Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 ·...

67
Mixture classification - exercises Seminar for Baltic States Outi Tunnela ECHA Helpdesk

Transcript of Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 ·...

Page 1: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

Mixture classification - exercises Seminar for Baltic States

Outi Tunnela

ECHA Helpdesk

Page 2: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 2

Examples: How are cut-off values used?

Page 3: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 3

Cut-off values

Ingredient w%

LD50(mg/kg)

Classification

Anionic surfactant

9.2 >5000 Not classified

Thickening agent

0.8 3600 Skin Irrit. 2

Water 90 Not classified

Example 1: Below cut-off value 1%. The mixture is not classified as Skin Irrit. 2.

Ingredient w% LD50(mg/kg)

Classification

Anionic surfactant

8.2

>5000

Not classified

Thickening agent

1.8

Skin Irrit. 2

Water 90 Not classified

Example 2: Above cut-off value 1%. The mixture might be classified.

Page 4: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 4

Sum of ingredients classified as:

Concentration triggering classification of a mixture as:

Skin Corrosive Skin Irritant

Category 1 Category 2

Skin Corrosive Categories 1A, 1B, 1C ≥ 5 % ≥ 1 % but < 5 %

Skin irritant Category 2 ≥ 10 %

(10* x Skin Corrosive Category 1A, 1B, 1C) + Skin irritant Category 2 ≥ 10 %

Generic concentration limits for skin corrosion/irritation Additivity approach applies Generic concentration limits of ingredients classified that trigger classification of the mixture (Table 3.2.3 of Annex I)

* Weighting factor of 10 if Category 1 component ≥ 1% but ≤ 5% in a mixture

Page 5: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 5

Ingredient classified as:

Concentration triggering classification of a mixture as:

Repr. tox cat. 1A Repr. tox cat. 1B

Repr.tox cat.2

Effects on or via lactation

Repro cat. 1A ≥ 0,3 %

Repro cat. 1B ≥ 0,3 %

Repro cat. 2 ≥ 3,0 %

Effects on or via lactation

≥ 0,3 %

Generic concentration limits for reproduction toxicity/effects on or via lactation Additivity approach does not apply Generic concentration limits of classified ingredients that trigger classification of the mixture (Table 3.7.2 of Annex I)

Page 6: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 6

Example: Methods for mixture classification

Page 7: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 7

Acute toxicity, when Data available for all ingredients: • In order to ensure that classification of the mixture is accurate and

that the calculation need only be performed once, the acute toxicity estimate (ATE) of ingredients shall be considered:

• Include ingredients with a known acute toxicity, which fall into any of the

acute toxicity categories shown in Table 3.1.1 • Ignore ingredients that are presumed not acutely toxic (e.g., water,

sugar) • Ignore ingredients, if the oral limit test does not show acute toxicity at 2

000 mg/kg bodyweight.

Page 8: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 8

Calculation Method - Additivity formula

Acute Toxicity

Total concentration of the ingredient(s) with unknown toxicity is <= 10 %;

Total concentration of the ingredient(s) with unknown toxicity is >10 %;

Page 9: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 9

Exposure route Classification category or experimentally obtained acute toxicity range estimate

Converted acute toxicity point estimate

Oral (mg/kg bw)

0 < category 1 ≤ 5 5 < category 2 ≤ 50

50 < category 3 ≤ 300 300 < category 4 ≤ 2000

0,5 5

100 500

Table 3.1.2

Conversion values Where an ATE is not available for an ingredient of a mixture, but available information can provide a value derived from the conversion table, this conversion value may be used for calculation. Conversion from experimentally obtained acute toxicity range values (or acute toxicity hazard categories) to acute toxicity point estimates for classification of the respective routes of exposure

Page 10: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 10

EXAMPLE: How mixture A is classified?

