Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

download Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

of 32

Transcript of Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    1/32

    %:78/,::89%0,.07/:.,943'8434149,74228843,3/98#0,8,943

    74/9,7$//6:

    -897,.9

    49,7/:.,943422884379-00;0/9,99070,9039075780

    413,943, 70.43897:.943 03970 /0503/ 43 90 6:,9 ,3/ 3:2-07 41

    5078438 .423 4:9 41 4:7 8.448 ,3/ .4008 3 9:73 90 6:,9 41

    0/:.,943,3/98.4397-:943943,943,/0;0452039-031:03.0/2489

    831.,39 - 90 .4250903.0 ,3/ .,7,.907 41 90,.078 %0 4228843

    14:3/9,99090,.070/:.,94388902390.4:397,89440,94574/:.0

    8:. 31:039, ,3/ .42509039 90,.078 %8 5,507 /8.:8808 90

    70.42203/,9434190422884320,3914770;,253,3/8970390339090,.070/:.,943,77,3020398,3/0,23083/09,,894,9090399080

    70.42203/,9438 .4:/ -0 25020390/ 974:/1107039 54. /0.,7,9438

    ,3/,.943 5747,2208 9,9070 9,03:5 /:73 90 ,89 14:7/0.,/08%0

    8:0894382,/0-9042288439,8-003,7:0/3985,507894/

    ;,/,3/,;009 94-0 1:25020390/40;07 3;041 80;07,4907

    88:08 ,3/ .,0308 9,9 ,70 02073 /:0 94 84.4 0.4342. ,3/

    90.344., /0;04520398 ,9 3,943, ,3/ 39073,943, 5,38 ,9902598 147

    2574;3 ,3/ 897039033 90,.07 0/:.,943 88902 ,;0 94 -0 .,770/

    1:7907 ,0,/ 41 90 42288438 70.42203/,9438 3 47/07 94 2,0 9088902 1: 700;,39 ,3/ 0110.9;0 3 90 5708039 ,3/ 1:9:70 .439098 41 4:7

    84.09

    %0'8434149,74228843

    %0 .42243 ,857,943 41 3/,3 50450 ,1907 ,;3 ,.0;0/3/0503/03.0,8 94800 3/,5747088 3, 85070841 10 14790 79

    -00;0/ 9,9 907 57485079 ,3/80.:79 0/ 43 3070.4342. .:9:7,

    ,3/549.,/0;04520394390308.,790/4:939043899:943413/,

    %03,943,/0;04520391479097,/943-4:3/3/,384.09/0503/0/43,

    507;,8;0 84., 97,381472,943 41 98 50450 . .4:/ 43 -0 -74:9

    974:90248954071:3897:2039410/:.,943%80,.9,890;843

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    2/32

    41 49,7 /:.,943 4228843 . ,8 ,554390/ 94 5705,70 ,

    -:05739 41 , 3,943, 5,99073 41 0/:.,943 172 -00;0/ ,3/

    ,..47/32,/0,9870.42203/,94389,99890/0;045203941:2,3

    7084:7.083;4;3.,308390340/08839070898,3/;,:084190

    50450,8,409,984;03/,843503/3574-0284154;079801

    8:11.03.3144/1:0254203984.,,3/3,943,3907,94309.43430

    ,3/,3/038:703,943,0.4342.,3/84.,/0;0452039,3/57485079

    41 90 2,8808 43 90 4907 %0 4228843 8970880/ 9,9 98 /70.9 3

    -09003 0/:.,943 90 840 3897:2039 41:2,3 7084:7.0 /0;0452039 ,3/

    3,943, /0;0452039 0898 43 03 90 3,943, 88902 41 0/:.,943 8

    57450747,30/-496:,9,9;0,3/6:,399,9;0,3/987010.90/390

    6:,9,3/3:2-07415078438.4234:9414:78.448,3/.4008

    3 ,3 ,990259 94 0110.9;0 70,90 0/:.,943 94 90 10 300/8 ,3/

    ,857,9438419050450,3/974:97,80907574/:.9;924/0730907

    4:944 ,3/ 3.:.,90 3 902 84., 247, ,3/ 8579:, ;,:08 ,3/ -73

    84.,3,943,3907,94339084.09970.42203/0/,74:3/.,308,3/

    2574;020398 3 90 03970 88902 41 0/:.,943 ,3/ 57080390/ , 30

    0/:.,943,5,9907341,8,.4224374:3/14725020393;,74:8

    0/:.,943,7014728,3/573.508

    0904228843025,80/06:,93,..088940/:.,943147,

    5045094:9/8.723,943,3/574;84341, 700;,39.:77.::2147907

    8:9,-00/:.,943,/0;0452039 9 7050,90/8970880/ 9,941, 901,.9478

    . 31:03.0 90 6:,9 41 0/:.,943 ,3/ 98 .4397-:943 94 3,943,

    /0;0452039906:,9.4250903.0,3/.,7,.9074190,.0788:3/4:-90/

    902489831.,3903.0 , 84:3/5747,22041574108843,0/:.,94341

    90,.078,8.438/070/,3088039,.43/943147906:,9,9;02574;02039

    41 0/:.,943 5 9 ,8 ,7:0/ - 90 9,9 3;0892039 3 90,.07

    0/:.,943.,30/;077./;/03/8-0.,:809013,3.,7084:7.08706:70/

    ,7082,0320,8:70/,,38990708:932574;0203983900/:.,94341

    2438

    %4: 985;49, 740 41 90,.078 3 3,943, /0;0452039 ,3/ 90

    300/147907574108843,5705,7,943,87050,90/8970880/-90&3;0789

    /:.,943 4228843 90 $0.43/,7/:.,943 4228843

    ,3/9039073,943,%0,243%0,.078,3/:77.:,3$0.43/,7$.448

    09 ,77,3020398 94 2009 98 300/ .4:/ 349 -0 2,/0 3 ,3 ,70

    20,8:70 8 , 708:9 0;03 ,1907 ,-4:9 94 /0.,/08 41 3/0503/03.0 90

    /:.,943 4228843 14:3/ 90 90,.07 0/:.,943 88902 8:11073 1742

    80;07,2,470,308808,82039430/-04

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    3/32

    O 84,943 41 572,7 ,3/ 80.43/,7 90,.07 97,33 3899:9438 17422,38970,24190,.,/02.104190:3;07891742/,574-0284190

    8.448,3/1742430,34907

    O":,94197,33 3899:9438702,389 100.059438090720/4.70

    475447O4250903989,111,.:9,70349,997,.90/9490,.070/:.,943O '9,9 ,3/ 70,82 ,70 ,.3 3 90 .:77.::2 ,3/ 5747,220 41 47

    ..4393:094-0,7097,/943,

    O $09 5,99073 ,3/ 7/ 90.36:08 ,70 1440/ 3 57,.9.0 90,.3 9 ,/870,7/1475708039/,300/8,3/4-0.9;08

    347/07947024;00,.4190800,308808,3/897039039090,.07

    0/:.,943 88902 3 90 .4:397 90 4228843 2,/0 80;07,

    70.42203/,9438.-0/8.:880/39080.9439,91448

    4228843>8#0.42203/,9438,3/9072502039,943

    !74108843, 5705,7,943 41 90,.078 147 6:,9,9;0 2574;02039 41

    0/:.,94384 9,90/:.,943-738/0;0452039,3/.,30 33/,384.09

    ,890;8434190147.9,/0570880/98.43.073,3/8:0890/

    ;,74:839,9;0894-09,03,9/11070390;0839880.9439014.:8843

    0,233 ,8 94,9 09039 ,3/ 3 ,92,3307 9080 39,9;08,;0 -003

    9,0394-732574;02039,3/.,30390,.070/:.,943

    ,38970,2341%0,.07/:.,943

    3 47/07 942,0574108843, 5705,7,943 41 90,.078 0110.9;0

    .438/070/ 9 30.088,7 94 -73 90,.07 0/:.,943 3 90 2,38970,2 41

    ,.,/02.1041:3;078908,80,8418.4488902,3/4;07,0/:.,943,

    /0;045203984/,9081440/30,.419080/42,38412,38970,23

    ,70/8.:880/070

    #024;384,9431742:3;078910

    /:.,943,8/893:80/ 174250/,4 84:/ -070.430/,8,3

    3/0503/039 ,.,/02. /8.530 ,3/ 3974/:.0/ ,8 ,3 00.9;0 8:-0.9 3

    .4:7808147901789,3/80.43//07008,3/8.448410/:.,943-0089,-80/

    3800.90/:3;07890894/0;0455747,2208390,.070/:.,943,3/89:/08

    ,3/7080,7.30/:.,9433.4,-47,94394907:3;0789/8.5308%8

    43 05-70, 90 84,943 41 90,.070/:.,943 1742:3;078908 %0

    422884389,90/33/,900307,9703/,8-00394/03910/:.,943

    950/,49,8-0039,:92489397,333899:9438,3/889:/0/

    43-94804/0./0940390790,.3574108843,19078:.,/0.843,8

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    4/32

    -0032,/0 3 90 0/:.,943,,/;,3.0/ .4:3970840;07 0/:.,943 ,8

    /0;0450/.438/07,-,8,84.,8.03.0,3/,805,7,90,.,/02./8.530

    %070,,9439,9 0/:.,9438 ,33897:203941.,3084., 549.,,3/

    0.4342. 8,;3 1,770,.3 25.,9438 349 43 147 0/:.,943 ,8,3

    3900.9:, /8.530 4170,9 8.0391.,3/ 54845.25479 -:9 1474907

    /8.5308,8098,8447934939,954845078,3/84.,8.039898

    ,;0-0:394;0850.,,9903943940/:.,943,8,325479,395,793907

    10/84189:/09070147070.42203/9,93;041903.70,838.450

    ,3/ 25479,3.0 0/:.,943 84:/ -0 70.430/ ,8 , 84., 8.03.0 47 ,3

    3/0503/039/8.5305

    %0,943,!4.43/:.,9439,9,701440/90

    7054798/030/9888:0,940907,90790%0,.07/:.,943:77.::2

    7,2047 -74:9 4:9 - #% 3 /8.:880/ 98 88:0 ,3/ 70

    025,80/ 9,9 0/:.,943 84:/ -0 411070/ ,8 , 8:-0.9 41 89:/ 147 -49

    47439, ,3/ ;079., 24-9 5 9 ,8 03;8,0/ 9,9 1 0/:.,943 8

    ,40/94-05:78:0/,8,3,.,/02./8.53004907/8.530879,1907

    89,3/,7/:59454897,/:,900;0,4394907/8.5308:3/074307441

    ,3/ ,84 ,8 9,8470390/ 97,33 5747,220 147 -0.423 90,.07 ,9 ,

    5,79.:,7 0;0 9070 8 , 89743 5488-9 9,9 0/:.,943 74 ,8 ,3

    25479,39 /8.530 9 ,8 ,84 03;8,0/ 3 90 7,2047 9,9 90,.07

    97,33 3899:9438 4:/ 5705,70 ;,74:8 9,8470390/ .4:7808 ,3/ 90

    :3;0789/05,7920398410/:.,9434://0;045;,709410/:.,943.4:7808

    94-05:78:0/,8,/8.5305

    3 47/07 94 1:7907 90 8 7084;0 3 98 70,7/ 90 !

    5745480/ 9,9 .4008 41 0/:.,943 ,3/ :3;0789 /05,7920398 41 0/:.,943

    -0 309470/ ,3/ 9,9 :3;0789 /05,7920398 41 0/:.,943 -0

    897039030/5:93090790!,3/!347!9,0/

    ,-4:9-70,39084,9434190,.070/:.,9433899:94381742:3;078908

    49 9080 /4.:20398 8550/ 90 88:0 41 /0;0452039 41 0/:.,943 ,8 ,

    /8.530 47,8, 84.,8.03.08 , 708:9#,2,2:794229900

    54390/4:99,990,.070/:.,9435747,2208.4393:094089384,94341

    90 ,.,/02. 10 41 90 :3;078908 5 94: 9 ,84 // 349 .0,7

    8:089,89449884,943.4:/-07024;0/

    3 90 74:3/ 9 ,8 -003 4-807;0/ 9,9 3 8420 $9,908 .4008 ,9

    :3/077,/:,90 0;0 34 41107 0/:.,943 ,8 ,3 45943, 8:-0.9 ,3/ 8420

    :3;0789/05,7920398410/:.,943,70344110733/:.,943,3

    /05,7920398 ,3/ .039078 41 0/:.,943 3 :3;078908 ,70 ,84 1,.9,93

    7080,7.30/:.,943$990708348:./0/.,90//05,792039410/:.,943

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    5/32

    3,3:3;0789.803970/0;490/94.43/:.937080,7.314:3/,943

    8:-0.98 41 0/:.,943 3 90 3/,3 .4390940;07 .039078 0$ ,9

    $&,74/,,7:8,303970147/:.,943,$9:/08,9&00

    ,70807;398.,:8094842009039/:.,943,8,/8.5300490784.,

    8.03.08 809 94,3 0307, 70.43943 8 43 ,8 98 89:,943 5078898

    90,.070/:.,943702,384,90/17422,38970,241,.,/02.104190

    :3;078908

    #0.0399,8-0035745480/94904;9413/,9,9,1:10/0/

    :3;0789410/:.,94384:/-0089,-80/390!,35074/147,14.:80/

    , 74:3/ /0;0452039 41 98 /8.530 ..059,3.0 41 98 574548943

    43 -0 , 82, 8905 147,7/ 3 70.433 90 89,9:8 41 0/:.,943 ,8 ,

    /8.530 ,3/ 05 3 1:7907 5742493 98 .,:80 40;07 98

    5745489430;0394:,..0590/,3/25020390/83494394.,3090

    89,90410307,84,94341 90,.070/:.,943 3899:9438 1742:3;0789 10

    ,.7488 90 .4:397 :3088 :3;078908 3 0307, ,/29 0/:.,943 ,8 , 84.,

    8.03.047,8,33/0503/039/8.530398,.,/02.10

    70,384,9431742$.4410

    47 -733 90,.07 0/:.,943 3899:9438 .4807 94 90 8.44

    1070,908,3/574-0284-9,30/390808.448849,990,.075705,7,943

    2, -0 .,770/4:9 43 247070,89. 74:3/8 9,8 8:0890/ - 9,9

    0903843 47 84:/ -0 2,/0 ,3 3907, 5,79 41 90,.07 0/:.,943

    5747,220 :23 ,884.,9438 41 90,.07 97,33 3899:9438 84:/ -0

    14720/ 94-73 940907 1,.:9202-078,3/ 9074/89:/039834 8.44

    90,.078 94/8.:88,3/ 5,3.:77.:, ,3/ 4907 5747,220884 5074/.

