Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

download Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

of 16

Transcript of Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    1/16

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    2/16

    2.

    NETNODSTO INPROVSTNE EFFICIENCYOF ROD DRAWN SUE-SURFACE PUMPS

    SPE 18828

    =-

    .

    —.

    —=

    .

    Very little gae is vented from the casing at

    pressures approachingor abovs the bubble point.

    Since at the higher pressure the gas bubbles are

    small, and easily entrained, they are carried in

    the same direction as the oil. Gae anchors are

    effectiveat lower pump intakepressyresof bubble

    point or less.

    As shown by Clegg , the rising

    velocitydependson the bubble size and ahape and

    the physical

    characteristics of

    the liquid.

    Also, when the pressure is decreased,bubble size

    increases and gas separation begins to improve.

    Relatively good pump efficiencies can often be

    obtained in the lower pressure

    range

    with an

    effective

    type gas

    anchor.

    The efficiency will

    decrease, however, with higher production rates.

    But higher production rates are needed in many

    wells due to higher water cut and the need

    continuesfor a pump design that will operate in a

    high volume

    mode

    with the presence of gaa

    interference.A pump design has evolved from the

    demand of

    deeper setting depths, high volume

    productionand with gas interference.The pump is

    referred.o genericallyae a two-stagehollowvalve

    rod pump.

    SACRGRODND

    The early history of the development of the

    Two-Stage(2S-HVR)Hollow Valve Rod Pump begins in

    West Texas,Gaines County,Adair Field,by a major

    oil company.

    The water flood project requiredlong strokes and

    large pumps - 1-3/4” and 2“ bore inserte, and

    2-1/4”bore tubingpumps. Valve rod failuresat the

    threaded ends pointed to a need for improved

    design. Collet-typefittings were used with some

    euccees, but failures were still high, Tubing

    failures in the first few jointe above the pump

    from wells under water flood and C02 injection

    system,

    started using hollow valve rod pumps to

    avoid buckling problems.They had experiencedpin

    threadfailuresof plungersalong with tubingwear

    and

    other problems. These wells also had gas

    interference from H2S,

    and problems with iron

    sulfide particles during shut down periods. Gas

    Locking

    had been a problem, and rather than

    re-spacethe clamp on the polishedrod to bump down

    m the pump, this company elected to cycle the

    pumpingtime with occasionalstop or “rest” time to

    allow the gae and pressure to “equalize” before

    resumption of

    pumping.

    It was realized that

    the top valve added as a sand check was also acting

    ss a two-stagevalve,which helped open the bottom

    plunger valve. These _ were not ~ lockin~.

    .

    5ome refinementswere made in the guide and lower

    pull tube coupling to enhance the pumps’ ability

    to handle the gas and particulate, and the pump

     as calledthe TWO-STAGEHOLLOWVALVEROD PUNP.

    I’ECRNICALDISCUSSION:

    Refer to figure (1) for a sequence of operation

    of the two-stagehollowvalve rod pump.

    POSITION - Top of The Upstroke

    The plunger valve has the hydrostatic

    pressure load.

    The

    top valve, or

    two-stagegas and sand check valve, is

    in equilibrium and the weight.of

    the

    ball closeson the seat.

    POSITION -

    Start of The Downstroke

    The plunger starts down, vacating the

    chamber above the plunger and below the

    close fitting guide.

    This creates a

    lower pressurein this chamberwhich has

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    3/16

    SPE 18828

    BOB COX ARD

    BIWN?tWILLIAMS

    3.

    dischargewill be primarilyup the pull tube and

    gassy welle in hundredsof installation, aee Case

    throughthe top valve.But with a gaa-liquidmixture

    Histories.Ball and seat and cage life expectancy

    - that is, a compressiblefluid - the volume is is increaseddue to the smooth transitionof fluid

    reducedat the higher pressureof hydrostatichead.

    load.

    In this case, the dischargedquantity may be much

    lessdue to compression.

    The two-stagehollow valve rod pump has been run

    by

    several

    operatora

    under a

    In

    the

    packer,

    and

    schematic of

    “Sequence of

    Operation”

    out-performed

    many typea of

    that

    the top

    valve is closed on the downstroke to

    pumps were

    previouslyin the well.

    illustratethe theoreticalconditionwhen pumping a

    compressible

    fluid.

