Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry...

18
CERUM Report Nr 42/2014 ISBN 978-91-7601-177-5 ISSN 0282-0277 Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to the Midway Alignment project Jonas Westin Robert Sörensson

Transcript of Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry...

Page 1: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

CERUM Report Nr 42/2014 ISBN 978-91-7601-177-5 ISSN 0282-0277

Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link

- Base Report to the Midway Alignment project

Jonas Westin

Robert Sörensson

Page 2: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

CERUM Report Nr 42/2014 ISBN 978-91-7601-177-5 ISSN 0282-0277 CERUM; Umeå universitet; 901 87 Umeå Tel: 090-786 56 99 Fax: 090-786 51 21 E-post: [email protected] www.cerum.umu.se

Page 3: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

TABLE OF CONTENTS

1 Introduction............................................................................................................................... 1

2 Data on transport flows and international freight demand ...................................................... 1

2.1 Commodity Flow Survey.................................................................................................... 2

2.2 Swedish National Accounts ............................................................................................... 2

2.3 Other data sources ............................................................................................................ 2

3 Results from previous studies of the Kvarken strait ................................................................. 3

4 Analysis of maximum potential freight volumes ....................................................................... 4

4.1 Catchment Area ................................................................................................................. 4

4.2 Potential Freight Volumes in the Catchment Area ........................................................... 5

5 Price elasticity and the effect of a free ferry ............................................................................. 8

5.1 Catchment Area and Potential Freight Volumes in a Free Reference Scenario ................ 8

6 Forecast of future demand ....................................................................................................... 8

7 Summary and concluding remarks .......................................................................................... 10

References ....................................................................................................................................... 11

Page 4: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to
Page 5: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

1

1 INTRODUCTION

The Kvarken Ferry Link is a maritime transport connection between Sweden and Finland. This report is a deliverable from the Centre for Regional Science (CERUM) at Umeå University to the

Midway Alignment project.1 The purpose of the report is to analyse the freight demand for the ferry by estimating the maximum potential freight transport in the catchment area of the ferry.

The analysis is based on a model analysis of the maximum potential freight volumes in the catchment area of the ferry across the Kvarken strait using input data from the Swedish national

freight modelling system Samgods. The results are combined with a scenario analysis where the effect of different forecasts for the Kvarken ferry is studied. The analysis might serve as an input in

a subsequent analysis of the market potential and transport demand for the ferry link between Vaasa in Finland and Umeå in Sweden.

The report is organized as follows. In Section 2 we turn to a description of the various data sources

that constitute the starting point in the process of estimating freight flows and briefly describe results from previous studies. Section 3 briefly describe results from previous studies of the

Kvarken strait. In Section 4, we analyse the maximum potential freight volumes in the catchment area for the ferry link between Umeå and Vaasa using a simulation model for different price

scenarios. In Section 5, we estimate the price sensitivity of the Kvarken ferry and analyse the effect of a scenario with a free ferry. In Section 6, we make a forecast of future demand using an approach

where three different scenarios with different growth rates and market shares are studied. Section 7 concludes and discusses implications for the design of a new ferry.

The Midway Alignment of the Bothnian Corridor is co-financed by the European Union. The sole

responsibility of this publication lies with the author. The European Union is not responsible for any use that may be made of the information contained therein.

2 DATA ON TRANSPORT FLOWS AND INTERNATIONAL FREIGHT DEMAND

It is important to stress, right at the outset, that no single data source is readily available to fully capture transport flows and freight demand neither within nor between Finland, Norway, and

Sweden. Rather, the available data on transport flows and international freight demand is the result of a structured process where the data are estimated from various sources (Edwards et al.,

2008; Edwards 2008). This process varies between countries as well as within countries and over time. These processes are usually commissioned by national agencies, institutes and/or consultants in the transport field. The data for transport demand is generally structured in the form

of origin-destination-matrices that describes the annual freight demand for different commodities at a base year between different pairwise geographical areas or zones. The matrices are usually

measured in tonnes per year. Since both the base year, the methodology, the zonal division and the commodity groups varies between different countries, it is often complicated to directly

compare the content of matrices from different countries. Other sources of data are traffic counts, harbour statistics, foreign trade statistics and estimates of transport costs for different transport

modes and logistics costs in harbours and terminals (Trafikverket, 2014a). The transport demand in the matrices are in general more uncertain for cross-border and transit transport flows

compared to domestic transport flows (Forsgren and Westin, 2014).

