IRCF Reptiles & AmphibiAns...IRCF ReptIles & AmphIbIAns • Vol 18, no 1 • mAR 2011 3 basking in...
Transcript of IRCF Reptiles & AmphibiAns...IRCF ReptIles & AmphIbIAns • Vol 18, no 1 • mAR 2011 3 basking in...
IRC
FReptiles & AmphibiAns
C o n s e r v at i o n a n d n at u r a l H i s t o r y
y1MAR
2011
VO L
NUM
IRCF ReptIles & AmphIbIAns • Vol 18, no 1 • mAR 2011 In thIs Issue
Hylarana tipanan was described in 2000, but the experts who describe biodi-versity are disappearing (see commentary on p. 39).
Ra
fe B
Ro
wn
this juvenile female Giant musk turtle (Staurotypus salvinii) was recently discovered in miami, miami-Dade County, Florida (see article on p. 55).
Du
stin
C. s
mit
h
melanistic sombrero Ameivas (Ameiva corvina) occur only on the small isolated island of sombrero, the northernmost of the lesser Antilles. this individual had just excavated a beetle grub (see travelogue on p. 42).
Ro
BeR
t Po
wel
l
texas horned lizards (Phrynosoma cornutum) are popular with texans who often bring them home. they regularly show up at the south plains Wildlife Rehabilitation Center in lubbock, texas (see article on p. 18).
Ga
D P
eRR
y
A distressed male Sphaerodactylus leucaster with the vertically elliptical pupil it shares with other nocturnal geckos (see article on p. 12).
Da
nie
l P.
sC
an
tleB
uR
y
back cover: stuart brookerAn adult male saint lucia Iguana (Iguana cf. iguana) from near the nesting site at louvet estate on saint lucia’s northeastern coast. this geneti-cally unique population might be threatened by invasive non-native Green Iguanas (I. iguana) that are breeding in the dry and mesic forests around soufrière in the southwest of the island. the most pressing concern is potential hybridization between individuals in the two populations, although com-petition between them could also pose a problem if they came into contact. see the article on p. 24.
Front cover: barry brownteiid lizards (racerunners and whiptails) are typi-cally not territorial, although males will fight for access to females and for other reasons we do not fully understand. these two male Curaçao Whiptails (Cnemidophorus murinus murinus) were so intent on each other that they tolerated a very close approach by the photographer. look for an article by Gerard van buurt about the teiid liz-ards of Aruba, bonaire, Curaçao, and the nearby paraguaná peninsula of Venezuela in an upcom-ing issue of Reptiles & Amphibians.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 1tAbleoFContents IRCF REPTILES & AMPHIBIANS • VOL15, NO 4 • DEC 2008 189TABLE OF CONTENTS
T A B L E O F C O N T E N T S
F E A T U R E A R T I C L E S
Chasing Bullsnakes (Pituophis catenifer sayi) in Wisconsin: On the Road to Understanding the Ecology and Conservation of the Midwest’s Giant Serpent ...................... Joshua M. Kapfer 190
The Shared History of Treeboas (Corallus grenadensis) and Humans on Grenada: A Hypothetical Excursion ............................................................................................................................Robert W. Henderson 198
R E S E A R C H A R T I C L E S
The Texas Horned Lizard in Central and Western Texas ....................... Emily Henry, Jason Brewer, Krista Mougey, and Gad Perry 204 The Knight Anole (Anolis equestris) in Florida
.............................................Brian J. Camposano, Kenneth L. Krysko, Kevin M. Enge, Ellen M. Donlan, and Michael Granatosky 212
C O N S E R V A T I O N A L E R T
World’s Mammals in Crisis ............................................................................................................................................................. 220 More Than Mammals ...................................................................................................................................................................... 223 The “Dow Jones Index” of Biodiversity ........................................................................................................................................... 225
H U S B A N D R Y
Captive Care of the Central Netted Dragon ....................................................................................................... Shannon Plummer 226
P R O F I L E
Kraig Adler: A Lifetime Promoting Herpetology ................................................................................................ Michael L. Treglia 234
C O M M E N T A R Y
The Turtles Have Been Watching Me ........................................................................................................................ Eric Gangloff 238
B O O K R E V I E W
Threatened Amphibians of the World edited by S.N. Stuart, M. Hoffmann, J.S. Chanson, N.A. Cox, R. Berridge, P. Ramani, and B.E. Young .............................................................................................................. Robert Powell 243
CONSERVATION RESEARCH REPORTS: Summaries of Published Conservation Research Reports ................................. 245 NATURAL HISTORY RESEARCH REPORTS: Summaries of Published Reports on Natural History ................................. 247 NEWBRIEFS ...................................................................................................................................................................................... 248 EDITORIAL INFORMATION ..................................................................................................................................................... 251 FOCUS ON CONSERVATION: A Project You Can Support ............................................................................................... 252
Front Cover. Shannon Plummer.Totat et velleseque audant mo estibus inveliquo velique rerchil erspienimus, quos accullabo. Ilibus aut dolor apicto invere pe dolum fugiatis maionsequat eumque moditia erere nonsedis ma sectiatur ma derrovitae voluptam, as quos accullabo.
Back Cover. Michael KernTotat et velleseque audant mo
estibus inveliquo velique rerchil erspienimus, quos accullabo. Ilibus
aut dolor apicto invere pe dolum fugiatis maionsequat eumque
moditia erere nonsedis ma sectia-tur ma derrovitae voluptam, as
IRC
F
REPTILES & AMPHIBIANSC O N S E R V AT I O N A N D N AT U R A L H I S T O R Y
T a b l e o f c o n T e n T s
F E A T U R E A R T I C L E S
baskingintheAlligatorsnappingturtle,Macrochelys temminckii(testudines:Chelydridae)................................................. ....................................................................................................... John L. Carr, Samuel R. Holcomb, and Mitchell J. Ray 2
sympatrybetweentwoWide-rangingsalamanderspecies............................................................................Jennifer Deitloff 6
notesonActivitypatternsofFivespeciesofSphaerodactylus(squamata:sphaerodactylidae)fromtheDominicanRepublic.............................................Daniel P. Scantlebury, Julienne Ng, Miguel Landestoy, Anthony Geneva, and Richard E. Glor 12
herpetofaunaAdmittedtothesouthplainsWildlifeRehabilitationCenter(lubbock,texas):Atwo-decadeperspective......................................................................................................E. Kathleen McGaughey, Mark Wallace, and Gad Perry 18
nativeandAlienIguanasonsaintlucia,WestIndies................................................ Matthew N. Morton and Ulrike Krauss 24
ReadingtheAshes:ArsonDecimatesatropicalWetland,butAllowsnewobservationsofaneotropicalmudturtle..................................................................................................................................... Jeremy E. Guinn and Palani Luger 34
C O M M E N T A R Y
themassextinctionofscientistsWhostudyspecies..................................................................................... Craig McClain 39
T R A v E L O g U E
sombrero:lizardsAmongtheRuins............................................................................................................ Elizabeth Wright 42
I N T R O D U C E D S P E C I E S
thetentacledsnake, Erpeton tentaculatumlacépède1800(homalopsidae),inFlorida........................................................ .........................................................................................................................Joshua D. Holbrook and Kenneth L. Krysko 52
CubanbrownAnoles(Anolissagrei)insaintlucia............................................. Matthew N. Morton and Christopher A. Cox 52
AFailed(?)IntroductionoflizardsandFrogsonst.Vincent.......................................................................... Amos Glasgow 54
thepacificCoastGiantmuskturtle,Staurotypus salviniiGray1864(Kinosternidae),anewnon-indigenousspeciesinFlorida......................................... Dustin C. Smith, Kenneth L. Krysko, Tracy A. Sorensen, and Maria N. Sider 55
v ConseRVAtIonReseARChRepoRts:summariesofpublishedReportsonConservation..................................................57
v nAtURAlhIstoRYReseARChRepoRts:summariesofpublishedReportsonnaturalhistory........................................57
v neWsbRIeFs..................................................................................................................................................................................58
v Advertisements...................................................................................................................................................................................61
v eDItoRIAlInFoRmAtIon.......................................................................................................................................................63
v FoCUsonConseRVAtIon:AprojectYouCansupport.......................................................................................................64
theGrandCaymanblue-fannedAnole(Anolis conspersus)istheonlynativeanoleonGrandCayman.however,introducedCubanbrownAnoles(A. sagrei)haveforcedA. conspersustousehigherperchesinopenhabitatswherebothspeciesoccur.
Joh
n F
. Bin
ns
2 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
AjuvenileMacrochelys temminckii(alsoillustratedinFig.2)baskingonafloatingrailroadtieat0727h.notetheleechoccupyingaspacebetweenthevertebralandrightlateralkeels.
Cr
edit
CARR,holComb,AnDRAY
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 3
basking in the alligator snapping Turtle, Macrochelys temminckii (Testudines:
chelydridae)Johnl.Carr1,samuelR.holcomb1,2,andmitchellJ.Ray1,3
1Departmentofbiologyandmuseumofnaturalhistory,Universityoflouisianaatmonroemonroe,louisiana71209,UsA([email protected])
2louisianaDepartmentofWildlifeandFisheries,p.o.box98000,batonRouge,louisiana70898,UsA([email protected])33321bluebirdRidge,newbraunfels,texas78130,UsA([email protected])
photographsbytheseniorauthor.
macrochelys temminckii is the largest freshwater turtle in northAmerica,andisoftenconsideredoneofthemostaquaticspecies
aswell(pritchard1967).onlyadultfemalesareknowntoregularlyleavethewater,andthenonlytonest(ernstandbarbour1972,Zappalorti1976,pritchard1989).baskinginthisspecieswaslongthoughttobenon-existentorextremelyrare(brattstromandCollins1972,ernstandbarbour1972).Althoughsomeauthorshavesuggestedthataquaticbask-ingoccursinthisspecies(Zappalorti1976,howeyandDinkelacker2009),nopublishedreportsdescribesuchbehavior.however,severalpublicationsdescribeaerialbaskinginM. temminckii,buteachliteraturereportcon-sistsofasingleobservation(ewert1976,shelbyandJensen2002,Farretal.2005,selmanetal.2009,thomas2009,selmanandWillig2010).ofthesixreportedinstancesofbasking,onewasahatchling(42mm,shelbyandJensen2002),threewerejuveniles(~100–200mmCl;ewert1976,thomas2009,selmanandWillig2010),andtwowereofadultsizes(~350–400mm,Farretal2005;~400–500mm,selmanetal.2009).oneinstanceofbaskingwasinferredfromcapturingaspecimeninabaskingtrap(shelbyandJensen2002).Intheotherfivecasesinwhichbaskingwasactuallyobserved,threeoftheturtlesappearedtohavebeenbaskingforsometime,astheanimalsweredescribedasdry(ewert1976,Farretal.2005,thomas2009),butthemaximumreportedobservationperiodlastednolongerthanabout12min(Farretal.2005).Allsixobservationswereassociatedwithlotichabitats(creeksorrivers),withbaskingsubstratesincludingafallentreetrunk,snags,andriverbanks.Wherereported,turtleswererestingonthebaskingsubstrateinclinedatanglesestimatedat30–60°,withtheheadpointedupslope(ewert1976,Farretal.2005,selmanetal.2009).Inonecase,theanimal’srestinganglewasnotnoted,butthesnagtoascendtothebaskingspotwasnearlyvertical(90°)andinvolvedclimbingoveraninterveningobstacle(selmanandWillig2010).thefiverecordedtimesforbaskingbehaviorwerebetween1000and1700h. Duringthe2009fieldseason,weobservedtwoinstancesofaerialbaskingandoneofaquaticbasking,allinvolvingjuvenileM. temminckii.observationsweremadeatblackbayoulakenationalWildlifeRefuge,11.5kmnorthofmonroeinouachitaparish,louisiana.thecenterpieceoftherefugeisalargelake(~845ha),whichisabackswamp(Wang1950)thathasbeendammedbyarailroadline,andnowhasthewaterlevelcon-trolledwithastop-logstructure.Airtemperatureswereobtainedfromtheneareststationinouachitaparishfortheappropriatedateandtime(WeatherUnderground,http://www.wunderground.com). Whileradio-trackingonblackbayoulakeatapproximately1400hon9march2009,ajuvenileM.temminckii(carapacelength[Cl]=174.3mm,weight=1.04kg)wasobservedwithitsheadexposedabovethewater.theafternoonwassunny,withverylittlecloudcover.Uponcloserinspec-tion,theturtlewasfoundtobefloatingaboveabedofsubmergedaquatic
vegetationcomposedprimarilyofEgeria densa (brazilianWaterweed) andCeratophyllum demersum (Coontail).theheadandkeelsofthecarapacewereexposedabovethewater,whereitremainedforaperiodof~5min,withnoindicationthatitwasforaging.theturtlewascapturedbyhandandbroughttothelabforexamination.ItwasidentifiedbyapIttagasa“head-started”juvenilefromthe2004year-classthatwereleasedon12June2008.Watertemperatureatthetimeofcapturewas21°Candairtemperaturewasapproximately27°C.thisobservationmatcheswellthe
AllIGAtoRsnAppInGtURtles
Fig. 1.JuvenileMacrochelys temminckii(A)baskingontheendofarailroadtieintheshadeofaWaterelm(Planera aquatica).thesameindividual(b)immediatelyaftercapture.notethelargeleechattachedtothecarapace.
4 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
descriptionofaquaticbaskingbymollandlegler(1971).theydescribedaquaticbaskingasbehaviorinwhich“turtles...weremotionlessatthesur-facewithlimbsfullyextendedandpartofthecarapaceoutofthewater,”andwentontosaythatthemostcommonsitesforaquaticbaskingofpanamaniansliders(Trachemys venusta)“wereoverbedsof[asubmergedaquaticplant]ornearothermatsofvegetation.” Inthecourseofterrestrialnestingsurveysalongtherailroadcausewayinthenorthwesterncornerofthelake,weobservedajuvenile(Cl=190.2mm,weight=1.52kg)on20April2009at0900h.Itwasrestingonanoldrailroadtieamongriprapatthemarginofthelake,29cmabovegroundlevel.thewetturtlewassittingaskewonthebankendoftherailroadtiewithalargeleechontherightsideofitscarapace(Fig.1).therailroadtiewasinclinedat~12°intothewaterfromthebank.basedontheanimal’spositionandthewettrailitleftonthetie,theturtlehadtohaveclimbedthebankandthentheendoftherailroadtie(~80–90°)toreachitsloca-tionatopthehigh,out-of-waterend.theturtlewaspositionedinsuchawaythatitwasrestingatananglenearhorizontal.thelefthindlegwasdanglingintheair,buttheright-sidelimbswereextendedandincontactwiththesubstrate;theheadandneckwerealsoextendedandrestingonthewood.thedigitswerenotmaximallyabducted(spreadapart).thisturtlewasobservedforjustafewminutesbeforebeingcaptured.Whenapproached,theanimalquicklydoveintothewateronthelake-sideoftherailroadtie.Atthetimeofthisobservationconditionswereclearandsunny,althoughthebaskingsitewasfullyshadedbyasmallWaterelm(Planera aquatica).Airtemperatureatthetimeofcapturewasapproximately17°C. WefoundanotherbaskingM. temminckiiduringaterrestrialnestingsurveyalongthelakemarginon29April2009.At0720h,ajuvenile(cara-
pacelength~140mm)wasobservedonarailroadtiefloating~3mfromtheshoreline(Fig.2).Ascanbeseeninthephotograph,thetailextendsstraightbehindthebody,therighthindlegisminimallyextendedwithoutabducteddigits,therightforelimbismorefullyextended,andallareincontactwiththesubstrate.theheadandneckarefullyextendedandtheanimalappearsalert,possiblywiththeproximalportionoftheneckrestingonthesubstrate.theweatheredrailroadtiewashorizontal,providinga0°baskingsurface,andwaslocatedintheearlymorningshadows,notexposedtothesun.Aleechwasnotedonthecarapace,andtheturtlewasphoto-graphedandobserveduntil0730h,atwhichtimetheobserver(JlC)leftthesite.Atapproximately0807h,whentheobserverreturnedtothebask-ingsite,theindividualwasseeninthesameposition,andthecarapacewasdrier,indicatingthatbaskinghadcontinuedinthemeantime.Inaddition,theleechthathadbeenobservedonthecarapacemoveduntilitwasoutofsight(Fig.2insert),whichfitswiththeideathatthedryingofaturtledur-ingbaskingwouldtendtocauseleechestoreleasetheirhold(pope1939,Cagle1950).theemptypupariumandanewlyemergedadultdamselfly(odonata:Zygoptera)arealsovisibleinoneofourphotos,sotheturtlehadremainedinthesamepositionlongenoughtoserveasasubstrateforemer-gencebythisaquaticinsect.thefirsttolastobservationsofthisindividualspanned58min.Airtemperaturewasapproximately22°C. ourobservationsincludethefirstspecificinstanceofaquaticbask-ingreportedforthespecies,andtwoadditionalinstancesofaerialbask-ing.obbardandbrooks(1979)notedapreponderanceofaerialbaskinginChelydra,buttheincidenceofaquaticbaskingwasashighas16%ofallbaskingobservationsforradio-telemeteredindividualsintheirpopulation.thesearetheonlyobservationsofbaskingM. temminckiithatwehave
Fig. 2.AsecondjuvenileMacrochelys temminckiibaskingonafloatingrailroadtie.notethattheleechismovingacrossthevertebralkeelat0816h.Intheinsert,theleechisnolongervisibleonthecarapaceat0817h.
CARR,holComb,AnDRAY
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 5
madeduring15yearsoffieldworkatthissitebytheseniorauthor(1996–2010),soweareinclinedtoagreewiththenotionthatbaskingoccursonlyrarelyinthisspecies(ewert1976).obbardandbrooks(1979)notedamongthereasonsthatbaskingmighthavebeeninfrequentlyreportedinChelydra serpentinapriortotheirstudywasthatindividualsalmostalwaysbaskaloneonaparticularobject,asopposedtoemydids,whicharefre-quentlyfoundinlargenumbersonthesameobjectorevenstackedononeanother.AllreportsofaerialbaskingMacrochelysareofsingleindividuals,thusiftheanimalsarewary,anindividualcouldveryeasilyslipintothewaterunnoticed.Inaddition,withrespecttoM.temminckii,thedarkcol-orationofthecarapaceandsoftpartswouldtendtobewellcamouflagedonmostlogsorotherwoodystructures,andtheroughtextureoftheshellandsoftpartswouldtendtodisrupttheoutlineoftheturtle,bothofwhichwouldcomplicateseeinganindividualbeforeitslippedintothewater. AllreportsofaerialbaskinginM. temminckiiinvolvesingleindi-vidualsonabankorwoodsubstrate.InC. serpentina(itsclosestnorthAmericanrelative),obbardandbrooks(1979)reportedthat99%of233aerialbaskingobservationsinvolvedasingleturtleonabaskingobject.thepostureassumedbythetwoaerialbaskingM. temminckiithatweobservedwassimilartowhatewert(1976)describedforChelydra,inwhichthefeetremainincontactwiththebaskingobject,ratherthanbeingfullyextendedinmid-airwiththedigitsmaximallyabductedasiscommonlyseenwiththehindlimbsinemydids(Cagle1950,Auth1975).obbardandbrooks(1979)reportedseeinglimbsextendedwiththewebbingspreadinChelydra, buttheydidnotquantifytheincidenceofthebehavior;however,intheirphoto,thelefthindlimbisnotelevatedabovethesubstratewiththedigitsmaximallyabducted.obbardandbrooks(1979)alsonotedthatonlyabout5%oftheirChelydrabaskingobservationsinvolvedanon-shorebaskingsubstrate.WithrespecttoMacrochelys,fouroftheaerialbaskingobservationshaveinvolvedbaskingsubstratesonthebankoralogattachedtothebank,andfourinvolvedfree-floatingorfixedoffshoreobjects. Withatotalofninebaskingobservationsforthespeciesnow,com-parisonwithfactorsrelatedtotheappearanceofthebehaviormaystarttobemade.someexplanationsforbaskingareapplicableonlytoadultturtles.ofthenineknowninstancesofbaskinginM. temminckii,themajorityofindividualswerejuveniles(7of9,includingour3observations),soanyassociationwithmaturationofovarianfolliclesinfemalesorwarmingbybaskinginthespringtoenhancematingbehavior(obbardandbrooks1979)couldaccountfornomorethanasmallfractionofthereportedcases.Anumberofgeneralexplanationsforbaskingbehaviorareavailable,includingthermoregulation(boyer1965,mollandlegler1971,obbardandbrooks1979),vitamin-Dsynthesis(pritchardandGreenhood1968),dryingoftheskinandshellsurfacethatcouldreduceectoparasiteandepi-zoophyteload(pope1939,Cagle1950,boyer1965,shelbyandJensen2002),andasaresponsetoillnessorinjury(selmanandQualls2009).thecaseofaquaticbaskingwouldseemclearlyrelatedtothermoregula-tionsinceitwasexposedtofullmiddaysunlightandistheearliestspringdaterecordedforbaskingwhenwatertemperatureswererelativelylow.ourothertwoobservationsbothinvolvedturtlesintheshade,ewert’s(1976)observationwasunderalightlyovercastsky,andthomas(2009)reportedtheindividualhesawwasinpartialsunlight.Althoughmostindividualsthathavebeenobservedwereexposedtosunnyskiesasonewouldexpectofaturtlebaskingforthermoregulation,indirectultravioletlightassoci-atedwithvitamin-Dsynthesiscouldstillreachaturtleunderacloudyskyorintheshade,butmuchlesseffectivelythanexposuretodirectsunlight.bothoftheaerialbaskingindividualsweobservedhadlargeleechesonthecarapace,andforoneofthetwo,wewereabletodocumentthattheleechreleaseditsinitialholdandmovedovertimeastheturtle’sshelldried.thiswassimilartoobservationsofGraptemysbyselmanetal.(2008)and
selmanandQualls(2009);however,thomas(2009)noted100+leecheswerestillattachedtothejuvenilehecapturedwhilebasking.
AcknowledgmentsthisresearchwasperformedunderlouisianastatescientificCollectingpermitlnhp–09–059andU.s.FishandWildlifeservicespecialUsepermit42651–09–03.FundingwasprovidedbythelouisianaDepartmentofWildlifeandFisheriesandtheU.s.FishandWildlifeservice,DivisionofFederalAid,throughthestateWildlifeGrantsprogram.headstartingwasundertakenbythenatchitochesnationalFishhatchery.WewouldliketothankthestaffofblackbayoulakenationalWildlifeRefuge,andKarenKilpatrickatthenatchitochesnationalFishhatcheryfortheircoopera-tion.WethankD.ligonforhelpfulcommentsonthemanuscript.
Literature CitedAuth,D.l.1975.behavioralecologyofbasking in theYellow-belliedturtle,
Chrysemys scripta scripta (schoepff).Bulletin of the Florida State Museum, Biological Sciences20:1–45.
boyer,D.R.1965.ecologyofthebaskinghabitinturtles.Ecology46:99–118.
brattstrom,b.h.andR.Collins.1972.thermoregulation.International Turtle and Tortoise Society Journal6(5):15–19.
Cagle,F.R.1950.thelifehistoryofthesliderturtle,Pseudemys scripta troostii(holbrook).Ecological Monographs20:31–54.
ernst,C.h.andR.W.barbour.1972.Turtles of the United States.UniversitypressofKentucky,lexington.
ewert,m.A.1976.nests,nestingandaerialbaskingofMacroclemysundernatu-ralconditions,andcomparisonswithChelydra(testudines:Chelydridae).Herpetologica32:150–156.
Farr,W.,p.Crump,andJ.Caraviotis.2005.Macrochelys temminckii(Alligatorsnappingturtle).Aerialbasking.Herpetological Review36:168.
howey,C.A.F.ands.A.Dinkelacker.2009.habitatselectionoftheAlligatorsnappingturtle(Macrochelys temminckii)inArkansas.Journal of Herpetology43:589–596.
moll,e.o.andJ.m.legler.1971.thelifehistoryofaneotropicalsliderturtle,Pseudemys scripta(schoepff),inpanama.Bulletin of the Los Angeles County Museum of Natural History, Science (11):1–102.
obbard,m.e.andR.J.brooks.1979.FactorsaffectingbaskinginanorthernpopulationoftheCommonsnappingturtle,Chelydra serpentina.Canadian Journal of Zoology57:435–440.
pope,C.h.1939.Turtles of the United States and Canada.AlfredA.Knopf,newYork.
pritchard,p.C.h.1967.Living Turtles of the World.t.F.h.publications,JerseyCity,newJersey.
pritchard,p.C.h.1989.The Alligator Snapping Turtle: Biology and Conservation.milwaukeepublicmuseum,milwaukee,Wisconsin.
pritchard,p.C.h.andW.F.Greenhood.1968.thesunandtheturtle.International Turtle and Tortoise Society Journal2:20–25.
selman,W.,b.Drescher,andC.Qualls.2009.Macrochelys temminckii(Alligatorsnappingturtle).Adultbaskingbehavior.Herpetological Review40:79.
selman,W.andC.Qualls.2009.Graptemys flavimaculata(Yellow-blotchedmapturtle).baskingandparasiteremoval.Herpetological Review40:78–79.
selman,W.,D.strong,andC.Qualls.2008.Graptemys gibbonsi(pascagoulamapturtle).baskingandparasiteremoval.Herpetological Review39:216.
selman,W.andm.Willig.2010.Macrochelys temminckii (Alligatorsnappingturtle).Aerialbaskingandclimbingability.Herpetological Review41:486.
shelby,J.A.andJ.b.Jensen.2002.Macrochelys temminckii(Alligatorsnappingturtle).Aerialbasking.Herpetological Review33:304.
thomas,t.m.2009.Macrochelys temminckii(Alligatorsnappingturtle).Aerialbasking.Herpetological Review40:336.
Wang,K.1952.Geologyofouachitaparish.Geological Bulletin(28):126.
Zappalorti,R.t.1976.The Amateur Zoologist’s Guide to Turtles and Crocodilians.stackpolebooks,harrisburg,pennsylvania.
AllIGAtoRsnAppInGtURtles
6 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
Plethodon cinereushasaverylargegeographicrangespanningmostofthenortheasternUnitedstates.
Lain
e G
iov
an
etto
DeItloFF
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 7
sympatry between Two Wide-ranging salamander species
JenniferDeitloff
Departmentofecology,evolution,andorganismalbiology,IowastateUniversity,Ames,Iowa50014(Currentaddress:Departmentofbiologicalsciences,AuburnUniversity,Auburn,Alabama36849;[email protected])
photographsbytheauthorexceptwhereindicated.
Abstract.—Understandinghowcloselyrelatedspeciescoexistremainsacentralproblemincommunityecology.habitatcharacteristics,pres-enceofpredatorsandcompetitors,andfrequencyofdisturbanceallaffectthegeographicdistributionofaspecies.Plethodon cinereusandP. electromorphus aretwocloselyrelatedandecologicallysimilarspeciesthathavealargegeographicoverlapintheirdistributions.Inthisstudy,Ihadtwomaingoals.First,Iwantedtodeterminehowcommonlysympatriclocationsoccurredbetweenthesetwospecies.toaddressthisgoal,Iconductedlandscape-scalesurveysinareasthatshouldcontainsympatriclocationsbasedontheirdistributions.mysecondgoalwastodetermineiftherelativenumberofindividualsofeachspecieswithinsympatriclocationswasstableovertimebymonitoringfoursympatriclocationsoverthreeyears.Inaddition,floodingoccurredduringoneyearofthestudy,impactingtwoofthefourmonitoredsympatriclocations;therefore,Iwantedtoexaminewhetherthisdisturbanceaffectedthesalamanderpopulationsatthoselocations.thisfloodingeventprovidedarareoppor-tunitytostudytheimpactoffloodingonterrestrialsalamanders,atopicaboutwhichlittleisknown.Ifoundthatsympatriclocationsoccurredlessfrequentlythanexpectedbychanceandthatsomesympatricsitesseemtoberelativelystablewhileatothers,therelativepopulationsizeofP. cinereuswasincreasing—andthatthisshiftmightbepositivelyaffectedbyflooding.WhilethisstudydemonstratedthatP. cinereusandP. electromorphus donotoccurinsympatryasfrequentlyasexpectedbychance,thecauseforthisresultisunknown.themostlikelyfactoristhatthetwospeciesexhibitsubtlehabitatdifferencesthathavenotyetbeendemonstrated.theinteractionsbetweenP. cinereusandP. electromorphusarecomplex,andthepatternsobservedherecouldhavebeengeneratedbyanynumberofmechanisms.Furtherresearchonthissystemcouldclarifysomeoftheseremainingquestions.
Understandinghowcloselyrelatedspeciescoexistremainsacentralproblemincommunityecology.theamountofoverlapbetweenthe
geographicrangesofcloselyrelatedspeciesisthoughttodepend,inpart,ontheextenttowhichsimilarspeciessharethesamehabitatrequirements.Closelyrelatedspeciestendtooverlapmorethanexpectedbychance,sug-gestingthatspecies’distributionsaremoreconstrainedbysharednicherequirementsandcommonancestrythanbycompetition(harveyandpagel1991,letcheretal.1994).Conversely,nichesimilaritymayleadtointensecompetitionandeventualexclusionresultinginrareco-occurrenceofthetwospecies(bowersandbrown1982).thedistributionofaspeciescouldbeaffectedbyanynumberofmechanismsthatcouldincludehabitatcharacteristicsandthepresenceofpredatorsorcompetitors.
