Metrological Traceability Measurement...
Transcript of Metrological Traceability Measurement...
![Page 1: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/1.jpg)
intro
PDB2
003a
Metrological Traceability&
Measurement Uncertainty
Prof Dr P De BièvreIndependent Consultant
onMetrology in Chemistry (MiC)
IUPAC-Anal Chem Div Committee
WIEN2004-02-17
© P De Bièvre WIEN Feb 2004
![Page 2: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/2.jpg)
PDB0
1130
Comparabililty of results of chemical amount measurements is needed in:
· determination of the value of goods in border-crossing trade· implementation of border-crossing environmental regulations (water, air, soil)· verification of safety of border-crossing food· border-crossing use of clinical measurements· application of forensic science across borders· detection of border crossing adulterated products · verification of authenticity of border-crossing products
Measurement results can only be compared if they have been obtained against acommon "stated reference".
© P De Bièvre BUCURESTI - MARIBOR - AL QAHERA Sep 2001AL QAHERA Jan 2003
ISCLS TEL-AVIV Nov 2003EILAT Nov 2003
![Page 3: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/3.jpg)
© P De Bièvre CITAC Sydney Oct1999
PDB9
9136
traceability
What istraceability ?
![Page 4: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/4.jpg)
© P. De Bièvre Stenungsund Nov 1998
Key 1 for Metrology in Chemical Measurement:
Traceability
property of the result of a measurement or thevalue of a standard whereby it can be relatedto stated references, usually national orinternational standards, through an unbrokenchain of comparisons all having stateduncertainties
PDB9
944
VIM 1993
![Page 5: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/5.jpg)
PDB9
9177
b
© P De Bièvre Chem and Law Wien Sep 1999
![Page 6: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/6.jpg)
0.00
0.05
0.10
0.15
0.20
0.25
0.30
0.35
0.40
0.45
0.50
0.55
c
m
mol
·kg
-1
-100
-90
-80
-70
-60
-50
-40
-30
-20
-10
0
10
20
Dev
iatio
n fr
om m
iddl
e of
cer
tifie
d ra
nge
in %
Experienced laboratory (self-declaration)Less experienced laboratory (self-declaration)Non experienced laboratory (self-declaration)No statement by laboratory
Pb
Results from all participants.
IMEP- 10 : Trace Elements in PolyethyleneCertified range [ U =k ·u c (k =2)]: 0.449 - 0.491 mmol·kg-1
© IMEP CCQM Orlando Feb 1999PORTOROZ Sep 2002
PDB9
936c
example of TMU of 15%around Reference Range
![Page 7: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/7.jpg)
© P. De Bièvre Sao Paolo Dec 1998
Key 2 for Metrology in Chemical Measurement:
Type A evaluation:method of evaluation of a standard uncertainty by the statistical analysis of a series of observationsType B evaluation:method of evaluation of a standard uncertainty by means other than thestatistical analysis of a series of observations
Uncertainty
ISO BIPM GUM 1993
PDB9
843
![Page 8: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/8.jpg)
© P De Bièvre KASTERLEE Feb 2002RIO de JANEIRO Apr 2002
EILAT Nov 2003
PDB2
0030
43
Current revision of the VIM:1. improvement through decrease of
- inconsistencies: • internal within VIM• internal within ISO Guides and Standards • external between ISO- and non-ISO documents
• no clarity
• no understanding
• no agreement possible
in tradein implementation of EC Directivesin mutual acceptance of measurement results
- unclarities, since: ...