1 The purpose of the Midway Alignment project is to upgrade the existing transport route by designing and developing a new ferry for the Kvarken strait. The project is coordinated by SSPA Sweden AB. In April 2014 SSPA commissioned a short description of freight flow data between the northern parts of Finland, Norway, and Sweden to CERUM.

Page 6: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

2

2.1 Commodity Flow Survey The Commodity Flow Survey (CFS) produces data on the movement of goods in Sweden with

Swedish and foreign recipients and consignors. The survey is commissioned by the Swedish agency Transport Analysis and provides information about the types of commodities shipped, their value,

weight, transport modes, sending, and receiving zones.

The sample survey covers the manufacturing, mining, and wholesale sectors. Whereas data for transport of forestry, dairy and sugar and other agricultural related products are obtained from

register sources. A sample of slightly more than 12 000 local units are used as a basis for the estimation of commodity flows corresponding to a total of approximately 23 000 local units. A local

unit is a single physical location where business transactions take place. Each local unit report on their individual shipments that comprise data on value and weight, commodity type, modes of

transport, cargo type, origin and destination, and geographic point of departure or entry from or to Sweden for foreign shipments (SIKA, 2006a; SIKA, 2006b).

The survey design is a three-stage cluster survey stratified by size of the local units in terms of

employees and turnover, industrial classification and region where applicable. The first sampling stage is local units, followed by reporting weeks and finally shipments. Smaller units, in terms of

employment or turnover, below a given cut-off limit are excluded (Trafikanalys, 2010; Trafikanalys, 2011).

2.2 Swedish National Accounts Statistics Sweden holds vital supplementary data to the CFS in the form of Swedish National Accounts (NA). To portray the working of the economy with particular emphasis on the process of

production and consumption three items from NA are practically useful.

Three items are:

• supply tables • use tables

• input/output tables

This set of tables answer the question: where do products come from and how are they used? Note that these relations are expressed in value terms whereas the CFS reports on these relations both

in weight and value terms. The main part of the supply table is a matrix of products by industry showing which industry supplies which product, whereas the main part of the use table is a matrix

of products by industry showing which industry uses which product. The supply- and use tables are an integral part of the process to compile the third type of tables, the input/output table. For

analytical purposes a transformation from a pair of supply- and use tables into an input/output table have the advantage of consistency for row and column totals, i.e. they are equal.

However, the supply and use-tables has a matrix dimension of products by industry, i.e. product×industry; so a choice must be made whether the product or industry dimension is the

most appropriate for the symmetric input/output table. Irrespective of the choice between a product×product or an industry×industry dimension the symmetric input/output matrix the

individual elements are still expressed in value terms.

2.3 Other data sources Another supplementary data source is the Central Company and Work Place Register (CFAR). The primary components of interest are employment, turnover, industry classifications and location.

These items are used to classify companies and their work places. To estimate international transport flows, the Foreign Trade Statistics (FTS) provides essential information about Swedish

Page 7: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

3

trade relations in the form of all export and all import flows. Note, however, that FTS record nation to nation relations expressed in value terms which implies that the data needs to be converted into

tonnes. The national trade statistics also need to be disaggregated into the regional level using model based estimations.

To summarize, the available data on transport flows and freight demand is constructed from

various sources and is therefore based on model estimations. This implies that the data only provides an estimation (or a best guess) of the transport flows rather than giving the real picture.

3 RESULTS FROM PREVIOUS STUDIES OF THE KVARKEN STRAIT

The freight transport across the Kvarken strait have increased with around 50 percent between 1998-2008. The increase has been stronger than other trade between Sweden and Finland (ÅF

Infraplan, 2012). The transport flows peaked in 2006 with close to 290 000 cargo tons and 14 000 cargo units per year. The transport flows decreased during the economic crisis but have during the

last three years almost reached the same levels as in the 2006 as shown in Figure 1 (Wasaline, 2014).

Figure 1: Annual freight volume measured in cargo tons / year. Source: Wasaline, 2014

The effect on freight volumes therefore differs from the effect on passenger volumes where the

end of tax-free sale on the ferry led to a large decrease in passengers after 1998 (ÅF Infraplan, 2010). The low level in 2002 was partly an effect of an unsuitable ferry and competing ferry services

from Botnia Link (ÅF Infraplan, 2012).