Interspecificcompetitionandterritorialaggressionseemtobeprev-alentwithin thegenusPlethodon (e.g., Jaeger1970,nishikawa1985,Anthonyetal.1997,marshalletal.2004).Insomeinstances,interspecificcompetitionhaslimitedthegeographicrangesofcompetingspecies(Jaeger1970,hairston1980,Arifetal.2007)andhasledtoavarietyofevolu-tionaryconsequencesbetweensympatricspecies,suchascharacterdisplace-ment(AdamsandRohlf2000),competitiveexclusion(Jaeger1971,myersandAdams2008),andalpha-selection—intenseinterspecificaggression(nishikawa1987,Deitloffetal.2009).Further,theseeffectsappeartohaveshapedspeciesdistributionsatabroadgeographicscale,becausepatternsofcommunitycompositionareconsistentwithwhatispredictedfromcom-petitive-basedmodelsofcommunitydynamics(Adams2007).
WIDe-RAnGInGsAlAmAnDeRspeCIes
Fig. 1.AdultPlethodon cinereus. Fig. 2.AdultPlethodon electromorphus.
8 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 DeItloFF
Plethodon cinereus(p.6andfig.1)hasaverylargegeographicrangespanningmostofthenortheasternUnitedstates;and,whilethegeographicrangeofP. electromorphus(Fig.2)ismuchsmaller,thisspecieshasarela-tivelylargegeographicrangecomparedtomanyotherspeciesinthegenusPlethodon(petranka1998).Inohio,thegeographicoverlapoftherangesofthesetwospeciesextendsthroughoutmostofthestate;but,whenviewedatafinerscale,thegeographicoverlapismoreaccuratelydescribedasinter-digitation(seeDeitloffetal.2008,figs.1and2).Inotherwords,allopatriclocationsmaybemorecommonlyfoundthansympatriclocations.Assug-gestedinDeitloffetal.(2008),thisdifferencebetweenthecoarse-andfine-scaleviewsofthegeographicdistributionsinthesetwospeciescouldleadtodifferingconclusionsabouttheextentofsympatry.therefore,Iaddressedtwogoalsinthisstudy.First,Iexaminedtheextentofsympatriclocationsbyconductinglandscape-scalesurveys(ratherthanusingpastdistributionmaps).second,Imonitoredfoursympatricsitesoverthreeyearstodeter-minewhethertherelativepopulationsizeofeitherspecieschangedovertime(i.e.,whethertheconditionofsympatrywasstableortransient). Duringtheperiodwhenthefoursympatricsitesweremonitored,oneoftheselocationswasstronglyaffectedbyaflood,anotherlocationwasweaklyaffectedbythesameflood,andtwolocationswerephysicallyundisturbedduringthestudy.thisdisturbanceprovidedanaturalexperi-menttoaddresstherelativeimpactoffloodingonthesepopulationsovertime.Floodingisacommondisturbanceofsalamanderassemblagesinbothaquaticandterrestrialsystems;however,moststudieshavefocusedonaquaticandsemi-aquaticspecies.Insomeinstances,individualsthatsurvivefloodingcanexhibitindicationsofcompetitiverelease(petrankaandsih1986);however,otherspeciesrequirealongertimeperiodforrecovery
(swansonetal.1998).theimpactoffloodsonterrestrialsalamandersislargelyunknown.
Materials and MethodsSpecies Co-occurrence.—Iconductedlandscape-scalesurveysofspeciespresenceduringspring2007andfall2007.toconducttheselandscape-scalesurveys,IsearchedforlocationswithinthedistributionaloverlapofP. cinereusandP. electromorphus.Iidentifiedlocationsonlywithincoun-tieswherebothspecieshavebeenfound(sympatriccounties)accordingtodistributionmapsofohio(pfingstonandmatson2003).Ichose21sympatriccountiesfromnortheasternohio(fromallpossiblesympatriccounties)becausethisareacontainedaconcentrationoftownships(sub-divisionsofcounties)wherebothspecieshavebeenfound(pfingstonandmatson2003).Withineachofthese21sympatriccounties,Iidentifiedlocationsthatcouldcontainsalamandersbyusingtopographicmapstodeterminewhichareascontainedwoodedhabitat.Afterarrivingataloca-tion,iftheareawasindeedsuitablehabitat,Isearchedforsalamanders.Ateachoftheselocations,IrecordedthenumberofindividualsofP. cinereusand/orP. electromorphusatthatlocation.eachlocationwassearchedforaminimumof20minutestodeterminethepresenceofsalamanders.Ifanysalamanderswerefound,theareawassearchedexhaustively(i.e.,allcoverobjectswereoverturnedandtheboundariesofeachsiteweredelineatedbyrivers,roads,ornon-forestedprivateproperty).Iadaptedthedistribu-tionmapsofpfingsonandmatson(2003)usingtheselocationsaswellasthelocationsmentionedbelow(sitesA,b,C,andD),whichalsowerelocatedwithinsympatriccounties(mapisdescribedinresults).locationswhereIfoundnosalamandersmighthavecontainedsalamanders;however,theseareaswerenotincludedintheanalysisdescribedbelowandtherefore
Fig. 3.siteA,wherefloodingsweptmostofthecoverobjectsfromtheslopesoftheravineintothestream.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 9
didnotinfluenceresults.Iamconfidentthatlocationsdescribedasbeingallopatricwereindeedallopatricbecause:(1)eachlocationwassearchedexhaustively,and(2)whensympatriclocationswereidentified,minimalsearcheffortfoundbothspecies(searchtimeaslowas5minandtwototalsalamandersconfirmedthepresenceofbothspecies).Also,whenanaly-seswerecalculatedexcludingsiteswithfewerthanfivetotalsalamanders,resultswerethesame.notethatIfocusedonlyoncountieswherebothspecieshadbeendocumented,and,thus,hadthebestchanceoffindingsympatriclocationsiftheyexisted. totestthehypothesisthatP. cinereusandP. electromorphusco-occurlessfrequentlythanexpectedbychance,Iusedthecollectiondataobtainedfromthelandscape-scalesurveystoconstructapresence/absencematrix.thismatrixwasusedtodeterminewhetherco-occurrencebetweenP. cinereus andP. electromorphuswasbestdescribedassegregation,aggrega-tion,orrandom.IusedtheC-scoreindex(stoneandRoberts1990)asameasureofco-occurrence.thisindexiscalculatedas:
Cij=(ri–S)(rj–S)
wheresisthenumberofsharedsites(sitescontainingbothspecies)andriandrjarethenumberofoccurrences(rowtotals)forspeciesiandj.IftheC-scorewasgreaterthanexpectedbychance,speciessegregate;iftheC-scorewas smaller thanexpectedbychance, speciesaggregate. IusedecosimVersion7.0(Gotelliandentsminger2007)tocomparetheobservedC-scoretotheaverageC-scoregeneratedfrom10,000randomlyconstructedassemblages.Iusedamodelwhererowvalueswereretainedsoeachspeciesonlyoccurredasoftenasintheobservedmatrix(fixedsum)andwheresites(columns)areequallylikelytoberepresented(equiprob-
able),eliminatingobserveddifferencesinspeciesrichnessofsitesinthenullassemblages.
Flood.—Ilocatedfoursympatricsitesinohioduringspring2004.siteAwas~3mieoflisboninelkRuntownship,ColumbianaCounty(40°46’04”n,80°43’33”W);sitebwas10minoflisbon insalemtownship,ColumbianaCounty(40°49’48”n,80°49’19”W);siteCwas12mineofnewarkinperrytownship,lickingCounty(40°10’01”n,82°15’28”W);andsiteDwas9minofnewarkinWashingtontownship,lickingCounty(40°11’27”n,82°26’38”W).thesefoursitesweremoni-toredduringsevencollectingtripsfromspring2004tofall2007.springcollectingtripsin2004,2005,and2007occurredinearlymay,andfallcollectingtripsin2004,2005,2006,and2007occurredinlateseptemberandearlyoctober.thesefoursitesweresimilarincompositioninthattheyalloccurredintemperatedeciduousforestineast-centralohio.DuringlateAugustandseptember2004,severeandfrequentrainsresultedinflood-ingofsitesAandb.WhensiteAwasvisitedon25september2004,Iobservedthatmostoftherocks(usedascoverobjectsbysalamanders)andleaflitter(usedforforagingandrefugiaduringdryerconditions)hadbeensweptintoaravinelocatedwithinthesite(Fig.3).salamanderhabitatatsitebwasalsodisturbedbytheflood,butnotasseverely,andmanycoverobjectsremainedontheslope.sitesCandDwerenotfloodedduringthestudyperiod. Duringvisitstoeachsite,IcollectedadultP. cinereusandP. elec-tromorphusandrecordedthenumberofindividualsofeachspecies.Duringfall2004,sitesbandCweresearcheduntilapproximately25salamandersofeachspecieswerecollectedforotherresearch.therefore,thiscollectingseasonwasnotincludedintheanalyses
WIDe-RAnGInGsAlAmAnDeRspeCIes
Fig. 4.photographofalocationwithallopatricPlethodon cinereus.thislocationwas8minWofnewarkinmcKeantownship,lickingCounty(40°08’06”n,82°32’05”W).
10 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
andisreportedonlybecausethiswasthecollectionthatoccurredimmediatelyafterthefloodandsiteAcontainedonlyonesalaman-der.Allcollectingwasconductedat0700–1100h,andallsalaman-derswerecapturedbyhand.Allsitesduringeachcollectionseasonweresearchedexhaustively(allcoverobjectswereoverturnedandtheboundariesofeachsiteweredelineatedbyrivers,roads,ornon-forestedprivateproperty).therefore,theareaateachsitethatwassearchedwasthesameforeachcollectionseason.Unfortunately,timespentcollectingsalamanderswasnotrecordedforthefirstcollectingseason(spring2004).threepeoplecollectedsalamandersduringthisseasonandeachsitewassearchedforapproximately1–2h(3–6col-lectingh/site).Forallothercollectingseasons,twopeoplecollectedsalamanders,andcollectioneffortpersitewassimilar(siteA:3heachcollectionseason;siteb:2–4h;siteC:2.5–4h;siteD:2h).thegoalofthispaperwastoestimatetherelativenumberofindividualsofP. cinereusandP. electromorphus,soactualpopulationsizeswerenotestimated.Instead,thenumberofindividualsofeachspeciesencoun-teredwasusedtocalculatetheproportionofP. cinereusateachsiteforeachseason,andthismeasureisreferredtoas“relativepopulationsize.”todetermineifthisproportionchangedsignificantlyovertime,Icomparedtheproportionfoundduringthesecondthroughseventhcollectingseasons(post-flood)totheproportionfoundduringthefirstcollectingseason(pre-flood)usingchi-squaretestswitha=0.05.
ResultsSpecies Co-occurrence.—Ifound20allopatriclocationsforP. cinereus (Fig.4),nineallopatriclocationsforP. electromorphus(twolocationswerewithinthesametownship),and12sympatriclocations;Ididnotfindanysalamandersin27townships.Fortheadaptedmap(Fig.5),eachtown-shipwascodedascontainingallopatricP. cinereus,allopatricP. electromor-
phus,bothspecies(sympatric), orneitherspecies.Plethodon cinereusandP. electromorphusco-occurredlessfrequentlythanwasexpectedbychance(C-score=180;p=0.0008).therefore,thedistributionsofP. cinereusandP. electromorphusinregardtothepresenceoftheotherspecieswouldbebestdescribedassegregation,asopposedtoaggregationorrandom.
Flood.—overthecourseofthisstudy,P. cinereuswasmorecommonthanP. electromorphus atallmonitoredsympatricsites.Atbothfloodsites(Aandb),IrecordedatemporalpatterninwhichP. cinereussignificantlyincreasedinrelativepopulationsizecomparedtoP. electromorphus(table1).Furthermore,infall2004(immediatelyaftertheflood),IfoundonlyoneadultP. cinereusandnoP. electromorphusatsiteA.Atthenon-floodedsites(CandD),relativepopulationsizesofP. cinereusandP. electromorphus didnotchangesignificantly(table1).morespecifically,atsiteC,anon-significantincreaseinP. cinereusoccurreduntilfall2006,whentherelativepopulationsizesweresimilartothefirstcollectingseason.WhilethechangewasnotsignificantatsiteD,noP. electromorphuswerefoundduringthefinalcollectingseason.
DiscussionthefirstgoalofthisstudywastoexaminetheextentofsympatrybetweenP. cinereusandP. electromorphusinohio,andIaddressedthisgoalbycon-ductinglandscape-scalesurveys.IfoundthatallopatricsitesofP. cinereusaremorecommonthansympatricsitesandallopatricsitesofP. electro-morphus,thatco-occurrencewaslessthanexpectedbychance,andthat,atsympatricsites,P. cinereusismoreabundant.thesecondgoalofthisstudywastomonitorsympatriclocationstodetermineiftheconditionofsym-patrywasstableovertime.Ifoundthatatonelocation,localextinctionofP. electromorphusmighthaveoccurred(siteD);atonelocation,therelativenumberofeachspeciesremainedapproximatelythesame(siteC);andattwolocations,therelativepopulationsizeofP. cinereusincreasedovertime(sitesAandb),butthesiteremainedsympatric. FloodingoccurredatthetwositeswhereP. cinereusincreased,sug-gestingthatfloodingcouldaffectrelativepopulationsizesofeachspecies.Furthermore,P. cinereusreturnedmorequicklyafterthefloodtositeAthanP. electromorphus.Atsiteb,wherefloodingoccurredbutdidnotdestroytheentireterrestrialhabitat,thecommunitychangedsignificantly,butthischangeoccurredoveralongertimeperiod.thismajordisturbanceappearedtoaffectthepopulationofP. electromorphus morethanthepopu-lationofP. cinereus.evidencesuggeststhatfloodinginfluencestherelativepopulationsizeofthesespeciesthroughoneofthree,non-mutuallyexclu-sivemechanisms:(1)enhancedcompetitiveexclusionofP. electromorphusbyP. cinereus,(2)achangeofenvironmentalcharacteristicsatthefloodedsites,makingthesesitesunsuitableforP. electromorphus,or(3)aslowerrateofreestablishmentforP. electromorphus relativetoP. cinereus. tomyknowledge,thisisthefirststudythatexaminedtheeffectsoffloodingonterrestrialsalamanders.naturaldisturbanceevents,suchasflooding,providerareopportunitiestostudypopulationdynamicsthatcannotbeunderstoodwithlaboratoryexperiments.Floodingcandisruptpopulationsofterrestrialsalamandersinmultipleways,includingdamag-ingthephysicalenvironmentbyremovingcoverobjectsthatarerequiredfortheirsurvival,decreasingpopulationsizesofpotentialcompetitorsandpredators,ortemporarilyremovingallindividuals. Inthissystem,localdistributionpatternsrevealthatcomplexinterac-tionsoccurbetweenthesetwospeciesandpossiblywiththeenvironmentorotherspecies(suchaspredators)notstudied.Competitionoftenplayssomeroleintheinteractionsofspecies,buttheimportanceofitseffectsinacom-munityarecontext-dependentandotherfactorsareimportantaswell(telloetal.2008),Forexample,disturbancehistory(hydeandsimons2001)andpredation(Connell1975)cansuppressdensitiestochronicallylowlevels,sothatsharedresourcesneverbecomelimiting—whichwouldpromoteco-occurrence.Unfortunately,theeffectofpredatorsoncommunitiesofPlethodonisunderstudiedandshouldbeexamined.Afullunderstandingof
Fig. 5.ResultsoflandscapesurveysofPlethodon cinereus andP. electromorphusinohioshowingsurveyedtownshipsoutlinedinblack(mapsadaptedfromohioDepartmentoftransportation2007).townshipswithsympatriclocationsarefilledwithblack,allopatricP. cinereuslocationswithlightgray,andallopatricP. electromorphuslocationswithdarkgray.townshipswhereIfoundnosalamandersarewhite.
DeItloFF
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 11
theroleofcompetition,predation,andenvironmentalconditionsinregulat-ingpopulationsrequiresbroadspatialandtemporalstudies(petrankaandsih1986)andwasbeyondthescopeofthisinvestigation.Futurestudiesshouldleadtoanunderstandingoftherelativeinfluenceofcompetition,predation,anddisturbanceinthecommunitydynamicsofterrestrialsalamanders.
AcknowledgementsIthankD.C.Adams,C.berns,K.barrett,J.o.Church,s.Graham,C.Guyer,V.Johnson,D.laurencio,e.m.myers,C.m.Romagosa,andD.A.steenforreadingdraftsofthiswork,andC.D.Anthony,J.o.Church,C.m.hickerson,e.m.myers,J.erickson,andG.Riceforhelpincollect-ingsalamanders.salamanderswerecollectedunderohioDepartmentofnaturalResources,DivisionofWildlifepermits122(2004),13(2005),144(2006),and299(2007),andwerehousedinaccordancewithIowa
stateUniversityCommitteeonAnimalCarepolicies(IACUC3-04-5618-D).thisresearchwassupportedbyaUsDAIFAFsmultidisciplinaryGraduateeducationtrainingGrant(2001-52100-11506).
Literature CitedAdams,D.C.2007.organizationofPlethodon salamandercommunities:Guild-
basedcommunityassembly.Ecology88:1292–1299.
Adams,D.C.andF.J.Rohlf.2000.ecologicalcharacterdisplacementinPlethodon:biomechanicaldifferences foundfromageometricmorphometric study.Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, U.S.A.97:4106–4111.
Anthony,C.D.,J.A.Wicknick,andR.G.Jaeger.1997.socialinteractionsintwosympatricsalamanders:effectivenessofahighlyaggressivestrategy.Behaviour134:71–88.
Arif,s.,D.C.Adams,andJ.A.Wicknick.2007.bioclimaticmodeling,morphology,andbehaviorrevealalternativemechanismsregulatingthedistributionsoftwoparapatricsalamanderspecies.Evolutionary Ecology Research9:843–854.
bowers,m.A.andJ.h.brown.1982.bodysizeandco-existenceindesertrodents:Chanceorcommunitystructure?Ecology63:391–400.
Connell,J.h.1975.somemechanismsproducingstructureinnaturalcommuni-ties:Amodelandevidencefromfieldexperiments,pp.460–490.In:m.l.Cody and J.m.Diamond (eds.),Ecology and Evolution of Communities.harvardUniversitypress,Cambridge,massachusetts.
Deitloff,J.,D.C.Adams,b.F.m.olechnowski,andR.G.Jaeger.2008.InterspecificaggressioninohioPlethodon:Implicationsforcompetition.Herpetologica24:180–188.
Deitloff,J.,J.o.Church,D.C.Adams,andR.G.Jaeger.2009.Interspecificagonis-ticbehavioursinasalamandercommunity:Implicationsforalpha-selection.Herpetologica65:174–182.
Gotelli,n.J.andG.l.entsminger.2007.ecosim:nullmodelssoftwareforecol-ogy.Version7.72.(<http://garyentsminger.com/ecosum.htm>).AcquiredIntelligenceInc.&Kesey-bear,Jericho,Vermont.
hairston,n.G.1980.theexperimentaltestofanalysisoffielddistributions:com-petitioninterrestrialsalamanders.Ecology61:817–826.
harvey,p.h.andm.D.pagel.1991.TheComparative Method in Evolutionary Biology.oxfordUniversitypress,oxford,england.
hyde,e.J.andt.R.simons.2001.samplingplethodontidsalamanders:sourcesofvariability.The Journal of Wildlife Management65:624–632.
Jaeger,R.G.1970.potentialextinctionthroughcompetitionbetweentwospeciesofterrestrialsalamanders.Evolution 24:632–642.
Jaeger,R.G.1971.Competitiveexclusionasafactorinfluencingthedistributionsoftwospeciesofterrestrialsalamanders.Ecology52:632–637.
letcher,A.J.,A.purvis,s.nee,andp.h.harvey.1994.patternsofoverlapinthegeographicrangesofpalearticandbritishmammals.The Journal of Animal Ecology63:871–879.
marshall,J.l.,C.D.Camp,andR.G.Jaeger.2004.potentialinterferencecompe-titionbetweenapatchilydistributedsalamander(Plethodon petraeus)andasympatriccongener(Plethodon glutinosus).Copeia2004:488–495.
myers,e.m.andD.C.Adams.2008.morphologyisdecoupledfrominterspe-cificcompetitioninPlethodon salamandersintheshenandoahmountains.Herpetologica64:281–289.
nishikawa,K.C.1985.Competitionandtheevolutionofaggressivebehaviorintwospeciesofterrestrialsalamanders.Evolution39:1282–1294.
nishikawa,K.C.1987.Interspecificaggressivebehaviourinsalamanders:species-specificinterferenceormisidentification.Animal Behaviour35:263–270.
petranka,J.W.1998.Salamanders of the United States and Canada.smithsonianInstitutionpress,Washington,D.C.
petranka,J.W.andA.sih.1986.environmental instability,competition,anddensity-dependentgrowthandsurvivorshipofastream-dwellingsalamander.Ecology67:729–736.
pfingsten,R.A.andt.o.matson.2003.Ohio Salamander Atlas.ohiobiologicalsurvey,Columbus,ohio.
stone,l.,andA.Roberts.1990.thecheckerboardscoreandspeciesdistributions.Oecologia85:74–79.
swanson,F.J.,s.l.Johnson,s.V.Gregory,ands.A.Acher.1998.Flooddistur-banceinaforestedmountainlandscape.BioScience48:681–689.
tello,J.s.,R.D.stevens,andC.W.Dick.2008.patternsofspeciesco-occurrenceanddensitycompensation:atestforinterspecificcompetitioninbatectopara-siteinfracommunities.Oikos117:693–702.
WIDe-RAnGInGsAlAmAnDeRspeCIes
Table 1.numberofindividuals(n)ofeachspeciescollectedduringsam-plingperiodsandtheproportionoftotalindividualsthatwereP. cinereus(%pc).AtsiteAduringfall2006and2007,theproportionofP. cinereustoP. electromorphusissignificantlygreaterduringthefirstcollectionseasonindicatingtheimpactofthefloodonrelativepopulationsizes.Inaddition,atsitebwhereminorfloodingoccurred,theproportionofP. cinereustoP. electromorphusissignificantlygreaterduringfall2006and2007.p-values(p)fromchi-squaretestsareprovided.
P. P. electro- cinereus morphus (n) (n) %Pc P
Site A: Flood Site
spring2004 34 8 0.81 0—
Fall2004 1 0 0— 0—
Fall2005 32 4 0.89 0.23
Fall2006 33 1 0.97 0.02*
spring2007 15 1 0.94 0.19
Fall2007 40 3 0.93 0.04*
Site B: Weak flooding
spring2004 23 9 0.72 0—
Fall2004** 25 22 0.53 0—
spring2005 27 5 0.84 0.12
Fall2006 58 2 0.97 <0.0001*
spring2007 22 5 0.81 0.27
Fall2007 17 1 0.94 0.03*
Site C: No flooding
spring2004 49 13 0.79 0—
Fall2004** 25 25 0.50 0—
spring2005 28 3 0.90 0.12
Fall2006 82 28 0.75 0.25
Site D: No flooding
spring2004 25 3 0.89 0—
Fall2004 8 1 0.89 0.97
spring2007 7 0 1.00 0.36
*IndicatessignificantdifferencesbetweenthepercentofPlethodon cinereusduringfirstcollectingseasonandsubsequentcollectingseasons.
**thenumberofsalamanderscollectedwasintentionallyapproximately25foreachspecies.thesecollectingseasonswereomittedfromanalyses.
12 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
maleSphaerodactylus thompsonifromalocalityofftheAlcoaRoad,northofCaboRojo.thisindividualisonalimestonerockthattypifiesthepreferredsubstrateofthisspeciesinthearea.
sCAntlebURYetAl.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 13
DwarfgeckosofthegenusSphaerodactylus(“sphaeros”)areoneofthedominantcomponentsoftheWestIndianherpetofaunainterms
ofspeciesrichnessandsheerlocalabundance—88WestIndianspeciesandnumeroussubspeciesarepresentlyrecognized(hendersonandpowell2009)andsomepopulationsapproachdensitiesof60,000/ha(Roddaetal.2001).Indeed,theyaresuchaubiquitousfeatureofCaribbeanherpetologythatsphaerosandrummightwellbestaplesofCaribbeanislands.thesegeckosoccupythefullscopeofavailablehabitatsintheWestIndies—coastalregionsincludingmangrovethickets,cactus-coveredxericbadlands,andmontanecloudforests.
sphaerosaretinygeckos,andincludethesmallestamniotespecies(hedgesandthomas2001).overall,thegenusisconsideredtobediur-nallyactive,althoughnocturnalactivityisreportedforafewspecies.mostspeciesliveasecretive,semi-fossoriallifestylethat,coupledwiththeirmin-isculesize,rendersobservationchallenging(e.g.,hendersonandpowell2009).thisdifficultyhasnodoubtcontributedtothefactthatwecur-rentlyknownexttonothingabouttheirbehavior,ecology,distributions,andfunctionalmorphology.thisdearthofknowledge,however,makessphaerosveryrewardinganimalstostudy.Almosteverydayoffieldworkspentonthesegeckosgeneratesnewdiscoveries.Inthispaper,wediscuss
notes on activity Patterns of five species of Sphaerodactylus (squamata: sphaerodactylidae)
from the Dominican RepublicDanielp.scantlebury1,Julienneng1,miguellandestoy2,AnthonyJ.Geneva1,andRicharde.Glor1
1Departmentofbiology,UniversityofRochester,Rochester,newYork14627-0211,UsA([email protected])2ministeriodemedioAmbienteyRecursosnaturales,santoDomingo,DominicanRepublic;sociedadornitologicadelahispaniola,santoDomingo,
DominicanRepublic([email protected])
photographsbytheseniorauthorexceptwherenoted.
SPhaerodaCtyluSIntheDomInICAnRepUblIC
maleSphaerodactylus ladaefromparquenacionalFrancisCaamaño.
MiG
ueL
La
nd
esto
y
14 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
somerecentobservationsofnocturnalorcrepuscularactivitypatternsinfivepoorlyknownspeciesfromtheDominicanRepublic. nocturnalityistheancestrallifestyleforgeckos,althoughdiurnal-ityhasevolvedmultipletimes.Infact,thefamilysphaerodactylidaecon-tainsamixtureofdiurnalandnocturnalspecies.thegeneraAristelliger,Saurodactylus,Euleptes, andTeratoscincus arepredominatelynocturnal(althoughsomespeciesofAristelligerareknowntobaskonexposedsur-facesduringtheday;hendersonandpowell2009).everyothergenusinthefamilyislargelydiurnal,althoughnocturnalorcrepuscularspeciesareknownfromGonatodes,Pristurus,andSphaerodactylus.sphaeroswithrecordednocturnalactivitypatternsincludeS. inaguae,fromxericcoastalareas in thebahamas,S. roosevelti, fromxeric forestsof southwesternpuertoRico,S. savageifromthexericsoutheasterncoastoftheDominicanRepublic,andS. sputatorfromthenorthernlesserAntilles(referencesinschwartzandhenderson1991,hendersonandpowell2009). Inspectionofwherethesespeciesfallwithinpublishedphylogenies(hass1991,Gambleetal.2008)suggeststhatnocturnalityhasevolvedmultipletimeswithinSphaerodactylus.however,thedifferencesbetweendiurnalandnocturnallifestylesmaybeexaggeratedbyhumanperception.becausesphaerosarelargelysemi-fossorial,theymaybe“activeinaper-petualtwilight”(hendersonandpowell2009)regardlessofthetimeofday.therefore,evendiurnallyactivesphaerosmightpossesstheocularmorphol-ogymoretypicalofnocturnallizards.Inanycase,solittleisknownaboutthesegeckosthatabasicunderstandingofactivitypatternsiscriticalfor
accuratesurveywork.Indeed,formostspecies,nopublisheddataaddressactivitypatterns.
Sphaerodactylus leucaster and S. thompsoniSphaerodactylus leucaster andS. thompsoniarepoorlyknownxerophilicgeckosfromhispaniola.DuringrecentresearchtripstotheDominicanRepublic,wecollectedindividualsofthesespeciesunderdeadAgaveplantsandrocks,respectively,duringtheday.shortlyaftercollectingtheseani-mals,wenotedthepresenceofverticallyellipticalpupils,whichstandsincontrasttotheroundpupilcharacteristicofmostspeciesinthegenus,andismoretypicalofnocturnalgeckos.Consideringtheoppressiveheatofthehabitat(exposedsurfacetemperaturesoftensurpass60°Cduringtheheatoftheday),wedecidedtosurveyhabitatsatnighttoseeifthesegeckoswereactive,andperhapsmoreabundantthandaytimesurveysimplied. onsuccessivenights,weobservedmultipleanimalsofbothspeciesmovingaroundonexposedsurfaces.ForS. leucaster,weobservedatotalof20individuals(alladultsorsub-adults)overthecourseoftwoseparatenights(21August2009,14January2010)onakarst-strewnhillsidesouthofmonteRío,Azuaprovince.Wefoundindividualsofbothsexesonthegroundoronthesidesofrocksrevealedbydirectencountersorreflectiveeye-shines.oncedisturbed,geckoswouldrunforthenearestcover,whichwaseitherdeadAgaveorkarsttalus.ForS. thompsoni,weobserved>30ani-malsduringmultiplenightsofsearching(August2009andJanuary2010)andatmultiplelocalitiesalongtheAlcoaRoadbetweenCaboRojoandlasmercedes.thegeckoswereonkarstrocksat2000–2300h,andincludedbothsexesandallageclasses.Animalswerefrequentlyfoundonverticalrockfaces,andwererarelyfarfromcrevices.Anumberofanimalsalsowerefoundbyflippingsmalltaluspiles.Insuchinstances,geckoswereoftenontheundersidesoftherocks.Wefoundmoreanimalsinthesepilesatnightthanwedidwithsimilareffortduringtheday.ourfieldobservationsarerecapitulatedforbothspeciesbycaptivespecimens;animalsemergeafterthelightsareturnedoffandremainactiveforseveralhours. WecollectedmicrohabitattemperaturedataforsomeindividualsofS. thompsonibyusinganinfraredtemperatureguntorecordthesurfacetemperatureatthesiteofencounter.theaveragesurfacetemperaturewas31.9±1.5°C(n=6).Wealsorecordedthetemperatureofactive,butundisturbed,tarantulas(Phormictopus cancerides),whichwehavewitnessedkillingSphaerodactylusladae.theaveragetarantulatemperaturewas29.1±0.8°C(n=3).Althoughthesamplesizeissmall,astudent’sttestindicatedthatthedifferenceinaveragetemperaturesofthesespecieswassignificant(t =2.97,df=7,p=0.02).theselimitedandadmittedlyverypreliminarydatasuggestthatinteractionsbetweentarantulasandgeckosmightbeminimizedbydifferentthermalpreferences.
sCAntlebURYetAl.
maleSphaerodactylus leucasterfromthekarsthillsofmonteRío,southofAzua.thislizardwasactiveatnight.
