Paper No. : 06 Human Growth Development and Nutrition ...
Transcript of Paper No. : 06 Human Growth Development and Nutrition ...
1
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
Paper No. : 06 Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Module : 07 Adaption of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
Prof. Anup Kumar Kapoor Department of Anthropology, University of Delhi
Development Team
Principal Investigator
Paper Coordinator
Content Writer
Content Reviewer
Dr. Meenal Dhall Department of Anthropology, University of Delhi
Dr. Monika Bhuker Research Associate EHI International Pvt Ltd, Delhi
Department of Anthropology, University of Delhi Prof. Satwanti Kapoor Department of Anthropology, University of Delhi
2
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
Description of Module
Subject Name Anthropology
Paper Name 06 Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Module Name/Title Adaption of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
Module Id 07
3
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
Contents of this unit
1. Introduction
1.1. Adaptation
1.2. Growth rate
1.3. Thermoregulation
1.4. Temperature and growth rate
1.5. Allen’s rule
1.6. Bergmann’s rule
1.7 Why is heat adaptation necessary?
2. Summary
3. Self-assessment
4. Suggested reading
Learning Objectives
How human body regulate its body temperature
Why people living in different climates have different body shape and size
Relationship between heat and growth rate
To what extent Allen’s rule apply on different populations
INTRODUCTION
The environment can have major influences on human physiology. Environmental effects on human
physiology are numerous; one of the most carefully studied effects is the alterations in
thermoregulation in the body due to outside stresses. This is necessary because in order for enzymes to
function, blood to flow, and for various body organs to operate, temperature must remain at consistent,
balanced levels. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ecophysiology)
Humans and many other mammals have unusually efficient internal temperature regulating systems
that automatically maintain stable core body temperatures in cold winters and warm summers. In
addition, people have developed cultural patterns and technologies that help them adjust to extremes of
temperature and humidity (http://anthro.palomar.edu).
Two main turning points in evolution are considered as the landmarks of progress in adaption to heat
stress. One was the transition from ectothermic to endothermic control of body temperature and the
other, morphological changes that occur in response to physical stress placed on bone (Bipedalism)
(Drinkwater).
4
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
1.1 ADAPTATION
Adaptation is used as a generic term encompassing acclimatization, acclimation and habituation (Folk,
1974). In biology, an adaptation, also called an adaptive trait, is a trait with a current functional role in
the life history of an organism that is maintained and evolved by means of natural selection.
Adaptation refers to both the current state of being adapted and to the dynamic evolutionary process
that leads to the adaptation. Adaptations contribute to the fitness and survival of individuals.
Organisms face a succession of environmental challenges as they grow and develop and are equipped
with an adaptive plasticity as the phenotype of traits develops in response to the imposed conditions.
The developmental norm of reaction for any given trait is essential to the correction of adaptation as it
affords a kind of biological insurance or resilience to varying environments. The capacity of any stress
to induce adaptation is a function of its application intensity, duration, frequency and variability
(Adolf, 1964), and of the genetic, phenotypic and situational status of the individual. In a modification
of the training impulse model (Banister, 1980), these variables may be used to quantify the cumulative
adaptation impulse (stress volume).
Figure 1: Adaptation theory: A hypothetical illustration of physiological changes following the
application and withdrawal of an adaptation stimulus. (Source: Taylor and Cotter, 2011)
1.2 GROWTH RATE
The changes in height of the developing child can be thought of in two different ways: the height
attained at successive ages and the increments in height from one age to the next, expressed as rate of
5
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
growth per year. If growth is thought of as a form of motion, the height attained at successive ages can
be considered the distance travelled, and the rate of growth, the velocity. The velocity or rate of growth
reflects the child’s state at any particular time better than does the height attained, which depends
largely on how much the child has grown in all preceding years. The blood and tissue concentrations of
those substances whose amounts change with age are thus more likely to run parallel to the velocity
rather than to the distance curve. In some circumstances, indeed, it is the acceleration rather than the
velocity curve that best reflects physiological events. (Britanica.com/human-development)
Figure 2a. Height chart for girls and boys (Encyclopedia Britanica, 2010)
6
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
‘
Figure 2b. Weight charts for girls and boys (Encyclopedias Britanica, 2010)
1.3 THERMOREGULATION
Thermoregulation is performed by a physiological control system consisted of central and peripheral
thermo receptors, an afferent conduction system, a central control for integration of thermal impulses,
and an efferent responses system leading to compensatory responses (Romanovsky, 2007). This system
regulates the balance between production (thermo genesis) and dissipation (thermolysis) of heat, in
order to maintain the body temperature near a constant level of 36.5°C (Gomes et al, 2013).
