is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu...

29
n this cover and their final version of the extended essay to is are not is

Transcript of is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu...

Page 1: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

n

this cover and their final version of the extended essay to

is are not

is

Page 2: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

a

Page 3: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

use

Examiner 1 Examiner 2 Examiner 3

A research 2 2

B introduction 2 2

c 4 4

D 4 4

E reasoned 4 4

F and evaluation 4 4

G use of 4 4

H conclusion 2 2

formal 4 4

J abstract 2 D 2

K holistic 4 4

Page 4: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

t n d s a Subject: Language A. Literature (Russian)

TeMa: fl pe,n;nOCbiJIKH C03,ZJ;aHH51 H CBOeo6pa3Me JKaHpa

«aHmU.MOJIUmBbl» B JIHpMKe

MuxauJia IOpbeBulJ.a Jlep.MoHmoea

ApxaHreJILCKa.R EJieHa 01/11/2012

Candidate number: Word Count: 3999

Page 5: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

A6cTpaKT

YBJieKa5fC.b BOITpocaMH ITCHXOJIOrHH, MeqTa5f B 6y.rzyru;eM CB5f3aT.b CBOIO )KI13H.b C 3TOH HayKOH, 5f He

MOrJia ITpOHTH paBHO,II:YITIHO MHMO TBopqecTBa IT03Ta-pOMaHTHKa M. JiepMOHTOBa. B ero CTHXax

HHTepeCHO Bee: 6yHTapCKHH xapaKTep JIHpnqecKoro repo5l, 3KCITpeCCHBH.biH CTHJI.b, IOHOIIIeCKa5f

CHJia qyBCTB H HeO)KH~aHHM M5f ero B03pacTa my6HHa M.biCJIH. Ero TBOptieCTBO ITpOTHBOpetiHBO,

ITOpOH OHO )KHBeT ITO 3aKOHJ «MMTHHKa»; IT.biTMC.b HaRTH H,I.(eaJII:.I, rapMOHHIO, aBTOp MetieTC5f

Me)K.Lzy 3eMJieH H He6oM, ,ll;eMOHOM H AHreJIOM ... rny6nHa ero J.(yiiieBH.biX Tpe6oBaHHH HaCTOJI.bKO

BeJIHKa, ~o OH He 6onTc5f pa3roBapnBaTI> Ha paBHI>IX c EoroM. CTP05f CBOH ~Manor c BceBI>IIIIHHM,

OH o6paru;aeTC5f K )KaHpy MOJIHTB.bl, HO 3TOT )KaHp Y30K M5l Hero, OH He BMeru;aeT my6HHY ero

~yiiieBH.biX ITepe)KMBaHHH, BOJIHeHHH, HCITOBe,I.(aJI.bHOH HCKpeHHOCTH. 11. JiepMOHTOB, IT.biTMC.b HaihH

YHHBepcaJII:.HhiH CITOC06 BI:.Ipa)KeHH5f 3THX tiYBCTB, C03~aeT HOB.biH )KaHp, OTJIHtiaiOIIJ;HHC5f OT

KaHOHOB MOJIMTB.bi. TI03TOMY M5f HCCJie,I.(OBaHM5f JI BI:.I6pana TeMy: npe~IIOChiJIKH C03,I.(aHHSI H

cBoeo6pa3He ~aupa aHTHMOJIIITBhl B TBopqecTBe M. JiepMOHTOBa.

,ll;JIJI TOrO tiT06hl HCCJie,I.(OBaT.b ,I.(aHeyiO TeMY, MHOIO 6I>IJIO ITpOtiHTaHO 60JI.biiiOe KOJinqecTBO

ciTeU:HaJII:.Holi JIHTepazypi>I. 5I ITOCeTnna HeCKOJII>KO TipaBocnaBHI>IX Co6opoB B pa3HI>IX CTPaHax,

pa3roBapnBana co CB5rru;eHHOCJIY)KHTeJI5fMH, ( B qacTHOCTH, c EaTIOIIIKOH KnpnnJioM B Co6ope TiaBna

n TieTpa r. AnMaTI:.I, Ka3axcTaH).

B pa6oTe HCITOJI.b30BaH.bi pa3JinqHI:.Ie BH~.bl aHaJIH3a: aHaJIH3 CTHXOTBOpeHHH C TOtiKH 3peHH5f )KaHpa,

aHaJIH3 o6pa3oB ,ll;eMoHa H AHrena, cTaTHCTHtieCKMH u cpaBHMTeJII:.HI:.IH aHaJIH3.bi. Bee 3TO

IT03BOJIHJIO C,I.(eJiaTI> B.biBO~, tiTO JiepMOHTOB ~eHCTBMTeJI.bHO C03~aeT HOB.blll )KaHp, KOTOp.biH

YCJJOBHO MO)KeT 6I>IT.b Ha3BaH )KaHpOM «aHTMMOJIHTB.bi». Ho 3TOT )KaHp, KaK H BCe TBOptieCTBO

JiepMOHTOBa, ITpOTMBOpetiMB H HeO~H03HatieH. llpnqllH.bl C03~aHHJI HOBOrO )KaHpa MO)KHO HaRTH

KaK B 6uorpa<PMH aBTOpa, TaK ll B ero 6yHTapCKOM MHpOB033peHHll, H IT05fBJieHMe 3TOrO )l(aHpa

CKOpee CBJI3aHO C yMeHMeM JiepMOHTOBa I.J;eJIOCTHO BOCITpHHMMaT.b 3TOT MHp.

TipoBe~eHHOe HCCJie~OBaHHe HaTOJIKHJJIO Ha M.biCJI.b 0 TOM, ~0 o6pa3 tieJIOBeKa B TBOptieCTBe

JiepMOHTOBa OtieH.b BeJIHK, r~e-TO ITO CHJie qyBCTB H M.biCJieH OH paBeH bory HJIH ,lJ;eMOHJ («C TaKOH

J.(yiiiOH TI>I Eor HJIM 3J1o~eli» ), qTo ~aeT B03MO)KHOCTI> B 6y,I.(yru;eM paccMOTPeTI:. TeMy: napanJieJih

lieJIOBeK - Jior B TBOpqeCTBe JiepMOHTOBa.

Konuqecmco CJlOB: 300

2

Page 6: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

EJiaro)lapHOCTh

B.oipruKaro orpoMeyro 6naro,n:apHOCT.o pyKoBo,n:IITeJIIO rrpoeKTa «Extended Essay», He3aMeHIIMOMY

y"LIHTeJiro PyccKoli JIMTeparyp.oi, HerroBTOpiiMOMY B,n:oxHOBHTeJIIO II caMoMy noHIIMarom;eMy

l:!eJIOBeKy, 6naro,n:ap5I KOTOpOMY BCe caM.Die XaOTM"LIH.bie M.biCJIII o6peraroT CM.biCJI - Bna,n:HMIIpOBOH

EneHe reopmeBHe. OrpoMHoe cnacu6o CB»m;eHHocJiy)l(MTeJiro IiaTIOIIIKe KHpMJIJiy H3

ITpaBocnaBHoro Co6opa ITerpa II ITaBJia, 3a He3a6.omaeM.oiii ,n:uanor, KOTop.oiii rroMor MHe rroH»T.o

3Ha"LieHHe MOJIIITB.bl, a TaiOKe OTKp.biBIIIIIH ,n:JI5I MeH5I MHp peJIHriiH C COBepiiieHHO HeO)l(M,ZJ:aHHOH

CTOpOH.bi. Iinaro,n:apro Koop,n:HHaTopa IB rrporpaMM.bi rypaJI.bHIIKa l1rop5I PoMaHOBII"Lia, 3a

OKa3aHHYfO rro,n:,n:ep)J(ey, a TaiOKe 3a 6ecu:eHH.Die MOTHBMpyrom;IIe cnoBa. Crracu6o 6M6JIIIOTeKapiO

Ypa30BOH ryn.oHap lllarraraTOBHe 3a cy)J(eHIIe pa,n:Myca IIOilCKa Heo6xo,n:HMOH JIHTeparyp.oi B

06IIIHpHOH 6M6JIHOTeKe HaiiieH IIIKOJI.bl ,n:o MilHIIMJMa, a TaiOKe cpMJiococpy AMpe6aeBOH )I{yJI,n:.bi3

ToKyHoBHe 3a ee 6ecu:eHH.Die coBeTI>I H Bepy B MeHJI. Oco6yiO 6naro,n:apHocr.o, xorenoc.o 6.o1

BI>Ipa3HT.b MOIIM po,n:HTeJI5IM ApxaHren.ocKoMy AneKceiO H ApxaHren.ocKoii TaTI>JIHe 3a

6e3rpaHH"LIHyro IIOMOID;.b, rro,n:,n:ep)I(I(y, TepneHIIe Il TIOHIIMaHile.

3

Page 7: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

Co,!lepmauu:e

I. IIpon:mopeLIHBOCTb H CJIO)KHOCTb TBOpLieCTBa nepMOHTOBa. 060CHOBaHHe

Bhi6opa TeMhi ......................................................................... 5-6

II. IIoHCKH aBTopoM co6cTBeHHoti MoJIHTBI>I.

• CTpyKTypa nocTpoeHIUI H cyTh KaHOHIILiecKoti xpiiCTIIaHcKoti

M OJIIITBbi ••...•.•.•...•........•............••••.....••.....••.•..••.•••...•... 6-9

e& ilpiiLIIIHhi o6parn:eHIDI K 3anpe,n:eJibHOMy, 60)KeCTBeHHOMY

MIIpy ••••.....••....••....•..............•...•..•...•...•.••.....•.•....•.•...•.. 9

• niiHapHasi onno3IIIJ,II.H ,[(eMoH-AHren .................................. 1 0-13

e «MOJIIITBhi» flepMOHTOBa ............................................... 13-21

III. CBoeo6pa3IIe )KaHpa «aHTIIMOJIHTBhi» B JIIIpiiKe nepMOHTOBa; IIOHCK

rapMOHIIII ......................................................................... 21-22

1. EII6JIHorpa<l:>II.H ....................................................................... 23-24

11. IIpiiJIO)KeHII.H ......................................................................... 25-26

4

Page 8: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

<<0H 6CeeJZacmHblU o6JZaoameJZb ZfOpcm6a flBJZeHuu :JICU3HU, OH 60cnpoU36ooum ux KaK ucmuHHbllA

XYOO:JICHUK," OH no3m pyCCKUU 6 iJyzue- 6 HeJ.1 ;JJCU6em npozueiJzuee U 1-lOCmOflUfee pyccKOzl :JICU3HU," 01-l

2JZy6oKO 3HOKOM C Bl-lympel-11-tUM MUpOM iJyzuU>>.