    Gas break-out,

    where

    small.

    Where sand and gas in combinationare encountered,

    babbles expand, occurs with a pressure change or a this pump should be a primary consideration.The

    temperaturechange.

    Turbulence and agitation also

    only disadvantageto the use of this pump design

    influencegas solution fluid behavior, and all of

    ia,

    as a bottom hold-down stationarybarrel, sand

    these factors take place

    in rod drawn sub-surface

    can pack between the barrel O.D.

    and the tubing

    pumps. I.D.

    Where this is a possibility, the bottom

    dischargevalve can be applied.

    The fluid path ia through the holes in the ported

    lower pull tube couplingand aroundthe pull tube to

    CASE EISTORIES COMPARING TNS TWO-STAGE HOLLOW

    guide clearance.This fluid flow helps keep sand or

    VALVE ROD POMP TO CONVECTIONAL POW

    other particulatematter in turbulenceand moving up

    and out of the pump.

    Case EW3tory  1

    POSITION -

    Start of The Upstroke Well information- ThunderCreek- Wyoming

    Depth:7,700feet

    The plungervalve seats and all pressure

    FluidType:Muddy

    load is on the plunger area. The standing

    Gas Percent:18MCFPD

    valve

    opens due to a

    pressure

    Scale/Sand:2X sand

    differential

    created

    by the

    plunger

    Productionhistory:15 BPD.

    vacating

    the chamber, allowing

    well

    Praviouspump: 2“ x 1-1/4”RHBC-16-4-6

    fluids to enter.Pump intake pressure is

    Surfaceoperation{7 5PM, 120” stroke

    equal

    to bottom hole pressure at

    the

    intakepoint,and is the force that fills

    Pumping problems included pump “gas lock” and

    the pump chamber.

    abrasionof plungerand barrel surface.The well

    POSITION-

    pulling frequencywaa high, with an average run

    UpstrokeCompletion of only

    i ro

    months. A packer was in place~

    The

    iorcingall fluid throughthe pump.

    plunger displaces

    fluid in

    the

    annulus between tha pull tube and barrel

    After installationof the two-stagehollowvalve

    through the pull tube and the top valve.

    The perforatedpull tube couplingaccepts

    rod pump, the well produced fifteen (15) BPD

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    4/16

    4.

    METEODS TO IKFROVS THE EFFICIENCY OF ROD DRAWN SDB-SURFACE PUMPS

    SPE 18828

    lulling

    frequency of

    the

    previous

    pump

    by

    Case History 6

    me-third.

    Well information-

    CanyonField SouthCowden

    :aseHistory 3

    - Texas

    Depth:8,000 feet

    Well information

    - RainbowRanchUnit - Wyoming

    Fluid type:N/A

    Depth:9,445 feet

    Gas percent:NfA

    Fluld type:Minnelusa

    Scale/sand:none

    Gas Percent:12 MCFPD

    Productionhistory:30% oil, 70% water

    Scale/sand:22 sand

    Previouspump:NfA

    Productionhistory:242 BPD, 10%water

    Previouspump:2-l/2’”x1-3/4”RHBC-24-6-6 Pumping problems included

    Surfaceoperation:8.3 SPM, 169”stroke

    corrosion-erosion

    of tubing opposite the fluid dischargeof the

    RHBC pump. Three tubing failurea in eix months

    Pt.mpingproblems included valve rod buckling

    were attributed to the constant discharge of

    wearing against the tubing, ias fluid pound

    corrosive fluid at the stationary valve rod

    and corrosiondamage to pump and tubing. Fluid

    guide.

    level recorded at 1,800 feet above the pump

    and conventionalpump could not pump the level

    ‘l’hepump was converted to a two-stagehollow

    down. Corrosion inhibitor wae ineffective.

    valve rod pump so that dischargeof the fluid

    was distributedover the stroke length.At last

    The two-stagehollow valve rod pump eliminated

    report the two-stagehollow valve rod pump had

    the gas-fluidpound, the bucklingproblem,and

    not been pulled in seven-and-a-halfmonths of

    pumped the fluid level down to 800 feet above continuousoperation.

    the pump.

