NSF Cubesat report
Transcript of NSF Cubesat report
National Aeronautics and Space Administration
www.nasa.gov
NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
October 2013
www.nsf.gov
annu
al re
port
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 1
Conte
ntsLETTERS OF SUPPORT 3CONTACTS 5NSF PROGRAM OBJECTIVES 6GSFC WFF OBJECTIVES 82013 AND PRIOR PROJECTS 11 Radio Aurora Explorer (RAX) 12 Project Description 12 ScientificAccomplishments 14 Technology 14 Education 14 Publications 15 Colorado Student Space Weather Experiment (CSSWE) 17 Project Description 17 ScientificAccomplishments 17 Technology 18 Education 18 Publications 19 DataArchive 19 Dynamic Ionosphere CubeSat Experiment (DICE) 20 Project Description 20 ScientificAccomplishments 20 Technology 21 Education 22 Publications 23 DataArchive 24 Firefly and FireStation 26 Project Description 26 ScientificAccomplishments 26 Technology 27 Education 28 StudentProfiles 30 Publications 31 Cubesat for Ions, Neutrals, Electrons and MAgnetic fields (CINEMA) 32 Project Description 32 ScientificAccomplishments 32 Technology 33 Education 33 Focused Investigations of Relativistic Electron Burst, Intensity, Range, and Dynamics (FIREBIRD) 34 ProjectDescription 34 ScientificAccomplishments 34 Education 342014 PROJECTS 35 Oxygen Photometry of the Atmospheric Limb (OPAL) 36 Project Description 36 PlannedScientificAccomplishments 36 PlannedTechnology 36 PlannedEducation 37
2 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
QB50/QBUS 38 Project Description 38 PlannedScientificAccomplishments 38 PlannedTechnology 39 PlannedEducation 40 Lower Atmosphere/Ionosphere Coupling Experiment (LAICE) 41 ProjectDescription 41 PlannedScientificAccomplishments 41 PlannedTechnology 41 PlannedEducation 42 Cubesat for Ions, Neutrals, Electrons and MAgnetic fields (CINEMA) 43 ProjectDescription 43 PlannedScientificAccomplishments 43 PlannedTechnology 43 Composition Variations in the Exosphere, Thermosphere, and Topside Ionosphere (EXOCUBE) 44 ProjectDescription 44 PlannedScientificAccomplishments 44 PlannedTechnology 46 PlannedEducation 47 Cubesat investigating Atmospheric Density Response to Extreme driving (CADRE) 49 ProjectDescription 49 PlannedScientificAccomplishments 49 PlannedTechnology 50 PlannedEducation 50 Publications 51 Firefly and FireStation 52 Project Description 52 PlannedScienceAccomplishments 52 PlannedTechnology 53 PlannedEducation 53 Focused Investigations of Relativistic Electron Burst, Intensity, Range, and Dynamics (FIREBIRD) 54 ProjectDescription 54 PlannedScientificAccomplishments 54 PlannedTechnology 54 PlannedPublications 54THE FUTURE 55
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 3
ThefollowingarelettersofsupportfromDr.RichardBehnke,NationalScienceFoundation,Head,GeospaceScienceSection,andMr.BillWrobel,NASAGoddardSpaceFlightCenter(GSFC),Director,WallopsFlightFacility(WFF).
LettersofSupport
4 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 5
Conta
cts
GSFC WFF Point of ContactWallopsFlightFacilityScottSchaireSmallSatelliteProjectsManagerPhone:757-824-1120Email:[email protected]
National Science Foundation Point of ContactGeosciences DirectorateThereseMorettoJorgensen,PhDProgramDirector,GeospaceSciencePhone:703-292-4729Email:[email protected]
6 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
NSFProgramObjectives TheNationalScienceFoundation(NSF)isanindependentfederalagencythatwascreatedby
Congressin1950“topromotetheprogressofscience;toadvancethenationalhealth,pros-perity,andwelfare;tosecurethenationaldefense…”Withanannualbudgetofabout$7billion,NSFfundsapproximately20%ofallfederallysupportedbasicresearchconductedbythenation’scollegesanduniversities.MostofthegrantsawardedbyNSFgotoindividualsorsmallgroupsofinvestigatorsforlimited-termspecificresearchprojectsthathavebeenjudgedthemostpromisingbyarigorousandobjectivemerit-reviewsystem.CurrentlyNSFissuesabout11,000newawardsperyear,withanaveragedurationof3years. Since2008,theDivisionofAtmosphericandGeospaceSciencesatNSFhasrunaprogramtosupportCubeSat-basedScienceMissions.Thisprogramimplementsanewandverydiffer-entapproachtoprovidingthescientificmeasurementsinandfromspacethatarecriticalforadvancingdiscoveryandunderstandinginmanyareasofscience.Itbuildsonrecentengi-neeringandsystemdevelopmentsofCubeSattechnologythathaveestablishedthetechnicalfeasibilityoftinyspacecraftmissionsthatcanbelaunchedassecondarypayloadsatverylowcostandrapidtimescalesastheyposevirtuallynorisktothelaunchvehicleoritsprimarypayload.ThismakesspacemeasurementsachievablewithinthescopeofthetraditionalNSFgrantsprogramsandgreatlyenhancestheparticipationofthelargeruniversitycommunityinspaceactivities.Inaddition,doingspaceinnewwayswithCubesatmissionsspursscienceinnovationandcreativityandalsomotivatesandinspiresengineeringinventionsandadvances.Equallyimportantly,CubeSatprojectsofferextraordinaryeducationalbenefits.Theyallowstudents,throughhands-onworkonreal,exciting,end-to-endproj-ects,todevelopthenecessaryskillsandexperienceneed-edtosucceedinScience,Technology,Engineering,andMathematics(STEM)careers.CubeSatprojectsarealsoaneffectivetooltobroadentheparticipationamongstunderrepresentedgroupsinSTEMresearchandeducation.Theprojectsstimulatewidespreadexcitementandinvolveauniquelydiversesetofskillsandinterest.Thereforetheyappealtoabroaderrangeofparticipantsthanmoretraditionalscienceandengineeringprojects.
Buildingonthisstrongmotivation,theNSFCubeSatprogrampursuesadualgoal:topro-moteoriginalandstimulatingSTEMeducationandworkforcedevelopmentaswellasfront-line,interdisciplinaryscientificresearchandtechnologyadvancesbyexploringuntraditional,creative,andlow-costwaystoprovidespacemeasurementsforscientificresearch.Specifi-cally,themainobjectiveofthecurrentprogramistoexecutesmallscientificsatellitemissionstoadvancespaceandatmosphericresearch.Anadditionalobjectiveistoprovideessentialopportunitiestotrainthenextgenerationofexperimentalspacescientistsandaerospaceen-gineers.Tothisend,theprogramsupportsthedevelopment,construction,launch,andopera-tionofsmallsatellitesystemsaswellasthedistributionandanalysisofthesciencedatafromthemissions.Tofacilitatelaunchofthesatellitesassecondarypayloads,thefocuscurrentlyisonCubeSat-basedsatellites.LaunchesarenotpartoftheprogrambutareprovidedbytheDODonacollaborativeorreimbursablebasisandbyNASAthroughtheirEducationallaunchprogram(ELaNa).
The Oxygen Photometry of the Atmospheric Limb (OPAL) mission consists of one 3U Cubesat.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 7
Proposalsaresubmittedtotheprogramthroughanannualsolicitation;basedonscientificandtechnicalpeerreviewonetotwonewprojectsareselectedeachyearforimplementationoutofapoolofroughly25proposals.Theselectedprojectsparticularlyexcelineachofthefollowingaspects: Compelling science case Theuniquenessandimportanceoftheobservationsandmeasurementstheyobtainforad-dressingkeyoutstandingsciencequestions.
Exceptional Student trainingTheextensiveandoutstandingeducationandtrainingopportunitiestheyofferandthehighlevelofstudentinvolvementinallofthevariousaspectsofthemissions.
Technical ingenuity and feasibilityThesignificantdegreetowhichtheyadvanceandmakeuseofemergingtechnologieswhiledemonstratingsatisfactorytechnologicalreadinessorheritage Strong team building and management Thesoundnessoftheirplansforcollaboration,management,scheduling,andriskreductionthroughoutthedevelopment,operations,andsciencephasesofthemission,respectively.
Sofar,theprogramhascarriedout4competitionsresultinginatotalof10projects.Typically,thegrantsawardedareintheamountof$900,000andof3yearsduration.Overthefirst5yearsoftheprogram(2008-2012),thetotalfundingintheprogramwasjustbelow$10mil-lion,includingaone-timeinfusionof$2.8millionfromtheAmericanReinvestmentandRecoveryActin2009.
Theprogramemploysamanagementapproachthatisunusualforsatelliteprograms:Minimaldirectivesandoversightobligationsareimposedonthemanagementoftheprojectsduringtheirimplementation,withtheonlystrictrequirementsbeingtheonesthataredictatedbylaunchacceptance.ThisimpliesthatthePrincipalInvestigatorsoftheprojectsarefullyrespon-sibleforconductingthemissions,includingscheduling,reviews,testing,documentation,andriskmanagement,andformeetingtherequirementsforanyofthissetbythelaunchprovider.However,technicalandmanagementsupport,includingaccesstotestandground-stationfacil-ities,isprovidedtotheteams,asneeded,throughthecollaborationwithNASAWallopsFlightFacility(WFF).Although,bydesign,limitedinscopethissupportisacrucialelementoftheprogram.Itcontributesessentialengineeringandmissionmanagementexpertiseandcapabil-itiesthatarecriticalforensuringthatallofthemissionsaresuccessfullyqualifiedforlaunchandcompleted.Openinter-teamdiscussionsasameanstopromotetransferofknowledgeandprovidecontinuitybetweentheindividualprojectsconstituteanotheruntraditionalman-agementtoolthattheprogramapplies.TojointlydevelopandimplementbestpracticesforthesegroundbreakingsmallsatelliteprojectsisanimportantauxiliarygoalfortheprogramatNSFandforthecollaborationwithWFF.
8 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
GSFCWFFObjectives TheveryfirstCubeSatlaunchedintheUnitedStateswasa3UCubesatcalledGeneSat-1,
manifestedontheTacast-2launchoutofGSFCWallopsinDec.2006.WFFmanifestedCubeSatswiththeTacsat-3launchonaMinotaur-1launchvehiclewhichlaunchedinMayof2009. ItwasduringthisTacSat-3projectthatWFFlearnedquiteabitaboutobjectdebrisanalysis,safety,andtherequiredCubeSatandP-PODtesting.
MainlybecauseofWFFexperiencewiththelow-cost,smallpayload,responsive,soundingrocketandballoonprograms,andworkingwithprincipalinvestigators,WFFisideallysuitedtosupportCubeSatendeavors.
In2008,theNationalScienceFoundation(NSF)choseNASAGSFCWallopsFlightFacility(WFF)tocollaboratewiththeirCubeSatactivities.WFFcontinuestosupporttheirCubeSatprogram.SomeoftheservicesthatWFFhasbeenprovidingtotheNSFandtheirCubeSatteamsincludethefollowing:
•MentoringtoCubeSatdevelopersandsupportofreviewsfromtheWFFengineeringstaff
•UseoflabtestfacilitiessuchasGPSsimulation,antennatestingandvibrationtesting •Interfacingwiththelaunchvehicleprovider
•Groundstationsupportwitha60-footdish.ThisallowstheCubeSattotransmitatupto300timesthetypicaldatarate.
ThereisaRadaratWFFthatisbeingusedasasatellitetelemetrygroundstation.InthepasttheRadarhadbeenusedfortrackingandstudyofreentrywakesintheuppertroposphere.InsupportofCubeSats,theUHFRadarwithitshighgainantennaprovidesagovernment-licensedfrequencyallocationthatenableshighdatarates(3.0Mbit/Sec).Thispresentsahugeimprove-mentoverthe9.6Kbit/sdataratesother-wiseavailable. TheUHFCubeSatgroundstationanswersagrowingneedforhighdataratefromCubeSatsoveragovernmentlicensedfrequency.GovernmentfundedCubeSatsusingamateurradiofre-quenciesmayviolatetheintentoftheamateurradioserviceanditisaviolationofNationalTelecommunicationsInformationAdministration(NTIA)rulesforagovernmentfundedground-stationtouseamateurradiofrequenciestocommunicatewithCubeSats.
NASA GSFC Wallops UHF Groundstation.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 9
ThesuccessandwidecommunitysupportfortheNSFCubeSatProgramcombinedwiththeincreasingnumberofNASAproposalsthatutilizeCubeSatsdemonstratesthematurationoftheCubeSatplatform.
TheprimaryvisionofGSFCWFFistobeanationalresourceenablingresponsivelow-costaerospacescienceandtechnologyresearch. GSFCWFFsupportsthefollowingNASAmissionthemes:
1) Enabling Scientific Research:SupporttheScienceMissionDirectoratebyprovidinglow-cost,highlycapablesuborbitalandorbitalcarriers,missionmanagement,andmissionservicestoenableEarthandspacescienceresearch.
A.Provideresearchcarriersandscienceplatformmissions,includingsoundingrockets,balloons,aircraft,andcarriersfororbitalmissions,andprovidebrokeringservicesforothercarrierssuchasUninhabitedAerialVehicles(UAV’s)andnon-NASAaircraft
B.DevelopnewtechnologiesandapplicationsforWFFcarrierssuchasuseofballoonsforplanetaryandEarthsciencemissions,andsoundingrocketsforplanetaryentry demonstrations
C.Develop,manage,andimplementsmallorbitalsciencemissions
D.ProvidespecializedmissionservicesthroughuseoftheWFFTestRange
E.ConductEarthsciencemeasurementssupportingglobalclimatechangeandcoastalresearch
F.LeadtheapplicationofballoontechnologytoplanetExplorationmissionsasselectedorassigned
2) Enabling Aerospace Technology and Facilitating the Commercial Development of Space:SupporttheAerospaceTechnologyandExplorationbyprovidingadvancedaero-spacetechnologydevelopment,testing,operationalsupport,andfacilitationofthecommerciallaunchindustrytoenablefrequent,safe,andlow-costaccesstospace.
A.ServeasaNASAtestsitefordemonstratingspacelaunchtechnologies
B.Supportdevelopmentadvancedrangetechnologiesthatimprovesafetyandreducelaunchcosts
3) Enabling Education, Outreach, and Innovative Partnerships:SupportotherNASAgoalsandobjectivesbyprovidingscienceandtechnologyeducationandoutreachprogramsinclud-inginnovativepartnershipswithacademia,otherGovernmentagencies,andindustry.
Wallops balloon prepares for launch with payload to search for antimatter and other cosmic particles.
Student team working on their sounding rocket experiment.
10 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
A.Providestudentflightprojectstoteachstudentstheprocessesassociatedwithconductingaerospaceandscientificresearch.
B.Seeknewopportunitiestocollaboratewithregionalcollegesanduniversities,especiallyHistoricallyBlackCollegesandUniversities(HBCU’s).
C.ContinueeffortswithWFFtenantsandregionalgovernmentorganizationstocreatenewbusinessopportunitiesforWFF.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 11
2013
and
Prior
Proje
cts Thispastyearandprioryearstherewerethefollowingresearchprojects:
•RadioAuroraExplorer(RAX-2)–UniversityofMichigan,SRIInternational,see http://rax.engin.umich.edu/ and http://rax.sri.com
•DynamicIonosphereCubeSatExperiment(DICE)–UtahStateUniversity,Embry-RiddleAeronauticalUniversity,ClemsonUniversity,seehttp://www.sdl.usu.edu/programs/dice
•ColoradoStudentSpaceWeatherExperiment(CSSWE)-UniversityofColorado, see http://lasp.colorado.edu/home/csswe
•CubesatforIons,Neutrals,Electrons,MAgneticfields(CINEMA)–UniversityofCalifornia,Berkley,Kyung-HeeU.,ImperialCollege,AppliedPhysicsLab,Inter-AmericanUniversityofPuertoRico,seehttp://newscenter.berkeley.edu/2012/07/31/cinema-among-tiny-cubesats- to-be-launched-aug-2/
•Firefly/Firestation–GSFC,HawkInstituteforSpaceSciences,SienaCollege,FireflyismanifestedtolaunchinNov.2013,seehttp://www.nasa.gov/topics/universe/features/ firefly.html. Firestation launched to the ISS on August 3, 2013, see http://www.nasa.gov/ content/goddard/firestation-to-international-space-station/ •Firebird–MontanaStateUniversity,UniversityofNewHampshire,AerospaceCorporation,manifestedtolaunchinDec.2013,seehttps://ssel.montana.edu/category/cubesat/
GSFC/Naval Research Labs Winds-Ion-NeutralComposition Suite (WINCS) Instrument slated to fly on CADRE.
