Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2,...

71
Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2 , L. Kullmann 1 , J.-P. Onnela 2 , A. Chakraborti 2 , K. Kaski 2 , A. Kanto 3 1 Department of Theoretical Physics Budapest University of Technology and Economics, Hungary 2 Laboratory of Computational Engineering Helsinki University of Technology, Finland 3 Dept of Quantitative Methods in Economics and Management Science Helsinki School of Economics, Finland

Transcript of Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2,...

Page 1: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Networks of Companies from StockPrice Correlations

J. Kertész1,2, L. Kullmann1, J.-P. Onnela2, A. Chakraborti2, K. Kaski2,

A. Kanto3

1Department of Theoretical PhysicsBudapest University of Technology and Economics, Hungary

2Laboratory of Computational EngineeringHelsinki University of Technology, Finland

3Dept of Quantitative Methods in Economics and Management ScienceHelsinki School of Economics, Finland

Page 2: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Motivation• Financial market is a self-adaptive complex system;

many interacting units, obvious networking.

Networks: • Cooperation Most important and most difficult• Activity, ownership• Similarity

• Temporal aspects• Networks generated by time dependencies• Time dependent networks

• Revealing NW structure is crucial for understandingand also for pragmatic reasons (e.g., portfolio opt.)

Many groups active: Palermo, Rome, Seoul etc.

Page 3: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Outline

• Classification by Minimum Spanning Trees (MST) (Mantegna)

• Temporal evolution

• Relation to portfolio optimization

• Correlations vs. noise: Parametric aggregational classification

• Temporal correlations: Directed NW of influence

Page 4: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

• Daily price data for N=477 of NYSE stocks (CRSP of U. of Chicago), such as GE, MOT, and KO

• Time span S=5056 trading days: Jan 1980 – Dec 1999

Daily closure price of GE:

PGE(t)

Daily logarithmic price:

lnPGE(t)

Daily logarithmic return:

rGE(t)=lnPGE(t) – lnPGE(t-1)

Data: price and return

Page 5: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

For each window a correlation matrix is defined with

elements being the equal time correlation coefficients:

where ri ,rj Rt, .. denotes time average. Transformation to distance-matrix with elements:

Minimum spanning tree (MST), which is a graph linking N vertices (stocks) with N-1 edges such that the sum of distances is minimum. Efficient algorithms.

Correlations and distances

11 where,2222

t

ij

jjii

jijitij

rrrr

rrrr

02 where,)1(2

tij

NN

ttij

tij dd D

NN

t

C

TN

t

R

Page 6: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Central vertex

To characterise positions of companies in the tree theconcept of central vertex is introduced:

• Reference vertex to measure locations of other vertices, needed to extract further information from asset trees

• Central vertex should be a company whose price changes strongly affect the market; three possible criteria:

(1) Vertex degree criterion: vertex with the highest vertex degree, i.e., the number of incident edges; Local.

(2) Weighted vertex degree criterion: vertex with the highest correlation coefficient weighted vertex degree; Local.

(3) Center of mass criterion: vertex vi giving minimum value for mean occupation layer (l(t,vi)); Global.

Page 7: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Central vertex: comparison

(1) Vertex degree criterion (local): GE: 67.2%

(2) Weighted vertex degree criterion (local): GE: 65.6%

(3) Center of mass criterion (global): GE: 52.8%

Page 8: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Asset tree and clustersBusiness sectors (Forbes)

Yahoo data

Page 9: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Potts superparamagnetic clustering

Kullmann, JK, Mantegna

Antiferromagneticbonds

Page 10: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Mismatch between tree clusters and business sectors?

1. Random price fluctuations introduce noise to the system

2. Business sector definitions vary by institutions (Forbes…)

3. Historical data should be matched with a contemporary business sector definition

4. Classifications are ambiguous and less informative for highly diversified companies

5. MST classification mechanism imposes constraint

6. Uniformity and strength of correlations vary by business sector (c.f. Energy sector vs. Technology)

Asset tree clustering

Page 11: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Mean occupation layer

In order to characterise the spread of vertices onthe asset tree, concept of mean occupation layeris introduced:

where vc is the central vertex, lev(vi) denotes the

level of vertex vi , such that lev(vc) = 0.

