Québec Court of Appeal€¦ · EYB 2015-246823 Tremblay, Gérald R. Respondent QC Final appeal...
Transcript of Québec Court of Appeal€¦ · EYB 2015-246823 Tremblay, Gérald R. Respondent QC Final appeal...
Page 1
The French version will be available soon.
Québec Court of AppealAppellate Cases Argued by Active McCarthy Tétrault Lawyers
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
1. QCCA Université McGill c.McGill UniversityNon Academic
Certified Association(MUNACA)
11/24/15 [2015] J.Q. no12744, 2015QCCA 1943, EYB2015-258949
Baril, André Appellant QC Final appeal Labour law - Collectiveagreement - Industrialaccidents andoccupational diseases -Jurisdiction of thegrievance arbitrator -Insertion of provisionsmore favorable to theworker in the collectiveagreement.
2. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd c.Conseil Québécoissur le tabac et lasanté
10/27/15 [2015] Q.J. No.7413, 2015 QCCA1737, 2015EXP-3171, J.E. 2015-1760, EYB 2015-258069
Potter, SimonV.Bouchard,Pierre-Jérôme
Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure - Securityfor costs - Appellantscondemned to pay over$8 billion in damages -Security orderedfurnished in the amountof $758 million forImperial Tobacco and$226 million forRothmans, payable inquarterly instalments
3. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. c.Québec (Procureuregénérale)
09/28/15 [2015] J.Q. no9382, 2015 QCCA1554,2015EXP-2886, J.E. 2015-1589, EYB 2015-256982
Potter, SimonV.Bouchard,Pierre-Jérôme
Appellant QC Final Appeal Health law - Public health- Tobacco-relatedDamages - Health CareCosts Recovery - Judicialrights - Burden of proof
Page 2
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
4. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. c.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté
07/23/15 [2015] Q.J. No.6159, 2015 QCCA1224, 2015EXP-2292, J.E. 2015-1283, EYB 2015-254767
Potter, SimonV.Bouchard,Pierre-Jérôme
Appellant QC Interlocutory Class action - Civilprocedure - Execution ofjudgments - Compulsoryexecution - Provisionalexecution - Production ofevidence - Sealing ofevidence - Confidentialityorder
5. QCCA Roy c. Mout 04/23/15 [2015] J.Q. no3390, 2015 QCCA692, 2015EXP-1475, J.E. 2015-814, EYB 2015-251191
Poupart,EmmannuelleDufort-Langlois,Philippe
Respondent QC Final appeal Medical malpractice -Causation - Moraldamages du to thevictim's spouse andchildren
6. QCCA Videotron, s.e.n.c. c.Bell ExpressVu, l.p.
03/06/15 [2015] J.Q. no1742, 2015 QCCA422, 2015EXP-846, J.E. 2015-446, EYB 2015-249113
Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Final appeal Civil liability - Medias -Telecommunication -Televison signal -Inadequate securitysystem - Dammagescaused to competitors
7. QCCA Syndicat desemployées etemployés del'Université deMontréal, sectionlocale 1244 (SCFP-FTQ) c. Université deMontréal
03/04/15 [2015] J.Q. no1612, 2015 QCCA411, 2015EXP-909, 2015EXPT-479, J.E. 2015-487, D.T.E.2015T-197, EYB2015-248878
Baril, André Respondent QC Final appeal Labour law - Grievancearbitration - JudicialReview - Arbitrator'sjurisdiction
8. QCCA Pagé c. Godbout 02/09/15 [2015] J.Q. no664, 2015 QCCA225, 18 C.C.L.T.(4th) 42, 2015CarswellQue 646,2015EXP-667,J.E. 2015-342,EYB 2015-247792
Dberge, DavidEmmanuelufour, Marc
Appellant QC Final appeal Civil liability - Causation -No fault regime - Novusactus interveniens -Transportation law - Caraccident
Page 3
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
9. QCCA Taberna PreferredFunding VI Ltd. c.Stichting HomburgBonds
01/16/15 [2015] Q.J. No.161, 2015 QCCA62, 2015EXP-369,J.E. 2015-188,EYB 2015-246975
Poplaw,MasonPerreault,JocelynDeslandrew,Nicolas
Respondent QC Interlocutory Insolvency - Companies’Creditors ArrangementAct - Compromises andarrangements withunsecured creditors -Priority - Directors claim
10. QCCA Jasmin c. Sociétédes alcools duQuébec
01/14/15 [2015] J.Q. no 78,2015 QCCA 36,2015EXP-336,J.E. 2015-171,EYB 2015-246823
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Final appeal Consumer protection -Class action -Authorization - Statemonopoly - Wines andliquors
11. QCCA Charland c. Lessard 01/12/15 [2015] J.Q. no 51,2015 QCCA 14,2015EXP-278,J.E. 2015-139,EYB 2015-246657
Lortie, JeanDesjardins,Sandra
Respondent QC Final appeal Corporate law -Shareholdersagreements - Protectionof minority shareholders -Directors liability
12. QCCA Association desmédecins résidentsde Québec c. Leclerc
12/17/14 [2014] J.Q. no14615, 2014QCCA 2374,2015EXP-256,2015EXPT-129,J.E. 2015-128,D.T.E. 2015T-52,EYB 2014-246254
Cantin,Philippe
Respondent QC Final appeal Labour law -Psychologicalharassment in a hospital- Medical examiner
13. QCCA Deraspe c. Zincélectrolytique duCanada Corporationltée
12/08/14 [2014] J.Q. no13990, 2014QCCA 2266,2015EXP-150,J.E. 2015-76, EYB2014-245560
Gagné,MichelRoberge,DavidEmmanuel
Respondent QC Final appeal Class action -Environmental law -Corporate personality -Alter ego - "Custody" of aplant.
14. QCCA St-Germain c.Benhaim
12/05/14 [2014] J.Q. no13772, 2014QCCA 2207,2014EXP-3922,J.E. 2014-2197,2014 CarswellQue
Platts, DavidE.Brousseau,Elisabeth
Respondent QC Final appeal Civil liability - Medicalmalpractice - Diagnosis -Damages.
Page 4
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
12131, 16C.C.L.T. (4th) 190,EYB 2014-245285
15. QCCA Groupe Enerstat inc.c. Siemens BuildingTechnologies(Siemens Canadaltée)
11/03/14 [2014] J.Q. no12142, 2014QCCA 2023,2014EXP-3591,J.E. 2014-2026,EYB 2014-243972
Giroux,François
Respondent QC Final appeal Obligations - Contractbreach - Remedies - Thegoods could not be usedfor the purpose for whichthey were intended.
16. QCCA Liu c. Comité dediscipline du Centrede santé et deservices sociauxHaut-Richelieu—Rouville
09/04/14 [2014] J.Q. no9486, 2014 QCCA1613, 2014EXP-2884, J.E. 2014-1647, EYB 2014-241713
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Final appeal Health law - Physicians -Discipline committees inhospitals - Complaint -Deadline for the medicalexaminer tocommunicate isconclusions.
17. QCCA 6926614 Canada inc.(Entreprises Tag)(Arrangement relatifà)
08/14/14 [2014] J.Q. no8712, 2014 QCCA1532, 2014EXP-2624, J.E. 2014-1497, EYB 2014-241156
Perreault,Jocelyn
Appellant QC Interlocutory Insolvency - Companies'Creditors ArrangementAct - Leave to appeal -Analysis of the requiredcriteria to appeal ajudgment rendered underthe CCAA.
18. QCCA Simard-BeaudryConstruction inc. c.Constructions Bob-Son inc.
06/10/14 [2014] J.Q. no5616, 2014 QCCA1182
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Final Appeal Contracts - Contract ofenterprise - Resiliation ofthe contract once thework started -Interpretation of thecontractual documents
19. QCCA Agence du revenu duQuébec c. Potvin
05/15/14 [2014] J.Q. no4541, 2014 QCCA1001
Discepola,Angelo
Respondent QC Final Appeal Tax - Provincial taxation -Notice of assessment -Determination of themoment of the grant ofthe stock options - Intentof the parties.
Page 5
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
20. QCCA Fortier c. MeublesLéon ltée
02/04/14 [2014] J.Q. no661, 2014 QCCA195, EYB 2014-232573
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Respondent QC Final Appeal Class action – Consumerprotection – Legal andsupplemental warranties– Seller's liability –Misrepresentation.
21. QCCA Banque deMontréal/Bank ofMontreal c. BanquedeNouvelle-Écosse/Bank of NovaScotia
09/12/13 [2013] J.Q. no114472013 QCCA 1548
Tremblay,Gérald R.Boodman,Martin
Respondent QC Final Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadapending(Docket35610,12/11/2013)
Banks and financialinstitutions – Civil liability– Customer of a bankengaged in fraudulentactivities (“kiting”) – Dutyof the bank to stop theillegal activities and not tobenefit from the saidactivities
22. QCCA Caron c. Voyer 08/07/13 [2013] J.Q. no9214, 2013 QCCA1335, 2013EXP-2710, J.E. 2013-1466, EYB 2013-225414
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Respondent QC Final Appeal Professional liability –Securities dealers –Liability of another –Investment Advisor –Evidence – Similar factevidence in civil matters.
23. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 05/27/13 [2013] J.Q. no5710, 2013 QCCA981
Jarry, ClaudeM.Dufort-Langlois,Philippe
Appellant QC Final Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadapending(Docket35495,26/08/2013)
Medical liability – childborn premature –causation – damagecaused by prematurebirth – discretionarypower of the court toreserve the right of thecreditor to apply foradditional damageswithin three years (art.1615 CCQ)
24. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 05/22/13 2013 QCCA 920 Chénier,Robert-JeanRoberge,David
Appellant QC Final Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupreme
Medical malpractice -Orthopedic surgery -Alleged late diagnosisand treatment - Anterior
Page 6
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
Emmanuel Court ofCanadadismissed(Docket35485,09/01/2014)
cruciate ligament injury -Causation
25. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 05/22/13 2013 QCCA 921 Chénier,Robert-JeanRoberge,DavidEmmanuel
Respondent QC Final Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket35486,09/01/2014)
Medical malpractice -Orthopedic surgery -Alleged late diagnosisand treatment - Anteriorcruciate ligament injury -Causation
26. QCCA MacMillan c. AbbottLaboratories
05/15/13 [2013] Q.J. No.5177, 2013 QCCA906
Gagné,MichelPoupart,Emmanuelle
Respondent QC Final Appeal Class action - Medication- Meridia - Authorizationstage - The facts allegeddid not justify theconclusions sought
27. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 03/15/13 [2013] J.Q. no2432, 2013 QCCA486
Roberge,David E.Gagnon,Isabelle
Respondent QC Final Appeal Medical malpractice -Erroneous diagnosis -Extinctive prescription -Moment at whichprescription started
28. QCCA Lorrain c PetroCanada
02/21/13 [2013] J.Q. No.1420, 2013 QCCA332
Poupart,Emmanuelle
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket35335,19/09/2013)
Class action – Criteria forauthorization –Calibration of gas pumps– Weights and measures
Page 7
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
29. QCCA Canada (Procurergénéral) c. ImpérialTobacco Ltd.
11/14/12 [2012] J.Q. no13162; 2012QCCA 2034
Potter, SimonV.Bouchard,Pierre-Jérôme
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure –Dismissal of action –Class action againsttobacco companies –Action in warrantyagainst Federal Crown –Federal governmentpolicy – Stare deciss –Public law immunity
30. QCCA Centre commercialLes Rivières ltée c.Jean Bleu inc.
09/19/12 [2012] Q.J. No8822; 2012 QCCA1663
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure –Contempt of Court – Oraljudgment – Order toproduct documents –Proof of the actus reusand of mens rea for civilcontempt – Availability ofeither remedies
31. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. C.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté
09/17/12 [2012] J.Q. no8750; 2012 QCCA1641
Potter, SimonV.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure –Production of documents– Survey data – Classction – Tobaccocompanies
32. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 07/11/12 [2012] J.Q. no.6756, 2012 QCCA1288
Chénier,Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket35025,14/03/2013)
Civil procedure – Partiesacting in a quarrelsomemanner – Dismissal ofthe appeal
33. QCCA Bitton c. AppleCanada Inc.
06/01/12 [2012] Q.J. No5120, 2012 QCCA991, 2012EXP-2286, EYB 2012-
Potter, SimonV.