    0.,30 41 89,11 -09003 .44507,93 8.448 ,3/ 90,.07 0/:.,943

    3899:9438 84:/ 9,05,.0,3//:0 70.43943 94-0;0394.44507,93

    8.448-$9,9005,792039841/:.,94314798,.941.44507,943

    3 8908 #%,8 ,-0 9447,300903843 807;.08 .039708 3

    ,-4:9507.03980.43/,790,.0797,333899:9438#39070

    070 0903843807;.08 .039078.07020,39 147 0903/3 05 94

    30-4:738.448,3/90,.0783907,.,/02.5:78:98$//6:

    ,;370.430/907831.,3.0147-70,384,943-090038.448,3/

    97,333899:94388:.09038430/:.,943:398070.70,90/3$#%8,3/

    %8 ,84 %080 :398 3 2,3 $9,908 34 ,70 349 ,.9;0 03,0/ 3

    0903843,.9;90838:774:3/38.448%0.43.05941,:23,884.,943

    41 5,88 4:9841 , 90,.07 97,33 3899:943 ,8 34949 411 9074:3/ %0

    .44507,938.448,703090770.430/09,9-90$9,9005,79203941

    /:.,943 347 9080 8.448 70:,7 3907,.9 9 90,.07 0/:.,943

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    6/32

    3899:9438 3 907 ,70, %0 43 290/ 4..,8438 03 90 8.448 ,3/

    3899:94384190,.0797,33.420394.439,.9,3/3907,.990,.4907,70

    5074/841 57,.9.0 90,.3 3 8.448 ,3/47,3,94341 3807;.0 97,33

    5747,22081478.4490,.0783 90,.0797,33 3899:9438;03439080

    4..,8438903907,.943702,381472,,3/7/%0/0,410.,30

    41 90,.078 -09003 .44507,93 8.448,3/.43.0730/ .4008 410/:.,943

    147,850.10/5074/,834970.0;0/70.439433903/,389:,943,809

    39070893 ,8 ,8 70.42203/0/ - 90 ! ,/

    850.1., 574;/0/ 9,9 , .,/70 41 90,.07 0/:.,9478 -0 .70,90/ ,3

    3907.,30 -0 47,30/ -09003 90,.3 ,3/ 90,.07 0/:.,943 ,3/

    8:11.0393:2-07418:5073:207,770807;05489438-0.70,90/38.448

    9403,-050450174298.,/70944,890,.0781470,780;070,78

    5:93493.43.7090,8-003/4309425020399080574;843884

    1,7 03.0 ,8 4-807;0/- #,2,2:79 4229900 ,842:. 41 84,943

    -0900390,.070/:.,943,3/8.4410.4393:08945078895

    .,25,31471472,94341,:23,884.,9438415,884:984190,.07

    97,333899:94389,.9;03;4;0203941901,.:92,-0,7842017:9

    3 98/70.943 47 089,-82039 ,3/ 740 41 0903843 :398 3, 90,.07

    97,333899:9438,3/1470.,30419071,.:9,3/8.4490,.0788420

    850.1.574;8432,,;094-02,/0390%34728147.425,3.0-

    ,90,.0797,333899:9438

    70,384,9431742430,34907

    9 ,8 4-807;0/ 3 705479 9,9 90,.07 0/:.,943 3899:9438

    411073 90,.07 97,33 5747,2208 147 /1107039 0;08 41 90,.078 41903

    702,3 84,90/ ,3/ 03.0 /4 349 -03019 1742 0,. 49078 7084:7.08 ,3/

    050703.08 %0 ! ! ,3/ 90 0397, $5438470/ $.020 147

    %0,.07 /:.,943 ,;0 970/ 94 7024;0 98 84,943 94 8420

    09039 1907 90 2502039,943 41 90 $.020 .4008 41 90,.07

    0/:.,943/05,7920398410/:.,9433:3;07890849:57,/0/949089,9:841

    $8 3 43,7/8 . ,70 706:70/ 94 5071472 90 1:3.943 41

    .42570038;0 .4008 41 0/:.,943 ,3/ 574;/0 147 570807;.03807;.0

    90,.07 0/:.,943 147 572,7 ,3/ 80.43/,7 90,.078 ,3/ 0;03 147 3:7807

    90,.078,3/ 90,.070/:.,9478:9 98 ,8 ,55030/ 43 , 290/ 8.,0,3/

    43,1090,.070/:.,9433899:9438,;0-003,-094-70,9884,943

    0893,243 902489419024709,390,.07 97,33 3899:9438

    89 702,3 84,90/ 1742 430 ,34907 -09907 ,3/ 0110.9;0 .44507,943

    -09003$8,3/$#%8./70.9.447/3,9090,.9;90841%8

    .,3 1:7907 05 3 -70,3 98 84,943 $8 ,.93 ,8 .42570038;0

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    7/32

    .4008 ,8 ;8:,0/- 84:/ -0.420 34/, 7080,7. ,3/ 7084:7.0

    .039078 ,3/ .42243 20093 5,.08 147 1,.:9 41 %8 ,3/ %8 43

    .4393:3 -,88 574;/0/ 9,9 9080 $8 ,70 0;03 45030/ ,.7488 90

    .4:397 3 , 5,330/ 2,3307 3 90 5,89 ,8 2,3 ,8 330 $8 070

    089,-80/-#3,830$9,90:94190297000890/343082,

    /897.9 41 9,9 $9,9008/08 0110.9;0309473 ,3/ 09038;0 .44507,943

    -043/ 3807;.0 0/:.,943 84:/ 9,0 5,.0 -09003 $8 ,3/ 7089 41 90

    90,.07 97,33 3899:9438 3 , ;03 ,70, 9 5708039 98 .44507,943 8

    .43130/ 9447,3,9434184203807;.0 97,335747,2208- $8147

    901,.:941%8,3/$#%8

    %0/0,41$9,904,7/841%0,.07/:.,943 ,8;8:,0/-

    . 070 8:55480/ 94 -0 7085438-0 147 , 1:3.9438 70,90/ 94 90,.07

    0/:.,943,9,0;08,3/3,10/830,.$9,90,834980039094190

    /,934%0,9073,9;0897:.9:7041$#%8,8-003.70,90/3$9,908-:9

    9 8 7085438-014790,.070/:.,943:594:5507572,70;094:9,84

    ,.98,8,.447/3,93,03.1473807;.00/:.,9434190,.078147,0;0841

    8.440/:.,943

    %0 4228843 ,/ ,84 8:0890/ 9,9 147 7024;3 0893

    805,7,943,24390,.070/:.,943 3899:9438, 90803899:943884:/-0

    :57,/0/ 94 90 .40,90 89,3/,7/ 3, 5,80/2,3307,3/ :92,90, 41

    90284:/-0-74:9:3/07908:507;84341:3;0789085$0.43/,7

    90,.07 0/:.,943 3899:9438 ,70 ,70,/ 473 :3/07 90 .43974 41

    :3;07890840;0790,.070/:.,9433899:9438147002039,7,3/3:7807

    0/:.,943 ,70 89 4:98/0 90,2-9 41:3;0789 8:507;843&57,/3 90

    %8 94 .40,90 0;0 8:70 2574;0 90 1,.:9 89,9:8 907

    249;,9436:,94190,.3,3/0,23,94389,3/,7/83!,3985,79

    419049,74228843870.42203/,9432,-09,03394.438/07,943

    %04228843,/7050,90/;8:,0/,325479,39,3/,.9;0740

    41 3,943, 47,3,943841 90,.078 ,3/ 90,.07 0/:.,9478 3 2574;3 90

    6:,94190,.070/:.,94394:24709,34308:.47,3,9438089,9

    90 3,943, 0;0 90 ,70 ,7/ 14:3/ 88902,9., .44507,93 ,3/

    .4,-47,93 3 ,.0;3 90 4, 41 2574;02039 41 6:,9 41 90,.07

    0/:.,943

    2574;3":,941%0,.07/:.,943

    %00.422039343906:,9 41 90,.07 0/:.,943,/

    4-807;0/9,908803.041,5747,2204190,.070/:.,94386:,9,3/3

    98,-803.090,.070/:.,943-0.420834943,13,3.,,890-:9,84:7.041

    4;07,/090747,94330/:.,943,89,3/,7/8591:7907702,70/9,9

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    8/32

    ;9,9 ,3/ 70,82 ,70 ,.3 3 90 .:77.:, ,3/ 5747,2208 41 47

    .4393:094-0,7097,/943,5;033,290/,70,02094/841

    90,.3 90 90,.07 0/:.,947 1,8 94 257088 :543 90 97,3008 ,-4:9 90

    :801:3088 ,3/ ,55.,-9 41 9080 2094/8 ,8 0 2801 7,70 :808 ,3

    2094/4907 9,3 909, ,3/ .,2094/$095,990738 41 088435,333

    ,3/7/90.36:084190,.3,701440/357,.9.090,.370,7/08841

    90 3,9:70 41 8:-0.9 2,9907 ,3/ 90 4-0.9;08 94 -0 ,.0;0/ 3 90728 41

    -0,;4:7, .,308 ;,:,943 574.0/:708 850., 9480 1440/ 147

    ,88088390.4250903.0414:/-090,.078,70-,3/,708:-0.9;0,3/

    :38.0391.80039413/4:92,348:..0881:1,.9:,340/0,8

    -003202470/%0 42288432,/0 80;07, 8:089438 94 2574;0 90

    6:,9 41 90,.07 0/:.,943 . 03.425,880/ 2574;020398 3 .439039

    .4:7808 574108843, 89:/082094/841 90,.3 ,3/0;,:,943 94 -0 :80/

    89:/03990,.3 850., .4:7808 ,3/ .:77.:, 147 , 0;08 41 90,.07

    0/:.,943

    40;0790808:089438 1,0/94,997,.990 ,990394341!

    ,3/98/0.,7,943,7/8500/4:9,38905894-09,031472574;020393

    90,.070/:.,943,3/98.:77.::2%0/7,19/:.,943!4.4.:203941

    432039430/9,990.:77.::24190,.070/:.,943,990002039,7

    ,3/80.43/,789,088:9,--0.,30/347/079403,-09090,.07894

    5, 907 574507 740 3 7014723 0/:.,943 , 5 -:9 98

    7,19!4..4:/30;0770,.9089,0412502039,9439,890%8

    /4.:2039%0,.07/:.,943:77.::2,2047.14790

    1789 920 90/ 90 90,.07 0/:.,943 70,90/ 4-807;,9438 41,3/

    8500/4:9/09,0/:/0308147.:77.::2.,30

    %0804-807;,943807097,38,90/394,47,-0 8.02041.4:7808

    -907,2047.8:0890/94-74,/24/0841.:77.::2430

    147570572,79480.43/,789,0,3/9049071478034780.43/,7,3/07

    0/:.,943.,/9700.42243.42543039841!0/,4.,%047

    473 9 422:39 ,3/ 439039.:22094/44 41 %0,.3

    $.44$:-0.98,3/!7,.9.0%0,.3%009,01479080.4254303983

    1789970089,08410/:.,9430570572,7572,7,3/80.43/,74:/-0

    507.039507.039,3/507.03970850.9;0,3/1470780.43/,7

    ,3/070/:.,9439,85745480/94-0507.039507.039,3/507

    .03970850.9;0,390,.070/:.,9433899:94381440/987,2047

    ,3/,/4590/988.020/:7390.4:7804170;8434190790,.070/:.,943

    .:77.:,

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    9/32

    .4807 44 ,9 70.42203/,9438 70,7/3 90,.07 0/:.,943

    .:77.::2 ;8;8 90 574;8438 2,/0 3 0/:.,943 54.08 ,3/ %0,.07

    /:.,943 :77.::2 7,20478 9,9 1440/ 9080 70.42203/,9438 9

    70.03970;0,8901443

    #047039,943418:-0.9340/09,;09470470398:-0.9340/04189:/03990,.07839070850.9;0

    8:-0.98 9,9 90 ,;0 ,70,/ 89:/0/ 0,707 .439039.:22094/44

    .4:7808 9 025,88 43 9,3 :5 7020/, ,3/ 037.2039 90,.3 3

    25479,39,3/30.43.0598370,90/8.448:-0.980703.47547,90/390

    .:77.::241002039,7,3/80.43/,790,.070/:.,94340;0798349

    8:70/:094,.417080,7.-,80/340/0,894,90903998007.80,8

    70,9,03:50110.9;039090,.0797,333899:94385,79.:,7,990

    0;04197,38,.94341.:77.::2-,80/439830.439039.:22094/44

    ,5574,. 9 ;07 2:. /0503/8 43 90 .4250903.0 41 90 8:-0.9 90,.07

    0/:.,9472094/2,8907,3/843:3/0789,3/34198,5574,.

