Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically &...

33
KIT The Research University in the Helmholtz Association Institute for Technical Physics www.kit.edu 3 mm Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and characterization Michael J. Wolf, Christoph M. Bayer, and Walter H. Fietz MEM Workshop, Tallahassee, March 21 23, 2016

Transcript of Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically &...

Page 1: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

KIT – The Research University in the Helmholtz Association

Institute for Technical Physics

www.kit.edu

3 mm

Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and characterization

Michael J. Wolf, Christoph M. Bayer, and Walter H. Fietz

MEM Workshop, Tallahassee, March 21 – 23, 2016

Page 2: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 2 21.03.2016

Motivation

Michael J. Wolf

Generation of high

magnetic fields

power

applications

Image Source:

W. H. Fietz, et al., (2013): Prospects of High Temperature Superconductors for fusion magnets and power applications.

Fus. Eng. Des. 88 (6-8), p. 440–445.

Page 3: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 3 21.03.2016

Motivation – High DC current applications

Michael J. Wolf

Fusion Magnets

Data

so

urc

es:

W. H

. F

ietz

, e

t a

l., (2

01

3):

Fus.

En

g. D

es.

88

(6

-8),

p.

44

0–4

45.

A.

Mo

ran

di, S

up

erc

on

d. S

ci. T

ech

nol. 2

8 (

20

15

) 1

23

00

1 (

16

pp

)

W. R

eis

er,

Pre

se

nta

tion a

t Z

IEH

L I

V w

ork

sho

p (

20

14

) o

nlin

e, la

st a

cce

sse

d 0

3-1

8-2

01

6: h

ttp

://w

ww

.ivsu

pra

.de

/im

ag

es/z

iehl/zie

lvo

rtra

ege

_20

14

/

ZIE

HL_

20

14

_In

dustr

iea

nw

en

du

ng

en

_H

och

str

om

sch

ien

en

_V

isio

n-E

lectr

ic-S

up

erc

on

du

cto

rs_

Reis

er.

pd

f

Page 4: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 4 21.03.2016 Michael J. Wolf

Outline

Introduction of the HTS CrossConductor:

Design

Fabrication concept

First results on on partially REBCO equipped HTS CroCos

V(I) – measurements @ T = 77 K

Electromechanical tests in the FBI facility

Terminations

Concept and fabrication

Achieved termination resistances

Realization of smaller HTS CroCos

Unfortunately, a leak in the water cooling of the 10 kA power supply of the FBI facility did not allow to

test the fully REBCO-equipped HTS CroCo sample yet. Maintenance is ongoing and to be finished soon.

Page 5: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 5 21.03.2016

HTS High Current Cable Concepts

Michael J. Wolf

CORC: Conductor on Round Core

D. van der Laan, SUST 22 (2009) 065013

Roebel - Cable:

W. Goldacker et al., IEEE TAS 17 (2) (2007) 3398ff.

TSTC: Twisted Stacked Tape Cable

M. Takayasu et al., IEEE TAS 21 (3) (2011), 2340

Page 6: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 6 21.03.2016

Stacked HTS High Current Cable Concepts

Michael J. Wolf

TSTC: Twisted Stacked Tape Cable

M. Takayasu et al., IEEE TAS 21 (3) (2011), 2340

Round - TSTC:

D. Uglietti, et al., IEEE TAS 24 (3) (2014), 4800704

TSTC - CICC

G. Celentano, et al., IEEE TAS 24 (3) (2014), 4601805

STARS Fusion cable

N. Yanagi, FUS. SC. & TECH. 60 (2) (2011), 648

Page 7: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 7 21.03.2016

How to fabricate easily long length –

high current HTS cables with TSTC-concepts?

Main Requirements

Simple long-length production method

Easy Joint Manufacturing & Current Transfer

(jointing single tapes is not feasible for a large scale application)

Twisting and bending without degradation

Michael J. Wolf

Page 8: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 8 21.03.2016

The KIT cable approach targeting a round strand

Michael J. Wolf

Existing concepts use

tapes of one width

Rectangle or Square

Page 9: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 9 21.03.2016

The KIT cable approach targeting a round strand

Michael J. Wolf

Existing concepts use

tapes of one width

Rectangle or Square

Max. geometrical filling factor

63,6 %

Page 10: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 10 21.03.2016

The KIT cable approach targeting a round strand

Michael J. Wolf

Existing concepts use

tapes of one width

Rectangle or Square

KIT approach

Use tapes of two different widths

HTS CrossConductor "HTS CroCo"

Max. geometrical filling factor

63,6 %

Max. geometrical filling factor

78,7 % + 23 %rel.