When choosing transport alternative, studies on freight transport has shown that transport price

is the most important factor for the choice of transport route given that a certain level of transport quality is reached. The transport quality includes factors such as reliability, consolidation

possibilities, punctuality and transport time etc. Other factors such as environmental concerns are generally ranked lower by the cargo holder (Vierth et al., 2012). Studies on the Kvarken link have

confirmed that many freight transports chose alternative routes such as the road through Haparanda/Tornio, both because of lower price and because of uncertainty about the time table

and the reliability of the ferry. The confidence in the quality of the transport service was also affected by earlier interruptions due to problem with the ice situation (ÅF Infraplan, 2010).

A description of the transport infrastructure on the Norwegian side is found in Sandberg and Solvoll

(2013).

0

50 000

100 000

150 000

200 000

250 000

300 000

350 000

2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013

Car

go t

on

s/ye

ar

Page 8: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

4

4 ANALYSIS OF MAXIMUM POTENTIAL FREIGHT VOLUMES

The following section contains an analysis of the maximum potential freight volumes in the catchment area of the ferry across the Kvarken strait. The analysis is based on cost calculations

using the CCM-model2 (Westin and Forsgren, 2014) and the base matrices in Samgods version 0.8 (Swedish Transport Administration, 2014). The CCM-model is a transport model developed in the

SimLab project. In a previous study, Forsgren and Westin (2012) used the Samgods model to analyse the effect from a strengthened connection across the Kvarken strait. The analysis revealed

several shortcomings in the Samgods model, mostly related to cross-border and transit traffic. Shortcoming was also identified in the way the ferry link was modelled. The CCM-model was

developed to overcome some of these problems. The CCM-model has a special focus on simulating freight transport in the NLC-corridor and to analyse the competitiveness and catchment areas of

competing freight transport corridors.

4.1 Catchment Area The catchment area for the ferry is analysed using the CCM-model (see Westin and Forsgren, 2014). The estimated catchment area for the ferry across the Kvarken strait is shown in Figure 2.

The analysis of the catchment areas is built on a cost-based approach where the generalized transport costs between each pairwise zone in the model are calculated. The multimodal transport

network and the zonal divisions are based on the network from the Samgods model (Swedish Transport Administration, 2014). The model calculates the generalized cost of a typical transport

on alternative transport routes. The generalized cost include time and distance based costs for road, rail and ferry modes as well as costs for waiting times, loading, unloading and handling costs

at terminals and harbors, see Hanssen et al. (2012). An important limitation of the approach is that the model does not consider capacity constraints or time restrictions such as driving time

regulations, ferry time tables and opening times in harbors and terminals etc. This implies that the model ignores some of the real world constraints and rigidities that restricts the ability of transport

companies to adapt to changes in the transport system. The results should therefore be treated with caution.

2 Competitive Corridor Model.

Page 9: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

5

Figure 2: Calculated catchment area for the ferry across the Kvarken strait. Base scenario using the CCM-model.

The catchment area is defined as the set of pairwise zones where the ferry across the Kvarken strait is the most competitive transport alternative for a typical freight transport. Since the route choice

is based on cost-minimization, the catchment area is hence the set of pairwise zones where the transport route with the Kvarken ferry has the lowest generalized cost compared to all alternative

transport routes. From the figure we see that for zones in the northern parts of Scandinavia and Finland, the route over Tornio/Haparanda has a lower generalized cost. The ferry route between

Stockholm and Turku/Helsinki does in a similar way have a lower generalized cost than the Kvarken ferry in the southern parts of Sweden and Norway. The costs for transport and loading and

unloading in the terminals are based on cost estimates in Vierth, Mellin and Karlsson (2014) and Hanssen et al. (2012).

4.2 Potential Freight Volumes in the Catchment Area To estimate the maximum potential freight volumes in the catchment we use data from the Swedish national freight model system Samgods. Samgods is a multimodal transport model for

forecasting and transport planning and is owned and developed by the Swedish Transport Administration. The Samgods model contains data describing the infrastructural network,

transportation costs and transport demand in the form of PWC-matrices describing the freight demand between producers and consumers in different geographical areas in the model. The

transport demand in the Samgods model is described in a number of PWC-matrices. The PWC-matrices contain estimations of the transport volumes between every pairwise zone in the model

divided into several commodity groups. The PWC-matrices are measured in tonnes per year and are estimated using data from the Swedish Commodity Flow Survey and trade statistics (Edwards,

Page 10: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

6

2008). In this analysis we have aggregated the data into 12 commodity groups using the STAN3 12 classification.