![Page 9: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/9.jpg)
© P De Bièvre KASTERLEE Nov 2002EILAT Nov 2003
PDB2
0030
44a
The (revision of VIM-2, yielding) VIM-3
2. takes on board chemical measurement
3. uses the “substitution principle”: any definition of a term for the definition of a concept must becapable of replacing that term in another definition
4. uses GUM, even if a number of GUM terms for concepts is already up for refinement in “GUM-2” (which is not yet planned)
![Page 10: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/10.jpg)
© P De Bièvre KASTERLEE Nov 2003
PDB2
0030
45
The (revision of VIM-2, yielding) VIM-35. obviously still suffers from a carry-over from 20th - and even
19th - century thinking6. contains “counting quantities is an implicit base quantity” 7. makes uncertainty part of the measurement result8. defines “metrological traceability”9. defines “traceability to the SI”10. defines “measurand” as a “quantity intended for measurement11. includes thinking in terms of “chemical measurement”
(for the first time !)12. includes examples of chemical measurements
(for the first time)13. introduces “calibration hierarchy”14. gives a definition of “comparability”15. specifies any “CRM” as a “measurement standard”
![Page 11: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/11.jpg)
© PDB KASTERLEE Feb 2003
PDB0
0012
2
Some examples justifying a revision: example 1: “measurand” example 2: “measurement result” example 3: “metrological traceability” example 4: “measurement uncertainty” example 5: “measurement unit” and “measurement scale” example 6: “metrological comparability” example 7: “target measurement uncertainty”
![Page 12: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/12.jpg)
PDB0
1133
Key 2: Measurement uncertainty (MU)
Measure of doubt about the measurement result.
1. an uncertainty of a measurement result is generated automaticallyfrom the very moment one starts measuring
2. measurement uncertainty is obtained through an evaluation process:
- type A evaluation- type B evaluation
(calculation comes only in at the end, after evaluation)
© P De Bièvre BUCURESTI - MARIBOR - EL QUAHIRA Sep 2001
![Page 13: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/13.jpg)
PDB0
1134
3. understanding the process called measurement, is a prerequisite for evaluation of measurement uncertainty
4. measurement uncertainty should be small enough for the intended use but, need not be smaller (it can, but need not be smaller)
© P De Bièvre BUCURESTI - MARIBOR - EL QAHIRA Sep 2001TALLINN Mar 2002
![Page 14: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/14.jpg)
© P Taylor GEEL Jan 1998
PT02
01
Uncertainty is new to chemists !
• absent in most university curricula• ISO/BIPM guide (GUM): only 12 years old !• Repeatability is thought of as uncertainty• Terra incognita !
![Page 15: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/15.jpg)
© P. De Bièvre SAPUZ Zürich July 1999
PDB9
981
ISO/BIPM-guide:the new approach
re-establishes the responsibilityof the analyst because
“evaluation of uncertainty”is a thinking process !
![Page 16: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/16.jpg)
© P. De Bièvre Geel Nov 1992
PDB9
952
DISCREPANCY
PROBLEM NO PROBLEMDISCREPANCY PROBLEMS CAN BE CAUSED
UNNECESSARILY BY LACK OF”ORTHODOX” UNCERTAINTY ASSESSMENT
NO DISCREPANCY
![Page 17: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/17.jpg)
© P De Bièvre KASTERLEE 2004
PDB0
4001
![Page 18: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/18.jpg)
© P. De Bièvre Sao Paolo Dec 1998
PDB9
833
Metrologycreatesrespect for the law
Lack of Metrologycreatescontempt of the law
![Page 19: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/19.jpg)
© P De Bièvre SAPUZ ZÜRICH July 1999
PDB9
9121
The task isto demonstratethe authority of the resultof the measurement.
This needsunderpinning (“Untermauerung”)of the measurement resultin order to lead tothe necessary credibility.
![Page 20: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/20.jpg)
PDB0
1135
Key 3: Target Measurement Uncertainty (TMU)
Range of uncertainties from which the analyst claims it contains a
specified “traceable” value for the measurand
1. The analyst needs a “target” for the measurement uncertainty he must attempt to achieve
2. A TMU usually originates from a requirement put down byregulatory authorities
© P De Bièvre BUCURESTI - MARIBOR - EL QUAHIRA Sep 2001
![Page 21: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/21.jpg)
© I SKUBIC PORTOROZ Sep 2002
PDB2
0030
77
TMU
!M
esu
rem
ent
cost
increasing QLincreasing TMU
QL
TMUo
MCo
QLo
![Page 22: Metrological Traceability Measurement Uncertaintyold.iupac.org/divisions/V/news/040217/DeBievre.pdf · introPDB2003a Metrological Traceability & Measurement Uncertainty Prof Dr P](https://reader030.fdocuments.in/reader030/viewer/2022020204/5aba083d7f8b9aa6018e8c86/html5/thumbnails/22.jpg)
PDB0
1144
© P Taylor GEEL Sep 1999
Metrology in chemistry :The Hubble telescope ...
= the ‘spectacles’ of the analytical chemist
BEFORE AFTER