Jurisprudence Salmond 8th

639
;'<l<v<-''»>-

Transcript of Jurisprudence Salmond 8th

other
source
in
doubt.
In
deciding
as
prompted
to
interpose
demand
"
II. The
past
or
present
of
any
legal
system,
but
raw
material
and
those
broad
principles
for
and
the
particular.
The
traditional
doctrine
jurisprudence
has
been
followed
since
his
day
by
a
series
of
English
writers,
including
the
follow-
ing
law,
so
customary
law.
imposed upon
Pufen-
dorf
(c)
with
intent
to
definite
organisation,
these
three
which
Divine
anger
are
expressions
motions
by
.
.
rightful
action.
Eight
or
justice
conduct laid
Natural
law
has
received
many
other
names
expressive
of
the
Law
of
Reason,
as
being
established
by
that
Reason
by
Law
(jus
non
scriptuvi),
as
being
law
(lex),
right
reason,
agree-
ing
with
nature,
diffused
among
all
men,
unchanging,
everlasting.
... It
is
not
Athens,
all,
even
;
to aliens
applicable
to
aliens,
players
have
expressly
or
tacitly
agreed
to
observe
in
their
conduct
of
the
game.
In
many
nalurel
dans
I'antiquit^
grecqiie
the
law
of
positive
morality;
but
irrespective
of
any
such
enforcement,
and
by
reason
solely
of
its
de
facto
observance,
it
is
itself
a
law
in
that
generic
sense
in
Covenant
of
the
League
of
Nations.
other.
law,
but
(sensu
concreto)
name
implies
For
good
in the transformation
expected
of the
we
may
be
free."
It
side-respect
to
their
persons."
Hence
the
authority
the
result,
its
complexity,
and
we
do
wisely
if
we
discover
the
golden
mean
conform
level
of
the
this
requirement
and
raises
non
curat
lex
is
undue
and
needless
complexity.
It
is
not
possible,
indeed,
for
any
fully
is
probable,
for
instance,
that
the
great
bulk
of
the
command
of
the
state
is
plausible,
and
is
created,
and,
like
every
other
the full
addressed,
not
to
the
public
at
large,
but
punishment
for
murder
is
death
is enforced as
rights
and
duties?
Before
attempting
try
to
conceived
as
imposed
upon
men
by
the
command
of
their
.force
and
all
their
authority,
mediately
or
immediately,
from
this
original."
merely
the
frustrate
ghost
of
the
have
no
significance
either
Similarly,
duties
right
in
general,
right
vested
in
liberty
extends,
both
private
and
public
justice
fall
extend,
the
justice
justice.
justice.
2.
No
recognition
of
non-imperative
law laid down
But it is
duty
of
the
judge
to
decide
is;
or
(3)
any
question
that
is
to
be
answered
by
the
jury
as
opposed
to
the
judge.
There
is,
however,
to
decide
in
accordance
with
it.
In
body
is
composed,
and
capable
as
such
of
is
applied.
familiar both
courts
in
reality
do
in
interpreting
an
ambiguous,
inconsistent,
such
proper penalty
law
of
England
and
legislature
it
is;
but
law of
marriage,
divorce,
succession,
and
domestic
land
discussion
as
to
the
meaning
way,
if
brought
before
the
Court
of
King's
Bench,
and
in
another,
if
adjudged
in
Chancery.
The
Judicature
Act,
1873,
put
an
end
to
this
justice.
The
administration
of
justice
was
part
of
law,
standing
side
by
the
Chancery,
I.
408,
note
(a).
a
(p)
A
law;
2.
Foreign
law
force
throughout
the
entire
territory
of
the
English
courts.
Standing
apart
from
this
system
of
general
temtorial
application
on
the
absence
of
any
other
rules
agreed
upon
by
the
parties
interested.
These
S.J.
7
partes,
it
their
source
in
the
royal
prerogative,
except
that
which
is
established
in
deroga-
the
subject
of
much
difference
of
opinion.
less than
in time
accurately
to
the
international
very
different
thing
from
the
recognition
of
duty
and
by
the
sovereign
state
which
calls
the
general
law
of
England
is
itself
divided
into
three
parts,
courts
by
by
the
courts,
as
being
the
law
normally
applicable
in
the
absence
of
any
other
law
which,
after
excepting
statute
law,
equity,
and
special
relation
which
3.
Questions
to
"
the
influence
associated
with,
and
with
the
ordeal
as
judicium
Dei
knows his
foe to
be at
their
own
pleasure."
peace.
already
shown
an
intention
of
doing
so.
Justice
is
administered
only
against
wrongdoers,
in
act
Or
of
right;
in
criminal
justice
it
amounts
merely
to
an
accusation
of
wrong.
Civil
justice
is
concerned
primarily
with
plaintiff
and
his
rights;
criminal
justice
with
resource
in
them the fear
latter
principle
prevails
in
it.
The
purely
reformative
theory
admits
only
such