    Production stabilized at

    242

    BPD, whereaa the

    conventional pump

    would

    Ca8e History 7

    “gae-lock”and productionwould vary daily. The

    conventional pump

    averaged

    only thfrty

    Well information-

    day run betweenpwnp repairs.

    SterlingCongerField- Texaa

    Depth:8,000 to 10,000feet

    Fluid type:Ciaco and CanyonReef comingled

    ;aaeE3atory 4

    Gas percent:600 MCFPD

    Scale/sand:Moderatesand

    Well information- ThunderCreek - Wyoming

    Productionhistory:30Z crude,i’OZwater

    Depth:

    10,110feet

    Fluid type:muddy

    Previouspump: 2“ x 1-1/4”RHBC-12-4-6

    Surfaceoperation:8 SPM, 84” stroke

    Gas percent:20 MCFPD

    Scale/sand:lightaand

    Pumping problems included gas lock and ~aqd

    Productionhistory:15 BPD

    abrasion of plunger

    Previouspump:2-1/2”x 1-1/4”RHBC-18-3-6

    and barrel. Conventional

    pump design, along with “Mother Hubbard” gas

    Surfaceoperation:7 SPJ, 84” etroke

    anchor

    system,

    was not effective to prevent

    gas lock and would not pump the well down.

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    5/16

    SPE 18828

    BOB COX AND BENNYWILLIAMS

    5.

    only three

    out of fourdays.

    Case History  9

    Well information- Red River - North Dakota

    Depth:7,700feet

    Fluidtype:N/A

    Gas percent:12 MCFPD

    Scale/sand:NfA

    Productionhistory:With

    conventional

    pump,

    well produced only fifty

    days

    out of

    eighty-two

    during

    the observed test

    period.

    Productionaverage

    per day was only44 BFPD.

    After the two-stsge hollow valve rod pump was

    installed,

    the production averaged eighty-nine

    BFPD with

    no days of

    zero production, in

    thirty-eightdays of observation.

    :ase tiistory 10

    This case history involves a study of pump

    failures on seventy-fivewells by a major oil

    company

    operating a

    unitized

    field

    near

    Levelland, Texas. Comparison is made on pump

    faihreS with conventional pumps versus the

    two-stagehollowvalve rod pumps over a two year

    period.

    The eummary statement concerninghe

    comparison of the two pump designs

    reads as

    follows:

    “Tagging”

    and

    pump failures

    result in:

    Brokenvalve rods

    Brokenplungerpina

    Bent pump barrels with seized plungers

    Excessivepump repaircosts

    Excessivedamage and handlingof sucker

    rods

    WBU~LINGtlOF VALVE RODSAND PULL ~ES

    Valve rods “buckle”

    or bend on the downstrokewhen

    pushing a plungerwith a ball and seat valve. The

    point of buckle can be calculatedvery accurately

    using

    the formula developed by Euler and tha

    parabolicor J. B.

    Johnson formula, discussed in

    the text book Fundamentalsof Mechanical Design,

    DeflectionAnalysissection.

    Per Euler

    ~_ Nfi2EI

    L2

    ...................,.

    (1)

    Per Johnson

    [

    1

    P= (A) sy-(~j’~~.~:

    ......(2)

    Application-

    for slendernessratiogreaterthan:

    t ‘(VY

    use Euler

    equation . . . . . . . . . . . .

    (3)

    Where:

    P = criticalload (bucklepoint)

    A = areaof column(squareinches)

    Sy = yieldstrengthof material,psi

    N = end constant

    E

    = modulusof elasticity(You~gs’),psi

    I = area moment of inertia,In

    L = length,in.

    k = radiusof gyration,in.

    The resistanceof the plunger imposedon the valve

    rod ia due to the differentialarea above and below

    the ball and seat.

    The criteria for determining

    columncriticalbucklingload is the length of the

    column (valve rod or pull tube),

    the diameter,

    load, slenderness ratio and the end condttion.

    In considering the end condition for valve rods

    and pull

    tubes, wa

    use

    the “fixed-free” for

    determiningthe columncriticalbucklingload. As a

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    6/16

    .