Respondent QC Appeal Class action –Authorization –Conditions precedent –Alleged false or
Page 8
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
207251 misleading informationconveyed by Apple in themarketing of iPodproducts regarding thememory capacity – Thefacts alleged did notjustify the conclusionssought
34. QCCA N.F. c. Montréal (Villede)
05/28/12 [2012] J.W. no5132, 2012 QCCA996
Desjardins,Sandra
Respondent QC Appeal Labour and employmentlaw – Industrial accidentsand occupationaldiseases – Jurisdiction ofgrievance arbitrator –Application of Weber v.Ontario Hydro
35. QCCA Brown c. B2B Trust 05/15/12 [2012] J.Q. no4652, 2012 QCCA900, 2012EXP-2035, J.E. 2012-1071, EYB 2012-206680
Loranger,Julie-MartineClavier, Elisa
Respondent QC Appeal Class action –Authorization – Fraud –Real estate investments– Duties and obligationfor directors and officersunder the Trust and LoanCompanies Act –Custodian liability.
36. QCCA Fortier c. Lavoie 04/23/12 2012 QCCA 754 Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability – Psychiatristliability as an expertwitness – “Biased anderroneous” report
37. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 02/29/12 [2012] J.Q. no1610, 2012 QCCA383, 2012EXP-1072, 2012EXPT-533, J.E. 2012-586, D.T.E.2012T-172, EYB2012-202902
Rousse,Jacques
Respondent QC Appeal Labour and employmentlaw – Labour relations –Jurisdiction of grievancearbitrator – Medicalreport – Forcedretirement –Fundamental justice –Procedural safeguards
Page 9
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
38. QCCA Watters v. White 02/09/12 [2012] Q.J. No.906, 2012 QCCA257
Platts, DavidGriffin, Sean
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket34758,30/08/2012)
Medical liability – rategenetic condition –obligation to inform –duty of confidentiality –patient’s extended family
39. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 01/30/12 [2012] J.Q. no.868, 2012 QCCA249, 2012EXP-726, J.E. 2012-401
Chénier,Robert-JeanHudon, Marc-Alexandre
Respondent QC Appeal Medical liability – medicalmalpractice – anesthetist– Obligation to inform –risks – consent givenorally – no obligation todisclose a very rarecomplication
40. QCCA Anvil Mining Ltd. v.Associationcanadienne contrel’impunité
01/24/12 [2012] J.Q. no.368, 2012 QCCA117, 2012EXP-513, J.E. 2012-277, EYB 2012-201106
Lehoux, Jean-FrançoisBouchard,Pierre-Jérôme
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket34733,01/11/2012)
Class actions – Privateinternational law –international jurisdictionof Québec authorities –personal action – legalperson having anestablishment in Québec– dispute unrelated to thelegal person’s activities inQuébec
41. QCCA Organisme canadiende réglementation ducommerce desvaleurs mobilières(OCRCVM) c.Beaudouin
12/06/11 [2011] J.Q. no183922011 QCCA 2247
Griffin, Sean Appellant QC Interlocutory Securities — self-regulatory organizations— jurisdiction rationemateriae —homologation of adisciplinary decision
42. QCCA OptionConsommateurs v.Infineon
11/16/11 [2011] Q.J. No.167692011 QCCA 2116
Renaud,MadeleineLegendre,
Respondent QC Appeal Appeal to theSupremeCourt of
Civil procedure — courts— jurisdiction andpowers — territorial
Page 10
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
Technologies AG Céline Canadadismissed(Docket34617,31/10/2013)
jurisdiction — declinatoryexceptions — classaction —- motion forauthorization — damagesuffered in Québec
43. QCCA Valeurs mobilièresDesjardins inc. c.Lepage
10/06/11 [2011] J.Q. no14061, 2011QCCA 1837,2011EXP-3086,J.E. 2011-1725,EYB 2011-196622, [2011]R.J.Q. 1805
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket34565,26/04/2012)
Professional liability –Financial advisors –Duties and obligations –Civil liability of aninvestment advisor andhis employer.
44. QCCA Volailles du fermierinc c. Éleveurs devolailles du Québecinc.
09/27/11 [2011] J.Q. no.136362011 QCCA 17722011 EXP-3012J.E. 2011-1686EYB 2011-196351
Vendette,Isabelle
Respondent QC Appeal Obligations —contractual liability(breach of contract) —consent of the parties —fraud — concealment ofvital information
45. QCCA Clouâtre c. FactoryMutual InsuranceCompany
09/19/11 [2011] J.Q. no128292011 QCCA 1690
Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — legalsubrogation — partialcollapse of a roof —liability of constructioncontractors
46. QCCA Collège desmédecins du Québecc. Genest
09/19/11 [2011] J.Q. no128312011 QCCA 1683
Dufour, MarcChamberland,Simon
Respondent QC Appeal Disciplinary law —physicians — re-entry onthe roll of the order ofphysicians after beingprovisionally struck offthe roll
47. QCCA Hébert c. Centrehospitalier affiliéuniversitaire deQuébec — Hôpital de
07/27/11 [2011] J.Q. no107082011 QCCA 15212011EXP-2700
Jarry, Claude Appellant QC Appeal Medical malpractice —cerebral angiogram —apportionment of liabilitywith the technologist —
Page 11
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
l'Enfant-Jésus J.E. 2011-1517EYB 2011-194586
solidary liability
48. QCCA Caisse populaireDesjardins de Côte-des-Neiges c.Banque Toronto-Dominion
06/17/11 [2011] J.Q. no76352011 QCCA 11482011EXP-2114J.E. 2011-1152EYB 2011-191973
Deschamps,MichelPerreault,Jocelyn
Respondent QC Appeal Bills of exchange —fraudulent alteration ofbill — clearing system
49. QCCA Bombardier c.Éleveurs de volaillesdu Québec
06/03/11 [2011] J.Q. no67572011 QCCA 1058EYB 2011-191589
Renaud,Madeleine
Respondent QC Appeal Agri-food — chickenmarketing — regulationsby self-regulationorganization — penalties— jurisdiction of theRégie des marchésagricoles et alimentairesdu Québec
50. QCCA Grenier c. Grenier 05/24/11 [2011] J.Q. no58772011 QCCA 964EYB 2011-1910822011EXP-1782J.E. 2011-982
Cantin,Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability — medicalmalpractice — caraccident — osteotomy
51. QCCA Greenberg c. Capitald'Amérique CDPQinc.
05/20/11 [2011] Q.J. No.58912011 QCCA 9582011EXP-1807EYB 2011-191159
Giroux,François
Respondent QC Appeal Commercial — contracts— agreement relating tothe purchase ofshareholdings — pre-contractual document
52. QCCA Nechi InvestmentsInc. c. Autorité desmarchés financiers
02/04/11 [2011] J.Q. no 7742011 QCCA 2142011EXP-693J.E. 2011-370EYB 2011-185915
Bourbonnais,Miguel
Respondent QC Interlocutory Securities — jurisdictionof Court of Québec —freezing orders
Page 12
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
53. QCCA Sodexin Financementmercantile inc. c.Sport Maska inc.
01/25/11 [2011] J.Q. no 2672011 QCCA 113
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency — effects ofthe contract —shareholders —corporate personality
54. QCCA R.K. v. Ackman(Succession d')
11/29/10 [2010] Q.J. No.124612010 QCCA 21802010EXP-4078J.E. 2010-2190EYB 2010-182783
Platts, DavidE.Chamberland,Simon
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadapending(Docket34077,28/01/2011)
Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — duty to inform— disclosure of risks
55. QCCA Domtar Inc. c.Produits Kruger ltée
10/29/10 [2010] J.Q. no109472010 QCCA 19342010EXP-3603J.E. 2010-1964EYB 2010-181157
Potter, SimonV.
Respondent QC Appeal Energy — hydroelectricity— sale of a factory —electricity supply to thefactory
56. QCCA Conseil de lamagistrature duQuébec c. Dubois
10/08/10 [2010] J.Q. no104282010 QCCA 18642010EXP-3409J.E. 2010-1882EYB 2010-180670
Tremblay,Gérald R.Bélanger,Marie-Eve
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadapending(Docket33973,07/12/2010)
Discipline and ethics —legal professions —judges — inquiry by theConseil de lamagistrature du Québec
57. QCCA P.L. c. Benchetrit 08/24/10 [2010] J.Q. no80672010 QCCA 15052010EXP-2900J.E. 2010-1600
Brabander,Kristian
Respondent QC Appeal Professionalresponsibility — medicine— plastic surgery —consent — expertevidence
Page 13
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
[2010] R.R.A. 606[2010] R.J.Q. 1853
58. QCCA Apple Canada Inc. c.St-Germain
07/28/10 [2010] J.Q. no73272010 QCCA 13762010EXP-2564J.E. 2010-1430EYB 2010-177247[2010] R.J.Q. 1627
Potter, SimonV.
Appellant QC Appeal Copyright — class action— iPod — royalties —proof — admission —necessity to establishthat internal mechanismis a sufficientcompensation
59. QCCA Château Drummondinc. c. 9171-8338Québec inc.
05/20/10 [2010] J.Q. no47462010 QCCA 1012
Schenke,Stephen G.
Appellant QC Appeal Property law — servitude— parking lot
60. QCCA Nunez de la TorreRomero c. Lichtblau
04/23/10 [2010] J.Q. no35512010 QCCA 8042010EXP-1480J.E. 2010-814EYB 2010-172928
Platts, DavidE.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —change of attorneys —disqualification — conflictof interest
61. QCCA Forest c. RaymorIndustries inc.
03/24/10 [2010] J.Q. no24392010 QCCA 5782010EXP-1238J.E. 2010-673EYB 2010-17147166 C.B.R. (5th)1972010 CarswellQue2474
Tardif, AlainN.Perreault,Jocelyn
Respondent QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency — companies'creditors arrangements— reorganization —dismissal of appeal —lack of sufficient legalinterest — mootness
62. QCCA Fabrikant c. Swamy 02/16/10 [2010] J.Q. no1352[2010] Q.J. No.13522010 QCCA 330EYB 2010-1700472010EXP-896
Lehoux, Jean-François
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed
Civil procedure —inherent power ofsuperior court to punishabuse of process — rightto be heard —fundamental right
Page 14
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
J.E. 2010-492 (Docket33675,08/07/2010)
63. QCCA Richard c. Gougoux 12/03/09 [2009] J.Q. no150882009 QCCA 2347
Bélanger,Marie-Eve
Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability —defamation —harassment — civilprocedure — dismissal ofthe appeal
64. QCCA N.L. c. Sabbah 11/19/09 [2009] J.Q. no120922009 QCCA 1995
Platts, DavidE.
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — dismissalof the appeal
65. QCCA Progistix-Solutionsinc. c. Commissiondes normes du travail
10/26/09 [2009] J.Q. no125382009 QCCA 2054EYB 2009-165565J.E. 2009-2045[2009] R.J.D.T.1103
Gagnon,Nathalie
Appellant QC Appeal Labour — labourstandards — collectiveagreement — differencesin treatment
66. QCCA Interinvest (Bermuda)Ltd. c. Herzog
07/24/09 [2009] J.Q. no74632009 QCCA 1428J.E. 2009-1451EYB 2009-161934179 A.C.W.S. (3d)1088
Potter, SimonV.,Brabander,Kristian
Respondent QC Interlocutory International private law— conflicts of jurisdiction— foreign corporation
67. QCCA Gestion Raymor inc.c. Ready PacCanada Co.
04/08/09 [2009] J.Q. no29732009 QCCA 679
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency —nanotechnology —safeguard order —interim receiver —intervention —proposition
68. QCCA Raymor Aerospaceinc. c. Béliveau
04/08/09 [2009] J.Q. no29722009 QCCA 678
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency —nanotechnology —
Page 15
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
EYB 2009-157156 safeguard order —interim receiver —intervention —proposition
69. QCCA Raymor Industriesinc. v. Ready PacCanada Co.
04/08/09 [2009] Q.J. No.2974[2009] J.Q. no29742009 QCCA 680J.E. 2009-813
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Interlocutory Bankruptcy andinsolvency —nanotechnology —safeguard order —interim receiver —intervention —proposition
70. QCCA Raymor Nanotechinc. c. Ready PacCanada Co.
04/08/09 [2009] J.Q. no29712009 QCCA 677
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Interlocutory Bankruptcy andinsolvency —nanotechnology —safeguard order —interim receiver —intervention —proposition
71. QCCA Gagné c. Fortin 04/06/09 [2009] J.Q. no28772009 QCCA 659EYB 2009-157100J.E. 2009-747[2009] R.R.A. 447
Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket33197,24/09/2009)
Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — psychiatrists —diagnosis — dismissal ofthe action — prescription
72. QCCA AP&C Revêtements& poudres avancéesinc. c. Ready PacCanadaCo.
03/30/09 [2009] J.Q. no29702009 QCCA 676
Tardif, Alain Appellant QC Interlocutory Bankruptcy andinsolvency —nanotechnology —safeguard order —interim receiver —intervention —proposition
Page 16
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
73. QCCA St-Arnaud v. C.L. 01/09/09 [2009] Q.J. No.259[2009] J.Q. no 2592009 QCCA 97[2009] R.J.Q. 239EYB 2009-152692J.E. 2009-284
Chénier,Robert-JeanDufresne,Marie-Eve
Appellant QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket33045,18/06/2009)
Civil procedure —incidental proceedings —provision for costs
74. QCCA OptionConsommateurs c.Bell Mobilité
11/19/08 [2008] J.Q. no117362008 QCCA 2201J.E. 2008-2293EYB 2008-150743
Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Appeal Telecommunications —class action —authorization — billing
75. QCCA OptionConsommateurs c.Banque Nationale duCanada
11/12/08 [2008] J.Q. no113432008 QCCA 2128
Deschamps,Michel
Respondent QC Appeal Class action —authorization — banks —loan of money —interpretation of contracts
76. QCCA Syndicat national destravailleurs des pâteset papiers de Port-Alfred c. CompagnieAbitibi-Consolidateddu Canada, divisionde Port-Alfred
10/08/08 [2008] J.Q. no97802008 QCCA 188772 C.C.P.B. 1562008 CarswellQue9740
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Labour — interpretationof a collective agreement— jurisdiction of arbitrator— retirement plan
77. QCCA Autorité des marchésfinanciers v. Panju
05/05/08 [2008] Q.J. No.36422008 QCCA 832EYB 2008-132929J.E. 2008-1075[2008] R.J.Q. 1233172 A.C.W.S. (3d)604
Legendre,Céline
Respondent QC Interlocutory Securities — civilprocedure — productionof exhibits byrespondents —confidentiality —protection of the publicinterest
Page 17
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
78. QCCA Ferland c. Ghosn 04/28/08 [2008] J.Q. no33512008 QCCA 797EYB 2008-132464J.E. 2008-987[2008] R.R.A. 295172 A.C.W.S. (3d)788
Bujold,Steeves
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — duty to inform
79. QCCA Baum c. Mohr 04/18/08 [2008] Q.J. No.29782008 QCCA 718EYB 2008-132239J.E. 2008-937[2008] R.R.A. 285167 A.C.W.S. (3d)813
Platts, DavidE.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadiscontinued(Docket32688,09/10/2008)
Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — surgery
80. QCCA Latte des berges inc.(Syndic de)
04/08/08 [2008] J.Q. no26572008 QCCA 617EYB 2008-131952J.E. 2008-858172 A.C.W.S. (3d)92
Lortie, Jean Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket33197,04/12/2008)
Contracts — sale ofassets — deposit
81. QCCA ConsortiumPromecan inc.(Syndic de)
12/18/07 [2007] J.Q. no147132007 QCCA 1835
Poplaw,Mason
Appellant QC Appeal Affirmed byQuebec(Revenue) v.CaissepopulaireDesjardins deMontmagny,2009 SCC 49,[2009] 3
Insolvency andbankruptcy — taxation —collection of taxes onconsumption — deemedtrust — order of priority
Page 18
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
S.C.R. 286
82. QCCA Clennet c. Loto-Québec
12/06/07 [2007] J.Q. no137022007 QCCA 1690J.E. 2008-99EYB 2007-126944[2007] C.A.I. 603167 A.C.W.S. (3d)88
Dufort-Langlois,Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Statute interpretation —interpretation — accessto information
83. QCCA Canada PostCorporation v. Lépine
08/10/07 [2007] Q.J. No.8498[2007] J.Q. no84982007 QCCA 1092[2007] R.J.Q. 1920J.E. 2007-1615EYB 2007-122903
Lortie, Jean Intervenor QC Appeal Confirmed bySociétécanadiennedes postes c.Lépine, 2009C.S.C. 16,[2009] 1R.C.S. 549
International private law— foreign judgments —recognition procedure —class action — lifetimeInternet service
84. QCCA 9026-9739 Québecinc. (Séquestre de) c.Roy, Métivier,Roberge inc.
04/11/07 [2007] J.Q. no29242007 QCCA 526[2007] R.J.Q. 828J.E. 2007-825EYB 2007-117894164 A.C.W.S. (3d)333
Bélanger,Philippe H.
Respondent QC Appeal Insolvency — bankruptcy— Farm Debt MediationAct — lift of stay
85. QCCA Trudel c. BanqueToronto-Dominion
03/19/07 [2007] J.Q. no21672007 QCCA 413J.E. 2007-701EYB 2007-116838165 A.C.W.S. (3d)987
Giroux,François M.
Respondent QC Appeal Class action —authorization —hypothecs — publicationof rights — acquittance ofa debt
Page 19
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
86. QCCA Curateur public duQuébec c. Centrehospitalieruniversitaire deQuébec
01/11/07 [2007] J.Q. no 172007 QCCA 31
Cantin,Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Persons — care —integrity of the person —confinement in aninstitution
87. QCCA Sheppard c. RoyalInstitution for theAdvancement ofLearning(McGill University)
01/09/07 [2007] Q.J. No. 772007 QCCA 46J.E. 2007-248EYB 2007-112066165 A.C.W.S. (3d)286
Gagnon,Nathalie
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — dismissal —just cause — contract ofemployment —resiliation
88. QCCA Thibault c.Assurancesgénérales desCaisses Desjardins
12/08/06 [2006] J.Q. no133442006 QCCA 1599EYB 2006-111820165 A.C.W.S. (3d)347
Cantin,Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — insurance ofgoods — exclusionclause — waiver
89. QCCA JetsGo Corporation(Syndic de)
11/27/06 [2006] J.Q. no136072006 QCCA 1521J.E. 2006-2336163 A.C.W.S. (3d)1011EYB 2006-111320
Poplaw,MasonBourbonnais,Miguel
Appellant QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency — trustee —letter of credit — bank
90. QCCA Fédération desinfirmières etinfirmiers du Québecc.Hôpital Laval
10/16/06 [2006] J.Q. no118032006 QCCA 1345[2006] R.J.Q. 2384J.E. 2006-2090EYB 2006-110652165 A.C.W.S. (3d)242
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Evidence — privilegeddocuments — medicalrecords
91. QCCA Aubin c. Moumdjian 10/03/06 [2006] J.Q. no12186[2006] Q.J. No.12186
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — neurosurgeon— disc herniation
Page 20
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
2006 QCCA 1264J.E. 2006-2056[2006] R.R.A. 82742 C.C.L.T. (3d)242EYB 2006-1101262006 CarswellQue8720164 A.C.W.S. (3d)531
92. QCCA Poupart c. Sécuriténationale, compagnied'assurances
09/12/06 [2006] J.Q. no103092006 QCCA 1184J.E. 2006-1895152 A.C.W.S. (3d)768EYB 2006-109729
Cantin,Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure —jurisdiction of superiorcourt — arbitration —compromissory clause
93. QCCA Daviault c.Climatisation GR inc.
05/17/06 [2006] J.Q. no4637, 2006 QCCA689, J.E. 2006-1108, 150A.C.W.S. (3d) 293,EYB 2006-105527
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Respondent QC Appeal Class action –Authorization – Similar orrelated issues –Assignment of claims –Contracts – Defect ofconsent – Fraud –Liability of financialinstitutions.
94. QCCA Kruger inc. c.Première nation desBetsiamites
04/28/06 [2006] J.Q. no3932[2006] Q.J. No.39322006 QCCA 569J.E. 2006-1004[2006] 3 C.N.L.R.19149 A.C.W.S. (3d)864
Potter, SimonV.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket31025,20/10/2005)
Aboriginal law — lands— logging — safeguardorder
Page 21
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
95. QCCA Québec (Procureurgénéral) c.Première nation deBetsiamites
04/28/06 [2006] J.Q. no3931[2006] Q.J. No.39312006 QCCA 567
Potter, SimonV.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket31025,20/10/2005)
Aboriginal law — lands— logging — safeguardorder
96. QCCA Université deMontréal c.Commissiondes droits de lapersonneet des droits de lajeunesse
04/10/06 [2006] J.Q. no33572006 QCCA 508J.E. 2006-991148 A.C.W.S. (3d)69EYB 2005-103827
Baril, André Appellant QC Appeal Labour — human rights— jurisdiction ofgrievance arbitrator andof Québec Human RightsTribunal
97. QCCA TIP InvestmentAdvisors Ltd. c.Gilbert
02/20/06 [2006] J.Q. no17182006 QCCA 275
Bélanger,Philippe H.
