Oregon Mortgage Fraud and State RICO
-
Upload
financial-crimes-digital-evidence-conference -
Category
Economy & Finance
-
view
753 -
download
0
description
Transcript of Oregon Mortgage Fraud and State RICO
Helping Protect the American Dream
Today’s Goal: Provide A Brief Overview Of
Mortgage Fraud and How to Fight
�What is Mortgage Fraud
�Types of Schemes
�Where the Lies are
�Why We care
�How to Fight –
� prosecution
What is Mortgage Fraud
Mortgage Fraud is any material
misstatement, misrepresentation
or omission relied upon by an
underwriter or lender to fund,
purchase or insure a loan.
What is Mortgage Fraud Cont . . .
�What does that mean?
�Sounds a lot like Justice Stewart's definition of pornography: “I know it when I see it.” Jacobellis v. Ohio, 378 U.S. 184, 197 (1964) (concurring).
What is Mortgage Fraud Cont . . .
Simply Put:
Mortgage fraud is lying to get money from a bank
Two Categories of Mortgage Fraud
�Fraud for Property: minor
misrepresentations by the applicant solely for the purpose of purchasing a property for a primary residence. Usually a single loan.
�Fraud for Profit: gross misrepresentations
concerning appraisals and loan documents and participants are frequently paid for their participation. Usually involves several loans.
Today’s Goal: Provide A Brief Overview Of
Mortgage Fraud and How to Fight
�What is Mortgage Fraud
�Types of Schemes
�Where the Lies are
�Why We care
�How to Fight –
� prosecution
Real estate
Investment 7%
Real estate
Investment 7%
BankruptcyFraud - 1%
BankruptcyFraud - 1%
Builder Bailout – 2%
Builder Bailout – 2% Equity
Skimming – 2%
Equity Skimming – 2%
Settlement related
Schemes (kickbacks)
14%
Settlement related
Schemes (kickbacks)
14%
Advance Fee -2%
Advance Fee -2%
Commercial Real EstateFraud – 4%
Commercial Real EstateFraud – 4%
Foreclosure Rescue – 2%
Foreclosure Rescue – 2%
Short Sale 4%
Short Sale 4%
Loan Origination(property flipping)
62%
Loan Origination(property flipping)
62%
SchemesSchemes
Loan Origination: Flipping
�False statement can include:
�False appraisal
�False straw buyer financial qualifications
�False transaction documents based on phony price
Most Common Fraud –
Flipping/Equity Stripping
Flipping Scheme:
Flipped Home
Flipped Home
Builder-Bailout
�False statement can include:
�False appraisal lender relies on for loan approval
�False transaction documents based on phony price
�Fictitious down payment
Builder-Bailout Example
Builder/Developer can’t sell his/her inventory
Builder/Developer gets inflated appraisalFor $500,000 for a
$400,000 home
Loan Documents falsely state $500,000
Transaction price
Lender funds a mortgage loan of $400,000 believing
that $100,000 was paid to the builder, creating home equity
Step 4
Step 3Step 2
Step 1
Step 5
Based on phony down payment. Lender funds 100% of
homes value. Builder/ Developer keeps his profit
Reverse Mortgage
Equity Skimming: Reverse Mortgage
�Home Equity Conversion Mortgage (“HECM”) Scheme:
� Perpetrators purchase properties using straw buyers
� Deed then transferred to senior
� After 60 days, with inflated appraisal, perpetrator helps senior obtain HECM, usually in lump sum
� Perpetrator absconds with all the money
Foreclosure Rescue Scam
�False statement can include:
�Failure to disclose homeowner’s interest in property in subsequent financing transactions
�Subsequent lender is misled if title transfer/deed is manipulated or forged
Foreclosure Rescue Scam
Perpetrator convinces homeowner they can save their home from foreclosure through deed transfers and up-front fees
Step 1
Step 2
Step 3
Step 4
The Perpetrator may sell the victim’s home without
the homeowner’s knowledge
The Perpetrator may secure a second loan without the homeowner’s knowledge
Deed Transfer. The deed is manipulated
and forged by the Perpetrator
Homeowner signs deed over to Perpetrator
Up-front fees
Victim’s House
Homeowner
Short Sale Scheme
�False statement can include:
�False appraisal lender relies on for loan approval
�False transaction documents based on phony price
�Perpetrators secret control of transaction and fact that straw buyer does not intend to be responsible for payments on loan
Short Sale Schemes:
Perpetrator identifies a home in the process of foreclosure.
Bank is owed $500,000.
Perpetrator finds a buyer to purchase the property for $400,000
Perpetrator makes an offer to the bank to purchase the property in a “short sale” for
$300,000. Bank agrees believing that a buyer willing to pay $300,000.