MIXTURE A Concentration LD50 oral Classification

Substance 1 1% 225 mg/kg

Substance 2 3% 100 mg/kg

Substance 3 10% Acute tox. category 3, oral

Water 76%

Page 11: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 11

1. Step: conversion from hazard category to point estimate:

Table 3.1.2 (Annex 1)

Exposure route Classification category or experimentally obtained acute toxicity range estimate

Converted acute toxicity point estimate

Oral (mg/kg bw)

0 < category 1 ≤ 5 5 < category 2 ≤ 50

50 < category 3 ≤ 300 300 < category 4 ≤ 2000

0,5 5

100 500

Page 12: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 12

2. Step: calculation of ATEmixture

100

ATEmixture =∑

Ci

ATEi n

Concentration LD50 oral Classification

Substance 1 1% 225 mg/kg

Substance 2 3% 100 mg/kg

Substance 3 10% Acute tox, cat 3

Water 76%

100

ATEmixture

1

225

+ 3

100

+ 10

100 ATEmixture = 743 mg/kg bw =

ATE: 100

ATE: - LD50 or LC50-value, or - Converted value (point estimate) for acute toxicity from Table 3.1.2 in Annex I,

relating to a value from a range test or to a classification category

Page 13: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 13

3. Step:conversion from hazard category to point estimate:

Table 3.1.2 Exposure route Classification category or

experimentally obtained acute toxicity range estimate

Converted acute toxicity point estimate

Oral (mg/kg bw)

0 < category 1 ≤ 5 5 < category 2 ≤ 50

50 < category 3 ≤ 300 300 < category 4 ≤ 2000

0,5 5

100 500

ATEmixture = 743 mg/kg bw

Page 14: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 14

4. Step: classification of a mixture

100

ATEmixture =∑

Ci

ATEi n

Concentration LD50 oral Classification

Substance 1 1% 225 mg/kg

Substance 2 3% 100 mg/kg

Substance 3 10% Acute tox, cat 3

Water 76%

100

ATEmixture

1

225

+ 3

100

+ 10

100 ATEmixture = 743 mg/kg bw =

Classification: Acute tox. cat 4, oral

ATE: 100

Page 15: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 15

Example: Bridging principles

Page 16: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 16

Determine classification for the following mixture (substantially similar mixtures)

Bridging principles

• Starting point: 2 mixtures, ingredients [A], [B] and [C] • Mixture 1: [A] + [B] • Mixture 2: [C] + [B]

• Concentration of [A] ≅ [C] • Concentration of [B] similar in both mixtures

• B is a sensitiser! • A and C are not sensitisers

• If either mixture (1) or (2) has been tested, the other can be classified using bridging principles (substantially similar mixtures)

Page 17: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 17

0.1 Substance 5 0.1 Substance 5

0.9 Substance 4 0.9 Substance 4

3.0 Substance 3 3.0 Substance 3

91.2 Substance 2b 91.0 Substance 2a

4.8 Substance 1* 5.0 Substance 1*

weight % Ingredient weight % Ingredient

Not tested mixture (Product 6)

Tested mixture (Product 1)

* Skin sensitiser

Page 18: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 18

Additional information on the tested mixture

Product

Weight % of substance 1* in

product

Patch-tests in humans occurrence of

sensitision

Product 1 5.0 0/298

Product 2 6.0 0/198

Product 3 6.0 0/307

Product 4 5.0 0/197

Product 5 2.5 0/103

Sum: 0/1103

* Skin sensitiser

All 5 products tested in animals without a sensitising result

Page 19: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 19

solution

Non-tested product 6 is not classified as sensitising, based on the test results on product 1 and the additional information that supports this decision.

Page 20: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 20

solution

Tiered approach to classification of mixtures for acute toxicity

1) Testing (test data as primary source) • whole mixture tested • classification criteria applied as for substances

2) Bridging principles (Annex I, part 1) – sufficient data available for similar mixture • diluting • batching • concentrating of highly toxic mixtures • interpolation within one toxicity category • substantially similar mixtures • aerosols

3) Classification based on concentration of ingredients • formulas (acute toxicity) • concentration limits (tables; other hazards apart from acute tox)

If no data

If even this is not possible Also this is a possibility -> would result in product 6 being a sensitiser, because the conc. of substance 1* is over 1%

Page 21: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 21

EXAMPLE: Classification for ENV hazards

Page 22: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 22

22

Environmental hazard: Chronic Categories 1,2,3 and 4 - summation method (1)

Ingr. A

1%

Ingr. C

10%

Ingr. B

10%

Mixture:

Chronic Cat. 1 Chronic Cat. 1

Chronic Cat. 2

Page 23: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 23

23

EXAMPLE: Classification for ENV hazards (Chronic Categories 1,2,3 and 4) - summation method (2)