    40;07 147 98 7047039,943 41 8:-0.9 340/0 7,70 ,3

    .4,-47,943814:3/94,;0-0032,/0-0900390,.070/:.,9433899:9438

    ,3/:3;0789/05,792039847-07,,798,3/8.03.0.4008390.43.0730/

    8:-0.980907 3 90147241 3;4;3 907 1,.:947:83 907 ,-47,947

    ,3/-7,71,.908%:89084,943-090039080948098413899:9438

    .4393:08940890;0790088/:094890,/025,88433807;.00/:.,943

    418.4490,.078 701708075747,2208 38:-0.9,70,8,70-0347,30/

    - %8 %8 ,3/ $8 3 . 8:-0.9 050798 1742 :3;0789

    /05,7920398,3/,798 ,3/8.03.0 .4008,709,3:590,.3437020/,

    ,3/037.2039.439039-,80/43 90700;,39 8.44 .:77.::2%:8 9,8

    -0034-807;0/9,9,90,8933807;.090,.070/:.,9439090,.0797,33

    3899:9438 ,3/ :3;0789 /05,7920398 ,3/ .4008 ,;0 .420 .4807 ,3/

    90,.078,;089,790//7,3-03019174298.4,-47,94394,90;0709039

    98,;,,-040;073570807;.090,.070/:.,94398/408349800294

    -097:0

    3907,90/;078:8574108843,.4:78088 147 ,77,33 47 0,78 3907,90/ .4:7808 41 0307, ,3/

    574108843,0/:.,943,8,8-003050720390/3#8,3/,.4:50414907

    3899:9438,99080.43/,790,.070/:.,94389,090422884339801

    ,88059.,,3/,/1099,994:/-09440,;,574548943,3/3709:73

    ;07290/3:2-074190,.078 94507 .03941 90 706:702039-0

    97,30/974:9824/059,/7,9078:0890/9,9084:/-09907

    .43.0397,90 43 2574;3 90 574108843, 430 0,7 .4:780 147 80.43/,7

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    10/32

    90,.07814439017894780.43//07001,9,8:.3907,90/.4:7808,70

    94-047,30/9039 84:/-0/4303908.448/05,7920398410/:.,943

    3 :3;078908 3 .4,-47,943 9 4907 /05,7920398 40;07 90

    4228843//,5570.,9090:9941 8:.050720398413907,9433,3

    0,89. ,3/ ;,70/ 88902 %8 3/ 41 05072039 3 3907,90/ .4:780 3

    90,.075705,7,943,8-003970/14790,89100,7834309.400841

    ,798,3/8.03.0,11,90/ 940&3;0789 1475705,73002039,78.44

    90,.07807038:-0.9.4:7808,439574108843,.4:780,709,:9:3/07

    4307441 3.480.4,-47,9439 901,.:9202-078 41/1107039 700;,39

    /05,7920398%0.4:780.,0/,.0474102039,7/:.,943/8

    , 14:7 0,7 5747,220 ,1907 % ,8 ,70,/ 34910/ 34728 147

    70.439434198.4:78040;0725,.94198334;,9;05747,220809

    94-0,8.079,30/-,30257.,7080,7.

    #0;9,8,94341574108843,89:/08

    %0 489,9:8 41 574108843, 89:/08 3 90,.07 97,33 3899:9438

    .8/:094,-803.041,/06:,907080,7.43574-02870,90/9490,.078

    47 38.44 33/,3 .43909 ,3/,84 /:0 94 90,.07 0/:.,9478 1,:70 94

    /0,9908089:/089/70.97010703.09490850.1..,88744289:,9438

    94-01,.0/-9097,30090,.0780,;082:.94-0/0870/147/0;045390

    507843,9,3/574108843,.4250903.04190574850.9;090,.078489,9:8

    8,84/:094343,;,,-941909-448,3/49072,907,843574108843,

    89:/08.,70799030053903/,3.43/94383;03-4938

    ,3/ 4907 7043, ,3:,08 %8 706:70/ 089,-82039 41 8420 8:.

    /0/.,90/0/:.,943,7080,7..03907847/05,7920398410/:.,943,7080,7.3

    :3;078908.4:/03970-0/0;490/945:78:07080,7.3574108843,

    89:/08,3/3,70,84114:3/,9438410/:.,94333/,3.43909,3/4:/3

    90 9 41 907 7080,7.084:/ :/0 90 90,.07 0/:.,943 5747,2208

    90,.07 0/:.,9478 ,3/ 79078 41 909-448 3 574108843, 89:/08 ,773 ,

    ;07 10 /05,7920398.039078 41 0/:.,943 3 :3;078908 , 90 90,.07

    0/:.,943 3899:9438 89 702,3 .425090 03,0/ 3 90,.07 97,33

    ,.9;9084314730907 90,;0 7084:7.08 347 920 94,9903/ 94 7080,7.

    ,.9;9083,3,70,3,2,,8,2,,/970/9439,90983/

    41 7080,7. - .70,93 , /0/.,90/ /05,792039 .,0/ 05,792039 41

    4:3/,943841/:.,943.,803;8430/945430077080,7.3,70,841

    14:3/,943841 0/:.,94333/,3.4390940;0790 334;,9;0 39,9;0

    .4:/30;07 9,0411 90 74:3//:0 9490/894790/ 7080,7.5747908 41 90

    /05,792039

    ;2574;0/2094/84190,.3,3/0;,:,943

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    11/32

    %04228843,/ 025,80/ :8041 8:.2094/84190,.3-

    90,.07 0/:.,9478 . 03.4:7,0 5,79.5,943 ,3/ 801 89:/ . ;0

    455479:39089497,30090,.078949370,/89:/,3//8.:88,3/3.

    89:/0398 ,;0 94 03,0 90280;08 ,.9;0 3 -7,7 47 5740.9 47

    5705,7,9434170;08,3/705479809.%0,.070/:.,9478070,84050.90/94

    708479 94 1706:039:8041 02073 30 90.34408 55 ,84

    70.42203/0/ 701472 3 0,23,943 88902 3 97,33 3899:9438 ,3/

    2502039,943 41 90 574.088 41 .4393:4:8 ,3/ .42570038;0 0;,:,943

    . ,8 ,3 3-:9 .42543039 41 39073, ,880882039 . 70.0;08 ,

    831.,395,.039013,,880882039:2:,9;070.47/4189:/0398,8,84

    8:0890/94-02,39,30/9907.438:9,94314790797,3330053

    8:.70.47/8

    %080 70.42203/,9438 41 070 7010.90/ 3 :77.::2

    7,2047039025,80/9,997,33,850.94190,.070/:.,943

    147 98 574507 9,8 47039,943 8 088039, ,8 98 03,-0 90 90,.07 94

    ,3/0;,709419,8838/0,3/4:98/090.,8874423/478390;0841

    430;,:,9439,7:0/9,970,-0,3/;,/39073,88902410;,:,943

    84:/-0/0;0450/3.14.:884:/.,301742,88088394:/3

    9097,30090,.074798,847941.3.,,5574,.9,,72,3/507843,

    94:.,88:0890/94-0 3974/:.0/35,.0419084.,0/2507843,,3/

    4-0.9;0 3472,9;0 ,5574,. 41 ,880883 507843,9 ,3/ 9,9 39073, ,3/

    09073,,8808820392:89-0843805,7,90,3/349,//0/94090794,830

    ,70,9055

    %0 ! ,3/ ! ,3/ 70;80/! ,84 /00/

    :5439825479,39,850.94190,.070/:.,943,3/025,80/3974/:.94341

    .4393:4:8 ,3/ .42570038;0 0;,:,943 .425:847 40;07 90

    /:.,943 !4. #0;0 4229900 708970880/ 90

    70.42203/,9438 ,3/ 90 0/:.,94354. 574;8438 - 89,93 9,9 90,.07

    97,335747,22084:/.4;07.43.0598,3/2094/870,9394./.03970/

    ,5574,. 2:97,/0 90,.3 .4393:4:8 ,3/ .42570038;0 0;,:,943

    ,/4593 5,, ,3/ ,.9;9 -,80/ ,5574,. 3 572,7 0/:.,943 09.

    55.070 03/4780/ 3 90 705479 41 90422990043

    !4.5

    25,8843;,70/,3/302094/84190,.3,3/574.088470390/

    7,907 9,3 43 574/:.9 470390/ 0;,:,943 41 90 97,30090,.07 .