Juvenile femaleSphaerodactylus ladaecollectedatnight fromparquenacionalFrancisCaamaño.
FemaleSphaerodactylus cryphiusfromanoldrockquarrybetweenDuvergéandJimaní.thescaleisinmm.thisgeckowascollectedasanadultunderneathadeadAgaveduringtheafternooninAugust2008;sheisstillaliveasof27January2011.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 15
Sphaerodactylus ladaeSphaerodactylus ladaeisknownonlyfromtheDominicanRepublic,whereitinhabitsthescrubbyfoothillsofthesierrademartínGarcíaandthesur-roundinglowlandstowardthecityofAzua.WehavecollectedthisspeciesfromnearRancheríaandatparquenacionalFrancisCaamaño.toourknowledge,thelattersiterepresentsthemostnorthernandeasternrecordsforthisspecies.Geckoswereabundantatbothsites.AtRanchería,wecol-lectedanimalsduringthedayfrombeneathdeadandrottingAgaveplants,completelyoblivioustowhatwewoulddiscoverlateratparquenacionalFrancisCaamaño.InJanuary2010,oneofus(ml)visitedtheparktopho-tographtheareaatsunsetandconductapreliminarysurveyoftheareaatnight.thistripresultedinthecollectionofthreeadultS. ladae,whichweremovingaround,fullyexposed,justaftersunset.WerevisitedthesiteoneyearlaterinJanuary2011at2200–2300handfoundfiveanimalsactivelymovingaroundinshallowleaflittercollectedonaboulder-strewnhillside.Allwerefemaleandincludedtwoadultsandthreejuveniles(Dpssexedthembasedonpatternandtheabsenceofanenlargedescutcheonpatch).Weobservedbutfailedtosecureanadditionalthreeanimals.thehabitatatthissiteconsistsofkarstlimestoneboulderswithashortscrubcanopy.theexposedgroundbetweenlargerocksconsistsofshallowleaflitteratopgravel.Weobservedallofthegeckoscompletelyexposedonthesepatchesofleaflitter. We also collected three S. leucaster at parque nacional FrancisCaamaño,wheretheyoccursympatricallywithS. ladae.oneadultfemaleandtwojuvenileswereactiveat2200–2300hinexposedpatchesofleaflitteradjacenttolargelimestonerocks.sympatrybetweenS. ladaeandS. leucasterisnoteworthybecausethesespeciesaresimilarinsize,activitypat-tern,andappearance(maleshaveapalegraybodywithastreaked,brightyellowhead;femalesareadullpurple-gray,withbolddorsolaterallines).
Sphaerodactylus cryphiusAfinalxerophilicspecieswehaveobservedwhileactiveatnightisS. cry-phius.thisobservation,however,islimitedtoasingleindividualobservedafter2200hcrawlinginleaflitternearthebaseofalimestonecliffatanoldrockquarrybetweenDuvergéandJimaní.Additionalworkisnecessarytoclarifyifthisisanisolatedincidentortypicalofthisspecies.
Sphaerodactylus cochranaeSphaerodactylus cochranaeisknownonlyfromthesouthernshoreofthebahíadesamaná.thisbeautifulandrarelyseenspecieshasbeencol-lectedbyonlyasmallhandfulofherpetologists.on11september2009at1800–1845h(justarounddusk),weobservedfourgeckoswithina50-mradiusonleaflitternearthecoastinparquenacionalloshaitises.threeofthesightingswerebetween1830and1845h,suggestingthattheywerejustbecomingactive.Alternatively,theanimalswereendingactivityandseekingroostingspots;however,thisseemsunlikely,consideringthatwespentmuchofthedayinsuitablehabitatanddidnotcollectanyindi-viduals.Additionally,previousinformalnighttimesurveysinloshaitisesconductedin1996–1998byoneofus(ReG)recoveredactiveS. cochranaeinandaroundbromeliads.
DiscussionoursuccessinfindingandcollectingS. ladae, S. leucaster, andS. thompsoni increasedatnight.Furthermore,wesubstantiallyreducedourimpactonthehabitatduringnocturnalsearchesbecausewedidnothavetodisturbdeadAgavesandrockpiles.ConsideringtheclosephylogeneticrelationshipofS. leucasterandS. thompsoni,wehypothesizethattherelatedspeciesS. asterulus, S. rhabdotus,andS. shrevei,whichalsoinhabitxerichabitats,are
SPhaerodaCtyluSIntheDomInICAnRepUblIC
FemaleSphaerodactylus cochranaeperchedonthetopleafofabromeliadthatiscommonatlocalitieswherethisspecieslives.thesegeckoshavebeenseencrawlingintheaxilsofthisplantatnight.
riC
ha
rd
e. G
Lor
16 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 sCAntlebURYetAl.
alsonocturnalandmightoccuringreaterabundancethandaytimesurveysimply.similarly,S. schuberti,thepresumedrelativeofS. ladaefromthesierradeneiba(thomasandhedges1998),mightbenocturnalaswell.Sphaerodactylus schubertiisonlyknownfromthetypelocality,butthisareaisverysimilartohabitatsinwhichwehavecollectedS. ladae.similarly,therangesofthesespeciesmightwellhavebeenunderestimated. ImaginingageckoassmallasS. cryphiussurvivinginbrutallyhotanddryhabitatsisdifficult.nocturnalbehaviorcouldconceivablyallowthis
speciestoforagewhensurfacetemperatureshavecooledsubstantiallyfromdaytimehighs.however,wemustnotethatweneverobservedS. plummeriactiveatnightduringsurveysforS. thompsoni.Sphaerodactylus plummeriisapproximatelythesamesizeasS. cryphiusandlivesinsimilarhabitatsonthesouthernpartofthebarahonapeninsula.however,wereadilycol-lectedS. plummeriduringthedayatthesamesitesatwhichwecollectedS. thompsonithenightbefore.Althoughmoreresearchisnecessary,thisishighlysuggestiveoftemporalnichepartitioning.
AfisheyeviewoftypicalhabitatofSphaerodactylus thompsoniandS. plummeri.notethehighpercentageofexposedsurfacesandxerophyticvegetation.
CoastalleaflitterinparquenacionalloshaitiseswherewecollectedSphaerodactylus cochranae.theorangeflaginthecenteroftheimagedenotestheexactplacewhereageckowasfirstseen.
AfisheyeviewofthehabitatwherewecollectedSphaerodactylus cryphiusandS. rhab-dotusduringtheday.thishabitat,withamixtureofscrubvegetation,deadAgave,andlimestonerocksistypicaloflocalitieswherewehavecollectedS. ladaeandS. leucaster.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 17SPhaerodaCtyluSIntheDomInICAnRepUblIC
nocturnalityhasevolvedmultipletimeswithinSphaerodactylus,andnoc-turnalsphaerosarelargelyrestrictedtohotanddryhabitats.Althoughamorerigorouscomparativeanalysisisnecessary(andforthcoming),wehypothesizethatnocturnalityisanadaptationtoxericconditionsasitwouldalmostcer-tainlyreduceevaporativewaterlossbyrestrictingactivitytocoolerperiods.suchtransitionsbetweenactivitypatternsmaybefacilitatedifsphaerosarealreadypre-adaptedtolow-lightconditionsbecauseoftheirsemi-fossorialnature.Futureworkshouldinvestigatetheocularmorphologyofspeciesinacomparativeframework,aswellasquantifyactivityacrossspeciesintermsofambientlightconditions—insteadofemphasizingtimeofday.theobserva-tionthatS. leucasterandS. thompsonipossessverticallyellipticalpupils,typical
ofmostnocturnalgeckos,whereasS. ladaehasroundpupils,suggeststhatmultiplepathscouldfacilitateseeinginthenight.
AcknowledgmentsWehumblythankthesociedadornitologicadelahispaniola,andinpar-ticularJorgebroccaforassistinguswithsecuringpermitsandfieldarrange-mentswhiletravelingintheDominicanRepublic.J.Yoelhernándezpro-videdinvaluableassistanceatparquenacionalFrancisCaamaño.Gabrielde lossantossantanaconfirmed the identityof the tarantulas foundalongsideS. thompsoni.WealsothanktheministeriodemedioAmbienteyRecursosnaturalesinsantoDomingoforprovidinguswithpermitsandassistanceinthefield.thequalityofthismanuscriptbenefitedfromtheinsightfulcommentsoftworeviewers.
Literature CitedGamble,t.,A.m.bauer,e.Greenbaum,andt.R.Jackman.2008.evidence
forGondwananvicarianceinanancientcladeofgeckolizards.Journal of Biogeography35:88–104.
hass,C.A.1991.evolutionandbiogeographyofWestIndianSphaerodactylus(sauria,Gekkonidae)–amolecularapproach.Journal of Zoology225:525–561.
hedges,s.b.andR.thomas.2001.Atthelowersizelimitinamniotevertebrates:AnewdiminutivelizardfromtheWestIndies.Caribbean Journal of Science37:168–173.
henderson,R.W.andR.powell.2009.Natural History of West Indian Reptiles and Amphibians.UniversitypressofFlorida,Gainesville.
Rodda,G.h.,G.perry,R.J.Rondeau,andJ.lazell.2001.thedensestterrestrialvertebrate.Journal of Tropical Ecology17:331–338.
schwartz,A.andR.W.henderson.1991.Amphibians and Reptiles of the West Indies: Descriptions, Distributions, and Natural History.UniversityofFloridapress,Gainesville.
thomas,R. ands.b.hedges.1998.Anewgecko from thesierradeneibaofhispaniola(squamata:Gekkonidae:Sphaerodactylus).Herpetologica54:333–336.
JuvenileSphaerodactylus schuberticollectedatthetypelocalitynearlaDescubiertainAugust2009.
maleSphaerodactylus plummericollectedatthetypelocalityalongtheAlcoaRoadinAugust2009.
18 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 mCGAUGheY,WAllACe,AnDpeRRY
Urbanboxturtles,suchasthisornateboxturtle(Terrapene ornata ornata)inlubbock,frequentlycrossroadsandsometimesgethitbycars.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 19
Herpetofauna admitted to the south Plains Wildlife Rehabilitation center (lubbock, Texas):
a Two-decade Perspectivee.KathleenmcGaughey,markWallace,andGadperry
DepartmentofnaturalResourcemanagement,box42125,texastechUniversity,lubbock,texas79409-2125,UsA
AllphotographsbyGadperryexceptwhereindicated.
morehumansthaneverliveinurbanareas,creatingcomplexenviron-mentalchallengesincludinginteractionswithnativespeciesandthe
introductionofspeciesnotnativetotheregionorevencontinent(Vitouseketal.1997,oldenetal.2006,mitchelletal.2008,Adamsandlindsey2009).Wildliferehabilitationcentersofferavenueforanimalsthathavesufferedfromtheinevitableencountersthatoccurbetweenhumansandanimals,whetherwild(e.g.,animalsinjuredbycarsorpets)orcaptive(e.g.,escapedpets;Karesh1995).theexactnumberofcertifiedwildliferehabili-tatorsintheUnitedstatesisunknown(nationalWildlifeRehabilitatorsAssociation2008),butestimatedat500–1,000(southeasternoutdoors2009,theWildlifeRehabilitationInformationDirectory2008).
thesouthplainsWildlifeRehabilitationCenter(spWRC),locatedinlubbock,texasandservingalargeareainthesouthernplains,rehabili-tatesandreleasesinjured,sick,displaced,ororphanedwildlife(southplainsWildlifeRehabilitationCenter1988).eachyear,spWRCacceptsavarietyofanimals,manyofwhicharenon-nativetotheregion.theadmissionsrecordskeptbythecenterprovideauniquerecordoftheinteractionsofresidentswithreptilesandamphibians,avaluablerecordofthepropagulepressurecontributingtothegrowinginvasiveherpetofauna(e.g.,Kraus2009,powelletal.2011),andhowthesechangeovertime.herewereportthenumbersofnativeandnon-nativeamphibiansandreptilesadmittedtothespWRCovertwodecadesandanalyzebothtaxonomicandtemporalpatterns.ouraimistoassessthemagnitudeofhuman-herpetofaunalinter-actionsinthismid-sizedcity,whichwillhopefullyofferanexampleofwhatmanyotherurbancentersacrossthenationexperience.thesedatacanbeusedtobettermanagesuchinteractionsatacommunitylevelandassistinpreparingarealisticresponseplantonon-nativespeciesarrivals.
MethodsWeexaminedallspWRCadmissionrecordsfortheyears1991–2009.ForeachwerecordedspeciesidentifiedbyspWRCstaff(untilrecently,iden-tificationswereprovidedbynon-herpetologistsandcouldnotbeindepen-dentlyverifiedbyus),arrivaldate,reasontheanimalwasbroughtin,whereitwasfound,injuriessustained(ifany),andultimatedisposition(died,hadtobeeuthanized,orwasreleased).Wecategorizedeachrecordasbelongingtoaspeciesnativeornon-nativetotheregion.Recordsvariedindetail,andnotalldatawereavailableforeachindividualanimal.
soUthplAInsWIlDlIFeRehAbIlItAtIonCenteR
thesehatchlingornateboxturtleshatchedattherehabilitationcenterinlate2010.theywilllikelybereleasednextspringinanappropriatehabitatintown—thisspeciesiscommonandpopularinsidethelubbockcitylimits.
A Red-eared slider (Trachemys scripta elegans) and baby ornate box turtles(Terrapene ornata ornata;atleft)arekeptinsideduringthewinteratthesouthplainsWildlifeRehabilitationCenter.Duringthespringandsummer,thisareanormallyhousesmanymoreturtles.
20 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
ResultsAlmost700individualsbelongingtoatleast43identifiedspecieswereadmit-tedtothespWRCbetween1991and2009.themajorityofthese,626indi-viduals(616reptilesand10amphibiansbelongingtoatleast19species)werenative,andanother52(48reptilesand4amphibians)belongingtoatleast24specieswerenon-native(Fig.1).byfar,mostadmittedindividualswerenativechelonians,primarilyornateboxturtles(Terrapene ornata ornata;n=342)andRed-earedsliders(Trachemys scripta elegans,n=138).Althoughthelatterspeciesisnativetothebroadregion,allorsomeofthesemighthaveoriginatedinthepettrade.othernativeturtlesincludedCommonsnappingturtles(Chelydra serpentina,n=20)andYellowmudturtles(Kinosternon flavescens flavescens,n=15).themostcommonlizardwasthetexashornedlizard(Phrynosoma cornutum,n=36),with1–2individualseachofeasternCollaredlizard(Crotaphytus collaris),lesserearlesslizard(Holbrookia maculata maculata),andanunidentifiedskink(whichmayormaynotbenative;andthereforewasnotincludedwiththenon-natives).themostcommonsnakeswerebullsnakes(Pituophis catenifer sayi,n=15)andCheckeredGartersnakes(Thamnophis marcianus,n=13),with1–2indi-vidualseachofakingsnakespecies(Lampropeltissp.)(which,liketheskink,mayormaynotbenative),GreatplainsRatsnake(Elaphe emoryi),WesternDiamondback(Crotalus atrox),Westernhognose(Heterodon nasicus),andWesternRattlesnake(Crotalus viridis).Amongnativeamphibiansthemostcommonwasthebarredtigersalamander(Ambystoma tigrinum mavortium,n=5),withsmallernumbersofunidentifiedspadefoots,toads,and“frogs”(whichalsomayormaynotbenative)completingthelist. turtlesalsodominatedamongnon-natives,withCommonmuskturtles(Sternotherus odoratus,n=9),Desertboxturtles(Terrapene ornata luteola,n=6), andAfricanspurredtortoises (Centrochelys [formerlyGeochelone]sulcata,n=3)beingthemostcommon,followedbyoneortwoeachoftheDeserttortoise(Gopherus agassizii),texastortoise(Gopherus berlandieri), Red-footed tortoise (Chelonoidis carbonaria), Alligatorsnappingturtle(Macroclemys temminckii),horsfield’stortoise(Testudo horsfieldii),easternboxturtle(Terrapene carolina),sabinemapturtle(Graptemys ouachitensis sabinensis),andWesternspinysoftshell(Apalone spi-nifera hartwegi).Identifiednon-nativearrivalsalsoincluded1–3individualseachofunknowngeckos(presumednon-nativebecausenospeciesisnativetotheregion),GreenIguana(Iguana iguana),monitorlizard(Varanussp.),stripedplateaulizard(Sceloporus virgatus),boaConstrictor(Boa con-strictor),easternCornsnake(Pantherophis guttatus),texasIndigosnake(Drymarchon corais erebennus),plainsGartersnake(Thamnophis radix),bullfrog(Lithobates catesbeianus),Americantoad(Anaxyrus americanus),andWesternspadefoot(Spea hammondii).perhapsmostsurprisingwasthenumberofcrocodilians,mostofwhichwereAmericanAlligators(Alligator mississippiensis,n=5).herpetologicaladmissionsgraduallyincreasedduringthe1990sandremainedroughlystableduringthedecadethatfollowed(Fig.2).theproportionofnon-nativesrangedfrom0–30%oftotaladmissionsforagivenyear,averaging7.6%.turtlesdominatedadmissionsduringtheentirestudyperiod(Fig.3).theirproportionofallherpetologicaladmis-sionsrangedfrom70–100%(includingthreeyearsinwhichallrecordedadmissionswereturtles),averagingabout85%. oftheknownreasonsforadmittanceofnatives,216individualswerereported“injured”(themostcommoninjurybeing“hitbyacar”;othersincludedcrackedshell,impaledwithafishinghook,attackedbyadogorcat,anddisease);57werefoundinorneartheroad,yard,home,orpark;18weresurrenderedpets;andonewasbroughtinforinjuringahuman.Amongnon-natives,knownreasonsforadmittanceweregenerallysimilar:11werefoundintheyard,road,orhome;sevenwereinjured;andthreewereconfiscatedbyauthorities(texasparksandWildlifeorAnimalControl). oftheknowndispositionsfornatives,361individualswerereleased(locationusuallyunspecified),54wereeuthanized,23died,threewerereturnedtothefinder,andtwoweretransferredtoalocalpetshop.Unfortunately,dis-positionsofnon-nativesfollowedasimilarpattern,with21being“released,”seventransferredtoalocalsciencemuseumorazoo,threedead,andtwoeuthanized.
DiscussionnativereptilesandamphibiansmadeupthemajorityofallherpetofaunaenteringspWRCin1991–2009.overallnumbersincreasedduringthe1990s,presumablyaresultofthegreaterexposuretheCenterhasachieved
Fig. 3.RelativeimportanceofcheloniansinherpetologicaladmissionsbythesouthplainsWildlifeRehabilitationCenterin1991–2009.
mCGAUGheY,WAllACe,AnDpeRRY
Fig. 1.numbersofamphibiansandreptilesadmittedbythesouthplainsWildlifeRehabilitationCenterovertheentireperiod1991–2009.
Fig. 2.numbersofnativesandnon-nativesadmittedbythesouthplainsWildlifeRehabilitationCenterin1991–2009.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 21
duringthisperiod,followingitsestablishmentin1988.mostanimalswerebroughtinbecauseofaninjuryand~20%eitherdiedorhadtobeeutha-nized.thisleftthespWRCwithasubstantialnumberofnow-healthyani-malsinneedofdisposition;mostofthesewerereleasedintownornearby.
percythepelicanisoneofmanyrehabilitatedanimalsatthecenter.
Achildexaminesastatueofaraptorintheareareservedforpresentationsforthegeneralpublic.educationisabigpartofthemissionofthecenter.
soUthplAInsWIlDlIFeRehAbIlItAtIonCenteR
Citizensdropoffanimalsinthisbuildingattheentrancetothecenter.theyareaskedtoprovideinformationaboutcollectioncircumstancesandencouragedtoleaveadonationtohelpdefraythecostsoftreatinganimals.
Duringthesummer,thispondservesashomeforseveralrehabilitatedturtles,mostlyRed-earedsliders.
Amuralofregionalscenery,somenativevegetation,andthecenter’slogowelcomevisitorsattheroadsideentrance.
22 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 mCGAUGheY,WAllACe,AnDpeRRY
non-nativespecies,mostofthemlikelyformerpets,average~8%ofannualadmissions.thisnumbermaybeagrossunder-estimate,becausemanyoftheRed-earedslidersreceivedbythecentermayhaveoriginatedinthepettradeandlikelyrepresentnon-localgenetics.evenignoringthis,thedataincludeseveralalarmingfeatures.First,thenumberofnon-nativespeciesbeingadmittedisslightlylargerthanthatofnatives.second,largeandpotentiallyaggressivespeciessuchascrocodiliansarecommon.third,atleastsomeofthem,suchasthemonitorlizard(asavannahmonitor,Varanus exanthematicus,capturedinabackyard;G.perry,unpubl.data),theRed-earedsliders,andthebullfrogs,arecapableormaybecapableofsurvivinginthelubbockregion.Fourth,ourdatarepresentafar-from-completelistingofsuchanimalsfoundinthecity.Forexample,alargealbinoburmesepython(Python bivittatus)hadbeencapturedbycityper-sonnelandnotdeliveredtothespWRC(G.perry,unpubl.data).Finally,thedispositionofmanyoftheseanimalsisfarfromsatisfactory.thepythonmentionedabovewas“released”intoacitypark(G.perry,unpubl.data),andnearlyallsurvivingnon-nativesweresimilarly“released”byspWRCstaff.ourdatathusshowbothintroductionpathwaysidentifiedbyKraus(2009),unintentional(escapesofpets)andintentional(poorly-considered“releases”).Forlubbock,theyalsosupportthecontentionofKraus(2009)andothersthatthepet-tradeiscurrentlytheprimarysourceofanimalsestablishinginvasivepopulations.Forexample,manyofthenon-nativetur-tleandtortoisespeciesadmittedtospWRCarethosedescribedbyCeballosandFitzgerald(2004)asbeingtradedintexasforpetsand/orfood. ornateboxturtlescomprisedabouthalfofthecheloniansadmittedtothespWRC.thespeciesiscommoninlubbockandoftenencoun-teredbyresidents,whotendtoviewitfavorably(sosa2009,sosaetal.2010).Unfortunately,theoutcomesfor“released”boxturtlesarerarelyhappy(Cook2004,sosa2009),apatternthatiscommonintranslocatedamphibiansandreptiles(Doddandsiegel1991,siegelandDodd2002,Germanoandbishop2008). otherchelonianswerealsoverycommonamongadmittedherpeto-fauna,perhapsbecausetothepublic,turtlesarethemostcharismaticandnon-threateningofallreptilesandamphibians.Consideringthefearthattheyofteninvoke(morrisandmorris1965),wewerepleasantlysurprisedthatquiteafewsnakesandlizardswerealsoadmitted. our study suggests that rehabilitation centers at other locationsmightalsobereceivingsubstantialnumbersofamphibiansandreptiles,anissuewehopethatfutureresearchwilladdress.Italsoidentifiestwoareasofconcern.First,overtheyears,spWRCstaffmembershavenotbeenproperlyeducatedaboutnon-nativespeciesissuesandtheconsequencesof“releasing”suchanimals.thisisunlikelytobelimitedtoadmissionsof
amphibiansandreptiles.thus,well-meaningpeoplehelpingaddressurbanhuman-wildlifeinteractionsmightbecontributingtofutureproblemswithinvasivespecies.Clearly,opportunitiesforimprovededucationexistatthis,andlikelymanyotherrehabilitationcenters.second,moresolutionsareneededfordispositionofrehabilitatednativeandnon-nativewildlifealike:thelattercertainlyshouldnotbe“released”andtherecordforoutcomesintheformerispoorlydocumentedandgenerallydiscouraging.Forexample,Rodríguezetal.(2010)reportedonthereasonsraptorswerebroughtintoarehabilitationcenterandstatedthatover1,000were“releasedintothewild,”butnotwhathappenedtothempost-release.Inoneofthefewstudiesthatlookedatpost-“release”survival,bennett(1992)reportedthat>90%ofGibbons(Hylobates muelleri)quicklydied.survivaloftranslocatedcarnivorescanalsobepoor(linnelletal.1997).successratesfortranslo-catedamphibiansandreptilesarealsodiscouraging,evenwheretheprocessismuchmorecarefullyconceivedthanthetypical“release”fromareha-bilitationcenter(Doddandsiegel1991,siegelandDodd2002,Germanoandbishop2008).boththelogicandtheethicsofinvestingconsiderableresourcesinnursingasickorinjuredanimalbacktohealth,onlytohaveitdieuponleavingthecenter,aresuspect.
AcknowledgementsWethankthesouthplainsWildlifeRehabilitationCenterforallowingusaccesstotheirwildlifeadmittancerecordsandprovidingtechnicalassis-tance.thisismsno.t-9-1206oftheCollegeofAgriculturalsciencesandnaturalResources,texastechUniversity.
ReferencesAdams,C.e.andK.J.lindsey.2009.Urban Wildlife Management.2nded.CRC
press,bocaRaton,Florida.
bennett,J.1992.Aglutofgibbonsinsarawak—Isrehabilitationtheanswer?Oryx26:157–164.
Ceballos,C.p.andl.A.Fitzgerald.2004.thetradeinnativeandexoticturtlesintexas.Wildlife Society Bulletin32:881–892.
Cook,R.p.2004.Dispersal,homerangeestablishment,survival,andreproductionoftranslocatedeasternboxturtles,Terrapene c. carolina.Applied Herpetology1:197–228.
Dodd,C.K.,Jr.andR.A.siegel.1991.Relocation,repatriation,andtransloca-tionofamphibiansandreptiles:Aretheyconservationstrategiesthatwork?Herpetologica47:336–350.
Germano,J.m.andp.J.bishop.2008.suitabilityofamphibiansandreptilesfortranslocation.Conservation Biology23:7–15.
Karesh,W.b.1995.Wildliferehabilitation:Additionalconsiderationsfordevelop-ingcountries.Journal of Zoo and Wildlife Medicine26:2–9.
thishorsfield’stortoise(Testudo horsfieldii),anAsianspeciescommoninthepettrade,reachedthecenterafteritwasfoundroaming.Itisnowkeptinanoutdoorenclosurebyoneoftheauthorsandisdoingjustfine,suggestingthatitcouldhavesurvivedinlubbock.
Jan
et W
aLk
er
thistortoise,initiallyidentifiedasasulcatatortoise(Centrochelyssulcata),nativetoAfrica,wasfoundroamingalongsideatexashighway.Itisoneofseveralsuchanimalstoreachthecenterinrecentyears.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 23soUthplAInsWIlDlIFeRehAbIlItAtIonCenteR
Kraus,F.2009.Alien Reptiles and Amphibians: A Scientific Compendium and Analysis.springerseriesinInvasionbiology4.springer,newYork.
linnell, J.D.C., R. Aanes, J.e. swenson, J. odden, and m.e. smith. 1997.translocationofcarnivoresasamethodformanagingproblemanimals:Areview.Biodiversity and Conservation6:1245–1257.
mitchell,J.C.,R.e.Jungbrown,andb.bartholomew(eds.).2008.Urban Herpetology.societyforthestudyofAmphibiansandReptiles,saltlakeCity,Utah.
morris,D.andR.morris.1965.Men and Snakes.mcGraw-hill,newYork.
national Wildlife Rehabilitators Association. 2008. Finding a Rehabilitator.<http://www.nwrawildlife.org/page.asp?ID=214>.
olden,J.D.,n.l.poff,andm.l.mcKinney.2006.Forecastingfaunalandflo-ralhomogenizationassociatedwithhumanpopulationgeographyinnorthAmerica.Biological Conservation127:261–271.
powell,R.,R.W.henderson,m.C.Farmer,m.breuil,A.C.echternacht,G.vanbuurt,C.m.Romagosa,andG.perry.2011.IntroducedamphibiansandreptilesintheGreaterCaribbean:patternsandconservationimplications,pp.63–143.In:A.hailey,b.s.Wilson,andJ.A.horrocks(eds.),Conservation of Caribbean Island Herpetofaunas.Volume1.brill,leiden,thenetherlands.
