .. ,. q
ll ~ " .. :: " " .. . . " . ~ " : . " : ~
: ; .
' l . . ! :': " .. :: r. : :r .. : . . : . ; : : "' . ! .. : : : • . :: : : ::
_ .. - .. --~filii!-... ,..,~ ... _.,._. ...... ..,. ...... -· , ... ,. -· -- ---- --- ----- - ·-=- ... - - •• - -l .. . .. - ~ -- - :j .... . .. = ;: - -- -' ... . .. i 5 § = - -.. .• . ., .. 5 i § = . .. . .... = ! - - ... . .• . - = = = a = :! ~ . - -- ~ 5 -. - ... ... ::
~ ...
§ -~ :: .. li: : ... = .. i : .. § ij = .. . ... = - :: = .:: - . .. :e ~ ::: . = ... .
j s = i -- s .. " .. : :: § 5 :: .... ~ - :: = .... : ..... 5 ! - - j
= ~ .. - = 5 s = i5 s s = : - = ::: -:; .. -.: ::: - ... .. ... .. . ....
§ = ~ :: I -= = :! .. 1t:: . ...
~ i . .. .... = ! = ~ = a .... : ..... = . ::: ... 5 E '::: = =:! = .:: . .. .... -. - : - ... s g s 5 = ~ ... - = i! ~ .:: . .. .. .. ....
~ . ... :; "· :: § .§ 5 i .. ~ ~ • .. .... e $ g -. .. " - -" ... .. ... .. .... ... ...
~ -- .. ,. -• ... ~ .... ~ ~ -= . - . ... = § 5 § ~ = : .... . :: i s .. . = .. .,. : ... - - - -,. ... .... ~
.. . .. .. § ~ -" ... .. ...
~ - 5 = § § -" .... . ... ,, - . .... = = = . :: . .. ':: = .. ,. . :: -,. .... . ~
.:: .. ... 5 ... ,. - . ....
~ ~ ! § -= ., .. : - e § = = ; - ... - i : ... . - . .. ... - ~ - ~
... i ~
... = .. ::: :t: ii ...
.:: .:: -.. = e ... " .... - .. :: § ! = ,. .... .... = = i 5 5
,. ... = -= - :e - = -= = = - .. ..
_ .. --. ......
- - - p;;; • - _ .. ...... - - -.-..-.~~ ... - ::: -= -- ::: = = '::
~ -i 5 =: ... ... - -§ = a E ~
.... ~- - -~
= :a ::: - ~ 5 -= = ::: - = i = e * .e g 5j i = - ~ i! 5 a .1: ::: t: 5 - E = :a = = s: i
I = ~ I = - - :: = :: = = ~ ::: 5 i a i F: i i
::: .:::
~ .• ~ ~ a 5
J: .:: :: e s ! :: ::: ~ :: :: =
= ::: ::: = i i = :; 5 5 :::: § 5 :: ::: = = = = ::: :: .:: -a ::: = 5 ... .:: r. .::: =
.. = = = ~
.::
I 5 i :: ! .1: g :: ~ = = 5 g ~ e :: 5i i §
:::
~ a = ~ = = ::: i = e :: :: = ~ = § i = = ~ e :: ::: j 5 i 5 !i - 5 = .::: ... ::: .. ... a ::: = ,; =
::: = g .:: ::: - .. = :.: g ~ f: i! §§ ~ " g § g 5 ! :::
~ j§ :j 5 = 5 ~ 5 ~ :: s ::: !i = = = :: ::: s - '::
= = s ::: = .:: :1 .:: .::
j -.. a -i -r: = - -= ~ = = e = = ! - e e g - - - .. s s = = = i .. = ::: :a :: ::: ::: :: ::: = - '::
:::: -~ :: ~
§ ::: - ~ I i .§ i ~
.. .. ::: = 5 --= s s .. 5 = -
= = ::: 5 g s = = -= = :: - :;:
~ ~ i § s a i = -· - - - - -~ .. ! i ! I i i i ... .::: = § 5 = - -:: = = ~ ~ 5 = - - - -= :a :: = - - § i - .•
.!: ~ .. = g -g ~ ~
= :: = - = - - - .. ':: - - - - - ::: -::: = = :: = - .. =
...
--- ----
..
-N ... .._._ .... _._ _::z.::;:-L:.-__ .., __
.: ;.:.:J .: .: .:.:: ... ......... : :::::::·· . : ,.:.:.: ~: .: .::: :::::::::: ~ .:~.:.:: .: .:.:: :::s:::::: , I t J J I ! I I e
ESis:!!i;; :::::::::: :•·"······ o I I 0 I I I I I a
.: .:.: .:.::.:.: .:; == :::::::: I I I 0 I I 0 I I • a:s:::::::
------------------
----------
-----------.-------- ·--
- -.... ...... :···· .:.: : : '::·· . , .. :: •·· ... ::::
j .! JJ= • :! : . .. I It f I I I • •
.:,: ~~ ~J; : • If
.1.:~.: :: ~:::
, .... .. ... . ,:::::::,.:: ; ....... :. ;:;::::::: : :::::: :•· .•....... ~ : .... ' ... .. :a a a I I a .. fl. ........... ~ .: ;: .:~-:::;.: J I .. a a a a a a a ..... ..... ...... •• • I I o I I I I .. .. ... .
.: .: .:: :J :.:: :: ...... ..
~·-_, __ ----·....-------_...._ __ ------------
-------
-N --~· ... ---- -
~ .:.:.:.:: .: .:.:: :::::::::: I I I o I ~ 0 I I • ; :::::;::: -· ····· I o I I I II a a * • .. .... . ··•······· .......•.. I f I I I I I I. 00
:: : :::: :~:. . . ..•..•• • ' •••• t • • • :::::::::: :::;:::::: .... .. ~ ... •·••••· ··· ... . ~ ... ... . .•••.... • ..... ...... : ::::::::
-
------..-..--------.._ __ _
------------
-:= - -.:: :::: ::: , .... .... §5i
. ' ... ::::: ..... ... ~ .:.: : .: .: .: : ::= ::::: .;..::: ~ : .. ··· • f .... . . .. . ...... ...... ........ . ..
0 I I 0 t I I I I e . . ... . .... .. .•...•••. .......... .......... :::::::::: SiS~~;s::: • • t • • • • ••• .•........ : ::::::··· .... .. .... :::::::::: • t • • • • • • •• . .. ......... : :::::···· : :: .:.: ;.:.:;:
:::::::::: . ' .. .. ~ ... ·······-
..
_ .. -~·TMI-·A-
.: .: f. ' ...... ,: J ~.: I t I t t ~
i! =::::::: .. .. .. .. . . ..... ..... . .. .. .... .. . .... :::::
::: · · .. .. . . .. ::::: ... .. . ...... ::::: ... ..... ::::: ::::: :::· · : .: :.:: ::::: ::"··
t I I t • ::::::
.. . .
I I J 4 5 I 7 I I tO II II 1114 13 tt 11
• ,.,.....,... .... ,, ,.,.,...........,.,_
_..,... _____ __ 1. 1!.-.rtr...._ .... _~
· o..-1--. ---~ ao._...,... .... ..,._~
•I•'$'Cr•
~ •
............. - .... .....,_.,-.,._._
._.!. f---!--
t ::=.-.::=:.=-~~-=-:=:..---...... ----· .. --
, .. 104b "' !>lid ..
I I • • 1--'-
3(0W.._. ••
• .._ __ .. 01101.- CIUCA1'1CM
-· -- ----· __ ... _ - ----- -- -· ----· -- - --
.. - ·----------·---. -----·-' -==:==:.:==---!!0:!=---
- -- -· -- ------ ----· ---
. · -·~ --.. -----·-----: :~~-..........
RECALCULATION OF STATE
TOXIC CRITERIA
~Fot:
8y;
u.s. Enwronmentol Protection Agency 0111 .. of Water Reg~lallona and Standarda Criteria and Slan<lardlo OMolon <401 MSifMI,SW Wuhii'\QIOII 0C 204eO
Mlng P. W~ Suo A. !jonton-Welton Larry A.-nor
Camp Dfuur & Mcllee 1830 UUio Rl- Turnpllle Annandale VA 22003
Contract No. ~1-&103
___ ._.
- --._.._. __ _ - --
~-----··-= ===-""='--.-.. -··---;g =--:;.""'=--! ....
---·-.. - --·-
. --·----.. _ ...... ---·---. -------' ·==-=·-===--.... ..... ,.,...
--------. . -
------ ~;:;
= ~ :: :: ; !5
I i =
I ~
I
::r::---... . -;;. ,_;e
-:. ::==:::--:!.-__ .. ____ _ ;; --=--,_,--
____ , -'¥ .
. ~- .. - -···--·--·---. ----·-·-. . =::::::=---................
----· - -- ------ -------
. ·- ·----:- :~~=----=====--
---- - -..--. ----- --- .......... ~ -i
= e;;;: I =-
= § = ==- 5
·~· ..
I § = a
·1!!5: i == § ;; = e
§ = == ~ = 15- = =- :5 ::::
---- ==-~ e -: ==-= =
. ~------... ·----·-----. .. ----·-. ... ----==--- -
-=. § !! ! = I =
..._. ""= ~-::::. !!! t tl ·=· ----
....
-· ~ .. , .. f!OII ....... ,.._.f'C'-R~ .... --
----· -- ==:--:-'::. . -
...
~-----·· ·~=~"£----___ ....,....,
------ ----- -
:. ==-===--=--=-----: :~~=--.....
- ------
II I f t I I I I f I f I t I I I I I I I I
b-J I I'! I I I I I! I J I I' I I I s
II t I f ; I I I I ; ; ! I l ; ; I ; f I I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . il· !SJ!III!!!!!!!I!IS!!I!I!I!m!lll!l!l!l!l!!!lll'lll'!!l!l!l!l!ltl!l!l!l!l!l!!!l!
I I
!' lltllltlddlltllllllltllltllltU~IIItldlldtllldlltllltllltldtldtU~Uitl I, I ~ . ~ .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . . .. . . ~~~~
I I I I "1111 til• I I I I I I I ! I I I I I ~ I I I I iMil
I !'' t ( ( I I I I t l
f II· ! ; 1 ; l ; 1 I 1
1 It· ! : j i i i i ! i 11· 'llllllllllllllilllllliiiiHIIIIIIII I
!' lltlltlltlllltlllllllllllllllldlltl •I II - - - . . - - - .
I I I l•l!tll .11
-· ____ , ---- -- ----· -~--- -- - -- -=-- ~ ~ - -- - -- -:-- ~ ~
e:::-. =-- : == -- .. g _.... . == . = ·= . =-. =-=-
-~ . =--- . ~ ·= w = . == . -. -It == ;::::;-. ==-
- , .. ·--- " -e e I :: :: ·: s . s:.-!5 .•. - - -
; ::. : : - : ;a: - "" -- "' _i'ii5--5 ·- - • if::EL.. $ ·- - - :==" = ===-§ .• I .. ~ :: = 5 ·-
1 :: = .... ::
5 ::. ~ -;;:
§ .• - -
··-- --- ·- --·---·----I "f":'----- . ------- I = e-::::t::. .. --- : =~~=-----,....,.... ____ ...,.
§ :: . : : 5 1 11'1
~ :: i ...
I :: = ·-=
----~ ----- -----
~----.. ·= ::..:::=----; =-..,.,-=--
! =.
! :.. ==.:::::-...:.-=....-... -. .. .. ---··-. ·==-=-..::=:r-e--.ee-
-- -· -- ---- ----------
. · •- • -": __ _ .. .. _ .. ___ , ___ _
. ··-... ----· ··----==----
-- ---- -----------l i
I ~ ~
i
-- ---- --=--~ ------
! §·
- · to:aenn,•u ""'*,._....,....,.ftC~ ICIM'WII\, ..-~ -----·-· --... -------- ...=-..:.. ------ --------·
.,.. --:. ==.:.=--..::.:...-=-----: =~~-===-=--
-· ,...,..,,.,_..._...na~..-.--. ... ~
--=-~ ------- ~-----
-
----·~ - --
-:. : ::"':..=-..:--===-=---.. ........ -.:...-
- - - - -· ~_.,.,.,_.,.....,no.,.~•-------- - -
"":""1!"------·· ·!=~~---"" _...., ___ __
-----· - - -------
-------
~----···====---; =---:..-:...,.
------...
~
I I I
- · ~.,., ..... ._.. .. ~ ..... 'NY'W..,....,"~ -- ----- - --·-----::::::::: = a =! =- ~ = ~ ~ = = e = a = =
~ = ~ - ~
~ -· - .:: - = -· - == - :: -· -- ~ =. m :. =~e=~:-__ _ ... ___ .............. ~~ ~E~~.;: --===----
-- -· ~ .. , ..... ~,...1'1C .... ~IIf~
-----' -----------
-
--= I 11 • I
:. :~~==~:-__ _ ------
-- --
----
_____ ., - --- ---- --
-
..,
- · ~ .. ,.,..,_... .... ..0~~·~ -- ------ ---=---=-···
§F. ! Q.
5iE=- if 3!':: § -· =-- ;s =- = -~ ti S!F a ==- '= = ~ :::::-
~ =
~
I
!§.
= ~ =
I I a
---- ------· ----- ---- ----· - --
. ··-·-'"- --.. - --·--·----~-: ===--=-=-.:..--·--···---........ ..,
----- ---
. --·---·· -----·---. --------·-------.-·--......... -
~
I I =
--------- ____ , - --
-§
=- = -=
-- ---- ----------
. --·----., . .. ....... ---·-----: =:-::.:=:~=--_.....,,__
-- ---·-· --
~-----.. ·= :::::.oo::. __ .. ___ .. __ ;: ;;...,-:;.p-R"'E,.,.
--=--..=.
. -------.. --.. ----~---. -----·- -' -:::--=::-=:.---........ -
-------
-
-· ""'*'" .. u._~,....,.t'IO..,......._.,_.
~-----··-====---; =--;;.;:.-.,.
------ --= = 5 = = ==
I 5
- -- --=--..::::... .:=--:-e=. '. ... . • .. ! .. l •
!E ·-;: = :::::.
;: 1: !t= ·-·-- 1:.:: ==- r.;
==. Iii § l§ == l! ===- :r.:
li1: !ili!5?" m::
1::::
i li :: ~~ =- ~~ ==-55. :::::
=- i5 - II ==-=.
~ ~~
___ _,
- -.. .. .-,.-=-'2::':' •.• -:;::- --- ____ , - -- -------. . ~
---· ----· -- - --
. _,_. ___ _
.. --·---·----. _,. ____ ..... ' -=:.::-::=.=--....... -
----- ... -. . ~
-- --..:-.:.. ------- ------~
1: - .. ii = = !i a= e ==:... !$ a
I i:: itt = ii ~ .
i5 I! =
I ~ ji = li ~ §
I ,_ i! = 1: :e I! i! !i
=== ::
~ ·= :: ii = t:
~ !I = §:: 15 t.
m--- . ·-··- ---- .. . ----·----==·--- : ==-_--= __ - __ ., ... -.:z.:.__ ~~em--ur--~~--~--------~~---~~---~------------_J
- · ~ .. f .. ,.,_.,__.NUI'f~rf--- -----~ - ~ ------- -~--=-
:. :=.:.=- ·-=--=----: = ~-::!:5.c..-
--...... --
-- ___ _,
--,_ ___ _ ---. . -
. __ .. ___ ._ :- ::--===-~=-----. 4 ___ _ -·-~----........ --
- · TOaan"M'" ,...,_....,.._.6ft~f'fm ... -- -------
_._._ .... __ _ :· =~i~~r -~---1 . -==-=:=....---
---
..
