Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore...

19
Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement period in Iceland Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore A.J., Edwards K.J., Einnarsson Á., Gathorne-Hardy, F.J., Lawson I.T., Mairs K.A., McGovern, T.H., Millard A.R., Newton, A. J., Streeter R., Roucoux K., Sveinbjarnardóttir G.

Transcript of Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore...

Page 1: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement period in Iceland

Mike Church (Durham University)

Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore A.J., Edwards K.J., Einnarsson Á., Gathorne-Hardy, F.J., Lawson I.T., Mairs K.A., McGovern, T.H.,

Millard A.R., Newton, A. J., Streeter R., Roucoux K., Sveinbjarnardóttir G.

Page 2: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

Icelandic woodlands before settlement c. 27% of area

Page 3: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

An ecological disaster?Case study = deforestation in Iceland

• Icelandic woodlands now c. 1% of area• Over 40% of soil lost since landnám

Page 4: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

Birch

Grass

Cereals

Initial interpretations (e.g. Hallsdóttir 1996)

Page 5: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

North AtlanticOcean

Reykjavik

Page 6: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement
Page 7: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

K920E935 H1341

K1500

V871

Charcoal production pit

Page 8: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

Charcoal analysis• Reducing environment produces

superb preservation (fragments of burnt leaf!).

• Charcoal from all 25 pits was mostly birch with a little willow.

• Evidence for live pruning and seasonality through recovery of hundreds of buds = cut in May/June.

• Evidence for branch stripping, perhaps akin to coppicing… managing the resource.

• Dating the pits… opportunity to combine radiocarbon dating of charcoal with tephrochronology.

Page 9: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

From Church et al. 2007 in Radiocarbon

Page 10: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

Helluvaðstjörn map

Helluvaðstjörn

The first pollen sequence from Mývatnssveit (Lawson et al. 2007)

Surrounded by Viking-age archaeological sites

Page 11: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement
Page 12: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

1. Betula pubescens and Juniperus decline together to 1300 AD

2. Initial response is expansion of Cyperaceae

3. After AD 1300 heath/mire taxa, especially Empetrum, expand

Page 13: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

Modern ecology e.g. Roucoux et al. 2007

Page 14: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

Modern vegetation surveys

Page 15: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

Slow SAR means spotting charcoal pits much easier

Page 16: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement
Page 17: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

Atmospheric data from Reimer et al (2004);OxCal v3.10 Bronk Ramsey (2005); cub r:5 sd:12 prob usp[chron]

400CalAD 600CalAD 800CalAD 1000CalAD 1200CalAD 1400CalAD 1600CalAD

Calibrated date

HOSK N CP1 925±35BP

HOSK N CP16 970±35BP

HOSK N CP17L 965±35BP

HOSK N CP17S 945±35BP

HOSK N CP19 895±35BP

HOSK N CP2 990±35BP

HOSK N CP23 935±35BP

HOSK N CP3 820±35BP

HOSK N CP5 890±35BP

Page 18: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

2009 fieldwork:• Sampled 5 more charcoal pit clusters• Sampled 10 more lakes for pollen

Page 19: Mike Church (Durham University) Ascough P.A., Cook G.T., Dugmore …nabo/meetings/glthec/groups/... · 2009-10-12 · Timing and mechanisms of deforestation during the Norse settlement

“The papers in this volume signify an increasing maturity to the archaeological literature in Iceland. I think it not too premature to claim that Icelandic archaeology is moving up a new level of sophistication, fostered in large part by the inter- disciplinary and international nature of its work.”

Gavin Lucas in the Editorial of Archaeologia Islandica 6 in 2006.