Rodríguez,b.,A.Rodríguez,F.siverio,andm.siverio.2010.Causesofraptoradmissionstoawildliferehabilitationcenterintenerife(CanaryIslands).Journal of Raptor Research44:30–39.
seigel,R.A.andC.K.Dodd,Jr.2002.translocationsofamphibians:provenman-agementmethodorexperimentaltechnique?Conservation Biology16:552–554.
sosa,J.A.2009.effectsofurbanizationonmovements,activity,andtranslocationsitefidelityofornateboxturtles(Terrapene ornata ornata)inthesouthernhighplainsoftexas.m.s.thesis,texastechUniversity,lubbock.
sosa,A.,o.Reyes,andG.perry.2010.turtlesinthedust:effectsofhands-onscientifictrainingonagroupofbehaviorallyat-riskstudents’knowledgeandempathy.Reptiles & Amphibians17:108–111.
southplainsWildlifeRehabilitationCenter.1988.AboutspWRC.<http://spwrc.org/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=17&Itemid=29>.
southeasternoutdoors.2009.WildlifeRehabilitatorsDirectory–UsA.<http://www.southeasternoutdoors.com/wildlife/rehabilitators/directory-us.html>.
Vitousek,p.m.,h.A.mooney,J.lubchenco,andJ.m.melillo.1997.humandominationofearth’secosystems.Science277:494–499.
theWildlifeRehabilitationInformationDirectory.2008.howtolocateaWildlifeRehabilitator.<http://www.tc.umn.edu/~devo0028/contact.htm>.
someturtlesarekilledimmediatelywhentheymeetvehicles,butothersarelessseverelywoundedandarebroughttothecenterforrehabilitation.
texashornedlizards(Phrynosoma cornutum)suchasthisonetendtodisappearfromurbancentersbutcanpersistontheoutskirtsoftownandmaybetransportedbyresidentsreturningfromtrips.theyregularlyshowupatthecenter.
thiseasternCornsnake(Pantherophis guttatus),clearlyawell-fedcaptive-bredindi-vidual,wasfoundonthefrontporchofalubbockresidentandbroughttothecen-ter.Itisextremelytameandobviouslyapetthatwasreleasedorallowedtoescape.
24 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
saintluciaIguana(Iguanacf.iguana)on“lyennDous”(UmbrellaVine,Ipomoea tiliacea).
Ma
tth
eW n
. Mo
rto
n, d
ur
reL
L W
iLd
LiFe
Co
nse
rv
ati
on
tr
ust
moRtonAnDKRAUss
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 25IGUAnAsonsAIntlUCIA
native and alien Iguanas on saint lucia, West Indies
matthewn.morton1andUlrikeKrauss2
1DurrellWildlifeConservationtrust,lesAugrèsmanor,trinity,JerseyJe35bp,ChannelIslands,Greatbritain([email protected])2saintluciaForestryDepartment,ministryofAgriculture,lands,Forestry&Fisheries,GabrielCharlesForestryComplex,Union,
saintlucia,WestIndies([email protected])
Status of Native Saint Lucian Iguanas
thetaxonomyoftheGreenIguana(Iguana iguana)remainsunresolved.maloneandDavis(2004)conductedgeneticanalysesthat“imply
thatatleastthreecrypticspeciesmayexist[withinthetaxoncurrentlyrecognizedasI. iguana] undertheevolutionaryandphylogeneticspeciesconcepts (CentralAmerican,southAmerican, [and]southAmerican[Caribbean]+lesserAntillean).”theyalsoindicatedthattheirdatasup-portedatleasttworadiationsintothelesserAntilles,“firstontosaintluciaandmorerecentlyontosabaandmontserrat.”lazell(1973)dis-missedthecontentionthatI. iguanaisarecentintroduction(e.g.,byCaribpeoples;Underwood1962)totheeasternCaribbean,althoughI. iguanaonmartinique(notconsideredbylazell)wasintroducedinthe1960s(breuil2009).breuil(2002)alsorejectedlazell’sargumentthatI. iguanaisnativetoGuadeloupe,whereitoccurswiththeendemiclesserAntilleanIguana(I. delicatissima).powell(2004)andpowellandhenderson(2005)highlightedtheimportanceofinsularpopulationsclassifiedcurrentlyasI. iguanaandtherisksofassumingtheycompriseasinglespecies. thenativepopulationofI. iguanaonsaintluciaisrestrictedtotheisland’snortheasterncoast,andpossiblyhasbeenrestrictedtotheeasterncoastsincethe19thCentury(tyler1850)1.Aslongasthispopulationissmallandhasarestrictedrange,itremainsaconservationpriorityforthe
ForestryDepartmentoftheministryofAgriculture,lands,Forestry&Fisheries(mAlFF),thestatutorybodyresponsibleforterrestrialbiodiver-sityconservationonsaintlucia.Duringabiophysicalinventoryofsaintlucia’sforestresourcesin2009,thedecisionwasmadetoformallyrefertothepopulationonsaintluciaasIguanacf.iguana—i.e.,similarto,butnotconfirmedas,Iguana iguana(Daltry2009a,morton2009)—andtorefertothispopulationas“thesaintluciaIguana,”withoutimplyinganyresolutionoftheprevailingtaxonomicuncertainty. ConcernsaboutthesurvivalofthesaintluciaIguanawereexpressedbythesaintluciaForestryDepartment(slFD)andJ.Gilardiinthe1990s(Anonymous1998,bendon2003),initiatingworkinthe2000sbytheDurrellWildlifeConservationtrust(Durrell)andslFDtoevaluatethestatusofthepopulationandthethreatsfacingit(morton2007).morerecently,slFDandRareAnimalReliefeffort(RARe)builtuponearlierawareness-raisingefforts(bendon2003)bymeansofa“pride”campaign(narcisse2009,RARe2010).thiscampaignpromotedthesaintluciaIguanaasaflagshipspeciesfortheisland’sendangereddeciduousseasonalforesthabitat,andinparticularthedeciduousseasonalforestsofsaintlucia’snortheasterncorridor.boththepridecampaign’siguanamascotandthenortheasterncorridorweregiventhenameIyanola,aphoneticversionofIouanalao,theAmerindiannameforsaintlucia,meaning“thelandoftheiguana”(Jesse1960).Inthisrespect,theimportanceofthesaintluciaIguanatoconservationeffortsontheislandwouldremainunchangedregardlessofitsfuturetaxonomicstatus.Itissaintlucia’s
1lazell’s(1973)reportofiguanasonmariamajorislandoffthesoutherntipofsaintluciaisinerror(J.lazell,inlitt.,23.VI.2010).
saintluciaIguana(left)andaniguanafrommontserrat(right).notethedifferencesinscalationbetweenthesetwoWestIndianiguanapopulations.
Ma
tth
eW n
. Mo
rto
n, d
ur
reL
L W
iLd
LiFe
Co
nse
rv
ati
on
tr
ust
26 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
largestnativeterrestrialanimal,strikinginitsappearance,andaculturalsignifieroflongstanding.Assuch,itisavaluableflagshipspeciesthatrep-resentsagloballythreatenedhabitattypeintheinsularCaribbean(WWFandmcGinley2007),anareathatappearstobethelastremainingstrong-holdofanumberofspeciesandsubspeciesendemictosaintlucia,par-ticularlybirdsandreptiles(Daltry2009a,2009b;morton2009;toussaintetal.2009). IfsaintluciaweretoproduceitsownRedlist,thesaintluciaIguanawouldrequireaRedlistassessmentofCriticallyendangered(IUCn2001)atanationallevel.Ifthispopulationweretobeaccordedspecificorsubspecifictaxonomicstatus,however,itwouldqualifyforaglobalstatusofCriticallyendangered.Ineithercase,thisassessmentisbasedonIUCn’s(2001)criteriab1a,b(i,ii,iii):extentofoccurrenceestimatedtobelessthan100km2(boththeextentofoccurrenceandareaofoccupancyare<50km2);dataindicatingthatthepopulationisseverelyfragmentedorknowntoexistatonlyasinglelocation(onelocation—northeasternsaintlucia);andindicatorsshowingcontinuingdecline,observed,inferred,orprojected,inthe(i)extentofoccurrence,(ii)areaofoccupancy,and(iii)area,extent,and/orqualityofhabitat(effectsoftourismdevelopments,sand-mining,livestockgrazing,andotherdocu-mentedthreatsthatareknowntoreducethequalityandextentofsuitablehabitats).historicalpopulationbaselinesarenotavailableforthesaintluciaIguana,butthisassessmentinfersadeclineinthepopulationbasedonitsveryrestrictedrangeandtheidentificationofanumberofongoingpressuresandthreats,mostnotablythatofintroducedmammalianpreda-torsandthethreatofproposed,large-scaletouristdevelopmentonsaintlucia’snortheasterncoast(morton2007). thecurrentrangeofthesaintluciaIguanacorrespondstooneofthetwoareasontheislandfarthestfrompavedroads(i.e.,leastacces-sibletohumans,theircommensals,anddomesticatedanimals).theotherareaisamountainousregionofsaintlucia’shighestpeaks,fromwhichnoiguanasareknown(perhapsduetoalackofsuitablenestinghabitat).thisdistributionimpliesthathunting(whichstilloccursonasmallscale,primarilyforfood;bendon2003,morton2007)mighthavebeenoneimportanthistoricaldriveroftheinferreddeclineinthesaintluciapopu-lation.Italsounderlinesoneofthethreatsarisingfromproposeddevelop-mentonthenortheasterncoast,overandaboveconversionofhabitat:theimprovementofroadaccessandhencehumanaccessthat,ifnotregulatedinsomeform,canbeexpectedtoincreasehuntingpressureaswellasthedensityofnon-nativemammalianpredatorssuchasmongooses,dogs,cats,andrats.Improvedroadaccessandahigherhumanpopulationinthenortheastmightalsoincreasethelikelihoodthatalieniguanas,nowestab-lishingonsaintlucia,aretransportedintothisarea,eitherdeliberatelyaspetsorfoodorinadvertentlystowedawayingoods.
Introduction and Establishment of Alien Iguanas – Potential ImpactsthequestionofthetaxonomicstatusofthesaintluciaIguanahasagaincometotheforewiththeconfirmationin2008thatnon-saintlucianGreenIguanasarebreedinginthedryandmesicforestsaroundsoufrièreinthesouthwestoftheisland(morton2008,GlobalInvasivespeciesDatabase2010a).themostpressingconcernforbiodiversityconserva-tiononsaintluciaisthelikelihoodofhybridizationbetweennativeandalieniguanas,potentiallycompromisingtheuniquegeneticidentityandlocallyadaptedgenecomplexesof thesaintluciapopulation.Iguana iguana isknowntohybridizewithitscongener,I. delicatissima,oneasternCaribbeanislandstowhichithasbeenintroduced(e.g.,Dayandthorpe1996,breuiletal.2007). Competitionbetweennativeandalienpopulationsisanotherconcern(hendersonandpowell2009).IUCn’sGlobalInvasivespeciesDatabase(2010b)mootsthepossibilitythatcompetitionbetweenintroducedGreenIguanasandtheircongener,I. delicatissima,mightthreatenthosenative
moRtonAnDKRAUss
Iyanola,saintlucia’sprideCampaignmascotforthesaintluciaIguanaandthenamebestowedontheisland’snortheasterncorridor,itslastknownrefuge.
sain
t Lu
Cia
Fo
res
try
dep
ar
tMen
t
thedistributionofthesaintluciaIguanaandapopulationofintroducedalienGreenIguanasonsaintlucia,shownaspresencein1x1-kmsquares.thedis-tributionofthesaintluciaIguanawasdeterminedduringfivemonthsofisland-wideface-to-facequestionnairesin2004–05(morton2007).“Falseabsences”wereminimizedbyquestioninglargenumbersofrespondentsaboutiguanasightingsinsquareswherethepresenceofiguanashadbeenindependentlydeterminedpriortothesurvey.Fromthis,wedeterminedtheminimumnumberofrespondentsthathadtobequestionedpersquareinordertoyield95%confidencethatatleastonerespondentwouldreportasightingif,infact,iguanaswerepresent.sightingsdeter-minedas“falsepresences”forthesaintluciaIguana(forquestionnairereturns,forexample,describingcaptiveiguanasorclearlyreferringtootherspecies,notablyCnemidophorus vanzoi)wereexcluded,althoughsomeoftheoutlying1x1-kmsquaresinthedistributionshownherecouldbefalsepositives,wherethepresenceofiguanashasnotbeenconfirmedbysearches.thedistributionofalieniguanaswasdeterminedfromquestionnaireresponsescollectedin2008–09.thislatterquestionnaireisanongoingefforttomaintainanupdateddemarcationofthespreadofthealienpopulation.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 27
populations.meanclutchsizeforthealieniguanais40(n=4clutches),butwithamaximum(todate)of60,whichmightmorecloselyrepresentthetruemeanassamplesizeincreases.bycontrast,meanclutchsizeforsaintluciaIguanas(n=14)is23,suggestingthatthealienscouldout-reproducethenativeiguanas.Competitioncouldalsobeasymmetricalinfavorofthealiensif,asthelimiteddataimply,thealiensattainagreaterbodymass,althoughthismightreflectlowermortalityfrompredatorsinapopulationthatisputativelystillrarecomparedwiththatofthesaintluciapopulation. burton(2004)citedanotherconcernover the introductionofI. iguana ontoGrandCayman,thenativerangeofC. lewisi,namelyconfu-sionofpublicawarenessmessagesfortheconservationofC. lewisi.thisis
asubstantiveconcerngiventhegrowingdiscontentovernegativeimpactsofintroducedGreenIguanasonGrandCayman.AsKryskoetal.(2007)noted,theintroductionofI. iguana toFloridainthe1960sraisedlittlecon-cern,butbythe1990s,thepopulationhadexplodedandpublicdiscontentwithiguanasgrew. othernegativeimpactsofalieniguanas,suchascropdamage(particu-larlytoornamentals),theriskofSalmonellainfections,orpossiblepredationonbirdeggsarealmostcertainlyexaggerated,althoughinvasiveiguanascanbeanuisanceandarelikelytohaveatleastsomeeconomicimpactonvegetation.WhatisclearisahighlevelofpublicdiscontentinplaceswhereinvasiveGreenIguanashavebecomeestablished,inlargepartdueto
IGUAnAsonsAIntlUCIAM
att
heW
n. M
or
ton
, du
rr
eLL
WiL
dLi
Fe C
on
ser
va
tio
n t
ru
st
Ma
tth
eW n
. Mo
rto
n, d
ur
reL
L W
iLd
LiFe
Co
nse
rv
ati
on
tr
ust
Ma
tth
eW n
. Mo
rto
n, d
ur
reL
L W
iLd
LiFe
Co
nse
rv
ati
on
tr
ust
tWy
La h
oLL
an
d, d
ur
reL
L W
iLd
LiFe
Co
nse
rv
ati
on
tr
ust
saintluciaIguanas(A,adultmaleandb,adultfemale)andalieniguanasintroducedinsaintlucia(C,adultmaleandD,adultfemale).themorenumerousandprominentnuchaltubercleofthealieniguana,anditslargersubtympanicscale,areclearlyvisible,asisthedifferenceinthecoloroftheiris.
A
C
B
D
28 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 moRtonAnDKRAUss
delayedandinadequateinterventionduringtheearlystagesofinvasion.InpuertoRico,alieniguanasareconsideredanair-strikeriskonrunwaysattheluismuñozmarínInternationalAirport,causingthesuspensionofflightssixtimesinonetwo-monthstudy(engemanetal.2005).sementellietal.(2008)documenteddamagetopublicinfrastructurecausedbyburrowingiguanasintroducedintoFlorida. Atthistime,thealieniguanapopulationonsaintluciaappearstobegeographicallyisolatedfromthenativepopulation,butbydintofsmallpopulationsizeratherthananyimpenetrablegeographicbarriers.evenifthemountainousrain-forestedinteriorofsaintluciadoesprovideabar-rier(wehavefoundnoreportsofsaintluciaIguanasinthisregion),thealienpopulationcouldstilldispersearoundthecoastandcomeintocon-tactwiththenativepopulation.successfulnestingoutsideofcaptivityhasbeenrecordedinthesoufrièrearea,andquestionnairereturnsandfieldobservationssuggestthattheintroducedpopulationhasdispersedatleast2kmfromthesiteoftheinitialintroduction,ahotelontheoutskirtsofsoufrière.mappingcapturesandreportedsightingsimplydispersalhasbeenprimarilyalongtheriverinecorridorsoftheRiversoufrièreandsomeofitstributaries,althoughthisconclusionmightreflectasamplingbias,astheselowerlyingareasaremorereadilyaccessiblebysearchteamsthantheverysteepslopesthatcharacterizemuchofthearea. thealieniguanasareeasilydistinguishedfromthenativesbyhavingalargernumberofmoredenselypacked,andmoreprominentnuchaltuber-clescales,whichare,bycomparison,muchreducedinsizeandnumberinsaintluciaIguanas.Inaddition,thesubtympanicplatethatdistinguishesI. iguana fromI. delicatissima ismuchlargerrelativetothetympanuminthealienpopulation,whereasthescalesimmediatelyanteriortothissubtym-panicplateareproportionatelymuchlargerinthesaintluciaIguana.theeyeofthesaintluciaiguana,atleastinadults,alsoappearstoconsistentlyhaveamuchdarkeriristhanthatofthealien.
Management of the Alien Iguanasthepathwayofintroductiontosaintluciaforalieniguanasappearstohavebeenviathepettrade,asappearstobethecaseforallalienpopulationsofI. iguana introducedintotheCaribbeanandelsewhere(Kraus2009).AfewindividualGreenIguanas(reportsvaryfromfourtosix)wereheldinaprivatecollection,withoutapermit,insoufrièreuntilatleast2002(m.morton,pers.obs.),afterhavingbeenimported,againwithoutapermit,ashatchlingsfromapetshopinCanadaduringthelate1980s(m.bobb,pers.comm.).theoriginofthesehatchlingsisunknown.Althoughtheundesirabilityoftheseanimalsbeingheldinanunsecuredprivatecollec-tioninsaintluciawasnotedin2002,confusionoverlegalinstrumentsapparentlyhinderedtheirconfiscation(tworemainingincaptivityin2009werebelatedlyconfiscatedandeuthanized).Inearly2008,reportsoffree-livingiguanas,adultsandhatchlings,inthesoufrièreareawerecollatedandmapped.Althoughthefoundingindividualswerestillincaptivityin2002(m.morton,pers.obs.),aquestionnaireofsoufrièreresidentscol-lectedreportsofiguanasightingspriorto2000(Krauss2010a),suggestingthattheybredincaptivityandoffspringapparentlyescapedpriorto2002(althoughthishasbeendeniedbytheformerowners). thecurrentgeographicalseparationofsaintluciaandalieniguanasontheislandandtheapparentlyrestricteddistributionofthealienpopula-tioncouldprovideanopportunityforeradicatingthealiens.Itmightalsoofferanopportunitytomitigatesomeoftherisksofmixedmessagesinpublicawarenesscampaignsthatcouldarisefromsimultaneouslytryingtoprotectoneiguanapopulationwhileattemptingtoeradicateanother. simulations of population growth using the population viabil-ityanalysissoftwareVortex(lacy1993,lacyetal.2009)haveledtosomepredictionsregardingthepotentialsuccessoferadicationefforts2.simulatingaworst-casescenarioof60%juvenilemortality(i.e.,thesameasthatestimatedforadultGreenIguanasinpanama;Randandbock1992)andanalienpopulationestablishedsince1990(i.e.,afewyearsafterhatchlingsinitiallywereimported)predictedthatextinctionprob-
abilitiesgreaterthanabout30%areveryunlikely—regardlessofanyhuntingpressurewecouldfeasiblyapply(morton2010).bycontrast,arelativelymodesthuntingpressure(60–180adultsor600–1,000juvenilesremovedperyear)couldraiseextinctionprobabilitiestoalmost100%inabest-casescenarioof90%juvenilemortalityandapopulationestablishedforonlyfouryears(i.e.,accountingonlyforthefirstrecordedappear-anceofhatchlingsinthewild.thisbest-casejuvenilemortalityisslightlylowerthanthatreportedbyharris(1982)andvanDevender(1982),butthosestudiescouldnotdistinguishlossofjuvenilesthroughemigrationanddeath).thesamehuntingpressureispredictedtoincreaseextinctionprobabilitiestoabout80–90%forintermediatescenarios(75%juvenilemortalityand/orapopulationestablishedsince2002,thelastyearwhenalltheknownfounderiguanaswereconfirmedtobeincaptivity).Vortexsimulationsalsopredictedthemostlikelycurrentalieniguanapopulationsizeundertheworst-casescenariotobeinthetensofthousands,whichisinconsistentwiththedifficultyoffindingalieniguanasaroundsoufrière,suggesting,atleastforthemoment,thattheworst-casescenarioisnotthemostaccuraterepresentationofreality.Allscenariospredictexplosivepopulationgrowthifuncheckedbyaggressivemanagementinterventions. In2010,theslFDandDurrellestablishedafour-yearcollaborativepartnershiptoeradicatethealienpopulationofI. iguana(Krauss2010b).todate,however,evenrelativelymodesthuntingpressuresusedinthesimulationsdescribedaboveexceedthealieniguanaremovalratesthatwehavebeenabletoachieveinthefirstyearofthisproject,despiteintensivesearches.Atthistime(late2010),only21adults(includingsub-adults)and132hatchlingshavebeenremoved.Alliguanaremovalshavebeentheresultofintensivevisualsearchessupplementedbyreportsfromlocalresidents,whichledtocapturesbyhandorpole-noose.Capturediguanasareeutha-nizedbylethalinjectionadministeredbytheVeterinaryDepartmentofmAlFF.ourlowcapturerateislikelyduetoacombinationofthecrypticnatureofiguanasatrestintreesandaniguanapopulationputativelyatlowdensities.Attemptstoevaluatedifferentsearchandcaptureapproachesareunderway.
2populationviabilityanalyses(pVAs)havebeencriticizedfornotprovidingvalidpredictionsofextinctionrisk,especiallyoverlongtime-scales(e.g.,>100yrs),astheyassumeconstantecological(andanthropogenic)processesthatareunlikely(boyce2001).theirutilityincomparingtherelativeeffectsofalternativeman-agementscenarios,however,hasbeennoted(boyce2001).AnothercommoncriticismofpVAsisthatallofthemodelparametervaluesarerarelyknownforthespeciesbeingexamined.AsWhite(2000)commented,ifparameterestimatesarelargelyguesses,thenmodelpredictionsarealsoguesses.boyce(2001),how-ever,pointedoutthatobtainingaccurateestimatesforallparametersisunrealisticandshouldnotdetractfromtheheuristicuseofpVAs,forexample,whencom-paringalternativemanagementscenarios.Forthescenariospresentedhere,someparameterestimatesweretakenfrompublishedliteratureonI. iguana.Ageoffirstreproductionwasestimatedattwoyears,whichispessimisticwhencomparedwithZugandRand’s(1987)estimates(butseeandprattetal.1994,citedinRodda2003).Reproductionwasassumedtobepolygynous(referencesreviewedinRodda2003).Adultmortalitywassetat60%usingRandandbock’s(1992)estimates,andjuvenilemortalitywassetat(asaworstcase,andpresumablypes-simistic)thesame.Asabestcase(andprobablyoptimistic),itwassetto90%,asnotedabove.twoparameterswerebasedonunpublisheddatacollectedbyusin2010,albeitusingsmallsamples:sexratioatbirthwasassumedtobe1:1basedonasexratioof37:40fromasampleof77hatchlings.meanclutchsizewasestimatedat40±12.18basedonasampleoffourgravidfemalesin2010.otherparameterswereguesses.percentofadultsbreedingwasestimatedas62.7%formales(givenpolygyny)and100%forfemales.environmentalvariationwassettohavenoeffectonbreeding(i.e.,novariationinreproductivesuccessfromyeartoyear).CarryingcapacitywassetashighasVortexallows(60,000)tomodeluncheckedgrowthinanexpandingpopulation.moredetailsareprovidedinmorton(2010).Althoughalloftheseparametervaluesareuncertain,webelievetheyarebiologicallyplausible(andmorelikelytoerronthesideofpessimism)—andtheydoallowustomodeldifferentmanagementscenarios.Asmoredataaccumulatefromalieniguanacapturesinsaintlucia,wewillbeabletorefineourparameterestimatesandrunfurthersimulations.Fornow,theydemonstratethepotentialutilityofthistoolandallowustosimulateresponsesofapopulationthesizeofwhichisbeyondourmeanstoreliablyestimateatthispoint.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 29IGUAnAsonsAIntlUCIA
Apilotstudyinseptember2009alsodeployed50tomahawklivetrapsand20releasing-locksnaresinabout0.5km2withinthecoreareaofiguanasightings,butnoiguanaswerecapturedbyeithermethodoverafour-weekperiod.trapsandsnareenclosureswerebaitedwitharomatic
fruit(e.g.,mango,banana)plusfragmentsofredfabric,asiguanasareknowntorespondtoreditemssuchashibiscusflowers(e.g.,Alberts2003).ourlackofsuccesscouldbeattributabletothearborealityoftheiguanas,theputativelowpopulationdensity,and/oranapparentsuper-abundanceoffood(foliage),whichwouldrenderthebaitedtrapslessattractive.Furthertrappingeffortsareprojectedforthenestingseasonin2011,whichispre-sumablyfromFebruarytoearlymay—basedonthetimingofnestinginsaintluciaIguanas(morton2007)andconsistentwiththetimingofalienhatchlingcapturesin2010.Duringthisperiod,femaleiguanaspresumablyspendagreaterproportionoftheirtimeonthegroundand,post-nesting,arelikelytobemoremotivatedtofeedafterhavingsuspendedfeedingwhilegravid(Rodda2003).Wealsoplantopilotandevaluatetheuseofdetec-tordogstolocatealieniguanasin2011.Detectordogshavebeenusedtolocateanotheralieninvasivearborealreptile,thebrowntreesnake(Boiga irregularis)onGuam,bothinairportcargo(Viceandengeman2000)andfree-livingintrees(savidgeetal.2008). Giventheallopatricdistributionofthetwoiguanapopulationsonsaintlucia,webelievethatnohybridizationhasyetoccurred.tissuesam-plesfrombothpopulationshavebeenbankedinordertosearchforallelesuniquetothealienpopulation.thesewillallowustosurveythenativepop-ulationforevidenceofintrogression.Althoughthealieniguanapopulationcurrentlyappearstoberestrictedtoarelativelysmallareainsaintlucia,itisreproducingandwillpresumablyincreaseitsrange.Kryskoetal.(2007)suggestedthatapopulationexplosionofalienI.iguana inFloridafollowedhurricaneAndrewin1992.possibleeffectsofhurricanetomasonsaintluciainoctober2010areunknown.thesoufrièreareawasamongtheworstaffectedbyseverefloodingandextensivelandslides.Alieniguanas,bothadultsandyoungoftheyear,however,havebeencapturedinthecoreareasincetomasstruck.Aswithmanyotherinvasivespecies,reptilianinva-sionsareoftencharacterizedbyanextendedlagperiod,sometimeslastingdecades,whichprecedesanexplosioninnumbersandrange(e.g.,Kryskoetal.2007,Kraus2009).Questionnairereturnsfrom2009and2010sug-gestedthatthealieniguanapopulationinsaintluciamightnowbemov-ing,orabouttomove,beyondthislagperiodintoaperiodofrapidgrowth.effortstoeradicatethealieniguanapopulationmustincludestrategiesforpreservingthesaintluciaIguanainthefaceofongoingthreatsemanatingfromthepossibilityofcontactwiththealieniguanapopulation.
Acknowledgementstheworkonwhichthisarticleisbasedwasfundedbythebalcombetrust,theInternationalIguanaFoundation,and(fortheremovalofalieniguanascomponent)theGlobalenvironmentFacilitythroughtheUnitednationsenvironmentprogramme andmanagedbyCAbI.the comments ofGordonRoddaandCharlesKnappgreatlyimprovedthefinaldraftofthismanuscript.manyslFDstaff,localfieldassistants,andoverseasvolunteerscontractedbyDurrellhavecontributedenormouslytothisworkin2002–2010,especially(forworkonsaintluciaIguanas)Agnesorgrodowczyk,AvrilKelly,bradleyAbraham,Curtismathurin,DenisemcGowan,egilDröge,Gabybesne-Garcia,GregAlexander,hannaho’Kelly,lizCorry,lizzieperret,meaganmcpharlin,neilocculi,andsophieharley;and(forworkonalieniguanas)Alansands,AmyClack,barbaraschaeffer,benjibarca,GraemeDuncan,lenniGriffiths,maryJames,mikeball,nateWood,nickCondie,peterJn.baptiste,Rachelbarwick,RobWilliams,RuthmcKee,stephenlesmond,andtwylaholland.specialthanksareduetoDonaldAnthony,whoinitiatedtheworkonsaintluciaIguanas;Anthony“seako”Johnny,long-timefieldassistantandlocaliguanaexpert;timotheusJn.baptiste,AlwinDornelly,andlyndonJohnfortheirongo-ingcontributionstoallaspectsofprojectmanagement;RichYoungforsageadviceonstudydesignandanalyses;andKarenGrahamforallhersupportandwisdom.Finally,aspecialmentionmustgotoourcolleagueonthealieniguanaremovalwork,lesterJn.baptiste,whowaskilledinalandslideduringhurricanetomasin2010;heisgreatlymissedbyallwhoworkedwithhim.
predictedeffectofhuntingpressureappliedtojuvenilesandadultsinthealieniguanapopulationestablishinginsaintlucia.thegraphsshowthepredictedprob-abilitythatthepopulationwillbeextirpatedifitisexperiencing:(a)low(60%)juvenilemortality,(b)moderate(75%)juvenilemortality,or(c)high(90%)juve-nilemortalityinadditiontothehuntingpressureapplied.thethreelinesineachgraphillustrateuncertaintyoverhowlongthispopulationhasbeenestablishing;i.e.,huntingissimulatedasbeingappliedtoafour-year-oldpopulation(huntingstartsatpoint4Yo),anine-year-oldpopulation(at9Yo),ora21-year-oldpopulation(at21Yo).Forapopulationexperiencinghighjuvenilemortalityinadditiontohunt-ing(c),theprobabilityofextirpationishigh,regardlessofhowlongthepopulationhasbeenestablishing.Formoderateorlowjuvenilemortalityinadditiontohunting(b,a),ahighprobabilityofextirpationexistsonlyfortheyoungerpopulations(firsthuntedat4Yoor9Yo).simulationswerecarriedoutusingVortex(lacyetal.2009);thisfigurewasadaptedfrommorton(2010),whodetailedtheVortex modelparametervaluesusedinthesimulations.