- BHccapHOH rpHropbCBIJII lieJHIHCKHH

«Cnacmu JlepMoHmo6a om 6ettHou nozu6eJZu Hellb3fl; HO, ttmo6bz «xomb CKOllbKO-Hu6yob

yMeHbZUUmb y;JJCOC, HO KOmOpblU 01-l o6pettel-t U KOmOpbl'U HeU3MepUMO YJICOCHee «nllflZUYU/UX

KpOCHblX ttepmeu», Mbl OOJl:JICHbl «06Jluttamb JlO;J/Cb eocnemozo UM OeMOHU3MO», m.e. JlO:JICb eceu

JZepMOHm06CKOU no33UU, ttbfl CYUfHOCmb, no MHeHUJO Bll. CoJZ06be6a u ecmb He ttmo uHoe, KaK

oeMOHU3M, npe6pamHoe C6epxttell06ettecmeo». 1

qeM rrpHBneKaeT IT033HH BenHKOrO ITpH3HaHHOrO KnaCCHKa 11HXaHna RJpbeBHqa HepMOHTOBa?

HeB03MmKHo o,n:Hocno)l(Ho OTBCTHTb Ha 3TOT sorrpoc. Mo)KeT 6biTb, TeM, qTo oHa oqeHb

nHqHOCTHaJI, qTO B COMHeHHHX, )KenaHHHX nHpHqecKOrO repo5I qyBCTByeTC5I HeyroMOHHa5I 5IpKa5I

HaTypa CaMoro aBTOpa. HeCMOTPH Ha Ka)l(Jll.I,HHC5I rreCCHMH3M, ero TBopqecTBO Henb35I Ha3BaTb

YHbinbiM. CaM nepMOHTOB - qenoBeK KOHTPaCTOB, OH .n:ep3KHH ll 3KCrrpeccHBHbiH, rropo:H HC)KHbiH ll

qyTKHH, rropo:H rpyCTHbiH ll CTpa,n:aiOll.I,HH, ni065Ill.I,HH ll HeHaBH.Il:Hll.I,HH. Ho rrapa,n:OKC B TOM, "liTO

HeHaBH.D:HT OH, ITOTOMY "liTO ni06HT; rpycTHT ll TOCKyeT, ITOTOMY "liTO Hll.I,CT u,n:ean:t.I; 6yHTyeT,

rroToMy q'fO ero He)KHaH H qyTKaH .n:yrna He MO)KeT cornacHTbCH c TeMH ycnoBHHMH )KH3HH, B

KOTop:t.IX oH BbiHy)fQJ:eH )KHTb, B KOTOpbie rrocTaBrrnu ero BpeMH, CeMbH, Cy,n:b6a. OH 6y,n:TO

Haxo,n:HTCH Me)K.D:J .n:syMH MHpaMH. OH rrpoTHBopequs HacTonbKO, qTo ,n:a)Ke xy,n:o)KHHKH, prrcyrom.ue

ero ITOpTpeT, y6e)K,n:MHCb B TOM, q'f0 Hll O.D:HH ITOpTPeT He ITOXO)K Ha ,n:pyro:H, ll Hll O.D:HH H3 HHX He

CMOr pacKpblTb HCTHHHOro HepMOHTOBa. 0H ll3MCH"l!HB, ll IT03TOMY ll3MCH"l!HBO, rrpOTHBopeqHBO ll

cno)KHO ero TBopqecTBO. He,n:apoM caMbiM HpKHM rrprreMoM ero TBopqecTBa rrpH3HaH rrprreM

aHTHTe3:t.I. B HeM Haxo,n:HT OTPa)KCHHH CTPaCTHI.Ie qyBcTBa caMoro asTopa; OHM MoryT 6biTb KaK

1 CTaT:t.H «fi03T CsepxqenoBeqecTBa». Crrop Mepe)KKOBCKoro c MHCHHeM B. ConosbeBa

< http://www.litmir.net/br/?b=l 02906&p=l>

5

Page 9: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

co3M,JJ;aTeJihHhiMM, TaK M pa3pyiiiHTeJihHbiMM, KaK rpexoBHhiMM TaK M 6e3rpeiiiHI>IMM. H rrpM 3TOM ero

II033M5I rJiy6oKa M CHJII>Ha, B 3TOM cKa3hiBaeTc5I ero Paccy~oK: «CJZoeo cJZyzuaemcJZ ezo, KaK 3Me5t

3aKJZUJ-tameJZJZ: om nol/mu nJZOUfaoHozi 3nuzpaMMbZ oo MOJZumebz, a ezo cmpoKu He u~vteJOm ce6e

paeHbZX HU e ooHoii no33UU Mztpa, co eceMu ux ozuu6KaMu u HemolJT-tocmR.lWW>? Ha yM rrprrxo,n;MT

KaHToBCKM TeopiDI o B3aMMOCB.SI3M l..JyscTB, Paccy~Ka M Pa3yMa, r,n;e pa3yM - 3TO CMHTe3

MDIIIIJieHIDI M cep,n;u:a, B KoTopoM )J(MBYT u:eHHOCTM - ,l1;o6po, KpacoTa, Enaro, lior.3

Ha rrepBI>IH

B3rJI5I,n;, B II033MM aBTopa 6om,me 6yHTapcKoro M pa3pymrrTeJII>Horo, He)J(eJIM rapMOHMqHoro M

C03M,n;aTeJII>Horo. Ho TaK JIM 3TO Ha caMoM ,n;eJie? EcTI> JIM B ero TBopqecTBO MecTo ,il;o6py n liory?

HacKOJII>KO ,n;yma ero HanoJIHeHa 6JiarocTI>IO necHonemi5I MOJIMTBI>I? KaKoB ero .n;rranor c EoroM?

11MeHHO 3TH BOITpOCI>I BOJIHOBaJIM MeH5I, KOr,n;a 5I nepeqMTI>IBaJia npOM3Be,JJ;eHIDI JII06MMOTO aBTOpa.

CJimKHOCTI> )J(M3HeHHDIX 3anpocoB JiepMOHToBa, ero OTHomeHrre K Eory, OTpa)J(eHHDie B

IIpOTMBOpeqMBhiX MOJIMTBaX, npOTMBOITOCTaBJieHhl npOCTOTe M JierKOCTM rreCHOIIeHIDI XpMCTMaHCKMX

MOJIMTB. OH CJIOBHO co3,n;aeT co6cTBeHHI>IH )J(aHp- )J(aHp <<aHmuMoJZumebz». Tio3TOMY Borrpoc Moeil

MCCJie,ZJ;OBaTeJIJ>CKOH pa60TJ>I: KaKOBbi rrpeJ!IIOCbiJIKH C03)!aHHH H B qeM CBOeo6pa3He jKaHpa

«aHTHMOJIHTBhl» B JIHpHKe JiepMOHTOBa?

,lJ;JUI TOTO qTo6hl OTBeTMTh Ha MCCJie,ZJ;OBaTeJII>CKHH BOIIpOC HaM60Jiee ITOJIHO, He06XOJJ;MMO npOHTM

HeCKOJII>KO 3TaiTOB aHaJIM3a:

• IIOH5ITI> cTpyKTYPY M CYTh rrocTpoeHIDI KaHOHMqecKoi1: xprrcnt:aHCKOH MOJIMTBDI;

II paCCMOTPeTJ> IIpMqMHI>I o6paiiJ:eHIDI aBTOpa K 3arrpe,n;eJIJ>HOMy, 6mKeCTBeHHOMJ MMpy;

11 rrpoaHaJIM3MpoBaTI> 6MHapH)'IO orrrro3MU:MIO ,ll;eMoH - AHreJI;

fl MCCJie,ZJ;OBaTI> CBOeo6pa3Me MOJlUme JiepMOHTOBa.

2 AHHa AxMaTOBa. Kpyr qTeHM5I: IIIKOJihHM rrporpaMMa. M.IO. JiepMOHTOB. «,ll;JI5I MMpa M He6ec

qy)J(OH». MocKBa IIIKOJia-rrpecc 1999. CTP. 7 3

)f(M3HI> M ¢HJioco¢M5I HMMaHyHJia KaHTa. 7 5IHBap5I 2011.

<http:/ /www.kantiana.ru/about/kant/page07 .php>

6

Page 10: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

qT06I:.I ITOH5IT.b, lJTO H3 ce65I npe.n:cTaBJI5leT MOJIHTBa flepMOHTOBa, .n:asafiTe paCCMOTPHM

o6rn;enpHH5ITOe, YHHBepCaJI.bHOe 3HalJeHHe MOJIHTB.bi. 06parn;a5IC.b K TOJIKOBOMJ CJIOBapiO C. Jii.

Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea- ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu

o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM»4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I B npasocnaBHH, B qeM ee oco6eHHOcTH?

CsJirn;eHHOCJIY)KHTeJI.b EaTIOIIIKa Knprrnn B Co6ope ilerpa H ilasna (ropo.n: AnMaT.bi, Ka3axcTaH),

.n:aeT oqeH.b npocToe H .n:ocTynHoe onpe.n:eneHrre MOJIHTBI:.I: «OUClJl02 c EozoM». B 6rr6nnH rosopHTC5I

o TOM, lJTO .n:yiiia - 3TO qacT.b Eora, H3 3Toro cne,n:yeT, lJTO MOJIHTBa- 3TO soccoe.n:nHeHHe q:enoseKa

c EoroM B o.n:HoM nopi>IBe o6rn;eHH5I H rrcnose.n:aHH5I. 06parn;a5ICI> K ilpocrpaHHOMY XpncTHaHcKoMy

KaTHXH3Hcy ilpasocnaBHOH Ka<J:>onrrqecKoiii BocTOlJHOH I(epKBH, MI>I Haxo.n:nM onpe.n:eneHIIe

MOJIHTBI>I: «Ecmb ceuoemeJZbCmeo CJZ06a Eo:JICUfl 0 moM, ttmo MOllUmea 5leJZ5lemcfl cpeocmBOM Oll5l

npuo6pemenun cnacumenbHOii naoeJICObl.>/.