12 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
RadioAuroraExplorer(RAX) Project Description
Ionosphericplasmaturbulenceoccursinresponsetointensesolarandmagnetosphericforcing.Theturbulenceconsistsofsub-metertodecameter-scaleelectrondensityirregularitiesthatim-pactcommunicationandnavigationsignals,suchasGPS.Asmallmisalignmentofionosphericirregularitiesfromthegeomagneticfieldresultsinwave-generatedparallelelectricfieldsthatdissipatesignificantlymoreenergypermV/mthantheperpendicularelectricfieldsthatareassociatedwithlarge-scaleionosphericconvection.Determiningthemagnetic-aspectsensitivityoftheturbulenceiscritical,notonlyforquantifyingelectronheatingandsubsequentchangesintheplasmachemistry,butalsoforquantifyingthetotalamountofelectromagneticenergyenteringintotheEarth’supperatmosphereduetosolarandmagnetosphericforcing.
RadioAuroraExplorer(RAX)isthefirstCubeSatfundedbytheNSFCubeSat-basedSpaceWeatherprogram.Itsmissionhasbeentorevealthemicro-physicsofionosphericplasmaturbulencebymeasuringAuroralscatterusingaground-to-spacebistaticRadargeome-try.IthasbeenjointlyconductedbySRIInternationalandUniversityofMichigan.Previously,Auroralscatterhasbeenmea-suredusingground-basedcoherentscat-terRadars.However,duetonearverticalmagneticfieldlinegeometryathigh-lat-itudes,ithasbeendifficulttoachievescatterperpendicularity.TheuniqueRa-darscatteringgeometryofaRAXexperiment,composedofatransmitteronthegroundandanorbitingreceiverinspace,enablesunprecedentedhigh-resolutionmeasurements.TwoRAXsatelliteswerelaunched(seepictureofRAX-1andRAX-2satellites).RAX-1waslaunchedinDecember2010,throughSTPfromKodiakAK,toapolarcircularorbit(650km).Thespace-craftwasterminatedduetothemalfunctioningsolarpanels.RAX-2satellitewaslaunchedinOctober2011fromVandenbergAirForceBasetoapolar-ellipticalorbit(400-820km).ThelaunchwasprovidedbyNASA’sEducationalLaunchofNanosatellites(ELaNa)program.
RAX-2completeditsnominal1-yearsciencemissionandproducedauniquedataset,someofwhichhasbeenanalyzedandpublishedinthescientificliterature.DetailsregardingtheRAXmissioncanbefoundontheteamwebsites:http://rax.engin.umich.eduandhttp://rax.sri.com.
Scientific Accomplishments
RAX-2completedmorethan30end-to-endexperimentswiththeAdvancedModularIncoher-entScatterRadar(AMISR)chainofradarsinAlaska,andResoluteBay,Canada.CoherentRadarechoingoccurredduringfourofthepasses:threewhenelectrondriftsexceededtheionacousticvelocitythresholdandoneduringHFheatingoftheionospherebytheHAARPheat-er.Thesmallnumberofdetectionsisexpectedbecauseoftheshortwindow(300s)ofeachexperiment.Nevertheless,thedetectionsspanalargerangeofelectrojetconditions(EXBdriftsfrom700m/sto1600m/s)andthisenabledobservationsofplasmaturbulenceforalargedynamicrangeofmagnetosphericforcing.
RAX-1 and RAX-2 Satellites.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 13
RAX-2hasprovidedthehighestcombinedresolutionforaltitudeandmagneticaspectanglemeasurementsofAuroralelectrojetscatterthusfar.Theaspectanglegraphshowstheexper-imentalgeometryforthepass1017thatcoincidedwiththesolarstormofMarch8,2012.IntheRadarechoesfigure,themappingofRadardataonaltitudeandmagnetic-aspectangleshowsthattheturbulentbackscatterisobservedwhenthespacecraftwascrossingtheloci-of-perpendicularityshownintheaspectanglegraph.Infact,weseethatthescatteringplasmastructuresarealignedwiththemagneticfieldwithinafractionofadegreeandarelocalizedatthealtitudeofapproximately110km.Thisaltitudeisexactlywheremostoftheelectrojet-drivenelectrontemperatureenhancementsweremeasuredpreviously.
Basedonthisandothersetsofcompellingbackscatterevents,RAXdatashowedthatsub-me-ter-scaleirregularitiesintheAuroralEregionaremorestronglyalignedwiththegeomagneticfieldthanpreviouslythought,andtheturbulenceisconfinedtoanarrow(~5km)altituderangecenterednear110km.Thesefindingsareimportantforaccuratemathematicalmodel-ingofEregionplasmaheatingandchemistry.
RAX-2findingssuggestthattheparallelelectricfieldsofsub-meterscalewavespropagatingatlargeranglesfromthemainEXBflowdirection(secondarywaves)aretoosmalltocontrib-utetoEregionelectronheating.Itispossiblethatthedynamicsofthosesub-meterscalewavespropagatingintheEXBdirection(primarywaves)orthedynamicsoflongerwavelengthsexplainanomalouselectronheatingintheAuroralelectrojet.
Technology
TheprojecthelpedadvanceCubeSatandCubeSat-basedpayloadtechnologyformoreeffectiveinstrumentationofthespaceenvironment.Thefirst-timesuccessfuloperationofaUHFreceiverpayloadonaCubeSatisatechnologydemonstrationthatelevatestheTechnologyReadinessLevel(TRL)ofthisparticularpayloadto9.Mostimportantly,thedemonstrationopensthewayforproliferationofsimilarradiopayloadsasdistributedsensorsinspace,enablingmoreeffectivecharacterizationoftheionosphere.EnormousefforthasbeenspenttobuildaCubeSatbusthatwouldsupporttherigidpower,thermal,attitude,andelectromagnet-icinterferencerequirementsofthepayload.RAX-2bussuccessfullymettheexpectationsby
Experimental geometry showing the loci of perpendicularity for scattering at the spacecraft.
Radar echoes mapped to altitude aned magnetic aspect angle/time coordinates for the first (left) and second (2) crossings of the loci perpendicularity. The echoing is observed very close to the 00 contour.
14 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
fulfillingitsnominalmissionlifetime.RAX-2designwillserveabasisforfutureCubeSatdevel-opmentsandthelessonslearnedwillsurelybecarriedforwardtobuildmorerobustones.
Education TheRAXprojectdemonstratedamajoreducationalimpactinthefieldofaerospaceengi-neeringbyengagingalargenumberofstudentsduringthedevelopmentandoperationofthespacecraft(seeFigureofRAXteammembers).Dozensofundergraduateandgraduatestudentsstudiedunderthisprojectandwentontocareersinspacesciencesandaerospaceengineering.SomeofthestudentshavegraduatedandarecurrentlyworkingforNASAonlargerspacecraft.
Publications
Journals
1.Bahcivan,H.,J.W.Cutler,J.C.Springmann,R.Doe,andM.J.Nicolls(2013),Magneticaspectsensitivityofhigh-latitudeEregionirregularitiesmeasuredbytheRAX-2CubeSat, J. Geophys. Res.,inreview,2013.
2.J.C.Springmann,B.P.Kempke,J.W.Cutler,andH.Bahcivan(2013),TimekeepingontheRAXSpacecraft,Acta Astronautica.,inreview,2013.
3.JamesW.Cutler,HasanBahcivan,TheRadioAuroraExplorer–AMissionOverview,AIAA Journal of Spacecraft and Rockets,PublishedonlineJune25,2013,10.2514/1.A32436.
Some of the RAX team members in the Michigan Exploration Labortory (MXL) of Professor James Cutler.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 15
4.SaraC.Spangelo,MatthewW.Bennett,DanielC.Meinzer,AndrewT.Klesh,JessicaA.Arlas,JamesW.Cutler,DesignandImplementationoftheGPSSubsystemfortheRadioAuroraExplorer,Acta Astronautica,Volume87,June-July2013,Pages127-138,ISSN0094-5765,10.1016/j.actaastro.2012.12.009.
5.Bahcivan,H.,J.W.Cutler,M.Bennett,B.Kempke,J.C.Springmann,J.Buonocore,M.Nicolls,andR.Doe(2012),FirstmeasurementsofradarcoherentscatterbytheRadioAuroraExplorerCubeSat,AGU Geophysical Research Letters,39,L14101,10.1029/2012GL052249.
6.J.C.Springmann,A.J.Sloboda,A.T.Klesh,M.W.Bennett,J.W.Cutler,TheattitudedeterminationsystemoftheRAXsatellite,Acta Astronautica,Volume75,June–July2012,Pages120-135,ISSN0094-5765,10.1016/j.actaastro.2012.02.001.
7.J.C.SpringmannandJ.W.Cutler,“Attitude-IndependentMagnetometerCalibrationwithTime-VaryingBias,”AIAA Journal of Guidance, Control, and Dynamics,Volume35,Number4,July–August2012,pages1080-108810.2514/1.56726.
8.H.BahcivanandJ.W.Cutler,“RadioAuroraExplorer:MissionScienceandRadarSystem,” Radio Science,Volume47,Number2,RS2012,10.1029/2011RS004817.
9.H.Bahcivan,M.C.Kelley,andJ.W.Cutler(2009),RadarandrocketcomparisonofUHFradarscatteringfromauroralelectrojetirregularities:Implicationsforananosatelliteradar, J. Geophys. Res.,114,A06309,10.1029/2009JA014132.
ConferencePublications
1.J.C.Springmann,“On-OrbitCalibrationofPhotodiodesforAttitudeDetermination,”AIAA/ USU Small Satellite Conference,Logan,UT,August2013.
2.R.Burton,S.Rock,J.Springmann,J.Cutler,“OnlineAttitudeDeterminationofaPassivelyMagneticallyStabilizedSpacecraft”,Proceedingsofthe23rdAAS/AIAASpaceflightMechanicsMeeting,Kauai,Hawaii,February2013.
3.R.Burton,S.Rock,J.Springmann,J.Cutler,“DualAttitudeandParameterEstimationofPassivelyMagneticallyStabilizedSpacecraft”,Proceedingsofthe63rdInternationalAstronauticalCongress,Naples,Italy,October2012.
4.J.CSpringmann,B.P.Kempke,J.W.Cutler,H.Bahcivan,“InitialFlightResultsoftheRAX-2Satellite”,Proceedingsofthe26thSmallSatelliteConference,Logan,Utah,August2012.
5.J.CSpringmann,B.P.Kempke,J.W.Cutler,H.Bahcivan,“DevelopmentandInitialOperationsoftheRAX-2CubeSat”,The4SSymposium,Portoroz,Slovenia,June2012.
6.J.CSpringmann,J.W.Cutler,“Attitude-IndependentMagnetometerCalibrationwithTime-VaryingBias”,The4SSymposium,Portoroz,Slovenia,June2012.
7.J.ArlasandS.Spangelo,“GPSResultsfortheRadioAuroraExplorer2CubeSatMission,”AIAARegion3StudentConference,AnnArbor,MI,March2012.
8.J.Springmann,J.Cutler,H.Bahcivan,“InitialFlightResultsoftheRadioAuroraExplorer,”Proceedingsofthe62ndInternationalAstronauticalCongress,CapeTown,SouthAfrica,October2011.
16 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
9.J.Cutler,H.Bahcivan,J.Springmann,S.Spangelo,“InitialFlightAssessmentoftheRadioAuroraExplorer“,Proceedingsofthe25thSmallSatelliteConference,Logan,Utah,August2011.
10.J.Springmann,“Attitude-IndependentMagnetometerCalibrationwithTime-VaryingBias,“Proceedingsofthe25thSmallSatelliteConference,Logan,Utah,August2011.
11.J.Springmann,J.Cutler,“InitialAttitudeAnalysisoftheRAXSatellite“,ProceedingsoftheAIAA/AASAstrodynamicsSpecialistConference,Girdwood,Alaska,August2011.
12.GeeyongPark,SherylSeagravesandN.HarrisMcClamroch,“ADynamicModelofaPassiveMagneticAttitudeControlSystemfortheRAXNanosatellite”AIAAGuidance,Navigation,andControlConference,2-5August2010inToronto,Ontario,Canada.
13.S.Spangelo,A.Klesh,andJ.Cutler,“PositionandTimeSystemfortheRAXSmallSatelliteMission,”AIAA/AASAstrodynamicsSpecialistConferenceProceedings,Toronto,Ontario,Canada,August2010.
14.J.Springmann,J.Cutler,H.Bahcivan,“MagneticSensorCalibrationandResidualDipoleCharacterizationforApplicationtoNanosatellites,”AIAA/AASAstrodynamicsSpecialistConferenceProceedings,Toronto,Ontario,Canada,August2010.
15.JamesCutler,MatthewBennett,AndrewKlesh,HasanBahcivan,RickDoe,“TheRadioAuroraExplorer–ABistaticRadarMissiontoMeasureSpaceWeatherPhenomenon,”InProceedingsofSmallSatelliteConference,August2010.
16.Klesh,Andrew,S.Seagraves,M.Bennett,D.Boone,H.Bahcivan,J.Cutler,“DynamicallyDrivenHelmholtzCageforExperimentalMagneticAttitudeDetermination,”AAS/AIAAAstrodynamicsSpecialistConference,09-311,Pittsburgh,PA,2009.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 17
ColoradoStudentSpaceWeatherExperiment
(CSSWE) Project Description
TheColoradoStudentSpaceWeatherExperiment(CSSWE)isa3UCubeSatdesigned,built,andoperatedbystudentsattheUniversityofColorado,Boulder.Itwasinsertedintoalowaltitude,highinclinationorbitonSept132012asasecondarypayloadonanAtlasVthroughtheNASAEducationalLaunchofNano-satellites(ELaNa)program.Thesciencepayload,theRelativisticElectronandPro-tonTelescopeintegratedlittleexperiment(REPTile),aminiaturizedversionoftheREPTinstrumentonboardtheNASA/VanAllenProbes,providesdifferentialmea-surementsofMeVelectronsandprotonstrappedintheradiationbeltsandfromsolarenergeticparticle(SEP)events.Hav-ingcompleteditsnominal90-daysciencemission,CSSWEcontinuestooperateandreturnvaluabledatatoday,almostayearlater.DetailsregardingtheCSSWEmissioncanbefoundontheteamwebsite:http://lasp.colorado.edu/home/csswe/.
Scientific Accomplishments
TheREPTileinstrumentonboardCSSWEhasbeenmakingvaluablemeasurementsofthenear-EarthradiationenvironmentsincethecommissioningperiodwascompletedinearlyOctober2012.TheEnergeticElectronsandProtonsfigureillustratesthemeasurementsrecordedfromthefirst20daysofscienceoperations.Thereareanumberofscientificpapersindevelop-mentusingCSSWEdatatostudythecomplicateddynamicsoftheradiationbelts,includingenergyandpitchangledependenciesofelectronaccelerationandloss.Afulllistofpublicationstodatecanbefoundattheendofthisreport.TheseresultshavealsobeenpresentedatnumerousscientificconferencesincludingtheGeospaceEnvironmentModeling(GEM)workshop2013,MeetingoftheAmericas2013,EuropeanGeophysicalUnion2013,andFallAmeri-canGeophysicalUnion2012.Additionally,papersstudyingREPTiledata,incombinationwith
The CSSWE CubeSat delivered in January 2012 next to its Poly-Picoset OrbitalDeployer (P-POD).
Energetic electron and proton fluxes color-coded by logarithm and organized by spacecraft position in geographic latitude and longitude. MeV protons and electrons from the inner radiation belt are visible as CSSWE files through the South Atlantic Anomaly (SAA) while electrons from the outer radiation belt are . . .