1

Page 11: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 11 21.03.2016

The KIT cable approach targeting a round strand

Michael J. Wolf

To avoid jointing of single tapes:

Use REBCO tapes with thick electro-plated Cu stabilization

to optimize current transfer and electrical stabilization

KIT approach

Use tapes of two different widths

HTS CrossConductor "HTS CroCo"

Max. geometrical filling factor

78,7 %

HTS CroCo offers more space for HTS tapes

Benefits:

Twisting can be done in a form-fit way

Page 12: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 12 21.03.2016

For economical fabrication

of long lengths:

all these steps

in one continuous process

Fabrication steps of a Stacked Conductor

Michael J. Wolf

Arrange the tapes

Pre-tin the tapes

Twist the stack

Solder all individual tapes

Form the stack

Apply a jacket or former

Page 13: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 13 21.03.2016

The fabrication routine

Michael J. Wolf

Page 14: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 14 21.03.2016

Jacketing by Rotary swaging

Michael J. Wolf

Outer diameter: 9.3mm

CroCo-Core

Soft filler material,

e.g. solder

Cu tube

Page 15: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 15 21.03.2016 Michael J. Wolf

Outline

Introduction of the HTS CrossConductor:

Design

Fabrication concept

First results on on partially REBCO equipped HTS CroCos

V(I) – measurements @ T = 77 K

Electromechanical tests in the FBI facility

Terminations

Concept and fabrication

Achieved termination resistances

Realization of smaller HTS CroCos

Page 16: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 16 21.03.2016

Image of a CroCo partially equipped with HTS

Michael J. Wolf

First trials with in total 30 tapes,

150 µm Cu tapes + some HTS-tapes with ≥ 100 mm electroplated Cu

20 tapes of 6mm width,

16 Cu + 4 HTS tapes

2 x 5 tapes of 4mm width,

2 x ( 4 Cu + 1 HTS )

Stack dimensions:

5.1 mm x 6.3 mm

Total solder thickness

~ 20 µm per tape

Page 17: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 17 21.03.2016

Ic-calculation of the 20%-equipped twisted CroCo

Cross-sectional layout:

Sum of tape Ics from the

manufacturer: ~ 950 A

Michael J. Wolf

6m

m

Input parameter for individual tapes

jc (77 K, sf) = 30 A/mmHTS

Field dependence of Ic from

Bykovsky et al., J. Phys.: Conf. Ser. (2014) 507 (2), 022001

Calculation of overall Ic

Ic ≈ 810 A

Page 18: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 18 21.03.2016

LN2 – testing of the 20%-equipped twisted CroCo

Michael J. Wolf

Twist Pitch ~ 80 cm

No degradation

Page 19: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 19 21.03.2016

Preparation of a sample for FBI testing

Sample Parameters:

Untwisted stack,

Total of 32 tapes

4mm wide: 4 HTS, 8 Cu

6mm wide: 4 HTS, 16 Cu

HTS tapes equally distributed

between Cu tapes

Calculated Ic: 920 A

Sheath: first trial with

slotted, solder filled copper tube

Michael J. Wolf

30 cm 30 cm 10 cm

116 cm

No degradation

Page 20: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 20 21.03.2016 Michael J. Wolf

The FBI test facility

Michael J. Wolf

Tensile force (100 kN)

Heater

Magnetic field (12 T)

Current (10 kA) T = 4.2-77 K

F

B

I

Page 21: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 21 21.03.2016

Performance in magnetic fields at T = 4.2 K

Michael J. Wolf

Ic = 2.1 kA @ B = 12 T

Ic = 52.5 A / mmHTS width

SuperPower AP – Tapes

show Ic ~ 45 - 65 A / mmHTS

for B || c Hazelton, LTHFSW (2013)

Hazelton, WAMHTS (2014)

Abraimov et al., WAMHTS (2014)

Celentano et al., WAMHTS (2014)

No degradation!

T = 4.2 K

B field

axis Tape

normals

c-axis ~ 45°

Ic (∢(B,c) = 45°) ≈ Ic (B || c) Xu et al, SUST 23 (1) 014003 (2010)

Senatore et al, WAMHTS (2014)

Page 22: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 22 21.03.2016

Tensile testing

Michael J. Wolf

HTS CroCo shows the same Ic-strain curve as individual tapes!