-· n.m"MtAf'll:.~._..ftOWW_..,.., ..... lt ____ , --·-::
5
-
-------. . ·~
. ....... ---.. -===--=-_.......,. .. _ .. _ ... ,.._ ;;;;...,-;;.;-..,. ..
-- ------- ...... - - · ~ .• , ...... ._.._ .. ~Lft~ ...... .,.._
----· ---·-- ---- -- -· ------ - -
:· :i~----1 -·-·~ .. --. .. ----·--.,---·-
-------
-· ~ .. TA,_,_,...._ .... ~"Iftaft
..... - -· ------liN-------- ------- ----- --·-.- ~
:· 'iitf----, -·--·· .. ---• -=::::::::=.:--- ~-----~ -~ e-~~-,_ __ e....,._,.,. ...
I I
- · ~ .. , .... ~,.....,., .... .,... ..... ,,. --- ...=-.:.. --=-~ .::;:--'=;=-~ .:r..:. --=--~ .:=--:;=-=:. - - .. _ = ..... - - ·- - · - :: ....
- .=- . = .... ._- - .. § =~== -=- 5 -- ::- ·.=_= i5 - · - --- := -· - -
~ -· --·- -::: :!§ ~ -· - -- - • a::::: 1i ... . ._. -
- .~ = .... --- - ·=" i - · .. ,.. .... . a -i .. ~ . - -- - .& I - · - -- .s = - · .._ .. - - . = == ·-. - -. . i. _-.. . - -- ·-= -- .. - ._.__ = -· - -==- = - . ~.....-..=··· .._.
- .e -= -· =- = - :_ ~~ ~ :·: - -==== :: - ·e:.. 5 ..... - -
IJJJllli§fJGffGI
-· ~ .. , .. ..,.,__.MIImCWl~ ,.., ... "
-.. ----· -------------.. . .. - - .. ....__ ~ -· --e!Olt .=.. == ~ :: : :
--- .. §==' ,s .... . --- ·=- ~ ·- - ·- ~ -· -.... ·= = -· --,_ - ·-- E --· ---,_ . = ~_:-___ = :: -: : -- ·~ - ·~ ~ -· - -- . ::-:.... = -· .._ -
- · =.. ~ ....... -- -- . =- ~ .. . --...... . ==- s - · - ---- ::- : =-=- -= :: : :
=' == ..... - ·=- 5 -~
- ·::: 5 -· - - v~ ; - · - .. - ·=- s -· - ..
-· ---- ---------------.·e.= .... . _.,
2 ..... ·- -==. =
--- --- ----·--. ----- ----
4f4f'-----· · -===-~ ·---·---;; =r--;;,-;., ..
- · .,.., .. , .... .._ ....... ftCI ..... ~ .. .,."
-- ----· --~- ----· ------- - ___ _ ....,. -------·- · ~ ·.. ·==-=-·==- ~ ·a = ·- :a: = ·-===- =
=-:::: ·= -·- =!;; .a -·= ~ . ;;:.
iiiio iii . == 5::_ ·==-
:~_ i . E:! '= 5 =---=
!· :~~-:.!--·-···----. ·~=.-:=::.::---
-· ~Mta,....._,_....,-cwe.~"'"aft
-----· ----- ... ___ ___
-~'§-._. . ==·=== ===-
--·--. --·-·= = :: :: =
--------· fODCinMfa,..,_.....,.,...nc&.R~I'¥'1TAft ____ , ---------·-
·, ~- a : ~ ~_i .==-. = =- = •§. = :- ~::---~ ·= .--- :.:
';; .-.- --= ·= :=:=·!,. ·.·:: -~
·5 _:_:: . === -·- ·'=
'"!""!"~~:..·---· .. -= =:::=-- -£ ==.;;...e .•
-· ----· -- - --
. ::::;'.:-:e·-.5=.;.:;:. 'ee.
~·--.. ···- ·--:· :~~t~r.:F---• ~ ==..=:::::---=---
----- - ·-. . -
----· ---· ~ ....... ._..,.. .................. ...
:· :ii~----- 1 -·- .. ·--·---·--·- u•---
----· - --- · ~-Tot·fiOI-----~1'10""-. ... """
..... -·-.::=-=
~ .. .. .i!
-- ----· ...... ._ - ._. __ - · ~~t&r•..,.~........-..clft~ .. .,.,.
