Numerical Tool for Evaluating Hall Thruster Stability · tool to evaluate the dispersion relations...
1
Plasma Rocket Instability Characterizer (PRINCE) The Plasma Rocket Instability Characterizer is a numerical tool to evaluate the dispersion relations relevant to the Hall thruster. The user specifies through a GUI (above) the dispersion relation to be solved as well as the geometry and background plasma parameters of the thruster. Publications: [1] Rojas Mata, S., Choueiri, E. Y., Jorns, B. A., and Spektor, R., “PRINCE: A Software Tool for Characterizing Waves and Instabilities in Plasma Thrusters,” 52 nd JPC AIAA Paper 2016-4533, July 2016. PI/Task Mgr. Contact Information: Phone: 818-354-2040 Email: [email protected] Numerical Tool for Evaluating Hall Thruster Stability Principal Investigator: Dr. Benjamin Jorns (353) Prof. Edgar Choueiri (Princeton University), Sebastián Rojas Mata (Princeton University), Dr. Rostislav Spektor (Aerospace Corporation) Program: Spontaneous Concepts Poster No. RPC-195 Project Objective: The primary goal of this project was to develop a software tool to predict the onset of oscillatory modes of operation in Hall thrusters. This effort had three major milestones: 1. Determine key dispersion relations for instabilities known to exist in Hall thrusters 2. Write a user-friendly program with GUI to solve the dispersion relations from (1) for a test-case Hall thruster and output predicted instabilities 3. Validate the code against real measurements of instabilities in a Hall thruster FY15/16 Results: We developed the Plasma Rocket Instability Characterizer (PRINCE), a prototype software tool implemented in Wolfram Research’s Mathematica. PRINCE was validated by reproducing results of a previous study concerning instabilities arising in a Hall thruster channel. Major accomplishments include • Developed a user-friendly graphical interface featuring versatile data input, customizable solver settings, and varied data visualization options • Implemented robust autonomous algorithms for the root-finding and root-tracking tasks • Tested and validated PRINCE with various types of data sets and different dispersion relations Benefits to NASA and JPL: The Hall thruster is a form of electric propulsion that has been flown on over a hundred commercial systems and has been identified in the past decade as a core enabling technology for JPL’s deep space applications. These include the proposed Asteroid Robotic Redirect Mission (ARRM) as well as Psyche, a Step 2 Discovery Program mission concept. When operated optimally, Hall thrusters will run stably and efficiently for thousands of hours while offering significant payload mass savings. However, under non-optimal conditions these devices can exhibit oscillatory behavior characterized by large-scale variations in the thruster’s plasma properties and discharge power. It currently is standard operating procedure to margin away from these oscillatory regimes by performing detailed empirical characterizations of engineering units. However, in the interest of being able to better design and more efficiently qualify these devices for future flight applications, the need is apparent for physics-based design tools that assess the nature and onset criteria of the unstable operating modes. The numerical solver that we have developed, PRINCE, represents a significant step toward achieving this goal. The version permits non-technical users to calculate whether key instabilities will onset in a thruster---provided they can input the geometry and measurements of the background plasma parameters. National Aeronautics and Space Administration Jet Propulsion Laboratory California Institute of Technology Pasadena, California www.nasa.gov National Aeronautics and Space Administration Copyright 2016. All rights reserved. Dispersion relation for unstable modes , ; ’ , ( ,… =0 The dispersion relation is a mathematical expression that can be used to represent an oscillating plasma mode. It depends on the mode frequency, ⍵, wave vector, k, and the background parameters, p i , such as geometry, electric and magnetic fields, and the plasma properties. By inputting the background parameters and solving the dispersion relation numerically for the oscillation frequency as a function of wavevector, ⍵(k), it is possible to determine if and where in the thruster geometry the mode described by the relation will be unstable. This solution is typically generated by fixing the wavevector and searching numerically for the frequency values that correspond to roots of the dispersion relation. Numerical solver for PRINCE PRINCE finds the complex frequency roots (green dots) of the input dispersion relation by fixing the wavevector and using Cauchy’s Argument Principle on a grid of cells (blue) defined in complex frequency space. In the event that multiple roots occur in a cell, the individual contributions are resolved through recursive application of the algorithm to subdivided cells. 