    NETEODS TO INPROVS TEE EFFICI’XKY OF ROD DRAWN SDS-SURFACE PDHPS

    SPE 18828

    seat only;

    we did not con$ider friction of t-he

    system such as inertia,fluid velocityor abrasio~.

    Buckle point of pull tubes

    for traveling barr(:l

    pumps are in parenthesis( ). The pull tube in RWl

    and SST style pumps

    support

    the fluid load on

    downstroke,and the free column length at the point

    of buckling is rather short compared to stationary

    barrel pumps equippedwith large valve rods or pull

    tubss.

    REVIEWOF CONVENTIONALAPI

    SUE-SURFACE PDKP~ -

    ADVANTAGES AND DISADVANTAGES OF APPLICATION

    API SPEC 11AX4

    designates two general types of

    pumps: The tubing pump (T), and the rod or insert

    pump (R).

    Both tubingand rod type pumps consistof

    metal barrel units with plungers having either

    metallicor non-metallicsealingsurfacea.

    API full barrels are all one piece tubes threaded

    at both ends.

    The sectional liner barrel and one

    piece liner barrelwere discontinuedas part of API

    SPEC llAXin 1979.

    Metal plungers may be of one piece or aasembled

    construction.One piece plungers generally have a

    hard plating or coating, while assembled plungers

    have a hard sleeve supportedby a plunger tube and

    end fittings.

    Refer to figure 2 for configurations of the

    followingclassificationsof pumps:

    TubingPumps

    The tubing pump is rugged in constructionand

    simple in design. The barrel of a tubing pump

    is attached directly to

    the

    tubing string,

    usuallyat the bottom.Below the pump barrelis a

    the pressure of oil in the casing annulus then

    opens

    the

    standing valve,

    filling the void

    creatad,by the upward movament of the plunger.

    AS the plunger starts down, the standing valve

    closes. The preseure below the plunger builds

    up and opens the travelingvalve. Thus the fluid

    that passed the standingvalve on the upstroke,

    passes the travelingvalve and throughthe hollow

    center of the plunger on the downstroke. This

    fluid ia now above the plunger in the amulus

    between the sucker rods and tubing. On the

    subsequentupstroke,this fluid, along with the

    rest of the fluid filling the rods and tubing

    annulus,is lifted.It is importantto note that

    the actual lifting of fluid is accomplishedon

    the upstroke. On the downstroke, the plunger

    drops through the oil which entered the pump

    through

    the standing valva on the upstroke.

    The decision aa,to whether to pump a well with

    a

    tubing pump or a rod pump is important.

    Rod Puqa

    The rod pump is preferredover the tubing pump

    in the great majorityof pumpedwells. The fact

    thai the complete pump can be pulled with the

    sucker rod stringwithout disturbingthe tubing

    is the main reason. This reduces pUl15ng Unit

    time at the well by more than fifty percentover

    the tubingpump when both the barrel.and plunger

    must be pulled. There are three types of rod

    pumps, the travelingbarrel bottom anchor (API

    RWT or RRT), the stationarybarrelbottom anchor

    (APIRWB or RNB), and the stationarybarrel top

    anchor(APIRWA or RNA).

    When a rod pump has been selected, an API

    seating nipple is run on or near the bottom

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    7/16

    .

    SPE 18828 BOB COX AND BENNT UILLIAHS

    7.

    quarter inch smaller than the nominal tubing

    Both standing and traveling valvea on the

    I.D. Where the maximum displacementis needed,

    traveling barrel pump have open type cages.

    the tubingpump is the logicalchoice.

    These are more rugged,have more fluid passage

    than blind cagesand are less prone to beat out

    A tubing pump is the etrongeetpump made. The

    from ball action.

    heavy wall barrel is connecteddirectly to the

    bottom of the tubing string with a collar,

    eliminatingthe need for a eeating assemblyon

    Due to equalized pressure on the outside of

    the pump to hold the pump in position.Alao,

    the barrel,

    a bottom

    anchored pump (either

    the sucker rod string connectedirectly to the

    traveling or stationary barrel)

    has greater

    plunger top cage, eliminatingthe need for the

    resistance

    to bursting

    than a

    top anchored

    valve rod required in stationary barrel rod

    pump.