Lender agrees to the short sale not knowing that the buyer has agreed to purchase the
property for $400,000.
Perpetrator sells the property at actual value for a profit, or has the property artificially
inflated to conduct an illegal property flip
Today’s Goal: Provide A Brief Overview Of
Mortgage Fraud and How to Fight
�What is Mortgage Fraud
�Types of Schemes
�Where the Lies are
�Why We care
�How to Fight –
� prosecution
Motivational Quote
“Like music, lying requires exquisite timing, a consistent beat and a melodic quality designed to sooth the most cynical beast.”
Robert F. Miller, real estate con-artist, Statement to the United States District Court, District of Columbia, 1:05CR00143
Form 1003
Is it claimed as a primary residence
Is the employment history true
Motivational Quote 2
“ Like painting, lying requires varying shades of color, depending on the visual or intellectual effect desired.”Robert F. Miller, real estate con-artist, Statement to the United States
District Court, District of Columbia, 1:05CR00143
Tax Returns
&
W-2s
Gift Letter
Motivational Quote 3
“ Like poetry, lying has to be precise, measured, lyrical and appealing.”Robert F. Miller, real estate con-artist, Statement to the United States
District Court, District of Columbia, 1:05CR00143
VOE
VOD
Seasoning Accounts
Appraisal
HUD-1
Cash at closing from Borrower
Final Motivational Quote
“ Are you kidding? I couldn’t make this much money selling crack in Detroit. Besides, this way no one shoots me and I get to wear a suit.”A. S., Straw Buyer, Proffer Session, EDKY
Real Estate Investment Schemes
� Louis J. Borstelmann:
� $18.9 Million Real Estate Ponzi Scheme
� Over 100 Victims in Several States, including Oregon, California, Hawaii, Montana, and Texas
� 108 Months’ Incarceration and $18.9 Million in Restitution
Today’s Goal: Provide A Brief Overview Of
Mortgage Fraud and How to Fight
�What is Mortgage Fraud
�Types of Schemes
�Where the Lies are
�Why We care
�How to Fight –
� prosecution
Why We Care
� Mortgage fraud has the single biggest impact on quality of life in an area� In Central Oregon
and Coastal cities prices have dropped more than 10 percent
State 12 Month Housing Price Index % Change
California -4.73% Nevada -6.56% Arizona -13.38% Florida -5.79% Oregon -10.02%
ForeclosuresIn 2008, Oregon’s foreclosure rate jumped 121 percent
In 2009, Oregon foreclosures 12th
highest in nation
In 2010, Oregon’s foreclosure rate increases 20 percent to 3rd highest in nation
FHA
Losses
Today’s Goal: Provide A Brief Overview Of
Mortgage Fraud and How to Fight
�What is Mortgage Fraud
�Types of Schemes
�Where the Lies are
�Why We care
�How to Fight –
� prosecution
Possible Federal Charges
� Bank Fraud
� Wire Fraud
� Mail Fraud
� Loan Application Fraud/False Statement to Banks
� Conspiracy
� Money Laundering
� Bankruptcy Fraud
Possible Oregon Charges� Aggravated Theft – by deception
� Forgery (and related offenses)
� Income Tax Fraud/Evasion
� Mortgage Broker Fraud (see list in ORS 86 et seq)
� Aggravated Identity Theft
� Money Laundering
� Racketeering--includes the above charges, and
� Federal Charges listed in Federal RICO such as:
� Bank Fraud, Wire Fraud, Mail Fraud, Money Laundering
Why Oregon Racketeering (“RICO”)?
� Can bring federal charges such as bank and/or wire fraud and state charges.
� Uniquely suited to target organized mortgage fraud.
� If real property – enterprise not required.
� Required pattern evidence – advantage.
� Class A felony.
What do you need for RICO?
A Pattern of Racketeering Activity (“PRA”)
At least two or more incidents with same/similar:� Intents, results, accomplices, victims, OR
� Methods of commission, OR,
� Otherwise are interrelated by distinguishing, including a nexus to the same enterprise (and not isolated)
� PRA –or “predicates” can include:� Aggravated Theft (Oregon),
� Bank Fraud (Federal), Wire Fraud (Federal)…
2 underused RICO weapons
RICOORS 166.720
(3) Enterprise (only)
(1) PROCEEDS &
REAL PROPERTY(or enterprise)
(2) INTEREST..
