N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010...

42
N-Hydrogen3 N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA

Transcript of N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010...

Page 1: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

N-Hydrogen3N-Hydrogen3Safe, Affordable, Efficient Safe, Affordable, Efficient

Hydrogen Now Hydrogen Now

N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D.

NHA 2010 Annual Conference

Long Beach, CA

Page 2: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Oil Experts See Supply Crisis in Five Years

International Energy Agency

July 10, 2007

Page 3: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

US military warns oil output may dip causing massive shortages by 2015• Shortfall could reach 10m barrels a day, report says

Surplus oil production capacity could disappear by 2012 a report from US Joint Forces Command, says. Photograph: Katja Buchholz/Getty Images

Source: guardian.co.uk

Page 4: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Mid EastMid East

Page 5: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Energy Independence GoalsEnergy Independence Goals

Use U.S. Resources for U.S. Energy NeedsEliminate Petroleum ImportsProvide a Bridge to Renewable EnergyProtect the EnvironmentCreate U.S. Jobs/Improve EconomyEliminate NH3 Imports

Page 6: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Background InformationBackground Information

Page 7: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Source: Ewald Breunesse, Shell Netherlands, 14th IAMA Annual World Conference, Montreux, June 14th 2004

The Fossil Fuel EraThe Fossil Fuel Era

% of totalTraditional

- Biomass - Wind- Water- Animals

Fossil Fuels

- Mechanical- Combustion - High temperature

Renewables

- Electric - Low temperature- Catalysts

0%

25%

50%

75%

100%

1800 1850 1900 1950 2000 2050 2100 2150

Page 8: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Oil ReservesOil Reserves

Page 9: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Compiled from “Worldwide Look at Reserves and Production,” Oil & Gas Journal, Vol. 104, No. 47 (December 18, 2006), pp. 24-25.

World Crude Oil Reserves Jan 2007

1,317.4 billion barrels 7,749 quads

(Coal: 22,171 quads)

(NG: 5.500 quads)

OPEC Share (68%)

Page 10: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Natural Gas ReservesNatural Gas Reserves

Page 11: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

World Total: 5500 Tcf, 5500 quads(Petroleum: 7749 quads)(Coal: 22,171 quads)

Source: PetroStrategies, Inc.

Page 12: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Coal ReservesCoal Reserves

Page 13: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

USDoE - EIA, unpublished data, Coal Reserves Database (April 2007). World Energy Council, 2004 Survey of Energy Resources, Eds. J. Trinnaman and A. Clarke (London, UK: Elsevier, December 2004).

World Recoverable Coal Reserves, Jan 2003

997.7 billion short tons22,171 quads

Oil: 7,749 quadsNG: 5.500 quads

Page 14: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

The Ideal Transportation FuelThe Ideal Transportation Fuel•Can be produced from any raw energy source (i.e. wind, solar, biomass, coal, nuclear, hydro etc.) Don’t exclude wind, solar, hydro and nuclear energy as potential transportation fuel sources!!!

•Is cost effective

•Has significant storage and delivery systems already in place

•Environmentally friendly

•Can be used in any prime mover (i.e. diesel engines, fuel cells, SI engines, gas turbines, etc.)

•Has a proven, acceptable safety record

•Produced in the U.S.

Page 15: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

N-Hydrogen3 Basics N-Hydrogen3 Basics NH3 can be produced from any raw energy

source, including all fossil, renewable and nuclear sources.

NH3 is cost competitive with gasoline as a transportation fuel

NH3 has extensive, worldwide transportation and storage infrastructure already in place

NH3 is very environmentally friendly when used as a transportation fuel and produces only N2 and H20 at the tailpipe with low-cost emissions controls.

NH3 is safer than propane and as safe as gasoline when used as a transportation fuel.

NH3 has been successfully demonstrated in SI engines, CI engines, and fuel cells.

Page 16: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

N-Hydrogen3 Basics N-Hydrogen3 Basics The U.S. imported over 50% of it’s nitrogen

fertilizer for the first time in 2004 and continues to import increasingly more than it produces domestically

NH3 high cost partially due to highly seasonal nature of use (inefficient use of infrastructure)

NH3 has been produced from coal in Beulah, North Dakota for decades and with CO2 capture since 2000. China has huge coal to NH3 capacity.