it is
punishment
of
the
wrongdoer
It is
assaulted
it is
promise
of
marriage,
and
operation
wrongfully
enriched
him-
self
the
receipt
equally
so,
true,
some
civil
proceedings
He
may
Hitherto we have
the
latter
term
is
duty
drawn
with
precision,
is
yet
broadly
marked."
in
the
extrajudicial
is
suppressed
by
troops,
this
is
state
represents
the
whole
population
of
with
the
term
subject.
Finally
it
is
persons
are
subjects,
as
being
subject
the
Crown,
I.
542,
it
personal
and
permanent
being
exclusively
first,
essential,
Crown?
Yet
facts.
Similar
discrepancies
exist,
however,
reflected
image
of
this
organisation
as
it
appears
in
legal
theory.
Although
in
constitutional
theory.
capacity
of
evoking
and
directing
the
activities
of
the
body
politic.
It
is
the
ability
to
make
power
which
is
superior
to
it,
and
to the
be
observed
sources,
but
case
I that
enacted,
and
therefore
sovereign
legislature.
The
chief
their control.
many
subordinate
departments.
to
have
the business
makes
laws
for
his
dog.
When
your
dog
does
you
legal development
eighteenth
century
the
process
has
been
going
on
in
European
countries,
and
isolated and
is
that
in
it has
logical
interpretation
is
entitled
to
supersede
grammatical.
dormant,
if
not
legislative power.
England,
declaratory
precedents
them. No
by
the
courts
recog-
law
legislation.
instance,
the
authority
of
this
case,
notwithstanding
the
respect
due
to
the
judges
who
decided
it,
is
not
binding
upon
us
but
which
acquire
a
weight
long
a
period
unchallenged,
should
not,
in
our
province
to
overturn
it."
to
be,
a
their
decision;
they
strive
law
attributing
to
custom
the
force
8.
tive
guide
Thus
in
California
the
customs
developed
on
the
gold-fields
for
the
regulation
been
extinguished,
be
ascertained."
the
Law,
p.
279.
days,
for
example,
a
exchange
that
served
merchant
as
to
those
instruments
was
derived
as
to
negotiable
instru-
ments,
it
may
rights
in
take water from
must
have
give
evidence
concerning
when
it
a,
318
b.
By
French
law
time
of
memory
was
held
to
extend
other than
the rule
departments
good
prescrip-
tive
title.
rule
of
special
and
customary
law
excluding
farm,
and
all
his
predecessors
in
title,
place,
not
to
place."
Since
prescription
and
custom
piescriptive
rights
has
been
brouglit
clearly
was time immemorial.
As
akeady
indicated
legal
custom
general
customs
of
the
realm,
and
that
of
conventional custom or
incorporation,
no
usage
can
a view to
recognition
of
the
rule
beasts
are
legal right against
whom
it
is
due;
there
can
be
no
right
unless
President
object^
in
the
money
in
his
pockets.
In
or
daughter,
or
for
the
sale
of
a
piece
Hitherto
make
termed
powers.
Examples
of
such
are
the
following:
the
right
to
legal
remedy.
A
synonym
for
it
is
responsibility.
to
include
the
have
already
shall
become
extinct,
but
merely
the
owner
is as
general
rule,
liability
for
to
do
another
any
manner
of
hurt,
save
special
ground
of
justification;
if I
tax,
the
right
like
account.
My
debt
is
not
theirs,
nor
stands
and
obligatio
on
the
other,
the
former
including
real,
and
the
latter
personal
rights.
personam.
An
actio
in
rem
was
an
action
for
the
recovery
this
distinction?
It
lies
in
the
fact
that
proprietary
rights
are
valuable,
and
pension may
the less.
(c)
Personal
capacities
and
incapacities,
as
opposed
and the
by
the
commentators
on
the
civil
law,
and
dealing
merelv
agreement
to
agree-
ment
runs
with
the
property,
while
by
a
right
over
the
pro-
perty
terminate incidence
terminate
incidence
(almost
all
posi-
tive).
Jura
ad
rem.
ck
thing,
oivnership
itself.
This
premises
on
cor-
poralis
n.
2 :
duplicate ownership,
by
beneficiary
the
former.
A
trust
beneficial
enjoyment
are not
legal
and
divergences
between
legal
only
and
not

in
fact.
we are
two ideas
limited to land
right.
It
may
be,
and
commonly
is,
right
itself.
be this
it the
something
to
the
contrary,
I
may
existence.
In
B.
V.
Moore
(o)
a
bank-note
was
dropped
in
the
shop
of
the
prisoner,
who
on
discovering
it,
picked
it
up
and
converted
it
property
the
thing
they
were
authorised
to
do
otherwise
by
the
In
such
the German
respect
it and
looks after
he holds
bailor
in
the
operation
of
equivalent
purposes
to be
;
In ten
persons
could
not
person
of mediate
immediate.
Constructive
delivery,
excluding
him.
So
physical power
over it
Savigny's
theory
possessor.
The
corpus
is
The
possession
of
a
thing
is
the
de
facto
condition
of
incor-
poreal
possession,
right,
but
 
§
one's
side
also.
Beati
possidentes.
first
give
up
possession,
and
then
proceed
rights,
in
addition
helps
himself
by
force
even
manner
of
right,
by
due
course
of
law.
In
the
case
of
chattels,
indeed,
security
jrossession
J .
I
Mediate
It is
which
rights
(cc).
of law
the beast
fitly
in
another
place.
(g)
Foster
v.
Dodd,
L.
E.
3
Q.
cremation,
Bee
Reg.
v.
Price,
12
Q.
B.
of
her.
Or
he
may
die
intestate,
and
his
is
for
many
a
 
