by Anna KoelschTHE CHRONICLE

For the second year in a row, a record number of high school seniors have ap-plied early decision to Duke.

The number of applicants increased by 14 percent, from 2,007 last year to 2,282 this year, said Dean of Undergraduate Ad-missions Christoph Guttentag.

Guttentag said the increase follows

the general trend the University has experienced in early decision applica-tions.

“In the last three years, we’ve seen a steady and dramatic increase,” Guttentag said. “I think we’ve done a better job of making sure students understand what a Duke education is about and why it is ap-pealing.”

Provost Peter Lange said the combina-tion of academic excellence and unique opportunities like DukeEngage partially accounts for the increase.

Of this year’s applicants to the Class of 2015, 1,923 applied to the Trinity Col-lege of Arts and Sciences and 359 applied to the Pratt School of Engineering—a 14 and 12 percent increase over last year, re-spectively.

The largest increases by geographic location among states with more than 100 applicants were seen in California, New York and Texas. Among states with at least 50 applicants, South Carolina, Michigan and Georgia experienced the greatest increases. Additionally, 191 in-ternational students applied early deci-sion, marking an 11 percent increase from last year.

“It’s my 28th year working in college admissions and I’ve never seen interest this high,” Guttentag said, adding that the increase in competitiveness in the past few

Upswing in early applicants continuesBrooks speaks on government inefficiencies

City still faces poverty, health challenges, DPD chief says

thanh-ha nguyen/the ChroniCle

Durham Police Chief Jose Lopez spoke in Duke Chapel Tuesday, ad-dressing the crime, drugs and mental health issues plaguing the city.

by Robert DunlapTHE CHRONICLE

Duke Police Chief Jose Lopez recognized the challenges that remain for Bull City in his Chapel address yesterday.

Although he praised both Durham for being an en-gaged city and the University for leaving its footprint “just about everywhere” in the city, he called poverty, drug addiction and mental health issues the biggest is-sues facing Durham.

“[We need to] look at the youth who are really discon-nected from society, who are not in school, who are not working and who live in a fantasy world and may com-mit a crime to supplement their income or supplement their addiction,” he said. “There are a lot of individuals who are depressed, addicted to a lot of different narcotics and drugs. And with a lot colleges nearby—and students there who use drugs, coupled with a lot of people who don’t watch after their property—it sets up a nice little situation for people to sell drugs and comfortably be able to purchase [them].”

Lopez said the prevalence of drugs leads to robberies and larcenies, particularly from “people who are on their way to buy drugs.”

Mental health is also a major issue that needs to be ad-dressed in Durham, he said. Lopez added that in a men-

tally healthy community, crime would not be as directly linked to poverty and drug addiction.

“There are a lot of people we see out there that really need help. They need to get their lives in order and the po-lice don’t do that,” he said. “That’s something that needs to be done by professionals and social workers. The police are a great agent, but you have to have someone to refer people to.”

The police chief addressed immigrant reform, as well, though he noted that “quite frankly it is not today’s is-sue—it has been in this country for many years,” and re-ferred to “the Irish and the Chinese who [helped] build this country.”

He said that although he believes there does need to be immigration reform, it will not come from a local level. Until that change arrives, he said he would like illegal im-migrants in Durham to feel more free to come forward and report crime without fear of compromising their own tentative position in America.

Lopez was at Duke for a discussion with Dean of the Chapel Sam Wells as a part of the Dean’s Dialogues series, “Listening to the Heart of Durham.” Lopez began the discussion by recounting the experiences that brought

SEE lopez ON PAGE 6

ChroniCle graphiC by melissa yeo

The number of early decision applicants to the University has risen in recent years, reaching record levels as some peer institutions have eliminated their early acceptance programs.

by Chinmayi SharmaTHE CHRONICLE

We hear too often about America’s im-pending doom, said David Brooks, political pundit and New York Times journalist. It is time, he believes, that we started talking about the remedy.

In Tuesday’s annual Terry Sanford Dis-tinguished Lecture, Brooks spoke to hun-dreds of students, faculty and political en-thusiasts about legislative gridlock. Brooks believes that increasing polarization has poisoned the political process and shaken Americans’ faith in government.

“People basically know what needs to be done,” he said of the need to reform the system. “[But] we don’t know the avenue to get there.”

Brooks said he believes that the two-party system has trapped politicians in a “social, tribal cycle” which prevents them from straying too far from their party’s ideology. This rigidity is a product of a congressional culture rooted less and less in personal interaction.

“The parties talk about each other as if the other side lacks human features,” he said, noting that congressmen rarely

SEE brooks ON PAGE 12 SEE early ON PAGE 5

Record 2,282 Class of 2015 applicants a 14 percent increase over last year

The ChronicleThe independenT daily aT duke universiTy

WEDNESDAY, NOVEMBER 10, 2010 ONE HUNDRED AND SIXTH YEAR, ISSUE 53www.dukechronicle.com

Bone marrow drive nets more than 200

registrants, Page 3

M. soccer takes on ACC tourney today, Page 7

onTherecord“The tradition may be fumbled, but the game is not

yet lost.” —Fourth-year med student Alex Fanaroff.” See column page 11

2 | wednesday, november 10, 2010 The ChroniCle

• Meet members of the program staff • Discuss program benefits and expectations

• Review important information about the application process

Please join us! Learn more at www.robertsonscholars.org ,

or contact Kristin Miller, miller@robertsonscholars.org .

Attention

first-year

students…

Did you know that you can

apply to become a Robertson Scholar?

The Robertson Scholars Program invites you to an open information

session to learn more about this opportunity!

Learn more at our info session: Wednesday, Nov. 10 at 5PM

Von Canon A/B

“ ”

worldandnation toDay:

6943

thursDay:

6436

toKyo — Japanese border disputes with China and russia are thwarting the goals of prime minister naoto Kan to improve ties with its neighbors and reduce dependence on the u.s. security umbrella.

the september collision of a Chinese fishing boat with two Japanese Coast guard vessels near islands claimed by both sides increased friction between asia’s larg-est economies. last week’s visit by russian president Dmitry medvedev to an island also claimed by Japan hurt ties as well.

the incidents underscored Japan’s weakness relative to its largest neighbors and its dependence on the united states, said bhubhindar singh, a professor at the s. rajaratnam school of international stud-ies in singapore who specializes in Japa-nese security policy. Former prime minister yukio hatoyama in February 2009 called for a “more equal” relationship with Japan’s biggest ally.

Washington, D.C. — With the num-ber of people 65 or older expected to double in the next three decades, the el-derly are driving more often, are taking longer trips and seem rooted in com-munities where getting around by car is the only option.

the graying of the roads prompted the national transportation safety board this week to host its first forum on aging drivers to analyze the impacts of the change.

Within 15 years, people 65 and older will make up more than 20 percent of the driving population, officials said. research shows that elderly drivers are getting into fewer deadly automobile accidents, but even those who try to select the saf-est hours of the day to drive can’t escape heavy traffic if they live in congested ur-ban regions where “rush hour” has ex-panded to encompass more of the day.

Elderly drivers become the focus of new traffic studies

Study says achievement gaps still prevalent

What you really value is what you miss, not what

you have. — Jorge Borges

miChael naClerio/the ChroniCle

Kalpana Sonar, mother of two teenage boys, was treated for high high blood pressure and dizziness last October. Within a week she was diagnosed with Type 2 diabetes. Doctors say a perverse twist of science makes Indians susceptible to diabetes--an ironic twist for those who have escaped childhood malnutrition and deprivation. 7.1 percent of Indian adults suffer from diabetes.

“the new Duke apparel website called ampersand threads has been shut down indefinitely after creator mitchell phillips had decided to not fight a legal battle with the university over copyright privileges. he also wrote that he never wanted to hurt the school or the team. smith is in the process of speaking to Duke stores to see if he can get some of his designs in stock.”

— From The Chronicle Sports Blogsports.chronicleblogs.com

Health Care Conferencegeneen auditorium, 8a.m.-4:30p.m. The Fuqua School’s Health Sector Management welcomes you to participate in its annual confer-

ence.

FREE Flu Shotsbryan Center, 11a.m.-5:30p.m.

Duke students, swing by the Bry-an Center to get a free flu shot! Getting sick is bad; getting every-

one else sick is worse!

An Evening with Dave Eggers page auditorium, 6-7p.m.

Dave Eggers will be discussing his award winning book “Zeitoun” and share his thoughts on Hur-

ricane Katrina.

