Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

download Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

of 118

Transcript of Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    1/118

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    2/118

    !"#$% '#$%()*+ ,)(+*)

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    3/118

    - " + # . # * $

    !"#$$%&' )*$+,*+%-$

    !"#$" # &' #$'() "#

    * +',-. /0 !"112"#3

    ./%+#"$

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    4/118

    !"#$% '#$%()*+ ,)(+*)

    4#'$5 1 '6". 23

    7 8 2 " # 6 + 0 7 - ( ) ' # . 5 8 $

    '$ . 9 $ $ " /0 : ; < 3 # $ "

    0*1&234- 51&-6

    7+1&8#"/

    9&%:*"$%+6

    ;"*$$

    7+1&8#"/

    !1

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    5/118

    =8$6"$65

    >6'$?8#. @$-,"#5-63 A#"55

    > 6 ' $ ? 8# .B = ' 1 - ? 8# $ - '

    C DE EE 23 6)" 6 ' $ ? 8 # . HF$ - 8# @$ - , " # 5 - # 3

    ?*%&' 7%&'46'6"5 8? 9T" #- (' 8$ '(-.U?#""B '#() -,'1UV F'1-6 3 K'K"#0

    G- 2 # ' # 3 8? = 8$ J# "5 5 = ' 6 ' 1 8J- $ JU - $ U A F2 1 - (' 6 - 8 $ +' 6 '

    W ' $ (3 B H"' $ U GF(0

    X / 6 # " 5 - $ JF1 ' # K 1 F# - " 1 0 / $ J1 - 5 ) Y

    6 ' $ ? 8# .B = ' 1 - ? 0 ^

    8 ," #" -J $6 3\ 4" () $h $%$

    ! /F18J3 ?8# 6)" Sh1Q" Lbf

    4)" >F#K#-5" 8? 6)" /,"$6 LfM

    &FT'$ /`("55 Lcc

    ! =8 5T8 5

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    6/118

    G"'.B '5 _ .8B 6)" ?18I$U'I'3 ,-#6F" 2'(e 68 "'#6)\

    3"5B 2'(e 68 28 .3 '$. 1-?" [ 6)'6 -6 T'3 J-," 6)" "'#6 ) -65

    T"'$-$JB ' )FT'$ T"'$-$Ji S'3 38F# 5K-#-6 '$. 38F#

    ,-# 6F" 5"#," 6)" T"' $-$ J 8 ? 6)" "'#6 )0 0 0 0 S ' $ '$.

    T'$;5 "'#6) '#" 56-11 F$"`)'F56". '$. F$.-5(8,"#".0\W-"6j5()"

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    7/118

    4) -5 "K-J# 'K) -5 ()85"$ VF-6 " ."1-2"#'6"130 _ #F $ 6)" #-5e 8? -65

    5""T-$J 68 1"$. -65"1 ? 68 ' ("#6'-$ =)#-56 -'$B -."'1 -56B '$. )FT' $-56

    68$"B ' 68$" -$ I)-() -6 -5 "'53 68 #"(8J$-j" 6)85" I"11UT"'$-$J

    ,- #6 F" 5 '$ . ,' 1F "5 6) '6 )' ," 18 85 ". F K 8$ 6) " I 8# 1 . '1 1 6) " 6) -$ J5

    6)'6 )'," .#-,"$ 6)" )FT '$ -63 8? 8F# ("$6 F#3 68 ."5K'-# 8,"# -65"1?BI) "# " 6)" 5" ,'1 F" 5 '#" 28 6) 2 1 - $ . 68 '$ . (8 T K1 - (- 6 -$ 6) -5 1" 66 -$ J

    1885"0 _$ )-5 8I $ I'3B W-"6j5() " )-T5" 1? I8F 1. )'," F$.8F2 6".1 3

    K'#6-(-K'6". -$ 6)-5 .F2-8F5B T8#'1-j-$J K-"630 96 '$3 #'6"B 6)" I8#.

    kT"'$-$Jk #'#"13 'KK"'#5 -$ )-5 I8#eB '$. 56-11 T8#" #'#"13 -$ '$3

    K85-6-," 5"$5"0 :$" I8F1. .8 I"11B 6)"#"?8#"B $86 68 J-," '$3 )'563

    -$6"#K#"6'6-8$5 8? -6 )"#"0 4)" '28," "`("#K6 'KK"'15 68 ' k)FT'$

    T"'$-$JBk 2F6 -6 .8"5 58 23 '??-#T-$J 6)'6 6)" )FT'$ A

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    8/118

    # ! & & &

    "15"l ='$ I" 6)-$e '$ "'#6) '$. ' )FT'$ 5F() 6)'6 6)"3 I8F1. 2"

    8$13 I)'6 6)"3 '#"\+,%&' E4+ " '#6) '$. )F T' $\ '$ . 5F ()

    6)'6 6)"3 I8F1 . 2" $8$" 8? 6)" ,'#-8F5 )8# -j8$5 8?6 "$ )'#28# ".

    F$. "# 6)"5" $'T"5 B $8$ " 8? 6)" kK"#5K"(6-,"5k 8# k,-" I5k %& :%*F

    8? I)- () I" )'," .-5?-JF#". )FT'$ 5 A8T'1-'B =)-('$85B >)--6"5B

    R W G = U = ' $ ' 1 &-56 8#-VF "B G-2"# -'B P-,' 6 &'J' .'$B W-J" #-'B 6)"

    G"'JF" 8? 6)" W8# 6) B 9?J)'$-56'$B _$.8$"5-'B >-e)5B &'-6 -B 7 8T '

    J3K5-"5 8? >18,"$-'B 4' -I'$ B < F#T 'B A G : B _#'VB _51'T-( R#8$ 6 >'1U

    ,' 6- 8$ B > )- $ - $ J A' 6) B o' F1 `U "$ Uo "1 -$ 5B W" F) 8? 0 0 0 0 :? (8 F# 5"B -6

    I 8F 1 . 2" .- ?? -( F1 6 68 2# -$ J 6)- 5 1-5 6 68 '$ "$ . -? 6)" '- T I'5 68 - $ U

    (1F." '11 6)" K1'("5B J#8FK5B 8# 'F6)8#-6-"5 6)'6 (8$56-6F6" 6)" 6)"U

    '6"# 8? 218 8.3 (8$?1-(65 'T 8$J -."$6-6 -"5B '5 I"11 '5 I)'6 -5 '6 56'e"

    -$ 6)"5" (8$?1-(650 4)"5" .'35 -6 -5 $86 '1I'35 K855-21" 68 5'3 I-6)

    '$3 '55F#'$(" I)"6)"# 6)"5" -."$6-6-"5 '#" -$6#'$'6-8$'1B -$?#'$'U

    6-8$'1B 8# 6#'$5$'6-8$'1[ I)"6)"# 6)"3 '#" k(F16F#'1Bk k#"1-J-8F5Bk

    k"6)$-(Bk 8# k)-568#-('1k[ I)"6)"# 6)"3 '#" 1"J-6-T'6" 8# $86\$86

    68 T"$6-8$ 6)" VF"56-8$ '28F6 I)-() 1'I I8F1. K#8,-." 5F() 1"U

    J-6-T'6-8$[ I)"6)"# 6)"3 '#" #"'1B T36)-('1B 8# -T'J-$'#3[ I)"6)"#

    6)"3 '#" -$."K"$."$6 8# k-$56#FT"$6'1-j".k 23 86)"# J#8FK5 I)8

    I- "1 . K8 1- 6- (' 1B "( 8$ 8T -( B '$ . -. "8 18 J- (' 1 K8 I"# 0 0 0 0

    4)-5 -5 6)" k"'#6)k I" '#" 5FKK85". 68 k-$)'2-6k 68.'3B 6)" "'#6)

    ?8# I)-() 6)" $'T" >'#'n",8 I-11 2"(8T" 6)" T'#63#U$'T"B 6)"

    6"56-T8$-'1U$'T"g 6)-5 -5 F5B I" I)8 '#" 5FKK85". 68 5'3 F* '5 -?

    I" e $ 8 I I) '6 I" '#" 5' 3- $J '$ . F,# I" '#" 6'1e-$J '28F60 4)-5

    "'#6) -5 '$36)-$J 2F6 ' 5)'#-$J 8? )FT'$-630 _6 -5 ' I8#1. 6)'6 .8"5$86 ","$ T'$'J" 68 (8$56-6F6" ' I8#1.[ -6 -5 ' I8#1. 1'(e-$J -$

    I8 #1 .B '$ . 1' (e -$ J -$ 6)" T" '$ -$ J 8? I 8# 1. 0 _6 -5 '$ "$ FT "# '6 -8 $

    6)'6 2#-$J5 68 1-J)6 6)" 5)""# $FT2"# '$. K#81-?"#'6-8$ 8? 6)"5" ,'#U

    -8F5 K81"5 8? '66#' (6-8$ '$ . #"KF15 -8$0 _ 6 -5 '$ "$.1"55 1-56B '$.

    ","#36)-$J )'KK"$5 -$ 5F() ' I'3 6)'6 8$" -5 #".F(". 68 e""K-$J

    '((8F$65 2F6 $","# 6'e-$J 6)" ?-$'1 68110 _6 -5 ' 1-6'$3B ' K#'3"# 8?

    KF#" 58##8I '$. KF#" 1855B 6)" K1"' 6)'6 ?'115 ?#8T 6)" 1-K5 8? T- 1U

    1-8$ 5 8? #"?FJ""5 ","#3 .'3g I)"6) "# 6)"3 2" ."K8#6""5B K"8K 1" 2"U

    5-"J".B 6)85" I)8 '#" TF6-1'6".B K"8K1" I)8 56'#,"B I)8 '#" #'K".B

    856#'(-j".B "`(1F.".B "`-1".B "`K"11".0

    ! ) ' 6 _ 'T 6' 1e -$ J '2 8F6 )"#" -5 (8 TK '5 5- 8$ B 2F6 $8 6 (8 TK '5 5- 8$

    '5 ' K-63 6)'6 ?""15 58##3 ?8# -65"1? '$ . ?"".5 8$ -65"1?0 =8T UK '5 5- 8$

    -5 6)" (8$6 'J-8 $B 6)" (8$6'(6 8? 2"-$ J I-6 ) 8$" '$86)"# -$ 6)-5 6F#U

    T8-10 =8TK'55-8$ -5 $86 '16#F-5TB $8# -5 -6 -."$6-?-('6-8$[ -6 -5 6)"

    .-56F# 2'$(" 8? ,-81 "$6 #"1'6".$"550

    ! ) ' 6 .8"5 6)" '2 8, "U$ 'T ". K# 81 -? "# '6 -8 $ #"V F-# " 8? F5B 6)- 5 K# 8U

    1-?"#'6-8$ 6)'6 5""T5 68 )'," $8 86)"# T"'$-$J 6)'$ 6)" -$."6"#T-U

    $'6" TF16-K1- ('6- 8$ 8? ("$6#-K"6'1 T"'$-$J5B T"'$-$J5 (185". -$ 8$

    6)"T5"1,"5 '$. 5FK"#5'6F#'6". I-6) 5-J$-?-('$("\6)'6 -5B T"'$-$J5

    6)'6 '#" $8 18$J"# T"'$-$J?F1 2"('F5" 6)"3 )'," (8T" 68 #"?"# 8$13

    68 6)"-# 8I$ (185F#"B 68 6)"-# )8#- j8$ 8? 'KK# 8K#- '6- 8$B '$. )',"

    2" JF $ 68 5K #" '. $8 6) -$ J 2F 6 ." 56 #F (6 -8 $B )' 6# ".B '$ . 6)" ." $- '1 8?

    "`-56"$("l

    ! ) ' 6 -? 6) -5 'F 6- 56 -( TF 16 -K 1- (- 63 B I) - ( ) 6"'#5 8K "$ '$ . -5 68 #$

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    9/118

    !$"

    8K"$B 1"65 F5 e$8I 6)'6 I" )'," $86 ","$ 2"JF$ 68 .-5(8,"# I)'6 -6

    -5 68 2" T'$3B ","$ 6)8FJ) k1' 6"##" ."5 )8TT"5k d -5 "`'(613 6)-5l

    ! ) ' 6 -? -6 1"6 5 F5 e $ 8 I 6) '6 -6 -5 -6 5" 1? 6) " ?- #5 6 1' 3- $J 2'# " AC%$* K

    &4D 8? ' I8#1. 6)'6 -5 8$13 6)" I8# 1.B 2F6 I)-( ) -5 6)" I8# 1. '2U

    581F6"13 '$. F$#"5"#,".13B I-6) $8 T"'$-$J 2"38$. 6)-5 ,"#3

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    10/118

    ' ( ! ;"*81-*

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    11/118

    q :?

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    12/118

    D ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    13/118

    b ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    14/118

    N ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    15/118

    a ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    16/118

    LE ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    17/118

    LD ?*%&' 7%&'4F () ' 2" -$ JB I) - ( )

    I 8 F 1 . 2" -65 8 I $ ? 8F $. '6 -8 $B 8# -J -$ B '$ . -$ 6- T' (3 B I 8 F 1 . 2" -$ (' UK'21" 8? ?*%&'G -$ ","#3 5"$5" 6)'6 6)-5 "`K#"55-8$ ('$ )'," )"#"0

    k

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    18/118

    ;b ?*%&' 7%&'4K-$8j'B 8# G"- 2$-jB 8$" '1U

    I'35 ?- $. 5 6) '6 6)" 6) "T " 8? ( #" '6 -8 $ -5 2F #. "$ ". I -6 ) '$ . T- 5# "K U#"5"$6". '5 ' K#8 21" T 8? K# 8.F (6- 8$B #-J) 6 FK F$ 6-1 6)" ."(-5-,"

    T8T"$6 8? 6)" 8$6818J-('1 '#JFT"$6;5 .8I$? '110 ]&"J"1;5 #"568#'6-8$

    8? 6)" '#JFT"$6B 6)" 8$" 68 I)-() > ()"11 -$J '55-J$". 5-J$-?-('$6 -T U

    K8#6'$("B -5 $8 6)- $J 2F6 '$ "1'28#'6-8$ 8? 6)" (8$("K6 8? (#"'6-8$0^

    4)" . -56-$(6-," ()'#'(6"#-56-( 8? 6)" (8$("K6 8? (#"'6-8$ -5 $86

    6)'6 -6 K85-65 ' (#"'68#B 2F6 6)'6B 8$ 6)" (8$6#'#3B -6 #"$."#5 6)" k(#"U

    '68#k -$.-56-$(6 ?#8T -65 k(#"'6-8$0k ]_6 )'5 68 2" 5'-.B )"#"B -$ ' J"$U

    "#'1 I'3B 6)'6 6)" .-56-$(6- ," ()'#'(6"#-56-( 8? !"56 "#$ T 8$8 6)" -5T

    -5 $86 6)" K85-6 -$J 8? ' 5-$J1" J8.B 2F6 #'6)"# 6)" "??'(-$J 8? 6)" .- U

    ,- $" '5 5F () -$ 6)" 6# '$ 5( "$ ." $( " 8? 6)" I 8 #1 . 0 ! - 6 ) #"5 K"( 6 68 6)"

    VF"56-8$ 8? 8#- J-$ B 6)-5 -5 5F#"13 6)" K#"(-5" K8-$6 '6 I)-( ) 6)" 1-$ e

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    19/118

    - N ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    20/118

    La ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    21/118

    D E ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    22/118

    D D ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    23/118

    D b ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    24/118

    D N ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    25/118

    D a ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    26/118

    dE ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    27/118

    d D 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    28/118

    db ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    29/118

    dN ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    30/118

    d a ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    31/118

    b E ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    32/118

    )* ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    33/118

    bb ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    34/118

    bN ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    35/118

    ba ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    36/118

    f E ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    37/118

    f D ?*%&' 7%&'4- 6F '6 -8 $- 56 (# -6 -V F" (8 $U

    6-$F". 68 #"?"# "55"$6-'113 68 58T"6)-$J 1-e" '$ -$6"#$'1 6#F6) ]."5U

    -J$'6".B ?8# "`'TK1"B 23 6)" $'T" k."5-#"k 8# k-T'J-$'6-8$k^B 6)"

    I) 81 " (8 $( "K 6 8? I ) -( ) -5 6)' 6 8? ' 5F2 n"( 6-, " 'K K# 8K #- '6 -8 $ 8? k 6#F "

    1-?"Bk -65"1? 6)8FJ)6 8? '5 8#-J-$ K#8K"#B '5 5"1?U."K183T"$6 '$. 5"1?U

    5'6-5?'(6-8$0 _$ 6)-5B >-6F'6-8$-5T ."T8$56#'6"5 6)" $"'#13 (8$56'$6

    ()'#'(6"#-56-( 8? 6)" T8. "#$ ( #-6-V F" 8? "`6"#-8#-63B 'KK"'#'$("B '$.

    58(-'1 '1-"$'6-8$\'6 1"'56B 5-$(" 78F55"'F0_ ("#6'-$13 .8 $86 I'$6 68 5FJJ"56 23 6)-5 6)'6 6)" (#-6-VF" 8?

    '1 -"$'6-8$B - 1 1F5-8$B 8# -."818J3 -5 -$"??"(6F'1 0

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    38/118

    fb ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    39/118

    fN ?*%&' 7%&'4F2n"(6B :6)"#B 8# >'T"^0

    ! ) ' 6 )' KK "$ 5 68 F5B 6) "$ B -5 6)" 56 #- KK -$ J 2'# " AC%$ K &4D 8? 58U

    (-'1 #"'1-63B 6)" ,"#3 "*1

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    40/118

    f a ?*%&' 7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    41/118

    N 8 ?*%&' 7%&'4K-$8j' '$. G"-2$-jB '16)8FJ) -$ .-??"#"$6B 2F6 "VF'1 13 "`"TK1'#3B

    I ' 3 5 \ 6 ) " 68 J"6 )" #$ "55 8# 2" -$ JU 68 J" 6) "# 8? ' 11 6) '6 -5g P 8 . -5 $8 6

    k P 8 . 0 k f D

    48J"6)"#$"55 '$. 2"-$JU68J"6)"# '#" $86 "VF-,'1"$60 ]:$ 6)" (8$U

    6#'#3B 6)" "VF -,8( '6- 8$ 2"6I" "$ 6)" 6I8 T'e" 5 6)" 56'6F5 8? 6)"

    J8.5 8? 8$68U6)"81 8J3 F$("#6'-$0 X!)"6) "# -6 -5 ' T'66"# 8?Y K'$U

    6)"-5TB K'$"$6)"-5TB K8136)"-5TB T8$86)"-5TB '6)"-5TB ."-5TB

    '$. 58 8$B X'#" 5F() J8.5Y #"K#"5"$6'21" 8# F$#"K#"5"$6'21"l X+8

    6)"3Y J#8F$. #"K#"5"$6'6-8$ 8# #"T8," -6l :# XT-J)6 6)"3Y ","$ 2"

    #"K#"5" $6'6-8$ -65" 1?l^ 48J"6)"#$" 55B -$ 6)" 5"$5" 8? 2"- $J ' 5F2U

    56'$6-," "$6-63B -5 ' (811 "(6 -8$ ]'5 -$ 6)" 6)"8# 3 8? 68J"6)"#$"55"5 A*&2

    $*CE)'#-$J A@1"+1'*D '$. K'55'J" (8$6#81 "'()

    86)"# #"(-K#8('1130 &F55"#1 I#-6"5B k_6 -5 "55"$6-'113 $"("55'#3 6)'6

    6)" +#'*+,*"&*$$ 8? T8$'.5B 6)"-# T"#" (8U"`-56"$("B 2" ' +*C@#"18,"#"-J$63\4"()$"

    ! ) ' 6 ?8 11 8I 5 -5 ' #" 5K 8$ 5" 68 ' #" VF "5 6 6) '6 (' T" ? # 8 T 6) "

    @$-6". >6'6"5 ?8# 58T" #"? 1"(6-8$5 8$ kI'# '$. 6"()$818J30k L _$

    6)" T-.56 8? I'# ]-6 -5 I8 #6 ) $86 -$J 6)'6 _ 'T 2"J-$ $-$ J 68 I#-6 "

    8$ DN R"2#F'#3 LMML[ 6)" J#8F$. '66'(e )'5 2"JF$[ -65 ?F6F#" -5 56-11

    F$("#6'-$^ F$ ."#6' e-$J 6)-5 58#6 8? #"? 1"(6-8$ T-J)6 2" -$(8$J #FU

    8F5B ","$ -$."("$60 :$ 6)" 8$" )'$.B I)'6 (8F$65 68.'3 -5 I)'6 -5

    $8 I '6 56'e"B 6)" ."'6)5B 6)" 5F?? "#-$J 8? '11 58#65B ' $. 6)" J#"'6

    53T K'6 )3 6)'6 '(( 8TK '$-" 5 '11 I'#50 ]_ )8K " 58T" 8? -6 '.)"#"5

    )"#"B 56F(e 68 6)"5" 1-$"50^ :$ 6)" 86)"# )'$.B I)'6 '158 (8F$65

    '#" 6)" K81-6-('1 ."6"#T-$ '6-8$5B 6)" 'KK#82'6-8$ '$ . (#-6-(-5 TB 6)"

    T86 -,"5 '$ . #"'58$5 6)'6 ('$ 56- 11B -? K855 -21"B "$J'J" ","#38$";5 #"U

    5K8$5-2-1-630 p"6B I" '#" '1#"'.3 #"5K8$5-21" -$ 56-11 '$86)"# I'3g

    I" )', " 6) " #" 5K 8$ 5- 2- 1- 63 68 6 )- $e 0 95 ?'# '5 T 8# ' 1B K 81 -6 -( ' 1B ' $ .

    '??"(6-," (8$5-."#'6-8$5 '#" (8$("#$".B kI'#Bk '5 -6 #"'KK"'#5 68.'3B

    -5 ' I)81" $"I #"'1-63 -$ ,-#6F" 8? -65 ,"#3 '#()'-5T0 _$ 86)"#

    I8 #. 5B 6)" #" 6F #$ 8? kI '# Bk $8 6 '5 6)" #" '1 -6 3 8 ? T - 1- 6 '# 3 8K "# '6 -8 $5

    2F 6 '5 ' ?- JF# " ]! '# ^ -$ 8F # 53 T2 81 -( 5K' ("B -5 F$ ." $ -' 2 13 ' $" I

    '$. 5-$JF1'# K)" $8T "$8 $B 2"('F5" -6 K#8.F("5 -65"1? -$ ' I8# 1.

    I) "# " 6) -5 5 3T 28 1 5""T 5 68 )' ," 2" "$ '1 1 2F 6 "?? '( ".0 4 ) - 5 -5 ("# U

    6'-$13 I8#6 ) 6)- $e-$ J0 9 $ . -6 T-J)6 2" 6)'6 6)-$ e-$ J '28F6 6)-5 -5

    F#J"$60 _6 -5 K"#)'K5 $8 18$J"# ' VF"56-8$ 8? 6)" ."J#"" 68 I)-()

    I' # -5 ' T8 #" 8# 1"55 $" ("5 5' #3 ", -1 B 8# ' T8 #" 8# 1"55 6# 8F 21 "5 8T "

    J88.0 _6 -5 ' VF"5 6-8 $\' $. -6 -5 ' VF"56-8$ ?8# 6)" I8# 1. \8 ? e$8IU

    _>_

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    62/118

    _ED Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* LEd

    -$J 68 I)-() 53T281-( 5K'(" I" ('$ "$6#F56 I)'6 -5 e$8I$ '5 1 -2U

    "#63B )FT'$-630

    !' #B -$ >K-6" 8? _ 6 9 1 1

    :? (8F#5"B I)' 6 'KK"'#". 68 2 " 6)" "??'(-$J 8? 53T 281 -( !'#

    (8$("# $". 8$1 3 6)" J#8FK 8? $'6-8$5 6)'6 T'e " FK 6)" K1'$"6;5 (8#"

    8? k8#."#Bk k1'IBk D '$. k.","18KT"$60k 4)" k6)-#.k I8#1. )'5 $","#

    568KK". 2"-$J #','J". 23 '#T". (8$?1-(65g 6)"3 '11 .-. )'KK"$B ","$

    -? 6)"3 .- . $86 ?-6 - $68 6)" 56#-(6 ('6"J8#3 8? I'#B 8# ","$ -? 6)"-# 18U

    ('1 ()'#'(6"# K#","$6". 6)"T ?#8T #"'()-$J ?F1 1 53T281-( .-J$-630

    >-$(" LMLbB -6 )'5 5""T". 6)'6B -$ 8$" I'3 8# '$86)"#B k!'#k ."U

    T'$.". ' kJ182'1k .-T"$5-8$0 _ I-1 1 (8T" 2'(e 68 I)'6 6)-5 '.n"(U

    6-," -TK1-"50 R-#56B 1"6 F5 6'e" FK 6)" K8-$6 6)'6 6)-5 kJ182'1-j'6-8$k

    -5 ." 6"# T-$ ". 1"55 23 6)" 5K#" '.-$ JU8F 6 8? 6)" '#"'5 8? (8$?1 -(6

    ]'J'-$B 6)"#" '#" (8$?1-(65 6)#8FJ)8F6 6)" I8#1.^ 6)'$ 23 6)" J182'1

    #81 "\" (8$ 8T- (B 6"()$-('1 B '$. 53 T2 81 -( \8 ? ("#6'-$ 56'6"5 I)85"

    58,"#"-J$63 -5 -$,81,". -$ 6)" I'#0 R8# I'# -5 $"("55'#-13 6)" I'# 8?

    58,"#"-J$5[ 6)'6 -5B 6)"#" -5 $8 I'# I-6)8F6 !'#18#.5g 6)-5 -5 I)'6 _

    I' $6 68 ." '1 I - 6 ) )"# "0

    _6 T-J)6 5""T 6)'6 6)-5 -5 )'#.13 6)" I'3 68 8K"$ 6)" VF"56-8$ 8?

    kI'# '$. 6"()$818J30k _6 I-11 588$ 2"(8T" (1"'#B )8I","#B 6)'6 #'6)"#

    6)'$ (8$("#$-$J T-1 -6'#3 6"()$818J3 ]'28F6 I)-() 6)"#" -5 $86)-$J

    5K"(-'1 68 2" 6)8FJ)6^B '66"$6-8$ .",86". 68 6)" $#:*"*%'& 8? '$. -$

    I' # #","' 15 I' # '5 +*-,&LG '5 1"+G 6)" "`"(F6-8$ 8# KF66-$J 68 I8#e 8?

    58,"#"-J$63 -65"1?0 p"6B I'# -5 '158 '$ -TK"# -8F5B ."(-5-," -$ 6"##F K6-8$

    X@#&-+41+%#&aG "`"TK1'#3 8? '1 1 8F# !"56"#$ 53T281-5 T0

    4) " I'# 8? >6'6"5 '$. (8'1 -6-8$5 8 ? >6'6"5B 6)" kJ#"'6 I'#k ]6)"

    I' # I ) -( ) -5B 23 '1 1 #- J) 65 B 8$ 1 3 ' K ' # 6 \ 2 F 6 '$ -T K8 #6 '$ 6B "` "T U

    K1'#3 K '# 6\ 8? 6)" "`"#(-5" 8? 6)" 56'6"Z$'6-8$'1 58,"#"-J$6-"5 -6 K#"U

    5FKK85"5B I'# K#8K"#13 5K"'e-$J '5 -6 )'5 2""$ ."?-$". 5-$(" 6)" 2"U

    J-$$-$ J5 8? 8F# )-5 68 #3\ _ I-1 1 (8T" 2'(e 68 6)-5^B 6)'6 I'#B -$58?'#

    '5 -6 -5 "'5-13 .-56-$JF-5)'21" ?#8T 86)"#5B -5 6)" X58#6 8?Y I'# I"

    6)8FJ)6 )'. 2""$ ( -#(FT5(#- 2".B - ? $86 5F5K"$.".B -$ 6)" ?-JF#" 8?

    6)" k(81.k I'# '$. $F(1"'# ."6"##"$("0

    4) -5 I'# T'e" 5 -65 #"6F# $B 8# '6 1"'56 '11 8? -65 5-J$5 '#" #"6F# $U

    -$J0 :# #'6)"#B I)'6 -5 )'KK"$-$JB I)'6","# -65 "`'(6 $'T" 5)8F1.

    2" B I - 1 1 )' ," 68 2" '( (8 TK '$ -" .B 5F 56 '- $" .B -1 1F 56 #' 6" .B '$ . ." (8 U

    #'6". I-6) 6)" 5-J$5B 5-J$-?-('6-8$5B '$. -$5-J $-' 8? I'#0 4)-5 I- 1 1

    )'," 2""$ -##"5-56-21"B '$. -6 I-11 $86 )'," 2""$ 6)" #"5F16 8? ' 5-TU

    K1" $"J1-J "$(" -$ 6)" F5" 8? I8#.50

    95 ?'# '5 6) " 1'5 6 ?8 #6 3U ?- ," 3"' #5 '#" (8 $( "# $" .B '$ . -$ 8# ." # 68

    )8 1. FK 6)" T856 -."$6-?-'2 1" ?-JF#"5 8? I'# ]?#8 T ' ?8#T' 1 K8-$ 6 8?

    ,- "I ^B 6) 85" -$ 6) " S' 1 ,- $' 5 '$ . P# "$ '. ' )' ," T8 56 (1 "' #1 3 K# "? -J U

    F#". 5F() ' #"6F#$0 ]_ 'T -$."26". 68 782"#6 R#'-55" ?8# K8-$6-$J

    8F6 6)" ."(-5-," -$.-('6-8$ 8? 6)-5 k#"6F#$k '$.B '5 )" KF6 -6B 8? 6)"

    kI-1. (8$6"$6T"$6k 6)'6 ('T" '18$J I-6) 6)" S'1,-$'5 !'#0^ :6)"#

    '#T". 8K"#'6-8$5 8??-(-'1 13 (8$("#$". 8F# kI8#1 .k 8$13 '5 K81 -(" -$ U

    6"#,"$6-8$5 -$ (8$?1-(65 6)'6 8K "#'6". 8$ 6)" 8#."# 8? #",816B 5F2,"#U

    5-8$B 8# k(-,- 1 I'#k ]' $'T" 6)'6B 1 -e" 6)" P#""e $+1$%$ 8# 6)" 78T '$

    $*/%+%#G -$.-('6"5 6)'6 -6 -5 $86 ' I'# 2"6I""$ 58,"#"-J$5B ' kI'##-8#5;

    I' #k ^B 8# ", "$ '$ -$ 6" #, "$ 6- 8$ -$ 6) " (8 $? #8 $6 '6 -8 $ 8? 58, "# "- J$ 5

    I ) 8 '#" ?'# 'I '3 ? # 8 T F5 B '$ . 8? 6" $ T8 #" 8# 1"55 VF "5 6- 8$ '2 1" 0

    ]/," #3 ."6'-1 8? 6)" F5"5B (1'- T5B T' $-K F1' 6-8 $5B 'K8#-'5 8? 58,"#U

    "-J$63 -$ 6)" K856(818$-'1 I8#1. 8FJ)6 68 2" "`K85".B '5 6)"3 '#" 2"U

    -$J "`K85 ". 68.'3 -$ 6)" K856U>8,-"6 I8 #1. 0 9 $ . 6)" ."6'-15 8?#4"

    #"1'6-8$5 68 '11 6)-5 58,"#"-J$63B 6)" (8$("K6 8? I) -( ) -5 8F#5B 5) 8F1 .

    '158 2" '..".0^

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    63/118

    _:b Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L

    ."1"J-6-T'6-8$B (8F1. )'," #"J'-$". ]8# '1T856 #"J'-$".^ -65 ?F11 1"U

    J-6-T'(3B I )-( ) T"'$5 6)" 1"J-6 -T'(3 8? 6)" 58,"#"-J$B '2581F6"130

    9 ( ( 8 # . - $ J 68 J 88 . K8 1- 6 -( 8U nF # -. -( '1 5" T' $6 -( 5B -6 -5 5' -. '$ .

    I #- 66 "$ 6) '6 -6 -5 $" -6 )" # (8 ## "( 6 $8 # 1" J- 6- T' 6" 68 F5" 6) " I 8# .

    kI'#k ?8# 6)" K#"5"$6 5-6F'6-8$0 _ I-11 (8T" 2'(e 68 6)-50 6'6"[ ?8# "`'TK1"B 8$ 13 FK F $U

    6-1 6)" R-#56 !8#1. !'# I'5 -6 (8TT8$ 68 #"?"# 68 >6'6"5 '5 kA8I"#50k

    :$ 6)" 86) "# )'$ .B 6 )" ?',8# "$n83". 23 6)" -."' 8? ' k>6'6" 8?

    1'Ik .#"I '66"$6-8$ 68 6)'6 "1"T"$6 -$ 58,"#"-J$63 #"J'#.". '5 "`U

    "TK6 ?#8T ,-81"$(" '$. -65 ?8#("0 _6 .#"I '66"$6-8$ 68 6)" K8-$6

    I) "# " 5F () ,- 81 "$ (" B I ) -( ) I 8 F 1 . )', " K# "5 -. ". -$ 6) " -$ 56 -6 F6 -8 $

    8? K8I"#B )' . 68 2" "??'(".B 5F21 -T'6 ".B 8# (F# 2".0 ! '# 5""T". 68

    2" '6 #"56 -$ 6) " K"' (" 8? $8 IU ." ?F $( 6 8# 82 581 "6 " ?" F. '1 -5 T5 '$ .

    $'6-8$'1 -5T50 9 $ . 6)" 'F#' 8? 58,"#"-J$63 J#"I . -T 6)"#" '5 I"1 10

    S8#"8, "#B 6)"#" I'5 $8 T8#" 6'1e 8? k-."818 J-"5k '$ . 6)" kI-6)"#U

    -$J 8? 6)" >6'6"0k _$ ."(1-$" I-6) #"J'#. 68 6)" J182'1 (8TK1"` 8?

    6"()$8U"(8$8T-(5B 6)" >6'6" 5""T5 68 )'," "$6"#". -$68 6)" 'J" 8?

    $*6'6"5 (8$("#$". e$"I )8I 68

    6'K -$68 6)" ,-#6F'1 -6-"5 6)'6 ?18F#-5)". -$ kKF21-( 8K-$-8$kg I'#

    (8F1. 'J'-$ 2" #"VF-#". 8# ."5-#".0 A'(-?-(-5T I'5 $8I 8$13 #8FU

    6-$" 8# '((-."$6'1B .-5#"J'#.". 23 6)" #"56 ?8# )',-$J ?'-1". 68 #"(U

    8J$-j" 6)" ?'5(-56 6)#"'6 $86 58 18$J 'J8B '$. ?8# #"K#"5"$6-$JB 5-$("

    6)" 2"J-$ $-$ J 8? 6)-5 ("$6F#3B $86 )-$ J 2F6 6)" "`'(6 '$. -TK 86" $6

    A%C@4%$$1&+D #","#5" 8? 6)" ,"#3 kJ18 2'1-j '6-8$k 8? I'#0

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    64/118

    -8 N Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&*

    5-8$ -5 K -63 [ '$. '16 )8FJ) 6)" 6#'J".3 8? 6)" I'##-8# -5 $86 6)" 8$1 3

    8$" -$ 6)-5 I8#1.B -6 '18$" 5""T5 68 )'," J#'$."F# 0 0 0 ^ 58B 8$ VF-6"

    ' .-??"#"$6 1","1B 6)" #"'? ?-#T' 6-8$ 8? I'# 5K#-$J5 ?8# 6) ?#8 T ' #"U

    .-5(8,"#". ,1E%+4$G#"."K183" . -$ ' $"I (8$6"`60 9,1E%+4$-5 ' I'3

    8 ?2"-$JB'. -5K85- 6 -8$8 ?T8#"5B'$*+,#$J

    ! ) - ( ) I' 3 8? 2" -$ J -5 -6l ! ) ' 6 -5 -6 T' ." FK 8? l S3 ?- #5 6 # "K 13

    I- 1 12 "5 -TK1" g -6 -5 6)"*+,#$8? I'#-65"1?[ -6 -56) -5 . -5K85- 6 -8$8 ?

    T8#"5B (-,-1 -j'6-8$B '$. 6)-$e-$J 6)'6 '?? -#T5 I'# $86 8$13 '5 6)"T"'$5 8? ' K81-6- (5 2F6 '158 '5 '$ "$. (85F256' $6-'1 I- 6) 6)" "`"#U

    (-5" 8? 58,"#"-J$63B I) -( ) '18$" )81.5 6)" "`("K6-8 $'1 #-J) 6 68 -60

    4) -5 #"5K8$5" K#"5FKK85"5 6)" (8$," $6- 8$ 8? ('1 1-$J 6)" F5" 8?

    >6'6" ?8#("B I-6) #"5K"(6 68 -65 8I$ #-J)6B k' K81-(" '(6-8$k '$. ('11U

    -$J 6)" "`"#(-5" 8? ' 58,"#"-J$ #-J)6 68 ."(-." 68 '66'(e '$86)"# 58,U

    "#"-J$ >6'6" ' kI'#0k _6 -5 K#"(-5"13 6)-5 (8$,"$6-8$ 6)'6 )'5 nF56

    2" "$ #" '( 6- ,' 6" .B I) "6 )" # I" I' $6 68 #" (8 J$ -j " -6 8# $8 60 ]R 8# "`U

    'TK1"B -$ 6"#T5 8? -65 (8$56-6 F6-8$ B R#'$(" -5 $86 '6 I' #\ ' $. #"U

    '113B I)8 -5B '$. '((8# .-$J 68 I)-( ) (8$56-6F6-8$l^

    W86)-$J -5 5FK"#-8# 68 ' 58,"#"-J$ #-J)6 N$4@*"1&*4$ T"'$5 6)'6

    '28," I)-() 6)"#" -5 $86)-$J^0 4)" #-J)6 68 I'J" I'# -5 6)" T856

    58,"#"-J$ 8? '11 #-J) 65 2"('F5" -6 '118I5 ' 58,"#"-J$ 68 ."(-." 6)'6

    '$86)"# 58,"#"-J$ -5 -65 "$"T3 '$. 68 6#3 68 5F2nFJ'6" -6B -$."". 68

    ."56#8 3 -6B 6)'6 -5B 68 #"1-"," -6 8? -65 58,"#"-J$6 3 ])"#"B 1-?" (8T"5

    -$68 6)" 2'#J'-$ A6'6" I'#5 '$ . I'#5 I'J". -$ 6)" $' T" 8? ' F$- U

    ,"# 5'1 K #- $ (- K 1" B 'J '- $5 6 "$ "T -" 5 8? ' ) F T ' $ 58 #6 0 R # 8 T 6) '6 T 8 U

    T"$6 8$ B 6)" VF"56-8$ 8? e$8I- $J -? 8$" (8F1. K#"5"$6 ' F$-,"#5'1

    58,"#"-J$63 I'5 KF6 ?8#I'#.0 0 0 0 ^

    4)" #-J)6 68 I'J" I'# "`("K65 -65"1? ?#8T 1'I '6 6)" ,"#3 K8-$6

    I) "# " -6 2"1 8$ J5 68 -6 2 86 ) '5 '$ 8# -J -$ '$ . '5 '$ "$ .[ 6) -5 K 8- $ 6 -5

    ' K8-$ 6 8? ?8F$ .'6- 8$B -$58?' # '5 I" '#" -$('K'21" 8? 6) -$ e- $J 8?

    ?8F$ .'6- 8$ I-6 )8F 6 58,"#"-J$63B 8# 8? 58,"#"-J$63 -65"1? I-6 )8F 6

    6) -$ e- $J -$ 6"#T5 8? "`("K6 -8$ '$. "`("550 4)" #-J) 6 68 I'J" I'#

    "`("K65 -65"1? ?#8T 1'I '6 ' K8-$6 #"K1"6" I-6) 58,"#"-J$ 2#-11-'$("

    A4& M-

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    65/118

    -8a Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L

    ?8# 6)" "$6-#" 6#'.-6-8$\_ I-11 (8T" 2'(e 68 6)-5\6)-5 "`K#"55-8$

    -5 #".F$.'$6B '5 #".F$.'$6 '5 6)" "`K#"55-8$ k.-#63 I'#k0 0 0 0 ^

    : F # '$`-"6 3 6"56-?-"5 68 6)" ?'(6 6)'6 8F# I8# 1. B 6)" I8# 1. 8?

    kJ182' 1-j'6 -8$Bk .-5K1'("5 6)" (8$("K6 8? I'#B '18$J I-6 ) '11 6)"

    K81- 6-(8 UnF#- .-(' 1 (8$("K65 8? 58,"#"-J$630 _$ ?'(6B 6)" k#"6F#$k 8?

    I' # 8$ 13 'KK "'# 5 '6 6) " )" '# 6 8? 6)"5 " .- 5K 1' (" T" $6 50 4 ) - 5 -5 I ) 3

    58T" )'," .'#". 68 5'3 6)'6 -6 .8"5 $86 'KK"'# '6 '110 "(8$.B -? -6 -5 (1"'# 6)'6 T3 K#"?"#"$(" ]I)-()B '6 6)-5 K8-$6B _

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    66/118

    $ 8 Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L - $

    )81. -$ #"5"#,"^ I'5 $86B -$ 6)-5 I'#B ?8# I'#B _ 'T $8$"6)"1"55

    e""$13 'I'#" 6)'6 6)" J#"'6 T'n8#- 63 8? 6)85" I)8 5F KK8# 6". 6)"

    I' # I' $6 ". 68 2" K' #6- 5' $5 8? ' 1' I 5F K" #- 8# 8# "`6 "#- 8# 68 56'6" 58, U

    "#"-J$6-"50 !)'6 -5 T8#"B T'$3 )'," 6"56-?-". 68 ' #"?-$". 5"$5" 8?

    6)" #"5K8$5-2-1-6-"5 8? '11 6)" K'#6-"5 -$,81,". -$ 6)" (8$?1-(6[ _ 'T

    5"66-$J '5-." '11 $86-8$5 8? -$6"$6-8$ )"#"[ _ 'T $86 (1'-T-$J 6)'6

    6)" I'# I'5 8$13 K'55". 8?? F$."# 6)" JF-5" AC1&+*14D 8? 1'I0 >8 T"

    .-. '5 TF()B 2F6 6)'6 -5 58 (1"'# '5 68 2" $8 18$J"# -$6"#"56-$J0

    ! ) ' 6 -5 -$ 6" #" 56 -$ J -5 6)' 6 -6 I'5 K8 55 -2 1" 68 '? ?- #T 6)" I'# B '$ . 6)"

    T'$$"# -$ I)-() 6)-5 I'5 K855-21" I'5 T8#" 8# 1"55 5-TK1" 8# I'#U

    1-e"B #"56#'-$". 8# (8TK1-('6 ".0

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    67/118

    LLD Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L LLd

    /$J 1' $. B '$. R#' $("0 _6 -5 6#F" 6)'6 '11 8? 6)-5 -5 KF#" ?'('." '$.

    6)'6B ?8# 6)" T856 K'#6B 6)" K"#-8. '?6"# 6)" I'# )'5 K#8K'J'6". (-,-1

    I' #B '6 1"' 56 -$ _# 'V ' $. m F I '- 6B '$ . 5"6 "( 8$ 8T -( I' # -$ T 86 -8 $

    'J'-$0 _6 #"T'-$5 6)" ('5"B )8I","#B 6)'6 k6)" ?'('."k K1'35 ' #81" -$

    6)" (8$56#F(6 -8$5 8? 6)" K81-6 -('1 '$ . (811"( 6-,-63 -$ J"$"#'10^

    _6 -5 6#F"B -$ ?'(6B 6)'6 _ 'T K#"5F KK85- $J 6)" -$6"#K#"6 '6-8$ 8? '

    $FT 2" # 8? ."6'-15B ?# 8T 6)" 'KK#8,'1 8? 6)" I'# 23 $'6-8$'1 K '#1-' U

    T"$65 ]I)-() -5 ' 5FK"#"#8J'68#3 T"'5F#" -$ ' K81-(" 8K"#'6-8$B '5

    I" 1 1 '5 -$ J" $F -$ "1 3 "` (" K6 -8 $' 1 ('5"5 8? .- 56 -$ (6 T- 1- 6' # 3 F# J" $( 3^

    68 '11 6)" -$.-("5 K#8,-.". 23 6)" 5"T'$6-(5B 5631"B '$. "TK)'5"5 8?

    T'$ 3 8? 6)" .-5(8F#5"5 .",86". 68 F#J"$(3B K"# -1B 5'(#-?-("B $'6- 8$'1

    .F63B T-1 -6 '#3 ,-#- 1 -63 B 6)" 5F21 -T-63 8? J#"'6 (8TT'$."# 5B 6)" F$U

    1"'5) -$J 8? K# -T' 1 ?8#("B '$. 58 8$ 0 ]R 8# -$56'$("B _ #"'. 6)" ?81 U

    18I-$J -$ ' K#8T-$"$6 R#"$() $"I5K'K"#g k2F6 )8I ('$ 8$" ?-J)6

    "??-(-"$613 I-6)8F6 ?#""-$J 8$";5 K#-T-6-," -$56-$(65lk[ 68 56'3 I-6)

    6)-5 K8-$6 ?8# ' T8T"$6B 6)-5 5"$6"$("B 6'e"$ '5 5F() '$. -$ 6)" 8#U

    .-$'# 3 (8$6"`6 8? 8F# (F16F#"B -5 F$.8F 26". 13 -##"K#8'()'21"[ '1U

    6)8 FJ) -6 .8"5 6"56-?3 68 6)" k8#.- $'# 3k (8$6"` 6 8? ' 56'6" I) -( )

    6"$.5 68I'#. 6)" ,F1J'#0^ 48 6)85" 1-56". '28,"B 8$" TF56 '.. 6)"

    .-5(8F#5 " 8? 6)" )81 3 T-5 5-8$ g 2 86) 5-."5 )'. P 8 . 8$ 6 )"-# 5-."

    XC#+,*#$,"#5F5 C#+,*#$RG '5 I"11 '5 ('115 ?8# 6)" k?8F$.'6-8$k

    8? ' $"I 8#."# 8# #"J-T"0

    _ )'," $8 -$6"#"56 -$ (81 1"(6-$J KF21-( '$. K#-,'6" .8(FT"$650

    4)" #" '#" ' J#"'6 T'$3 8? 6)"T 0 _$6"#K#"6-," ,-81"$(" -5 )'#.13

    ('11". ?8# -$ 8#."# 68 ."(-K) "# -$ 6)" T 6)" K#"5"$(" 8? ' 53T2 81U

    -5T '$. I'#1 -e" ?'$6'53 6)'6 -5 T8#" 8# 1"55 F$826#F5-,"13 T-`".68J"6)"# I-6) #"'58$5 6)'6 )'," 68 .8 I-6) 1'I '$. 6)" $"". ?8# K8U

    1-(" '(6-8$50 4)-5 .8"5 $86 T"'$ 6)" 1'66"# '#" .-5VF'1-?-".B 2F6 6)"

    ?8#T"# TF56 2" 2#8FJ)6 68 1-J)60

    _$ '..-6-8$B -6 -5 -TK855-21" 68 ?8#J"6 6)" #81" K1'3". 8$ 286) 5-."5

    23 6)" K8 1- 6- (' 1 ."5 -#" '$ . $" ". 68 #"( FK" #'6 " T- 1- 6' #3 ."?" '65 ]o -" 6U

    $'T 8$ 6)" 9T"#-('$ 5-."B '$. >-$'- 8$ 6)" 9#'2-(B ","$ 6)8FJ)

    6)" 6I8 ('5"5 '#" ,"#3 .-??"#"$6^0 _$ 6)" ('5" 8? 6)" @ $- 6" . >6'6"5B

    6)" T856 K8I"#?F1 8? 68.'3;5 '.,"#5'#-"5B I)'6 $"".". 68 2" I'5)".

    'I'3 I'5 $86 8$13 6)" )FT-1-'6-8$ 6)'6 '66'()"5 68 '11 ."?"'65B 2F6

    '158 ' I'# 6)'6 )'. T'." I'# 5)'T"?F10

    _$." ".B 6)" 6'56" ?8# 6)" 5K"(6'(1" 8? "K-( 2"'F 63 '$. )"# 8-(

    ,- #6 F" B I ) -( ) I'5 58 (1 "' #1 3 1' -. 8F 6 . F # -$ J 6)" 2 F -1 .F K 68 I' # '$ .

    -$ -65 ?-#56 K)'5"5B I-11 $86 2" "'5-13 ?8#J866"$0 9?6"# '11B 6)"5" -TU

    'J"5 '#" $86 6)" 51-J)6"56 2-6 .-??"#"$6 ?# 8T 6)85" 8? I'# ?-1T 50 &8 I U

    ","#B _ .8 $86 58 TF() I '$6 68 n8- $ ?8#("5 I-6 ) 6)" (#-6-(5 8? 6)"

    k5K"(6'(F1'# 58(-"63k I)8 )'," T'." ' K8 -$6 8? VF'1 -?3-$ J 6)-5 '5 '

    k5K"(6'(F1'#k I'# ]6)" ."$-'1 8? I) -() -5 .-#"(613 53TT"6# -('1 68

    I) '6 -5 '6 I8 #e -$ 6) " .- 5( 8F #5 " 8? 1' I^ 0 p"6 B 6) " -T' J" 5 8? I '# . - .

    ?8# T ' K'#6 8? 6)" I' #\ ' $. K"#)'K5 I'# -65"1? -5 1-e" ' ?-1TB ","$

    2"? 8#" ' ?- 1T -T -6 '6 "5 I'# 0 _$ 6) " ?'(" 8? )8 ## 8# '$ . K- 63B I ) - () -5

    I) "# " -6 $"( "5 5'# -13 "$. 5 FK B 6)" #" I 8 F 1 . 2" $8 I' # I- 6) 8F 6 ' I' #U

    1-e" T8 T" $6 FT 8? 6)" -T'J-$'#30 _65 5K"(6'(1" -5 -$"`6#-('213 28F $.

    FK I-6) 6)" 58T"6-T"5 56FK"?3-$JB T"()'$-('1 (8$56#'-$6 6)'6

    T'e"5 6)" 581.-"# T'#() 8$0 4 )" K53()818J-565 8? 6)" 9T" #-( '$

    '#T3 688e K1"'5F#" -$ "`K1'-$-$J ]8$ 6"1",-5-8$^ 6)'6 6)" E#6$ .8 $86

    T'#() ?8# ' ('F5"B ?8# #-J)6 8# ."T8(#'(3B 2F6 8$13 58 '5 $86 68 J-,"

    FK -$ ?#8$6 8? 6)"-# (8TK'$ -8$50 4) '6 -5B I)'6 .#-,"5 )8$8# '$.

    J18#3 '1#"'.3 2"18$J5 68 6)" 8#."# 8? 6)" k5K"(6'(1"Bk '$. -6 ('$$86

    2" .- 5T ' $6 1 ". 23 6) " 5- TK 1" ." $F $( -' 6 -8 $ 8? ' T8 . " # $ 'J" -$

    I ) - ( ) 5 -T F1 ' 6- 8$ -5 J" $" #' 1- j" . ' $. ( 8T T 8. - ? - " . 0 ]_ $ ' . . -6 -8 $ B

    '$. '5 '1I'35 )'KK"$5 I- 6) 6)-5 58#6 8? .-5(8F#5"B 6)"#" I"#" J88.

    #"'58$5 ?8# I8$. "#-$ JB 8$ #"'.-$J ("#6'-$ (#-6 -VF"5 8? 6)" kI'#U

    5K"(6'(1"Bk '28F6 6)" $856'1J-' #","'1". 6)"#"B $856'1J-' ?8# 6)" J88.

    81 . I'#5 8? 3"56"#3"'#0^ !) '6 - 5 '6 K1'3 -$ 6)" k5K"(6'( 1"k 8? I'#

    J8"5 TF() ?F#6)"# 2'(e 6)'$ 6)'6B "`6"$.-$J 8F6 68 6)" ,"#3 1-T-65

    8 ? ' I)8 1 " (F1 6F#" ]8 ? I)-() _5 1 'T -5 ' K'#6 ^\ '$ . F$.8 F26" .1 3","$ 2"38$. 6)'60

    _ 'T $86 (1'-T-$J 6)'6 6)" "K-( -5 8$ -65 I'3 2'(e\$"-6)"# 6)"

    &8T"#-( "K-(B $8# 6)" W'K81"8$-(B $8# ","$ 6)85" 6)'6 ('$ 56-11 2"

    '558(-'6". I-6 ) 6)" 2'661"5 8? 78T T" 1B S8 $6J 8T" #3B G"(1"# (B 8#

    PF ." #- '$ B ?8# "`'TK 1"0 ] 91 1 6)" 5'T"B 6)"#" I'5 6'1e 8? 6)" k1"JU

    "$.'#3 K'56k 8? ,'#-8F5 F$-6 5 8# ,")-(1"5 8? I'# 6)'6 ) '. ('##-" . 6)"

    'F#' 8? 6)"-# ."".5 ?#8T 6)" 1'56 I8#1. I'# -$68 6)" PF1?0^ 9 J#"'6

    ."'1 -5 $"".". ?8# 6)" "K-( 68 T'e" ' (8T"2'(eB 2F6 6)-5 kJ#"'6 ."'1k

    -5 $86 "$8F J) 68 "$5F#" 6)'6 $8 '5K"(6 8? 6)" '??- #T'6 -8$ 8# ("1"2#'U

    6-8$ 8? I'# I8F 1. # "T'-$ 0 96 6)" ,"#3 1"'56B 6)" ?'("65 8? ' 2#-1 1-'$ 6

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    68/118

    LLb Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* LLf

    AM-

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    69/118

    $ N Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&*

    I' #k 2' (e . 8 I $ 68 -65 ?8 F$ .' 6- 8$ -$ 6) " 58 ," #" -J $ "` (" K6 -8 $0 R8 #

    "`'TK1"B - 6 -5 (1"'#13 $86 ?#8T 6)" #-J)6 6 8 \ 8 # 18J-( 8?\ I' # 6)'6

    8$" ('$ -$?"# 6)" -$6"#.-(6-8$ 'J'-$56 -$(1F.-$J J"$"6-( K'6#-T8$-"5

    I - 6 ) - $ 6) " 'T 2 -6 8? I '# 1- e" ." 56 #F (6 -8 $0

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    70/118

    &% Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L

    5"55". 8? -65 8I$ 1'I5 '$. B 8$ 6)" 86)"#B ?#8 T k6"( )$818 J3k '5 '$

    k'#6- ? -(-'1 k T"'$5 8? #"'()-$ J -65 "$.50 ;,4$%$ ' $ . +*-,&L\8$"

    (8F1. 5'3 k2-#6) k XkQ(185-8$kY '$ . k'#6k \'#" 6I8 T8."5 8? '((8TU

    K1-5)T"$6 '$. '#"B -$ 6)-5 #"5K"(6B 6)" 5'T" ]2F6 $86 -."$6-('1^ -$

    6)"-# .-??"#"$("g 6)" 5'T" '5 (8$("#$5 '((8TK1-5)T"$6 -$ J"$"#'1B

    '5 KF66-$J 68 I8#e 8# ('##3-$J 8F6 A

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    71/118

    _DE Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L

    6F#"k '$. k6"()$818J30k ]9158 $86" 6)" kI)8113 $'6F#'1k 'T2-JF-63

    8? 8F# F $."#5 6'$ .-$J 8? 5F() ' 5"$6"$("g -5 -6 ' T'66 "# 8? I'# (8$ U

    5-."#". '5 '$ -$6"#T".-'#3 K85-6-8$ 2"6I""$ $'6F#" '$. 6"()$81U

    8J3B 8# -5 -6 ' T' 66"# 8? I'# I)- () 6'e"5 K1'(" 2"6I""$ $'6F#" '$.

    6"()$818J3l A#"(-5"13 5K"'e-$JB I" '#" #"'.3 68 6)-$e 6)"5" 6I8

    6)-$J5 68J"6)"#0^ !'# -5 I)'6 6)"#" -5 6)'6 -5 T856 '$.Z8# 1"'56 k$'6U

    F#'10k _6 '#-5"5 ?#8T 6)" T856 2#F6'1 -$56-$(65 '$.Z8# ?#8T 6)" (81.U

    "56 ('1(F1'6-8$B '$. 58 8$0 4)-5 K85-6-8$ -5 $86 I-6)8F6 ("#6'-$ (8$U

    $"(6-8$5 68 6)'6 K1'(" 2"6I""$ k'#6k '$. k$'6F#"k 6)'6 I" J-," 68

    k2" 'F 63 0k 4 )-5 K85- 6 -8$B I)-() -5 286) K#821" T'6-( '$. K#-, - U1" J" .\ '$ . -5 -65"1? #"K1'3". 6I-(" 2"6I""$ 6I8 8#."#5B 6)'6 8? '#6

    '$. I'#B (8$5-."#". -$ 58T" I'3 68 2" 8KK85". 68 8$" '$86)"#\

    -5 $86 I-6)8F6 -TK8#6'$("0 !" I-11 #"6F#$ 68 6)-5 2"18I0

    /,"#3 (8$5-."#'6-8$ '28F6 "$.5 1"'.5 2'(e 68 58,"#"-J$630 4)"

    K8I" # 8? "$.5B ' 5 6)" K8I" # 8? 6)" F16- T'6 " 8# "`6#"T"B #"5-."5 -$ '

    58,"#"-J$630 9 $ . ","#3 "$.B '5 5F()B -5 $"("55'#-13 8#."#". 23 ' 58,U

    "#"-J$ "$. ]' k58,"#"-J$ J88.k ^0 R8# 6)" I)81" 8? 8F# 6)- $e- $JB 6)"

    /$. -5 -$ >8,"#"-J$63B '$. >8,"#"-J$63 -5 -$ 6)" /$.0 4)" '2581F6"

    6#'$ 5("$. "$("B 8 # 6)" '2355B 8# 6)" T356"#3 8? 5FK# "T" "$.5 6)'6 -5

    ?8F$. '11 6)#8FJ)8F6 6)" 6#'.-6-8$\?8# "`'TK1"B 6)" -TK855-2-1U

    -63 8? ."6"#T- $-$J 6)" k(8$6"$6k 8? 6)" A1'68$-( P 88 . 8# 6)" m'$6U

    -'$ G'I\-5 )"1. ?-#T13 I-6)-$ 6)-5 (-#(1"g 6)'6 I)-() -5 58,"#"-J$ -5

    ?-$'1B 6)'6 I)-() -5 ?-$'1 -5 58,"#"-J$0

    >8,"#" -J$63 -5 6)" K8I" # 8? "`"(F6 -8$ 8# 6)" K8I"# 8? ?-$-5)-$ J '5

    5F()B '2581F6"13 58 '$. I-6)8F6 '$3 ?F#6)"# 5F28#.-$'6-8$ 68 58T"U

    6)-$J "15" ]68 '$86)"# "$.^0 +-,-$" (#"'6-8$ '$. 6)" #83'1 ."(-5-8$

    (8TK85" -65 .8F21" -T'J"g 68 T'e" 8# F$T'e" ' I8#1.B 68 5F2T-6

    68 ' I-11B 68 ."5-J$'6" '$ "$"T30 916)8FJ) '$6-(-K'6". 23 6)" 1"JU

    -51'6-," K8I"# '$. (8$6#811". 23 6)" nF.-(-'1 K8I"#B 6)-5 -5 I)3 6)"

    "`"(F6-," K8I"# '66'-$5 68 '$ "`("K 6-8$'1 56'6" X8? K8I"#Y -$ I'#[

    -$ 5K-6" 8? ","#36 )-$JB )8I","#B 6)-5 8((F##"$(" 68F()"5 FK 8$ ]."

    nF #" '$ . ." ?'( 68^ 6)" ," #3 "` 6# "T -6 3 8? . "( -5 -8 $ T ' e- $J '$ . K8 I" #

    ]K8I"#?F1 ."(-5-8$ '$. ."(-5-," K8I"#^ I)"#" -6 '((8TK1-5)"5 -65

    k"`"(F6-,"k "55"$(" T856 K#8K"# 13B 6)" 58 ,"#"-J$ "55"$(" 8? < " - $ J \

    Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L LDL

    I) "# " 6) -5 -5 kK 8I "# k ]'5 6) " K# -$ (" B >6' 6"B $' 6- 8$ B K" 8K 1" B ?' 6) "#U

    1'$.B '$. 58 8$^0

    4) -5 -5 I)3 '((F5- $J ' 58,"#"-J$ K8I"# 8? I'$ 6-$ J I'# 58 82,- U

    8F513 ?'115 5)8#6 8? 6)" T'#e0 4 )" "`"(F6 -8$ 8? 6)-5 ."5-#" A:#48 6)' 6 -6 -5 $8

    18$J"# '$ 8#J'$ I-6 ) #"J'#. 68 6)" "`"(F6 -8$ 8? 5F() ."5-#"[ - $U

    56"'.B -6 -5 58,"#"-J$63 -65"1? -$ -65 ?-$-5)-$J\-$58?'# '5 I" 6)-$e

    58,"#"-J$63 '((8#.-$J 68 6)" 8$13 (8$("K6 6)'6 -5 '6 8F# .-5K85'10

    _$ I'#B 6)"#" -5 58T"6)-$J 6)'6 -TT".-'6"13 J8"5 2"38$. '11 6)"

    K855-21" J8'15 8? I'#B I)"6 )"# 6)"3 2" ."?"$5-," 8# 8??"$5-,"g 6)"

    '(( 8TK 1-5) T"$ 6 8? 6)" >8,"#"-J$ '5 5F() -$ ' #"1'6-8$ 8? '2581F6"

    8KK85-6-8$ I-6) '$86)"# >8,"#"-J$0 !'# -5 -$.-558(-'213 6)" @,6$%$

    '$ . +*-,&L8? 58,"#"-J$630 _65 1'IB 6)" "`(" K6-8 $ 8? -65 1'IB )'5 '5 -65

    (8F $6" #K8 -$6 6)" 1'I 8? J#'("g 2F6 I-6 ) 6)" 1'66"#B 6)" >8,"#" -J$

    $","# -."$6 -?-"5 -65 "1? $8# "`"(F6"5 -65"1? ,-5UuU,-5 6)" #+,*"J

    _? -6 I"#" $"("55'#3B 8$" (8F1. ?-$. ' ("#6'-$ (8$?-#T'6-8$ X8?

    6)-5Y -$ 6)" ,"#3 K"(F1-'# 53T281-( 8# ?'$6'56-('1 I"-J)6 8? 6)" -$U

    56#FT"$ 65 '$. T' ()-$ "#3 8? I'#0 _6 -5 .-??-(F16 68 ."$3 6)'6 ","$ -?

    6)" PF 1? !' # J'," #-5" 68 '$ "`K1- (-6 .-5(8F#5" 8? 58,"#"-J$63 8$13

    -$ '$ 'IeI' #. '$. (F#58#3 T'$$ "#B 6)'6 -5B -$ 6)" ?8#T 8? ' ."$-'1B

    -6 ("#6'-$13 '#8F5". '$ "`("K6-8$'1 ."K183T"$6 8? 6)" -T'J"5 8?

    6'$e5B n"65B T-55-1"5B '$. )"1T"6". 581.-"#5B -T'J"5 5'6F#'6". I-6)

    53T281 -( I"-J)60 _ 6 ","$ ."K183". -T'J"5 8? 53T28 1-( 5'6F#'6-8$

    -65"1?B I)-( ) (8F1 . I"11 (8$56- 6F6" ' 6#'-6 8? 58,"#"-J$ ?-$-5)-$J0

    :2n"(65 185" 6)"-# 53T281-( ()'#'(6"# 68 6)" "`6"$6 6)'6 6)"-#

    6"()$-(-63 J#8I5B '6 1"'56 6)'6 6"()$-(-63 K85-6". -$ 6"#T5 8? ?F$(U

    6-8$'1-63 ]-$ 6"#T5 8? T"'$5^[ 2F6 6)-5 .8"5 $86 K#","$6 6)" 82n"(6

    ?#8 T 2"-$J 53T281 -(' 113 ]8# ?'$6'56-('113^ -$,"56". 'J'-$0 ! - 6 ) #"U

    J'#. 68 6)-5B 6)-$e 8? ' 5-(e1"B ' )'TT"#B ' 5"6 8? J"'#5B '$. ","$ '

    (-#(F-6 28'#.0

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    72/118

    LDD Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* LDd

    58,"#"-J$ ."56#F(6- 8$B 8# 68 "`"(F6" -65"1? -$ ."56#F (6-8$ B 1$ + " U

    56#F (6-8 $ ]8? 6)" 86)"# 58,"#"-J$^0 4) -5 -5 $86 #"'113 ' ?F$ (6-8 $[ -6 -5

    ' ."56-$'6-8$g 68 J-," '$. #"("-," (811"(6-," ."'6)B ."'6) 5F21-T'6".

    -$68 6)" ."56-$3 8? 6)" (8TTF$-63B 6)" (8TTF$-63 -."$6-? -". -$ '

    58,"#"-J$ "`K85-6-8$ 68 ."'6)0 ]_5 +"'6) 6)" 6#F" >8,"#"-J$ -$ 6)-5

    I) 81 " '?? '-# l !" I - 1 1 (8 T" 2' (e 68 6) -5 0^

    4)F5B I'# 28#."#5 8$ '#60 4)-5 -5 $86 68 5'3 6)'6 -6 28#."#5 8$ 6)"

    '#6 8? I'#B 6)" 6"( )$8 18J 3 8? 6)" 56#'6"J-56[ -6 -5 68 5'3B #'6)"#B 6)' 6 -6

    28 #." #5 8$ '#6 F$ ." #5 68 8. '2 58 1F 6" 13 -$ -65 T 8. "# $ 5"$5 "B +*-,&L' 5' T8." 8? 6)" "`"(F6-8$ 8? 8,"#"-J$ G"'."# 8# W'U

    6-8$ I)"#" 6)" (8TTF$-63 ? -$.5 -65 ? -$-5)-$J0 !'# -5 6)" T8$FU

    T"$6 B 6)" ?"56-,'1B 6)" 58T2" # '$. KF#" 5-J$ 8? 6)" (8T TF $- 63 -$

    -65 58,"#"-J$630

    _$ "55"$("B I'# -5 (811"(6-,"B '$. 6)" (811"(6-,-63 6)'6 -5 "$.8I".

    I - 6 ) 58 ," #" -J $6 3 ]6) " m - $ J . 8 T B >6' 6"B 8# / TK -# "^ -5 23 ." ?- $- 6- 8$

    "$.8I". I-6) 6)" #-J)6 68 I'# ]'5 4)8T'5 9VF-$'5 I#-6"5B QE*

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    73/118

    LDb Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L LDf

    $'6-8$'1 1'Ik '$. k58,"#"-J$630k 4)-5 5'-.B )8I","#B -6 -5 ",-."$613

    $86 6)"5" (8$("K6F'1 .-??-(F16-"5 6)'6 T86-,'6" 6)" ,'#-8F5 .-??"#"$6

    nF .J T" $6 5 '$ . )"5 -6 '6 -8 $5 0 0 0 0 4) "5 " .- ?? -( F1 6- "5 .8 "`K# "55 6)" '(U

    6F'1 56'6" 8? ' I8# 1. "$(F T2"# ". 23 58,"#"-J$63B 2F6 -6 -5 ' I8# 1.

    6)'6 .8"5 $86 e$8I )8I 68 .-5K1'(" 8# J8 2"38$. 58,"#"-J$630^

    _$ 8#."# ?8# 6)" ."(-5-8$ 68 J8 68 I'#\'J'-$56 P"#T'$3B 'J'-$56

    _# 'V \- $ 6)" $'T" 8? )FT '$ #-J)65 68 2"(8T" ' ."(-5-8$ ]' $. $86

    ' I-5)^B -6 I'5 $"("55'#3 6)'6 6)-5 ."(-5-8$ 6'e" ?8#T '$. ?8#(" -$

    '$. 23 I'3 8? 6)" 58,"#"-J$63 8? ' >6' 6"\ '$ .Z8 # '$ '11-'$ (" 8?

    >6'6"50 !) " $ 8$" 8# 5","#'1 >6'6"5 5K"'e -$ 6)" $'T" 8? 6)" #-J)65

    8? T' $B ' $.B F$." # 6)-5 $'T"B KF 6 68 F5" 6)" K#"#8J'6-,"5 8?+,* H4$

    E*6'6"5 ]'$.B -? 8$" (8$5-."#5 -6 ('#"?F113B 6)"

    'F6 )8# -63 8? 58T" 86)"# >6'6"5 '5 I"11^ )'5 2""$ 58 (8TK 1"` '$ . 58

    5-TK1" '6 6)" 5'T" 6-T"B 58 ."1-('6" '$. 58 -$."1-('6"0 4)" 1"J-6-U

    T'(3 I-6)8F6 58,"#"-J$63 8? k-$6"#$'6-8$'1 1'Ik $"".". ' 58,"#"-J$

    +*-,&L\'$. $86 nF56 ' T"'$5 8? "`"(F 6-8$ B '5 I" )'," 2""$ T'."

    68 2"1-","0 K '# 6' I'5 6) '6 56'6 " I) - () J'," -6 5" 1? I' #

    '5 +,*"$. 8? -65 56#F(6F#" '$. ?8#T '6-8 $B '$ . A1'68 5F2n"(6". -6 68

    ' 5","#" (#-6-VF"0 !)'6 (8$56-6F6"5 6)" K#-$(-K1" 8? ?-$'1 K"'(" )'5

    F$.8F26".13 5)-?6". T8#" 6)'$ 8$("B $86 8$13 -$ ?'(6\I)-() -5

    T8#" 6)'$ ",-."$6B 2F6 -$ 6)"8#3 -65"1? ]?8# "`'TK1"B 23 T-`-$J 6)"

    18J-( 8? kK"'("k 68J"6)"# I-6) ' 18J-( 8? #"1-J-8F5 (8$,"#5-8$B 8#

    I - 6 ) ' 18 J- ( 8? 6)" 8( (F K' 6- 8$ 8? ' 6" ## -6 8# 3 (1 '- T" . '5 '$ -$ )" #- U

    6'$("^0 W8$"6 )"1"55B 6)" J"$"#'1 6)"8#"6-('1 #"JF1'6-8$ 8? !"56 "#$

    I' # #" T' -$ 5 6) '6 8? K' (- ?- (' 68 #3 I' # ]' T 8 6 - ? 6) '6 )'5 2" "$ "`U

    6"$.". 58 ?'# '5 68 -$(1 F." 6)" "`K8#6'6-8$ 8? ("#6'-$ (818$-'1-5 6

    ?8#T5 8? kK"'("k^0 !"56"#$ I'# ."$-"5 -65"1? '5 58,"#"-J$ "$.B '$.

    -65 ."$-'1B 8? (8F#5"B (8$56-6F6"5 -65 '.T-5 5-8$ 0

    _6 I8F1. 2" $"("55'#3 )"#" 68 6'e" 6)" 6-T" 68 '$'13j" 6)" (8TU

    K1"` K1'3 2"6I""$ 6)" 6)#"" J#"'6 T8$86) "-5T 5 k8? 6)"

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    74/118

    LDN Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* LDc

    ('F5" 8? 6)-5 1'( e 8? 58,"#"-J$63 0 :$ 6)" 86) "# 5-."B 6'e "$ FK -$ 6)"

    5"#,-(" 8? !"56" #$ 56'6-5T '$. $'6 -8$' 1-5T B 6)" _51'T-( H%,1/

    #"-J$-6"5 6)" ?1'T " 8? 6)" =#F5 '."5 - $ 6)" ?'(" 8? K"'(" '$. 6)" #F 1"

    XK81-("Y 8? 1'I0 _$ "'() -$56'$("B )8I","#B H"I-5) T8$ 86) "-5 T ('$

    -. " $6- ? 3 '$. 5F TT8$ A1$$%'&*"D '$"I 6)" 5F21-T" >8,"#"-J$63 -6

    KF65 -$68 K1'3[ I)-1" '6 ","#3 T8T"$6B _51'T ('$ 6'e" 6)" '2581F6"

    >8,"#"-J$63 6)'6 5"'15 -65 (8TTF$-63 '$. K1F$J" -$68 (8$6"TK1'U

    6-8$ '$. '2'$.8 $T"$60 _$ 6)-5 I'3B 6)"$B 6#-K1" T8$86)"-5 T -5 K8U

    5-6-8$". I-6)-$ ' .8F21" #"J-T" 6)'6 -5 (8$56-6F6".B 8$ 6)" 8$")'$ .B 23 6)" I'# 8? >8,"#"-J$6-"5 '$. B 8$ 6)" 86)"#B 23 6)" 6"$5-8$

    2"6 I"" $ -65 "` "( F6 -8 $ '$ . -65 #" 6# "' 6\ ' 6" $5 -8 $ 6) '6 8( (F #5 -$ "' ()

    8$" 8? 6)"TB '$. 2"6I""$ 6)"T0

    8,"#"-J$63 #"VF-#"5 6)" -$('$."5("$(" 8? 6)"

    "`("K6-8$ '$ . 6)" -."$6-? -'21" .-56 -$( 6-8 $ 8? -65 ?-$-5)-$J0 ]_$ ?'(6B

    .8 I" ","# -."$6-?3 1 K"'("B K#"5"$6". -$ K"#58$B "`("K6 F$."# 6)"

    $'T" '$. -$5 -J$-' 8? '$ "TK-#"\@1 U "#C1&1G @1U 1C*"%-1&1vR

    4) " 58,"#"-J$63 8? 1'IB I)- () I8 F1. $"("55'#-13 56#F(6F#" K"'("B

    -5 -$",-6'213B '$. 68 )8I","# 5T'11 '$ "`6"$6B 58,"#"-J$63 23 ."U

    ?'F16\I)"#"'5 6#F" 58,"#"-J$63 6'e"5 K1'(" $86 8$13 -$ K1"$-6F."

    2F 6 -$ "`("5 5 ' $ . '5 "`(" 550 /, "$ $8 IB 6) -5 ?F $ .' T" $6 '1 .- 5K 85 -U

    6-8$ K#","$65 I'# ?#8T ","# 5-TK13 2"(8T-$J ' 6"()$-VF" ."56-$".

    68 "$1-56 ?8#(" -$68 6)" 5"#,-(" 8? #-J)6B I-6)8F6 -6 '158 '1I'35 2"-$J

    6)" +*-,&L 8? 58,"#"-J$ '??-#T'6-8$0

    _6 -5 $86 5F??-(-"$6B 6)"#"?8#"B 68 e""K #"6F#$-$J 68 6)" ?-$'1 "`-U

    J"$(3 8? K"'("B '$3 T8#" 6)'$ - 6 -5 5F??-(-"$6 68 ."$8F$ (" 6)" -11 FU5-8$ 8 ? 5F() '$ ' -T ' $. #"13 8$ 6)" #"'1-5 T 8? ?8#("0 _ $ "55"$("B

    6)"5" 6I8 .-??"#"$ 6 ?'("5 8? 6)" 5'T" '66-6 F." )'," #"JF1'6 ". 8F#

    (8TK8#6T"$6 68 6)" #"("$6 I'#B 23 T"'$5 8? 6)" 686'1 8# K'#6-'1 #"U

    K#"55-8$ 8? I)'6 _ )'," '66"TK6". 68 1'3 8F6 )"#"0 48 #"T '-$ '6 6)-5

    K8-$6B )8I","#B -5 68 K#"K'#" 6)" I'3 ?8# 6)" I'#5 68 (8T"\'$.

    I - 6 ) 8 F 6 "," $ 2 86 )" #- $ J 68 e $ 8 I -? 6) " #" 56 #' -$ 6 6) '6 )'5 2" "$

    5)8 I$ -$ ("#6 '-$ '5K"(65 8? (8$ .F( 6-$ J 6)-5 I'# ]68 5F() '$ "`6"$6

    6)'6 6)"#" I'5 $86 k6#F13k ' I'#B '16)8FJ) 6)"#" )'5 2""$ '11 6)" ."U

    5-#'21" ."56#F(6-8$^ .8"5 $86B -$ ?'(6B #"K#"5"$6 ' 5T'11 56"K 68I'#.

    ' (8TK1"6" k# "1"J-6 -T'6 -8$k 8? I'#B I)"#" 6)" (8$. -6- 8$5 8? 5F() '

    K855-2-1-63 I8F1. $86 2" '5 ?'# 'I'3 '5 8$" I8F1. )'," 1-e". 68 2"U

    1-"," 8# 2""$ 1". 68 2"1-","0

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    75/118

    LDa Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* LDM

    96 6) -5 K8 -$ 6B 8$" T- J) 6 82n "(6 6)' 6 6)" "T K) '5 -5 K1 '( ". 8$ 6)"

    53T 281 -( 8#."# 8? 58,"#"-J$ 63 ."$-"5B "-6)" # '6 6)" 5'T" 6-T" 8# -$

    6F#$B 6)" 'F6)"$6-(-63 8? 6)" $"". ?8# 1'I '$. 6)" K1'3 8? "(8$8T-(

    ?8#("50 W86 '6 '11B '5 I" I-11 5""0 7'6)"#B ' 53T281-( 8#."# 58 I-."13

    '$. .""K13 I8,"$ -$68 6)" I)81" (F16F#" K#8.F("5 '11 -65 "??"(65 -$

    6)" #"'1 ]'$. 6)F5B ?8# "`'TK1"B -$ "(8$8T3 '$. 1'I[ -$ 6#F6)B )8IU

    ","#B $8$" 8? 6)"5" k8#."#5k 5-T K1 3 (8T"5 ?#8T 6)" 53T 281 -( 8# 6)"

    #"'10 0 0 ^0 _6 -5 -TK8#6'$6 $86 68 T-5F$."#56'$. 6)"5" "??"(650 HF56 '5

    TF() '5 '#6B '$36)-$J 6)'6 -5 K#8K"#13 68 2" ('11". I'# -5 '2581F6"13

    '#()'-( -$ -65 53T281-( ()'#'(6"#B I)-() -$.-('6"5 6)'6 -6 "5('K"5 ?#8T2" -$ J ' K' #6 8? k) -5 68 #3 k F$ ." #5 68 8. '5 6) " K#8 J#" 55 8? ' 1- $" '#

    '$.Z8# (FTF1'6-," 6-T"0 8,"#"-J$630 4)- 5 k'#()'-5 Tk ]'J'-$B 1-e " 6)'6 8? '#6^ 6)F5

    82"35 1'I5 6)'6 '#" T8#" .""K13 5"6 I-6)-$ 8F# (-,-1-j'6-8$B -$ 5F()

    ' I'3 '5 68 -$.-('6" 6)'6 -6 -5 58T"6)-$J T8#" 6)'$ ' #"J#"66'21"

    )81.8,"# X8w-,*4$* $4":%:1&-*DJ 6'6"5 6)"T5"1,"5 6)' $ I-6 ) 6)" TF16 -K1 " ?8#T5 8? 6)"

    kK#"5"$(" k 8? 6)"5" >6'6"5 6)'6 5K'$ 6)" I8# 1. ] -$6"#"565B j8$" 5 8?

    -$?1F"$("B '$. 58 8$^0 95 5F()B I'#ZK81-(" '(6-8$ '158 2"(8T"5 '

    (8$?#8 $6'6-8 $ 8? kI8#1.,- "I5kg ' kI8#1 .,-"I k -5 $","# 6)" '66#-2F6"

    8? 58,"#"-J$63[ 23 ."?-$- 6-8$B 58,"#"-J$63 -5 )-J)"# 6)'$ '$3 k,-"IBk

    '$. 6)" kI8 #1 .k -5 6)" -TK #-$ 6 8? -65 ."(-5-8$0 4) " K8I"#5 )'," 6)"

    I 8 # 1 . '5 6) " 5K' (" J- ," $ ?8 # 6) " K1 '3 8? 6) "- # 58 ," #" -J $6 -" 50 < F 6

    I ) "$ 6) -5 5K' (" -5 5' 6F #' 6" . '$ . 6)" K1 '3 (1 85 ". 8??B 6)" I 8 # 1 . '5

    5F() 2"(8T"5 ' K#821"T0 _6 -5 $8 18$J"# ("#6'-$ 6)'6 6)" ?-$-5) 8?

    6)-5 I8# 1. ('$ 2 " "$,-5'J". -$ 6)" 5'T" I'3 6)'6 6)" I8#1 . 8? 58,U

    "#"-J$5 I'50 4)" I8#1.B 6)'6 -5B T'$ 8# J182'1 )FT'$-63B -5 $86 6)"

    5FT 686'1 8? )FT'$-63 8# 6)" -$56'11'6-8$ 8? ' $"I 58,"#"-J$63 ](8$U

    6#'#3 68 I)'6 )FT'$-5T 58FJ)6 '$. ."5-#".B ","$ 68 6)" K8-$6 8?

    "`)'F56-8$^0 4) " I'#ZK81-(" '(6-8$ 8? J182'1 ) FT' $-6 3 KF65 6)"

    "$.5 8? kT'$k .-#"(613 -$68 K1'3B I)"#"'5 58,"#"-J$ I'# "`K85"5 6)"

    "$. -65"1 ?0 9 $ . nF56 '5 I' #\ '$ . '# 6\( 8TK85 ". 6)" +*-,&1% 8? 58,U

    "#"-J$63B 58 J182'1 )FT'$-63 )'5 $8 +*-,&* 8? -65 8I$g )8I","#

    6)8#8FJ)13 k6"()$818J-('1k 8F# (F16F#" T'3 2"B -6 -5 8$13 +*-,&L -$

    5F5K"$5-8$0 _6 -5 $86 5F#K#-5-$J 6)'6 I'# )'F$65 F50 0 0 0

    95 ' (8 #8 11 '# 3 68 6) " ." ," 18 KT "$ 6 8? ' I8 #1 . T' #e "6 B 8$" (' $ 5""

    -$ 6)" -$, "$6- 8$ 8? I8 #1 . I'# 6)" #"5F16 8? '11 6)" I'#5 6)'6 '((8T U

    K'$-" . 6)" (#"'6-8$ 8? 6)" (8$6"TK 8#'#3 I8#1 .g 8$ 6)" 8$" )'$ .B

    6)"#" '#" 6)" 9T"#-('$ 7",81F6-8$'#3 !'# '$. =-,-1 !'#B I'#5 -$

    6)" 6#'. -6-8$ 8? 58,"#"-J$ I'# '$. 2" '#-$J 6)" 5"1?U'?? -#T'6-8$ 8? '

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    76/118

    LdE Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* LdL

    $"I '$. .-56-$(6 >8,"#"-J$63 ].F#-$J 6)" $-$"6""$6) ("$6F#3B 6)"5"

    5"#,". '5 6)" T8."1 ?8# 6)" I'#5 '$.Z8# ?8F$.-$J 8? $'6-8$5B K#-$U

    (-K'113 6)" $"I P"#T'$3[ ","$ 1'6"#B 6)-5 T8."1 I'5 -$)"#-6". 23

    ,' #- 8F 5 (8 18 $- "5 ^[ 8$ 6) " 86 )" # ) '$ .B 6)" #" -5 6)" I' # 8? 1- 2" #' 6- 8$

    -$ 6)" $'T" 8? )F T' $e -$ .B -$ 6)" $'T" 8? -65 k$'6F#'1 k #-J)65 '$.

    ?#'6"#$-63B 5F() '5 -6 I'5 -$,"$6". -$ 6)" R#"$() 7",81F6-8$0 _6 -5

    6)-5 5"(8$. T8."1 6)'6 $8 18$J"# (8##"5K8$.5 56#-(613 68 6)" 58,"#U

    "-J$ 5()"T'g -6 85(-11'6"5 2"6I""$ ' J"$"#'1 #",816 'J'-$56 6)" ,"#3

    8#."# 8? 58,"#"-J$5 ]I)8 '#" ('11". +6"1&+$G ' 6"#T 6)'6 T'e"5 '$

    'KK"'1 ?8# ' K855-21" 1"J- 6-T'(3 8? #"2"1 1-8$ I-6 )- $ 6)" "6)-( 8UnFU

    # -.-(' 1 6 #'.- 6 -8 $^ '$. ' K8 1 -(". '.T -$-5 6#'6 -8 $ 8 ? )FT '$e -$.B

    I ) - ( ) #" 56# '-$ 5 -6 5" 1? ?# 8T '2 F5 -$ J -65 J8 ," #$ '$ (" 0

    95 5F () B 6) "$ B 6)" J1 82 '1 56'6" 8? I '# "`K #"55 "5 ' 5- TK 1" $" ". B '5

    "-6)"# -65 ('F5" 8# -65 "??"(6g -6 $"".5 '$ 'F6)8#-63 6)'6 J8"5 2"38$.

    6)'6 8? >8,"#"-J$5 "$.8I ". I-6 ) 6)" #-J)6 68 I'#0 >6# -(613 5K"'eU

    -$JB 6)"#" -5 $8 K1'(" ?8# 6)-5 $"". I-6)-$ 6)" 5K'(" '$. 18J-( 8?

    58,"#"-J$630 S8 #" K#"(-5"13B -6 ('$ 2" '$'13j ". -$ 8$" 8? 6)" ?81U

    18I-$J I'35g "-6)"# 6)-5 'F6)8#-63 I8F1. )'," 68 2" ' J182'1 58,"#U

    "-J$63B I)- () (8 F1. $8 6 2" -$ ' 56'6" 8? I'# I-6 ) '$38$" 8$ "'#6)

    ]2F6 8$1 3 I-6) '1 1 6)" J'1'(6-( "TK-#"5 8? 5(-"$(" ?-(6-8$B I)- ()

    ."T8$56#'6"5 6)'6 I" #"'113 8$13 )'," 8$" T8."1 '6 8F# .-5K85'1

    ?#8 T I)-( ) 68 "`6#'K81'6"0 0 0 0 ^[ 8# 6)-5 'F6) 8#-63 -5 8? '$86)"# $'U

    6F#"B ' $. 8? '$86)"# 8#- J-$ ]'$. "$.^B 6)'$ 6)'6 8? 58,"#"-J$630

    R# 8T 6)" G"'JF" 8? W'6-8 $5 68 6)" @$- 6" . W'6-8$ 5B 6)"#" )'5

    2" "$ '$ -$( "5 5' $6 K F6 6- $J -$ 68 K1 '3 8? 6) " 'K8 #-' 5 8? 5F () k5 FK #' U

    58,"#"-J$63Bk 286 ) ?#8T 6)" 56'$.K 8-$6 8? -65 1"J-6-T'6" ?8F$.' 6-8$

    '$. ?# 8T 6)" 56'$ .K8-$ 6 8? -65 ('K'(-63 68 "$.8 I -65"1? I- 6) '$ "?U

    ?"(6-," ?8#("0 48 .-??"#"$6 ."J#""5B '$'18J8F5 K#821"T5 '#" K85".

    23 6) " ,' #- 8F 5 6# '$ 5$ '6 -8 $' 1 8# J' $- j' 6- 8$ 5 8? 9 ? #- (' $ 8# 9 5 - ' $

    >6'6"50 _$ 3"6 '$86)"# I'3B /F# 8K" -6 5"1? -5 (8 T- $J FK 'J'-$56 6)"

    K#821"T 8? %&+*"2G +"1&$2G 8# $4@"1&1+%#&1

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    77/118

    LdD Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L Ldd

    8$13 1'I 'KK"'#5 68 "1F." -60 4)-5 -5 2"('F5"B #-J)6 'I'3B 1'I 5"65 -6U

    5"1? FK 2"6I" "$ ?-#56 K#-$(- K1"5 ' $. ?-$'1 "$.5 ]6)" 58,"#"-J$ 5K'("

    -5 6)" ?-JF#"[ 6)" nF#-.-('1 5K'(" -5 6)" -$6"#,'1^0 G'I (8$5"$65 68 1"6

    K#-$(-K1"5 '$. "$.5 ?'11 F$."# '$ 'F6)8#-63 86)"# 6)'$ -65 8I$B '$.

    6)-5 (8$5"$6 2"18$J5 68 -65 56#F(6F#"0 _6 6)F5 "5('K"5 ?#8T 6)" T8."1

    8$13 -$ 8#."# 68 ."5-J$'6" '$"I 6)" K1'("5 I)"#" 6)" T8."1 'KK1-"5g

    '6 "'() 8? 6)" 6I8 "`6#"T-6-"5B K #-$(-K 1"5 '$. "$.50 >8,"#"-J$63

    ('$$86 568K )'F$6-$J F5B 5-$(" -6 -5 '6 6)"5" "`6#"T-6-"5 6)'6 1'IB 8?

    -65 8I$ '((8#.B 18('6"5 'F6)8#-63 A

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    78/118

    Ldb Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&*Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* Ldf

    ",-6'21"g 6)'6 -5B 6)" 5FK#"T" .8T-$ '6 -8$ 8? I)'6 I8F 1. $"-6)"#

    )'," 6)" 2#-11-'$(" AM-8F6)B -$ 6)" /'560 0 0 ^B -6 5""T5 6)'6 ,-(68#3 '$. ."?"'6 '#" J#8IU

    -$J (185"# 68J"6)"#B 6"#T5 I)-() 6)"T5"1,"5 '#" '5 F$6"$'21" '5 6)"3

    '#" -$5-J$-?-('$60 R-$'113B '5 ","#38$" e$8I5 K"#?"(613 I"11B 6)" 6#F"

    #"'1T 8? 6)-5 I'# )'5 #","'1". -65"1? 68 2" 6)'6 8? "(86"()$-(' 1 I'#B

    8# (8$?#8$6'6-8$B ' ."56#F(6-," '$. 'KK#8K#-'6-," T'$"F,"#-$J

    I- 6 ) 8F 6 58 ," #" -J $ 2# -1 1- '$ (" 0 >F () I' # 3- "1 .5 $ 8 6 )- $ J 68 #"' 1 I' #

    '5 ?'# '5 K8I"# '$. 6)" 6"()$818J-"5 8? #F- $'6 -8$ ' $. (8$VF"56 '#"

    (8$("#$".0

    4) " (1'55 56#FJJ1" I'5 5FKK85". 68 2" 6)" 86)"# 8? 28 6) 58,"#"-J$

    I' # '$ . "(8 6"( )$ -(' 1 I'# 0 _? 8$ " (1 '- T5 6)' 6 6)- 5 56# FJJ1 " -5 $8 18$ J"#

    6'e-$J K1'("B 8# 6)'6 -6 $8 18$J"# )'5 ' K1'(" -$ I)-() 68 6'e" K1'("B

    6)"$ 8$" -5 '158 5'3-$ J 6)'6 6)"#" -5 $8 (8$?1- (6 8F65-." 8? 58,"#"-J$

    I' # ]( '1 1" . ' kK 81 -( " X' (6 -8 $Y Bk -$ 8# ." # 68 2" ." $- ". '6 6) " ," #3

    K8- $6 8? -65 #"6F#$^ '$. "(86"()$-('1 I'# ]I)-() -5 ('11". k(8TK"6 -U

    6-8$k^0 W8I)"#"B 6)"$B -5 6)"#" I'#B '$. ","#3I)"#" 6)"#" -5 6"'#-$J

    'K'#6B 6#'TK1-$J .8I$B (-,-1 -j". ,-81"$("B '$. 6)" 2#F6'1-6-"5 6)'6

    '#" T"#" ('#-('6F#"5 8? '$(-"$6B 5'(#". ,-81"$("0 !'# -5 $8I)"#" '$.

    ","#3I)"#"B #"1'6". 68 '$3 "$. I-6)8F6 '$3 18$J"# 2"-$J #"1'6". 68

    -65"1? '5 5FK#"T" "$. 0 _$ ' 5"$5"B 6)"$ B "(86"()$-(5 -5 '158 KF#"

    +*-,&*G 6)" KF#" +*-,&L8? $8$58,"#"-J$63g 2F6 2"('F5" 6)" "TK63

    K1'(" 8? 58,"#"-J$63 #"T'-$5 8( (FK -".B " $(FT 2"#" . 23 6)-5 ,"#3

    ,8 -. B "(8 6"( )$- (5 .8"5 $8 6 '6 6' -$ 68 I' #. '$ 86 )"# 6 )- $ e- $J 8? 6 )" "$ .

    I- 6) 8F 6 "$ .0

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    79/118

    LdN Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L Ldc

    '11 58,"#"-J$6-"5B "`("K6 ?8# 6)85" 6)'6 -$ #"'1-63 (8-$(-." I-6)

    "(86"()$-('1 K8I"#0 W'6- 8$'1 -5T5 B I)"6)"# 6)"3 2" 8? '$ '$(-"$6

    1-$"'J" 8# 8? #"("$6 "`6#'(6-8$ B ."1-,"# 6)"T5"1,"5 FK 68 6)" K'-$? F1

    -T-6 '6-8 $5 8? ' TF TT -? -" . 58,"#"-J$630 4) " (F##"$6 5K'(" 8? 58,U

    "#"-J$63B I)-() ('$$86 2" #"(FK"#'6". 23 '$3 (85T8K81-6'$-5T

    ]2"('F5" (85 T8K 81- 6'$ -5T -5 '1I'35 6)" .#"' T1-e " 8KK85-6" 8? 6)"

    58,"#"-J$ 8#."#^B I)-() -5 '158 6)" 5K'(" 8? 6)" ?-$-5)-$J 8? -."$6-63

    -$ J"$"#'1B -5 581"13 ' .-56"$.". 5K'(" ?F11 8? )81"5B I)"#" $8 6)- $J

    ('$ (8T" 68 K#"5"$("0

    d0 6'6" '5 "TK63 ?#8T $8I 8$0

    4)-5 -5 '158 I)3 "(86"()$-(5 -65"1? ('$ 5FTT8$ 6)" ?-JF#" 8? 58,U

    "#"-J$63 -$68 6)-5 "T K63 K1'("0 4)F 5 6)" J'K-$J 8K"$ 8? 6)" ?8F$U

    .'6-8 $ 8? 1'IB '$. '11 6)" VF"56-8$5 #",81,- $J '#8F$ . "`("K6-8$ '$.

    "`("55B ('$ 2" ?8#J866"$ -$ 6)" 58,"#"-J$ 2#-11-'$(" 6)'6 6)" K8I"#

    K#8K"#13 I-6)8F6 K8I"#B I)-() K81-("5 6)" I8#1. 8#."# '$. I'6()"5

    8,"# 6)" K#-(" 8? K#- T'# 3 #"58F#("5B 28# #8I5 -$ 6)" 6-T" 8? I'#0 : #"15"B 68 KF6 -6 -$ '$86)"# I'3B 6)" "TK63 K1'(" 8? 6)" 8$" I)8 #"U

    (-6"5 '$ "K-( 6'1" -5 $8I 8(( FK- ". 23 6)" 58,"#"-J$ ?-JF#" 8? 6)"

    K#8K )"6 8? 6)" T8#'1 G' I ]I)8 ('$B '6 6)" 5'T" 6-T"B T'e " )-T U

    5"1? -$6 8 6)" $'##'68 # 8? 5T'11"#B T8 #" ?'T- 1-'# "K-(5B 1- e" k8F# 2835

    ?#8T 4"`'5k^0 :,"# '$. 'J'-$56 6)-5B '$86)"# ?-JF#" '66"TK6". 68

    #"-J$-6" 6)" 9#'2 "K-(B I-6) 6)" 581" '-T 8? 6'e-$J K'#6 -$ 6)"

    "(86"( )$-(' 1 K8I "# 8? 6)" T'56"#5 8? 6)" I8#1 .0 0 0 0 _ $ 28 6) ('5"5B -6

    I'5 $"( "55 '#3 6)' 6 6)" T8 ." 15 B 6)" -. "$ 6- ?- '2 1" "`' TK 1" 5 8? 6)" 58, U

    "#"-J$ '11F#"B JF'#'$6"" 6)" 2"56 K#" 5FT K6- 8$ 8? nF56-("B 8# 8? K"8U

    K1" A#4 /* @*4@

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    80/118

    Lda Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* LdM

    4)" "TK63 K1'(" 8? >8,"#"-J$63 I-11 J-," #-5" 68 T8#" 8# 1"55 5F(U

    ("55?F1 5F256-6F6-8$5 8 ? 6)-5 63K"B 6)'6 -5 B F$ 6 - 1 6)-5 K1'(" 1$$4-,- 5

    5F2T-66". 68 VF"56-8$-$J '$. ."(8$56#F(6-8$B 6)'6 -5B F$6-1 I" )',"

    '5e". 6)" VF"56-8$ '28F6 6)" "$. I-6)8F6 #"5"#,"B 6)" VF"56-8$

    '28F6 6)" "`6#"T"U1-T-6 8? ? -$-5)-$J '$. -."$6-?3B I)-() -5 ?#8T

    $8 I 8$ 6)" VF"56 -8$ 8? '&$#:*"*%'& C*1&%&''5+,* :*"6 $*&$* #8

    +,* ,4C1&%+6 #8 ,4C1&$ 1&/ +,* '

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    81/118

    LbE Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&L Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* LbL

    1-2"#'6". ?#8T ('K-6'1^B -5 6)" +*-,&L #8 ?-$-6F." 8# 5K'(-$J0 4)-5 -5

    $8 18$J"# 6)" 6"()$-('1 T"'$5 68 '$ /$.B 2F6 +*-,&L -65"1? '5 -$U? - U

    $-6" "$.B +*-,&L '5 6)" "`-56"$(" 8? ?-$-6" "`-56"$(" -$ '11 -65 2 # - 1 U

    1-'$(" '$. ,-81"$("0 _6 -5 k6"()$818J3k -65"1?B 2F6 -6 -5 ' 6"()$818J3

    6)'6B 8? -65"1?B #'-5"5 6)" $"("55-63 8? 'KK# 8K#- '6-$ J -65 T"'$ -$J

    'J'-$56 6)" 'KK#8K# -'6- ," 18J-( 8? ('K-6 '1 '$ . 'J'-$56 6)" 58,"#"-J$

    18J-( 8? I'#0

    _$ 6)" "$.B 6)" VF"56-8$ -5 $86 I)"6)"# I'# -5 k2'.0k !'# -5

    k2'.Bk '$. -6 -5 '2581F6"13 58B "5K"(-'113 I)"$ 6)" 5K'(" I)"#" -6."K1835 -65"1? $8 18$J"# K"#T-65 6)" J18#-8F5 '$. K8I "#?F1 K#"5"$U

    6'6-8$ 8? -65 ?-JF#" ]'5 6)" ?-JF#" 8? 6)" ."'6) 8? '11 ?-JF#"5^0 !)"$

    6)-5 5K'(" 0 0 0 (8$56-6F6" 5 5K'( -$JB 6)" -$6"#5 "(6- 8$ 8? 5-$JF 1'#- 6-"5B

    '$. $8 6 6)" (8$?# 8$6 '6- 8$ 8? ?'("5 8# T'5e50

    _6 -5 )"#" 6)'6 8F# )-568#3 (8T"5 FK8$ -65 J#"'6"56 .'$J"# '$. -65

    J#"'6"56 8KK8#6F$-630 _6 -5 )"#" -$ 6)" 56-11 K88#13 K"#("-,". -TK"#'U

    6-," 8? ' I8#1 . 6)'6 -5 -$ 6)" K#8("55 8? (#"'6-$J -65 J182 '1 (8 $.- U

    6-8$5B -$ 8#."# 68 #"$."# F$6"$'21" '$. ('6'56#8K)-( 6)" 5)'#-$J 8?

    #-()"5 '$. K8,"#63B 8? -$6"J #'6-8$ ' $. "`(1F 5-8$B 8 ? ","#3 W8 #6 )

    '$. >8F6 )0

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    82/118

    LbD Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* Z1"G u%',+G 7#:*"*%'&+6WS*-,&* Lbd

    -5 '2581F6"13 $'-,"\I)"$ -6 -5 $86 5-TK13 )3K8(#-6-('1 0 48 'KK#8U

    K#-'6" 8$";5 8I$ 6-T" )'5 '1I'35 2""$ F$)"'#. 8?0 )--6"5 ' K"8K1"l 9 $ .

    6)" &" 2#" I5 '$. Z8# _5#'"1-5 '$ .Z8# H"I5l 9 $ . 6)" k"`U/'5 6 P" #U

    T'$5kl !) '6 '#" 6)" #"1'6-8$5 8? ' k58,"#"-J$k K"8K1 " 68 ' kK 8K FU

    1'#k K"8K1"l !) "#" 6 8 K1'(" 6#-2"5B (1'$5B 2#86)"#)88 .5l 9 $ . _ )',"

    68 -$5-56 8$ 6)-5B I)"#" 68 K1'(" (1'55"5B 1","15B T'#J-$5B T-1-"F5B 58U

    (-'1 $"6I8#e5l 4)" '1T 856UT8$56#8F5 TF16- K1-(' 6-8$ 8? 6)"5" VF"5U

    6-8$5 -5 6)" T'#e 8? 6)" K#821"T '28F6 I)- () _ 'T 5K"'e-$J0 W "- U

    6)"# 6)" 58,"#"-J$ T8."1B $8# 6)" 'F6)8#-63 8? 6)" 1'I '..#"55"56)-5 K#82 1"T [ 6)"3 8$1 3 ."$3 -60 _$56 "'.B I)'6 -5 8? (8$ ("#$ )"#" -5

    '

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    83/118

    q /F18 J3 ?8# 6)" Sh1Q"

    Nc#" 71"1H*:#G e1"-, %@@$R

    k>'#'n",8k )'5 2"(8T" +,* "`K#"55-8$ 8? ' (8TK1"6" 5356"T ?8#

    6)" #".F(6-8$ 68 -."$6-630 L _6 -5 $8 18$J"# ' 5-J$ 8$ 6)" I'3B 8# '

    5-J$ -$ )-568#3[ -6 -5 $8 18$J"# ' K855-21" ."56-$'6-8$ ?8# 2F5-$"55

    6#-K5 8# -11-(-6 #"$."j,8F5B 8# 6)" F$("#6'-$ 5K'(" ?8# ' ?8#6F-68F5

    T""6-$J 8# .-56#'(6". I'$."#-$J0 _6 -5 ' .-T"$5-8$U1"55 K8-$6 8$ '

    .-'J#' T 8? 58,"#"-J$63B '$ 8#6 )8U$8 #T'6 -," J'FJ" 8$ ' 2'11-56-( '$ .

    K81-6-('1 (8TKF6"#B ' 6'#J"6 ?#8j"$ -$ ' 6"1"5(8K-( 5-J)6B '$. -6 -5 6)"

    ," #3 ?- JF #" 8? 6)" "` '( 6- 6F ." 8? 6' e- $J ' -T B 6) " KF #" 6 'e -$ J ' - T 8?

    '$ "55"$("0 >8T"I)"#"B ' KF#" >F2n"(6 ."(1'#"5 6)'6 -6 -5 6)" A"8U

    K1"B 6)" G'IB 6)" >6'6"B 6)" _."$6- 63 -$ 6)" $'T" 8? I) -( ) k>'#' U

    n" ,8 k TF 56 2" -. "$ 6- ?- ". KF #" 13 ' $ . 5 -T K 13 '5 ' 6'# J"60

    >'#'n",8 -5 5-TK13 ' $'T" 8# ' 5-J$ 6)'6 J#'25 8F# '66"$6-8$

    ACLC* @'#'n",'$ 1'$.5('K"B 8# 6#-K5 68 >'#'n",8B

    2F 6 8 $1 3 ' KF #" '$ . $' e" . -. "$ 6- 63 0 _6 -5 5F () 58 6) '6 $ 86 )- $J "15"I - 1 1 J"6 T -` ". -$ I - 6 ) -6 B '$ . 58 6) '6 I" .8 $8 6 J"6 T- `" . FK -$ -6 B

    6)'6 -5B I" 86)"# (85T8K81-6'$ /F#8K"'$50

    9 (- 63 .8 "5 $8 6 )' ," 68 2" -. "$ 6- ?- ". 23 '$ 36 )- $ J 86 )" # 6) '$ '

    $'T"B I )-( ) -$.-('6"5 ' K1'("B 6)" K1'(" 8? ' CL

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    84/118

    LbN .4'#'n",8B

    6)"#" I'5 $8 $"". 68 -."$6-?3 >'#'n",80 '#'n",8. -" ? #8T6)"."'6)8 ?>'#'n",8%+$*'#'n",8 '#" "`-1". ?#8T 6)-5 K1'("B

    "`K"11". 23 6)-5 28.30 4)"3 '#" "`-1". ?#8T 6)" T-`B ?#8T 6)" 6)'6

    CL

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    85/118

    Lba .4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    86/118

    .4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    87/118

    .4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    88/118

    Lfb .4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    89/118

    LfN .4-(-1-'$ 8?

    6)" FKK"# "()"18$5 8? 58(-"63l =8 F1 . 6)"3 2" (8$?F5".l _6 I8 F1. B

    -$ ?'(6B 2" T8#" 1-e"13 6)'6B -$ =)-('J8B 8$" I8F1. (8$?F5" ' >-(-1U

    -'$ k8? 6)" K"8K1"k '$. ' A81" k8? 6)" K"8K1"Bk 8# 6)'6 "15"I)"#"B

    8$" I8F1. (8$?F5" 58T"8$" ?#8T 6)" A'1"#T8 FKK"# (1'55 '$.

    58T"8$" ? #8T 6)" FKK"# (1'55 8? G38 $0 @$. "# 6)" K#"55F#" 8? I'$6U

    -$J 68 )'," $86)-$J T8#" 68 .8 I-6) -

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    90/118

    Lfa .4'#'n",8 -5 ' (-63 .-,-.". -$68 '6 1"'56 6)#"" (-6-"5B 286) 5F(("5U

    5-," '$. 5-TF16'$"8F5B '$. 6)'6 F2n"(6-," G8J-([

    8# 6)" +8(6 #-$" 8? 6)" W86- 8$ 0k

    4)-5 5"$6"$(" ('$ 2" #"'. -$ 6I8 I'350 9((8#.-$J 68 6)" ?-#56

    #"'.-$JB I)-() -5 ("#6'-$13 6)" T856 82,-8F5 2"('F5" -6 (185"13 (8$U

    ?8#T5 68 I)'6 K'55"5 ?8# 6)" ('$8$-('1 -$6"#K #"6'6-8 $ 8? &"J"1 -'$

    6) -$ e-$ JB 6)-5 5"$6"$(" 5-J$-?-"5 6)'6 6)" 6'5e 8? K)- 185 8K) 3 -5 68

    _bs

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    91/118

    -N 8 S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+

    -#&-*%:* 6)'6 8? I)- () 6)" ","$6 -5 8$13 6)" K)"$8 T"$8 $0 G "6 F5 2"

    T8#" K#"(-5"0 R8 # K)-1858 K)3B 6)"#" -5 ?-#56 8? '11 6)" 6#F6 ) 6)'6 -5

    (8$ 6'- $". -$ I)'6 )'KK"$5B '$ . 6)"$B -$ 1-J)6 8? 6)-5 6#F6 )B 6)"

    (8$ ("K6 -8$ 8? -65 ,"#3 K#8 .F( 6-8 $ 8# "??"(6F'6-8$ B I)-( ) 'KK"'#5

    ?#8T 6)" 8F65-." '5 '$ k","$6B KF#" '$. 5-TK1" NE

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    92/118

    - N D S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+

    _6 -5 23 I'3 8? 6)-5 .-??"#"$(" 8# 6)-5 5F#K1F5 8? 6# F6 )\ $8 6 6)"

    6#F6 ) '28," 6)" 6#F"B 2F6 6)" 6#F6) 8 ? 6)" 6'e-$J K1'(" 8? 6)" 6# F" \

    6)'6 &"J"1 8K"$5 FK T8."# $-63B I)"#" 6)" 8K"$- $J 8? T8." #$- 63 -5

    $86)-$J 86)"# 6)'$ 6)" 8K"$-$J 8? 6)-$e-$J 68 6)" ","$6 '5 5F()B 68

    6)" 6#F6 ) 8? 6)" ","$6 2"38 $. ","#3 '.,"$6 8? T"' $-$ J0 _ $ 6)" 8K"$U

    -$JU FK 8? T8. "#$ -63 ]8#B KF6 '$86 )"# I'3B -$ 6)" (185F#" 8? T"6'U

    K)35-(5B I)- () -5 -65"1? $86)-$ J 86)"# 6)'$ 6)" ","$6 8? 6)" 8K"$-$ JB

    6)" ","$6 8K"$-$J 6)-$e-$J 68 6)" 5F#K1F5 6)'6 8,"#?18I5 6)" 8#-J-$^B

    6)"#" -5 6)-5 6#'(" K8-$6". -$ 6)" .-#"(6-8$ 8? 6)" ","$6 1$5F()0

    4) -5 -5 I)' 6 -5 '6 56'e"g 6)" 6'5e 8? K)- 185 8K) 3 -5 $86 ' T'66"# 8?

    5F256-6F6-$J ?8# 6)" $'##'6-," f*$-,*,*& 58T" 5F256#'6FT 8# 5F2U

    n"( 6 6) '6 .8" 5 $8 6 )' KK "$ 8# 8( (F #B 2F 6 5 -T K1 3 -5 ]I )- () B -$ 58 ?' # '5

    -6 -5 5FKUK85". A$4@2@#$MDG )'5 '1I'35 '1#"'.3 2""$\6)" k2"-$J

    I) '6 -6 I' 5B k 6)" +# +% *& *%&1% 8? 9#-5686 1"^0

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    93/118

    LNb S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ LNf

    T'66"# 8? "`"#(-5-$J -$6"#K#" 6-," ,-81"$(" B $8# -5 -6 ' T'66"# 8? T'eU

    -$J &"J"1B (8$6#'#3 68 )-5 8I$ T'`-TB 1"'K 8,"# )-5 8I$ 6-T"0 _6 -5

    ' T'66"# 8? #"'1-j-$J 6)'6 )" TF56 2" T'." 68 5'3 6)-5B )8I","# 5F#U

    K#- 5-$J 6)'6 T- J)6 5""T 68 6)" k&"J" 1-' $5k ]-? 6)"#" '#" '$3 1"?6^B

    '$. ' T'66"# 8? $86- $J 6)'6 &"J"1 ;5 8I$ 6-T" - $ K)-185 8K)3B 6)"

    6-T" 8? 6)" T8."# $ (185F#"Z8K"$-$JB -$(1F ."5 6)-5 5F#K#-5" I-6) -$

    -65"1?\' 5"(#"6 A$#4"/*D '$`-"63 N9&"4,*R #"J'#.-$J 6)" ","$60

    4)-$e-$J 6)" ","$6 -$ -65 "55"$(" '5 ","$6 5F#K#-5"5 &"J"1-'$

    6) -$e -$J ?#8 T 6)" -$5-."0 :? (8F#5"B 5F() ' 6)8FJ) 6 (185"5 -$ 8$ -6U

    5"1? nF56 '5 VF-( e13 '5 -6 -5 8K"$" .0 _$ 5)8#6B &"J" 1 1"65 6)" f*$-,*,*&(8T" '$. J8B )'KK"$ '$. 1"',"B I-6)8F6 5"-j-$J -60

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    94/118

    %mm S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ LNc

    $"-6)"# kK#'(6-('1k $8# kK8"6-(Bk '$. 6)" 5(-"$(" I)-() K#8("".5

    ?#8T I8$."#\%&$#81" 1$ 6)-5 -5 "`'(613 I)'6 K#8,-."5 '(("55 68 6)'6

    5(-"$(" I)-() -5 -65 8I$ "$.0 !8$."#B 6)"$B .8"5 $86 'KK"'# '5

    58T" -J$8#'$(" 68 2" 8,"#(8T" 8# '5 '$ 'K8#-' 68 2" 5F#T8F$6".B

    I ) -( ) I 8 F 1 . 2" ' 5- 6F '6 -8 $ I) "# "- $ 8$ " 5( -"$ (" (8 F1 . $8 6 #" '1 13 2"

    .-56-$JF-5)". ?#8T 6)" 86)"#5[ -$56"'.B I8$."# 'KK"'#5 '5 ' .-5K8U

    5- 6 -8$ 68I'#. $#@,%1 ?8# -65 8I$ 5'e"0 !8$."#B 6)"$B -5 K#8K"#13

    K)-18U58K)-('10 :$" (8F1. ","$ 'KK"'1 68 6)-5 -$6"#K#"6'6-8$ -$ 5'3U-$J 6)'6 I8$."# -5 '1#"'.3B 23 -65"1?B ?8F$. I-6)-$ 6)" "1"T"$6 8?

    $#@,%1 8#B -$ ' K'#'11"1 T'$$"#B 6)'6 $#@,%1 )81.5 I-6)-$ -65"1? 6)"

    T8 T" $6 8? I8$ ."#0 ] _$ 6)" 5'T" K'55'J"B 9#- 568 61" ."(1'#"5 6)'6

    6)" @,%

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    95/118

    -Na S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+

    6) " %& &%,%

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    96/118

    _cE S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ LcL

    6)" F$"` K"(6" . '##-, '10 9 $ . 6)" 6-T " 8? 6)" F$" `K"(6 ". '##-, '1 -5

    k"TK63 k 6-T"0 4) " ,8-. 8? 6-T"B 8# 2"66"# 56-11 B 6)" ,8-. '5 6-T" B 6)"

    , 8 - . -$ 6) " T 8. " 8? 6- T" B -5 k$ "J '6 -, -6 3 ?8 # -6 5" 1? k ]6 )" K) #' 5" 23

    I ) -( ) &" J "1 ." ?-$ "5 6- T" -$ 6) " .&-6-

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    97/118

    LcD S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ Lcd

    K#"5"$6B '$. 6)-5 1"'K -5 6)" (8T-$JB 8# 6)" K#"U5"$(" 8#@"1*2$*&$

    -65"1? I-6 )8F 6 ' K#"5"$60

    ! ) " $ k6 )" -$ ?' $6 -5 28 # $ B k '5 &" J" 1 5'35 -$ 6)" ?' T8 F5 K'55 'J"

    ?#8T 6)" ;,*C*

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    98/118

    Lcb S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+ Lcf

    "eU5-56"$6 6"$5-8$g -65 -$6"$5-63B 6)" -$6"$5-63 8# 5F#K#-5-$J 68$" 8?

    "`-56"$("0

    9 ( ( 8 # . - $ J 68 6) "5" (8 $. -6 -8 $5 B -? ' 5( )" T' 6- 5T 8? 6) " 5F #K #- 5"

    I" #" $" (" 55 '# 3\ '$ . -6 -5 $"( "55 '#3 [ -6 -5 I) '6 (8 $( "# $5 F5 )" #"[ -6

    -5 $"("55'#3 68 J-," 6)" ' K#-8#- ( 8$.- 6-8$ 5 8? J#'5K- $J 6)" 5F#K#-5"

    '5 5F()B 6)" (8$.-6-8$5 8? ' 5F#K#-5" 5"-jF#" 8? 5F# K#- 5"\ -6 (8F 1.

    2" 5' -. 6) '6 6)" 5F #K #- 5" -5 6) " 5( )" T' 6- 5T -65 "1? 0 R8 # -? 6 )" 5( )" T' U6-5T -5 6)" K#8. F(6 -8$ 8? ' kKF#" ,-5 -8$ Bk '$6"#-8# 68 ","#3 ?-JF#"B

    '$. -? kKF#" ,-5-8$k -5 -65"1? 6)" "`UK85-6-8$ 8? 6-T" '5 kKF#" 'F68U

    '??" (6-8 $Bkk -6 -5 -$ KF#" 'F68U'??"(6-8$ 6)'6 ,-5-8 $ 5""5 -65"1? 5""-$J

    '$.B %& +,%$ F16G 5""5\]6)"^ $86)-$J0 _$ J"$"#'1B 6)" 5()"T'6-5T

    -5 K#-$(-K'1 13 6)" ,-5-2-1 -63 8? $86)-$J '5 ' (8$.-6-8$ ?8# 6)" K855-U

    2 -1 -6 3 8? '$ 3 ,- 5- 2- 1- 63 8? 58 T" 6) -$ J0 _$ ", "# 3 ,- 5- 8$ 8? 58 T" 6) -$ J B

    6)" ,-5-8$ ?-#56 8? '11 5""5 -65"1? '5 KF#" ,-5-8$B 5""-$J $86)-$JB 5""-$J

    $86)-$J 6)"#"\'$. 3"6B - 6 -5 '1#"'.3 k,-5-8$Bk '$. '5 5F() -5 ')"'.

    8? -65"1? 8# 8F65-." -65"1?B $86 ' ?-JF#" ' $. 6)" ?-JF #" 8? 6)" $86 )U

    -$J\6)-5 5F#K#-5-$J ?-JF#" I-6)8F6 ?-JF#" 6)'6 6)" ","$6 8?

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    99/118

    %] m S,* 74"@"%$* #8 +,* .:*&+

    K#"5"$6 I-6) k6)" )8#5"5 I)-() ('##3 T"Bk I)"#" $86)-$J -$.-('6"5

    ' 568KK-$J K8-$6 -$ '$3 ?8#T'1 I'30 _$ ?'(6B 6)" 5K"'e"#;5 ()'#-86

    "$6"#5 6)" .8T '- $ 8? 6)" J8.."55B 2F 6 6)-5 .8T' -$ -5 8$1 3 K#"U

    5"$6". '5 6)" #8'. 8K"$". I-." 23 6)" J'K-$J 8K"$-$J 6)'6 +-e"

    'J#"". 68 8K"$0 &"B 6)" k38F$J T'$Bk 6)" 8$" I)8 ke$8I5k 8#

    k5""5k )-5 #8'. kK'55 6)#8FJ) '11 6)" (-6-"5Bk .8"5 $86 (8T" .8I$

    ?#8T )-5 ()'#-860 &" -5 -$56#F(6". 23 6)" J8.."55 '18$J 6)" I'3B

    I- 6 ) 8F 6 56 8K K- $J B -$ 56 #F (6 ". $8 6 '2 8F 6 ","$ T-1 1 -8$ 5-` )F$.#". 6)8F5'$. K8F$.5 56"#1 -$J ?8#

    ='$8 , '5 S,* f"1-*$ -5 ' (8TT"#(-'1 6#F6) 6)'6 -5 $"-6)"# T"'5F#".

    $8# "`("55-,"0 4"$ 2-11-8$ K"8K1" 8$ /'#6) -5 ' K#85K"(6-," ."T8U

    J#'K)-( 6#F6)B I)-() -5 $"-6)"# T"'5F#". $8# "`("55-," '5 5F()0

    _$ 6F#$B 6)"5" ?-JF#"5 6)"T5"1,"5 T"'5F#" 58T"6)-$Jg 6)" "$J'J"U

    T"$6 I-6) ("#6'-$ ",'1F'6-8$5 I-6)-$ ' T'#e"6B 6)" "$J'J"T"$6

    I - 6 ) ' (" #6 '- $ $F T2 " # 8? # -5e 5 '$ . 6'5e 5 -$ ' I 8# 1 . ]- $ ' I 8# 1 . 6) '6

    _]]

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    100/118

    Lca z4C1& .U-*$$ z4C1& .U-*$$ LcM

    2" (8 T" 5 I 8# 1 . 1 3 23 6) -5 ," #3 "$ J' J" T" $6 ^0 _$ 86 )" # I8 #. 5B "' ()

    6-T" 6)"5" ?-JF#"5 T"'5F#" ' #"5K8$5-2-1-630

    4'e -$J '((8F$6 8? 6)" k" ("55k 8? 1'#J" $FT2" #5 58T"6- T"5

    (8T"5 .8I$ 68 5-TK13 "56'21-5)-$J ' K#8K#-"63 6)'6 )'5 $8 5"$5"

    8? k"`("55k I-6) #"1'6-8$ 68 -65"1? ]'5 -5 6)" ('5" I-6) (F#-85-6-"5

    ?#8T '1T'$'(5B #"(8#. 288e5B 8# 6)" KF#"13 5K"(6'(F1'# "`)-2-6-8$

    8? 6)" F$-,"#5";5 .-T "$5 -8$ 5\ '1 1 8? -6 5(-"$(" '$. 6#F6) ?8# ?8815^0

    -` T - 1 1 - 8 $ k -5 -$.-558U

    (-'21" ?#8T 6)" >)8')0 k>-` T-11-8$k ]'5 I"11 '5 ?-JF#"5 ?8# 86)"# "`U

    6"#T-$'6-8$5 '$. T'55'(#"5^B '5 -6 -5 F5".B .8"5 $86 T"'$ 6)" 5'T"

    '5 2"-$ J k,"#3 2- Jk 8# k688 )-J )B k "`("55-," 8# 8F6 8? K#8 K8# 6-8 $0

    ! 8 F 1 . -6 2" kI -6 ) - $ T" '5 F# "k 68 e - 1 1 6" $ H "I 5B 8# ' ) F$ . #" . 9 # T " U

    $-'$5B 8# 6I"$63U?-," 4F65-5l _5 -6 kI-6)-$ T"'5F#"k 68 1"6 6I8 K"8U

    K1" .-" 8? )F$J "# #'6)"# 6)'$ ' T-11- 8$l 4)"5" ?-JF #"5 .8 $86 ."5U

    -J$'6" ' 5F#K'55-$J 8# J8-$J 2"38$. A/M@1$$*C*&+D ]8? I)'6 $8#T l

    8? I)'6 ',"#'J"l^0 4) "3 -$. -('6" '$ 8#."#B ' #"J-56"# 'KK#8K#-'6" 68

    "$J'J"T"$6 '$. #" 5K8$5-2-1-63B 8? I) -() 6)"3 '#" 6)"T5"1,"5 ' K'#60

    ] :? (8F#5"B 8$" TF56 6#'(" 2'(e 68 S' #` 6)" #81" 1'#J" $FT2"#5

    K1'3 -$ I)'6 T-J)6 2" ('1 1". T8#'1 "`K85-6-8$0 _$ 8#."# ?8# 6)"

    ?F$ (6-8 $ 6)"5" $FT2" #5 5"#," 68 nFTK 8 F6 -$ ?#8$6 8? 8F# "3"5 -6 -5

    "$8FJ) 6 8 J1'$(" 6)#8FJ) '$3 $FT2 "# 8? ()'K6"#5 ?#8T !1@%+1

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    101/118

    _>: z4C1& .U-*$$

    T-$ '6- 8$ ]6)" $'T" 8? I) -() -$. -('6"5 '11 688 I"11 I)'6 -6 -5 5'3U

    -$J g 68 J8 68 6"#TB "`)'F56 6)" '((8F$6 AM@4%$*"

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    102/118

    LaD z4C1& .U-*$$ z4C1& .U-*$$ Lad

    P 8 . -5 6)" "`("55-," T"'5F#" AN/MRC*$4"*D '((8#.-$J 68 I)-()

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    103/118

    =85T85

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    104/118

    -aN !#$C#$ ?1$*

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    105/118

    -aN !#$C#$ ?1$*

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    106/118

    -aa !#$C#$ ?1$*

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    107/118

    u*8*"*&-* e1++*"

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    108/118

    W86"5

    A.@%'"1@,D

    /A_P79A&>:@7=/gR#-".#-()W-"6j5()"BS,4$7@1O*~1"1+,4$+"1G6#'$50

    70 H0 &811-$J.'1" ]W"I p8#eg A"$JF-$

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    109/118

    LMb 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$DU f 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ bW_> LMf

    6-(F1'# 13 F$(8T?8#6'21" I)"$ 6)" 'F6)8# F5"5 (8TK8F$. "`K#"55 -8$5

    5F() '5L+"*21:*-8 #L+"*2*&$*CE6'$?8#.B ='1-? 0 g >6'$?8#.@ $ - U," #5 -6 3 A#" 55 B LMM d^B dM NB $ LD 0\ 4# '$ 50

    b0 k

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    110/118

    LMN 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ __2_b 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ _mW=b LMc

    Lb0 G"6 T" 2" VF-6 " (1"'# 6)'6 6)" '11 F5-8 $ 68 G'('$ -5 ."1-2"#'6 "0

    Lf0 _ T T ' $ F " 1 m ' $ 6 B!"%+%V4* #8 ;4"*u*1$#&G 6# '$5 0 W 8 # T ' $ m " T K>T-6) ]W"I p8#eg >60 S'#6-$5 A#"55B LMNf^B fEb0 9158 K#"5FKK85". )"#" -5

    S ' # 6 - $&"-."JJ"# ;51&+$ S,*$* 9E*" /1$ 7*%&] R # ' $ e ? F # 6 ' T S ' - $ go - 6 U68#-8 m1856"#T'$$B LMNd^ 0

    LN0 4) " (8TK1"` 'T2- JF-6 3 W'$( 3 "TK)'5-j"5 )"#" -5 $86 "'5 -13 ('KU

    6F#". -$ /$J1-5)0 _6 8K"#'6"5 '18$J 6I8 '`"5B 8$" )',-$J 68 .8 I-6) 6)"

    "`K#"55-8$KF. U

    ."$13B -$ T3 $-J)6B -$ T3 581-6F."B '$`-"63 J-,"5 I'3 68 (8$,-(6-8$g -6 -5

    5 13B $8 18$J"# ","$ .-56F #2-$ J ]23 .-$6 8? -65 2"-$J .-56F #2- $JB -6 $8

    18$J"# .-56F#25^ B$4//*&"(6-8 $ DB I" 6#'$51 '6". +#4-,*"K '5 k68 68F()k 5-$(" 6)" (8$U

    6"`6 5K"(-?-". 5F#?'("5 6)'6 68F() 8$" '$86)"#0 &"#"B 6)" K#-T'#3 5"$5" -5

    8? #"'( )-$J 8# '6 6'- $-$J '$ "$ .B 2F 6 -6 -5 '158 -TK 8#6 '$6 6 8 2"'# -$ T - $ .

    6)" 6'(6- 1" 5"$5"B '5 I"1 1 '5 6)" T 8#" ( 8T T 8$ 5"$5" 8? k2" -$J - $ 68 F()

    I - 6 ) 0 k \ 4 # ' $ 5 0

    LM0 ! ) " $ 6)" 'F6 )8# K#"5"$6". 6)-5 5"(6 -8$ ]' 18$J I-6 ) >"(6-8$5 f ' $.

    N^ '5 K'#6 8? k:K" $-$J 5g 4)" >K'(" 8? 4) -$ e- $J Bk ' (8$?"#"$(" '6 o' $U

    ."#2-16 @$-,"#5 -63 -$ H'$F'#3 LMMNB )" '..". 6)" ?81 18I-$J VF86'6-8$

    ?#8 T m' $6 '5 '$ "K- J#'K) g k 0 0 0 -? I" I"#" "$6- 61". 6 8 #"J'#. T'6"#- '1 2"U

    -$J5 '5 6)-$J5 -$ 6)"T5"1,"5 0 0 0 6)" F$-63 6)'6 -5 6)" 2'5-5 8$ I)-() $'6U

    F#' 1 ?8#T '6-8$ 5 '#" K855-21" I8 F1 . 2" 8$13 6)" F$-6 3 8? 5K'("B '$. 3"6

    5K'(" -5 $86 ' 2'5-5 X#"5K8$5-21"Y ?8# #"'1- 63 8? K#8 .F(6 5 2F6 -5 8$1 3 6)"-#

    ?8#T'1 (8$.-6-8$[ 5K'(" T"#"13 #"5"T21"5 6)" 2'5-5 I" '#" 5""e-$J -$'5U

    TF() '5 $8 K'#6 -$ 5K'(" ('$ 2" ."6"#T-$". "`("K6 -$ #"1'6-8$ 68 6)"

    I) 81 " ]58 6) '6 X- $ -65 ('5" 68 8Y 6) " K8 55 -2 -1 -6 3 8? 6) " K' #6 5 -5 2' 5" . 8$ 6) "

    K#"5"$6'6-8$ 8? 6)" I)81"^k ] _TT '$F"1 m'$ 6B!"%+%V4* #804/'C*&+G6#'$50! " # $ " # >0 A 1 F )' # X_ $. -' $' K8 1- 5B _ $ . 0 g &' ( e " 6 6 AF 2 1 - 5 ) - $ J = 8 T K ' $ 3 B

    LMacYB DMd^0

    DE0 >"" H"' $UG F( W'$(3 ;531/*-#&$+"4-+%#&/4 -,"%$+%1&%$C*G ? 8 # 6 ) U( 8 T - $ J 0

    DL0 4) " #"("$6 288e 23>"#J"S ' # ( " 1 B3*+#CE*14/4/%*41"+%$1&]A'#-5g

    G"5 O.-6-8$5 ." S - $ F - 6 B LMMf^ -5 '$ 'T'j -$ J #"#"'.-$ J 8? 6)" S%C1*4$G

    I ) - ( ) T ' 3 8? ?"# 5 8T "6 )- $J VF -6 " (1 85 " 68 6) " $ 8 6 - 8 $ 8? 6) " A1 ' 6 8$ - (

    ."T -F# J" 8? k(#"'6- 8$k _ 'T 6#3- $J 68 2#- $J 8F6 )"#"0

    DD0 .-6#'528F#JB LMMN^[ )" .-5U

    (F55"5 -6 -$ #"1'6-8$ 68 ' .-5(8F#5" '28F6 J"$"#'1-j". k'#()-6"(6F#"k '$.

    -65 2"(8T-$J k"` -56"$6-' 1 0k

    Db0 >"" qdNB qdcB '$ . qNa( 8? &"-."JJ"#;5?*%&'1&/S%C*J_$ 18I"#-$J6)" 56'6F5 8? (F#-85 -63 23 T"'5F# -$J -6 'J' -$56 6) - $e- $JB I )-( ) -5 ' ?' -# 136#'.-6-8$'1 J"56F#" B &"-."JJ"# (8TK1"6" 13 T-5F$."#56'$.5 '$. ()"'K"$5

    '$ "1"T"$6 8? 6)" T8. "#$ I8# 1. g 5(-"$(" '$. 6"()$818J3 0 _$ 6)-5 I'3B )"

    ()'11"$J"5 I)'6 )" 86)"#I-5" K#"6"$.5 68 ' ? ? -#T '5 2"18$J-$J 68 6)"

    k5"$.-$Jk 8?

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    111/118

    LMa 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ =b2Y_ 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ Y]W[q LMM

    Da0 _ 'J#""B 6)"$B I -6 ) H'(VF"5 +"##-.' ; 5 (# -6-VF " 8? ? #'6"#$-63 -$ ) -5

    ;#"" A'#6LBqd 8 ?_ T T ' $ F " 1 m ' $ 6 ; 5^*"*%&`%'C#' 6 8 8 6 ) 8 8? B ' $ .+F J' 1. S F# .8 () X=' T2#-. J"g ='T 2#- .J" @$-,"#5 -63 A#"55 B LMabY B Daf^0

    dc0 _$ ' 5"$5"B G", -$' 5 6"56-?-"5 68 6)-5 K#821 "T' 6- ( -$ '$ "`"T K1' #3

    T'$$"#0 ""S ' # (9FJQ ;5) 7*&$*8#" +,*y+,*"PS,*S%C*

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    112/118

    DEE 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ >Wm_ 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ m_2ms DEL

    I 8 # . 0 48 F$ . "# 56 ' $. 6) " K' 55' J"B )8 I" ," #B 6) " #" '. "# TF 56 #" T" T2 "#

    6)'6 /"#%+('## -"5 T'$ 3 (8$$86'6-8$5 6)'6B -$ / $J1- 5) B ' 66'() 68 6)" I8# .k 1 ' I 0k \ 4 # ' $ 5 0

    bM0 _ 'T nF56 J8-$ J 68 (8$5-. "# -6 ' 53TK 68 T -$ -65"1?B I)-( ) -5 ' 56-11

    T8#" #"T'#e'21" 53TK68T J-,"$ 6)" F$"`K"(6". #"6F#$ 68 ?',8# -6 )'5

    )'. 5 -$(" 6)" . "'6) 8? P F 3 + "2 8# . - $ LMMf0 : $ " I8 F1 . )'," 68 (- 6" 6)"

    '#6-(1"5 6)'6 'KK"'#". '6 6)" 6-T" 68 5)8I )8I 6)" #"?"#"$(" 68 +"28#.

    (8F1. 'KK"'# 68 2" $"("55'#3 '$. -TK8#6'$6B (8F1. 'KK"'# '5 6)" 1'56 (#-6U

    -(' 1 #"58F#(" 8? ' I8#1. I- 6)8F 6 (# -6-V F"0 : $ 6)" VF"56-8 $ 8? ?"6-5)-5T

    '$. (#-6-VF"B 5"" H'(VF"5+ " # # - . ' B7@*-+*"$#8 e1"UPS,* 7+1+*#8^*E+G +,*Z#"O#8e#4"&%&'G1&/+,* 5*Fp&+*"&1+%#&16#'528F#JB

    LMMfY^U

    ff0 :$ " 5)8F1. e""K - $ T - $ . 6)'6 k(8'KK"'#k 6#'$51'6"5 -#C2@1"4+%#&G6)" "`'(6 /$J1-5 ) "VF-,' 1"$6 8? I)- () -5 k (8TK"' #-$J0 k 4)-5 -65" 1? -5 ' 1"U

    J'1 6"#T 6)'6 -5 F5". 68 ."5-J$'6" 'KK"'#-$J 2"?8#" ' nF.J" 68J"6)"# I-6)

    '$86)"# K"#58$0\4#'$50

    fN0 >"" 6)" ?8#6) (8T-$ J ,81F T" 3BM+,%V4*#"%'%&1%"* ]I)-() 56'#65 I-6)&"-."JJ"#^ 0

    fc0 R8# -$56' $("B 5"" 6)" 6-6 1" 8? A'F 1 7-(8"F# ;5 y&*$*

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    113/118

    D E D 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ ]>2]s 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ q>2qq DEd

    8? 6)" k5K"(6'(1"k '5 5F() 0 S8 #" 8?6"$ 6)' $ $86B 6)" J"$"#'1 (#-6-V F" 8?

    6 ) " k 5 K " ( 6 ' ( F 1 ' # k \ 8 ? T " . - ' 6 - j ' 6 - 8 $ B 6 " 1 " , - 5- 8 $ B ' $ . 5 8 8 $ \ K # 8 , - . " 5 ' $

    '1-2 - '$. 56'J" ?8# ' ,"#3 K88# -."818J30 !)"6)"# -6 -5 2" 1 1 -J"#"$6B I)-$U

    -$JB 8# .-5.'-$?F1 B - 6 -5 T856 -$6"#"56". -$ K#8K'J'6-$J 6)" $86-8$ 6)'6 -6

    K855"55"5 6)" e"3 68 I)'6 -5 '$ -11F5-8$ '$. I)'6 -5 $860 R8# "`'TK1"B -6

    K#"6"$.5 68 e$ 8I 6)'6 kK"8K1"k '#" k?8815k 2"('F5" 8? k6"1", -5-8$B k I)-( )

    -5 68 5'3B 2"('F5" 8? k6"1"U(#'(30k < F6 6)-5 -." 818 J3 e$8I5 $8 6) -$ J '28F 6

    6)" J"$F -$" F5" kK "8K1 "k T 'e" 8? 4 o \ ' F5" 6)'6 -5B K "#)'K 5B T F( )

    T8#" .-56 '$(" . 6) '$ 6)" (#-6-( 5 I8 F1 . 1- e" 6 8 ' . T - 6 \ 8 # '$ 36) -$J ' 28F6

    6)" #"'1 56'6"B 58T" 6-T "5 J"$F-$ "13 k?881 -5) Bk 8? 6)" K8K F1' # (F16F #"5 8?

    "'#1-"# 6-T"50 4) " (#-6-VF " 8? 6)" 5K"(6'(F1'# )'5 2""$ K"#?8 #T- $J -65 #8FU

    6-$" ?8# 58T" 6 - T " \ 2 F 6 $ 8I - 6 - 5 2" J-$ $-$ J 68 J"6 81 .0

    NL0 _? @,6$%$i I)'6 K#"5"$65 -65"1? '$ . I)'6 '((8TK1 -5)"5 -6 5"1? 23 -6U

    5"1?B 6)"$ 6)" kI- 6)k -5 8? ' .-??"#"$6 8#."#0 /," $ k- $ $'6F #"Bk 5K"(-"5 K#8U

    1-?"#'6" '$. 1-," '18$J5-." 8$" '$86)"#0 S*-,&L I 8 F 1 . ' 1 I ' 3 5 )'," 68 .8

    I- 6 ) I) '6 $" -6 )" # K# 8( "" .5 ?# 8 T $8 # 68 -65 "1? B I - 6 ) .- 5K '# -6 3B (8 $6 -J F- 63 B

    '$. B 6)F5B I-6 ) '$ F$'()-", ". '$. F$'()-",' 21" "55"$(" 8? 6)" kI-6 ) 0k

    ND0 9 1 1 6) -5 #"?"#5 B 82,-8F513B 68 6)" I8# e 8? +"# #-. ' '$. G'(8F "U

    G'2'#6)" 8$ C%C*$%$G ' $. 68 6)" I8#e 8? /6-" $$"

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    114/118

    DEb 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ {#W_>= 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ _>=W%{ DEf

    5-63 A#"55B LMMf 0 "" ) -5 k=8 TT F$ -(' 6- 8$

    '$. 6)" !8#eBk S,*7@1-*#83%+*"1+4"*G6#'$50 9 $ $ >T8 (e ] G - $ ( 8 1 $ g@ $ - U," #5 -6 3 8? W" 2# ' 5e ' A# "55 B LMa D^0

    cM0 &"-."JJ"#B?*%&' 1&/S%C*GdEa0aE0 _6 I8F1. 2" "'53B 2F6 6".-8F5B 68 ?F#$-5) 6)" 8,"#'2F$.'$6 ",-U

    ."$(" ?8# 6)-50

    aL0 _ )'," -$ T - $ . B )"#"B 6)" -$.-('6-8$5 ?#8T &"-."JJ"#;5 ?*%+"/'* `4"

    ;,%8B '16)8FJ) I" )'," (8$U

    5 -56"$613 6#'$51'6".8,"#"-J$63 \4"()$hB ku*+,%&O%&'S*-,2""- $J '5 6)" I)8 1" 8?

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    115/118

    DEN 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ _bsW_mq 5#+*$ +# ;1'*$ _mq2_qq DEc

    D0 P 0 !0 R0 & " J " 1 B z*'*F) #e' TK o"#1'J B LMNMY B DNE^ 0\4# '$5 0

    d0 _ $ 6)" R#" $() ".- 6-8 $B kG 8J- VF " .F (8$("K6 k -5 6)" 6-61" 8? 6)" 5"(U

    8$. ,81FT" 8? &"J"1 ;5 7-%*&-* #83#'%-G I)-() -5 6#'$51'6". 23 k>F2n"(U6-," G8J-( [ 8# 6)" +8( 6# -$" 8? 6)" W8 6- 8$ k -$ 6)" '28," /$J1- 5) ".-U

    6 - 8 $ 0 \ 4 # ' $ 5 0

    b0 _2-.0B fML0

    f0 4) " T 856 ( 8 T T 8 $ 6 #'$ 51' 6-8 $ 8 ? 6)" I8 #. "#J-8 S8# ',- ' B0#4"&1

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    116/118

    - " + # . # * $

    !"#$$%&' )*$+,*+%-$

    H " ' $ U G F (W ' $ ( 3 B?*%&'7%&'4

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    117/118

    G 8 F - 5 S ' # - $ B74E"#J" G"(1'-#"B ) !,%

  • 7/22/2019 Jean Luc Nancy Singular Plural Copy

    118/118

    4) -5 288eB 2 3 8$" 8? 6)" T856 -$$8,'6-, " '$. ()'11"$ J-$J (8$6" TK8 #'

    6)- $e"# 5B (8$5-565 8? '$ "`6"$5-," "55'3 ?# 8T I) -( ) 6)" 288e 6'e"5 -65 6-61"

    '$. ?-," 5)8#6"# "55'35 6)'6 '#" -$6"#$'113 #"1'6". 68 k-$JF1' # A1F #' 1k -$ 68 58K)-56-('6". .-5(F55-8$5 8? $'6- 8$'1 58,"#"-J$63B

    I' # '$. 6" () $8 18 J3 B -. "$ 6- 63 K8 1- 6- (5 B 6)" P F 1 ? !' #B ' $. 6)" 6#'J-( K 1-J)6 8?

    >'#'n",80 4)" "55'3 k/F18J3 ?8# 6)" Sh1Q"Bk -$ K'#6-(F1'#B -5 ' 2#-11-'$6.-5(F55-8$ 8? -."$6-63 '$. )32 #-. -5T 6)'6 #"58$'6"5 I-6 ) T '$3 (8$6"TK8 #'#3

    58(-'1 (8$("#$50

    95 W ' $ ( 3 T8 ," 5 6)#8FJ) 6)" "` K8 5- 6- 8$ 8? )- 5 (" $6 #' 1 (8$( "#$B 2"-$JUI-6) B