Paul Rudolph's Fluted Concrete Buildings_tcm45-344645

2
S ince 1962, architect Paul Rudolph of New Haven, Con- necticut, has been developing a technique for building in concrete which demonstrates a new means for achieving a beautiful concrete finish. In the Yale University Art and A rc h i t e c t u re building in New Haven, and in the Endo Laborato- ries building at Garden City, Long Island, Mr. Rudolph has built with a rough concrete surface. Rather than showing the wood texture of the concrete forms after they have been removed, this surface shows the beauty of the concrete itself. Mr. Rudolph’s method invo l ve s the preparation of finned forms. On a plywood backing, trapezoidal fins 2 inches deep by 1 _ inches at the base by _ inch at the top are nailed in place. They form a regular pat- tern, the space between the fins be- ing equal to the width of the fins. These forms are placed as usual for any concrete wall. A stiff mixture of concrete with about a 2-inch slump and 1- to 1 1/2-inch aggre- gate is then placed. Cement, sand, and aggregate for the entire job are stock-piled before starting in order to assure consistency of surface tone. After removal of the forms, the fins are broken off with a hammer, thus exposing the aggregate. Often the aggregate breaks along with the concrete, and the interior tones of the aggregate are exposed. The stiff mixture avoids filming over aggregate stones which are not bro- ken. In this way, the building takes on the warm tone of the aggregate. This method does more than dec- orate an otherwise smooth concrete surface. Often used both inside and outside, it eliminates the necessity of any further finishing of the con- c re t e. In addition, the vertical fins suppress the subtle color changes visible in a smooth concrete surface. The finned method of concrete surface treatment was developed for the building at Yale, where Mr. Rudolph is chairman of the archi- tectural department. Se ve ral experi- ments were made before the suc- cessful method was found. One experiment involved backing the t ra p ezoidal elements with cross slats, in order to achieve the rough surface without the necessity of hammering. This method, however, was found to produce too weak a form when applied to the scale nec- essary in building. Therefore, the plywood backing was used. A large sample section was placed on the building site before the method was approved. Nearly all concrete surfaces in the Yale building are treated with the rough finned technique. The four hollow rectangular pillars which are the major structural elements rising inside the building are finished in this way. Those walls which are not glass are also treated with fins. Only parts of the basements and the sixth and seventh floors, where artists need tackable surfaces, are given a smooth finish. The Long Island laboratory differs from the Yale Art and Architecture building in two ways. First, the finned technique, used only on flat surfaces in New Haven, is applied to curved surfaces. In most places this is done without the necessity of curving the forms. The transitions between 1-foot flat segments set on a curve are easily obscured by the activity of the fluted surface. The ap- pearance is that of a true curve. A true curve was, in fact, used on the forms of only a small portion of the building. On the whole, the corduroy sur- face is used more sparingly at Endo. The only interiors finished with the rough surface are those of the tur- rets on the office wing and of the lobby. The remainder of the build- ing called for smooth interior finish, since it is to be used for laboratories. General contractor for Yale’s Art and Architecture building was the George B. H. Macomber Company. The aggregate for the Yale building was brought from Easton, Massa- chusetts. The Easton stone was cho- sen for its warm yellow and gold tones which would be exposed by the hammering. The aggregate for the Endo build- ing was a standard bank-run gra ve l from Long Island. This stone has a high percentage of light-colored quartz. All the concrete work on that building was done by the Ce n t ra l Cement Finishing Company of New York City. General contractors were Walter Kidde Constructors. Both jobs ran an average cost of $26.00 per square foot. The Rudolph treatment calls for one to two dol- lars more per square foot than a conventional concrete surface. This figure includes the extra one inch of width which must be allowed in the volume of concrete, and the cost of creating the fluted forms. The fluted technique, howe ve r, still under- prices many alter native surface treatments, since the final surface is built into the concrete walls. Paul Rudolph’s Fluted Concrete Buildings

Transcript of Paul Rudolph's Fluted Concrete Buildings_tcm45-344645

Page 1: Paul Rudolph's Fluted Concrete Buildings_tcm45-344645

Since 1962, architect Pa u lRudolph of New Ha ven, Co n-

necticut, has been developing atechnique for building in concre t ewhich demonstrates a new meansfor achieving a beautiful concre t efinish. In the Yale Un i versity Art andA rc h i t e c t u re building in Ne wHa ven, and in the Endo Labora t o-ries building at Ga rden City, LongIsland, Mr. Rudolph has built witha rough concrete surf a c e. Ra t h e rthan showing the wood texture ofthe concrete forms after they havebeen re m oved, this surface show sthe beauty of the concrete itself.

M r. Ru d o l p h’s method invo l ve sthe pre p a ration of finned form s. Ona plywood backing, tra p ezoidal fins2 inches deep by 1 _ inches at thebase by _ inch at the top are nailedin place. They form a regular pat-t e rn, the space between the fins be-ing equal to the width of the fins.