Territorial disagreements cause friction in Japan

onschedule...

onthe web

TODAY IN HISTORY1801: Kentucky outlaws duel-

ing.

offthe wire...

The ChroniCle wednesday, november 10, 2010 | 3

CLIMATE CHANGE, BOREAL FORESTS AND THE LEGACIES OF HISTORY

Dr. Nancy LangstonNovember 11th at 4:30 p.m.Love Auditorium, LSRCDuke University (West Campus)

The 2010 Lynn W. Day Distinguished Lectureship in Forest and Conservation History welcomes Dr. Nancy Langston, Professor in the Department of Forest & Wildlife Ecology with appointments in the Department of History and the Nelson Institute for Environmental Studies at the University of Wisconsin - Madison.

Author of Forest Dreams, Forest Nightmares and Toxic Bodies: Hormone Disruptors and the Legacy of DES, Langston is Editor-elect for the journal Environmental History. She will explore the connections between forests, fisheries, toxics, and climate change, focusing on Lake Superior boreal forests.

Parking is available in the parking deck on

Science Drive at a cost of $2.00.For a map of the area go to:

http://map.duke.edu/parking/1

A reception will follow at 5:30 p.m. in the Hall of Science.

The Lectureship is sponsored by the Forest History Society, the Duke University Department of History, and the Nicholas School of the Environment. For more information and directions please call the Forest History Society, 919/682-9319.

www.foresthistory.org

Thursday, Nov. 11 Noon - 1 p.m.

Sanford 04 Free

The Living Policy Forum andthe Sanford School of Public Policy

Co-sponsored by the Kenan Institute for Ethics,Duke LGBT Center and OUTLaw

Contact: Mary Lindsley 613-7312www.sanford.duke.edu

Staff Sgt. Eric Alva was the first American wounded in the Iraq war. He received a medical discharge, a Purple Heart and instant fame in 2003. He is also gay. In 2007, he joined the Human Rights Campaign to work for repeal of the “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy. This Veteran’s Day, come hear why this combat veteran has taken the public stage to speak against this policy.

present

“Ending Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” Eric Alva

shariza baranyanKa/the ChroniCle

Dean and Vice Provost for Undergraduate Education Steve Nowicki speaks at the 100th anniversary celebration of former Duke President William Few’s inauguration, held in Perkins Library Tuesday.

A Few good menStudents sign up to donate bone marrow

Group aims to balance exec duties

DUU

by Brandon LevyTHE CHRONICLE

In an attempt to save the lives of leukemia patients, prospective bone marrow donors swabbed their cheeks in the Bryan Center last Thursday. Although the process of reg-istration is simple, it could save many lives.

For senior Kyle Gerbe, whose close friend died of leukemia because no donor could be found for her, the cause is an im-portant one.

“You [can save] a life by doing it,” he said. “It’s an incredible opportunity. There’s no downside to registering.”

More than 200 students participated in a bone marrow donor registration drive in Von Canon Hall in the Bryan Center. The event was sponsored by DKMS Americas, a branch of an international nonprofit that registers bone marrow donors and matches them with patients.

About 70 percent of patients in need of a bone marrow transplant must depend on donors outside their family, but only four out of 10 of those patients will eventually receive the transplant they need, according to the DKMS website. College students are particularly important as registered donors because 40 percent of DKMS’ donors first registered between the ages of 18 and 22.

Last week’s registration drive was planned and organized by Gerbe, the

by Tullia RushtonTHE CHRONICLE

With a goal of more evenly distribut-ed responsibilities and increased clarity among executive positions, Duke Univer-sity Union members voted Tuesday to re-structure its executive board.

Members moved to replace the vice president of internal affairs, vice president of external affairs and secretary positions with vice president programming and vice president administrative. According to current Vice President of Internal Affairs Elliot Johnson, a senior, these new roles would create more cohesion among board members and more distinct and defined roles as well.

“Looking at the roles of the vice presidents... for the VP external affairs, there’s not much to do anymore while [VP internal affairs] does quite a bit,” said current Vice President of External Affairs Will Benesh, a senior, adding that DUU would get more done if certain VPs weren’t overloaded with their responsi-bilities.

Johnson said VP programming would assume essentially all of the roles of VP internal affairs, which handles anything in DUU among specific committees.

SEE duu ON PAGE 6SEE donors ON PAGE 5

4 | wednesday, november 10, 2010 The ChroniCle

traCy huang/the ChroniCle

Students outline their plans for “smarter living” at the William B. Senner Grant Awards Competition at the Duke Smart Home Tuesday, presenting either research, prototype or implementation projects.

Live SmartObama backs India for U.N. council seat

by Scott Wilson and Emily WaxTHE WASHINGTON POST

NEW DELHI - President Barack Obama endorsed India’s desire for a permanent seat on an expanded U.N. Security Coun-cil, a symbolic gesture sure to cement the goodwill he earned on a visit here this week but equally likely to trouble neighboring China and Pakistan.

Obama’s embrace of the idea, part of a generous valedictory to India’s Parliament and people, demonstrated the geopolitical complexity that the United States faces in the region and that the president has had to navigate. There is little prospect that other members of the Security Council will agree to invite India in, and Washington is heavily dependent on China for its eco-nomic engine and counts on Pakistan to help it wage the Afghan war.

On the eve of his arrival five days ago, many Indians believed Obama placed their interests behind those of its regional rivals. Few Indians hold the same opinion as he leaves.

“The United States not only welcomes India as a rising global power, we fervent-ly support it, and we have worked to help make it a reality,” Obama said. “With India assuming its rightful place in the world, we have an historic opportunity to make the relationship between our two

SEE india ON PAGE 6

UNC-Duke partnership has slow start

Apparently Duke students wouldn’t collaborate with the Tar Heels if you paid them.

No applications had been submitted as of Monday for the Kenan-Biddle Part-nership, which will allocate $150,000 over three years to collaborative proj-ects at Duke and the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, The Daily Tar Heel reported.

The initiative will support student-led projects that contribute to the scholarly or public service missions of the two universities in grants of about $5,000 each, according to a Duke News release.

Duke Student Government Presi-dent Mike Lefevre, a senior, told the DTH that a lack of effective promo-tion might explain the lack of appli-cations. Since reading the article the Daily Tar Heel published, however, he told The Chronicle that he now realizes the issue can likely be at-tributed to the tendency of college students to put off applications until the last minute. The program’s dead-line is Nov. 15.

“Reading that article, I actually got some new insight,” Lefevre said. “Since then, I’ve heard about at least two [applications] that are in the works.”

—from staff reports

The ChroniCle wednesday, november 10, 2010 | 5

years makes early decision an attractive option for seniors.

Other top universities have experi-enced sharp increases in early decision applicants. Northwestern University re-ported a 22 percent increase in appli-cants and the University of Pennsylvania reported a 17 percent increase.

Although many institutions have re-cently eliminated their early admittance programs, the practice continues to be a

stronghold for Duke, Guttentag said, add-ing that the University is not considering phasing out early decision.

“There is a cohort of students for whom Duke is a clear first choice,” he said. “We like having some proportion of the class that is able to say that they knew Duke was their first choice.”

Lange said Duke especially empha-sized the advantages of applying early decision this year, which may help to ex-plain the rise in applications.

In light of the economic downturn, Guttentag said there has been a “deliber-ate effort” to assure applicants and their

families that financial aid is available.“We are serious in our desire to make

Duke affordable,” Guttentag said. He added that the University’s need-blind admissions policy demonstrates a com-mitment to offering all admitted students the opportunity to attend.

Director of Financial Aid Alison Rabil said she does not know how many appli-cants applied for financial aid.

University recruitment has likewise been affected by the tightening budget. Duke Admissions reduced its recruiting expenses by 10 percent this year and has not made any major changes in its meth-ods, Guttentag said.

“We didn’t make any special efforts to attract students, which makes the increase [in early decision applications] interest-ing,” he said, adding that the most visible change in recruitment was the distribu-tion of a poster featuring a photo mosaic of the Duke Chapel.

Guttentag said he does not think the 2010 national championship win by the men’s basketball team was the underly-ing factor for the increase. He added that the University is in an “enviable” position because of the strong track record of the basketball team and Duke Athletics as a whole.

“If we had lost the game on the last shot, it is hard for me to imagine a stu-dent choosing not to apply to Duke,” Gut-tentag said. “Then again, we didn’t lose the game. So, who knows?”

Guttentag, however, stressed that applicants are attracted to more than Duke basketball, highlighting the “classy” reputation of Duke’s Cameron Crazies.

“It’s the spirit that Duke students show toward teams, plural,” he said. ”It’s the atmosphere that supports teams that em-bodies a sense of spirit.”

EARLY from page 1

philanthropy chair of Kappa Alpha Order, with the help of several dozen volunteers.

Gerbe first contacted DKMS in late September, and the organization helped him get the necessary supplies. Other than that, he said, most of the work consisted of contacting as many people as possible about the event.

“Publicity and getting the word out were all there was to it,” he said.

A total of 217 Duke students registered at Thursday’s event, Gerbe said, adding that he was highly satisfied with the drive’s results. The drive was even more successful than similar events held at other universi-ties recently, he added, with 180 registered at Harvard University and nearly 500 at the University of Missouri, a larger school whose drive lasted five days.

To help plan, publicize and run the event, Gerbe enlisted the help of multiple university organizations, including several other Greek organizations. Gerbe said approximately 50 students volunteered at the drive itself, in-cluding 45 Kappa Alpha members.

In addition, the volunteers organized a fundraiser to help cover the costs of labor and long-term storage of donor informa-tion. They hosted the Metro 8 club on 9th Street on the night of the drive, donating the $1 cover charge to the bone marrow registry. Junior Austin Sutton, who led the planning of the fundraiser, said the event raised $450.

“It wasn’t as large a turnout as we could have had, but overall we’re just happy we could help out,” Sutton said.

DKMS covered the $65 cost of registering each student, allowing the Duke volunteers to focus on publicizing the event. Although students were able to make donations to DKMS when they registered, Gerbe said that

money was not what was important. “We just asked people to pay whatever they

could,” Gerbe said. “DKMS really helped to cover the cost pretty much exclusively.”

Many people avoid registering as mar-row donors because they have an inaccu-rate perception of the donation process, Gerbe said. In the past, donors were given no anesthesia and the procedure could only be performed by extracting marrow directly from the donor’s pelvis with a large needle.

“Because of that, nobody wanted to be a registered donor,” Gerbe said. “People were scared. That stigma has stayed attached to it, which is why the registry is so small.”

But a new procedure called periph-eral blood stem cell collection allows do-nors to help leukemia patients through a much less painful procedure. In the process, blood is removed from one arm and passed through a machine that sepa-rates the stem cells from the blood while the remaining blood is returned through the other arm. Although the process takes about 6 to 8 hours, it is no more painful than giving blood.

Alex Miller, a junior who registered at a similar drive organized by the Delta Delta Delta sorority last year, was recently matched with a patient—something that does not happen to most registered do-nors. Miller received a package in the mail and a phone call telling him that he had been selected.

“It came out of nowhere. I was really sur-prised,” he said.

After undergoing a series of tests to en-sure that he is healthy, Miller must now wait for the patient to be well enough for the transplant. When the time comes, DKMS will fly him to Washington, D.C., for the procedure.

“I’m really excited to do it but definitely still kind of anxious,” he said.

DONORS from page 3

“If we had lost the [national championship] game on the last shot, it

is hard for me to imagine a student choosing not to

apply to Duke.” — Christoph Guttentag,

dean of Undergraduate Admissions

Visit dukechronicle.com

to comment on The Chronicle’s news, sports and opinion stories.

6 | wednesday, november 10, 2010 The ChroniCle

NeuroCog Trials, a rapidly growing company with close ties to Duke University Medical Center, has been involved in design and implementation of multi-site clinical trials, including rater training and data quality assurance, and neurocognitive test development, for 10 years.

We are looking to fill a full-time PhD-level position. This individual will assist in novel test development and validation, trial design, data analysis and interpretation, and business development, and will oversee neurocognitive rater certification and data quality control for multi-site pharmaceutical company trials. These clinical trials usually involve a large meeting of investigators and testers who require certification. Travel to US or international meetings is expected. The person filling the position should be proficient in Excel, SPSS and/or SAS. Expertise in visual design, presentation, and software development is a plus.

The starting salary will be competitive with pharmaceutical industry standards with medical benefits.

Management skills are essential. Additional requirements: PhD in psychology, neurosciences or related field; experience with neuropsychological or cognitive data collection and analysis; ability to travel on limited basis (average of 3-5 days per month); large-group presentation skills. Experience with schizophrenia, bipolar disorder, and dementia is a plus.

Contact: Dr. Richard Keefe email: PhDpsych@neurocogtrials.com

phone: 919-401-4642

help wanted

Jaclyn Lautz & Fang Yuan; Masters of Engineering Management Program“Visualization Techniques and Spectral Analysis of High-frequency Corona Discharges in Living System Capillaries”

Meghan Semancik & Sarah Hochendoner; Neuroscience“Your Brain and the 5 ‘Neurosenses’ “

Carrie Olson-Manning, Paul Durst, & Andrew Manning; Biology & Biochemistry“Let Them Eat Cake!”

Kara Leimberger & Ben Finkel; Evolutionary Anthropology“Beyond “Monkey See”: The Diversity of Primate Perception”

Claire Gordy & Deirdre Fuller, Damian Maseda, Carlos Goller; Immunology“How Does the Immune System Sense an Infection?”

Angela Jiang, Ellen Litkowski, Katherine Xu, & Baninder Baidwan; Biology & Psychology FEMMES: (Females Excelling More in Math, Engineering, and Science):“The Five Senses”

Nancy Yang, Charles Li, Jenny Jin, Fola Omofoye, Eva Williams,Yi Yang, & Becky Zon; Public Policy, Biology & ChemistryScienceDays at Duke: “Sensational Sensory Exploration”

Congratulations to our 2010 Student Science Education Outreach Grant Awardees!

This year’s theme focused on the five senses and how they help us make sense

of science, medicine, and everyday life.

Need Cash Fast?

� Complete computer questionnaires at Fuqua School of Business

� Receive cash on the spot! For real! We need research participants to fill out business research surveys. You come in and do a 15 minute computer questionnaire and we pay you $8 in cash right on the spot! No joke! There are many different studies listed with varying time lengths and payment amounts.

Look at our website: http://experimetrix.com/fuqua

For more questions contact: Sarah, spd@duke.edu

FUQUA SCHOOL OF FUQUA SCHOOL OF FUQUA SCHOOL OF BUSINESS BUSINESS BUSINESS

him to Durham in 2007 after serving in Connecticut at the Hartford Police De-partment for more than 23 years. Having applied for the position of police chief of Durham five years earlier, he decided to take the city up on its offer when the posi-tion opened again.

“I wanted to move to the South be-cause I got into an argument with my snowblower and I did not want to be around it anymore,” Lopez joked before getting serious. “I looked at the statis-tics, looked at the police department, and from a professional law enforce-ment stance [DPD] looked like a very good organization.”

During the discussion, Wells addressed the media’s negative portrayal of the Duke-Durham relationship and how it af-fected the community’s interaction with the University.

“Many people watching will be quite frustrated with [the] very one dimen-sional stereotype of rich, white Duke and poor, non-white Durham, [because] obviously, none of those descriptions are accurate or helpful,” Wells said. “None-theless, they seem to lodge in the imagi-nation of people, particularly [those] looking for a brief story or looking for information that confirms that kind of story.”

Looking forward to Durham’s future, Lopez said he believes that the city must focus on raising employment rates.

“We have to build on this economy, and we have to build from the outside,” he said. “There is no gold here.... A lot of corpora-tions are looking for a home [and] this is a great home for them. We have to look at the job situation here in this county—there are a lot of people here who really need blue collar jobs.”

Lopez said he is pleased by the positive contribution that law enforcement can make to the community.

“You have to care about people. You have to want to make a difference,” he said. “Law enforcement is the only oc-cupation where no matter what you do, whether you’re arresting [someone] or whether you’re solving a crime and assist-ing a victim, that you’re making a positive difference in someone’s life.”

LOPEz from page 1

VP programming would also be in charge of “committee bonding,” organizing events such as retreats and orientations. VP administrative will assume the responsibilities of VP external affairs as well as those of the secretary position, which will be eliminated for the 2011-2012 executive board. In addition to taking notes for each meeting, VP administrative will continue VP external affairs’ role over the Union Consulting Group—which helps student organizations with event planning—and take on overseeing the Freshman Internship Program.

Despite the majority of members voting in favor of the executive board restructuring, there was some concern about the overall effect it will have in the future.

