Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

11
Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK

Transcript of Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Page 1: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data

Nora G. Agustero, PhDUniversity of Sheffield

UK

Page 2: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Options

• Storytelling approaches• Case study approaches• Analytical framework approaches

(Patton, p. 439)

Page 3: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Storytelling approaches

• Chronology and history– Describe what happened chronologically, over

time, telling the story from beginning to end. This focuses on some development over time to portray the life of a person, the history of an organisation or community, or the story of a family.

Page 4: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Storytelling approaches

• Flashback– Start at the end, then work backward to describe

how the ending emerged. For example, in an evaluation study, a participant case study might begin with the outcome realised (or unrealised) and then present the chronology or story that illuminates that outcome.

Page 5: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Case study approaches

• People– If individuals or groups are the primary unit of

analysis, then case studies or people or groups may be the focus for case studies. In Respect, Sara Lawrence-Lightfoot (2000) illustrates different forms of respect through case studies of people who manifest those different forms in the way they live their lives.

Page 6: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Case study approaches

• Critical incidents– Critical incidents or major events can constitute

self-contained descriptive units of analysis, often presented in order of importance rather than in sequence of occurrence. McClure (1989) reported a case study of a university through the critical incidents that shaped it.

Page 7: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Case study approaches

• Various settings– Describe various places, sites, settings, or

locations (doing case studies of each) before doing a cross-setting pattern analysis. In an evaluation of multi-national efforts to preserve ancient buildings, we reported on cases in Japan, England, and Indonesia before drawing cross-cultural conclusions.

Page 8: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Analytical framework approaches

• Processes– Qualitative data may be organised to describe

important processes. For example, an evaluation of a program may describe recruitment processes, socialisation processes, decision-making and communication processes, and so on. Distinguishing important processes becomes the analytical framework for organising qualitative descriptions.

Page 9: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Analytical framework approaches

• Issues– An analysis can be organised to illuminate key

issues, often the equivalent of the primary evaluation questions, for example, variations in how participants changed as a result of the programme. In a study of leadership training, we organised the qualitative report around such key issues as conflict management, negotiation skills, enhancing creativity, and effective communications – all important training issues.

Page 10: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Analytical framework approaches

• Questions– Responses to interviews can be organised

question by question, especially where a standardised interviewing format was used. For example, if an evaluation includes questions about perceived strengths and perceived weaknesses, responses to these questions would be grouped together.

Page 11: Organising and Reporting Qualitative Data Nora G. Agustero, PhD University of Sheffield UK.

Analytical framework approaches

• Sensitising concepts– Where sensitising concepts such as “leadership”

vs “followership” have played an important pre-ordinate role in guiding fieldwork, the data can be organised and described through the sensitising concepts.