30 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 moRtonAnDKRAUss
Literature CitedAlberts,A.C.2003.ConservingtheremarkablereptilesofGuantánamobay,pp.
67–73.In:R.W.hendersonandR.powell(eds.),Islands and the Sea: Essays on Herpetological Exploration in the West Indies.Contributionstoherpetology,Volume20.societyforthestudyofAmphibiansandReptiles,Ithaca,newYork(reprinted2006.Iguana13:8–15).
Anonymous.1998Commoniguana(Iguana iguana).West Indian Iguana Specialist Group Newsletter1(1):6.
bendon,J.s.2003.thest.lucianiguana-aspecialcase?Iguana10:71–78.
boyce,m.s.2001.populationviabilityanalysis;development,interpretation,andapplication,pp.123–136.In:t.m.shenkandA.b.Franklin(eds.),Modeling in Natural Resource Management: Development, Interpretation, and Application.Islandpress,Washington,D.C.
breuil,m.2002.histoirenaturelledesamphibiensetreptilesterrestresdel’ArchipelGuadeloupéen.Guadeloupe,saint-martin,saint-barthélemy.Patrimoines Naturels, Paris54:1–339.
breuil,m.2009.theterrestrialherpetofaunaofmartinique:past,present,andfuture.Applied Herpetology6:123–149.
breuil,m.,F.Guiougou,andb.Ibéné.2007.taxonreport:lesserAntilleanIguana(Iguana delicatissima).Iguana Specialist Group Newsletter10(2):15–17.
burton,F.J.2004.Cyclura lewisi.In:IUCn2010.IUCN Red List of Threatened Species.Version2010.4.<www.iucnredlist.org>.
Daltry,J.C.2009a.thestatusandmanagementofsaintlucia’sForestReptilesandAmphibians.technicalReportno.2tothenationalForestDemarcationand bio-physical Resource Inventory project, FCG International ltd,helsinki,Finland.<www.bananatrustslu.com/index.php?link=doccentre&project=sfa2003>.
Daltry, J.C. 2009b. biodiversity Assessment of saint lucia’s Forests, WithmanagementRecommendations.technicalReportno.10tothenationalForestDemarcationandbio-physicalResource Inventoryproject,FCGInternationalltd,helsinki,Finland.<www.bananatrustslu.com/index.php?link=doccentre&project=sfa2003>.
Day,m.l.andR.s.thorpe.1996.populationdifferentiationofIguana delicatis-simaandI. iguanainthelesserAntilles(abstract),pp.436–437.In:R.powellandR.W.henderson(eds.),Contributions to the West Indian Herpetology: A Tribute to Albert Schwartz.societyforthestudyoftheAmphibiansandReptiles,Ithaca,newYork.
engeman,R.m.,h.t.smith,andb.Constantin.2005.InvasiveGreenIguanasasairstrikehazardsatsanJuanInternationalAirport,puertoRico.Journal of Aviation-Aerospace Education and Research14:45–50.
GlobalInvasivespeciesDatabase.2010a.Iguana iguana. Detailsofthisspeciesinsaintlucia.IUCnInvasivespeciesspecialistGroupGlobalInvasivespeciesDatabase.<www.issg.org/database/species/distribution_detail.asp?si=1022&di=53061&pc=*&lang=en>.
predictedsensitivitytoextirpationofthealieniguanapopulationestablishinginsaintluciadependingonwhetherhuntingpressureisappliedtotheadultpopulation(a,b)orthejuvenilepopulation(c,d).populationsexperiencinglowjuvenilemortalityinadditiontohunting(a,c)andmoderatejuvenilemortality(b,d)areshown.Forpopulationswithhighjuvenilemortality,theprobabilityofextirpationunderhuntingishighinallcases.simulationswerecarriedoutusingVortex(lacyetal.2009);figureadaptedfrommorton(2010).
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 31IGUAnAsonsAIntlUCIA
GlobalInvasivespeciesDatabase.2010b.Iguana iguana. locationspecificImpacts.IUCnInvasivespeciesspecialistGroupGlobalInvasivespeciesDatabase.<www.issg.org/database/species/distribution_detail.asp?si=1022&di=53061&pc=*&lang=en>.
harris,D.m.1982.thephenology,growthandsurvivaloftheGreenIguana,Iguana iguana innorthernColombia,pp.150–161.In:G.burghardtandA.s.Rand(eds.),Iguanas of the World: Their Behavior, Ecology, and Conservation.noyespublications,parkRidge,newJersey.
henderson,R.W.andR.powell.2009.Natural History of West Indian Reptiles and Amphibians.UniversitypressofFlorida,Gainesville.
IUCn.2001.IUCnRedlistCategoriesandCriteria.Version3.1.IUCnspeciessurvivalCommission.IUCn,Gland,switzerlandandCambridge,UnitedKingdom.
Jesse,C.1960.The Amerindians in St. Lucia (Iouanalao).saintluciaArchaeological&historicalsociety,Castries.
Kraus,F.2009.Alien reptiles and Amphibians: A Scientific Compendium and Analysis.Invadingnature:springerseriesinInvasionbiology4.springer,newYork.
Krauss,U.2010a.Invasivealienspecies(IAs)awarenessbaselinesurvey,saintlucia,2010.projectno.GFl/2328–2713-4A86,GF-1030-09-03.ForestryDepartment,mAlFF,saintlucia(<www.ciasnet.org>).
Krauss,U.2010b.saintlucianprojectprofile:“mitigatingthethreatofinvasivealienspeciesintheinsularCaribbean,”p.8.ForestryDepartment,mAlFF,saintlucia.<www.ciasnet.org/wp-content/uploads/2010/08/stlucia.pdf>.
Krysko,K.l.,K.m.enge,e.m.Donlan, J.C.seitz, ande.A.Golden.2007.Distribution,naturalhistory,andimpactsoftheintroducedGreenIguana(Iguana iguana)inFlorida.Iguana14:142–151.
lacy,R.C.1993.Vortex:Acomputersimulationmodelforpopulationviabilityanalysis.Wildlife Research20:45–65.
lacy,R.C.,m.borbat,andJ.p.pollak.2009.Vortex:Astochasticsimulationoftheextinctionprocess.Version9.95.ChicagoZoologicalsociety,brookfield,Illinois.
lazell,J.D.1973.thelizardgenusIguanainthelesserAntilles.Bulletin of the Museum of Comparative Zoology145:1–28.
malone,C.l.ands.K.Davis.2004.GeneticcontributionstoCaribbeaniguanaconser-vation,pp.45–57.In:A.C.Alberts,R.l.Carter,W.K.hayes,ande.p.martins(eds.),Iguanas: Biology and Conservation.UniversityofCaliforniapress,berkeley.
morton,m.n.2007.saintluciaIguana:Report2002–06.UnpublishedreporttoDurrellWildlifeConservationtrust,Jersey,andsaintluciaministryofAgricultureForestryDepartment,Union,saintlucia.
morton,m.n.2008.theUrgentproblemofAlienGreenIguanasAroundsoufrière.UnpublishedreporttoDurrellWildlifeConservationtrust,Jersey,andsaintluciaministryofAgricultureForestryDepartment,Union,saintlucia.
morton,m.n.2009.managementofCriticalspeciesonsaintlucia:speciesprofilesandmanagementRecommendations.technicalReportno.13tothenationalForestDemarcationandbio-physicalResourceInventoryproject,FCGInternationalltd,helsinki,Finland.<www.bananatrustslu.com/index.php?link=doccentre&project=sfa2003>.
morton,m.n.2010.simulatedimpactofdifferentlevelsofhuntingpressureontheprobabilityofextinctionofanalienGreenIguanapopulation.UnpublishedReport toDurrellWildlifeConservationtrust, Jersey, andsaintluciaForestryDepartment,Union,saintlucia.
narcisse-Gaston,F.2009.Campaignresultsandcriticalreview.UnpublishedreporttosaintluciaForestryDepartment,Union.
pratt,n.C.,J.A.phillips,A.C.Alberts,andK.s.bolda.1994.Functionalversusphysiologicalpuberty:AnanalysisofsexualbimaturismintheGreenIguana,Iguana iguana.Animal Behaviour47:1101–1114.
powell,R.2004.ConservationofIguanas(Iguana delicatissimaandI. iguana)inthelesserAntilles.Iguana11:239–246.
powell,R.andR.W.henderson.2005.ConservationstatusoflesserAntilleanreptiles.Iguana12:2–17.
Rand,A.s.andb.C.bock.1992.sizevariation,growth,andsurvivorshipinnestingGreenIguanas(Iguana iguana)inpanama.Amphibia-Reptilia13:147–156.
RARe.2010.Conservationonahumanscale.<www.rareconservation.org/cp/docs/overviewbrochure_english2010.pdf>.
Rodda,G.h.2003.biologyandreproductioninthewild,pp.1–27.In:e.R.Jacobson(ed.),Biology, Husbandry and Medicine of the Green Iguana.KriegerpublishingCo.,malabar,Florida.
savidge,J.,R.Reed,J.stanford,G.haddock,andR.stafford.2008.Canineteamdetectionof free-rangingradio-telemeteredbrowntreesnakes(abstract),pp.19–20.In:northAmericanbrowntreesnakeControlteam,browntreesnaketechnicalWorkingGroupmeeting:Agenda&Abstracts,16,17,&18April2008.Kingsville,texas.
sementelli,A.,h.t.smith,W.e.meshaka,Jr.,andR.m.engeman.2008.JustGreenIguanas?theAssociatedCostsandpolicy ImplicationsofexoticInvasiveWildlife in southFlorida.Public Works Management & Policy12:599–606.
toussaint,A.,C.l.John,andm.n.morton.2009.thestatusandConservationofsaintlucia’sForestbirds.technicalReportno.12 to thenationalForestDemarcationandbio-physicalResource Inventoryproject,FCGInternationalltd.,helsinki,Finland.<www.bananatrustslu.com/index.php?link=doccentre&project=sfa2003>.
tyler,R.e.1850.ontheiguanaofsaintlucia,Metopoceros cornutusofWagler.Proceedings of the Zoological Society of London18:106–110.
Underwood,G.1962.ReptilesoftheeasternCaribbean.Caribbean Affairs (N. S.)1:[2]+192pp.
UniversityofFloridanews.2005.petsgonewild:IguanasspreadrapidlyinsouthFlorida.<http://news.ufl.edu/2005/01/31/iguanawild/>.
VanDevender,R.W.1982.Growthandecologyofspiny-tailedandGreenigua-nas,withcommentsontheevolutionofherbivoryandlargebodysize,pp.162–183.In:G.burghardtandA.s.Rand(eds.),Iguanas of the World: Their Behavior, Ecology, and Conservation.noyespublications,parkRidge,newJersey.
Vice,D.s.andR.m.engeman.2000.browntreesnakediscoveriesduringdetec-tordoginspectionsfollowingsupertyphoonpaka.Micronesica33:105–110.
White,G.C.2000.populationviabilityanalysis:Datarequirementsandessen-tialanalyses,pp.288–231.In:l.boitaniandt.K.Fuller(eds.),Research Techniques in Animal Ecology: Controversies and Consequences.ColumbiaUniversitypress,newYork.
WorldWildlifeFund(WWF)andm.mcGinley(topiceditor).2007.WindwardIslands dry forests. In: C.J. Cleveland (ed.), Encyclopedia of Earth. environmentalInformationCoalitionandnationalCouncilforscienceandtheenvironment,Washington,D.C.(<www.eoearth.org/article/Windward_Islands_dry_forests>).
Zug,G.R.andA.s.Rand1987.estimationofageinnestingfemaleIguana iguana:testingskeletochronologyinatropicallizard.Amphibia-Reptilia8:237–2007.
32 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
malesaintluciaIguana(Iguanacf.iguana).thisindividualisknowntohavebeenkilledforfoodbyhuntersatGrandAnseestatetheyearafterthisphotographwastaken.
eLiz
aB
eth
Co
rr
y, d
ur
reL
L W
iLd
LiFe
Co
nse
rv
ati
on
tr
ust
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 33
proudsponsoroftheIRCFandthiscenterfold
34 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
AburnedwetlandatpaloVerdenationalpark,CostaRica;notetheaggregationofdeadscorpionmudturtles(Kinosternon scorpioides)intheforeground.
GUInnAnDlUGeR
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 35neWobseRVAtIonsoFAneotRopICAlmUDtURtle
Reading the ashes:arson Decimates a Tropical Wetland,
but allows new observations of a neotropical Mud Turtle
Jeremye.Guinnandpalaniluger
environmentalscienceprogram,sittingbullCollege,Ft.Yates,northDakota58538,UsA
Allphotographsbytheseniorauthor.
DuringanationalscienceFoundation-fundedsummerresearchpro-gramforundergraduates,wewitnessedthelossofmorethan5,000
haofprimesemi-fossorialturtlehabitatnearCatalinastation,paloVerdenationalparkinGuanacaste,CostaRica.Accordingtoparkofficials,thefirewassetintentionallybypoacherstoallowaccesstowildlifefromthetempisqueRiver,whichbordersthepark.naturalwildlandfirescanbedevastating,butalsobeneficialforalocalecosystem;however,human-inducedfiresaregenerallymoredestructiveduetolackofperimetercon-trolsandheavyfuelloads.Wetlandfiresareespeciallydamagingbecauseof
thelossofhabitatandindividualsfromspeciesthatarenotadaptedforfastoverlandmotility.AlthoughCattails(Typhasp.)areexoticinthisregion,theyprovidehabitatforanumberofnativespecies,includingsemi-fossorialturtles.thefireprovidedauniqueopportunitytoviewawetlandcommu-nitythatwewouldotherwisehavebeenhardpressedtoobserve. As the fire still smoldered in the Área de Conservación Arenaltempisque,wemadeapreliminaryhikearoundthesouthernperimeterofthefire.thelandscapewasdominatedbyhundredsofblackVultures(Coragyps atratus)andCrestedCaracara(Polyborus plancus)feastingonthe
AnirruptionofblackVultures(Coragyps atratus)thatarrivedtopickupthepiecesfollowingthefire.
36 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 GUInnAnDlUGeR
remainsofturtlesandotherwildlifekilledbythefire.theputridcombi-nationofsmellsfromburnedflesh,ash,andwetlandsludgehungintheairandclungtoourclothes.thevisualscenewasnomoreappealing;anastonishingabundanceofdeadturtleswasclearlyvisibleevenfrombeyondtheborderofthefirezone.sodramaticwastheeffectthatfrontpagesoflocalandnationalpapersincludedanimageofaburnedturtle(CamposandArroyo2008).
BackgroundpaloVerdenationalparkislocated28kmsouthofbagaces,CostaRicainthetempisquebasin.theparkconsistsofmorethan13,000haof
floodplain,marshes,limestoneridges,andseasonalpoolsinthemiddleofthedriestregioninCostaRica.paloVerdeservestoconnecttotwootherreserves,theDr.RafaellucasRodriguezCaballeroWildlifeRefugeandthelomasbarbudalbiologicalReserve.theswamplandsthatconnectpaloVerdetotheotherreservesarethreatenedbylocalentrepreneurswhohaveinvestedinpermitstocleartheswampforestandplantcrops,whichwouldfurtherincreasetheisolationofthesereserves(baker2004). theregionexperiencesdistinctwetanddryseasons.thelackofpre-cipitationfromroughlynovembertomarchcausestheregiontobecomeverydry.Duringthisperiod,somefarmerswillintentionallystartfiresinordertoclearlandfortheircrops.Inthisregion,iflandisclearedofforest
Remainsofscorpionmudturtles(Kinosternon scorpioides)consumedbyfireatpaloVerdenationalpark.theindividualintheupperrighthadpartiallyburieditselfduringthefire.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 37neWobseRVAtIonsoFAneotRopICAlmUDtURtle
bynaturalcauses,itisessentiallyopentofarming.Additionally,poacherssetfirestoimproveaccesstocertaincovetedwildlifespecies. paloVerdeanditssurroundingreserveshave15differenthabitats,includingseveraltypesofswampsandmarshlands.thesehabitatsprovideforawealthofspeciesdiversityrangingfromWhite-tailedDeer(Odocoileus virginianus),White-nosedCoati(Nasua narica),andAmericanCrocodile(Crocodylus acutus)toendangeredspeciesincludingtheGreatCurassow(Crax rubra),Yellow-napedparrot (Amazona auropalliata), andKingVulture(Sarcoramphus papa). prescribedfireisabeneficialmanagementtoolthatcanmaintainorrestoredesired,historicecologicalconditions(e.g.,brockwayandlewis1997,CarterandFoster2004).prescribedburninghasbecomeaprimarytoolofecosystemrestorationintheUnitedstatesbecauseofthebenefitsandhistoricalassociationoffireinsomeecosystems(Johnsonandhale2002).Withsuchanincreaseintheuseofprescribedfires,understandingtheeffectsonwildlifebecameincreasinglyimportant(Fordetal.1999).Unfortunately,littleinformationexistsabouttheeffectsofprescribedfireonamphibiansandreptiles(mcleodandGates1998,Fordetal.1999,Greenburgetal.1994,pilliodetal.2003).Althoughsomeobviousandimmediatedeclinesofamphibianandreptilianpopulationswilloccurdur-ingawetlandfire,vegetativerecoveryandrestructuringmightprovidebet-terhabitatforindividualpopulations—asubjectinneedofmorestudy.
Recording the EffectsWedocumentedturtlesandotherspecieswithinandaroundthefirezonebyutilizingstandardizedtransectsamplingmethods.Wealsoattempted
todetermineturtledensitiesindifferentareasofthefirezonebyusingastratified-randomstudydesign.thefirezonewasclassifiedintothreecategories:(1)Closetotheignitionpoint,(2)closetotheterminusofthefire,and(3)anintermediatearea.Withineachzone,werandomlyselectedthree1,000x1,000-mstudyplots.Withineachplot,wecountedturtleswithinfive300-mtransects. Weexpectedtofindanassemblageofturtlespeciesinthewetland,butthescorpionmudturtle(Kinosternon scorpioides)wasconsideredthemostlikelytooccur.Itrangesatlowelevationsfromsoutherntamaulipas,méxico,southwardtonorthernArgentina,bolivia,andnorthernperú(ernstetal.1992).thisspeciesisomnivorousandwilleatfish,snails,amphibians,insects,algae,andotherplants(Vanzolinietal.1980).Ithasahigh-domedcarapacethatcanmeasureupto17.5cminlength.thecarapacehasthreewell-developedlongitudinalkeelsandisanunmarkedbrowntoblackincolor.theplastronhasasinglemovablehingebetweenthepectoralandabdominalscutes.theplastronmightnotbelargeenoughtocompletelyprotecttheanimalwhenclosed(ernstetal.1992,berryandIverson2001). one subspeciesofscorpionmudturtle, theRed-cheekedmudturtle(K. s. cruentatum),wastheonlyturtleobservedinthefirezoneoradjacentareas.turtlesoccurredatadensityof6.33turtles/transector316.5turtles/ha.thiswassimilar,butslightlygreaterthanthe254turtles/hareportedbymedinaetal.(2007)foranother subspeciesofK. scorpioides(K. s. albogulare).Intemperateregions,Gibbons(1983)reported56K. subrubrum/haandboninetal.(2006)reporteddensitiesforseveralspeciesofmudandmuskturtles,including260turtles/haforK. subrubrum,229
Additionalspecieskilledinthefirezoneincludednortherntamandua(Tamandua mexicana;A),White-lippedpeccary(Tayassu pecari;b),White-nosedCoati(Nasua narica;C),andboaConstrictor(Boa constrictor;D).
A
C
B
D
38 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 GUInnAnDlUGeR
turtles/haforSternotherus carinatus,and194turtles/haforS. odoratus.nodensityestimateswereavailableforK. s. cruentatuminotherareas. nosignificantdifferences(one-wayAnoVA,F=0.08,p=0.10)existedinthenumbersofturtlesobservedamongsitecategories,suggestingthatturtlesdidnotmakelargemovementsawayfromtheignitionpoint.mudturtlesmightbeparticularlysusceptibletofiresduetoanadaptationtoseasonaldryweather;theyoftenburrowinthemuduntilthenextrain(ernstetal.1992).thisadaptationcouldbeoneexplanationforwhysomanymudturtleswerekilledinthepaloVerdemarshlandfire.perhapstheydidnottrytoescapethefire,butinsteadsimplytriedtoburrowintothesediments.however,teska(1976)reportedsubstantialmovementsofturtlesinGuanacasteprovinceduringthedryseason. Additionalspecieskilledinthefirezoneincludednortherntamandua(Tamandua mexicana),White-lippedpeccary(Tayassu pecari),White-nosedCoati(Nasua narica),andboaConstrictor(Boa constrictor)alongwithsev-eralunidentifiablesnakespecies.othersources(CamposandArroyo2008)alsolistedtheGrayFox(Urocyon cinereoargenteus).Documentationofsuchmobilespeciesandaccountsfromparkofficialssuggestthatthefirewasextremelyfast-moving.however,thesespeciesmighthavetriedtoclimborburrowinunsuccessfulattemptsatescapingthefire.Interestingly,nocrocodilianswereobservedinthefirezone. While the lossof individualsdue to this actof arson cannotbeoverstated,theinsightintoturtlecommunitiesprovidedbythisresearchincreasesparkmanagers’knowledgeoftheherpetofauna.Accordingtosavage(2002),“verylittleisknownofthelifeofthiscommonspecies”(Red-cheekedscorpionmudturtle).Also,duringourfinaltransect,werecordedtheonlylivingturtlesthatwereobservedduringourentiretimeatpaloVerdenationalpark.threeRed-cheekedmudturtlesmadetheirwayalongthefireline,theirshellsslightlycharred,butotherwiseunscathed.bytheendofourstudy,freshgreensproutswerealreadyeruptingfromtheashes.moll(1990),Gibbonsetal.(1983),andpritchardandtrebbau(1994)suggestedthatscorpionmudturtlescouldrapidlymoveintodif-
ferentareasinresponsetodroughtandhabitatavailability.theoutlookforreestablishingtheturtlepopulationinthisareaappearstobeverypositive.
Literature Citedbaker,C.p.2004.Moon Handbook: Costa Rica.5thed.Avalontravelpublishing,
emeryville,California.
berry,J.F.andJ.b.Iverson.2001. Kinosternon scorpioides.Catalogue of American Amphibians and Reptiles(725):1–11.
bonin,F.,b.Devaux,andA.Dupré.2006.Turtles of the World.translatedbyp.C.h.pritchard.JohnshopkinsUniversitypress,baltimore,maryland.
brockway,D.G.andC.e.lewis.1997.long-termeffectsofdormant-seasonpre-scribedfireonplantcommunitydiversity,structure,andproductivityinalongleafpinewiregrassecosystem.Forest Ecology and Management 96:167–183.
Campos,C.andF.Arroyo.2008.tragediaincalculableenpaloVerde:biologosestimanquerecuperciondeecosistemastardarasiglos.Al Día Periódico,11may2008.
Carter,m.C.andC.D.Foster.2004.prescribedburningandproductivityinsouth-ernpineforests:Areview.Forest Ecology and Management191:93–109.
Costa, h.C., F.b. molina, V.A. sao-pedro, and R.n. Feio. 2010. Reptilia,testudines,Kinosternidae,Kinosternon scorpioides scorpioides (linnaeus,1776):Distributionextension.Check List6:314–315.
ernst,C.h.,R.G.m.Altenburg,andR.W.babour.1992.Turtles of the World.smithsonianInstitutionpress,Washington,D.C.
Ford,W.m.,m.A.menzel,D.W.mcGill,J.laerm,andt.s.mcCay.1999.effectsofacommunityrestorationfireonsmallmammalsandherpetofaunainthesouthernAppalachians.Forest Ecology and Management114:233–243.
Gibbons,J.W.1983.Reproductivecharacteristicsandecologyofthemudturtle,Kinosternon subrubrum(lacépède).Herpetologica39:254–271.
Gibbons,J.W.,J.l.Greene,andJ.D.Congdon.1983.Drought-relatedresponsesofaquaticturtlepopulations.Journal of Herpetology17:242–246.
Greenburg,C.h.,D.G.neary,andl.D.harries.1994.effectofhigh-intensitywildfireandsilviculturaltreatmentsonreptilecommunitiesinsand-pinescrub.Conservation Biology8:1047–1057.
Johnson,A.s.andp.e.hale.2002.thehistoricalfoundationsofprescribedburn-ingforwildlife:Asoutheasternperspective,pp.11–23.In:W.m.Ford,K.R.Russell,andC.e.moorman(eds.),theRoleofFireinnongameWildlifemanagement and Community Restoration: traditional Uses and newDirections.proceedingsofaWorkshop.15september2000,nashville,tennessee,UsA.GeneraltechnicalReportne-288.UsDAForestservicenortheasternResearchstation,newtownsquare,pennsylvania.
medina,G.F.,o.V.C.mora,ando.montenegro.2007.Abundance,populationstructure,andconservationofKinosternon scorpioides albogulareontheCaribbeanIslandofsanAndres,Colombia.Chelonian Conservation and Biology6:163–169.
mcleod,R.F.andJ.e.Gates.1998.Responseofherpetofaunalcommunitiestofor-estcuttingandburningatChesapeakeFarms,maryland.American Midland Naturalist139:163–177.
moll,D.1990.populationsizesandforagingecologyinatropicalfreshwaterstreamturtlecommunity.Journal of Herpetology24:48-53.
pilliod,D.s.,R.b.bury,e.J.Jyde,C.A.pearl,andp.s.Corn.2003.FireandamphibiansinnorthAmerica.Forest Ecology and Management178:163–181.
pritchard,p.C.h.andp.trebbau.1984.The Turtles of Venezuela.societyforthestudyofAmphibiansandReptiles,Ithaca,newYork.
savage,J.m.2002.The Amphibians and Reptiles of Costa Rica: A Herpetofauna Between Two Continents, Between Two Seas.UniversityofChicagopress,Chicago,Illinois.
teska,W.R.1976.terrestrialmovementsofthemudturtleKinosternon scorpioidesinCostaRica.Copeia1976:579–580.
Vanzolini,p.e.,A.m.m.Ramos-Costa,andl.J.Vitt.1980.Repteis das Caatingas.AcademiabrasileiradeCiencias,RiodeJaneiro,brasil.
oneofthefewscorpionmudturtlesthatsurvivedthefire,itsshellslightlycharred,butotherwiseunscathed.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 39CommentARY
c o M M e n T a R y
Wearecurrentlyinabiodiversitycrisis.Aquarterofallmammalsfaceextinction,and90%ofthelargestoceanfisharegone.species
aregoingextinctatratesequaledonlyfivetimesinthehistoryoflife.butthebiodiversitycrisiswearecurrentlyencounteringisn’tjustalossofspe-cies,it’salsoalossofknowledgeregardingthem.scientistswhoclassify,describe, andexamine the relationshipsbetweenorganismsare them-selvesgoingextinct.themillionsofdollarsspentgloballyontechnologytocatalogspeciesmayactuallybepushingoutthepeoplewerelyupon:taxonomistsandsystematists.We’relikeyoungchildrenfrantictoaddnewbaseballcardstoourcollections,whiletheactualcreatorsofthebaseballcardsthemselvesarevanishing. take,forexample,theaplacophorans,arare,raregroupofinverte-bratescloselyrelatedtooctopuses,squids,snails,andclams.mostofuswillneverseeevenoneoftheapproximately360knownspeciesofsmall(lessthanacoupleofincheslong)aplacophoransthatinhabitoceandepthsgreaterthan50feet—butignoranceofthisgroupisnotlimitedtothepublic.Fewerthantwodozenscientificpapershavebeenpublishedonthegroupsince2005,eventhoughmanynewspeciesawaitdiscoveryanddescription—andmostofthesestudiesweredonebyonescientist,thevenerableAméliescheltemaofWoodsholeoceanographicInstitute.Assheedgesclosertoretirement,shemaysadlybecomethelasttostudyapla-cophorans.If50%ofthespeciesofaplacophoranwentextincttomorrow,wewouldneverknow. Amelie’sstoryistragicallycommon.martinsørensenofthenaturalhistorymuseumofDenmarkisoneoftheveryfewactivekinorhynch,ormud-dragon,taxonomists.martinalsorepresentsoneofonlytwoliv-ingtaxonomistswhohavestudiedgnathostomulids.theother,Wolfgangsterrer,isretired.bothkinorhynchsandgnathostomulidsaresmall,lessthanone-tenthofaninchinlength,anddwellbetweengrainsofsandandmudontheoceanfloor.Fewerthan300speciesaredescribedfrombothofthesephyla—thebroadestclassificationintowhichscientistsgroupanimals—andourknowledgeofthemisbasedalmostentirelyoncol-lectionsfromthewell-exploredeasterncoastoftheUnitedstates,themediterranean,andthewesterncoastofeurope. “evenwithintheseareas,newspeciesappearquiteoften,andwhenIcollectoutside[theseareas],Ialwaysexpecttofindundescribedtaxaexclu-sively,”sørensenwroteinarecente-mailtome.hisnewworkintheeastChinaseahasalreadyuncovered15newspecies.Indeed,themorninghee-mailedme,sørensen,lookingthroughhismicroscope,hadjustdiscov-eredanothernewspecies.“thenumberoftaxonomistsworkingontheseobscuretaxahasalwaysbeenratherlow(whichexplainsourlimitedknowl-edgeaboutthem),butwithinthelast20yearstaxonomyasadisciplinehas
comeunderevenharderpressurewhichhasresultedinafurtherdeclineinthenumberofexperts,”sørensenwrote. thisproblemplagueswell-knowngroups,too.Forexample,nema-todesrepresentmorethan28,000describedspeciesoffreshwater,marine,terrestrial,andparasiticroundworms.ontheseafloor,theyaccountfor85–95%ofallorganisms.however,anewstudyfoundthenumberofscientificpapersdescribingnewnematodespeciesishalfofwhatitwas
The Mass extinction of scientists Who study species1
CraigmcClain2
1Adaptedwithpermissionfrom<www.wired.com/wiredscience/2011/01/extinc-tion-of-taxonomists/>(posted19January2011).