Cellulosic NH3 can be produced via commercially available technologies.

Page 17: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

cng

Page 18: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Freedom Car Targets w/ 2005 Freedom Car Targets w/ 2005 NH3 ComparisonNH3 Comparison

Parameter Units 2007 2010 2015 NH3 (2005)

Spec. Energy kWh/kg 1.5 2 3 3.0

Energy Density kWh/L 1.2 1.5 2.7 2.7

Storage Cost $/kWh 6 4 2 2.1

Fuel Cost $/gal. Gas equiv 3 1.5 1.5 1.7*

*$280/ton NH3

Page 19: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Fuel CostsFuel Costs

$/MMBtu NH3 - $200/tonne (Tampa, 1/10) $10.01 Methanol - $0.79/gallon* $13.68 NH3 - $350/short ton (coal) $19.26 NH3 - $415/tonne (Tampa, 4/10) $20.77 Ethanol - $1.65/gallon $21.69 Gasoline - $2.50/gallon $21.92 Gasoline - $3.50/gallon $30.69 Wind NH3-$1000/short ton (estimate) $55.02

Page 20: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Future CompatibilityFuture Compatibility

Hydrogen + Nitrogen

NH3

Storage & Delivery – Pipeline, Barge, Truck, Rail

Stationary Power Fertilizer Transportation

Page 21: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Delivery InfrastructureDelivery Infrastructure

Page 22: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

NH3 Storage & TransportNH3 Storage & Transport

Page 23: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

NHNH33 and Gaseous H and Gaseous H22 Transport Transport

H2 (104 bar)

12”, 1k mile H2 Pipeline

12”, 1k mile NH3 Pipeline

NH3 Synthesis

H2 Comp. 690 bar

2.22 kWhe/kg H2

10,580 GJ -4.9% (loss)

4.16 kWhe/kg H2

19823 GJ

-19.0% (loss)

Assume: H2/NH3 used to gen. kWhe @ 55% Eff.

0.31 kWhe/kg H2 1477 GJ -0.7% (loss)

1.85 kWhe/kg H2 8815 GJ -8.5% ( loss)

184,507 GJ 84.9% eff.

75,712 GJ 72.5% eff.

736 t/day H2

104,350 GJ/day1,531 t/day H2

217,065 GJ/day

0.9

Page 24: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

NHNH33 and Cryogenic H and Cryogenic H2 2 StorageStorage

H2 (104 bar)

H2 Liquefaction

NH3

Liquefaction

NH3 Synthesis

Liquid H2 Storage

2.22 kWhe/kg H2

18,409 GJ -4.9% (loss)

10.0 kWhe/kg H2

165,313 GJ

-44.7% (loss)

Assume: H2/NH3 used to gen. kWhe @ 55% Eff.

0.03 kWhe/kg H2 432 GJ -0.1% (loss)

1.82 kWhe/kg H2 8672 GJ -2.3% ( loss)

320,636 GJ 84.9% eff.

203,716 GJ 53.9% eff.

2,664 t H2

377,701 GJ2,664 t H2 377,701 GJ

Liquid NH3

Storage

0.18 kWhe/kg H2 2597 GJ -0.6% (loss)

0.9

Page 25: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

U.S. NH3 PipelineU.S. NH3 Pipeline

3000 Miles Total

Page 26: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Natural Gas PipelinesNatural Gas Pipelines

Page 27: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Crude Oil PipelinesCrude Oil Pipelines

Page 28: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Refined Products PipelinesRefined Products Pipelines

Page 29: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

CaliforniaCaliforniaHydrogenHydrogenStationsStations

http://www.fuelcellpartnership.org/fuel-vehl_map_print.html

Page 30: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Iowa Hydrogen Refueling Iowa Hydrogen Refueling StationsStations

Over 800 retail NH3 (the “Other Hydrogen”) outlets currently exist in Iowa.

Page 31: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

NH3 Refueling StationNH3 Refueling Station

Page 32: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Anhydrous ApplicationAnhydrous Application

Anhydrous NH3 expands into a gas as it is injected into the soil where it rapidly

combines with soil moisture.

Page 33: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

End Use ApplicationsEnd Use Applications

•Spark-Ignition Internal-Combustion Engines (w/ethanol)

•Diesel Engines (w/biodiesel and/or DME)

•Direct NH3 Fuel Cells

•Gas Turbines

•Gas Burners (including residential furnaces)

Page 34: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

SafetySafety NH3 is a common, naturally occurring chemical found in all

animal life forms. It is not a carcinogen and is not a greenhouse gas.

NH3 is safer than propane and as safe as gasoline when used as a transportation fuel.

Iowa Energy Center funded comparative quantitative risk assessment (CQRA) study completed by March 2009, Quest Consultants Inc., Norman, Oklahoma

“Safety assessment of NH3 as a transportation fuel”, Nijs Jan Duijm, Frank Markert, Jette Lundtang Paulsen, Riso National Laboratory, Denmark, February 2005

NH3 plant operators NH3 safety is an engineering issue. It can be made to be as

safe as is necessary. NH3 is classified by DOT as a non-flammable liquid and an

inhalation hazard (not a poison)

Page 35: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Scapegoat?Scapegoat?NH3 NH3

Ephedrine and Pseudoephedrine C10H15NO

Methamphetamine C10H15N

VOC’s + NOx + O2 + Sunlight = ozone = smog+

NOx + H2O + NH3 = ammonium nitrate = smog-

If the NOx doesn’t form ammonium nitrate it goes to ozone (worse)

Fossil fuels (the source of NOx ) are the problem, not NH3

NH3 is actually used to clean up NOx emmissions at coal plants

Page 36: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

CQRA Study – NH3, Propane, GasolineCQRA Study – NH3, Propane, GasolineTransport TrucksTransport Trucks

Page 37: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

CQRA Study – NH3, Propane, GasolineCQRA Study – NH3, Propane, GasolineRefueling StationRefueling Station

10-6

10-6

10-6

Page 38: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Progress 1Progress 1•Flex fuel (gasoline/NH3) vehicle successfully driven from Michigan to California (NH3 Car)

•Demonstrated in a SI engine (HEC)

•Irrigation pump demonstration with SI engine (HEC)

•Direct NH3 fuel cell bench-scale demonstration (Howard U.)

•1.5 Mw wind to NH3 demonstration funded, construction underway (U. Minn. Morris)

•95% NH3, 5% diesel, 110% rated power in a John Deere diesel engine (IEC/ISU)

Page 39: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Progress 2Progress 2•New NH3 synthesis technologies under development that match well with renewable energy sources.

•NH3 trademarked as “The Other Hydrogen TM” (HEC)

•Comparative quantitative risk assessment (CQRA) report completed. (IEC)

•NH3 Fuel Network (AFN) website established

•Focused RFP for NH3 research/demonstration issued, grants awarded (IEC)

Page 40: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Economic ImpactsEconomic Impacts

T Boone Pickens - $700 Billion new U.S. industry.

Page 41: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Summary 1Summary 1 Any known transportation fuel has some associated safety

risks but NH3 is as safe as gasoline and safer than propane when used as a transportation fuel.

NH3 meets most 2015 Freedom Car targets today NH3 has a very extensive, worldwide transportation and

storage infrastructure already in place. With relatively minor modifications, existing oil and natural gas pipelines could be converted to transport NH3

Only H2 and NH3 have no tailpipe greenhouse gas emissions

Only H2 and NH3 can be made from electricity and water (+air for NH3)

NH3 can replace diesel fuel, gasoline, natural gas and propane in all fuel applications

Page 42: N-Hydrogen3 Safe, Affordable, Efficient Hydrogen Now N. Olson P.E., J. Holbrook Ph.D. NHA 2010 Annual Conference Long Beach, CA.

Summary 2Summary 2 NH3 is the world’s most hydrogen dense chemical by

volume, ~50% greater than liquid hydrogen. Results in outstanding green energy storage capability.

NH3 from coal, natural gas and nuclear energy now NH3 from renewables in the near future (Including wind,

solar, OTE and hydro!) NH3 diesel (CI) and spark-ignition (SI) engines now Direct NH3 fuel cells in the near future NH3 is an very prevalent, naturally occurring chemical NH3 looks very good now and in the future Hydrogen stored, delivered and utilized in the form of NH3

may be the key to cost-effective, near-term U.S.A. energy independence