“I’m not opposed to the change, but

I don’t see a purpose to the change,” said Speakers and Stage Chair Alex Shapanka, a sophomore.

Shapanka expressed specific con-cern with eliminating the position of secretary, saying that taking notes during meetings hinders participa-tion in conversation. However, cur-rent Secretary Joyce Kim, a senior, said she can both actively contribute to group discussions and take notes efficiently.

in other business: Chairs gave updates about their

respective committees, discussing progress and highlighting upcoming events. Animal Planet’s Jeff Corwin will be speaking at Reynolds Theater Thursday at 8 p.m. and will hold a book signing afterward. DUU Ma-jor Attractions will also be present-ing Matisyahu with Freddie Gibbs Wednesday, Nov. 17 at 8 p.m. in Page Auditorium.

Chris Dall/the ChroniCle

Members of Duke University Union voted to introduce two new executive positions, in order to better distribute duties among officers, at their meeting Tuesday.

DUU from page 3

countries a defining partnership of the century ahead.”

On his last day, Obama paid tribute to India’s national hero, Mohandas K. Gan-dhi, called Prime Minister Manmohan Singh “a dear friend,” and, in a speech that he sprinkled with Hindi words and phrases, criticized Pakistan for failing to stop terrorism.

That criticism in some ways may have been an effort to make amends for an ear-lier rhetorical misstep, when on a first-day visit to a memorial he failed to mention Pakistan as the staging ground for the Nov. 26, 2008, terrorist attack in Mumbai, which killed more than 160 people. The next day a 19-year-old college student in Mumbai asked him why he did not call Pakistan a “terrorist state.”

His careful answer, coupled with the previous day’s omission, infuriated Indian commentators, who said Obama was cod-dling Pakistan.

But in his parliamentary address, Obama said, “We will continue to insist to Pakistan’s leaders that terrorist safe havens within their borders are unacceptable, and that the terrorists behind the Mumbai at-tacks be brought to justice.”

The line received the most applause of the evening.

“In Mumbai, Obama looked like a salesman of American companies,” said Sanjay Nirupam, a lawmaker from Mum-bai, referring to the billions of dollars in aircraft, engine and other export con-tracts Obama announced there. “In to-day’s speech, he came across as a sales-man for India.”

Obama’s fondness for India is in part rooted in his fondness for its leader.

Singh is a bookish, Oxford-educated economist whom Obama admired from the time of their first lunch together at the Group of 20 summit in London in 2009.

At a news conference after their Mon-day meeting, Obama called Singh “a man of extraordinary intellect and great integri-ty.” Singh returned the favor by endorsing a U.S. move to promote economic growth at home that has angered other economic powers on the eve of the G-20 summit in Seoul. Obama heads to the conference later this week.

INDIA from page 4

Duke looks to continue hot streak in ACCsmen’s soccer

left to right: addison corriher, ted knudsen, addison corriher/the chronicle

Duke enters the Acc Tournament with the conference’s offensive and defensive players of the year.

JasonPalmataryOn Football

Duke’s defense goes back to square one

See palmatary on page 8

women’s bAskeTbAll

Finley and Wenger named ACC’s offensive and defensive players of the year

No. 2 recruit verbally commits to Duke

Halfway through the victory in annap-olis two weeks ago, it appeared that the key adjustments the Duke defense had been making were coming to fruition with some degree of permanence. But,

just six quarters of football later, it is very clear such a hasty conclusion was ill drawn.

The sea-son started off with three ter-

rible performances in which the defense yielded an average of 48 points a game on 511 yards of total offense. In those games, the defense was victimized by both strong rushing and passing attacks and its own

mistakes, including penalties and miscom-munication.

Following the humiliating defeat at the hands of alabama, the defense, spe-cifically the front seven, began to dem-onstrate some improvement over the next four outings. Despite a turnover epidemic in those games that resulted in opposing offenses continually start-ing possessions deep in Duke territory, the defense relented a more respectable average of 32 points a game on 392 yards of total offense.

The unit furthered this sense of mo-mentum by blanking navy for a half, but any hope of sustained defensive improvement would completely van-

by Andrew BeatonTHe CHRonICLe

Last year, Boston College shut out Duke during the regular season and then again in the first round of the aCC Tournament. With a 1-0 victory over the eagles earlier this season, the no. 19 Blue Devils are looking to fully avenge last year’s losses as they kick off their aCC Tournament tomorrow night at WakeMed Soccer park in Cary, n.C.

“They beat us twice last year, and we’re going to beat them twice this year,” senior Cole grossman declared.

Duke catches Boston College (9-3-5, 2-2-4 in the aCC) at a good time, as the no. 21 eagles have struggled through conference

play this season. although they impressive-ly tied conference powerhouses Maryland and north Carolina, they only pulled out two conference victories while losing to and drawing with teams they should have beaten. These struggles earned them the no. 5 seed in the tournament.

Duke (9-4-4, 3-3-2), on the other hand, enters the tournament as the no. 4 seed, coming off a strong three-game winning streak to finish the season, in which it col-lectively outscored its opponents 12-2.

“We’re absolutely buzzing—we’ve come off three big wins,” sophomore goalie James

See recruit on page 8

elizabeth williams

by Staff ReportsTHe CHRonICLe

a pair of Duke sophomores nabbed the top aCC all-Conference awards yes-terday, marking the first time that the Blue Devils have earned both awards in the same season.

Ryan Finley, a forward, and andrew Wenger, a defender, were named the of-fensive and defensive players of the year, respectively, after leading Duke to a 9-4-4 record and the no. 4 seed in the aCC Tour-nament. Wenger is the first Blue Devil to win top defensive honors, and Finley is the second on the offensive side of the ball, fol-lowing Mike grella’s award in 2008.

Finley leads all Division I players in goals scored, 17, and in total points with 37. He has netted three hat tricks this season, a

Duke record, and has recorded points on 20 of the Blue Devils’ 32 goals.

Wenger, as Duke’s center back, leads the team in minutes played. The defen-seman has posted six shutouts on the year and surrendered 15 goals in 17 games. He was also a first-team all-aCC selection last year, making him the first Duke player since 1995 to earn top-team honors in his first two seasons.

The no. 19 Blue Devils had other award recipients as well. Senior Cole grossman, a midfielder, garnered first team all-aCC honors, giving the Blue Devils three first-team selections for the first time in 11 years. Sophomore James Belshaw, the starting goal-keeper, was named to the second team, and Jonathan aguirre and Sebastien Ibeagha both earned all-Freshmen Team honors.

by Andy MooreTHe CHRonICLe

Much hype has been made of the recruit-ing class brought in by head coach Joanne p. McCallie for the 2010-11 season.

Let it now begin again for 2011-12. elizabeth Williams, the no. 2 player in the Class of 2011 according to eSpn’s Hoopgurlz.com, will sign a letter of in-tent to play at Duke, the Virginia Beach, Va., native told The Chronicle yesterday.

“I’m really happy with my decision,” said the 6-foot-3 center. “I feel great. I definitely went with my gut, prayed about it and it felt right for me. [Duke] had the factors I was looking for.”

Williams said she had recently nar-

rowed her choices down to two schools, Duke and Tennes-see, and the deci-sion to turn down legendary coach pat Summitt’s pro-gram was a hard one. While play-ing for Team USa in the FIBa U17 World Champi-onships this sum-mer, she also com-peted with—and befriended—several future Tennessee recruits, further complicating the call

See m. soccer on page 8

SportsThe Chronicle

www.dukechroniclesports.com

WEDNESDAYNovember 10, 2010

>> ONLINE Kellie Catanach racked up quite the hardware this week, winning ACC player of the week and College Volleyball Update’s national player of the week

8 | wedneSday, november 10, 2010 The ChroniCle

ANNOUNCEMENTS

Learn to SCUBa Dive at the Chapel Hill Community Cen-ter. Intro Session for weeknight class on 11/13. Classes begin 11/16. Contact Water World for more information and/or to sign-up. 919-596-8185 www.wa-terworldinc.com

DUKe SUMMer SeSSion 2011!

It’s not too early to plan your summer. View projected sum-mer course offerings at www.summersession.duke.edu. Ques-tions? Contact us at summer@duke.edu. Registration for Sum-mer 2011 opens on February 21.

HELP WANTED

earn $1000-$3200 a Month to drive our brand new cars with ads placed on them. www.AdCarDriver.com

We are LooKing for StUDent MarKeting in-ternS to promote Fastnote.com on the Duke Campus this fall/winter. Hiring immediately.