    In wells that pound fluid, or in wells

    pumps.

    where top anchoredpumps have experiencedburst

    barrels, the traveling berrel pump is a good

    Disadvantages

    application.

    The greatest disadvantageof the tubing pump

    Disadvantages

    la the fact that the tubing string must be

    pulled in order to replace the pump barrel.

    The travelingbarrelpump is at a disadvantage

    This increases the pulling unit time at the

    in wells that have a low static fluid level

    well.

    because of the greater.pressure drop between

    the well bore and the pumping chamber. Since

    The tubingpump is a poor installationin gassy

    the standingvalve is located in the plunger

    fluid. Because of the length of the standing

    top cage on a travelingbarrel pump, it is

    valve assembly and the puller on the plunger

    smaller in diameter and therefore uses a

    (and frequently the increased bore of an

    smaller ball and seat than would be used in

    extensionnipple)there ia a large unswept area

    the standingvalve blind cage on a stationary

    at the bottom of the stroke,

    causing a poor

    barrel pump.

    compression

    ratio.

    This

    reduces the

    effectivenessof the pump valving, and cauaes

    There is a relationshipbetween pump length,

    low pump efficiencyin wells where gas entera

    well depth

    and

    pump bore which must be

    the pump suctionalongwith the producedfluid.

    observed.

    When the standing valve (in the

    Plunger top cage) is closed, a column load is

    The incre&3ed bore of a tubing pump causes

    transmittedby the plunger through the pull

    increasedload on the rod string and pumping

    tube and seating assembly into

    the seating

    unit. It also increasesstroke loss due to rod

    nipple. In a deep well, this load will be

    and tubingstretch.As the pump is set deeper,

    sufficientto put a bow in a long pull tube,

    this strokeloss may actuallyresult in a lower

    thus setting up a drag between the pull plu~

    net displacementthan would be obtained with

    and the pull tube.

    the smaller plunger of a rod pump. API RP1lL

    calculationsshould be made on both the tubing

    Stationary Barrel Bottom Anchor Pumps

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    8/16

    .

    .

    NETNODS TO IMPROVE TEE EFFICIENCY OF

    ROD DRAWNSUB-SURFACEPUMPS

    SPE 18828

    gas anchor.

    The short rise required for the

    fluid to pass the standingvalve and enter the

    pump minimizes the tendency to foam and thus

    redqceefficiency.

    Disadvantages

    It is hazardous to run a

    stationary barrel

    bottom anchor pump in a sandy well since sand

    can settle tightly in the annulus between the

    pump and the tubingand stick it tightlyin the

    jcint.

    It alao has the disadvantageon intermittent

    operation that sand or other foreign material

    can settle past the barrel rod guide and on

    top of the pump plungerwhen the well is shut

    down, with the possibilityof stickingthe pump

    when it is put back on production.

    stationaryBarrel Top Anchor Punps

    Advantages

    The top anchor pump is recommendedin sandy

    wells where a bottom anchor pump may become

    sandedin and cause a strippingjob. The amount

    of sand that can settle over the seating ring

    or top cup is limited to a maximum of about

    three inches, since the fluid discharge from

    the guide cage keeps it washed free above this

    point. In this respect, it is even superior

    to the traveling barrel bottom anchor pump,

    since if a travel barrel pump is spaced too

    high, sand can settle around the pull tube

    right up to the lowest point reached by the

    pull plug on the downstroke.

    The top anchor,pumpis specificallyrecommended

    In low fluid level gassy or foamy wells where

    it is particularlyadvantageous to have the

    efficiency.Where gas interferenceis a problem

    a properly designed gas separator should be

    installedas a part of the sub-surfacepumping

    assembly.Variousstylesare availablewith each

    havingmerits for particularwell conditions.It

    is importantto keep the back pressure on the

    gas at the wellheadat a minimum.

    Installations where fmmation aand can be a

    problem.