The maximum potential freight volume for the ferry between Umeå and Vaasa is calculated by

aggregating the transport volumes in the PWC-matrices from Samgods for the each pairwise zone in the calculated catchment area from the CCM-model. The freight volumes in the catchment area

are shown in Table 1 below. The catchment area is estimated using the CCM-model for the base scenario and aggregated freight volumes are based on the Samgods PWC-matrices for year 2006.

The volumes are divided into eastbound (from Umeå to Vaasa) and westbound (from Vaasa to Umeå) transports.

In total, roughly 720 000 tonnes per year are transported across the Kvarken strait in the catchment area in the Samgods PWC-matrices. Of the total transport flows, 180 000 tonnes per

year are transported from Norway and Sweden to Finland and Russia, and 540 000 tonnes per year are transported from Finland and Russia to Sweden and Norway. Figure 3 and 4 shows the share

of commodity groups for eastbound and westbound transport flows in the catchment area of the ferry.

Figure 3: Share of commodity groups in eastbound transport flows in the catchment area of the ferry. The total

transport volume is 180 000 tonnes per year.

3 Strategic Transport Analysis Model.

1. Agricultural and forest products

2. Pulp wood and round timber3. Other wood

products

4. Food products

5. Oil6.

Petroleum

products

7. Iron ore

8. Metal products

9. Paper and pulp

10. Building materials

11. Chemical products

12. Manufactured

products

Page 11: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

7

Figure 4: Share of commodity groups in westbound transport flows in the catchment area of the ferry. The total

transport volume is 540 000 tonnes per year.

The figures reveal that a large share of the westbound transport flows are pulp wood and round

timber that currently do not use the ferry. For eastbound transport flows the commodity groups are more balanced even though paper and pulp has the largest share. To estimate the maximum potential freight volumes that can use the ferry we therefore need to exclude commodity types

that is unlikely to use the ferry. Removing timber and wood from the total freight volumes the maximum potential freight volumes for the ferry link is reduced to 326 000 tonnes per year of

which 172 000 tonnes per year are eastbound and 150 000 tonnes per year are westbound. The main reduction in transport volumes with or without timber and wood products comes from

Russian export of timber products to Sweden. This highlights the importance of marketing and investigating the possibility to attract commodities that does not use the ferry link now.

These figures can be compared to official statistics from the ferry shown in Figure 1. The PWC-matrices are estimated for the base year 2006 estimated on data mostly collected during 2004 and

2005. Comparing the official statistics with the estimated maximum potential for the same period (excluding commodity group 2, pulp wood and round timber) we see that the Kvarken ferry roughly

has a theoretical market share of 75% of the estimated maximum potential freight volumes in the catchment area.

Based on the estimated maximal freight potential in the catchment area of the ferry, the analysis

indicates that there is a small room for further growth by attracting existing freight flows from other transport alternatives in the catchment area. The freight volumes for the ferry has also been

stable around 230 000 to 250 000 tonnes per year after the peak in 2006. Hence, in order for the ferry to increase freight volumes, either the catchment area or the total transport volumes need

to increase.

1. Agricultural and forest products

2. Pulp wood and round timber3. Other wood

products

4. Food products

5. Oil

6. Petroleum products

7. Iron ore

8. Metal products 9. Paper and pulp

10. Building materials11. Chemical

products

12. Manufactured products

Page 12: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

8

5 PRICE ELASTICITY AND THE EFFECT OF A FREE FERRY

To analyze the price elasticity of demand4 of the Kvarken ferry we create a scenario where the ferry price is reduced by ten percent and study the effect on the catchment area. By comparing the

transport volumes in both scenarios we get a rough estimate of elasticity of demand. The elasticity of demand from a price change of the ferry is -4 which indicates that the maximum potential

demand is very sensitive for changes in transport price. The largest increase in freight volumes from a price change is between Sweden and Finland. However, since the model calculations is

based on generalized costs and calculates the change in the maximum potential from an increased catchment area, the actual effect on the demand for the Kvarken ferry from a decrease in the

transport price may differ. The analysis does however indicate the existence of a strong competition between alternative transport routes. To validate the estimated elasticity, it is

therefore important to supplement the model based analysis of the elasticity of the maximum potential demand with empirical studies on micro level data from the ferry. Several such studies

have already been conducted, e.g. ÅF Infraplan (2012) and Vectura (2012).