Responsibilities:

- Use our ideas and your own to promote this new website.

- Hold weekly phone calls with our corporate office to evaluate progress.

- 5-10 hours/week

- Flexible hours, self-scheduled

- Initial 1-2 hours of training

Please send a resume to dcar-ney@websitemm.com and tell us why you are interested and qualified for this job.

This position pays $10/hour.

MEETINGS

DUKe in aUStraLia sum-mer 2011 info meeting on Thursday, Nov. 11 in Allen 226 at5:30pm.

The faculty director, Prof. Jon Shaw (Biology) will give an over-view of this exciting four week, one course Duke summer pro-gram. Questions? Contact the GEO-U at 684-2174. Also visit our website: http://global.duke.edu/geo

DUKe in ghana summer program info meeting

on Thursday, Nov. 11, 2010 in Social Sciences 105 starting at 4:30pm.

Meet the faculty director, Katya Wesolowski, and learn about this amazing 6 week summer program. Questions: Contact the GEO-U at 684-2174 and visit http://global.duke.edu/geo.

SERVICES OFFERED

neeD heLp With DepreS-Sion, anxiety, aDhD?

appointments available now

call 919-636-5240

doc@cognitive-psychiatry.com

www.cognitive-psychiatry.com

traveL/vaCation

BAHAMAS SPRING BREAK

$189 for 5-DAYS or $239 for 7-DAYS. All prices include: Round-trip luxury cruise with food. Accommodations on the island at your choice of thirteen resorts. Appalachia Travel www.BahamaSun.com 800-867-5018.

CLASSIFIEDS

please recycle

ish shortly. The Midshipmen erupted for 31 second-half points and almost pulled off the unfathomable upset. and, in last week’s win, the Blue Dev-ils were gashed for 48 points and 643 yards, and the offense had to drive the length of the field in two minutes after a double-digit fourth quarter lead was relinquished.

It has become clear to me the respect-ability that the defense showed just a few weeks ago was actually an aberration.

poring over statistics to try and de-termine its major area of weakness is a difficult task. pretty quickly it becomes apparent that it is the group’s deficien-cies as a whole that are leading to these track meets.

In terms of total points allowed and yards given up, Duke ranks 114th and 116th out 120 teams in Division 1-a. In both of these categories, Duke is the lowest-ranked major conference team with the exception of pacific-10 cellar dweller Washington State.

The run defense and pass defense, giv-ing up 200 and 258 yards per game, re-spectively, are equally responsible for the opposition’s huge outputs. To many in the stands, it may seem like the Blue Devil defense is too basic and conservative. Instead of putting pressure on offenses, they are content to use a ‘bend-but-don’t break’ mentality, which the team insists isn’t the reality.

“I don’t feel like that is our philos-ophy, though it may seem like it to an outsider,” linebacker abraham Kromah told me yesterday. “The coaches put us in the right place, and then we have

to go force turnovers and make plays. That’s something that we control.”

The coaching staff has preached in-creasing takeaways, and, in fact, Duke has not lost in a game in which it has won the turnover battle. not much progress has been made, however.

at the end of the week, Duke came in 117th in the nation with just eight sacks, and its eight interceptions put it in the bottom half of the country in that category. In many respects, the two statistics go together as a quarterback under duress is more likely to make a bad decision. But concerns in the sec-ondary have limited Duke’s willingness to send extra rushers.

“We’re not rushing the passer very well, and that’s something we’re look-ing at,” Cutcliffe said in yesterday’s press conference. “But, to get more into blitzing, it’s dependent on the matchups in coverage.”

Cutcliffe also pointed to the great size that many of the aCC receivers have and the problem that poses for his smaller de-fensive backs. So, even when the commu-nication is sound and they are in the right position, their lack of ball skills is getting them beat.

not much has gone right on the defen-sive side for Duke this year. Fortunately, this lack of success leaves plenty of room for improvement, and the ever-optimistic Cutcliffe praises even the unit’s smallest victories as he works to solve his team’s most pressing need.

“With all these points being scored, the defense has been on the field when the game was won [the last two weeks],” Cutcliffe said. “They are doing what they need to do in crunch time.”

But not on many other occasions.

pAlmATAry from page 7

Belshaw said. “We’ve got momentum. The whole team’s ready, and everyone’s in a great spirit.”

Regardless of momentum, to pull off an-other win against Boston College the Blue Devils will have to improve their play from the regular-season matchup. although Duke was successful in holding the eagles scoreless, Boston College had a number of good offen-sive looks that ultimately did not translate to the scoreboard.

“We did a lot of things well, [but] in fact we also did a lot of things not so well,” head coach John Kerr said. “[Since then] we made a couple of defensive adjustments to accommodate what B.C. likes to do.”

In addition, the Blue Devils struggled on offense for much of the earlier match-up, notching only two shots on goal in the first half. The eagles focused on shutting down sophomore striker Ryan Finley, who faced a tough, physical defense through-out the match and was held scoreless. Finley, named the aCC offensive player of the year yesterday, finished the regular season as the Division I leader in goals with 17. Knowing he could be guarded heavily again, Duke will have to be open minded in its offensive game plan, creat-ing other opportunities if its top scorer is

rendered ineffective. “Hopefully we can capitalize on some

free kicks and corner kicks, and if we start doing that we’re going to be really hard to beat,” grossman said. “When we’re un-selfish and willing to make the last pass, it makes a huge difference.”

Still, tactics aside, the largest factor in this game for the Blue Devils seems to be their hunger for revenge against the team that booted them from last year’s aCC Tournament. That game was partic-ularly frustrating as it was defined less by the players and more by the hurricane-like conditions during the match.

“It’s in our minds —it hasn’t gone away yet,” Kerr said. “We felt unfortunate that we had two losses against them last year, so we’re excited about the opportunity to rectify that.”

Looking ahead, should the Blue Devils pull off the win tomorrow, they will likely face the tournament’s no. 1 seed, north Carolina, in the semifinals. Furthermore, if Duke can win both of those games and make it to the championship, it may earn a bye in the nCaa Tournament.

For now, however, beating the eagles and exacting revenge is on the Blue Dev-ils’ minds.

“We’ve given them one win back from their win in the regular season last year,” Belshaw said. “So there’s one more score to be settled.”

m. soccer from page 7

to choose Duke.Still, she couldn’t pass up the chance to

play under McCallie—and occupy a front-court that loses Krystal Thomas after this season and returns only allison Vernerey.

“[Tennessee has] won so many cham-pionships, and I got close with other re-cruits while playing for the FIBa team this summer,” Williams said. “But I still think that I made the right decision.”

The associated press and gatorade State player of the Year for Virginia, Wil-liams brings a complete and polished game for a post player. She’s a shot-blocking force, swatting 172 shots as a junior at princess anne High School. She’s also a standout on the offensive side of the court, averaging 16.9 points and 11.1 rebounds per game last year.

perhaps the most impressive bullet on her resume, Williams has won gold medals for the United States with the FIBa U16 and U17 teams.

“I’m a smart player, a team player. I just like to win,” she said.

Born in england, Williams is the daugh-ter of nigerian-born parents. She grew up playing soccer and didn’t pick up basket-ball until the age of nine. once she began playing basketball, though, she quickly dropped the pitch for good in favor of the hardwood. according to Williams, her soc-cer background is still evident—especially in her footwork in the paint.

Williams is also the daughter of a doc-tor, and she cited Duke’s medical facili-ties as being a factor in the decision.

“academics are really important to me,” Williams said. “and I love the peo-ple and the environment [at Duke]. It’s just such a great place.”

recruiT from page 7

Follow along to each basketball game’s live blog:

dukechroniclesports.com

the chronicle wednesday, november 10, 2010 | 9

DiversionsShoe Chris Cassatt and Gary Brookins

Dilbert Scott Adams

Ink Pen Phil Dunlap

Doonesbury Garry Trudeau

Sudoku Fill in the grid so that every row, every col-umn and every 3x3 box contains the digits 1 through 9. (No number is repeated in any column, row or box.)

Answer to puzzle

www.sudoku.com

the chronicle who we would have denied admission:

failgating sister to 14-year-old: ...................................twei, antonysee 2 down: ...............................................................................ruppwe’re a hit-making machine: ......................................................kimsee 2 up: ................................................................................busstopthis one is way too obvious: ...............................andyk, other andydon’t deny chronrage (alcoholism): ....... fraddison, yeo, crod, christhe five percent against: .................................................... xpentinastupid people WHO FILL UP EVERY MMS CLASS: .......................ianBarb Starbuck welcomes everybody: ....................................... Barb

Student Advertising Manager: .........................................Amber SuAccount Executives: ........................ Phil deGrouchy, Claire Gilhuly,

Nick Hurst, Gini Li, Ina Li, Spencer Li,Christin Martahus, Ben Masselink,

Emily Shiau, Kate ZeligsonCreative Services Student Manager ...........................Christine HallCreative Services: ...............................Lauren Bledsoe, Danjie Fang

Caitlin Johnson, Megan Meza , Hannah SmithBusiness Assistant: ........................................................Joslyn Dunn

Duke students’ Saturday morning Tailgate tradition has been ended at last. In an e-mail sent to the student body Mon-day night, Vice President for Student Affairs Larry Moneta declared that Tailgate will not take place be-fore the game against Boston College this Saturday, and Tail-gate will no longer exist with University sanctioning.

The manner in which the administration took action against Tailgate does not in-spire confidence. After waf-fling on the issue for years and implementing hollow, marginal adjustments to the event each season, the Uni-versity has taken swift action at an inopportune time—just before the end of the season.

Additionally, the reasons

expressed for the cancellation of Tailgate failed to address the true root of the problem with Blue Zone festivities. Mon-eta and other administrators have long seen Tailgate as an

embarrassment to the Univer-sity, so to use

an isolated safety incident and low attendance at a successful home game as an impetus to cancel the event belies larger issues that should have been dealt with earlier.

Nonetheless, the decision to end Tailgate was a signifi-cant one for several key rea-sons. First, Tailgate creates an unsafe environment for the student body. The event regu-larly results in numerous stu-dents being sent to the hospi-tal for alcohol-related injuries. Saturday’s incident, when a

minor was found unconscious in a Porta Potty at the end of Tailgate, is symptomatic of a larger problem involving alcohol abuse at Tailgate. Al-though some degree of exces-sive drinking is inevitable on a college campus, the University cannot continue to support an event that has consistently pro-duced alcohol-related EMS calls.

Second, Tailgate adversely impacts Duke’s reputation. As a top-ranked, prominent uni-versity, Duke faces constant scrutiny from the public. As a result, events such as Tailgate are publicized in national me-dia outlets, drawing attention away from Duke’s academic successes and instead rein-forcing negative stereotypes about our social scene.

The final reason to end

Tailgate is its connection to Duke Football. Although few legitimate ties exist between these two entities, other than the event’s name and the time at which it is held, Tail-gate inevitably corresponds with football games.

We do not believe that stu-dents should be required or unfairly pressured to attend football games—in the same way that they ought not to be mandated to attend other on-campus events—but the student body does have an obligation to show the team more respect. Players are con-tributing members of the Uni-versity, and Tailgate makes a mockery of their efforts.

Students have responded strongly to Tailgate’s cancella-tion, with individuals express-ing a sense of entitlement to

the tradition and outrage at its sudden demise. With this outcry have come bloated characterizations of Tailgate’s unifying effects for campus life. Students should consider other, more constructive ven-ues for creating campus unity.

In looking to the future, a vacuum now exists in the social climate of the Fall se-mester. Duke Student Gov-ernment should take some agency in coordinating a vi-able replacement to Tailgate, but students themselves are also responsible for generat-ing a new alternative. The administration has done its best to create a football-cen-tric pre-game atmosphere on Main Quad, but the student body must determine what will occupy its time on Satur-day mornings in the Fall.

commentaries10 | wednesday, november 10, 2010 the chronicle

the c

hron

icle

The

Ind

epen

dent

Dai

ly a

t D

uke

Uni

vers

ity

editorial

Don’t forget what I did

End of an era

Want more opinion? Visit the backpages blog at www.chronicleblogs.com

”“ onlinecomment

incisive & insightful column! Observations & conclu-sions were worth my time reading the column.

—“avidreader” commenting on the column “‘Abbreving’ our experience.” See more at www.dukechronicle.com.

Letters PoLicyThe Chronicle welcomes submissions in the form of letters

to the editor or guest columns. Submissions must include the author’s name, signature, department or class, and for purposes of identification, phone number and local address. Letters should not exceed 325 words; contact the editorial department for information regarding guest columns.

The Chronicle will not publish anonymous or form letters or letters that are promotional in nature. The Chronicle reserves the right to edit letters and guest columns for length, clarity and style and the right to withhold letters based on the discretion of the editorial page editor.

Direct submissions to:

E-mail: chronicleletters@duke.eduEditorial Page DepartmentThe ChronicleBox 90858, Durham, NC 27708Phone: (919) 684-2663Fax: (919) 684-4696

Inc. 1993Est. 1905

Everyone has a claim to something. Even when you do that so selfless act from the deepest part of your heart, you still appreciate the recognition for such. It’s just, well somewhat, ra-tional.

Take for instance “Citizen You: Doing Your Part to Change the World.” Changing the world seems more feasible than ever, Jonathan Tisch proclaims. The CEO of Loews Hotels calls upon the nation with contagious excitement to join the new shift in civic engagement. No longer just “volunteers” teetering around and addressing symptoms of societal issues, citizen profession-als, entrepreneurs and activists are getting more to the root causes of matters.

As major sponsor of Tufts’ Jonathan M. Tisch College of Citizenship and Public Service (quite a tongue-tischer), he has surely done his fair share of contribution to society. And yet, I would be remiss not to acknowledge the 40 times either the words “Tufts” or “Tisch College” were used throughout the book. After an extensive breakdown of what this particular college has done and represents, it humbly wraps up with Tufts being just “one of many colleges and universities around the coun-try” that take civic engagement seriously.

Within this glorious section are stories of Tufts students who have hit the ground running, in-spired by the new wave of activism. I did not so much seize upon these inspiring anecdotes as much as I was overwhelmed by the constant adver-tisement of implicitly Tisch-sanctioned work. At a certain point, I thought I was reading an applica-tion essay, except this one was a two-fold combina-tion of the story of Al-Chalabi, the engineer-policy double major, and Tisch, the authenticator. Ac-cording to the book, the student had to finally put on hold his fascinating project, as the economic climate wasn’t there to support it. Nonetheless, despite the disappointment, we find that this is OK, as he has learned that “the process of social change often is measured in years rather than in days, weeks or months”—thank you Confucius.

But this inherent self-recognition is no singular phenomenon. Before reading this book, I got a chance to skim former President Bill Clinton’s “Giv-

ing”; if you don’t get the main idea from the title of book, you’ll surely get a clue after the exhaustive list of potential forms of giving that we average, time-

crunched Americans can do and must do. (Let me digress: While the “giving” sentiment is a good one, I think the Bible already covered “do unto others” quite nicely.) And of course, Clinton could not withstand speaking on his own endeavors of giving, for what basis could he write a book about the idea? Suffice to say he resists for 186 pages before reciting the accomplishments of his eight years in the White House: an enumeration of how millions of

Americans now get family leave, safer drinking wa-ter, patients’ rights, college aid and immunization who wouldn’t have gotten it had a guy named Clin-ton not been president.

During the open session with Tisch on his new book a couple weeks ago, I got a chance to ask him some small questions. My meager attempts at investigative reporting left me somewhat empty-handed. First question: “What was the selection process like for your work’s stories?” First sentence of his answer: “They were good.” Second ques-tion: “What do you think about other social action works, such as Bill Clinton’s ‘Giving’ or his wife’s ‘It Takes a Village?’” First sentence of his answer: “First off, I am a big fan of Bill Clinton, especially his work ‘Giving.’” Of course, Bill had attended the “Citizen You” launch party, in which he gave a rousing speech, so yes, again, bad question.

To be sure, these books do give interesting ac-counts of people truly “doing good” and making a difference in society. There’s no harm done with a little self-promotion of what it means to be an active citizen. If you want your legacy to be the impassioned, model image of what it means to do right, then by all means, be confident and share your side of the story. ’Tis the spirit of social en-trepreneurship, having a selfless heart for engage-ment tinged with a business ethic. A little adver-tisement could just be the difference necessary to change our world.