Humans lose thermal energy to the environment by convection, radiation and sweating. Dubois (1937)
demonstrated that the role of sweating becomes increasingly important in humans as ET rises, as it is
impossible to lose heat by other methods when the environment is hotter than the body.
7
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
Figure3. Process of thermoregulation (Source: adapted from Wikipedia)
1.3.1 Heat stress
It is defined as an environment that acts to drive body temperature above set-point temperature
(Hansen, 2009). Heat stress is composed of two components: 1) heat load which rises from
metabolism, heat exchange, radiation, and convection with the environment; and 2) heat dissipation
which is release of the heat load through sweat evaporation (Vernacchia, 1998). According to
Brotherhood (1987), heat stress is any factor (e.g., high temperatures) or any combination of factors
(e.g., high temperature and high humidity) that overloads the thermoregulatory system thereby raising
the body temperature.
Heat stress can lead to disruptions in reproductive processes through two general mechanisms. First,
the homeokinetic changes to regulate body temperature can compromise reproductive function. One
example is redistribution of blood flow from the body core to the periphery to increase sensible heat
loss. Another homeokinetic control mechanism for body temperature is reduced feed intake during heat
stress. Reducing feed intake reduces metabolic heat production but also can lead to changes in energy
balance and nutrient availability that can have large effects on cyclicity, establishment of pregnancy
and foetal development. A second mechanism for disruption of reproduction during heat stress is the
failure of homeo-kinetic systems to regulate reproduction. (Hansen, 2009)
Children have anatomical and physiological characteristics that differ from adults, such as distinct
values of body composition, water, and bone density. Morphologically, children have a higher ratio
between surface area and body mass, which leads to a more rapid increase in body temperature when it
8
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
is thermally stressed by heat (Rowland, 2008 and Inoue et al, 2004). The evaporative heat loss is
crucial for the maintenance of thermal homeostasis regardless of age.
Table 1. Reported differences in immature relative to mature thermoregulation
Heat stress Effect of thermoregulation
Higher surface area to mass ratio Greater heat loss in mild and cold environments,
and possibly greater heat gain in very high heat
Lower sweating rate Less heat lost via evaporative cooling in hot
climates
Well-developed vasodilation Effective shunting of blood from periphery to
core, higher skin temps in heat stress
Lower blood volume and maximum cardiac
output
Possible cardiac instability while active in heat
stress
Smaller sweat glands Lower sweating output
Lower sweat gland sensitivity Higher sweating threshold
Greater oxygen cost of locomotion Greater metabolic heat production during exercise
Adapted from Little & Hochner, 1974 and Thomas, 1994.
!.3.2 Heat acclimation or Heat acclimatization
The improved tolerance to exercise in heat is known as heat acclimatization. It is specific to the stress
imposed on the human body. For example, passive exposure to heat induces some responses, notably
an improved ability to dissipate heat. In contrast, physical training in a cool-dry environment results in
metabolic, biochemical, hematologic, and cardiovascular adaptations. Heat acclimatization via
strenuous exercise induces responses attributed to both passive heat exposure and training in cool
environments. (Armstrong, 1998)
1.4 TEMPERATURE AND GROWTH RATE
Climate appears to influence growth and development, helping to determine body size and proportions.