5.1 Catchment Area and Potential Freight Volumes in a Free Reference

Scenario In addition to the elasticity calculation, we have also analyzed the catchment area and potential

freight volumes in a reference scenario where the price of using the ferry is zero. Assuming that, everything else equal, there is no monetary cost of using the ferry, the model indicates that the

maximum potential freight volumes can be ten times larger than in the base scenario and increase the catchment area to include transport nodes in both southern Sweden and northern Finland. The

result indicates that a free Kvarken ferry has the potential to attract part of the freight volumes that today use ferry services between Stockholm and Åbo/Helsinki, see e.g. ÅF Infraplan (2010).

However, this result strongly depends on the assumption that the transport cost on competing routes are fixed. Since a decrease in the price on the Kvarken ferry can lead to increased

competition with alternative transport routes, such as competing ferry services in southern part of Sweden, the result from the model is likely to overestimate the real effect. Scheduling and time restrictions can also limit the size of feasible the catchment area.

6 FORECAST OF FUTURE DEMAND

The maximum potential freight volumes estimated in previous section are based on data on the transport demand in 2006. If foreign trade increases in the future, it is likely that the estimated

maximum potential will underestimate future transport demand. The high elasticity also indicates that the pricing strategy of the ferry can have a strong impact on the future freight volumes.

The Swedish Transport Administration (Trafikverket) estimates in their current forecast that the

demand for freight transport (measured in tonne kilometer) will increase with 50% between 2006 and 2030 corresponding to an annual increase of 1.7%. A large part of this increase is attributed to

mining and an increased share of foreign trade. Excluding the effect from mining, the corresponding annual increase is 1.5%. The forecast is related to a high degree of uncertainty and

is based on an assumption on high economic growth of especially foreign trade during the period (Trafikverket, 2014b).

4 The price elasticity of demand is a measure of the relationship between a change in price and a change in demand. The price elasticity of demand is calculated as the change in demand (measured in percent) divided by the change in price (measured in percent). An elasticity of -4 implies that if the price is decreased with 1%, the (maximum potential) demand increases with 4%.

Page 13: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

9

In the forecast for the Swedish National Transport Plan 2014-2025, the Swedish Transport Authority estimate that the foreign trade will increase heavily between 2006 and 2030; they

estimate that export (measured in tonnes per year) will increase with 75%, import with 95% and transit traffic with 9%. The largest share of the increase for both export and import are assumed

to come from the mining sector and other types of raw materials (Trafikverket, 2013). Unless a new Kvarken ferry manage to also attract these commodity types, the effect on the transport

volumes on the ferry will be lower than the totals indicate above. Forecasts for transport volumes in the whole Baltic area estimate an annual increase in transport demand of around 2% (Baltic

Transport Outlook, 2011). The model analysis also indicate that a new pricing strategy has a potential to increase the market share of the ferry considerably.

To deal with the uncertain factors we conduct a scenario analysis where we analyze different

growth scenarios and estimate the effect on the demand for ferry transport. In the first scenario we assume an annual increase of 1.5% corresponding to the general forecast for freight transport

by the Swedish Transport Administration, in the second scenario we base the growth rate on the estimations on growth rates from Baltic Transport Outlook 2030 (2%) and in the third scenario we

analyze a situation where the market share of the ferry increases with 4% per year. We also include a no growth scenario as a reference point corresponding to a situation where the freight volumes

do not increase. The forecast is hence based on assumptions regarding the growth rate of the transport volumes and the market share of the ferry. The first two scenarios with a 1.5% increase

and a 2% increase the market share is assumed to be constant corresponding to a business-as-usual situation where the ferry is operated in a similar way as before. The growth hence comes

from an assumed increase in the trade between mainly Sweden and Finland and Sweden and Russia. The third scenario corresponds to an annual increase of 4%. Observe that the last scenario

relate to a situation where the ferry operator takes active measures to increase the market share, for example though lower prices for freight transport. The forecast for the different scenarios are

shown in Figure 5.

Figure 5: Forecast of the demand for freight transport on the Kvarken ferry based on different growth scenarios.