Ingr. A

1%

Ingr. C

10%

Ingr. B

10%

Step 1: use Table 4.1.2 of Annex 1(Classification of a mixture for chronic (long term) hazards, based on summation of classified components Mixture classified as Category Chronic 1, if ∑(Chronic Category 1 x M) ≥ 25%

Mixture:

Chronic Cat. 1 Chronic Cat. 1 Chronic Cat. 2

Page 24: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 24

24

25

50

75

100

1% x 10 = 10%

10% x 1 = 10%

Step 2: use the formula ∑(Chronic Category 1 x M)

Chronic 3

Chronic 2

Chronic 1, M1

Chronic 1, M10

Chronic 1, M100

Ingr. A

1%

Ingr. C

10%

Ingr. B

10%

10% + 10% = 20%, which is < 25%. Hence, mixture is not classified as Chronic 1.

Page 25: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 25

25

Step 3: use Table 4.1.2 of Annex 1(Classification of a mixture for chronic (long term) hazards, based on summation of classified components Mixture classified as Category Chronic 2, if ∑(Chronic Category 1 x M x 10) + ∑(Chronic Category 2) ≥ 25%

Page 26: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 26

26

Step 4: use the formula ∑(Chronic Category 1 x M x 10) + ∑(Chronic Category 2)

Chronic 3

Chronic 2

Chronic 1, M1

Chronic 1, M10

Chronic 1, M100

Igr. A

1%

Ingr. C

10%

Ingr. B

10%

100

200

300

1% x 10 x 10 = 100%

10% x 1 x 10 = 100%

10%

100% + 100% + 10% = 210%, which is ≥ 25%. Hence, mixture is classified as Chronic 2.

Page 27: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 27

27

CHRONIC

CATEGORY 2, H411

Step 5: final classification (according Table 4.1.2., Annex I):

Ingr. A

1%

Ingr. C

10%

Ingr. B

10%

Page 28: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 28

Example: Translation - Mixtures

Page 29: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 29

Example: Old (classification): Mixture is not classified and contains: 98% water 2% of substance with R34 (causes burns) New (translated classification): 1. Step: use the translation table – cannot be used 2. Step: use table 3.2.3 of Annex 1 to get Category: NOTE: the NEW generic concentration limit is 1% but the corresponding limit of OLD system is 5%!

Page 30: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 30

Table 3.2.3

Sum of ingredients classified as:

Concentration triggering classification of a mixture as:

Skin Corrosive Skin Irritant

Category 1 (see note below)

Category 2

Skin Corrosive Categories 1A, 1B, 1C

≥ 5 % ≥ 1 % but < 5 %

Skin irritant Category 2 ≥ 10 %

(10 × Skin Corrosive Category 1A, 1B, 1C) + Skin irritant Category 2

≥ 10 %

Generic concentration limits of ingredients classified for skin corrosive/irritant hazard (Category 1 or 2) that trigger classification of the mixture as corrosive/irritant to skin

Skin Irritant; Cat.2

Page 31: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 31

3. Step: use table 3.2.5 of Annex 1 to get H statement : 4. Step: determine the final classification Skin Irritant; Cat 2; H315 (Causes skin irritation)

Page 32: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 32

Mixture classification exercises

Page 33: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 33

Page 34: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 34

Environmental hazard

Mixture X with components A to F: Classification data is available for all components of the mixture Guidance on the Application of CLP Criteria, section 4.1.4

Page 35: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 35

Acute aquatic hazard

M Long-term aquatic hazard

M C (%)

A Acute 1 10 Chronic 1 10 1

B Acute 1 1 Chronic 2 - 3

C Not classified

- Chronic 2 - 10

D Not classified

- Chronic 3 - 10

E

Not classified

- Not classified

- 10

F Not classified

- Not classified

- 66

Information on ingredients, classification and concentration

Page 36: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 36

Which approach will you use?

Page 37: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 37

• Valid test data on the mixture as a whole (for all three trophic levels) is not available.

• Valid test data on similar tested mixtures is not available, either, meaning that any bridging principle cannot be used.

Therefore, classification should be considered based on

individual components using the summation method.