2CraigmcClainisassistantdirectorofscienceforthenationalevolutionarysynthesisCenterandhasconducteddeep-searesearchfor13years,participatingindozensofexpeditionsinthemostremoteregionsofthepacificandAtlanticoceans.mcClainfocusesontheecologicalandevolutionarydriversofmarine-invertebratebiodiversityandbodysize,mostlyindeep-seasystems.heoftenexplorestheconsequencesoffoodlimitationonbiologicalsystems.mcClainisalsothechiefeditoroftheaward-winningscienceblog,Deep-seanews.
thedearthoftaxonomistsandsystematistsisnotasdireforterrestrialvertebratesasforinvertebrates.nevertheless,ongoingnewdiscoveriesofmammals,birds,reptiles,andamphibianspreviouslyunknowntoscienceprovideampleevidencethatwemightbeunderminingoureffortstoprotectbiodiversitybynotsupportingeffortsthatencourageyoungscientiststolearnandimplementtheskillsnecessarytogenerateessentialknowledgeoflife’sdiversitybeforeitdisappears.thisandthefollowingimagesfeaturefourU.s.-basedscientistsactivelyinvolvedinthetaxonomyandsystematicsofamphibiansandreptiles.Janaleep.Caldwell,ofthesamnobleoklahomamuseumofnaturalhistoryandDepartmentofZoology,Universityofoklahoma,inafieldcampinbrazil.Amazoniaandtheneotropicsingeneralhar-boraplethoraofundescribedspecies.CaldwelldescribedthedendrobatidHyloxalus chlorocraspedusin2005.malesserveastheparentalfrog,carryingasmanyastentadpolesontheirbacksbeforereleasingthemintosmallforestpoolsshortlybeforemetamorphosis.
Jan
aLe
e p.
Ca
LdW
eLL
Lau
rie
J. v
itt
40 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 mCClAIn
adecadeago,andathirdofthedecadebeforethat.Anywherebetween10,000and100,000speciesremainundescribed. Whythelossoftaxonomists?Wehavedevaluedtheircontributions,bothmonetarilyandscientifically.someattributethedeclineoftheseresearcherstothereplacementofoutdatedmethodsthatwouldnotmeetthescrutinyofsciencetoday.thesecriticsenvisiontaxonomistsaslone
l.leeGrismer,oflasierraUniversityinRiverside,California,incollaborationwithhissonandanumberofnationalscientists,hasdescribedover70newspeciesinthepastsixyears,allfromsoutheasternAsiaandmanyofthosefromthemalayArchipelago.theaptlynamedCnemaspis psychedelicaisaninsularendemicknowntooccurononlyoneof92poorlyexploredVietnameseislandsthatarebeginningtoshowasurprisingdegreeofendemismanddiversity.thisdiscoveryclearlysuggeststhat,despiterecentwork,theherpetofaunaldiversityoftheregionisbarelyknown.
L. L
ee G
ris
Mer
Rafebrown(topright),ofthenaturalhistorymuseumandbiodiversityInstitute,UniversityofKansas,withgraduatestudentsinthephilippines.Hylarana(formerlyRana) tipanan (center)wasdescribedbybrownandcolleagues in2000;whenitsIUCnRedliststatuswasassessedin2004,thespecieswasdeterminedtobeVulnerableduetoahighlyfragmenteddistributionattributablelargelytoacontinu-ingdeclineintheextentandqualityofitsforesthabitatonluzoninthephilippines.thediscoveryofa2-m-longlizard(bottom)intheforestsofthephilippinesspeaksclearlytothelackofcurrentknowledgeofthearchipelago’sbiodiversity,evenasitsforestsaredecliningatanalarmingrate.Varanus bitatawaisoneofonlythreeknownspeciesof frugivorous(fruit-eating)monitor lizards intheworld.e.o.Wilson(1992.The Diversity of Life.W.W.norton&Co.,Inc.,newYork)asked:“Williteverbepossibletoassesstheongoinglossofbiodiversity?Icannotimagineascientificproblemofgreaterimmediateimportanceforhumanity.biologistsfinditdifficulttocomeupwithevenanapproximateestimateofthehemorrhagingbecauseweknowsolittleaboutdiversityinthefirstplace.…wedonotknowthevastmajorityofspeciesoforganismswell;wehaveyettoanointsomanyas90per-centofthemwithscientificnames.”
Jose
ph B
ro
Wn
ra
Fe B
ro
Wn
Luk
e W
eLto
n
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 41CommentARY
museumscientistssurroundedbydustywoodcabinetsandbottlesofform-aldehydewherespeciesdescriptionismoreartthanscience—butthispor-trayaloverlooksthesuiteofmoderngeneticmethodsthatthoseinterestedindiscoveryanddescriptionofnewspeciesusewithincreasingfrequency.
thisnewbreedoftaxonomistsincludesChrismahofthesmithsoniannationalmuseumofnaturalhistoryandAdrianGloverofthenaturalhistorymuseuminlondon,whoareamongtheworld’sleadingexpertsonseastarsandmarineworms,respectively.bothdemonstratethatthemostinformativesciencecomesfromsynthesizinggenetictechniqueswithmoreclassicaltaxonomybasedonknowledgeoftheanatomyandnaturalhistoryoforganisms. extinctionoftaxonomistscontinuesdespiteagrowingpooloffundsforbiodiversityprogramsanddatabases.eUnIs,eol,obIs…thelistgoeson.thesedatabaseshavepooledourcollectivebiodiversityknowledge,helpingidentifywhatdrivesbiodiversityandsetconservationpriorities.thankfully(myownresearchhasrelieduponthem),thousandsofhoursandmillionsofdollarshavebeenspentontheseinitiatives.however,manyoftheseprogramsdidnotfinanciallysupporttaxonomistsgeneratingthedatathesedatabasesrequired. Afteradecadeand650milliondollars,theCensusofmarineliferepresentsoneofthelargestinitiativestodocumentbiodiversityonourplanet.Insomeregards,itwasagreatsuccess,supporting2,700scientiststoproduce2,600newscientificpublicationsandthousandsofnewspeciesdescriptions.butastheCensusendsthisyear,noagencyororganizationisofferingtofillthefundingvoidpreviouslyfilledbytheAlfredp.sloanFoundation.perhapsmoreimportantly,theCensus,likemanyinitiatives,didnotprovidelong-termpositionsandappointmentsforthosedoingtaxonomicwork.manybiologydepartmentswithinuniversitiesnolongeremployataxonomist.theremainingpositionsarerelegatedtomuseums. Why?Assørensenexplains,“thedecliningnumberoftaxonomistsandsystematistsisatleasttosomeextentlinkedtothefactthatyoursci-entificproductiontodayshouldbemeasurable.”theunitsofmeasure-mentarecollectedgrantmoneyortheimpactfactorofajournalpaper.taxonomyhasneverbeenconsideredhot,andpuretaxonomicstudiesarerarelyfunded,hewrote.Departmentsneedgrantmoneytooperate. scienceasaninstitutionmayalsobepartlyresponsibleforundercut-tingtaxonomicwork.Althoughacrudemetricfraughtwithseveralissues,wemeasuretheimpactofascientificpaperbyhowmanytimesothersci-entificpapershavecitedit.similarly,wemeasuretheimpactofscientistsbycountingtheircumulativecitations.Unfortunately,taxonomicworkisrarelycited,evenwhenitshouldbe. ontheotherhand,thebrilliantbiodiversitydatabaseswehavecre-atedleadtoaplethoraofscientificpapers.thepaleobiologyDatabase,acomprehensiveonlinecatalogoffossilspecies,hasalreadygeneratedmorethan100publications.buttherequirementforusingthisdatabase,likemostothers,iscitationofthedatabaseitself,notthenearly35,000papersgeneratingtheoriginaldata. thedeclineintaxonomistsmeansthatatsomepointinthefuturewewillbeunabletotrainnewgenerationsoftaxonomists.thisproblemisrecognizedbythenationalscienceFoundation,whichin1994createdaprogramtoenhancetaxonomicresearch.Whilethisinitiativeprovidestraining,itdoesnotcreatejobopportunities.otherproblemsaretakingformtoo.Forexample,in2006,Isetouttoexplorehowbiodiversityandbodysizewerelinkedamonganimals.todosoIneededinformationonthelargest-andsmallest-sizedspeciesforeachgroupofanimals—some-thingsurprisinglynotreadilygarneredfromthepublishedliterature.Ireliedonmyconnectionswithtaxonomistsforguidanceandinformation,butformanygroupsIstruggledtofindacontact.evenforwell-knownanimals,Iwasamazedbyhowfewscientistsstillstudiedthem.mypersonalexperiencehighlightshowprogressinbiologyasawholemaybeimpededifwelosetaxonomy.theproblemwefaceisalossofknowledgenotyetrecordedinthescientificliterature.Inourtechnologicaleffortstoconcen-trateourbiodiversityknowledge,wemayberenderingafieldandbodyofknowledgeobsolete—and,intheprocess,wemaybeunderminingourowneffortstoprotectbiodiversity.
s.blairhedges,inhislaboratoryatpennsylvaniastateUniversity,hasfocusedmostofhisattentionontheWestIndianherpetofauna,whichhasgrownfrom585knownspeciesin1991towellover700today—withasmanyas1,000speciespossible—iftheyarediscoveredanddescribedbeforefallingvictimtodevelopment(mostattributabletothetourismindustry),deforestation,andinvasivespecies.theworld’ssmallestknownspeciesoflizard(Sphaerodactylus ariasae,fromthesouth-westernDominicanRepublic)andthesmallestknownsnake(Leptotyphlops carlae,frombarbados)bothoccurintheregion.
s. B
Lair
hed
Ges
Jess
iCa
kn
uth
42 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 WRIGht
thedeterioratingrelictsofhumanpresenceonsombrerohavebeeneffectivelyintegratedintothenaturalecosystem.
eLiz
aB
eth
Wr
iGh
t
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 43tRAVeloGUe
T R a v e l o g u e
thisisaninterestingtimetobealive.humansarerunningoutoflandandconstantly searching fornewopportunities to fueleconomic
growth.Atthesametime,weseeagrowingawarenessofthenaturalenvi-ronment,theresourcesitprovides,andtheharmfuleffectsofhumanpopu-lationgrowthontheearth’sotherspecies.somepeopledenythataprob-lemexistsandsuggestthatweshouldcontinueasweare.othersbelievethatweshouldparkourcars,moveintothewoods,abandontechnology,andbecomeonewithnature.mostofusfallsomewherebetweenthosetwoextremes.Ibelievethatwemustlearntocoexistwithnaturewhilefindingawaytofostereconomicgrowthwithoutdestroyingourplanet.Iamfascinatedbythatgoalandthinkthatthefirststepisinunderstandingwhatisatstake.howcanwecoexistwithnatureifweremainignorantofhercomponents?Ihadanopportunitytowitnessafewimplicationsofthisage-oldparadoxduringarecentvisittosombrero,atinyislandabout60kmnorthofAnguilla. onafinemorninginoctober2010,IwasoneofateamboardingtheaptlynamedOcean Girlz,acatamarancharteredbytheConservationAgencyforatriptosombrero.sombreroisunique.Risingoutoftheocean
sometimeintheearlypliocene,itisabout1.5kmlongandabout0.4kmatitswidestpointandhasneverbeenpartofanotherbodyofland.sombreroisthenorthernmostofthelesserAntilles,andispartofthenationofAnguilla.lifeonthe38haofmarlylimestonearrivedbymigrat-ingfromthemainlandorsmallerislandsonfloatingdebris,byflying,or
sombrero: lizards among the RuinselizabethWright
DepartmentofForestry,Universityofmissouri,Columbia,missouri
AsthenorthernmostofthelesserAntilles,sombreroisalongwayfromeverywhere,sittingonitsownislandbankandneverconnectedtoanyotherlandmass.
Joh
n s
. pa
rM
erLe
e, J
r.
sombreroisoneofthreelesserAntilleanislandsthatharborblackAmeivas.InadditiontoAmeiva corvina(namedafterequallyblackcrows),A. coraxlivesonlittlescrubIslandoffthenortheasterncoastofAnguilla,andA. atratalivesonRedonda,anotherisolated“rock”emergingfromthesea.
ro
Ber
t po
WeL
L
44 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 WRIGht
Accessbyladderisnecessaryforscalingthesheerwallsoftheisland,limestonecliffsshooting12mstraightupoutofthewater.
ro
Ber
t po
WeL
L
theanolesofsombreroareverysimilartoAnolis gingivinus,whichisubiquitousontheAnguillabank.Geneticstudieswilldetermineiftheyarethesamespecies.
Ga
d p
err
y
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 45tRAVeloGUe
beingcarriedbystorms,birds,orhumans.theislandisfrequentlydelugedbygiantwaves,andmightbeentirelysubmergedduringseverehurricanes.suchconditionsmakeithardtogetthereandevenhardertosurvive.theresultingfoundereffect—thesometimesconsiderableimpactthatthefewfoundingindividualscanhaveonlatergenerations—dramatically
increasesthechanceofendemism(Ivie1999).thisiswhyweweregoingtosombrero. thetripwasorganizedbyDr.Robertpowell,aherpetologistatAvilaUniversity,whowantedtolearnmoreaboutthelizardsofsombrero.Dr.Jameslazell,thepresidentoftheConservationAgency,hadvisitedtheislandin1963andhaddiscoveredthatthreespeciesoccurredontheisland(notjusttheonethathadbeenpreviouslyreported):AnanolecurrentlyidentifiedasAnolis gingivinus,thecommonspeciesonthenearbyAnguillabank;aDwarfGecko,whichlazelldescribedasSphaerodactylus“near”spu-tator,thespeciesthatoccursonboththeAnguillaandst.Christopherbanks;andthespectacularblackGroundlizard,Ameiva corvina(lazell1964).In
theDwarfGeckosonsombreroexhibitvariablepatterns,somespotted,somealmostunicolored,andotherswithstripes,asseenonthesetwoadults(A/b)andonejuvenile(C).
s. B
Lair
hed
Ges
Island Girlz,hereanchoredoffsombrero,madetheexpeditiontotheislandacom-fortableexperience—althoughthecaptainhadnotpreviouslybeentosombrero.
Ga
d p
err
y
Abrownbooby(Sula leucogaster),silhouettedagainstthesunlitskyonwhatlookedlikearustyloadingcrane,greetedourarrival.
Ga
d p
err
y
Althoughproficientscavengerswhenbirdsorpeopleprovidewelcomemeals,theAmeivasofsombrerousuallyhavetodigandrootforfood.
ro
Ber
t po
WeL
L
46 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
the1960s,whenDr.lazellvisitedsombrero,noonewasyetdreamingofthesecretsthatDnAmightonedayreveal,andtissuescollectedduringasurveybyDr.JennyDaltry(1999)weresubsequentlylost.thetimehadcometocollectsomemoresamplessothattherelationshipsandperhapstrueidentitiesoftheselizardscouldfinallybeestablished.ourteamalsoincludedDr.Gadperry,aconservationbiologistattexastechUniversity,Dr.Wenhualu,anentomologistwiththeConservationAgency,andsusanValentine-Cooper,anexperiencedentomologist,who,likeme,hadbeeninvitedtocomealongandhelpcollectsmallarthropods. so,therewewereaboardOcean Girlz,onourwayfromGuanaIslandinthebritishVirginIslands,wherewewereconductinglong-termresearchprojects,tosombrero.Iwasinaweoftheflyingfishastheyexplodedoutofthewaterandsoaredforwhatappearedtobehundredsofmetersacross
thewaves.Asweapproachedtheislandsomethreehoursintoourvoyage,wesawasmallvesselanchoredneartheladderthatprovidesaccesstotheisland.Accessbyladderisnecessaryforscalingthesheerwallsoftheisland,limestonecliffsshooting12mstraightupoutofthewater.Ialmostfellintothewateronmyfirstattempttostepfromthebowofourcatamaran,movingup-and-downwiththewaves,ontotheladder,andwassavedonlybythequickactionofthecrew.mysecondattemptwassuccessfulandIclimbedup,themetalhotundermyhands.
migratoryblackpollWarblers(Dendroica striata)dartedabout,searchingforthesameinsectsweweretryingtocollect(A).thesetinybirds,whichbegantheirvoy-ageinthenortheasternUnitedstates,hadflownoveropenoceanfordays.totallyspent,someindividualsunluckyatmakingtheirfirstlandfallonadesolateislandlikesombrero,wereunabletoscroungeforsparsefoodintimetofendoffexhaus-tionanddeath(b).Althoughunfortunateforthebirds,theAmeivasreadilyscav-engedthecarcasses(C).
ro
Ber
t po
WeL
LeL
iza
Bet
h W
riG
ht
eLiz
aB
eth
Wr
iGh
t
thepowerfulclawsontheforelimbsofAmeivasareideallysuitedforrootinganddiggingforfood.
s. B
Lair
hed
Ges
WRIGht
theauthor,withaspiratorinhand,searchesforsmallarthropodsamongtheruins.
Ga
d p
err
y
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 47
theotherboathadcarriedtheimmigrationofficialfromAnguillawhowastomeetusandcheckourpassports.IwasnervousasIapproachedthetopoftheladder,expectingalargeAnguillianofficialwithascowl.WhatIencounteredatthetopoftheladder,however,wasthemostnon-threateningimmigrationofficerIcouldimagine.hewasslenderandworeastrawhat,aloose-fittingbutton-upshirt,andkhakipants,andhewassweatingandsmilingandsettledonarock.Wegavehimourpassports,heverifiedthatwewerewhowesaidwewere,andbeganhislongjourneyhome.Weturnedtotakeinoursurroundings. thelandscapewasdesolate.notatreeinsight,justvineyplantscriss-crossingtherocks.overhead,abrownbooby(Sula leucogaster)wassilhou-ettedagainstthesunlitskyonwhatlookedlikearustyloadingcrane.blackAmeivaswereabundant,scurryingabitwhenwegottooclose.magnificentFrigatebirds(Fregata magnificens)hoveredinpocketsofhotair,theirredthroatsacsflappingalittleinthewind.migratorybirds,mostlyblackpollWarblers(Dendroica striata)dartedabout,searchingforthesameinsectsIwasintendingtocatch. Despiteitsrelativeisolation,humanshavehadaconsiderableimpactonsombrero.oldrustymetalstructuresjuttedupallovertheisland.Giantpitsinthelimestonepepperedtheotherwiseflatterrain,testamentto19th-centuryAmericanandbritishminingoperationsthatquarriedconsider-ablevolumesofphosphates(mineralizedguano)foruseasfertilizerinanefforttoresuscitatethesoilsofthesouthernstatesthathadbeenexhaustedbytheplantationsystem.theyevenblewupwholesectionsofthehat-shapedislanduntilonlythebrimremained(pappalardo2001).however,thiswasnottheonlytimetheislandwasthreatenedbyhumanactivities.In1999and2000,bealAerospaceoftexaswasconsideringsombreroasapotentiallaunchingsiteforrocketscarryingcommercialsatellitesintospace.triggeredbyresistancefrombirdenthusiastswhoclaimedthatsombrerowasanimportantnestingsiteformanyWestIndianspecies,bealcon-ductedanenvironmentalassessmentthatclaimedthatthenestingsitewasnotthatimportantandthatonlyonespeciesoflizardlivedontheisland—andthattherocketswouldnotaffectthem.bealultimatelydecidednotWindowsintheruinsoftheoldlighthousekeeper’squarterslookoutoverthe
desolatelandscapeofsombrerototheAtlanticoceanbeyond.
Ga
d p
err
y
tRAVeloGUe
Ravagedby19th-centuryminingactivitiesanderodedovertimebyrainandwavesofwaterviolentlywashingovertheisland,thesurfaceofsombreroisamazeofsharpandporous“dog-tooth”limestone.
Ga
d p
err
y
48 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
tousesombrero,notbecauseofthedestructivenatureoftheprojectbutbecausetheweatherwasnottotheirtaste(pappalardo2001). theisland’sguanodepositswereexhaustedby1890,leaving“dog-tooth”limestonethatissharpandporous,erodedovertimebyrainandwavesofwaterviolentlywashingovertheisland.IwasveryawareofhowexposedmyfeetwereinChacosandals.Despitetheapparentdesolation,
Iknewtheislandwasteemingwithcreatures.“Well,wedon’thavemuchtime,”Dr.powellsaid,awakeningmefrommystateofawe.“let’sstartcollecting.”Drs.powellandperrywentoffinsearchoflizards.“Catch’emifyoucan,ladies!”Dr.perrycalled,referringtolizards,ofcourse,ashetrudgedinthedirectionofthelighthouse. theentomologyteamstartedcollecting.typically,webeatvegetationandcatchfallinginsectsinournetsbeloworsweepthroughgrasseswith
WRIGht
oneofthelargerminingpits,relictsof19th-centuryeffortstoextractmineralizedphosphates(guano)thathadaccumulatedoverthecenturiescourtesyofinnumerablegenerationsofnestingseabirds.
Ga
d p
err
y
Duringtheheatoftheday,nestingbrownboobies(Sula leucogaster)liftedtheirbodiesofftheireggstopreventoverheating.squawkingabitifweapproachedtooclosely,theywereotherwiseindifferenttoourpresence.
ro
Ber
t po
WeL
L
Catchingelusivelittlegeckosintherubbleofsombrerowasnotalwayssuccessful.Inthisinstance,however,thebrokentailwillprovideDnAforgeneticstudiestodetermineiftheDwarfGeckosofsombreroare“near”Sphaerodactylus sputator,aslazell(1964)indicated.thelizardescapedandwillregenerateanewtail.
eLiz
aB
eth
Wr
iGh
t
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 49
nets—butsombrerohasnotallvegetation.so,westartedturningoverrocksandpiecesofrustymetal.Wewouldbepreparedwithouraspirators—devicesinvolvingasmallplasticjarequippedwithtubestosuckuplittlecritters.Arubbercorkinthejarhastwocurvedmetaltubesstickingouteitherside,ashortonewithascreenthatleadsintothejarthatisconnectedtoalongrubbertubethatyousuckwithandalongeronethatisplacedneartheinsectyouwant.Yousuckinandtheinsectisvacuumedintothejar(andnotintoyourmouthbecauseofthescreen).Itriedlookingunderrocksallovertheisland,butinsectswerefewandfarbetween—untilweclimbeddownintooneoftheminingpits,whereIfoundsomethingthatIhadnotseen—hugecongregationsoftinymites.perhapstheywereinthepitbecausethetemperaturewaslowerorperhapsthepocketsandcrevicesretainedalittlemoisture. After little success while flipping rocks, I started picking apartsomeofthesmallplantsand,loandbehold,Ifoundwebspinners(orderembioptera).Webspinnersareverycoolprimitiveinsectswithsilkglandsusedtospinthegalleriesinwhichtheylive.Iruthlesslysuckedthemupwithmyaspirator.Ialsolookedthroughanoldboobynest,whereIfoundseveralbeetleandflylarvae.Isuckedthoseup,too—assistedbyanAmeivawithwhomIgladlysharedthetroveofinsectlarvae. Alreadysunburnedandwithlittletimeleftontheisland,Idecidedtoexploresomeofthebuildings.thelighthouse,builtin1868afterashiphadrunintotheislandin1859,wasinruins.evenafterminingoperationswereabandoned,thebritishboardoftrademaintainedthelighthousetoguideshipsthroughtheAnegadapassage.In1960,ahurricanedestroyedthelighthouse,whichwasreplacedandhasgonethroughseveralincarna-tionssince.Itwasautomatedin2002,butleftahistoryclearlyportrayedbythedecayingruins.
eLiz
aB
eth
Wr
iGh
tr
oB
ert
poW
eLL
tRAVeloGUe
onafood-limitedisland,lizardsmustactivelysearchformeals.thisAmeivawasforagingthroughtheremainsofaboobynestinsearchoffood.
eLiz
aB
eth
Wr
iGh
t
theabundanceofdown-coveredboobychickstestifiedtothedearthofpredatorsonanisolatedisland.
ro
Ber
t po
WeL
L
50 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 WRIGht
theconcretebaseoftheoldlighthouseandtheremainsofthelighthousekeeper’squartersstandside-by-sidewiththenewautomatedlighthouse.
Ga
d p
err
y
thissombreroAmeivahadjustexcavatedabeetlegrub.
ro
Ber
t po
WeL
L
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 51
Despitetheirghostlyappearance,thebuildingshavebeenintegratedintotheisland’secosystem.AsIenteredwhatwasleftofoneoftheoldstaffhouses,IencounteredtwolargeAmeivas—andonehadsomethingyellowandinsect-likehangingoutofitsmouth.Icreptcloser,determinedtostealtheirsnack.thelizardsscurriedunderapileofplywoodplanks.AsIcare-fullyliftedthem,theAmeivasslippedoutadoorwaywithemptymouths,leavingayellowandbrownscorpionthatlaylifelessandstingerlessontheplank.Icollecteditimmediately. Iwanderedintoanotherbuildingandsawananoleonthewindowsillwithsomethinginitsmouth.Iwasveryconfidentnow,andedgedcloser—buttheanolewasmoreskittishthanthemorerelaxedgroundlizardsanditsprinteddownthewall,acrossthefloor,andunderalargeloosetile.
Itiptoedcloserandslowlystartedtoflipthetile.thelizardranoutbutlefthislunch,alivelycricket.Igrabbeditbeforeithoppedawayandslippeditintotheplasticbagwiththedeceasedscorpion.Ithankedthelizardsandapologizedforstealingtheirlunchesbeforeheadingbacktowheretheoth-ershadgathered. Asthelastspecimenswerebeingcollected,IdecidedthatIneededtocatchmyfirstlizard.Whatbetterplacetodoitthanonanislandliterallycrawlingwithhundredsofimperturbableblacklizards?Icrouchedlowtothegroundandwaitedpatientlyasthelizardsdrewnearer.AssoonasIreachedouttograbone,however,itwoulddashoutoftheway.Dr.perryapproachedandaskedifIwantedalittlehelp.hehandedmeanoose.“Juststickthenooseneartheheadandpullup—prettycomplicated.”Withliz-ardscrawlingaroundmelikesassylittleblackdinosaurs,Ihadonewithinaminute.Dr.perrytaughtmehowtocorrectlyholdalizardbygraspingbothlegsofonesideinthesamehand.Inamedhimbobert.mytwominutesoflizard-catchingblisscametoanabruptendaswedecidedtocallitaday. Whenthecaptainandcrewsawusheadingtotheladder,theypickedusuponebyone.thistimewehadtojumpfromtheladdertothebobbingboat.Again,IalmostfellintryingtoimpersonateIndianaJonesandbarelymadeitontotheboat.Ibeggedthecaptaintoletmetakeadiptocoolmysunburnedbodybeforeweheadedoutandassoonasheagreed,Iwasoutofmyfieldclothes,inmysuit,anddivingoffthesideoftheboat.IhaveneVeRswuminsuchclearwater.WhatIhadassumedwasonlyabout15feetdeepwas,infact,morelikefifty!Itwaslikeswimminginliquidglass. onthetriphome,IthoughtaboutwhatIhadseen,asnapshotofaverycomplexanddelicateecosystem.Iwishedthatwehadhadmoretime,achancetocollectatnight,tomakemoreobservations.I’msureawholebookcouldbewrittenabouttheecologyofsombrero.Despitethemin-ingoperationsandtheproposedrocket-launchingsite,sombrerohashungon.Forthemomentatleast,littleblacklizardsandbigbrownboobieslivelargelyundisturbedbyhumaninterlopers—andmaybethat’showitshouldstay.
AcknowledgementsKarimV.D.hodge,Director,Departmentoftheenvironment,Anguilla,facilitatedourvisittosombreroandissuedpermitsforcollectingspeci-mensandtissuesamples.theConservationAgency,withagrantfromtheFalconwoodFoundation,charteredtheboatthatcarriedustosombrero.thestaffofGuanaIslandmadearrangementsforthecharterandsupportedoureffortsinmanyways.
Literature CitedDaltry,J.C.1999.ConservationassessmentofthesombreroGroundlizard:With
notesontheotherreptilesofsombrero.Flora&FaunaInternational–UKoverseasterritoriesprogramme,Cambridge,UnitedKingdom.