Compared to the year 2013, the scenarios correspond to an increase of 29%, 40% and 95% to 2030.

If the forecast is compared to the base year 2006 used in the previous analysis, the scenarios correspond to an increase of 14%, 24% and 72% to 2030. The difference depends on the choice of

base year.

0

100 000

200 000

300 000

400 000

500 000

600 000

2000 2005 2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035

Ton

nes

/yea

r

Historic data 1.5% increase 2% increase

4% increase No growth scenario

Page 14: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

10

7 SUMMARY AND CONCLUDING REMARKS

Based on the estimated transport demand in the Samgods base matrices, the analysis indicates that the ferry currently has a theoretical market share of around 75% of the estimated maximum

potential freight volumes in the catchment area. The relatively high market share suggests that the Kvarken ferry already has attracted a large share of the potential freight volumes in its current

catchment area. To increase freight volumes, the ferry therefore needs to either increase the catchment area, for example through lower prices for freight transport, attract other commodity

groups or rely on a general growth in the freight volumes across the Kvarken strait, e.g. as a result of a higher growth in the central parts of the catchment are compared to the rest of Sweden and

Finland or increased transport through the catchment area. With an annual increase of the demand for freight transport on the Kvarken ferry of 2%, the demand for freight would be 24% higher 2030

compared to 2006. However, the growth of transport demand depends on the assumption that the Kvarken ferry can continue to offer a competitive transport alternative in the future.

Literature on freight transport indicate that the most important factor for transport alternative is

transport price given that a certain quality level is met. The quality aspect both include punctuality and reliability (that the cargo is delivered on time and is not damaged) and transport time (Vierth

et al., 2012). It is therefore important to design the ferry to keep the price down without reducing the transport quality, especially in terms of reliability and punctuality. The high elasticity of

demand also suggests that it is possible from a price perspective to increase the ferry’s market share of freight transport between Sweden and Finland by making the ferry service more

competitive relative to other transport routes.

The model shows that the demand is very sensitive to changes in the transport price. This increases

the uncertainty of the results but also indicates that the price of using the ferry potentially could be an important factor for future freight volumes. Further analysis of sales data from the ferry and discussions with transport owners and freight operators are therefore important.

Competition between freight transports and passenger cars during peak season is a common problem in transportation. The problem can be seen in many ways. One alternative is to treat the

problem as a capacity problem and design the ferry to handle peak load. The downside of this strategy is that it will lead to lower fill rates during the remaining year and that it can increase the

cost of the ferry. The problem can also be seen as a question of pricing and prioritization. During peak load, should the ferry operator (and the municipalities) prioritize passenger cars or freight

transports? What is the mix the operators wants to achieve? To deal with these conflicting interests over how to allocate the limited capacity, many principles can be used. The allocation principle can

be based on pricing where the price of using the ferry is higher during peak season. Another alternative is to allocate the limited space using a first-come-first-serve principle, either using

separate quotas for passenger cars and trucks or using a combined quota. An alternative solution to the capacity problem is to design the ferry to allow for double trips in order to temporarily

increase capacity during peak season when demand is high.

Page 15: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

11

REFERENCES

Baltic Transport Outlook (2011) Report on Task 3: Scenarios, Baltic Transport Outlook 2030.

Edwards, H. (2008) Update of Samgods Base Matrices 2008, PM, Vägverket Konsult.

Edwards H, Bates J and Swahn H (2008) Swedish Base Matrices Report – Estimates for 2004,

estimation methodology, data and procedures, PM, Vägverket Konsult.

Forsgren and Westin (2012) Analys av en förstärkt förbindelse över Kvarken, CERUM.

Forsgren and Westin (2014) Infrastructure planning – A challenge for cross-border cooperation,

CERUM Report Nr 41/2014.

Hanssen, Mathisen and Jørgensen (2012). Generalized transport costs in intermodal freight transport. Procedia-Social and Behavioral Sciences, 54, 189-200.

Sandberg, T-E. and Solvoll, G. (2013) Transportinfrastruktur og handel over landegrensene i nord.

SIB-rapport nr 3-2013

SIKA (2006a) Varuflödesundersökningen 2004/2005 / Commodity flow survey 2004/2005, SIKA

Statistik 2006:12.

SIKA (2006b) Varuflödesundersökningen 2004/2005 - Metodrapport, Bilaga till SIKA Statistik 2006:12.