    572,714.:80843053,3/:/32.4393:4:894/0;0452394

    , 80389;0 334;,9;0,3/.42509039 90,.07 8,2,47 2574;02039 3 90

    ,70,4190,.32094/44390,.070/:.,9433899:9438

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    12/32

    40;07 ,8 0;/039 1742 90 :77.::2 7,2047 147 ":,9

    %0,.07 /:.,943 % ,8 349 2:. 8,9810/ 9 9080

    70.42203/,94384190,3/4907.42299008,3/90.43806:039.,308

    -74:9390,.3,3/97,332094/8390,.070/:.,94394-807;0/9,9

    90.,308,9900;04190,.070/:.,943,;0349,/06:,90708543/0/94

    900207370,908,9908.44 0;05,79.:,7,190790 3974/:.94341

    5,99073,3/4907/0;04520398.4:94130.0889/02,3/97,33

    4190,.078 330 50/,4,3/334;,9;00;,:,943 90.36:083890,/41

    :83 , :31472 2094/44 41 90,.3 ,3/ 0,733 90 7,2047

    8:0890/ 9,9 89,0 850.1. ,3/ .:9:70 850.1. 50/,4., 57,.9.08

    97,38,.943,897,9008,3/0;,:,9432094/884:/-09,:9 949097,300

    90,.07855%0/4.:20394-807;0/9,99889349-039,03.,70

    32489 41 90 90,.070/:.,943 3899:9438 9 025,80/ 9,9 147 0110.9;0

    .:77.:,7 97,38,.943 3907,.9;0 90,.3 .44507,9;0 90,.3 0,733 801

    /8.4;07,5574,.0809.84:/-0:80/,3/39097,33574.088025,88

    84:/-043/0;045203941.4250903.08,3/88.4:/-0051:3

    8,53419090,.07147,30110.9;07405,5

    ;%:73357,.9.090,.3394,30110.9;05747,220413907385

    $9:/03990,.3 8 90 .470 41 ,3 90,.07 97,33 5747,220 ,3/

    9070147092:8903,-09097,30090,.0794800147280190573.508,3/

    574.088084190,.30,7330;,:,94309.,80,739-2904709.,3

    907 1: 57,.9., 1472,3/ 974: 98 70,050703.02:89 03,-0 2 94

    /0;045,/0870/.4250903.08390,.394-0:80/3;,70/.43/94383

    8574108843,10

    ,84190453439,989:/03990,.384:/-0574;/0/394

    5,80814798-09907 25,.94397,30090,.07%04-0.9;0419017895,80

    84:/ -0 94 ,.6:,39 2 9 90 03970 8.44 10 974: /09,0/

    4-807;,9438 ,3/39,90 2 394,.9:,90,.33.02,,84-03

    857,.9.090,.3-90,.33/;/:,./703,3/90394,82,74:5

    4189:/0398%080.43/5,8084:/03,-0294/4.4393:4:890,.3147

    ,90,8909008:3/07,.9:,8.44.43/9438-473,8,90,.073,

    800.90/ 8.44 5%4:// 349 :80 90 9072 3907385 147 90

    80.43/89,04189:/03990,.390;071,.99,93985,809,390/90

    97,300 94 90,. 0 , 90,.07 .4393:4:8 147 09 008 8:0898 9,9 9

    20,39390738539080.43/5,804157,.9.090,.3

    %,8470390/90,.070/:.,9438890207090,.07894-070,/0/

    147 0110.9;0 5071472,3.0 41 8 740 070 57,.9.0 90,.3 8 088039,

    2,/02470 70,89. ,3/ 8:90/ 94 ,.9:, .,887442 89:,943 - :83 80708

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    13/32

    41 82:,93 ,3/ 2.7490,.3 89:,9438 -01470 803/3 4:9 90 97,300

    90,.078 14757,.9.0 90,.3,8 70.42203/0/3% 5%0

    7,2047//349850.1.,574;/01473907385,89,81099,9

    3907385 5747,220 ,8 349 70, 430 -043/ 57,.9.0 90,.3 .43.059

    40;07907,2047439030841025,80/57057,.9.0

    90,.3 ,.9;908 . 3.:/0 88902,9. 82:,90/ 90,.3 ,3/

    4-807;,9434108843894-0/0;070/-90,.070/:.,9478,3/44/90,.078

    ,.9:,57,.9.090,.3974:-4.90,.3,5574,.7,9079,3/0;073

    430088430;07/,,3/548957,.9.090,.3144:5-9,3:570,90/

    57,.9.,47 30;,:,94309. $3.047050703.0,3/0,90/:.,943

    ,3/70.70,943,,.9;908,;0-003 3.:/0/ 3.:77.::257,.9.0 90,.3

    /:7,943 ,8 94 -0 8:-89,39, 3.70,80/ ,3/ ,9 0,89 088438 070

    70.42203/0/,9,557457,903907;,5

    ,945,/,4228843,841099,939073854:/349

    43 05 /0;045 90,.3 88 3 70,90/ 8:-0.98 9 4:/ ,84 5705,70

    90,.071472,34907740808050.90/945,4:98/090.,887442%8

    706:70834943,84:3/5747,22041570390738582:,90/90,.3-:9

    ,84,.44507,943-09003.44507,938.4498573.5,,3/90.44507,93

    90,.07 :3/07 480 8:507;843 98 97,30090,.07 .425090 8

    3907385%8,850.9702,386:900,841,73903,2041390738543

    -4.57,.9.0 90,.3 847,30/. 80307,.43130/94 .,887442

    90,.3 050703.0 %0 4228843 79 4-807;0/ 9,9 98

    70.42203/,94341;03,-4:990390,78,4,8702,30/:3,9903/0/

    84 1,7 5 9 8:0890/ 3907385 3 / 147 ,9 0,89 8 008 94 -0

    570.0/0/-,0307,47039,94341430005#,2,2:794229900

    944,8, 147390738524/04189:/03990,.3,3/,/147,7/0/

    80;07,/09,0/,7:20398,80,88:089438147982502039,943,,389

    90.43;03943,57,.9.090,.3%824/0413907385,870.42203/0/

    147 ,.,90470841 8.4490,.078540;07422990043

    !4.,84190;09,9,9902420399070,70340/4.:20390/

    050703.084390390738524/0,3/57,.9.,,850.9814798,/4594343,

    ,70 8.,0 ,3/ 98 .425,7,9;0 ,/;,39,08 300/ 94 -0 0,230/ 1:7907 9

    8:0890/ 9,9,305079-4/41% 84:/89:/ 9024/0 3/059,3/

    :/090,.070/:.,9433899:94385

    40;07 90 "% 14:3/ 9,9 .,308 3 90 5,99073 ,3/

    57,.9.08 41 89:/03990,.3 ,;0 -003 43 507507, ,3/ 90.439039.:2

    2094/44 ,5574,. 070;07 ,9902590/ 702,30/ 290/ 94 90

    3974/:.94341,3,//943,.4254303941.43903994:91:,.0;390

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    14/32

    4-0.9;0 41 3907,943 %0 574-02 84;3 ,5574,. /8.4;07 2094/

    .4250903.-,80/90,.30,733,3/,55.,943410/:.,943,90.344

    31472,9.8 9002,9.8 .-073,9.8 09. ,;0 09 94 2,0 , /8.073-0

    0,/,98:0890/574;843413/:.9435747,2201475745070548:7094

    8.44 050703.08 1440/ - 8.44 -,80/ 57,.9.0 90,.3 147 .,5,.9

    -:/3.84:/3.:/057,.9.,4749079,3.,8874423897:.9438

    0.422:39050703.08,3/,.9;90870,90/94507843,9,3/0,/0785

    /0;045203955

    3907385 94: 8:0890/ - ,3/ 4907 .42299008 ,3/

    .42288438 ,8 702,30/ , 0, ,3/ 0:8;0 8905 3 90,.07 97,33

    5747,2208 5,79.:,7 03 0 9, ,-4:9 98 6:,9 ,3/ /:7,943

    ,8 70907,90/ 90 300/ 147 :80 41 3907385 24/0 3 , 570807;.0

    90,.07 97,33 5747,2208 3 47/07 94 8:89,3 90,.07 03,02039 9

    ./703 3 8.44 89:,9438 ,3/ 050703.08 41 90,.3 ./703 ,438/0

    70:,7 90,.078%8 9,8 79,7:0/05 90,.078 .4480/083

    47,30 ,3/ .43/:.9 20,331: .,887442 ,.9;908 .79., 7010.9 :543

    9074357,.9.08,3//0;045897,90081470;,:,93./70380,733147

    100/-,.394.:77.::2,3/50/,45

    ;0;045203941850.,.4:7808

    %0 70.42203/0//0;04520394130.4:7808347/07 942009

    850., 300/8 0 97,335747,220 1470,/2,89078,3/573.5,8 850.,

    .4:780 147 90,.07 0/:.,9478 41 572,7 ,3/ 80.43/,7 97,33 3899:9438

    .4:7808147 97,33 90,.078 14794 .4380.:9;0 89,084738:.,, 9,9

    984201:790747039,9434797,3390.4:/,8490,.,9,070;0

    $:..4:7808,;03490307,-0035,330/38420011479,8-0032,/0

    9497,390,.070/:.,9478147002039,797,333899:94383#8,3/,2,

    , 8,2, 907802489 41 90 90,.070/:.,9478 ,9 , 0;08 89,793

    1742570572,7 974:8034780.43/,7,70-0397,30/974:,0307,

    /5747,220%0300/147850.,97,331470,/2,89078,8,84-003

    10943,507507,8.,0,2,,84370.039,:3.0/,/542,.4:7803

    8.442,3,02039,3/,.4:780430/:.,943,,/23897,9438,70,/-03

    411070/1476:90842092040;07-08/089080850.,.4:780814720093

    90 850., 300/8 41 90,.078 ,3/ 90,.07 0/:.,9478 9070 ,70 2,3 4907

    02073,70,8.507,5807034914:3/84:703947/893.9,990920

    039049,74228843,/8:7;00/900/:.,943,89:,943,3/300/

    390.4:397-:93490,84300/94-0,//70880/9443, ,708.,047

    0,250 .4:7808 147 90,.3 ,3/.,550/ ./703 9 /1107039 14728 41

    58.,,3/2039,.,0308,.4:78014790790,.070/:.,9478,.4:7803

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    15/32

    % ,55.,943 ,3/ 3907,943 3 0/:.,943 , .4:780 147 0/:.,943,

    8:507;843 ,3/ :/,3.0 , .4:780 43 2,3,02039 31472,943 88902 3

    0/:.,943,.4:780147 ;4.,943,0/:.,943 90,.078,3/90,.070/:.,9478,

    97,33.4:780147,9073,9;0,3/334;,9;00/:.,943.03907809.3/4783

    9802073300/147850.,90,.070/:.,943.4:7808"%79

    4-807;0/9,94-,:58:70147:3;078,0/:.,94305484341340/0

    ,3/ 050.9,943 ,3/ ,857,9438 147 -09907 6:,9 41 10 ,;0 0/ 94 90

    0547,943 41 ,9073,9;08 94 90 1472, 88902 . 3.:/08 3431472,

    0/:.,943 ,/:9 0/:.,943 /89,3.0 0/:.,943 09. 8 /024.7,. ,84

    03;8,0806:,93494339072841,..088-:9,843,.0;02039,3/90

    10 .,3.08 98 .,8 147 3/;/:, ,9903943 94 ./ 3 90 .,887442 147

    . 90,.07 300/8 94 -0 97,30/ 974: ,9073,9;0 24/08 41 90,.07

    5705,7,943 ,3/ ,84 94 -0 803890/ 94 90 300/8 41 ./703 9 850.,

    .7.:289,3.08,3//11.:90850;04533090,.070/:.,943.4:7808

    84:/-0,.4393:3007.80.84:/-0.4393039:5439002073

    300/8419084.09

    ;#0;843,3/2574;0203941.:77.::2

    3;04190/0;045203989,35,.039084.09,93,943,,3/

    39073,943, 5,38 ,3/ 3 8.44 0/:.,943 ,8 ,84 3 90 9 41 90

    1:3/,2039,4-0.9;08415705,7390,.078147907;,70/7085438-9089

    ,8 109 30.088,7 - 9,9 .:77.:, ,3/ 5747,2208 ,9 , 0;08 41

    90,.070/:.,9432:89-070;80/%0%2,/01789/09,0/,990259

    94 2502039 98 7084;0 41 90 4228843 ,3/ .,20 4:9 9 2574;0/

    24/084190,.070/:.,943.:77.:, 14790,.078415708.4489,0572,7

    89,080.43/,789,0,3/0780.43/,7,3/.40,9089,08%05745480/

    .:77.::2 17,2047 ,/ 8:-89,39, /05,790/ 1742 90 0,707 97,/943,

    90,.070/:.,943.:77.::2394,8309,99,/805,7,90;8:,0/

    .:77.::2897:.9:70147/110703989,08410/:.,943,3/949,/1440/,

    80208907,5574,.39080.:77.:,%0.4:780897:.9:70,8,84.,30/3

    9847039,943,3/,5574,.9,8830/507.03909,09450/,4.,

    9047 507 .039 09,0 94 473 9 .422:39 ,3/ 507 .039

    09,0 94.439039.:22094/44,70,.3.:/0/57,.9.0 90,.3

    ,3/ 70,90/ 57,.9., 47 473 9 .422:39 9 ,8 03;8,0/ 3

    % 574;/0 ,.9:, 10 050703.08 94 90 97,300 90,.07 .