    “A pump will inherentlyhave problems if sand

    is allowed to enter. Therefore,it is best to

    utilize some method of sand control to prevent

    entrance of sand Into

    the well bore. Gravel

    packs, screens,and chemicalbonding age..csare

    frequentlyused for this purpose.

    CONMON PDNP PROBLEMS AND SOLUTIONS

    Corrosion.

    Corrosion occurs in many wells with resulting

    damage to

    sub-surface equipment. Flany NACE

    papersand documentshave been issueddescribing

    inhibitorsand methods of treatment to reduce

    damage to

    down-hole

    equipment.

    However,

    inhibitorsdo not protect the sub-surfacepump

    efficiently. It is

    recommended

    that

    pump

    metallurgybe seriously consideredas a method

    of corrosioncontrol.

    Fluid Pound.

    When a pump does not fill completelywith liquid

    durf,ngthe upstrokea low pressuregas cap forms

    in the top of the pump chamber between the

    traveling

    and

    standing valve.

    During

    the

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    9/16

    SPE 18828

    BOB COX AND BENNY WILLIAMS

    9.

    When a fluid pound is allowed to exist extreme special attention given to the pump

    damage can occur to the entire system and can intakepaasages.

    be the primary cause of the followingequipment

    failures:

    Gaa Pound

    1. SurfaceEquipment.

    A. Fatigue failure of the pumping unit

    A gaa pound is very similar to a fluid pound,

    structure.

    but is differentin the followingrespects:

    B. Fatigue failure of gear teeth and

    bearings.

    1. A “pump off” conditiondoes not exist.

    C. Fatigue failure of the pumping unit

    2. A “restrictedintake” condition might or

    base.

    might not exist.

    2. Sub-SurfaceEquipment

    A. Fatigue failure within the rod string.

    Gaa pound is causedby:

    (Fluid Pounding is especiallydamaging

    to the lower portion of the rod string

    1. Free gaa going through the sub-surface

    because of the compressive

    force

    gas separator and

    entering

    the pump

    applied upward by

    the

    fluid pound

    intake. This condition usually

    causes

    condition).

    erraticgas poundingin various downstroke

    B. Within the pump, a fluid pound causes

    positions.

    accelerated damage to the traveling

    d. Gas

    breaking out of

    solution

    during

    valve and its cage.

    Valve

    rod

    upstroke pump

    fillage after

    passing

    breakage,barrel rupture,and standing

    through the gaa separator.This.condition

    valve failurecan occur.

    usually cauaes consistentgas pounding in

    C. Fluid pound action accelerate wear the same downstroke.

    of the tubing threadscausing leakage.

    3. If gas

    entering

    the

    It is frequently the cause of the

    pump ia at

    sufficientlyhigh pressure due to a high

    fatigue

    parting of

    the

    tubing.

    fluid level in the annulus the resulting

    gaa pound will be cushioned and less

    Minimizing Damaging

    Effects of

    Fluid Pound:

    severe than a fluid pound. As the closed

    travelingvalve moves downward toward the

    A good approach to this probim is to design

    liquidin the pump chamber,the compressed

    a Pumping system and a pump diaplscementthat,

    gas supplies a pneumatic

    cushion which

    when working at eightypercent efficiency,will

    reducesthe severityof the inpacc.As the

    achieve

    the desired

    production fro= the

    pressurz of the gas entering the pump

    reservoir.Fluid pound that occurs in the first

    decreases,the severity of the gas pound

    twentypercentof the downstrokeis leas severe increases.

    than those occurringin the mid-portionof the

    4. If gas pound is caused by free gas going

    downstrokewhere pump plunger velocity ia the

    through the separator, a

    better

    higheat.When pump capacitygreatly exceeds the

    sub-surfacegaa separatoris needed. If it

    well productivitythe stroke length, pumping

    is cauaed by gas breaking out of solution

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    10/16

    scale

    deposits in aieas where agitation or 3. Use of top valve, a slide type check valve with

    pressuredropa occur. Usually this problem is a close fit to the valve rod and housed in an

    best resolved by use

    of chemical treatment

    open cage (see Figure 5). This

      essory

    item

    which prevents,

    reduces or dissolves the

    deposit.

    acts as a sand check valve to prevent sand from

    recenteringthe pump chamber.