Respondent QC Appeal Winding up — civilprocedure — safeguardorder
98. QCCA Syndicat national desemployéeset employés duCentre de soinsprolongés Grace Dart(CSN) c. Holligin-Richards
02/07/06 [2006] J.Q. no 9522006 QCCA 158147 A.C.W.S. (3d)721EYB 2006-100971
Gagnon,Nathalie
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievancearbitration — dismissal —right to arbitration
99. QCCA Beaupré c. Lavoie 01/12/06 [2006] J.Q. no 1092006 QCCA 36
Baril, André Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievancearbitration — claim forloss of revenue anddefamation — jurisdictionof arbitrator
100. QCCA Terreault c. Bigras 12/15/05 [2005] J.Q. no185852005 QCCA 1243[2006] R.J.Q. 126
Poupart,Emmanuelle
Respondent QC Appeal Legal ethics — feeagreement —cancellation of theagreement — agreement
Page 22
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
J.E. 2006-125145 A.C.W.S. (3d)166EYB 2005-99100
giving to the legalprofession a profit—seeking or commercialcharacter
101. QCCA Ruffo (Re) 12/09/05 [2005] J.Q. no17953[2005] Q.J. No.179532005 QCCA 1197[2006] R.J.Q. 26J.E. 2006-60144 A.C.W.S. (3d)863
Bélanger,Marie-Eve
Friend of theCourt
QC Report of theCourt ofAppealregarding arequest for theremoval ofJudge Ruffo
Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket31304,18/05/2006)
Discipline and ethics —legal professions —judges — removal of aprovincial court judge
102. QCCA Trikon Technologiesinc. c. Panametricsinc.
09/07/05 [2005] J.Q. no132672005 QCCA 796
Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure —contract — arbitrationclause
103. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada ltée c.Canada (Procureuregénérale)
08/22/05 [2005] J.Q. no111742005 QCCA 725142 A.C.W.S. (3d)423
Potter, SimonV.
Appellant QC Appeal Reversed byCanada(AttorneyGeneral) v.JTI-MacdonaldCorp., 2007SCC 30;[2007] 2S.C.R. 610
Constitutional — freedomof expression —advertising andpromotion of tobacco
104. QCCA Rothmans, Benson &Hedges inc. c.Canada (Procureuregénérale)
08/22/05 [2005] J.Q. no111752005 QCCA 727142 A.C.W.S. (3d)592
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Reversed byCanada(AttorneyGeneral) v.JTI-MacdonaldCorp., 2007SCC 30;[2007] 2
Constitutional — freedomof expression —advertising andpromotion of tobacco
Page 23
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
S.C.R. 610
105. QCCA Therrien c. Launay 07/06/05 [2005] J.Q. no90432005 QCCA 665J.E. 2005-1345141 A.C.W.S. (3d)669
Chénier,Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket31151,16/02/2006)
Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — diagnosis
106. QCCA Jalbert c. Centrehospitalieruniversitaire deQuébec, pavillonHotel-Dieu deQuébec
04/19/05 [2005] J.Q. no48902005 QCCA 446
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure — motionto dismiss the action
107. QCCA Association deschiropraticiens duQuébec c. Office desprofessions duQuébec
02/25/05 [2005] J.Q. no10872005 QCCA 189[2005] R.J.Q. 691J.E. 2005-559137 A.C.W.S. (3d)1236
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Professions —chiropractors —interpretation of theChiropractic Act —diagnosis
108. QCCA Tecsys inc. c. Sociétéen commandite CDTIde Montréal
12/10/04 [2004] J.Q. no13394137 A.C.W.S. (3d)1912004 CanLII46686
Potter, SimonV.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30753,25/08/2005)
Lease — interpretation —determination of rights —rent — arrears
Page 24
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
109. QCCA Citadelle,Coopérative deproducteurs de siropd'érable c. Régie desmarchés agricoles etalimentaries duQuébec
12/03/04 [2004] J.Q. no13206J.E. 2005-193136 A.C.W.S. (3d)981
Renaud,Madeleine
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30771,30/06/2005)
Agri-food — maple syrup— marketing control
110. QCCA Produits alimentairesJacques et Fils inc. c.Régie des marchésagricoles etalimentaires duQuébec
12/03/04 [2004] J.Q. no13205136 A.C.W.S. (3d)980REJB 2004-81157
Renaud,Madeleine
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30772,30/06/2005)
Agri-food — maple syrup— marketing control
111. QCCA Chambre de lasécurité financière c.Carciero
11/10/04 [2004] J.Q. no12036
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Respondent QC Appeal Disciplinary law –Securities – Statutoryoffenses – Act respectingthe distribution offinancial products andservices.
112. QCCA Banque Amex duCanada c. Procureurgénéral du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10130135 A.C.W.S. (3d)29
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30655,10/03/2005)
Class action —authorization — civilprocedure — joinder ofactions — functus officioI
Page 25
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
113. QCCA Banque canadienneimpériale decommerce c.Procureur général duQuébec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10127135 A.C.W.S. (3d)24
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30646,10/03/2005)
Class action —authorization — civilprocedure — joinder ofactions — functus officioI
114. QCCA Banque de Montréalc. Procureur généraldu Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10133135 A.C.W.S. (3d)30REJB 2004-70909
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30645,10/03/2005)
Class action —authorization — civilprocedure — joinder ofactions — functus officioI
115. QCCA Banque Laurentiennedu Canada c.Procureur général duQuébec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10129135 A.C.W.S. (3d)26EYB 2004-70919
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30650,10/03/2005)
Declaratory judgment —class action — joinder ofactions — right to beheard — adjudicationbeyond the conclusions
116. QCCA Banque MBNACanada c. Procureurgénéral du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10134J.E. 2004-1921135 A.C.W.S. (3d)31
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed
Class action —authorization — civilprocedure — joinder ofactions — functus officioI
Page 26
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
(Docket30647,10/03/2005)
117. QCCA Banque Nationale duCanada c. Procureurgénéral du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10128135 A.C.W.S. (3d)28
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30648,10/03/2005)
Class action —authorization — civilprocedure — joinder ofactions — functus officioI
118. QCCA Banque Royale duCanada c. Procureurgénéral du Québec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10132135 A.C.W.S. (3d)27
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30649,10/03/2005)
Class action —authorization — civilprocedure — joinder ofactions — functus officioI
119. QCCA Banque Toronto-Dominion c.Procureur général duQuébec
09/28/04 [2004] J.Q. no10123135 A.C.W.S. (3d)25
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30651,10/03/2005)
Class action —authorization — civilprocedure — joinder ofactions — functus officioI
120. QCCA Fédération desproducteursacéricoles du Québec
07/15/04 [2004] J.Q. no7880J.E. 2004-1583
Renaud,Madeleine
Respondent QC Appeal Agri-food — maple syrup— marketing control
Page 27
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
c. Citadelle,coopérative deproducteurs de siropd'érable
134 A.C.W.S. (3d)52004 CanLII 3284
121. QCCA Paquet c. Tardif 05/14/04 [2004] J.Q. no6699J.E. 2004-1248
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30457,06/01/2005)
Medical — civil liability —civil procedure —communication ofmedical records
122. QCCA Perez c. Bank ofNova Scotia
05/07/04 [2004] J.Q. no6451
Tremblay,Gérald R.Giroux,François M.
Respondent QC Appeal Private international law— declinatory exceptions— defendants' activitiesin Québec
123. QCCA Hrtschan c. Ville deMontréal
03/22/04 [2004] J.Q. no2772[2004] R.J.Q. 1073J.E. 2004-799[2004] R.R.A. 329133 A.C.W.S. (3d)708REJB 2004-55545
Arpin, Sophie Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket30354,06/01/2005)
Municipal — civil liability— defamation — mayor
124. QCCA Ville de Montréal c.M.J. Oppenheim
03/22/04 [2004] J.Q. no2773J.E. 2004-767[2004] R.R.A. 325133 A.C.W.S. (3d)539
Arpin, Sophie Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — insurancepolicy — defamation —civil liability
Page 28
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
125. QCCA Ordre des dentistesdu Québec c. Forget
03/10/04 [2004] J.Q. no3437
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — disciplinecommittee — dentists
126. QCCA Wolofsky c. GestionKenmont inc.
02/03/04 [2004] J.Q. no 620J.E. 2004-385133 A.C.W.S. (3d)364
Poplaw,Mason
Appellant QC Appeal Property law —servitudes — servitudeby destination ofproprietor
127. QCCA Essaris c. Kiriazis 12/19/03 [2003] J.Q. no19212J.E. 2004-269131 A.C.W.S. (3d)1141
Lortie, Jean Respondent QC Appeal Real estate — leases —publication of rights —cancellation — safeguardorder
128. QCCA SSQ Sociétéd'assurance-vie inc.c. La Société desservices dentaires(A.C.D.Q.) inc.
12/01/03 [2003] J.Q. no17929
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure —acquiescence in ademand — letterconfirming theunconditional nature ofthe acquiescence
129. QCCA UL Canada inc. c.Procureur général duQuébec
10/01/03 [2003] J.Q. no13505[2003] R.J.Q. 2729234 D.L.R. (4th)398J.E. 2003-197510 Admin. L.R.(4th) 36
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Affirmed byUL CanadaInc. c.Québec(Procureurgénéral),2005 CSC 10,[2005] 1R.C.S. 143
Constitutional —distribution of legislativepowers — colour ofmargarine — freedom ofexpression
130. QCCA Dans l'affaire de lafaillite de : Réjean St-Pierre c. RaymondChabot inc.
09/09/03 [2003] J.Q. no11751J.E. 2003-1712127 A.C.W.S. (3d)400
Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Appeal Bankruptcy andinsolvency — proof ofclaim — cattle broker —seizure and sale ofcalves — preferentialpayments
Page 29
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
131. QCCA Assurance-vieDesjardinsLaurentienne c.Poirier-Wilson
08/29/03 [2003] J.Q. no10949J.E. 2003-1670[2003] R.R.A.1098127 A.C.W.S. (3d)1242
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — insuranceon hypothecs — falsestatements —interpretation of theinsurance contract
132. QCCA Labonté c. Tanguay 06/02/03 [2003] J.Q. no6539J.E. 2003-1218[2003] R.R.A. 774126 A.C.W.S. (3d)1034
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —causation — faults ofomission
133. QCCA Laforce c. Dumont 05/05/03 [2003] J.Q. no4945J.E. 2003-959[2003] R.R.A. 422125 A.C.W.S. (3d)911
Platts, DavidE.
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — vicariousliability — causation
134. QCCA Banque deMontréal/Bank ofMontreal c. BanquedeNouvelle-Écosse/Bank of NovaScotia
04/28/03 [2003] J.Q. no4362J.E. 2003-917[2003] R.R.A. 400
Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — childbirth —caesarean
135. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 04/17/03 [2003] J.Q. no5510
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Professions — lawyersand attorneys — security— hypothecs —contracts
136. QCCA Enterprises R & G St-Laurent inc. C.Québec (Procureurgénéral) (Ministèredes Transports duQuébec)
04/17/03 [2003] J.Q. no5450
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Professions — lawyersand attorneys — security— hypothecs —contracts
Page 30
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
137. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 04/07/03 [2003] J.Q. no3320[2003] R.J.Q. 1081J.E. 2003-828REJB 2003-39879125 A.C.W.S. (3d)994
Tremblay,Gérald R.Giroux,François M.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket29810,09/10/2003)
Corporations —oppression remedy —unanimous shareholdersagreement — referral toarbitration
138. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 03/13/03 [2003] J.Q. no4495J.E. 2003-747
Dufresne,Marie-Ève
Appellant QC Appeal International private law— declaratory judgment— forum non conveniens— action in damagesfiled in Texas
139. QCCA MacMillan c. AbbottLaboratories
02/21/03 [2003] J.Q. no 984J.E. 2003-472
Tremblay,Gérald R.Lortie, Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket29199,26/06/2003)
Insurance — class action— value of payment ofannual premiums
140. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 02/11/03 [2003] J.Q. no 669J.E. 2003-493
Potter, SimonV.