Page 38: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 38

Acute aquatic hazard:

• Information on classification & associated M-factors and the % of the components in the mixture are available.

• Classify for acute hazard if: Σ (Acute 1 x M) ≥ 25%

• Is it?

Page 39: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 39

(1 x 10) + (3 x 1) = 13 which is <25%. Hence, no classification for acute aquatic hazard.

Page 40: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 40

Long-term aquatic hazard Step 1: Classify as Chronic 1 if: Σ (Chronic 1 x M) ≥ 25% (if not, then go to

Step 2). Step 2: Classify as Chronic 2 if: Σ (10 x Chronic 1 x M) + Σ (Chronic 2) ≥

25% (if not, then go to Step 3). Step 3: Classify as Chronic 3 if: Σ (100 x Chronic 1 x M) + Σ (10 x Chronic 2)

+ Σ (Chronic 3) ≥ 25% (if not, then go to Step 4). Step 4: Classify as Chronic 4 if: Σ (Chronic 1) + Σ (Chronic 2) + Σ (Chronic 3) + Σ (Chronic 4) ≥ 25%

Page 41: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 41

Using the classification of the components of the mixture: Step 1: (1 x 10) = 10 (which is < 25% → Step 2).

Step 2: (10 x 1 x 10) + 3+10 = 113 (which is > 25%). Hence, classify as Category Chronic 2.

Page 42: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 42

Labelling elements based on the classification:

Element Aquatic hazard information that could appear on

the label

GHS Pictogram

Signal Word

Hazard Statement

Precautionary statement(s)

GHS09

-

H411

P273, P391, P501

Acute aquatic hazard:

Long-term aquatic hazard:

Not classified.

Category Chronic 2.

Aquatic hazard classification

Page 43: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available
Page 44: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 44

Mixture classification exercise 1: classification for acute toxicity

Mixture ingredients

Classification (by ingredient)

Conc. (% w/w) Info on testing

Animal tests (rat, oral)

1 ? 4 LD50: 125 mg/kg

2 - 92 N/A

3 ? 3 LD50: 1500 mg/kg

4 - 0,8 N/A

5 ? 0,2 LD50: 10 mg/kg

Physical properties have been tested -> no phys. hazards. No other test data.

Page 45: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 45

Mixture classification exercise 1: instructions

Check in CLP Annex I (pp. 81-87) the criteria for classification for acute toxicity

1) Check component classifications in table 3.1.1 (based on LD50-values):

• Component 1: Component 3: Component 5:

2) Consider if formula 3.1.3.6.1 or 3.1.3.6.2.3 should be used? • Unknown: ATEmixture

3) When you have ATEmixture, see table 3.1.1 for the classification of the mixture 4) Note the relevant ingredients from section 3.1.3.3 (p. 83) and table 1.1 (p. 38): Additional labelling?

Hazard class Generic cut-off values to be taken into account

Acute Toxicity: – Category 1-3 – Category 4

0,1 % 1 %

Skin corrosion/Irritation 1 %[1]

Serious damage to eyes/eye irritation

1 %[2]

Hazardous to Aquatic Environment – Acute Category 1 – Chronic Category 1 – Chronic Category 2-4

0,1 %[3] 0,1 %[4]

1 %

Page 46: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 46

Mixture classification exercise 1

3.1 Acute toxicity - ATE

• ATE: Acute Toxicity Estimate • LD50- or LC50 -value [mg/kg bw] OR • Converted acute toxicity point estimate for the classification of mixtures

when using ATEmixture formulas • Experimentally obtained acute toxicity range estimated • Classification category

• If LD50 or LC50 for mixture or its components is not known, but classification is known, a numerical value derived from classification can be used (for calculating acute toxicity)

Page 47: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 47

Mixture classification exercise 1

3.1 Acute toxicity - ATE

Table 3.1.1 Acute toxicity hazard categories and

acute toxicity estimates (ATE) defining the respective categories

Exposure Route Category 1 Category 2 Category 3 Category 4

Oral (mg/kg bodyweight) See Note (a) ATE ≤ 5 5 < ATE ≤ 50 50 < ATE ≤ 300 300 < ATE ≤ 2000

Dermal (mg/kg bodyweight) See Note (a)