If,
therefore,
on
a
company
person
altogether
from
the
subscribers
jus
it
by
ultra
vires
of
the
corporation,
and
authority;
and
employer's
Uability
for
rule
of
law
deal,
but
common
ownership
instrument
to
deal.
propria
persona
must
put
him
or defaults of
disappearance
of
its
corpus
or
bodily
There is no
personify
and
incorporate
the
empire
as
a
whole,
certain
purposes
bodies
politic
and
corporate.
For
by
of
the
State
divest a
right by
thinks
fit;
but
if
he
leaves
a
duly
executed
will,
in
which
he
expresses
all.
The
two kinds
as
synonyms,
to
mean
a
bilateral
act
in
the
law
an
obligation,
that
is
to
say
a
right
in
personam.
The
objection
to
this
usage
know
nothing
of
it
If,
on
the
other
hand,
or
the
justice
with him.
creation
of
rights,
there
are,
therefore,
these classes
at the
equity.
is not a
this
power
the
agreement
not
only
ceases
agree
together
upon
any
matter
as
they
please
error,
for
there
the other
other
(n).
This
reason,
motive,
or
inducement,
by
which
a
man
is
moved
to
bind
himself
by
an
agreement.
he
agrees
to
bear
new
burdens
or
to
forgo
a
promise
of
performance,
and
though
itself
scrupulous
provides
that
dispute,
has its
madman
who
when
actually
exercised,
in
any
way
concerned
to
day
is
irrelevant;
in
burglary
it
is
material.
An
part
of
Any
(g)
Holmee,
Common
Law,
p.
sine
injuria.
The
special
result
of
competition
in
trade
may
be
of
adjoining
proprietors.
He
may
the
community,
yet,
owing
to
its
triviaHtj^
or
a
nature
that
the
legal
remedy
would
§
three
alternatives
as
it
thinks
fit
in
the
particular
case.
adopted
for
most
purposes.
mitted in
is determined
corresponding
positive
act
ought
date of
results is
tional nor
of
any
conscious
purpose
or
design,
no
part
intent,
he
cannot
be
dealt
with
on
the
footing
of
wilful
wrongdoing.
If
liability
So
far,
therefore,
belonged
to
A.
So
if
a
woman
marries
With
respect
to
that
circumstance
inten-
I
desire
and
intend
a
certain
end,
I
also
accidents
will,
notwithstanding
all
precautions,
occur
to
the
workmen
so
employed.
may,
consequences
due
to
will cause
the
particular
case
{h).
(i)
means
badness,
physical
distinct
things.
the
Roman
lawyers,
the
sufficient basis
irrelevance
of
motives
there
are,
however,
very
important
exceptions,
more
especially
in
the
the act
commonly
criminal
if
it
goes
may
a
man
go
along
the
path
of
his
criminal
intent,
and
yet
turn
back
in
safety
if
his
long supposed
England
that
principle.
The
result in
falls
under
the
head
of
damnum
sine
injuria
so
long,
may
father;
it
may
be
quences.
No
also
intended.
Nothing
identified
with
thoughtlessness
or
inadvertence,
is
still
to
the
reply
In
each
case
carelessness,
that
surgeons
or
attorneys
until
of
mens
rea.
In
general
we
he
who
magnitude
England (vi).
were
it
possible
Colliery
Co.,
reasonable under the
6. 1.
is
the
omission
to take such care as under the circumstances it is the
legal
duty
of
a
person
SUMMARY.
The
from him to
The
maintain
by
force
those
principles
of
right
and
wrong
land
disregards
at
be
excused,
but
peril,
law
tried,
in the
liability
for
the
last
relics
master was
is
really,
in
its
historical
origin,
they
die,
any
one
King
Alfred
(p)
and
redemption
both
ancient
every
man answerable for those who are kin to him. In the
Mosaic
legislation
it
in the
which he
obtained. Such
his
own.
A
second
that criminal
for
penal
redress,
being
A
threat
prevented
would
be
far
outweighed
by
may
be
many
that
the
affection. To
kill one's
more
severely
than
another,
of
and
limbs
property
in
his
own
person,
the
saying
of
Ulpian
a
thing
to
the
law.
flow from the
in
him.
Were
his
right
to
determine
to-morrow
in
any
manner,
my
own,
relieved
of
which
subject
there been
Crown
only
on
an
intestacy,
and
therefore
can
be
prevented
from
doing
so
by
the
§
one
or
the
other
according
to
the
the case of those
every
man
his
portion
in
owns
property,
the
latter
is
good-will
purpose
of
deceiving
the
pubhc
three
only
tenancies.
Although
a
lease
of
land
and
a
a
tenancy
of
land.
A
lease,
in
this
generic
is
that
form
technical
separation
of
ownership
and
rightfully
possesses
it,
but
does
is he
or for
lease. A
during
the
lease,
although
I
may
have
granted
a
merely
an
encumbrance
of
one
piece
of
land,
but
only
one
class
of
servitudes
as
above
defined.
(0
It
is
only
of
successive
must (it
the
principal
debtor.
With
this
form
of
security
we
are
not
here
concerned,
When
on
the
other
hand
a
debtor
encumbers
his
right
in
favour
right
secured
by
it,
reconveyance.
beneficial
or
equitable
owner
of
it
in
the
mortgagee,
it
is
a
security
is
a
lien,
leaving
preceding
no
reason,
however,
why
it
reforms
effected
by
The
so-called
mortgages
for such
present,
the
right
will
in
de
jure.
of
possession
occupy
in
the
long
run,
if
used
with
due
safeguards,
it
is
being
has been
possession
may
have
been.
;
fixed
term
of
years.
Joint
ownership
is
such
that
the
right
of
him
who
dies
that
the
possessor
of
a
chattel
may
of
the
French
Civil
Code
lays
down
the
general
principle
that
En
de
meubles
la
possession
with the
person wronged,
personality
the
destination
to withdraw
nullius.
Absolute
ownership.
has
incurred
or
obligatio
true nature
proprietary
right
in
personam.
All
other
proprietary
rights
(including
such
objects
of
rights
debtors,
however,
is
whole amount due. The creditor is not
obliged
recover
surety,
pro-
a
case
they
by
Lord
Justice
Collins
(h)
owner of
(l),
any
further
examination
in
this
place
(m).
EngUsh
law,
however,
tort
has
become
specialised
in
meaning,
and
now
includes
merely
one
particular
class
of
civil
wrongs.
A
tort
may
wrong;
crimes
are
wrongs,
but
are
not
in
themselves
torts,
though
there
is
nothing
to
prevent
the
point
cannot
yet
be
horse
damage
of
contract
and
tort
was
complicated
and
obscured
by
the
con-
true
tort,
but
a
contract.
along
duty
without
causing
such
damage
undoubtedly
are
arises not
other,
in
which
case
the
law
is
said
to
imply
a
origin.
The
theory
that
all
respect,
the
resource
of
wager
of trust or
institute
proceedings
are
questions
of
procedural
law,
for
they
relate
merely
to
the
other.
Although
the
distinction
between
at
rather than
equivalent
of
our
it
tends
in
any
degree
such
an
effect
may
be
called
its
probative
force,
and
evidence
may
known
to
of
judicial
evidence.
Testimony
is
extrajudicial
probative
force,
That
secondary
evidence
should
not
be
used
when
primary
circumstantial.
he is
of
error,
that
B.
is
guilty.
Direct
evidence
is
commonly
con-
sidered
But
in
this,
inflexible
rules
excluding
judicial
They may
case.
estimate
of
probabilities,
but
are
established
for
the
purpose
of
placing
the
These rules of
impossible
to
rejection
common with
form,
recourse to
the first
place jus
developed
and
administered
in
right
terms which
mean in
is
usually
abstract,
application
we
speak
considering
may
be
regarded
by
the
exists
objectively.
The
legal
already
con-
sidered
by
us,
the
primary
sense
in
all
cases
physical
to
the
ethical
sense
various other derivative
the Latin
possible,
the
second
class,
represented
by
The
following
are
agreement
Lex,
so
used,
trasted,
at
least
in
the
language
of
the
philosophers,
with
<pva-L<;,
or
senses.
dooms of
makes its
this
is
so,
the
origin
of
lex
is
to
be
found
in
the
Latin
lego,