Brandon Maffei is a Trinity sophomore. His column runs every other Wednesday.

the chronicleLindsey Rupp, Editor

Toni Wei, Managing EditorTayLoR doheRTy, News Editor

andy MooRe, Sports EditorCouRTney dougLas, Photography Editor

Ben BRosToff, Editorial Page EditorWiLL RoBinson, Editorial Board Chair

ChRisTina peña, Managing Editor for OnlinejonaThan angieR, General Manager

dean Chen, Director of Online Operations jeff sChoLL, Sports Managing Editor MaTTheW Chase, University Editor joanna LiChTeR, University EditorsaManTha BRooks, Local & National Editor CiaRan o’ConnoR, Local & National Editorsonia haveLe, Health & Science Editor TuLLia RushTon, Health & Science EditorMeLissa yeo, News Photography Editor MaRgie TRuWiT, Sports Photography Editorkevin LinCoLn, Recess Editor MiChaeL naCLeRio, Multimedia Editor Lisa du, Recess Managing Editor naThan gLenCeR, Recess Photography EditorChaRLie Lee, Editorial Page Managing Editor dReW sTeRnesky, Editorial Page Managing EditorsaneTTe Tanaka, Wire Editor CaRTeR suRyadevaRa, Design EditorandReW hiBBaRd, Towerview Editor LaWson kuRTz, Towerview EditorChase oLivieRi, Towerview Photography Editor Maya RoBinson, Towerview Creative DirectorzaChaRy TRaCeR, Special Projects Editor hon Lung Chu, Special Projects Editor for OnlineaLex BeuTeL, Director of Online Development Cheney Tsai, Director of Online Designjinny Cho, Senior Editor juLia Love, Senior Editordan ahRens, Recruitment Chair jessiCa LiChTeR, Recruitment ChairMaRy WeaveR, Operations Manager ChRissy BeCk, Advertising/Marketing DirectorBaRBaRa sTaRBuCk, Production Manager ReBeCCa diCkenson, Chapel Hill Ad Sales Manager

The Chronicle is published by the duke student publishing Company, inc., a non-profit corporation independent of duke university. The opinions expressed in this newspaper are not necessarily those of duke university, its students, faculty, staff, administration or trustees. unsigned editorials represent the majority view of the editorial board. Columns, letters and cartoons represent the views of the authors.

To reach the editorial office at 301 flowers Building, call 684-2663 or fax 684-4696. To reach the Business office at 103 West union Building, call 684-3811. To reach the advertising office at 101 West union Building call 684-3811 or fax 684-8295. visit The Chronicle online at http://www.dukechronicle.com.

© 2010 The Chronicle, Box 90858, durham, n.C. 27708. all rights reserved. no part of this publication may be repro-duced in any form without the prior, written permission of the Business office. each individual is entitled to one free copy.

brandon maffeigiving back

Let me be the first to say it in public: Thank you, Larry Moneta.

Thank you for saving Duke’s undergraduate popula-tion from itself.

Why the 14-year-old passing out in a Porta Potty was the straw that broke the camel’s back—and not the junior doing coke off the hood of a car (UNC Tailgate, 2004), or the time there were nine EMS calls (Richmond Tailgate, 2009), or the general appearance of every single Tail-gate since tailgate underwent its malig-nant conversion into Tailgate—is beyond me. But still, better late than never.

Let’s get your objections out of the way first. Yes, I’m a crusty graduate student. Yes, what I think about Tailgate should have no bearing on its future. Yes, you should be able to have your good times the same way that I had mine.

But:1. I’m an alumnus, and I care about my alma

mater;2. I’m old enough that not all of my decisions are

awful ones, and I’m young enough that I still remem-ber what it was like to have fun;

3. So maybe I’m in a fairly unique position to con-tribute here.

If you don’t buy that, more power to you. Moneta’s going to cancel Tailgate regardless. (And regardless of how many students come to a Main Quad protest Tail-gate this Saturday.)

Some historical perspective may be in order.Tailgate—as we know it, with costumes, spandex

and beer showers—is not a grand historical tradition on the level of the Magna Carta or even Krzyzewskiville. Around 2000, a small number of students (mostly ath-letes) started wearing costumes during their Blue Zone tailgates. When I showed up in the Fall of 2003, Chron-icle columnist Jonathan Ross actually wrote, “Football games are huge at most Division I schools, with tailgat-ing and parties and all that, but here, they’re almost an afterthought.”

In the summer of 2004, thanks to visiting fans’ com-plaints that students vandalized their cars and the ef-forts of heretofore unrecognized Tailgate heroes Ted Roof and Joe Alleva, student tailgaters gained exclusive use of the back lot in the Blue Zone. Perhaps not coin-cidentally, most alumni remember 2004 as the year that tailgating became Tailgate. Following a “ruckus” (The Chronicle’s words) at the final tailgate of the year, the 2005 tailgating season was marked by the official par-ticipation of University administrators, who monitored the situation in the Blue Zone and passed out free hot dogs. Green-shirted student leaders wore shirts embla-zoned with the legend “Don’t Fumble the Tradition” and herded students into the football game before kick-off.

Tailgate 2005 was somewhat different than Tailgate

2010. It was held in the back lot of the Blue Zone, a larger space than the first lot. There was free food and water. It was supervised by University administrators

and cops, rather than just cops. Student groups were permitted to bring grills into Tailgate, and many of them did, in-cluding my own fraternity. I have no idea if any of this reduced hospitalizations, fistfights or cocaine abuse, but I do know that I brought my own younger brother to one of these Tailgates and that he didn’t wind up passed out in a portable toilet.

Still, Moneta and the rest of the Stu-dent Affairs people decided that Tailgate,

as it stood then, was “extremely unsafe,” and essentially made the decision to stop supporting a centralized Tail-gate in favor of a more protean vision of tailgating. But the administration’s official pull-out was not the death-knell for Tailgate. Instead, it just moved from the back of the Blue Zone to the front lot where it is now. Since then, with occasional changes—off-and-on (mostly off) official University support, a guest policy, a cars policy, a 30-case-per-vehicle policy—Tailgate has looked pretty much the same.

Looking back on it, Tailgate 2005 seemed both fun and safe, with decentralized clumps of students freely mingling around grills and baby pools filled with beer. Actually, it seemed an awful lot like a tailgate at any other school in the country. Tailgate 2010, meanwhile, looks like a cross between a riot and an orgy, which is 75 percent awesome, but also 25 percent dangerous. Especially if you’re 14.

The major difference between the Tailgates of my “youth,” and the current Tailgates appears to be the active involvement and presence of University admin-istration, rather than just the imposition of limits and restrictions.

Obviously, this makes sense. Adolescents (and here we include anyone younger than, say, 22) are neuro-logically programmed to make poor decisions. Put a thousand adolescents in an enclosed space, allow them to police themselves with no input from real adults, and you’re going to get a bad result. It’s like “Lord of the Flies,” except with beer.

So here’s some unsolicited advice, for Moneta and the rest of the undergraduate leaders who are appar-ently going to hammer out a Tailgate plan this Spring: More free food and water. More involvement by Uni-versity administrators. More grills. More T-shirts with clever slogans. More incentives (basketball tickets?) for students to behave themselves and actually attend foot-ball games.

The tradition may be fumbled, but the game is not yet lost.

Alex Fanaroff is a fourth-year medical student. His column runs every Wednesday.

commentariesthe chronicle wednesday, november 10, 2010 | 11

City lights

letterstotheeditorTailgate cancellation—it’s about time

As a Duke student and Durham native, I am always acutely aware that the “Duke bubble” does not extend to athletic events. Non-student football and basketball specta-tors often consist of my neighbors, my friends’ parents and my parents’ coworkers. I ran into a middle-school-aged girl from my neighborhood at a football game this season, and later found out that she had been relieved to find me so “nicely dressed.” I had been wearing a ratty Duke sweatshirt and basketball shorts, hardly “nice” by real-world standards, but in stark contrast to many of my peers dressed in span-dex and drenched in Busch Light. Family members who are Duke alums (even as recent as ’00) have also expressed confusion about and disapproval of Tailgate. Tailgate is not a Duke tradition, and I’m glad to see it go.

Laurel Burk Trinity ’13

Discrepancies in administration’s support of extracurriculars What angers and disappoints me the most about the

administration’s decision to cancel Tailgate is the idea that the football team deserves more support than other student organizations and on-campus events.

I’m tired of Coach Cutcliffe and Larry Moneta trying

to make me feel guilty for not caring about or supporting Duke football. Coach Cutcliffe, why didn’t the football team show up to support me last Spring when I represent-ed Duke in a global health case competition at Research Triangle Park?