Trafikanalys (2010) Varuflödesundersökningen 2009 / Commodity flow survey 2009, Statistik

2010:16, Trafikanalys, Stockholm 2010.

Trafikanalys (2011) Metodrapport Varuflödesundersökningen 2009, PM 2011:13, Trafikanalys.

Trafikverket (2013) Prognoser för arbetet med nationell transportplan 2014-2025 –

Godstransporters utveckling fram till 2030, Rapport 2013:056

Trafikverket (2014a) Samgods 0.8 User Manual, Report, TRV 2011/64746

Trafikverket (2014b) Prognos för godstransporter 2030 – Trafikverkets basprognos 2014, Rapport

2014:066

Vectura (2012) Godsflödesstudie Kvarken, Vectura

Vierth et al. (2012) Kartläggning av godstransporterna i Sverige, VTI Rapport 752, VTI.

Vierth, Mellin and Karlsson (2014). Analys av effekter av IMO: s skärpta svavelkrav:

modellberäkningar på uppdrag av Trafikanalys, VTI Notat 33-2013.

Wasaline (2014) The bridge over bay of Bothnia – History and Future – NLC Ferry.

Westin and Forsgren (2014) Analys av NLC-korridorens konkurrenskraft och upptagningsområde, Proceeding at the joint NLC/SimLab East-West Conference, Umeå 2014.

ÅF Infraplan (2010) Socio- och företagsekonomisk analys av Kvarkentrafiken och en fast förbindelse

över Kvarken, Rapport ÅF Infraplan.

ÅF Infraplan (2012) Färjetrafikens betydelse för näringslivet och medborgarna i regionen, Kvarken

Shortcut, Bilaga till Kommunikationsministeriet (2012) Beredningen av en strategi för att trygga fartygstrafiken i Kvarken, Arbetsgruppens slutrapport 11.10.2012, Kommunikationsministeriets

publikationer 17/2012

Page 16: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

12

CERUM Reports

1. Lars-Olof Persson, Erik Sondell (1990) Från Lantbruksföretag till lanthushåll

2. Folke Carlsson, Mats Johansson, Lars-Olof Persson, Björn Tegsjö (1993, på engelska) Creating Labourmarket Areas and Employment Zones. New Regional Divisions in Sweden Based on Commuting Statistics

3. Ulf Wiberg (ed.) (1994, på engelska) Marginal Areas in Developed Countries

4. Erik Bergkvist, Lars Westin (1994) Värderas godstransporter rätt vid järnvägsinvesteringar? En granskning av Banverkets investeringsmodell

5. Lars Westin (1995) En modell för integrerad analys av regional struktur och transportflöden

6. Erik Bergkvist, Lars Westin (1997, på engelska) Estimation of Gravity Models by OLS Estimation, NLS Estimation, Poisson, and Neural Network Specifications

7. Sven erik Sahlin, Aurora Pelli (2000) Euroreg, förstudie

8. Peter Hall (2001, på engelska) Urban Development and Research Needs in Europe

9. Steffen Ahl (2001, på tyska) Schwedenhäppchen

10. Roberta Capello (2001, på engelska) Urban Growth in Italy: Economic Determinants and Socio-Environmental Consequences

11. Robert Sörensson (2003) Effektstudie av gruvetableringar i Lycksele och Storumans arbetsmarknadsregioner

12. Mats-Olov Olsson och Lars Westin (2004) Risks and Nuclear Waste: Nuclear Problems, Risk Perceptions of, and Societal Responses to, Nuclear Waste in the Barents Region Sammanfattning av projektets resultat

13. Lars Westin (2005) Marknaden för studentbostäder i universitets- och högskolor

14. Jouko Säisä, Lars Westin, Peder Axensten, Agnes von Koch, Susanne Sjöberg (2005) Trafikantmerkostnader vid vägåtgärder en samhällsekonomisk analys

15. Ove Grape, Sofia Lundberg och Anna Nordström (2005) Kompetenspoolen, ett alternativ till att bryta långtidsarbetslöshet

16. Anna Nordström och Susanne Sjöberg (2006) Utvärdering av Urkund, ett verktyg för plagiatkontroll

17. Anna Nordström (2006) Utvärdering av GenuineText, ett verktyg för plagiatkontroll

18. Olof Stjernström (2007) Hållbar utveckling och restriktiv markanvändning i Västerbotten

19. Hanna Sundén (2010) Ekologiska fotavtryck i norra Sverige: Metoddiskussion och beräkningar för fyra län

20. Fredrik Olsson Spjut (2010) Beräkning av historisk BRP Beräkning av bruttoregionprodukter 1968-1992: beräkningsmetod och data