senses,
and
I
do
not
know
what
evidence
statutum,
with
it,
doctrine
which
we
may
term
Hobbes's
political
theory
of
sovereignty.
It
was
not,
indeed,
originated
by
the
have no solid
cases to be found in its
entirety
within
the
alleged
that
A.
are
here
dealing
exclusively
assembly.
composite legislature.
judicial powers
could not
things
is
unlimited
in
extent,
therefore
the
de
facto
sovereignty
more nor
that
of
any
other.
What
difficulty,
I
say,
there
should
sovereignty
which
to be
to
recognise
and
apply
is
by
that
very
by
what
process
of
reasoning
the
jurist
(t).
The
by
the
courts,
example,
the
most
striking
would be amended in
which meets
with due
Constitution of
unalterable
until
the
year
stifled at
form
which
is
at
the
time
brief
and
they
are
the
the
Roman
sources
extreme
conse-
was
In
exceptional
cases,
however,
the
opposite
See
jus
facit.
A
precedent,
even
though
erroneous,
will
make
valid
law,
if
its
authority
give
protection
of
praecepta juris
justice
The
penalty
of
nullity
property
as
not
to
The
rigour
of
the
law,
untempered
by
equity,
imperfect
statute
law
extensive
interpretation
based
its
aspects
as
concerned
with
the
sources
place
the
Introduction
com-
prises
the
principles
of
private
After the Introduction comes
juridical
position
from
its
relations
from
the
private
law
concerning
the
subjects
of
the
parents),
law of
status, however,
permissible
sense,
of the
by
which
the
extension
of
the
King's
dominions
is
effected,
is
by
the
dependencies.
The
legal
position
years
undergone
a
singular
change.
the
system
of
to
the
England
only,
and
area of
 
These are
(d).
4.
British
Settlements,
protec-
sovereignty
internal
sove-
princes.
Whatever
authority
international
relation
Empire
has
delegated
a
portion
internal
sovereignty
are
issued
determining
in
respect
of
each
protectorate
the
organisation,
protectorates
protectorate
such
sovereignty
is
not
exercised,
territory
over
British
dominions,
case
of
protectorates.
In
China,
for
example,
the
Crown
the Crown.
many
other
territory
in
law.
British
territory
de
facto
territory
was
acquired,
they
of
another.
This
distinction
between
territorial
sovereignty
and
ownership
chapters
of
Sir
Anton
is,
of
imperative
law,
namely,
who
nations is

nations,
it
is
(a)
De
Corpore
Politico,
Eng.
and
positive
justice
are
prevalent opinion,
II.
3.
23.
(d)
Principes
du
moral
casuistry.
The
law
of
nations
as
customary
law.
species,
are thus sanctioned
applied
inter-
International
hopelessly
discordant.
Moreover,
there
to the literature
their most
9th ed.
et
lawyers.
His
admirably
lucid
and
methodical
expositions
of
Roman-French
law
are
the
source
of
great
part
justice,
140
Goodeve
on
Real
Property.
Goodeve
on
Personal
Property.
Deane's
or
Gibson's
Conveyancing.
Inderm.aur
s
Common
Law
or
It embodies
balanced and
marginal precis
expounded
excellent
piece
as
indispensable
companion
to
all
re-wriiten
and
considerably
expanded,
by
most
pass
students
and
satisfies
their
one
desire
Con-
tracts.
By
first
part.
It
knowledge

tract—Evidence—Real
student's
requirements
for
frequently
studied
by
acquainted
a book
type."
acquiring
a
knowledge
combination
students
an
aid
to
revision,