--------- ----· - -·-c:e:-·=== ·== .§ ·=w5: :;; ·=-. ;;;::.. := :=--·= = ·= • ==: .m ·=-~ =.
i·=ij=j=---- 1 -·--·,·---. .. ::::..=::::::.=:---
------
-· ............... .-... ........ ~_,_, ... .,.." - · """"' .. n,_._.,_...._,..,.~rr•u" ....... ----· - --- .::=-":=-::. . . - --... ----~ . f§:_ -=
~-----.... ===--:::.. _ _,_ _____ _ •;.,.-=--:-.-
~- : ~j-~_:";:- __ , ;. =~fr---- , -·-·~·---• :::::--=::.-:::::.:::---
- · "'-"' ... ,. .... ...,..~ .... ,.. ... .,...... ....... -- ___ _, -- -- ---------
-:. ::r::-=:-..==.-___ _,_ .. __ ,._ ;. =--;;..-._ ......
·-~~... I -·- ll.,. __ _ ;· ===== ----. · ===-=~--
-- ----·· ------------·=-,=..
]§-i :~.. I .:.p. =-= ·===-·=- ~-~ . ::_= ·=-=- -= • ==="-, =:::-- -----.= ·=- 1 . - ___ ;;_-_ . ::::::=:: ::: = -
----· - ---·--
_,___..,_. ---. . -
_____ , -- ~----- ------- ...... _ ----· - --·-.. ==- .,. =:. §
- · -...ern .. , .. ,..,__,. ...... ~ ............ "
------- ----- - -. . ..
-----=--~ -------·= . ;;;;;: --=-
.. §
~===--=--==-=-=·--==--=..-......
-- -· ------ - -- -------- ..... _ - · ~ .. t ..... ._...,.,...11C'"~'"m11
~----... = ===·----; ;;.;:,-,. .. :· =~@~---~ -·--~··---• . ::::--==:.-=::.---
----· - -- __ ..,_ ---0 0 0 ----- -- --------0 0 o o
-___ ._._
---• • oo
· ~, = = =
·~-----··-~- ~l:.---... -C'lo .....,III!!P,......,..,..
-· ----· -- - -- ----------0 0 -
. ; !I
I I ~ I
(
~ i ~ I ! I ! i ~ i ~ i ~ I ; i ! i 3 i It ,.l: •••••• ,. . .... .. .. ... ::. l·
liiJIIIIJI11f1111111111111JIIIIIIfflllf1111111111111JIIIJIIIIIllllliiliJIIIIf'll.; i J I
&mmiimmdiiiiiUnnnumrmiiUIIlummuUidli•mmmmun .11
~ ~ ! ~ ~ ! ! ~ ~ ! ! ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ! ! ~ II I ~
I I i I i t i i ' ' i i I I I I 1 i ·If J ~ § I § ' I I I J I f ~ I f f J l ) l :II I
. . .I • I i ;
1 I 11 ! • " I• ~
11111111 .;
.I nmm 11
-· -- ----· ---·--- -----. . . - -- ----· __ .,.._
,-r -- - -~ -=- ~ --.:-- -- .. __ == -.-·. ..... . :::... -==.... !S - .. __ ·:::=:: = ...
::::. ·=-~= -· """" I !!:5:*: -...-..._ ·=- --- . ==-. .:! . . ie,.._ : ·.
- - ·==.. ~ -:::::... = - ·- -~- -· -- ·= -=- 5 ... - ·= - .e-_ ~ : : ~.
= ~- .. ==- 5::: :_: ~. - - · ~ -- ·;g- :: ..w..... ·---- - -· :- :~i ::
- :- :~ ~ ::
-· -- -~-..:;..
·-= ·=-.. = =
-· TOIICin MtAI'Oil.,....,.nl ..... l'IC~ ...._., .. &n
-------
:. :ll~.::.Z::::::--: :~-=~:e=-:-
- · .._,..,t•~~-iiOM'nCUPtc:lllf1Wii.rr..,.,.-
-- -----· ------ - ---- --- -· -----· -- --
:· :~~--z== --I -·---u, __ _ . -~=:::=---
--------
- · ~ .. , .... .-...-....: .... ~ ... ...,. - · ftiiOCI'ft .., .. ,. ,_...,,.,....._"""_,__ ., .. n,
-----· - -- ------- - · ----· -- -- ---- ----· -- - · ----· -- - -- -------. . ~
-· ~MtAf'Oil,_.,_,....~~IIY.rArt
-· ____ .. --------- ---·-. . -• :="" = -~
-· JCNICifTMfAI'OII,_.,,..._,.JC .... '~IIY.r•ll
----· ----------. . -
-:.=sE~=----e;;...,-=..-..........
-- ____ , -- ---
·-----· -~~-· "·=:-----. -~:=:=-:::-
-------. . -
..,
-· fOCICII'fMl'POa.._...,....._ .... ........,ft ... .,.
-------. . -
:· =~t~-----1 ··====-=-
------ ..... . . -·-! .:::
... "' .... - ----· ----- --- ~--=-
.. ~:..-=-.:-;. ::.:::'= .. --.. -· ===------
---- ----- - ---
:· =~tr--·-···---·-----·- u .. --
----.. ---------- ....... .-..
:· :~~"":..--- ~ -·--.. ·---• ·:::::--=:=---
-· -- --·--· - --
·~---... -.. -= =..::.-=----;:;;.....-=.,--....
------ ~
:· 't~r-~--1 -·-,.·---• -=::::=::=---
--.... ----. . - .,. ........... -· f'ODC'm'M.lA"'OI~....,nc: .... ~w ... .,._
-- ----" ---- -- ----· -- - -- --- -- - --
'if"!. ........ ___ _
.. -~ 2-:;.:£---~-e ........ -.-se-.....
