overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase...

36
overcoming challenges changing lives Guide: Gerald Garavuso Jamie Samuel Moore | Emma Sarles | Amy Hughes Hannah Folby | Elizabeth Nicolas | Robert Henry Upper Extremity Team

Transcript of overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase...

Page 1: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

overcomingchallengeschanginglives

Guide: Gerald Garavuso

Jamie Samuel Moore | Emma Sarles | Amy HughesHannah Folby | Elizabeth Nicolas | Robert Henry

Upper Extremity Team

Page 2: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Presentation Agenda

2

Project Objective Concept SelectionFeasibility Analysis Material Considerations CAD Full System Layout CAD Exploded View Renderings Bill of Materials Feasibility Analysis Ergonomic Analysis Full System Architecture CAD Exploded View Rendering Bill of Materials Branding Purchasing Engineering Requirements UpdateRisk Management Testing Plan Subject Matter Expert InterviewsProject Plans Individual Contributions

Cat

ch&

Laun

chSt

rike

Proj

ect

Upd

ates

Phas

e 4

Plan

ning

Page 3: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Project Objective

3

“Design a wheelchair attachment that provides user independence

when throwing, catching, and striking objects.”

Page 4: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

4

Concept Selection

• Must meet functions: throw, catch, strike, attach

• Ease of Integration into mobility device

• Ease of Use

• User Independence

• FeasibilityDislikes:• Front of user• Metal railsLikes:• Handle in front of user• Adjustable position• Within dimensions of chair

Page 5: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

5

Concept Selection

Dislikes:• Weight• SafetyLikes:• User Interaction• Can be adapted for better ergonomics

Dislikes:• Not Feasible for level 1• Good reaction time neededLikes:• Accommodates most levels •Incorporates all functions

Page 6: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

6

Catch&Launch

Page 7: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Exploded View | Catch&Launch

7

Page 8: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

CAD System Design Layout | Catch&Launch

8

*Increased exposure to view internals Extension springTracks with bearings

Rubber punch projects ball Handles attached to punch > moves as one

Page 9: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

9

Feasibility Analysis | Catch&Launch

Page 10: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

10

AttachmentDrill a hole at the end of the cannon. Use small quick clip to attach the net.

2.0mm Premium High Density Poly TwineUV Treated & Stabilized

Polypropylene Thermoplastic PolymerLow energy surface Common glues will not workE=1300-1800N/mm2

Material Considerations | Catch&Launch

Page 11: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Bill of Materials | Catch&Launch

11

Poly twine net PVC pipe for testing

Page 12: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Rendering | Catch&Launch

12

Page 13: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

13

Lever Attachment

Page 14: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

14

Design Details

Page 15: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Exploded View | Strike

15

Page 16: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Rendering | Strike

16

Page 17: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

System Design Layout | Strike

17

Page 18: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

18

Feasibility Analysis | Strike

ProjectileMotion:Assumptions:

• Initialvelocity=11.2m/s• Distancetraveled=4.6m

𝑑𝑑 = 𝑣𝑣!"𝑡𝑡 + .5𝑎𝑎!𝑡𝑡!𝑑𝑑 = 𝑣𝑣!"𝑡𝑡 + .5𝑎𝑎!𝑡𝑡!𝑣𝑣!" = 𝑣𝑣!" + 𝑎𝑎𝑎𝑎Momentum:Assumptions:

• COR“gatorball”=0.3• Ballvi=vball=0m/s(sittingonatee)• Wifflebat• Massispointloadatendofbatwhereballis

inimpact

𝑒𝑒 =𝑣𝑣!"#! − 𝑣𝑣!"##!

𝑣𝑣!"## − 𝑣𝑣!"#

𝑚𝑚!"#𝑣𝑣!"# +𝑚𝑚!"##𝑣𝑣!"## = 𝑚𝑚!"#𝑣𝑣!"#! +𝑚𝑚!"##𝑣𝑣!"##!

GearAnalysis:Assumptions:

• Frictionlessbearings• ϴ=75°

𝑉𝑉 = 𝜔𝜔𝜔𝜔

∝=𝜔𝜔!! − 𝜔𝜔!!