    703147.08904709.,0,73385$2,79,81099,92094/8,70

    20,331: 03 9,:9 3 70,943 94 .439039 %4 ,.0;0 98 03/ 9 ,8

    8:0890/9,990,.3882,-0/0;0450/39474:58;.47088

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    16/32

    .,703/85038,-0147,95084190,.078,3/850.1.8830.088,7147

    90,.3/11070398:-0.98,9/11070390;08

    4397,794870.42203/,9431473433907,90/90,.0797,33

    5747,220890,943,422884343%0,.078,831,;4:741

    0,73907,90/24/04190,.0797,33,1907.84:/14.:843-49

    0307,0/:.,943,3/574108843,0/:.,94340;07 9,84 8:0890/ 9,9

    :39 98 24/0 8 25020390/ ,9902598 84:/ -0 2,/0 94 89703903 90

    0893 430 0,7/ ,3/ 0,7542, 3002039,7 90,.07 0/:.,943

    .4:7808-70;,25390.:77039.:77.:,,3/0903/390473/,894,9

    0,89 3 ,3 ,.,/02. 0,7 %0 4228843 ,84 109 9,9

    2094/8 41 90,.3 47 .439039.:22094/44 .42543039 3 90,.07

    97,33.4:7808702,38900,08933.,3,3/9,938:11.039920,3/

    ,99039438-035,/9457,.9.090,.338.448%7,3390.344083

    90 97,33 .4008 ,;0 94 -0 2574;0/ 7,/., - :83 0/:.,943,

    90.344 3 97,33 97,30090,.078 ,3/ - 97,33 902 3 98 :80 3

    8.448 %4: 9 .42203/0/ 90 ,990259 2,/0 - 90 % 94 8970 ,

    -,,3.0-090030/:.,943,9047,3/57,.9.0974:98%099

    1099,9390941050703.084190,.070/:.,9433899:9438,3/9030

    /02,3/8439090,.079817,2047,84300/870;84303.0390

    %70;80/980,707:77.::27,204714790,.070/:.,943

    %0 70;80/ 17,2047 ,8 57080390/ 147 , 89,08 41 0/:.,943. ,/

    9700 2,47 .425430398 41 9047 57,.9.0 90,.3 ,3/ 57,.9., 47 3

    57,.9.0 90,.3 ,9 572,7 ,3/ 07 0;08 90 .43.059 41 50/,4.,

    ,3,8841700;,398.448:-0.98,8903014.:8-08/0857,.9.090,.3

    ,3/ 4-807;,943 4124/0 088438 $2,7 3 57,.9., 47 ,850.98 0

    8.44050703.0 3.:8;0 41 390738547 0/:.,943 8.44.422:39

    3907,.943 ,.943 7080,7. 89:/08 ,3/ 47,3,943 41 700;,39 0/:.,943,

    ,.9;90809.0703.:/0/%0 90,.070/:.,943.:77.:,07070;80/ 3

    90941987,2047-:99,81099,9,99097,38,.943,0;090,.07

    0/:.,9478 .4:/ 349 .,77 4:9 50/,4., ,3,88 41 .439039 ,3/ 84 90

    .4393:0/94144904/,5574,.415,33314790,.33.:77.::241

    80.43/,7 90,.07 0/:.,943 8420 45943, .4:7808 .43.0733 .:77039 88:08

    ,3/ .43.0738 0 ;4.,943, 0/:.,943 03;7432039, 0/:.,943 .425:907

    0/:.,94309.0703.47547,90/

    %0 ,85, 4229900 #05479 03990/ 0,733 94:9

    :7/03,83490/9,990025,88390,.070/:.,9435747,220884:/

    -04303,-397,300894,.6:7090,-91478010,733,3/3/0503/039

    933 08590 , 9080 .43.0738 ,3/ 70.42203/,9438 79 4-807;0/

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    17/32

    3 70,9 90,.070/:.,9435747,2208 94/,97,3 90,.078 94

    ,/:899490300/841,889023.0/:.,94388003,89097,382884341

    31472,943 9902598 ,9 .:77.:,7 701472 ,9 8.44 0;0 ,;0 349 -003

    ,/06:,908:554790/90114798,990,.070/:.,9438935747,2208

    /4 349 ,//7088 .:77.:,7 /083 ,3/ 88:08 41 70,9438 -09003 8.44 ,3/

    84.09 %070 8 990 03,02039 9 90 3:2074:8 70.039 334;,9;0

    0/:.,943,050720398503.09070 8,300/ 94.420:59,1708

    8.0204190,.070/:.,9435747,2208..,305397,38,.939030

    8.44.:77.:, 3 79507850.9;0,3/03,-0 90,.078 3 708543/3 94 90

    ./7038300/8,3/-73/0870/.,3083902%840;074:/349

    -0,..42580/ ,8,8.,:9430/-9049,74228843-,3 39,

    90,.0797,3340;07.425090 9 89 4-807;0/ 9,9 902470/3,2.,

    ;4.,943890088.,3.089070,7041;3,.42509039,97,33$4

    ,9 8 25479,39 3 , 90,.07 97,335747,220 8 ,8 8970880/-,85,

    4229900,8494/0;04539089:/039389,3/:3/0789,3/390

    .,5,.9 94 0,73 ,3/ 7084:7.01:3088 55 %8 34907 47/8,8

    ,84 8970880/ - 39073,943, 4228843 43 /:.,943 03 9

    4-807;0/9,939,0/:.,943.,3-070,7/0/,854071:19,8574;/0/

    90 2509:8 ,3/ 14:3/,943 9,9 2,0 9 5488-0 94 .4393:0 94 0,73

    974:4:9105

    ;!4897,/:,90.4:78030/:.,943

    %0,8,84.43.0730/,-4:954897,/:,90.4:780830/:.,943

    1470,733,89078/070030/:.,943.,7030907.48030/9

    574108843, 300/8 ,9 , 07 0;0 347 90 ,;0 90 /059 ,3/ 390389

    30.088,71479089:/410/:.,943,8,/8.5305:7,94341/

    4:780 ,3/ 98 .:77.::2 -49 300/ , 70;0 70.42203/0/ 9,9 98

    /:7,94384:/-00903/0/949700,.,/02.90728347/0794,489:/0398

    94 :3/079,0 , /00507 8.0391. ,3/ ,.,/02. 89:/ 3 8420 850.1. 10/

    706:73850.,340/0,3/39,9;0,3/84:/.4388941.470.4:78083

    14:3/,943 41 0/:.,943 .4:7808 3 ,70,8 41 850.,,943 89:/ 41

    2094/44417080,7.,3/, /88079,943%08054897,/:,90.4:7808,;0

    -003 70;00/ ,3/ 2574;0/ -:9 90 /:7,943 41 9080.4:7808 ,8 702,30/

    :3.,30/47/9.4393:0894-04300,7,3/1473/:.,9439

    80,78$479/:7,9434154897,/:,90.4:78030/:.,943/057;0889:/0398

    412,30,733,.9;908,3/455479:390841574108843,/0;0452039

    :7,943414:7808

    49,74228843,84190;09,9002039,790,.070/:.,943

    5747,22084:/-0410,78/:7,943,3/80.43/,790,.0797,3341430

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    18/32

    0,7:93,3,.,/02.0,7398;0907084:/-0,90,89473

    /,8 3 90 430 0,7 / 5747,220 47 / ,8 89,90/ 0,707 9

    70.42203/0/0,785074/3890,/4108934300,7

    %0 :77.::2 7,2047 ,3/ ,943, !4. 43

    /:.,943,3/!,;057010770/90 0893,77,302039 41

    940,78 97,33,1907 80347 80.43/,7 8.44 147 002039,7 90,.078,3/

    430 0,78 97,33 ,1907 7,/:,943 47 5489 7,/:,943 147 80.43/,7 8.44

    90,.0789038433473/,83,3,.,/02.0,71742/,894

    /,8 147 2,3 -09907 :80 41 430 0,7 /:7,943 ,8 70.42203/0/ - 90

    422884340;0714713,3.,,3/57,.9.,70,8438904228843//

    349,700949057454894341940,78/5747,2205

    %0/0,4109038433473/,8390,.,/02.0,794/,8

    . ,8 24/10/ 94 /,8 3 90 70.42203/,9438 41 90 ,943,

    422884343%0,.0785.4:/349,31,;4:7174290,.07

    97,333899:9438,80,8174290%%0%83472147473

    /,8 706:708 ,9 0,89 90,.3 /,8. 3.:/08 /,8 3907385

    %0,.070/:.,9433899:9438,;094,/07094908034728

    %4:,834931,;4:741,940,7/5747,220%3

    98 /4.:2039 :77.::2 7,2047 147":,9 %0,.07 /:.,943

    ,85745480/8:.,5747,220,3/,8.4204:99:/0308147908,20

    5%8940,7/24/08:3/0705072039314:7#8,3/:,7,9

    '/,5009 147 90 ,89 10 0,78 ":,9 41 4:95:9 41 98 24/0 ,3/ 98

    0110.9;0308880994-0,8.079,30/98,7:0/9,92,310,9:708419094

    0,78/.,3-0.43/0380/ 3 9008934300,7 5747,2209 8420

    09038433473/,8,8,870.42203/0/-%8,88:..0881:

    -003970/3,2,,8,2,,3/:7:8097,&3;0789

    %0%0,.07/:.,943:77.::27,2047,/70.42203/0/

    705,.02039410893,33:,88902-80208907889020700,.80208907

    84:/-0 ,9 0,89 41 1: 473 /,8 3 47/07 94 2502039 90 9,8

    470390/ 90,.07 97,33 5747,220 8:0890/ - 9 5 %0 /0, 41

    802089078890231789/0700.4:78030/:.,94380994.,9.:5390,.07

    97,33 3899:9438 147 98 43 57,.9., 70,8438 ,3 :3;078908 ,;0

    89.0/4;07174280289078,9439490,33:,88902

    %0 6:08943 41 0903843 3 /:7,943 41 002039,7 47 80.43/,7

    90,.07 0/:.,943 5747,220 94 14:71;0 47 94 0,78 ,8 13,3.,

    0/:.,943,,3/,/23897,9;025.,94384:70,73907,90/.4:7808070

    0307, 0/:.,943 ,3/ 574108843, 0/:.,943 8 3907,90/ .,3 0110.9;0 -0

    411070/30307,.4008,3//05,7920398410/:.,9433:3;0789087,907

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    19/32

    9,33.4008410/:.,943%82,,840537024;384,943-09003

    /05,792039 410/:.,943 47 .40041 0/:.,943 ,3/:3;078982,38970,2

    /05,7920398:9940,78/,88:0890/-%,8,,4:9-09003

    430 0,7 ,3/ 14:7 0,7 24/08 2, -0 47,30/ 3 .4008 41 90,.07

    0/:.,943 9 706:70 03,3.02039 3 1,.:9 897039 ,3/ 317,897:.9:7,

    1,.908 3 .4008 41 90,.07 0/:.,943 ,3/ $8 47 ,39 41 097,

    7084:7.08,3/3;08920399070,550,7894-0,0307,,.41039:8,82147

    940,78/94:3573.5098,5570.,90/,898050.90/94574;/0

    247085,.09497,30090,.07894,.6:70.4250903.0390,.3

    ,3,0203941%0,.07/:.,943974:$9,904,7/8

    %8,88:0890/-9,9$9,904,7/841%0,.07/:.,943

    -0 809 :5 3 0,. $9,90 . .43/:.9 8:7;08 41 90,.07 0/:.,943

    5747,2208 ,3/ .:77.:, ,3/ 39,90 30.088,7 ,.943 147 2,39,33

    89,3/,7/84190,.070/:.,943390$9,908%0804,7/8,;030907-003809

    :5347 ,3 ,907 .4229900847.42288438 ,;00;07.,70/94/8.:88 907

    300/471472,9433890,/$#%8,8$9,900;0897:.9:708,;0-003.70,90/

    %0804:3.8,;041903702,30/.43130/ 94002039,7 90,.070/:.,943

    94:84209208 90,84471473807;.00/:.,9434180.43/,78.44

    90,.0781907 90089,-8203941 90 3,943, 89,9:947 70:,947 -4/41

    %9070/408349800294-0,3300/,3/700;,3.041$9,900;04,7/8

    41%0,.07/:.,94331,.90349,7422884370.42203/0/9,9,

    90,.0797,333899:943884:/-0;03.40,9089,9:8,3/90,84:/

    :92,90 -0 -74:9 :3/07 90 8:507;843 ,3/ .43974 41 :3;078908 9 3

    9801 /0025,80/ 90 300/ 147 .70,943 41 $9,90 4,7/8 41 %0,.07

    /:.,943

    !4897,/:,904:7808,3/#080,7.3/:.,943

    9,84-807;0/-9,9089354897,/:,90.4:780830/:.,943

    ,70349.48030/9574108843,300/8,9,070;0347/490,;0

    90 /059 ,3/ 390389 30.088,7 147 90 89:/ 41 0/:.,943 ,8 ,3 ,.,/02.

    /8.530%0,550,7 94 ,;0 743 4:9 41 90/ .4:7808 94:9 ,3

    .0,7 /0, 41 907 5:75480 5 3 ;0 41 90 3.70,83 /02,3/ 147

    6:,10/ 90,.07 0/:.,9478 147 783 3:2-07 41 002039,7 80.43/,7 ,3/

    490790,.070/:.,9433899:943898:7039706:70/9,9.:77.:,415489

    7,/:,90 90,.07 0/:.,943 .4:7808 ,70 70;,250/ 0053 3 ;0 90 89,0

    850.1. 300/8 41 90,.07 97,3008 90 .,308 9,9 ,70 -03 3974/:.0/ 3

    8.44 .:77.::2 ,3/ 90,.07 5705,7,943 5747,2208 ,3/ ,84 90 30

    .,03089,9,70-031,.0/-8.440/:.,943

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    20/32

    %00893/5747,22087954390/4:9-&8#0;0

    422990043/:.,943 ,. 0110.9;03088 ,3/ 94:91: /70.943 ,3/9,9

    90 ,70 2489 473,2039, 0.059 147 807;.08 3 , 97,33 .400 5

    %080.4:7808,70.,7,.9070/-,.41507850.9;039072841.4390398,8

    0,86:,1.,9438,3/,700307,,.,/02. 33,9:70,3/349,/06:,90

    574108843, 3 .439039 % 47 ,39 41 9080 300/8 90 #0;80/

    ! 7084;0/ 9,9 0893 5747,2208 41 90,.07 0/:.,9478 -0

    8:9,-24/10/472574;3/.4:78090,945,/,4228843

    .,0/ 147 970,93 9 ,8 ,30903843 41 90 5074/41574108843,

    5705,7,943. 84:/ .439,3 3 9, /070041 850.,,943,3/ -0

    0,70/ 94 90 5705,7,943 41 90,.07 0/:.,9478 .:77.::2 .438:9,398

    3850.94788:507;8478,3/0/:.,943,,/23897,94785$2,7%

    3 98 :77.::2 7,2047 147 ":,9 %0,.07 /:.,943 ,84

    8:0890/ 47,3,943 41 805,7,90 / 5747,2208 147 /1107039

    .,904708,70,8 94 .,907 94 90 300/ 41 89,0 850.1. ,3/ .,9047 850.1.

    5705,7,94341 90,.070/:.,94780/!70!72,7/02039,7

    /$0.43/,7,3/$0347$0.43/,7/ $50.,/ 89,3.0

    09.%41:790703,3.0906:,94190,.070/:.,947890!!