Ivie,m.A.1999.InitialReport,Invertebratebiodiversitysurveyofsombrero,november1999.<http://groups.yahoo.com/group/caribbean-biodiversity/message/521>.
lazell,J.D.,Jr.1964.thereptilesofsombrero,WestIndies.Copeia1964:716–718.
pappalardo,J.2001.loveandrockets.The Dallas Observer.1march2001.
tRAVeloGUe
lackingtrees,typicallythefavoredhabitatofWestIndiananoles,theanolesofsombrerolivedonrockfacesorthedeterioratingruins—theonlyverticalhabitatsavailableontheisland.thismale(A)andfemale(b)wereonpouredconcretewallsnearthelighthouse.
Ga
d p
err
y
52 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 IntRoDUCeDspeCIes
I n T R o D u c e D s P e c I e s
thetentacledsnake, Erpeton tentaculatumlacépède1800,isastrictlyaquaticspeciesofAsianorigin(Winokur1977),whichtypicallyoccurs
insloworstagnantbodiesoffreshandbrackishwater(hahn1973),ofteninveryturbidlakes,streams,andricefields(lovic2010).thisspeciesfeedsmostlyonfishes,althoughsmallamountsofvegetationhavealsobeendoc-umentedinthediet(hahn1973).Erpeton tentaculatumpossessesapairoffleshytentaclesontherostrum,whicharelikelyusedasbothsensorystruc-tures(Winokur1977)aswellasanaidincamouflage(smithetal.2002).thisspeciesattainsanadultlengthof50–90cmtotallength(lovic2010). on9December2010at2023h,ajuvenile(280mmsVl,305mmtotallength)Erpeton tentaculatumwasfoundjustoutsidethepropertyofananimalimporter’sfacilityat6450stirlingRoad,hollywood,browardCounty,Florida(26.04591on,80.21976oW,WGs84datum).thissnakewasfoundunderapieceofartificialhumandebrisdirectlyadjacenttoasourceofwater.theindividualappeareddead,likelybecauseofthecold(13oC)evening,butrevivedafterbeingwarmed.thesnakewasdepositedintheFloridamuseumofnaturalhistory,UniversityofFlorida(UF163086).speciesidentificationwasconfirmedbyGregoryWatkins-Colwell,Yalepeabodymuseum. theintroductionpathwayforErpeton tentaculatuminFloridaisthepettrade.theadjacentareassurroundingtheactivefacilityarewellknownforunusualnon-indigenousspeciesandfrequentlysearchedfortheirille-gallyreleasedorescapedanimals.thissnakelikelyhadescapedfromanenclosureattheimporter’sfacilityorwasintentionallyreleased,andrepre-sentsthefirstknownvoucherforthisfamilyandspeciesinFlorida.Furthersearchesbytheauthorsandcolleagueshavefailedtoturnupanymoreindi-vidualsofErpeton tentaculatum,andabreedingpopulationisnotsuspected,norlikelyduetoinsufficienthabitatinthegeneralarea.
AcknowledgmentsWetrulythankJavierborrero(AycockVeterinaryClinic)forpermissiontocollectanimalsonprivatepropertydirectlyadjacenttotheanimalimporter’sfacility;GregoryWatkins-Colwell(peabodymuseumofnaturalhistory)for
speciesconfirmation;andGadperry,Robertpowell,tomChesnes,andananonymousreviewerforprovidinghelpfulcommentsonthisresearchnote.
Literature Citedhahn,D.e.1973.CommentsontentaclestructureandfunctioninErpeton tentacu-
latum(serpentes:Colubridae).Journal of Herpetology7:304–306.
lovic,V.2010.Erpeton tentaculatum (tentaclesnake,Fishingsnake).<www.thai-landsnakes.com>.
smith,t.l.,G.David,e.povel,andK.V.Kardong.2002.predatorystrikeofthetentacledsnake(Erpeton tentaculatum). Journal of Zoology256:233–242.
Winokur,R.m.1977.theintegumentarytentaclesofthesnakeErpeton tentacula-tum:structure,function,evolution.Herpetologica33:247–253.
The Tentacled snake, Erpeton tentaculatum lacépède 1800 (Homalopsidae), in florida
JoshuaD.holbrook1andKennethl.Krysko2
1palmbeachAtlanticUniversity,Westpalmbeach,Florida33401,UsA([email protected])2Floridamuseumofnaturalhistory,UniversityofFlorida,Gainesville,Florida32611,UsA([email protected])
tentacledsnake(Erpeton tentaculatum)(UF163086),collectedon9December2010inhollywood,browardCounty,Florida.
Josh
ua
d. h
oLB
ro
ok
CubanbrownAnoles(Anolis sagrei)arenativetothebahamaIslands(Caysal,Conception,Crooked,Acklins,Grandbahama,little
bahama,RumCay,andsansalvadorislandbanks),Cubaandassociated
cays,IsladelaJuventud,andlittleCayman,includingmostsatellitesandcayswithevenrudimentaryvegetation.thespeciesalsohasbecomeestab-lishedinJamaica,eithernaturallyorthroughhumanmediation.more
cuban brown anoles (Anolis sagrei) in saint lucia
matthewn.morton1andChristopherA.Cox2
1DurrellWildlifeConservationtrust,lesAugrèsmanor,trinity,JerseyJe35bp,ChannelIslands,Greatbritain([email protected])2CaribbeanenvironmentalhealthInstitute,p.o.box1111,Castries,saintlucia,WestIndies([email protected])
photographsbynathanA.Wood(DurrellWildlifeConservationtrust)
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 53
recently introducedpopulationsareknown inGrandCayman,swanIsland,sintmaarten,Grenada,saintVincent,theGrenadines(Canouan),barbados,theAtlanticCoastofméxicoasfarasbelize,theIslasdelabahía(offhonduras),Aruba,hawaii(oahuandCoconutIsland,Kauai),taiwan,thesoutheasternUnitedstates,andCalifornia(orangeCounty;hendersonandpowell2009andreferencestherein,Fläschendräger2010).
At least some introducedpopulationsoriginated in the southeasternUnitedstates. Anindividualofthisspecieswasfirstphotographedandrecordedbyoneofus(CAC)on8June2003athisresidentialpropertyatlatoc,justwestofsaintlucia’scapitol,Castries(photographicvouchermilwaukeepublicmuseummpmp-752).thesinglemalewasfoundinastockpileofcabletelevisionwireonoldtimbersincontactwiththeground.thespeciesisnotknowntohavebeenseenagainuntilreportswerereceivedon5December2010fromasecondresidentialpropertyatlatoc,approxi-mately300mnorthwestofthefirstsightingat14°0’35”n,61°0’13.5”W.thissiteisapproximately1.3kmsouthwestofsaintlucia’smainseacargoport,portCastries.tenA. sagrei werecapturedandphotographedatthissecondsite;threeofthesephotographshavebeendepositedasmuseumvouchers(seefigure).Atthissecondsite,individualswerefoundonandnearconstructionmaterials(primarilylumber)andonfencepostsaroundasmallovergrowngardenplot.endemicA. luciaeandintroducedA. wattsi wereobservedwithinafewmetersofA. sagrei,andintroducedA. extremuswasobservedwithin100m.AsA. luciae canattainalargeradultsizethan A. sagrei (hendersonandpowell2009),negativeeffectsonsaintlucia’snativeanolemightbeminimal,assuggestedforeffectsofA. sagreionendemicA. aeneusandA. richardiionGrenada(Greeneetal.2002). Whetherthenewlyestablishedpopulationremainslargelyrestrictedtoseverelyalteredhabitats,asonGrenada(Greeneetal.2002,Germanoetal.2003),saintVincent(hendersonandpowell2005,treglia2006,tregliaetal.2008,ealesandthorpe2010),andsintmaarten(Fläschendräger2010)remainstobedetermined.theoriginofthepopulationonsaintluciaisunknown,althoughthelocationforoursightingssuggeststhattheintroductionpathwaywaslikelycargo,probablylumber,fromthesouth-ernUnitedstates,againassuggestedfortheintroductionofthisspeciestoGrenada(Greeneetal.2002).
Acknowledgementsthelocationatwhichvouchersweretakenwasfirstbroughttoouratten-tionbyGerardandniallbergasse,whokindlygaveusaccesstothesiteandhelpeduscatchthelizards,asdidbarbaraschaeffer,benjibarca,mikeball,nateWoods,nickCondie,andtwylaholland.mnmisfundedbythebalcombetrustandworksinsaintluciaalongsideDurrell’spro-gramcounterpartsinthesaintluciaForestryDepartment(ministryofAgriculture,lands,Forestry&Fisheries).
Literature Citedeales,J.andR.s.thorpe.2010.Revealingthegeographicoriginofaninvasive
lizard:theproblemofnativepopulationgeneticdiversity.Biological Invasions12:77–86.
Fläschendräger,A.2010.CubanbrownAnoles (Anolis sagrei) inst.maarten.Reptiles & Amphibians17:121-122.
Germano,J.m.,J.m.sander,R.W.henderson,andR.powell.2003.herpetofaunalcommunitiesinGrenada:Acomparisonofalteredsites,withanannotatedchecklistofGrenadianamphibiansandreptiles.Caribbean Journal of Science39:68–76.
Greene,b.t.,D.t.Yorks,J.s.parmerlee,Jr.,R.powell,andR.W.henderson.2002.Discoveryof Anolis sagreiinGrenadawithcommentsonitspotentialimpactonnativeanoles.Caribbean Journal of Science38:270–272.
henderson,R.W.andR.powell.2005.Geographicdistribution:Anolis sagrei.Herpetological Review36:467.
henderson,R.W.andR.powell.2009.Natural History of West Indian Reptiles and Amphibians.UniversitypressofFlorida,Gainesville.
treglia,m.l.2006.Anannotatedchecklistoftheamphibiansandreptilesofst.Vincent,WestIndies.Iguana13:251–262.
treglia,m.l.,A.J.muensch,R.powell,andJ.s.parmerlee,Jr.2008.InvasiveAnolis sagreionst.VincentanditspotentialimpactonperchheightsofAnolis trinitatis.Caribbean Journal of Science44:251–256.
male (Aandb)and female (C)CubanbrownAnoles (Anolis sagrei) fromlatoconst.lucia.photographicvouchershavebeendepositedinthemilwaukeepublicmuseum(mpmp-753).theidentityoftheselizardsandtheindividualphotographedin2003wasconfirmedfromphotographsbyRobertW.henderson(mpm).
IntRoDUCeDspeCIes
54 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
In late october 2010, quarantine officers working in layou, st.Vincent,discoveredtwoCubanbrownAnoles(Anolis sagrei)andthree
GreenhouseFrogs(Eleutherodactylus planirostris)inacontainerofornamen-talplantsshippedbyplantationspiceGrowersinGoulds,miami-DadeCounty,Florida.photographicvouchersforA. sagreiandspecimensofE. planirostrisaredepositedinthemilwaukeepublicmuseum(mpm-p754andmpm33993–5,respectively).RobertpowellconfirmedtheidentityoftheanolesandKennethl.Kryskothatofthefrogsfromphotographs.RobertW.hendersonconfirmedtheidentificationofthefrogsafterexam-iningspecimens. bothspeciesarenativetoCuba,mostbahamianislands,andatleastsomeoftheCaymanIslands.bothhavebeenpresentinFlorida,theoriginofthisandpresumablymostotherintroductionsofbothspecies,foroveracentury(meshakaetal.2004).Anolis sagreihasbeendocumentedfromanumberoflocationsoutsideitsnaturaldistributionandisalreadyestablishedonst.Vincent(hendersonandpowell2005,tregliaetal.2008,ealesandthorpe2010)andelsewhereintheregion(powelletal.2011).Althougheffectsonnativeanoleshavetodatebeenlimited(tregliaetal.2008),largely
becauseoftherelativelyrestricteddistributionofA. sagreionst.Vincent,thatspecieshasexpandeditsrangetothepointwhereeradicationislikelytobeimpossible.however,augmentingestablishedpopulationsorintroducinglizardstonewsites(suchaslayou)shouldbeavoidedinordertopreventmorewidespreadcompetitiveinteractionswithnativecongeners. IntroducedpopulationsofEleutherodactylus planirostrisareestablishedonGreatInaguaIsland(bahamas),Jamaica,andtheCaicosIslands,andhavebeenintroducedtoGrenadaandpossiblyGuadeloupe,butarenotknowntobeestablishedthere(powelletal.2011).IfE. planirostisbecameestablished,itwouldprobablyinteractmostintenselywithE. johnstonei,whichisubiquitousatlowelevationsonst.Vincent,phenomenallyabun-dantinurbanareasanddisturbedhabitats,andisitselfanintroducedspe-cies(e.g.,malleryetal.2007,powellandhenderson2007).AlthoughE. planirostrisisgenerallyconsideredtobemoreterrestrialthanE. john-stonei,thelatterisquiteabundantinterrestrialsituations(underrocksanddebrisinditchesandontheground)onst.Vincent(malleryetal.2007),andfrogsinatleastsomepopulationsofE. planirostrisarerou-tinelyfoundinarborealsituations(e.g.,bromeliads;hendersonandpowell
a failed (?) Introduction of lizards and frogs on st. vincent
AmosGlasgow
ForestryDepartment,st.VincentandtheGrenadines,Campdenpark,st.Vincent
IntRoDUCeDspeCIes
thismaleCubanbrownAnole(Anolis sagrei)ispartofanestablishedpopulationinthemontroseneighborhoodinKingstown,st.VincentandtheGrenadines.Individualsshippedintolayoucouldhavefoundedanadditionalcolonyifnotfortheactionsofthequarantineofficers.
aLe
Jan
dr
o J
. sá
nC
hez
Mu
ño
z
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 55
2009).however,initsnativerangeE. planirostrisreacheselevationsthat,ifexploitedonst.Vincent,couldresultincontactwithendemicPristimantis shrevei,whichislistedasendangeredontheIUCnRedlist(hedgesandpowell2004)andalreadyisthreatenedbycompetitionwithE. johnstoneiandongoingdeclinesinhabitatqualityandextent. Individualsofeitherspeciesareunlikelytohaveescapeddetection,buttheorganizationthatreceivedtheplants(natureCaresVG)hasbeeninstructedbyquarantineofficerstomonitorthemcloselywhilestillon-siteandafteranysalesandrelocations.
AcknowledgementsthequarantineofficersatlayouaretobecommendedfortheirdiligenceindiscoveringtheseinvasiveanimalsandforbringingthemtotheattentionoftheForestryDepartment.IthankRobertW.henderson,Kennethl.Krysko,andRobertpowellforidentifyingspecimens.
Literature Citedeales,J.andR.s.thorpe.2010.Revealingthegeographicoriginofaninvasive
lizard:theproblemofnativepopulationgeneticdiversity.Biological Invasions12:77–86.
hedges,b.andR.powell.2004.Pristimantisshrevei.In:IUCn2010.IUCnRedlistofthreatenedspecies.<www.iucnredlist.org>.
henderson,R.W.andR.powell.2005.Geographicdistribution:Anolis sagrei.Herpetological Review36:467.
henderson,R.W.andR.powell.2009.Natural History of West Indian Reptiles and Amphibians.UniversitypressofFlorida,Gainesville.
mallery, C.s., Jr., m.A. marcum, R. powell, J.s. parmerlee, Jr., and R.W.henderson.2007.herpetofaunalcommunitiesoftheleewardslopesandcoastsofst.Vincent:Acomparisonofsitesvariouslyalteredbyhumanactiv-ity.Applied Herpetology4:313–325.
meshaka,W.e.,Jr.,b.p.butterfield,andJ.b.hauge.2004.The Exotic Amphibians and Reptiles of Florida.KriegerpublishingCo.,malabar,Florida.
powell,R.andR.W.henderson.2007.thest.Vincent(lesserAntilles)herpeto-fauna:Conservationconcerns.Applied Herpetology4:295–312.
powell,R.,R.W.henderson,m.C.Farmer,m.breuil,A.C.echternacht,G.vanbuurt,C.m.Romagosa,andG.perry.2011.IntroducedamphibiansandreptilesintheGreaterCaribbean:patternsandconservationimplications,pp.63–143.In:A.hailey,b.s.Wilson,andJ.A.horrocks(eds.),Conservation of Caribbean Island Herpetofaunas.Volume1.brill,leiden,thenetherlands.
treglia,m.l.,A.J.muensch,R.powell,andJ.s.parmerlee,Jr.2008.InvasiveAnolis sagreionst.VincentanditspotentialimpactonperchheightsofAnolis trinitatis.Caribbean Journal of Science44:251–256.
IntRoDUCeDspeCIes
theseGreenhouseFrogs(Eleutherodactylus planirostris)werediscoveredinaship-mentofornamentalplantsfromFlorida.
aM
os
GLa
sGo
W
thepacificCoastGiantmuskturtle,Staurotypus salviniiGray1864,isindigenoustothepacificlowlandsofoaxacaandChiapas,mexico,
rangingeastwardintoelsalvadorandGuatemala(ernstandbarbour1989).thisspeciesfeedsonfishes,invertebrates,andamphibians,andlivesinslow-moving,softbottomlakes,rivers,andotherwaterwayswithaquaticvegetation(ernstandbarbour1989). on2october2010at1400h,anadult(270mmcarapacelength[Cl]) femaleStaurotypus salvinii (Fig. 1; photographic voucherUF160342)wascollectedon thepropertyofZoomiami,miami-DadeCounty,Florida,alongtheperimeterfenceofahoof-stockexhibitadja-cent toa0.85-km-longman-made lake (25.60276°n,80.40123°W,WGs84datum).thisS. salviniiwasplaced in the zoo’squarantinefacilityforafutureexhibit,whereitwaskeptina300-gallonenclosure.on26october2010,theanimalwasradiographedbecauseofunusualbehavioranddiscoveredtocontaintwocalcifiedeggs(Fig.2).on15november2010,thisS. salviniiovipositedthetwoeggsinsubstrateof
sandandleaflitterintheenclosure.theseeggs(10.1g,39.5x20.8mm;9.9g,39.5x19.7mm,respectively)wereremovedandplacedonver-miculitesubstrateandincubatedwithinaGQF1550hatcherIncubator(savannah,Georgia)at28.6°Cwithahumidityofapproximately80%.on2December2010,thetwoeggsappearedtohavefailedtodevelopandwerediscarded. on1november2010at1210h,ajuvenile(107mmCl)femaleStaurotypus salvinii(Fig.3;photographicvoucherUF162276)wascollectedcrossingazooserviceroadbetweenexhibits(25.61079°n,80.40068°W),0.9kmnorthofthefirstindividual.thenearestwatersourcetothisloca-tionisa0.13-km-longman-madelake,whichisnotconnectedtothelarger,0.85-kmlakewherethefirstindividualwasfound.thisS. salviniiwasalsoplacedinthezoo’squarantinefacilityforafutureexhibit,whereitwaskeptinaseparateenclosure. Zoomiamicontainsapproximately300haofpinerockland,approxi-mately133haofwhicharedevelopedfortheinstitution.Althoughmuch
The Pacific coast giant Musk Turtle, Staurotypus salvinii gray 1864 (Kinosternidae),
a new non-indigenous species in floridaDustinC.smith1,Kennethl.Krysko2,tracyA.sorensen1,andmarian.sider1
1Zoomiami,12400sW152ndstreet,miami,Florida33177,UsA([email protected],[email protected],[email protected])2Floridamuseumofnaturalhistory,UniversityofFlorida,Gainesville,Florida32611,UsA([email protected])
photographsbytheseniorauthor.
56 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
ofeasternmiami-DadeCountyconsistsofurbandevelopment,propertiesdirectlyadjacenttothezoocompriselargetractsofmostlyundevelopedpinerockland.noneofthesepinerocklandareasareresidential,andforsecuritythezooisborderedbya2.5-m-tallchain-linkfenceandconcreteperimetermoat.Staurotypus salviniihasneverbeenkeptaspartofthezoo’scollection,butisavailablethroughthepettrade,whichislikelytheinva-sionpathway.Althoughthisspecieswasprobablyintentionallyreleasedonthegroundsbyazoovisitor,weacknowledgethatitalsocouldhavebeenreleasedalongperimeterpropertiesbecauseofgapsundergatesandotherpotentiallycompromisedareas.likeinothermiami-DadeCountyparks(e.g.,seeKryskoetal.2010),numerousnon-indigenousamphibianandreptilianspeciesfrequentlyarefoundonornearzoogrounds;thesewerelikelyreleasedbyzoovisitorsand/orpreviousownerswhonolongerwanttocarefortheiranimals.thepresenceofmultipleS. salvinii,includingafemalewitheggsandajuvenilefoundatdifferentsitesonzoogrounds,sug-gestslikelyreproductionandestablishmentofthisspeciesthere.however,beforemakingthisclaimwebelieveevidenceofreproductioninthewildisnecessary.thisisthefirstknowndocumentedintroductionofthisspeciesinFlorida.
AcknowledgmentsWethankJohnb.Iverson,peterA.meylan,paulVanderschouwandJasonbourqueforspeciesconfirmation;J.steveConners,nicoleAtteberry,Gadperry,Robertpowell,andananonymousreviewerforhelpfulcommentsonthispaper.
Literature Citedernst,C.h.andR.W.barbour.1989.Turtles of the World.smithsonianInstitution
press,Washington,D.C.andlondon.
Krysko,K.l.,K.m.enge,e.m.Donlan,e.A.Golden,J.p.burgess,andK.W.larson. 2010. the non-marine herpetofauna of Key biscayne, Florida.Herpetological Conservation and Biology5:132–142.
IntRoDUCeDspeCIes
Fig. 1.Adultfemale(UF160342)Giantmuskturtle,Staurotypus salvinii,frommiami,miami-DadeCounty,Florida.
Fig. 2.Radiographoffemale(UF160342)Giantmuskturtle,Staurotypus salvinii,frommiami,miami-DadeCounty,Florida.
Fig. 3.Juvenilefemale(UF162276)Giantmuskturtle,Staurotypus salvinii,frommiami,miami-DadeCounty,Florida.
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 57
Conserving Hellbendershellbenders (Cryptobranchus alleganiensis) areobligateaquaticsalamandersthatareindeclineduetohabitatlossanddisease.twosubspecieshave been described based on morphologicalcharacteristics:C. a. alleganiensis (easternsub-species)andC. a. bishopi(ozarkhellbender).Currentconservationstrategiesincludecaptivepropagationforrestorativereleaseseventhoughinformation regarding the current levels ofgeneticvariabilityandstructurewithinpopula-tionsisnotsufficienttoeffectivelyplanforcon-servationofthegeneticdiversityofthespecies.toinvestigatepatternsofpopulationstructureinthehellbender,Crowhurst et al.(2011.Conservation Genetics,DoI:10.1007/s10592-
010-0170-0, published online 28 December2010)genotyped276hellbenders fromeightmissouriRiverdrainages,representingbothsub-species.theirresultsshowedlowlevelsofwithin-drainagediversitybutstrongpopulationstructureamongrivers,andthreedistinctgeneticclusters.FSTvaluesrangedfrom0.00to0.61andaveraged0.40.theresultsconfirmedpreviousreportsthatC. a. bishopiandC. a. alleganiensisaregeneticallydistinct,butalsorevealedanequidistantrelation-shipbetweentwogroupswithinC. a. bishopiandallpopulationsofC. a. alleganiensis.Currentsub-speciesdelineationsdonotaccuratelyincorporategeneticstructure,andforconservationpurposes,thesethreegroupsshouldbeconsideredevolu-tionarilysignificantunits.
ConseRVAtIonReseARChRepoRts
c o n s e R v a T I o n R e s e a R c H R e P o R T s
Hurricanes and Amphibian Communities in Coastal Wetlands
Isolatedwetlands in the southeasternUnitedstatesaredynamichabitatssubjecttofluctuat-ingenvironmentalconditions.Wetlandslocatednearmarineenvironmentsaresubjecttoaltera-tions inwaterchemistryduetostormsurgesduringhurricanes.GunzburGer et al.(2010.Wetlands Ecological Management18:651–663)evaluatedtheeffectofstormsurgeoverwashonwetlandamphibiancommunities.theysam-pled32wetlandsinnorthwesternFloridaovera45-monthperiodtoassessamphibianspeciesrichnessandwaterchemistry.Duringthisstudy,sevenwetlandswereoverwashedbystormsurgefromhurricaneDennis,whichmadelandfallon10July2005intheFloridapanhandle.specificconductanceacrossallwetlandswas lowpre-storm(<100υs/cm),butincreasedpost-stormattheoverwashedwetlands(mean=7,613υs/cm).Increasedspecificconductancewasstronglycor-relatedwithincreasesinchlorideconcentrations.Amphibianspeciesrichnessshowednocorrela-
tion with specific conductance. one monthpost-stormtheauthorsobservedslightlyfewerspecies in overwashed compared with non-overwashedwetlands,but this trenddidnotcontinuein2006.morespeciesweredetectedacrossallwetlandspre-storm,butnodifferencewasdetectedbetweenoverwashedandnon-over-washedwetlandswhenconsideringallamphib-ianspeciesoradultanuransandlarvalanuransseparately.Amphibianspeciesrichnessdidnotappeartobecorrelatedwithphorthepresenceof fish, although the amphibian communitycompositiondifferedbetweenwetlandswithandwithoutfish.Resultssuggestthatamphib-iancommunitiesinwetlandsinthesoutheast-ernUnitedstatesadjacenttomarinehabitatsareresistanttotheeffectsofstormsurgeoverwash.
Site Fidelity and Extended Activity in Crawfish Frogs
Crawfish Frogs (Lithobates areolatus) basetheirnonbreedingactivitiesinandaroundtheentrancesofcrayfishburrows.thissiteprefer-enceallowsmonitoringofindividualsusingstillandvideoimagingtechniques.hoffman et al.(2010.BioScience60:829–834)usedthreecam-eratypesofferingdifferentcontinuities,scales,andresolutionsofdatatoobserveactivitypat-ternsandnonbreedingbehaviors.theauthorsobservedtwobehaviorsnotpreviouslyreportedforamphibians:(1)Circumdielactivitypatterns,and(2)longperiods(days)ofsurfaceactivity.AlthoughthesebehavioralfindingsareatthistimespecifictoCrawfishFrogs,theymightnotbeunusualactivitypatternsforotherfrogs.theuseofimagingtechniquesthattakeadvantageofthisspecies’dependenceonburrowsanduseofburrowentrancesfacilitatedtheobservationofthesepatternsforthefirsttime.
eastern hellbenders (Cryptobranchus alleganiensis alleganiensis)aregeneticallydistinctfromtwogroupswithinwhathasbeen traditionallyconsidered theozarkhellbender (C. a. bishopi).All three repre-sentevolutionarilysignificantunitsthatshouldbeaddressedseparatelybyeffortstoconservethem.
ad
aM
L. C
ra
ne
newlyemployed imagingtechniquesrevealedcir-cumdielactivityandlongperiodsofsurfaceactivityinCrawfishFrogs(Lithobates areolatus).WhethertheseactivitypatternsareuniquetoCrawfishFrogsisatthistimeunknown.
suza
nn
e L.
Co
LLin
s, C
na
h
speciesnotdetectedpost-storm fromoverwashedwetlandsbutpresent innon-overwashedwetlandswereHyla squirella,Pseudacris ornata(top),Lithobates(Rana)catesbeianus,Lithobates(Rana)clamitans(mid-dle),andPseudobranchus striatus(bottom).twoofthesespecies,L. clamitansandL. catesbeianus,werealsonotdetectedattheoverwashedwetlandspriortothestorm.
suza
nn
e L.
Co
LLin
s, C
na
h
n a T u R a l H I s T o R y R e s e a R c H R e P o R T s
58 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 neWsbRIeFs
Iguana Conservation in Hispaniola and Fiji
the endemic and Critically endangeredRicord’sIguana(Cyclura ricordii),isrestrictedtosouth-centralhispaniola,wherefourdisjunctsubpopulationsremaininanarealessthan100km2.three subpopulationsoccurwithin theJaragua-bahoruco-enriquillobiosphereReserveintheDominicanRepublic(DR).thefourth,thesmallest,andmostthreatenedsubpopulationisfoundinsoutheasternhaiti. Conservationactivities in theDRfocusonhabitatmonitoringandregularpatrollingbymembersoflocalsupportgroupstopreventdisturbances. this integrative, low-cost pro-gramiseffective,raisesawareness,andservesasamodelforotherendangeredspeciesprogramsintheDR.Inseptember,withfundingfromananonymousdonor,theInternationalIguanaFoundation(IIF)andGrupoJaraguapurchased20hectaresintheDRencompassingacriticallyimportant nesting area for Ricord’s IguanascalledFondadelatierranearpedernales.over140hatchednestsweredocumentedinthisareaearlierthisyear.InAnse-a-pitres,haiti,wherethe most fragile subpopulation of Ricord’sIguana exists, the IIF and Grupo Jaraguarecentlyconductedaworkshopforlocalauthor-itieswithaproposal to create amunicipallyprotectedhabitat.Ifsuccessful,thisprotectedareawouldbethefirstofitskindinhaiti.theIIF,UsFWs,macArthurFoundation,Disney,andsociedadespañoladeornitologíasupportworkonRicord’sIguana.
InFiji,twosignificantfindingsemergedfromfieldworkconductedover thepastyearbythenationaltrustofFiji,Universityofthesouthpacific,FijiDepartmentofenvironment,natureFiji-mareqetiViti,tarongaZoo,andtheUsGeologicalsurvey.thefirstfindingwasthediscoveryofsizeablepopulationsofthenewlydescribedFijianbandedIguana(Brachylophus bulabula)ontwogovernment-ownedislands,mokogaiandmakodrago.thesepopulationswillhopefullyserveasthefocusofanassessmentforapotentialnewnationalparkwithinFiji. thesecondfindingwasconfirmationthatGreenIguanas(Iguana iguana),illegallyintro-ducedtoFijiearlierthiscentury,nowoccuronatleastfourislandswithdocumentedbreedingontwoislands.GreenIguanasarehighlyinva-sive,andjuvenilesareverysimilarincolorandshapetothethreatenedendemiciguanasofFiji,asimilarityexpectedtohampercontrolefforts.partialfundingforfieldworkinFijicamefromCepFandtheIIF.