-------
-- ----· --- - -- · 1C*CftTMJ~,...,_...,. .... ft:~ ........... "-_.....,_ .....
---. . -. ~ .. -· ----· -- -- --------
•
-- ----·-- - -- __ ..__ ---. . .. -- -----~ -- - -..-·-·-=
;· :~~w·----~ -·--··----...... ·-- ---_, __ '"'_~--
-~
-~
·--------. . ..
-· n:lrleCWfMfA ... .._._.fWI~W'I~Wit'Aft
..--.------. . .
·~-----···~~l!.-----... ------
---.:=:. --=-=:-
:. :~~-=--··----· ·=-~---·_.,. .. __ _
----· - --·-II ~ .. -:':
-· f'OD:I'N .. , .... ._..,. ..... t'C .... ...-.., .... ,.
----- - -. . " ----=--~ ·-E:!:: ·== ·=-.E == ·-·= .~ .a-·= .;;;-:~ :==.=: -= . §:-=-:a =-
' §:.
-----:- ~ ~
----· - .- .... -- - ---. . -
~----~· · = ==--=---........ ·---; --=----
-· ------ - ~ :: :: $
--=--~
-· ~W.Ta,_~-.M~N-.-.~.,_,nan
-------. . . -· ----· -- - --··--- e_ . ==-
ii_ •.• _-: ·.§E f ::.=:=- _j .==: -
: ~ I ~:: ~
:~ i .. -
:~ l=: = :· :~~~-·---- I -·--,.,·--. .. -_,·---·-···---
- .......... ----. . -
-- . - .. :::... = ·=- ---!5:. ~
~.,__ __ · · ·=~·--; ;;..,-=,.-;;....
..... -
:·=iii=:.===-- , -·- ·····--• · :-..:" .. -=:.---
-· ~ .. , .. ,.,_...la......C""~"'"·"
----·· ----- -- ----... ::
I = i l
!· :~~~-·..:.---, -·-u•---• . =:-..o::l:.-:=::.---
- - --- - -. . ..
.. ,
, __ - · "'*'" .. , • .._,_..,,..~._...~rra•ll
----· ----- ----. . ..
~-----.. ~! e-~s .. ---. .,... __ _
-- ----· .__ - ---
: · :~iif----·---·------.·-----·-··· .. ---
..... _ - · TOJIIQTTOA'f.t.!"'ff,_.,.,,_,...1'1Cl.w'l~""a"
-- ---·-· ___ _. --------== =
.... ~ .... -· ---_...,., - --
:· '~i~-=------ I -·--.,. .. __ _ • -:::::--=::o:::.=---
-· -- ----· - -- ----~ - -
i· =~~ -~-- 1 _._ ..... __ _
·------u·---
-------- ----· - --·--·=.=::..-·5:
·==·= =-:-=-:-:: :~ :==-
~= ==·=-·=-.
·= =
- · ~.,,,.,.. ,_...,_....nc..,......._n .. a.ft
- ·------. . - -----· -- _...,.. __ - --
!· =if~r~---- ~ -·--···---· ·=--=~--
-------. . -
-- -------- - -··-·~
·~
- · ~Mf&faft..__.,.. ..... TICLft.~l"faTtft
-·-.-----. . ..
.utol,.OIJD IOU~Ir"l' OAU fftlll f"USifW.UU A,OI,jAtfCV't C.lllrtt.'IJ4. • ., ITAtl
-~ .... -~ ~- ----"!· ... =:~ ;~t g~1t~:-::·'"··-
-- ---·-· ·----- - ·-· .... - rc.-..c ..... -- ..... -. . ..
/ol'l't.lfOIJ. O 10•1<10 04U. ' 011 fiiU.liW.UIJI AOI/Atll; llll'"l c:artii!IA. I Y ITAtf
---·-~ - -....·-, ___ ,.. ·- ·~- -------~ 1~-l- -.1-~"A.
___ ,_. - --......... _ - .-.... .,. _ .•. ----------------~~-c·~~~ -··-·
·--=-
~~ .~
:~ ~ .. ~
·· ==-'
:~ ~
'-'"1110110 TOJIC!ty o'f• '<* r lltPfWot.tt:ll.o.io\J-,c un c:Mnu"' n su.u
. _. .... - -·-=-·::..~.: ... .=-~· .. -::.~""'·~ --------- !• • ·~
___ ... _ . - ,, __ ··· ~-·--~~~ ·-~~-·--
:~ J1 I :::.=....
:~
:~ ·~· ·:~ . . E !::=-·~-, $:.,
......... IO&IC!n ~t& ~ 'JtU.WW"'ft:JIII(MI4ftC u•t etw'I UIIA,. • f SUITt
Alt!l>flli(lo~
fO.(ICff" OAU, f'~ fNII'IWIItl,. A.OUAntun CIIOI:IW.. 11 ""tt
-·~-·-· - ........ -·-->lt ..... ..,.._ - -· -.. . · ~·· ----·-· - ·-·-___ .,., .... _ ---. . ..
.....
...
""".a~'. a roe~CJn Clo''" "O"c l'~w•raa o'OIUit'IClift e-nUIWt.. ' ' ttart
----·-· __ ...,..,_ - -·-- "'*--·--::r: ::.
" ;='~
. . .
....... _ _ ... ... .... ·----· ~ ... ~ .... ·--- .... .. ~: ;~}~:;.~h::..-::,:.-.•e••-
---~ .... -- -·-. . .
~OIJD
ro£lOTT OAU 1''0111 ll!f.X..tt lll •O\o'AriC r.Jrt CJtflt~ t • ST•fl
---·-· -oo-.W"'lLoo•~-- -- --·--" -•u- •r .. , .. , __ . --··... -~ ... ---·-... ~. , .. ~ . ..,..,.. ··-~-·--· . lis-··-·-·----· --·--........... .... _, --':E;• ·~==-~ ~
i~'
~ ......... -.... ·- · ~ ... ,
: §~~·-· ~
" ;;~ :,';~-
~~:;~
! • 1,_ • • • •• ···· ... ,_
-~ ··-~"llo!i
..,., ..
I i~ !~
·- - ---~"':.'.. ..=''--=""~ ~-----'"-'-" . ..
- .. ---·-· - -- .... ,_ ,_..... - ., ___ -~..4!1.--...J.!!!
·-·
---·-· --... l--~ ........ ~--~----........ -------~--~~---~·~ ~ ~
·~r ~·· ·--.. 1 ··~--··-·--•-H - .... ~ _ ........ .... ~.--.. -··--........ ___ , ... _ __ .,. ......... _..._ -·--···""' .. _ ____ _
---·-· _.,.,._..,._ - ·-·- - .... -__ _..::..-"'...~·L- _, .... .. ., _ .. ,.. --·==- ::: =· \::::
... .... ~--.... ~ .. .. .... _ .. __ _ ..... . _ ... -.. .... .... ._ .... ..... _ .. """ ... _ :: : ::·::.~~;:-;-
-·-
---·-· - --... ., .. _ -_ ......... ·-,_ ·----. ==-Me.. 5:!:: .a.:=.
~:::
---J'C--- -· -. . . .
-··- ·-···-· ---· ... -- ~*-·,..- - .. ·· -1.'1 ~·· l!! l••,j
t SC4
;~~:?t~~~~~---·~ -..... ........ __ ....
---·-· - --· ,_ ~--'' E.
""' -·•· -----·-· ---.. ···--- .., .. _ .. - ..... -
CJ.. \ ' ' •• , .l"J..
.: ... t..::~Y ... ......... -....... .. -.. ~··--- ·--..... - ... .. ~ ~-· .. -· ... -.....
---·-· - -·-
. _.._, .. -~ .. -. ....... -....-
:~
:~ ·y-·@_ .. , .. :.;;!:0::::\·-·-~·-~· I ~-······ _ ........ .. - ·-·~ .. ........ --,.,. .... -·-.. ... _ ........ ..... -. .-.. -·····-· .... ·-···--• ... 1 ·--
___ .,... __ _ - .... -.. . ..
.. ---. ·-
""""''""0 tOJoclt'l' OUA FOil. Fll'Uk.AfU1:.40\IAIIC \I- f tlll1lN&." 11A1l
-·----- - -. . .. ...m·..ar•o
fO.otm o.U.ij F<NI FJIUWW.lfll t.ou.AM urt C:M'l:"*-'. 11' wu.tt
....-=-"!_:.-.. -:._· .. _. _· ... -._-_-=.,. _ ... _-..., .. l. ---·-· - ~--.. ·-.. ;;;. ~s
_.....__""' .... ~-- ·-. . ..
_. .... l~ .. , .. r011 ,..._...., ,01 aa.u.tc ..-e: tati'UM. . , • ta tt
---·-· __ .. __ - _ ..... - -· - -~ ---·-· -- - ..__ ..
·-···~ ~ ........ ~~ I -··--·· .... · .. - - '-···-"··-=-·~-·-·· ~--·-· -····•:.·----· -··· ............. _ :;:·~-;:.:~-----
----~ - -· -. . .. ---·-· - ,.,._
·~ ... - ---· ..... --- .... ·-. . ..
....... ...... -.... .. . ~·. ::---E.;:. ... ~--__ .......
t••• ·-·000 1 Af
-·----· - ... _ .. ..... -·---.. -~-·-,_ ....... -----t•··--· ::~ ·~
~~ ·= :f;_
:~ :c._
_"", ........... ...... . t'-!!::':,c;.;.,e.:.·.·-···· I ~E~·;:-3:::~c::;;.··· ...... . ......
.. .• ·
·-~
- ------- --. . ..
.,.
----· __ N. __ ,___ - -...... ------------ l!A.- J!.L ..cl-....\!.'.L
"'
~~ · t~ ~-:E
· ~ =-·~ ::_ : ~ ::=
' e!:-
.•. ....
~~ 1~ ~~
. -...... -~ .. -t == · ~ .... -~ ~·~ ~
-·~---· ·· .. ·-~-"""' :: !~3!.~-_ ..... _ x· ...... ,mu•.......,., ..
----· - --· ·-. =:. ·~ ....