    /0./0/94.70,90,805,7,90.,/704190,.070/:.,9478147,554392039,889,11

    3$#%8%8,3/%85

    ,84/8.:880/3/09,906:,9417080,7.30/:.,943,3/109

    9,9 90/0;0452039410/:.,943, 7080,7.4, 43, 35705,73

    5078438.425090399447,99054897,/:,900;040;079,84,..0590/

    9,9 0;0754897,/:,90 0.9:707300/349-0, 7080,7.470770,/4941

    7080,7.89:/0830/:.,943,;0-003,..42580/%0708,300/9414.:8

    90243300/8,3/574-028418.44890,.078,3/89:/0398

    ":,941%7,333899:9438

    347/07948970390390,.0797,333899:943841/11070390;0890

    2,/0 89,0 850.1. 70.42203/,9438 ,341 9080 70.42203/,9438

    ,;083.0-0033.47547,90/38:..00/30/:.,943,54./4.:20398%0

    70.42203/,9438.4;070/1,.:9,3/58.,7084:7.08,3/89:/0398039073

    390803899:9438

    $0.43/,790,.0797,333899:9438

    %0,.070/:.,9478,9980;0,703,/06:,905705,70/%084:/5488088

    , /4:-0 ,89078 /0700 3 ,.,/02. 8:-0.9 ,3/ 0/:.,943 ,3/ , 1,7

    574547943 8, 507 .039 84:/ ,84 4/ /4.947,90 /07008 :9 3

    58.44 84.44 8.03.0 47 2,902,9.8 850.,898 94:9 ,

    574108843, 97,33 2, -0 ,554390/ %0 4228843 70.42203/0/

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    21/32

    8:-89,39, 3.70,80 3 4:95:9 41 !8 /8 ,3/ 8 3 /:.,943 %4

    2574;0905071472,3.04147390,.070/:.,947847,3,943418:2207

    3899:908 147 902 ,8 70.42203/0/ 5 $4 1,7 ,8 6:,9 41 89:/0398

    43390803899:94388.43.0730/90,;082:.94-0/0870/$0.43/,7

    97,333899:9438/4349,997,.989:/03984/344//07008,3/90.420

    9 /01.03.08 3 8:-0.9 340/0 . -0.4208 , 8074:8 :7/0 94

    5747088 03 9 8 5745480/ 94 :57,/0 90 .:77.:, 41 80.43/,7 8.448

    8:-89,39, 9 ,8 70.42203/0/ 9,9 - 411073 8.4,7858 3 90,.07

    97,33 3899:908,3/44/8,,70838.448-099076:,10/89:/039884:/

    -0 ,997,.90/ $2,7 9 ,8 4-807;0/ 9,9 1,.908 ,;,,-0 3 9080

    3899:94383.:/3-7,708,-47,94708,:/4;8:,,/8,3/478458,3/

    .7,1974428,701,717428,981,.947,3/908,2084:/-02574;0/974:

    39038;00114798!74;8434148901,.9,90,89147,1419089:/0398,8

    5,79.:,770.42203/0/-904228843

    3899:908147572,790,.078

    %0 14:3/ 90 .43/943 41 572,7 90,.07 97,33 3899:908 ;07

    /0570883 ,3/ 907 89,3/,7/8 2470 :38,981,.947 9,3 80.43/,7 97,33

    3899:908 ,3/ 03.0 , 8:57020 011479 ,8 8:0890/ 94 -02,/0 94 2574;0

    907 .43/943 9 ,8 4-807;0/ 9,9 907 89,11 8 0307, 9,03 1742

    80.43/,7 8.448 4 ,70 97,30/ 147 80.43/,7 89,0 %0 4228843

    70.42203/0/9,99089,114190803899:90884:/5488088,,89078/0700

    090730/:.,94347 3,3,.,/02.8:-0.9,3/84:/-0,/06:,9097,30/

    147907470907974:850.,47039,943473/:.94397,33.0593

    .,80 41 572,7 97,33 3899:9438 4.,90/ 3 - .908 90 .43/943 41

    1,.908390803899:9438,814:3/94-00307,5447

    %:943100

    ,84190;09,99:94310083,90,.07897,333899:90884:/-0

    ,-480/

    ;0243897,9438.44

    97,33 3899:908 84:/ ,;0 , /0243897,943 8.44 47 05072039,

    8.44.-0:80/1475:75480841/0243897,94347850.,89:/08

    ;39,0.,5,.9

    %7,33 1,.908 84:/ -0 /7,89., 03,3.0/ 94 2009 90 /02,3/ 147

    97,30/ 90,.078 %0 70.42203/0/ 9,9 908041,30893 572,7

    90,.07 97,33 3899:90 84:/ -07,80/ 94,232:241,3/ 9,941,

    80.43/,790,.07897,333899:94394944592,:90901,.90841

    90803899:908473090,.0797,333899:90890232:28084:/349

    -0 088 9,3 89:/0398 3 5,333 90 4.,943 41 , 90,.07 97,33

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    22/32

    3899:943 80;07, 1,.9478 84:/ -0 .438/070/ ,3/ , .079,3 574547943

    0850.,9480,990572,789,084:/-04.,90/37:7,,70,8

    742901,.9857080390/0,707982,-0.0,79,990,.070/:.,943

    3899:9438,9002039,7,3/80.43/,70;08//34970.0;0,3,99039433

    90!9,91440/90#%0%,84/0,9943

    .:77.:,7 70147283 90,.070/:.,94394:9 701077394 902574;020398

    300/0/39058.,,3/:2,37084:7.0.43/94384190803899:94388,

    708:9,,703:2-074190002039,790,.0797,333899:9438,3/

    80.43/,7 90,.07 97,33 3899:9438 070 14:3/ 8:11073 1742

    3,/06:,90 1,.908 :2,3 58., ,3/ ,.,/02. 94 574;/0 44/

    574108843, 0/:.,943 ! %4 038:70 9,9 .43/943 41 9080

    3899:9438 30.088,7 2574;08 ! 03;8,0/ , 850., 0397,

    $5438470/ $.020 147 %0,.07/:.,943 . ,8 0;039:, ,:3.0/ 3

    9 ,77,3020398 41 8:-89,39, 1:3/3 147 897039033 ,3/

    089,-82039 41 002039,7 ,3/ 80.43/,7 90,.07 0/:.,943 3899:9438;