Respondent QC Appeal Corporations —shareholders —unanimous shareholdersagreement — sale ofshares — dividends
141. QCCA Lorrain c PetroCanada
01/23/03 [2003] J.Q. no4024J.E. 2003-383[2003] R.R.A. 127
Cantin,Philippe
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — subrogation— exception to theinsurer's subrogatoryclaim
Page 31
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
142. QCCA Consultants Aecominc. C. Société duQuébec
12/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no5287
Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket29567,02/10/2003)
Corporations —receiver—manager —oppression — abuse ofright by directors
143. QCCA Canada (Procurergénéral) c. ImpérialTobacco Ltd.
12/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no5286
Poplaw,Mason
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket29567,02/10/2003)
Corporations —receiver—manager —oppression — abuse ofright by directors
144. QCCA Centre commercialLes Rivières ltée c.Jean Bleu inc.
12/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no5282J.E. 2003-45120 A.C.W.S. (3d)768REJB 2002-36022
Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket29567,02/10/2003)
Corporations — receiver— manager —oppression — abuse ofright by directors
145. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. C.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté
11/25/02 [2002] J.Q. no5088J.E. 2003-32119 A.C.W.S. (3d)260REJB 2002-35845
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Labour — dismissal —senior manager — noticeof termination
Page 32
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
146. QCCA Han c. Demers 10/22/02 [2002] J.Q. no4749118 A.C.W.S. (3d)57
Bélanger,Philippe H.
Appellant QC Appeal Reversed byBanquenationale deParis(Canada) c.165836Canada Inc.,2004 CSC 37;[2004] 2R.C.S. 45
Obligations —transaction — offer tosettle
147. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 10/22/02 [2002] J.Q. no4750
Bélanger,Philippe H.
Respondent QC Appeal Reversed byBanquenationale deParis(Canada) c.165836Canada Inc.,2004 CSC 37;[2004] 2R.C.S. 45
Obligations —transaction — offer tosettle
148. QCCA Thibault c. Marina dela Chaudière inc.
09/09/02 [2002] J.Q. no3859[2002] R.J.Q. 3005118 A.C.W.S. (3d)208REJB 2002-33889J.E. 2002-16932002 CanLII41226
Tremblay,Gérald R.Potter, SimonV.
Appelant(Tremblay)Respondent(Potter)
QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket29449,12/06/2003)
Contracts — sale ofbusiness — distributionof auto parts —noncompetitionagreement —assessment of damages
149. QCCA Bitton v. AppleCanada Inc.
08/23/02 [2002] J.Q. no3571[2002] R.R.A. 771
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Real estate — sale ofland — professionalliability — notary
150. QCCA N.F. c. Montréal (Villede)
06/14/02 [2002] J.Q. no3141REJB 2002-32242
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — civilprocedure — action inwarranty
Page 33
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
151. QCCA Masson c. Centre desanté et de servicessociaux de St-Jérôme(CSSS)
06/04/02 [2002] J.Q. no3086
Tremblay,Gérald R.Lortie, Jean
Appellant QC Appeal Corporate law — value ofshares — interest
152. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 05/08/02 [2002] J.Q. no1057[2002] R.R.A. 296116 A.C.W.S. (3d)126REJB 2002-30304
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — duty to inform
153. QCCA Matériaux deconstructionOldcastle CanadaInc. c. St-Bruno-de-Montarville (Ville de)
05/08/02 [2002] J.Q. no1056[2002] R.J.Q. 1262J.E. 2002-937[2002] R.D.I. 241[2002] R.R.A. 3172002 CanLII41120116 A.C.W.S. (3d)131REJB 2002-31662REJB 2002-34963
Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — promise ofsale — preference clause— assignment of rights— Paulian Action —damages — extrajudicialfees
154. QCCA Watters v. White 05/08/02 [2002] J.Q. no1058
Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — promise ofsale — preference clause— assignment of rights— Paulian Action —damages — extrajudicialfees
155. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 04/24/02 [2002] J.Q. no2851
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Damages — abuse ofprocess — assessmentof evidence
156. QCCA Anvil Mining Ltd. v.Associationcanadienne contrel’impunité
03/18/02 [2002] J.Q. no 464 Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Municipal — contracts —liability — infrastructureproject
Page 34
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
157. QCCA Organisme canadiende réglementation ducommerce desvaleurs mobilières(OCRCVM) c.Beaudouin
03/07/02 [2002] J.Q. no 696J.E. 2002-543REJB 2002-30825
Tremblay,Gérald R.Lortie, Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket29199,26/06/2003)
Insurance — class action— civil procedure —authorization — right ofappeal
158. QCCA OptionConsommateurs v.InfineonTechnologies AG
02/12/02 [2002] J.Q. no 194[2002] R.J.Q. 328J.E. 2002-402112 A.C.W.S. (3d)1014
Deschamps,Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket29156,27/03/2003)
Winding up — funds —loss of legal status
159. QCCA Banque deMontréal/Bank ofMontreal c. BanquedeNouvelle-Écosse/Bank of NovaScotia
02/05/02 [2002] J.Q. no 279[2002] Q.J. No.279
Gagnon,Nathalie
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievancearbitration — judicialreview
160. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 01/23/02 [2002] J.Q. no 68J.E. 2002-297[2002] R.D.I. 36113 A.C.W.S. (3d)154
Tremblay,Gérald R.Dufour, Marc
Respondent QC Appeal Real estate — contracts— commercial lease —resiliation — assignmentclause
161. QCCA Enterprises R & G St-Laurent inc. C.Québec (Procureurgénéral) (Ministère
01/17/02 [2002] J.Q. no 28 Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — lease —eviction of the lessee —transaction
Page 35
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
des Transports duQuébec)
162. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 11/16/01 [2001] J.Q. no5776[2001] R.R.A. 881
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — claim forbenefits — assessmentof medical evidence
163. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 11/12/01 [2001] J.Q. no5990
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Contracts — obligations— partnerships — lawfirm — partner leaving
164. QCCA MacMillan c. AbbottLaboratories
11/04/01 [2001] J.Q. no5001
Deschamps,Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Security — contracts —discharge of debtors
165. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 10/16/01 [2001] J.Q. no491627 M.P.L.R. (3d)267
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Constitutional —municipal amalgamations— injunction
166. QCCA Lorrain c PetroCanada
10/16/01 [2001] J.Q. no4821[2001] R.J.Q. 2520J.E. 2001-196127 M.P.L.R. (3d)173108 A.C.W.S. (3d)980
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket28869,07/12/2001)
Constitutional —municipal amalgamations— injunction
167. QCCA Scotia McLeod Inc. c.Banque de Nouvelle-Écosse
08/28/01 [2001] J.Q. no3815, [2001]R.J.Q. 2099, J.E.2001-1654, 27C.C.P.B. 169, 108A.C.W.S. (3d) 89,REJB 2001-25542
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Appellant QC Appeal Confirmed byBank of NovaScotia v.Thibault, 2004SCC 29,[2004] 1 SCR758
Annuities – Self-directedregistered retirementsavings plan – Exemptionfrom seizure – Right towithdraw funds –Alienation of capital.
Page 36
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
168. QCCA Canada (Procurergénéral) c. ImpérialTobacco Ltd.
07/13/01 [2001] J.Q. no7614[2001] R.R.A. 619
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — lifeinsurance — suicide —exclusion clause
169. QCCA Centre commercialLes Rivières ltée c.Jean Bleu inc.
06/12/01 [2001] J.Q. no2783J.E. 2001-1273[2001] R.R.A. 567REJB 2001-24643107 A.C.W.S. (3d)6942001 CanLII20632
Poupart,Emmanuelle
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — neurosurgeon— diagnosis — medicaltreatment
170. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. C.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté
05/03/01 [2001] J.Q. no2228
Schenke,Stephen G.
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — contract ofenterprise — awarding ofthe contract — good faith— compliance of bid
171. QCCA Han c. Demers 04/30/01 [2001] J.Q. no1893[2001] R.R.A. 3102001 CanLII14425
Chénier,Robert-Jean
Appellant QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —medical malpractice —diagnosis
172. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 04/09/01 [2001] J.Q. no1446[2001] R.J.Q. 846J.E. 2001-812[2001] R.R.A. 332107 A.C.W.S. (3d)287REJB 2001-23520
Deschamps,Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Financial institutions —banks — negotiableinstrument — clearingrules
173. QCCA Teixeira c. TetraVision Inc.
03/22/01 [2001] J.Q. no1219, J.E. 2001-747, 2001 CanLII5481, REJB 2001-23492
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Respondent QC Appeal Class action – Criteria forauthorization – Leasing –Setting-up of acomputerized system ofadvertising.
Page 37
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
174. QCCA Thibault c. Marina dela Chaudière inc.
02/19/01 [2001] Q.J. No.592[2001] R.R.A. 39
Schenke,Steve G.
Appellant QC Appeal All-risk insurance —claim for insuranceindemnity — constructionproject — faulty design
175. QCCA Bitton v. AppleCanada Inc.
02/01/01 [2001] J.Q. no 258[2001] R.J.Q. 875200 D.L.R. (4th)470J.E. 2001-4242001 CanLII17930104 A.C.W.S. (3d)784
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket28479,04/10/2001)
Professions — lawyers— eligibility for theprofession
176. QCCA N.F. c. Montréal (Villede)
01/09/01 [2001] J.Q. no 9[2001] R.J.D.T. 10J.E. 2001-259102 A.C.W.S. (3d)909REJB 2001-21823
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Labour — labourstandards — overtime —application of the LabourStandards Act — seniormanager
177. QCCA Masson c. Centre desanté et de servicessociaux de St-Jérôme(CSSS)
10/23/00 [2000] J.Q. no3776J.E. 2000-2005[2000] R.D.I. 56348 R.P.R. (3d) 22100 A.C.W.S. (3d)890
Deschamps,Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Hypothecs —hypothecary remedies —taking in payment —emphyteusis
178. QCCA McMahon Essaiminc. c. ToulonDevelopment Corp.
06/28/00 [2000] J.Q. no2117
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts and obligations– Suretyship – Paulianaction – Transfer ofmoney – Discharge ofpayment.