18 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
measurementsfromtheNASA/VanAllenProbesand2013BARRELballooncampaignareinpreparationandsubmittedtotheJournalofGeophysicalResearchandGeophysicalResearchLetters.CSSWEisaprimeexampleofhowsmallinexpensiveCubeSatscanbeusedtocom-plementlargermissionsandgreatlyenhancetheirscientificreturn.
Technology
TherehavealsobeenanumberoftechnologicalachievementsandlessonslearnedfromCSS-WE.ThesewerepresentedattheCubeSatDevelopers’Workshop/SmallSatelliteConferencethispastAugust2013,willbepublishedintheJournalofSmallSatellites,andwerehighlight-edinarecentnewsarticle(http://www.newspacejournal.com/2013/08/11/can-cubesats-do-quality-science-for-one-group-yes/).ContactwithCSSWEwasestablishedonitsfirstpassoverBoulderafterlaunch,andamateurradiooperatorsacrosstheworldhavehelpedtrackanddecodebeacons.On-orbitperformancehasbeeninlinewithexpectationsfrompredictionsandtesting,withinteriortemperatureswithintherangesofthethermalvacuumtestingper-formedbeforedelivery,andthepassivemagneticattitudecontrolsystem(PMACS)convergingtothelocalmagneticfieldwithin~oneweek.Anumberoflessonslearnedhavebeendocu-mentedandpassedontofutureCubeSatmissionsbothattheUniversityofColoradoaswellasotherinstitutions.Theseincludekeepingthedesignandoverallsystemassimpleaspossibletominimizeriskwhilestillmeetingrequirements.Additionally,integratedsystemtestingwascrucialtocharacterizingthesystemperformanceandpreparingforon-orbitresults.
Education
TheCSSWECubeSatwasdesigned,built,tested,delivered,andoperatedbyateamofstu-dentsunderadvisingfromprofessionalsattheUniversityofColoradoandtheLabo-ratoryforAtmosphericandSpacePhysics(LASP)aswellasothersinthecommunity.Over60students,bothgraduateandundergraduate,fromdisciplinesrangingfromelectrical,mechanicalandaerospaceengineeringtoastrophysicsandcomputerscience,workedonCSSWEovertheproj-ectlifetime.TheresultsofthemissionwillbeincorporatedintothedissertationsofthreePhDstudents,twofocusingontheen-ergeticelectronmeasurementsfromREPTileandoneonthepassivemagneticattitudecontrol(PMACS)system.ThesestudentshavepresentedCSSWEworkintheFrankJ.ReddAnnualStudentScholarshipCompetitionheldattheSmallSatelliteConferenceandplacedinthetopthreeforthreedifferentpapers.TheCSSWEteampicturefromSpring2010showstheteamholdinganengineeringmodeloftheREPTileinstrument(frontcenter)wellastheCubeSatoutershell(backrow).Theprojecthasallowedstudentstherareexperiencetobeinvolvedinallstagesofasatellitemissionlifetime,frompreliminarydesignandtestingthroughtooperationsanddataanalysisphases.
CSSWE team in Spring 2010.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 19
Publications
Gerhardt,D.,S.Palo,Q.Schiller,L.Blum,X.Li,andR.Kohnert(submitted),TheColoradoStudentSpaceWeatherExperiment(CSSWE)On-OrbitPerformance,Journal of Small Satellites.
Li,X.,Q.Schiller,L.Blum,S.Califf,H.Zhao,W.Tu,D.Turner,D.Gerhardt,S.Palo,R.Selesnick,S.Kanekal,D.N.Baker,J.Fennell,J.B.Blake,M.Looper,G.D.Reeves,andH.Spence(submit-ted),FirstResultsfromCSSWECubeSat:CharacteristicsofRelativisticElectronsintheNear-EarthEnvironmentDuringtheOctober2012MagneticStorms,Journal of Geophysical Research.
Li,X.,S.Palo,R.Kohnert,L.Blum,D.Gerhardt,Q.Schiller,andS.Callif(2013),SmallMissionAccomplishedbyStudents-BigImpactonSpaceWeatherResearch,Space Weather Journal, 11,doi:10.1002/swe.20025,2013.
Li,X.,S.Palo,R.Kohnert,D.Gerhardt,L.Blum,Q.Schiller,D.Turner,W.Tu,N.Sheiko,andC.S.Cooper(2012),ColoradoStudentSpaceWeatherExperiment:DifferentialfluxmeasurementsofenergeticparticlesinahighlyinclinedlowEarthorbit,inDynamicsoftheEarth’sRadiationBeltsandInnerMagnetosphere,Geophys. Monogr. Ser.,vol.199,editedbyD.Summersetal.,385–404,AGU,Washington,D.C.,doi:10.1029/2012GM001313.
Li,X.,S.Palo,andR.Kohnert(2011),SmallSpaceWeatherResearchMissionDesignedFullybyStudents,Space Weather Journal9,S04006,doi:10.1029/2011SW000668.
LaurenBlum,QuintinSchiller,withadvisorXinlinLi(2012),CharacterizationandTestingofanEnergeticParticleTelescopeforaCubeSatPlatform,26thAnnualAIAA/USUConferenceonSmallSatellites.
ScottPalo,X.Li,D.Gerhardt,D.Turner,R.Kohnert,V.HoxieandS.Batiste(2010),Conduct-ingSciencewithaCubeSat:TheColoradoStudentSpaceWeatherExperiment,24thAnnualAIAA/USUConferenceonSmallSatellites.
QuintinSchiller,AbhishekMahendrakumar,withadvisorXinlinLi(2010),REPTile:AMiniatur-izedDetectorforaCubeSatMissiontoMeasureRelativisticParticlesinNear-EarthSpace,24thAnnualAIAA/USUConferenceonSmallSatellites.
DavidT.GerhardtwithadvisorScottPalo(2010),PassiveMagneticAttitudeControlforCubeSatSpacecraft,24thAnnualAIAA/USUConferenceonSmallSatellites.
Data Archive
Level1sciencedata(electronandprotoncountrates)fromthefirstsixmonthsofthemissionhavebeenmadepubliclyavailableandcanbedownloadedatthefollowingsite:http://lasp.colorado.edu/home/csswe/data/download/.
TheteamisconsideringputtingthedataintheCEDARdatabaseortheVirtualSolarTerrestrialObservatoryasalongtermarchiveaswell.
20 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
DynamicIonosphereC
ubeSatExperiment
(DIC
E) Project Description
FundedbytheNSFCubeSatandNASAELaNaprograms,theDynamicIonosphereCubeSatExperiment(DICE)missionconsistsoftwoidentical1.5UCubeSatsdeployedsimultaneouslyfromasingleP-POD(NASA’sPolyPicosatelliteOrbitalDeployer)intothesameorbit. ThesuccessoftheDICEmissionhasrequiredaverylargeteamofpeople.TheDICEPrinci-palInvestigatorisGeoffCrowley,fromASTRALLC.CharlesSwenson,SpaceDynamicsLab/UtahStateUniversity(USU/SDL),istheDeputyPrincipleInvestigator.ChadFish,USU/SDLandVirginiaTech,istheProgramManagerandascienceCo-Investigator.ScienceteamCo-Inves-tigatorsincludeMarcinPilinskiandIrfanAzeemfromASTRAandArohBarjatyafromEmbryRiddleAeronauticalUniversity.TheprojectleadengineerisTimNeilsen,USU/SDL.ASTRAisleadingthemissionscienceanalysis,withsupportfromUSU/SDLandEmbryRiddle.TheDICEengineeringcomponentwasimplementedatUSU/SDL,withsupportfromASTRAandEmb-ryRiddle.MajorengineeringindustrypartnersincludeL-3Communications,TiNiAerospace,ClydeSpace,ATKAerospace,andPumpkinInc.GPSsimulatortestingoccurredattheNASAGoddardSpaceFlightCenter.MissionoperationsareconductedbyUSU/SDL,incollaborationwithNASAWallopsFlightFacilityandSRIInternational.
Bothsatellitesareexpectedtoremainonorbitforabout15yearsandthegoalwastogetatleastsixmonthsofscientificdatafromthem.EachsatellitecarriestwoLangmuirprobestomeasurein-situionosphericplasmadensities,ascienceandattitudemagnetometers,andelectricfieldprobestomeasureDCandACelectricfields.TheLangmuirProbesarefullyde-ployed,anddatahasbeencollectedfromthemaswellasfromthesciencemagnetometer.InadditiontobeingascientificpathfinderintermsofmeasuringelectricfieldsfromadistributedsetofspacecraftinLEO,theDICECubeSatshaveachievedsciencedatadownlinksunprece-dentedinpreviousCubeSatmissions.DetailsregardingtheDICEmissioncanbefoundontheteamwebsite:http://astraspace.net/research-development/dicecubesat-mission/.
Scientific Accomplishments
ThefollowingisasummaryofmajoraccomplishmentsresultingfromtheDICECubeSatmission:
•Firstin-situSEDobservationsfromasatelliteflyingintheionosphere•FirstdemonstrationofFieldAlignedCurrent(FAC)observationsintheionosphereusingabody-mountedmagnetometeronaCubeSat•Developmentofahigh-speedcommunicationslinkforCubeSatswithunprecedenteddata-ratesforthisclassofspacecraft•FirstCubeSatconstellationfundedspecificallyforscientificpurposes•Nearlytwoyearsofsuccessfuloperationsatthetimeofwriting
TheprimaryscientificaccomplishmentsoftheDICEmissiontodatehavefocusedonthechar-acterizationofStormEnhancedDensities(SEDs)intheionosphere,andthedetectionofFieldAlignedCurrents(FACs)athighlatitudes.TheDICEteamiscurrentlysubmittingseveralre-searchpapersrelatedtothiswork.TheDICEteamalsoworkedwithMillstoneHillandothers
Left: The twin DICE spacecraft, Farkle and Yahtzee. Right: DICE CubeSat showing one of the Langmuir Probes in a deployed position.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 21
toorchestrateseveralIncoherentScatterRadar(ISR)conjunctioncampaignsresult-inginmulti-instrumentobservationsofthetop-sideandbottom-sideionosphere.Datafromthejointionosphericconfigurationmeasurementsiscurrentlybeinganalyzed.
Field Aligned Currents:TheDICEsatellitehasmadethefirstobservationsofmag-neticresidualsattributedtoFAC’susingaCubeSatbody-mountedmagnetometer.ThepresenceofstrongFAC’sinthevicinityofaDICEnorth-polarpasswasconfirmedbybothAMIEandAMPEREandcorre-spondstothemeasured400nTpertur-bationonMay22nd2013(seeAMPEREdBmagnitudeFigure).Whilesignificant,suchFAC’sresultinmagneticperturba-tionswhicharestillonly1%oftheEarth’smagneticfieldmagnitude,makingthemdifficulttodetect.TheDICEbody-mountedmagnetometerisabletodetectsignificantFACevents(>100nT)andthusserveascost-effectivespace-weathermonitors.
Ionospheric Storm Enhanced Densities: A geomagneticactivityonMarch16-17,2013resultedinthegenerationofSEDfeaturesinthenorthernandsouthernhemispheres.ThesouthernhemisphereSEDevolutionwasobservedbytheNSFDICECubeSats.TheDICEplasmaob-servationsfigurecomparesDICEplasmadensitywithIDA4DassimilationofthesouthpolarionosphereandAMIEconvectionpatterns(contours).TheAMIEconvectionpatternssuccessfullylocatedtheduskconvectioncellbyassimilatingdatafromDMSPion-driftmeters,SuperDARNradarsandgroundbasedmagnetometers.TheSEDisshowntomovetowardstheconvection“throat”regionnear14-15LTandisthenconvectedacrossthepoleaspolarcappatches.Thisresultsinahorseshoeshapeplasmaformationinthesouthernpolarcapwhichisobservedasadouble-peakedplasma-densityenhancementbytheDICE-Fsatellite(righthandsideofDICEplasmaobservationsFigure).TheDICEobservationsonMarch17th,2013representthefirstCubeSatobservationsofSED’sandcompleteanimportantscientificobjectiveoftheDICEmission.ThelocaltimeandaltitudecoverageaffordedbyDICErepresentauniqueandcom-plementaryviewrelativetothetopsideobservationsbyDMSPintheeveningsectorathigherlatitudes.Furthermore,thein-situDICEsatellitedataprovidesauniquevalidationofIDA4Dplasmadensitiesinthesouth-polarregion,whichisnormallyconsidereddata-sparse.IDA4DreproducedmanyofthefeaturesassociatedwiththeSEDandobservedbyDICE.
Technology
OneofthemajorchallengesforCubeSatmissionshasbeendownloadingsufficientamountsofengineeringandsciencedatafromthesatellitetotheground.AsaresultoftechnologydevelopedundertheDICEprogram,thetotalon-boardformatteddataacquisitionrateof
Ampere dB magnitude (top) with DICE dB measurements (bottom). The locations of the satellites are indicated with red triangles.
22 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
eachDICEsensor-satis>6.8Kbits/swhenin35Hzsciencemode(11.8Kbits/sin70Hzmode).These downlink rates are much greater (by a factor of 100-200) than those used on previous CubeSat missions.Thetotalamountofhousekeeping,attitudedetermination,andsciencedatademodulatedfrombothsatellitessincelaunchhasbeenapproximately9GBduringthecourseoftheprimarymission.TostoreandforwardtransmitthisdatatothegroundfromtheDICEconstella-tiononadailycadencerequiresanon-boardstorageof~1Gbit/dayandadownlinkrategreaterthan1.5MBits/second(assumesapproximately7-10minutesofoverpassdownlinktimepersensor-satperday).Theon-boardstoragerequirementiswellwithintypicalCubeSattechnologyspecifications.Therefore,incollaborationwithL-3Commu-nications,theDICEteamdevelopedtheCadetUCubeSatradiotoenablehighdownlinkdataratesandtooperateingovernmentassignedandregulatedUHFbandsforbothuplinkanddownlinkcommunications.TheuseofUHFbandsavoidscongestedS-bandoperations,andprovidesbettersignaltonoiselevelsoverthesamecommunicationpath.EachDICEsensor-satcontainsaCadetUradio.CadetUisa6.9x6.9x1.3cmhalf-duplexmodemweighingonly0.07kg,andcapableof9600kbpsuplink(450MHz)and20MBits/sofFECencodeddown-link(460-470MHz).TheDICECadetUradiosdownlinkat3MBits/sasthatismorethanamplebandwidthforthemissiontelemetryneeds.Continuousreceiveoperationsconsume~200mWofpowerontheDICECubesats,whiletransmissionconsumes~9Wofpowertoproduceupto2WofRFoutputpower.
Education
TheDICEprojectinvolvedmajorcontributionsfromitstwograduateandsixundergraduateengineeringstudents.Approximately68%ofDICEfundingforlaborhourssupportedstudentcontributors.Studentswereintegraltotheassembly,integrationandtest(AI&T)process.UponlaunchanddeploymentoftheCubeSats,studentswerealsoinvolvedinperformingday-to-dayoperations,andanalyzingthedatareturnedfromtheDICEinstruments.Studentswerealsoinvolvedintestingdata-recoveryalgorithmsandrecoveringadditionaltelemetryfromtherawtransmittedI/Qdata.ThespecificdutiesofthestudentsincludedDeputyProgramManager,SystemsEngineer,StructuralandThermalAnalysis,MechanicalDesign,ElectricalandComputerAnalysisandDesign,SoftwareDesign,MissionOps,DevelopmentofConceptsofOperations(CONOPS),CommunicationAnalysisandDesign,InstrumentationDesign,AssemblyandTest,andCalibration.