ATE ≤ 50 50 < ATE ≤ 200

200 < ATE ≤ 1000

1000 < ATE ≤ 2000

Gases (ppmV[1]) see: Note (a) Note (b)

ATE ≤ 100 100 < ATE ≤ 500

500 < ATE ≤ 2500

2500 < ATE ≤ 20000

Vapours (mg/l) see: Note (a) Note (b) Note (c)

ATE ≤ 0,5 0,5 < ATE ≤ 2,0

2,0 < ATE ≤ 10,0

10,0 < ATE ≤ 20,0

Dusts and Mists (mg/l) see: Note (a) Note (b)

ATE ≤ 0,05 0,05 < ATE ≤ 0,5 0,5 < ATE ≤ 1,0 1,0 < ATE ≤ 5,0

[1] Gas concentrations are expressed in parts per million per volume (ppmV)

Page 48: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 48

Mixture classification exercise 1 3.1 Acute toxicity - ATE

Table 3.1.2 Conversion from experimentally obtained acute toxicity range values (or acute toxicity hazard categories) to acute toxicity point estimates for classification for the respective routes of exposure

Exposure routes Classification Category or experimentally obtained acute toxicity range estimate

Converted acute toxicity point

estimate (see Note 1)

Oral (mg/kg bodyweight)

0 < Category 1 ≤ 5 5 < Category 2 ≤ 50 50 < Category 3 ≤ 300 300 < Category 4 ≤ 2000

0,5 5

100 500

Dermal (mg/kg bodyweight)

0 < Category 1 ≤ 50 50 < Category 2 ≤ 200 200 < Category 3 ≤ 1000 1000 < Category 4 ≤ 2000

5 50 300 1100

Gases (ppmV)

0 < Category 1 ≤ 100 100 < Category 2 ≤ 500 500 < Category 3 ≤ 2500 2500 < Category 4 ≤ 20000

10 100 700 4500

Vapours (mg/l)

0 < Category 1 ≤ 0,5 0,5 < Category 2 ≤ 2,0 2,0 < Category 3 ≤ 10,0 10,0 < Category 4 ≤ 20,0

0,05 0,5 3 11

Dust/mist (mg/l)

0< Category 1 ≤ 0,05 0,05 < Category 2 ≤ 0,5 0,5 < Category 3 ≤ 1,0 1,0 < Category 4 ≤ 5,0

0,005 0,05 0,5 1,5

Page 49: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 49

Mixture classification exercise 1

3.1 Acute toxicity – ATE Data available for all ingredients ⇒ Formula 1:

• Ci= concentration of ingredient i • ATEi = Acute Toxicity Estimate of ingredient i • ATEmix = Acute Toxicity Estimate of mixture • n = number of ingredients

i ∑ = n i mix ATE

C

ATE

100

Page 50: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 50

Mixture classification exercise 1

3.1 Acute toxicity - ATE

Data is not available for all ingredients (ATE is not known) and the conc of such an ingredient is > 10% ⇒ Formula 2:

• Ci= concentration of ingredient i • Cunknown= conc. of ingredient of unknown acute toxicity • ATEi = Acute Toxicity Estimate of ingredient i • ATEmix = Acute Toxicity Estimate of mixture • n = number of ingredients

100 – ( Σ Cunknown >10 %) _______________________

ATE mix

= Ci _____

ATE i Σ n

Page 51: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 51

Mixture classification exercise 1: solution

Tiered approach to classification of mixtures for acute toxicity

1) Testing (test data as primary source) • whole mixture tested • classification criteria applied as for substances

2) Bridging principles (Annex I, part 1) – sufficient data available for similar mixture • diluting • batching • concentrating of highly toxic mixtures • interpolation within one toxicity category • substantially similar mixtures • aerosols

3) Classification based on concentration of ingredients • formulas (acute toxicity) • concentration limits (tables; other hazards apart from acute tox)

If no data

If even this is not possible

Page 52: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 52

Mixture classification exercise 1: solution

General strategy

• Relevant concentration limits for each hazard • For mixtures that must be classified according to the additivity principle (additive

effects: acute toxicity, skin and eye corrosion) • Table 1.1 is not always enough • Always check also criteria for mixture classif under respective hazard