179. QCCA Fortier c. Lavoie 06/12/00 [2000] J.Q. no1921J.E. 2000-125899 A.C.W.S. (3d)
Lehoux, Jean-François
Appellant QC Interlocutory Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilprocedure — medicalexamination — fees paid
Page 38
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
40REJB 2000-18714
in part by the other party
180. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 06/05/00 [2000] J.Q. no1870[2000] R.J.Q. 1692J.E. 2000-1221[2000] R.R.A. 633
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — lifeinsurance — suicide —insurer's duty toindemnify — duty toinquire about the healthof his client
181. QCCA Matériaux deconstructionOldcastle CanadaInc. c. St-Bruno-de-Montarville (Ville de)
06/05/00 [2000] J.Q. no1909
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — lifeinsurance — suicide —insurer's duty toindemnify — duty toinquire about the healthof his client
182. QCCA Watters v. White 05/01/00 [2000] J.Q. no1548[2000] R.D.I. 20298 A.C.W.S. (3d)927
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Contractual obligations— sale and delivery ofimmoveable property —forced execution —permanent injunction —transfer of title
183. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 04/17/00 [2000] J.Q. no1215[2000] R.J.Q. 1086J.E. 2000-85698 A.C.W.S. (3d)809
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Publishing andpublications — legalpublications — access tocourt decisions inQuébec
184. QCCA Anvil Mining Ltd. v.Associationcanadienne contrel’impunité
04/04/00 [2000] J.Q. no1040J.E. 2000-77798 A.C.W.S. (3d)1108REJB 2000-174802000 CanLII 7400
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket27953,
Extra-contractual liability— prescription — realestate — purchase ofimmoveable — leaseagreement — option torenew
Page 39
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
25/01/2001)
185. QCCA Organisme canadiende réglementation ducommerce desvaleurs mobilières(OCRCVM) c.Beaudouin
03/02/00 [2000] J.Q. no6184
Chénier,Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — post-operativefollow-up
186. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 12/14/99 [1999] J.Q. no5502[2000] R.J.Q. 58J.E. 2000-126REJB 1999-15659
Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Appeal Movable hypothec —hypothecary remedies —sale by judicial authority
187. QCCA Enterprises R & G St-Laurent inc. C.Québec (Procureurgénéral) (Ministèredes Transports duQuébec)
10/04/99 [1999] J.Q. no4446J.E. 99-2033[1999] R.R.A. 817
Poplaw,Mason
Appellant QC Appeal Reversed inpart byPrévost-Masson v.General Trustof Canada,2001 SCC 87,[2001] 3S.C.R. 882
Contracts — obligations— obligations in solidum— professional liability —chartered accountant
188. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 06/03/99 [1999] J.Q. no1790J.E. 99-134389 A.C.W.S. (3d)281D.T.E. 99T-598REJB 1999-12823
Tremblay,Gérald R.Gagnon,Nathalie
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadiscontinued(Docket27464,10/22/2000)
Labour — dismissal —just cause — seniordirector
189. QCCA MacMillan c. AbbottLaboratories
05/20/99 [1999] J.Q. no4293[1999] R.R.A. 441
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — lifeinsurance — death ofinsured
Page 40
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
REJB 1999-13936
190. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 04/26/99 [1999] J.Q. no6870
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — lifeinsurance — totaldisability — benefits
191. QCCA Lorrain c PetroCanada
03/01/99 [1999] Q.J. No.572
Gagnon,Nathalie
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — wrongfuldismissal — sufficientcause
192. QCCA Centre commercialLes Rivières ltée c.Jean Bleu inc.
12/02/98 [1998] J.Q. no3667J.E. 99-253[1999] R.J.D.T. 984 A.C.W.S. (3d)902
Baril, André Appellant QC Appeal Labour — unions —certification — sale ofundertaking
193. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. C.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté
10/29/98 [1998] J.Q. no3165
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Contract — formationand execution — sale ofland — damages — lossof profits —reimbursement ofexpenses — damage toreputation — evidence —admissions
194. QCCA Han c. Demers 06/15/98 [1998] J.Q. no1944[1998] R.J.Q. 1722J.E. 98-146282 A.C.W.S. (3d)244
Giroux,François M.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure — partialannulment of anarbitration award —service of proceedings
195. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 06/15/98 [1998] J.Q. no1946[1998] R.J.Q. 1731J.E. 98-146382 A.C.W.S. (3d)282
Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanada
Bankruptcy andinsolvency — civilprocedure — recusal of ajudge — reasonableapprehension of bias
Page 41
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
REJB 1998-06799 dismissed(Docket26815,04/03/1999)
196. QCCA Thibault c. Marina dela Chaudière inc.
06/05/98 [1998] J.Q. no186680 A.C.W.S. (3d)1108J.E. 98-1367REJB 1998-06604
Chénier,Robert-Jean
Appellant QC Appeal Medical — disciplinecommittee — judicialreview — rules of naturaljustice
197. QCCA Bitton v. AppleCanada Inc.
04/29/98 [1998] J.Q. no1257[1998] R.R.A. 385
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — surgery —post-operatory follow-up
198. QCCA Masson c. Centre desanté et de servicessociaux de St-Jérôme(CSSS)
02/17/98 [1998] Q.J. No.373J.E. 98-518[1998] R.D.F. 183REJB 1998-04774
Gagnon,Nathalie
Respondent QC Appeal Family law — custodyand access to children —interest of childparamount
199. QCCA Matériaux deconstructionOldcastle CanadaInc. c. St-Bruno-de-Montarville (Ville de)
12/02/97 [1997] J.Q. no4040
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket25547,29/05/1997)
Evidence — solicitor-client privilege
200. QCCA Watters v. White 11/24/97 [1997] J.Q. no4132[1998] R.R.A. 1
Chénier,Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — neurosurgeon
201. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 09/29/97 [1997] J.Q. no3204[1997] R.J.Q. 2663
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Successions —administration — trusts— termination of trust —
Page 42
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
156 D.L.R. (4th)376J.E. 97-1866
production — annualaccounts
202. QCCA Anvil Mining Ltd. v.Associationcanadienne contrel’impunité
06/09/97 [1997] J.Q. no2125J.E. 97-135679 C.P.R. (3d) 40373 A.C.W.S. (3d)189REJB 1997-010731997 CanLII10706
Renaud,Madeleine
Intervenor QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket26256,30/04/1998)
Agri-food — hog sale —modification of regulation— jurisdiction of Régiedes marchés agricoles etalimentaires du Québec
203. QCCA OptionConsommateurs v.InfineonTechnologies AG
05/29/97 [1997] J.Q. no2295J.E. 97-1431[1997] R.R.A. 687
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability — huntingaccident — act or fault ofanother
204. QCCA Banque deMontréal/Bank ofMontreal c. BanquedeNouvelle-Écosse/Bank of NovaScotia
05/27/97 [1997] J.Q. no1914[1997] R.R.A. 314
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — houseinsurance — coverage —secondary house
205. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 05/14/97 [1997] J.Q. no1603[1997] R.R.A. 310
Bélanger,Philippe H.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket26144,18/12/1997)
Civil liability —investments — kiting —financial situation ofcorporations
Page 43
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
206. QCCA Enterprises R & G St-Laurent inc. C.Québec (Procureurgénéral) (Ministèredes Transports duQuébec)
05/07/97 [1997] J.Q. no1586
Bélanger,Philippe H.
Respondent QC Appeal Hypothecs —hypothecary remedies —description of theimmoveable
207. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 03/11/97 [1997] J.Q. no 796 Gagné,Michel
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —medical malpractice
208. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 03/10/97 [1997] J.Q. no 792J.E. 97-575[1997] R.R.A. 275
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket25986,06/11/1997)
Insurance — loans —accuracy of declarationsby the insured
209. QCCA MacMillan c. AbbottLaboratories
03/10/97 [1997] Q.J. No.692J.E. 97-611
Lehoux, Jean-François
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — dismissalof the action —prescription
210. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 03/10/97 [1997] Q.J. No.693
Lehoux, Jean-François
Respondent QC Appeal Medical malpractice —dismissal of the action —extinctive prescription
211. QCCA Lorrain c PetroCanada
02/25/97 [1997] J.Q. no 575 Bélanger,Philippe H.
Appellant QC Appeal Banks — winding up —irrevocable letter of credit
212. QCCA Consultants Aecominc. C. Société duQuébec
02/21/97 [1997] J.Q. no 513[1997] R.J.Q. 816148 D.L.R. (4th)255J.E. 97-58871 A.C.W.S. (3d)
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanada
Elections — contestation— illegal or corruptpractice
Page 44
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
711997 CanLII10409
dismissed(Docket25848,16/10/1997)
213. QCCA Centre commercialLes Rivières ltée c.Jean Bleu inc.
12/16/96 [1996] J.Q. no4136
Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — installationof fuel tanks — paving —leak
214. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. C.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté
05/31/96 [1996] J.Q. no1342
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure —production of documents
215. QCCA Han c. Demers 03/06/96 [1996] J.Q. no 524J.E. 96-602EYB 1996-7180861 A.C.W.S. (3d)1083
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Construction — call fortenders — bid depositorysystem — conformity ofbid
216. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 02/21/96 [1996] J.Q. no 339[1996] R.D.J. 193
Tardif, AlainN.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Bankruptcy andinsolvency — proposal —commercial leases —rents — stay
217. QCCA Thibault c. Marina dela Chaudière inc.
02/12/96 [1996] J.Q. no 293 Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Contracts —interpretation — leasingagreement — priceprovision
218. QCCA Bitton v. AppleCanada Inc.
02/12/96 [1996] J.Q. no 293 Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Interpretation of contract— fixed lease rate —layman
219. QCCA N.F. c. Montréal (Villede)
12/12/95 [1995] J.Q. no1140J.E. 96-126[1996] R.R.A. 25
Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — duty to inform
Page 45
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
220. QCCA Masson c. Centre desanté et de servicessociaux de St-Jérôme(CSSS)
12/12/95 [1995] J.Q. no1112J.E. 96-121[1996] R.D.J. 6259 A.C.W.S. (3d)1033
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure —uncontested — judicialauthorizations —executor — request fordismissal — s.885 Codede procédure civile —statutory interpretation
221. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 11/22/95 [1995] J.Q. no 931J.E. 96-2EYB 1995-57702[1996] R.D.I. 6
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Servitude — perpetuity— immoveable —electricity — transmissionand telephone lines
222. QCCA Matériaux deconstructionOldcastle CanadaInc. c. St-Bruno-de-Montarville (Ville de)
10/06/95 [1995] J.Q. no 727[1995] R.J.Q. 597[1995] R.D.J. 597
Renaud,Madeleine
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket25029,05/12/1995)
Labour — work stoppage— essential publicservices — bus service— power of council toorder return to work
223. QCCA Watters v. White 08/28/95 [1995] J.Q. no 663J.E. 95-172757 A.C.W.S. (3d)754EYB 1995-56924
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Securities law —commission fees —public order — validity ofcontracts — jurisdiction— prescription — actionsin warranty
224. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 08/08/95 [1995] J.Q. no 529J.E. 95-1631[1995] R.D.J. 53757 A.C.W.S. (3d)738
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance policy —jurisdiction — lis pendens— forum non conveniens— prescription
225. QCCA Anvil Mining Ltd. v.Associationcanadienne contrel’impunité
05/31/95 [1995] J.Q. no 475J.E. 95-1225[1995] R.D.J. 47955 A.C.W.S. (3d)
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure —discontinuance —transaction — offer tosettle
Page 46
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
1262
226. QCCA Organisme canadiende réglementation ducommerce desvaleurs mobilières(OCRCVM) c.Beaudouin
05/18/95 [1995] J.Q. no 445J.E. 95-1183[1995] R.R.A. 58955 A.C.W.S. (3d)432
Deschamps,Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability —professional liability —auditor
227. QCCA OptionConsommateurs v.InfineonTechnologies AG
04/21/95 [1995] J.Q. no 420[1995] R.J.Q. 1329J.E. 95-109155 A.C.W.S. (3d)769
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket24729,29/06/1995)
Canada Election Act —contestation of election— presentation of notice— time frame — statuteinterpretation
228. QCCA Banque deMontréal/Bank ofMontreal c. BanquedeNouvelle-Écosse/Bank of NovaScotia
04/06/95 [1995] Q.J. No.334
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Damages — limits ofcompensatory damages— prohibition againstdouble recovery — bars— payment bymanufacturer
229. QCCA Enterprises R & G St-Laurent inc. C.Québec (Procureurgénéral) (Ministèredes Transports duQuébec)
02/23/95 [1995] J.Q. no 184 Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Appeal Contracts — contract ofadhesion — no legalrelation between theparties
230. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 01/16/95 [1995] J.Q. no 25[1995] R.J.Q. 63J.E. 95-222[1995] R.R.A. 4
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupreme
Line of credit — security— respondent seizure —loss of profits —prescription
Page 47
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
52 A.C.W.S. (3d)1013
Court ofCanadadismissed(Docket24608,27/05/1999)
231. QCCA MacMillan c. AbbottLaboratories
11/28/94 [1994] J.Q. no1000J.E. 95-19EYB 1994-55894
Dufour, Marc Respondent QC Appeal Administrative law — realestate assessment —judicial review — powersof superior court
232. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 11/28/94 [1994] J.Q. no 999J.E. 95-8767 Q.A.C. 1[1995] R.D.J. 3351 A.C.W.S. (3d)1075EYB 1994-28943
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Union grievance —dismissal — arbitration —admissibility of evidence— hearsay — burden ofproof
233. QCCA Consultants Aecominc. C. Société duQuébec
08/31/94 [1994] J.Q. no 611[1995] R.D.J. 11849 A.C.W.S. (3d)1305
Potter, SimonV.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —interlocutory injunction —sale of business —noncompetition clause