DICE plasma density observations compared with IDA4D assimilation of the south polar ionosphere and AMIE convection patterns (contours). Note that the enhanced densities observed by DICE (red arrows in the bottom plot) correspond to passes through a tongue.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 23
SeveralMaster’sTheseswereconductedduringthecourseoftheDICEprojectandonePhDdissertationiscurrentlyinprogress.ThesedocumentsincludesubjectssuchasElectricFieldBoomDeploymentfromaCubeSatandCubeSatSystemsEngi-neering.TheDICEmissiondesignwasalsothefocusofanumberofcoreclass-esatUtahStateUniversity,includingSpaceEnvironmentsandSatelliteSystemsEngineeringcourses.ThisapproachofintegrationoftheCubeSatmissionsintocoreclassesledtoanothermissionstudythatwasthetechnicalimpetusfortherecentlyawardedNSFOpticalProfilingoftheAtmosphericLimb(OPAL)CubeSatmission. TheDICEengineeringactivitywasimplementedatSpaceDynamicsLab(SDL),enablingdirectinteractionofthestudentcorewithfulltimeprogrammanagementandengineeringprofession-als.ThisinteractionprovidedrealworldaerospaceexperienceandguidancefortheDICEstu-dentteam.ThreeDICEteamstudentshavesinceprogressedtofulltimepositionsatSDLandcontinuetocontributeinkeydesignareasonanumberofSDLassociatedCubeSatprograms,includingtheNSFOPALandLowerAtmosphere/IonosphereCouplingExperiment(LAICE)mis-sionsaswellastheNASAHyperAngularRainbowPolarimeter(HARP)mission. TheDICEstudentcoreengagedindustrypartnersandmanageddevelopmentofkeytechnol-ogyonDICE,includingtheCADETUhighspeedcommunicationsradiofromL-3Communica-tions,theiCASTgroundstationandmissionoperationscontrolcenterwithL-3Communications,andaminiaturizedFrangiboltactuatorfromTiNiAerospace.SubsequentlyanumberofDICEstudentswereinvitedasinternsatL-3Communications,withoneacquiringpermanentemploy-mentwithL-3. Additionally,thestudentsfromDICEarenowactivelysupportingthedevelopmentanden-hancementofL-3CommunicationshighspeedradiosforfutureCubeSatmissions.Thiseffort,whichisledbyDrs.JakeGuntherandCharlesSwensonandrunbystudents,isexecutedoutoftheSDLCubeSatmissionoperationsandhighspeedcommunicationscenterwhichwasdevel-opedonDICE.
Publications
Barjatya,A.,M.Pilinski,C.Swenson,C.Fish,G.Crowley,TheLangmuirProbeInstrumentontheDICECubeSat,inpreparation,Journal of Geophysical Research,2013.
Crowley,G.,C.Fish,C.Swenson,R.Burt,T.Neilsen,A.Barjatya,G.Bust,M.LarsenDynamicIonosphereCubesatExperiment(DICE),SSC10-III-7,ProceedingsoftheSmallSatelliteConference,Logan,UT,August,2010. Crowley,G.,C.Fish,C.Swenson,R.Burt,E.Stromberg,T.Neilsen,S.Burr,A.Barjatya,G.Bust,andM.Larsen,DynamicIonosphereCubesatExperiment(DICE),SSC11-XII-6,ProceedingsoftheSmallSatelliteConference,Logan,UT,August,2011.
DICE student team with professional advisors in January 2010.
24 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
Crowley,G.,M.Pilinski,C.Swenson,C.Fish,A.Barjatya,I.Azeem,etal.,ModelingandObservationsOfStormEnhancedDensitiesintheIonosphereDuringTheMarch17th,2013GeomagneticStorm,inprepara-tion,SpaceWeatherJournal,2013.
Crowley,G.,M.Pilinski,C.Swenson,C.Fish,A.Barjatya,I.Azeem,etal.,IonosphericResponsetoGeomagneticActivityduringMarch2013,in preparation,JournalofGeophysicalResearch,2013.
C.S.Fish,C.M.Swenson,G.Crowley,A.Barjatya,T.Neilsen,J.Gunther,I.Azeem,M.Pilinski,R.Wilder,J.Cook,J.Nelsen,R.Burt5,M.Whiteley,B.Bingham,G.Hansen,S.Wassom,K.Davis,S.Jensen5,P.Patterson,Q.Young,J.Petersen,S.Schaire,C.R.Davis,M.Bokaie,R.Fullmer,R.Baktur,J.Sojka,M.Cousins,Design,Development,Implemen-tation,andOnorbitPerformanceoftheDynamicIonosphereCubeSatExperimentMission,manuscriptinsubmission,SpaceScienceReviews,2013.
Fish,C.,C.Swenson,T.Neilsen,B.Bingham,J.Gunther,E.Stromberg,S.Burr,R.Burt,M.White-ly,G.Crowley,I.Azeem,M.Pilinski,A.Barjatya,andJ.Petersen,DICEMissionDesign,Devel-opment,andImplementations:SuccessandChallenges,SSC12-XI-1,26thAnnualAIAA/USUConferenceonSmallSatellites,2012.
Jandak,M.,R.Fullmer,AnExtendedKalmanSmootherfortheDICEMissionAttitudeDetermi-nationPostProcessingwithDoubleElectricalFieldProbeInclusion,2011,AAS11-598.
Neilsenetal.,TheDICESatelliteCommunications(Specificsofimplementinghigh-speedcom-municationsontheDICECubeSats),manuscriptinpreparation,2013.
Pilinski,M.,G.Crowley,C.Swenson,C.Fish,A.Barjatya,I.Azeem,etal.,Field-AlignedCurrentObservationsusingtheDynamicIonosphereCubeSatExperiment(DICE)BodyMountedMag-netometer,inpreparation,JournalofGeophysicalResearch,2013.
Ryan,K.,R.Fullmer,S.Wassom,ExperimentalTestingoftheAccuracyofAttitudeDetermina-tionSolutionsforSpin-StabilizedSpacecraft,2011,AAS11-599.
Swensonetal.,DICECommunicationsSystemOverview,manuscriptinpreparation,2013.
Data Archive
TheDICEsciencedatawillbemadepubliclyavailableonlinebyASTRALLCandwillbehostedontheASTRAwebsite.ThefollowingisasummaryofDICEdataproductswhichwillbemadeavailableinnetcdfandASCIIformats.TheL1productsincludeplasmadensities,plasmatemperatures,andmagneticresidualsandwillbemadeavailablewitharesolutionofap-proximately1degreelatitude.TheL0dataproductswillbemadeavailableatacadenceof30Hz.DocumentationwillbeprovidedontheASTRAwebsitewhichdescribesthedatapro-cessing.
The Mission Operations Center (MOC) is run by students at USU/SDL.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 25
•LangmuirProbeDataoDCLangmuirProbe•L0probedata•Dateandtime,Counts,latitude,longitude,altitude,spacecrafttemperature,IRIdensityandtemperature,IDA4Ddensityandtemperature•L1normalizedplasmadensities•Dateandtime,Juliandate,Density,latitude,longitude,altitude,IRIdensitiesandtemperatures,IDA4Ddensities
oSweepingLangmuirProbe•L0sweepdata•Dateandtime,Juliandate,Sweepvectorincounts,appliedvoltagevector,latitude,longitude,altitude,instrumenttemperature,IRIdensityandtemperatures,IDA4D densities•L1sweepdata•Dateandtime,body-to-inertialframequaternion,Juliandate,IonDensity,ElectronDensity,PlasmaTemperature,latitude,longitude, altitude,IRIdensitiesandtemperatures,IDA4Ddensities
•MagnetometerDataoBody-MountedMagnetometer•L0magnetometerdata•Dateandtime,magnetometervectorinbodyreferenceframe,latitude,longitude,altitude,IGRFvectoringeodeticreferenceframe•L1magnetometerdata•Dateandtime,magneticresidualvectoringeodeticreferenceframe,latitude,longitude,altitude,IGRFvectoringeodeticreferenceframe
26 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
FireflyandFirestation
Firefly, a milk-carton-sized satellite, will study gamma-ray bursts that accompany lightning. Credit: Zina Deretsky, National Science Foundation.
Project Description
Lightningdischargesrepresentthereleaseofenormousamountsofenergyandareassociat-edwithfamiliarandpowerfulmanifestationsneartheEarth’ssurface:thunder,abrightflash,andpowerfulcurrentsthatcanshattertreesandturnsandtoglass.Lightninggivesriseto
x-rayandgamma-raybursts,andunlikethewell-knownflashesoflightandclapsofthunder,theseenergeticraysarechanneledupwardandcanbedetectedonlyfromspace.ACubeSatmission,calledFirefly,sponsoredbytheNationalScienceFoundation,willexploretherela-tionshipbetweenlightningandtheseburstsofradiationcalledTerrestrialGammaRayFlashes(TGFs).FireflydemonstratesthecapabilityofsmallmissionssuchasCubeSatstodoimportant,focusedscience,withabundantstudentinvolvement,andwithaminimalbudgetandavailableresources.TheFireflyFigureshowsacartoonoftheprocessesinvolvedinTGFgeneration. Scientific Accomplishments
TGFswerefirstdiscoveredbytheComptonGammaRayObservatoryinthemid-1990s.Sincetheirdiscovery,theRHESSI,Fermi,andAGILEsatelliteshaveconvincinglytiedtheseeventstolightningdischarges,demonstratedthatthegammarayemissionsextenduptomillionsofelec-tronvolts,andshownindirectevidenceforenergeticelectronsandpositronsthatcanescapetheEarth’satmosphereandbemagneticallytrappedintheVanAllenradiationbelts.TheseelectronsaregeneratedbysecondaryinteractionsoftheTGFgammaswiththeupperatmo-sphere.However,noneofthesepreviousmissionswerededicatedtothestudyofTGFsandenergeticelectronsgeneratedbythunderstorms.FireflyisthefirstdedicatedmissiontostudyTGFs,theirlinktolightning,andtheireffectinproducingenergeticelectronsthatmaybecomestablytrappedintheinnerradiationbelt.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 27
TGFsareofinherentinterest,astheyresultfromthemostpowerfulnaturalparticleaccelera-tionprocessonEarth,inwhichthermalelectronsareenergizedtotensofmillionsofvoltsinlessthanonemillisecond.BystudyingTGFs,wecanlearnfundamentalphysicscriticalinunder-standingnotonlylight-ning,butalsosolarflares,cosmicshocks,blackholes,andevenduststormsonMars. Fireflyisasmallsatellite(3.6kg,10x10x34cm),thatwasdesigned,built,andtestedaspartofthisNSFgrant.TheFireflyteamiscollaborationbetweenSienaCollegeandNASA.Studentsatalllevels(grade-schooltocollege)areinvolvedinallaspectsoftheproject,fromdesignanddevelopmenttomissionoperationsanddataanalysis.
InadditiontoFirefly,arelatedmissioncalledFireStationhasbeeninstalledaspartoftheSTP-H4platformontheInternationalSpaceSta-tion(ISS).FireStationreliesheavilyonexistingflightexperiencefromtheNSF-fundedFireflyCubeSatmission,withsomemodificationstointerfaceandsensors.FireStationconsistsof:
1)Asensitiveminiaturizedradioreceiver,withonboardFFTcapability,VLFsearchcoilandVLF-MF(100Hzto30MHz)electricantenna.Theradioreceiverhassmartonboardprocessing,utilizinganewLEONinFPGAdesignindependentlydevelopedbyGSFCoverthelastyear.2)Anovelphoswichenergeticradiationdetector,basedonanultrafastinorganicscintillator(GYSO:Ce),capableofdeadtimesshorterthan1µsforhighcountrateapplications.ThisdetectorrepresentsthefirstflightofGYSO:Ce,whichissimilartoBGO,butprovidesamuchfasterresponsetime,andhasaveryhighradiationtolerance.Thephoswich designofourenergeticradiationdetectoralsopermitsdiscriminationbetweenenergeticphotons(X-andgamma-rays)andenergeticelectronsinthe100keVto5MeVenergyrange.
3)Amulti-channelphotometersystem,includingmulti-wavelengthfiltersandhighspeedreadouts,providingaccuratelocalizationoflightningflashes,aswellasaccuratetimingathighresolution,andmulti-wavelengthobservation.
Technology
ThegravitygradientboomprovidesattitudestabilizationforFireflyaswellasasensitiveVLFantenna.Earlydeploymenttestingin2011validateddesignbutresultedinsomeneedfor
Inside the body of the Firefly CubeSat is the Gamma-Ray Detector (GRD). On the nadir side of the satellite are four photometers to optically detect lightning. Each photometer is angled slightly to obtain a general direction vector. The CubeSat is also equipped with a Very-Low Frequency (VLF) detector. Previous studies have shown correlation between ground-based VLF-detectors and TGFs.
28 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
reworkofgearing,etc.ReworkandtestingoftheGGBwasaccomplishedin2013.Theinstru-mentcontrollerFieldProgrammableGateArray(FPGA)wasdevelopedtosupportFirestationin2012/2013andthenmodifiedfortheFireflyCubeSatin2013.Itconnectstheinstrumenttotheflightsoftwareandflightcomputer. Education
BothFireflyandFirestationhavehelpedtrainundergraduatesatSiena,obtaininghands-onexperiencedesigning,building,testing,andwilltrainstudentsonoperatingthespacecraft,aswellasanalyzingthedata. SpecificcourseandtutorialsatSienaCol-legerelatedtoFireStationinclude:•OrbitalDynamics•SatelliteDesignandEngineering•SpacecraftInstrumentation•STKCertification
StudentsatSienaCollegeworkedonand/orstarteddevelopmentofthefollowing:
1)ExperimentExpansionModules,FFT,Filterbank,advancedtriggeringmechanisms2)AWESOMEVLFReceiverDevelop-ment,Ground-basedVLFsupport3)GSE,MATLABInstrumentControlToolbox4)Instrumentmodeling,Opticalphotodiodecollimatoroptimization5)DataProcessingandAnalysis6)LEGOFireflyMissionDevelopment7)GeographicInformationSystem,Worldwidelightningnetwork8)STK,SatelliteToolkitOrbitDevelopment
Firestation International Space Station Experiment.
Firestation being placed on the ISS.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 29
AGU Student Presentations
•AE33B-0306.FireflyandFireStation:MissionstoStudyTerrestrialGamma-rayFlashes,KevinA.Melsert;LindsayE.McTague;NguyenTruong;JackSneeringer;JoshuaDeJoy;JosephT.Kujawski;DouglasE.Rowland;AllanT.Weatherwax
•SA31A-1958.Anovelself-localizationprotocolforspacecraftclusters,ThaddeusSavery;GrazianoVernizzi;JosephT.Kujawski;RiccardoBevilacqua;AllanT.Weatherwax
Other Presentations
•Firefly:UnderstandingEarth’smostPowerfulParticleAccelerator,byA.T.Weatherwaxetal.,FallMeetingoftheAstronomicalSocietyofNewYork,October25,2009.
•TheFireflyCubeSatMission,DougRowlandetal.,DartmouthCollegePlasmaSeminarSeries,April14,2009.
•TheFireflyCubeSatMission,DougRowlandetal.,CubeSatDevelopers’Workshop,CalPoly,SanLuisObispo,April22-25,2009.
•TheFireflyCubeSatMission,A.T.Weatherwaxetal.,CEDARCubeSatWorkshop,2009.
•TheLinkBetweenLightningandTerrestrialGammaRayFlashes,BillWanamaker(highschoolstudent)etal.,MAStateScienceFairFinalsatMIT,May2009.
•Firefly:AnNSFCubeSatMissiontoUnderstandEarth’sMostPowerfulNaturalElectronAcceleratorbyAllanWeatherwax(SienaCollege)andtheFireflyTeam,UnionCollegePhysicsSeminarSeries,September17,2009.
•TheNSFFireflyCubesat:Progressandstatus,Rowland,D.E.,Weatherwax,A.T.,Klenzing,J.H.,Hill,J,AGUFallMeeting2009,abstract#SM42A-07
•FIREFLY:ACubeSatmissiontostudyterrestrialgamma-rayflashes,Authors:Klenzing,J.H.,Rowland,D.E.,Hill,J.,Weatherwax,A.T.,AmericanGeophysicalUnion,FallMeeting2009, abstract #SM33C-1577.
Students on Firefly and Firestation were involved in all aspects of spacecraft design and operation.
30 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
Student Profiles
JoshDejoyworkedonFireflyandFirestationaspartofahighschoolhonorsprogramforgiftedandtalentedstudents.JoshcompetedintheGreaterCapitalRegionScienceandEngineeringFairatRPIandwonseveralawards.HewasalsoinvitedtocompeteintheNationalAmericanMeteorologicalScienceFair.JoshgraduatedNewPaltzhighschoolfirstinhisclassinJune2013andiscurrentlyaphysicsmajoratGeneseoCollegeinNewYork.