My point is not that the football team should have shown up at my competition or that Moneta should have sent out an e-mail to the student body to chastise it for not heavily at-tending my event. I believe that both are unfair expectations given the legitimate differences in interest among students. The discourse surrounding this decision should be about more than whether Duke students should be supported by the University as they get drunk in Halloween costumes—it should also focus on unseating the assumption that certain kinds of extra-curricular participation should be encour-aged and supported more than others.

Brian ClementTrinity ’11

Clarifying costs of housing for financial aid students In his column, “Anticipating unknown unknowns”

Gregory Morrison states that “the differential [housing] fees... have been abolished.” We feel it is necessary to clarify that the fees remain in place, but do not apply to students

on financial aid.In addition to raising over $300 million for financial aid

and limiting or eliminating parental contribution and stu-dent loans based on family income, the Financial Aid Initia-tive of 2005-2008 also eliminated the differential on-campus housing costs for students on financial aid. As a result, stu-dents receive financial aid based on the actual cost of their housing no matter where they live on campus. This means that it does not cost a student on aid more to live in a single room than it does for them to live in a triple. However, this and other pertinent information has often been unclear to the students who base decisions on such factors.

Students on financial aid must be accurately informed about how their financial aid factors into the costs associated with being a Duke student beyond just tuition. Through this and other efforts, they should be able to participate in cam-pus life in the same way as students who do not receive aid. Duke must not just consider financial resources as a barrier to enrollment, but also to equal participation in campus life.

Alison Rabil, Assistant Vice Provost and Director, Office of Financial Aid

Brooke Kingsland, Chair, DSG Financial Aid Advisory Committee Trinity ’11

Tradition fumbledYesterday I played a game I haven’t since childhood.

It was Jell-O, the car game also known as statue, where you sit rigid unless the car moves you and fall against

windows and into neighbors’ laps. The terrain made for an especially challenging game. The road wound right and left on a cliff above the ocean. The waters below were those of leg-ends—the Cape of Africa that sailors have feared for centu-ries. We had spent the last two weeks on these beaches study-ing for exams and examining the invertebrates in tidal pools.

On this drive, were headed back to Cape Town from a marine reserve called De Hoop—“the hope” in Afrikaans, for The Cape of Good Hope, a moun-tainous, rocky area with white dunes, zebra and southern right whales. The next morning, we would fly on a northward diago-nal to Johannesburg and drive seven hours to Kruger: home. Life in the Cape, which included our mid-semester break of climbing mountains, surfing and nights out in Cape Town, was a life more similar to that I lived in the States.

When we first reached Pretoria in the middle of October, I had not seen a vehicle moving faster than 30 miles per hour in two months. The city, its traffic lights, crowds, Jacaranda trees in rows, hawkers, and strangers were, understatedly, over-stimulating. We spent two days there and in Johannes-burg visiting museums before flying to Cape Town.

We had in some ways longed for the city while we lived in the bush; a chance to enter a room with our hair sleek and clean, our eyelashes coated in mascara and not red savannah dust. But by the time I adjusted to urban commotion enough to enjoy any of those small pleasures of civilization, I longed to return to Kruger again. I missed the comfortable sleep that comes only from breathing fresh air, waking up to a day of work outdoors, and how I hear hyenas who-whooing outside my window. I felt a strange sorrow being in the polished civiliza-tion that was Cape Town, a reminder that in December I would leave this country for busy roads and downtowns back home.

“Cape Town is not like the rest of Africa,” a South Afri-can classmate told me.

Cape Town was brilliant. I climbed into the mist to the top of Table Mountain, snorkeled with Cape fur seals, bar-hopped and watched surfers in Kalk Bay, but nothing about the city and the thrills it offered could rival how much better I felt a week later, when we stayed at a marine reserve and moved our mattresses into a field to sleep outside under stars.

My life at Duke is full of commotion and crowds. Though I miss many parts of it, I was reminded, when I went to Cape Town, that soon I would have to leave my life in the field. I was happy when our bus pulled into the Kru-ger gate, happy to see the savannah again, greener with the rains we’d missed in our month away.

Rachna Reddy is a Trinity junior. She is studying ecology in South Africa for the semester. Her column runs every other Wednesday.

rachna reddyfield notes

alex fanarofffarewell tour

12 | wednesday, november 10, 2010 the chronicle

lunch together, as they once did, and frequently choose to live outside Washington D.C.

As a result, Brooks said, congressmen are less able to reach across the aisle, for fear of losing the party support necessary for re-election. The columnist said he thinks the broken system will render America un-able to avoid the national bankruptcy and financial meltdown he believes is currently inevitable. In order to change course American government needs a “total system reformation,” he said.

Brooks said that President Barack Obama has worsened the problem by pushing an aggressive agenda insensitive to the na-tion’s economic fears. He noted that the president set in mo-tion 131 major initiatives in his first six months with an admin-istration that Brooks described as “woefully understaffed.”

Tuesday’s midterm “shellacking,” as Obama called it, was a message from voters that they did not like his leg-islative priorities, especially his decision to push health care reform when nationwide unemployment was hov-ering at its highest rates in a decade, Brooks said. Just as Bush’s failed policies helped Obama take office two years ago, he said, the president’s agenda to date has fostered voter discontent and engendered grassroots movements like the Tea Party.

Although Brooks believes that the rise of the Tea Party is representative of a desire to reform government, he said the movement itself relies on twisting the truth and ma-nipulating societal ignorance to gain a following.

Brooks insists the solution lies with America’s third ideological tradition: centrism. He said centrists want “a limited but energetic government to enhance social mobility,” but find themselves hampered by an insuffi-cient fund-raising apparatus and an inability to spread their message.

Still, Brooks remains hopeful that the system can change.

“I maintain my optimism against all sanity,” he said. “There has to be change in intellectual landscape, change in the institutional landscape and change in the political landscape.”

Brooks, who was a guest professor at Duke in Fall 2006, was invited to speak at the Sanford School of Public Policy

by Gridlock, a new program that aims to find solutions to restructuring America’s inefficient bureaucracy.

“When walking around Duke, [Brooks] gazed into an empty classroom and remembered when he was a guest lecturer here,” said David Schanzer, co-founder of the Gridlock program and associate professor of the prac-tice for public policy. “He spoke nostalgically about the free flow of creative ideas in that class. He sees that as the promising future of America.”

Brooks concluded his remarks by conveying his faith in that future.

“[This is] the most wholesome generation in his-tory,” he said, noting that the next generation to enter Washington will be able to boast a third fewer teenage pregnancies and abortions than this one.

His remarks seemed to resonate with students in atten-dance.

“I was very impressed by his open consideration of various Democratic and Republican party strategies, with equal critique for both,” freshman Jack Wagner said. “[But] I think maybe his views of sweeping systematic change might be hyperbolic and idealistic.”

ADVERTISEMENT

A quesadilla so loaded,It might just buy you dinner.

great food. low price. open late.

1920 1/2 Perry St. at Ninth St. Just a block from East Campus

10% off with Duke ID!

Researcher discovers happiness enzyme in off-campus food

Make the Holidays Happy for a Family in Need

Project Share 2010Family #38 – This grandmother is barely making ends meet as she raises her four grandchildren and cares for her ailing husband. She is deeply sad-dened that she has no extra money to purchase gifts for her family. Please make one of her wishes come true by providing gifts for her grandchildren to find as they awaken on Christmas morning.

Family #177 – This single mom is raising her eight year-old son who has been diagnosed with leukemia and hearing loss. She is struggling to keep her job while keeping his many medical appointments. She would love to provide her son with some well-deserved holiday cheer.

Family # 256 – Clothes and age appropriate toys will help these grandpar-ents bring holiday cheer to their seven year-old grandson who lives with them. Will you help?

Family #507 - This mother was recently laid off from her job and is barely maintaining her household with her unemployment benefits. She would love your help providing her three young boys with clothes and toys.

Family #512 – This visually impaired woman deserves to feel love and sup-port from the community during the holiday. Will you be the one to make the season a happier one for her?

To adopt a family or make a monetary contribution towards the pur-chase of gifts, call 684-4377 or visit our Web site, http://scvp.civic.duke.edu/main/philanthropic-programs/project-share

The Duke Office ofStudent Community Volunteer Programs

brooks from page 1

ted knudsen/the ChroniCle

New York Times columnist and political pundit David brooks spoke Tuesday at the sanford school of Public Policy’s Fleischman Commons. brooks addressed the polarization of Congress, among other topics.