• For each hazard: check possibilities to remove factors

• Ignore what is not relevant for the hazard in question • Conc. below the value taken into account / generic cut-off value • Not classified for that hazard • Is the conc. to be classified using additivity formula (additive effects: acute

toxicity, skin and eye corrosion)

• Remember the limit values relevant for SDS

Page 53: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 53

Mixture classification exercise 1: solution Ingredient classification from Table 3.1.1: • 1: category 3 (50-300 mg/kg) • 3: category 4 (300-2000 mg/kg) • 5: category 2 (5-50 mg/kg)

Mixture classification formula (Section 3.1.3.6.2.3, unknown ingredients > 10%): (100 – (Σ Cunknown if >10%))/ ATEmix = Σn Ci/ATEi 100 – 92/ ATEmix = 4/125 + 3/1500 + 0.2/10 8/ATEmix= 0.032 + 0.002 + 0.02 = 0.054 ATEmix = 148 mg/kg –> category 3 (acute toxicity)

• Additional labelling: ”92 % of the mixture consists of ingredients of

unknown toxicity” (Table 3.1.3, Note 2)

Page 54: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 54

Mixture classification exercise 1: solution

Justification: 1. No available test data for mixture

2. Use of bridging principles is not possible (no classified similar mixture; section

3.1.3.5.1)

3. Classification can be based on section 3.1.3.6: mixture classification when data NOT available for all components

4. Applying section 3.1.3.3(a), ”relevant ingredients” -> ingredient 4 is not taken into account in calculating ATEmix, because its conc. is < 1%, and other info is not available

5. Justification 4 cannot be used for ingredient 5, because the cut-off value for a category 2 substance is 0.1% in Table 1.1

6. Total conc. of ingredients, whose toxicity is unknown (i.e. ingredient 2), is 92% -> ATEmix formula in section 3.1.3.6.2.3 must be used (the over 10% rule)

7. ingredients 1, 3 and 5 are included in the formula, because their classification is one of acute tox categories (3.1.3.6.1 a).

8. Calculation uses real LD50 values for substances 1, 3 and 5 (Table 3.1.1, note a)

Page 55: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 55

Labelling for the classification obtained

• Choose the pictograms, signal word, hazard- and precautionary statements from Table 3.1.3

• Choose appr. 6 most suitable P-statements

• What else should there be on the label?

Page 56: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 56

Labelling

Acute toxicity cat. 3 + additional labelling ”92% of the mixture consists of ingredients of unknown toxicity”

Statements from Table 3.1.3:

• P501 • P-statement on disposal

• P405 • P-statement on storage

• P301 + P310 P321, P330

• P-statement on response

• P264, P270 • P-statement on prevention

• H301: Toxic if swallowed

• Hazard statement

• Danger • Signal word

• GHS-pictogram

• Acute toxicity category 3

• classification

Page 57: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 57

Labelling

MODEL Ingredient 1 Ingredient 3 Ingredient 5 92% of the mixture consists of ingredients of unknown toxicity

Toxic if swallowed. (Keep out of reach of children.) Do not eat, drink or smoke when using this product. IF SWALLOWED: Immediately call a POISON CENTER or doctor/physician. Store locked up. Dispose of contents/container according to local regulations. (5L)

Oy Tehdas Ab Tehdaskatu 1 33100 Tampere Tel. 03 111111

DANGER

Page 58: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 58

Labelling

Justification: • Elements from Table 3.1.3 • Most reasonable P-statements (CLP guidance (p.510), Art. 22+28, and

Guidance on labelling). • Volume must be mentioned if the product goes to consumer use, and if it not

mentioned elsewhere on the package. To products for consumer use also the statement ”Keep out of reach of children” must be added. (Annex IV, Table 6.1).

• Remember the child-resistant fastening and the tactile warning.

CLP, Art. 18: Product identifiers: 3. ... shall consist of both the following:

• The trade name or the designation of the mixture; • The identity of all substances in the mixture that contribute to the classification

of the mixture as regards acute toxicity, skin corrosion or serious eye damage, germ cell mutagenicity, carcinogenicity, reproductive toxicity, respiratory or skin sensitisation, specific target organ toxicity (STOT) or aspiration hazard.