JackSneeringerworkedonFireflyandFirestationaspartoftheShakerHighSchoolResearchprogram.HecompetedinnumerousNewYorksciencefairswherehewontheWal-terEppensteinAstronomy/PhysicsAwardandtheAmericanMeteorologicalSocietyAwardforhiseffortsonprelimi-naryFireflydataanalysis.HeiscurrentlyacomputerscienceandphysicsmajoratColgateUniversity.
JenniferWilliamsgraduatedwitha3.73GPAinphysicsatSienaCollegeandiscurrentlyworkingonherPh.D.inopticsatBostonUniversityandherO.D.attheNewEnglandCollegeofOptometry.RobertCarroll,graduatewitha3.82GPAasaphysicsmajorandisworkingonaPh.D.inengineeringattheCollegeofNanoscaleScienceandEngineering.RobertCarrollwasstudentleadonthelightningphoto-detectordesign.Aprimarytaskwastocalculatethefieldofviewofthephoto-detectorandtheoverlapfunction.Minimumandmaximumfieldofviewwerecalculatedbasedonthegeometryofthephotodetectorandcollimator.Asundergraduates,theywereco-authorsonthepaperentitled,TheNSFFireflyCubeSatmission:Ridesharemissiontostudyenergeticelec-tronsproducedbylightning,Aerospace,IEEEdoi:10.1109AERO.2011.5747231.
UndergraduatephysicsmajorJohnDeMatteoleadtheorbitalmechanicseffort.Johnwasenrolledintheindepen-dentstudycourseentitled“OrbitalMechanics”,underthesupervisionofProfessorAllanWeatherwax.InMay,2010,JohnbecamecertifiedontheSatelliteTookKit(STK)soft-warepackagefromAnalyticalGraphics,Inc.
LindsayMcTaguegraduatedSienaCollegeinMay2013withaB.Sinphysicsandminorsinmathematicsandcomputerscience.AtSiena,LindsayworkedonbothFireflyandFirestation
High School student Josh Dejoy displays the CubeSat frame in the Siena Space Sciences Lab.
Jennifer Williams (left) and Robert Carroll are shown testing an early prototype of Firefly’s photometer experiment.
Jack Sneeringer worked on Firefly and Firestation.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 31
withsupportfromtheNSF.LindsayprimarilyworkedontheopticalandmechanicaldesignoftheFireflyandFirestationphotometerboards.ShelearnedSolidWorksandMatlabaspartofresearchstudiesandhelpedconstructtheinterfacebracketforthephotome-terinstrumentthatwasrecentlydeployedontheInternationalSpaceStation.Inaddition,aspartofherseniorindependentstudyprojectentitled,SpaceMissionDesignEngineering&Operations,shebecameSatelliteToolKit(STK)certifiedandworkedonorbitalanalysisscenar-iosforbothmissions.LindsayiscurrentlyenrolledatDukeUniversitywheresheispursuingaPh.D.degreeinelectricalengineering.
Publications
•Rowland,D.,A.T.Weatherwax,etal.(2011),TheNSFFireflyCubeSatmission:Ridesharemissiontostudyenergeticelectronsproducedbylightning,Aerospace,IEEEdoi:10.1109AERO.2011.5747231.
Lindsay speaking at the NSF CubeSat panel.
(Left) Lindsay building Firefly in the Space Sciences Lab at Siena College. (middle) The photo-optical board that Lindsay helped design and build. (right) Firefly ready for launch!
The Firestation photodiode and optical assembly developed for the International Space Station. Undergraduate student Lindsay McTague was the lead on the mechanical design of this instrument.
32 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
CubesatforIons,Neutrals,Electronsand
MAgneticfields(CIN
EMA) Project Description
TheCubesatforIons,Neu-trals,ElectronsandMAgneticfields,orCINEMA,isa3UspacecraftbuiltbystudentsattheSpaceSciencesLabo-ratory(SSL)attheUniversityofCaliforniaBerkeley(UCB).CINEMAcarriestwoexcit-ingnewscienceinstruments,oneofwhichwasdevelopedexplicitlyforthisproject.TheSupra-Thermal,Electrons,IonsandNeutrals(STEIN)detectorisa32-pixelsilicondetectorwitharemarkable2-4keVenergythresholdandpeakenergyrangeof200keV.STEINusesthesamethinwindowtechnologythatUCBpioneeredfortheSTEREO-STEinstrument,butcombinesitwithanewlydevelopedASIC,providedbyCEA-Sa-clay(TheFrenchAtomicEnergyAgency)toexpandfrom4channelsto32whilereducingthepowerandvolumetothepointwhereinclusioninaCubeSatbecamefeasible.CINEMAalsocarriesMAGIC,amagnetoresistivemagnetometerthatwasprovidedbyImperialCollege-Lon-don.Ithaspairedinboard-outboardsensors,thesecondplacedonadeployed1-meterstac-erboomdesignedatBerkeley.Thisinstrumentisalsoremarkablysensitive(~nT)withdevelop-mentdrivenbytheneedtobelowmassandlowpower.TheMAGICsensorheadis~1cm^3andweighs10g.TheCINEMAprojectwasextendedtofourspacecraftofroughlyequivalentdesignthroughcollaborationwithKyung-HeeUniversity(KHU)ofSeoul,Korea.KHUhasbuilttwoadditionalcopiesoftheCINEMAspacecraftandUCBhasaddedafourthcopywithadditionalfundingfromNSFandAirForceresearchLabs.Together,MAGICandSTEINaredesignedtoprovidehighsciencequalityobservationsoftheearth’sringcurrent,precipitatingchargedparticlesandthemagneticfieldinitsorbit. Scientific Accomplishments
CINEMAhasbeenoperatingsinceitslaunchinSeptember2012,butscienceoperationsareonlynowrampingup.Twotechnicalissueswiththespacecraftbushavenecessitatedsignif-icantinvestigativeeffortandworkarounds.Asaresult,afterayearonorbit,theinboardandoutboardMAGICsensorscannowsuccessfullybeoperated,andtheoperationsteamisworkingtoturnontheSTEINinstrumentshortly.ThecontinuingeffortsoftheCINEMAteamonthefirstspacecraftbusonorbithaveallowedkeydesignchangestobedetermined,prog-ressthatwillbeinvaluableastheupcominglaunchofCINEMA2and3approachesaswellasthefourthcopy.Thefirstissueiscommanduplinkreliabilityinthefewpercentrange.ThisappearstobeprimarilyinterferencebetweentheUHFreceiveronboardandotherspace-craftsystems.However,wehaveincreasedtheantennagainweuseonourgroundstationandmodifiedouroperationsmodesuchthatwehaverecentlybeengettingsignificantlyhighercommandthroughput.Thisprovidesapathtoresolvethesecondissue,involvingalockupoftheprimarydatastorageSDcard.Thisissueisharder,ascardreads/writesweretestedthoroughlyonthegroundbothbeforelaunchandontheengineeringmodelpostlaunch,withnosuccessinrecreatingtheissueinthelab.Workaroundsforsmallvolumesofdatahavebeendevelopedtoallowcommandedsciencedatacollectionandtheseshowinitialsuccess.Thesecondthroughfourth‘copies’ofCINEMAhaveimprovedsoftwarereliability,significantlybetteruplinkmarginandothersmallerrevisionstotheoriginal’sdesign.
The CINEMA spacecraft showing the MAGIC sensor and 1m stacer boom.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 33
Technology
TheCINEMAinstrumentpayloadshaveattractedsignificantattention.Inadditiontothemulti-plefuturecopiesofCINEMAthatareinthepipeline(KHUlaunchesitspairofCubeSatslate2013),MAGIChasbeenadaptedforinclusioninotherCubeSatsandSTEINhasbeenadaptedintoaninstrumentthatisslatedtobelaunchedontheEuropeanSpaceAgency’sSolarOrbitermission.Detectorsthataremorehighlymodifiedhavebeenproposedforsciencear-easasfarrangingasun-derstandinglunarsurfacefeaturesandshockacceleratedplasmasatthesun.CINEMAadditionallybrokenewgroundfordataratesonaCubeSat,utilizingtheexistingS-bandinfrastructurefordownlinkavail-ableatBerkeley.CINEMA’sdevelopmentandoperationalhurdleshaveprovedinstructiveaswell,withnumerouslessonslearnedinthemanagementanddevelopmentofsuchacomplex,multi-institution,multi-spacecraftproject.SomeoftheselessonslearnedhavebeenpresentedattheCubesatDevelopers’Workshop,andallarebeingappliedtothefollowonCINEMACubeSats,potentialfutureCubeSatsatUCB,partnerinstitutions,andhopefully,throughouttheCubeSatcommunity.InparticulartheimportanceofhandlingstudentlaborandstudentturnoveronsuchalargeprojectwasrecognizedearlyanddocumentationrequirementswereimplementedthatmadeCINEMA’slateryearsrunfarmoresmoothlythanitsearlyones.Thecomplexityofthesystemalsodemandedmoresystemleveltestingthanwasscheduledorcosted,partlybecauseSTEINwassuchalargeinstrumentdevelopmenteffortandtooktimefromthoroughspacecraftsystemsleveltesting.Thatsaid,CINEMAisaremark-ableCubeSateffort.
Education
CINEMAinvolved24undergraduatestudentsatUCB,fourmaster’slevelstudentsandonePhDcandidate.Thesystemswereprimarilydesignedandimplementedbythestudentworkforce.Ourfouracademicpartnerinstitutionsemployedmorethanthe16studentswhovisitedBerkeleytohelpwithvariousaspectsofthedevelopmentandtakethoselessonsbacktotheirowninstitu-tions.Atleast10oftheUCBCINEMAstudentshavegoneontoearlypositionsinaerospaceengineering.ApictureoftheCINEMAteamsfromsuccessivesummersisincluded.
The CINEMA student teams from Summer 2010 and 2011.
The CINEMA student teams from Summer 2010 and 2011.
34 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
FocusedInvestigationsofRelativisticElectron
Burst,Intensity,Range,anDynamics(FIREBIRD) Project Description
Themissionatargeted,goal-directed,spaceweatherCubesatmissiontoresolvethespatialscalesizeandenergydependenceofelectronmicroburstsintheVanAllenradiationbelts.Rel-ativisticelectronmicroburstsappearasshortdurationsofintenseelectronprecipitationmea-suredbyparticledetectorsonlowaltitudespacecraft,seenwhentheirorbitscrossmagneticfieldlineswhichthreadtheouterradiationbelt.Previousspacecraftmis-sions(e.g.,SAMPEX)havequantifiedimportantaspectsofmicroburstproperties(e.g.,occurrenceprobabilities),however,somecrucialproperties(i.e.,spatialscale)remainelusiveowingtothespace-timeambiguityinher-enttosinglespacecraftmissions.Whilemicroburstsarethoughttobeasignificantlossmechanismforrelativisticelectrons,theyremainpoorlyunderstood,thusrenderingspaceweathermodelsofEarth’sradiationbeltsincom-plete.
Scientific Accomplishments
TheFIREBIRD1CubeSatislaunchinginDecember,2013onNROL-39.Itwasdelivered,integratedintotheP-POD,integratedintotheNavalPostgraduateSchoolCubeSatLauncher(NPSCuL),attachedtotheCentaurLaunchVehicle(LV)upperstage,andstackedonthepadinSeptember,2013.TheFIREBIRD2CubeSatismanifest-edtolaunchonaDeltaIIfromVandenberginOctober,2014,andwillbedeliveredinJuly,2014.
Anengineeringdevelopmentunit(EDU)andtwoflightunitsweredeveloped,andtested.TestingoftheFIREBIRDinstrumentatAerospaceCorporationbracketedthefullwidthathalf-maximum(FWHM)oftheelectronbeam.InMarch,2013,theEDUpassedaproto-qualificationvibrationtestwithamasssimulator.InApril,2013,FIREBIRDwaspresentedataMissionRead-inessReview.INMay,2013,theFIREBIRDinstrumentwassuccessfullycalibratedatAerospaceCorporation. Education
FIREBIRDhasprovideduniqueopportunitiesforgraduatestudentsatMontanaStateUniversityandtheUniversityofNewHampshireforhands-oneducation.OnesuchstudentisAlexCrew.Crew,aPh.D.candidateintheSpaceScienceCenter,attheUniversityofNewHampshireIn-stitutefortheStudyofEarth,Oceans,andSpace(EOS),hasspentthreeworkingonFIREBIRD.CrewpresentedaposteronFIREBIRDataNSFworkshopinArlington,VA.HejoinedCubeSatprojectscientists,engineers,educators,andstudentsfromaroundthecountrytoexplorehowCubeSatprojectscanenablescientificdiscoveriesandengineeringinnovationandplayama-jorroleinhelpingsolvecriticalsocietalproblemsrelatedto,forexample,climatechangeandspaceweather.Seehttp://www.eos.unh.edu/Spheres_0812/firebird.shtml.
FIREBIRD CubeSat.
Beam Testing of FIREBIRD Instrument.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 35
Alex Crew holds FIREBIRD’s full-size engineering unit, which contains twin particle detectors. The boxy struc-ture to Crew’s left is a copy of the miniscule FIREBIRD spacecraft. Photo by David Sims, UNH-EOS.
2014 PROJECTS
Thefollowingeightprojectsareplannedtocontinueorbeginin2014:
•CubesatforIons,Neutrals,Electrons,MAgneticfields(CINEMA)–UniversityofCalifornia,Berkley,Kyung-HeeU.,ImperialCollege,AppliedPhysicsLab,Inter-AmericanUniversityofPuertoRico,seehttp://newscenter.berkeley. edu/2012/07/31/cinema-among- tiny-cubesats-to-be-launched-aug-2/.
•Firefly/Firestation–GSFC,HawkInstituteforSpaceSciences,SienaCollege,FireflyismanifestedtolaunchinNov.2013,see http://www.nasa.gov/topics/universe/ features/firefly.html.FirestationlaunchedtotheISSonAugust3,2013,seehttp:// www.nasa.gov/content/goddard/ firestation-to-international-space-station/.
•Firebird–MontanaStateUniversity,UniversityofNewHampshire,AerospaceCorporation,manifestedtolaunchinDec.2013,seehttps://ssel.montana.edu/category/ cubesat/.
•CompositionVariationsintheExosphere,Thermosphere,andTopsideIonosphere(EXOCUBE)–ScientificSolutionsInc.,CalPoly,UniversityofWisconsin,GSFC,scheduledforlaunchinOctober2014,seehttp://www.sci-sol.com/Exocube-Oct2011.pdf.
•CubeSatinvestigatingAtmosphericDensityResponsetoExtremedriving(CADRE)–UniversityofMichigan,NavalResearchLabs,manifestedonanAtlasV,forlaunchinOct.,2014,seehttp://exploration.engin.umich.edu/blog/?page_id=961.
•OxygenPhotometryoftheAtmosphericLimb(OPAL)–UtahStateUniversity,UniversityofMaryland,EasternShore(UMES),HawkInstituteforSpaceSciences,DixieStateCollegeofUtah.
•QB50/QBUS–VonKarmanInstitute(VKI)ofBelgium,EuropeanUnion(EU),see https://www.qb50.eu/index.php/requirements-and-reviews/pdr-submission.
•LowerAtmosphere-IonosphereCouplingExperiment(LAICE)–VirginiaTech,UniversityofIllinois,Urbana,TheAerospaceCorporation,ColoradoResearchAssociates, see http://www.space.vt.edu/news/articles/RockSat-X_Payload.html.
36 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
OxygenPhotometryoftheAtmosphericLimb
(OPA
L) Project Description
TheOxygenPhotometryoftheAtmosphericLimb(OPAL)missionconsistsofone3UCubeSatthatisdesignedtounderstandthethermospherictemperaturesignalsofthedynamicsolar,geomagnetic,andinternalatmosphericforcing.Thismissioncanbeaddressedbyremotesensingofthealtitudetemperaturefromtheatmosphericlimbfromamid-tohigh-inclinationorbit(>50°)thusprovidingdaytimeobservationsofthemid-andlow-latitudes.OPAL’steamcombinesstudents,advisors,andprofessionalsfromUtahStateUniversity/SpaceDynamicsLaboratory,UniversityofMarylandEasternShore,HawkInstitutedforSpaceSciences,andDixieStateCollegetopromotethetrainingofthenextgenerationofengineersandscientists.
