Judgement - Infocity Roltas v. Voltas

7/26/2019 Judgement - Infocity Roltas v. Voltas

1/34

!"#$%&'()"

!" $%& '()*&+& ,-(*$ -. !"/!0

,!1!2 0))&220$& 3(*!'/!,$!-"

,!1!2 0))&02 "-4 5678 -. 569:

;0=?@ ABC AD '2) ;,=E=FG "A4 8669H AD 5698G

1AFCI> 2=J=CKL 444 0MMKFFI?C

1KB>

*AFCI !?L=I 2=J=CKL 444*K>MA?LK?C

!"#$

,!1!2 0))&02 "-4 567N -. 569:;0=?@ ABC AD '2) ;,=E=FG "A4 899OH AD 5698G

% ' ( ) * + , #

(-./0 *-12/3 %4

2KIEK @


2/34

*

0MMKIF> "A>4 7 AD 5698 I?L X AD 5698 QI> >KC I>=LK CQK

UBL@JK?C I?L A>KL PS CQK

FKI


3/34

+

RA?>C [?AT? I> *AFCI VQITI? !!

;*VZ!!G I?L *AFCI VQITI? !!! ;*VZ!!G I?L IF>A DAC RKMBCK>

IKW A? 84954566: CQK MA?LK?C CK


4/34

,

5:4X45699W D=FKL CQK RAB?CK< RFI=J AD *>4888W78W8HW65NaZ

CA@KCQK< T=CQ =?CKC IC CQK ?AC JI=?CI=?IPFK I?L

TI> IF>A PI


5/34

-

A? TQ=RQ CQK RIB>K AD IRC=A? IK> I?L CQK LICK A?

TQ=RQ CQK RAB?CK< RFI=J => D=FKL4 0DCK< >A AM=?=?@ CQK

FKI =? CQK FKCCK LICKL 57CQ0MCI[IPFKRA?>R=AB>?K>> AD =C> A? CQK MIMA?LK?C4 $QK FI>C FKCCK< LICKL 5OCQ +I CQK ?AC=RK AD CQK 0LEARICK> AD CQK*K>MA?LK?C I>>K


6/34

.

IDCK< ILEK =? LKCI=F I?L CQK RA?CK?C=A?>

KL PS CQK FKIKF DA< CQK MIW


7/34

7

>I=L IJAB?C I> LKJI?LKL4 'BRQ L=>MBCK> CQB>L=L ?AC K\=>C TQK? CQK ?AC=RK =?EA[=?@ I=LK RAJJK?RKJK?C AD L=>MBCKW KEK?=? >BRQ RI>K A? CQK LICK AD D=F=?@ CQK RAB?CK

994 +


13/34

/+


14/34

/,

NS()< Q$*+. T$'+ $'( 3%0,*"UW CA PAF>CK< CQK

>BPJ=>>=A? CQIC =? CQK RI>K IC QI?L CQK L=>MBCK> I>

LA ?AC RA?>C=CBCK I L=>MBCK

RIMIPFK AD


15/34

/-

^0 L=>MBCK IK> TQKMBCK => K>>K?C=IF DA< IMMA=?CJK?CAD I? IBMC=A? IK TQKCQK< CQK L=>MBCK JK?C=A?KL =? CQK

RA?C


16/34

/.

AMBCK CA PK

4

VS FKCCK< LICKL 9484566H CQK IMMKFFI?CW TQ=FK


17/34

/7

RFI=J MBC DAKF CQIC =C TABFL RAJMBCK =C>

FA>>K>W LIJI@K>W RA>C>W RQIW K\MK?>K>W KCR4 IDCK< CQK

PB=FL=?@ TA AEK< I?L RFI=J CQK >IJK DKFW =?C=JICKL CQK MA?LK?C CQIC =C TI>

?AC F=IPFK CA MIS I?S IFFK@KL FA>>K>W LIJI@K>W RA>C>W

RQI I?L K\MK?>K>W IFFK@KLFS >BDDK>K JILK IPABC CQK FA>>K> >BDDK>KEK ?AC

F=IPFK CA MIS CA CQK IMMKFFI?C I?S RAJMK?>IC=A? I?L

LIJI@K> A< ACQK< IJAB?C> I> RFI=JKL =? CQK FKCCK< LICKL

9484566H CA CQK MA?LK?C4 !? DIRCW CQK MA?LK?C TI>

RAJMKFFKL CA CKCK< g

0>>AR=ICK>W I?L CQK MA?LK?C QIL >BDDK>K>

I?L LIJI@K> I?L QIL =?RBW RQI I?L

K\MK?>K> DA< TQ=RQ CQK IMMKFFI?C TI> >AFKFS MA?L=PFK4

!C TI> IF>A JK?C=A?KL =? CQK FKCCK< CQIC CQK MA?LK?C


18/34

/@

K C CQK

IMMKFFI?C I> MK< CQK I@ CQK DIRCBIF K\MA>=C=A? TABFL

B?DB

DI=F=?@ TQ=RQ =C T=FF =?EA[K CQK II=L RAJJB?=RIC=A? I?L I?ACQK< RAJJB?=RIC=A? LICKL

594:4566N TK >QIFF CI@K TQ=FK LKIF=?@

T=CQ CQK ACQK< DIRKC AD >BPJ=>>=A?4 !C JIS PK ?ACKL QKc Z

^-B< RF=K?C> LK?S CQIC CQK RFI=J JILK I@I=?>CSAB => DIF>K I?L D4 -B< RF=K?C> LK?S CQICI?S IJAB?C => LBK CA SAB DA< CQK IFFK@KL P


19/34

/A

!? E=KT AD TQIC => >CICKL QKLK?S CQIC CQKS IBJ AD*>4NXWN8W75W7:846X A< I?S ACQK< >BJ4_

9N4 $QB>W CQK RA PKCTKK? CQK MI JI[K =C

E=E=L CQIC CQK RFI=J> JILK PS CQK MA?LK?C TK


20/34

*8

IMM=@?ICKL 3BL@K AD CQK ,Q=KD 3B>C=RK AD

VAJPIS %=@Q ,AB


21/34

*/

9X4 !? CQ=> >CAB< I?L


22/34

**

MK< KJMFASKKW KCR4 I?L ABC>CI?L=?@ JAP=F=bIC=A? ILEI?RK

BJ I>

JK?C=A?KL =? CQK FKCCK< TI> *>47:W7XW8:WO594H:4 .I=L IJAB?C JA?=K> MK< CQK RA?C4NW9:WN5W97X4:N TK


23/34

*+

PKDA


24/34

*,

594 $Q=> ,ABKL CTA YBK>C=A?>W ?IJKFSW TQKCQK< CQK

MA?LK?C =? I? I

59 I?L :8 AD CQK 0RC I?L 'KRC=A? 8 AD CQK

2=J=CIC=A? 0RCW 9ON8W AM=?KL CQB>c Z

^'KRC=A? 8 AD CQK 2=J=CIC=A? 0RCW 9ON8 >MKR=D=K>CQK LICK AD =?>C=CBC=A? DA< >B=CW PBC LAK> ?AC>MKR=DS CQK LICK AD ^=?>C=CBC=A?_ DA< I CA TQIC TABFL PK CQKLICK AD ^=?>C=CBC=A?_ =?


25/34

*-

TI> D=FKL B?LK< 'KRC=A? 99 AD CQK 0RC4 !? E=KT AD'KRC=A? 59 AD CQK 0RC MC=CBC=A? AD CQK

RAB?CK


26/34

*.

-:1. 19"*0 %, +./ 19"*0",+ ",7 ,%+ %, +./ 7"+/ %&&*9*,< %& +./ 1%:,+/(19"*04_

i!CIF=R> => ABj

584 +


27/34

*7

FI?@BI@K KJMFASKL =? 'KRC=A? 59W CQIC I? K\RKMC=A? QI>

CA PK RIIEK> CQK F=J=CIC=A? DA< D=F=?@ I

RAB?CK< RFI=J =D I MA?LK?C I@I=?>C TQAJ I RFI=J QI>

PKK? JILK >IC=>D=K> CQK CT=? CK>CW ?IJKFSW QK QIL JILK I

RFI=J I@I=?>C CQK RFI=JI?C I?L >AB@QC IYBI CA CQK RI>K IC

QI?L =?I>JBRQ I> CQK IMMKFFI?C QIL KL CQK RAB?CKAB@QC I =?CK?C=A?

A? ?BJPK< AD ARRI>=A?>4 $QIC IMI IF>A MK>B=A? => CQIC =C

=> T=CQ=? F=J=CIC=A?4

5H4 )K?CFS CA CQK IFCKKF DA< CQK IMMKFFI?C4 !C

PI>=RIFFS MK CA CQK ?ICBRAMK I?L @IJBC AD

IMMF=RIP=F=CS AD CQK K\RKMC=A? RIBMIE=?@ I RAB?CKBPJ=C CQIC CQK MA?LK?C QIL


28/34

*@

RCIFF=bKL =C> RFI=J> PS FKCCK< LICKL 974:4566N

IJAB?C=?@ CA *>4NXWN8W75W7:846X TQK =? CQK RAB?CK

Judgement - Infocity Roltas v. Voltas

Documents

Transcript of Judgement - Infocity Roltas v. Voltas