The Role of Technical Analysis Bloomberg Technical Analysis Conference
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1 Technical Analysis Two Main approaches to valuing...
-
Upload
miranda-mckenzie -
Category
Documents
-
view
243 -
download
8
Transcript of Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1 Technical Analysis Two Main approaches to valuing...
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 11
Technical AnalysisTechnical Analysis
Two Main approaches to valuing stocks include– Fundamental analysis– Technical analysis
Some use only technical analysis while others use both fundamental and technical analysis
Technicians focus on charts of market prices and transactions statistics– Think that these statistics will reveal all
Technicians study patterns in security prices
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 22
Theoretical FoundationTheoretical Foundation Edwards & Magee (1997) state the basic
assumptions of technical analysis– A security’s market value is based on supply and
demand– Supply and demand are based on both rational
and irrational factors– Security prices tend to move in persistent trends– Changes in trends occur due to shifts in supply
and demand– Shifts in supply and demand can be detected
using charts of market transactions– Some chart patterns tend to repeat themselves
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 33
Theoretical FoundationTheoretical Foundation
Technicians believe past patterns will recur– Therefore can be predicted
Technical analysts estimate prices– Whereas fundamental analysts estimate
value
Technicians tend to ignore issues such as a firm’s riskiness and earnings growth– Instead focus on barometers of supply and
demand
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 44
Theoretical FoundationTheoretical Foundation
Technicians claim technical analysis is– Easier– Faster– Can be applied simultaneously to more stocks than
fundamental analysis
But, does technical analysis work? Technicians argue that when using
fundamental analysis– Must wait until market realizes a stock is undervalued– Must rely on inadequate accounting statements – It is hard work– Must use ambiguous estimates of growth
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 55
The Dow TheoryThe Dow Theory
Originated by Charles Dow– Founder of the Dow Jones Company and editor of
Wall Street Journal
Dow Theory presumes market moves in persistent bull and bear trends– Often used for market as a whole, but used for
individual securities also
Types of movements defined by Dow theorists– Primary trends (bull or bear market)– Secondary trends (corrections)
• Market collapses or upward surges lasting a few weeks or months
– Tertiary moves (little daily fluctuations)• Meaningless random wiggles but should be studied to
determine if relate to a primary trend
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 66
The Dow TheoryThe Dow Theory
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 77
Bar ChartsBar Charts
Represent price (high, low, close) of security over time
Each bar spans the distance from the day’s highest price to the day’s lowest price, and a small cross on each bar marking that day’s closing price
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 88
Sample Bar ChartSample Bar Chart
High
Low
Close
PricePrice
DaysDays
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 99
Bar ChartsBar Charts
S&P CNX NIFTY May 01, 2003 - Aug31, 2003
900925950975
10001025105010751100112511501175120012251250127513001325135013751400
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1010
Support and Resistance Support and Resistance LevelsLevels
Resistance level– Ceiling (peak) above which
stock price is not expected to go
• Supply of security is expected to increase
Support level– Floor (trough) below which
stock price is not expected to drop
• Demand of security is expected to increase
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1111
Contrarian logic : Short Interest Contrarian logic : Short Interest
Short Interest - total number of shares that are sold short
When short sales are high : – Market is going to be Bullish
Logic : – when stock is sold short, it must be
repurchased to close out position. When short interest is high, there will be buying pressure when shorts close out their positions
Bearish market is not ruled out though – Large short sales indicate widespread
belief that stock prices will fall
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1212
Breadth of the MarketBreadth of the Market
It is possible that an index would still be raising for some time after the market for the majority of lesser known stocks have already turned down
Measuring the number of advances and declines
Net advances = # advances - # declines
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1313
Breadth of the MarketBreadth of the Market
Day # Adv# Dec Net BreadthMon 800 680 120 120Tue 850 720 130 250Wed 750 785 -35 215Thu 600 880 -280 -65Fri 690 756 -66 -131
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1414
Breadth of the MarketBreadth of the Market
Breadth statistic may become negative during a bear market
However, it is arbitrary and depends on the date the cumulative breadth series began
Only the direction and not the level of the statistic is important
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1515
Breadth of the MarketBreadth of the Market