Planned Scientific Accomplishments
TheOPALtemperaturemeasurementsinthelowerthermosphere,andthescientificstudiesthatcanbeconductedwiththem,arehighlyrelevanttogoalsoftheNa-tionalSpaceWeatherProgram(NSWP),andtotheNSF-sponsoredcommunity-wideCoupling,EnergeticsandDynamicsofAtmosphericRegionsprogram.OneofthemaingoalsoftheNSWPis“tomitigatetheadverseeffectsofspaceweatherbyprovidingtimely,accurate,andreliablespaceenvironmentspecifications.”Thelowerthermosphereisanimportantelementinthisprogrambecauseofitsinterfacebetweenthelowerandupperatmospherewithvariableso-larforcingfromaboveanddynamicalwavecouplingfrombelow.SomeofthetasksthatarerequiredtoaccomplishtheprimarygoaloftheNSWPincludethedevelopmentofasuiteofsensorstoprovidethenecessaryobservations,thedevelopmentofdataanalysisalgorithms,andscientificstudiesofspaceweatherphenomena.OPALaddressestheseelements.
TheOPALinstrumentisahighresolutionimagingspectrometerthatsimultaneouslycollectsspatially-resolvedA-bandspectrainmultipleazimuthaldirectionsandacrossthefullaltituderangeofA-bandemission.Asthetemperatureincreases,therelativeintensityoftheRbranch(759-762nm)increasesandshiftstoshorterwavelengthwhilethePbranch(762-770nm)widensandshiftstolongerwavelength.Thus,theneutraltemperature(Tn)canbeestimatedfromthequalitativeshapeoftheA-band.
Overthenextyear,theteamwillcompletethesystemrequirementsreview,finalizetheradio-metricmodel,completeaPreliminaryDesignReview(PDR),anddeveloptheengineeringunit.
Planned Technology
Thesatellitebuswillincorporateanumberofuniquefeatures:
A.Thesatellitewillpointatthelimbtowithinafewfractionsofadegreeandmakelowerthermospherictemperaturemeasurements
OPAL instrument viewing the earth limb.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 37
B.ThesatellitewillusethenextgenerationhighspeedCADETradiolinkthatwillbesupportedprimarilybytheNASAWFFUHFstationandsecondarilybytheDoDMC3 stations
C.ThesatellitebusisaCOLONY2bus
Planned Education
About12studentswillbeinvolvedfromUtahState,UniversityofMarylandEasternShore,andDIXIEState(inUtah).Theywillsupportdevelopmentoftheprograminallareas,includingsci-ence,instrumentdevelopment,missionoperations,testandcalibration,andon-orbitoperations.
38 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
Project Description
QB50isaninternationalnetworkof50CubeSatsformulti-point,in-situmeasurementsinthelargely-unexploredlowerthermosphereandre-entryresearch.LedbytheVonKarmanInsti-tute(VKI)ofBelgium,theQB50projectisexpectedtobepredominantlyfundedfromtheFP7GrantbytheEuropeanUnion(EU).However,afundinggapexists,whichistobecoveredbytheNationalScienceFoundation.
QBUSeffortsbeganinearnestin2011andreceivedplanningsupportfromtheNationalScienceFoundation.Consortiummemberscoalescedaroundacommonarchitectureanddesignphilosophyfrombroadcommunityengagementduring2011andmemberintuitionsprovidedsignificantfeedbackanddesigneffortsduringregularworkshopsandtelecoms.
InAprilof2012,theconsortiumsubmittedaproposaltoparticipateinQB50forconsiderationtoVKI.QBUSwasnotifiedthatuponreviewtheproposalwasamongthetopofanyproposinggroupfromamong70+proposalsrepresentingmorethan25countries.
InMayof2012,theconsortiumsubmittedaproposaltotheNationalScienceFoundationtohelpsupportthescientificinvestigationsandbroaderimpactsenabledbyQB50participation.FundingfromNSFbeganinOctober2013.ThemoneyfromNSFallowedconsortiumstudentteamstobeginbuildingandtestingtheCubeSatbuses.ThisalsoallowedteamstopurchaseIon-NeutralMassSpectrometer(INMS)instrumentsfromtheMullardSpaceScienceLaboratory(MSSL). Planned Scientific Accomplishments
All50CubeSatswillbelaunchedtogetherinApril2015intoacircularorbitat320kmalti-tude,inclination79º.Duetoatmosphericdrag,theorbitswilldecayandtheCubeSatswillbeabletoexplorealllayersofthelowerthermospherewithouttheneedforon-boardpropul-sion,downto90or100km,dependingonthequalityoftheirthermaldesign.ItisexpectedthatthenetworkwillspreadaroundtheEarthwithinamonthbydeployingonlyoneCubeSatduringeachorbit.ThelifetimeoftheCubeSatsfromdeploymentuntilatmospherere-entrywillbelessthanthreemonths.
TheQBUSteamwillbuildfouridentical2UCubeSatflightunits,withparticipatingmembersprovidingtheusualsatellitefunctions(attitudedeterminationandcontrol,uplinkanddown-linktelecommunications,powersubsystemincludingabatteryandbody-mountedsolarcells,on-boarddatahandlingandstoragebyaCPU).TheQBUSteamhasselectedtheMullardSpaceScienceLaboratory(MSSL)Ion-NeutralMassSpectrometer(INMS)sensorfromthethreeQB50options.EachuniversityontheQBUSteamwillprovideaflightunitwiththeintegratedpayloadsprovidedbyQB50,whichwillbedeliveredtoDraperLaboratoryforfinaltesting,checkoutandITARcompliantshipment.Furthermore,QBUSwillprocureadditionalcomponentsforqualificationandtestingduringthebuildphase,providingadditionalriskmitigation,spareparts,andloweredcosts(5+componentpricesaresignificantlylower).TestinganddeliverywillbecommensuratewiththespecifiedQB50timeline.
Thisfirst-of-a-kindthermosphericconstellationofCubeSatswillallowtheinvestigationofthetransitionregionbetween100–300km.Thisareaoftheatmosphererangesbetweenwellmixed,neutrallydominatedforcingandheavilyionized,electricallydominatedforcing.Thechangefrompressuregradientdrivenresponsestoelectricfielddrivendynamicsprovidesa
QB50/QBUS
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 39
sourcetermformomentumandenergytransferthatishighlydynamicandoftenunpredictable.Thisleadstouncertaintyinthebehaviorofdensity,winds,andtemperaturesofboththeionsandtheneutrals.Thereisalsoalackofunderstandingofatmosphericcompositioninthisre-gionduetoscarcityofmeasurementsaswelltheinfluenceofbackgroundparameters,chemis-try,andforcingfromthelowerthermosphere. TheINMSoneachofthefourQBUSCubeSatscanuncovernewinformationaboutthecompo-sitionandvariabilityofthelowerthermosphere.Whencombinedwiththefullsuiteofinstru-mentationintheQB50constellation,boththeionizedandneutralstateparametersoftheatmosphere/ionosphere,itsvariability,response,andinterconnectionscanbeuncovered.Inadditiontocuriosity-drivensciencethataimstodeterminethegoverningphysicsoftheregion,theQB50missionwillalsoprovideapracticalapplicationformeasurementsrelatedtosat-ellitedrag.InatimewhensatellitepresenceinLEOcontinuestoexpandandde-orbitingsat-elliteshavebecomemorecommon,itisimportanttobeabletopredictwherethesesatellitesmightre-entertheatmospheretoensurehumansafety.Thisrequiresbettercharacterizationofthelowerthermosphericmassdensityandwinds.
Further,thelowerthermosphereandionospherearehighlydynamic,withauroral,solarandtidalinputsallmixingtogether.Thismeansthatitiscrucialtohavemultipointmeasurementsifwearetounderstandhowthesystemevolvesovertime.Theconstellationapproach,bothwith-intheconsortiumandacrosstheinstrumentsuitesontheQB50CubeSats,willprovideanewsetoftransformativemeasurementsthatwillleadtoanenhancedunderstandingoftheregionaswellasnewpredictivecapabilities.
Planned Technology
Eachofthe2UCubeSatsforQBUSwillhaveaUniversityofMichigan(UM)structurewithtwodeployedsolarpanelstoform“wings”,allowingmoresolarenergytobecollect-ed,asshowninthefigure.Thetwofunda-mentalrequirementsoftheQB50satellitesaretoflytheinstrumentpackagefacingintheramdirectionandtominimizethedragtoallowforlongerlifetime.Therefore,theQBUSCubeSatswillbeflownwiththeinstrumentpointedintoramandthe“top”rotatedinsuchawaytomaximizesolarcollection,allowingustomaximizetheop-erationtheinstrumentsineachorbit.EachoftheproposedQBUSCubeSatsisde-signedtocarryanINMSpackage.CommunicationwiththegroundwilloccurviaaLithiumUHFradio,whichhasflownonmanyoftheNSFmissions.ThepowersystemwillbethepreviouslyflownUniversityofMichigan(UM)designedsystem(blendoftheRAX,RAX-2andM-CubedEPSsystems).Theon-boardcomputerwillbetheMSP430,whichhasflownonawidevarietyofmissions,andhasalargesoftwarebasedesignedforitfromUMandUniversityofColora-do(CU).Theattitudedeterminationandcontrolsystem(ADCS)willbeamagnetictorquerodonlysystemwithheritagefromUM(throughCADRE)ortheMAI-QB50singlewheelsystem.TheUMsystemisbaselined,buttheviabilityoftheMAI-QB50willbeinvestigatedintermsofcost,massandcomplexitybythepreliminarydesignreview(PDR).
QBUS Cubesat cut-away layout.
40 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
Planned Education
Currently,QBUS(QB50US)isaconsortiumofsevenUSinstitutions(threeresearchuniversities,oneHispanicminorityundergraduateuniversityandtwonationallaboratories,and1smallbusiness)allwithsignificantCubeSatandscienceexperience.
QBUSenablesstudents’scienceandhands-onengineeringexperiencewithinaUniversity/Laboratoryconsortiumexpandingaccesstoparticipationandprovidesvaluableprofessionalcontacts.Thegoalistohaveover200participatingstudents.Thiswillincludealargenumberofunrepresentedgrounds,suchasHispanicstudentsfromaminorityservingundergraduateinstitutionsinPuertoRico.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 41
LowerAtmosphere/IonosphereCoupling
Experiment(LAIC
E) Project Description
LAICEisalowEarthorbit(LEO)CubeSatmissionfocusedonunderstandinghowwavesgener-atedbyweathersystemsintheloweratmospherepropagateanddeliverenergyandmo-mentumintothemesosphere,lowerthermosphere,andionosphere(MLTI).Thesewavesareavitallyimportantbutunder-exploredfacetofatmosphericphysics.Theystronglyinfluencethedynamicsofthemediathroughwhichtheytravelbymodifyingthestructureoftheatmosphereataltitudeswellabovetheirsourceregions,andtheymayseedthedevelopmentofplasmainstabilitiesthatscintillateanddisruptradiopropagation.Ourexperimentwillbethefirstglobalsatelliteinvestigationtofocusentirelyonthesewaves,andtoattempttoconnecttheircausesandeffectsinthreewidelydifferentaltituderanges.In-situinstrumentationaboardLAICEwillmeasuretheperturbationsthewavesproduceinbothneutralandionden-sitiesatF-regionheights,whileon-boardphotometerswillsimultaneouslymeasurethewavelengthsandamplitudesofthewavefieldsintheuppermesosphere.Subsequentmodelingcoupledwithmeteorologicaldatawillrevealtheconnectionsbetweentropo-sphericstormsandtheMLTIsystemusingstate-of-the-artraytracingtechniquesthatincludetheeffectsofwavedissipation.
Planned Scientific Accomplishments
ThepreferredorbitforLAICEiscircularat375-400kmaltitude,ataninclinationnear45degrees.Thisorbitwillallowthesystemto:
1. Systematically observe gravity waveswithlargeverticalwavelengthsatlowerF-regionheights,andcorrelateonaglobalscaleremotely-sensedwave-inducedairglowperturbationsintheuppermesospherewithin-situmeasurementsofionandneutraldensityfluctuationsathigheraltitudes;
2. Produce global maps of active gravity wave re-gionsinthemid-andlow-latitudeionosphereovermultipleseasonsatalllocaltimes,sothatglobalpatternsandclimatologicalvariationscanbequantitativelycomparedtoandcorrelatedwithterrestrialweathersystemsviaray-tracemodeling.
TheLAICEprojectwasfundedearlyinthesummerof2013,sotodatetheteamhascarriedoutdesignworkontheinstrumentationandflightsoftware.Somehardwarehasbeenfabricat-ed(seetheRetardingPotentialAnalyzer(RPA)figure),andschematicshavebeengeneratedfortheinstrumentationsystems.Testingoftheflightsoftwarehasbegunusingsimulateddatastreams.TheUIandVTteamsholdweeklytelecomstofostercollaborativedesigneffortsbetweenthegroups.
LAICE in Orbit.
Retarding Potential Analyzer for the LAICE system.
42 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
TheLAICEinorbitfigureshowsacartoonviewoftheLAICEsystemtoprovideabetterunder-standingoftheoverallconfiguration.
Planned Technology
Thisisthefirst6UCubeSatfundedbyNSF,anditincludes3distinctinstruments.Oneoftheinstruments(SpacePressureSensor)comprisesatechnologydemonstrationcomponentutilizingcoldfieldemittersasaspace-basedionizationsource.ThebusfortheLAICEsatelliteincludestheILLINI-2buswhichincludesmagnetictorqueforattitudecontrolusingcoilsimbeddedinflexcircuits.AmechanicalstructureusingarailassemblyprovidesasimplifiedassemblyandexpandstovariousCubeSatdimensions.Thesolarpanelsubstratesareacarbonepoxyforlowmassconsiderations.BothaCadetRadio(460-470MHz)whichwaswelltestedonthetwoDICEspacecraftandanamateurbandradio(437MHz)areplannedforcommunication.TheamateurbandradioincludesauniquemodemusingaDigitalSignalProcessing(DSP)micro-processor.
Planned Education
Fromtheeducationalstandpoint,VTdoesnothaveaspecificcoursebuiltaroundtheLAICEproject,butelementsoftheLAICEdesignwillbeaccomplishedthroughaseniordesigncourse.Inadditiontothis,variouselementsoftheLAICEprojectareformingthebasisforgraduatethesisandprojectwork(M.Engineeringdegree).FiveVTgraduatestudentsareutilizingLAICEdesigneffortstosatisfytheirresearch/designdegreerequirements,andthreeundergradu-atesareassistingintheseefforts.
TheplannededucationalelementsatUIincludethedirectinvolvementofElectricalandAeroEngineeringstudentsinaSeniorDesignclassnamed‘Cubesat’.TheLAICEsatellitedevelop-mentactivitiesintheclasslaboratorywillinvolvetheLAICEsatellitedevelopmentandtesting.Itisestimatedthat15studentswillbeintheclass.A5-6experiencestudentteamwillcontinuesoftwaredevelopmentforthebus(3students)and2-3otherswillworkhardwareandtesting.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 43
CubesatforIons,Neutrals,Electronsand
MAgneticfields(CIN
EMA) Project Description
TheCubesatforIons,Neutrals,ElectronsandMAgneticfields,orCINEMA,isa3UspacecraftbuiltbystudentsattheSpaceSciencesLaboratory(SSL)attheUniversityofCaliforniaBerke-ley(UCB).CINEMAhasoneoperatingspacecraftandisscheduledtobecomeafoursatelliteconstellationmissionwiththeultimategoalofimagingtheEarth’sdynamicringcurrentthroughremotesensingofEnergeticNeutralAtoms(ENAs).ENAsrepresentauniquewaytoremotesenseenergeticplasmapopulationsandCINEMApushestheinstrumentationtostudytheseparticlesfrom4keVtohundredsofkeVintoremarkablysmallpackages.CINEMA-2and-3areslatedtobelaunchedbycollaboratinginstitutionsinFall,2013andthe4thcopyisplannedforlaunchinmid-2014.TheseadditionalcopiesoftheCubeSathavesolvednumer-ousoperationalissuesfoundinthefirstCINEMAandexpectationsforgoodsciencereturnarehigh.