    %830;07/897.94190.4:397,3/%8,3/$83800.90/

    80.43/,7 90,.07 0/:.,943 3899:9438 8 41 /,90 ,74:3/ %8

    %8 ,3/ $8 ,;0 -003 574;/0/ 0397, ,8889,3.0 147 ,77,33

    8:11.0391,.908,3/1,.:9390803899:9438

    % 43 98 5,79 038:70/ 9,9 90,.07 0/:.,9478 3 80.43/,7 ,3/

    002039,790,.0797,333899:94385488088232:2/0870/6:,1.,9438

    - 2,3 9 2,3/,947 9,9 , 80.43/,7 90,.07 0/:.,947 2:89 5488088 ,

    /4:-0 2,89078 /0700 3 8.44 8:-0.9 ,3/ 574108843, 0/:.,943 ,3/ ,8

    706:70/-&,!/070047%30/:.,943,8,870.42203/0/-

    ,84 47 002039,7 90,.07 0/:.,947 ,84 90 088039, 6:,1.,9438

    3.:/0,2,89078/070030/:.,9434738.448:-0.997,/:,90/0700

    3 0/:.,943 9 1;0 0,78 8.44 90,.3 050703.0 %0 8

    70.42203/,9439,92,8907 /07004/0783 84.4458.44 8.03.0

    47 2,902,9.8 94:9 ,3 574108843, 97,33 2, -0 ,554390/ ,8

    80.43/,790,.070/:.,9478.4:/349-0,..0590/,897,30/0/:.,947839080

    8:-0.98,7034,;,,-08 70.42203/,9431478:-89,39, 3.70,80 3

    4:95:9 3/,3/ ,3/ ! 3 /:.,943 8 -03 25020390/ ,9 ,

    845,.0 94: 90/02,3/ 147 9080 .4:7808 8 890,/ 3.70,83/:0 94

    .4393:0/ 089,-82039 41 30 3899:9438 41 90,.07 0/:.,943 43 , ,70

    8.,0 40;07 90 1,.:9 -03,554390/ 3 002039,7 90,.07 0/:.,943

    3899:943889/40834970.0;0574108843,97,333002039,70/:.,943

    7,9072489 41 902,70 97,30/ 147 80.43/,7 0/:.,943 %070 8 , 8074:8

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    23/32

    /0,7941002039,790,.070/:.,943.4:7808,9-491789,3/80.43//0700

    0;0830/:.,943

    4228843870.42203/,9431472574;02039358.,1,.908,70

    34 , 5,79 41%8 34728 147 317,897:.9:70 09. 147 , 90,.07 0/:.,943

    3899:943,3/9080,;094-0088039,,/070/94-,9090,.0797,33

    3899:943840;079070.42203/,943843.425:847574;843414890

    1,.9 3 97,33 3899:9438,3/574;84341/0243897,9434705072039,

    8.44,99,.0/90,.4190803899:943894:6:9025479,39,;0349

    -0030307,25020390//:09413,3.,,3/,/23897,9;070,8438$3.0

    90 8:-28843 41 # 8,,708 ,3/ 807;.0 .43/9438 41 90,.078 ,;0

    70.0;0/ 8:-89,39, -4489 43 90 70.42203/,9438 41 ! ,3/

    ,945,/,, 4228843 ,3/ 9 ,8 94 ,3 09039 050/ 3

    ,997,.938420,9-0990789:/0398,80/:.,94789490,.0797,333899:9438

    94:147490770,84388990-089,24389902,70349.4239497,33

    3899:9438

    %0870.42203/,943418041089380.43/,747002039,7

    90,.070/:.,9433899:94341,3/89:/039870850.9;01474592:2

    :9,94341981,.908,83491:-00325020390/489419097,33

    3899:9438 0893 47 30 ,;0 ,3 39,0 41 89:/0398 43 %0

    70.42203/,94341 13 ,232:2 39,041 89:/0398 330 90,.07

    97,33 3899:9438 ,84 ,8 349 -003 25020390/ %0 %8 34728 147

    39,0 41 89:/0398 ,;0 70897.90/ 9 94 :398 41 ,3/ 89:/0398 147

    002039,7 ,3/ 80.43/,7 97,33 3899:9438 70850.9;0 3 90 -0333

    . .,3 ,907 -0 03,3.0/ 94 94 47 2470 :398 8:-0.9 94 8,981,.943 41

    34728 147 05,3843 %0 42288438 70.42203/,943 147 45033 ,3

    3899:90 147 ,9 0,89 473 /,8 3 ,3 ,.,/02. 0,7 ,8 -003 14:3/

    :310,8-0-%,3/9,870897.90/99490,.3/,8.3.:/08

    /,84139073853.:8;0415705,7,943147908,2055%0

    42288438;09,905,3843397,331,.93 0,.$9,90 84:/-0

    -,80/ 43 , 574507 /0;0450/ 05,3843 897,90 ,3/ 43 ,3 3899:943,

    4.,9435,3,8,7/70.0;0/,3,99039430.0599,93.,8041002039,7

    90,.07 97,33 3899:9438430 $9,90 7:3% 834 088039, 4.,90/ 3

    0,. /897.9 3 90 ,-803.0 41 ,3 /0;0452039 5,3 147 90,.07 0/:.,943

    3899:94330,.$9,90:3-,,3.0/05,384341 90803899:94380850.,

    ,990,3/84157;,903;0894788 9,35,.043,,708.,09897:09,9

    8990708,:0:31:10//02,3/14797,30/90,.078%884:/-0209

    -089,-833899:943843 90-,8841,507850.9;0 5,3,3/3899:943,

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    24/32

    2,553007.80849,99005,3843824700;03/897-:90/,3/-0.4208

    -0301.,14797,30090,.078,3/8.448,8,8,7:0/-

    3807;.0/:.,94341$.44%0,.078

    4393:33807;.00/:.,943,3/97,33414738.4490,.078,80

    ,81,.:9202-0784197,333899:94388,300/415,7,24:39831.,3.0

    147 2574;3 90 6:,9 41 8.44 0/:.,943 0850., 03 90 5,.0 41

    05,38433340/0,3/.,308306:520394147,70,550,73,9,3

    :3570.0/039,1,895,.0;8:,0/98300/14:7/0.,/08,4.,8

    43 -0.420 2:. 2470 700;,39 ,3/ /02,3/3 - 34 47 3807;.0

    0/:.,943 88902 94 -0 0110.9;0 ,9903943 43 9700 2,47 /2038438 ,8

    025,80/ - 88902,9. 144 :5,1907 0;07 43 9072 3807;.0

    0/:.,9435747,22094,:09825,.9439074:3/.480.447/3,943

    -09003 8.44 ,:947908 ,3/ 3807;.0 0/:.,943 ,03.08 ,3/

    .4393:3 3807;.0/:.,943 94-0 8:554790/-7080,7. 30/:.,943070

    708:98417080,7.14/43948.448,3/97,333899:908,3/574-02841

    9080 3899:9438 .2- :5 94 7080,7. 3899:9438 9 ,84 8:0890/ 9,9

    3807;.00/:.,94341,90,89949497002439884:/-070.0;0/-0;07

    90,.07 3 , -4. 41 0,78 41 8 807;.0 47 .4393:3 574108843,

    /0;0452039 41 8.44 90,.078 ,84 70.42203/0/ 089,-82039 41

    8.44.425008,8,3334;,9;0897,90,243.:89078418.448

    25479,3947390/70.943413807;.00/:.,943,/89,790/390

    .4:397 3 11908 9 90 089,-82039 41 903843 $07;.0 039708 ,3/

    903843 $07;.0&398 3 90,.078 .4008 ,3/9 90 80993:541$9,90

    3899:90841/:.,943248941.,90705,3/0/94$#%814780.43/,7

    ,3/002039,78.4490,.0789,8,77,30/-#%,3/904393:3

    /:.,943 039708 809 :5 :3/07 98 ,08 147 572,7 90,.07 0/:.,9478 ,3/

    572,7,3/80.43/,78.4490,.078,9078.44.425008070,84

    809 :5 3,7 %,2,/:,7,3,#,,89,3 ,3/,,7,897, ,943,

    4228843 43 %0,.078 5 :9 ,8 4-807;0/ - 4228843 43

    %0,.0783807;.00/:.,94330907-0.,204-,9471470;0790,.07147

    8574108843,749347,.4393:,1:79070,733.4:/-0.420,5,7941

    4709484190,.3574108843553807;.090,.070/:.,9438,3

    3907, ,3/ 43089 5,79 41 90 90,.07 0/:.,943 .4393::2! ,/

    794-807;0/9,9570807;.0,3/3807;.00/:.,943.4254303984190,.07

    0/:.,943,703805,7,-05%00397,$5438470/$.020147%0,.07

    /:.,943574;/0/,15943807;.00/:.,9434190,.078,3/90,.07

    0/:.,9478-1:3/3%8$#%8%8,3/$8147/11070390;0841

    90,.078 ,3/ 90,.070/:.,947840;07 90 $.020 /:90/ 90 /:7,94341

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    25/32

    3807;.00/:.,943,3/7084;0/9,90;0790,.07-0706:70/94:3/074

    ,97,3341,90,89970000830;07-4.411;00,78418807;.0

    90803899:9438,.9;047,30/3807;.00/:.,9435747,2208

    0859090803807;.00/:.,943,.9;90890/:.,943!4.#0;0

    4.:2039 14:3/ 8420 41 90 8,20 4/ 0,308808 3 3807;.0

    0/:.,943 5747,2208 ,8 070 349.0/ - 9 89,90/ 9,9 3807;.0

    5747,2208 ,70 349 0110.9;0 47,30/ 9070 8 , 5447 .447/3,943 ,3/

    2439473 41 3807;.0 0/:.,943 5747,2208 ,3/ 7080,7. -,80 1472,3

    3807;.0 0/:.,943 2470 0110.9;0 8 ,-8039 5 2470 -,,3.0/

    ,9903943 43570807;.0 ,3/ 3807;.0 97,33 41 90,.078 ,8 8970880/ 3 90

    ! 5 08590 2,3 3807;.0 0/:.,943 70,90/ 39,9;08

    5,79.:,7,1907 9089:,943413807;.00/:.,943390.4:397,8

    349 14:3/ 94-0;0703.4:7,3-% 3 98 ,943,":,9%0,.07

    /:.,9437,20479,84-807;0/9,943,3,;07,0507.039

    419090,.078,70574;/0/3807;.090,.070/:.,94343.04;07,5074/41

    1;00,785,3/9,99448290/94,2,2:2/:7,94341008

    38:..7.:289,3.0847,3,94341243983807;.097,33147

    0;07 473 90,.07 4;07 0;07 -4. 41 1;0 0,78 41 807;.0 ,8 ,8

    70.42203/0/ - 80028 94 -0 , 702490 5488-9 43 %0 3807;.0

    5747,2208 ,8 -0347,30/ - #% $#%8 %8 ,3/ $8 147

    90,.078,3/90,.070/:.,947889300/4941170844-49,9907.439039

    ,3/897,90470,25090 334;,9;0897,900841$.44425008,3/

    %0,.078039708.,;0 ,70,/ -003 970/ 8:..0881: 3 90.4:397

    300/ 94 -0 545:,70/ ,43 9 4907 897,9008 ,3/ ,03.08 41 3807;.0

    0/:.,943 41 90,.078 84 9070 8 ,3 :7039300/ 94243947 906:,941

    9080 3807;.0 5747,2208 ,3/ 0;,:,90 907 25,.9 3 70.039 0,78 9 ,8

    -003349.0/9,9$9,90 4;07320398,3/$#%8 3 ,3,99025994200990

    3:207., ,3/0503/9:709,7098,703/:3 38074:8.4257428089

    6:,94190805747,2208

    !74108843,0;045203941%0,.078307/:.,943

    49,7 4228843 ,/ 79 4-807;0/ 9,9 3 3/, 9070 8 34

    574;843 147 90 574108843, 39,943 41 , :3;0789 90,.07 -0.,:80 8

    97,33 8 70,7/0/ ,8:330.088,7 9 8970880/ 9,9 9070 8 , 300/ 147 8420

    47039,943,3/97,3341:3;07890.9:7078-043/,3/4:-9$494-03

    9 8:9,-0 ,77,3020398 41 574108843, 47039,943 41 :347 0.9:7078 3

    07 0/:.,943 84:/ -02,/0 - :3;078908 47 , 74:5 41 :3;078908

    70:,747039,9434130,554390/1,.:9-047,30/30;07:3;0789

    ,3/ 070 5488-0 3 0;07 .400 ,3/ 3-07 :3;07890847 74:5 41

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    26/32

    :3;078908 9080 .4:7808 84:/ -0 47,30/ 43 , 5072,3039 -,88 -

    089,-83 89,11 .4008 5 %0 574108843, 47039,943 41 07

    0/:.,94390,.078.4:/ 70.0;0 8420,990394343,1907902502039,943

    4190!.03;8,0/089,-8203941.,/02.$9,1140083

    /1107039 5,798 41 90 .4:397 94 47,30 0307, 574108843, 47039,943

    .4:7808 41 14:7 008 /:7,943 147 30 ,554390/ 0.9:7078 :3/07 /70.9

    1:3/31742&%080.4008-0,39447,3047039,943.4:78081742

    ,907 90070,84 ,8830/ 90 7085438-9 41 47,33 8:-0.9

    -,80/70170807.4:780841 9700008/:7,943 147803471,.:93 /1107039

    /8.5308 %020 -,80/ 8023,78 ,3/ 478458 147 90 -03019 41 1,.:9

    202-078,3/,.,/02.,/23897,947841070/:.,9433899:9438,70,84

    47,30/-908089,11.40089,;0941:79071,.9,90574108843,

    /0;0452039 41:3;0789 90,.07843, ,707 8.,0&,8 ,84 0903/0/

    8:5547994 :3;0789089447,30 70170807.4:78083/1107039/8.5308 3

    90 .43.0730/ /05,7920398 - ,4993 902 #0170807 4:780 039708 147

    850.1.8:-0.9840;07841,73494:9,8-003;039447,3,94341

    1:10/0/ 570807;.0 97,33 3899:908 147 .400 0.9:7078 49,7

    422884394://3492,0,370.42203/,943398/70.9439 //

    349949,7:04:9905488-941983/4139,9;0

    $9,3/,7/83%0,.07/:.,943

    ,8.43.0730/,-4:9 90 ,-803.041 ,3,943, 47$9,900;0

    ,:94799,9.4:/038:7089,3/,7/8390,.070/:.,9433890,/418:0893

    147.70,94341,389,9:947-4/147985:7548090422884357010770/94

    70.42203/9,9989,8-0/430-,43989,3/3.422990094-0809:53

    &9705708039,9;0841#%$9,904,7/841%0,.07/:.,943,3/

    490747,3,9438%0422990084:/-0.43.0730/9,,850.98,3/

    ,0;084190,.070/:.,943$2,770.42203/0/9,9$9,904,7/8

    41%0,.07/:.,94384:/-0809:5,3/90804,7/884:/-07085438-0

    1477,839089,3/,7/84190,.070/:.,943,990$9,900;0%04;0732039

    84:/574;/01:3/8 94& 147 2574;3 90,.070/:.,943 3:3;078908

    ,3/ 974: , .0397, 85438470/ 8.020 $9,908 84:/ ,84 -0 ,88890/ 94

    2574;090,.070/:.,943

    3 70854380 94 9080 70.42203/,9438 90 & 14720/ , $9,3/3

    422990043%0,.07/:.,943.4924/090,.070/:.,943.:77.:,

    /0;0450/147-49:3/077,/:,90,3/54897,/:,90.4:7808390,.070/:.,943

    ,3/ 90 8,20070 ,/4590/-2489 41 90 90,.07 0/:.,943 /05,7920398 3

    :3;07890847053 90:3;078908 942574;090,.070/:.,943 3 907

    /05,7920398 ,3/ 3 .4008 ,3/ 3899:908 41 90,.07 0/:.,943 ,8 05,30/

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    27/32

    0,707 ,1907 0,78 41 # 90 4;0732039 ,:3.0/ , $.020 147

    $97039033 ,3/ #047,33 41 %0,.07 /:.,943 . ,8

    4507,943,0/ 974: 90 $9,90 4;07320398 %0 089,-82039 41 $9,90

    4,7/8 41 %0,.07 /:.,943 40;07 .4:/ 349 9,0 5,.0 %0 740 ,3/

    1:3.9438,8;8:,0/14790804,7/8,;040;07-0032,39,03:5

    -%,3/ 98 7043, .4229900883.0,3/ 84201:3.9438 -90

    $#%8

    43902547,788:08,3/:9:70,0308

    8 0;/039 1742 90 570;4:8 ,..4:39 90,.07 0/:.,943 050703.0/

    8420.,3084390308419070.42203/,94382,/0-5,79.:,7

    ,1907 90 2502039,94341 90! 09 9080 .,308 702,30/2:.

    -0490050.9,943841904228843%090,.070/:.,94388902,89

    0898 94/, 8 349 74-:89 034: 94 0110.9;0 1,.0 90 .,0308 41 4:7

    0/:.,943 88902 3 90 89 .039:7 !7479 ,9903943 300/8 94 -0 5,/ 43

    2,3 9 2470 700;,39 94 90 02073 300/8 41 .,33 84.4.:9:7,

    .43909413/,384.09

    !74108843,823%0,.07/:.,943

    %0,.070/:.,9435747,2208,9,0;08300/94-0847024/00/9,9907010.9574108843,82390574.0884190,.3,3/97,33%008803.0

    ,3/ .0397, .43.073 41 574108843, /0, 8 .4250903.0 . 038:70

    6:,9 ,3/ .,7,.907 41 90,.3 3 4:7 8.448 !7,,8 5 %0,.07

    0/:.,94370;,250/998/0,3;006:590,.0789507843,

    ,997-:90841 025,9507.059434190300/57410410,730781742/1107039

    0/:.,943,-,.,7/80.94384184.09,3/.,5,-99425,790/:.,9433

    , ,850.98 41 .439;0 ,3/ ,110.9;0/42,38,80,858.424947 88

    #,2,2:7959 84390574108843,80/90,.070/:.,943.

    0570,090;8434114790,.070/:.,943.,8807989,992:89-0.420247080389;0949002073/02,3/841908.4488902

    ,3/5705,709090,.07945,9074041,303.4:7,38:55479;0:2,30

    1,.9,947390,.30,73389:,94385

    !74108843,82 3 90,.07 0/:.,943 30.0889,908 9,9 90,.078 ,70

    8:-0.90/94,574430/5074/415705,7,943,3/05480/94, 80,-0-4/

    41 850.,0/ 340/0 !,3/0 5 %8 /02,3/80903843 3

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    28/32

    /:7,943 41 90,.07 0/:.,943 5747,2208 ,3/ 70,907 025,88 43 0

    47,30/ 3907385 43 90 70, 8.44 74:3/8 25,88 43

    574108843,8,943,84/02,3/8850.,0/14.:8,9/11070390;08,3/9508

    4190,.070/:.,9430904301470,7./44/.,70,3/0/:.,94347147

    47 07 80.43/,7 89,0 47 147 ;4.,943, 8970,2 90,.078 09. /:0 94

    /893.9/110703.083903,9:70410,73078,3/.:77.:,41908089,08

    0;045203941/:.,943,8,8.530

    30/99088:041574108843,8,9434190,.070/:.,943

    89088:041/0;0453,3/70.4330/:.,943,8,/8.530/:.,943

    8 89 570/423,39 507.0;0/ 93 90 /42,3 41 90,.07 97,33 ,3/

    06:,90/950/,4.8050.90/ 94-04.,90/397,333899:9438

    %8 70897.90/ ;0 41 90 7. ,70, 41 89:/ 41 0/:.,943 ,8 .:7-0/ 98

    /0;0452039 3 90 5,89 $074:8 ,9902598 - 0/:.,943, ,/23897,9478 3

    :3;078908 ,;0 94-0 2,/0 94;8-.4770.9 98507.059439 84:/

    ,.6:70 90 8,20 5,.0 3 90,.3 ,3/ 7080,7. ,9 :3/077,/:,90 ,3/

    54897,/:,90 0;08,884..:50/-490784., 8.03.08,3/ ,7,907.4807

    3907/8.53,7 3907,.943 84:/ -0 03.4:7,0/ /:.,943 84:/ ,84 -0

    43041908:-0.98411070/3803470;0.;807;.080,23,9438,3/,3,

    3/,807;.0.,/70410/:.,9478-0.70,90/849,90/:.,943,.6:7089089,9:8

    41,1:10/0/3/0503/039,70,4189:/3.00/:.,943,.0;089889,9:8

    ,707 3:2-07 41 89:/0398 9 ;,70/ ,28 3 ;0 0 94 89:/ 98

    /8.530 ,3/ 9 0,8 -0.420 , 5,79 41 90 2,38970,2 10 41 90

    :3;078908,3/9884,90/,3/89,3,3908903.0-0705,.0/-/3,2.