Page 23: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 23 21.03.2016 Michael J. Wolf

Outline

Introduction of the HTS CrossConductor:

Design

Fabrication concept

First results on on partially REBCO equipped HTS CroCos

V(I) – measurements @ T = 77 K

Electromechanical tests in the FBI facility

Terminations

Concept and fabrication

Achieved termination resistances

Realization of smaller HTS CroCos

Page 24: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 24 21.03.2016

Types of Terminations

Michael J. Wolf

Stair

The tapes are

shortened indi-

vidually by 4mm

and soldered

to a termination

(InAg)

Ramp

Sloped cutting (< 3°)

and polishing of a HTS stack

followed by soldering to

a matching part (InAg)

Tube termination

Solder the HTS

CroCo as a whole

to a terminal

(R = 40 nW obtained in a different

terminal and measurement geometry)

M. J. Wolf et al., IEEE TAS 26 (2) (2016), 2521323

Stack in Groove

The HTS stack is soldered (PbSn, InAg)

to a groove in the terminal

(10 x 30 x 120 mm)

„parallel“ „perpendicular“

Page 25: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 25 21.03.2016

Measuring the termination resistance

„Current Leads“ are of the same length as the terminations (12 cm)

Two voltage taps on the bottom side of the termination for statistics

Corresponding tap on the HTS CroCo far from the termination

Calculation of the solid-state contributions of solder and copper parts

R = 13 nW T = 77 K

Michael J. Wolf

Page 26: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 26 21.03.2016

Resistance measurements

Michael J. Wolf

Critical current was not reached (limited by the power supply)

Linear V(I) curves observed

Page 27: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 27 21.03.2016

Results

Michael J. Wolf

„Stack in Groove“ and „Stair“ show both R ~ 50 nW

Page 28: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 28 21.03.2016

Comparison

Soldered termination:

R ~ 125 nW for L = 150 mm

Michael J. Wolf

D. Uglietti et al. (2014): Development of high current HTS conductors for Fusion at CRPP.

Presented at WAMHTS workshop, DESY Hamburg, 21.05.2014. Online, last accessed: Mar. 18, 2016:

https://indico.cern.ch/event/308828/session/3/contribution/16/attachments/589815/81182

3/Uglietti_-_Development_of_high_current_HTS_conductor_for_Fusion_at_CRPP.pdf

M. Takayasu et al. (2016):

IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. 26 (2) (2016) 6400210

soldered „folding fan“ termination:

R = 6 nW for 24 mm x 70 mm

Page 29: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 29 21.03.2016

Comparison

Soldered termination:

R ~ 125 nW for L = 150 mm

Michael J. Wolf

D. Uglietti et al. (2014): Development of high current HTS conductors for Fusion at CRPP.

Presented at WAMHTS workshop, DESY Hamburg, 21.05.2014. Online, last accessed: Mar. 18, 2016:

https://indico.cern.ch/event/308828/session/3/contribution/16/attachments/589815/81182

3/Uglietti_-_Development_of_high_current_HTS_conductor_for_Fusion_at_CRPP.pdf

M. Takayasu et al. (2016):

IEEE Trans. Appl. Supercond. 26 (2) (2016) 6400210

soldered „folding fan“ termination:

R = 6 nW for 24 mm x 70 mm

Page 30: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 30 21.03.2016 Michael J. Wolf

Outline

Introduction of the HTS CrossConductor:

Design

Fabrication concept

First results on on partially REBCO equipped HTS CroCos

V(I) – measurements @ T = 77 K

Electromechanical tests in the FBI facility

Terminations

Concept and fabrication

Achieved termination resistances

Realization of smaller HTS CroCos

Page 31: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 31 21.03.2016

HTS CroCo: Now available in different sizes

Motivation: smaller twisting pitch and bending radii and smaller basis units

Michael J. Wolf

6/4 CroCo 4/2 CroCo 3/2 CroCo

9.1 mm 6.8 mm 5.7 mm

Page 32: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 32 21.03.2016

Parameters of the different HTS CroCos

Michael J. Wolf

6/4 CroCo 4/2 CroCo 3/2 CroCo

Number of

REBCO tapes

20 x 6 mm

10 x 4 mm

16 x 4 mm

16 x 2 mm

16 x 3 mm

8 x 2 mm

tape thickness ~ 165 µm ~ 95 µm ~ 95 µm

Ø incl. tube 9.1 mm 6.8 mm 5.7 mm

Ic(4.2 K, 12 T) 8000 A 4800 A 3200 A

Ic(77 K, s.f.) 3000 A 1800 A 1300 A

Bending radius > 60 cm > 40 cm > 30 cm

Page 33: Progress in HTS CrossConductor (HTS CroCo) fabrication and ...The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes! Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination

Institute for Technical Physics 33 21.03.2016

Conclusions

The concept of the HTS Cross conductor (HTS CroCo):

Improving the filling factor by using tapes of two different widths

The „all-in-one“ fabrication routine of the HTS stacks works!

easy long-length production of twisted HTS stacks is possible

FBI testing of a partially equipped sample shows excellent results

The CroCo strand is electrically & mechanically as good as its tapes!

Soldering the stacks as a whole to a copper termination of 12 cm length

can provide termination resistances of ~ 50nW

The fabrication routine can be extended to narrower tapes as well for

better twisting and bending properties and smaller basis units.

Michael J. Wolf