Planned Scientific Accomplishments
CINEMAhopestobecomethefirstCubeSatmissionwithfouroperating3UCubeSatsimagingtheEarth’sringcurrentfrommultipleperspectives.Theconstellationofsatelliteswillmakeco-ordinatedmeasurementsandwillcomplementnicelywiththeinsitumeasurementsbeingmadebylargersatellites,suchasthetwosatelliteVanAllenProbes,andthemultisatelliteTHEMISmission.CINEMA’ssensitiveSTEINinstrumentwithmultipleviewingangleshasthecapabilitytomakethehighesttimeresolutionimagesofinjectionsintotheearth’sringcurrentandstudytheearlytimeprofileofringcurrentgrowthacrossalllocaltimes.Softwaretointegratethemulti-pleviewinganglesintoimprovedspatialinformationisunderdevelopmentandshouldprovideatoolforadditionalfutureringcurrentENAobservations.
Planned Technology
LessonslearnedfromCINEMA1arebeingincorporatedintoCINEMA2,3and4spacecraftwillbesharedwithotherteamsthroughthemonthlyNSFPrincipalInvestigator(PI)teleconfer-ences.
44 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
CompositionVariationsintheExosphere,
Thermosphere,andTopsideIonosphere(EXOCUBE) Project Description
TheExoCubesatelliteisbeingdevelopedbyScientificSolutions,NASAGoddard,CaliforniaPolytechnicStateUniversity,UniversityofWisconsinandUniversityofIllinois.Theprimarymissionofthesatelliteistomeasure[O],[H],[He],[O+],[H+],[He+]overthepolesandoverincoherentscatterradar(ISR)groundstations.DatafromthesatelliteandtheISRstationswillbecompared.
ExoCubeisonELaNa-XSMAP,–scheduledforlaunchinOctober2014.Theorbitwillbeap-proximately400x670kmaltitudeand98°inclinationwithanexpectedorbitallifetimeofeightyears.Expectedminimummissionlifewillbesixmonths.ThefiguresbelowshowExoCubeanditsorientationinorbitandtheexpectedoverpassesofgroundbasedobservingsites.
Planned Scientific Accomplishments
TheExoCubemissionisdesignedtoacquireglobalknowledgeofthein-situdensitiesof[O],[H],[He],[O+],[H+],[He+]intheupperionosphereandlowerexosphere,usingagatedtime-of-flightspectrometer.Atomicoxygenandheliumhavenotbeenmeasuredinsitusincetheearly1980sduringtheeraoftheDynamicsExplorerandthenonlyfor18months.Atomichydrogenhasneverbeendirectlymeasuredinsituinthisregion.Byprovidingbenchmarkmea-surementsoverArecibo,Wisconsin,KittPeak,andCerroTololo,ExoCubeaidsinthevalidationandinter-comparisonofground-basedobservationsfromthesesitesusingpassiveopticalin-terferometryandphotometryofneutralairglowemissionsaswellasactiveISRtocharacterizethelocalionosphere.
ExoCubedensitymeasurementswillbeusedtocharacterizetheclimatologyoftheupperion-osphericandlowerexosphericcomposition.Thecombinationoforbitalinclinationandpreces-sionwillenablearobustassessmentofdiurnaldensityandcompositionvariations,whiletheexpectedminimumsix-monthmissionlifetimewillfacilitatecomparisonsbetweenequinoxandsolsticeconditions.Keyscientificobjectivesincludeinvestigationofupperatmosphericglobal,diurnal,andseasonalvariability,chargeexchangeprocesses,atmosphericresponsetogeo-magneticstorms,andvalidationofempiricalandclimatologicalatmosphericmodels(e.g.MSIS,TIE-GCM).ExoCubemeasurementsofin-situneutralhydrogenalsohelpconstrainretrievalsof
Left: ExoCube orientation on-orbit. Right: With updated orbital parameters, ExoCube’s observatory overpasses can be predicted for timing coincident ground based airglow observations.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 45
aeronomicalpa-rametersofinterestfromairglowobser-vationsandforwardradiativetransfermodeling.
Aground-basedremotesensingobservationofthefluorescentBalmerαcolumnemissionfromatomichydro-genisoneoftheprimarymethodsforstudyingthehydro-gendistributionintheupperthermosphereandexosphere.Thesemeasurementsaresensitivenotonlytothermosphericandexosphericatomichydrogendensity,butalsotothesolarexci-tationfluxandradiativetransfer,includingmultiplescatteringofthesolarLymanβexcitationradiationbelowtheEarth’sshadow.Geophysicalquantitiesareretrievedbyreconcilingtheseobservationswithforwardmodelpredictionsbasedonspecificationofamodelhydrogendis-tributionfunctionandcalculationofradiationtransport(RT)toaccountforthesignificantmulti-plescatteringinthegeocorona.ExoCubemeasurementsofin-situhydrogendensitieswithnearcoincidentground-basedBalmerαwillprovideanindependentconstrainttotheseretrievalsofthehydrogendensityprofileandflux.
ChargeexchangeprocessesinvolvingH,O,H+,andO+,areimportantforsustainingnight-timeF-regionionosphericdensityaswellasforgoverningthermalequilibriumandnon-equi-libriumatmosphericescapeprocesses.Theequationsgoverningsuchprocesses(theprotoncontinuityequationandtheO+momentumandenergybalanceequations)requireaccuratespecificationofrelevantspeciesdensitiesinordertoisolatekeychargeexchangecollisionalcrosssectionsastheonlyfreeparameters.Sincetheseratecoefficientsarenotwellcharac-terizedbylaboratorymeasurements,theExoCubeconstraintswillthusenablemoreaccuratedeterminationoftheratecoefficientsandhenceretrievalofthebothOandHdensityfrompastandfutureground-basedobservations.
ExoCubein-situobservationswillprovideadatasetthatcanbeusedforvalidationofbothempiricalandclimatemodels.ThermospherichydrogendensitiesintheempiricalNRLMSISE-00modelarederivedfromchargeexchangeequilibriumanalysesofAtmosphericExplorersat-ellitesimultaneousobservationsofH+,O+,andO.Comparisonsofground-basedhydrogenemissionobservationswithMSISindicatediscrepancies.ExoCubein-situmeasurements[H],[O],and[He]willbecomparedwithMSISatdifferentlatitudesandduringdifferentdiurnalandseasonalconditions.SimilarlyExoCubein-situmeasurementsofneutraldensitieswillprovidearesourceforvalidationofclimatemodelssuchastheThermosphere-Ionosphere-Meso-sphere-EnergeticsGlobal-Circulation-Model(TIME-GCM)andthethermosphericextensionoftheWholeAtmosphereCommunityClimateModel(WACCM).Insitumeasurementsofhydro-genwillalsohelpvalidatetheupperboundaryconditionsforhydrogenchemistryandcompo-sitionincludedinthesemodels.
LEFT: an STK model of ExoCube orbits passing over ground based sites. RIGHT: a view of ExoCube passing over ground based observatories; the red circles are the field-of-view of the ground based instruments at the nominal orbital altitude.
46 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
Planned TechnologyEnvironmental Chamber
TheEnvironmentalChamberisthehousingforthetwoscientificinstruments,aminiaturizedmassspectrometerandanionsensor.Itisdesignedtosecuretheinstrumentsandprovidetheneces-saryconditionsforaccuratedatacollection.Thechamberincorporatesthefollowingfeatures:
•ShapeMemoryAlloyWireActuators •Allowforthecontrolledreleaseofhatchescoveringinletports •AdjustableCheckValve •UsedtofillthechamberwithSulfurHexaflouride(SF6) •Providesunidirectionalflow •UmbrellaValves •Sealthechamberuntilspecifiedpressuredifferentialisreached •ServeasexhaustportsfortheSulfurHexaflouride •SiliconeO-RingGaskets •Maintainpositivepressureinthechamber •Providealow-outgassingsealAttitude Determination Control System (ADCS)
Toachieveaccuratemeasurements,therearepointingandorientationrequirementsforthemission.ThesatellitemustmaintainaNadirpointingof+/-10degreesandaramknowledgeof+/-5degrees.Tomaintaintheserequirements,anattitudedeterminationcontrolsystem(ADCS)wasdevelopedbyPolySatandintegratedonthesatellite.Thecontrolsystemhasthefollowingcomponents:
•GravityGradientsystemwithdeployablebooms oProvidespassivecontrolofthesystemwithnopower oHelpsmaintainpointingandrateofchangeofthesatellitewithADCS turnedoff oProvidesstabilityduringmomentumwheelspinup oBoomsdevelopedin-house •SinclairMomentumWheel o10-mNmmomentumwheel oOrientatedonpitchaxistoproviderigidityandstabilityofpointing oCouplesrollandyawaxestogethertoprovidegyroscopicstability •KalmanFilter oCalculatesorientationbasedonSGP4propagator,solararray measurements,andmagnetometers oFiltersoutnoisefromsensors,actuators,andothersystemdisturbances toachieveaccurateorientation oAcquireinitialorientationusingTRIADalgorithm oStaysonfordurationofmission oWorksforeccentricities<.1andrates<10degrees/second •PDcontroller oPDcontrollawdevelopedbyBongWieforagravitygradientADCS oChosenforsimplicityandpowerefficiency oProvenglobalstabilitybyBongWie
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 47
•SensorsandActuators oMagnetometersforreadingmagneticfield oSolararraysensorsforcalculatingorientationinreferencetothesun oMagnetorquers,designedbyPolySat,fortorqueingandcontrollingthe satellite oGyroscopeforverificationofrates •Z-panelcamera oOmnivision3Megapixelcamerawith25degreefieldofview oOnbothz-panels oUsedforverificationofboomdeployment oCancalculateratesandorientationofsatellitewithseveralsuccessive pictures oDerivativeimagingscalestheimagesdowntomakedownloadfrom satellitequickerandeasier oCamerasweretestedonCP8balloonlaunchandareonCP8whichis scheduledforlaunchattheendof2013 Planned Education
Anewremotesensinginstrument(SpatialHeterodyneSpectrometer)forBalmer-al-phaairglowmeasurements(coincidentwithin-situExoCubedensitymeasure-ments)hasveryrecentlybeeninstalledatPineBluffObservatoryandiscurrent-lybeingfieldtested.SHSintensityandsensitivitycalibrationsarebeingconduct-ednowbyUWMadisongraduatestu-dentDerekGardneraspartofhisPh.D.dissertationwork.ThisSHSisexpectedtobefullyoperationalbynextsummerandwillbeoneofseveralopticalinstrumentscontributingtothecoordinatedgroundbasedcampaignobservationeffortsoftheExoCubemission.
Senior Projects
•KyleTeixeiraandMelodyGolobic(Submitted),PolysatExoCubeEnvironmental ChamberDesignandTesting.
•BrianGilbertTubb(2012),RadioLinkAnalysisandCharacterizationofPastand FutureCalPolyCubeSats. http://digitalcommons.calpoly.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1195&context=eesp
•BlakeSimon(2013),ExoCubeStructure.
•DominicBurtillino(2013),ImplementingaMATLABBasedAttitudeDetermination AlgorithminCwithinthePolySatSoftwareArchitecture. http://digitalcommons.calpoly.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1080&context=cpesp
Proposed Kalman filter for ExoCube.
48 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
•MattZimmerer(2013),LeoNano-SatelliteClockSynchronizationSoftware. http://digitalcommons.calpoly.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1107&context=cpesp
Master Thesis
•RyanSellers(2012),AGravityGradient,Momentum-BiasedAttitudeControlSystem foraCubeSat. http://digitalcommons.calpoly.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2057&context=theses
•ArashMehrparvar(InProgress),KalmanFilterDesignandAttitudeDesign. •AustinWilliams(InProgress),Compact,ReconfigurableUHFCommunicationSystem forusewithPolySat’sEmbeddedLinuxPlatform.
•SeanFitzsimmons(2012),ReliableSoftwareUpdatesforOn-orbitCubeSatSatellites. http://digitalcommons.calpoly.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1849&context=theses
High School Balloon Launches
CalPolyhasbeendoinganoutreachprogramwithlocalhighschoolsforthelastthreeyears.Thehighschoolstudentsparticipateintheprogramoversummeronthecollegecampus.Thestudentsbrainstormprojectideasandmissiongoalsforapayloadonahighaltitudeballoon.TheCalPolystudentsteachtheprocessforatypicalmissionfromproposaltoflight.ThehighschoolstudentsthenfollowasimilarprocessfortheirpayloadastheCalPolystudentsassist.Payloadstypicallyincludeacameracontrolledbyamicrocontrolleralongwithenvironmentalsensors.CalPolyfacilitiesareusedbythestudentstohelpcreatetheirpayload.TheballoonistrackedwithamateurradioequipmentandaGPStransmittingtoAPRSstationsforlivetracking.ThestudentsandtheCalPolyteamthentracktheballoonasitascendsanddescendswithaparachute.See http://digitalcommons.calpoly.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=3945&con-text=pao_pr.
The CalPoly ExoCube team!
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 49
CubesatinvestigatingAtmospheric
DensityResponsetoExtremedriving(CADRE) Project Description
TheCubesatinvestigatingAtmosphericDensityResponsetoExtremedriving(CADRE)isa3UCubeSatdesignedandbuiltbyundergraduateandMaster’s-levelsstudentsattheUniversityofMichigan(UM).ThescientificgoalofCADREistostudyhowtheauroradepositsenergyintotheupperatmosphereandhowtheatmosphererespondstothatenergyintermsofwaves,windsandcompositionalchanges.CADREwillbelaunchedinlate2014onanAtlasVthroughtheNASAEducationalLaunchofNanosatellites(ELaNa)programintoahighinclinationorbitsothatitcanviewtheauroraonmostorbits.ThesciencepayloadofCADREistheWindIonNeutralCompositionSuite(WINCS),whichwillmeasurethethermosphericandion-osphericdensity,temperature,windsandcompositionusingfourelectrostaticanalyz-ers(ESAs)andtwomassspectrometers.
Planned Scientific Accomplishments
CADREisaimingforaone-yearsciencemission.TheESAswillbemountedinpairs,withonepairmountedperpendiculartotheotherpair.ThiswillallowWINCStomeasurethehorizontalandverticalcross-trackwinds.TheESAwillmeasurethebulkenergyoftheflow,whichwillallowthethirdcomponent(thein-trackwind)tobederived.Oneofeachpairwillmeasuretheionflowswhiletheotherwillmeasuretheneutralflows.Inordertogetthemea-surementsrequiredforthewinds,CADREwillhavetohavethree-axisstabilitytoonedegreeofcontroland0.1degreeofknowledge.Thismeansthatthreereactionwheelswillfly,astartrackerandtwofinesunsensors.
TheUniversityofMichiganhaslaunchedthreeCubeSatsintoorbit-RAX,RAX-2andM-Cubed.RAXandM-Cubedweresomewhatdifferentdesigns,withtheM-Cubedstudentsbeingessentiallyindependentofanyrealfacultyadviseforthedesignphaseofthemission,whiletheRAXstudentswerebeingledbyJamesCutler.TheteamhasrecentlydeliveredM-Cubed-2,whichisahybriddesignbe-tweenRAXandM-Cubed.CADREisusingsignificanttechnologythathasbeencreatedforM-Cubed-2’savionicspackage.
Planned Technology
M-Cubed-2wasdeliveredinJuly,2013.CADREwilluseM-Cubed-2’sCommandandDataHandlingboard,whichisbasedonamicroprocessorrunningLinux.TheElectricandPower
CADRE Exploring the Ionosphere.
CADRE Spacecraft Deployed.
50 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
System(EPS)fromM-Cubed-2workedprettywell,butitwasquitenoisy,sotheteamisinves-tigatingahybridbetweentheM-Cubed-2andRAXEPS.Thisshouldonlytakeamonthortwotocreate.Thebasicdesignofthestructureiscompleted,withthedeployablepanelandhingedesignsnearlycomplete.Theteamhascreatedmassmodelsforeachofthemostexpensivepartstoallowustoshakethestructuretolimitsofthelaunchvehicle.TheUHFbeaconiscom-pletedandwillbemountedontheCDHboard.TheWINCSpayloadisbeingmanufactured;withtheWINCSinterfaceboardbeingdeliveredtoUMinSeptember,2013.