B-O-M-S is compared with the Market Index
The breadth and the market Index normally move in tandem
TAs watch for the trend in breadth to diverge from the trend in Index
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1616
Relative Strength AnalysisRelative Strength Analysis
Some securities exhibit relative strength – The prices of these securities rise
relatively faster in a bull market or decline relatively more slower in a bear market
Watching the price of the security in relation to– Industry– Market
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1717
Relative Strength AnalysisRelative Strength Analysis
Year Security* Industry** Market***2001 300 170 21002002 360 180 25002003 720 200 2850
* Avg. Price of the security in the year **Industry Average for the year *** Avg. of the Market index for the year
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1818
Relative Strength AnalysisRelative Strength Analysis
Year Sec/ Ind Sec/ Mkt Ind / Mkt2001 1.76 0.14 0.082002 2.00 0.14 0.072003 3.60 0.25 0.07
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 1919
Relative Strength AnalysisRelative Strength Analysis
Sec / Mkt
Ind / Mkt
Sec / Ind
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 2020
Charting Volume of Charting Volume of Shares TradedShares Traded
Technicians argue volume measures the intensity of investor’s feelings
Volume is studied in conjunction with prices
Technicians analyze resistance and support levels along with volume
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 2121
Charting Volume of Shares Traded Charting Volume of Shares Traded
Selling ClimaxesSelling Climaxes When supply and demand are out of
balance (price is moving) volume is watched closely– Market is bullish when high volume is
combined with a rising price– Market is bearish with high volume and
falling prices
Falling prices and high volume are considered bullish if a selling climax occurs
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 2222
Charting Volume of Shares Traded Charting Volume of Shares Traded
Speculative BlowoffsSpeculative Blowoffs
If one believes the end of bear market is near and high volume occurs– Means last of bearish investors are
liquidating their holdings• Clears the way for bullish investors to start bidding
up price
A speculative blowoff marks the end of a bull market– High volume pushes prices to peak
• Exhausts bullish speculators enthusiasm, enabling bearish market to begin
– A bull dies with a bang, not a whimper
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 2323
Moving Average AnalysisMoving Average Analysis
Moving averages are used to provide a smooth reference point for– Individual securities– Market indices– Commodity prices– Interest rates– Foreign exchange rates
Some use a 150-day (30 week) moving average– Changes each day
• Most recent day is added and oldest day is dropped– Following calculation is performed
» M150 Pt = (1/150)(Valuet + Valuet-1 + … Valuet-149)
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 2424
Moving Average AnalysisMoving Average Analysis
Moving averages computed over short time frames follow daily prices more closely– More volatile than longer-term moving averages
Technicians analyze difference between daily price and moving average– If daily prices penetrate moving average line it is a
signal to take action• If daily price moves down through a moving average,
price fails to rise for many months– Sell signal
• If daily prices are above moving average but difference is narrowing
– Signals end of bull market may be near
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 2525
Moving Average Analysis – Moving Average Analysis – Buy Buy SignalsSignals
Moving average analysts recommend buying stock if 1. Moving average line flattens and stock
price moves up through moving average line
2. Price of stock falls (temporarily) below moving average line that is rising
3. Stock price is above moving average line, falls, turns around and rises again without penetrating moving average line
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 2626
Moving Average Analysis – Moving Average Analysis – Sell Sell SignalsSignals
Moving average analysts recommend selling stock if1. Moving average line flattens and stock price
drops down through moving average line2. Stock price temporarily rises above a declining
moving average line3. Stock price falls through moving average line
and turns around only to fall again without penetrating above moving average line
Strategy is more successful if moving average is calculated over a longer time frame
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 2727
Moving Average AnalysisMoving Average AnalysisNIFTY 200 DAY MA :OCT 01, 2002 - AUG 31, 2003
800
900
1000
1100
1200
1300
1400
1-Sep-02 21-Oct-02 10-Dec-02 29-Jan-03 20-Mar-03 9-May-03 28-Jun-03 17-Aug-03 6-Oct-03
Closing
200 Day MASell Signal
Buy Signal
B1
B1
B3
S1S1
Lokanandha Reddy Irala / Technical Analysis 2828
The Bottom LineThe Bottom Line
Technical tools are used to detect price patterns Technical analysis assumes shifts in supply and
demand occur gradually over time Price change pattern is extrapolated to predict
future price changes Many financial economists believe technical
analysis cannot predict market prices– Believe security prices are a random walk
• Occur in reaction to random arrival of new information
– Believe a series of similar independent changes in prices are coincidence