0 th Recursion Step 1 st Recursion Step Schematic representation of Hall thruster cross-section PRINCE output showing frequency of unstable oscillation Stable Unstable kHz Radial magnetic field In thruster channel Negative gradient drives oscillation unstable Validation of PRINCE We validated PRINCE against publically available data on the SPT-100, a 1.35 kW commercially-flown Hall thruster that operates with xenon propellant. Using experimental data sets of electron density, plasma potential, and radial magnetic field, we generated with PRINCE a spatial map of the frequencies of the oscillations associated with the Esipchuk-Tilinin mode in the thruster channel. The dispersion relation for this oscillation is 1 − / 1 ( + 3 453 − 6 7 ( 1 ( − 3 453 =0 where the coordinate system and physical parameters are shown in the figure to the right. The plot of the oscillation frequencies for this mode as generated by PRINCE matches estimates from a previous study on this instability in the SPT-100 channel (Choueiri, E. Y., “Plasma Oscillations in Hall Thrusters," Physics of Plasmas, Vol. 8, No. 4, 2001, pp. 1411-1426.). Moreover, it is well-known that this oscillation becomes unstable when the radial magnetic field exhibits a negative gradient. The calculated localization of the instability to this region in the thruster geometry is additional validation of the solver. V D Discharge voltage E ax Axial electric field u i Ion drift velocity u dey Electron drift velocity in azimuthal direction B rad Radial magnetic field
Transcript of Numerical Tool for Evaluating Hall Thruster Stability · tool to evaluate the dispersion relations...
Plasma Rocket Instability Characterizer(PRINCE)
The Plasma Rocket Instability Characterizer is a numericaltool to evaluate the dispersion relations relevant to the Hallthruster. The user specifies through a GUI (above) thedispersion relation to be solved as well as the geometry andbackground plasma parameters of the thruster.
Publications:[1] Rojas Mata, S., Choueiri, E. Y., Jorns, B. A., and Spektor, R., “PRINCE: A Software Tool for Characterizing Waves and Instabilities in Plasma Thrusters,” 52nd JPC AIAA Paper 2016-4533, July 2016.
PI/Task Mgr. Contact Information:Phone: 818-354-2040Email: [email protected]
Numerical Tool for Evaluating Hall Thruster StabilityPrincipal Investigator: Dr. Benjamin Jorns (353)
Prof. Edgar Choueiri (Princeton University), Sebastián Rojas Mata (Princeton University),Dr. Rostislav Spektor (Aerospace Corporation)
Program: Spontaneous Concepts
Poster No. RPC-195
Project Objective:The primary goal of this project was to develop a software tool to predict the onset of oscillatory modes of operation in Hall thrusters. This effort had three major milestones:
1. Determine key dispersion relations for instabilities known to exist in Hall thrusters
2. Write a user-friendly program with GUI to solve the dispersion relations from (1) for a test-case Hall thruster and output predicted instabilities
3. Validate the code against real measurements of instabilities in a Hall thruster
FY15/16 Results:We developed the Plasma Rocket Instability Characterizer (PRINCE), a prototype software tool implemented in Wolfram Research’s Mathematica. PRINCE was validated by reproducing results of a previous study concerning instabilities arising in a Hall thruster channel. Major accomplishments include
• Developed a user-friendly graphical interface featuring versatile data input, customizable solver settings, and varied data visualization options
• Implemented robust autonomous algorithms for the root-finding and root-tracking tasks
• Tested and validated PRINCE with various types of data sets and different dispersion relations
Benefits to NASA and JPL:The Hall thruster is a form of electric propulsion that has been flown on over a hundred commercial systems and has been identified in the past decade as a core enabling technology for JPL’s deep space applications. These include the proposed Asteroid Robotic Redirect Mission (ARRM) as well as Psyche, a Step 2 Discovery Program mission concept. When operated optimally, Hall thrusters will run stably and efficiently for thousands of hours while offering significant payload mass savings. However, under non-optimal conditions these devices can exhibit oscillatory behavior characterized by large-scale variations in the thruster’s plasma properties and discharge power. It currently is standard operating procedure to margin away from these oscillatory regimes by performing detailed empirical characterizations of engineering units. However, in the interest of being able to better design and more efficiently qualify these devices for future flight applications, the need is apparent for physics-based design tools that assess the nature and onset criteria of the unstable operating modes. The numerical solver that we have developed, PRINCE, represents a significant step toward achieving this goal. The version permits non-technical users to calculate whether key instabilities will onset in a thruster---provided they can input the geometry and measurements of the background plasma parameters.