Both static and dynamic central vertex may beused: exhibit similar behaviour Robustness

N

i

tic v

Nvtl

1

)lev(1

),(

Page 12: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Asset tree: topology change

Normal market topology crash topology

Yahoodata

Page 13: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Robustness of dynamic asset tree topology measured asthe ratio of surviving connections when moving by one step:

Single-step survival ratio:

Robustness: single-step survival

1

1

1

ttt EE

N

T = 4 years, T = 1 month

Page 14: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Tree evolution: multi-step survival

• Within the first region decay is exponential

• After this there is cross-over to power law behaviour:

(t,k) ~ t--z

T (y) t1/2 (y)

2 0.22 4 0.46 6 0.75

t1/2=0.12T

Half life vs. window width

Connections survived vs. time

Power lawdecay: z ≈1.2

ktttktt EEE

N

1, 1

1

Page 15: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

k=0

Page 16: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

k=1

Page 17: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

k=2

Page 18: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

k=4

Page 19: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

k=6

Page 20: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

k=12

Page 21: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

k=24

Page 22: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

k=36

Page 23: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

k=48

Page 24: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Distribution of vertex degrees

The topological nature of the network is studied by analysing the distribution of vertex degrees:

• Power law distribution would indicate scale-free topology, a feature unexpected by random network models

• Vandewalle et al. find for one year data while we found

• Power law fit ambiguous due to limited range of data1.01.21.08.1

2.2

Page 25: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Distribution of vertex degrees

• L: normal• R: crash

Page 26: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Portfolio optimisation In the Markowitz portfolio optimisation theory risks offinancial assets are characterised by standard deviations of average returns of assets:The aim is to optimise the asset weights wi so that the overall portfolio risk is minimized for a given portfolio return(minimum risk portfolio is uniquely defined)

1

min

1

1

1,

N

ii

N

iii

jij

N

jii

w

rwr

rrww

and

given

),Cov(2

1

0 iw :selling-short No

Page 27: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Weighted portfolio layerHow are minimum risk portfolio assets located on graph?

• Weighted portfolio layer is defined

by imposing no short-selling, i.e. wi 0, and it is

compared with the mean occupation layer l(t).

Page 28: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Portfolio layer

No short-selling Short-selling

portfolio layer mean occupation layer

Static c.v. Static c.v.

Dynamic c.v. Dynamic c.v.

Page 29: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Correlations vs. noise

Correlation matrix contains systematics and noise.

MST: Non-parametric, unique classification scheme, but!

Even for uncorrelated random matrix MST would lead to

classification…

Meaningful clustering and robustness already signalize significance.

Different methods to separate noise from information:• Eigenvalue spectra (Boston, Paris)• Independent/principal component analysis

(economists)

Page 30: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Here: Building up the FCGTree condition may ignore important correlations.

(General classification problem) Visualization through Parametrized Aggregated Classification (PAC): Add links one by one to the graph, according to their rank, started by the strongest and ended with a Fully Connected Graph (FCG). Strongly correlated parts get early interconnected, clustering coefficient becomes high.

Price time series data for a set of 477 companies.Window width T=1000 business days (4 years), located at the beginning of the 1980’s

Comparison with random graph (obtained by shuffling thedata)

Ci = # of -s / [k(k-1) / 2] where k is the degree of node i

Page 31: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 0

Page 32: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 10

Page 33: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 20

Page 34: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 30

Page 35: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 40

Page 36: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 50

Page 37: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 60

Page 38: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 70

Page 39: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 80

Page 40: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 90

Page 41: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 100

Page 42: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 120

Page 43: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 140

Page 44: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 160

Page 45: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 180

Page 46: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 200

Page 47: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 300

Page 48: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 400

Page 49: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 500

Page 50: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 600

Page 51: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 700

Page 52: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 800

Page 53: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size= 900

Page 54: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

size=1000

Page 55: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Elementary graph concepts