21. Fredrik Olsson Spjut (2010) BRP i Norr – utveckling och trender Bruttoregionalproduktens utveckling i Norrlandslänen 1968-2007

22. Richard Ström (2010) Att etablera alternativkultur – En rapport om det annorlunda Umeå

23. Johanna Edlund och Marcus Holmström (2010) Det kommunalekonomiska utjämningssystemet – Effekter för Västerbotten, Norrland och Sveriges funktionella arbetsmarknader

24. Anna Jonsson och Lisa Svendsberget (2010): Investeringsläget i Norrland 1940-1970 – Industrins investeringar i Norrland 1997-2007

25. Martin Eriksson (2010) Synen på befolkning och försörjning i Norrland 1940-1970 – En översikt av forskning och samhällsdebatt

26. Gunnar Brandén, Andreas Forsgren, Marcus Holmström och Fredrik Olsson-Spjut (2011) 39 000 anställningar till och med 2020 En studie av rekryteringsbehovet i Västerbottens län

27. Johanna Liljenfeldt och Carina Keskitalo (2011) Kriterier och indikatorer på hållbar utveckling: exempel från teori och praktik

28. Johanna Liljenfeldt och Carina Keskitalo (2011) Regionala och kommunala mål för hållbarhetsarbete i Umeåregionen

29. Martin Eriksson (2011) Norrländska utvecklingsstrategier under nya förutsättningar för tillväxt och beslutsfattande 1990-2010

Page 17: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

13

30. Jenny Rönngren (2011) Omvärldsbevakning i Västerbotten

31. Fredrik Garli och Örjan Pettersson (2011) Befolkningsutveckling och –prognoser – teori och tillämpning för Västerbottens län

32. Fredrik Garli (2011) Flyttningar till, från och inom Västerbotten – Flöden och åldersfördelning år 2009

33. Fredrik Björkman (2011) Marken i Västerbotten – användning, värde och ägande

34. Johanna Edlund och Marcus Holmström (2011) Kommunala och regionala löner, fastighetspriser och attraktivitet – En studie av lönekostnadsutjämningen

35. Lars Larsson och Nils-Gustav Lundgren (2011) Socialt kapital i Västerbotten

36. Roger Filipsson (2011) Sport Region Västerbotten – En analys av sportsektorn (sportnäringen)

37. Tommy Lind (2011) Olika uppfattningar om livsvillkoren i stora och små kommuner i norra Sverige

38. Richard Ström (2012) Mot verkan! Via samverkan. En rapport om Region Västerbottens kulturdialog i skapandet av 2012 års kulturplan

39. Thomas Pettersson och Robert Sörensson (2012) Hur kan forskningsmiljön och den akademiska profilen stärkas i Örnsköldsvik? - En förstudie

40. Robert Sörensson och Fredrik Olsson Spjut (2013) Förutsättningar för bostadsproduktion på orter med gruvverksamhet. - Underlag till Boverkets regeringsuppdrag, 2013-05-16, N2013/2524/FIN, att utreda förutsättningar för bostadsproduktion på gruvorter m.m.

41. Andreas Forsgren och Jonas Westin (2014) Infrastructure planning – A challenge for cross-border cooperation.

42. Jonas Westin och Robert Sörensson (2014) Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link – Base Report to the Midway Alignment project.

Page 18: Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Linkumu.diva-portal.org/smash/get/diva2:765258/FULLTEXT01.pdf · Potential Freight Volumes of the Kvarken Ferry Link - Base Report to

CERUM

Centrum för regionalvetenskap

901 87 Umeå Tel: 090-786 56 99 Fax: 090-786 51 21 E-post: [email protected] www.cerum.umu.se

Centrum för regionalvetenskap vid Umeå universitet, CERUM, har till uppgift att initiera och genomföra forskning om regional utveckling, bedriva flervetenskapliga forskningsprojekt samt sprida forskningens resultat till skilda samhällsorganisationer. Forskningsprojekten sker i interaktion med de många vetenskapliga discipliner som berör det regionalvetenskapliga forskningsfältet.