    It also acts as

    an upper standingvalve to check the hydrostatic

    Casingperforationscan become pluggedby scale

    pressure from acting on the traveling valve

    which reduces well productivity and causes

    during the downstroke on

    conventional pumps.

    prematurepump off. Gas separatoropenings can

    become plugged

    causing “starved pump”

    The top valve also dampens the effect of fluid

    condition.

    pound on the

    rods since it

    assumes

    the

    hydrostaticpressure load at the start of the

    All valves, openings,and parts within a pump downstroke.This accesaoryitem is often used in

    can becomepluggedmaking the pump inoperative.

    conjunction with the

    rod-connected

    mechanically-openedlunger valve (see Figure 3)

    Scale can cause a stuck plunger condition.Use

    in stationarybarrel rod pumps. It is applicable

    of an RH or T.Htype pump with barrel length

    to either RWA, RHA, KWB or RHB API conventional

    and extension length designed to assure that

    pumps.When adaptingto existingpumps, a longer

    a Portion of the plunger will stroke out of

    valve rod ie necessary,equal to the added length

    each end of the heavy wall barrel on every

    of the cagehousing.

    stroke will

    reduce stuck plunger problems

    cauaedby scale.

    The addition of the top valve to a stationary

    barrel pump can be an economical meana of

    kCCSSSORYITEMSFOR SUB-SURFACE

    improving pump efficiency in gaseous wells. Ae

    POMPEPPICIENCYINCREASE

    the valve closesat the start of the downstroke,

    the plunger traveling downward creates a low

    SasInterference

    pressure in the chamber above the plunger. The

    low pressurehelpe the travelingvalve ball and

    1.A mechanically

    opened

    rod

    connected seat to open so that fluid in the barrel will

    plunger-valve

    syetem” (eee

    Figure 3) that

    travelthroughthe plunger to the upper ckamber.

    replacesthe plunger,ball and seat and cage of

    the conventional API pump.

    The mechanically The top valve should be a prime consideration

    openedplunger-valveopens at the start of the

    for top anchoredinsertpumps when run to depthe

    downstroke,allowingthe gas and fluid to pass

    greaterthan 4,000feet (1,220metere).

    through the inside of the plunger body to the

    upper chamber of the barrel. On the upstroke

    Scale/SnndProblems

    the drop on the bottom of the connectingrod

    seats to the mating surface lapped on the

    1. BottomDischargeValve

    plunger body and lifts the fluid into.the

    tubingcolumn.

    The partial bottom discharge valve (see Figure

    6) ie designed to be used with a stationary

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    11/16

    SPE 18828

    BOB COX AND BESNY WILLIAMS

    11.

    =

    .

    in the compression chamber Is forced out

    a stationarybarrel pump and a travelfnsbarrel

    through the

    side of

    the bottom discharge

    pump. It can be used in low fluid wells, and

    valve into the annulus between the pump and

    it is easier to fill because the fluid only

    tubing.

    has to pass through the large standing valve.

    The traveling barrel creates fluid turbulence

    On the downstroke, the hydrostatic pressure

    around the hold-down which helps prevent sand

    is equal

    on the top

    al,d bottom of the from settlingand preventingthe pump from being

    discharge

    ball and seat, The force moving pulled. In very sandy wells a bottom discharge

    fluid through the ball and seat is due to valve can be installedon the standingbarrel.

    fluid dynamic back pressure from the flow of Tha no-go ring is located on the standingvalve

    fluid throughthe insi

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    12/16

    .

    12.

    HETEODS TO IMPROVE TSE EFFICIESC2 OF ROD DRAW SDB-SDRFACE PUMPS

    SPIZ18828

    S1 L-LWC CONCESSION FAC’IWS

    ft X 3.048* E-01 = m

    fts

    X

    2.831 685 E-O% = ms

    psi x 6.894 757

    E+OO = lcp

    SCF/bblX 1.801 175 E-01 = std mslms

    in X 2.54* E+OO = cm

    ft*

    X 9.290 304*

    E-02 = mz

    bbl X 1.589 875

    E 1 =

    ma

    gal

    X 3.785 412

    E-03 = ms

    sq. in. x 6.451 6*

    E-00 = cmz

    cu. in. x 1.638 706

    E+O1 = cm3

    *Conversionfactoris exact.