According to Bergmann’s and Allen’s rules, body size and proportions of warm-blooded, polytypic
animals are related to temperature. Allen’s rule states that longer extremities and appendages relative
to body size are found in warmer climates, while the reverse is true in colder climates. Bergmann’s rule
states that a larger body size would be expected in colder versus warmer climates. (Cameron, 2002).
A link between adult human body size and environmental temperature, evolved through adaptation to
heat stress, was first recognized a century ago and is now well accepted in human biology. Increasing
heat stress favours smaller body size and an increased ratio of surface area to mass. Many developing
country populations inhabit relatively hot environments compared to industrialized populations, but
growth faltering in developing countries is invariably attributed to the combination of poor nutrition
and infection. The growth faltering can relieve heat stress in both infancy and childhood. The
hypothesis that heat stress plays a role in human growth faltering in hot environments therefore merits
empirical investigation (Wells, 2000). According to Newman (1953), the smaller statures observed
9
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
near the Equator supports Bergmann’s rule, and the shorter legs among the Inuit supports Allen’s rule.
Finally, Schreider demonstrated that amount of body surface area tends to increase from cold to hot
climates (Bogin, 1988).
A negative correlation between adult body mass and environmental temperature (ET) has been
demonstrated by Roberts (1953), Newman (1953), Froment & Hiernaux (1984), Schreider (1964), and
Crognier (1981).
As Kleiber (1961) demonstrated in his monograph “The Fire of Life'', heat production is proportional
to the body mass, M, but heat loss is proportional to the surface area, SA. The ability of an animal to
conserve or lose thermal energy is therefore strongly influenced by the SA(surface area): M (Body
mass) ratio.
1.4.1 Adaptation to thermal stress has been invoked to explain the tall lean proportions of the Nilotic
populations of east Africa (Hiernaux, 1974), and the small stature of tropical rainforest inhabitants such
as the Mbuti (Hiernaux, 1974). Both these adaptations increase the SA: M ratio, facilitating heat loss.
In hot environments, cultural factors are less successful at mitigating the thermal stress, and greater
variation in body size and shape is seen (Crognier, 1981). Roberts (1978), for example, demonstrated a
stronger relationship between size and ET (environmental temperature) in African populations than in
populations inhabiting more temperate climates.
Eveleth (1966) studied American middle-class children reared in Brazil and found them to be more
linear than expected. Stinson & Frisancho (1978) compared the children Andean migrants to the
Amazon jungle with children living in the Andes. Those reared in the jungle were more linear, the
length of the extremities clearly greater.
Figure 4. Relationship between mean annual temperature and body weight and relative sitting height.
(Source: Roberts, 1978)
10
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
The relationships observed between body proportion and environmental temperature can be explained
in terms of the body’s thermoregulatory process. In hot environments, heat dissipation is crucial to
avoid hyper thermic stress, or overheating. A body that has greater surface area relative to total body
size or volume more efficiently dissipates heat produced by the body’s metabolism and activity. One
method through which heat is lost is convection, which is the transfer of heat from the body to the
environment through the movement of air over the body; thus, a greater surface area over which wind
can pass is beneficial to humans in hotter climates. (Cameron, 2002)
The effect of both growth and maturation as of heat acclimation is the increase of the sweat gland
cholinergic stimulus. Moreover, it occurs concomitantly to the acceleration of stimuli toward the
peripheral sympathetic nervous system (Lee et al, 2010).
With physical growth, especially of body surface area, a decrease in the density of sweat glands
activated by heat is verified. This phenomenon does not favour increased perspiration, but, on the other
hand, glands increase in size (hypertrophy), increasing the amount of sweating rate (Inoue et al, 2004).
Growth and maturation provide increased ability to sweat glands, however, unevenly. This means that
some areas may have a higher cholinergic sensitivity compared to other ones (Inoue et al, 2004).
Crognier (1981) studied the relationship between climate and anthropometric measurements in 85 East
African, European, and Middle Eastern populations. He found that mean annual low temperature was
strongly correlated with cranial measurements, but postcranial measurements were strongly correlated
to heat and dryness.