Glenn Gerber and Miguel García Co-Chairs,IguanaspecialistGroup
WithcontributionsfromernstRupp,masaniAccimé,andRobertFisher
IUCnSpecies52:21–22
Bringing Down the Serpent KingAbroken lockonasuitcasemovingthroughKualalumpurInternationalAirportthissum-merledtothediscoveryofnearly100babyboaConstrictors,twovipers,andasouthAmericanturtle.thiswasafairlymodestcacheforawild-lifesmuggler,butthemanwhoclaimedthesuit-casewasnoordinarycriminal.hewasAnsonWongKengliang,theworld’smostnotoriouswildlifetrafficker—and,insteadofaslaponthewrist,whichhemightreasonablyhaveexpected,Wongwasabouttoreceiveasurprisingpunish-ment. Fromthetinymalaysianislandofpenang,inastorefrontnolargerthanyouraveragenailsalon,Wongcommandedoneof theworld’slargest wildlife trafficking syndicates. muchoftheworkofWong’scompany,sungaiRusaWildlife,wasabove-board.helegallywhole-saledtensofthousandsofwildreptilesannu-ally,makinghimthelikelysourceformanyofthesnakes,lizards,turtles,andfrogsonsaleinAmericanpetstores.however,usingaprivatezooasacover,healsoofferedanastoundingarrayofcontraband,includingsnowleopardpelts, panda skins, rhino horns, rare birds,andKomodoDragons.hesmuggledcriticallyendangered wildlife from Australia, China,madagascar,newZealand,southAmerica,andelsewheretomarketslargelyineurope,Japan,andtheUnitedstates.
Wong’slongcareerbeyondthereachofthelawoffersawindowonthe$10–20billion-a-yearillegalwildlifetradeandourbrokensystemtocombatit.Underfundedlawenforcement,governmentcorruption,controversy-shynGos,andafeebleinternationallegalframeworkhaveyieldedfewinroadsagainstwildlifesyndicatesorkingpinslikeAnsonWong.Wong’sarrestandhissentencinginnovember2010provideales-sononhowtochangethat. Wonggot into thebusiness in theearly1980s,sellingexoticanimalstozoosanddeal-ersaroundtheworld.Changesininternationalandmalaysianlaweventuallyledhimtofocusonreptiles,whichhebelievedwerenotaspro-tectedasotherspecies.Wong’stechniquesmir-roredthoseofnarcoticsandothertraffickers.hepaidmulestocarryKomodoDragonshiddeninsidesuitcases,andhidendangeredmalagasytortoisesatthebottomoflegalwildlifeship-ments.purchasingvacationpackagesascover,hesentmenouttopoachrarewildlifefrombreed-ingfacilitiesinnewZealand.themostimpor-tanttechniqueWongandotherlarge-scalesmug-glersemploy,however,isfarlessexoticthanallthat.Instead,ithastodowithpaperwork. the primary treaty governing interna-tionalwildlife trade is theU.n.ConventiononInternationaltradeinendangeredspeciesofWildFaunaandFlora(CItes),whichclas-sifieswildlifeintothreegroups:AnimalslistedinAppendixI,suchastigersandgorillas,aresoclosetodisappearingthattheyarebannedfrominternational commercial trade;Appendix IIanimalsmaybetradedunderapermitsystem;andAppendixIIIanimalsareprotectedbyacountrywitharequest thatothershonortheprotection.smugglersscantheglobeforcoun-trieswithweaklawsorcorruptlawenforcementofficialstaskedwithstampingtheiranimals’doc-umentation,paperthatisasmuchindemandastheanimalsthemselves.suchcountriesbecomewildlifelaunderingpass-throughpoints—ani-malscomeinillegallyandleave“legally.” Fewplaceslaunderasmuchillegalwildlifeaspenang.thiswaslargelytheworkofWong:“Icangetanythingherefromanywhere,”heboasted toanAmericanundercoveragent inmarch1997.“nothingcanbedonetome.Icouldsellapanda—and,nothing.AslongasI’mhere,I’msafe.”thekey,heexplained,waspayingoffgovernmentofficials. Wong’sactivitiesfinallylandedhimontheradarofinternationallawenforcementagenciesintheearly1990s,whenspecialoperations,theeliteundercoverunitoftheU.s.FishandWildlifeservice(UsFWs),madehimthetargetofaninvestigationcalledoperationChameleon.Agentssetupareptileimportingcompanyout-side san Francisco and a retail operation in
n e W s b R I e f s
the smallest and most threatened population ofRicord’sIguana(Cyclura ricordii;top)isinsoutheast-ernhaiti.thediscoveryofFijianbandedIguanas(Brachylophus bulabula;bottom)ontwogovernment-ownedislandsmightservetofacilitateestablishmentofanewnationalpark.
pete
r h
ar
LoW
Joh
n F
. Bin
ns
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 59
Reno,nevada,andbegandoingbusinesswithWong.beforelong,theydiscoveredWongnotonlysmuggledrareandendangeredreptiles,butalsocriticallyendangeredbirdsandmammals.hisreachwasglobal. toarrestWong,agentsneededarusetolurehimoutofmalaysia.Alucrativeinterna-tionalblackmarket inbearbile is fueledbydemandasacure-allintraditionalAsianmedi-cine.UsFWsspecialAgentGeorgemorrison,actingundercover,offeredWongapieceofabear-bilesmugglingoperationheclaimedtoberunning,ononecondition:thetwomenhadtomeetinperson.Wongagreed,butbecausehewasalreadywantedintheUnitedstatesonsmugglingcharges,hewouldonlyagreetomeetinmexico. WhenWongsteppedoffaJapanAirlinesflightinmexicoCityon18september1998,he was met by morrison, along with specialAssistantU.s.AttorneyRoberts.Andersonandateamofmexicanfederales,whoarrestedhim.ItwastheculminatingmomentofoperationChameleon,whichhadgrownintooneofthelongestandmostsuccessfulundercoveropera-tionseverundertakenbytheUsFWs,andoneinvolvingauthorities in fourcountries.WongfoughthisextraditionfrommexicototheUnitedstatesfortwoyears,buteventuallygavein. In June 2001, Wong was sentencedin California to 71 months in prison, fined$60,000, andbanned fromexporting to theUnitedstatesforthreeyearsafterhisrelease—butthesentencedidnotstophim.Whilehewasinprison,hiswiferanhiswildlifebusiness,includingsalestotheUnitedstates.Whenhegotoutin2003,Wongreturnedtomalaysia,grewaponytail,andwentbacktowork. Wong’sU.s.convictionhadnodiscern-ibleimpactonhisabilitytooperateinmalaysia.tothecontrary,hisnewplantobuildatigerzooreceivedfundingandlandfromthepenanggovernment. misliah mohamad basir, thewildlife department official directly respon-sibleforpolicingWong,consideredhimtobealegitimatebusinessman,andbelievedtheU.s.authoritieshadframedhim. IntheyearssincetheUsFWs’srevolution-arystingoperationtookdownWong,theglobalwildlife kingpin had grown more powerful,whilethepeoplewhobroughthimtojusticehadfallenonhardtimes.specialoperationsfailedtomakeanothermajorcaseafterWong’s;today,itsbestagentshavegivenupundercoverwork—andtheunit,whichneverconstitutedmorethanahandfulofagents,isallbutdefunct.thingsdidn’tbegin to changeuntil January2010,whenNational GeographicpublishedaprofileofWong,detailinghisgovernmentcon-nectionandhisnewplanstoexploittigers.theoutcrybyboth thepublic and journalists inthemalaysianpresswasimmediate.malaysiannewspapersandtelevisionarestate-controlled,
whichmakesitdifficultforjournaliststocriti-cizethegovernmentdirectly—buttheyarefreetodisclose foreignreportingaboutmalaysia.Inthecourseofthepastyear,theministryofnaturalResourcesandenvironmentannouncedarevampofitswildlifedepartment,promisingto rotate senior officers every three years. Itstrippedthedepartmentofkeypowersandisintheprocessoftransferringmisliah,whoisnowalsounderinvestigationbythemalaysianAnti-CorruptionCommission.Whileinternationalwildlife nGos were cautious about causingtroubleinmalaysia,theyhaveprovidedinvalu-ableadvicetothecountry’sgovernment,includ-ingtheparliament,whichpassedthefirstover-haulofitswildlifelawinnearlyfourdecades. Asaresult,whenWongwascaughtwithasuitcaseofboaConstrictors,hedidn’tgetawaywithit.themalaysiangovernmentrevokedhisbusinesslicenses,shutdownhiszoo,andseizedhisentirecollectionofanimals, includinghisbengaltigers.Innovember,ajudgesentencedhimtofiveyearsinprison,anunprecedentedtermforawildlifetraffickerinmalaysia. the effort to catch Wong offers a fewimportant lessonsonwhat it takes to stopakingpin.twoprinciples float to the surface.First,where long-term,high-volumeinterna-tionalwildlife traffickingexists,oneormoregovernmentofficersareeithercomplicitinthesmugglingor socomplacentas tobe reason-ablyconsideredaccomplices.Aslongasafewcountriesarewillingtobendtherulesandfudgesomepaperwork,itdoesn’treallymatterwhateveryoneelsedoes:Asinglecountry,evenasin-glewildlifeenforcementofficial,canunderminetheentireglobal“system”tocontroltrafficking.
second,thepublicinthekingpin’shomecountryisthebestweaponagainsthim.nosteptomalaysia’sunprecedentedlegalandadmin-istrativereformsthisyearwasmoreimportantthan theoutcry inmalaysia fromconcernedcitizens.Dozensofarticles—manyof themonmalaysiannewspapers’frontpages—finallytoldthestoryofoperationChameleon,Wong’spenangoperations,andthehistoryofpoorman-agementbythecountry’swildlifedepartment,exposingyearsofbadpolicyandofficialvenality. exposureisacriticalingredientforchange.lawenforcement,nGos,andotherswillfindtheirworkmagnifiedandlastingoncethepublicbecomesawareofit.Fullstoriesneedtobetoldinthemedia.IntheUnitedstates,wherewild-lifetraffickingbustsareoftentreatedashumor-ousnewsitems,thatmeansjournalistshavetorealizethatcriminalsyndicatesareoftenbehindthosepeoplestoppedatairportswithexoticani-malshiddenundertheirclothes. ofcourse,nofixisforever.Wildlifesmug-glers, likeanyotherbreedof trafficker,obeythe lawsofsupplyanddemand.As longasamarketforrareandendangeredanimalsexists,someonewillsupplythem.RisingincomesinChina, India, and even in southeasternAsiameanmorecustomersforendangeredwildlife.In2009,over18,000 liveanimalsandmorethan267tonsofdeadanimalsandderivativeproductswereseizedinlawenforcementactionsinsoutheasternAsiaalone—andthatappetitewon’tgoawayjustbecauseWongtemporarilydid.Whethermalaysia’sreformswilltakerootremainstobeseen,asiswhatwillhappenuponWong’srelease.still,somewhereinmalaysiaoranothercountrysomeoneisallbutguaranteed
neWsbRIeFs
ChineseWaterDragons(Physignathus cocincinus),suchasthisjuvenile,escapedfromthecompoundofAnsonWongKengliangonpenangIslandandhavebecomeestablishedinnearbywaterwayswheretheyappeartobedisplacingsomeofthenativeriparianspeciesintheagamidgenusGonocephalus.
L. L
ee G
ris
Mer
60 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
tobewillingtolooktheotherway,andaspiringkingpinsareeagertotakeoverhisbusiness.
Bryan Christy Adaptedfromanarticle.
28December2010
Snake Owners See a Furry Bias in Invasive Species Proposal
manysnake lovershavebeenseethingat theAmericangovernmentsinceearlylastyear,whenitsoughttobantheimportationandinterstatetransportationofninespeciesofforeignsnakes.thefederalFishandWildlifeservicesaidtheanimals,iffreed,posedaseriousrisktonativeecosystemsacrossthesouthernUnitedstates. WhentheFishandWildlifeservicemovedtobantradeinthesnakes,whichincludeboasandspeciesofanacondasandpythons,itarguedthattheymetthelegalcriteriaforbeingbothinjuriousandinvasive.Invasivespecies—fromAsiancarp,whichthreatentheGreatlakes,toZebramussels,whichspreadexponentially—areaseriousenvironmentalconcern,onethatisoftennotdealtwithuntilaspecieshasbecomefirmlyestablished.theFishandWildlifeservicearguesthat,inthecaseofthesnakes,theyaretryingtogetaheadoftheproblem. It is the first time the government hastried to list animals so widely held as pets.RoughlyonemillionAmericansarebelievedtoownsnakesofthetypes listedbytheInteriorDepartment,accordingtotheU.s.AssociationofReptileKeepers,and31,000wereimportedin2008,themostrecentyearforwhichthegovern-menthasdata.tradeinthesespeciesisbigbusi-ness—morethan$100millionannually.thosewithrarecolorscanfetchupwardof$75,000. themove toban the snakeshas setoffaswellofangeramongaggrievedsnakeown-ers andbreeders,whohave themost to losefinancially,aswellasasmatteringofacademicherpetologists,zookeepers,andrepresentatives
of international conservation groups. Whenthe regulations came up for public review,theyfloodedthegovernmentwithobjections.Attheheartoftheirargumentsisacritiqueofthe emerging science of invasive species riskassessment,andtheirresponsehashighlightedthechallengesthatthegovernmentfacesasitincreasinglymovestoprotectnativefloraandfaunanotjustfromcurrentinvasivespeciesbutalsofromfuturethreats. thereptilekeepersgroup,whichclaims12,000 professional breeders and sellers asmembers,hasfiledformalobjectionswiththeInteriorDepartmentandisthreateningalawsuitbasedonwhatitsaysisthegovernment’spoorscientificevidence.AndrewWyatt,thepresidentoftheassociation,arguesthatthegovernmentisnowpromotinganative-species-onlyagendafavored by environmental groups. “this hasimplicationsforeveryanimalinterestoutthere,rightdowntofamilypets,”hesaid,addingthatbysuchstandards,“allamphibiansareinjuriousandcatsanddogscan’tbefarbehind.” thebattlegoesbackto2006,whenthesouth Florida Water management DistrictpetitionedtheFishandWildlifeservicetolistthesnakesunderthelaceyAct,whichwouldmake it a crime to transport them into theUnitedstatesoracrossstateborders.burmesepythons—somethoughttobedumpedbypetownersandsomethatescaped—wereestablish-ingthemselvesacrosstheeverglades,wheretheywereswallowingupeverythingfromendangeredKeylargoWoodRatstoalligators.thepopula-tionhasbeenexpandingnorthwardatroughlythreeandahalftosixmilesayear—Indy500speedsinreptilianterms. Inrecentyears,Floridaofficialshadtakensignificantstepstolimitownershipofinvasivesnakeswithinthestatebutstillwantedmoretobedone.WhatwastoprotecttheevergladesfromasnakeboughtinGeorgiaandcarriedacrossstatelines?tobanthesnakesunderfederallaw,thegovernmentwouldhavetoshowthattheyposedathreattonativeplants,crops,oranimals.WithverylittlescienceavailableabouthowreptilesthatcomefromdistantplaceslikesubtropicalAsiaandAfricamightfareinAmerica,theU.s.Geologicalsurveywasaskedtoassesstherisk. theagencylookedatmanyfactors,includ-ingthedamageintheeverglades.Italsoturnedtoacomputermodeltodeterminewhatpartsofthecountrymighthaveahospitableclimateforthespecies.thescientistslookedatvariablesincludingmeanmonthlytemperaturesandrain-fallatawiderangeofelevationsinthenativehabitatsoftheanimalsandmatchedthemtopatternsintheUnitedstates.
theyestimatedthatsuitableclimatesfortheburmesepythoninparticularmightincludethe11southernmoststatesfromCaliforniatonorthCarolina.Ifglobalwarmingcontinuedapace,thegeologicalsurveyadded,thesnakesmightevenbeathomeinnewYorkCityby2100.thenationalnewsmediagavegleefulattentiontotheprospectofasnakeinvasion—butsoonafter,biologistsattheCityUniversityofnewYorkdid theirownmodeling,usingmorefactorsanddifferentoneslikeprecipita-tionduringthewettestperiodsoftheyear,andcameupwithonlyFloridaandsoutherntexasaspossiblehabitatsforthesnakes.IndependentstudiesofsnakescapturedintheevergladesandtakennorthtoGainesville,Florida,andsouthCarolinafoundthatmostoftheanimalsdiedwhen leftoutside inwinter in those regions.thesefindingswerefurtherbolsteredwhenanunusualcoldsnapintheevergladeslastJanuaryleftalargenumberofburmesepythonsdeadoncanalbanksandlevees. thestudieshavefiredupthesnakeindus-try,whichseesthemasproofthatthegovern-ment is pursuing a hostile and unwarrantedagenda.onebreedersaidthatthegovernmentregulations,whichdonotpreventbreedingandowningbutdoprevent transportationacrossstatelines,wouldruinhisbusinessandthou-sandslikeit.“thereptileindustrywouldsufferacrushingblowoversomethingthatdoesnotmakesense,”hesaid. Dr.elliottJacobson,aprofessorofveteri-narymedicineattheUniversityofFloridaandaspecialistinreptiles,alsoseesthegovernment’sscienceasskewed.hesaidhesuspectedthatthegovernmentwaslesssympathetictoreptilesthantomorecuddlycreatures.“theimpactofferalcats,forexample,onwildlifeismuchgreaterthanwhat theburmesepythonscando,”hesaid,notingthatacateatsmuchmorethanasnakeofthesamesize. however, thomas strickland, assistantsecretaryfor fishandwildlifeandparks, saidthat the government was not going to backdownand that itwould approve the regula-tions by next summer. the science is solid,mr.stricklandsaid,andthegeologicalsurveywillsoonpublishapeer-reviewedanswertoitscritics.likeother invasivespecies,snakesarearealandgrowingproblem,hesaid.“Youarenotdealingwithhamstershere,”hesaid.“Iwasdownintheeverglades,andittookfourpeopletoholda19-footburmesepython.thesethingswreakhavoc.”
leslieKaufmanNew York Times 8January2011
neWsbRIeFs
theU.s.Geologicalsurveyestimatedthatsuitableclimatesfortheburmesepython(Python bivittatus)mightincludethe11southernmostU.s.statesfromCaliforniatonorthCarolina.Ifglobalwarmingcon-tinuedapace,thegeologicalsurveyadded,thesnakesmightevenbeathomeinnewYorkCityby2100.
suza
nn
e L.
Co
LLin
s, C
na
h
IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011 61
Order online at:www.IRCF.org/LBB
Published by the IRCF
Award-winning conservation biologist Fred Burton has released a fascinating new book about saving one of the most endangered reptile species on earth. “The Little Blue Book: A short History of the Grand Cayman Blue Iguana” is the true story of how a noble and charismatic iguana is rescued from the brink of extinction. An engaging read and a beacon of hope for the conservation of reptiles.
Blue Iguana Story in Print
180 pages$19.95 plus p&p Maps & rare photographsRichly illustrated in full colorActual history and natural historyBlue cloth hardcover with dust jacketMore details online at www.ircf.org/LBB
62 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
Set up your own Exo Terra Monsoon Season
For more information on these or other Exo Terra products please call 1.800.724.2436 (US) 1.800.554.2436 (CA)
Sloping Top: makes filling water reservoir easier.
Easy to connect and install Flexible spray nozzles can be pointed in any direction.
Easy to install tubing; fits through the closeable wire/tube inlets (featured on all Exo Terra Terrariums).
The Exo Terra Monsoon RS400 is a programmable rainfall system suitable for all types of terrariums and greenhouses. It helps maintain optimal humidity by generating precipitation at programmed intervals, the duration and frequency of which can be easily adjusted depending on the type of animal or plant housed. Frequent rainfall helps stimulate breeding behaviour, and is a necessity when housing live tropical plants such as Bromeliads, orchids, mosses, etc.
•Programmablerainfallunitforterrariumsandgreenhouses•Easytoinstallonanytypeofterrariumorgreenhouse•Multiplenozzleapplications(upto6!)•Large4liter(1gallon)reservoir
High-pressure Rainfall System
NEWPRODUCT
editorsRobert Powell
Executive Editor AvilaUniversity,KansasCity,mo
AJ Gutman Editor
bloomfield,Ct
Gad Perry Associate Editor
texastechUniversity,lubbock,tX
Lilianna Gonzalez Assistant Editor
texastechUniversity,lubbock,tX
Jim McDougalAssistant Editor
Guilford,Ct
Michael Ripca Art Director
Atco,nJ
John Binns Graphics/Photography
InternationalReptileConservationFoundation,tucson,AZ
Sandy Binns Services Coordinator
InternationalReptileConservationFoundation,tucson,AZ
editorial boardAllison C. Alberts
ZoologicalsocietyofsanDiego
Frederic J. BurtonblueIguanaRecoveryprogram
Arthur C. EchternachtUniversityoftennessee
L. Lee GrismerlasierraUniversity
Robert W. Hendersonmilwaukeepublicmuseum
John B. IversonearlhamCollege
Charles R. KnappZoologicalsocietyofsanDiego
Gunther Köhlersenckenbergmuseum
Kenneth L. KryskoFloridastatemuseumof
naturalhistory
Jan RamerIndianapolisZoo
Thomas WiewandtWildhorizons
Copyright©2011bytheInternationalReptileConservationFoundation,Inc.Allrightsreserved.nopartofthisjournalmaybereproducedinanyformorbyanyelectronicormechanicalmeans,includ-inginformationstorageandretrievalsystems,withoutthepublisher’swrittenpermission.IRCF, Reptiles & Amphibians, Conservation and Natural History (Issn1098-6324)ispublishedquarterlybytheInternationalReptileConservationFoundation,anonprofit,tax-exemptorganization,pobox90270,tucson,AZ85752.periodicalpostagepaidattucson,AZ.
sTaTeMenT of PuRPoseThe International Reptile Conservation Foundation works to conserve reptiles and amphibians and the natural habitats and ecosystems that support them.
theInternationalReptileConservationFoundation,Inc.isanon-profit501(c)(3)Californiacorporation.
MeMbeRsHIP InfoRMaTIonIRCF, REPTILES & AMPHIBIANS, CONSERVATION AND NATURAL HISTORY, the Journal of theInternationalReptileConservationFoundation,isdistributedquarterly.
AnnualRates:Individual U.S. Membership ........................................................................................................... $25.00Individual Membership, Digital (Adobe PDF)*.................................................................................$25.00Institutional U.S. Subscription...........................................................................................................$30.00International Membership (including Canada)..................................................................................$55.00International Institutional Subscription.............................................................................................$60.00
Additionalcurrentandbackissuesareavailable.Visitwww.ircf.org/bissuetoorderhardcopiesand/orpdffiles.membersreceiveadiscountonpurchasesofadditionalissues.
*theAdobepDFisoptimizedforwebpublishinganddoesnotprovidethequalityandresolutionofthearchivalprintedversion,especiallynoticeableinphotographsandcomplexgraphics.
JoIn onlIne: www.IRcf.org
MeMbeRsHIP [email protected],ortollfree1-877-472-3674(U.s.only),orwriteto:IRCF,pobox90270,tucson,AZ85752
solIcITaTIonstheIRCFencouragescontributionofarticles,letterstotheeditor,newsitems,andannouncementsforpublicationinREPTILES & AMPHIBIANS.Generalarticlescandealwithanyaspectofreptilianoramphibianbiology,includ-ingconservation,behavior,ecology,physiology,systematics,orhusbandry.submissionofphotographstoaccompanyarticlesisencouraged.Guidelinesforsubmissionsandfiguresareatwww.ircf.org/about/submissions.manuscriptsmaybesubmittedviae-mail([email protected]).Authorsofonepageormoreofprintwillreceiveafreecopyofthejournalinwhichtheircontributionappears,andwillreceiveapDFfileoftheirarticlefordistribution.
DonaTIonsForanydonations,pleaseincludeyourname,address,phonenumber,ande-mailaddress.
aDveRTIsIng PolIcyWeadvertiseonlynon-livingproducts(exceptfeederinsects).Foradvertisingratesandoptionscontactsandybinns,AdvertisingDirector,[email protected],pobox90270,tucson,AZ85752.
2011hasbeendesignatedtheYearoftheturtle.thedesignationrecognizesthesadstateofmanyoftheworld’scheloniansandtheurgentneedtohelpmanyspecies.Ifyouhaven’talready,weencourageyoutochecktheFocus
onConservation(p.64)andbecomeinvolvedinsomecapacityinthe2011Year-of-the-turtleeffortstoconservethesespecialcreatures. onaseparatebutnolessurgentissue,theIntroducedspeciessectioninthis(beginningonp.52)andrecentissuesshowsthatherpetologicalintroductionsareongoing.Documentingthemisessentialforidentifyingthemecha-nismsandoutcomesoftheseeventsandprovidinginformationthatregulatorscanusetoaddressandmoderatetheproblem.thesituationisofparticularconcernonmanyislands,whereendemicspeciesarethreatenedbycompeti-tivelysuperiorcontinentalinvasives.AsCharlesDarwinwroteinThe Origin of Species by means of Natural Selection or, The Preservation of Favoured Races in the Struggle for Life(1872.6thed.):“Asnaturalselectionactsbycompetition,itadaptstheinhabitantsofeachcountryonlyinrelationtothedegreeofperfectionoftheirassociates;sothatweneedfeelnosurpriseattheinhabitantsofanyonecountry,althoughontheordinaryviewsupposedtohavebeenspeciallycreatedandadaptedforthatcountry,beingbeatenandsupplantedbythenaturalisedproductionsfromanotherland.”Weencouragetheresponsibleownershipofamphibiansandreptiles.Ifyoukeepnon-nativespecies,pleasetakeeveryprecautionyourself,andsharewithothersyourconcernsovertheescapeorreleaseofanimalstoplaceswheretheydonotbelong.
theeditorsofReptiles & Amphibians
Editors’ Remarks
64 IRCFReptIles&AmphIbIAns•Vol18,no1•mAR2011
turtlesaredisappearingfromtheplanetfasterthananyothergroupofanimals.today,nearly50%ofturtlespeciesareidentifiedasthreat-
enedwithextinction.however,it’snottoolate.theUnitedstateshasmoreendemicturtlespeciesthananywhereonearthandisatrueturtlebiodiversityhotspot.Carefulstewardshipcanpreservetherarespeciesandkeepcommonspeciescommon. thebadnewsisthathumanscausethegreatestharmtoturtlepopu-lations—butthegoodnewsisthatwehavethepowertomakepositivechangestowardturtlesurvival.thegreatestthreatstoturtlepopulationsinclude:(1)habitatlossanddegradation;(2)over-harvestingofwildturtlesforfood,traditionalmedicines,andpets;(3)mortalityfromroads,agricul-turalmachinery,fishingby-catch,andpredators(manyofwhicharenon-native);(4)exoticinvasivespeciesanddiseases;(5)lossofgeneticallyuniquepopulationsduetohybridization(oftenasaconsequenceofturtlesreleasedintoareaswheretheydonotoccurnaturally);and(5)climatechange. throughouttheyear,turtleconservationgroupsinpartnershipwithpartnersinAmphibianandReptileConservation(pARC)willberaisingaware-
nessoftheissuessurroundingturtlesthroughpressreleases,newsletters,photocontests,andrelatedevents.Citizens,naturalresourcemanagers,scientists,andthepet,petfood,andrelatedindustriescanworktogethertoaddressissuesandtohelpensurethelong-termsurvivalofturtlespeciesandpopulations. bookmarkwww.yearoftheturtle.organdcheckitfrequentlyformoreinformationonhowyoucangetinvolved!thewebsiteincludeslinksto2011stateoftheturtleandUsAturtlemappingproject,informationonsubmittingaphotographfortheYear-of-the-turtlephotocontest,andthe2011Yearoftheturtlevideo.Youcanalsosignupformonthlynewslet-tersthatcontain:(1)Adownloadableturtlephotocalendarforeachmonth(ifyouenterthephotocontest,yourphotocouldbeinthecalendar!);(2)informationaboutturtleconservationeffortsandgroups,andhowyoucanhelp;(3)interviewswithturtleexperts,andanswerstosubmittedques-tions;(4)informationonhowyoucanhelpspreadthewordaboutturtles;(5)educationalmaterials;(6)turtleart,poetry,andculturalinformation;andmuchmore!Contactyearoftheturtle2011@gmail.comwithanyques-tions,ortobeapartnerinYearoftheturtle.
2011year of the Turtle
f o c u s o n c o n s e R v a T I o n
thespottedturtle(Clemmys guttata)isendemictotheeasternUnitedstates.ItiscurrentlylistedasVulnerableontheIUCnRedlist.
Joh
n W
hit
e, v
irG
inia
her
peto
LoG
iCa
L so
Cie
ty
A m
ale
Bar
ahon
a Li
mes
tone
Sph
aero
(Sph
aero
dact
ylus
thom
pson
i) d
emon
stra
tes
the
vert
ical
ly e
liptic
al p
upil
it sh
ares
with
oth
er n
octu
rnal
gec
kos
— a
lthou
gh v
ery
little
is k
now
n ab
out t
he a
ctiv
ity p
erio
ds o
f m
ost s
peci
es o
f sph
aero
s. Se
e th
e ar
ticle
on
p. 1
2.
Daniel P. Scantlebury