    TABLE 1

    COLUMN CRITICAL BUCKLE LE&TB IN INCESS

    Valve Rod

    Fluid Lift Fluid Lift Fluid Lift

    Fluid Lift

    PlunSer - Pull Tube

    2300’ (1000 PSI) 4600’ (2000 PSI) 7000’ (3000 PSI) 9200’ (4000 PSI)

    1-1/4” 11/16”

    120”

    86” 70”

    60,,

    7/8”

    192”

    138”

    108”

    98,,

    Sta. Bbl. Pull Tube

    200”

    140” 115” 100”

    rrv. Bbl.

    Pull Tube (95”) (60”)

    (50”) (45”)

    1-1/2” 11/16”

    100”

    741, 60,, 521:

    7/8”

    168”

    115”

    95

    81’

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    13/16

    s

    TASLE 2

    COLUHSSITICALUCSL2SGOAD,OUNDS

    Size

    ?’SSSOLOHIlSRG2E.tWSSS

    O.D.

    I.D.

    Inches

    40

    50

    60

    70 80 90 100

    110 120 130 140 150 160

    170 180 190 200 210

    VALVSSODISq.lnclr

    Area

    11/16° .371

    2,.$421,563

    1,085 797 610

    482

    390

    322

    271 231 200

    173

    152 135 120 108

    97 88

    718” .601

    6,389

    4.089 2,839 2,086

    1,597 1,262 1,022 844 709

    604

    521

    454

    399

    3s3 3iZ

    283

    255 231

    1-1/16” .836

    13,890

    8,890

    6,173

    4,535 3,472

    2,743 2,220

    1,836

    1,5431,3151,133

    987 868 769

    685 615

    555 503

    PULLUSE / Sq . IrIcb

    Area

    553-c

    .384

    15/16”

    X 5/81’ 6,774

    4,335

    3,012

    2,210

    1,689 1,334 1,080 893 750

    640

    550

    480 422 374 333 300

    270 245

    533-E .552

    1-118° X 314”

    13.388 8,966 6,227

    4,574 3,502

    2,767 2,241

    1,852 1,S56 1,326 1,143

    996 875

    775 690 620 560 508

    232-K

    .773

    1-1/2” X 1-1/8”

    24,592 21,028 16,671 12,317

    9,430

    7,451

    6,035

    4,987 4,190 3,570 3,080 2,680 2,357 2,088 1.862 1,670 1,508 1,368

    232-N

    .994

    I-718° x 1-112”

    34,798 32,000 28,588 24,522 19,884 15,711 12,726 10.517

    8,837 7,530 6,492 5,656 4.971

    4,4003.92’7,5253,1612,885

      Used on 1 3/4” and 2“ borepumps.

    **U~~d“& l/41t a d 2-1 12 1 b~re pumps.

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    14/16

    “A

    Fig.1

    ssQusNcE

    .

    l,-*).

     

    1

    ,

    m

    Fig. 2

    AmericanPetrolsumI -

    st@ts”s TypicslPumpAsssmblii  nd Dm”gnstians

    8

    m

    :;

    m

    N“

    00

    A

    Q

    OF OPENATION

    lWO STAGS HOIJ X l VALVE BJ)D PUMP

    ~ FLUID LOAD [Hydrostatic Column)

    A PUMP INTAKEPNESSUNS

    ~ SLIGSTLY ,...}

    ~ > FLulDWAD

    A SLNETLY

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    15/16

    = 18828

    4

    m

    u

    Q

    ill

    k

    u

  • 8/18/2019 Methods to Improve the Efficiency of Rod-Drawn Subsurface Pumps

    16/16

    Fig. 6 Pa rt ia l Bot t om Discharge Valve

    < ~-

    /4

    /5

    4

    ,6

    ,7

    ,12

    K -

    /8

    ,9

    ,10

      . 7 Three-Tube

    ump

    I

    -9

    2

    3

    —4

    A

    -lo

    =

    I-

     1

    —12

    Fig. 8 Stroke Through pump

      Modified