234. QCCA Canada (Procurergénéral) c. ImpérialTobacco Ltd.
06/02/94 [1994] J.Q. no 458[1994] R.J.Q. 1269J.E. 94-97948 A.C.W.S. (3d)292
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket24314,01/12/1994)
Insurance —enforcement of foreignjudgement —executory/final judgment— cross-claim
235. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. C.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté
05/24/94 [1994] J.Q. no 447[1994] R.J.Q. 1493J.E. 94-107448 A.C.W.S. (3d)907
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure — costs— abuse of procedures— specific orders — legalfees —criteria tocondemn lawyer for costs
Page 48
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
EYB 1994-59173
236. QCCA Han c. Demers 05/20/94 [1994] J.Q. no 417[1994] R.J.Q. 1196J.E. 94-92664 Q.A.C. 3148 A.C.W.S. (3d)15721 C.H.R.R. 189
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket24291,21/11/1996)
Human rights —discrimination —intellectual disability —right to free publiceducation
237. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 03/18/94 [1994] J.Q. no 218[1994] R.R.A. 230
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance contract —interpretation —exclusions clause —insurer's duty toindemnify
238. QCCA Thibault c. Marina dela Chaudière inc.
01/24/94 [1994] J.Q. no 48[1994] R.J.Q. 289J.E. 94-25060 Q.A.C. 5045 A.C.W.S. (3d)673
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Crown immunity —senior civil servant —dismissal — injunction
239. QCCA Bitton v. AppleCanada Inc.
12/23/93 [1993] J.Q. no2222[1994] R.J.Q. 29J.E. 94-8861 Q.A.C. 30744 A.C.W.S. (3d)1020EYB 1993-643061993 CanLII 4401
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Civil procedure —mandamus — Barreaudu Québec — judicialreview
240. QCCA N.F. c. Montréal (Villede)
12/17/93 [1993] J.Q. no2254J.E. 94-193
Arpin, Sophie Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —interlocutory —examination on discovery
Page 49
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
60 Q.A.C. 168[1994] R.D.J. 17244 A.C.W.S. (3d)1199EYB 1994-64491
after defence
241. QCCA Masson c. Centre desanté et de servicessociaux de St-Jérôme(CSSS)
07/30/93 [1993] J.Q. no1204[1993] Q.J. No.1204[1993] R.J.Q. 2070J.E. 93-142058 Q.A.C. 16142 A.C.W.S. (3d)75
Tremblay,Gérald R.Deschamps,Michel
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket23850,10/02/1994)
Winding up — registeredpension plans — depositadministration contracts— priority
242. QCCA Fortier c. Lavoie 07/30/93 [1993] J.Q. no1203[1993] Q.J. No.1203J.E. 93-141958 Q.A.C. 211[1994] R.L. 26842 A.C.W.S. (3d)76
Tremblay,Gérald R.Deschamps,Michel
Intervenor QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket23851,10/02/1994)
Winding up — mutual lifeinsurance society —provisional liquidator —priority claim
243. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 07/06/93 [1993] J.Q. no1201[1994] R.D.J. 13EYB 1993-5919441 A.C.W.S. (3d)799
Dufour, Marc Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —dilatory exceptions —particulars
244. QCCA Matériaux deconstructionOldcastle CanadaInc. c. St-Bruno-de-Montarville (Ville de)
05/19/93 [1993] J.Q. no 632J.E. 93-87456 Q.A.C. 215[1994] R.L. 12639 A.C.W.S. (3d)
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt of
Contracts — attribution ofa contract by a publicbody — call for tenders— injunction —declaratory judgment
Page 50
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
1120 Canadadismissed(Docket23633,23/09/1993)
245. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 03/11/93 [1993] J.Q. no 436 Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability — mandate— securitiesmanagement agreement— duty to inform —negligence
246. QCCA Anvil Mining Ltd. v.Associationcanadienne contrel’impunité
02/24/93 [1993] J.Q. no 282 Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket23850,10/02/1994)
Winding up — provisionalexecution of a superiorcourt judgment
247. QCCA Organisme canadiende réglementation ducommerce desvaleurs mobilières(OCRCVM) c.Beaudouin
02/24/93 [1993] J.Q. no 283 Tremblay,Gérald R.
Intervenor QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket23851,10/02/1994)
Winding up — motion fordirections — stay —priority claims
248. QCCA OptionConsommateurs v.InfineonTechnologies AG
02/22/93 [1993] J.Q. no 275 Renaud,Madeleine
Respondent QC Appeal Constitutional —Competition Act —declaratory judgment
Page 51
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
249. QCCA Banque deMontréal/Bank ofMontreal c. BanquedeNouvelle-Écosse/Bank of NovaScotia
01/15/93 [1993] J.Q. no 1[1993] Q.J. No. 1[1993] R.J.Q. 375102 D.L.R. (4th)289J.E. 93-32953 Q.A.C. 7948 C.P.R. (3d) 41738 A.C.W.S. (3d)55
Potter, SimonV.
Respondent QC Appeal Affirmed byRJR -MacDonaldInc. v.Canada(AttorneyGeneral),[1994] 1S.C.R. 311
Constitutional — freedomof expression —advertising andpromotion of tobacco —stay — relief fromcompliance withregulations
250. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 08/27/92 [1992] J.Q. no1445
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability — personalinjury — fall
251. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 03/30/92 [1992] J.Q. no 495[1993] R.L. 432 A.C.W.S. (3d)1071
Potter, SimonV.
Appellant QC Appeal Corporations — directorsand officers — right toindemnification
252. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 03/16/92 [1992] J.Q. no 44795 D.L.R. (4th)644J.E. 92-59646 Q.A.C. 21[1992] R.D.J. 33332 A.C.W.S. (3d)699
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Environmental law —class action — civilprocedure — motion tostrike paragraphs —modification of the natureof the remedy
253. QCCA Lorrain c PetroCanada
01/29/92 [1992] J.Q. no 76J.E. 92-336[1992] R.D.J. 35831 A.C.W.S. (3d)539
Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —cross-demand —connectivity between thecauses of action
254. QCCA Consultants Aecominc. C. Société duQuébec
12/30/91 [1991] J.Q. no2310J.E. 92-13644 Q.A.C. 271[1992] R.R.A. 331 A.C.W.S. (3d)
Chénier,Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —medical malpractice —diagnosis — prescribedmedication
Page 52
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
162
255. QCCA Canada (Procurergénéral) c. ImpérialTobacco Ltd.
09/18/91 [1991] J.Q. no1669J.E. 91-155342 Q.A.C. 125[1992] R.L. 3366 C.C.L.I. (2d) 20929 A.C.W.S. (3d)550
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — sale of astolen good — claim of astolen good — action inwarranty — subrogation— good faith
256. QCCA Centre commercialLes Rivières ltée c.Jean Bleu inc.
07/30/91 [1991] J.Q. no1264[1991] R.J.Q. 1852J.E. 91-127040 Q.A.C. 20028 A.C.W.S. (3d)470
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Expropriation —jurisdiction of Court ofQuébec (expropriationchamber) — assessmentof damages
257. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. C.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté
06/07/91 [1991] J.Q. no1025J.E. 91-1034[1991] R.L. 64647 C.L.R. 21327 A.C.W.S. (3d)399
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket22641,06/02/1992)
Construction — defect —architects — civil liability
258. QCCA Han c. Demers 06/07/91 [1991] J.Q. no1026
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket
Construction — defect —architects — civil liability
Page 53
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
22641,06/02/1992)
259. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 06/06/91 [1991] J.Q. no1068[1992] R.D.J. 127 A.C.W.S. (3d)797EYB 1991-57899J.E. 91-1114
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —incidental proceedings —illegal amendment —extinctive prescription
260. QCCA Thibault c. Marina dela Chaudière inc.
06/03/91 [1991] J.Q. no1002J.E. 91-102951 Q.A.C. 107[1991] R.D.J. 46627 A.C.W.S. (3d)610
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket22623,16/01/1992)
Company law — sale ofshares — warranty —claim for sharesownership
261. QCCA Bitton v. AppleCanada Inc.
04/10/91 [1991] J.Q. no 630J.E. 91-672EYB 1991-94675
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Contracts — publiccontracts —infrastructure works —execution on contractualobligations
262. QCCA N.F. c. Montréal (Villede)
11/30/90 [1990] J.Q. no2124J.E. 91-94[1991] R.D.I. 36
Poplaw,Mason
Appellant QC Appeal Real estate — lease —municipal taxation —taxes payable by thelandlord
263. QCCA Masson c. Centre desanté et de servicessociaux de St-Jérôme(CSSS)
11/21/90 [1990] J.Q. no2140J.E. 91-55[1990] R.D.J. 598EYB 1990-5810524 A.C.W.S. (3d)548
Gagné,Michel
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — medicalmalpractice — civilliability — extinctiveprescription
Page 54
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
264. QCCA Fortier c. Lavoie 11/07/90 [1990] J.Q. no2018
Rousse,Jacques
Respondent QC Appeal Labour — grievancearbitration — discipline —dismissal —reinstatement
265. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 09/21/90 [1990] J.Q. no1662[1990] R.J.Q. 2498J.E. 90-149232 Q.A.C. 1 ext23 A.C.W.S. (3d)351
Renaud,Madeleine
Intervenor QC Reference Affirmed byReference reEducation Act(Que.), [1993]2 S.C.R. 511
Constitutional - education- linguistic school boards
266. QCCA Matériaux deconstructionOldcastle CanadaInc. c. St-Bruno-de-Montarville (Ville de)
06/19/90 [1990] J.Q. no1062[1990] R.J.Q. 1547J.E. 90-1033
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket22101,07/02/1991)
Bankruptcy andinsolvency — trustee —proof of claim
267. QCCA General Accident Cied'assurance duCanada c. Duhaime
06/01/90 [1990] J.Q. no1003
Loranger,Julie-Martines
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance – Subrogatoryremedy.