National Aeronautics and Space AdministrationJet Propulsion LaboratoryCalifornia Institute of TechnologyPasadena, California
www.nasa.gov
National Aeronautics and Space Administration
Copyright 2016. All rights reserved.
Dispersion relation for unstable modes
𝔇 𝜔, 𝒌; 𝑝', 𝑝(, … = 0The dispersion relation is a mathematical expression thatcan be used to represent an oscillating plasma mode. Itdepends on the mode frequency, ⍵, wave vector, k, and thebackground parameters, pi, such as geometry, electric andmagnetic fields, and the plasma properties. By inputting thebackground parameters and solving the dispersion relationnumerically for the oscillation frequency as a function ofwavevector, ⍵(k), it is possible to determine if and where inthe thruster geometry the mode described by the relationwill be unstable. This solution is typically generated byfixing the wavevector and searching numerically for thefrequency values that correspond to roots of the dispersionrelation.
Numerical solver for PRINCE
PRINCE finds the complex frequency roots (green dots) ofthe input dispersion relation by fixing the wavevector andusing Cauchy’s Argument Principle on a grid of cells (blue)defined in complex frequency space. In the event thatmultiple roots occur in a cell, the individual contributionsare resolved through recursive application of the algorithmto subdivided cells.
0th Recursion Step 1st Recursion Step
Schematic representation of Hall thruster cross-section
PRINCE output showing frequency of unstable oscillation
Stable
Unstable
kHz
Radial magnetic field In thruster channel
Negative gradient drives oscillation unstable
Validation of PRINCE
We validated PRINCE against publically available data onthe SPT-100, a 1.35 kW commercially-flown Hall thrusterthat operates with xenon propellant. Using experimentaldata sets of electron density, plasma potential, and radialmagnetic field, we generated with PRINCE a spatial map ofthe frequencies of the oscillations associated with theEsipchuk-Tilinin mode in the thruster channel. Thedispersion relation for this oscillation is
1𝜔 − 𝑘/𝑢1 (
+𝑘3 𝑢453 − 𝑢6
𝑘7(𝑢1( 𝜔 − 𝑘3𝑢453= 0
where the coordinate system and physical parameters are shown in the figure to the right. The plot of the oscillation frequencies for this mode as generated by PRINCE matches estimates from a previous study on this instability in the SPT-100 channel (Choueiri, E. Y., “Plasma Oscillations in Hall Thrusters," Physics of Plasmas, Vol. 8, No. 4, 2001, pp. 1411-1426.). Moreover, it is well-known that this oscillation becomes unstable when the radial magnetic field exhibits a negative gradient. The calculated localization of the instability to this region in the thruster geometry is additional validation of the solver.
VD Discharge voltageEax Axial electric fieldui Ion drift velocityudey Electron drift velocity in
azimuthal directionBrad Radial magnetic field