These forms are placed as usualfor any concrete wall. A stiff mixtureof concrete with about a 2-inchslump and 1- to 1 1/2-inch aggre-gate is then placed. Cement, sand,and aggregate for the entire job arestock-piled before starting in ord e rto assure consistency of surf a c et o n e. After re m oval of the form s, thefins are broken off with a hammer,thus exposing the aggre g a t e.

Often the aggregate breaks alongwith the concre t e, and the interi o rtones of the aggregate are exposed.The stiff mixture avoids filming ove ra g g regate stones which are not bro-ken. In this way, the building takeson the warm tone of the aggre g a t e.

This method does more than dec-o rate an otherwise smooth concre t es u rf a c e. Often used both inside and

o u t s i d e, it eliminates the necessityof any further finishing of the con-c re t e. In addition, the ve rtical finss u p p ress the subtle color changesvisible in a smooth concrete surf a c e.

The finned method of concre t es u rface treatment was deve l o p e dfor the building at Ya l e, where Mr.Rudolph is chairman of the arc h i-t e c t u ral department. Se ve ral experi-ments we re made before the suc-cessful method was found. On ee x p e riment invo l ved backing thet ra p ezoidal elements with cro s ss l a t s, in order to achieve the ro u g hs u rface without the necessity ofh a m m e ring. This method, howe ve r,was found to produce too weak af o rm when applied to the scale nec-e s s a ry in building. There f o re, theplywood backing was used. A larg esample section was placed on thebuilding site before the method wasa p p rove d .

Nearly all concrete surfaces in theYale building are treated with therough finned technique. The fourh o l l ow rectangular pillars which arethe major stru c t u ral elements ri s i n ginside the building are finished inthis way. Those walls which are notglass are also treated with fins. On l yp a rts of the basements and the sixthand seventh floors, where art i s t sneed tackable surf a c e s, are given asmooth finish.

The Long Island labora t o ry differsf rom the Yale Art and Arc h i t e c t u rebuilding in two ways. First, thefinned technique, used only on flats u rfaces in New Ha ven, is applied toc u rved surf a c e s. In most places thisis done without the necessity ofc u rving the form s. The tra n s i t i o n sb e t ween 1-foot flat segments set on

a curve are easily obscured by theactivity of the fluted surf a c e. The ap-p e a rance is that of a true curve. At rue curve was, in fact, used on thef o rms of only a small portion of theb u i l d i n g .

On the whole, the cord u roy sur-face is used more sparingly at En d o.The only interiors finished with therough surface are those of the tur-rets on the office wing and of thel o b by. The remainder of the build-ing called for smooth interior finish,since it is to be used for labora t o ri e s.

Ge n e ral contractor for Ya l e’s Artand Arc h i t e c t u re building was theGe o rge B. H. Macomber Co m p a n y.The aggregate for the Yale buildingwas brought from Easton, Ma s s a-c h u s e t t s. The Easton stone was cho-sen for its warm ye l l ow and goldtones which would be exposed bythe hammeri n g .

The aggregate for the Endo build-ing was a standard bank-run gra ve lf rom Long Island. This stone has ahigh percentage of light-colore dq u a rtz. All the concrete work on thatbuilding was done by the Ce n t ra lCement Finishing Company of Ne wYo rk City. Ge n e ral contractors we reWalter Kidde Co n s t ru c t o r s.

Both jobs ran an ave rage cost of$26.00 per square foot. The Ru d o l p ht reatment calls for one to two dol-lars more per square foot than ac o n ventional concrete surf a c e. Thisf i g u re includes the extra one inch ofwidth which must be allowed in thevolume of concre t e, and the cost ofc reating the fluted form s. The flutedt e c h n i q u e, howe ve r, still under-p rices many altern a t i ve surf a c et re a t m e n t s, since the final surface isbuilt into the concrete walls.

Paul Rudolph’sFluted Concrete Buildings

Page 2: Paul Rudolph's Fluted Concrete Buildings_tcm45-344645

A chipper, one of four employed nearlyfull time on this aspect of theconstruction of the Yale building,executes the final step in creating thecrusted concrete surface. Forms havejust been removed from flutings at theleft. Note that practically no pebbles arevisible in the concrete. Photo shows achipper breaking off the fluting with ahammer, exposing the aggregate. Onepiece of broken concrete flies off (infront of shadow).

A stack of the concreteforms (left) used toachieve the fluted,crusted surface of Yale’sArt and Architecturebuilding. These flutedforms were cut and madein a shop on the buildingsite.

Endo Laboratories, Garden City, Long Island. Nearly allsurfaces of this building are finished in the same crustedtechnique.

The Art and Architecture Building at YaleUniversity was designed by architect Paul Rudolphand is built chiefly of reinforced concrete. Theunusual fluted concrete finish is used on bothinterior and exterior surfaces.

Sketch shows details of construction of forms for casting of thewalls. Beveled fir strips were nailed on vertically and secured withwalers and 1/2-inch bolts.

PUBLICATION #C650084, Co py right © 1965, The Ab e rdeen Gro u p, All rights re s e rve d