Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

41
Foreign Workers, Utility Subsidies, CO2 Emissions and the Case for Automation A Demand Side Approach

description

Foreign Workers, Utility Subsidies, CO2 Emissions and the Case for Automation

Transcript of Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

Page 1: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

Foreign Workers, Utility Subsidies, CO2 Emissions and the Case for Automation

A Demand Side Approach

Page 2: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

A Migrant Worker’s Cost Benefit Analysis

Motivating Discussion

Page 3: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

3

BenefitsState Subsidies

Page 4: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

4

Subsidized Fuel / “Free” Public Transportation

Page 5: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

5

Page 6: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

6

Free* Public Transportation

Page 7: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

7

Free Electricity

Page 8: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

8

Page 9: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

9

Free Water

Page 10: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

10

Page 11: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

11

Free Health

Page 12: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

12

Page 13: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

13

Page 14: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

14

CostsDirect

Page 15: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

“IQAMAS”

IQAMAS

Page 16: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

16

CostsIndirect

Page 17: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

17

Environmental Impact

Page 18: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

18

Page 19: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

19

Page 20: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

20

Page 21: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

21

Page 22: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

22

Page 23: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

23

Page 24: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

24

Page 25: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

25

Page 26: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

26

Health Care Impact

Page 27: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

27

Page 28: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

28

Page 29: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

29

Page 30: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

30

Page 31: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

31

Law and Order Impact

Page 32: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

32

Page 33: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

The Mathematical Formulation Current Modus Operandi

Page 34: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

34

Current processes in Kuwait are typically of the type solving the following stochastic non linear optimization problem:1 2

1 2

:

: Space of stochastic processes satisfying certain regularity and

integrability conditio

inf exp( )

. .

( , , , )

ns

:Time indexed production possibility fronti

0

{

er

T

}

: h

:t t

t

Where

S

g

aL L b

s t

g X L L t T

X X t T S

X

1

2

e optimized process

: Unskilled labour

: Skilled Labour

: Technology

: Strictly positive processes

a : Small positive constant

L

L

b

Page 35: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

35

• Relatively technology neutral,

• Being heavily penalized for hiring skilled labour,

• Has little incentive to innovate and,

• In real terms is being subsidised for hiring unskilled workers.

In the above problem, the representative agent is:

Page 36: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

Research ProposalNatural Resource and Environmental Impact

of Objective FunctionTransformation Policies

Page 37: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

37

We postulate the study of a family of policies Θ which transform representative objective functions as in the example below:1 1 2

: Space of stochastic processes satisfying certain regularity and

integrability conditions

:Time indexed produc

inf 1/ / ( ( ) )

. .

tion possibility frontier

( , , , ) 0

: Technology

:

t

i

S

g

L e a aL bL

s t

g X T L

X S

L Lab

0

: Production possibilty frontier at time t

( ): ( ) depending on such that: lim 0

t

a

our

g

e ae e a a

a

Page 38: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

38

•A high technology component and,

•A “small” unskilled labour component *.

Optimal solutions to such problems will all have the following desirable characteristics:

*Indeed, by making e depend on a as indicated above, he policy maker can insure that the amount of L1 remains low even as a – in real terms – declines.

Page 39: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

39

In this problem, the agent is:

•Being encouraged to introduce technology and substitute this for labour in general.

•Being heavily penalized – e(a) can also be made to depend on externalities – for using unskilled labour

Page 40: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

40

•Technology demand will increase for each choice of policy in the set Θ

•Depending on which policy in Θ is chosen, the quantity of skilled labour required will remain at most constant, and may for some choices of policies in Θ decrease

•Demand for unskilled labour will decrease for each choice of policy in the set Θ

Impact on factor of demand:

Page 41: Kuwait 2030, what Tony\'s Team Left Out

41

•Reduction in usage of public utilities (health, water, electricity, fire, police)

•Reduction in traffic congestion

•Reduction in emmisions (fewer diesel run busses /older vehicles/ jawalla Taxis)

•Fewer violent crimes

Pottential environmental and social impacts: