Keys To The Reduction of Risk

46
HSAWCF Annual Meeting Keys To The Reduction of Risk September 18, 2014 Hanba Lazar P.C. Larry Cianciosi Jon Rea

Transcript of Keys To The Reduction of Risk

HSAWCF Annual Meeting

Keys To The Reduction of Risk

September 18, 2014 Hanba Lazar P.C.

Larry CianciosiJon Rea

Key Topics:

o Michigan Statisticso Definitionso Assault

o Motor Vehicle Accidents (MVA)o Seasonal Employmento Willful Misconduct

2005

2005

2009

2005

2009

2014

Definitions:

o 301 (1)

Definitions:

o 301 (1)o An employee, who receives a

personal injury arising out of and in the course of employment shall be

paid compensation

Definitions:

o 301 (3)

Definitions:

o 301 (3)o An employee going to or from his

or her work while on the premises where the employee’s work is to be performed and within a reasonable

time before and after his or her working hours is presumed to be in

the course of his or her employment

Assaults:

Assaults:

Assaults:

Assaults:

o To be compensable the assault must be connected with employment and not

motivated by personal reasons

Assaults:

o Devault v GMCo 149 Mich 765 (1986)

o Published Caseo Magistrate Awarded Benefitso WC Board Denied Benefits

o Court of Appeals Affirmed Denial

Assaults:

o Morris v Solowayo 170 Mich App 765 (1986)

o Published Case

Assaults:

Assaults:

o Investigation is the keyo Whoo Whato Wheno Whereo Whyo How

Motor Vehicle Accidents:

Motor Vehicle Accidents:

Motor Vehicle Accidents:

Motor Vehicle Accidents:

o In general MVA’s occurring while going to and from

employment are not compensable where the

MVA does not occur on the employer’s premises.

Motor Vehicle Accidents:

o Stark v L.E. Meyerso CO 58 Mich App 439 (1973)

o Law was evolving to a rule whereby compensation should be

awarded only where there is a sufficient nexus between the

employment and the injury so that it may be said the injury was a circumstance of employment.

Motor Vehicle Accidents:

o Thomas v Staff Builderso Health Care 168 Mich App 127 (1988)

o Six possible exceptionso Special Mission

o Special Benefit to Employer

o Employer Furnished Transportation

o Dual Purpose

o Traffic Risk

o Flexible Working Schedule

Motor Vehicle Accidents:

Motor Vehicle Accidents:

o Keys to success identify:o Motor Vehicle Involved

o Route

o Deviation

o Work Schedule

o Purpose of Travel

o Responsibility for Travel Expenses

o Travel Necessity

Seasonal:

Seasonal:

Seasonal:

Seasonal:

o 301 (4) Defines ‘disability’ as a limitation of the

employee’s wage earning capacity due to injury

Seasonal:

o A sufficient nexus must exist between the wage loss

and the injury

Seasonal:

o Raybon v DP Fox Football Holdings

o LLC 2007 Mich App Lexis 1751 Unpublished

Seasonal:

Seasonal:

o Keys to successo Prove a Pattern

MESC Social Security Earning Reports

Contracts for Employment State and Federal Income Tax

Returns

Willful Misconduct:

Willful Misconduct:

Willful Misconduct:

o 305 If the employee is injured by reason of his or her intentional and willful

misconduct he or she shall not receive compensation

under the provisions of this act.

Willful Misconduct:

Willful Misconduct:

o Allen v National Twist Drill & Tool

o Co 324 Mich 660 (1949)

o Got Comp

Willful Misconduct:

o Shepard v Brunswicko Corp 36 Mich App 307 (1971)

o Comp Denied

Willful Misconduct:

Willful Misconduct:

Willful Misconduct:

Willful Misconduct:

o Keys to Success

o Employer Rules and Policieso Proof of Enforcement

o Terminate