2𝜃𝜃

𝑇𝑇!"# =∝ 𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀 = 𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀!"# +𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀!!"#$% +𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀𝑀!"#$%

𝑇𝑇!" = 𝑇𝑇!"#𝑟𝑟!𝑟𝑟!

𝐹𝐹!"#$% =𝑇𝑇!"

𝐿𝐿!!"#$%

Page 19: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Bill of Materials | Strike

19

Page 20: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Ergonomic Analysis | Strike

20

Wheelchair User•Forward reach: Up: 48” Down: 15” Toward Handle: 7”•Side reach with 10” distance between chair and wall: Up: 54” Down: 9” Preferred:15”•Lever: Length: 2” Width: 4.7” Handle: 8”

The Measure of Man & Woman by Henry Dreyfusshttps: //simanaitissays.files.wordpress.com/2014/06/wheelchair.jpg

Page 21: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

21

Attach to Chair

Page 22: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

22

Attachment

Track system vs .clips

Adjustable

*1 bar for 2 designs*Aluminum

Page 23: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

23

Attachment

Page 24: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

24

Project Updates

Page 25: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Branding

25

Outlined Text

Titles: Shree Devanagari 714 Bold

Subtitles: Shree Devanagari 714

Body: Helvetica Regular

C=92 M=62 Y=12 K=1

overcomingchallengeschanginglives

overcomingchallengeschanginglives

Outlined Text

Titles: Shree Devanagari 714 Bold

Subtitles: Shree Devanagari 714

Body: Helvetica Regular

C=92 M=62 Y=12 K=1

overcomingchallengeschanginglives

Page 26: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

26

Purchasing

Page 27: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Engineering Requirements Update

27

0.0889 [m]

0.198 [kg]

-45° - +45°

1.524 - 9.144 [m]

75%

0.1542 [m]

0.068 [kg]

-30° - +30°

3.048 - 9.144 [m]

Client’s current students who use wheelchairs

Object diameter:

Object mass:

Horizontal angle thrown:

Distance object struck:

Number of mobility aids:

Previous Current

Redefining scope •Centerline focus on both powered and standard wheelchairs •Centerline focus on Gator Ball

Page 28: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Risk Management

28

Page 29: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Testing Plan

29

Overall System1. Attachment time of chosen attachment “clips” a. Mini Quick Fist® b. Team designed rail “clip”2. Team performing different physical activities from the wheelchair3. Attachment adjustability range (height, distance from wheelchair)

Page 30: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Testing Plan

30

Lever Attachment1. Use of different striking apparatus to make sure ball is hit within range2. Difficulty of activity3. Striking of different balls (size, material, weight)

Catch&Launch1. Most effective device angle 2. Difficulty of activity 3. Catching and launching of different balls (size, material, weight)

Page 31: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Testing Plan

31

Post IRB Approval1. Target user will complete activities using the attachments2. Questions: a. Is this device comfortable to use? b. Would you purchase this device? c. Do you feel included? d. Do you feel independent?

Page 32: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

32

Plans for Phase 4

Page 33: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Subject Matter Expert Interviews

33

• Machining Materials• Ergonomics and Human Factors• Design for Manufacture• Gear Design: Dr. Alfonso Aznar (Assoc Professor Mechanical Engineering)

Page 34: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Project Plan

34

Page 35: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

Individual Contributions

35

Hannah

• User testing• Final feasibility of Lever Attachment• CAD model - gears• CAD drawings• EDGE updates

Emma

• User Experience• Refine CAD Drawings• CAD Simulations• Renderings• Ergonomic analysis of Catch&Launch

Robert

• CAD Drawings• Fabrication Plans• Access make vs. buy• Develop MSD II project plan

Amy

• Purchase required materials• CAD drawings• Update risk analysis • Materials testing

Jamie

• Model making• Ergonomic analysis• Presentation• Process book Updates

Liz

• Detailed target user test plan• Interview subject matter experts• CITI Training monitoring • Materials Testing

Page 36: overcomingchallengeschanginglivesedge.rit.edu/content/P17047/public/Detailed Design Documents/Phase 3 Presentation (2).pdfPresentation Agenda 2 Project Objective Concept Selection

36

Questions?