Malina and Bouchard (1991) suggested that the typical body shapes associated with extremes in
temperature, growth in hot environments is prolonged, since there is an association between delayed
maturation and a linear body type. Studies of the mean age at menarche, however, contradict this
conclusion, because a negative correlation to annual mean temperature has been observed indicating
that maturation occurs earlier in hotter climates.
1.5 ALLEN’S RULE
Allen's rule is a biological rule posited by Joel Asaph Allen in 1877.The rule says that the body shapes
and proportions of endotherms vary by climatic temperature by either minimizing exposed surface area
to minimize heat loss in cold climates or maximizing exposed surface area to maximize heat loss in hot
climates. The rule predicts that endotherms from hot climates usually have ears, tails, limbs, snouts,
etc. that are long and thin while equivalent animals from cold climates usually have shorter and thicker
versions of those body parts (Asaph, 1877 and Holstun, 1986).
Katzmarzyk and Leonard (1998) said that there is a negative association between body mass index and
mean annual temperature for indigenous human populations, meaning that people who originate from
colder regions have a heavier build for their height and people who originate from hotter regions have
a lighter build for their height.
11
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
Figure5. These two rectangular prisms have the same volume, but they have different surface areas.
1.6 BERGMANN’S RULE
Bergmann’s rule is an ecological principle which states that body mass increases with latitude. Human
populations, who live near the poles, including the Inuit, Aleut, and Sami people, are on average
heavier than populations from mid-latitudes, consistent with Bergmann's rule (Holiday, 2009). They
also tend to have shorter limbs and broader trunks, consistent with Allen's rule (Holliday, 2009)
According to Marshall T. Newman in a 1953 article for the Journal of the American Anthropologist,
Native American populations are generally consistent with Bergmann's rule although the cold climate
and small body size combination of the Eastern Eskimo, Canoe Indians, Yuki, Andes natives and
Harrison Lake Lillouet runs contrary to the expectations of Bergmann's rule. Newman (1953) contends
that Bergmann's rule holds for the populations of Eurasia, but it does not hold for those of sub-Saharan
Africa.
1.7 WHY IS HEAT ADAPTATION NECESSARY
The ability to respond to heat is seen in all extant human populations, regardless of the environment in
which they now live or how many generations they have been removed from the heat (Edholm &
Weiner, 1981). It is very clear that physiological adaptations remain of paramount importance in
survival. Heat adaptation are very much necessary not just for human beings but for every single
organism for their better survival in hot environments.
Humans acclimate to heat in a rapid and effective manner. Acclimatization involves increased sweating
which reduces body temperature and circulatory strain. The stimulus is elevated body temperature for
short periods over several, consecutive days. In addition to a higher rate of perspiration,
acclimatization also involves a greater sensitivity to environmental heat, as evidenced by the lower
12
Anthropology Human Growth Development and Nutrition
Adaptation of Growth Rates to Heat Stress
temperature at which sweating begins, as well as a redistribution of recruitment patterns and a greater
sodium and chloride economy (Hanna & Brown, 1983). Well adapted human beings more easily
tolerate heat and enhance the level of heat tolerance (Gisolfi et al, 1969). Acclimatization to heat has a
positive effect on work performance and improves maximum work capacity (Shvartz et al, 1977). A
linear body build is of advantage in hot climates if it promotes heat loss.
SUMMARY
Heat Acclimatization is necessary to prevent or reduce the severity of heat illness.
Humans are remarkably well adapted to tolerate heat whether derived from environmental or
from metabolic sources.
Higher surface area to mass ratio in homeotherms is beneficial in terms of heat loss.
Stature, weight and limb length are phenotypically plastic and have a significant environmental
input.
With physical growth, especially of body surface area, a decrease in the density of sweat glands
activated by heat is verified.
Allen’s rule states that longer extremities and appendages relative to body size are found in
warmer climates, while the reverse is true in colder climates.
Bergmann’s rule states that a larger body size would be expected in colder versus warmer
climates.
Heat adaptation are very much necessary not just for human beings but for every single
organism for their better survival in hot environments.