B JII060H MOJIHTBe, He3aBHCHMO OT ee co.n:ep)KaHH5I .lJ:OJI)KHbi C06JIIO.n:aTI>C5I .ll:Ba OCHOBHbiX YCJIOBH5I.

ilepsoe - 3TO oTpeqeHne OT ceMH CMepTHI>IX rpexos: zopoocmb, cpe6po!llo6ue, 6JZyo, 3aeucmb,

ttpeeoyzooue, zHee u YHbZHUe. ,Z:Wyroe - 3TO npoB03rnaiiieHne ceMH .n:o6po.n:eTeneiii: Jllo6oeb,

Hecm5l:JICaHue, ZfeJZoMyopue, cMupeHue, eo3oepJtcaHue, Kpomocmb, mpe3eeHue. TeM caMI:.IM,

no.n:Tsep)K.lJ:aeTc5I onpe.n:eneHIIe MOJIHTBI:.I Q)Kerosa, HO HeJI.b35I He yrolJHHTI>, lJTO MoJIHTBa B

XpHCTHaHCTBe BOCITpiiHHMaeTC5I IIIHpe, qeM npOCTO «06parn;eHHe K Eory», .ll:Jl5I JII06oro BepJIOrn;ero

XpHCTHaHHHa- 3TO TallHCTBO, co.n:ep)Karn;ee B ce6e rny60KHH CM.biCJI.

KaKOBbi )Ke 3TaiT.bi ITOCTpOeHH5I MOJIHTBI:.I? ,lJ,asaHTe paCCMOTPHM YHHBepCaJII>HI>IH ITOp5I.lJ:OK

nocrpoeHH5l MOJIHTBI>I Ha npMMepe «T'ocno.n:HH MoJIHTBbi» EsaHreJIH5I OT MaT<J:>e5I:

4 C.H. Q)Keros H H.IO. lllse.n:osa. TonKoBI>IH Cnosap.b PyccKoro 5l3I>IKa. B.H. Mono.n:I>IH, CTHJiesoe

o<J:>opMneHne, 1997

s ilpocTpaHHbiH ilpasocnaBHI>IH KaTHXH3HC ilpasocnaBHOH KaQ?onnqecKOH BocTolJHOH UepKBH

Cs5ITHTeJI.b <l>HJiapeT, MnrpononnT MocKOBCKHH H KonoMeHCKHH. 0 MoJIHTBe 386. < http://www .pravoslavieto .com/books/ catechism_ sv _ filaret/hope l.htm>

7

Page 11: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

o6paUfeHue, 0TLie Ham, fuce ecM Ha He6ecax!

npU3emme

eocxecmemte, I. ,ll,a CB5ITMTC5I MM5I Tsoe, 2. .n;a rrpmmeT ~~

npouteHUfl UapcTBMe Tsoe; 3. .n;a 6y,n:eT BOJUI Tso5I,5IKo

Ha He6ecM M Ha 3eMJIM.

npocb6a MOflb6a 0 4. Xne6 Hacyi.I.J:HbiH na?Kll.b Ha nHeci>;

eae CeML

MOJlb6a 0 npOUfeHUU 5. I1 OCTaBM HaM ,UOJlfM Harna, 5IKO)Ke I1 M.bi )""'8> npomeHHH

OCTaBJI5IeM ,IJ;OJI)KHMKOM HalliMM

MOJlb6a 0 6. I1 He BBe,UM HaC BO MCK)'IlleHMe,

npeaocmepe:JICeHuu, 7. HO M36aBM HaC OT nyKaBOfO

tfeJZoMyapuu

cJZaea, eo3eblUteuue 5IKo Tsoe eCT.b I(apcTBO, M cMJia, M cnasa so

6oza, cJZaeocJZoeue BeKM. AMHHh 6•

Ta6nMu:a .n;eMOHCTpMpyeT :narri>I rrocrpoeHI15I MOJIMTB.bi: o6pai.I.J:eHMe, conposo)K,IJ;aeMoe

socxsaneHMeM BceBhliiiHero: «0mlfe Haut, Jf:J!Ce ecu Ha He6ecax». 3aTeM - socxsaneHMe, KaK OJl:HO

M3 ceMH rrporneHMH, TO ecTI> npoiiieHMe o coxpaHeHMM BeLIHoro BeJIMLII15I Tsopu:a. ,ll,anee MllYT

nporneHM5I o e.n;e, npoi.I.J:eHMM M u:enOMYllPMM. 3aseprnaeTC5I MOJIMTBa cnasocnosMeM Bora M cnosoM

«AMMHI>», 3TO HeKoe PMTYaJII>HOe no.n;Tsep)K)J;eHMe MCTMHI>I. TaKMM o6pa30M, npasocnaseyro

MOJIMTBY MO)KHO pa3,n;eJIMT.b Ha TpM OCHOBH.biX 3Tana ee IIOCTpOeHI15I: IJpu3eaHUe, CeMb npouteHUU,

CJZaeocJZoeue. qTo )Ke Mhi BMllMM y JiepMoHTosa? qT06I>I nponoJI)KMT.b MccnenosaHMe co6cTBeHHO

nepMOHTOBCKOH «MOJIMTB.bi», He06XOllMMO IIOH5IT.b, B "CJ:eM )Ke MCTOKM ero o6pai.I.J:eHI15I K Eory?

6AMHHh- c .n;peBHerpe-qecKoro AMeH- «MCIIOJIHMTeJib».

8

Page 12: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

0eyHa5Icb B rro:nnqecKIIM Mnp MnxallJia IOpbeBFPia JiepMOHTOBa, 6I>IBaeT cnmKHO rrpoBeCTH rpaHb

Me)l(.zzy o6pa30M JIHpnqeCKOrO rep05I ll CaMHM aBTOpOM. JlHpHKa JlepMOHTOBa oqeHb JillqHOCTHM,

oHa oTpa)l(aeT ero co6cTBeHHbie rrepe)KHBaHH5I CJIO)l(HbiX )l(lf3HeHHbiX MOMeHToB. Cy,n:r,6a

JiepMOHTOBa qacTO 6I>IJia K HeMY He6JiarOCKJIOHHa. Bc5I ero )l(ll3Hb - 3TO HeB03MO)l(HOCTh

IIpHMHpeHIUI C 60JibiO IIOTepn 6JIH3KHX JIIO,n:eii, 3TO IIpOTeCT IIpOHIB 3aKOHOB CaMo,n:ep)l(aBIDI,

He)KeJiaHne cTaTI> «JIHIIIHHM» repoeM «cBoero BpeMeHn». HecrrpaBe,n:nnBOCTH cy,n:r,6r,I pa3BHBaiOT B

JiepMOHTOBe )l(eJiaHIDI 6yuTapH-poMaunnca. PoMaHTlflleCKHH HacrpoeHHhiH aBTop rronoH aM6HIJ.HH

n cTpeMJieHHii K ,n:eiicTBlliO. Ho ero )l(eJiaHIDI He coBrra,n:aiDT c 3aKoHaMH BpeMeHH. HeB03MO)l(HOCTb

HaHTH rapMOHlliO, CB06o.zzy, cqaCTbe Ha 3eMJie 3aCTaBJI5IeT aBTOpa o6paii(aTbC5I K 6o)l(eCTBeHHOMY

Mnpy n co6cTBeHHO K Eory, K rrorri>ITKe HaiiTn H,n:eanr,I. Ho qTo n,n:eanr,Ho? H,n:eaneH JIH Mnp BHe

3eMJIH? 3Tn BOIIpOCbi BOJIHYJOT aBTOpa, KOr,n:a OH IIhiTaeTC5I IIOCrpOHTb ,n:nanor C IioroM, ,n:nanor Ha

paBHbiX, ,L(llaJIOr, IIOJIHbiM IIpOTllBOpeqnBhlX MbiCJieH, COMHeHHH. lJT06bi ITOH5ITb ero cyrr,, ,n:aBaifTe

pa36epeMC5I C OCHOBHbiMH o6pa3aMH 6o)l(eCTBeHHOfO MMpa- o6pa3aMM ,lJ;eMOHa M AHreJia.

06pa3 ,lJ;eMOHa B JIMpMKe JiepMOHTOBa oqeHb 3KCIIpeCCMBeH If rrpOTllBOpeqMB. ,lJ;eMOH - 3TO HeKHH

a6crpaKTHblll o6pa3, KOTOpbiH 5IpOCTHO IIpOTMBOIIOCTaBJieH 6M6JieHCKIIM M,n:eanaM. ABTOp C03,n:aeT

ero IICMXOJiomqecKMH IIOpTpeT B CTMXOTBOpeHMM «MOM ,lJ;eMOH» (1829). 3,n:ecb Ha6JIIO,n:aiOTC5I

cne,n:yiOII(Me KaqecTBa rrepcoHa)l(a: rrpe3peHMe, paBHo,n:yiiine, rHeB, YHI>IHne, rop,n:ocTb, a6coJIIOTHYID

BOJIIO. Ka3anocr, 6I>I, 6naro,n:ap5I 5IpKoMy ncrroJib30BaHHIO ou.eHoqHoii, 3MOU.MOHaJibHOH JieKCHKM,

aBTop co3,n:aeT o6pa3 MpaqHoro, BhiCOKOMepHoro, orranKHBaiOII(ero repo5I:

CM,n:HT YHI>IJI n MpaqeH OH,

OH He,n:oBepqHBOCTb BCeAAeT,

OH rrpe3pen qncTYJO JII060Bb ...

Ho oH o,n:HHOK, M nMeHHO 3TO po)l(,L(aeT qyBcTBO coqyBcTBIDI K HeMy. KpoMe 3Toro, OH ,n:eiicTBeHeH

(«HOC5ICb Me)!( ,L(biMHbiX 06JiaKOB»), OH BCe-TaKH yMeeT JII06MTh:

9

Page 13: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

OH mo6IIT 6ypu poKOBI>Ie,

H rreey peK, H IIIYM .rzy6pos •••

B ero .rzyiiie 3BY"t!HT ronoc CHJII>He:H:IIIHX qyscTB - cTpacTeH. H 3TH xapaKTepHCTHKH y)Ke

IIpHBJieKaiOT "tJ:HTaTemi K 3TOMY rrepcoHa)I(J, a He OTTaJIKHBaiOT OT Hero. ,II;eMOH He IIpOCTO

IIpHBJieKaeT aBTOpa, II03T "tJ:YBCTByeT B HeM CXOJJ:CTBO CO CBOeH HaTypo:H: (He,n:apoM HCIIOJin3yeTC5I

IIpHT5I)KaTeJibHOe MeCTOHMeHHe «MOM» B Ha3BaHHH CTHXOTBOpeHI15I). ,II;eMOH- 3TO OTpa)KeHHe JJ:YIIIH

IOHOrO II5ITHa.JJ:IIaTHJieTHero II03Ta. H IIO"t!TH CTOIIpOI1eHTHOe COBna,n:eHHe Me)K.Izy o6pa30M ,n:eMOHa I1

o6pa30M JIHpH"tJ:eCKOrO rep05I nepMOHTOBa (IIO"t!TH aBT06HorpacpH"tJ:eCKHM) Mbl HaXOJJ:HM B

CTHXOTBOpeHHH « 1831-ro HIOIDI 11 JJ:IDI»:

TocKa 6ny)KJJ:aeT Ha MoeM qene.

H xono,n:eH H rop.n:; H ,n:a)Ke 3JihiM

Tonne Ka)KycJI ...

TaK)Ke, KaK H ,II;eMOH, rOHHMbiH H3 pa5I I13-3a CBOeH rOp.JJ:biHH, nepMOHTOB He HaXOJJ:HT B CBOeM

OKpy)KeHHH pOJJ:CTBeHHOH JJ:YIIIH, OH TaKOH )Ke «T'OHHMhiH», crpa,n:aiOliiHM OT JIIOJJ:CKOM

HecrrpaBe.JJ:JIHBOCTH, OJJ:HHO"tJ:eCTBa.

Ba)KHO aKIIeHTHpOBaTb BHHMaHHe Ha TOM, "t!TO o6pa3 «Moero» ,II;eMOHa pa3BHBaeTC5I. liepe3 ,n:sa

ro,n:a, nepMOHTOB IIHIIIeT H3MeHeHHYIO BepCHIO rrepBOrO CTHXOTBOpeHI15I. lieM :>Ke OTJIH"tJ:aeTC5I

«HOBbiH» ,n:eMOH OT CBOero rrpe,n:IIIeCTBeHHHKa? C OJJ:HOH CTOpOHbi, ,n:yiiia ,II;eMOHa pacKpbiBaeTC5I

6onniiie M5I ni06BH: «0H JII06IIT rracMypHI>Ie HO"t!H, TyMaHI>I, 6ne,n:eyiO nyey, Ynni6KH ropnKHe H

O"t!H, oe3BeCTHbie CJie3aM H cey». HoC ,n:pyroif CTOpOHbi, eCJIH rrpe)KJJ:e «OH OTBepran BCe MOJIHTBbi»,

TO Terrepb H BOBCe OH BbiCMeHBaeT Bepy: «H BC5IKI1H Bep5Iliii1H CMeiiiOH». (Bo3MO)KHO, 3JJ:eCh

B03HHKaiOT rrpe,n:IIOCbiJIKH pO)KJJ:CHH5I <<aHmZlMOJlUm6bl»).

06pa3 ,II;eMOHa IIOJiyqaeT OKOH"tJ:aTeJibHYIO cpopMyJIHpOBKy B II03Me «,II;CMOH». HeCMOTp5I Ha BCe

OTpHI.J;aTeJibHbiC qepTbi, OH YJJ:HBHTeJibHO IIpHBJieKaTeJieH (,n:aHb poMaHTI13My), I1 HMeHHO 3JJ:eCb,

oco6eHHO B rrepso:H:: qacTH, ronoc ,II;eMoHa - ecTh no cyllleCTBY ronoc caMoro II03Ta, )KeJiaiOlllero

BepHTb, JII06HTb, MOJIHTbC5I, HO He CIIOC06Horo Ha 3TO:

10

Page 14: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

Xoqy a c He6oM npHMHpHTC5!,

Xoqy mo6nn, xoqy MOJIHTbC5!,

Xoqy a nepoBaTb ,n:o6py ...

AHac.popa Ha OCHOBe CJIOBa «xoqy» YCHJIHBaeT T_POeKpaTHO 3TO )KeJiaHHe, ,n:eJia5! ero He06biKHOBeHHO

CHJibHbiM. Ho HecMOT_P5! Ha TibiJIKHH Hpan, ):(eMoH my6oKo HecqacTeH. «/(eMOH - dyx He cmoJZbKO

3JZ06HblU, CKORbKO cmpada!OUfUU U CKOp6HblU, npu 6CeM 3mOM dyx 6RacmHblU, 6eJZUI.[G6blit». 7

IIapa,n:OKCaJibHO TO, ~0 CHJia ,n:eMoHnqecKHX qyBCTB noqTH pasHa 6o)KeCTBeHHbiM. rpaHb,

pa3,n:emnoiiJ;a5! CTOJib KOHT_PaCTHbie IIOH5ITI15I, KaK ,n:o6po 11 3JIO, aHreJibCKOe H ,n:eMOHHqecKOe,

CJIHIIIKOM rrp03paqHa. «CoeepUteHHOe Hed060JlbCm60 co601o, MUpOM, JZIOdbMU, Hed060JZbCmeo

muxoe, YHbZJZoe... u ommozo cmpeMJZeHue 3a npedeJZbl ktupa... MOJZumea cepdlfa Jll06RUfe2o,

ymoMJZeHHOZO 6opb6o10, HO He Kpoeaeozo, He pacmep3aHHOzo; cmpeMJZeHue K zpycmu o

npoUtedUteM ... >> 8 3TH CT_POKH HnKoJiaa IIoJieBoro HenepoaTHO ToqHo xapaKTepH3YIOT cyiiJ;HOCTb KaK

CaMOfO JiepMOHTOBa, TaK H ero }.:(eMOHa. KopeHb IIpOTHBOpeq.HBOCTif - B OTCYTCTBHH rapMOHHH

BHYTPH caMoro aBTopa. Ho OH oco3HaeT ueJIOCTHOCTb MHpa: ecJIH ecTb 3Jio, 3HaqaT eCTb n ):(o6po,

ecJIH ecTb 3eMJI5I, 3HaqaT ,n:oiDKHo 6biTb n He6o, ecJIH eCTb ):(eMOH, 3HaqnT cymecTByer n AHreJI,

ecJIH ecTb MecTo MoJIHTBe, 3HaqHT HMeeT rrpano Ha cymecTBoBaHne 11 npoTecT - «He-MOJIHTBa»

( aHTHMOJIHTBa ).

11 KaK ,n:yiiia }.:(eMOHa, TaK H ,n:yrna JiepMOHTOBa HaXO,ll;HTC5! B BeqHOM TIOHCKe H,IJ;eaJia. ilo:::>TOMY

JiepMOHTOB o6pamaeTC5! H K ,n:pyroMy 6o)KeCTBeHHOMY o6pa3y - AHreJiy, KOTOpbiH He MeHee

7 MnxaHJI AneKcaH,n:poanq Bpy6eJib, ):(eMoH ( CHMIIJ;Hii). ):(eTCKHe o6pa3bi B )KHBOIIHCH

<http:/ /webstarco.narod.ru/painting/vrubell.html>

8 HnKoJiaii IIoJienoii. 3HUHKJiorre,n:na .D:JI5! ,n:eTeii. ToM 9. PyccKaa JIHTepaTypa. q, 1. Or 6r,mnH n

JieTorrnceii ,n:o KJiaccHKH XIX neKa. IIo,n: pe,n:aKuneii M. AKceHonoli:. MocKBa: AnaHTa+, 1999, cT_P.

349

11

Page 15: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

MHTepeceH LJ:JUI Hero. I1 ecnM ,l(eMOH - o6pa3 HeO,n:H03HaqHJ)IH, OH He TOnbKO OTTaJIKJ:IBaeT, HO M

rrpnBneKaeT, TO KaKoB )Ke AHren?

Mbi 3aMeqaeM MCTOKM )KenaHMH I1pM6nM3MTbCH K CBHTbiHe, MCTMHe Ha rrpMMepe CTMXOTBOpeHJ:IH

«AHren». rrpoM3Be,n:eHJ:Ie «AHren» 3aBopa)KJ:IBaeT trn:TaTenH CBOeH Heo6bP:IaHHOH MY3biKaJibHOCTbiO.

0Ho caMo 3ByqJ:IT KaK cBeTnaH, 6na)KeHHM rrecHH. l13o6IIniie anniiTepau,nn Ha MHrKyiO cornaceyiD

«n» c03,n:aeT BrreqaTneHHe He)KHOCTM, nerKOCTM M B03LJ:YIIIHOCTM. TaK Mbi 3HaKOMMMCH c caMMM

o6pa30M nepMOHTOBCKOrO «AHrena» II C ero «TMXOH, CBHTOH» rrecHeH, oqeHb CXO)KeH C

XpiiCTJ:IaHCKOH MOnMTBOH. «fipeKpaCHOe CTIIXOTBOpenne «AHren»: B3LJ:OX TOCKYIOIIJ,eH LJ:YIIIM,

ITOMHHIIJ,eH IIeCHb aHrena, HeCyiiJ,ero ee B MMp, CBII,n:eTenbCTByeT, qTO CeMHa,n:n;aTMneTHHH aBTOp 6biJI

HaCbiiiieHO pa3H006pa3HeM KpaCMBeHIIIIIX 3l1MTeTOB: «6e3rpeiiiHbie ,n:ynm», «paHCKJ:Ie ca,n:bi», «,n:yrna

Mna,n:aH», «)KJ:IBOH 3BYK», <(liYLJ:HOe )l<enaHJ:Ie». AHren pacCKa3biBaeT HaM 0 HeCoKpyiiiiiMbiX H,n:eanax

OH rren o 6na)KeHCTBe 6e3rpeiiiHbiX ,n:yxoB .•.

0 Bore BeniiKOM oH rren, II xBana

Ero HerrpMTBopHa 6I>ma.

"£ITO )Ke TaK I1piiBneKaeT aBTOpa B 3TOM o6pa3e? B rrepBYfO oqepe,n:b- ero MCKpeHHee, HerrpMTBOpHoe

)KenaHJ:Ie rreTb 0 «BenMKOM» Bore. 3,n:ecb HeT HJ:IKaKoro COMHeHJ:IH B TOM, qTo Bor BeniiK M LJ:OCTOIIH

XBaJibi. liHbiMM CnOBaMM, 3TH CT})OKM LJ:OKa3biBaiOT y6e)K,n:eHHOCTb aBTOpa B B03MO)KHOCTH

cyiiJ,eCTBOBaHJ:IH MCKpeHHeH MOnMTBhl - rreCHM 0 Bore. 3,n:ecb 3ByqJ:IT MOTMB TOCKM aBTOpa ITO

9 AHaMHe3MC - TepMMH qmnoco<Pnn IInaTOHa, 03HaqaiOIIJ,MH rraMHTb qenoBeKa o TOM, qTo .n:o

po)KLJ:eHMH, qenoBeqecKM .n:yrna rrpe6I>mana B 6o)KeCTBeHHOM MIIpe. 10

BHqecnaB HBaHOB. CTaTbH «JiepMOHTOB». BceMMpHaH 6n6nnoTeKa rro33MM. MIIXaMJI JiepMOHTOB

CTliXOTBOpeHJ:IH. 000 «l13,IJ.aTenbCTBO «3KCMO», 2007, CTp. 27

12

Page 16: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

H,n:ea.rry, COBepmeHCTBy. Ho :na rreCH5I- MOJIHTBa C03,n:aHa Ha He6e, a He Ha 3eMJie B «MHpe rreqaJIH

H CJie3».

06pa3 AHreJia, KaK H o6pa3 .D:eMOHa rroJiyqaeT pa3BHTHe B TBopqecTBe JlepMOHTOBa. AHreJia Mni

BCTpeqaeM H B II03Me «.ll:eMOH». Ho B rrepBOH qacTH II03Mni, 3TOT o6pa3 He CTOJin IIpHBJieKaTeJieH,

OH c,n:aeTC5I, OTCTyrraeT, OH MeHee ,n:e5ITeJieH qeM .ll:eMOH. fopa3.ll:O HHTepecHee OH IIp05IBJI5IeTC5I BO

BTopoli qacTH, r.n:e ero HaMepeHHe crracTH ,n:ymy TaMapr,I HerroKoJie6HMO.

TipOTHBOpeqHBOCTn o6pa3a Mni BCTpeqaeM H B CTHXOTBOpeHHH «Hoqr,, I»:

I1 BCTpeTHJIC5I MHe CBeT03apHnlll aHreJI;

H TaK, cBepKHyBmH B3opoM, MHe cKa3a.rr .•.

3,n:ecr, anzell Ha,n:eJieH ne anZeJlbCKUMu qepTaMH: ero B30p cBepKaeT rroqTH rro-,n:eMoHHqecKH. HTaK,

o6pa3 aHreJia, KaK H o6pa3 ,n:eMOHa, TO)Ke IIpOTHBOpeqHB. Ho 6e3 HHX MHp Tep5IeT CBOIO

~eJIOCTHOCTn. fpaHr, Me)K,n:y ,n:o6poM H 3JIOM oqem, TPY.D:HO HaliTH . .ll:Harra3oH rroHCKOB rapMOHHH

JlepMOHTOBa oqeHn illHpOK. B IIOHCKaX H,n:ea.rra OH MeqeTC5I Me)K,n:y .ll:eMOHOM K AHreJIOM, Me)K.ll:y

3eMJieli H He6oM, H, B03MO)KHO, orrrro3H~mr He6o - 3eMJI5I po)K.ll:aeT 6o11ee rny60KYIO orrrro3H~HIO

MoJIHTBa - AHTHMOJIHTBa.

KaKOBa )Ke MOJIHTBa JlepMoHTOBa? Mr,I BCTpeqaeM TPH CTHXOTBopeHH5I, Ha3BaHHnie caMHM aBTopoM

«MOJIHTBaMH»: «He o6BHH5IM MeiDI, BcecHJinHMli •.• » (1829), <Ol, MaTepr, Eo)KH5I ... » (1837) H «B

MHHyTy )KH3HH TPY.D:HyiO» (1839) . .D:aBaliTe paccMOTpHM, MO)KHO JIH OTHeCTH 3TH MOJIHTBM K

pa3p5I.D:Y KJiaccHqecKOM KaHOHHqecKOH rrpaBOCJiaBHOM MOJIHTBM?

PaccMOTPHM CTHXOTBopeHHe <Ol, MaTepr, Eo)KHH ... ».

3TaiiLI Cosna,a:eHHe ll;HTaTa

n pU36Gl-lUe + 5£, MaTepi> 60)KH5I, HniHe C MOJIHTBOIO

llpe,n: TBOHM o6pa30M, 5IpKHM CWIHHeM

13

Page 17: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

CeJHb npouteuuu + 1. 5I BpytiHTb XOliJ ,IJ;eBy HeBHHHy:IO

2. 0Kpy)KH CtiaCTHeM

3. ,lJ;aH eH conyTHHKOB

4. Mono,n:oCTb cBeTJIYIO

5. CTapocTI> rroKOHHYIO

6. Cep.n:rzy He3no6HoMy MHp

yrroBaHH.H

7. TI>I BOCIIpH5ITh IIOIIIJIH K JIO)l(J

IIetiaJihHOMy

Jiyqiiiero aHrena ,n:yiiiy

rrpeKpacHy:IO

CJtaeoc;weue -

HcxoM H3 BbiiiieH3JIO)KeHHoro aHaJIH3a CTHXOTBopeHH5I, MI>I 3aMetiaeM cxo,n:CTBO B IIOCTPOeHnn no

cpaBHeHHIO C KJiaCCHtieCKOH MOJIHTBOH. H3 HHX: 5IpKOe o6pai.IJ;eHne K BCeBbiiiiHeMy, ero

BOCXBaJieHHe: <Ol, MaTepb 60)KH.H, HhlHe C MOJIHTBOIO, ilpe,n: TBOHM o6pa30M, .HpKHM CH.HHHeM».

CTOHT OTMeTHTb, liTO y)Ke rrepBI>Ie ,IJ;Be BCTYIIHTeJibHI>Ie CTPOKH COBMei.IJ;aiOT B ce6e KaK CMeJioe,

.HpKO Bblpa)KeHHOe o6pai.IJ;eHHe K 6o)KeCTBy, KOTOpoe, 6e3yCJIOBHO, HaiiOMHHaeT HaM IIaHernpHK,

COIIpOBO)K,IJ;aeMI>IH B03BbiiiieHHOH MeTa<PopOH «.HpKOe Cll5IHHe», TaK H YIIOMHHaHne C06CTBeHHOH

JIHtiHOCTH, tiTO IIpOTHBOpeqnT 3aKOHaM KaHOHHtieCKOH MOJIHTBI>I. Be,n:I> He 3p5I CaMO CTHXOTBopeHHe

HatiHHaeTC5I C MeCTOHMeHH5I <Ol». 3TO rOBOpHT HaM 0 JIHtiHOCTHOM yqaCTHH B «HCIIOBe,IJ;aHHH», 0

CMeJIOCTH H 0 CHJie JllltiHOCTH, tiTO TaK xapaKTepHO ,IJ;JI5I JIHpHKH JiepMOHTOBa. 3TO CKOpee He

CBOeBOJII>Ha5I ,n:ep30CTI>, a JIHtiHOCTHa.H HCKpeHHOCTh. ,lJ;anee, Mbl BCTPeqaeM CeMI> IIpOIIIeHHH, HO B

14

Page 18: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

HMX He BXOMT eKTeH.o5I11

o e,n:e, o nporu;emm 11 TaK ,n:anee. O,n:HaKo JKeJiaHM5I JIHpnrrecKoro repo5I

3,n:ec.o oqeH.o He3ayp5IJJ:H.OI. Bo-nepB.oix, TI5IT.o ero npomeHMH B.OipaJKeHDI qepe3 oTpm~aHMe, qTo CHOBa

npOTMBOpeqMT MCKOHHDIM npaBOCJiaBHDIM KaHOHaM: «He 0 cnaceHMH, He nepe,n: 6MTBOIO, He C

6Jiaro,n:apHOCT.OIO, MJI.b noKa5IHMeM, He 3a CBOIO MOJIIO JJ:YlliY nycT.OIHHYIO». B npOTMBOBeC

HacToHru;eii MOJIMTBe 3ByqaT M ,n:ep3KHe 3a5IBJieHM5I JIHpHqecKoro repoH: «He o cnaceHMH, He c

6Jiaro,n:apHOCT.biO ... ». 3,n:ec.o HeT If noKa5IHM5I. B qeM JKe CM.OICJI 3TOH MOJIMTBDI? 0 qeM OH npocMT?

JIHpHqecmii repoii 3a6oTMTC5I He o cBoeM 6JiarononyqHM, a o JIID6MMOH. MoTMB.OI B.OICOKOMepH5I,

TaK qacTO BCrpeqaiOII.J;MeC5I y JiepMOHTOBa, OTXOJJ:5IT Ha BTOpOH nJiaH: BCe TI5IT.b npomeHMH

HanpaBJieH.oi Ha cqacT.oe JII06MMoro qeJioBeKa. He 3TO JIM 3a6om o 6miJKHeM, qTo TaK xapaKTepHo

JJ:JI5I npaBOCJiaBM5I? J1 HeCMOTp5I Ha ,n:ep30CT.b If 60JI.blliOe KOJIMqeCTBO orpuo;aHHH, B 3TOM

CTMXOTBOpeHMM £IYBCTByeTC5I HeBep05ITHOe TeTIJIO M npHB5I3aHHOCT.b, KOTOpDie COnpOBOJK,n:aiOTC5I

p5IJJ:OM KpaCMB.biX 3nMTeTOB KaK no OTHOllieHHIO K 6oJKeCTBy, K KOTOpOMY MJJ:eT o6paru;eHMe: «TBOH

o6pa3, HpKoe Cl15IHMe; TenJia5I 3aczynHMna», TaK M no OTHomeHum K ,n:eBymKe, pa,n:M q.oero

6JiaronoJiyql15I oH npocMT: «,n:eBa HeBMHHaH; ,n:yma ,n:ocTOHHM; cep.n:ne He3JI06Hoe». MoJIMTBa

3aKaHqMBaeTC5I CJIOBaMH:

T.oi BOCnp115IT.b noiiiJIM K JIOJKy neqan.oHOMy,

Jiyqmero aHreJia ,n:ymy npeKpacHyiD.

I1 XOT5I 3,n:ec.o nOJIHOCT.biO OTCYTCTByeT 3aBepmamru;ee CJiaBOCJIOBMe Eora, qnTaTeJI.O ocrpo

£IYBCTByeT CMJIY JKeJiaHM5I JIHpHqecKOfO rep05I noMoq.o ,n:eBymKe.

I1TaK, HeCMOrp5I Ha TO, £ITO CTMXOTBOpeHMe Ha3BaHO «MOJIMTBOH», MDI BMJJ:MM 60JI.blliOe KOJIJiqecTBO

npOTMBOpeqn:ii npH ee IIOCrpOeHMH. cf>opMaTI.bH.biH CTpOH MOJIMTB.OI HapymeH. 3-fanDI nocTpOeHM5I

MOJIMTB.OI He co6JIIO,n:eH.OI, HO cnJia JKeJiaHM5I JIHpurrecKoro repo5I rroMO'Ih, nonpocnT.o o 6JIUJKHeM,

HaCTOJI.OKO BeJIMKa If MCKpeHHa, qTO ITO CO,n:epJKaHifiO 3TO CTMXOTBOpenne MOJKeT 6.0IT.b OTHeCeHO K

JKaHpy MOJIMTB. ilepeqJICJieHH.Oie npOTHBOpeql15I IIpMBOMT K MDICJIM, qTO JKaHp KaHOHJiqecKOH

liE n ~ KTeH.05I - paBOCJiaBHa5I nOCJieJJ:OBaTeJI.OHOCT.b MOJIMTBeHHDIX npomeHMH

15

Page 19: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

MOJIMTB.bl He IIO)JXO.lJ:MT JlepMOHTOBY ,n:mi B.bipa){(eHM5I ero LJYBCTB, 3TO 3aCTaBJI5IeT ero MCKaT.b HOB.bie

){(aHphL

qTO M.bl BM.lJ:MM B ern:e O.D:HOH MOJIMTBe «B MHHYTY ){(I13HM TPY.ll:flYIO .•• »?no CBOeMy cpopMaJI.bHOMy

IIOCTpoeHHIO OHa OII5IT.b OTJIW:IaeTC5I OT KJiaCCM"'!eCKOH MOJIMTB.bl. M.bi BM.ll:MM IIOJIHOe OTCYTCTBMe

TPex ocHOBH.biX ee 3TarroB: ilpM3BaHMe, CeM.b nporneHMH H CnaBocnoBMe. TeM He MeHee, M.bi MO){(eM

pa3,n:eJIMTh 3TY MOJIMTBY Ha TpM MH.biX ycJIOBHbiX 3Tarra: YH.biHMe, OIIpe,n:eJieHMe MOJIHTB.bl H

yTeiiieHHe. He60JibiiiOe CTHXOTBOpeHHe O"'leHb rrapa,n:OKCaJibHO, OHO BKJIIO"l!aeT B ce65I KaK

XpHCTHaHCKHe rpeXH, TaK H ,n:o6po,n:eTeJIH. ,l(yiiieBH.bie rrepe:H<:HBaHH5I JIMpM"'IeCKOrO rep05I

pa3BHBaiOTC5I OT LJYBCTBa M5ITe){(HOCTH, rpyCTM, IIO,n:aBJieHHOCTM, "'ITO C"'IHTaeTC5I CMepTH.biMM

rpexaMM ,n:JI5I npaBOCJiaBH5I, H rrepeXOMT K peJIHrH03HOMY CMMpeHHIO, ,n:yiiieBHOMy IIpOCBeTJieHHIO,

"'ITO MO){(eT 6biT.b OTHeCeHO K ,n:o6po,n:eTeJI5IM. A pOJI.b 3TOrO rrepeXO.lJ:HOrO COCT05IHM5I .lJ:OCTaeTC5I

MMeHHO MonMTBe. CaMa MOJIMTBa xapaKTepH3yeTc5I c rroMOW:hiO BhiCOKoii neKCMKH: «cHJia

6naro,n:aTHaH», «C03BY"l!be cnoB ){(MB.biX», «CB5ITa5I npenecTb .lJ:.biiiiHT B HHX». B 3TOM CTHXOTBopeHMH

JlepMOHTOB IIOKa3biBaeT HaM CBOe TperreTHOe OTHOIIIeHMe K M,n:ee MOJIMTB.bi. I1MeHHO 3.D:eC.b

HaH6onee 3Ha"l!MMO B.bipa){(eHo 3Ha"l!eHHe MOJIMTB.bi B )KH3HH JiepMOHTOBa. Heo6.bi"'lai1Ha5I

MY3.biKaJibHOCT.b CTHXOTBOpeHH5I .D:JI5I aBTOpa - 3TO MOJIMTBeHHaH MeJIO.lJ:H5I Ha,n:e){(.lJ:.bi, IIpOCBeTJieHM5I,

CBeTJI.biX .lJ:YIIIeBH.biX IIOp.biBOB, 3TO OTpa){(eHHe MCTHHHhiX ){(eJiaHHH aBTOpa, IIOMCK ,n:yiiieBHOH

rapMOHMH, MeJIO.ll:HH, coe,n:HH5IIOW:eH ,n:Ba IIpOTHBOIIOJIO){(H.biX MHpa M O.lJ:YIIIeBJieHHOe IIOH5ITMe 0

CM.biCJie ){(M3HM.

Ho y JiepMOHTOBa, KaK Mbl y6e,n:HJIHC.b B.biiiie, He BCe TaK O.lJ:H03Ha"'!HO. J1 HapH,n:y C TaKHMM

CBeTJI.biMH, cyrn:eCTBYIOT COBeprneHHO IIpOTMBOIIOJIO){(H.bie CTPOKH. J1CTOKH TaKoro «Ma5ITHMKa» B

TBOp"'IeCTBe - He TOJI.bKO B ){(eJiaHHH o6o5IT.b BeC.b He06o5ITH.biH MHp, ( OT -qepHoro K 6eJIOMJ, OT

,n:eMOHa K aHreny), HO H B 6HorpacpH"'!eCKHX OTrOJIOCKaX B TBOp"'!eCTBe II03Ta. BCIIOMHMM

CTHXOTBOpeHHe «HHW:MH»:

TaK 5I MOJIMJI TBOeH JII06BH

16

Page 20: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

C CJie3aMM rop.bKHMM, C TOCKOIO;

TaK qyscTBa Jiyqrrme MOM

06MaH)'Thi HaMeK To6mo!

K qeMy rrpuso,rvrr 3Ta Mon.r,6a o mo6su? B OTBeT JIHpuqecKMM repoii rroJiyqaeT o6MaH. H ecJIM Ha

3eMJie TaK MHOfO JI)KM If 06MaHa, TO, B03MO:IKHO, TaK :IKe IIOCTpOeH If He6eCHhiM MHp? 0II.biT )KM3HM

po)K)l,aeT HeBepHe, crpax. BepHeMC.si K CTMXOTBOpeHHIO «Hoq.r,, l». qeM OTBeqaeT JIHpll"t!eCKMM repoif

Ha rpe6osaHMe aHreJia: «MOJIHCh - CTpa~aii ••• H BMCTpa~aii npm.ueube ••• »? JIMpuqecKoro repo.s~

03ap.s~eT cTparrma.s~ MhiCJih:

H MHe 6JiecHyJia MhiCJih (TsopeH.be a~a):

qTO, eCJIM speM.si COBepiiiHT CBOM Kpyr

H rrorpy3MTC.si B seqHoCTh HeBo3spaTHO,

H HMqero MeH.si He ycrroKOMT,

H He rrpiiJJ:yT CIO,rJ;a rrpocMTh MeH.si? ..

K qeMy TOr,rJ;a MOJIMT.bC.si, eCJIM IIOCJie CMepTM Heqero He 6y,rJ;eT?

,[(ep3KMM OTKa3 OT MOJIMTBhi 3ByqMT B CTMXOTBOpeHHM «ilOKMHIIe»:

He xoqy .s~ rrpe,ll; He6ecH.hiM

0 crraceH.r,e cJie3.bi JIIIT.h

HJI.r, CIIOKOMCTBMeM qy,rJ;eCHhiM

,[(yrny rpeiiiH)'IO OMhiTh;

JIIIpH"tJeCKa.si repOMH.si He TOJI.bKO He xoqeT MOJIMTC.si CaMa, HO He xoqeT qTo6.bi MOJIMJIHC.b II 0 ee

,rJ;yiiie:

Ho Ha,ll; MHOIO He MOJIIIC.si

He,rJ;ocToiiHa .si MOJI.h6.bl.

HeT CMHpeHM.si II IIOKa.siHM.si B 3TMX CTpoqKaX. 3To IIOXO:>Ke Ha pOIIOT. I10,rJ;06HhiM )Ke pOIIOT 3ByqMT If

B ,ll;pyroM CTMXOTBOpeHMM «1830. Ma.s~ 16 qiicJia». JIHpll"t!eCKHM repoii pa3M.biiiiJI.sieT 0

IIpe,rJ;Ha3Haqemm )KM3HM II03Ta II He HaXO,li;IIT qeTKOfO OTBeTa Ha 3TOT BOIIpOc:

••• Tsopeii,

Ha To JIM .s~ 3syqaJI crpyHaMM,

Ha TO JIM co3,rJ;aH 6.r,m rreBeii?

17

Page 21: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

Ha TO JIM a,n:oxHoaem:.e, cTpacTH

MeHR K MorHJie npHBeJIH?

3TH crpOIJKH OnRTb ,L(aJieKH OT CMHpeHH5I, 3,L(eCb OTI5l:Tb crpeMJieHHe nOHRTb CMbiCJI CBOeH )KH3HH H

o6paii.'(eHH5I K Eory C )KeJiaHHeM nOJIYIJHTb OT Hero OTBeT, H Eor 3,L(eCb - He OT):(aJieHHOe He6eCHOe,

Heonpe,n:eJieHHOe cyii.'(eCTBO, a peaJibHbiH onnoHeHT JIHpHIJeCKOrO repOR, C KOTOpbiM OH CnOpHT, H K

KOTOpoMy o6paii.'(aeTC5I C KOHKpeTHbiMH BOnpocaMH (rpe6yR (!) KOHKpeTHbiX OTBeTOB Ha HHX):

Ho IJYBCTB)'IO: nOKOH HeT,

H TaM, H TaM ero He 6y,n:eT ...

MbiCJib, KaK H cyrna JIHpHIIecKoro repoR, )KHBeT no 3aKOHy «MMTHHKa». H onRTb-TaKH ,n:nana3oH

HeHMOBepHO IIIHpOK. «CHJibi He06'b&THbie» TaRTCH B rop,n:OH cyme JIHpHIJeCKOrO repOR JiepMOHTOBa:

••. MHoro 3Jia

0Ha CBepmHTb rOTOBa, XOTb MOrJia

CocTaBHTb cqacTbe TbiCRIJH mo,n:eii:

C TaKoii ,n:ymoii Tbi Eor HJIH 3JIO,n:eH:.

rJiy6HHa MbiCJIH H IJYBCTBa JIHpHIJecKoro repo&, no ero MHeHHIO, pasHa 6o)KeCTBeHHbiM. Ho

,n:ep3oCTb, ,n:yx npoTHBopeiJHH HH3BepraeT ero )Ke B 6e3,n:Hy (Hano,n:o6ne ,lJ;eMoHa), H pa3 B cyme ecTb

MeCTO 60)KeCTBeHHOMY H 3JIO,n:efiCKOMy, TO On&Tb )Ke Mbl npHXO):(MM K BbiBOcy, IJTO HapR,n:y C

MOJIHTBOH 6y,n:eT MeCTO H aHTHMOJIHTBe B TBOpiJeCTBe n03Ta.

Hy H, nO)KaJiyH, CaMbiM HpKHM npMMepoM aHTHMOJIHTBbi MO)KeT CIJI-ITaTbCH CTHXOTBOpeHHe «He

o6BHH&li MeHR, BcecHJII>HI>Ili».

3ranM Cosna,n:eHHe ll;HT3Ta

II pzi3eaJme + He o6BHH&H: MeH&, BcecHJII>HI>IH:,

18

Page 22: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

H He Kapaa MeiDl, MOJIIO

Ce.Mb npomeHutt + 1. MpaK 3eMJUI MOrHJibHOH

C ee cTpacT5IMH 5I mo6mo

2. B ,n:ymy pe,n:KO BXO.IJ:HT

)l{HBbiX peqeii: TBOHX crpyH

3. B 3a6Jiy)K.IJ:eHI>e 6po,n:HT

Moil yM .n:aneKo oT Te6H

4. JiaBa B.IJ:OXHOBeHb51

MOKOYieT Ha rpy,n:H MOeii:

5. YITO .IJ:HKHe BOJIHeHb51

MpaYiaT CTeKJio MOHX oqeii:

6. MHp 3eMHOH MHe TeceH,

K Te6e JK rrpoHHKHYTb 5I 6moch

7. qacTO 3BYKOM rpemHbiX rreceH

5I, EoJKe, He Te6e MOJIIOCb

CJZaeoc;zoeue ...

3To CTHXOTBOpeHHe - O.IJ:HO H3 CaMbiX CBOeBOJibHbiX, ,n:ep3KHX H 3KCrrpeCCIIBHbiX ITO cpaBHeHHIO C

,n:pyrHMH CTIIXOTBOpeHH5IMH, CB5I3aHHbiMH C o6pam;eHHeM K Eory, C MOJIHTBOH. CrpaiDHbie Beiii;H, C

TOYIKH 3peHH51 rrpaBOCJiaBH51, 3ByYiaT B TaK Ha3hlBaeMOH «MOJIHTBe»: «MOll YM ,n:aJieKO OT Te651», «51,

EoJKe, He Te6e MOJIIOCb». BcH KOMIT03HIJ;H51 CTIIXOTBopeHH51 rrocrpoeHa Ha aHTHTe3e. Mbi om;ym;aeM

I1pOTHB060pCTBO «.IJ:HKIIX BOJIHeHHH» ,n:ymn: C O.IJ:HOH CTOpOHbi, - om;ym;eHHe TBOpYieCKOrO TaJiaHTa,

«JiaBbi B.D:OXHOBeHb5I», 3KCI1peCCHBHOrO JKeJiaHH51 CaMOBblpaJKeHH51, C ,n:pyroii:, - JKeJiaHHe

OCB060.IJ:HTbC51 OT 3TOH «crpaiDHOH JKaJK,n:bi rreCHOITeHb51». 3TO He MOJIHTBa, - 3TO .D:HaJIOr C EorOM Ha

19

Page 23: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

paBHI:.IX, HO JJ:JHlJIOr ,n:ep3KHM If BOJII:.HOJJ:YMHhlM. 3To HOBbiH ~aHp, C03JJ:aHHI:.Ill aBTOpOM. B LieM )I(e

ero oco6eHHOCTH?

Bo-nepBhiX, MI:.I o6paii(aeM BHHMaHHe Ha LiaCTOe HCIIOJII:.30BaHHe JIIfl.fHI:.IX MeCTOHMeHHll B pa3HI:.IX

QJOpMaX (.s:, MeHH, MOll If T.JJ:.), B HTOre - 11 pa3, B TO BpeMH KaK o6paii(eHHe K Bory - 8 pa3. 3TO

rOBOpHT 06 HHJJ:HBif.lzyaJII:.HOM yLiaCTHH B «pa3rOBOpe», B03BI:.IIIIeHHH JIHLIHOCTH, )I(eJiaHHH

rrpH6JIIf)I(eHHH K BceBI:.IIIIHeMy H caMoyTBep)I(,n:eHHH.

Bo-BTOphlx, o6paTHM BHHMaHH:e Ha o6paii(eHHe K Tsop:u:y, MaHepy o6II(eHHH JIHpHLiecKoro repo.s: c

BoroM . .5IpLialliiiee yrrorpe6neHH:e B03BhliiieHHOM, csoeBOJII:.HOll JieKCHKH 3asopa)I(H:BaeT LIHTaTeJI.s:.

06pa!I(MCI:. K marOJII:.HOMY p.s:.n:y: «He 06BHHHll, He Kapai:f, yraCH, rrpeo6paTH, OCTaHOBH», MI:.I

3aMeLiaeM MHOrOKpaTHOe OTPH:U:aHHe H HeiiOBHHOBeHH:e. ilMrrepaTH:BHI:.Ill rraQJOC CTHXOTBOpeHHH

IIpOTHBOpeLIH:T HCTHHHOMY XpHCTH:aHCKOMY MHpOB033peHHIO.

B-TpeThHX, rrapa,n:OKCaJieH TOT QJaKT, LITO CaMM «HeMOJIHTBeHHaH» MOJIHTBa JlepMOHTOBa BKJIIOLiaeT

B ce6.s: 60JII:.IIIHHCTBO KaHOHOB KJiaCCifl.feCKOll MOJIHTBI:.I. 3,n:eCI:. rrpHCYTCTByeT o6pam:eHHe K

BCeBhHIIHeMy: «He 06BHHHll MeHH, BceCHJII:.HI:.Ill»; «il He Kapall MeHH, MOJIIO», IIIeCTI:.

aHaQJOpHLIHbiX rrpomeHHll, HaLIHHaiOII(HXC.H CO CJIOB: «3a TO, LITO», aKn;eHTHpyiOII(HX BHHMaHHe Ha

LIYBCTBe BHHI:.I aBTOpa.

KaKOBO )I(e co~ep~aHHe ero rrpomeHHll? 3To mo6oBh K rpexoBHOMY («MpaK 3eMJIH MOrHJII:.HOll c

ee CTpaCTHMH .H JII06JIIO»), OTCTpaHeHHe OT OO~eCTBeHHhiX HCTHH («MOll YM ,n:aJieKO OT Te6.s:») If

<<,LI;HKHC BOJIHCHMI» ~ymH 3BTOpa, KOTOpi:.Ie If OTJJ:aJIHIOT rro:na OT CB.HTOll HCTHHI:.I, «MpaLiaT

CTeKJIO MOHX OLiell». ,li;Be 3aKJIIOLIHTeJII:.HI:.Ie CTPOKH rrpomeHHll If paCKMHHH JIHpHLieCKOrO repo.s:

IIpHKOBhlBaiOT BHHMaHHe LIHTaTeJI.s::

M11p 3eMHOll MHe TeceH,

K Te6e )I( rrpoHHKHYTI:. H 6oroci:..

3,n:eCI:. - HeBepOHTHOe npOTHBOOOpCTBO Me~y ~ymoH H TeJIOM, ~eJiaHHeM H HeB03MO~HOCThiD

ero HCIIOJIHeHHB. JlHpHLieCKHM repOll - LieJIOBeK, KOTOpi:.IM CJIHIIIKOM BeJIHK JJ:JIH 3eMHOrO MHpa,

20

Page 24: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

HJiliTO)KHf>IX ITJIOTCKHX HaCJIIDK,ZI:eHHM, HO CJIHIIIKOM MaJI rour MHpa COBepmeHHOro. ,Il;yma IT03Ta

HaxOJJ;HTCH Me)K)ly )lBYMH MHpaMH, OHa HID;eT ITpHIOTa, m::o;eT ITOKOH, HO He HaXO)lHT.

Em,e o.n;u:oii oco6eu:u:ocTMO 3Toro )KaHpa >IBJI5IeTcH 3aKJiroqeHHe - 3,n;ecr, HeT cJiaBOCJIOBHH, HO

,n;o6aBJI5IIOTC5I qeTI>Ipe oqeHI> Ba)KHf>IX IIpOIIIeHH5I:

Ho yracH cell: qy,n;HhlH ITJiaMeHI>,

Bceco)KHraiOI:o;Hii KOCTep,

Tipeo6paTH MHe cep.n;:o;e B KaMeHI>,

OcTaHoBH roJIOJJ;HI>IM B3op.

JlHpHqeCKHM repoii CJIOBHO OTKa3I>IBaeTC5I «HeCTH CBOH KpeCT», OH ITpOCHT JIHIIIHTI> ero

6o)KeCTBeHHoro .n;apa. H TOJibKO Ha 3THX ycJIOBH5IX, ecJIH TBope:o; BI>IIIOJIHHT 3TJ ITpocr,6y,

JIHpl1lieCKHM repoii BepHeTCH Ha «TeCHI>IH ITYCTI> CITaCeHH5I»:

OT cTpamHoii )Ka)KJJ;I>I ITecHoiTeHI>H

TiycKaH, TBOpe:o;, OCB060)KJCI>,

Tor.ua Ha TeCHI>IH rryTI> CITaceHI>H

K Te6e H CHOBa o6pamycr,

A 3TO y)Ke ITpHMOH maHTIDK, qTo COBepmeHHO KOHTpaCTHO ITO OTHOIIIeHHIO K MOJIHTBe. 3TO H

IT03BOJI5IeT HaM C)leJiaTI> BI>IBO)l 0 TOM, "CITO JiepMOHTOBI>IM 6biJI C03JJ;aH HOBI>IH )KaHp - )KaHp

«aHTHMOJIHTBI>I», CYTI> KOTOpOH He ITpOCTO pa3rOBOp C EoroM, H )liDKe He CITOp C HHM, a

BI>IJJ;BH)KeHHe CBOHX YCJIOBHH, KOTOpb!e )lOJI)KHf>I 6I>ITI> BI>IIIOJIHeHI>I EoroM, JJ;JIH TOrO qTo6r,I

JIHpHqecKrrii repoH: BepHyJicH Ha «TeCHI>Iii ITYTI> ciTaceHHH» •

iloJJ;BOM HTOrH HCCJie,IJ;OBaTeJII>CKOH pa60Thl, MQ)KHO CJJ;eJiaTI> CJie.n;yiOI:o;He BhlBOJJ;I>I.

CTHXOTBopeHHH, Ha3BaHHI>Ie «MOJIHTBaMH» caMHM aBTopoM, oqeHI> pa3Hopo,n;HI>I KaK ITO

co.n;ep)KaHmo, TaK H ITO <PopMaJII>HbiM ITpH3HaKaM. PaMKH KJiaccHqecKoif MOJIHTBI>I cJIHIIIKOM Y3KH

JJ;JIH JiepMOHTOBa, B HHX HeB03MO)KHO yMeCTHTI> CHJIY qyBCTB H MI>ICJieH II03Ta. MoJIHTBa JJ;JIH

JiepMOHTOBa - CKOpee CITOC06 CaMOBI>Ipa)KeHH5I, 3TO O'rpiDKeHHe ero MHpoorn;yi:o;eHH5I. il03TOMy

21

Page 25: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

aBTOp pa3BMBaeT 3Ty <f>opMy, OH rpaHc<f>opMMpyeT CYTb peJIHrM03HOrO TaMHCTBa H M,L(eT ,n:am:,me -

C03,L(aeT HOBhlH, ITO cyiil,eCTBy, )KaHp, KOTOpbiH ycJIOBHO MO)KeT 6biTb Ha3BaH «He-MOJIHTBOH»,

«aHTM-MOJIMTBOH». IJoMHMO rrepeLIMCJieHHbiX rrpMLIMH IIOMCKOB HOBOrO )KaHpa aBTOpOM, MO)KHO

OTMeTMTb em.e H orrpe,n:eJieHHOe COMHeHHe B 60)KeCTBeHHOH CMJie («HOLib. 1»), H ,n:aHb pOMaHTH3My.

Ho caMbiMM maBHbiMH rrpe,n:IIOCbiJIKaMM C03,L(aHmi ,n:aHHOrO )KaHpa MO)KHO Ha3BaTh IIOIIbiTKY HaUTH

rapMOHHIO M rro3HaTb nenocTHOCTh 3Toro rrpoTMBopeLIMsoro MHpa, r,n:e ecTI> 3eMJIH H He6o, ,II;eMoH

M AureJI, a 3HaLIHT ecTI> MecTo MoJIHTBe M AHTMMOJIHTBe. II em.e: )KeJiaHHe OTKpi>ITb csoro ,n:ymy

KOMY-HH6y,n:h paBHOMY ce6e, Hcrrose,n:aTI>C5I 3acTaBJI5IeT asTopa rrcKaTI> rryTH o6m.eHH5I c

BceBI>IIDHMM. Crroco6bl .n:ymesuoro rrcrrose,n:aHM5I aBTopa oLieHI> HeO)KH,n:aHHI>I: OT rrpocb6F..I 3a

JII06MMoro LieJioBeKa, ,n:o crropa c BoroM, porroTa M ,n:a)Ke mauTa)Ka. HoBI>IH )KaHp OTJIMt.IaeTC5I oT

KaHOHMLieCKOH MOJIHTBbl M CJIMillKOM CMJibHbiM B03BeJIMLJHBaHMeM «JI» JIHpHqecKOrO rep05I H ero

Mauepoii o6m.eHM5I c BoroM. CMJia MhiCJIH M l.JYBCTB JiepMOHToBa orpoMHa. Oua TO)K,L(eCTBeuua

60)KeCTBeHHOH CMJie, CHJie Tsopna, M MMeHHO II03TOMY JIMpMLieCKOrO rep05I JiepMOHTOBa HeJib35l

CLIMTaTI> rrpocTo LienoseKoM. Ou BI>Ime, ou Ha paBHbiX pa3rosaprrsaeT c BoroM, rroToMy LITO ua

3eMJie eMy rro,n:eJIMTbC5I He c KeM. Tipo6neMa B3aHMOOTHomeHHH rrpe,n:cTaBMTeJI5I 3eMJIM H Tsopna

MO)KeT 6biTb B 6y.n:ym.eM paCCMOrpeua B TeMe: napaJIJICJlh lJeJIOBeK - Eor B TBOp'1CCTBC

JlepMOHTOBa. Ho, IIO)Ka.Jiyll, rJiaBHhlll BbiBO,L(, KOTOphlH MO)KHO C,L(eJiaTb B 3TOH pa60Te, 3TO TO, LITO

,n:ep3Koe o6pam.eHHe K Bory - 3TO ue )KeJiaurre ocKop6MTb qyscTBa sepyrom.MX M caMoro Bora, a

IIOIIbiTKa HaHTM H,L(eaJibHOrO co6ece,n:HMKa. A 3TO 3HaLIMT, LITO M MOJlUmea, M aHmUMOJlUmea - 3TO

,[(Be CTOpOHbl O,L(HOH IIOIIbiTKM o6peCTM rapMOHMIO. (CxeMa 1.)

Kollullecmeo c!loe: 3999

22

Page 26: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

0CHOBHOH pecypc:

• M.IO. JiepMOHTOB. Co6paHHe co-qHHeHHe B -qeTE>Ipex TOMax. ToM rrepBE>Iii. «MocKBa.

Xy,n;mKeCTBeHHasr JIHTepaTypa. 1975». BczyrrHTeJIE>Hasr cTaTE>H H rrpHMe-qaHHH H. JI.

AH,n;poHHKOBa.

BcnoMonneJihHhle pecypcM:

e BceMHpHM 6H6JIHOTeKa Il033HH. MHXaHJI JiepMOHTOB CTHXOTBOpeHHH. 000 «il3,ZJ;aTeJibCTBO

«3KcMo», 2007. CocTaBHTeJIE>, aBTOp rrpe,n;HCJIOBHH H KOMMeHTapHeB C. KopMHJIOB

• 3aKOH Eo)Kllif M.H ceME>H H IIIKOJIE>I. CocTaBHTeJib - IIpoTOiepell: CepaqmM'b Cno6o,n;cKoll:.

H3,n;aHHe «HHKOJio-EonocoBcKoro MOHacTE>Ipsr», 1999

• KaK Hay-qHTbC}! MOJIHTC}!. CoBeTE>I CBHTHTeJISI <l>eoTcpaHa 3aTBOpHHKa. H3,n;aTeJIE>CTBO

«OT-q:Hif ,.[.(oM», MocKBa, 1999

• Kpyr "({TeHH}!: IIIKOJIE>HM rrporpaMMa. M.IO. JiepMOHTOB. «.II:n}! MHpa H He6ec -qy)Koif».

MocKBa IIIKona-rrpecc 1999. BczyrrHTeJIE>HM cTaTb}! B. P03aHOBa

e CeMb CMepTHbiX rpexoB. HaKa3aHHe H IIoKaSIHHe. E.JI. HcaeBa. 000 rpyrrrra KoMITaHHM

«PHrron KnaccHK. MocKBa», 2009

CJioBapu:

• C.M. O)KeroB H H.IO. liiBe,n;oBa. ToJIKOBhlM CnoBapE> PyccKoro 5l3biKa. B.H. Mono,n;E>Iii,

CTHJieBoe ocpopMJieHHe, 1997

BcnoMora:TeJihHhle HuTepueT PecypcM:

• ,.[.(MHTPHM Mepe)KKOBCKHM. CTaTb}! «Ilo3T CBepx-qenoBe-qecTBa».

• )l{H3HI> H cpHJiococpH}! ilMMaHyHJia KaHTa. 7 5IHBap}! 2011.

23

Page 27: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

• MHXaFIJI AneKcaH,ll;pOBJili Bpy6eJih, ,lJ;eMoH ( CIIMI.I1J:Iii). ,lJ;eTCKrre o6pa3bi B )l(llBOrrrrcrr

• TipocTpaHHbiH TipasocnaBHI>Iii KaTIIXII3IIC TipasocnaBHoii Ka<):>omrqecKoii BocTOl:IHOH

[(epKBrr. CB5ITIITeJib <!>IIJiapeT, MrrTporronrrT MocKOBCKIIii rr KonoMeHcKIIii.

• XpoHonorrrl:IeCKM KaHBa )Kll3HII M.IO. JiepMOHTOBa. B.A. MaHyiiJios, C.E. JiaTI>IrneB 1981

24

Page 28: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

IIpnJio~euuH

CxeMa 1.

ti;EMOH

AHTMMOJIMTBA

BHYTPEHHME UPOTHBOPEqM.H

AHTHTE3A

AHfEJI

MOJIMTBA

CxeMa J. IIOKa3biBaeT O'Tpa)l(eHHe 6yHTapCKOH HaTJpbi aBTOpa B ero II033HH. ilpHeM aHTHTe3bl B ero

TBOp~eCTBe, KaK O)J;HO H3 HaH60Jiee SipKHX XY,D;O)I(eCTBeHHDIX cpe,D;CTB aBTOpa, YKa3biBaeT Ha

IIpOTHBOpe~BOCTb .n;ymeBHOrO COCTOSIHHSI. 3TO BJie~eHHe OT .AJITena K ,lJ;eMOHJ. JiepMOHTOB B

25

Page 29: is are not EXTENDED ESSAY...Q)Kerosa, M.bi y3HaeM, liTO «MoJZumea-ycmaHoeJZeHitbtU KaHoHuttecKuu meKcm, npoU3HOCUMbZU npu o6pazlfeHuu K Eozy, K ceflmbzM» 4. KaKosa )Ke pon.b MOJIHTBI>I

ITOHCKax rapMOHHH. 06paiiJ;ruiC.b K HCTOKaM XpHCTHaHCTBa, K MOJIHTBe, OH OIDIT.b ::>Ke He HaXO.D:HT

H,n:eaJia. TaK po:>K.n;aeTCSI HOB.biH ::>KaHp <<AHTHMOJIHTBbi», B KOTOpOM aBTOp He CJie.n:yeT KaHOHaM

MOJIHTB.bl, O.D:HaKO HaXO.D:HT B 3TOM ::>KaHpe CITOC06 HCITOBe,n:aHH» ,lzylliM.

TipuJio~euue 2. MHXaHJI ArreKcaH,n:poalfl! Bpy6eJI.b. ",lJ;eMoH (cH,n:»IIJ;Hif)". 1890

12 «/feMOH - oyx He cmOllbKO 3ll06HblU, CKOllbKO cmpaOa!OUfUU U CKOp6HblU, npu eceM 3mOM oyx

e!lacmHblU, eeRuttaeblU»- MuxaWl AlleKcam)poBU'I Bpy6e.nb

12 MHxaHJI ArreKcaH,n:pOBifll Bpy6eJI.b",lJ;eMoH (CH.D:»IIJ;IIii)". XoJicT, MacJio. 114x211. rocy,n:apcTBeHHIDI TpeT.bSIKOBCKIDI raJiepe», 3aJI .N'!! 33. < http:/ /en.wikipedia.org/wiki!File: V rubel_Demon.jpg>

26