268. QCCA Sivananda YogaVedanta Centre Inc.c. Val Morin(Municipalité)
03/14/90 [1990] J.Q. no445, J.E. 90-584,[1990] R.L. 204
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Appellant QC Appeal Municipal taxation –Property and schooltaxes – Invalidity of theassessment roll.
269. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 03/13/90 [1990] J.Q. no 424[1990] R.D.J. 249
Poplaw,Mason
Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —evidence —examinations ondiscovery after defence— communication ofexhibits
Page 55
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
270. QCCA Anvil Mining Ltd. v.Associationcanadienne contrel’impunité
02/23/90 [1990] J.Q. no 280 Poplaw,Mason
Respondent QC Appeal Contracts — real estatebroker — sale of animmoveable — promiseof sale
271. QCCA Organisme canadiende réglementation ducommerce desvaleurs mobilières(OCRCVM) c.Beaudouin
02/22/90 [1990] J.Q. no 278J.E. 90-495[1990] R.R.A. 26819 A.C.W.S. (3d)1259
Chénier,Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —medical malpractice —diagnosis
272. QCCA OptionConsommateurs v.InfineonTechnologies AG
02/06/90 [1990] J.Q. no 216[1990] R.J.Q. 655J.E. 90-42229 Q.A.C. 2516 C.E.L.R. (N.S.)1501990 CanLII 3338
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket21891,05/07/1990)
Environment — classaction — air pollution —bauxite — alumina
273. QCCA Banque deMontréal/Bank ofMontreal c. BanquedeNouvelle-Écosse/Bank of NovaScotia
01/09/90 [1990] J.Q. no 10[1990] R.J.Q. 121J.E. 90-13218 A.C.W.S. (3d)1212
Potter, SimonV.
Respondent QC Appeal Bills of exchange —cheques — banks —negligence
274. QCCA St-Arnaud c. C.L. 09/05/89 [1989] J.Q. no1606[1989] R.J.Q. 2287J.E. 89-141629 Q.A.C. 199
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket21653,
Suretyship — contract ofpersonal suretyship —liberation of debtor
Page 56
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
01/02/1990)
275. QCCA Enterprises R & G St-Laurent inc. C.Québec (Procureurgénéral) (Ministèredes Transports duQuébec)
09/05/89 [1989] J.Q. no1605
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket21653,01/02/1990)
Suretyship — contract ofpersonal suretyship —liberation of debtor
276. QCCA Cohen c. Hill Samuel& Co.
06/16/89 [1989] J.Q. no1066, [1989]R.J.Q. 2078, J.E.89-1265, 33Q.A.C. 1, 16A.C.W.S. (3d) 117
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Respondent QC Appeal International private law –Exemplification of foreignjudgments – Diplomaticcertificate.
277. QCCA Lévesque c. Hudon 04/25/89 [1989] J.Q. no 696[1989] R.D.J. 209
Potter, SimonV.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Evidence — testimony —objections — declaratoryremedy — trial judge'sdiscretion
278. QCCA Hudon c. Carpentier 04/20/89 [1989] J.Q. no 680J.E. 89-1567[1989] R.D.F.Q.138[1989] R.L. 36115 A.C.W.S. (3d)45
Gagnon, GuyA.
Appellant QC Appeal Tax — appeal of taxassessments — income— commission on sales
279. QCCA Banque canadienneimpériale decommerce c.Carbonneau
04/03/89 [1989] J.Q. no600, [1989] R.J.Q.1091, J.E. 89-721,EYB 1989-63412,22 Q.A.C. 115
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Respondent QC Appeal Consumer protection –Annulment of contracts –Lesion between personsof full age - Assignmentof claims.
Page 57
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
280. QCCA MacMillan c. AbbottLaboratories
03/21/89 [1989] Q.J. No.453J.E. 89-69621 Q.A.C. 161[1990] R.L. 12814 A.C.W.S. (3d)358
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Family law — divorce —accessory measures —compensatory allowance
281. QCCA Dufour c. Havrankova 03/13/89 [1989] J.Q. no 429[1989] R.J.Q. 82059 D.L.R. (4th)743J.E. 89-62825 Q.A.C. 20142 Admin. L.R.17514 A.C.W.S. (3d)167
Potter, SimonV.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket21376,08/06/1989)
Civil procedure — appeal— conservatoryintervention
282. QCCA Lorrain c PetroCanada
02/09/89 [1989] J.Q. no 218[1989] R.J.Q. 1101J.E. 89-72334 Q.A.C. 3614 A.C.W.S. (3d)67
Rousse,Jacques
Appellant QC Appeal Labour — labourstandards — notice —layoffs — differences intreatment
283. QCCA Consultants Aecominc. C. Société duQuébec
02/01/89 [1989] J.Q. no 200 Lehoux, Jean-François
Respondent QC Appeal Civil liability — securityguards — injuries
284. QCCA Centre commercialLes Rivières ltée c.Jean Bleu inc.
09/30/88 [1988] J.Q. no1719
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — civil liability— fire — worker
285. QCCA Imperial TobaccoCanada Ltd. C.Conseil québécoissur le tabac et lasanté
09/29/88 [1988] J.Q. no1715
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Real estate —commercial lease —resiliation of lease
Page 58
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
286. QCCA Han c. Demers 09/28/88 [1988] J.Q. no1704J.E. 88-1270[1988] R.D.J. 58012 A.C.W.S. (3d)53
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket21150,23/02/1989)
Municipal — municipalcouncillors — quowarranto — right ofappeal
287. QCCA F.L. c. Lesage 09/15/88 [1988] J.Q. no1650[1988] R.J.Q. 2605J.E. 88-122928 Q.A.C. 228[1988] R.D.I. 593
Jolin, Pierre Appellant QC Appeal Property law —application of theconstitution or TenureSystem Act — mobilehome
288. QCCA Thibault c. Marina dela Chaudière inc.
05/24/88 [1988] J.Q. no 896J.E. 88-831EYB 1988-58859
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Loans — small loans —class action
289. QCCA Bitton v. AppleCanada Inc.
04/29/88 [1988] J.Q. no 695 Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Corporations — civilprocedure — evidence —objection — right to beheard
290. QCCA N.F. c. Montréal (Villede)
04/29/88 [1988] J.Q. no 696J.E. 88-66014 Q.A.C. 295[1988] R.L. 249[1988] 2 C.T.C. 6488 D.T.C. 6267
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Tax — tax evasion —prescription
291. QCCA Masson c. Centre desanté et de servicessociaux de St-Jérôme(CSSS)
09/09/87 [1987] J.Q. no2220[1988] R.R.A. 124
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — propertyinsurance — stolengoods — insurer's duty toindemnify
Page 59
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
292. QCCA Simard c. Gilbert 06/11/87 [1987] J.Q. no10328 Q.A.C. 283
Chénier,Robert-Jean
Respondent QC Appeal Medical — civil liability —transaction — opinion asto the ability to return towork
293. QCCA Matériaux deconstructionOldcastle CanadaInc. c. St-Bruno-de-Montarville (Ville de)
05/19/87 [1987] J.Q. no 8368 Q.A.C. 19[1987] R.L. 3884 A.C.W.S. (3d)442
Jolin, Pierre Respondent QC Appeal Tax — retail sales tax —assessments
294. QCCA Watters v. White 05/12/87 [1987] J.Q. no 825 Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Civil procedure —arbitration —homologation of anaward
295. QCCA Fontaine c. Beique,succession
12/23/86 [1986] J.Q. no2259
Loranger,Julie-Martine
Respondent QC Appeal Information not available.
296. QCCA Guénard c. Oliver 02/07/86 [1986] J.Q. no 273 Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Oppression remedy —payment of dividends —civil procedure — dilatoryexception — jointconclusions
297. QCCA Anvil Mining Ltd. v.Associationcanadienne contrel’impunité
01/17/86 [1986] J.Q. no2835
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Municipal taxation — realestate assessment —interpretation
298. QCCA Organisme canadiende réglementation ducommerce desvaleurs mobilières(OCRCVM) c.Beaudouin
11/15/85 [1985] J.Q. no 553J.E. 85-1055
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Insurance — lifeinsurance — additionalbenefit in case ofaccidental death —exclusion clause
299. QCCA OptionConsommateurs v.InfineonTechnologies AG
09/23/85 [1985] J.Q. no 592[1985] R.D.J. 608J.E. 85-960
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Appellant QC Interlocutory Civil procedure —examination on discoveryafter defence — thirdparties
Page 60
The French version will be available soon.
NUMBER COURT CASE DATE CITATIONS LAWYERACTEDFOR
REGIONTYPE OFAPPEAL
FURTHERHISTORY
LEGAL AND INDUSTRYFOCUS
300. QCCA Labranche c. Ciepétrolière impérialeltée Esso
09/18/85 [1985] J.Q. no 519 Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Competition — consumerprotection — class action— oil companies —price-fixing
301. QCCA Cie d'assurancesProvinces-Unies c.Lorent
05/01/85 [1985] J.Q. no 556 Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Insurance — fire — civilliability — landlord andtenant relation
302. QCCA Domaine de la rivièreinc. c. Aluminium duCanada ltée
01/25/85 [1985] J.Q. no 96J.E. 85-249[1985] R.D.J. 30
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Interlocutory Property law — evidence— right to hear expertevidence and to file anexpert report
303. QCCA Télémédiacommunications Inc.c. Samson
12/14/84 [1984] J.Q. no 759J.E. 85-81[1985] R.D.J. 478
Jarry, ClaudeM.
Appellant QC Appeal Obligations — contracts— interpretation ofcontract — penal clause
304. QCCA Réserves du Nord(1973) Ltée (In re):Hôtel Pilma sur leLac Inc. et Bertrand
09/04/84 [1984] J.Q. no 741J.E. 84-729[1984] C.A. 500
Tremblay,Gérald R.
Respondent QC Appeal Application forleave toappeal to theSupremeCourt ofCanadadismissed(Docket19071,20/12/1984)
Bankruptcy andinsolvency — fraudulenttransaction — settingaside
305. QCCA Gérard Nolin Ltée (Inre): Banquecanadienne nationalec.Bellavance
02/08/79 [1979] J.Q. no 317J.E. 79-235[1979] C.A. 168
Deschamps,Michel
Appellant QC Appeal Insolvency — bankruptcy— cancellation oftransactions prior tobankruptcy — novation
306. QCCA Bean c. Langlois 12/21/67
[1967] J.Q. no 4[1968] B.R. 135
Drouin,Richard
Appellant QC Appeal Civil liability — damages— dismissal of appeal
QCCA TotalAppeals:306
Page 61
The French version will be available soon.