    ,3/3907/8.53,75747088

    7/3,5-09003$.44,3/%0,.07/:.,943:77.:,

    %0,.070/:.,943,9/1107039 0;08702,380,14790 1,.9

    9,9985747,2208,;09908.4504189:/0838.448:-0.9884/:094

    ,.417080,7.0843574-0281,.0/38.448900589090,.070/:.,943

    5747,220,3/57,.9.086:90,44141908.44300/8.005.,33

    ,3/,707010.90/ 398:5/,90/.:77.:,,9/11070390;08%0,.070/:.,943

    ,8 9470:,7,99:309801 9490/02,3/841 908.44.:77.::2-493

    9072841340/0,3/.4250903.038:-0.989,:938.448,80,83

    907 50/,4.,47039,9438 47 0,25050,.0 0/:.,943 03;7432039,

    0/:.,9438:89,3,-0/0;0452039'$0/:.,943-03025,880/3

    90 70;80/ 3,943, .:77.::2 17,2047 147 8.448 84:/ -0

    7010.90/ 3 ,3 :5/,90/ 90,.07 0/:.,943 .:77.::2 $2,7 90

    .43897:.9;89,5574,. 1440/ 3 90 ,3/ 90 819 3 14.:8 41

    50/,4. 9047 1742 5:70 /8.53,7 340/0 94 90 0,7307 ,3/ 8

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    29/32

    .43909 5 300/ 94 -0 220/,90 7010.90/ 3 90,.07 0/:.,943

    5747,220884 9,9 90 8579 ,3/ 39039 41 9030 .:77.::2 17,2047 8

    70,0/38.448

    ":,9439743%0,.07/:.,943

    %,8,89,9:94770:,947-4/87085438-094038:709,9

    90,.070/:.,9433899:94384-807;0088039,34728,//431472,39,33

    89,3/,7/8416:,9410/:.,9439,8,849,03900541347/0794

    09 9080 6:,9 89,3/,7/8 41 90,.07 0/:.,943 3899:9438 ,880880/ ,3/

    ,..70/90/40;0798.42243340/09,96:,989,3/,7/80850.,

    70,93941,.:9,3/97,33574.08808,7089349-0383.0702,39,30/

    3 90,.07 0/:.,943 3899:9438 %070 8 , 1003 9,9 43.0

    .0791.,94387,390/3899:943805499/:094,-803.041,320.,382

    147 144:5,.943-47%!07889039144:5 300/8 94-0 ,3

    4343 7085438-9 41 43.0 9 .,7708 4:9 39, ,880882039 ,3/

    ,..70/94341,390,.070/:.,9433899:943

    %0.:77.:,4190,.070/:.,9433899:9438,;0,8494-0:594/,90

    ,3/,99:30/9 90 02073 84.,3,943,,3/ 39073,943, 88:08%080

    ,;094-02470/3,2.,3/7085438;0949002073/02,3/84190

    84.09 ,3/ 8.44 .:77.::2 0 2:9.:9:7, 0/:.,943 :2,3 798

    0/:.,943.425:907,3/%,55.,94330/:.,943:804190.344390

    97,38,.94341.:77.::209.:45,/,5

    00/147":,10/%0,.07/:.,9478

    0307, /01.03. 349.0/ 3 2,3 90,.07 0/:.,943 3899:9438

    70,90894343,;,,-9418:9,-6:,10/90,.070/:.,94783902%88

    8074:8,110.936:,94190,.3,3/97,33390803899:9438:094

    /0,79413899:943841107354897,/:,905747,2208147 90,.07 0/:.,9478

    90,.07 0/:.,943 3899:9438 ,70 147.0/ 94 ,55439 :3/07 6:,10/ 47 5447

    6:,9:38:9,-090,.070/:.,9478%0701470,77,3020398300/94-02,/0

    9403,3.0.,5,.9413899:94381475705,7390,.070/:.,9478147,0;08

    ,3/95084197,333899:9438

    4-,8,94341.434208

    47 20,331: 8:7;;, 41 0/:.,943, 3899:9438 3 89 .039:7

    4-,80/47/,/06:,905705,7,943839072841.4389,39.:77.::2.,308

    3 0/:.,943, 3899:9438 8 3/85038,-0 ,9 8.44 :3;0789 ,3/ 90,.07

    0/:.,943 0;08 %8 /02,3/8 90,.078 94 -0 84 0254070/ 9,9 90

    .4393:4:8:5/,90 90.:77.::2,3/,70,-0 9497,38,.99 390.,33

    507850.9;08 41 0/:.,943 %0,.07 0/:.,943 3899:9438 300/ 94 06:5 98

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    30/32

    574850.9;090,.078990,-994/4.,701:1:9:708.,3334190970,98

    ,3/455479:390831:9:70,3/9470,.948:.;,:,-0340/0.2,

    47 ,8-,80147.4389,39 .:77.::2.,30 3,84.09.8,/3,2.

    ,3/;-7,3984.40.4342.88902

    4-,8,943 41 0.4342. ,.9;908 ,8 , 89743 .:9:7, /203843

    ,84 9 3.70,8082:9.:9:7,47039,943,3/7.30884190 0948384.09

    .088039,/02,3/89,9981:9:70.90382:89,;090.,5,.994;0

    50,.01:,3/3,72439504501742;,70/.:9:708%0,.070/:.,943

    88902 4:/ ,;0 94 06:5 90 90,.078 9 90 ,-9 94 /0, 9

    2:9.:9:7,70,90838.448,3/.,8874428,3/,84990.4250903.0

    94 90,. 907 ./703 94 0,73 94 ;0 940907 9 :3/0789,3/3 ,3/ 3

    ,724332:9.:9:7,809938

    3.70,830/,$:554793.:/30%0.34408

    ,89 5,.0 /0;04520398 3 90.344 5,79.:,7 90 31472,943

    422:3.,943%0.3448147.39809038;0:80397,33.4008,3/

    8.4481472574;3906:,94190,.3,3/0,733%0,.070/:.,9478,8

    0 ,8 574850.9;0 90,.078 300/ 94 -0 97,30/ 94 :80 ,3/ 3907,90 9080

    90.34408 0110.9;0 3 90,.3 ,3/ 0,7332,/0,,70 41 90 84:7.08

    174207094098419,70,3/5,3 3,089.:77.::2,3/,84 -084

    ,.6:,390/9 0;07 ,850.9 41 90 ,7/,70 9,9 90 ,70 ,-0 942,39,3

    902 ,9 907 43 147 907 :33/070/ :80 3 .,8874428 %0,.07 97,33

    5747,2208 4:/ ,;0 94 -0 8:11.039 70/0830/ 94 3.47547,90 9080

    90.34470,90/300/8410/:.,9478,3/97,30090,.078

    4393:3/:.,94341%0,.078

    %07,5/.,3347/,85480/90.,030412,30,733,

    10 43574.0884709,3,3430 080 98 90 340/047074 8

    706:70/941,.098.,03024890110.9;0,8906:,9410/:.,943-03

    25,790/ - 2 03970 /0503/ 43 8 1443 41 90 573.50 41

    0,733 974:4:9 10 %8 /02,3/8 /0;0452039 41 3807;.0 90,.07

    0/:.,943 3 , 2,3307 9,9 9 ,48 1706:039 ,..088 94 9 - 90,.078 ,3/

    1,.9,908902334943005390280;081:,-70,8941/0;045203983

    907 ,70, 41 90,.3 -:9 ,84 3 70303 907 90,.3 88 -,80/ 43

    /0;045203989,35,.0331472,943,3/.422:3.,94390.3440847

    98 5:75480 8:. /0/.,90/ 3807;.0 0/:.,943 3899:9438 ,;0 94 -0

    089,-80/07074:3/ 900,71,.908 ,3/:2,3 7084:7.08,70,;,,-0

    349 43 147 3807;.0 97,33 41 90,.078 -:9 ,84 147 4907 807;.08 0

    :/,3.0 7080,7. 7084:7.0 8:55479 09. 94 902 3 3/, 84 1,7 $%

    5747,2208 94: /893.9 025,80/ ,1907 ! ,;0 349 70,

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    31/32

    -0.420 ,;03:08 41 300/ -,80/ .4393:4:8 574108843, /0;0452039 41

    90,.078

    3899:94380$8%8,3/%8,80,8%0,.078039708,3/

    $.448425008970,907 8:55479,3/,:94342 3 907,.9;9082,

    -0.420 5072,3039 .039078 41 .4393:3 0/:.,943 ,3/ 7084:7.0 8:55479 147

    90,.078

    &370:,90/5,384341%0,.07/:.,943

    .059147,-74,/54./0.,7,943147/0;04520394190,.07

    0/:.,943 3899:94383 90.4:3979,9 89,9089,9 430%3 0,./897.9

    ,3/%8,3/$8,.7488,$9,9088,-0089,-80/9070834

    4907/09,0/5,335,.0147/0;04520394190,.070/:.,943390.4:397

    3 90 ,-803.0 41 ,3 8:. 5,3 2:87442 749 41 90,.07 0/:.,943

    3899:94385,79.:,7 39057;,9080.9478 9,35,.0%8 8,/;0780

    ,110.93 90 6:,9 41 97,33 -03;03 3 8:. 3899:9438 %070 8 ,3

    :7039300/945705,70,/09,0/90,.070/:.,943/0;04520395,3-,80/43,

    8:7;04190300/14797,30/90,.0783/110703980.9478,9$9,90,3/8:-89,90

    0;08%070:,947,:94798,84706:70/94 03147.024704-0.9;0,3/

    8973039 20,8:708 94 2,39,3 6:,9 41 90,.3 ,3/ 97,33 3 9080

    3899:943843.4393:3-,88

    42243$.44$8902

    9,;094574;/00/:.,9434106:9,-06:,994,./70398

    0 9,9 3 1:9:70 .42243 8.44 88902 3 5,.0 412:9,070/ 8.44

    88902 8 3974/:.0/ -0333 3 98 /70.943 ,8 -0032,/09 90

    9203/2039949043899:943.,87,390/#994/:.,943;/0

    79.0 9490/703&3/079042243$.44$8902./70341

    ;,70/-,.74:3/817429030-4:744/4.,9,9903/908,208.44

    ,3/ 70.0;0 0/:.,943 41 90 8,20 6:,9 38:73 6:,9 41

    0/:.,94330,.30-4:744/8.44-0,.,0301479890,.078,3/

    ,/23897,9478 . 4:/ 300/ 850., 47039,943 ,3/ 5705,7,943 41 90

    90,.07894:3/0789,3/90;,70/.439098300/8,3/,857,9434189:/0398,3/

    8,981908,209490-08941907,-9974:701472:,94341.:77.::2

    8,-:8,3/909-448,3/7024/034190,.3897,9008,3/2094/4408

    948:99889:,943

    43.:843

  • 8/3/2019 Khothari_MHD Siddiqui Comment

    32/32

    3901470435,0890;8434149,74228843,-4:990,.078

    ,3/ 907 740 3 90 574.088 41 0/:.,943, ,3/ 3,943, /0;0452039 3 90

    .4:397,8-003/8.:880/%04228843,/70.42203/0/80;07,,.9438

    9497,38,9098;843394 70,9%0805745480/,.9438070,8420,39147

    7024;3 ;,74:8 0,308808 9,9 070 14:3/ 94 -0 5708039 3 90 90,.07

    0/:.,943 88902 41 90 .4:397 :73 90 ,89 14:7 /0.,/08 ,8 05,30/

    0,7072,3 ,9902598 ,;0 -0032,/0 94 2502039 9080 70.42203/,9438

    ,3/-73 2574;020398 3 90 90,.07 0/:.,943 8890240;07 1742 90

    /8.:884357080390/070980;/0399,990,.070/:.,9438099470.0;090

    /0870/0;041,9903943410/:.,943,,/23897,9478,3/49078%0;84341

    904228843,3/248941985745489438,7089;,/,3/700;,39',74:8

    84.40.4342. /0;04520398 3 90 70.039 5,89 ,;0 5480/ 1708 .,0308

    -01470 90 0/:.,943 88902 1:7907 703147.0/ ,3/ .70,9;0 7047,30/

    90,.07 0/:.,9434:/ 4, 43,305390 0/:.,943 88902 1,.0

    9080 .,03080110.9;0 98 8:..088 0 32,3 9801.4393:4:8

    ,99:30/9490.,33300/8,3/.:77.:,418.448,3/49073899:9438,8

    ,84 94 90 /02,3/8 2,/0 - 90 .4393:3 0.4342. ,3/ 90.344.,

    ,/;,3.08