If, in the case referred to in (b), this requirement leads to the provision of

multiple chemical names, a maximum of four chemical names shall suffice, unless more than four names are needed to reflect the nature and the severity of the hazards.

http://guidance.echa.europa.eu/docs/guidance_document/clp_en.pdf

Page 59: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available
Page 60: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 60

Mixture classification exercise 2 Classify for skin corrosion /irritation – mixture pH 2.5

Component Skin corrosion/ irritation class.

Conc. (% w/w)

SCL (specific conc. limit)

Surfactant C Cat 2 0,4

Surfactant D Cat 2 3.0

Surfactant A Cat 2 0,7

Hydrogen peroxide Cat 1A 3,0 C ≥ 70 %: skin Cat 1A 50 % ≤ C < 70 %: skin Cat

1B 35 % ≤ C < 50 %: skin Cat

2

Ethanol Not classified 2

Water Not classified 90.9

Mixture pH: 2.5 – 3.0 Mixture contains three surfactants, none of which are corrosive/ irritant under 1% (CLP Annex VI does not have specific concentration levels), and classification is determined by additivity principle

Page 61: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 61

Mixture classification exercise 2 Guide to solution

Decision logic in CLP guidance (p.238):

CLP Table 3.2.3

Note relevant ingredients!

GCL :

Page 62: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 62

Mixture classification exercise 2 Guide to solution

If the classification of a mixture can be determined with the additivity approach, and if some of the components have specific concentration limits, the following formula can be used:

Mixture is classified skin corrosive / irritant, if • Sum (ConcA / clA) + (ConcB / clB) + ….+ (ConcZ / clZ) on ≥ 1

• Where ConcA = conc of substance A in the mixture

clA = conc limit (specific or generic) of substance A ConcB = conc of substance B in the mixture clB = conc limit (specific or generic) of substance B

etc. • This formula can be found in the CLP Guidance (p.234) and in Directive 1999/45/EC.

Page 63: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 63

Mixture classification exercise 2 Guide to solution

General strategy • Concentration limits to be taken into account for each hazard class

• For mixtures that must be classified using the additivity principle (additive effects: acute toxicity, skin and eye corrosion /irritation)

• table 1.1. is not always enough • Always check also the criteria for that hazard under ”classification criteria for mixtures”

• For each hazard check the possibilities to remove factors • ”off with what is not relevant for the hazard class”

• Concentration under the relevant concentration limits • Not classified in that hazard class • Should that concentration be classified using the additivity principle (additive effects: acute toxicity, skin and eye corrosion

/irritation)

• Remember the concentration limits that must be given on the SDS

Page 64: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 64

Mixture classification exercise 2: solution

• Classification according to pH is not applicable as pH>2

• Ethanol and water can be ignored, as they are not classified for the hazard in question. Also surfactants A and C can be ignored, because their concentration is below 1% (3.2.3.3.1. relevant ingredients = concentration > 1%)

• No SCL has been determined for Surfactant D, so the generic concentration limits from Table 3.2.3 will be used.

Page 65: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 65

Mixture classification exercise 2: solution

Sum of ingredients classified as Concentration triggering classification of a mixture as:

Skin Corrosive Skin Irritant

Category 1 (see note below) Category 2

Skin corrosive Categories 1A, 1B, 1C

≥ 5% ≥ 1% but < 5%

Skin irritant Category 2 ≥ 10%

(10 x Skin corrosive Category 1A, 1B, 1C) + Skin irritant Category 2

≥ 10%

Determine whether mixture belongs to skin category 1: Mixture contains 3% hydrogen peroxide, which is the only substance in the mix in Cat. 1. As this is below 50% (see SCL for hydrogen peroxide), the mixture is not classified Cat. 1 for skin corrosion. Determine whether mixture belongs to skin category 2: (% hydrogen peroxide / SCL) + (% surfactant D / GCL) = (3/35) + (3/10) = 0.39 < 1 thus mixture is not classified in Cat. 2 for skin irritation.

(eye irritant?)

Page 66: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

3/5/2012 66

Mixture classification exercise 2: labelling according to classification

• Not classified => not hazardous

Page 67: Mixture classification - exercisesbaltacthaz.bef.ee/files/c15/c197/13_Mixture... · 2014-09-25 · 5 . 100 . 500 . Table 3.1.2. Conversion values. Where an . ATE is not available

Thank You. Outi Tunnela [email protected]