------- -·-. . . ii'"1'""~ 1 •. ··-'1: I ;.;:c: J • ::::.:: . '"""". 'l • :; ::::
il ~ ' ~
__.__, ~ ..... ~21
~~
~~ ...
~--
~--
. .. II II
; : ::::;...:...'::...: . ....-::_~:;:.:···· -· .. ---~ ... . -4'11 .. 0 4 0 0'
.... .................. ~ · --·'Y_ ............... "
__._ ... ; ! : ;
I : :
i'
-i
= t: :
r , -. • r • -~'" ...
~ :; ::~ c: .. z: t;
HU wm ------·--
"""c:lfOI•t llfc.t.u:vLAIIO!Ii I'ICIULd
.... ,; --.... -· .. i3~;
~ ·•: J
i " ~ .. ~ : .
r· ll!
-~ ,...... ~1' ·mf-~ rrr: ... ........ £: n ; n : : : : :: : :l
z:::. !:~ : : :
R lUI IL:::n 111111 r-~~--~--------~~~~~----.
: t::;'!;':;;'_,'."'::'!::~::::.: ·· ........ . "' ... 4
":. ... · .. ~·:::.~-: .r .... . ....... ~4 ... , .......... ... ~-\1"""'••-+•1\
~ ....... ;=
'I .. ,_ ..
w ~ "
, I
i
--m'r:Tl •'Hl:: 1
. .. . : .!
~ ::t:
~ ~: 5
.. .......
~ n~
~~ tH
1111 ::: ~ !! : ....... .. :; ! i ·:
.. .. ..... ~ ; ~t
........
:~ ~ §; ~ ~: ~
, .. , .•. ...,, .. ....... ~ ...... . . ·- ~ ....... H
,..,..._or•• ~CL'\AfiOtlt•U~lt.
......... . ..,.,._.
........
.... . .,,. •)<•l't• ........ ... .....
[ ~ 1 ! .. ;
l I I'll
l!ll : ::::
li!l :.;iLl ~r~~
: :., : : : : : ~ . ! : ; 1 i ; ~ ~ § g !u :; :: ==~· :: .... ~ . . ' . .. .. " .. ,,. . .... .. ••• • • I • . .. ,. -. ... .... . ... . ., .. ........ . . .... .. • • I • • 0 ! oo 'n : :i: : : : ::: .... ~ . . .. ... .. .. ' .. ' . "' , . .. . .
• ...... ~-·-........ , •• • l .. ll .... _ .... "" • .l' .. __ .............. -......... ~ . .. .......... ~ ............ _. __ , ......... _, . ._
I EE
I ~§ !~ ::: ·;§~ ~ .. -"' ~- ,,...,, .. ~.
·~::: :=:: !' .... 'f""" ;::; t-·· ··- ;:::: ! .... ·=:: ::;:
• - n o!...., ' ::! .,_, ~3 i:! •:,o• • _ .. . r:: ·- ·
~~ ~~ i~ i~ :s Hi .i~ ~$
r · 11
- .e .. -...
~i I if m. . .
·-· ·-
--·--' ~ r T]
'§ ;~·.---~.~~::::.~---_=-._~_!· ~-~· § :~ ·. ·~ ~
i ~~
~· :f
l '! ':.['11'1 !
-
::t ;
11-:::::: .. --::t..:..· .•• -::::.~.;:.: .:-··· ...,. ... - • .. ·-~ ......... ~- ..... -_. .. ___ •·
n : :0:
" .
......
!I
!I'll HH r;!:;! ~ . .. " ;lo - 4
4- .. ~.
Hl '
.... -...
·' * '
·;:,:.--.~.~~";.!'
~Trrr~
nnn~ § J~~ :pq:: : :-: ~ ididi a: :: !UH:: :: :::~
! i:;!! : :: : f f I o 0 I 0 " . o ......... ..
. :!:;: = ~ = . .. . ... : i!ii!! ~ ~ i
dHll ::.: .......... . I I o I o o .. • o
:::::: : : : :::!!! i ~ ~ :n:n t ::: s: .. , . . .
I n II II
I .
I:·· =
., .
' . ..
... .- ···-- -,,.. .. ... ... U ·- -·- --....... .. ... .. ~
J,.. .... .... .
·; :~
:~
,._
II ··-~-e ....... .. .............. . ,
..,. .. ._ .. O«l IU:t.A.I.~IAATI(NII~fl
i Ji' : .. '~ . .
l
H. ·~·"' \ ·• t
.............. ...__,.'"""' ' ' ' .._, .... ... ..... ,.. ... ' !_ ..... . ....... ~ ..... ... .... 0\ . ..... .............. _ ................ ....
il .,._ _ ..•. , ·-···"
-·--·- ,.
.
! ! fl :1 ;
j-j
~ f; ~ :::! : :
II II =~ : :
HH :: =:
~T-nT ;a . n ~
I :,: ~~
i i~
ll
.. ~ .. -....... \ ._ .. '•/'<o\011 ~ · ·
:::!: ~~ ::: ~E .,,. .. ,,_, ·- ,_
! ::C:!:.l:~ .. :::':"!!;.~:t.:..· ::- ····~· .... .,.,. • • • .., . ..... .,.,. • ., ... ,._ !1 .... - ·., ...... _,f\