in REAL PROP.(or enterprise)
(4) Conspire/
Endeavor
Why underused??? Because lawyers are like this guy…
Unlawful Proceeds
and Mortgage FraudORS 166.720(1)
� IF proceeds from PRA and
� Proceeds used to finance enterprise, OR
� In the acquisition of any title to, or any right, interest or equity in, real property
� Injury from proceeds itself. � Kotera v. DAIOH International, 179 Or.App. 253, 277 (2002)
� THEN CHARGE RICO
RICO example #1
Unlawful proceeds in Mortgage Fraud
Suspect’s unlawful proceeds used toobtain real property
Suspect generates unlawful proceeds through 2x mortgage fraud
Suspect uses unlawful proceedsas down payment
$$$$$
RICO example #2
Unlawful proceeds in Mortgage Fraud
Suspect’s unlawful proceeds used toobtain real property
Suspect generates unlawful proceeds through 2x drug sales
Suspect uses unlawful proceedsas down payment
$$$$$
Interest or Control
and Mortgage FraudORS 166.720(2)
� IF from a PRA, a person
� Acquires, maintains, direct or indirect, interest or control
� Of any enterprise,
OR
� ANY REAL PROPERTY
� Injury from acquisition, etc., itself.
� Kotera v. DAIOH Int’l, 179 Or.App. 253, 277 (2002)
� THEN CHARGE RICO
RICO example #3
Interest or Control in Mortgage Fraud
Suspect falselyRepresents toTo Bank #1 that HELOC is for home improvement. In reliance, Bank #1 Issues HELOC #1 for house #1
Suspect then Obtains HELOC #2 from Bank #2 for House #2 by using money from HELOC #1 and by concealingOrigin of money.
Money from HELOC #2 is used to acquire House #3 by concealing the origin of the money.
Some Oregon Charges available?
�Racketeering (1x) with predicates:
�Aggravated Theft (3x)
�Bank Fraud (3x)
�Wire Fraud (3x)---if electronic….
�Aggravated Theft (3x)
�….More…….
So why not charge RICO?
� RICO is a class A felony.
� Maximum penalty:
� 20 years
� $375,000 fine
� Actual penalties can include sentencing based on the highest level predicate.
� Sentencing may be consecutive to underlying predicates. State v. Blossom,88 Or.App. 75, 78-79 (1987).
Sample Proceeds (subsec.1)
Indictment Language� “The Defendant, between [begin date here] through [end
date here], in [county here], did unlawfully and knowingly receive the direct or indirect proceeds of a pattern of racketeering activity, used or invested,directly or indirectly, any part of such proceeds, derived from the use thereof, in the acquisition of title, rights, interests, or equity in real property, to-wit; [identifying real property information/location here]
� The pattern of racketeering activity consisted of incidents that were not isolated but that had the same or similar intents, results, accomplices, victims, or methods of commission, or were otherwise interrelated by distinguishing characteristics is more particularly described as follows:
� [allege predicates individually here]”
Sample Interest/Control (subsec.2)
Indictment Language
� “The Defendant, between [begin date here] through [end date here], in [county here], through a pattern of racketeering activity, did unlawfully and knowingly acquire, maintain, directly or indirectly, an interest or control in real property, to-wit;
� [identifying real property information/location here]� The pattern of racketeering activity consisted of incidents
that were not isolated but that had the same or similar intents, results, accomplices, victims, or methods of commission, or were otherwise interrelated by distinguishing characteristics is more particularly described as follows:
� [allege predicates individually here]”
RICO Remedies� Injunctions and orders
� Divestitures of --interests in enterprise OR real property;
� Restricting future activities, investments, enterprise; � Dissolution or reorganization of any enterprise.� Suspensions or revocations of licenses, permits, etc. � Forfeiture/revocation of authority to conduct business.
� Forfeiture of personal or real property, and proceeds� Seizure without court process -- incident to arrest,
administrative inspection warrant, prior RICO judgment.� Award of costs of investigation and litigation - for
agencies working case. Includes attorney fees.� The AG, any DA, and state agency with jurisdiction over
predicates may institute civil forfeiture proceedings.
Civil RICO Complaint� Any DA, state agency, investigative agency, or the AGO –
may file civil RICO.� Any aggrieved person – may file civil RICO, with limit:
� It must follow a RICO criminal conviction with appeal rights expired OR Civil RICO Complaint limited to selected list of predicates from ORS 166.715(6)(a) – most not mortgage fraud.
� May seek forfeited property or proceeds superior to the state, attorney’s fees, three-fold the actual damages sustained and, when appropriate, punitive damages. Damage awards are supplemental and not mutually exclusive of other damages.
� Collateral Estoppel: If criminal RICO conviction, then estoppel in subsequent civil actions or proceedings.
RICO
� Use Oregon RICO to fight mortgage fraud –
� When there is a predicate involving a pattern of mortgage fraud.� Two or more is sufficient for a pattern
� Use to bring federal and state charges.
Questions?
AUSA Scott Bradford
AAG Jonathan Groux
�541-465-6771
�503-934-4400