Graph size: number of edges in the graph (variable)

Graph order: number of vertices in the graph (constant)

Spanned graph order: number of vertices in the subgraph spanned by the edges, thus excluding the isolated vertices (variable)

These definitions can be applied also to clusters (two types)(1) edge cluster(2) vertex cluster

Edge clusters are more meaningful in the asset graph context

Page 56: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Cluster growth

The growth patterns of clusters can be divided into four topologically different types:

(I) Create a new cluster (two nodes and the incident edge) when neither of the two end nodes are part of an existing edge cluster (spanned cluster order +2, size +1)

(II) Add a node and the incident edge to an already existing edge cluster (spanned cluster order +1, size +1)

(III) Merge two edge clusters by adding an edge between them (combined spanned cluster size +1)

(IV) Add an edge to an already existing edge cluster, thus creating a cycle in it (spanned cluster size +1)

Page 57: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Cluster growth

empirical random

N=477

Page 58: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Spanned graph order

empirical random

N=477

Page 59: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Number of vertex clusters

empirical random

N=477

Page 60: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Cluster size for edge clusters

empirical random

N=477

Page 61: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Vertex degree distribution

empirical random

p=0.01N=477

Page 62: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Vertex degree distribution

empirical random

p=0.25N=477

Page 63: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Clustering coefficient

empirical random

N=116

Page 64: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Mean clustering coefficient

empirical random

N=116

Page 65: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

NO TIME REVERSAL SYM. ON THE MARKETS

Physics close to equilibrium: Time reversal symmetry (TRS) Detailed balance

Symmetric correlation functions, Fluctuation Dissipation Th. (FDT)

No fundamental principle forcing TRS on the market. In contrast: The elementary process, a transaction is irreversible:Though the price is set by equilibrating supply and demand, both parties (or at least one of them) feel that the transaction is for their advantage and would not agree to revert it.

Possibility of • Asymmetry in the cross correlation functions• Differences between the decay of spontaneous fluctuations and of response to external perturbations

Page 66: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Time dependent cross correlations

log return of stock A between t and tt

Correlation fn between returns of company A and BIt depends on t and . Is it symmetric?

Difficulties: • trade not syncronized, frequencies are very different • bad signal/noise ratio

Approptiate averaging

Page 67: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Toy model to test the method:Persistent 1d random walk (increment x 1):

We take two such walks, which are correlated, with increments x and y

The correlation function can be calculated:

We corrupt the data to have similar quality to real onesOnly 1% of the data are kept.

(o=200, =1000, =0.99)

Page 68: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

The measured correlations on a finite set of data depends on the averaging procedure (moving average)

The appropriate choice is t min t o

DATA set:Trade And Quote, 10000 companies tick by tick54 days: 195 companies traded more than 15000 timest = 100s but results checked for 50-500s.

Page 69: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Results

• We measure max, C(max), and R = C(max)/noise• Consider Imax I > 100, C(max) > 0.04, and R > 6 as ‘effect’

• Not all pairs of comp’s show the effect• Peak not only shifted but also asymmetric• Large, frequently traded companies ‘pull’ the smaller ones• Weak effect and short characteristic time (minutes)

XON: Exxon(oil)

ESV: Ensco(oil wells)

Page 70: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

• No chains• Many leaders for a follower• Many followers for a leader• Disconnected graph

Directed network of influence

Page 71: Networks of Companies from Stock Price Correlations J. Kertész 1,2, L. Kullmann 1, J.-P. Onnela 2, A. Chakraborti 2, K. Kaski 2, A. Kanto 3 1 Department.

Conclusions

• Networks constructed from cross correlations of stock price time series (MST, PAC)

• Though Cij noisy, much information content, useful forportfolio optimization

• MST robust, reasonable classification, interesting dyn. at crash-time

• Clusters (branches) not equally correlated, PAC reveals differences, separation of noise from info

• Asymmetric time dependent cross correlations lead to directed network of influence