TheteamhasbeenworkingonmanytechnologicalinnovationsforCADRE.Forexample,theS-Bandradioisnew.ThereareveryfewS-BandradiosinaCubeSatformfactorthatcanreachspeedsof1Mbps(Mega-bit-per-second).Theteamisdevelopingonebecauseitwasfeltthatbuyinganexistingonewouldrequirealmostasmuchworkasbuildingone(interfac-ing,modulation,etc.).Fortheattitudedetermi-nationandcontrolsystem,CADREismostlyusingoff-the-shelfparts,butassemblingtheentireunitwithcustomsoftware.APh.D.studenthasbeenworkingonthealgorithmsforthis,anditwasfeltthatpurchasingacompletepackagewouldnotallowtheflexibilityofsoftwarethatbuildingonewouldoffer.
Planned Education
ThetwolargestsubsystemsthatneedworkaretheS-Bandradio,whichisbeingbuiltalmostexclu-sivelybythestudents.Anexperiencedstudentdidmostofthedesignworkontheradiooverthelastyear,butgraduatedinApril.Heiscontinuingtohelpwiththeradio,butremotely.Thestudentswhoareworkingonitnowarelearningasfastastheycanandaredebuggingproblemsthatarise.TheAttitudeDeterminationandControlSystem(ADCS)ismadeupofsensors(startracker,finesunsensors,rategyrosandamagnetometer)aswellasactua-tors(reactionwheelsandmagnetictorquerods).
Thereisagroupofstudentswhoareworkingoneachofthedifferentcomponents.Twoofthestudentsarecreatinganelectricaldesignoftheentiresystemandareclosetobread-boardingitup.Theyhaveflownsomeofthesensors(magnetom-eterandgyros)onballoonflights.Thewheelshavebeenorderedanddelivered.Astudenthasveri-fiedthattheycangetthewheelstospin.Softwaredrivershavebeenwrittenformanyofthedevices.Inaddition,aKalmanfilterhasbeenwrittentodeterminetheorientationofthesatellitegiventhesensorinputs.Further,acontrolalgorithmhasbeenimplementedtodrivetheactuators.Thiscombinationoforientationandcontrolsoftwareworktogetherandhavebeentestedonvariousplatformsusingsyntheticdata.TheteamisworkingonportingthisovertoaplatformthatwillbeconsistentwiththeADCSprocessor.
CADREisbeingdesigned,builtandtestedbystudentsattheundergraduateandMaster’slevelattheUniversityofMichigan.Over50studentsattheselevelsareworkingonCADRE
CADRE 3-U Housing and Preliminary Design.
CADRE Main Components.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 51
throughdifferentclassprojects(Aerospaceseniordesign,andvariousAtmospheric,OceanicandSpaceSciences-AOSS-designclasses)andduringthesummerthroughpaid“internships”.ThevastmajorityofthestudentsareAero-spaceengineeringstudents,buttherearealsomanyMechanicalandElectricalEngineeringstudents.TheMaster’sstudentsareallMas-ter’sinSpaceSystemsEngineeringAOSSstudents.
TherehavebeentwoPh.D.stu-dentswhohaveworkedonCADRE,namelyworkingonthedesignoftheADCSalgorithmsanddeterminingthenumberofsolarcellsonthebodyanddeployedpanels.WehaveanewPh.D.studentwhohasjuststartedinSeptember2013.
Publications
J.T.Hwang,D.Y.Lee,J.W.Cutler,andJ.R.R.A.Martins,“Large-ScaleMDOofaSmallSatelliteusingaNovelFrameworkfortheSolutionofCoupledSystemsandtheirDerivatives“,Proceed-ingsofthe54thAIAA/ASME/ASCE/AHS/ASCStructures,StructuralDynamics,andMaterialsConference,Boston,MA,April2013.
D.Y.LeeandJ.W.Cutler,“DesignoptimizationofaSolarPanelAngleanditsApplicationtoCubeSat‘CADRE’.”In2013CubeSatDevelopers’Workshop,April2013.
JamesCutler,AaronRidleyandAndrewNicholas,CubesatInvestigatingAtmosphericDensityResponsetoExtremeDriving,25thAnnualAIAA/USUConferenceonSmallSatellites,Logan,UT,August2011(SSC11-IV-7).
Presentations
AaronRidleyandJamesCutler,UsingConstellationsofSmallSatellitestoAddressLargeProblems,CEDAR,Boulder,CO,June24-28,2013.
AaronRidleyandJamesCutler,UMCubeSatActivities,CEDAR,Boulder,CO,June24-28,2013.
AaronRidley,JamesCutlerandAndrewNicholas,CubesatInvestigatingAtmosphericDensityResponsetoExtremeDriving,CEDAR,SantaFe,NM,June25-29,2012.
AaronRidley,JamesCutlerandAndrewNicholas,CubesatInvestigatingAtmosphericDensityResponsetoExtremeDriving,CNSF,WashingtonDC,May15,2012.
AaronRidley,JamesCutlerandAndrewNicholas,MissionAssuranceVersusCost-ThinkinginaSmallerBox,AGUFallMeeting,SanFrancisco,CA,December5-9,2011.
AaronRidleyandmanyothers,Armada-ANanosatConstellationMissiontoStudytheThermosphericReactiontoEnergyInputAcrossAllScales,QB50Meeting,Brussels,Belgium,May2011.
CADRE Team.
52 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
Project Description
Lightningdischargesrepre-sentthereleaseofenormousamountsofenergyandareassociatedwithfamiliarandpowerfulmanifestationsneartheEarth’ssurface:thunder,abrightflash,andpowerfulcurrentsthatcanshattertreesandturnsandtoglass.Light-ninggivesrisetox-rayandgamma-raybursts,andunlikethewell-knownflashesoflightandclapsofthunder,theseenergeticraysarechanneledupwardandcanbedetectedonlyfromspace.ACubeSatmission,calledFirefly,sponsoredbytheNationalScienceFoundation,willexploretherela-tionshipbetweenlightningandtheseburstsofradiationcalledTerrestrialGammaRayFlashes(TGFs).FireflydemonstratesthecapabilityofsmallmissionssuchasCubeSatstodoimportant,focusedscience,withabundantstudentinvolvement,andwithaminimalbudgetandavailableresources.TheFigureshowstheFireflyCubeSatassembledandreadyforlaunch. Planned Science Accomplishments
FireflyandFirestationwillsoonanswerthefollowingsciencequestions.WhatcausesaTGF’shigh-energyflashes?Doesittriggerlightning--ordoeslightningtriggerit?Coulditberesponsibleforsomeofthehigh-energyparticlesintheVanAllenradiationbelts,whichcandamagesatellites?Seehttp://www.nsf.gov/discoveries/disc_summ.jsp?cntn_id=124901.TheFireflyCubeSatandFireflyISSpayloadwillreturnthefirstsimultaneousmeasurementsofTGFsandlightning.“Firefly(andFirestation)willprovidethefirstdirectevidenceforarela-tionshipbetweenlightningandTGFs,”saysWeatherwax.“Identifyingthesourceofterrestrialgamma-rayflasheswillbeahugesteptowardunderstandingthephysicsoflightninganditseffectonEarth’satmosphere.”
Firestationcoversawidermeasurementrange.Itwilltakeadvantageofacamera,alsoonboardtheISSpallet,tosnapphotosoflightningflashessothatresearcherscanpreciselylocatewheretheyareoccurring.Furthermore,Firestationwillenjoyadataratethatisabout3,000timeslargerthanFirefly’s,whichmeanstheteamwillbeabletosampleeverylightningstroke,insteadofFirefly’scarefullyselectedsample.Seehttp://www.nasa.gov/mission_pages/sunearth/news/firestation-rowland.html.
FirestationwillalsooperateinorbitlongerthanFireflyprovidinganorderofmagnitudebet-tercoverage.Duringthefirst1100secondsorsoofthispartialorbitshowninthefigure,thereisanicecleanlow-backgroundinterval(afewhundredcountspersecond).TypicalTGFswillbe10-100countsinonemillisecond,andsowillstandoutnicely.Thehighercountrateback-groundregionsareintheSouthAtlanticAnomaly(SAA)andhigherlatituderegions(primarilySAA).
FireflyandFireStation
Firefly, assembled and ready for delivery for launch.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 53
Planned Technology
LessonslearnedfromtheoperationofbothFireflyandFirestationwillbesharedwithotherteamsthroughthemonth-lyNSFPrincipalInvestigator(PI)teleconferences.
Planned Education
UndergraduatestudentsatSienaCollegehavebeeninvolvedinallaspectsoftheproject,fromdesignandde-velopment,throughfabricationandtest,tomissionoperationsanddataanalysis.Thesestudentsreceivedaveryrareopportunityforhands-on,end-to-endexperienceonareal-lifespaceproject.Inthefuture,theywillalsogetachancetotraveltonationalmeetingstotalkabouttheirworkonFireStationandFirefly,andtolearnfromotherscientistsandengineers. LocalhighschoolstudentsandinternswillalsohaveaccesstotheFireStationdataandedu-cationalmaterials.TheFireStationprojectwillalsoinvolvetheoperationoftwoWorldWideLightningLocationNetworkVLFgroundstations,oneatSienaandanotherattheUniversidadPrivadaBoliviana(Dr.AugustaAbrahamse),providingstudentaccesstoatoolthatcanbeusedformanydataanalysisprojects,andthatwillbeapermanentadditiontotheeducation-alinfrastructureattheseinstitutions.
TheSienaundergraduateteamwillfurthersupportthedevelopmentofawebsite,withcontin-uousupdatesonthedevelopmentoftheinstrumentandspacecraft,andon-orbitmissionstatus,openaccesstothedataandscienceresults.
Second averaged count rates in the Firestation detector, as well as four other panels showing geolocation of the ISS (L-value, latitude, longitude, and whether in the South Atlantic Anomaly).
54 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
FocusedInvestigationsofRelativisticElectron
Burst,Intensity,Range,andDynamics(FIREBIRD) Project Description
Themissionatargeted,goal-directed,spaceweatherCubesatmissiontoresolvethespatialscalesizeandenergydependenceofelectronmicroburstsintheVanAllenradiationbelts.Rel-ativisticelectronmicroburstsappearasshortdurationsofintenseelectronprecipitationmea-suredbyparticledetectorsonlowaltitudespacecraft,seenwhentheirorbitscrossmagneticfieldlineswhichthreadtheouterradiationbelt.Previousspacecraftmissions(e.g.,SAMPEX)havequantifiedimportantaspectsofmicroburstproperties(e.g.,occurrenceprobabilities),however,somecrucialproperties(i.e.,spatialscale)remainelusiveowingtothespace-timeambiguityinherenttosinglespacecraftmissions.Whilemicroburstsarethoughttobeasignif-icantlossmechanismforrelativisticelectrons,theyremainpoorlyunderstood,thusrenderingspaceweathermodelsofEarth’sradiationbeltsincomplete. Planned Scientific Accomplishments
FIREBIRD’suniquetwo-point,focusedobservationsatlowaltitudes,thatfullyexploitthecapabilitiesoftheCubesatplatform,willanswerthreefun-damentalscientificquestionswithspaceweatherimplications:
•Whatisthespatialscalesizeofanindividualmicroburst?
•Whatistheenergydependenceofanindividualmicroburst?
•Howmuchtotalelectronlossfromtheradiationbeltsdomicroburstsproduceglobally?
See https://ssel.montana.edu/firbird-cubesat-constellation-in-production/.
Planned Technology
Firebird2continuestobeimproved.LessonslearnedfromFirebird1willbeincorporatedintoFirebird2andsharedwithotherteamsthroughthemonthlyNSFPrincipalInvestigator(PI)teleconferences.
Planned Publications
SpaceWeatherJournal,AGU,“SpaceWeatherandScienceMotivationsoftheFocusedInves-tigationsofRelativisticElectronBurstIntensity,Range,andDynamics(FIREBIRD)NSFCubeSatMission.”
FIREBIRD Logo.
(NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH [ 55
THE F
UTUR
E Theamazingresultsthathavebeenachievedoverthefirstfiveyearsoftheprogrampointtowardsanexcitingandprolificfuture.Recently,the2012SolarandSpacePhysicsDecadalSurveyfromtheNationalResearchCouncilincludedastrongrecommendationtargetingthedevelopmentofverysmallsatelliteflightopportu-nitiesasakeygrowthareaforbothNASAandNSF.Ourplansfor2014alreadyincludeanumberofspecificactivitiesthatwillfurtherpushtheboundariesforCubeSattechnology,andfortheprogram.
Twonewprojectshavejustbeenstartedthateachrepresentsanotherfirstintheprogram:thefirst6UCubeSat(theLAICEmis-sion),whichisalsothefirstprojectcarryinganimaginginstrument,andthefirsthyper-spectralimagingproject(theOPALmission).ThecomingyearwillalsoseethestartoftheQBUSproject,theobjectiveofwhichistoprovidefourCubeSatstotheEuropean-ledQB50project.Aimingtolaunchapproximately40CubeSatscarryingsetsofidenticalscientificinstrumentsamaingoaloftheprojectistoinvestigatethelowerthermosphere,alargelyunex-ploredregionoftheEarth’satmospherebetween90and320km.ThisconstitutesthefirstNSFparticipationinamajorCubeSatconstellationmission.
Moregenerally,evidencefromtheprogramsofarstronglysug-geststhatthefutureofscientificCubeSatprojectsisonlylimitedbytheimagination.Crucialmea-surementsfromspaceareneed-ednotonlytoaddressmanyun-solvedscienceproblemsbutalsotosolvecriticalsocietalprob-lems,suchasclimatechange;landuseandresourceman-agement;pollutionanddisastermonitoring;communication;andspaceweather.ExploringandcreatingnewandexpandedpossibilitiesforCubeSatstopro-videtheseremainsamaingoaloftheprogram.
ThecapabilitiesofCubeSatsystemsaregrowingatanever-increasingrateastech-nologicaladvancesaremade.Opportunitiesaremanytoacceleratethistechnologythroughengineeringresearchinanarrayoffields,includingmaterialsresearch,3-Dprinting,sensorminiaturization,micro-electro-mechanicalsystems,systemsengineering,radioscience,communi-cationalgorithms,andnetworks.PrivatefirmsandothergovernmentagenciesarealsostartingtoadopttheCubeSatconceptasalow-costwayofflyingpayloadsinspacewhilecreatingimportanteducationalopportunitiesforfutureleadersofindustry.
CubeSat investigating At-mopsheric Density Response to Extreme driving (CADRE).
Firefly CubeSat in Poly Picosatellite Orbital Deployer (P-POD) on Vibration Table at NASA GSFC WFF.
56 ] (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
Thisoffersnewandexpandedopportunitiesforpartnershipsandcollaborations.Specifically,avarietyofadditionalCubeSat-basedinitiativesarecurrentlyemergingalsoattheDODandNASA.UniquetotheNSFprogram,however,isthefocusonpursuingscientificdiscoverywhilealsoprovidingvisionaryandinspiringtrainingandeducationopportunitiesandtargetingmainlytheacademiccommunity.Consequently,theprogramwillcontinuetoplayakeyroleintheoverallnationalsmallsatelliteagendainthefuture.
Cubesatprojectsstimulatewidespreadexcitementandinvolveauniquesetofskillsandinter-ests.Therefore,theyappealtoabroaderrangeofparticipantsthanmoretraditionalscienceandengineeringprojects.ThismakesthemaperfecttoolforaddressingwidespreaddiversityandbroadeningparticipationgoalsinScienceTechnologyEngineeringMath(STEM)researchandeducation.
NSF is pioneering exciting CubeSat-based science missions for Geospace and atmospheric research
October 2013NATIONAL SCIENCE FOUNDATION (NSF) CUBESAT-BASED SCIENCE MISSIONS FOR GEOSPACE AND ATMOSPHERIC RESEARCH
annual report
NP-2013-12-097-GSFC